Roseberry 1989 Peasants World

download Roseberry 1989 Peasants World

of 10

Embed Size (px)

description

Chapter in Economic Anthropology, Plattner 1989.

Transcript of Roseberry 1989 Peasants World

  • 0czjE0

    dic)-l-

    .

    -4-,

    in

    C

    I

    4-,in

    inCCin

    C0)

    Cc-iIa)

    C

    0)in

    CinI0)Cin

    inC

    LI)

    C.404-

    a)

    ir

    -d

    -d

    C

    -4-,

    C

    c)-I-CC

    H

  • Peas

    ants

    and

    the

    Wor

    ldin

    toexper

    imt

    with

    new

    ones

    .A

    lthou

    ghse

    ver

    alatt

    empt

    sw

    ere

    made

    ,-

    one

    dese

    rves

    spec

    ial

    men

    tion:

    the

    Puer

    toR

    ICO

    proje

    ctle

    dby

    Julia

    nSt

    ewar

    dand

    condu

    cted

    byst

    uden

    tsw

    hoha

    vesin

    cebe

    com

    em

    ajor

    contr

    ibut

    ors

    tonth

    ropo

    l0gM

    llit

    erat

    ure,

    incl

    udin

    gR

    ober

    tM

    anne

    rs,

    Sidn

    eyM

    intZ

    ,El

    ena

    Padi

    la,

    Ray

    mon

    dSc

    heel

    e,and

    Eric

    Wol

    f.B

    ased

    on

    field

    wor

    kcondu

    cted

    inth

    ela

    te194

    0S

    ,th

    epr

    oject

    was

    dire

    ctly

    re

    late

    dto

    two

    majo

    rpub

    licat

    ions

    inth

    eth

    odol

    ogic

    alre

    thin

    king

    oft

    hepe

    riod:

    Stew

    ard

    sAr

    eaRe

    sear

    ch:

    Theo

    njan

    dPr

    actic

    e(1

    950)

    ,a

    meth

    odolo

    gica

    lhan

    dboo

    k;and

    The

    Peop

    leof

    Puer

    toRi

    co(S

    teward

    etal.

    1956

    ),w

    hich

    conta

    ins

    the

    subs

    tant

    ive

    findi

    ngs

    ofth

    est

    udy.

    Wor

    ldSY

    Stem

    The

    ory

    Alth

    ough

    thes

    eand

    rela

    ted

    stud

    ies

    contr

    ibut

    edto

    ape

    riod

    ofm

    eth

    odo

    logi

    calf

    erm

    enti

    nth

    e195

    0S

    ,th

    ein

    fusi

    onof

    depe

    nden

    cylit

    erat

    ure

    and

    worl

    dsys

    tem

    pers

    pect

    ives

    inth

    e19

    60s

    and197

    oS

    prod

    uced

    aneven

    more

    serio

    uscr

    isis

    of

    nth

    ropo

    1ogi

    cal

    confid

    ence

    .D

    epen

    denc

    ylit

    erat

    ure

    (gen

    erally

    asso

    ciat

    edw

    ithits

    most

    popu

    lar

    and

    extr

    eme

    spok

    esm

    ani

    And

    reG

    unde

    rFr

    ank;

    see

    his

    1967

    and

    1969

    work

    s)and

    the

    clos

    ely

    rela

    ted

    world

    sYst

    emlit

    erat

    ure

    (gen

    erally

    ass

    ocia

    ted

    with

    lmnt

    anU

    elW

    alle

    rste

    iflse

    ees

    peci

    ally

    his

    1974

    and

    1979

    work

    s)ca

    me

    from

    outs

    ide

    anth

    ropo

    logy

    but

    off

    ered

    impo

    rtant

    impl

    icat

    ions

    for

    the

    anth

    rop0

    l0gi

    lst

    udy

    of

    peas

    ants

    .W

    riter

    sin

    this

    trad

    ition

    did

    not

    star

    tw

    ithth

    epe

    asan

    tvill

    age,

    and

    the

    ders

    tand

    ing

    ofv

    illag

    elif

    ew

    as

    not

    thei

    rcho

    sen

    prob

    lem

    .R

    athe

    r,th

    eyw

    ere

    tryi

    ngto

    acco

    unt

    for

    the

    cre

    atio

    nand

    pers

    iste

    nce

    ofec

    onom

    icba

    ckw

    ardn

    ess

    or

    unde

    rdev

    eloP

    rnent,

    and

    they

    arg

    ued

    that

    back

    war

    dnes

    sw

    asa

    dire

    ctpr

    oduc

    tof

    the

    deve

    lopm

    ento

    fcap

    italis

    m.

    The

    basic

    ass

    um

    ptio

    nsofa

    world

    SYSt

    empe

    rspe

    ctiv

    ear

    eth

    ese:

    i.A

    soci

    alsc

    ient

    ists

    houl

    dst

    udy

    soci

    alw

    hole

    s.In

    the

    mode

    rnw

    orld

    ,th

    ere

    isonly

    one

    effe

    ctiv

    eso

    cial

    who

    le,a

    nd

    that

    isth

    ew

    orld

    syst

    em.

    a.Th

    ew

    orld

    syst

    emis

    inte

    grat

    edec

    onom

    ical

    lyra

    ther

    than

    polit

    ica

    lly.T

    hati

    s,it

    isa

    world

    econom

    yco

    mpo

    sed

    of

    num

    ero

    us

    polit

    ical

    lyin

    depe

    nden

    tbut

    econom

    ical

    lyin

    terd

    epen

    dent

    stat

    es.

    .

    The

    world

    syst

    emis

    econom

    ical

    lydi

    ffer

    entia

    ted,

    com

    pose

    dof

    (a)a

    core

    ,co

    nsi

    stin

    gof

    the

    stat

    esat

    the

    deve

    lope

    dce

    nte

    roft

    hew

    orld

    econom

    y(fo

    rexam

    ple,

    the

    Uni

    ted

    Stat

    esand

    nort

    hwes

    tern

    Euro

    pe);

    (b)a

    perip

    herY

    consi

    stin

    goft

    heunde

    rdev

    elop

    edst

    ates

    inth

    eso

    -cal

    led

    Thi

    rdW

    orld

    (fore

    xam

    ple,

    Boliv

    ia,

    Hon

    dura

    s,and

    Jam

    aica

    )and

    (c)a

    sem

    iper

    iphe

    rYic

    om

    pose

    dof

    buffe

    rsta

    tes

    that

    have

    more

    opp

    ortu

    nitie

    sfo

    rde

    velo

    pmen

    tth

    anpe

    riphe

    ral

    stat

    es,

    exer

    cise

    som

    ede

    gree

    of

    eco

    nom

    icin

    fluen

    ceover

    thei

    rneig

    hbor

    Sbu

    tar

    enoneth

    eles

    snot

    co

    re

    (fore

    xam

    ple,

    Mex

    ico,

    Ven

    ezue

    la,S

    outh

    Afri

    ca,a

    nd

    vario

    usM

    edite

    rra

    nean

    and

    East

    Eur

    opea

    nco

    untr

    ies).

    4.T

    his

    inte

    rnat

    iona

    llyst

    ruct

    ured

    ineq

    ualit

    yis

    ade

    eply

    roote

    dhi

    sto

    rical

    prod

    uCts

    cre

    ate

    dw

    ithth

    efo

    rmat

    ion

    ofa

    capi

    talis

    tw

    orld

    econ

    om

    yin

    the

    sixt

    eent

    hcentu

    ryand

    shap

    edac

    ross

    four

    centu

    ries

    ofc

    olo

    nia

    land

    post

    colo

    nial

    chan

    ge.

    .

    Soci

    alpr

    oces

    ses

    inpa

    rticu

    lar

    regi

    ons

    can

    beunde

    rsto

    odonly

    inte

    rms

    oft

    hepl

    ace

    and

    func

    tion

    oft

    hose

    regi

    ons

    with

    inth

    ela

    rger

    world

    syst

    em.

    Inde

    ed,

    itis

    com

    mon

    for

    world

    -sys

    tem

    theo

    rists

    toexpl

    ain

    prob

    lem

    sin

    the

    perip

    hery

    or

    sem

    iper

    iphe

    rYin

    term

    sof

    two

    fact

    ors:

    (a)de

    velo

    pmen

    tsocc

    urr

    ing

    inth

    eco

    re;

    or

    (b)th

    em

    ain

    tena

    nce

    requ

    ire

    ments

    ofth

    esy

    stem

    asa

    who

    le.

    Ifth

    ispe

    rspe

    ctiv

    eis

    take

    nse

    rious

    ly,

    itse

    ems

    tole

    ave

    no

    spac

    efo

    rth

    ean

    thro

    polo

    gYm

    ost

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    prac

    tice.

    Yet

    many

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    who

    dota

    keth

    isse

    rious

    lYha

    veal

    soqu

    estio

    ned

    key

    prov

    isio

    nsof

    the

    world

    -sys

    tem

    pers

    pect

    ive.

    The

    peop

    lew

    eliv

    ew

    ithand

    writ

    eabo

    utge

    nera

    llyliv

    ein

    the

    perip

    hery

    and

    sem

    iper

    iphe

    ryofW

    alle

    rSte

    ins

    world

    syst

    em.

    As

    the

    pric

    eof

    thei

    rpr

    oduc

    tsco

    llaps

    eson

    world

    mar

    kets

    ,as

    fore

    ign

    corp

    orat

    ions

    buy

    up

    thei

    rla

    nd,

    or

    asoth

    erfo

    reig

    nin

    vest

    ors

    aba

    ndon

    wha

    thad

    once

    been

    apr

    ospe

    rOus

    iliv

    ely

    regi

    ofl

    the

    capi

    talis

    tcore

    prof

    ound

    lyin

    fluen

    ces

    perip

    hera

    lreg

    ions

    and

    the

    peop

    lew

    holiv

    ein

    them

    .B

    utw

    eal

    sose

    em

    ajora

    spec

    tsoft

    heir

    econom

    ic,s

    oci

    al,a

    nd

    cultu

    ral

    life

    that

    cannotb

    eex

    plai

    ned

    inte

    rms

    ofth

    eco

    re.

    We

    see

    livel

    yre

    gion

    alm

    ark

    etin

    gsy

    stem

    Sin

    whi

    chlo

    cally

    prod

    uced

    com

    modi

    ties

    are

    cir

    cula

    ted.

    We

    see

    loca

    lm

    erc

    hant

    sw

    hofo

    llow

    entr

    eP

    rene-

    lst

    rate

    gies

    that

    are

    atodd

    sw

    ithth

    est

    rate

    gies

    offo

    reig

    nin

    vest

    ors.

