Public Disclosure Authorized...

56
bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized

Transcript of Public Disclosure Authorized...

Page 1: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

bMeBjbMNgR)afña

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

wb20439
Typewritten Text
67349
Page 2: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure
Page 3: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

B M E B J B M N G R ) A F Ñ AbMNinsRmab;GnuvtþyuT§sa®sþkMeNInenAkm<úCa

bMeBjbMNgR)afña

Page 4: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

©rkSasiT§iedayFnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2012

FnaKarBiPBelak

113 mhavifIRBHneratþm

raCFanIPñMeBj

TUrs½BÞelx ³ +855 ¬0¦23 217 304

eKhTMB½r ³ www.worldbank.org/kh

Éksarbec©keTsRtÚv)ane)aHBum<pSay edIm,Ipþl;B½t’manBIlT§plkargarrbs;FnaKarBiPBelakeTAkan;

shKmn_GPivDÆn_edaymankarBnüareBltictYcbMput. ehtuenH sMeNAÉksaredImCaRbePTGtßbTminTan;

)anerobcM[RsbeTAtamnItiviFIsmRsbénGtßbT Edl)anEksRmÜlCapøÚvkarenAeLIyeT. RbPBmYycMnYn

EdldkRsg;enAkñúgÉksarenH GacCaÉksareRkApøÚvkarEdlminTan;man.

lT§plrkeXIj karbkRsay nigkarsnñidæan EdlbgðajenAkñúgÉksarenH KWCaKMnitrbs;GñkniBn§ nigmin)an

qøúHbBa©aMgBITsSn³rbs;FnaKarGnþrCati sRmab;karsßabna nigkarGPivDƼFnaKarBiPBelak nigGgÁPaB

Bak;B½n§rbs;FnaKar b¤CaKMnitrbs;RbFanRbtibtþiénFnaKarBiPBelak b¤rdæaPi)alEdlxøÜntMNageLIy.

FnaKarBiPBelakminFanaBIPaBRtwmRtÚvénTinñn½yEdlmanbBa©ÚlkñúgÉksarenHeT. RBMEdnBN’ kareRbIR)as;

eQµaH nigB½t’manepSg² bgðajenAelIEpnTIenAkñúgÉksarenH minbgðajBIkarvinicä½yelIEpñkNamYyrbs;FnaKar

BiPBelakBak;B½n§nwgsßanPaBRsbc,ab;rbs;EdndINamYy b¤karGnum½t b¤TTYlykRBMEdnTaMgenHeT.

siT§i nigkarGnuBaØat

ÉksarenAkñúgesovePAe)aHBum<pSayenHRtÚv)anrkSasiT§i. karftcmøg nig¼b¤karpSBVpSayEpñkNamYy b¤

TaMgRsúgénÉksarenH edayKµankarGnuBaØat KWCakarbMBaneTAelIc,ab;CaFrman. FnaKarGnþrCatisRmab;

karsßabna nigkarGPivDƼFnaKarBiPBelak elIkTwkcitþ[mankarpSBVpSayBIkargarrbs;xøÜn ehIyCaFmµta

pþl;karGnuBaØat[eFVIkare)aHBum<pSayeLIgvijnUvEpñknanaénÉksarenHPøam².

sRmab;karGnuBaØat[eFVIkarftcmøg b¤e)aHBum<pSayeLIgvijnUvEpñkNamYyénÉksarenH sUmepJIsMeNIGm

CamYyB½t’manlm¥iteTAkan;mCÄmNÐl rkSasiT§iftcmøg EdlmanGasydæan 222 Rosewood Drive/

Danvers/MA 01923 shrdæGaemrik TUrs½BÞelx 978-750-8400 TUrsarelx 978-750-4470

eKhTMB½r www.copyright.com.

ral;cm¶l;TaMgLayTak;TgnwgsiT§i nigGaCJab½NÑ rYmTaMgsiT§ibuRtsm<½n§ KYrepJIeTAkan;kariyal½y

e)aHBum<pSayFnaKarBiPBelak 1818 H Street NW TIRkúgv:asIunetan DC 20433 shrdæGaemrik

elxTUrsar 202-522-2422 sareGLicRtÚnik

[email protected].

