gragnili VI - tsas.ge...UAC (uak) 378. 627 (479. 22) (066)+27-725:37 T - 388 Tbilisis sasuliero...

348
gragnili VI

Transcript of gragnili VI - tsas.ge...UAC (uak) 378. 627 (479. 22) (066)+27-725:37 T - 388 Tbilisis sasuliero...

  • gragnili

    VI

  • TBILISI THEOLOGICAL ACADEMY

    THE SCROLL

    ECCLESIASTICAL-SCIENTIFIC COLLECTION

    VI

    TBILISI THEOLOGICAL ACADEMY AND SEMINARY

    PUBLISHING HOUSE

    TBILISI 2018

  • Tbilisis sasuliero akademia

    gragnili

    saeklesio-samecniero krebuli

    VI

    Tbilisis sasuliero akademiisa da

    seminariis gamomcemloba

    Tbilisi 2018

  • UAC (uak) 378. 627 (479. 22) (066)+27-725:37

    T - 388

    Tbilisis sasuliero akademiisa da seminariis perioduli gamocemis, saekle-

    sio-samecniero Sromebis krebul โ€žgragnilisโ€œ winamdebare VI tomSi Sevida am

    saswavleblis doqtorantebis naSromebi. zogierTi am statiaTagani amJaminde-

    li doqtorantebis samagistro naSromebis Semoklebul versiebs warmoadgens,

    zogierTi ki - momavali sadoqtoro naSromebis nawilebs. kvlevebi moicavs

    sasuliero mwerlobis ramdenime dargs (homiletika, dogmatika, egzegetika, aske-

    tika, saeklesio mwerloba). garda siaxleebisa, maTSi warmodgenilia sakiTxis

    irgvliv samecniero mimoqcevaSi ukve arsebuli cnobebi, rogorc qarTvel, aseve,

    ucxoel RvTismetyvelTa kvlevaTa Sedegebi. krebulSi qveyndeba, agreTve, didi

    bizantieli saeklesio mamebis Txzulebebis aqamde gamoucemeli ramdenime uZve-

    lesi qarTuli Targmani.

    In the present volume, volume VI, of the periodical edition of ecclesiastical-scientif-ic works executed at Tbilisi Theological Academy and Seminary, titled โ€œGragniliโ€ (The Scroll), comprises the papers of Doctorate students of this educational institution. Some of these articles represent compilations of Masterโ€™s Degree papers, prepared by the present Doctorate students, others are parts of the future Doctorate works. The research encom-passes several branches of spiritual literature (Homiletics, Dogmatics, Exegesis, Ascetics, Ecclesiastical Literature). Apart from novelties, they contain already known information which circulates in scientific spheres, results of the researches of both Georgian as well as foreign theologians. This edition also contains several Old Georgian translations of the writings belonging to great Byzantine Church Fathers which have not been published heretofore.

    ยฉ Tbilisis sasuliero akademiisa da seminariis ga momcemlobaISSN 2233-3975

  • saredaqcio kolegia

    Teologiisa da filologiis doqtori, protopresviteri giorgi zviadaZe,

    Teologiisa da filologiis doqtori, dekanozi biZina gunia, Teologiisa

    da istoriis doqtori, dekanozi giorgi guguSvili, Teologiis doqtori,

    arqidiakoni demetre daviTaSvili, istoriis doqtori, dekanozi Teimuraz

    TaTaraSvili, filologiis mecnierebaTa doqtori lela xaCiZe, bernar utie

    (samecniero kvlevaTa saxelmwifo centri, safrangeTi), maia axvlediani.

    redaqtori filologiis mecnierebaTa doqtori

    nino meliqiSvili

    Editor of the Publication Nino Melikishvili Doctor of Philological Sciences

    recenzenti filologiis mecnierebaTa doqtori

    maia rafava

    Reviewer Maia Raphava

    Doctor of Philological Sciences

  • Tbilisis sasuliero akademia da seminaria

  • s a r G e v i

    grigol bendeliani

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi ....................................... 13

    Rรฉsumรฉ .................................................................................................... 27 gamoyenebuli literatura ............................................................. 28

    saba gelaSvili

    wm. andria kriteli `sityuaยก lazaresaTยขs, oTx-dRe momkudrisa, romeli-igi aRadgina ufalman~Zveli qarTuli Targmani (teqsti da gamokvleva) ................. 31

    winasityva ............................................................................................. 33

    teqstisaTvis ..................................................................................... 35

    wmidisa da netarisa mamisa Cuenisa andria ierusalimelisa, kritel mTavarepiskoposisaยก โ€žsityuaยก lazaresaTยขs, oTx-dRe momkudrisa, romeli-igi aRadgina ufalman ....................................................... 37

    ยง I qristologiuri swavlebebi wm. andria kritelis homiliaSi โ€žlazaresaTยขsโ€œ ............................................................... 75

    ยง II zneobriv-asketuri da samoRvaweo Segonebani wm. andria kritelis homiliidan โ€žlazaresaTยขsโ€œ ...................... 83

    daskvnebi ............................................................................................... 87

  • Rรฉsumรฉ ................................................................................................... 89

    gamoyenebuli literatura ............................................................ 91

    mRvdeli nikoloz sxuluxia

    xatmebrZoleobis eresi da wmida ioane damaskelis sami apologeturi sityva xatTayvaniscemis dasacavad ............................................................................................ 95

    winasityva ............................................................................................. 97

    Sesavaliwmida ioane damaskelis cxovreba da moRvaweoba ..................... 99

    apologeturi sityvebis qarTulad naTargmni teqstebis istoria .......................................................................... 103

    Tavi I

    ยง I xatmebrZoleobis eresis warmoSoba da misi ganviTarebis pirveli etapi ........................................................ 105

    ยง II xatmebrZoleobis eresis batonobis meore periodi ......... 116

    Tavi IIยง I pirveli qristianuli xatebi da gamosaxulebebi, maTi warmomavloba, tradicia da kanonika ............................... 119

    ยง II qristianuli xatis azri da mniSvneloba .............................. 126

    Tavi III

    ยง I โ€žsityuaยก sityยขs-sagebeli maTi, romelni hgmoben wmidaTa xatTaโ€œ .................................................................................. 132

    ยง II โ€žsityuaยก wmidaTa xatTaTยขs meoreโ€œ ....................................... 147

    ยง III mesame apologeturi sityva wmida xatTa dasacavad ........................................................................................... 155

  • daskvna ................................................................................................ 164

    Rรฉsumรฉ ............................................................................................... 166

    gamoyenebuli literatura ........................................................... 168

    laSa tyebuCava

    fsevdooqropiris naTlisRebis homiliis qarTuli Targmani .......................................................................... 171

    winasityva ......................................................................................... 173

    I fsevdooqropiris naTlisRebis sakiTxavis avtorisidentifikaciis sakiTxi homiliis saRvTismetyvelo Sinaarsis konteqstSi ..................................................................... 174

    II fsevdooqropiris naTlisRebis sakiTxavis mimarTeba berZnul dedanTan ........................................................................... 194

    daskvnebi ............................................................................................ 199

    Rรฉsumรฉ ................................................................................................ 201

    gamoyenebuli literatura .......................................................... 203

    giorgi janjRava

    wminda sofron ierusalimeli โ€žsityuaยก migebebisaTยขs uflisa da RmrTisa da macxovrisa Cuenisa iesu qristesisaโ€œ .......................................................... 205

    winasityva ......................................................................................... 207

    teqstisaTvis ................................................................................... 208

    sofron ierusalimeli patriarqisa `sityuaยก migebebisaTยขs

  • uflisa da RmrTisa da macxovrisa Cuenisa ieso qristesisa~ ....................................................................................... 210 wminda sofron ierusalimelis egzegetika homiliis -โ€žsityuaยก migebebisaTยขs uflisa da RmrTisa da macxovrisa Cuenisa ieso qristesisaโ€œ mixedviT ...................... 230

    wmida sofrom ierusalimelis qristologia homiliis - `sityuaยก migebebisaTยขs uflisa da RmrTisa da macxovrisa Cuenisa ieso qristesisa~ mixedviT ....................... 247

    Rรฉsumรฉ ................................................................................................. 256

    gamoyenebuli literatura .......................................................... 258

    levan WankvetaZe

    Teodore abukuras Txzuleba โ€žgangebulebisaTยขs da ganยฃorcielebisa, da viTarmed guami vidreme ganยฃorcielda, xolo bunebaยก RmrTeebisaยก SeeerTa kacobrivsa bunebasa guamsa Sina sityยขsa RmrTisasaโ€œ ....................................................................................... 263

    Teodore abukuras swavleba gankacebulimacxovris hipostasSi ori bunebisSeerTebis Sesaxeb ............................................................................ 265

    teqstisaTvis ................................................................................... 271

    ganagebulebisaTยขs da ganยฃorcielebisa, da viTarmed guami vidre ganยฃorcielda, xolo bunebaยก RmrTeebisaยก SeeerTa kacobrivsa bunebasa guamsa Sina sityยขsa RmrTisasa ..................................... 272

    Rรฉsumรฉ ................................................................................................. 281

    gamoyenebuli literatura .......................................................... 282

  • dekanozi daviT WiRlaZe

    liturgikuli swavleba cxovelmyofeli jvris Sesaxeb .................................................................................. 283

    Rรฉsumรฉ .............................................................................................. 299

    gamoyenebuli literatura .......................................................... 300

    jaba qoiava

    uznobi avtoris leqsi uflis vnebis Sesaxeb ....................... 301

    Sesavali ........................................................................................... 302

    teqsti ............................................................................................... 303

    sulxan zarandia

    swavlaTagan wmidisa basilisTa rCeviT gamokrebulni .................................................................................. 307

    xelnawer Jer 14-Si Semavali 10 asketikuri Txzulebis Sesaxeb ........................................................................... 315

    `prologi 34~-isa da sakvlevi Txzulebis urTierTmimarTeba .......................................................................... 316

    teqstisaTvis .................................................................................... 328

    teqsti ................................................................................................. 329

    Rรฉsumรฉ ............................................................................................... 342

    gamoyenebuli literatura .......................................................... 343

  • wm. grigol feraZe

  • 13

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi

    moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    grigol bendeliani

  • grigol bendeliani

    14

    xelmZRvaneli Teologiis doqtori,

    dekanozi maqsime Wanturia

  • 15

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi

    moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    meoTxe saukune saqarTvelos eklesiisTvis, iseve rogorc sxva adgilobrivi eklesiebisTvis, Zalian mniSvnelovania da epoqaluri gardatexis periodia. am periodis saqarTveloSi, marTalia, mcire raodenobiT, magram qristianebi namdvilad cxovrobdnen. savaraudoa, rom saqarTvelos eklesiaSi, sxva adgilobrivi eklesiebis msgavsad, iqnebodnen aramarto samRvdelo xarisxis mqone sasuliero pirebi, aramed gandegili moRvaweebic. Cveni mosazrebis marTebulobaSi gvarwmunebs, aseve, meoTxe saukuneSi siriasa da kapadokiaSi arsebuli sakmaod aqtiuri monazvnuri cxovreba. siriis anu antioqiis eklesiasTan saqarTvelos eklesias ierarqiuli damokidebuleba da sakmaod axlo kavSiri hqonda, kapadokia ki qarTvelebiT dasaxlebuli adgili iyo da mezobluri urTierTobebi akavSirebda saqarTvelos mosaxleobasTan. TavisTavad cxadia, rom aRniSnuli garemoebebi didad Seuwyobda xels saqarTveloSi monazvnuri cxovrebis Camoyalibebasa da ganviTarebas.

    sanam uSualod Temaze daviwyebT saubars, aRvniSnavT, rom am sakiTxTan dakavSirebiT wm. mRvdelomowame grigoli (feraZe) wers: โ€ždaujerebeli meCveneba, rom bermonazvnoba Tavisi qveynis SigniT (saqarTveloSi g.b.) mxolod me-6 saukuneSi dawyebuliyo. me Cems naSromSi gamovTqvi varaudi, rom bermonazvnoba saqarTveloSi bevrad adre unda dawyebuliyo, magram meudabnoeobis (anaqoretobis) umkacresi formiT. es berebi cxovrobdnen samyarosgan mTlianad mowyvetilebi, sadRac udabur tyeebSi an udabnoebSi. anaqoretebis principi yvelaze popularul formad darCa qarTul bermonazvnobaSi. yvela CvenTvis nacnobi wmindani gaurbis aramarto amqveyniur samyaros, aramed Tavis TanamoZmeebsac ki. mxolod raime xilvas an romelime xelisufalis Tu keTilgonieri beris Carevas unda vumadlodeT, rom man dagvanaxa am adamianis niWi, ... Tumca amiT xalxisaTvis bevri sulieri da kulturuli Rirebuleba ikargeba. bermonazvnobis saTaveebTan CvenTan sirielebi dganan (ione zedazneli da misi mowafeebi g.b.). am

  • grigol bendeliani

    16

    mamebma Cauyares safuZveli CvenTan kenobitur cxovrebas. maT aaSenes monastrebi, romlebmac qarTveli xalxis kulturis istoriaSi Zalian didi da mniSvnelovani roli iTamaSesโ€œ(feraZe 2006: 142-144). rogorc vxedavT, wm. asureli mamebis moRvaweoba iyo kenobituri saxis da maT didi roli Seasrules eris kulturul ganviTarebaSi, daaarses samonastro kerebi, romlebic qarTuli swavla-ganaTlebis kerebic gaxdnen, amitomac qarTveli istorikosebi yovelTvis gansakuTrebul yuradRebas uTmoben maT, gansxvavebiT im anaqoretebisgan, romelTa Rvawli, rogorc aRvniSneT, idumali askeziT suliwmidis madlis moxveWaSi mdgomareobda.

    meoTxe saukuneSi saqarTvelos istoriaSi mniSvnelovani movlena moxda โ€“ mis kvlav mosaqcevad Rirsi deda nino Camovida.

    samwuxarod, Zalian mwiri cnobebi mogvepoveba meoTxe saukunis saqarTveloSi moRvawe sasuliero pirebis Sesaxeb, Tumca es mcire cnobebic sakmao warmodgenas gviqmnis saqarTveloSi arsebuli qrstianuli cxovrebis gadmosacemad.

    pirvel rigSi SevexebiT 325 wlis nikeis1 pirvel msoflio saeklesio krebas, romelsac saqarTvelodan ori episkoposi eswreboda โ€“ stratofile pitiunteli (biWvinTeli) da trapezunteli domne (domnusi) . savaraudod, isini, maTi saxelebis mixedviT, saqarTveloSi moRvawe berZeni mRvdelTmTavrebi arian.

    cota mogvianebiT saqarTveloSi vxedavT episkopos ioanesa da mRvdel iakobs sxva Tanxmleb sasuliero pirebTan erTad, romlebic imperatorma konstantinem mcxeTaSi gamoagzavna (Satberdis krebuli 1979: 322).