    And

    on

    occa

    sion

    and

    unde

    rco

    ndi

    tions

    not

    of

    thei

    rch

    oosi

    ng,

    we

    see

    loca

    lpe

    ople

    ado

    ptin

    ga

    varie

    tyof

    form

    sof

    resi

    stan

    ceto

    the

    dem

    ands

    ofl

    ocal

    and

    fore

    ign

    capi

    tal.

    Alth

    ough

    we

    try

    tose

    epe

    asan

    tsas

    part

    of

    the

    wid

    erw

    orld

    ,w

    eal

    sovie

    wan

    app

    roac

    hth

    atatt

    empt

    sto

    expl

    ain

    every

    thin

    gin

    term

    sof

    the

    needs

    or

    dyna

    mic

    sof

    the

    capi

    talis

    tco

    re,

    or

    of

    the

    syst

    emas

    aw

    hole

    ,as

    prof

    ound

    lyfu

    nctio

    nalis

    tand

    redu

    ctiv

    e.Th

    eat

    tem

    ptto

    main

    tain

    anan

    thro

    polo

    gica

    lper

    spec

    tive

    with

    ina

    glob

    alfr

    ame

    pres

    ents

    enorm

    ous

    hist

    oric

    aland

    eth

    odol0

    gil

    prob

    lem

    s.Th

    ischa

    pte

    rfo

    cuse

    son

    thes

    epr

    oble

    ms

    buti

    tdi

    scus

    ses

    them

    inth

    eco

    nte

    xtof

    anex

    ampl

    efr

    omV

    enez

    uela

    .A

    fterp

    rese

    ntin

    gth

    eex

    ampl

    e,w

    edi

    scus

    sa

    varie

    tyofi

    ssue

    sth

    atar

    ise

    from

    it.

    Will

    iamRo

    sebe

    rrY

  • peas

    ants

    und

    the

    Wor

    ld11

    311

    2W

    illia

    mRo

    sebe

    rry

    AV

    enez

    uela

    nE

    xam

    ple

    The

    Boc

    on

    Dis

    trict

    isth

    epo

    litic

    alde

    sign

    atio

    nfo

    rtw

    ohi

    ghriv

    erval

    leys

    surr

    ounde

    dby

    mounta

    inw

    alls

    inth

    eV

    enez

    uela

    nA

    ndes

    .1

    Itis

    rela

    tivel

    yis

    olat

    ed,

    thou

    ghha

    rdly

    inac

    cess

    ible

    .The

    majo

    rhig

    hway

    sth

    atconnect

    west

    ern

    Ven

    ezue

    law

    ithCa

    raca

    spa

    ssth

    roug

    hlo

    wla

    nds

    toth

    enort

    hand

    south

    .Fr

    omea

    ch,

    asin

    gle

    road_

    trea

    cher

    ous

    inth

    era

    iny

    seas

    on

    Cros

    ses

    the

    cord

    iller

    ato

    the

    mounta

    inval

    ley

    and

    tow

    nof

    Boc

    on.

    As

    one

    cross

    esth

    em

    ounta

    ins

    and

    driv

    espa

    stpe

    asan

    thou

    ses

    prec

    ario

    usly

    perc

    hed

    on

    mounta

    insl

    opes

    ,th

    esm

    ell

    of

    cooki

    ngfir

    esand

    the

    sigh

    tof

    coffe

    edr

    ying

    on

    smal

    lpa

    tios

    or

    on

    the

    edge

    of

    the

    pave

    men

    tsof

    bana

    nas

    or

    bunc

    hed

    blac

    kbe

    ans,

    or

    of

    the

    head

    of

    afr

    eshl

    ybu

    tche

    red

    hog

    hang

    ing

    from

    the

    rafte

    rsnear

    the

    hous

    eentr

    ance

    isenough

    toco

    nvin

    ceth

    etr

    avel

    erth

    athe

    or

    she

    isente

    ring

    adi

    ffer

    ent

    world

    .If

    the

    trav

    eler

    spen

    dsm

    uch

    time

    inBo

    con

    ,the

    first

    impr

    essi

    onw

    illbe

    valid

    ated

    toa

    cert

    ain

    exte

    nt.

    The

    encl

    osed

    val

    ley

    form

    sa

    disc

    erni

    ble

    econom

    icand

    soci

    alunit,

    with

    the

    tow

    nofB

    ocon

    se

    rvin

    gas

    abu

    lkin

    gand

    dist

    ribut

    ion

    cente

    rfo

    ranum

    bero

    fsat

    ellit

    eto

    wns

    and

    vill

    ages

    .The

    tow

    nis

    also

    the

    capi

    talo

    fan

    adm

    inis

    trativ

    edi

    stric

    twith

    inth

    est

    ate

    of

    Truji

    llo.A

    ndth

    ere

    ism

    uch

    inth

    eto

    wn

    and

    countr

    ylif

    eoft

    here

    side

    nts

    that

    iscultu

    rally

    spec

    ific.

    Yet

    even

    the

    first

    impr

    essi

    onw

    ould

    bepa

    rtial

    .U

    pon

    arriv

    al,

    one

    notic

    esth

    atth

    eto

    wn

    isha

    rdly

    isol

    ated

    from

    the

    wid

    erw

    orld

    .C

    ara

    cas

    new

    spap

    ers

    and

    maga

    zine

    sar

    ere

    adily

    avai

    labl

    e.Te

    enag

    ers

    wear

    sweats

    hirts

    from

    u.s.

    univ

    ersi

    ties

    whe

    nth

    eyar

    enot

    wearin

    gth

    eir

    high

    scho

    olunifo

    rms.

    Stor

    esow

    ned

    byIta

    lian

    and

    Ara

    bim

    mig

    rant

    sse

    llcl

    othe

    s,fu

    rnitu

    re,a

    pplia

    nces

    and

    hard

    war

    em

    anufa

    ctur

    edin

    oth

    erpa

    rtsofV

    enez

    uela

    or

    inCo

    lom

    bia

    or

    the

    Uni

    ted

    Stat

    es.

    Ifone

    also

    inve

    stig

    ates

    som

    eth

    ing

    ofth

    ehi

    stor

    yand

    soci

    allif

    eof

    Boc

    on,

    one

    quic

    kly

    encounte

    rssu

    rpris

    es.A

    nin

    etee

    nth-

    cent

    urY

    new

    spa

    per

    will

    offe

    rexpr

    essi

    ons

    ofpr

    aise

    and

    sorr

    ow

    upo

    nth

    ede

    ath

    of

    Gar

    ibal

    di.

    Avis

    itto

    the

    countr

    ysid

    eto

    parti

    cipa

    tein

    afu

    nera

    lm

    ark

    ing

    the

    first

    anniv

    ersa

    ryoft

    hede

    ath

    ofa

    fam

    ilypa

    triar

    chw

    illpr

    oduc

    eim

    ages

    that

    confir

    mth

    eim

    pres

    sion

    ofi

    sola

    tion

    and

    imag

    esth

    atsu

    gges

    tw

    ider

    connectio

    nsand

    netw

    orks

    .Si

    tting

    outs

    ide

    the

    hous

    edr

    inki

    ngm

    iche

    (aho

    mem

    ade

    rum

    )with

    agr

    oup

    of

    men

    whi

    leoth

    ers

    say

    the

    rosa

    ryin

    side

    ,the

    vis

    itorh

    asto

    expl

    ain

    whe

    rehe

    has

    lived

    and

    wha

    the

    isdo

    ing.

    And

    hele

    arns

    tohi

    ssu

    rpris

    eth

    atal

    loft

    hem

    en

    have

    been

    toC

    arac

    asw

    ithin

    the

    past

    year

    ,som

    est

    ayin

    gfo

    rsev

    eral

    month

    sto

    work

    .

    He

    liste

    nsas

    they

    star

    tto

    exch

    ange

    sugg

    estio

    nsab

    outw

    ork

    opp

    ortu

    nitie

    sand

    mpl

    oyer

    sas

    som

    eof

    thei

    rnum

    berb

    egin

    topl

    ananoth

    ertr

    ipto

    the

    city

    durin

    gth

    esla

    ckse

    ason.

    Thes

    esu

    rfac

    eim

    pres

    sion

    sgi

    veonly

    ahi

    ntoft

    hepr

    oble

    ms

    that

    con

    fron

    tthe

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    stw

    hoatt

    empt

    sto

    unde

    rsta

    ndpe

    asan

    teco

    nom

    icand

    soci

    allif

    ein

    term

    sof

    loca

    land

    daily

    inte

    ract

    ions

    and

    rela

    tions

    hips

    and

    inte

    rms

    of

    the

    wid

    erec

    onom

    icre

    latio

    nsand

    field

    sofp

    ower

    that

    affe

    ctth

    ose

    daily

    and

    loca

    lint

    erac

    tions

    .

    The

    Impo

    rtanc

    eof

    Coffe

    eTh

    epr

    imar

    ypr

    oduc

    tof

    the

    Boc

    on

    Dis

    trict

    isco

    ffee.

    Inth

    ese

    cond

    half

    of

    the

    nin

    etee

    nth

    centu

    ry,

    Boc

    on

    was

    one

    of

    ase

    ries

    of

    high

    val

    leys

    inth

    eV

    enez

    uela

    nA

    ndes

    that

    bega

    nto

    attr

    act

    mig

    rant

    sfr

    omoth

    erpa

    rts

    ofV

    enez

    uela

    and

    imm

    igra

    nts

    from

    south

    ern

    Euro

    pe,

    espe

    cial

    lySp

    ain

    and

    Italy

    .The

    mig

    rant

    sse

    ttled

    on

    uncla

    imed

    natio

    nall

    ands

    asw

    ella

    son

    disp

    uted

    indi

    geno

    usre

    serv

    ela

    nds

    (resgu

    ardoS

    )and

    star

    ted

    smal

    l-sca

    leco

    ffee

    farm

    s.Th

    eE

    urop

    ean

    imm

    igra

    nts

    sett

    led

    into

    wns

    like

    Boc

    on

    and

    com

    bine

    dpe

    ttyco

    mm

    erce

    with

    the

    coffe

    etr

    ade.

    Thes

    etr

    ader

    sw

    ould

    buy

    the

    coffe

    efro

    msc

    atte

    red

    farm

    ers,

    ofte

    nexte

    ndin

    gcre

    ditt

    ose

    cure

    ase

    tofc

    off

    eepr

    oVid

    ing

    clie

    nts.

