The Extent to Which Emotion Plays a Role in Foreign Policy Decision Making

8/14/2019 The Extent to Which Emotion Plays a Role in Foreign Policy Decision Making

1/73

"#$ $%"$&" "' (#)*# $+'")'& ,-./0 .

1'-$ )& 2'1$)3& ,'-)*/ 4$*)0)'& +.5)&3

67

589:;; +? 6,A7B:0B

":; C>=D;


2/73

K

!"#$% '( )'*+%*+,

-#,+."/+ 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 1

.BO>?PG;F@;H;>9A000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 2

3*+.'45/+6'* 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 7

8"9'. !:%'.%+6/"$ ;+."*4, "*4 ).6+6/"$


3/73

N

-M;!A-)!

0B:?G8@ 8BO>?PG;F@;F 9:; QB; ?E 8 BG;8< ;H?9=?>8G B?HQ?>;>9

=> =>9;89=?>8G Q?G=9=BAJ IR9 G=99G; 9 H8O=>@ S2,4+TU ":=A A;;H=>@G7 98I??

9?Q=B =A R>F;8G Q?G=9=BAJ 8FF=>@ 9? 9:; R>;8A=>;AA

AB:?G8F Q?G=9=B8G 8B9? =9 =A AR@@;A9;F 9:89 9:;?9:;B; F;;H;F W8GXU ":; =F;8 ?E 8>

;H?9=?>8G B?HQ?>;>9 => 2,4+ A:?RGF >?9 B8RA; F=AYR=;9U ":; E=;GF ?E QA7B:?G?@7

:8A E9G7 B? =>F=D=FR8GXA 8F8Q9=D;

9F8H;>98G Q8@ F;B=A=?>

H8O=>@U 0? P:7 A:?RGF 9:;D?O; ;H?9=?> =>

=>9;89=?>8G Q?G=9=BA[ ":=A F=AA; IR=GFA RQ?> 8B8F;H=B F=AB?R@ 8

BAB=?RA =>=9=89=?> ?E ;H?9=?> => G?P;B9=?>A 9:89

G??QA P=9: :=@:;< ER>B9=?>=>@U #=@:;< ER>B9=?>=>@ =A ;>@8@;F => A G=O; 2,4+U ":; 8B9=D89=?> ?E I?9: G;D;GA => B?HI=>89=?> P=9: A9F Q:7A=B8G G=>OA => 89 H8O=>@J

;H?9=?>J 8>F 8G B:?=B; 8AA;B?>AB=?RA 8B9=D89=?> ?E ;H?9=?> P:;>

8>8G7A;F P=9: A=@>=E=B8>9 2,4+ H?F;GAU ":=A R>8D?=F8IG; RA; ?E ;H?9=?> =>

F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ =AJ => H?A9 B8A;AJ =HQ?9 9? H8O=>@ F;B=A=?>A => 9:; E8B; ?E

R>B;97 8>F B8> I; A;;> 8A ;D?GR9=?>8 I;>;E=9 9? =>F=D=FR8GA 8>FJ 8A

ARB:J B?>9F;F=>@ ?E =>9;89=?>8G Q?G=9=B8G Q?P;


4/73

\

":=A P?98=>A >? H89; 8BB;Q9;F E?< 9:;

8P87 ?9:;< F;@ 8>7 R>=D;FJ 9? 9:; I;A9 ?E H7 O>?PG;F@; 8>F I;G=;EJ

B?>98=>A >? H89;A;>9 9? 9:=A B?Q7 ?E H7 9:;A=AJ P:;> F;Q?A=9;F

=> 9:; C>=D;F

Q:?9?B?Q7=>@U


5/73

]

-)OPQR@


6/73

_

B?B; 8>F Q ?E >?9 7;9 QRIG=A:;F H89;F>;AA 8>F Q8AA=?> 9?P8A=?> ?E Q?G=9=B8G QA7B:?G?@7 =>

=>9;89=?>8G AJ 8 Q8AA=?> A:88GG7 ) P?RGF G=O; 9? 9:8>O H7 ;F=9=>@ 8>F H?9=D89=?>8G `F


7/73

b

3P!AQHT)!3QP

)H8@;A ?E B?DRGA=>@

;D?O;A 8 F;;Q D=AB;8G ;ZQ;B; P=9:=> Q;?QG;U )> 8FF=9=?>J 9:;

B?HQG;Z=97 ?E 9:; :;89;F 8G F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ ;>D=H;>9 EG??F;F P=9: ;H?9=?>8G 8>F :RH8>

EGR;>B;U 6R9 9? P:89 ;Z9;>9 8 H8O; 9? ;>@8@; 9:;=A => B@ 8>F B8A[ .>F I;7?>F 9:=AJ

:?P P?RGF 9:; =>9;89=?>8G A9RF=;A 8B8F;H=B F=AB=QG=>; 8F;YR89;G7 8BB?R>9 E?@8@;A 9:; 8B8F;H=B

I8BO@ A:?RGF E==>@ 9:; =HQ?B; ?E 9:; 7?R>@;< Q?G=9=B8G QA7B:?G?@7

F=AB=QG=>;U 2?GG?P=>@ 9:=A =A 8 G=9;


8/73

d

8B8F;H=B 8


9/73

e

8-UQA !V":; 7?R>@;< E=;GF ?E Q?G=9=B8G QA7B:?G?@7 8=HA 9? 98O; 9:; P=F;G7 A9RF=;F 8>F

G8F BB;Q9R8G R>F;F=>@ ?E :RH8> I;:8D=?R Q?G=9=B8G QA7B:?G?@7J 9:; G8F 9 E=;GF ?E F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ FJ 8GG