    aseve arsebobs mosazreba, rom saqarTveloSi imyofeboda wminda evstaTi antioqielic. amis Sesaxeb istoriis mecnierebaTa doqtori l. tyeSelaSvili wers: CvenTvis antioqiis eklesiis warsuli mniSvnelovania, radgan, Zveli qarTuli tradiciiT, ierarqiulad swored antioqiis eklesias eqvemdebareboda saqarTvelos eklesia.

    zogierTi iziarebs informacias evstaTi antioqielis saqarTveloSi mosvlis Sesaxeb. mkvlevarTa meore nawili ki amas gadaWriT uaryofs, radgan erTob saeWvod gamoiyureba is faqti, rom aRniSnuli informacia

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒœแƒ˜แƒ™แƒ”แƒโ€ƒ(แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ แƒซ.โ€ƒฮฮฏฮบฮฑฮนฮฑ,โ€ƒแƒ—แƒฃแƒ แƒฅ.โ€ƒฤฐznik)โ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒแƒซแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ‘แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ“แƒโ€ƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ–แƒแƒœแƒขแƒ˜แƒฃแƒ แƒ˜โ€ƒแƒฅแƒแƒšแƒแƒฅแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ›แƒชแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”โ€ƒแƒแƒ–แƒ˜แƒแƒจแƒ˜.โ€ƒแƒ“แƒฆแƒ”แƒกโ€ƒแƒ˜แƒ–แƒœแƒ˜แƒฅแƒ˜,โ€ƒแƒฅแƒแƒšแƒแƒฅแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ“แƒโ€ƒแƒ แƒแƒ˜แƒแƒœแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ—แƒฃแƒ แƒฅแƒ”แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒ‘แƒฃแƒ แƒกแƒแƒกโ€ƒแƒžแƒ แƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒชแƒ˜แƒแƒจแƒ˜.โ€ƒแƒฅแƒแƒšแƒแƒฅแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒแƒ‘แƒกโ€ƒแƒ˜แƒ–แƒœแƒ˜แƒฅแƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒขแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒกแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ”แƒ—โ€ƒแƒกแƒแƒœแƒแƒžแƒ˜แƒ แƒแƒ–แƒ”.

  • 17

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    mxolod XII saukuneSi Cndeba. amis Sesaxeb azrs gamoTqvamen: efrem mcire, nikon SavmTeli, arsen beri da ruis-urbnisis krebis Zegliswera. sergi gorgaZis azriT ki, pirveli mRvdelTmTavari, romelic saqarTvelom bizantiidan miiRo, evstaTi antioqieli ar yofila, aramed igi am ukanasknelis xelTdasxmuli da misive samwysos erTi wevrTagani unda yofiliyo (tyeSelaSvili 2012: 21-25). miuxedavad imisa, rom danamdvilebiT ar SegviZlia vTqvaT, iyo Tu ara wminda evstaTi saqarTveloSi namyofi, erTi faqti mainc ueWvelia โ€“ wminda evstaTis dros saqarTvelosa da antioqiis eklesiebs Soris kavSiri arsebobda.

    xsenebuli sasuliero pirebis garda, leonti mrovelis istoriaSi mravali ucnobi sasuliero piri moixsenieba.

    mirianis Zem - mefe baqarma โ€žganamravlna mRdelni da diakonniโ€œ (qarTlis cxovreba 1955: cxovreba qarTvel mefeTa), baqarisa da mis meuRlis Sesaxeb ioane rufusi wers: โ€žRvTismoSiSebis iseT simaRleze avidnen, rom isini, Tumca mefuri modgmisani iyvnen, TavianTi mefobis ganmavlobaSi monazonis asketur cxovrebas misdevdnen (georgika 1964: 249-250). mefis daxasiaTebidan vxedavT, rom qristianuli asketuri cxovreba meoTxe saukuneSi sakmaod iyo gavrcelebuli.

    es ar aris gasakviri, radganac mefe baqarma โ€žaRaSena eklesia wilknisaโ€œ (qarTlis cxovreba 1955: cxovreba qarTvel mefeTa), romlis maxlobladac aRmoCenilia samarxi, samarxi ki miuTiTebs, rom iq berTa gansasvenebeli iyo. 1979 w. arqeologiuri kvlevis centris mcxeTis arqeologiurma eqspediciam (xelmZR. a. afaqiZe) soflis aRmosavleTiT, 1,5 km-is daSorebiT IV-V ss-is akldama Seiswavla. akldamaSi qristianuli wesiT (gulaRma gaSotili, TaviT dasavleTiT) dasvenebuli iyo sudaraSi gaxveuli 8 mamakacis ConCxi. akldamis kedlebze SemorCenilia jvris gamosaxulebebi, agreTve wiTeli da Savi saRebaviT Sesrulebuli oTxpwkariani berZnuli warwera: โ€žme tikasma da berma (ฮทฯƒฯ…ฯ‡ฮฑฯƒฯ„ฮทฯ‚) , Cemma amba faranusesma gavakeTeT es akldama Tlili qvebisagan CvenTvis. papriupasi (?) isdigerdesi (?) aseve aq ganisvenebenโ€œ (yauxCiSvili T. 1982: 134-148). akldamis gverdiT gamovlinda gvianantikuri xanis ormosamarxebi da qvis samarxebi, romlebSic micvalebulebi dakrZalulni iyvnen qristianuli wesiT, Tixis sarecelze. (gamyreliZe 2011:611).

  • grigol bendeliani

    18

    mkvlevari q. diRmelaSvili samarxis Sesaxeb wers: โ€ždasavleT kedelze Sesrulebuli berZnuli warweris mixedviT, akldama vinme tikass da monastris winamZRvar faranusess auSenebiaT da gankuTvnili yofila oTxi adamianisTvis, Tumca mcire intervalis Semdeg kidev oTxi daukrZalavTโ€œ (diRmelaSvili 2012: T.II). saxelebi, romlebic realurad aris warweraSi, berZnul-romauli warmoSobis araa, magram berZnuli formiT arian gadmocemuli. savaraudod, aRdgenili saxelebi, iranuli warmoSobis unda iyos. warweris Sinaarsis, teqstis agebulebis, asoTa moxazulobis safuZvelze TariRdeba IV-V saukuniT (yauxCiSvili T. 2000: 214). wilknis samarxis arseboba, Tavisi arqeologiuri aRmoCenebiT, naTlad metyvelebs, rom meoTxe saukunis saqarTveloSi monazvnuri cxovreba arsebobda, sadac isaqisti mamebi jgufurad moRvaweoben.

    baqaris memkvidrem - mirdatma - โ€ždaadginna mRdelni moZRurad klarjTaโ€œ da mis cxovrebaSi moxseniebuli aris episkoposi iakobi da episkoposi iobi (qarTlis cxovreba 1955: cxovreba qarTvel mefeTa). mirdati varaz-baqarma Secvala . varaz-baqaris Semdeg taxtze adis misi simamri Trdati, โ€žda amis-ze mokuda episkoposi iakob, da dasua mis wil eliaโ€œ (qarTlis cxovreba 1955: cxovreba qarTvel mefeTa).

    aseve, unda aRiniSnos, rom 381 wlis konstantinepolis msoflio saeklesio krebaze damswre pirebs Soris meufe anania (jafariZe) qarTvel episkoposebsac asaxelebs: โ€žmeore msoflio krebis kanonebs qarTvelma episkoposma pantofilem moawera xeli. Cvenamde moRweulia II msoflio krebis xelismomwer 150 episkoposTa sia, maT Sorisaa โ€žponto amisiis olqidan pantofile iberieliโ€œ. zogierT xelnawerSi pantofiles nacvlad weria โ€žponsife iberieliโ€œ an โ€žpasifil iberieliโ€œ. am krebis xelismomweri episkoposebi qalaqebis eTnikuri kuTvnilebis da saxelwodebebis mixedviT moixsenebian, aseve amis mixedviT, rogorc Cans, berZnul-romauli kulturuli arealis gareT mcxovreb xalxTa episkoposebs zogjer eTnikuri saxelebiT moixseniebdnen. iberebi anu qarTvelebi aRniSnul dros cxovrobdnen mTel aRmosavleT SavizRvispireTSi. iberebi, cxadia, cxovrobdnen ponto amisiis olqSic. xmelTaSuazRvispireTidan Savi zRvis aRmosavleT sanapiromde vrceli regionebi dasaxlebuli iyo qarTvelTa jgufebiT. maTgan iyo pantofile iberieli Tu saqarTvelodan (politikuri iberiidan),

  • 19

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    CvenTvis ucnobiaโ€œ (jafariZe 2003: Tavi II). sainteresoa, meoTxe saukunis cnobili asketi evagre pontoeli (346-

    399), romlis qarTuli warmoSoba berZnul da koptur literaturaSia damowmebuli (kekeliZe 1960:544). e. WeliZe amis Sesaxeb wers: sxva rom araferi, qarTvel mkvlevarTa azriT, es pirovneba, SesaZloa, kapadokieli mamebis msgavsad saqarTvelosTan dakavSirebuli yofiliyo genetikurad, Tumca evagre pontoeli gaxlavT bizantieli avtori (WeliZe, video saubari : 292).

    rac Seexeba mexuTe saukunis saqarTvelos, miuxedavad, qveynis politikurad rTuli mdgomareobisa, aq aqtiuri qristianuli cxovreba iyo da am saukuneSi moRvawe sedarebiT meti qarTveli sasuliero piria cnobili.

    mexuTe saukuneSi saqarTvelos ramdenime gamorCeuli mefe hyavda, magram qarTuli eklesiis winaSe yvelaze didi damsaxureba wminda vaxtang gorgasals miuZRvis. swored mefeTa cxovrebis aRweraSi mraval pirdapir da irib miTiTebas vxvdebiT saqarTveloSi moRvawe sasuliero pirebis Sesaxeb. zogierTi maTgani saxeldebiT aris moxseniebuli, zogierTi ki - saxelis gareSe.

    mexuTe saukunis dasawyisSi mirdati gamefda, mis dros โ€ždaipyres qarTliโ€ƒsparsTa,โ€ƒ...โ€ƒxoloโ€ƒnaTesavniโ€ƒmefeTaniโ€ƒdarCesโ€ƒแƒดevsaโ€ƒkaxeTisasa,โ€ƒdaโ€ƒsแƒณmonโ€ƒepiskoposiโ€ƒmaTโ€ƒTana-veโ€œโ€ƒ(qarTlisโ€ƒcxovrebaโ€ƒ1955:โ€ƒcxovrebaโ€ƒqarTvel mefeTa).

    misi memkidre arCili gaxda, man โ€žyovelsa qarTlsa Sina ganamravlna mRdelni da diakonni da msaxurni eklesiaTaniโ€œ (qarTlis cxovreba 1955: cxovreba qarTvel mefeTa). sainteresoa, vin igulisxmeba eklesiis msaxurebSi? eseni ar arian arc episkoposebi da, TavisTavad, arc mRvdlebi da diakvnebi. aq mematiane gulisxmobs maTze dabal safexurze myof eklesiis msaxurebs; SesaZloa, aq igulisxmebodnen kerZo-diakvnebi an wignismkiTxvelni, an saerTodac samonazvno dasi, radgan monazvnebi aucileblad iqnebodnen mexuTe saukunis saqarTveloSi.

    arCilis Semdeg ki samefo taxtze wminda vaxtang gorgaslis mama - mirdati avida, romelmac sagduxti moiyvana colad. โ€žsagduxt dedofalman gamoikiTxa sjuli qristesi: rameTu qmarman misman mohguarna kacni sjulisa mecnierni, da uTargmanes saxareba uflisa

  • grigol bendeliani

    20

    Cuenisa ieso qristesiโ€œ (qarTlis cxovreba 1955:cxovreba vaxtan gorgaslisa). aRniSnul istoriaSi yuradRebas ipyrobs dedofalTan misuli rjulis mecnierni, romlebmac dedofals saxareba uTargmnes. vin iyven sjulis mecnierebi? savaraudod, eseni RmrTivganbrZnobili adamianebi iyvnen, romlebic, im periodis samefo karTan daaxloebuli sasuliero pirebisgan gansxvavebiT, sulierebis ufro maRal safexurze idgnen, amitomac aseTi mniSvnelovani saqmisTvis, rogoricaa dedoflis gaqristianeba da WeSmarit gzaze moqceva, samefo kari am adamianebs mouwodebs. gasaTvaliswinebelia, rom arc arCil mefe da arc misi Ze mirdati, romlebic sakmaod arian ganswavluli saRvTo sjulSi, aseve arc mravali episkoposi Tu sasuliero piri, romelic im periodSi samefo karis irgvliv msaxurobda, ar cdilobda am misiis Sesrulebas, aramed am misias sjulis mecnierebs akisrebda. am adamianebma dedofals โ€žuTargmanesโ€œ anu ganumartes saxareba. TiTqmis SeuZlebelia, rom aRniSnul sjulis mecnierebSi ganswavluli saero mecnierebi vigulisxmoT, romlebic qristianuli mwignobrobiT iqnebodnen dakavebulni, radganac am periodSi qristianuli mwignobruli mecniereba aseT doneze naklebsavaraudoa, rom yofiliyo. swored sagduxtma moiwvia saberZneTidan miqael episkoposi (qarTlis cxovreba 1955:cxovreba vaxtang gorgaslisa).

    vaxtangis mefobisas ki mefe sabrZolo eqspediciaSi wminda grigol RvTismetyvelis mowafeebs: petre mRvdelsa da samoel monazons gaicnobs da maT saqarTveloSi wamoiyvans. Semdeg wminda mefe cdilobs saeklesio damoukideblobis mopovebas da am mizniT saqarTveloSi antioqiidan kidev 12 episkoposi Camodis. โ€žantioqelman patriaqman akurTxna Tormetni episkoposni... mcxeTas mefeman vaxtang aRaSena eklesia mociqulTa, sueti cxoveli, da mun Sina dasues petre kaTalikosad da samoel episkoposad mcxeTasave saepiskopososa. da dasua erTi episkoposad klarjeTs, eklesiasa axizisasa; erTi artans, eruSeTs; erTi - javaxeTs, wundas; erTi - mangliss; erTi - bolniss; erTi - rusTavs; erTi - ninowmidas, ujarmis karsa, romeli gorgasalsa aReSena; erTi - Werems, missave aRSenebulsa; erTi - CeleTs; erTi - xornabujs da erTi - agaraks, romel ars xunans gamarTebiT. Semdgomad missa aRaSena eklesia niqozisa sagzebelsa Tana cecxlisasa. da dasua episkoposi, sada-igi efla guami wmidisa

  • 21

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    raJdenisi, romeli iwama sparsTa mier wyobasa vaxtangissaโ€œ (qarTlis cxovreba 1955:cxovreba vaxtang gorgaslisa).

    rogorc vxedavT, wminda mefem ramdenime axali saepiskoposo daaarsa da axlad nakurTxi episkoposebi iq dasva. es kaTedrebia:

    1) klarjeTSi - axizis kaTedra. dakavSirebulia axizis cixesTan, romelic wminda vaxtangma ganaaxla. mdebareobs TurqeTSi, mdinare artanujiswylis marcxena napirze.