    The

    trad

    ersw

    ould

    then

    org

    aniz

    em

    ule

    trai

    nsth

    atw

    ould

    carr

    yth

    eco

    ffee

    over

    the

    mounta

    ins

    toa

    low

    land

    city

    ,w

    here

    the

    coffe

    ew

    ould

    bede

    posi

    ted

    inth

    ebr

    anch

    ware

    hous

    esof

    aM

    arac

    aibo

    trad

    ing

    com

    pany

    .Fr

    omth

    ew

    are

    hous

    e,it

    would

    becarr

    ied

    toa

    port

    on

    Lake

    Mar

    acai

    boand

    then

    ship

    ped

    byst

    eam

    erto

    Mar

    acai

    boand

    even

    tual

    lyto

    Ham

    burg

    or

    New

    Yor

    k.Th

    eM

    arac

    aibo

    Com

    pani

    esexte

    nded

    cred

    itto

    loca

    ltr

    ader

    ssu

    ch

    asth

    ose

    inB

    ocon

    ,fo

    llow

    ing

    stra

    tegi

    essi

    mila

    rto

    thos

    efo

    llow

    edby

    loca

    ltr

    ader

    sin

    thei

    rde

    alin

    gsw

    ithlo

    calf

    arm

    ers.

    Sinc

    eth

    enin

    etee

    nth

    cen

    tury

    ,th

    en,

    loca

    lfa

    rmer

    sha

    vebe

    enpa

    rtof

    aco

    mpl

    exw

    ebth

    ateven

    tuaM

    yconnecte

    dth

    emto

    the

    cente

    rsoft

    hew

    orld

    econom

    y.W

    hen

    one

    rem

    em

    bers

    that

    coffe

    eis

    subje

    ctto

    dram

    atic

    pric

    eflu

    ctua

    tions

    ,th

    eim

    porta

    nce

    oft

    hese

    connectio

    nsbe

    com

    esev

    enm

    ore

    app

    aren

    t.Ef

    fect

    sof

    ade

    clin

    ein

    pric

    esw

    ould

    bem

    ulti

    ple.

    Letu

    ssa

    yth

    atth

    epr

    ice

    ofc

    offe

    edr

    oppe

    dby

    50pe

    rcen

    tdur

    ing

    anin

    tern

    atio

    nalC

    risis.

    (This

    isa

    mode

    stass

    um

    ptio

    n:D

    urin

    gth

    ede

    pres

    sion

    of

    the

    1930

    S,

    pric

    esin

    Ven

    ezue

    ladr

    oppe

    dto

    one-f

    ourth

    oft

    heir

    1928

    leve

    l.)W

    ithsu

    ch

    adr

    op,

    the

    loca

    ltr

    ader

    must

    prov

    ide

    the

    Mar

    acai

    boCo

    mpa

    nyw

    ithtw

    ice

    asm

    uch

    coffe

    ejus

    tto

    meet

    his

    prev

    ious

    lyco

    ntr

    acte

    dde

    bts.

    Todo

    this

    ,he

    must

    pres

    shi

    slo

    calp

    rodu

    cers

    topr

    ovid

    ehi

    mw

    ithm

    ore

    coffe

    efo

    rth

    esa

    me

    rea

    son.

    Bec

    ause

    coffe

    eis

    ape

    renn

    iala

    nd

    does

    not

    prod

    uce

    ayi

    eld

    fort

    hefir

    stfe

    wye

    ars

    afte

    rpla

    ntin

    g,th

    efa

    rmer

    isnoti

    na

    flexi

    ble

    posi

    tion

    and

    cannot

    resp

    ond

    easi

    lyto

    the

    swin

    gsofm

    ark

    etpr

    ices

    .T

    hede

    scrip

    tion

    oft

    his

    dist

    ricti

    sbas

    edon

    mat

    eria

    lfou

    ndin

    Ros

    eber

    ry198

    3.

  • 114

    Will

    iamRo

    sebe

    rry

    But

    letu

    ssa

    yhe

    give

    sin

    toth

    ede

    man

    dsof

    the

    Boc

    on

    trad

    erand

    plan

    tsm

    ore

    coffe

    e,expa

    ndin

    gin

    tom

    argi

    nall

    ands

    that

    will

    bele

    sspr

    odu

    ctiv

    eor

    expa

    ndin

    gin

    tola

    ndth

    atha

    dpr

    evio

    usly

    been

    devo

    ted

    tofo

    odcr

    ops

    .Th

    eim

    med

    iate

    effe

    cts

    may

    bedr

    amat

    ic.

    Wha

    teve

    ref

    forts

    are

    unde

    rtake

    n,so

    me

    oft

    hefa

    rmer

    sand

    som

    eoft

    hetr

    ader

    swill

    beun

    able

    topr

    ovid

    eenough

    coffe

    eto

    meett

    heir

    debt

    obl

    igat

    ions

    .Eve

    nth

    ose

    who

    dow

    illfa

    cedi

    fficu

    lties

    inpr

    ovid

    ing

    for

    thei

    rfa

    mili

    es.

    They

    will

    have

    less

    inco

    me

    topu

    rcha

    sefo

    odand

    oth

    ernec

    essi

    ties,

    and

    the

    ex

    1pans

    iofl

    ofc

    offe

    ew

    illha

    vele

    ftth

    emw

    ithle

    ssho

    meg

    row

    nfo

    odfo

    rthe

    hous

    ehol

    d.If

    pric

    esre

    cover

    ina

    few

    year

    s,th

    ede

    cisi

    onto

    expa

    ndcof

    fee

    acre

    age

    (exten

    dedm

    any

    times

    over

    inoth

    erre

    gion

    s)m

    aycontr

    ibut

    eto

    asi

    tuat

    ion

    ofo

    verp

    rodu

    ctio

    nth

    atw

    illcontr

    ibut

    eto

    yeta

    noth

    erm

    ar

    ketc

    risis

    .The

    expa

    nsio

    nm

    ayal

    sole

    adto

    anec

    olo

    gica

    lcris

    isth

    atm

    aynotb

    ecom

    eapp

    aren

    tfor

    deca

    des.

    Itis

    readi

    lyapp

    aren

    t,th

    en,

    that

    the

    att

    empt

    tounde

    rsta

    ndth

    ecof

    fee

    econom

    yof

    l3oc

    on

    must

    enga

    gea

    var

    iety

    of

    leve

    lsof

    anal

    ysis

    .O

    nem

    ust

    take

    into

    acco

    untt

    hevario

    usle

    vels

    atw

    hich

    econom

    icac

    tors

    are

    ope

    ratin

    gand

    mak

    ing

    deci

    sion

    sth

    ataf

    fect

    Boco

    n&

    inN

    ewY

    ork,

    Ham

    burg

    ,Mar

    acai

    bo,B

    ocon

    .O

    nem

    ust

    exam

    ine

    the

    stra

    tegi

    esofl

    ocal

    merc

    hant

    sand

    ofl

    ocal

    prod

    ucer

    sin

    ord

    erto

    unde

    rsta

    ndth

    elik

    ely

    out

    com

    eofa

    crisi

    sor

    the

    resp

    onse

    tope

    riods

    ofec

    onom

    icbo

    om.4

    ndone

    must

    consi

    dert

    heoth

    erar

    eas

    from

    whi

    chpe

    ople

    have

    com

    eto

    Boc

    on,

    the

    prac

    tices

    ,tra

    ditio

    ns,a

    nd

    valu

    esth

    atm

    igra

    nts

    and

    imm

    igra

    ntsb

    ring

    with

    them

    toan

    expa

    ndin

    gre

    gion

    .

    Petro

    leum

    Yet

    the

    invo

    lvem

    ent

    of

    Boc

    on

    with

    aw

    ider

    world

    isnot

    limite

    dto

    the

    coffe

    eec

    onom

    y.Tw

    oadd

    ition

    alre

    latio

    nsde

    serv

    em

    entio

    n.W

    hen

    peop

    leth

    ink

    of

    Ven

    ezue

    la,

    they

    thin

    knot

    ofc

    offe

    ebu

    tof

    petro

    leum

    .A

    lthou

    ghco

    ffee

    was

    Ven

    ezue

    las

    most

    impo

    rtant

    expo

    rtin

    the

    late

    nin

    etee

    nth

    and

    early

    twen

    tieth

    centu

    ries,

    petro

    leum

    has

    dom

    inat

    edV

    enez

    uela

    sec

    onom

    yand

    polit

    ysin

    ceth

    e192oS

    .Th

    edi

    rect

    and

    indi

    rect

    effe

    cts

    have

    been

    rem

    arka

    ble.

    The

    petro

    leum

    sect

    orits

    elfe

    mpl

    oys

    few

    peop

    leand

    prod

    uces

    enorm

    ous

    wealth

    .In

    the

    supp

    ort

    serv

    ices

    and

    indu

    strie

    sth

    atgr

    ewup

    aro

    und

    petr

    oleu

    m1

    and,

    more

    impo

    rtant

    ,in

    the

    expa

    nsio

    nof

    the

    stat

    ese

    ctor

    on

    the

    basi

    sof

    roya

    lties

    from

    pe

    trol

    eum

    com

    pani

    es1

    anucle

    usw

    asfo

    rmed

    for

    the

    tran

    sfor

    mat

    ion

    of

    Ven

    ezue

    la.

    Gro

    wth

    of

    the

    stat

    ese

    ctor

    and

    of

    apo

    pula

    tion

    of

    mid

    dle-

    inco

    me

    bure

    aucr

    ats

    stim

    ulat

    edth

    egr

    owth

    of

    ala

    rge

    tert

    iary

    sect

    orof

    com

    merc

    eand

    serv

    ices

    ,ase

    ctor

    loca

    ted

    ina

    num

    ber

    ofc

    ities

    butm

    ost

    impo

    rtant

    lyin

    Cara

    cas.

    The

    petro

    leum

    expa

    nsio

    nw

    as

    occ

    urr

    ing

    justa

    sth

    eco

    ffee

    econom

    y

    Peas

    ants

    and

    the

    Wor

    ld11

    5

    ente

    red

    into

    am

    ajorc

    olla

    pse

    with

    the

    1930

    Sie

    pres

    sion

    .Th

    epo

    stu

    late

    dnga

    tive

    conse

    quen

    ces

    of

    acr

    isis

    desc

    ribed

    abov

    ew

    ere

    realiz

    edw

    itheven

    grea

    ter

    sever

    ity.T

    oth

    isda

    y,th

    efa

    llof

    coffe

    eis

    anevent

    of

    trem

    endo

    ussy

    mbo

    licim

    port

    inV

    enez

    uela

    npu

    blic

    mem

    ory

    .W

    ithth

    echa

    nges

    ass

    ocia

    ted

    with

    the

    petro

    leum

    econom

    y,ho

    wev

    er,

    resi

    dent

    sfr

    omB

    ocon

    and

    oth

    erco

    ffee

    area

    sco

    uld

    move

    toci

    tiesl

    ike

    Mar

    acai

    boor

    Car

    acas

    .Th

    ism

    ovem

    ent

    has

    been

    soim

    porta

    ntth

    atit

    isdi

    fficu

    ltto

    limit

    one

    sst

    udy

    toB

    ocon

    w

    ithou

    ttak

    ing

    into

    acco

    unt

    popu

    latio

    nm

    ovem

    ents

    betw

    een

    Boc

    on

    and

    Cara

    cas

    and

    oth

    erci

    ties.