98GO ?E Q?P;< =A 9:; >?9=?> 9:89 ! => A?H; P87 8EE;B9A #a S-RO;A Meb\J QU K_TU )>

9:=A P?9=E=;A 9:G7 9:; E= 9:=A F=AA;J 8A 9:; E= Q?G=9=BA 8>F QA7B:?G?@7 H? A9 =A 9:; QGRF

F=H;>A=?> ?E I?9: F;B=A=?> 8>F >?>VF;B=A?=> H8O=>@U

":=A `=>D?GD;A 8 YR8G=E=;F B P:=B: F;B=A=?>A 8 Q?9;>9=8G =AAR;A ?D;< P:=B: 9:; ?IA;EG=B9 ?E

=>9; 8A ;HI?F=;F => ;ZQF;F=>@ ?E 9:; =>9;89=?>8G Q?G=9=B8G EG??< ?E Q?P; 8FF@ 2,4+ => 8 9


10/73

ML

":; QA7B:?G?@7 EG??< ?E R>F;F=>@ E?< 9:=A F=AA;


11/73

MM

(=9:=> 9:; G8A9 F;B8F;J 9:; A?H; 899;HQ9 9? F=ABRAA ;H?9=?> =>

E? Q?G=B7 F;B=A=?>VH8O=>@U )>F;;FJ 9:; 8> =>B 9:; =>9;@;F :89; =HQ8B9 9:; P=F;< E=;GF ?E Q?G=9=BAU 0B:?G8A ?>

E? Q?G=B7 Q;AJ B:?=B;AJ 8>F =>9;FG7J 9:; H8=> F;I89; ?E =>F=D=FR8G E? Q?G=B7

I;:8D=?R< :8A I;;> I;9P;;> 9:; 8G 8>F B?@>=9=D; AB:??GA ?E 9:?R@:9U .>F

G8A9G7J ;H?9=?> =A F=EE=BRG9 9? F;E=>; 8>F H;8AR


12/73

MK

(:=G; 9:; ?E 9:; => 2,4+J 9:;F F=A9=>@R=A:;F 88G AU 2R>F8H;>98GG7J `8B9?F

899=9RF;A => =>9;89=?>8G A =>BGRF; 8EE;B9=D; ;D8GR89=?>A ?EJ 8>F

?989=?>A 9?P889=?>A ?< G;8F;9;89=?>8G 8B9?< :?GFA

9?P8?9:; =>

G=>; P=9: =>9;89=?>8G A F=AB?RF QB;Q9R8G

E ?> 9:; Q; 8>F

8>8G7A=A ?E =>9;89=?>8G ;D;>9AU ":;7 ;>@8@; => A?H; I8A=B :7Q?9:;A=A 9;A9=>@ =>

G=>; P=9: 9:=A B?>B;Q9R8G E9 8>F 8A 9:;

B;>9B;A => E? Q?G=B7 F;B=A=?>VH8O=>@U ":; 8>F E? Q?G=B7 F;B=A=?>VH8O=>@J 8A =9 8BB?R>9A E?< E;P;< D898I=G=97 8>Fi?A98G7A=A ?E =>9;89=?>8G A 8A

`=>F=D=FR8GA 8D=H;>9 8>F 8B9 RQ?> 9:;

B?>9;>9A ?E 9:;A; H?F;GAJ A?GD=>@ QAa S07GD8> h

k?AA MeedJ QU dTU *?>A;YR;>9G7J 9:; @;>;


15/73

M]

P:=B: :8A ?>; ?E 9:; H?A9 A=@>=E=B8>9 8G A Q ;>@8@;F 89 G?P;< 8>F :=@:;< >;R ?E 2,4+f `9:; B:?=B;A =>F=D=FR8GAJ @A H8O; 9:89

8EE;B9 8 >89=?>XA 8B9=?>A ?> 9:; =>9;89=?>8G A98@;a S+=>9l h 4;1?R;> KLMLJ QU NTU

":=A QA=F;B;97J :=@: A98O;AJ

8>F A=@>=E=B8>9 F R>=>9;>9=?>8GG7 I=8A;FJ Q


16/73

M_

@3!


17/73

Mb

G=9;A H87 G8BO 9:; >;B;AA8A=A9;>B7 @=D;> 9:;

B:8>@;A I;9P;;> FA ?> 9:; B?>A=A9;>B7 ?E 9:; D8=9=?>A ?E ;H?9=?>U ":89 =AJ =E

P; P;8G7A; 9:; ;H?9=?>8G B?HQ?>;>9 ?E 8 A=9R89=?>J =9 P?RGF I; F=EE=BRG9

9? ;>AR=9=?>A ?E ;H?9=?> P?RGF 8GG?P E?< 9:; A8H; E8B9?< ? 8 9:;?=9=?>VE8G ;ZQ;B;U )> 9:; A8H; P87J 9:;=< P@ G;8D;A 9:;

?QQ?=97 9? YR;A9=?> P:;9:;< 9:; 8 B?>A=F;9 ?E

;HQ= P=9: 9:; =>@ 9:;??9:;< Q ?E I?99?HVRQ 8>F 9?QVF?P>

8QQ=AHA B?HQ ?E ;H?9=?>J 4< 1?A; +B4;

=>AQ= E?< 9:; B?>9;>9 ?E 8>F 8B8F;H=B 8QQ 8A A:;

P => F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U $8B: Q?=>9 A:; H8O;A E8G 8B9?


