Post on 04-Apr-2018
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
1/68
XOLNF GF MBF
@BQ]]GHBF?
MNB CBQ]BF IBFQ& \IGQISJ]B
73&73
xxx&lnffbsj&mb
HBXGD] GR@
Q]& HBOSH?
BNF OU@BS CBSNAL]B]
BRSB FS& 7 @SMGQ FGAL]DBCBF
MBS BNF[NHB UGS]^UDGFBSIN] MBI ]SGIUBDU@GM
MNB@GJ]BF
&MG]BF[RI
GNMQ
XBD]
]GH
3573
MNBXGLD;
XBSHBXNFF]MBFQ[BFBUSBNQMBQ
KGLSBQ?
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
2/68
Cglflo` in}Riq}bnhbihdnal)jbn} {ri Sbhnofgd)rfm @bsfpbsjbls
Pbscrfm}gsn`hbcnb}
Cglflo` ombs Lgd}burfj}
ib}sofoi Qbspnababf}bs
#Fosmqbb)]gj}#
#Xbqbs)]gj}#
#Bdcb)]gj}#
#Gddbs)]gj}#
#Dbnfb}gd)]gj}#
Ar|lgpbf
Csbibf Lc`
Q}gmb
Lgiigl
Lniibdu`os}bf
Lbal}lgrqbf
Lbiioos
Xnfhq}
AgmbfcbshbO}}bsfmos`
Losfbcrsh
Cr|}blrmb Lgicrsh)Lgscrsh
Ibajbd`bdmIgqalbf
Cnbfbfc}}bd
Xnfqbf ,Drlb.Sgmcsral
Cgsmoxnaj
Dfbcrsh
Abddb
Lgffopbs Lc`
Bd{b ,Lgf.
Fos}lbni,Lgf.
H}}nfhbf
Dgrbfcsaj ]oq}bm}
Qalbbbd
So}bfcrsh,Xiib.
Qo}}sri
O}}bsqcbsh,Lgf.Qg
hblo
sf
Csbi
bf)
Ocbsfb
rdgf
m
JdbajbfLn}}`bdm
Qus}{b
Crallod{,Fosmlbnmb.
Lgicrsh Lc`
Cgm Cbpbfqbf
Qrmbscrsh
Rf}bsd
Bqalbmb
Hsocrshxbmbd
Nqbsflghbf
Cgf}bdf
Gd`bdm ,Dbnfb.
@sbmbf ,Dbnfb.
Bnfcbaj Qgd{mbslbdmbf
Fs}bf)Lgsmbfcbsh
Jsbnbfqbf
Dgfhbflghbf In}}b
Qgsq}bm}
Fosmq}biibf
Q}bddb
Gqlg
rqbf
Rbd{bf
ib}sofoi ]ghbq}najb}q
Qnfhdb ,7 Ubsqof$ 35 .
Hsruub ,cnq 2 Ubsqofbf$ 3> .
@glssgmjgs}b ,hgf{}hnh$ = .
Mnb ib}sofoi ]ghbq}najb}q qnfm hd}nh;
gddb ib}sofoi [hb
3& Jdgqqb
Io@s gc >&55 Rls
Qgiq}gh$ Qoff}gh$ @bnbs}ghb hgf{}ghq
ib}sofoi Qbspnababf}bs
Qbspnababf}bs Crallod{ ,Fosmlbnmb.
Cglflo`qq}sgb 7$ 373== Crallod{
Qbspnababf}bs Q}gmb
Gi Cglflo` 7=$ 3702 Lgicrsh
Qbspnababf}bs * Sbnqbcso Bqalbmb
Cglflo`qq}sgb 25$ 3>1=< Bqalbmb
ib}sofoi Jrfmbf{bf}sri
@rfmcso
Q}&)Pn}n)Q}s& 72
3>232 Rbd{bf
]bd&; ,528 70=)70=
@g|; ,528 70=)70>
B)Ignd; jrfmbf{bf}sriEmbs)ib}sofoi&mb
,Io@s 8&15 7
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
3/68
Lo$ lo$ lorfm qalof nq} 3573 `gq} xnbmbs poscbn& Xns lg}}bf mbf xold uodn}nqalq}bf AQM
qbn} Kglsbf$ bnfb hbdrfhbfb Xgld mbq Is& Dbg}lbs Brsoub 3573 rfm gral mnb Dbqcnqal
Qalxrdbf @ndi}ghb doaj}bf xnbmbs b}dnalb Ibfqalbf nf mnb Jnfoq& Mnb LgicrshbsQ{bfb lg} qnal pof bnfbs qbls hr}bf Qbn}b usqbf}nbs}' Gcbs bq nq} fnal} gddbq cbq}bfq&
Mnb [gld mbs LNP)Fbrnf`bj}nofbf nq} bsfbr} gfhbq}nbhbf& Xgsri mgq qo nq}$ xnb Cb)
}so``bfb in} mbs Jsgfjlbn} rihblbf rfm oc GNMQ ihdnalbsxbnqb cgdm lbndcgs nq}$
dbq} nls nf rfqbsbs ]n}bdhbqalnal}b gr` mbf Qbn}bf 0 cnq 75& Gfhbcdnal qodd gi 37&73&
mnb Xbd} rf}bshblbf xbnd mbs Igkg)Jgdbfmbs bfmb}& Gddbf Pbsqalxsrfhq}lbosnbf
{ri ]so}{ hblbf xns mgpof grq$ mgqq qnal mnb Bsmb xbn}bs msblbf xnsm rfm xns cb)
qnffdnal mgq @bq} mbs Dnbcb rfm gral Qndpbq}bs bnbsf jffbf& Bnfb jrdnfgsnqalb Sbnqb
mrsal Lgicrsh in} ]nuuq$ xo nls bq}dnal qubnqbf jff}$ nfmb} nls nf rfqbsbi Hgq}so)Qubangd gr` mbf Qbn}bf 15 rfm
17& Rfm xns sbrbf rfq hgf{ cbqofmbsq gr` mbf 3>& Mb{bicbs; Ni Qalinm}q ]npodn xnsm mbs Hodmbfb lnffbsj 3573
pbsdnblbf& Gddb Foinfnbs}bf nfmb} nls gr` mbf Qbn}bf 70 rfm 78&Xns xfqalbf gddbf Dbqbsnffbf rfm Dbqbsf qoxnb gddbf Jrfmbf rfm Hbqal`}qugs}fbsf bnfb snbmdnalb Gmpbf}q{bn}$
bnf cbqnffdnalbq Xbnlfgal}q`bq} rfm bnfbf hr}bf Sr}qal nfq fbrb Kgls'
Brbs Alsnq}ngf Bxbs}
NFLGD]
lnffbsj73&3573 1
]lbig Qbn}b 0
Uodn}nj Qbn}b 7=
Ibnf Lgicrsh Qbn}b 75
Cbgr}n`rd Uboudb Qbn}b 33
Grqhblbf Qbn}b 3=
Jrd}rs Qbn}b 1=
Usohsgii Qbn}b =3
Niusbqqri Qbn}b 2=
An}~ Hrnmb Lgicrsh Qbn}b 20
Iocndn}} Qbn}b 03
Sbnqb Qbn}b 0=
GRQ MBI NFLGD]
70Bq nq} qoxbn}; Bfmb
Mb{bicbs xnsm mbs Hod)
mbfb lnffbsj pbsdnblbf&
Gf xbf mnb Usbnqb hblbf$
dnbh} gddbnf nf Brsbs
Lgfm& Lnbs nfmb} nls
gddb Foinfnbs}bf rfm
bs`gls} $ xgsri qnal mnb
Gcq}n iirfh gral `sbral dolf}&
RFQBSB SRCSNJBF
0Ufj}dnal {ri Xbd} Gnmq ]gh gi
7&73& jgibf mnb gj}rbddq}bf
LNP) rfm Gnmqq}g}nq}njbf lbs)
grq& Mnb [gld mbs Nf`n{nbs}bf nq} gr` bnfbf
fbrbf Lalq}q}gfm hbjdb}}bs}& Xns lg)
cbf mnb [gldbf rfm @gj}bf&
=Odnpng Kofbq ugaj} qalof
igd nlsb Jo``bs& Gf`gfh
3571 }grqal} qnb gfhbcdnal
mbf Jnb{ hbhbf mbf grq}sgdnqalbf
Rsxgdm rfm {nbl} nfq Mqalrfhbd)
agiu& Ombs moal fnal}? Xns hbcbf
bral mbf gj}rbddbf Q}gfm mbs Mnfhb&
02Kgjb Hbfbqnq nq} bnf gr`)
q}bnhbf mbs Q}bsf gi
Uosfo)Lniibd& @s mgq
Hdoqq) Ighg{nfb
qaldu`}b mbs gddhbibnf
hr} cbq}aj}b Lbss mbs
Qalu`rf h nfq Cg}igf)
Joq}i rfm {bnh} rfq$
xnb qb|~ mnb ibfqaldnalb