    2) eruSeTSi - artaanis kaTedra. axlandeli TurqeTis saxelmwifoSi. moicavda teritorias arsianis qedsa da nialis vels Soris.

    3) javaxeTSi โ€“ wundis kaTedra; wunda โ€“ istoriuli qalaqi javaxeTSi, misi uZvelesi centri. axlandeli aspinZis raionis sof. naqalaqevisa da mis mimdebare teritoriaze.

    4) manglisi โ€“ daba TeTriwyaros municipalitetSi, mdebareobs TrialeTis qedis samxreT kalTaze, mdinare algeTis marcxena napirze.

    5) bolnisi โ€“ qvemo qarTlis centralur nawilSi mdebareobs. 6) rusTavi โ€“ rusTavi qvemo qarTlis mxaris yvelaze msxvili

    qalaqia. qarTlis cxovrebis uZvelesi avtori leonti mroveli qalaq rusTavis mSeneblobas qarTvelTa winapris, qarTlosis cols miawers. rusTavis istoriaSi mniSvnelovani cvlilebebi moxda IV saukunis meore naxevridan.

    7) ninowmindaSi โ€“ ujarmis karTan. ujarma โ€“ istoriuli cixe-qalaqi saqarTveloSi. mdebareobs sofel ujarmis CrdiloeTiT 4 km-is daSorebiT, mdinare ivris marjvena napirze. vaxtangma ujarma Tavis erT-erT rezidenciad aqcia, swored iq aResrula wminda mefe.

    8) Weremi โ€“ mdebareobs gurjaanis raionSi, gomboris qedis Crdilo-aRmosavleT kalTaze. qalaqi V saukuneSi daaarsa mefe vaxtang gorgasalma . V saukunis bolos, iranis jaris mier darbevis Semdeg ufro daqveiTda.

    9) CeleTi anu JaleTi โ€“ mdebareobda amJamad daba sionis wyliT datboril midamoebSi.

    10) xornabuji โ€“ istoriuli qarTlis samefos erT-erTi provinciis, kambeCovanis centri. xornabujis nangrevebi SemorCenilia axlandeli dedoflis wyaros raionuli centris maxloblad.

    11) agaraki, romelic xunanis pirdapiraa. xunani โ€“ mxare istoriul

  • grigol bendeliani

    22

    aRmosavleT saqarTveloSi, moicavda teritorias mdinareebis pasansusa da ZegamCais Soris (axlandeli azerbaijanis teritoria).

    12) niqozi. sofeli aRmosavleT saqarTveloSi, Sida qarTlis mxaris goris municipalitetSi. goridan 30 kilometri. niqozi daarsa vaxtang gorgasalma warmarTuli salocavis adgilze, sadac dakrZaluli iyo sparselebisagan wamebuli raJdeni.

    mexuTe saukunis qarTlis eklesiis meTaurebis Semdegi sia gvaqvs: svimeon I daaxl. V s.-is dasawyisidan 20-ian wlebamde, Semdeg - mose, iona, ieremia, grigol I, basil I, mobidani, iovel I, miqael I, da petre I - qarTlis pirveli kaTalikosi, romelic samoel I Secvala (ssek 2011:10).

    aRsaniSnavia, rom mexuTe saukunis moRvawis, wminda SuSanikis cxovrebaSic vxedavT ramdenime sasuliero pirs, naSromis avtori - iakob xucesi, afoc episkoposs axsenebs, romelic pitiaxSis saxlis episkoposadaa moxseniebuli da aRniSnavs, rom episkoposi im dros iq ar imyofeboda โ€“ wasuli iyo viRac wminda kacis saxlSi an monasterSi da iakobic Tan axlda: โ€žxolo episkoposi ... afoc, ara mun iyo, aramed vanad kacisa visame wmidisa misrul iyo kiTxvad raแƒฒsameโ€ƒsityแƒณsa.โ€ƒdaโ€ƒmeca,โ€ƒxucesiโ€ƒdedoflisaโ€ƒSuSanikisi,โ€ƒTanavhyvandiโ€ƒepiskopossa masโ€œ (WeliZe 2005 : 5-8). aRniSnuli wminda kaci Cveni varaudiT, aris didi sulieri gamocdilebis mqone beri, romelsac episkoposi sulier rCevas ekiTxeboda, da romelsac SeiZleba im dros ecxovra an saxlSi an monasterSi, radgan, rogorc e. WeliZe aRniSnavs, sityva โ€žvaniโ€œ saxlsac niSnavs da monastersac (WeliZe 2005: 50-51). aRniSnul sakiTxs exeba mkvlevari a. jiqiac, igi ambobs, rom es โ€žwminda kaciโ€œ yovelgvari saeklesio xarisxis gareSea moxseniebuli. saeklesio xarisxis SemTxvevaSi iakobi mas aucileblad Sesabamisi tituliT moixseniebda, โ€“ rogorc mas Cvevia, magram aq mas ucnobi ubralod โ€žwminda kacadโ€œ hyavs moxseniebuli (jiqia 2010:159-162). am mosazrebas Cvenc viziarebT da vTvliT, rom es โ€žwminda kaciโ€œ mexuTe saukunis saqarTveloSi moRvawe erT-erTi anaqoretia. garda amisa, wminda SuSanikis cxovrebaSi moxseniebulni eseni arian: samoel da ioane episkoposebi (WeliZe 2005: 19).

    sagulisxmoa, rom mexuTe saukuneSi ori msoflio saeklesio kreba gaimarTa da orive maTganSi qarTveli episkoposebis monawileoba

  • 23

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    dasturdeba: 431 wlis efesos krebis momzadebaSi monawileoba miuRia egreTwodebuli qarTlis โ€žsparsuli nawilisโ€œ episkopos ieremias. โ€žiberieli ieremiaโ€œ yofila nestorianelTa winaaRmdeg mebrZoli. Tavis Tavs igi ase uwodebs: โ€žieremia urhaeli, qarTveli marTlmadidebeli, yaribobis gamo Tavisianebsa da samSoblos daSorebuliโ€œ (jafariZe 2003: T. III). rac Seexeba meoTxe msoflio saeklesio krebas: zogierTi cnobiT qalkedonis krebis muSaobaSi monawileoba miuRia sebastopolis (nikofsiis) episkoposs. qalkedonis krebis xelismomwer episkoposTa Soris aseve dasaxelebulia โ€žatarve trapezunteliโ€œ. maSasadame, istoriuli saqarTvelodan qalkedonis krebas ori episkoposi eswreboda (jafariZe 2003: T. IV).

    sainteresoa, rom IV-V ss-Si qarTvel sasuliero pirTa da asketTa moRvaweobis kvali wminda miwaze da antioqiaSic sCans.

    wminda mefe mirians, ierusalimSi piligrimobis dros, imperator konstantinesgan ierusalimis maxloblad samSeneblo adgili miuRia da iq jvris monasteri augia. jvris monastris meoTxe saukuneSi qarTvelTa mflobelobas sxvadasxva wyaroebze dayrdnobiT adasturebs wminda grigol feraZe sakuTar naSromSi โ€žucxoel piligrimTa cnobebi qarTveli berebisa da qarTuli monastrebis Sesaxebโ€œ da wminda kirion saZagliSvili naSromSi - โ€živeriis kulturuli roli ruseTis istoriaSiโ€œ (kirioni 2009: 25). e. gabiZaSvili wers: โ€žpalestinis IV-V saukuneebis monastrebSi qarTvelTa moRvaweobis faqti eWvs ar iwvevsโ€œ (gabiZaSvili 2010a:19), sxvagan ki, timoTe gabaSvilis cnobis Tanaxmad, aRniSnavs, rom saqarTvelos urTierTobas palestinasTan uZvelesi tradiciebi aqvs. timoTe gabaSvilis cnobiT, jvaris monastris adgili moipova wminda ninos mier ierusalimSi wargzavnilma mirian mefem (gabiZaSvili 2010b:56). samwuxarod, CvenTvis ar aris cnobili IV saukunis palestinaSi moRvawe sasuliero pirebis saxelebi.

    am movlenebidan aSkaraa, rom wminda miwaze qarTvelTa ltolvas wmida ninos dros unda Cahyroda safuZveli, mexuTe saukuneSi ki es mogzauroba aqtiur fazaSi gadadis, amis naTeli dadasturebaa wminda SuSanikis martvilobaSi arsebuli movlena, kerZod, saubaria im faqtze, rodesac dedofalTan sparsi mogvi qali midis da misgan gankurnebas iTxovs. wminda dedofali mas qristianobaze moaqcevs da etyvis:โ€ƒโ€žmivedโ€ƒierusalแƒฑmdโ€ƒdaโ€ƒganswmidneโ€ƒganborebisaโ€ƒmagisganโ€ƒSenisaโ€œโ€ƒ

  • grigol bendeliani

    24

    (WeliZe 2005:26).mexuTe saukuneSi ucxoeTSi myof qarTvelTagan yvelaze metad

    petre iberma gaiTqva saxeli. petre iberis anu murvanos ufliswulis Sesaxeb biografiul cnobebs vpoulobT leonti mrovelis mefeTa cxovrebaSi, ioane rufusTan da zaqarias avtorobiT Sesrulebul naSromSi. am cnobebis Tanaxmad, is qarTveli ufliswuli iyo. murvanosi dabadebula 411 wels (sxva mosazrebiT โ€“ 409 wels) (jafariZe 2001: T. II). konstantinepolSi mZevlad myofi murvanosi ramdenime qarTvelTan erTad palestinaSi gaipara. maT Soris miTridate lazisa da zaqaria qarTvelis yofna wyaroebiTaa dadasturebuli. juanSeris Tanaxmad: โ€žSemdgomad amissa saflavsa uflisasa miiwivnes, da mun aRkuecil iqmnes monazonebad da aRaSennes monasterni da qsenoniโ€œ (qarTlis cxovreba 1955: cxovreba vaxtang gorgaslisa).

    petre iberma da ioane lazma ierusalimsa da palestinaSi ramdenime monasteri aaSenes, agreTve โ€“ egvipteSic (jafariZe 2001:T.III). petre ibers hyavda sxvadasxva erovnebis mimdevrebi, maT Soris qarTvelebic, romelTac samSoblodan petresTan CahqondaT ambebi. mis mierve agebul sastumro saxlSi maspinZlobda Tvistom piligrimebs, aarsebda maTTvis savaneebs, tovebda iq qarTulad Sedgenil memorialur nawerebs. igi 490 wels zRvispira q. iamnias gareubanSi gardaicvala (xurcilava 2018: 35). samwuxarod, am monastrebSi moRvawe qarTvelebis saxelebic ar aris cnobili.

    unda aRiniSnos, rom wminda miwaze mravalma qarTvelma imogzaura da SeZlebisdagvarad Seiswavla iq arsebuli qarTuli monastrebis kvali. am mxriv didi wvlili gaswies wminda grigol feraZem, al. cagarelma da mravalma sxvam.

    cagareli wers: aRsaniSnavia, rom mexuTe saukuneSi wminda miwaze arsebobda ara erTi qarTuli monasteri, sadac iyo saxli stumrebisTvis da sadac SeiZleba yofiliyo mTargmnelobiTi saqmianoba, rac Zalian esaWiroebodaโ€ƒmaSindelโ€ƒqarTulโ€ƒeklesiasโ€ƒ(ะฆะฐะณะฐั€ะตะปะธโ€ƒ1888:โ€ƒ37).

    wminda grigol feraZec wminda miwaze qarTvelebis aqtiuri moRvaweobis sakmaod mniSvnelovan cnobebs gvawvdis, kerZod: uflis saflavis eklesiisken mimaval gzaze mravali Zveli monasteria. ramdenime aseTi monastris gverdiT unda Camevlo. pirveli quCa marcxniv, patara borcvze gadadis da franciskanelTa monastrisken mivyavarT.

  • 25

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    am monasters โ€žsan salvadoresโ€œ eZaxian. franciskelebi ar uaryofen im faqts, rom igi erT dros qarTvelebs ekuTvnoda. savaraudoa, rom es aris yvelaze Zveli qarTuli monasteri, daarsebuli me-5 saukuneSi petre iberis mier (feraZe 2016: T.3).

    aRsaniSnavia, rom meeqvse saukuneSi imperatorma iustinianem wminda miwaze 20 monasteri aRadgina, maTgan erT-erTi qarTuli iyo, aqedan gamomdinare, a. cagareli askvnis, rom Tuki meeqvse saukunis monasters aRdgena esaWiroeboda, maSin is gacilebiT adre unda yofiliyo aSenebuli (ะฆะฐะณะฐั€ะตะปะธ 1888: 37).

    wminda miwaze qarTveli berebis moRvaweobis Sesaxeb sakmaod saintereso kvleva awarmoa b. xurcilavam, romlis naSromic - โ€žqarTvelTa nakvalevi wminda miwazeโ€œ sakmaod mniSvnelovan cnobebs gvawvdis. igi istoriul da arqeologiur wyaroebze dayrdnobiT wers: israeleli arqeologebi, faqtiurad, yovlewliurad axal-axal aRmoCenebs akeTeben, erT-erTi maTgania monasteri -โ€žfurtaโ€œ, romelic 2002-2004 wlebSi ierusalimis SemogarenSi, umm leisunad wodebul arabul dasaxlebaSi arqeologis, j. zeligmanis mier warmoebuli gaTxrebisas aRmoCnda. es monasteri me-7 saukuneSi daiqca. arqeologiurma gaTxrebma mraval sxva mniSvnelovan masalasTan erTad akldamac aRmoaCina. akldamaSi gamovlinda qvis filaze amoRaruli asomTavruliโ€ƒwarwera:โ€ƒโ€žeseโ€ƒsamarxoแƒฒโ€ƒiohaneโ€ƒfurtavelโ€ƒโ€ƒepiskoposisaแƒฒโ€ƒqarTvelisaแƒฒโ€œ,โ€ƒ romelicโ€ƒ me-5-6โ€ƒ saukuneebiTโ€ƒ daTariRdaโ€ƒ (xurcilavaโ€ƒ2018: 41-45).