19/73

Me

=>D8GR8IG; A?R


20/73

KL

$A98IG=A:=>@ 8 Q:7A=?G?@=B8G G=>O I;9P;;> 9:; A9F F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ 8GG?PA E?< 9:; ;HQ=BF;F=>@ A?R@:9 I7 9:; 8B8F;H=B B?HHR>=97U '>B; 9:=A :8A @8;?R@: ARQQ?BF RQ?> :?P 9:;

A:=Q I;9P;;> ;H?9=?> 8>F F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ =>EGR;>B;A ?9:;B;

R>V9;89=?>8G AU .9 8 I8A=B G;D;G 9:?R@:J ?RF;F=>@ ?E :?P ;H?9=?> QG87A 8 H8O=>@ B8> I; AQG=9J G=O;

9:; G=9;?9 9:;=9=D; B?HQ?>;>9 => 9:; F;B=A=?>

H8O=>@ QF =A 9:;

=>EGR;>9=8G 8 9:89

;H?9=?> QG87A 8 H8O=>@ 9:A9;R?H=BA H87 A;;H 8> 8IA9 9:=A

E;7 ;9 8GU 98O; 8 A=H=G8< 8QQ 8A 9:;7 A;;O 9? B?HI=>; F=EE;9 F=AB=QG=>8A9?H=BA F

>;RF;F=>@A ?E =A:H;>9 => 9:=A 8@R=A: P:;9:;< 9:;;R?H=B I;:8D=?R


21/73

KM

8R9?H89;F ?< B?>9A;J @ AB:?G8E;7 ;9 8GU B 9:=A P=F;J B P=9: ?9:;F R9=G=98=AHU +B4;


23/73

KN

$H?9=?>8G 1;8B9=?>A 9? 9:; 'R9B?H;A ?E 1=AO7 'Q9=?>AXJ S+;GG;9@ ?> 9:; 9:;?F 8>F G89; 9:;=< ;8


24/73

K\

;H?9=?> =>9; 9:; 2,4+ QV+8O=>@XJ A:; F=ABRAA;A 9:; B?@>=9=D;

B?>A9F AB:;H8A => 9:; 2,4+ QXA

8; ?E 9:; H?A9 =HQ?9 => 9:=A P=F;

B?@>=9=D; A9B; 8>F A?B=8G QA7B:?G?@7a S-8

Mee\J QU MdTU .E9;< QA 8>F D=>B=>@G7 8AA;@ A?H; E?=9=D;

B?HQ?>;>9 => B?HI=>89=?> P=9: 8> ;H?9=D; ;ZQ;B; => 2,4+U ":=A H= => 2,4+ 8A 8 >;@89=D;

=>EGR;>B;U -8 8B; ?E AB:;H8A 8>F ?Q;8G B?F; I;G=;E

A7A9;HA => 2,4+ => 8 P87 9:89 8GG?PA 8>F ;>B?R@ A=9R89=?>A => 9:;=< ?P> ;ZQ;B;A Q H8O=>@ A=9R89=?>A cRA9 8A ?9:;E? =A RAR8GG7 =>B?HQG;9;U 6R9

H?; 8B9??PG;F@; ?E ;>FAVH;8>A A:=QA =A >?9 8IG; 9?

U 3;??9 8G?>; => 9:=A

B H8O=>@ ;:8H SMebNT 8>F -RB; h 18EE=8XA SMeeLT P?@ 3;?@ 9:; ?>; 9:89 9:=A F=AA; 899;HQ9A 9? QR9 E?8G ;>D=H;>9 A:?RGF I; F=A


27/73

Kb

B?HHR>=AHJ B8Q=98G=AHJ ?< =HQ;


28/73

Kd

899 9:;?;9;89=?>8G 8B9?< ?R9B?H;A 9?

899 9:;? 9? 9:?A; QA7B:?G?@=B8G 8>F Q?G=9=B8G A?R 9;A9;F Q:7A=B8G 8G *8GBRGRA ?E 2? ,?G=B7 4;B=A=?>Af 3;99=>@

$H?9=?>A ?R9 ?E 9:; *G?A;9X SKLL_T B?>B;>9 9:; E8=GR8G =>EGR;>B; 9? 9:; F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ Q8G AU ":;=< B@a ?E ;H?9=?> => Q?G=9=BAU ":=A

ARQQ? H8O=>@ 9:89 =A F=

?E ;H?9=?>J 9:; ;D=F;>B; I;:=>F 8 A?H89=B R>F;F=>@ ?E ;H?9=?> => F;B=A=?>

H8O=>@J 9:; B?@ B?@>=9=D; ;D=F;>B; 8>F 89A I;:=>F 9:; A8H;


29/73

Ke

R>F;F=>@J 8>F 8 P=F; F=ABRAA=?> ?E P:89 2,4+ =AJ 8>F P:89 ;D=F;>B;

BR => Q?G=9=BAU ":; 8G7A=A =A BG;8< g 9:89

9:=A F=AA; HRA9 B?GG89; ;HQ= => F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ 9?

B;P B?>B;Q9R8G EEGR;>B;A 2,4+U ":=A

F= P:89 =A 8 P?F R>F;8G7A;F

A9RF7 ?E =>9;89=?>8G A9RF=;AU


30/73

NL

F;X)VQ@QS3)-@


31/73

NM

A7HQ9?HAU .EE;B9 =A ?E9;> RA;F =>9;@;8IG7 P=9: ;H?9=?>J IR9 9:; 9P?