    Itis

    notun

    com

    mon

    tofin

    dan

    aged

    farm

    erw

    how

    illte

    flyo

    uth

    atal

    l ofh

    ischi

    ldre

    nliv

    ein

    Car

    acas

    and

    that

    hevis

    itsth

    emth

    ere

    once

    aye

    ar.

    The

    second,

    rela

    ted,

    deve

    lopm

    ent

    conce

    rns

    the

    impa

    ctof

    the

    pe

    trol

    eum

    tran

    sfor

    mat

    ion

    on

    thos

    ew

    hoha

    vere

    main

    edin

    Boc

    on.

    The

    grow

    thoft

    heV

    enez

    uela

    nst

    ate

    has

    resu

    lted

    inin

    crea

    sing

    centr

    aliz

    atio

    nofp

    oliti

    csand

    econom

    ics.

    Ove

    rth

    epa

    st30

    year

    sth

    ego

    vern

    men

    thas

    cre

    ate

    da

    num

    bero

    fcre

    dita

    nd

    mark

    etin

    gpr

    ogra

    ms

    that

    have

    disp

    lace

    dpr

    ivat

    em

    erc

    hant

    sfr

    omth

    eir

    form

    erly

    dom

    inan

    tpos

    ition

    inth

    eco

    ffee

    econom

    y.A

    tpr

    esen

    t,th

    ego

    vern

    men

    tis

    the

    most

    impo

    rtant

    cre

    dito

    rand

    coffe

    ebu

    yer

    inB

    ocon

    .C

    redi

    tde

    cisio

    nsin

    varia

    bly

    requ

    ireap

    prov

    alin

    ace

    ntr

    aloffi

    ce,

    meanin

    gth

    atlo

    cal

    farm

    ers

    are

    incr

    easi

    ngly

    depe

    nden

    tupo

    nth

    ecentr

    algo

    vern

    men

    t.Su

    chde

    cisi

    ons

    invo

    lve

    polit

    ica

    lfav

    oriti

    smas

    wel

    l,gi

    ving

    the

    party

    inpo

    wer

    incr

    ease

    dle

    vera

    geover

    loca

    lfar

    mer

    s.T

    heH

    isto

    rica

    lDim

    ensi

    on

    The

    desc

    riptio

    nof

    the

    Boc

    on

    Dis

    trict

    alre

    ady

    sugg

    ests

    one

    of

    this

    cha

    pter

    sm

    ost

    impo

    rtant

    poin

    ts.T

    ooofte

    nanth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    have

    form

    ula

    ted

    thei

    rpr

    oble

    ms

    and

    condu

    cted

    thei

    rst

    udie

    sw

    itha

    shal

    low

    time

    fram

    e.W

    hen

    func

    tiona

    listp

    ersp

    ectiv

    esw

    ere

    dom

    inan

    t,th

    issy

    nchr

    onic

    focu

    sw

    as

    take

    nas

    apo

    into

    fhon

    or.

    On

    the

    one

    hand

    ,it

    was

    arg

    ued

    that

    the

    hist

    ory

    of

    the

    peop

    lew

    est

    udie

    dco

    uld

    not

    bere

    cover

    ed.

    On

    the

    oth

    erha

    nd,i

    twas

    sugg

    este

    dth

    atev

    enif

    hist

    oric

    alpr

    oces

    ses

    could

    bekn

    own

    (and

    inm

    any

    case

    sit

    beca

    me

    clea

    rth

    atdo

    cum

    enta

    ryand

    ora

    lhis

    toric

    also

    urc

    es

    wer

    em

    uch

    riche

    rtha

    nha

    dbe

    ensu

    ppos

    ed),

    his

    tory

    itsel

    fco

    uld

    tell

    us

    ver

    ylit

    tle.

    Age

    netic

    app

    roac

    hw

    as

    rejec

    tedin

    favo

    rof

    anan

    alyt

    ical

    ap

    proa

    ch;

    the

    ope

    ratio

    nand

    func

    tioni

    ngof

    apa

    rticu

    lar

    soci

    alfe

    atur

    eco

    uld

    beex

    plai

    ned

    inte

    rms

    of

    the

    stru

    ctur

    eof

    the

    soci

    alre

    latio

    nsof

    the

    pres

    ent.

    Econ

    omic

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    were

    espe

    cial

    lypr

    one

    tosu

    cha

    sync

    hron

    icbi

    as,g

    iven

    the

    ass

    um

    ptio

    nsth

    eyw

    ere

    taki

    ngfr

    omec

    onom

    ics

    and

    the

    natu

    reof

    the

    data

    (inpu

    t-out

    put

    analy

    ses,

    hous

    ehol

    dbu

    dget

    s,pr

    ice

    fluct

    uatio

    ns,a

    nd

    the

    like)

    they

    were

    colle

    ctin

    g.Th

    usth

    ecl

    assic

    monogr

    aph

    mig

    htco

    nta

    inan

    intro

    duct

    ory

  • ii6W

    illiam

    Rose

    berry

    cha

    pter

    that

    would

    incl

    ude

    ase

    ctio

    non

    histo

    ry,b

    utth

    ehi

    stor

    ical

    sket

    chw

    ould

    not

    bein

    tegr

    ated

    with

    the

    soci

    aland

    econom

    ican

    alys

    isin

    the

    book

    sco

    re.

    Yet

    ahi

    stor

    ical

    pers

    pect

    ive

    isfu

    ndam

    enta

    lto

    all

    att

    empt

    sto

    plac

    elo

    cal

    regi

    ons

    with

    ina

    world

    syst

    em.

    Such

    ape

    rspe

    ctiv

    eha

    sse

    ver

    aldi

    men

    sion

    s,and

    the

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    stw

    how

    ould

    use

    aw

    orld

    -sys

    tem

    ap

    proa

    chm

    ust

    beca

    refu

    lnott

    ore

    duce

    his

    or

    herh

    isto

    rical

    unde

    rsta

    ndin

    gto

    the

    sim

    ple

    stat

    emen

    tth

    ata

    parti

    cula

    rreg

    ion

    has

    long

    been

    part

    ofa

    capi

    talis

    teco

    nom

    y.

    The

    Impo

    rtanc

    eof

    Stud

    ying

    Patte

    rns

    ofCh

    ange

    over

    Tim

    eIt

    shou

    ldbe

    clea

    rth

    atth

    enatu

    reof

    the

    rela

    tions

    hip

    betw

    een

    alo

    cal

    regi

    onand

    the

    world

    econom

    ych

    ange

    sw

    ithtim

    e.D

    urin

    gth

    eco

    loni

    aler

    a,B

    ocon

    and

    the

    Ven

    ezue

    lan

    And

    esin

    gene

    ralw

    ere

    quite

    marg

    inal

    toth

    eco

    loni

    alec

    onom

    y.A

    lthou

    ghone

    can

    com

    eup

    with

    alis

    tof

    impo

    rts

    and

    expo

    rtsfo

    rthe

    perio

    dth

    atsh

    ows

    are

    latio

    nshi

    pbe

    twee

    nth

    ere

    gion

    and

    the

    em

    erg

    ing

    cente

    rsoft

    hew

    orld

    econom

    y,it

    would

    bein

    app

    ropr

    iate

    tosu

    gges

    ttha

    tone

    could

    unde

    rsta

    ndth

    edy

    nam

    ics

    ofl

    ocal

    life

    or

    oft

    here

    gion

    alec

    onom

    yonly

    inte

    rms

    ofth

    eneeds

    or

    dyna

    mic

    soft

    hew

    orld

    syst

    emor

    oft

    hesy

    stem

    sco

    re.

    Dur

    ing

    the

    nin

    etee

    nth

    cen

    tury

    ,th

    ede

    velo

    pmen

    tof

    aco

    ffee

    econom

    ybr

    ough

    tth

    ere

    gion

    into

    am

    uch

    more

    inte

    gral

    rela

    tions

    hip

    with

    the

    cente

    rsof

    the

    world

    econom

    yas

    the

    inte

    rnat

    iona

    ldiv

    isio

    nofl

    abor

    inte

    nsifi

    ed.

    Cap

    italw

    as

    inve

    sted

    inth

    ere

    gion

    ,V

    enez

    uela

    nand

    Eur

    opea

    nim

    mig

    rant

    sse

    ttle

    din

    the

    re

    gion

    ,and

    fund

    amen

    tala

    spec

    tsofl

    ocal

    life

    depe

    nded

    on

    coffe

    epr

    ices

    dete

    rmin

    edels

    ewhe

    re.E

    ven

    durin

    gth

    ispe

    riod,

    how

    ever

    ,itw

    ould

    bein

    adeq

    uate

    totu

    rnone

    satt

    entio

    nso

    lely

    toin

    tern

    atio

    nalc

    off

    eem

    ark

    ets.

    Loca

    lm

    erc

    hant

    sw

    ere

    inde

    bted

    tola

    rger

    trad

    ing

    hous

    es,

    but

    they

    did

    not

    act

    as

    thei

    rage

    nts.

    Rat

    her,

    they

    purs

    ued

    pers

    onal

    inte

    rest

    sth

    atw

    ere

    not

    necess

    aril

    yid

    entic

    alw

    ith,

    and

    inm

    any

    case

    sw

    ere

    contr

    adi

    ctor

    yto

    ,th

    ein

    tere

    sts

    of

    fore

    ign

    merc

    hant

    sor

    of

    the

    syst

    emas

    aw

    hole

    .Dur

    ing

    the

    twen

    tieth

    centu

    ry,t

    here

    gion

    scl

    ose

    inte

    grat

    ion

    with

    the

    worl

    dm

    ark

    etw

    as

    loos

    ened

    asco

    ffee

    decl

    ined

    ;ye

    tlo

    cal

    dyna

    mic

    sw

    ere

    draw

    nm

    ore

    tight

    lyth

    anbe

    fore

    into

    the

    proc

    esse

    sof

    the

    worl

    dsy

    stem

    as

    Ven

    ezue

    labe

    cam

    ean

    oil

    repu

    blic

    .A

    sin

    dica

    ted

    abo

    ve,

    this

    prec

    ipita

    ted

    anatio

    nal

    tran

    sfor

    mat

    ion

    that

    had

    prof

    ound

    loca

    lconse

    quen

    ces.