Report number: 67349-KH

KRmbesovePA

TItaMg ³ saklviTüal½yksikmµenAraCFanIPñMeBj

rUbfteday ³ Dylan Walker

Page 5: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

bMNinkmøaMgBlkmµ man\T§iBleTAelIkarrIkceRmInrbs;RbeTskñúgkarGPivDÆesdækic© karkat;

bnßyPaBRkIRk nigkarbegáItkargar. karvinieyaKkñúgEpñkbMNinkmøaMgBlkmµ )ancUlrYmcMENk

begáIn[manplitPaBx<s; nigGacelIkkm<s;karRbkYtRbECg nigbegáIn»kaskargarnigkar

lUtlas;kan;EtRbesIreLIgEfmeTot. bNþaRbeTssmaCikGas‘an rYmman RbeTskm<úCa)an

TTYlsÁal;BIsar³sMxan;énbMNinsRmab;PaBcRmúgceRmIn nigBüayamelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆbMNin

niglMhUredayesrIénBlkmµRbkbedayCMnajEdlCaEpñkmYyénshKmn_esdækic©Gas‘an.

rebobvar³énkarGPivDÆbMNin mansar³sMxan;Nas;sRmab;RbeTskm<úCa. edaysarEtRbCaCn

v½yekµgmancMnYneRcIn RbeTskm<úCanwgGacemIl eXIjBIkMeNInesdækic© bERmbRmÜlbec©kviTüa

nigkargarrbs;xøÜnnaeBlGnaKt EdlEp¥kelIsmtßPaBkñúgkarTTYl)anbMNinrbs;yuvCnsm½yfµI.

ehtudUecñH raCrdæaPi)alkm<úCaTTYlsÁal;BIsar³sMxan;énbMNin TukCaEpñkmYyényuT§sa®sþctuekaN

rbs;RbeTskm<úCaedIm,IPaBrIkceRmInkargarsmFm’ nigRbsiT§PaB.

kñúgbribTenH ]tþmRkumRbwkSaesdækic©Cati (SNEC) )anesñI[FnaKarBiPBelakcUlrYm nigeFVI

kargar rYmKñaelIkarviPaKmYysþIBIGtulüPaBbMNinEdlekItmaneLIgcMeBaHesdækic©RbeTskm<úCa

b¤sKl;énbBaðaTaMgenaH nigviFankareqøIytbEdlGaceFVIeTA)anpgEdr. lT§plCaEpøpáaEdl

TTYl)anBIkic©shkar nigkarEckrMElkcMeNHdwgenaH KWCar)aykarN_bMNinsRmab;bMeBjbMNg

R)afñaRbeTskm<úCa ³ karGnuvtþyuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCabnÞab;BImanvibtþi.

lT§plrkeXIjdMbUgénr)aykarN_enH nigEpnkarskmµPaBGPivDÆbMNinEdl)anelIkeLIg RtÚv

)anelIkykmkBiPakSakñúgkic©RbCMutumUlmYy EdlmankarcUlrYmBItMNagmkBIbNþaRksYgnana

nieyaCkkñúgvis½yÉkCn nigPaKIBak;B½n§déTeTotEdl)anR)arBVeFVIeLIgenATIRkugPñMeBjnaéf¶TI31

ExmIna qñaM2011. kic©BiPakSaenH )anKUsbBa¢ak;BIsar³sMxan;énkareRCIserIsyuT§viFIvdþCIvit

cMeBaHkarGPivDÆbMNin karTTYlsÁal;famUldæanRKwHd¾sMxan;sRmab;bMNinnana RtÚv)anbegáIteLIg

enAkñúgkarGb;rMkumartUc nigCaEpñkénkarGb;rMkRmitmUldæan. elIsBIenHeTottMNagkñúgvis½y

ÉkCn )anelIkeLIgBIPaBcaM)ac;kñúgkarpþl;bMNinEdlmankñúgRbB½n§Gb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalrbs;

RbeTskm<úCa[RsbeTAnwgtRmÚvkarkñúgTIpSarkargar.