B?>B;Q9A 898=>A 9:F ;H?9=?>U $D8GR89=?> =A 8 H=GF Q98G A989; 9:89 G8BOA 8 AQ;B=E=B 98F

:8A 8 Q@;F FRU ":;


32/73

NK

E?GG?P=>@ EA 9:89 -?;P;>A9;=> ;9 8GU

;Z8H=>;U 2R8G7A=A A:?PA 9:89 9:;B9=?> I;9P;;> 9:;

R>B?>AB=?RA 8>F B?>AB=?RA ;ZQ;B; ?E ;H?9=?> 8>F =9A A:=Q P=9:

F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U

,:7A=?G?@=B8G $ZQG8>89=?>A ?E $H?9=?> => 4;B=A=?> +8O=>@f

2 ?BBR9;8G A9=HRG89=?>U &;R@;A ?BBR< => B?>cR>B9=?> P=9: 9:;

Q:7A=?G?@=B8G Q H8O=>@ => Q?G=9=BAJ 8>F

9:89 =A 9? :;GQ 8>AP;< 8 B;>9 ?E Q?G=9=B8G QA7B:?G?@7f R>F;< P:89

B?>F=9=?>A F? ;H?9=?>A :;GQ F;B=A=?> H8O=>@[ 0:; AR@@;A9A 9:89 P; B?>A=F; I8A;F H?F;GA B8> 8HQG=E7 ?R< ;Z=A9=>@ H?F;GA ?E F;B=A=?> H8O=>@J

8AA;@ 9:89 => 8 H?D; 9?P88G 8G=97J P; B?>>;B9 B?@>=9=D;

>;R B?>A=A9A ?E E?R< H8c?< B?HQ?>;>9Af 8

H?9=D89=?>8G B?HQ?>;>9J 8 A?H89=B B?HQ?>;>9J 8 I;:8D=?R;>9J 8>F 8

ARIc;B9=D;V;ZQ;9=8G B?HQ?>;>9 S*G?


33/73

NN

>;B;AA8


34/73

N\

;H?9=?>8G 8QQ@;8G ;>@8@;H;>9 => 9:; F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ Q 8>F E;;G=>@J 8G?>@ P=9: 9:; B?D;;F;@ 9:;HJ 8AA=A9 RA P=9: 9:; F8R>9=>@ 98AO ?E Q@ 8>

R>B; ER9RF QG8>>=>@ ?R< 8B9=?>A 8BB?@G7a SMee_J QU Z===TU ":=A

Q:7A=?G?@=B8G H8B:=>;9? 9P? G;D;GAU ":; G?P;< G;D;G J 8G?>@ P=9: I?F=G7 ER>B9=?>A 9:89 8;B;AA8A98>9G7 =>

B?>98B9 P=9: 8GG ?A => 9:; I?F7U ":=A 8GG?PA E?< 9:; I?F7 9? I; =>D?GD;F => 8

B:8=> ?E ?Q;A 9:89 G??QA 9? 9:; :=@:;A9 G;D;GA ?E =>@J F;B=A=?> H8O=>@J

8>F 9:;R=97U (:=G; 9:=A G??Q G=>OA G?P;< G;D;GA

?E =>E? Q=>@J 9:; G?P;< G;D;GA 8F;>9G7 ?E :=@:;< =>@U #=@:;< =>@ B8>>?9 ?Q;F;Q;>F;>9G7 ?E G?P;< QA=IG; E?< @ 9:; 8R9?>?H=B >;=>@ 9:89 G?P;< Q Q:7A=?G?@=B8G 8A; 9? ;H?9=?>8G A9=HRGRAU ":=A A7A9;H QR9 EFA I7 A;>F=>@

H;AA8@;A 9? 9:; 8R9?>?H=BJ Q8F A7HQ89:;9=B >;


35/73

N]

":=A Q98G B? H8O=>@U ":;7 IG;>F ;Z9;8G 8>F =>9;8G A;>A?E? 9:89

B?>B;A A?H89=B SI?F=G7T 8>Fi?< ;H?9=?>8G A989;A IR9 89 F=EE;9 G;D;GA A? 9?

B?>9 H8O=>@ Q


36/73

N_

DH,2* =A 8B9R8GG7 8 A9B?F=>@ ?E 8EE;B9=D; D8GR;A ?E

;H?9=?>8G A9=HRG= SQ9 9? =>9;89=?>8G Q?G=9=BA =A 9:; >;R H8O=>@ =>

9:; E8B; ?E 8> R>B; 8>Fi?< B?HQG;Z A=9R89=?>J 8A 9:89 =A P:89 B?>E9A

8B9? 2,4+U 48H8A=?XA R>F;F=>@ ?E :=@:;< B?AU ":; >;?B? 9:8> 9:; G?P; 9? 9:; P? F;B=A=?>

H8O=>@ E?H=BAU 08>E;7 ;9 8GU 8 H8O=>@J P=9: HRB: ?E P:89 9:;7

R>B?D;< B?>9@ 9? ?R< R>F;F=>@ ?E :?P R>F;@ >;R H8O=>@ Q9


37/73

Nb

F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ => 8 >;P E9 I;B?H; 9??

:=@:U ":;7 Q I;9P;;> ARIA7A9;HA 9:89 87 @=D;> F;B=A=?>U $H?9=?>A 8 A;;> 9? I; :=@:G7

8R9?H89;F A;A 9:89 B?RGF I;>;E=9 E => 9:; R>F;F=>@

?E 9:; R>F;@ >;R=AHAU

.>?9:;< 9:;?OA ;H?9=?> 8>F F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ =A 9:89 ?E 9:; A?H89=B

H8


38/73

Nd

B?@>=9=D; ?< 8EE;B9=D; B?HQ?>;>9U 6;B:8F 9:; BRF;F=>@ ?E P:89 =9 H;8>A 9? I; =>D?O=>@ F=EE;9 >;R@U +?A9 A=@>=E=B8>9G7J 9:;7 A:?P 9:89 >;R8G 9:; QBGRA=?>