@dbmbsigrq grqqblbf
jff}b&
Bq xbnlfgal}b} qbls
fg}sdnal gral nf rfqbsbs
Mb{bicbsgrqhgcb' Fbcbf
]nuuq rfm ]bsinfbf {rs
Gmpbf}q{bn} hbcbf xns bral Nf`osig}no)
fbf {ri Xbd})Gnmq)]gh rfm sbmbf in}
Uou)Q}gs Jb-lg cbs mgq bxnhb Dbcbf&
1=Bnf ]~u sq Cb}}$ gcbs fnal} rfcbmnfh} ri in}
nli {r Ir}}n {ri ]bb {r glsbf& Bs q}gii} grqmbi Cndmcgfm K/O$ mbf xns bral mnbqbf Iofg}
b}xgq hbfgrbs posq}bddbf& @sbr} bral gr` qbls
ulgf}gq nbgfsbhb fmb Io}npb&
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
4/68
Hsgfm Usn|)]sgri hbudg}{}
]P jgff jdrhigalbfRQ)Uodn}nj cdbnc} loio`sbrfmdnal
@o}oq;
LOQNXnbf$
BINIrqna$
Albq}bs7
55,Rmo
Hsni
cbsh
.png
Xnjnibm
ngAoiiofq$
Xln}b
Lorqb$
Gdb|gf
mbs
Dgdkgj
$Mgpn
mQlgfj
cofb
Odnpng }grqal} Jnb{hbhbf MqalrfhbdHbl} qnb ombs hbl} qnb fnal}? O``n{nbdd lg} qnal xbmbs S]D foal Odnpng
qbdcq} mg{r hbrbs}$ gcbs mnb CNDM nq} qnal qnalbs$ mgqq Lgicrshq
Jnb{hsb rfm Msghwrbbf Odnpng Kofbq cbni falq}bf MqalrfhbdagiuGrq}sgdnbfq Rsxgdm kbmb Ibfhb @gscb pbsdbnlbf xnsm& Hbqugff} qnfm
xns$ oc qnb gdq Ugsgmnbqpohbd Odnpng ombs gdq mbs rfhbqalinfj}b Odnpbs
nfq Agiu bnf{nblbf xnsm& [xgs jbff} qnb gq} hgf{ Mbr}qaldgfm frs in}
`gdqalbf Csq}bf rfm Ubsajb$ gcbs xnb xndd qnal mnb Msgh)Wrbbf mos}
kbmbf Ioshbf qo q}~dbf? Mnb Jgfmnmg}bf ms`bf fidnal frs bnf uggs
ubsqfdnalb Qgalbf in}fblibf& Gi 77& Kgfrgs 3571 xbsmbf xns bq
bs`glsbf& Fbcbf Odnpng ugajbf gfhbcdnal Hbsigf~q fb|} ]ouiombd)
Jgfmnmg}nf @nofg Bsmigff$ B|)MQMQ)Q}bsfalbf Krdnb}}b Qalouuigff
rfm mnb Ir}}bs pof nal cnf pof Cbsr` ]oal}bs Mgfnbdg Jg}{bfcbshbs$
Nsnq Jdbnf$ mnb Jo``bs& Mnb sbq}dnalbf Jgfmnmg}bf q}blbf foal fnal} bq}&
@s mbf Lgicrshbs MK Injb Ibdgfhb l}}b bq bnfb hsob Qgalb xbsmbf
jffbf; mnb Qalxbn{ cbni Brsopnqnof Qofh Aof}bq} 3571 nf Qalxbmbf pbs}sb)}bf& Mgsgrq xnsm fnal}q& In} qbnfbi Bdba}so) / Mgfab)Qofh Lbddo Sninfn jgi
bs {xgs nf mnb Posgrqxgldsrfmb$ gcbs fnal} nfq @nfgdb mbq Posbf}qalbnmq& Gr`
qbnfbi @gabcooj)Uso nd cbmgfj}b qnal Injb cbn qbnfbf @gfq& Xns lgcbf rfq
cbs qo pnbd [rqusral hb`sbr} rfm mgfjbf gddbf$ mnb rfq qo }g}js`}nh rf}bsq}}{}
lgcbf& Pnbddbnal} jdguu}q kg 357=&
Mgqq RQ Usqnmbf} Ocgig ni Xbnbf
Lgrq cdbnc}$ lg} bs gral mbf loioqb|r)
bddbf Xldbsf {r pbsmgfjbf& Ri`sghbf
bshgcbf$ mgqq cnq {r 82" pof nlfbf `s
mbf Mbiojsg}bf q}niibf xodd}bf& Xold
bnf Mgfjbqalf$ mbff jbnf Gi}qnflgcbs
pos nli qb}{}b qnal qo `s mnb Hdbnalq}bd)
drfh pof Qalxrdbf rfm Dbqcbf bnf xnbOcgig& Cbn qbnfbs Mgfjbqsbmb qgh}b bs$
mgqq bq kbmbs nf Gibsnjg qalg``bf jffb$
bhgd oc bs qalxgs{ ombs xbn$ hg~ os
q}sgnhl} qbn& Gral lnffbsj hsg}rdnbs} {r
@ors iosb ~bgsq& Cbqofmbsq hdajdnal
cbs mbf Xgldgrqhgfh ms`}b bnf jdbnfbq
Imalbf qbnf& Mnb {blfklsnhb Qoulng
lg}}b Ocgig bnfbf Csnb` hbqalsnbcbf
rfm nli cbs Lfqbdbnbf nf mbs Qalrdb
cbsnal}b}$ xbnd qnb hdbnalhbqaldbal}dnalb Bd}bsf lgcb& Qnb cg} ri Sg} rfm cbjgi
kb}{} bnfb Gf}xos}$ mnb pof Ocgig q}giibf qodd& Qo lbn} bq {ri Cbnqunbd$ mgqq
qnb qnal hdajdnal qal}{bf jffb$ Bd}bsf {r lgcbf$ mnb qnal qbls dnbcbf& Xns
`nfmbf; Mgribf loal&
Bnfb RQ)gibsnjgfnqalb Q}rmnb xndd fgalhbxnbqbf lgcbf$ mgqq
@bsfqblqbsnbf in} qalxrdbf Lgru}) rfm Fbcbfmgsq}bddbsf [rqalgr)
bs }odbsgf}bs igalbf& Xns xsmbf mgq hbsfb hdgrcbf$ moal gr`
mnb S]D)Jdnqalbb)Jg}gq}soulb Mbs cbxbh}b Igff qbls sbn fgal
Sgd` Jfnh jgff qnal mgq fnal} cb{nblbf& Pnbddbnal} lbd`bf gcbs mnb
nf mnbqbs Qgnqof gfhbdgr`bfbf Qn}aoiq ]lb Fbx Fosigd ,Qalxr)
dbq Uggs rfm nlsb Dbnlir}}bs. ombs Ugs}fbsq ,Qalxrdbq Uggs rfm
Lb}bso)Uggs. {rinfmbq}$ mnb Qnal}cgsjbn} {r bsllbf& ]lb Fbx
Fosigd xrsmb mg`s hbsgmb in} mbs Osmbs bnfbs poddq}fmnhbf
Q}g``bd cbdolf}& Bnf mbr}qalbs Qbfmbs ombs Qbfmb}bsinf q}bl} foal
grq& Xbs in} bnfbi PUF)[rhgfh FCA bnfb RQ)NU)Friibs poshgr)
jbd}$ jgff qnal gddb @odhbf gr`
l}}u;//xxx&fca&aoi/}lb)fbx)fosigd gfqblbf&
Foaligd UgugBd}of Kolf$ niibslnf qalof 02 Kglsb gd}$ rfm qbnf Ugs}fbs Mgpnm
@rsfnql xbsmbf {ri {xbn}bf Igd Bd}bsf& Mnb Dbnlir}}bs$ mnb
cbsbn}q pos srfm {xbn Kglsbf
nlsbf Qolf [galgs~ {rs Xbd}
csgal}b$ nq} fgal Ibmnbf)
nf`oq qbn} bnfnhbf Iofg}bf
bsfbr} qalxgfhbs& Xbs mnb
@sgr nq}$ qodd xbn}bslnf hb)
lbni hblgd}bf xbsmbf& Bnf
@sbrfm mbq Uggsbq qgh}b mbs
[bn}rfh ]lb Qrf kbmoal$
mgqq qnb qbls hr} bf}dolf}xrsmb&
= lnffbsj73&3573
FBXQ
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
5/68
Bnf Qalxrdbflgqqbs?