    Furt

    herm

    ore,

    the

    impo

    rtan

    ceof

    this

    ques

    tion

    cannot

    bere

    duce

    dto

    aho

    mily

    that

    would

    tell

    us

    sim

    ply

    that

    the

    natu

    reof

    the

    rela

    tions

    hip

    betw

    een

    alo

    calr

    egi

    onand

    the

    world

    syst

    emis

    const

    antly

    cha

    ngin

    g.It

    isal

    soim

    port

    antt

    ore

    cogn

    ize

    that

    the

    soci

    alre

    latio

    nsth

    atcha

    ract

    eriz

    eone

    peri

    odor

    one

    type

    of

    rela

    tions

    hip

    contin

    ueto

    carr

    yso

    cia

    l,econom

    ic,

    and

    polit

    ical

    weig

    htin

    asu

    bseq

    uent

    peri

    od.

    The

    de

    Peas

    ants

    and

    the

    Wor

    ld11

    7

    velo

    pmef

    ltofa

    coffe

    eec

    onom

    yin

    trodu

    ced

    fun.

    amer

    Ltal

    chan

    ges,

    buti

    t!w

    as

    not

    cre

    ate

    douto

    fthi

    nair

    .Stru

    ctur

    alfe

    atur

    es(fo

    rexam

    ple,

    mark

    etin

    gsy

    stem

    Sro

    ad

    netw

    orks

    ,fo

    rms

    of

    prop

    erty

    sett

    lem

    ent

    patte

    rns,

    clas

    sre

    latio

    ns)o

    fth

    eco

    loni

    alec

    onom

    yse

    rved

    asth

    eim

    med

    iate

    con

    text

    for

    the

    inve

    stm

    ent

    of

    capi

    tal

    inco

    ffee

    prod

    uctio

    n.M

    any

    of

    thes

    efe

    atur

    esw

    ere

    tran

    sfor

    med

    ;so

    me

    could

    betr

    ansf

    orm

    edonly

    thro

    ugh

    apo

    litic

    alst

    rugg

    lebe

    twee

    nlib

    eral

    sand

    conse

    rvat

    ives

    durin

    gth

    ela

    stha

    lfoft

    henin

    etee

    nth

    centu

    ry.

    The

    Impo

    rtanc

    eof

    unde

    rsta

    ndin

    gthe

    Past

    inO

    rder

    toEx

    plai

    nth

    ePr

    esen

    tA

    noth

    erconse

    quen

    ceofa

    nhi

    stor

    ical

    app

    roac

    his

    the

    fres

    hpe

    rspe

    ctiv

    eit

    prov

    ides

    on

    the

    loca

    lact

    ors

    them

    selv

    es.

    Too

    ofte

    n,anth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    deba

    teth

    ere

    lativ

    ew

    eig

    htofl

    ocal

    ,re

    gion

    alnatio

    nal,

    and

    inte

    rnatio

    nalf

    acto

    rson

    the

    activ

    ityofl

    ocal

    peas

    antS

    art

    isan

    s,or

    trad

    ers

    as

    ifth

    ese

    acto

    rsw

    ere

    sim

    ply

    hist

    oric

    algi

    vens

    ,re

    ady

    toac

    tw

    ithin

    and

    bein

    fluen

    ced

    byth

    epr

    esen

    tsi

    tuat

    ion.

    This

    ispa

    rticu

    larly

    true

    whe

    nw

    econsi

    der

    peas

    antr

    ies

    the

    stru

    ctur

    eofw

    hich

    may

    bepr

    ojecte

    din

    toa

    dim

    past

    and

    who

    sefo

    rmat

    ion

    may

    bese

    en

    aslo

    gica

    llyand

    hist

    ori

    cally

    prio

    rto

    the

    influ

    ence

    of

    aw

    orld

    syst

    em.

    Inl3

    ocon

    ,ho

    wev

    er,

    smal

    l-sca

    lefa

    mily

    farm

    sbe

    gan

    toapp

    ear

    only

    with

    the

    form

    atio

    nof

    a

    coffe

    eec

    onom

    yin

    the

    nin

    etee

    nth

    centu

    ry,

    inas

    soci

    atio

    nw

    itha

    tran

    sfo

    rmat

    ion

    of

    prop

    erty

    rela

    tions

    hips

    that

    brok

    eup

    form

    erly

    impa

    rtibl

    eco

    loni

    alpr

    oper

    ties

    and

    indi

    geno

    usre

    serv

    ela

    nds.

    Ina

    fund

    amen

    tals

    ense

    ,th

    ever

    yem

    erge

    nce

    ofa

    peas

    antry

    was

    tied

    toth

    ere

    gion

    sin

    tegr

    atio

    nw

    ithin

    an

    inte

    rnat

    iona

    ldi

    visi

    onof

    labo

    r.Fu

    rthe

    rmor

    e,m

    any

    of

    the

    smal

    lfar

    mer

    sw

    hotu

    rned

    toco

    ffee

    or

    who

    moved

    into

    the

    regi

    onto

    plan

    tco

    ffee

    wer

    ebe

    com

    ing

    more

    entr

    epre

    neuria

    l,contr

    actin

    gde

    bts

    and

    plan

    ting

    anex

    port

    com

    modi

    tyon

    thei

    rbe

    stla

    nds

    durin

    ga

    perio

    dofe

    conom

    icbo

    om.

    Cer

    tain

    asp

    ects

    oft

    heir

    stra

    tegy

    were

    bequ

    eath

    edto

    thei

    rch

    ildre

    nand

    gran

    dchi

    ldre

    nas

    a

    boom

    econom

    yente

    red

    into

    crisi

    s.Th

    ere

    spon

    seof

    smal

    lfa

    rmer

    sto

    the

    mid

    twef

    ltie

    thtu

    rYcr

    isis

    would

    mak

    elit

    tlese

    nse

    unle

    ssone

    unde

    rsto

    odth

    ese

    nin

    etee

    nth-

    cent

    ury

    lega

    cies

    .

    Clos

    edan

    dO

    pen

    Peas

    antC

    omm

    uniti

    esIn

    one

    sense

    this

    poin

    tish

    ardl

    ysu

    rpris

    ing.

    Ina

    prel

    imin

    ary

    typo

    logy

    ofL

    atin

    Am

    eric

    anpe

    asan

    trieS

    made

    over

    thre

    ede

    cade

    sag

    o,Er

    icW

    olf

    (195

    5)su

    gges

    ted

    anopp

    ositi

    onbe

    twee

    ncl

    osed

    and

    ope

    npe

    asan

    trie

    S.Th

    edi

    stin

    ctio

    nw

    as

    base

    din

    hist

    ory.

    The

    clos

    edty

    pecorr

    esp

    onde

    dto

    form

    ernucl

    ear

    area

    sin

    Mes

    oam

    eric

    aand

    Peru

    that

    had

    prec

    olon

    ial

    stat

    esy

    stem

    sand

    peas

    anta

    gric

    ultu

    re.T

    hecorp

    orat

    eco

    rn-

    I I

  • uS

    Will

    iamRo

    sebe

    rry

    munity

    was

    seen

    asa

    colo

    nial

    prod

    uct

    1fix

    ing

    the

    indi

    geno

    uspo

    pula

    tion

    on

    the

    grou

    ndas

    aso

    urc

    eof

    labo

    rand

    tax

    reven

    ue.

    The

    ope

    nty

    pew

    as

    seen

    toem

    erge

    infr

    ontie

    rzones

    durin

    gth

    enin

    etee

    ntht

    hh1Y

    ex

    pans

    ion

    ofe

    xpo

    rtpr

    oduc

    tion.

    The

    Boc

    on

    peas

    antry

    was

    clea

    rlyope

    nin

    Wol

    fsse

    nse

    (seeC

    anci

    ans

    disc

    ussi

    onin

    Cha

    pter

    6).To

    oofte

    n,ho

    wev

    er,t

    hehi

    stor

    ical

    natu

    reofW

    olfs

    dist

    inct

    ion

    iSlo

    st,

    espe

    cial

    lyw

    hen

    nth

    ropo

    l0gi

    st5

    stud

    ycl

    osed

    type

    s.Fi

    eldW

    orke

    r5m

    ayha

    vea

    bitt

    osa

    yab

    outt

    heea

    rlyco

    loni

    alpe

    riod

    and

    the

    cha

    nges

    intr

    odu

    ced

    byconqu

    est,

    butt

    hey

    will

    then

    skip

    over

    four

    centu

    ries

    toth

    eeth

    nogr

    aphi

    cpr

    esen

    tas

    ifth

    ein

    terv

    enin

    gpe

    riods

    invo

    lved

    no

    fund

    am

    enta

    lch

    ange

    s.R

    ecen

    tre

    eval

    Uat

    iofls

    dem

    onst

    rate

    ,how

    ever

    ,th

    atth

    ede

    velo

    pmen

    tof

    expo

    rtpr

    qduc

    tion

    incr

    ops

    such

    asco

    ffee

    intro

    duce

    dim

    porta

    ntcha

    nges

    incl

    ose

    zones

    iust

    asit

    was

    crea

    ting

    peas

    antri

    esin

    ope

    nzones

    .O

    nere

    cent

    stud

    yha

    sre

    exam

    ined

    the

    hist

    ory

    ofm

    any

    of

    the

    com

    muniti

    esin

    Chi

    apas

    ,a

    regi

    onof

    som

    eof

    the

    most

    exte

    nsiv

    eanth

    ropo

    logi

    cal

    field

    wor

    kfl

    recent

    deca

    des,

    and

    has

    foun

    dfu

    ndam

    enta

    ltr

    ansf

    orm

    atio

    nsin

    thos

    eco

    mm

    uniti

    esw

    ithth

    ede

    velo

    pmen

    tof

    coffe

    epr

    oduc

    tiofl

    the

    mig

    ratio

    nof

    Indi

    ans

    tow

    ork

    on

    low

    land

    plan

    tati0

    nsand

    the

    like

    (Was

    serst

    rom

    1983

    ).A

    mon

    gth

    em

    ost

    inte

    rest

    ing

    of

    the

    new

    deve

    lopm

    ents

    ,bot

    hin

    this

    stud

    yand

    else

    whe

    re,i

    sthe

    rein

    terp

    reta

    tion

    oft

    hede

    velo

    pmen

    toft

    heciv

    ilrel

    igi0

    ushi

    erar

    chy.