9:89 P:;> =>D?O=>@ 8 :=@:;< ?< ;HQG?7=>@ =>@ 9;B:>=YR;A P:;> H8O=>@ 8

F;B=A=?>J P; P=GG @;>;8G B?HQ?>;>9 9:RA ;>@8@=>@

G?P;< G;D;GA ?E >;R 9:; G??Q A;YR;>B; A989;F ;8 8 B?HQG;Z F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ A=9R89=?>J 9:;> F;B=A=?> H8O;;R E?< 9:; => F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U ":;?=9=D; Q QG87A => F;B=A=?>

H8O=>@ 8@ P:;> RA;F => B?>cR>B9=?>

P=9: Q:7A=B8G ;D=F;>B;U )9 =A >?9 AR 9:89 H8>7 ?E 9:; H?A9 =>EGR;>9=8G

AB:?G8=E=B8>9

=F;8A ?> :?P ?R< B?@>=9=D; QcR>B9=?> P=9:

;H?9=?>A P:;> H8O=>@ F;B=A=?>A => =>9;89=?>8G 8EE8=


39/73

Ne

0B:;H8 B8> =>EGR;>B; 2,4+U +B4;=;A 9:=A 8>8G7A=A P=9: 8> 8 9:; WE;;G=>@ ?E 8G=97XJ

B?>9@ 9? :;< 8GEGR;>9=8G Q?A=9=?> P=9:=> 9:; Q?G=9=BA ?E ;H?9=?>

G=9;A 9:; =HQ?9 8>F P;GGV;A98IG=A:;F A:=QA

I;9P;;> H??F 8>F F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U +??FJ 8 B?@>=9=D; Q:;>?H;>?>J =A >?9 9? I;

RA;F =>9;@;8IG7 P=9: ;H?9=?> 8A F;E=>;F ;8


40/73

\L

,A7B:?G?@7 ?E ^RF@;H;>9 8>F 4;B=A=?> +8O=>@X SKLMLTU 6;=>@ 8 W8GX 8B9?< =>

R>B; ?< R>O>?P> B=B;A =A B; 8G I;:8D=?R< 8A `I;:8D=?R< 9:89

H8Z=H=l;A 9:; D8GR; ?E B?>A;YR;>B;Aa SQU KNbTU )9 =A 9:; 89 AR8G B:?=B;

9:;?


41/73

\M

2,4+ => 9:; E8B; ?E R>B;97J =9 G;>FA =9A;GE ;YR8GG7 RA;ERGG7 9? 9:=A 8>8G7A=A ?E

=>F=D=FR8G F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ => @;>;F=9=?>A ?E R>B;97U ":;=< 8 =>AQ=BGRA=?> ?E 8 A=HRG98>;?RA

;Z8H=>89=?> ?E 9:;A; 8F=D=FR8G F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ =>D?GD;A 9:;

B?@>=9=D; Q H8O;< ;HQG?7A 8 ?E Q?AA=IG; ?R9B?H;A 8>F B?>A;YR;>B;A => ?U ":=A =A B?>A=A9;>9 P=9: 0=H?>XA ;8

H8O=>@ =A A=HQG7 8 Q B:??A=>@ 8H?>@ O>?P> 8>F R>O>?P>

8G9;89=D;A 9:89 8O;F P=9: ?R9B?H;A 8>F B?>A;YR;>B;AU 0=H?>J 8G?>@ P=9:

H8>7 ?9:;< AB:?G8@ P=9: 9:;

Q?QRG8< B?HQR989=?>8G H?F;G ?E F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U ":=A =A B?>A=A9;>9 P=9: 9:;

F=AB=QG=>; ?E QA7B:?G?@7 E8D?R@ 8 B?HQR989=?>8G ?E Q:7A=B8G

8>F B?@>=9=D; A9F;;FJ RA=>@ 8 B?HQR989=?>8G

?E 9:; =>F=D=FR8G F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ QA 8I?R9

Q E8D?R8G H?F;G 8A 8 WQA=A9=>@ ?E 8 G8RHI;< ?E B

?Q9=?>A 9:89 @;>;


42/73

\K

B?HQR989=?>8G H?F;G ?E B?@>=9=D; 8AA;AAH;>9 E?< F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ => R>B;

A=9R89=?>AU -?;P;>A9;=> ;9 8GU => 9:;=< KLLM 8@AX 8FFA 9?

9:=A H?F;F=>@U ":;7 8GA? P G=>; P=9: BR 8>F 8EE;B9 => G??O=>@ 89 9:; ;H?9=?>8G ;ZQ;B;

8AA?B=89;F P=9: F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U ":;7 AR@@;A9 9:89 ;H?9=?>8G A 9? A B8> 8B9R8GG7 ?D;?=9=D; 8AA;AAH;>9A ?E

9:?A; A=9R89=?>AJ ;H?9=?>8G A B8> F ?R< B?HQR989=?>8G =>9;@ =A @ 9:89 9:; H8O=>@ A=9R89=?>J 9:; H? H8O=>@ =A

9? I; I8A;F S;=9:;< ;ZQG=B=9G7 ?< =HQG=B=9G7T => B?@>=9=D; 8B9=D=97U $Z8HQG;A ?E 9:=A

8 => 9:;=< F=ABRAA=?> ?E 8>9=B=Q89?F 8>9=B=Q89;F ;H?9=?>A S8A A989;F

;8 ;H?9=?>8G ;ZQ;B; B8> :8D; ?> F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U