GarmÖkfa

Page 6: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

r)aykarN_enH pþl;CaTsSn³d¾mantémøsRmab;RbeTskm<úCa edIm,Icat;viFankarEdlGaceFVIeTA

)ankñúgkarGPivDÆbMNinepSg²sRmab;bMeBjbMNgR)afñaRbeTskm<úCa. r)aykarN_enH k¾)an

KUsRBagBIviFankarCak;lak;mYycMnYnkñúgkarsRmÜldl;lT§PaBTTYl)anB½t’mankñúgTIpSar kargar

BRgIkGnþraKmn_epþatelIRKÜsar edIm,IelIkkm<s;GRtaKg;vgSkñúgkarsikSa nigBRgwgkmµviFI»kas

elIkTIBIr k¾dUcCa karGb;rM nigbNúþHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³pgEdr. edIm,IksagmUldæan

RKwHsRmab;eBlGnaKt r)aykarN_enH)anelIkeLIgBIviFId¾l¥bMput edIm,IbegáInhirBaØb,Tan

sRmab;karGPivDÆkarGb;rMkumartUc BRgwgsßab½n nigCMruj[mankarelIkTwkcitþcMeBaHsßab½nEdl

manlT§pll¥RbesIrkñúgcMeNamsßab½nbNþúHbNþalbMNin rYmman RKwHsßan]tþmsikSaCaedIm.

karviPaKr)aykarN_enH bgðajBIkarcUlrYmshkard¾manGtßRbeyaCn_cMeBaHyuT§sa®sþkMeNIn

nigrebobvar³énkarGPivDÆmnusSrbs;RbeTskm<úCa ehIyeyIg´sgÇwmfa r)aykarN_enHnwg

mansarRbeyaCn_sRmab;elakGñk.

Page 7: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

r)aykarN_enH erobcMeLIgedayRkúmkargarénFnaKarBiPBelak EdldwknaMedayelakRsI

Hana Brixi eRkamkic©shkary:ags¥itrmYtCamYynwgCMnajkarén]tþmRkúmRbwkSaesdækic©Cati

(SNEC). elak Arvil Van Adams, elakRsI Sandra D’Amico ¬saCIvkmµFnFanmnusSkm<úCa¦

nigelak Alexander Krauss )ancUlrYmkñúgkarsikSamUldæan.

RkúmkargarenH )aneFVIkarpøas;bþÚreyabl; nigTTYl)anGnusasn_d¾mantémøBIsMNak;m®nþIrdæaPi)al

mkBIRksYg nigTIPñak;garrdæaPi)alepSg² rYmman RksYgesdækic© nighirBaØvtßú (MEF) RksYgkargar

nigbNúþHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ (MLVT) RkúmRbwkSaGPivDÆn_km<úCa (CDC) nigsßab½nrdæaPi)al nigsßab½n

édKUnana dUcCa AusAid CaedIm. m®nþIrdæaPi)alCan;x<s; nigCMnajkarCaeRcIn)anpþl;mti nig

sMeNIsMxan;²mYycMnYn kñúgGMLúgkic©RbCMutumUlsþIBIbMNinenATIRkugPñMeBj naéf¶TI31 ExmIna

qñaM2011.

RkúmkargareyIg´ sUmEføgGMNrKuNcMeBaHkarENnaMEdlminGackat;éfø)anBIsMNak; ³ Ék]tþm

hgS CYnNar:un rdæelxaFikarRksYgesdækic© nighirBaØvtßú nigCaGnuRbFanGcié®nþy_én]tþmRkúm

RbwikSaesdækic©Cati Ék]tþm eBC esaP½n rdæelxaFikarRksYgkargar nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³

nigÉk]tþm b:uk )a:n; rdæelxaFikarRksYgkargar nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³. eyIg´k¾sUmEføg

GMNrKuNCaBiesscMeBaHm®nþICan;x<s;mYycMnYn sRmab;karcUlrYmcMENkbec©keTsdl;karviPaK

enH rYmman Ék]tþm sux cinþa GKÁelxaFikarénRkúmRbwkSaGPivDÆn_km<úCa Ék]tþm mIu klüaN

TIsþIkarKN³rdæm®nþI Ék]tþm eLA hIum GKÁnayk énGKÁnaykdæanGb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs

nigviC¢aCIv³ Ék]tþm ehg sY GKÁnaykén GKÁnaykdæankargar nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ Ék]tþm

hug CYn RbFanTIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargar Ék]tþm m:k; g:y GKÁnaykénGKÁnaykdæanGb;rM

yuvCn nigkILa elakbNÐit Cin ehogfavriT§i naykviTüasßanbec©keTskm<úCa Ék]tþm rs; sIlv:a