    Fund

    amen

    tal

    asp

    ects

    oft

    his

    syst

    emar

    enow

    seen

    toha

    veem

    erg

    eddu

    ring

    the

    nin

    ete

    enth

    centu

    ry(R

    usand

    Was

    sers

    trom

    1980

    ;C

    hanc

    eand

    Tayl

    or19

    85).

    nth

    ropo

    l0gi

    5ts

    who

    try

    topl

    ace

    peas

    antri

    esin

    aw

    ider

    world

    ,the

    n,cannot

    beconte

    ntw

    itha

    sync

    hrof

    licap

    proa

    ch.T

    hey

    need

    topa

    ycl

    ose

    att

    entio

    flto

    the

    com

    plex

    inte

    rpla

    yofe

    xte

    rnal

    pres

    sure

    and

    inte

    rnal

    re

    spon

    seover

    time

    and

    need

    tobe

    awar

    eof

    the

    poss

    ibili

    tyth

    atth

    ose

    feat

    ures

    ofp

    easa

    ntlif

    eth

    atse

    emm

    ost

    trad

    ition

    alor

    cust

    omar

    ym

    aybe

    1 the

    resu

    ltsof

    past

    impo

    siti0

    fl5re

    spon

    seS

    or

    acco

    mm

    oda

    tions

    .Itm

    aybe

    that

    the

    trad

    ition

    alpe

    asan

    tisp

    arto

    fam

    ode

    rnhi

    stor

    y,a

    hist

    ory

    that

    has

    plac

    edth

    epe

    asan

    tin

    aw

    ider

    world

    .

    The

    Met

    hodo

    logi

    calD

    imen

    sion

    This

    hist

    oric

    ally

    orie

    nted

    world

    -sys

    tem

    pers

    pect

    ive

    pres

    ents

    anum

    ber

    of

    thod

    olO

    gica

    ldi

    lem

    mas

    for

    the

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    st.T

    hefir

    stcon

    cern

    sth

    eapp

    ropr

    iate

    leve

    lor

    unit

    ofa

    nal

    ysis

    .How

    does

    one

    talk

    abo

    utlo

    calr

    egi

    ons

    inte

    rms

    ofl

    ocal

    ,nat

    iona

    l,and

    inte

    rnat

    iona

    lfac

    tors

    wit

    hout

    losi

    ngth

    odo1ogic

    contr

    ol?

    The

    Wal

    lers

    tein

    solu

    tion_

    that

    one

    stud

    ies

    soci

    alsy

    stem

    sas

    who

    les

    and

    ther

    efor

    econcentr

    ates

    on

    the

    world

    syst

    emits

    elf_

    leav

    esno

    room

    for

    anth

    rOPo

    l03.

    Mos

    tanth

    ro

    Peas

    ants

    and

    theW

    orld

    119

    polo

    gist

    Sw

    hopa

    yatt

    entio

    nto

    such

    issu

    esw

    ill&v

    ant

    tost

    art

    with

    alo

    calr

    egi

    onand

    att

    empt

    tosa

    yso

    met

    hing

    ab6u

    ttha

    treg

    ion

    inte

    rms

    ofl

    ocal

    and

    extr

    aloc

    alre

    latio

    nshi

    psand

    soci

    alfo

    rces

    .Yet

    they

    will

    beconfr

    onte

    dby

    aconst

    ant

    met

    hodo

    logi

    cals

    trai

    n.U

    nfor

    tuna

    tely

    ,m

    ost

    of

    the

    meta

    phor

    santh

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    use

    tota

    lkabo

    utsu

    ch

    ast

    rain

    are

    eith

    ersp

    atia

    lor

    invo

    lve

    som

    econcept

    ion

    of

    analy

    tical

    laye

    rsor

    leve

    ls.Th

    ecl

    assic

    early

    conce

    ptio

    nw

    asJu

    lian

    Stew

    ard

    sle

    vels

    ofs

    oci

    ocul

    tura

    lint

    egra

    tion

    (Stew

    ard19

    55).

    Der

    ived

    from

    his

    evolu

    tiona

    ryst

    udie

    s,it

    arg

    ued

    that

    earli

    erle

    vels

    ofso

    cial

    org

    ani

    zatio

    n(fo

    rexam

    ple,

    fam

    ily,b

    and,

    and

    com

    munity

    )wer

    ein

    corp

    orat

    edbu

    tnot

    fully

    subs

    umed

    with

    inhi

    gher

    leve

    lsofo

    rgan

    izat

    ion.

    Thu

    sth

    efa

    mily

    ,once

    am

    axim

    alunit

    oforg

    aniZ

    atio

    niw

    as

    inco

    rpor

    ated

    with

    inst

    ates

    with

    out

    losi

    ngits

    dist

    inct

    ive

    char

    acte

    r.W

    hen

    this

    concept

    was

    app

    lied

    toth

    est

    udy

    ofc

    om

    plex

    soci

    etie

    s,one

    could

    stud

    yth

    evario

    usso

    cio

    cultu

    ral

    leve

    lsand

    thei

    rin

    terr

    elat

    ions

    .Sp

    atia

    lm

    eta

    phor

    sre

    sult

    from

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    field

    prac

    tice.

    We

    stud

    yin

    com

    muniti

    es,

    and

    asw

    econsi

    der

    the

    effe

    ctof

    natio

    nala

    nd

    glob

    alph

    enom

    ena

    1w

    eas

    kw

    hat

    with

    inth

    elo

    cals

    ituat

    ion

    isto

    beunde

    rsto

    odin

    term

    sofl

    ocal

    rela

    tion

    ship

    sand

    wha

    tis

    tobe

    unde

    rsto

    odin

    term

    sofl

    arge

    rfor

    ces.

    As

    we

    ask

    thes

    equ

    estio

    ns1

    we

    ofte

    nst

    artw

    ithan

    impl

    icit

    or

    expl

    icit

    spat

    ialm

    ode

    lth

    atm

    oves

    from

    com

    muniti

    esto

    regi

    ons

    tonatio

    nsto

    the

    world

    .

    The

    Prob

    lem

    with

    aR

    egio

    nalA

    ppro

    ach

    As

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    beca

    me

    diss

    atis

    fied

    with

    com

    munity

    stud

    ies,

    som

    eof

    them

    moved

    tow

    ard

    regi

    onal

    stud

    ies.

    Alth

    ough

    this

    alte

    rsone

    sde

    finiti

    onofl

    ocal

    and

    nonlo

    calr

    elat

    ions

    ,itd

    oes

    little

    toadd

    ress

    the

    centr

    alm

    eth

    odol

    ogic

    alpr

    oble

    m.I

    tten

    dsto

    rem

    ove

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    from

    the

    intim

    ate

    daily

    inte

    ract

    ions

    that

    have

    been

    the

    sourc

    eofm

    uch

    eth

    nogr

    aphi

    ckn

    owle

    dge,

    yeti

    tdoe

    snotn

    eces

    saril

    ygi

    veth

    ema

    bird

    s-

    eye

    vie

    w.I

    ndee

    d,th

    eym

    ayst

    illha

    vea

    w

    orm

    s-e

    yevie

    w

    inth

    atm

    any

    oft

    hefo

    rces

    and

    rela

    tions

    that

    affe

    cta

    regi

    onar

    elo

    cate

    dels

    ewhe

    re(cf

    .C.

    Smith

    1976

    :3).

    Reca

    llth

    eV

    enez

    uela

    nex

    ampl

    e.To

    unde

    rsta

    ndB

    oco

    n,

    one

    has

    tota

    lkabo

    utth

    efo

    rmat

    ion

    ofa

    coffe

    eec

    onom

    yin

    the

    nin

    etee

    nth

    centu

    ry,t

    heco

    llaps

    eoft

    hate

    conom

    yin

    the

    conte

    xtofa

    pe

    trol

    eum

    boom

    ,th

    em

    igra

    tion

    ofre

    side

    nts

    toC

    arac

    asand

    oth

    erci

    ties,

    and

    the

    centr

    aliz

    atio

    nof

    the

    Ven

    ezue

    lan

    stat

    eand

    itsin

    crea

    sing

    role

    inlo

    call

    ife.R

    egar

    dles

    sofw

    heth

    erone

    star

    ted

    with

    alo

    calc

    om

    munity

    or

    the

    Boc

    on

    Dis

    trict

    asa

    who

    le,m

    ost

    ofth

    ese

    deve

    lopm

    ents

    would

    bese

    en

    asex

    tral

    ocal

    ,and

    the

    vie

    wone

    gets

    of

    them

    from

    Boc

    on

    isnecess

    aril

    ypa

    rtial

    .

  • Peas

    ants

    and

    the

    Wor

    ld12

    112

    0W

    illiam

    Rose

    berry

    The

    Impo

    rtanc

    eof

    Und

    ersta

    ndin

    gM

    acro

    level

    Influ

    ence

    son

    Micr

    olev

    elBe

    havi

    orTo

    reso

    lve

    the

    met

    hodo

    logi

    cal

    dile

    mm

    a,w

    eneed

    tom

    ove

    beyo

    ndth

    esp

    atia

    land

    laye

    rca

    kem

    eta

    phor

    sw

    euse

    tode

    scrib

    eit.

    Our

    earli

    erdi

    scus

    sion

    show

    edth

    atth

    ever

    yfo

    rmat

    ion

    ofm

    any

    regi

    ons

    and

    com

    muniti

    esis

    tied

    totr

    ansf

    orm

    atio

    nsin

    the

    world

    econom

    y.To

    igno

    reth

    e-

    world

    econom

    yand

    stud

    ya

    loca

    lre

    alm

    apa

    rtfr

    oma

    nonlo

    cal

    realm

    may

    pres

    erve

    anal

    ytic

    alrig

    or,

    but

    atth

    eexpe

    nse

    of

    hist

    oric

    alunde

    rst

    andi

    ng.

    Toav

    oid

    this

    ,w

    eneed

    toco

    nce

    ntr

    ate

    on

    rela

    tions

    hips

    that

    tran

    scen

    dsp

    atia

    lbo

    unda

    ries,

    that

    take

    the

    app

    aren

    tlyexte

    rnal

    and

    mak

    eit

    inte

    rnal

    toour

    mode

    lof

    aso

    cial

    situ

    atio

    n.A

    nthr

    opol

    ogis

    tsdo

    nts

    tudy

    vill

    ages

    ,w

    rote

    Cliff

    ord

    Gee

    rtz(1

    973:

    22),

    th

    eyst

    udy

    invill

    ages

    .A

    lthou

    ghhe

    was

    mak

    ing

    aso

    mew

    hat

    diff

    eren

    tpo

    int,

    this

    insi

    ght

    isre

    leva

    ntto

    the

    pres

    ent

    disc

    ussi

    on.

