Alternativetopractical

3

Click here to load reader

Transcript of Alternativetopractical

Page 1: Alternativetopractical

First of all we can read the aims from the specification:

3.3 Assessment details

This unit is assessed by means of a written examination paper. The

assessment for this unit covers planning an experiment, analysing data and

drawing conclusions. A laboratory is not required for this assessment.

Planning Students will be expected to plan an experiment that is set by

Edexcel, although they will not be expected to carry it out.

Students may be required to:

identify the apparatus required

discuss calibration of instruments, eg whether a meter reads zero

before measurements are made

describe how to measure relevant variables using the most

appropriate instrument and correct measuring techniques

identify and state how to control all other relevant variables to make

it a fair test

discuss whether repeat readings are appropriate

identify health and safety issues and discuss how these may be dealt

with

discuss how the data collected will be used

identify possible sources of uncertainty and/or systematic error and

explain how these may be reduced or eliminated

comment on the implications of physics (eg benefits/risks) and on its

context (eg social/environmental/historical).

Page 2: Alternativetopractical

You should remember and take into account the next points: Difference between accuracy and precision: Accuracy is referred to how far a measurement is from the real value. Precision is referred to the total uncertainty that a measurement has(because of the significant figures) Accuracy is affected by the systematic errors (uncertainties) like zero error, parallax error, time of reaction... Accuracy can be improved by repeating measurements and taking the main value, or trying to get a line of best fit (These both options are considered as methods to improve accuracy). Accuracy can also be improved by adjusting the zero error, the point of view or even by ensure a straight movement of objects (measuring vertically ensuring with a set square), starting from rest, etc… (You should realize the difference between methods and precautions to improve accuracy). Of course you can improve accuracy if you use apparatus like light gates to take time measurements (this will eliminate the human time of reaction; if you use this, take care about naming data logger + to computer) Precision is affected by random errors, like all those that can be due to the changes in the conditions of measurements. Precision can be improved (but it will never be perfect) by using instruments with better resolutions (the smallest measurement that can be taken: calipers/micrometers for lengths if it is able, digital scales for masses, wider measuring cylinders for volumes…) or by adjusting with a line of best fit. Also by calculating a gradient with a longer line. Calculations: Don’t forget to follow the number of significant figures (s.f) while you get an average value from a set of measurements. Also remember to express the result of a calculation with the same number of s.f. of the measurement that has the smallest one. Making an average value will increase accuracy but not precision, so don’t put more s.f. Remember that if you have an uncertainty value, the this will fix directly the last s.f. of the measurement. When doing averages, the uncertainty must cover all the values all of the set of measurements. The percentage difference to show whether the measurements are consistent is calculated by:

%𝑒𝑟𝑟𝑜𝑟 = 𝑚𝑒𝑎𝑠𝑢𝑟𝑒𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡 − 𝑟𝑒𝑎𝑙 𝑣𝑎𝑙𝑢𝑒

𝑟𝑒𝑎𝑙 𝑣𝑎𝑙𝑢𝑒

Information from graphs: Think about the units in the two axes and hence get the units for the gradient (units in axe “y” divided units in axe “x”), the area under the graph (units in axe “y” times units in axe “x”), and both intercepts will have the same units of each axe. Safety precautions: Any logical comment can be accepted but usually they look for, avoiding burnt, kicked, spoiled or damaged in any part of the body, specially in the face (using goggles or lab robes are usually a good option)

Page 3: Alternativetopractical

Explaining an experiment: Choose the correct formula you must use to achieve the experiment. Identify the variables and the constant values. Choose the independent and the dependent variables and try to keep constant the rest of them if it is needed. Think about the instruments needed to measure both variables and the method to change the independent one in order to get a line of best fit (if there is no chance to change one of them, then you should repeat measurements to increase accuracy). Recall the information from graphs to explain the calculations. See in “precautions to improve accuracy” to show the best way to do it. Rearrange equations to show calculations. Always try to look for the form: y=mx+c. Ensure that “m” and “c” are constant. Criticizing measurements: For a line of best fit are needed at least six measurements. All the measurements of the same set must have the same precision. The range of measurements for a line of best fit must be as large and steeply proportional as possible. Precision of the measurements must be reasonably good. All the measurement must have units. Doing graphs and calculating gradients and areas: Once you have all the points written in the table transpose them to the graph trying to get the largest graph in the sheet that is possible. Choose the line of best fit just by using only the points you fixed (don’t use the origin unless you got it as a point). Draw the line leaving the same number of points at each side of the line (think that you must choose the smallest sum of distances from the points to the line). To calculate areas, just divide always the total area in rectangles and triangles (if it is needed you can count squares). To calculate gradients use always the largest line you can use (even extrapolating the straight line if you can (this is a way of improving precision) Don’t forget to show the units of whatever you calculate.