    aRsaniSnavia, rom mexuTe saukuneSi qarTvelebi antioqiaSic arian. netari Teodorite kvireli wminda svimeon mesvetis (ufrosi) cxovrebaSi aRniSnavs: โ€žwminda svimeonTan mravali adamiani midioda, ara mxolod Cveni qveynis mcxovrebni, aramed ismaitelebic, sparselebic da maTi xelqveiTi somxebic da iberielebicโ€œ (ะคะตะพะดะพั€ะธั‚ ะšะธั€ัะบะธะน 1996: XXVI, 11).

    aRniSnul sakiTxze msjelobs d. kldiaSvili, igi wers: โ€žqarTvelebis xSir mimosvlaze (igulisxmeba antioqis; โ€“ g.b.) da wminda svimeonisadmi gansakuTrebul damokidebulebaze aseve miuTiTebs is gamorCeuli Tayvaniscema, romelsac adgili hqonia saqarTveloSi. amis damadasturebelia rogorc garejuli saxviTi tradicia (wm. svimeonis freskuli gamosaxulebebi), aseve arqeologiuri masala โ€“

  • grigol bendeliani

    26

    vercxlis medalioni wm. svimeonis da marTas gamosaxulebebiT garejis monastrebidan. am medalionis msgavsi nimuSebi jer kidev wm. svimeonis sicocxleSi didi raodenobiT mzaddeboda sakvirvel mTaze da iq Casuli mlocvelebisTvis umniSvnelovanes evlogias warmoadgenda (kldiaSvili 2001:84).

    wminda miwaze qarTvel berTa aqtiurad moRvaweobis Sesaxeb wminda saba ganwmedilis cxovrebidanac vigebT. wminda saba ganwmedili sikvdilis win (532 w.) daweril anderZSi sagangebod aRniSnavs, rom mis monasterSi โ€žiberielebicโ€œ arian (โ€žliturgikuli xelnawerebiโ€œ). meeqvse saukuneSi wminda miwaze sakmaod mravali qarTveli beri moRvaweobs, romlebsac sakuTar mSbliur enaze sxvadasxva saRvTismsaxuro wignebic aqvT. meoTxe saukuneSi dawyebuli qarTul-palestinuri kavSiri gagrZelebuli da sakmaod gaZlierebulia.

    aRniSnuli movlenebi adasturebs, rom ara marto saqarTveloSi, aramed mis sazRvrebs gareTac uamravi sasuliero piri da monazoni moRvaweobda.

  • 27

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    Georgian clergymen who in the 4th-5th centuries

    resided and worked beyond Georgia

    Rรฉsumรฉ

    Many Georgian and foreign historical records contain ac-

    counts about the lives and activities of Georgian clergymen

    who resided and worked in Georgia and beyond her in the

    4th-5th centuries. It should be noted that the names of many

    of them are known to us but those of many others are not.

    Besides the lives of bishops and clergy, various historical re-

    cords and archaeological discoveries testify to a dynamic life

    and labour of monks and nuns in this period. In effect, the

    Church in Georgia was very strong in the 4th-5th centuries

    and many of the Georgian clergy lived in the Holy Land and

    in Antioch.

  • grigol bendeliani

    28

    gamoyenebuli literatura

    1. gabiZaSvili 2010 a - gabiZaSvili enriko. โ€žSromebi, I tomiโ€œ. Tbilisi, 2010 w.

    2. gabiZaSvili 2010 b - gabiZaSvili enriko. โ€žSromebi, II tomiโ€œ. Tbilisi, 2010 w.

    3. gamyreliZe 2011 - qarTlis cxovrebis topoarqeologiuri leqsikoni. Seadgina g. gamyreliZem, Tbilisi, 2011 w.

    4. georgika 1964 - georgika t. II. gamosca simon yauxCiSvilma. Tbilisi, 1964 w.

    5. kekeliZe 1960 - kekeliZe korneli, Zveli qarTuli literaturis isto-ria, tomi I, Zveli mwerloba. Tbilisi, 1960 w.

    6. kirioni 2009 - kirion episkoposi, โ€živeriis kulturuli roli ruseTis istoriaSiโ€œ. gamosacemad momzadda Semoqmedis dedaTa monasterSi arqi-mandrit nikolozis (Rlonti) locva-kurTxeviT. 2009 w.

    7. kldiaSvili 2001 - samonastro cxovreba udabnoSi - gareja da qris-tianuli aRmosavleTi. saerTaSoriso simpoziumis masalebi, Tbilisis universiteti, 2000 wlis seqtemberi. garejis kvlevis centri. Sromebi. xelmZR. z. sxirtlaZe. Tbilisi, 2001 w.

    8. sek 2011 - saqarTvelos eklesiis kalendari 2012. saqarTvelos sapatri-arqos gamomcemloba. Tbilisi, 2011 w.

    9. tyeSelaSvili 2012 - tyeSelaSvili levan. saqarTvelos eklesiis avtoke-faliis istoriis ZiriTadi sakiTxebi. quTaisi, 2012 w.

    10. feraZe 2006 - wminda mRvdelmowame grigol feraZe, bermonazvnobis dasawyisi saqarTveloSi - T. WumburiZis gamokvleviT da redaqciiT. Tbilisi, 2006 w.

    11. feraZe 2016 - feraZe grigol, ieriqonis vardebi, wminda miwasa da siriSi mogzaurobis dRiuri. red. T. mgalobliSvili, Tbilisi, 2016 w.

    12. yauxCaSvili 2000 - yauxCaSvili TinaTin, saqarTvelos, berZnuli warwerebis korpusi. Tbilisi, 2000 w.

  • 29

    IV-V saukuneebis saqarTveloSi da ucxoeTSi moRvawe qarTveli sasuliero pirebi

    13. Satberdis krebuli 1979 - Satberdis krebuli X saukunisa, b. gigin-eiSvilisa da e. giunaSvilis gamocema. Tbilisi, 1979 w.

    14. WeliZe 1996 - WeliZe ediSer, wminda grigol palama, wminda mTis tomosi memyudroeTa Sesaxeb, Jurnali โ€œgza sameufoโ€, N 1(4). 1996 w.

    15. WeliZe 2005 - Zveli qarTuli saeklesio literatura, t. I. Zeglebi Targmna, gamosacemad moamzada da sqolioebi daurTo ediSer WeliZem. gamomcemloba โ€žaxali ivironiโ€œ. Tbilisi 2005 w.

    16. xurcilava 2018 - xurcilaba beJan, qarTvelTa nakvalevi wminda miwaze, Tbilisi 2018.

    17. jafariZe 2003 - mitropoliti jafariZe anania, โ€žmsoflio saeklesio krebebi qarTvel episkoposTa monawileobiTโ€œ. Tbilisi, 2003 w.

    18. jafariZe 2001 - mitropoliti jafariZe anania, petre iberi - marTl-madidebeli episkoposi. Tbilisi, 2001 w.

    19. jiqia 2010 - jiqia a., religiis istoriis sakiTxebi, I, Tbilisi, 2010 w.

    20. ะฆะฐะณะฐั€ะตะปะธ 1888 - ะฆะฐะณะฐั€ะตะปะธ ะ. ะŸะฐะผัั‚ะฝะธะบะธ ะณั€ัƒะทะธะฝัะบะพะน ัั‚ะฐั€ะธะฝั‹ ะฒ ะกะฒัั‚ะพะน ะ—ะตะผะปะต ะธ ะฝะฐ ะกะธะฝะฐะต, ะกะฐะฝะบั‚-ะŸะตั‚ะตั€ะฑัƒั€ะณ 1888.

  • grigol bendeliani

    30

    internetresursebi

    1. diRmelaSvili 2012 - diRmelaSvili q., qristianuli simbolika I-VI ss-is saqarTveloSi. Tbilisi, 2012. saunje. ge

    2. โ€žliturgikuli xelnawerebiโ€œ - โ€žliturgikuli xelnawerebiโ€œ, xelnawerTa erovnuli centris ZiriTadi bibliografia, geomanuscript.ge

    3. moqcevaแƒฒโ€ƒ qarTlisaแƒฒโ€ƒ 1979โ€ƒ -โ€ƒ moqcevaแƒฒโ€ƒ qarTlisaแƒฒ,โ€ƒ Satberdisโ€ƒ krebulisโ€ƒ1979 wlis gamocemidan. http://www.amsi.ge/

    4. qarTlis cxovreba - qarTlis cxovreba. simon yauxCiSvilis gamocema. tomi 1. Tbilisi 1955 w. Amsi.ge

    5. javaxiSvili 1979 - javaxiSvili ivane, qarTveli eris istoria, t I, Tbilisis universitetis gamomcemloba, 1979 w. www. Amsi.ge

    6. ะคะตะพะดะพั€ะธั‚ ะšะธั€ัะบะธะน 1996: ะ‘ะปะฐะถะตะฝะฝั‹ะน ะคะตะพะดะพั€ะธั‚ ะšะธั€ัะบะธะน. ะ˜ัั‚ะพั€ะธั ะ‘ะพะณะพะปัŽะฑั†ะตะฒ, ะธะปะธ ะŸะพะฒะตัั‚ะฒะพะฒะฐะฝะธะต ะพ ัะฒัั‚ั‹ั… ะฟะพะดะฒะธะถะฝะธะบะฐั…. ะŸะฐะปะพะผะฝะธะบ 1996. www. Azbyka.ru

    7. qarTvel wmidanTa cxovrebani - โ€žqarTvel wmidanTa cxovrebaniโ€œ, Tbili-si, 2004 w. Orthodoxy.ge

    8. WeliZe, videosaubari - WeliZe ediSer, 257โ€“e radiosaubari qristianuli literaturis Sesaxeb. library.church.ge

    9. WeliZe, videosaubari - WeliZe ediSer, 292-e videosaubari evagre pon-toelis Sesaxeb. library.church.ge

  • 31

    saba gelaSvili

    wm. andria kriteli

    `sityuaY lazaresaTKs, oTx-dRe momkudrisa,

    romeli-igi aRadgina ufalman~

    Zveli qarTuli Targmani

    (teqsti da gamokvleva)

  • 32

    xelmZRvaneli filologiis mecnierebaTa

    doqtori nino meliqiSvili

  • wm. andria kriteli `sityuaA lazaresaTYs...~

    33

    winasityva1

    แƒ˜แƒ› แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒแƒš แƒแƒ•แƒขแƒแƒ แƒ—แƒ แƒจแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒแƒช แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜ แƒ แƒแƒšแƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒแƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒก

    แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒšแƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒ แƒแƒขแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒแƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒจแƒ˜, แƒ”แƒ แƒ—-แƒ”แƒ แƒ— แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒฉแƒ”แƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ˜แƒšแƒก แƒ˜แƒ™แƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก แƒฌแƒ›. แƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ แƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ (660-740 แƒฌแƒฌ.). แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜ แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ’แƒแƒ แƒช แƒฉแƒแƒœแƒก, แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒ›แƒแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒแƒฆแƒแƒšแƒ˜ แƒแƒ แƒแƒขแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒœแƒ˜แƒญแƒ˜แƒ— แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒฅแƒ›แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜. แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜แƒœแƒ˜ แƒšแƒแƒ›แƒแƒ–แƒ˜, แƒ“แƒแƒฎแƒ•แƒ”แƒฌแƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜ แƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ— แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ˜แƒ แƒฉแƒ”แƒ•แƒ. แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒแƒ แƒกแƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒ˜แƒ•แƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒจแƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒ–แƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒ แƒฆแƒ แƒ›แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฆแƒ•แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ›แƒ”แƒขแƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ–แƒœแƒ”แƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒ˜แƒ•-แƒแƒกแƒ™แƒ”แƒขแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜ แƒกแƒฌแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜. แƒ˜แƒ› แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒ—แƒ แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒกแƒ˜ แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒช แƒฌแƒ›. แƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ แƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒšแƒก แƒ”แƒ™แƒฃแƒ—แƒ•แƒœแƒ˜แƒก, แƒ“แƒฆแƒ”แƒ›แƒ“แƒ” แƒฏแƒ”แƒ  แƒ™แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ• แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฃแƒชแƒ”แƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒ.

    แƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ” แƒœแƒแƒจแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒจแƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ แƒฌแƒ›. แƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ แƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒก แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ—แƒแƒšแƒ˜ แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒ”แƒ‘: โ€žแƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒฒ แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก, แƒแƒ—แƒฎ-แƒ“แƒฆแƒ” แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒแƒฆแƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ˜แƒœแƒ แƒฃแƒคแƒแƒšแƒ›แƒแƒœโ€œ2. แƒ—แƒฎแƒ–แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒ˜ แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒฆแƒฌแƒ”แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒแƒ—แƒฎแƒ˜ แƒœแƒฃแƒกแƒฎแƒ แƒฃแƒซแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒกแƒ˜แƒ - XI-XIII แƒกแƒแƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒซแƒ”แƒ’แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒก แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒœ.

    แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ แƒฃแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒฅแƒ›แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜ แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒฎแƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒžแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ“แƒจแƒ˜, แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒก แƒจแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ—แƒก. แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒแƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒ—แƒ•แƒแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—, แƒ˜แƒก แƒ˜แƒแƒแƒœแƒ”แƒก แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก XI แƒ—แƒแƒ•แƒจแƒ˜ แƒ’แƒแƒ“แƒ›แƒแƒชแƒ”แƒ›แƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ›แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก แƒ”แƒฎแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ—แƒแƒšแƒ˜ แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒ”แƒ‘.

    แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ˜ แƒžแƒ˜แƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ“ แƒกแƒแƒ› แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒจแƒ”แƒ˜แƒซแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ“แƒแƒ˜แƒงแƒแƒก: แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒ˜, แƒซแƒ˜แƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ“แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒ“แƒแƒกแƒ™แƒ•แƒœแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ˜ แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜.

    1. แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒ˜ แƒซแƒแƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒœ แƒ›แƒแƒ™แƒšแƒ”แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒซแƒ˜แƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ“แƒ˜ แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒก แƒ—แƒฎแƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒ•แƒแƒ›แƒ–แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก. แƒแƒฅ แƒแƒ•แƒขแƒแƒ แƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ”แƒฃแƒš แƒ›แƒแƒซแƒฆแƒ•แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒก แƒฎแƒแƒขแƒแƒ•แƒœแƒแƒ“ แƒแƒ“แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก แƒ›แƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒช แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒขแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ แƒ›แƒกแƒฃแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒก แƒฃแƒจแƒฃแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒแƒ แƒฌแƒงแƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒก.