Mgs` nal cn}}bf
Mbs Uou)Qjgfmgd cdbnc} grq& Mnb
Q}gg}qgfxgd}qalg`} Igfflbni
dbn}b} hbhbf mnb Irqnjbs
\gpnbs Fgnmoo ,@o}o. rfm
Jood Qgpgq jbnf sidn)
albq Pbs`glsbf xbhbfPodjqpbslb}{rfh rfm mbq
Gr`sr`q {ri ]o}qaldgh bnf&
Hbhbfcbs Qunbhbd Ofdnfb
cbq}}nh}b bnf Qusbalbs$ mgqq bq
mg`s fgal Us`rfh mbq ]b|}bq jbnfbf
grqsbnalbfmbf Gf`gfhqpbsmgal} hnc}&
Mnb Krhbfmoshgfnqg}nof mbs Dnfjqugs)
}bn lg}}b Gf{bnhb bsq}g}}b}$ xbnd mbs
Qofh Xo qnfm qnb kb}{} loiouloc
rfm podjqpbslb}{bfm qbnf qodd& Gr)
bsmbi qoddbf Jnfmbsqalfmbs in}
Loioqb|rbddbf hdbnalhbqb}{} xbs)
mbf& Qo lbn} bq {ri Cbnqunbd; Nal
qalfbnm bral kb}{} igd mnb Gsib
rfm mnb Cbnfb gc$ rfm mgff `najbnal bral nf mbf Gsqal$ qo xnb
nls bq in} mbf Jdbnfbf igal}&
Fgnmoo rfm Qgpgq lg}}bf
mnb Posxs`b ni Nf}bsfb}
{rsajhbxnbqbf&
lbn} bq gi 3& @bcsrgs ni Ugsjlo}bd
Qalfcsrff$ mbff mgff `nfmb} mos} mbs 70&Xnbfbs Sbhbfcohbfcgdd q}g}}& Gc qo`os}
cbjoii} nls `s mgq Bpbf} ]najb}q& Nf}bsbq)
qnbs}b qodd}bf qnal cbbndbf$ nf mnbqbi Kgls xgs
mbs Cgdd grqpbsjgr`}& ]sgmn}nofbdd hbl}
bq gf mnbqbi Gcbfm nf bsq}bs Dnfnb ri
hbmnbhbfb Rf}bslgd}rfh ni jdgqqnqalbf
Q}nd mbs Xnbfbs Cgdd}sgmn}nof& Gcbs mnb
Pbsgfq}gd}rfh q}bdd} {rhdbnal bnfb xnal)
}nhb Igfn`bq}g}nof dbqcnqal)qalxrdbs
Jrd}rs mgs$ mnb pof gddbf oc loio$
cn$ }sgfqhbfmbs ombs lb}bso hbibnfqgi
hbfoqqbf xnsm& ]najb}q cbjoii} nls
gc =< Brso gr` xxx&sbhbfcohbfcgdd&g}&
Loio)Q}gsJg}~ Ubss~ jbff} nls grq mbi Sgmno&
Fnal} hgf{ qo cbjgff} xnb nlsb Qofhq nq}
mnb ]g}qgalb$ mgqq qnal mnb Qfhbsnf qbls
`s mnb Hdbnalq}bddrfh pof Loioqb|rbddbf
bnfqb}{}& Mnb Hsruub ]lb ]sbpos Usokba}$
mnb nf mbf RQG {&C& bnfb Lo}dnfb `s krfhbqrn{nmhb`lsmb}b Loioqb|rbddb lg}$ pbsdbnl}
nls mg`s mbf Lbso Gxgsm& Mbs Usbnq xnsm
Jg}~ Ubss~ Gf`gfh Mb{bicbs gr` bnfbs Hgdg
nf Lodd~xoom cbssbnal}& Mnb 3
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
6/68
Nf Mbr}qaldgfm dbcbf Bfmb 3573 srfm 8< 555
Ibfqalbf in} LNP ombs Gnmq$ b}xg 27 555 mg)
pof qnfm Loioqb|rbddb& Mgq hbl} grq mbf fbrb)
q}bf Qal}{rfhbf mbq Socbs} Joal Nfq}n}r}bq ,SJN.
lbspos$ mnb Bfmb Fopbicbs poshbq}bdd} xrsmbf&
Jbnfb Bf}xgsfrfh hnc} bq cbn mbf Fbrnf`bj}nofbf&
[xgs qnfm mnb [gldbf gr`hsrfm bnfbs fbrbf Cbsbal)
frfhqib}lomb fnal} mnsbj} in} mbfbf grq 3577
pbshdbnalcgs$ mbffoal hnc} bq$ rfgclfhnh pof mbs
Cb}sgal}rfhqxbnqb$ bnfb [rfglib& 1 =55 Ibf)
qalbf lgcbf qnal fgal SJN)Cbsbalfrfhbf nf mnbqbi
Kgls crfmbqxbn} in} mbi LN)Pnsrq nf`n{nbs}& Mnb
hs}b Hsruub nq} rfm cdbnc} in} ansag 3 255 mnb mbs
Loioqb|rbddbf& Cbqofmbsq kfhbsb Qalxrdb qalbn)
fbf bq in} mbs Uspbf}nof fnal} qo hbfgr {r fbl)
ibf rfm {rinfmbq} }bndxbnqb nf bnfb Gs} Bhgd)
Q}niirfh {r pbs`gddbf$ mbff mnb ibnq}bf Fbrnf)
`bj}nofbf hnc} bq nf mbs Gd}bsqhsruub mbs 35 cnq
1>)Klsnhbf& Hsfmb mg`s pbsir}b} mgq SJN nfpbsqalnbmbfbf @gj}osbf& Qo qnfm kfhbsb Uoqn}npb o`}
foal fnal} nf ]lbsgunb rfm mgin} gral `}bs nf`bj)
}nq rfm qnb lgcbf ibls qb|rbddb Jof}gj}b gdq foal
kfhbsb ombs d}bsb Loioqb|rbddb& Grbsmbi xnsj}
qnal xold gral mbs Gfq}nbh mbs Q~ulndnqnf`bj}nofbf
gr` mnb LNP)Fbrnf`bj}nofbf grq$ mbff gral lnbs nq}
cbqofmbsq mnbqb Gd}bsqhsruub cb}so``bf&
Bnf xbn}bsbq Usocdbi nq} mnb Mrfjbd{n``bs& Hbqal}{}
xnsm$ mgqq nf Mbr}qaldgfm gj}rbdd b}xg 7= 555
Ibfqalbf LNP lgcbf$ bq gcbs fnal} xnqqbf& Mnb
[gld nq} mgin} }so}{ gddbs Gfq}sbfhrfhbf$ fnal} mng)
hfoq}n{nbs}b LNP)Nf`n{nbs}b {ri ]bq} {r io}npnbsbf$
hbq}nbhbf& Gral s mnb falq}bf Kglsb sbalfb} mgq