":89 =AJ :RH8>A 8EGR;>B;F I7 9:; Q?AA=I=G=97 ?E ;ZQ;B=>@ 8 ER9R 8E9;< F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ 8>F 9:; 8>9=B=Q89=?> ?E 9:89 ;H?9=?> H87 F H8O=>@U ":;7 ;D;> ;Z8H=>; 9:; 9 H8O=>@ AREE;@ P:;> 8EE;B9=D; =>QR9A SB?@>=9=D;G7V@8G F=AQ?A=9=?>A 9? E8D?RXA 8QQ H8O=>@ Q


43/73

\N

":; E=>8G 98AO => ;Z8H=>=>@ 9:; B?@>=9=D; =>EGR;>B; => F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ =A

9? 8AA;AA :?P Q;?QG; B?H; RQ P=9: 9:;A; :=@:G7 =>EGR;>9=8G =>F=D=FR8G 8EE;B9=D;

=>QR9A 9:89 :8D; I;;> A:?P> 9? =>EGR;>B; F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U )HQ?9G7J 9:=A

=>D?GD;A ;Z8H=>=>@ 9:; A?B=8G QA7B:?G?@7 G=9;F @

9:; P?9 +8O=>@X SMee\TU 0:; =A 8>?9:;< 8FD?B89; ?E 9:; Q?G=9=B8G

QA7B:?G?@7 8QQ ?> 2,4+U .A ARB:J A:; =A

8IG; 9? F H8O=>@ Q


44/73

\\

S-8 Mee\J QU MdTU ":;7 88G?@=;AJ 8IA9?PG;F@;J 8>F ;Z;HQG8


45/73

\]

8I?R9 :?P 9? 8B9U ,?G=B7 H8O;A 8I?R9 :?P 9:; ?9:;< 8B9?< ?< @F 9? ;8B: Q?G=B7 ?Q9=?>U

)9 =A ;D=F;>9 9:89 9: ?E 9:; H?A9 Q;;>9 9:;H;A => 9:;

QA7B:?G?@7 G=9; F;B=A=?> H8O=>@J 9:89

9:;=8IG; Q8 9:; A 8>F 9:; P87A 9:89 E? Q?G=B7 F;B=A=?> H8O;


46/73

\_

=>E? QU


47/73

\b

FQ@3!3)-@ ;)3


48/73

\d

8>8G7A=A ;A98IG=A:;F 9:89 ;H?9=?> 8>F B?@>=9=?> 8 H8O;< 8>F 9:;=< ;ZQ;B989=?>A 8I?R9 9:; F;B=A=?>

;>D=H;>9U 6;G=;EA 8 H8O;E?U 0=H=G8F Q?AA=IG; 8B9=?>A ?E ?9:;A9F=D=FR8G 8>F A?B=;97 =A E?R>F 9:B;Q9A B=9=D; H8Qa ?E 9:; F;B=A=?> H8O; I;=>@ H8F;U 2=@U M I;G?P BG;8:8H ER8G

;D;>9A 8>F 9:; B?@ 8B9=?>A ?E A989;A SQ;B; 9? ARQQ?


49/73

\e

2=@R


50/73

]L

":; H8O;< =A @=D;> 8 >;P A=9R89=?> Q;;>9 9? 9:;=< A989; => 9:;

=>9;89=?>8G A7A9;H 8>F 9:;F A98@; =A 9:;

A;8 ;ZQG8>89=?>U )> 9:=A Q H8O;< 8AA;AA;A 9:; ;Z9;>9

9? P:=B: 9:;7 I;G=;D; 9:;7 Q?AA;AA 8GG 9:; >;B;AA8E? 9? B?HQF

P:89 :8A ?BBRX => 9:=A B8A; =A A8=F 9? I; `9:; 8>;B9=>@ 8 A;9 ?E 9P? ?< H?B;Q9Aa S0:8Q=:8H MebNJ

QU M_\TU ":; =>=9=8G B?>B;Q9 =A H?A9 B?HH?>G7 9:; =>9;89=?>8G 8B9?

H?9=D89=?> ?< =>9;>9U ":; Q89: =A H8F; E 9?

B?>A;YR;>B;SATU '>B; 9:=A >;P =>E? :8A H8F; B?>B;Q9A => 9:; B?@>=9=D;


51/73

]M

A7A9;H ?E 8 F;B=A=?> H8O;B;Q9A 8>F Q H8O;;P =>E? =>9? ;Z=A9=>@ 9:;?F I;G=;EAU ":; D8G=F=97

?E 0:8Q=:8HXA =F;8A =A H8=>98=>;F 8A =>E? QF=9=?>=>@ 9? =F;8A ?> 9:; 8I=G=97 ?E ER9R H8O=>@ ?D;< 9:; E?RB; 9:;=< 8


52/73

]K

F=H;>A=?>A B8> ;ZQG8=> 0:8Q=:8HXA 9:=G7 8B =A

P:;@ :8A I;;> B?>FRB9;FJ P=9: H8>7

AB:?G8@ 9? QR9 E? H8O=>@

?R9B?H;AU "8G A?B=?VQA7B:?G?@=B8G Q;@ 8 F;B=A=?> ?R9B?H; =A 9? B?>A=F;< 9:; H;8>A =>

P:=B: F;B=A=?> H8O; 9:A BA 8F D8G=FU )> 0:8Q=:8HXA 8>8G7A=A 9:;7 ;HQG?7 8

G;Z=B?@ B8GBRGRAJ 8AARH=>@ 9:; F;B=A=?> H8O;< RA;A 9:;=< H?A9

=HQ?9 Q?G=B7 ?Ic;B9=D; E=? F=A9=>@R=A:8IG; 8FD8>98@;A 8


53/73


54/73

]\

R9=G=97 ?< Q H8O;@ 8GG Q?AA=IG; ?R9B?H;A =>9?