    As

    we

    stud

    yin

    com

    mu

    niti

    es,

    we

    need

    tobe

    crea

    tive

    inour

    conce

    ptua

    lizat

    ion

    and

    stud

    yof

    rela

    tions

    hips

    ,ins

    titut

    ions

    ,and

    netw

    orks

    that

    are

    app

    aren

    tlyfo

    reig

    nto

    the

    com

    munity

    .Le

    tus

    consi

    derr

    ecent

    att

    empt

    sto

    doth

    is,be

    ginn

    ing

    with

    our

    Ven

    ezuela

    nex

    ampl

    e.Th

    eau

    thor

    spr

    inci

    palm

    etho

    dolo

    gica

    ldec

    isio

    nin

    Do

    con

    was

    toconcentr

    ate

    on

    coffe

    e.Su

    cha

    com

    modi

    tyorie

    ntat

    ion

    can

    beextr

    emel

    yuse

    fulb

    ecau

    seth

    ein

    vest

    igat

    oris

    deal

    ing

    with

    apr

    oduc

    ttha

    tis

    prod

    uced

    loca

    llybu

    texcha

    nged

    on

    world

    mar

    kets

    .In

    the

    case

    ofB

    ocon

    6,co

    ffee

    was

    the

    prin

    cipa

    lmeans

    ofi

    nteg

    ratio

    nbe

    twee

    nth

    ere

    gion

    and

    the

    natio

    nand

    world

    inth

    enin

    etee

    nth

    and

    early

    twen

    tieth

    cen

    turie

    s.A

    nin

    vest

    igat

    orco

    uld

    deal

    with

    loca

    lpro

    duct

    ion

    arr

    ange

    men

    t5th

    etr

    ansf

    orm

    atio

    noff

    orm

    sofl

    ande

    dpr

    oper

    tyand

    work

    org

    aniz

    ati0

    flre

    latio

    nsw

    ithlo

    cal

    merc

    hant

    s,co

    nnec

    tions

    betw

    een

    loca

    lm

    erc

    hant

    sand

    trad

    ing

    com

    pani

    esand

    soon.

    Of

    cours

    e,ce

    rtai

    nki

    nds

    of

    info

    rm

    atio

    nar

    enec

    essa

    rily

    lost

    insu

    cha

    stud

    y.A

    lthou

    ghco

    ffee

    dom

    inat

    esth

    elo

    cale

    conom

    y,it

    occ

    upi

    esa

    smal

    lper

    cent

    age

    ofcu

    ltiva

    ble

    surf

    ace

    area

    .A

    ndth

    ere

    isa

    livel

    yre

    gion

    alm

    ark

    etin

    gnetw

    ork

    com

    plet

    ely

    sepa

    rate

    from

    the

    coffe

    etr

    ade.

    Such

    choi

    ces,

    and

    the

    recogn

    ition

    that

    one

    s

    stud

    yis

    necess

    aril

    ypa

    rtial

    ,are

    basic

    toan

    thro

    polo

    gica

    lfie

    ldw

    ork.

    With

    acom

    modi

    tyorie

    ntat

    ion,

    how

    ever

    ,one

    can

    shift

    the

    spat

    ial

    focu

    sat

    vario

    uspo

    ints

    inth

    ere

    sear

    ch.

    Inth

    eV

    enez

    uela

    nst

    udy,

    the

    auth

    orconcentr

    ated

    on

    the

    tow

    nof

    Boc

    on,

    the

    cente

    rof

    aco

    ffee-

    prod

    ucin

    gre

    gion

    and

    the

    hom

    eof

    agr

    oup

    ofc

    offe

    em

    erc

    hant

    s.Fr

    omth

    atpo

    int,

    the

    stud

    yco

    uld

    shift

    itsfo

    cus

    tow

    ard

    loca

    lpr

    oduc

    ers

    byfo

    llow

    ing

    the

    mer

    chan

    ts

    netw

    orks

    ,or

    itco

    uld

    turn

    att

    entio

    nbe

    yond

    Boc

    on

    tow

    ard

    the

    trad

    ing

    com

    pani

    esby

    follo

    win

    ganoth

    erse

    tofn

    et

    work

    s.G

    iven

    are

    late

    dse

    tof

    rese

    arc

    hpr

    oble

    ms

    this

    stud

    yconcen

    trat

    edon

    rela

    tions

    hips

    betw

    een

    merc

    hant

    sand

    nall

    farm

    ers

    with

    inth

    ere

    gion

    ,co

    mbi

    ning

    arch

    ival

    rese

    arc

    hin

    the-

    land

    regi

    stry

    (whe

    reit

    was

    poss

    ible

    tore

    const

    ruct

    chan

    ges

    incr

    edit

    stru

    ctur

    esby

    exam

    inin

    gold

    mort

    gage

    s)and

    inte

    rvie

    ws

    with

    key

    figur

    es.

    The

    stud

    ydi

    dnot,

    how

    ever

    ,move

    tow

    ard

    the

    wid

    erw

    orld

    with

    the

    sam

    ede

    tail.

    Itdi

    dnot

    expl

    ore

    the

    arch

    ives

    oft

    heM

    arac

    aibo

    trad

    ing

    com

    pani

    esth

    emse

    lves

    or

    exam

    ine

    thei

    rrela

    tions

    with

    Ger

    man

    or

    Am

    eric

    anm

    arke

    ts.

    Exam

    ples

    ofIn

    nova

    tive

    New

    Mac

    rolev

    elRe

    sear

    chO

    ther

    stud

    ies

    have

    been

    equa

    llyse

    nsi

    tive

    tolo

    cal

    proc

    esse

    sw

    hile

    payi

    ngm

    ore

    att

    entio

    nto

    deve

    lopm

    ents

    beyo

    ndlo

    calr

    egio

    ns.T

    wo

    re

    cent

    work

    spr

    ovid

    em

    ode

    lsfo

    rfut

    ure

    work

    .A

    nnSt

    oler

    sre

    cent

    stud

    yoft

    hepl

    anta

    tion

    belt

    inSu

    mat

    ra(1

    985)

    was

    notl

    imite

    dto

    asi

    ngle

    com

    modi

    tybu

    tconcentr

    ated

    on

    the

    plan

    tatio

    nbe

    ltofS

    umat

    ras

    East

    Coa

    st.

    The

    regi

    onpr

    oduc

    edru

    bber

    ,to

    bacc

    o,te

    a,and

    palm

    oil,

    am

    ong

    oth

    ergo

    ods.

    Wha

    tmost

    clea

    rlym

    ade

    the

    regi

    ona

    unit

    was

    the

    conjun

    ction

    of

    plan

    tatio

    npr

    oduc

    tion

    and

    Dut

    chco

    loni

    alism

    .In

    unde

    rtaki

    nghe

    rst

    udy,

    she

    condu

    cted

    field

    wor

    kin

    the

    regi

    on,

    inte

    rvie

    win

    gw

    ork

    ers,

    fore

    men

    ,and

    manage

    rsand

    stud

    ying

    one

    oft

    hequ

    asi-p

    easa

    ntvill

    ages

    .B

    utsh

    eal

    soexam

    ined

    arch

    ives

    inSu

    mat

    raand

    the

    Net

    herla

    nds,

    and

    whi

    lein

    the

    Net

    herla

    nds

    she

    inte

    rvie

    wed

    retir

    edpl

    anta

    tion

    manage

    rs.

    Bec

    ause

    Java

    nese

    mig

    rant

    sconst

    itute

    much

    oft

    hela

    borf

    orce

    ,sh

    ew

    as

    able

    toin

    corp

    orat

    ein

    sigh

    tsfr

    omea

    rlier

    field

    wor

    kin

    Java

    asw

    ell,

    notin

    gfu

    ndam

    enta

    ldi

    ffer

    ence

    sbet

    wee

    nJa

    vane

    sevill

    age

    life

    and

    the

    att

    empt

    tore

    const

    itute

    the

    sem

    blan

    ceofp

    easa

    ntlif

    ein

    apl

    anta

    tion

    conte

    xt.

    Chr

    isG

    jordin

    gs(fo

    rthco

    ming

    )stu

    dyof

    apr

    opos

    ed(b

    utnever

    real

    ized

    )copp

    erm

    inin

    gpr

    oject

    inPa

    nam

    ais

    also

    inno

    vativ

    e.G

    jordin

    gwas

    concern

    ed

    abo

    utth

    epo

    tent

    iali

    mpa

    ctoft

    hepr

    oject

    on

    the

    Gua

    ymiI

    ndi

    ans,

    and

    hew

    as

    also

    inte

    rest

    edin

    thei

    rde

    velo

    ping

    resi

    stan

    ceto

    the

    proje

    ct.To

    ass

    ess

    impa

    cts

    and

    gain

    insi

    ghti

    nto

    the

    form

    atio

    nof

    new

    soci

    alm

    ovem

    ents

    ,he

    had

    tocondu

    ctlo

    cal

    field

    wor

    k.A

    full

    unde

    rst

    andi

    ngoft

    heim

    pact

    oft

    hepr

    oject

    also

    requ

    ired

    anal

    ysis

    ofn

    atio

    nal

    and

    inte

    rnat

    iona

    lde

    velo

    pmen

    ts.

    Gjor

    ding

    esc

    hew

    eda

    spat

    ial

    defi

    nitio

    nofh

    isunit

    ofa

    nal

    ysis

    and

    concentr

    ated

    on

    the

    min

    ing

    proje

    ctits

    elf.

    This

    allo

    wed

    him

    toex

    plor

    eth

    ero

    leoft

    hepr

    oject

    with

    inth

    eP

    anam

    ania

    nst

    ate

    spl

    ans

    fore

    conom

    icand

    polit

    ical

    deve

    lopm

    ent,

    the

    plan

    sof

    vario

    usm

    ulti

    natio

    nalc

    orp

    orat

    ions

    that

    ente

    red

    and

    with

    drew

    from

    the

    proje

    ct,flu

    ctua

    tions

    with

    inth

    ein

    tern

    atio

    nalc

    opp

    erm

    ark

    et,

    deci

    sion

    -m

    aki

    ngpr

    oces

    ses

    atth

    eW

    orld

    Ban

    k,and

    the

    incr

    easi

    ngly

    ass

    ert

    ive,

    ifco

    nff

    ictu

    al,

    att

    empt

    sby

    Gua

    ymi

    Indi

    ans

    tofin

    dan

    app

    ropr

    iate

    re

    spon

    seto

    apr

    oject

    they

    cam

    eto

    rega

    rdas

    ath

    reat

    toth

    eir

    livel

    ihoo

    d.Fi

    eldw

    ork

    invo

    lved

    resi

    denc

    eam

    ong

    the

    Gua

    ymi,

    buti

    talso

    invo

    lved

  • Peas

    ants

    and

    the

    Wor

    ld12

    3

    ape

    riod

    of

    time

    inPa

    nam

    aCi

    tyin

    terv

    iew

    ing

    gove

    rnm

    ent

    offi

    cial

    sas

    wel

    las

    time

    inN

    ewY

    ork

    inte

    rvie

    Win

    gm

    ulti

    natio

    nal

    exec

    utiv

    esand

    Wor

    ldB

    ank

    offi

    cers

    .B

    oth

    of

    thes

    est

    udie

    soffe

    rmode

    lsfo

    rfu

    ture

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    calw

    ork

    .Li

    keth

    eV

    enez

    uela

    stud

    y,th

    eyco

    nce

    ive

    alo

    cal

    situ

    atio

    nin

    agl

    obal

    conte

    xt.