SJN in} bnfbi Gfq}nbh mbs [gldbf& Bq `osmbs} mbq)
lgdc xbn}bs pbsq}sj}b Igfglibf ri mnb [gld mbs
Fbrnf`bj}nofbf bnf{rmiibf rfm s} }so}{ gddbs
Bsjbff}fnqqb cbs bnfb pbsinfmbs}b Nf`bj}noqn}}
mrsal bnfb xnsjqgib LNP)]lbsgunb$ Jofmoib {r
fr}{bf& Mbff fgal xnb pos hnd}; LNP nq} fnal} lbnd)
cgs'
Bq hnc} gfdqqdnal mbq Xbd})Gnmq)]ghbq gcbs gral
hr}b Fgalsnal}bf$ pos gddbi grq gfmbsbf ]bndbf mbs
Xbd}& Mbs js{dnal poshbq}bdd}b Kglsbqcbsnal} mbs
Pbsbnf}bf Fg}nofbf {rs Gnmq)Cbjiu`rfh {bnh}$
mgqq qnal mnb [gld mbs Fbrnf`bj}nofbf nf bnfnhbf
Dfmbsf in} mbf xbd}xbn} ibnq}bf Gnmq)Bsjsgfjrf)
hbf$ posfblidnal nf G`snjg$ qbn} 3557 msgq}nqal pbs)
snfhbs} lg}& Nf gddbf Q}gg}bf qmdnal mbs Qglgsg mbs
gi qaldniiq}bf cb}so``bfbf Sbhnof nf`n{nbs}bf
qnal 3577 b}xg 32 Uso{bf} xbfnhbs Ibfqalbf in}
LNP gdq foal 3557& Foal q}sjbs xgs mbs Sajhgfh
in} ibls gdq =5 Uso{bf} nf mbs Jgsncnj$ mbs fgal
G`snjg gi qalxbsq}bf rf}bs Gnmq dbnmbfmbf Sbhnof&
Xnbmbs iblsNF@N[NBS]B
Mnb [gld mbs LNP)Nf`n{nbs}bf nf Mbr}qaldgfm q}bnh} xbn}bs
rfm xnbmbs bnfigd qnfm Qalxrdb gi lr`nhq}bf cb}so``bf&
Mnb Jgiughfb Csbfq}gsj s mnb Gnmq)Lnd`b nq} {r bnfbs
hsobf Qubfmbfgj}nof {ri Xbd})Gnmq)]gh hbxgalqbf& Mnb
mrsal mbf Pbsjgr` mbs kbmbq Kgls gfmbsq grqqblbfmbf Qodn)
mgsn}}qcsalbf bs{nbd}bf Bsdqb joiibf grqqaldnbdnal
mbs Gnmq)Lnd`b {rhr}b& Gral nls jff} lbd`bf; mbfmnbqklsnhbf Bnqcsbf cbjoii} nls s qbalq Brso
bf}xbmbs mnsbj} cbn mbs Gnmqlnd`b nf mbs Dgfhbf
Sbnlb ombs gf pbsqalnbmbfbf Gj}nofqq}fmbf rfm
nf pnbdbf Hbqal`}bf&
27 555 Qalxrdbnf Mbr}qaldgfmlgcbf LNP/Gnmq
3 255 Qalxrdblgcbf qnal mnbqbq Kgls
fbr nf`n{nbs}
]N]BD XBD] GNMQ ]GH
0 lnffbsj73&3573
@o}oq;NXXN]$HbsmGd}igff/Un|bdno&mb
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
7/68
Bnf lgdcbq Dbcbf uoqn}np@sgf{$ 2=; Kb}{} jgff nal inal bfmdnal gddbf dgqqbf
@sgf{ nq} 2= Kglsb gd}$ qbn}32 Kglsbf LNP)uoqn}np rfm Grqlfhb)
qalndm mbs Jgiughfb mbs Mbr}qalbf Gnmqlnd`b&Gdq bs mnb Mnghfoqb cbjgi$ xgs bs qnal qnalbs$ mgqqmnbq qbnf ]ombqrs}bnd qbn& ]g}qaldnal pbsqaldniibs}bqnal qbnf hbqrfmlbn}dnalbs [rq}gfm msgq}nqal& Mrsalfbrb LNP)]lbsgunbf q}gcndnqnbs}b qnal qbnf [rq}gfmxnbmbs& Lbr}b nq} mgq LN)Pnsrq nf qbnfbi Cdr} usgj)
}nqal fnal} ibls fgalxbnqcgs&
Mrsal mnb bs`odhsbnalb ]lbsgunb nq} mbnfbPnsrqdgq} qalof iblsbsb Kglsb rf}bs mbsqohbfgff}bf Fgalxbnqhsbf{b& Mr cnq}
usgj}nqal fnal} ibls gfq}bajbfm& Xgq lg}qnal mgmrsal cbn mns pbsfmbs}?Mgq lg} pos gddbi mbf Rihgfh in} ibnfbf Ugs}fbsfxnbmbs dbnal}bs rfm mbf Qb| nf}bfqnpbs hbigal}& Pos)lbs xgs mg bcbf niibs mnb Gfhq}$ mgqq b}xgq ugq)qnbsbf jff}b& Kb}{} jgff nal inal ibls gddbf dgqqbf$jgff bq ibls hbfnbbf& Mgq nq} mb`nfn}np qo& Bq lg} gfWrgdn}} hbxoffbf& Nf ibnfbi Gd}bs nq} ins Wrgdn}}bl xnal}nhbs gdq Wrgf}n}}&Mr lgq} pos 7< Kglsbf mbnfbf Ugs}fbsjbffbfhbdbsf}& Xgs LNP mgigdq bnf hsobq]lbig s bral?@s inal kg& Nal lg}}b bnf`gal Gfhq} mgpos$ mgqq nalnlf gfq}bajbf jff}b$ ocxold xns niibs gr`hbugqq}rfm Qg`bs Qb| hbigal} lgcbf& Gcbs bq jgff kg }so}{)
mbi niibs xgq ugqqnbsbf& Cbn nli xgs mgq gddbsmnfhqgfmbsq& Bs qgh}b ins hgf{ mbr}dnal$ mgqq mgq `s nlffnal}q fmbsf xsmb&In}}dbsxbndb `ls} nls bnfb o``bfb Cb{nb)lrfh& Xbff mr Qb|ugs}fbs lgq}$ igalq} mrmgff mbnfb LNP)Nf`bj}nof pof mns grq {ri]lbig?Cbn Qb|ugs}~q ombs Mg}bq jdsb nal poslbs$ mgqqnal {xgs uoqn}np$ gcbs mrsal mnb ]lbsgunb fnal}ibls nf`bj}nq cnf&Xbff mr mgq gfqusnalq} rfm mgff qghq}$mgqq mr fnal} nf`bj}nq cnq}; Xbn mg
kbmbs$ xgq mgin} hbibnf} nq}?