    2.แƒซแƒ˜แƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ“แƒ˜ แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒแƒแƒœแƒ”แƒก แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก 11, 1-44 แƒ›แƒแƒœแƒแƒ™แƒ•แƒ”แƒ—แƒ˜แƒก แƒฆแƒ แƒ›แƒ แƒ”แƒ’แƒ–แƒ”แƒ’แƒ”แƒขแƒ˜แƒ™แƒแƒก แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ’แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ’แƒ”แƒœแƒก แƒ“แƒ แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒก แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒšแƒก แƒ›แƒแƒ˜แƒชแƒแƒ•แƒก.

    3. แƒ“แƒแƒกแƒ™แƒ•แƒœแƒ˜แƒ—, แƒแƒกแƒ™แƒ”แƒขแƒฃแƒ  แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒšแƒจแƒ˜, แƒฌแƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒ“แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒก แƒกแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒก, แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒฎแƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒžแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒก แƒฆแƒ˜แƒ แƒกแƒ”แƒฃแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ’แƒแƒขแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ™แƒ”แƒœ แƒ›แƒแƒฃแƒฌแƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒกแƒแƒช แƒกแƒ˜แƒ›แƒ‘แƒแƒšแƒฃแƒ แƒแƒ“ แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒแƒก แƒฃแƒ™แƒแƒ•แƒจแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก.

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ”โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒ›แƒแƒ’แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ แƒโ€ƒ แƒœแƒแƒจแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜โ€ƒ แƒ™แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšโ€ƒ โ€žแƒ’แƒ แƒแƒ’แƒœแƒ˜แƒšแƒจแƒ˜โ€œโ€ƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒโ€ƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜โ€ƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒแƒ™แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—.โ€ƒแƒ“แƒแƒ˜แƒœแƒขแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšโ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ™แƒ˜แƒ—แƒฎแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒกโ€ƒ แƒแƒฅแƒ•แƒกโ€ƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒซแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒšแƒแƒ‘แƒ,โ€ƒ แƒœแƒแƒจแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒกโ€ƒ แƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒ˜แƒ—โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒแƒ”แƒชแƒœแƒแƒกโ€ƒ แƒ—แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒกแƒแƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒโ€ƒแƒแƒ™แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒžแƒแƒขแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒ™แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒแƒ“แƒโ€ƒแƒ“แƒแƒ’แƒ›แƒแƒขแƒ˜แƒ™แƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒ™แƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒ–แƒ”.

    2โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒชแƒ”แƒ›แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒ:โ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒ ยนEi/j to\n tetrah/meron Laza/ronโ€ƒ[Maryโ€ƒB.โ€ƒCunningham/An-dreasโ€ƒofโ€ƒโ€ƒCreteโ€ฒsโ€ƒHomiliesโ€ƒonโ€ƒLazarusโ€ƒandโ€ƒPalmโ€ƒSunday:โ€ƒAโ€ƒCriticalโ€ƒEditionโ€ƒandโ€ƒCommentary/Theโ€ƒUniversityโ€ƒofโ€ƒBirminghamโ€ƒ1983].

  • saba gelaSvili

    34

    แƒฎแƒกแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒจแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒ›แƒฎแƒ แƒ˜แƒ•แƒแƒ แƒกแƒแƒงแƒฃแƒ แƒแƒ“แƒฆแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ. แƒฌแƒ›. แƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒกแƒแƒ—แƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฎแƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒญแƒ”แƒ•แƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒขแƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒ แƒ“แƒ, แƒแƒฅ แƒ•แƒฎแƒ•แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ— แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒ›แƒแƒแƒ“ แƒฆแƒ แƒ›แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฆแƒ•แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ›แƒ”แƒขแƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ, แƒ“แƒแƒ’แƒ›แƒแƒขแƒฃแƒ  แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒกแƒ™แƒ”แƒขแƒฃแƒ  แƒกแƒฌแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก; แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒจแƒ˜ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒงแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒ แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒฃแƒ—แƒ แƒ˜แƒ• แƒ“แƒแƒ’แƒ›แƒแƒขแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜ แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒแƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒฅแƒแƒœแƒ” แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ—แƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฎแƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒขแƒ”แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒšแƒแƒ’แƒ˜แƒ.

    แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒก แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ™แƒ•แƒšแƒ”แƒ•แƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒจแƒ˜แƒช แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ›แƒแƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒ แƒฌแƒ›. แƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ แƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒก แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒจแƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒแƒšแƒแƒ’แƒ˜แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒกแƒฌแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒ–แƒœแƒ”แƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒ˜แƒ•-แƒแƒกแƒ™แƒ”แƒขแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒแƒช แƒฎแƒกแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ˜แƒชแƒแƒ•แƒก.

  • wm. andria kriteli `sityuaA lazaresaTYs...~

    35

    teqstisaTvis

    แƒฌแƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ แƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒก แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ โ€žแƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒกโ€œ แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒ˜ แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒ-

    แƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒฉแƒ•แƒ”แƒœแƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ” แƒ›แƒแƒฆแƒฌแƒ”แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜.1

    แƒซแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒฅแƒแƒ แƒ—แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ’แƒ›แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒก แƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒแƒกแƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ”แƒœแƒแƒ“ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ•แƒ˜ แƒงแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ— แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒ’แƒ˜ 6 แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒแƒช แƒšแƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ•แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒญแƒ”แƒ—: A 162 (XI แƒก., A); A 140 (XII แƒก., B); A 129 (XIII แƒก., C); A 613 (XIII-XV แƒกแƒก., D ); H 1760 (XV แƒก., E); S 4930 (XVI แƒก., F).

    แƒซแƒ˜แƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ“ แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒแƒ“ แƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒฆแƒ”แƒ— A แƒšแƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒ— แƒแƒฆแƒœแƒ˜แƒจแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ A 162 แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒแƒช แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒฎแƒกแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ˜แƒก แƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒ” แƒซแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒœแƒฃแƒกแƒฎแƒแƒ; แƒแƒ›แƒแƒกแƒ—แƒแƒœ, แƒกแƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ“ แƒ”แƒก แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ’แƒแƒก แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒœแƒฃแƒš แƒ“แƒ”แƒ“แƒแƒœแƒ—แƒแƒœ แƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒ” แƒแƒฎแƒšแƒแƒก แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒ›แƒแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒ™แƒแƒคแƒ˜แƒแƒ“ แƒ˜แƒ™แƒ˜แƒ—แƒฎแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ.

    แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒก แƒแƒฎแƒšแƒแƒ•แƒก แƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒแƒžแƒแƒ แƒแƒขแƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒช 2 แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒงแƒแƒคแƒ˜แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒก แƒ›แƒแƒ˜แƒชแƒแƒ•แƒก:

    1) แƒฅแƒแƒ แƒ—แƒฃแƒš แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ—แƒแƒœ แƒ“แƒแƒ™แƒแƒ•แƒจแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ•แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœแƒขแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒœแƒ˜แƒจแƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒแƒฆแƒœแƒ˜แƒจแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ’แƒ•แƒแƒฅแƒ•แƒก แƒแƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒชแƒ˜แƒคแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ— - 1, 2, 3 ...

    2) แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒซแƒ˜แƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ“ แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ—แƒแƒœ แƒแƒจแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ–แƒ” แƒ’แƒแƒ™แƒ”แƒ—แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ—แƒแƒœ แƒ“แƒแƒ™แƒแƒ•แƒจแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒœแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ แƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒœแƒ˜แƒจแƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒแƒฆแƒ•แƒœแƒ˜แƒจแƒœแƒ”แƒ— แƒ•แƒแƒ แƒกแƒ™แƒ•แƒšแƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒ— - *, **, *** ...

    แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ˜ แƒžแƒแƒ แƒแƒ’แƒ แƒแƒคแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒ“แƒแƒ•แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒ— แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒฌแƒงแƒแƒ แƒแƒก: Mary B. Cun-ningham/Andreas of Creteโ€ฒs Homilies on Lazarus and Palm Sunday: A Critical Edition and Commentary/The University of Birmingham, 1983 - แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฎแƒ”แƒ“แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—.

    แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ›แƒแƒ•แƒ” แƒ’แƒ•แƒ”แƒ แƒ“แƒ–แƒ” แƒฌแƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒœ แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜แƒ•แƒ” แƒชแƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒขแƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒœแƒฏแƒ”แƒ แƒ›แƒ” แƒ›แƒ”แƒแƒ แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ, แƒกแƒฅแƒแƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒจแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒฎแƒ”แƒš แƒ•แƒฃแƒ—แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ—. แƒแƒ›แƒแƒกแƒ—แƒแƒœ, แƒฌแƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒœ แƒ›แƒแƒฎแƒ›แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒš แƒชแƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒขแƒ”แƒ‘แƒก แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒจแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒแƒฎแƒ แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜ แƒจแƒ แƒ˜แƒคแƒขแƒ˜แƒ— แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ•แƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ”แƒœแƒ— แƒ“แƒ แƒ‘แƒ แƒญแƒงแƒแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒจแƒ˜ แƒ•แƒกแƒ•แƒแƒ›แƒ—, แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒžแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒคแƒ แƒแƒ–แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒชแƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒขแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒแƒœ แƒแƒ•แƒขแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒแƒช แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒกแƒฎแƒ•แƒแƒ“แƒแƒกแƒฎแƒ•แƒ แƒžแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ—แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒก, แƒ›แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ‘แƒ แƒญแƒงแƒแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒจแƒ˜ แƒ•แƒแƒ—แƒแƒ•แƒกแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ—.

    แƒ—แƒ˜แƒ—แƒฅแƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ แƒฎแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒจแƒ˜ แƒ’แƒ•แƒฎแƒ•แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒฑ-แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒงแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ”-แƒก แƒœแƒแƒชแƒ•แƒšแƒแƒ“, แƒ แƒแƒช แƒกแƒฅแƒแƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒจแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒจแƒ” แƒจแƒ”แƒ•แƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ— (แƒ›แƒแƒ’. แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒฑ - แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ”; แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒฑแƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ - แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ ...). แƒ”แƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒœแƒ˜แƒจแƒ•แƒœแƒ แƒ”แƒฎแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒซแƒ˜แƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ“แƒแƒ“ แƒฃแƒฑ แƒ™แƒแƒ›แƒžแƒšแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒก.

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒ›โ€ƒแƒœแƒฃแƒกแƒฎแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒแƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒฉแƒแƒ›แƒแƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ•แƒแƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ˜แƒฎ:โ€ƒแƒ’แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒซแƒแƒจแƒ•แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒ2009:โ€ƒ196.โ€ƒ

  • saba gelaSvili

    36

    แƒ›แƒœแƒ˜แƒจแƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ•แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒฆแƒ•แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ›แƒ”แƒขแƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒขแƒ”แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒแƒœ แƒ›แƒ—แƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒคแƒ แƒแƒ–แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒแƒฎแƒแƒšแƒฅแƒแƒ แƒ—แƒฃแƒš แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ’แƒ›แƒแƒœแƒ—แƒแƒœ แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒแƒ“ แƒกแƒฅแƒแƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒจแƒ˜ แƒฉแƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒœแƒ”แƒ—.

    แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒก แƒซแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒฅแƒแƒ แƒ—แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ’แƒ›แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒแƒ  แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒ•แƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒข-แƒœแƒแƒ™แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ–แƒฃแƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒ— แƒ›แƒ˜แƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒœแƒฃแƒš แƒฌแƒงแƒแƒ แƒแƒก, แƒ แƒแƒช แƒ–แƒแƒ’แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒ— แƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ˜แƒšแƒแƒก แƒฅแƒแƒ แƒ—แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ’แƒ›แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒ•แƒ แƒชแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒจแƒ˜ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ˜แƒฎแƒแƒขแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ. แƒฅแƒแƒ แƒ—แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ˜ แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒฌแƒงแƒแƒ แƒแƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒแƒ แƒ แƒ แƒ”แƒ“แƒแƒฅแƒชแƒ˜แƒฃแƒšแƒแƒ“, แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒ›แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ•แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœแƒขแƒฃแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒกแƒฎแƒ•แƒแƒแƒ‘แƒก.

  • wm. andria kriteli `sityuaA lazaresaTYs...~

    37

    [A165v] แƒฌแƒ›แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒœแƒ”แƒขแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒฃแƒกแƒแƒšแƒ˜แƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ1, แƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒš แƒ›แƒ—แƒแƒ•แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒžแƒ˜แƒกแƒ™แƒแƒžแƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ2, แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒฒ

    แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก, แƒแƒ—แƒฎ-แƒ“แƒฆแƒ” แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ,3 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒแƒฆแƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ˜แƒœแƒ แƒฃแƒคแƒแƒšแƒ›แƒแƒœ*4

    1. **แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ” แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒแƒ™แƒ แƒ˜แƒ‘แƒ5 แƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒ“แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒกแƒ”แƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒงแƒแƒคแƒแƒ“, แƒ“แƒ แƒขแƒแƒ‘แƒšแƒแƒกแƒ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒฐแƒ›แƒ–แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒก แƒฆแƒ˜แƒ แƒกแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ— แƒขแƒ แƒคแƒ˜แƒแƒšแƒ—แƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก6 แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒœแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒฌแƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ7 แƒฏแƒ”แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒœแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒกแƒ›แƒ” แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒแƒฌ แƒจแƒ”แƒ˜แƒ›แƒ–แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก. แƒฃแƒคแƒ แƒแƒฒแƒกแƒฆแƒ แƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ•แƒ” แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ›แƒ–แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ แƒก แƒ“แƒ แƒจแƒฃแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒฌแƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒš แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒœแƒœแƒ˜แƒชแƒ8 แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ—แƒ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒกแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ‘แƒแƒซแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ—แƒแƒ•แƒ—แƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ9 แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ—แƒ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒš แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ˜แƒš แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœ. แƒ“แƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ -แƒ›แƒ” แƒฐแƒงแƒแƒคแƒก-แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒแƒœแƒฃ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ  แƒกแƒแƒญแƒ›แƒ”แƒš แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜, แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒ–แƒ”แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒฆแƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜, แƒแƒœแƒฃ แƒ แƒแƒฒ แƒแƒ แƒก แƒกแƒ”แƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜, แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒ–แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜? แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒแƒฌแƒ•แƒ” แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒแƒก10 แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ›แƒแƒœ แƒฌแƒ”แƒกแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒฎแƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ.11