B?>A=F; E


55/73

]]

H8O;9;89=?>8G 88J 9:; 8>8G7A=A 9:89 -RB; h 18EE=8 RA; =A

8IG; 9? @? I;7?>F 8>F AQ;BRG89; 8A 9? :?P 9:=A ) &'$-'$F=A9 =A H8F; I7

9:; F;B=A=?> H8O; =A I8A;F RQ?> 9:?A; A8H;

B?@>=9=D; Q89:P87A 9:89 8 H8O;9;89=?>8G ;D;>9A 8


56/73

]_

E?R>F89=?> ?E F;B=A=?> H8O=>@ 9:;?F =A 8BO>?PG;F@;F I7 0:8Q=:8HU )>F;;FJ 8>8G7A=A ?E 899 9:;?;< Med]T 8>F ;H?9=?>U ":;F B?>999A:=Q I;9P;;> ;EE?F=9RF

?R9B?H; S(;=>;< Med]TU )9 =A BG;8< 9:89 => 9:; F=ABRAA=?> ?E 2,4+J 9:89 9:; =F;8A

(;=>;< B?>B;Q9R8G=A;A 8>F 9:89 0:8Q=:8H 8>F ^;F ER>F8H;>98G 9? 9:; R>F;F=>@ ?E I?9: 9:; F;B=A=?> H8O=>@

QU +?A9 A=@>=E=B8>9 9:?R@: =A 9:; 8AA;

9:89 Q;;< =A

B?>E=F;>9 => :=A ?P> ;HQ==>@ 9:; A9@ 9: ?E

H?9=D89=?>J B?>9 8FA =9A @;>; ;H?9=?>AU )9 =A 9:; :?Q;

?E 9:=A B;Q9R8G E ;H?9=?>8G ;ZQ;B; RQ?> F;B=A=?> H8O=>@J 9:; =F;8A B8>

@;>;F ;Z9;>F;F 9? 2,4+U

2O;GXA I??O QRIG=A:;F => Me_d 9=9G;F W":; +8O=>@ ?E 2? ,?G=B7f .>

.>8G7A=A ?E 4;B=A=?> +8O=>@X =A 8 F=ABRAA=?> ?E :?P Q;?QG; H8O; F;B=A=?>A P=9:

A?H; 8>;BF?98G ;D=F;>B; ?E :?P 9:;A; 8F => 2,4+ Q


57/73

]b

@;>; H8O=>@ QAJ A989=>@ 9:89 9:;


58/73

]d

E?BRA 8GA? 8GG?PA E?< 9:; F=ABRAA=?> ?E AB:?G8 8> =>9; 9:;

B?@>=9=D; ;G;H;>9 ?E E? Q?G=B7U

)>EGR;>B;A E


59/73

]e

=>F=D=FR8G 8QQ8G A7A9;H=B 8>F

A989;VG;D;G 8QQ@ E8D?R8G

AU .>?9:;< E8=GR9=E7 =A 8@8=> FR; 9? 9:=A Q=9=?> 8>F 8G=97 ?D;< ;H?9=?>J F;AQ=9; ?D;@ ;D=F;>B; E8G A =F;?G?@=;AU 2?< ;Z8HQG;J E;8< QG87A 8 B;>9A ?E =>9;89=?>8G A;BRA9J

D=;P ;H?9=?>A 8A 8 G;>A => P:=B: =>9;89=?>8G 8B9?A; ?E 9:;=9;89=?>8G A :8D; A?R@:9 9? Q


60/73

_L

9:89 9:; P? H8O;< 9? 8 WR>=98 H87 I; P:89 =>9;89=?>8G A9RF=;A 8FD?B89; E? => 8=F ?E H?9;89=?>8G A

8>8G7A=AJ =A A9; => :;< F=AB89=?> I;9P;;> ?GFVE8A:=?>;F 8>8G7A;A ?E A989;

I;:8D=?R< 8>F P:89 8 :RH8> F;B=A=?>

H8O=>@ Q ?E 9:=A G=9;8G ;;F E?< ;P;F

=>9; :?P :RH8>A H8O; F;B=A=?>AU ":=A =>BGRF;A 9:; F;E=B=;>9 F=ABRAA=?> ?E

;H?9=?> => 2,4+U 4;AQ=9; 9:; F=ABRAA=?> ?E >RH; QG87A 8


61/73


62/73

_K

I;:8D=?RF ARIc;B9=D;V;ZQ;9=8G B?HQ?>;>9A 9? =9 P:=B: 8=FA 9?

F=A9=>@R=A: =9 E;>9A

9? 0:8Q=:8HXA 2,4+ H?F;GU ":; 8HQG=E=B89=?> ?E I;G=;EAJ 9:; A;8 ;ZQG8>89=?>J A;8AJ 8>F G8A9G7 =A 9:; B:?=B; ?E 8 Q?G=B7U ":=A

=A 9:; H?A9 B?HQA=D; 8>F ;EE=B=;>9 H?F;G F=ABRAA;F => 9:=A F=AA;

P=9: =9A ?P> EG?PVB:8 H8O=>@ Q;>9A @ 9? 8 E? Q?G=B7 H8O;EGR;>B; ?E

;>D=H;>9J QJ 8>F 9:; ?R9B?H; ?E 8B9R8GG7

Q Q;A AB:;H89=B R>F;F=>@ ?E 9:; A=9R89=?>U

. E? Q?G=B7 F;B=A=?> H8O;=9=D; A9@ Q8A9 H;H?F 8>8G?@=;AU ":=A =A ?E9;> => G=>; P=9: 9:;=< ?Q;8G

B?F; I;G=;E A7A9;HJ 8 B?>B;Q9 9:89 P:=G; G=@:9G7 F=ABRAA;F P=9:=> 9:=A F=AA;J

P8A Q?QRG8< => Q?G=9=B8G AB=;>B; I;E?@8@;H;>9 ?E 9:; QA7B:?G?@7

G=9;F

I;G=;E A7A9;H 8B9 8A 8 E=G9;@ QAf =A 9:;?R@: F;FRB9=D; ARQQ? ;ZQG8>89=?>[ .>F =A 9:;?R@: F;FRB9=D; ARQQ?; 8G9;89=D;[ )E


63/73

_N

9:;A; YR;A9=?>A 8AP;?XJ 9:;> 8BB?@ 9? 9:; H?F;G QR9 E?FRB9=D; ARQQ?