Mgq nq} foal fnal} nf gddbf Ju`bf gfhbjoiibf& Nfmbs Dbmbs) rfm @b}nqalq{bfb nf mbs nal inal kglgru}qaldnal cbxbhb nq} mgq Xnqqbf mgscbs gddbs)
mnfhq qalof qbls pbscsbn}b}&Xnbqo hbsgmb mos}?Mnb qb|rbddbf Usgj}njbf jffbf lnbs bnf`gal qalofigd lb`}nhbs grq`gddbf& Bhgd$ oc bq ri QI$ @nq}bfombs gfmbsb Qgalbf hbl}& Mnb cbs}sghrfhqsnqn)jbf jffbf gfmbsb qbnf&Xgq cbmbr}b} `s mnal Pbsgf}xos}rfh nfCb{rh gr` Qb|?Nal qoshb mg`s$ mgqq nal niibs rf}bs mbs Fgalxbnq)hsbf{b cnf& Nal dgqqb mgq sbhbdinh s{}dnal jof}sod)dnbsbf& Xgq nal ubsqfdnal hgs fnal} igh$ qnfm If)fbs$ mnb pnbddbnal} pnbs$ `f` ombs ibls Qb|ugs}fbs gfbnfbi Xoalbfbfmb xoddbf& Ombs ]~ubf$ mnb sri)msrajqbf$ oc qnb qnal igd lgcbf }bq}bf dgqqbf&Foal niibs hnc} bq hbhbf LNP)Uoqn}npb
Rs}bndb xbhbf pbsqral}bs Jsubspbsdb}){rfh$ qbdcq} xbff nlsb Pnsrqdgq} rf}bs mbsFgalxbnqhsbf{b nq}Mg dgqqbf pnbdb Snal}bs nlsb bnhbfbf iosgdnqalbf Gf)qalgrrfhbf nf mnb Rs}bndb bnf`dnbbf& Bq nq} rfbs}sh)dnal$ mgqq Uoqn}npb gr}oig}nqal nf qo bnfb jsninfbddbBajb hbq}bdd} xbsmbf&@ldq} mr mnal mg mnqjsninfnbs}?Jdgs& Nal cnf qbn} qbalq Kglsbf rf}bs mbs Fgalxbnq)hsbf{b& Nf mbs [bn} lgcb nal frf hgf{ qnalbs fnbigf)mbf nf`n{nbs}& Nal jbffb Dbr}b$ mnb qnal fnal} ibls}bq}bf dgqqbf$ mgin} qnb nlsbf Q}g}rq fnal} jbffbfrfm igf nlfbf hbsnal}dnal fnal}q jgff& Mgq jgff
moal fnal} mbs Qnff qbnf' Gcbs bq hbl} ins foal rib}xgq gfmbsbq$ fidnal ri mgq hbfbsbddb ]lbigmbs Pbsgf}xos}rfh&Mr ibnfq} mnb Pbsgf}xos}rfh cbni Qb|?Kg& Nshbfmxgff cbni Qb| hnc}q mnb Qn}rg}nof$ xoxns {ri Jofmoi hsbn`bf ombs bcbf fnal}& Mg lg}`s qnal kbmbs nf mbi Ioibf} {r bf}qalbnmbf$ xnddnal mgq ombs xndd nal mgq fnal}& Rfm xbff nal bcbffnal}q qghb$ mgff lgcb nal mg`s nf mbi Ioibf}gral mnb Pbsgf}xos}rfh {r cbsfblibf& @s inalhgf{ gddbnfb&
]N]BDXBD] GNMQ ]GH
LNP nq} bnfb qb|rbdd cbs}sghcgsb Nfbj}nof&Mghbhbf jgffq} Mr Mnal qal}{bf&Hbhbf mnb @odhbf frs qalxbs&Gcco}} osqal} ni Cbsbnal LNP rfm GNMQrfm rf}bsq}}{} Gnmq)Lndbf nf Mbr}qaldgfm&
Xnqqbfqxbs}bq rfm Gj}rbddbq {ri ]lbigUspbf}nof$ LNP rfm GNMQ `fmbq} Mr gr;xxx&hgs}bf)mbs)drbq}b&aoi
Grhbf gr` ni Hgs}bf mbs Dq}b&Jofmoib qal}{bf&
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
8/68
FNAJQJODRIFB
Fnaj gscbn}b} gdq
Ibmnbfibfqal
ni LNP)Cbsbnal
rfm cbsnal}b} s
rfq iofg}dnal&
Lguu~ Algsn}~
Qbgqof'
Mg nqqbs xnbmbs; mbs Xbd})GNMQ)]gh$ xbff gddb xnbmbs csgp s {xbn)bnflgdc ]ghb bnfb so}b Qaldbn`b }sg)hbf$ fbf Brso nf mnb Qubfmbfmoqbqalibnbf ombs bnfbf fnbmdnalbfGNMQ)]bmm~ jgr`bf& Mgq Hbxnq)qbf nq} cbsrlnh} gr` hbl}q {riXbnlfgal}qqlouunfh& Xbd}xbn} `l)dbf qnal Q}gsq rfm Q}bsfalbf US)xnsjqgi cb}so``bf rfm igalbfQubfmbfgr`sr`b `s GNMQ)Xgnqbf)jnfmbs nf G`snjg ,in} Msohbfhbcsgr)albfmbf ombs Qb|gscbn}bsf igh qnalgddbsmnfhq jbnfbs pof nlfbf gqqo{nnb)sbf.$ rfm nf pnbdbf Q}m}bf hnc} bq
hdgiorsqb GNMQ)Hgdgq in} crf}biQloxusohsgii&Qo qalf bq nq}$ Gr`ibsjqgijbn}mrsal Abdbcsn}~)Uoxbs {r cbjoi)ibf; @s inal qnfm mnb xglsbf Lbd)mbf mnb rf{ldnhbf lgru}) rfm bl)
sbfgi}dnalbf Gj}npnq}bf xbd}xbn}$mnb nf nlsbf bnhbfbf Aoiirfn}~qombs gr` hdocgdbs Bcbfb mg`s gscbn)}bf$ mgqq Ibfqalbf [rhgfh {r Ib)mnjgibf}bf cbjoiibf$ mgqq Ibf)qalbfsbal}b gral s Ibfqalbf in}LNP hbd}bf$ mgqq xbn}bslnf Gr`jd)srfh cbs LNP cb}snbcbf xnsm$ rfmmgqq mnbkbfnhbf$ mnb gi ibnq}bf pofLNP cb}so``bf qnfm rfm mg{r {l)
dbf bcbf gral Msohbfhbcsgralbf)mb$ Qb|gscbn}bs$ ]sgfqhbfmbs rfmQalxrdb hbq}sj} xbsmbf&Nal xsmb ins qo xfqalbf$ mgqq xnsgddb mgq ]lbig fnal} frs bnfigd niKgls xglsfblibf$ qofmbsf mgqq xnsrfq hsgmb xns gdq qalxrdb Iffbs cbxrqq} xbsmbf$ mgqq LNP fgalxnb pos hgf{ bfh in} rfqbsbi Dbcbf{r }rf lg}$ kbmbf ]gh&Xbff xns xnsjdnal b}xgq `s mbfhr}bf [xbaj }rf xoddbf$ dgqq} rfqmbf hsobf Hsgcbf {xnqalbf Uoqn}n)pbf rfm Fbhg}npbf cbscsajbf$dgqq} rfq rfqbsb Poscblgd}b mbf gf)
mbsbf hbhbfcbs gccgrbf$ pbs{nal)}bf xns Fbhg}npb gr` Joiibf}gsbxnb qgrcbs$ mr cn}}b gral nf rfqb)sbf Ofdnfb)Uso`ndbf$ rfm xbsqfoal fnal} ombs qalof dfhbs fnal}hb}gf lg} ; Dgqq} Bral }bq}bf'
Fbrb Q}rmnbf cbdbhbf; dnbh} mnb Pn)srqdgq} cbn LNP)Nf`n{nbs}bf mrsal bnfbbs`odhsbnalb ]lbsgunb qbn} infmbq}bfqqbalq Iofg}bf rf}bs mnb Fgalxbnq)hsbf{b rfm qnfm jbnfb gfmbsbf Q]Nposlgfmbf$ nq} bnfb cbs}sghrfh mbsJsgfjlbn} fglb{r grqhbqaldoqqbf&
Gcbs xgq lbn} mgq kb}{}? [rsajdbl)fbf rfm bnf`gal gr`q Jofmoi pbs){nal}bf xbnd qalof fnal}q ugqqnbsbfxnsm? Jbnfbqxbhq& Xgq nq}$ xbff mbsQb|ugs}fbs fnal} mnb Xglslbn} qgh}ombs hgs fnal} xbn$ xnb qbnf LNP)Q}g)}rq nq}? Jofmoib qnfm rfm cdbncbf niqalxrdbf Qb|dbcbf gr` mbs `sbnbfXndmcglf bnf xnal}nhbs Cbq}gfm}bnd&Mgq Hriin xbhdgqqbf$ gral xbffkbigfm uoqn}np$ gcbs fnal} ibls gf)q}bajbfm nq}$ qodd}b} nls frs nf Grqfgl)ib`ddbf$ qgh} Igsa Hsbf{ pof Lbnf @nb}b& Mnbqb Pnsrqdgq}ib}lomb nq}gr` iofohgib Cb{nblrfhbf cb)qalsfj} rfm cbmbr}b} bnfb q}fmnhb
s{}dnalb Jof}soddb rfm qaldnbdnal qodd)}b jbnfbs mbs Ugs}fbs bnf qaldbal}bqHb`ld mgcbn lgcbf& Mbff bhgd ockbigfm in} LNP nf`n{nbs} nq} ombs fnal};mrsal Qb| olfb Jofmoi jff} nlsbral gral in} {gldsbnalbf gfmbsbfJsgfjlbn}bf ombs Bssbhbsf nf`n{nbsbf$
cbnqunbdqxbnqb in} Lbug}n}nq$ Aldgi~)mnbf ombs ]snuubs& Cbn Lbnf@nb}b niUrdpbs}bnal 37 jff} nls bral mnbfq)}ghq rfm moffbsq}ghq {xnqalbf 70rfm 7< Rls }bq}bf rfm/ombs cbsg}bfdgqqbf& B|ubs}bf q}blbf bral in} Sg}rfm ]g} {rs Qbn}b rfm `s gddb$ mbfbf qobnf ]bsinf rfgfhbfbli nq}; gddbq xnsmpbs}sgrdnal rfm pos gddbi gfof~i cb)lgfmbd}& Fnbigfm grbs mbs hb}bq}b)}bf Ubsqof bs`ls} mgq Bshbcfnq$ mbffmbs Dgcoscbsnal} xnsm fgal mbi Hb)qusal pbsfnal}b}& Frs xbff hb)xfqal}$ mgs` bs s bnfnhb Iofg}b niGsalnp gr`cbxgls} xbsmbf& Ibls Nf)`oq nfmb} nls gr` xxx&lbnf`nb}b&mb&
Qb|
olfbHriin?Jbnf @sbn`gls}qalbnf
Fgal xnb pos hnd}; igalq in}'
]N]BD XBD] GNMQ ]GH
< lnffbsj73&3573
Mgpnm$ =2 Kglsb
Gfhbq}bdd}bs ni qo{ngdbf Cbsbnal
LNP)uoqn}np
NALLGCBLNP&
L}}bnalgralmbnfb?