    2. แƒ›แƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ— แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ” แƒ“แƒ แƒฌแƒ˜แƒ’แƒœแƒ˜ แƒฌแƒ›แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ12 แƒดแƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ•แƒ˜แƒฆแƒแƒ— แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฉแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒแƒกแƒ13 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒจแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒแƒคแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒœแƒ”แƒกแƒขแƒณ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒซแƒ˜แƒแƒ— แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒ™แƒฃแƒ”แƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒกแƒฌแƒ แƒแƒคแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ14 แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒณแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒ•แƒ”แƒฎแƒœแƒ”แƒ— แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒœแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ›แƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒ•แƒกแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒแƒซแƒฆแƒฃแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒœแƒ˜, แƒœแƒแƒ™แƒแƒ“แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒแƒœแƒแƒ“ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒงแƒแƒคแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ,15 แƒฃแƒจแƒฃแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ•แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒญแƒœแƒ”แƒ— แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒก แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ•แƒกแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒœ.16

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ โ€ƒแƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ]แƒแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒ(แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒฃแƒกแƒแƒšแƒ˜แƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒD)โ€ƒABCF.2โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ—แƒแƒ•แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒžแƒ˜แƒกแƒ™แƒแƒžแƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒBE.3โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒโ€ƒC.4โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฃแƒคแƒแƒšแƒ›แƒแƒœ]โ€ƒ+แƒ’แƒฃแƒแƒ™แƒฃแƒ แƒ—แƒฎแƒ”แƒœ,โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒโ€ƒAB.โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒโ€ƒแƒ’แƒฃแƒแƒ™แƒฃแƒ แƒ—แƒฎแƒ”แƒœโ€ƒC.5โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒแƒ™แƒ แƒ‘แƒโ€ƒABCE.6โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒขแƒ แƒคแƒ˜แƒแƒšแƒ—แƒโ€ƒE.7โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒœแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒแƒ“แƒโ€ƒแƒฌแƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ(แƒฌแƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—โ€ƒD)โ€“E.8โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒœแƒœแƒ˜โ€ƒC.9โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ—แƒแƒฒโ€ƒD.10โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒโ€ƒD.11 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒฎแƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒF.12 โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.13โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฉแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.14 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒกแƒฌแƒ แƒแƒคแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒDF.15 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.16โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒœโ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒD.*marg.โ€ƒD-แƒจแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒขแƒ”แƒฅแƒกแƒขแƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒฌแƒ˜แƒœโ€ƒแƒฌแƒแƒ›แƒซแƒฆแƒ•แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒโ€ƒแƒ’แƒแƒ“แƒแƒ›แƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜:โ€แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒœ,โ€ƒแƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒแƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒกโ€ƒแƒ“แƒโ€ƒแƒ›แƒจแƒแƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒโ€ƒ

    แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ—แƒโ€ƒแƒจแƒ”แƒฃแƒœแƒ“แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒกโ€ƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ›แƒแƒœ.โ€œ**marg.โ€ƒ C-แƒจแƒ˜โ€ƒ แƒ™แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ–แƒ”โ€ƒ แƒœแƒฃแƒกแƒฎแƒ-แƒฎแƒฃแƒชแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒ—โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒ:โ€ƒ โ€žแƒแƒ›แƒแƒกโ€ƒ แƒ“แƒฆแƒ”แƒกแƒโ€ƒ แƒแƒฆแƒแƒžแƒ˜โ€ƒ แƒแƒ แƒกโ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ™แƒ˜แƒแƒกโ€ƒ แƒซแƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒ

    แƒฅแƒแƒ แƒแƒคแƒ˜แƒ™แƒแƒ•แƒ–แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ”แƒ“แƒแƒœแƒ”แƒกแƒ˜โ€ƒ แƒ“แƒโ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒ แƒซแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒ แƒ’แƒ˜แƒแƒ แƒ’แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜.โ€ƒ แƒ“แƒโ€ƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒ›แƒชแƒโ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒฃแƒจแƒแƒšแƒแƒก,โ€ƒ แƒฆแƒ›แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ›แƒแƒœโ€ƒ แƒแƒ—แƒ—แƒโ€ƒแƒชแƒแƒ“แƒ•แƒแƒ—แƒแƒ—แƒณแƒกโ€ƒแƒฐแƒ™แƒ˜แƒ—แƒฎแƒแƒกโ€ƒแƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒกโ€ƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ“โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒกแƒšแƒ•แƒแƒกแƒ.โ€œ

  • saba gelaSvili

    38

    3. แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ’แƒ˜แƒœ แƒแƒฌ แƒจแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒกแƒ แƒฆแƒ›แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ›แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜1 แƒ˜แƒแƒ•แƒแƒœแƒ”, แƒ—แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒ˜แƒ—-แƒ›แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒแƒคแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ2 แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ—แƒฎแƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฃแƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒแƒฒ,3 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜4 แƒ›แƒ™แƒ”แƒ แƒ“แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒงแƒ แƒ“แƒœแƒ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ•แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒ”แƒ“ แƒฆแƒ แƒฃแƒ‘แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒแƒฌแƒ แƒฌแƒงแƒแƒ แƒแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ›แƒงแƒแƒคแƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ˜แƒ•แƒกแƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒ—แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒก แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ5 แƒฃแƒคแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒกแƒแƒ˜แƒ“แƒฃแƒ›แƒšแƒแƒ—แƒ6 แƒ›แƒแƒ— แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ›แƒแƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒฒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒ›แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“7 แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒš แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ แƒ“แƒแƒกแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ›แƒกแƒ แƒกแƒแƒฃแƒคแƒšแƒแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ— แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ—แƒแƒกแƒ แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒ, แƒแƒ›แƒแƒก แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒก แƒ–แƒ”แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒฆแƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒ, แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒ”แƒ— แƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒก: โ€žแƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒ›แƒ” แƒฃแƒซแƒšแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜ แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ” แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒแƒฒแƒ—8, แƒ“แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ—แƒแƒฒแƒกแƒกแƒ, แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 11. 1). โ€žแƒ›แƒ˜แƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒก แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ” แƒ˜แƒ”แƒกแƒฃแƒฒแƒกแƒกแƒ9 แƒ“แƒแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒฐแƒ แƒฅแƒฃแƒ”แƒก: แƒฃแƒคแƒแƒšแƒ, แƒแƒฐแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜10 แƒ’แƒ˜แƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ“แƒ, แƒกแƒœแƒ”แƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ แƒกโ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 11. 3). แƒ”แƒกแƒ›แƒ แƒ แƒแƒฒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒ˜แƒ”แƒกแƒฃแƒก, แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ: โ€žแƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒกแƒœแƒ”แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ11 แƒแƒ แƒ แƒแƒ แƒก แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”, แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก แƒฆแƒ›แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ,12 แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒก แƒซแƒ” แƒฆแƒ•แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒœโ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 11.4).

    4. แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒ-แƒ•แƒงแƒแƒ—,13 แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒฃแƒซแƒšแƒฃแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒฑแƒกแƒ˜ แƒ–แƒแƒ’แƒแƒ“แƒ˜ แƒกแƒœแƒ”แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ‘แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ 14 แƒ™แƒแƒชแƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒ˜แƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ-แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒ แƒ™แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒแƒกแƒ15 แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒœแƒ˜ แƒฐแƒฅแƒแƒœแƒแƒœ แƒ‘แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒœแƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ™แƒแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒœแƒ˜,16 แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ แƒฆแƒฃแƒ”แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒ˜ แƒฌแƒ”แƒกแƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒขแƒ™แƒ˜แƒชแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ—แƒ17 แƒ™แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒ-แƒฒแƒกแƒ18 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒก แƒขแƒณแƒ แƒ— แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœ แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ›แƒซแƒ˜แƒ›แƒ” แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ - แƒดแƒแƒ แƒชแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฌแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœแƒœแƒ˜. แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ–แƒ”แƒ–แƒ˜ แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒก แƒฃแƒซแƒšแƒฃแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ.19 แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜20 แƒ—แƒฅแƒ›แƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ แƒก, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒแƒ แƒ แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ“ แƒจแƒ”แƒ”แƒ›แƒ—แƒฎแƒณแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก, แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“21 แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฆแƒ›แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ›แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜]โ€ƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ›แƒ”แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒ”แƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒD.2โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ“แƒแƒคแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒแƒฒโ€ƒDF.3โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฃแƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒโ€ƒDF.4โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒD.5โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœโ€ƒแƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ]โ€ƒแƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒแƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœโ€ƒB.โ€ƒแƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœโ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒโ€ƒแƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœโ€ƒE.โ€ƒแƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒแƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.6โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฒแƒ“แƒฃแƒ›แƒšแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒB.โ€ƒแƒกแƒฒแƒ“แƒฃแƒ›แƒšแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒE.7โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“]โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒขแƒแƒ“โ€ƒ(แƒ›แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“โ€ƒ+D)โ€ƒF.8โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ‘แƒ”แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒแƒ—โ€ƒF.9โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ˜แƒ”แƒกแƒฃแƒฒแƒกแƒกแƒโ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒD.10โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒCF.11 โ€ƒ แƒกแƒœแƒ”แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ]โ€ƒแƒฃแƒซแƒšแƒฃแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒโ€ƒD.12 โ€ƒ แƒฆแƒ›แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ]โ€ƒแƒฃแƒคแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒAB.13โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒแƒฒ-แƒ•แƒงแƒแƒ—โ€ƒD.14 โ€ƒ แƒ‘แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.15 โ€ƒ แƒ™แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒC.16โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ™แƒแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒœแƒ˜]โ€ƒแƒจแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ™แƒ˜แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒœแƒ˜โ€ƒC.17 โ€ƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒขแƒ™แƒ˜แƒชแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ˜โ€ƒF.18โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ™แƒ”แƒ แƒซแƒแƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.19โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฃแƒซแƒšแƒฃแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.20โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜]โ€ƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšโ€ƒโ€ƒAB.21 โ€ƒ แƒแƒ แƒแƒกแƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ“โ€ƒแƒจแƒ”แƒ”แƒ›แƒ—แƒฎแƒณแƒโ€ƒ(+โ€ƒแƒ”แƒกแƒ”โ€ƒD)โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒก,โ€ƒแƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“โ€ƒโ€“E.

  • wm. andria kriteli `sityuaA lazaresaTYs...~

    39

    แƒฆแƒ›แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒก แƒซแƒฑ แƒฆแƒ›แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒ,1 แƒแƒ›แƒแƒก แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒกแƒ แƒ แƒ”แƒชแƒ2 แƒแƒฅแƒฃแƒก แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ›แƒ” แƒ“แƒแƒคแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒฒ3 แƒ“แƒ แƒซแƒœแƒ˜แƒแƒ“ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒกแƒแƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒฒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒชแƒ แƒแƒ แƒ แƒแƒ“แƒ•แƒ˜แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ›แƒ“แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒกแƒ แƒžแƒ˜แƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒกแƒแƒกแƒ, แƒ“แƒ แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ  แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒ“แƒ’แƒแƒ› แƒ”แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ”แƒก4 แƒฃแƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒกแƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒกแƒ.

    5. แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒจแƒ”แƒฃแƒ“แƒ’แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒแƒก,5 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒšแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”? แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒฆแƒแƒ›แƒชแƒ6 แƒกแƒฎแƒฃแƒแƒฒ, แƒ—แƒณแƒœแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒฏแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ? แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒกแƒ7 แƒฏแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ˜ แƒแƒ แƒก [A166r] แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ›แƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ’แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ›แƒแƒœ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒฃแƒฌแƒงแƒแƒ“แƒ แƒฃแƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒก แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ—แƒ. แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒแƒชแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒก8 แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ9 แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ”แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ—แƒ แƒฏแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒชแƒฃแƒ›แƒแƒฒ10 แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ11 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ›แƒแƒœ-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒ แƒฏแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ แƒชแƒฎแƒณแƒšแƒ˜12 แƒจแƒ”แƒฃแƒ แƒแƒชแƒฎ-แƒงแƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒงแƒแƒคแƒแƒ“ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒชแƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒก แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒฆแƒ•แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ›แƒฅแƒแƒ“แƒแƒ’แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜. แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒœแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ— แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒแƒกแƒ13 แƒ–แƒ”แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒฃแƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒ™แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ”แƒ’แƒœแƒ”แƒก14, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒชแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ™แƒœแƒ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜แƒœแƒ˜ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒแƒ›แƒแƒœ? แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒ“แƒแƒฆแƒแƒชแƒแƒ—แƒฃ แƒแƒ แƒ แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜15 แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒแƒœแƒฃ แƒ›แƒชแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”แƒ—แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ˜16 แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒแƒฆแƒ“แƒ’แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒแƒ—แƒฎแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒฆแƒ˜แƒกแƒ17 แƒ“แƒแƒงแƒ แƒแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒแƒ แƒกแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—18 แƒžแƒ˜แƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒก แƒ˜แƒงแƒ,19 แƒ’แƒแƒ แƒœแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ— แƒ•แƒ”แƒ  แƒ›แƒแƒแƒšแƒ‘แƒแƒ‘แƒ“แƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ20 แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒแƒฒ,21 แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ แƒแƒ แƒ แƒ•แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ,22

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒ]โ€ƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒœโ€ƒCDF.2โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒ”แƒชแƒโ€ƒ-โ€ƒA.3โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ“แƒแƒคแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒฒโ€ƒABE]โ€ƒแƒ“แƒแƒคแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒโ€ƒCDF.4โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ”แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ”แƒกโ€ƒAC]โ€ƒแƒ”แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒœแƒ”แƒกโ€ƒBDEF.5โ€ƒ โ€ƒ โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒกโ€ƒD.6โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒฆแƒแƒ›แƒชแƒโ€ƒD.7โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒกแƒกแƒโ€ƒBCE.8โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜โ€ƒE.9โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒE.10โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฏแƒ•แƒแƒ แƒชแƒฃแƒ›แƒโ€ƒD.11 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒDEF.12 โ€ƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ แƒชแƒฎแƒณแƒšแƒ˜]แƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒD.13โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒแƒ›แƒแƒœโ€ƒB.14 โ€ƒ แƒ–แƒ”แƒ“แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฃแƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒ™แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“โ€ƒ(แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฃแƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒ™แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“โ€ƒCF)โ€ƒแƒ”แƒ’แƒœแƒ”แƒกโ€ƒ-B.15 โ€ƒ แƒแƒ แƒชแƒโ€ƒแƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜โ€ƒD.16โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒœแƒฃโ€ƒแƒ›แƒชแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”แƒ—แƒโ€ƒแƒกแƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ˜โ€“โ€ƒF.17 โ€ƒ แƒแƒ—แƒฎแƒ“แƒฆแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒE.18โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—]แƒ›แƒแƒกโ€ƒD.19โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ]แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒโ€ƒE.20โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ]โ€ƒแƒฎแƒ˜แƒšแƒ•แƒโ€ƒD.21 โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.22 โ€ƒ แƒ•แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ]แƒ•แƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒแƒ“แƒ”โ€ƒD.โ€ƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒแƒ“แƒ˜โ€ƒF.