GKÁelxaFikarrgén]tþmRkúmRbwkSaesdækic©Cati Ék]tþm pan; pløa GKÁelxaFikarrgén]tþm

RkúmRbwkSaesdækic©Cati Ék]tþm Ca vuT§I GKÁelxaFikarrgTTYlbnÞúktMbn;esdækic©BiessénRkúm

RbwkSaGPivDÆn_km<úCa Ék]tþm san vDÆna GKÁelxaFikarrgén CARD-SPCU elak eTB eGOn

GKÁnaykrgénGKÁnaykdæankargar nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ elak G‘ug luyNa RbFanEpñk

RsavRCav nigviPaKeKalneya)aysgÁmén]tþmRkúmRbwkSaesdækic©Cati elak sYn supl

GnuRbFanTTYlbnÞúktMbn;esdækic©BiessénRkúmRbwkSaGPivDÆn_km<úCa elak éh suvuT§a GnuRbFan

EpñkeKalneya)aysgÁmén]tþmRkúmRbwkSa esdækic©Cati elak éL suxXag GñkRsavRCavén

]tþmRkúmRbwikSaesdækic©Cati nigelak sU c½nÞRKwsña buKÁlik CARD-SPCU.

esckþIEføgGMNrKuN

Page 8: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

RkúmkargareyIg´ sUmEføgGMNrKuNcMeBaHkarcUlrYmBIsMNak;édKUminEmnrdæaPi)al Edl)an

pþl;CaTsSn³ nigB½t’mand¾mansarRbeyaCn_ rYmman ³ GñkRsI lIlI sIusm,tþi FO/IFC G-PSF ¬evTikardæaPi)al- vis½yÉkCn¦ elak Pierre Tami ¬sßabnikGgÁkar Hagar GnþrCati¦

GñkRsI Nicky Enriquez ¬RbFanRKb;RKgFnFanmnusSmkBIRkúmh‘un Mobitel¦ elak Si Len

¬RbFanRKb;RKgkarbNþúHbNþal CAMFEBA¦ elak Ken Loo ¬nayk GMAC¦ elak yuK suFI

¬nayk NTTI¦ elak Ca m:ar:ug ¬GñkRsavRCavCan;x<s; BDLINK Cambodia Co., Ltd¦

elak Ehm tula ¬GñkRbwkSaRbcaM BDLINK Cambodia Co., Ltd¦ elak eBA sM ¬nayk

RbtibtþieragcRkpÁt;pÁg;GaharsmuRT Nautisco¦ elak KYc KIm ¬CSDEC¦ GñkRsI has; DINa

¬sux suxxa¦ elak carü exmrin ¬NTTI¦ elakbNÐit tan; munIvNÑ ¬GnuRbFanRkúmh‘un

m:ugb¤T§IRKúb¦ GñkRsI éh sIuEft ¬Loran Imp. Ezp.com., Ltd¦.

shesvikénFnaKarBiPBelakCaeRcIn rYmman elak Mathew Verghis, elak Stephane

Guimbert, elak Carlos Sobrado, GñkRsI Omporn Regel, elak Timothy A. Johnson, elak Christian Bodewig, elak Jamele Rigolini, elak ebg sIuemt, elak Tsuyoshi

Fukao, elak Julian Clarke, elak Harold H. Alderman, GñkRsI Mariana Infante Villarroel, nig elak eb:g va:n;nI Edl)ancUlrYmCamtieyabl; nigsMeNIepSg²d¾mansarRbeyaCn_.

eyIg´k¾sUmEføgGMNrKuNdl;GñkRsI Mariana Infante Villarroel, elak eb:g va:n;nI nigGñkRsI

eCob r:av:an; Edl)anCYysRmÜldl;karbegáIte)aHBum< nigdMeNIrkarbkERbr)aykarN_enH.

RkúmkargarbkERbénRkúmh‘un NaTIExµr Edl)anbkERbr)aykarN_enHeTACaPasaExµr.