RFM MNB
GJ[BU]GF[IBNFBQ ALB@Q&
Jof{bu}&Mbqnhf;jgjonnCbsdnf
tq}bnfsajb*nal
Jdf
t@o}o;Qbcgq}ngf
Lfbd
[bnh Qaldbn`b Nf`osinbsb mnal Xbsmb gj}npXBD])GNMQ)]GH&MB[bnh Qaldbn`b Nf`osinbsb mnal Xbsmb gj}np7&73&Uoqn}np {rqgiibf dbcbf&
@o}oq;C{hG$
nq}oajulo}o&aoi
n
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
9/68
Nf Mbr}qaldgfm qnfm fgal gj}rbddbfQal}{rfhbf {xbn Msn}}bd gddbs LNP)Uoqn}npbf cbsr`q}}nh& Frs bnfb Inf)mbslbn} pof nlfbf }sgr} qnal$ mbi Alb`ombs mbf Joddbhbf gral {r qghbf$mgqq qnb LNP)uoq}np qnfm& Cbn bnfbs pofmbs Mbr}qalbf Gnmqlnd`b ,ni Gr`}sgh
mbs C{hG. mrsalhb`ls}bf Q}rmnb hg)cbf 07 Uso{bf} mbs Cb`sgh}bf gf$ nlsbNf`bj}nof gi Gscbn}qudg}{ {r pbs)qalxbnhbf& Mbs lr`nhq}b Hsrfm nq}mnb Gfhq} pos Cbfgal}bndnhrfh& MnbqbCb`sal}rfh nq} o``bfcgs fnal} rfcb)hsfmb}& Gdgsinbsbfmb 88 Uso{bf}mbs cb`sgh}bf Ibfqalbf in} LNP lg)cbf ni Kgls pos mbs Cb`sghrfh Mnqjsn)infnbsrfh ni Gdd}gh bsdbc}&$ qgh}bC[hG)Mnsbj}osnf Uso`& Ms& Bdnqgcb}lUo}}& Xns xoddbf rfm iqqbf nssg}no)fgdb fhq}b gccgrbf rfm I~}lbfbf}hbhbf}sb}bf$ ri Grqhsbf{rfh pofIbfqalbf in} LNP {r pbslnfmbsf&Ri mnbqbi [nbd bnf Q}ajalbf flbs{r joiibf$ lg} mnb Mbr}qalb Gnmqlnd)
`b nf [rqgiibfgscbn} in} Uodn}nj rfmgfmbsbf Oshgfnqg}nofbf mnb Jgiug)hfb Uoqn}np {rqgiibf dbcbf' nfqDbcbf hbsr`bf& In} ir}nhbf Q}g}b)ibf}q xnb Nal lgcb LNP& Rfm mbfSbqubj} ibnfbs Joddbhbf& L}}b nalgral Mbnfbf? xbscbf Nf`n{nbs}b gr`
Udgjg}bf qoxnb nf bnfbi Jnfo) rfm ]P)Quo} s ]odbsgf{ rfm Qodnmgsn}}&Mbs Qalxbsurfj} mbs Jgiughfb dnbh}ni Cbsbnal LNP nf mbs Gscbn}qxbd}&Bnfb LNP)Nf`bj}nof `ls} fnal} gr}o)ig}nqal {rs Gscbn}qrf`lnhjbn}& Ibf)qalbf in} LNP jffbf rfm iqqbf snlsbf Dbcbfqrf}bslgd} qoshbf&$ qgh}Crfmbqhbqrfmlbn}qinfnq}bs MgfnbdCgls& Rf}bsq}}{rfh cbjoiibf mnbNfn}ng}osbf grq mbs Xns}qalg`}& Qo nfn}n)nbsbf {ri Cbnqunbd @osm rfm DeOsgdGj}nofbf hbhbf Q}nhig}nqnbsrfh rfmMnqjsninfnbsrfh& Foal ibls Nf`oq$ Pn)mboadnuq rfm Uos}sgn}q mbs Jgiug)hfbf)Hbqnal}bs `nfmb} nls gr` xxx&xbd})gnmq}gh&mb
MNB @GINDNB ]R] XGQ
Mnb Xrfmbscgs pbsxgfmbd} qnal gi 15&77& gc 33 Rls {rs hsobf Qubfmbf)Do)ag}nof& Gddb In}gscbn}bs$ mgsrf}bs Grqlnd`bf xnb Msghwrbbf Pgdbs~ Ubgsd rfm@gsnm Iddbs$ pbs{nal}bf gr` Dolf rfm ]snfjhbdm$ ri mgq Hbdm bnfbi hr}bf [xbaj{rjoiibf {r dgqqbf& Gral gddb Bnf}sn}}qhbdmbs ,2 uso U&. xbsmbf hbqubfmb}&
AGFMDB DNHL] XGDJ
Mbs ]sgmn}nofqigsqal nf Hbmbfjbf gf mnb gf Gnmq Pbsq}oscbfbf q}bl} gi 15&77&rf}bs mbi Io}}o {rqgiibf q}blbf$ {rqgiibf hblbf& Fgal bnfbi Ho}}bq)mnbfq} ni jribfnqalbf @osri nf mbs Lg`bfan}~ ,7< Rls. cbhnff} mbs Igsqalmos} ri 7>&15 Rls rfm ls} mrsal mnb Nffbfq}gm} rfm Q}& Hbosh {r Lbnf@nb}b&
LBSOBQ GHGNFQ] GNMQ
Mnb Cbfb`n{pbsgfq}gd}rfh s mnb Lgicrshbs Gnmqlnd`b nfmb} gi 7&73& gc 37 Rlsnf mbs ]gf{qalrdb Cgdgmnf ,Gd}ofg. q}g}}& Bq qunbd} {&C& mnb Cnh Cgfm ]lb Hsbbf)losfq$ bq hnc} bnfb ]gf{qlox$ bnfb ]oicodg rfm mnb Gnmqlnd`b lg} pbsqalnbmbfbGr`jdsrfhqqunbdb mgcbn& MK ]ocna qosh} ni Gfqaldrqq s Ugs}~q}niirfh& Bnf)}sn}}; < &
MNB UG]BF HBIBNFQGI HBHBF GNMQ
Xoalbfdgfh xrsmbf cbsgdd nf mbs Q{bfb Qubfmbf s mgq Qalrdgr`jdsrfhquso)kbj} Qoosri hbqgiibd}& Gi 7&73& xnsm gc 37 Rls mnb Qalbajcbshgcb ni ilahb`bnbs}& In} mgcbn qnfm mnb Wrn{igq}bs Srmn rfm Qgdd~ ,Aof}ga} Cgs. qoxnb MK Sof,Xrfmbscgs.& Mbs Bnf}sn}} nq} sbn$ Qubfmbf xbsmbf kbmoal hbsf hbqblbf&
LBNF & @NB]B)CBFB@N[UGS]^Qalof igd pbsqral}$ bnf Jofmoi cdnfm cbs bnfbf Mndmo {r {nblbf? Mgq jff}nls gi 7&73& gc 31;&15 Rls cbn mbs Cbfb`n{ugs}~ ni ]oiq Qgdoof usocnbsbf& Cbnpbsqalnbmbfbf Gj}nofbf mbs Qg`b}~ Asbx jff} nls `s Lbnf @nb}b qubfmbfombs bral bnfbf b|}sg {rcbsbn}b}bf Aoaj}gnd cbq}bddbf$ pof mbqqbf Usbnq bnf ]bndhbqubfmb} xnsm&
Pbsgfq}gd}rfhbf
Uoqn}npni KocLgc} nls mbf Ir}
{ri Or}nfh?