  • saba gelaSvili

    40

    แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“1 แƒฃแƒคแƒ แƒแƒฒแƒกแƒฆแƒ2 แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒแƒคแƒ˜แƒชแƒฎแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ“แƒ3 แƒ“แƒ แƒœแƒ˜แƒ•แƒ— แƒกแƒ˜แƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒแƒขแƒ˜แƒก4 แƒ”แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ. แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒชแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒแƒ แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ–แƒ”แƒ–แƒ˜ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒชแƒ5 แƒกแƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒš แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒฌแƒแƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒœแƒ”แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒชแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ–แƒ”แƒ–แƒกแƒ6 แƒฏแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ—แƒณแƒก แƒ“แƒแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒ. แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ“แƒแƒฆแƒแƒชแƒแƒ—แƒฃ แƒžแƒ˜แƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒš แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ—แƒ แƒแƒฅแƒฃแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒชแƒ แƒฆแƒ›แƒ”แƒ แƒ—แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒซแƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒฆแƒ›แƒ แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ, แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒแƒแƒ แƒกแƒกแƒ7 แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ, แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“8 แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒแƒ“แƒฌแƒ›แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒ9 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒดแƒแƒ แƒชแƒ˜แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒœแƒ”แƒขแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒงแƒแƒคแƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒชแƒ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒดแƒแƒ แƒชแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒกแƒ10 แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒ”แƒš-แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒ แƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ•แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒกแƒแƒคแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ.

    6. แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒแƒฆแƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ— แƒ’แƒ–แƒแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒญแƒ”แƒจแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ›แƒแƒœ แƒ›แƒแƒœ11 แƒ’แƒ–แƒแƒ›แƒแƒœ แƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ•แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ›แƒแƒœ, แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒ›แƒแƒœ, แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ12 แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœ13 แƒ“แƒ แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ:14 โ€žแƒฃแƒคแƒ แƒแƒฒแƒกแƒ˜15 แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒกแƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒแƒ แƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒแƒฅแƒฃแƒก, แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒแƒ›แƒชแƒ แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ˜ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœ แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ•แƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ—แƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ—แƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก16โ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 15. 13). แƒญแƒ”แƒจแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒ“,17 แƒ›แƒแƒœ แƒ—แƒแƒ•แƒแƒ“แƒ›แƒแƒœ แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ•แƒ แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ—แƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ—แƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก,18 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ›แƒแƒœ-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒฃแƒฌแƒงแƒแƒ“แƒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒžแƒ˜แƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒš แƒ›แƒชแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒŸแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ˜แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒฏแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ— แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒจแƒคแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ19 แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฉแƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ”แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ•แƒ20 แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ— แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ แƒแƒฆแƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ’แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜21 แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ™แƒแƒ˜แƒแƒคแƒแƒชแƒ22 แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒซแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ“แƒ23 แƒฃแƒคแƒแƒšแƒกแƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘24 แƒงแƒแƒคแƒแƒ“ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ— แƒฏแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ. แƒ’แƒแƒ แƒœแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒ—แƒแƒ•แƒแƒ“แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒแƒ”แƒ“แƒ•แƒ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ˜แƒ—แƒฃแƒ แƒ—25 แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ˜

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“โ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒD.2โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฃแƒคแƒ แƒแƒกแƒฆแƒโ€ƒF.3โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒคแƒ˜แƒชแƒฎแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“โ€ƒF.4โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒแƒขแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒBEF.5โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒกโ€ƒF.6โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ–แƒ”แƒ–แƒกแƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.7โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒแƒแƒ แƒกแƒกแƒ]โ€ƒแƒแƒ แƒกแƒกแƒโ€ƒD.8โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“]โ€“D;โ€ƒ+โ€ƒแƒจแƒ”แƒœโ€ƒF.9โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฌแƒ›แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒD.10โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒโ€ƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜โ€ƒD.11 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒœโ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒDF12 โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒณแƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒโ€ƒE.13โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœโ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒF.14 โ€ƒ แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒโ€ƒ+โ€ƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“โ€ƒDF.15 โ€ƒ แƒฃแƒคแƒ แƒแƒกแƒ˜โ€ƒF.16โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ—แƒโ€ƒF.17 โ€ƒ แƒญแƒ”แƒจแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒ“โ€ƒ+แƒ—แƒณแƒ—โ€ƒBCE.18โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒญแƒ”แƒจแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒ“โ€ƒโ€ฆแƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ—แƒแƒ—แƒณแƒกโ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒF.19โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒ+โ€ƒแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.20โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ”แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ•แƒแƒฒโ€ƒD.โ€ƒแƒ”แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒโ€ƒF.21 โ€ƒ แƒแƒฆแƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ’แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšโ€ƒEF.22 โ€ƒ แƒ™แƒแƒ˜แƒแƒคแƒแƒชแƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.23โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ”แƒซแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ“แƒ”แƒกโ€ƒF.24 ~โ€ƒโ€ƒแƒ—แƒแƒœแƒแƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘โ€ƒแƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒD.25 ~ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒ˜แƒ—แƒฃแƒ แƒ—โ€ƒแƒ“แƒแƒ”แƒ“แƒ•แƒโ€ƒBCDE.

  • wm. andria kriteli `sityuaA lazaresaTYs...~

    41

    แƒ›แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก1 แƒ“แƒ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒฃแƒจแƒ˜แƒจ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ. แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ›แƒแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ” แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ  แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒกแƒ, แƒแƒ›แƒแƒก2 แƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ“-แƒฐแƒงแƒแƒคแƒก แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒฒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ,3 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜4 แƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒก, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“: โ€žแƒฃแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒ”แƒกแƒฃแƒก แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ“แƒแƒฒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”โ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 11. 5) แƒ“แƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒ›แƒชแƒ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒ”แƒ— แƒกแƒแƒœแƒแƒขแƒ แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜,5 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒš แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒ— แƒ‘แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ— แƒกแƒ˜แƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ6 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒฆแƒ•แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ•แƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒกแƒกแƒ?7 แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒแƒชแƒ แƒ แƒแƒฒ แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒณแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒš แƒแƒ แƒก, แƒฃแƒ™แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ“แƒ”แƒ“แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒชแƒ, แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ›แƒดแƒœแƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒšแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—8, แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ— แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒšแƒ•แƒแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒกแƒ แƒฌแƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒแƒ แƒก แƒ“แƒ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒจแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก, แƒ“แƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒกแƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒœ แƒ›แƒฌแƒงแƒแƒšแƒแƒ‘แƒ”แƒš แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ”9 แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒ“แƒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒ›แƒ“แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒแƒ— แƒ–แƒ”แƒ“แƒ แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜10 แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒฃแƒ–แƒ”แƒจแƒ—แƒแƒ”แƒก11 แƒงแƒ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ— แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ•แƒ—แƒ แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ˜แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ’แƒแƒ แƒ“แƒแƒ›แƒแƒขแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒณแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ?12

    7. โ€žแƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒชแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ›แƒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒกแƒœแƒ”แƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ แƒก แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”, แƒ›แƒแƒจแƒ˜แƒœ แƒ“แƒ-แƒฆแƒ-แƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ แƒ13 แƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ˜แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก, แƒกแƒแƒ“แƒ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒแƒ  แƒ“แƒฆแƒ”โ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 11. 6). แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก14 แƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒ”แƒ— แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒแƒ’แƒ, แƒแƒœแƒฃ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ–แƒ”แƒ–แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก? แƒ’แƒแƒ แƒœแƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒ  แƒฃแƒฌแƒงแƒแƒ“แƒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒกแƒœแƒ”แƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒกแƒ˜แƒ™แƒฃแƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ”แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ, แƒ“แƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ แƒ™แƒ แƒซแƒแƒšแƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—, แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœ15 แƒ“แƒแƒกแƒ“แƒ•แƒแƒก แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒ–แƒ”แƒ“แƒ แƒ‘แƒ แƒแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒแƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒšแƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ. แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ—แƒณแƒก แƒŸแƒแƒ› แƒ”แƒ แƒ— แƒ“แƒแƒ”แƒงแƒ”แƒœแƒ แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ‘แƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒ16 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒ“แƒ แƒฃแƒจแƒฃแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒจแƒ”แƒฐแƒ แƒแƒชแƒฎแƒ,17 แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒฃแƒฌแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒฃแƒฉแƒœแƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒกแƒ›แƒ”แƒœแƒแƒกแƒแƒ•แƒ” แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ แƒ›แƒงแƒ˜แƒก แƒแƒฆแƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ18 แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ.19

    8. [A166v] แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒ“แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ“ แƒฐแƒ แƒฅแƒฃแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒฌแƒแƒคแƒ”แƒ—แƒ: โ€žแƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ— แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒกแƒขแƒแƒœแƒแƒ“,โ€œ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒฆแƒ•แƒ—แƒ˜แƒ•แƒจแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ 20 แƒฐแƒงแƒแƒคแƒก แƒ“แƒ แƒ™แƒ”แƒ—แƒ˜แƒš แƒ™แƒแƒ“แƒœแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒกแƒ

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ—แƒโ€ƒแƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ—แƒแƒ—แƒณแƒกโ€ƒD.2โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃโ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ”โ€ƒแƒ˜แƒงแƒโ€ƒแƒ“แƒโ€ƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ โ€ƒแƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒกแƒ,โ€ƒแƒแƒ›แƒแƒกโ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒF.3โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.4โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜]โ€ƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃโ€ƒD.5 ~ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ›แƒชแƒแƒฒโ€ƒแƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒ”แƒ—โ€ƒแƒกแƒแƒœแƒแƒขแƒ แƒ”แƒšโ€ƒแƒ˜แƒงแƒโ€ƒF.6โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.7โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒกแƒกแƒ]+แƒ˜แƒ”แƒกแƒฃโ€ƒD.8โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—โ€ƒC]โ€ƒแƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒโ€ƒBDEF.โ€ƒแƒ‘แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—โ€ƒA.9โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒ”]โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒฌแƒงแƒแƒšแƒ”โ€ƒF.10โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜โ€ƒC]โ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒABDEF.11 โ€ƒ แƒฃแƒ–แƒ”แƒกแƒ—แƒแƒ”แƒกโ€ƒC.12 โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒณแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒDF.13โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒฆแƒโ€ƒแƒ“แƒแƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ แƒโ€ƒF.14 โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒกโ€ƒF.15 โ€ƒ แƒแƒ แƒแƒ•แƒ˜แƒœโ€ƒE.16โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฐแƒแƒ›แƒ‘แƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒ]โ€ƒแƒฐแƒแƒœแƒ‘แƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒA.โ€ƒแƒแƒ›แƒ‘แƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.17 โ€ƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒฐแƒ แƒแƒชแƒฎแƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.18โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒฆแƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“โ€ƒD.19โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฉแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒD.20โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฆแƒ•แƒ—แƒ˜แƒ•แƒจแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒแƒ“โ€ƒD.

  • saba gelaSvili

    42

    แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒกแƒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ -แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒฌแƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒ’แƒ˜แƒœแƒ” แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ1 แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒ—แƒฎแƒฃแƒ”แƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒงแƒแƒคแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒณแƒก แƒกแƒแƒ˜แƒ“แƒฃแƒ›แƒšแƒแƒฒแƒกแƒ2 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ’แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ. แƒ’แƒแƒ แƒœแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒฌแƒแƒคแƒ”แƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฃแƒ’แƒ”แƒก แƒ“แƒ แƒฐแƒ แƒฅแƒฃแƒ”แƒก: โ€žแƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜! แƒแƒฌแƒฆแƒ แƒ’แƒ”แƒซแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒœ แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒฅแƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒแƒ™แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒ“แƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒฃแƒœแƒ•แƒ” แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฎแƒฃแƒแƒš-แƒ?โ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 11. 8) แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ›แƒแƒ™แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒก แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒ“แƒ แƒฃแƒคแƒ แƒแƒฒแƒกแƒฆแƒ3 แƒคแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒ›แƒ”แƒชแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒœแƒ˜. แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ”แƒ—แƒฃแƒ›แƒชแƒ แƒ”แƒชแƒœแƒ4 แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒซแƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ5 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก, แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒชแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒ”แƒ— แƒซแƒœแƒ”แƒš-แƒฃแƒฉแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ”6 แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜, แƒแƒ แƒชแƒแƒ›แƒชแƒ แƒฃแƒดแƒฃแƒ›แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒก แƒดแƒ›แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ”แƒกแƒ”แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒœแƒ˜, แƒกแƒแƒชแƒœแƒแƒฃแƒ แƒ›แƒงแƒแƒคแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒ˜7 แƒกแƒ˜แƒฉแƒฃแƒ™แƒœแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ8 แƒ“แƒ แƒ‘แƒฃแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒซแƒšแƒฃแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒœแƒ˜. แƒแƒ›แƒแƒก9 แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒฏแƒ”แƒ แƒ”แƒ— แƒœแƒแƒ™แƒšแƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ•แƒแƒœแƒชแƒ แƒ˜แƒงแƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒก แƒกแƒแƒ แƒฌแƒ›แƒฃแƒœแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒกแƒแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ—แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒแƒ˜แƒชแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒจแƒ˜แƒจแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒแƒชแƒ แƒ˜แƒฌแƒงแƒ”แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒกแƒ10 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ— แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒ“ แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒ—แƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ”แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ: โ€žแƒแƒฌแƒฆแƒ แƒ’แƒ”แƒซแƒ˜แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒœ แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒฅแƒ•แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒแƒ™แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒ“แƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒฃแƒœแƒ•แƒ” แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฎแƒฃแƒแƒš-แƒ11?โ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 11. 8) แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฃแƒ’แƒ แƒ˜แƒ”แƒกแƒฃ แƒ“แƒ แƒฐแƒ แƒฅแƒฃแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—12: โ€žแƒแƒ แƒ แƒแƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒขแƒœแƒ˜ แƒŸแƒแƒ›แƒœแƒ˜ แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœ-แƒ13 แƒ“แƒฆแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒœแƒ˜? แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒ›แƒ” แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒฆแƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜, แƒแƒ แƒ แƒฃแƒ‘แƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒ›แƒ”แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒกแƒแƒคแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ แƒฎแƒ”แƒ“แƒแƒ•แƒก. แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ14 แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒ›แƒ” แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒฆแƒแƒ›แƒ”, แƒฃแƒ‘แƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒ›แƒ”แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒแƒ แƒ แƒแƒ แƒก แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒ15โ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 11. 9-10). แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒฃแƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒœแƒ แƒ™แƒœแƒ˜แƒœแƒฆแƒ แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒชแƒ˜แƒ แƒ”แƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒงแƒแƒคแƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒŸแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒ แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“16 แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒ•แƒ”แƒš17 แƒงแƒ•แƒœแƒ แƒ—แƒณแƒกแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒฏแƒฃแƒแƒ แƒชแƒฃแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ.