CacugeRkay RkúmkargareyIg´ sUmEføgGMNrKuNy:agRCaleRCAcMeBaHelak Qimiao Fan

¬RbFanRKb;RKgkariyal½yFnaKarBiPBelakRbcaMkm<úCa¦ cMeBaHkar)anpþl;CaeKalkarN_

ENnaMyuT§sa®sþ GñkRsI Annette Dixon ¬nayikaFnaKarBiPBelakRbcaMRbeTskm<úCa-Lav-

ma:eLsuI-éf nigCatMNagrbs;FnaKarBiPBelakRbcaMRbeTsPUma¦ cMeBaHkarENnaMEdlminGac

kat;éfø)an GñkRsI Xiaoqing Yu ¬nayikaEpñkGPivDÆmnusS-KaMBarsgÁm¦ elak Eduardo Velez

¬GtItRbFanRKb;RKgEpñkGb;rM¦ nigelak Luis Benveniste ¬RbFanRKb;RKgEpñkGb;rMbc©úb,nñ¦

cMeBaHkar)anpþl;CaeKalkarN_ENnaMyuT§sa®sþ.

Page 9: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

esckþIsegçb 1

1> yuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa TamTar[manbMNinl¥RbesIrCagmun 6

2> etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc? 12

2>1 etInieyaCkRbQmnwgkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNinGVIxøH? 12

2>2 etIPaBxVHxatkñúgkarpþl;bMNinsßitenARtg;Na? 16

2>3 etIkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNinkñúgRbeTskm<úCa bNþalmkBImUlehtuGVIxøH? 29

3> skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa 32

3>1 karbegáItEpnkarskmµPaBbMNin 33

3>2 karGnuvtþEpnkarskmµPaB nigkarBicarNaelIyuT§sa®sþ[)anTUlMTUlay 42

Éksareyag 44

matika

Page 10: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

AusAid TIPñak;garGU®sþalI sMrab;karGPivDÆn_GnþrCati

CAMFEBA shB½n§nieyaCk nigsmaKmBaNiC¢kmµkm<úCa

CARD RkumRbwkSasþarGPivDÆn_vis½yksikmµ nigCnbT

CDC RkumRbwkSaGPivDÆn_km<úCa

CSES karGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic© km<úCa

D&D vimCÄkar nigvishmCÄkar

ECD karGPivDÆkumartUc

EMIS RbB½n§RKb;RKgB½t’manGb;rM

GDP plitplsrubkñúgRsúk

GMAC smaKmeragcRkkat;edrenAkm<úCa

IFC saCIvkmµhirBaØvtßúGnþrCati

IT bec©kviTüaB½t’man

MEF RksYgesdækic© nighirBaØvtßú

MoEYS RksYgGb;rM yuvCn nigkILa

MLVT RksYgkargar nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³

NEA TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargar

NGO GgÁkareRkArdæaPi)al

NTB KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal

NTTI viTüasßanCatibNþúHbNþalbec©keTs

RGC rdæaPi)alkm<úCa

SEZ tMbn;esdækic©Biess

SNEC ]tþmRkumRbwkSaesdækic©Cati

SPCU GgÁPaBsRmbsRmÜlKaMBarsgÁm

STEP bMNinedIm,ITTYl)ankargar nigplitPaB

TVET Gb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³

UNESCO GgÁkarshRbCaCatisRmab;karGb;rM viTüasa®sþ nigvb,Fm’

GkSrkat;

Page 11: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

1

1 kMNt;smÁal;enH erobcMeLIg bnÞab;BIr)aykarN_rbs;FnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2010 sþIBIkarpþl;bMNinsRmab;smFm’ nigPaBrIkceRmIn nigbEnßmBIelIkMNt;smÁal;qñaM2010 rbs;FnaKarBiPBelaksþIBI karGnuvtþyuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCaeRkayeBlmanvibtþi.

kMNt;smÁal;enH Ep¥kelIkic©BiPakSakñúgebskkmµKaMBarsgÁmrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak kalBIExvicäika qñaM2010 nigEp¥kelIkarCECk

BiPakSaeKalneya)ayenAevTikaesdækic©km<úCa qñaM2011. kMNt;smÁal;enH maneKalbMNgKaMRTrdæaPi)alkñúgkarkMNt;skmµPaB

edIm,IedaHRsay]bsKÁCakatBVkic© nigkarRBagyuT§sa®sþbMNinrbs;RbeTskm<úCa sRmab;eBlGnaKt. sUmeFVIkarENnaMedaysYr