lnffbsj73&3573 >
]N]BDXBD] GNMQ ]GH
NALHsnfmbdMs& ibm& ]loigq Crlj Ms& ibm& Q}b`gf @bfqjb
Uso`& Ms& ibm& Lgfq)Kshbf Q}bddcsnfj
Hsnfmbdgddbb 12 357=0 Lgicrsh
NAL In}}bQ}b`gf Lgfqbf
UM Ms& ibm& Alsnq}ngf Lo``igff
Mgii}osq}sgb 38 3512= Lgicrsh
NAL Q}& HboshMs& ibm& G|bd Gmgi Ms& ibm& Inalgbd Qgcsgfqjn
Ms& ibm& Agsd Jfrm Qalbxb
Csbffbsq}sgb 87 355>> Lgicrsh
xxx&nal)lgicrsh&mb
Pnbdbf Mgfj `smgq Pbs}sgrbf 3573'
Qalfb @bq}}ghb xfqalbfG|bd Gmgi ]loigq Crlj Q}b`gf @bfqjb Q}b`gf Lgfqbf
Alsnq}ngf Lo``igff Inalgbd Qgcsgfqjn Agsd Jfrm Qalbxb
Lgfq)Kshbf Q}bddcsnfj Loig Cgqlnsn Ub}sg Cosf
Sr{g Co}na Nsnfg Cr}jrq Dnqg Hsbigff Qrqgffb Lbbqal
Gfgq}gqng Lbdir} Hngo Db Kbffn`bs Dnfmbdo Gdb|gfmbs Ignfjg
Dgrsg)Qoulnb Fnbdqbf Alsnq}nfg Orcgsn Igsdbfb Ugsbnsg
Qnhsnm Uodg} Mbffnq Sgm{rxbn} Fg}gdng Qalfrm} Q~dpng Q}bddcsnfj
Hgcn Rscgfa{~j Kgf [nbdjb rfm Bffo @bfqjb)Crsibq}bs
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
10/68
G|bd Gmgi bscdnaj}b 7>01 nf Slbnfdgfm)U`gd{ mgq
Dnal} mbs Xbd}& 7>>3 gscbn}b} bs ni NAL Q}& Hbosh$ bnfbsLNP)Qalxbsurfj}usg|nq& Mos} dbsf}b bs pos gq} 35
Kglsbf qbnfbf lbr}nhbf Ugs}fbs jbffbf$ in} mbi
bs qbn} Ign 3575 nf mbs Flb pof Dfbcrsh gr` bn)
fbi gd}bf Cgrbsflo` xolf}&
Alsnq}oul Sbn``bs} nq} @rfmsgnqnfh)
Joosmnfg}os mbs Dbqcnqal Qalxrdbf
@ndi}ghb rfm qosh} mg`s$ mgqq qnal
mgq @bq}npgd `nfgf{nbsbf jgff
@ndi gc&&&
Qo xnb gr` mbi Cndm ocbf jbffbf G|bd Gmgi mnb xbfnhq}bf& Xbff bs fnal} nf mbs Usg|nq nq}$
cgr} bs {rqgiibf in} qbnfbi Ugs}fbs mbf bnhbfbf Cgrbsflo` ri&
Qalof gdq Jnfm xodd}b G|bd Gs{} xbsmbf& Bn)
hbf}dnal Alnsrsh$ gcbs bs ibsj}b qalfbdd$ mgqq
Jsgfjbflrqbs fnal} qbnf Mnfh qnfm& Qbn} Gf)
`gfh mbs Fbrf{nhbs Kglsb gscbn}b} mbs =>)Klsnhb nf
mbs Usg|nq nf mbs Csbffbsq}sgb& Bq nq} qbnf ]sgrikoc$
xnb bs qgh}$ gddbsmnfhq lg} mnbqbs gral Qalg}}bfqbn)
}bf& Pos gddbi slbs irqq}b bs pnbdbf Iffbsf qg)
hbf$ mgqq qnb q}bscbf xsmbf& Gf Gnmq& Nal qblb
inal foal cbn pnbdbf Ug}nbf}bf fnal} hbhbfcbsqn})
{bf qofmbsf fbcbfmsgf rfm xns lbrdbf {rqgi)
ibf&
[r Cbhnff qbnfbs Dgr`cglf xgs mnb Ibmn{nf foal
fnal} qo xbn} `os}hbqalsn}}bf$ mgq uoqn}np Hb}bq}b}b}lbsgunbs} xbsmbf joff}bf& [r qo igfalbi$ mbi
bs mnb Fgalsnal} cbscsnfhbf irqq}b$ lg} bs fgal
xnb pos Jof}gj}& Xbff qnb fnal} hbq}oscbf qnfm$
qnfm hgf{ pnbdb niibs foal mg& Rfm mgq nq} }o}gd
qalf& Kb}{} jgff nal {r nlfbf in} @rh rfm Sbal}
qghbf; kb}{} xbsmbf xns hbibnfqgi gd}& Mnbqbq gd}
xbsmbf pbsmgfjbf mnb Ibfqalbf ]gcdb}}bf& Lbr})
{r}ghb sbnal} igfaligd qalof bnfb Unddb gi ]gh$ ri
mnb Pnsrqdgq} rf}bs Jof}soddb {r lgd}bf rfm$ ni Hb)
hbfqg}{ {r slbs$ fosigd dbcbf {r jffbf& Mgq nq}
grq Qnal} pof G|bd kbmoal gral bnf Usocdbi$ mbff
mgq Cbxrqq}qbnf lg} qnal mgmrsal pos gddbi cbn kf)
hbsbf Qalxrdbf hbfmbs}& Nal lgcb lr`nh krfhb
Dbr}b pos ins qn}{bf rfm xbff nal mbfbf qghb$ mgqq
qnb uoqn}np qnfm$ sbghnbsbf qnb fnal} bnfigd& QbnfbsIbnfrfh fgal dnbh} mgq {ri ]bnd gral mgsgf$ mgqq
mnb fgaljoiibfmbf Hbfbsg}nofbf cbslgru} fnal}
xnqqbf$ xgq qodal bnfb Mnghfoqb pos bnf uggs Kgls)
{blf}bf foal cbmbr}b}b& Mnb lgcbf jbnfb @sbrf)
mb$ mnb mgigdq cb}so``bf xgsbf$ mbfbf qnfm fnal}
hgf{b @sbrfmbqjsbnqb xbhhbq}oscbf& Mbf Qalsbj)
jbf pof LNP qblbf mnb fnal}& Gdq Gs{} pbsqral} bs$
krfhb Qalxrdb {r qbfqncndnqnbsbf$ mbff gral xbff
bq pnbdb fnal} qaldnii `nfmbf$ }hdnal bnfb ]gcdb}}b
{r qaldrajbf$ fmbs} qnal mgq Dbcbf mrsal mgq LN)
Pnsrq mbffoal& Mgq cbmbr}b} sbhbdinhb Gs{}cb)
qralb$ sbhbdinhb Cdr}gcfglib$ gdqo gddb msbn
Iofg}b bnfb Fgmbd nf mbs Pbfb rfm mgq cbmbr}b}$
mgqq igf Ibmnjgibf}b fnii} rfm {xgs bnf Dbcbf
dgfh$ olfb {r xnqqbf$ xgq fgal {blf ombs {xgf{nh
Kglsbf ugqqnbs}& G|bd ibnf} mnb Fbcbfxnsjrfhbf&
Ibmnjgibf}b xbsmbf ansag {xbn Kglsb nf Q}rmnbf
hb}bq}b}$ qgh} bs& Fbcbfxnsjrfhbf$ mnb gcbs bsq}
fgal bnfbs dfhbsbf Bnffglib gr`}gralbf jffbf$
xbsmbf mgcbn fnal} hbqblbf& Qbnf Guubdd nq} bnfmbr)
}nh; Bq dolf} gral lbr}b foal$ qnal fnal} in} LNP {r
nf`n{nbsbf' Gral ri mnbqb Co}qalg`} {r pbscsbn}bf$
bfhghnbs} qnal mbs Ibmn{nfbs nf mbs Q{bfb& G|bd qn}{}
ni Usokbj}cbnsg} pof Lbnf @nb}b rfm gscbn}b} in}
mbs Lgicrshbs Gnmqlnd`b {rqgiibf$ cbsnal}b} rf}bs
gfmbsbi pof Jofhsbqqbf&Qbnf Cbsr` lg} gral qbnf Usnpg}dbcbf fgallgd}nh hb)
ush}$ mbff qbnf Ugs}fbs dnb` nli fnal} gi Jldsbhgd
ni Qrubsigsj} cbs mbf Xbh& Mgq bsq}b Igd hbqb)
lbf lgc nal nlf lnbs nf mbs Usg|nq& Bs jgi gdq Ug}nbf}
sbnf hbq}nb`bd}& Jrs{b [bn} qu}bs }sg`bf qnal cbnmb
gr` bnfbs Ugs}~ xnbmbs$ qbn}mbi qnfm qnb {rqgiibf&
Ni @bcsrgs `bnbs} mgq Uggs qbnfbf nf{xnqalbf 7
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
11/68
cbsfnii
Pbsgf}xos}rfh
`s Mnal '
Xnb nal in} Pbsgf}xos}rfh cbni Qb| rihblb$
bs{ld nal Mns gr xxx&nxxn}&mb
@sgf{ ,2=.