    9. แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒแƒ แƒ18 แƒ“แƒแƒ›แƒแƒงแƒ”แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒš แƒแƒ แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ19 แƒ“แƒฆแƒ”แƒ“ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒ-แƒฐแƒงแƒ20 แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒญแƒ”แƒจแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฃแƒ‘แƒ แƒฌแƒงแƒ˜แƒœแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒแƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ]โ€ƒแƒ˜แƒงแƒโ€ƒD.โ€ƒแƒ˜แƒฅแƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒโ€ƒE.2โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒ˜แƒ“แƒฃแƒ›แƒšแƒแƒกแƒโ€ƒF.3โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฃแƒคแƒ แƒแƒกแƒฆแƒโ€ƒDF.4โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ”แƒชแƒœแƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.5โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.6โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฃแƒฉแƒœแƒ“แƒ]โ€ƒ+โ€ƒแƒกแƒแƒฅแƒ›แƒ”โ€ƒF.7โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒชแƒœแƒแƒฃแƒ แƒ›แƒงแƒแƒคแƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒ˜โ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒD.8โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒœแƒ˜โ€ƒE.โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.9โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ—โ€ƒE.10โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.11 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฎแƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.12 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—โ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒCDEF.13โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒœโ€ƒE.14 โ€ƒ แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ]โ€ƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃโ€ƒC.15 โ€ƒ แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.16โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“]โ€ƒแƒงแƒแƒคแƒแƒ“โ€ƒF.17 โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒฃแƒ”แƒšโ€ƒABE.18โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒแƒ แƒแƒฒโ€ƒABCE.19โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ]โ€ƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃโ€ƒD.20โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒแƒฒ-แƒฐแƒงแƒโ€ƒD.โ€ƒแƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒ-แƒงแƒโ€ƒE.

  • wm. andria kriteli `sityuaA lazaresaTYs...~

    43

    แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒก1 แƒ’แƒ–แƒแƒกแƒ2 แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒ–แƒ”แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒ แƒ แƒฃแƒ‘แƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒ›แƒ”แƒก แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒชแƒ”แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒคแƒ”แƒ แƒดแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ3 แƒฅแƒ•แƒแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒกแƒ,4 แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒฎแƒ”แƒ“แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒก5 แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒกแƒแƒคแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒš แƒแƒ แƒก แƒฅแƒแƒ“แƒแƒ’แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ.6 แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒคแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ7 แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ” แƒแƒ แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒก: โ€žแƒ›แƒ” แƒ•แƒแƒ  แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒคแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒโ€œ (แƒ˜แƒœ. 8. 2). แƒ“แƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“, แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒ-แƒฐแƒงแƒ8 แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒฅแƒแƒ“แƒแƒ’แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒแƒชแƒ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ9 แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒจแƒแƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒฆแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ แƒ“แƒ แƒฌแƒ”แƒกแƒ˜ แƒ™แƒ”แƒ—แƒ˜แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒแƒฅแƒแƒšแƒแƒฅแƒ”แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ,10 แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ -แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ›แƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ แƒก, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“: โ€žแƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒ”แƒ— แƒ‘แƒ แƒฌแƒงแƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ•แƒ“แƒ˜แƒœ แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ”แƒœแƒ˜ แƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒจแƒ” แƒ™แƒแƒชแƒ—แƒโ€œ (แƒ›แƒ—. 5. 16), แƒ“แƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒ“แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒ˜ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜.11

    แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒฆแƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒ-แƒงแƒแƒ•12 แƒฃแƒฉแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ13 แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒจแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ,14 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒ–แƒ”แƒ“แƒ แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒœแƒ›แƒ” แƒ›แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ“แƒ”แƒ•แƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒ”แƒ—แƒ แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒœ แƒ’แƒ–แƒแƒกแƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒ15 แƒแƒฉแƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒจแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒ16 แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฐแƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒก, แƒ”แƒกแƒ”แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ›แƒ—แƒฎแƒฃแƒ”แƒ•แƒ˜แƒก แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ”แƒกแƒ, แƒšแƒแƒ“แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒจแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ™แƒแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ, แƒ›แƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒฌแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒจแƒ” แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒกแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒš แƒ˜แƒงแƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒก แƒฃแƒ แƒฌแƒ›แƒฃแƒœแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ. แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ  แƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ” แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ›แƒ—แƒฎแƒฃแƒ”แƒ•แƒ˜แƒก? แƒ’แƒแƒ แƒœแƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ แƒ”แƒ—, แƒ แƒแƒŸแƒแƒ›แƒก แƒแƒ แƒ แƒแƒฅแƒฃแƒœแƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒจแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ,17 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒฌแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒ“แƒ”แƒ•แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒแƒฉแƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜ แƒจแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ,18 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ แƒ‘แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒแƒฉแƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒš แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒฌแƒงแƒ˜แƒœแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ,19 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒแƒฅแƒฃแƒœแƒ“แƒ แƒจแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒ20 แƒ›แƒแƒก แƒฌแƒ”แƒ แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒกแƒ. แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒแƒฉแƒ แƒ“แƒ˜แƒšแƒ˜แƒชแƒ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒฃแƒฉแƒ˜แƒœแƒ แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒก แƒกแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒแƒ“ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒฃแƒšแƒ”แƒ•แƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ— แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒšแƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒแƒ—แƒ.21

    10. แƒ™แƒฃแƒแƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ“แƒฆแƒ”แƒ“ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒ-แƒฐแƒงแƒ แƒœแƒฃแƒฃแƒ™แƒฃแƒ” แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ”แƒชแƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒš แƒแƒ แƒก แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒแƒฆแƒ›แƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒฌแƒงแƒ˜แƒœแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒแƒ‘แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒแƒฒ22

    1โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒDF.2โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒ–แƒแƒกแƒโ€ƒ+โ€ƒแƒ›แƒแƒกโ€ƒD.3โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒคแƒ”แƒ แƒดแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒDF.4โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ˜แƒ•แƒกแƒโ€ƒD.5โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฎแƒ”แƒ“แƒแƒ•แƒกโ€ƒCEF.6โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.7โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒคแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.8โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒแƒฒ-แƒงแƒแƒ•โ€ƒD.9โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.10โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒฅแƒแƒšแƒแƒฅแƒ”แƒแƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.11 โ€ƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜โ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒD.12 โ€ƒ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒแƒฒ-แƒงแƒแƒ•โ€ƒD.13โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒฃแƒฉแƒ˜แƒœแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ]โ€ƒแƒฃแƒฉแƒ˜แƒœแƒโ€ƒแƒงแƒแƒคแƒโ€ƒF.14 โ€ƒ แƒกแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒDF.15 โ€ƒ แƒ“แƒโ€ƒโ€“โ€ƒF.16โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒD.โ€ƒแƒกแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.17 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.18โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒโ€ƒF.19โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒโ€ƒDF.20โ€ƒ โ€ƒ แƒกแƒฏแƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒโ€ƒF.21 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ“แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒ—แƒแƒฒโ€ƒF.22 โ€ƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกโ€ƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ แƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜โ€ƒแƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒโ€ƒแƒ“แƒแƒ‘แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒแƒฒ(แƒ“แƒแƒ‘แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒโ€ƒDF)โ€ƒโ€“E.

  • saba gelaSvili

    44

    แƒ›แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒ•แƒกแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒ–แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ‘แƒ แƒฌแƒงแƒ˜แƒœแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ,1 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒ›แƒ”แƒงแƒกแƒ แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒ แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒแƒ—แƒšแƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒœ2 แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒแƒšแƒœแƒ˜3 แƒ”แƒ แƒœแƒ˜4 แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœแƒœแƒ˜,5 แƒ“แƒ แƒฃแƒคแƒ แƒแƒฒแƒกแƒฆแƒ6 แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒฅแƒฃแƒ”แƒงแƒแƒœแƒแƒฒ7 แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒกแƒขแƒแƒœแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ,8 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒแƒ แƒฆแƒแƒ แƒ9 แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒ— แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ—แƒฎแƒ แƒแƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ แƒแƒฒแƒ›แƒ” แƒฃแƒดแƒ›แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒณแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ—แƒ แƒฅแƒแƒ“แƒแƒ’แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ,10 แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ11 แƒ—แƒณแƒ— แƒ›แƒแƒ— แƒจแƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒก แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ“แƒ แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒ•แƒ” แƒ’แƒแƒœแƒชแƒฎแƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒแƒ“.

    แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒฆแƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒ-แƒฐแƒงแƒ แƒจแƒคแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒแƒชแƒ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒฐแƒฃแƒ แƒ˜แƒแƒ—แƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒแƒฒ,12 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ”แƒ  แƒ“แƒแƒ‘แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒ“แƒ”แƒก แƒ’แƒฃแƒ’แƒแƒœแƒ˜13 แƒกแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒ—แƒแƒœแƒ˜ แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒ•แƒ” แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒจแƒ”แƒ˜แƒ›แƒ—แƒฎแƒณแƒ”แƒก, แƒฃแƒ›แƒ”แƒชแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒฒ แƒ“แƒ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ‘แƒ แƒ›แƒฑ, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ -แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ›แƒฃแƒš แƒแƒ แƒก, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒแƒ แƒ แƒชแƒœแƒ”แƒก, แƒแƒ แƒชแƒ แƒ’แƒฃแƒšแƒ˜แƒกแƒดแƒ›แƒ-แƒงแƒ•แƒ”แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ—แƒฃ [A167r] แƒ‘แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒก.14 แƒแƒ แƒ แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒ—, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒš15 แƒแƒ แƒ แƒ˜แƒœแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒก แƒ›แƒ˜แƒฎแƒ”แƒ“แƒ•แƒแƒฒ16 แƒœแƒแƒ—แƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒก, แƒ‘แƒœแƒ”แƒšแƒกแƒ แƒจแƒ˜แƒœแƒ แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ‘แƒ แƒฌแƒงแƒ˜แƒœแƒ•แƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒšแƒกแƒ, แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒแƒ แƒชแƒแƒฆแƒ แƒกแƒแƒกแƒฌแƒแƒฃแƒšแƒ—แƒแƒ’แƒแƒœ แƒจแƒ”แƒ˜แƒ™แƒ“แƒ˜แƒ›แƒ”แƒก,17 แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ—แƒ แƒ“แƒแƒฆแƒแƒชแƒแƒ—แƒฃ แƒกแƒฎแƒฃแƒแƒฒ แƒแƒ แƒแƒ แƒแƒฒ, แƒแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒ“ แƒกแƒ˜แƒ›แƒ แƒแƒ•แƒšแƒฑ แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒกแƒแƒ™แƒณแƒ แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒแƒ—แƒแƒฒ18 แƒฏแƒ”แƒ -แƒ˜แƒงแƒ แƒ™แƒ›แƒ-แƒงแƒแƒคแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒแƒ›แƒแƒฅแƒชแƒ”แƒ•แƒ”แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒ“แƒ, แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒœแƒ˜-แƒ˜แƒ’แƒ˜ แƒญแƒ”แƒจแƒ›แƒแƒ แƒ˜แƒขแƒแƒ“ แƒฆแƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒ›แƒกแƒ’แƒแƒ•แƒกแƒ”แƒ‘แƒฃแƒš แƒ˜แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒœแƒ”แƒก, แƒ แƒแƒแƒ“แƒ”แƒœแƒ—แƒแƒชแƒ แƒฃแƒ แƒฌแƒ›แƒฃแƒœแƒแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ›แƒแƒ—แƒ˜แƒ—แƒ แƒ”แƒฅแƒ›แƒœแƒ แƒฅแƒ แƒ˜แƒกแƒขแƒ” แƒšแƒแƒ“ แƒจแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ แƒ™แƒแƒšแƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒ™แƒšแƒ“แƒ” แƒกแƒแƒชแƒ—แƒฃแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ˜แƒกแƒ,19 แƒ“แƒ แƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒ˜แƒงแƒแƒ•แƒœ แƒกแƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒกแƒ แƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ—แƒณแƒก, แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ—แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒ”แƒ“:20 โ€žแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜ แƒ•แƒ˜แƒ“แƒแƒ“แƒ˜แƒก แƒ“แƒฆแƒ˜แƒกแƒ˜โ€œ. แƒฎแƒแƒšแƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒ“แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ“ แƒ˜แƒขแƒงแƒณแƒก แƒ›แƒแƒฎแƒแƒ แƒ”แƒ‘แƒ”แƒšแƒ˜:

    11. โ€žแƒ”แƒกแƒ” แƒฐแƒ แƒฅแƒฃแƒ แƒ“แƒ แƒแƒ›แƒ˜แƒกแƒ แƒจแƒ”แƒ›แƒ“แƒ’แƒแƒ›แƒแƒ“ แƒ—แƒฅแƒฃแƒ: แƒšแƒแƒ–แƒแƒ แƒ”, แƒ›แƒ”แƒ’แƒแƒ‘แƒแƒ แƒ›แƒแƒœ แƒฉแƒ”แƒ›แƒ›แƒแƒœ, แƒ“แƒแƒ˜แƒซแƒ˜แƒœแƒโ€œ (