64/73

_\

B?@>=9=D; A9 9:; Q H8O=>@ Q H8O=>@ A:=Q I;9P;;> 9:; 8H7@F8G8 8>F ?8GT A989;A => F;B=A=?> H8O=>@U ":=A FR8G Q 9:;?=E=B8>9 9? =>9;89=?>8G AU

-;D;GA ?E ;ZQ;B; 8 2,4+U ":=A =A ;Z;HQG=E=;F => 08>E;7 ;9

8GUXA 8>8G?@7 ?E F@ 8 H8>R8G B8


65/73

_]

=> =9A


66/73

__

M3M@3QSA-FVX

.:H;FJ 0 KLL\J H3+ I6216')2 J-2$1$,% -5 K(-1$-.J 1?R9G;F@;J &;P /? +8O=>@ 8>F 9:;

'


67/73

_b

4?G8>J *^ KLLNJ W$B?>?H=B ,?G=B7 8>F 4;B=A=?> +8O=>@ 89 9:; )>9; ?E

4?H;A9=B 8>F )>9;89=?>8G ,?G=9=BAf ":; .FD?B8B7 *?8G=9=?> 28G $B?>?H=B *?R>B=GXJ H3+ J-2$,* O16/$+% S-6'.)2J D?GU NMJ >?U KJ QQU KLeVKN_U

2O;GJ ^ Me_dJ H3+ T)


68/73

_d

#8A9=;J 1 h 48P;AJ 1+ KLMLJ P)1$-.)2 I3-$,+ $. ). X.,+'1)$. D-'2/7 H3+

J%*,3-2-@* -5 S6/@+(+.1 )./ Q+,$%$-. T)AJ ":?RA8>F

'8OAJ *8G=E?=8U

#;>J +3 h 5;@G;7 ^O=>@ 4;H?BF )>9;89=?>8G

,;8B;f ,;J k+ KLLbJ U-'+$@. J-2$,* !.)2*%$%7 I2)%%$, )./ I-.1+(&-')'* H3+-'*J

1?PH8> h -=99G;E=;GFJ +8FU

^8>=AJ )- h +8>>J - MebbJ Q+,$%$-. T)


69/73

_e

5=F>; -=;R ?E 189=?>8G=97f ,A7B:?G?@=B8G ,; 2? ,?G=B7 4;B=A=?> +8O=>@XJ H3+ S-6'.)2 -5 I-.52$,1 P+%-261$-.J D?GU KKJ >?U

\J QQU bLbVbN]U

-8J 4( Mee\J W":; 1?G; ?E 6;G=;E 07A9;HA 8>F 0B:;H8A => 2? ,?G=B7

4;B=A=?>V+8O=>@XJ J-2$1$,)2 J%*,3-2-@*J D?GU M]J >?U MJ QQU MbVNNU

-?;P;>A9;=>J 32J (;I;@AXJ

J%*,3-2-@$,)2 #622+1$.J D?GU MKbJ >?U KJ QQU K_bVKd_U

-?P;>A9;=>J 3 h 0B:O8F;J 4 MeeeJ W(?RGF>X9 =9 I; &=B;[ ,@ 2R9R@AXJ => 58:>;H8>J 4J 4=;>;@ C>F;< C>B;97XJ =>

+?A;J -?>F?>U

+B4;


70/73

bL

+;GG;?U NJ QQU NNKVN\]U

+;GG;EGR;>B; ?E .FD=A; 2? ,?G=B7 4;B=A=?> +8O=>@f .>

$ZQ;98G 09RF7XJS-6'.)2 -5 I-.52$,1 P+%-261$-.J D?GU \_J QQU NN]VN_\U

1;FG8PAOJ 4 KLL_J U++2$.@ J-2$1$,%7 K(-1$-. $. J-2$1$,)2 ;.5-'()1$-. J'-,+%%$.@J

,8G@J 3?AD=GG;J k==8U

1;>A:?>J ^ h -;;V+8O=>@J 9:; 1?G; ?E $H?9=?>A => 2?

,?G=B7XJ => *:

(=G;7 h 0?>AJ (;A9 0RAA;ZU


71/73

bM

08>E;7J .3J -?P;>A9;=>J 3J +B*GRJ ^4 KLL_J W&;R?H=BAf

B F;B=A=?>VH8O=>@XJ H'+./% $. I-@.$1$E+ O,$+.,+%J D?GU

MLJ >?U NJ QQU MLdVMM_U

0B:P8@A 8A )>E?f )HQG=B89=?>A E?< .EE;B9=D; )>EGR;>B;A

?> )>E? ,


72/73


73/73

bN

(=>;B?EEJ .J *G=9:;

The Extent to Which Emotion Plays a Role in Foreign Policy Decision Making

Documents

Transcript of The Extent to Which Emotion Plays a Role in Foreign Policy Decision Making