7/30/2019 hinnerk 12.12
12/68
Grunfh$ mbs hs}b qbdcq})
q}fmnhb Cb}}bflbsq}bddbs mbsFnbmbsdgfmb$ lg} bq qalof niibspbsq}gfmbf$ Qaldg`joi`os}$@rfj}nof rfm Q}nd {r iombsfbi
rfm {bn}doq bdbhgf}bi Mbqnhf {rpbscnfmbf& Kfhq}bq Cbnqunbd mg)`s nq} mgq fbrb Grunfh)Cb}} Bq)qbf}ngd ,@o}o.$ mgq mnbqbq Kglsin} mbi sbfoiinbs}bf Sbm Mo}Mbqnhf Gxgsm grqhb{bnalfb}xrsmb& Grunfh qb}{} gr` Wrgdn}}rfm @rfj}nofgdn}}& Frs xbffqnal Qaldg`bshofoinb$ hr}bMrsald`}rfh$ Msrajpbs}bndrfhrfm Rf}bsq}}{rfh {rs ubs`bj)}bf @osi pbsbnfbf$ bf}q}blbf
grqhb{bnalfb}b Cb}}bf$ qo mnb@nsibfulndoqoulnb& Kb}{} qb}{}mgq Rf}bsfblibf gral nf mbixnal}nhbf q}sg}bhnqalbf @bdm mbsjodohnb rfm Fgallgd}nhjbn} bnf
[bnalbf& Cbsbn}q ni @slkgls lg})}b mbs Lbsq}bddbs mgq cbhbls}bQndpbs Asgmdb)}o)Asgmdb)[bs}n`n)jg} s qbnfb fbrb Ig}sg}{bf)Dn)fnb rfm mgq Cb}}iombdd Bqqbf}n)gd bslgd}bf& Mgq Wrgdn}}qqnbhbdnq} Pbsqusbalbf rfm Pbsu`dnal)}rfh& Bq hgsgf}nbs}$ mgqq mnb Uso)mrj}b {r ibls gdq 25" grq sba~)abd}bi Ig}bsngd lbshbq}bdd} cb){nblrfhqxbnqb gddb Ig}bsngdnbfxnbmbspbsxbs}cgs qnfm& Gj}rbdd
cnb}b} Grunfh mgq bsq}b$ joi)udb}} fgal mnbqbi Usnf{nu usomr){nbs}b Cb}}q~q}bi gf& Xbs mnbhgf{b Xbd} mbs Grunfh)Cb}}bf$mnb joiudb}}b Joddbj}nof gf Cb}})
hbq}bddbf$ Co|qusnfhcb}}bf$ Ig)}sg}{bf$ Qaldg`}b|}ndnbf rfm Ga)abqqonsbq bsdbcbf xndd$ nq} nfMbr}qaldgfmq hs}bi Udg{g hr}gr`hblocbf& Mbf Lgicrshbs@dghqlnuq}osb `nfmb} nls ni q}nd)xbsj nf mbs Hsobf Bdcq}sgb&
GRQHB[BNALFB] QALDG@BF
Mbs Qoffb bf}hbhbfBq irqq fnal} niibs Hsgf Agfgsng qbnf& Xnb xsb bq {&C& in}]lgndgfm$ Nfmofbqnbf$ Igdg~qng ombs Qnfhgurs? BFKO^ GQNGnq} brbs Qub{ngdnq} s Gqnbfsbnqbf rfm G~rspbmg)Jrsbf$ hgf{ fbr{r `nfmbf nf mbs Qalindnfqj~q}sgb 13 gr` Q}& Hbosh& [r Xbnl)fgal}bf lg} BFKO^ GQNG bnf cbqofmbsbq Ugjb} hbqalfs}; CbnCralrfh bnfbs ugrqalgdbf @bsf) ombs G~rspb)mgsbnqb cnq 17&Is{ 3571 cbjoii} kbmbsJrfmb bnfb 05)inf}nhb G~rspbmgigqqghbpof mbs lgrqbnhbfbf Igqqghb}lbsgubr}nfhsg}nq& Fg}sdnal jff} nls bnfb Sbnqb) ombsIgqqghbcblgfmdrfh gral ubs Hr}qalbnf pbs)qalbfjbf&
BFKO^ GQNG$Qalindnfqj~q}sgb 13$ xxx&bfko~gqng&mb
Dr|rq `s mnb Lgr}Pbshbqq} mbf ]srcbd mbs Hsoq}gm} rfm }gral}ni Cgcos Cbgr}~ Qug nf bnfb fbrb Xold`ldxbd}bnf& Nls cbjoii} mos} fnal} frs jdgqqnqalb Hb)qnal}q) rfm Jsubscblgfmdrfhbf$ qofmbsf gralloalb``bj}npbq Gf}n)Ghnfh rfm bnfb nfmnpnmrbddbIgjb)ru Cbsg}rfh& Gi Qgiq}gh$ 3= 57xxx&cgcos&mb/ccq)lghbf
Mbs cbqofmbsb HbfrqqBsdbc} in} qgiopg mnb iombsfb ]bbjrd}rs Igmb nf Hbsigf~& Hbhsfmb}grq Dbnmbfqalg`} `s Qub{ngdn}}bf grq ]bb rfm Jsr}bsf$ q}bl} mgq nflgcbshb)`ls}b Rf}bsfblibf `s fbrb Hbqaligajqbsdbcfnqqb grq cbq}bf Solq}o``bf$bnf usinbs}bq Mbqnhf rfm grbshbxlfdnalb Pbsgfq}gd}rfhbf$ xnb {ri Cbn)qunbd iombsfb ]gf{}bbq rfm mbf Ulndoqoulnqalbf Qgdof& Hbsgmb ni Xnf}bsqalibaj} ]bb cbqofmbsq dbajbs$ qo qalf pbsugaj} rfm nfq{bfnbs} xnb cbn qgio)pg bnhfb} qnal mbs ]bb hgf{ cbqofmbsq gdq Hbqalbfj `s qnal qbdcq} ombs mbfDnbcq}bf& Xbn}bsb Nf`oq cbjoii} nls gr` xxx&qgiopg&fb}
Grunfh Udg{gHsob Bdcq}sgb 0