    Also

    like

    the

    Ven

    ezue

    last

    udy,

    anal

    ysis

    oft

    here

    latio

    nsofp

    rodu

    ctio

    nand

    exch

    ange

    invo

    lved

    with

    expo

    rtco

    mm

    odi

    ties

    prov

    ides

    the

    means

    for

    asi

    gnifi

    cant

    expa

    nsio

    nofa

    nth

    ropo

    l0gi

    focu

    s.U

    nlik

    eth

    eV

    enez

    uela

    stud

    y,th

    eyar

    ele

    ssro

    ote

    din

    apa

    rticu

    lar

    loca

    le;

    the

    field

    -w

    ork

    ers

    condu

    cted

    rese

    arc

    hat

    the

    cente

    rsoft

    hew

    orld

    econom

    yas

    wel

    las

    the

    perip

    herie

    Sand

    they

    made

    cert

    ain

    aspe

    cts

    ofth

    edy

    nam

    ics

    of

    the

    cente

    r(co

    lonial

    polic

    ies

    mark

    etflu

    ctua

    tions

    ,co

    rpor

    ate

    inve

    stm

    ent

    stra

    tegi

    es,

    lend

    ing

    agen

    cyre

    quire

    mef

    lt5and

    soon)i

    nter

    nal

    toth

    eir

    analy

    sis

    ofp

    artic

    ular

    regi

    ons

    inth

    epe

    riphe

    ryoft

    hew

    orld

    syst

    em.

    The

    prob

    lem

    of

    Soci

    alH

    omog

    enei

    tyin

    Peas

    ant

    Com

    mun

    ities

    Ase

    cond

    meth

    odol

    ogic

    alis

    sue,

    notr

    est

    ricte

    dto

    world

    -sys

    tem

    analy

    ses,

    issi

    mul

    tane

    ousl

    ycre

    ate

    dand

    obs

    cure

    dby

    the

    styl

    eofp

    rese

    ntat

    ion

    ado

    pted

    inth

    isch

    apte

    r.W

    eha

    veta

    lked

    abou

    tpe

    asan

    tsand

    the

    world

    as

    ifpe

    asan

    tsw

    ere

    asi

    mpl

    e,undi

    ffer

    entia

    ted,

    and

    isola

    ble

    grou

    p.Th

    ism

    ake

    sse

    nse

    inte

    rms

    ofa

    nan

    thro

    polo

    gica

    lhis

    tory

    :Mos

    tof

    the

    issu

    esdi

    scus

    sed

    inth

    ischa

    pter

    cam

    eout

    ofan

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    calm

    ove

    tow

    ard

    the

    stud

    yof

    peas

    antp

    opul

    atio

    ns.

    The

    pres

    enta

    tion

    mak

    esle

    ssse

    nse

    ,

    how

    ever

    ,in

    term

    soft

    heco

    ncr

    ete

    soci

    alsi

    tuat

    ion

    ofa

    ctua

    lpea

    sant

    ries.

    Inth

    efir

    stpl

    ace,

    peas

    antri

    esar

    ege

    nera

    llych

    arac

    teriZ

    edby

    mark

    edso

    cial

    diff

    eren

    tiatio

    n.A

    few

    hous

    ehol

    dsm

    aybe

    able

    ,in

    most

    year

    s,to

    prov

    ide

    for

    them

    selv

    esw

    ithou

    tse

    ndi

    ngho

    useh

    old

    mem

    bers

    tow

    ork

    els

    ewhe

    refo

    rwag

    esand

    with

    outt

    urni

    ngto

    the

    mark

    etex

    cept

    fort

    hose

    ess

    entia

    lsth

    atcannotb

    epr

    oduc

    edon

    the

    farm

    .Som

    eho

    useh

    olds

    will

    bem

    ore

    favo

    rabl

    ysi

    tuat

    ed,

    hirin

    gla

    bore

    rsand

    selli

    ngm

    uch

    of

    thei

    rpr

    oduc

    e.(W

    ithexpo

    rtco

    mm

    odi

    typr

    oduc

    tion

    such

    asth

    atfo

    und

    inB

    ocon

    ,m

    ark

    etre

    latio

    nsar

    em

    ore

    com

    plic

    ated

    fora

    lloft

    hety

    pes

    dis

    cuss

    ed

    here

    .)M

    any

    hous

    ehol

    dsw

    ill,

    how

    ever

    ,be

    less

    favo

    rabl

    ysit

    uate

    d,and

    they

    may

    have

    tose

    nd

    som

    eho

    useh

    old

    mem

    bers

    out

    tow

    ork

    on

    are

    gula

    rbas

    is.I

    ndee

    d,so

    me

    mem

    bers

    oft

    heho

    useh

    old

    may

    work

    outs

    ide

    sofr

    eque

    ntly

    that

    itis

    more

    app

    ropr

    iate

    toconsi

    dert

    hem

    prol

    etar

    ians

    .In

    the

    seco

    nd

    plac

    e,anth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    stud

    ying

    rura

    lpe

    ople

    sha

    venot

    deal

    tsi

    mpl

    yw

    ithpe

    asan

    trieS

    .Fro

    mqu

    iteea

    rlyon

    they

    have

    also

    stud

    ied

    enti

    eth-

    cent

    ury

    plan

    tatio

    nzones

    with

    popu

    latio

    nsof

    rura

    l

    prol

    etar

    ians

    .Th

    ePu

    erto

    Rico

    proje

    ctcoord

    ined

    byJu

    lian

    Stew

    ard

    exam

    ined

    ara

    nge

    ofr

    ura

    ltyp

    es,

    from

    the

    peas

    ants

    prod

    ucin

    gto

    bacc

    oand

    coffe

    ein

    the

    inte

    rior

    toth

    eru

    ral

    prol

    etar

    ians

    on

    corp

    orat

    esu

    gar

    plan

    tatio

    nsO

    flth

    eco

    ast.

    Inde

    ed,

    Sidn

    eyM

    intz

    sst

    udyo

    fa

    plan

    tatio

    ncom

    munity

    on

    Puer

    toRi

    cos

    south

    coas

    tint

    rodu

    ced

    the

    conce

    ptofr

    ura

    lpr

    olet

    aria

    nto

    anth

    ropo

    logi

    cal

    disc

    ours

    e(S

    teward

    etal.

    1956

    ;M

    intz

    1953

    ,19

    59,1974a,

    1974

    b).

    Sinc

    eth

    en,a

    nth

    ropo

    logi

    sts

    have

    exam

    ined

    ara

    nge

    ofp

    rodu

    ctiv

    eente

    rpris

    esand

    rura

    ltyp

    es.

    Yet

    the

    prob

    lem

    isev

    enm

    ore

    com

    plex

    .A

    naly

    tical

    dist

    inct

    ions

    are

    easy

    whe

    nw

    econtr

    ast

    aco

    mm

    unity

    ofpe

    asan

    ts

    with

    acom

    munity

    of

    pr

    olet

    aria

    ns.

    But

    thes

    edi

    stin

    ctio

    nsbe

    com

    em

    ore

    diffi

    cult

    whe

    nth

    ein

    vest

    igat

    oris

    att

    empt

    ing

    tounde

    rsta

    nda

    popu

    latio

    nofs

    mal

    l-sca

    lela

    ndow

    ners

    who

    farm

    thei

    rlan

    dbu

    twho

    also

    regu

    larly

    enga

    gein

    wage

    labo

    r.In

    som

    eca

    ses,

    the

    mix

    of

    farm

    work

    and

    off-

    farm

    work

    isun

    evenly

    dist

    ribut

    edw

    ithin

    the

    hous

    ehol

    d,w

    ithone

    mem

    ber

    (say,

    the

    husb

    and

    and

    fath

    er)m

    ain

    tain

    ing

    the

    farm

    whi

    leoth

    erm

    em

    bers

    (sons

    and

    daug

    hter

    s)w

    ork

    els

    ewhe

    re(on

    oth

    erfa

    rms,

    innearb

    yto

    wns

    ,as

    labo

    rers

    or

    asdo

    mes

    ticse

    rvants

    ),and

    whi

    leoth

    erm

    em

    bers

    (thew

    ifeand

    daug

    hter

    s)ta

    kein

    laun

    dry

    or

    mak

    ela

    cefo

    rsa

    leto

    merc

    hant

    s.In

    such

    case

    s,a

    pr

    olet

    aria

    tse

    ems

    tobe

    hidd

    enw

    ithin

    ape

    asan

    tcom

    munity

    (cf.M

    intz1974a)

    .Th

    eco

    mpl

    exity

    ofr

    ela

    tions

    hip

    isnot

    rest

    ricte

    dto

    the

    rela

    tions

    hip

    of

    peas

    antt

    opr

    olet

    aria

    n.O

    urim

    age

    ofpe

    asan

    tsis

    ofte

    none

    that

    em

    pha

    size

    san

    agr

    icul

    tura

    lst

    rate

    gyw

    ithth

    eho

    useh

    old

    unit

    farm

    ing

    api

    ece

    of

    land

    and

    work

    ing

    off

    the

    farm

    for

    wag

    esto

    supp

    lem

    ent

    farm

    pro

    duce

    .Rec

    entr

    ese

    arc

    h,ho

    wev

    er,s

    how

    sth

    atsu

    chho

    useh

    olds

    enga

    gein

    avarie

    tyofr

    epr

    oduc

    tion

    and

    accu

    mula

    tion

    stra

    tegi

    es,i

    nclu

    ding

    weav

    ing,

    sew

    ing,

    bric

    km

    akin

    g,co

    oki

    ng,p

    etty

    trad

    e,and

    the

    like.

    The

    cla

    ssic

    imag

    eoft

    hepe

    asan

    tmay

    beth

    ere

    sult

    ofa

    nagr

    icul

    tura

    lbia

    sin

    our

    mode

    lsth

    atbl

    inds

    us

    toa

    larg

    epo

    pula

    tion

    ofs

    impl

    ecom

    modi

    typro

    duce

    rsw

    ithlit

    tleac

    cess

    tola

    nd.I

    talso

    prec

    lude

    sa

    more

    soph

    istic

    ated

    unde

    rsta

    ndin

    goft

    heac

    tual

    repr

    oduc

    tion

    stra

    tegi

    esoft

    hose

    peop

    lew

    eca

    llpe

    asan

    ts(fo

    rgoo

    ddi

    scus

    sionS

    ofs

    impl

    ecom

    modi

    typr

    oduc

    er5

    see

    Coo

    k19

    7