CasMnYr nigpþl;eyabl;eTA Hana Brixi EdlCaRbFanRkúmsRmab;kmµviFIKaMBarsgÁmrbs;FnaKarBiPBelakkñúgRbeTs. km<úCa

([email protected]).

rdæaPi)al)anRBmeRBógkMNt;ykbMNinCaEpñkmYy ényuT§sa®sþctuekaNrbs;RbeTskm<úCa

edIm,IPaBrIkceRmIn kargar smFm’ nigRbsiT§PaB. CaeRcInTsvtSr_knøgmkenH RbeTskm<úCa

)anelIkkm<s;bMNinkmøaMgBlkmµrbs;xøÜn EdlkmøaMgBlkmµenHmankarrIkceRmInyWtCageK

ebIeRbóbeFobCamYyRbeTsdéTeTotkñúgtMbn;GasIubUBa’. eTaHbICaRkúmh‘unmYycMnYnkñúgRbeTs

km<úCayl;eXIjfa bMNinminEmnCa]bsKÁcm,gkñúgGaCIvkmµrbs;xøÜnk¾eday k¾bBaðaxVHxatbMNin

Gacman\T§iBlGviC¢mandl;dMeNIrkarelIkkm<s;vis½y]sSahkmµ ksikmµ nigBiBiFkmµesdækic©.

karGegátbriyakasvinieyaKqñaM2007 )anbgðaj[eXIjfa Rkúmh‘unEdlraykarN_fa bMNinCa

]bsKÁcm,graMgsÞHdl;karrIkceRmInmankMeNInBI 6/5° dl; 15/5° enAqñaM2003. elIsBIenH

Rkúmh‘unbreTsenARbeTskm<úCa cMnYn 22° )ancat;TukbMNinCa]bsKÁ {F¶n;F¶r b¤F¶n;F¶rbMput}

dl;kareFVIGaCIvkmµrbs;xøÜn. kñúgeBleFVIkarvinieyaKpÞal;BIbreTsmanTMnak;TMngviC¢manCamYy

nwgkareRbIR)as;bec©kviTüaTMenIb nigkmøaMgBlkmµEdlmanCMnajenaHkarvinieyaKpÞal;BIbreTsfµI

RtÚvkarcMNaysRmab;»kaskargar. elIsBIenH edaysarRbCaCn 56°manGayueRkam 25 qñaM

kñúgqñaM2008 eTIbsmtßPaBrbs;yuvCnbc©úb,nñkñúgkarTTYl)anbMNinnwgCYyelIkkm<s;lT§pl

esdækic© nig»kasrIkceRmInrbs;RbeTskm<úCanaeBlGnaKt.

nieyaCkcg¥úlbgðajBIGtulüPaBCarcnasm½<n§kñúgkarpþl;bMNin rYmTaMgkgVHxatsisSbBa©b;kar

bNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³eRbóbeFobCamYynwgsisSbBa©b;karsikSakRmit]tþmsikSa. kñúgkarGegát

fµImYyelInieyaCk 78 nak; rbs; HRINC ¬qñaM2011¦ nieyaCk 73° )anraykarN_fa

sisSbBa©b;karsikSakRmit]tþmsikSaminTan;manbMNineqøIytbnwgkargar ¬cMENknieyaCk

12° eTot )anniyayfa cMnYnsisSbBa©b;karsikSakRmit]tþmsikSaminTan;manRKb;RKan;¦

nieyaCk 62° )ankt;smÁal;eXIjfa sisSbBa©b;karbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³minmanbMNineqøIytb

nwgkargarenaHeT ¬cMENknieyaCk 38° eTot )anelIkeLIgfa sisSbBa©b;karbNþúHbNþal

viC¢aCIv³mancMnYntictYcbMput¦. elIsBIenH nieyaCk 31° )ankt;smÁal;eXIjfa karbNþúHbNþal

b¤karelIkkm<s;kmøaMgBlkmµbc©úb,nñ KWCakarlM)akEdlkargarenHGacbNþalmkBIKuNPaBTab

énkmµviFIbNþúHbNþal nigPaBTn;exSayénmUldæanbMNinsRmab;karbNþúHbNþalbEnßm.

esckþIsegçb

Page 12: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

2

nieyaCkyl;eXIjfa fñak;RKb;RKgCan;x<s;mankarxVHxatbMNinF¶n;F¶r ehIynieyaCitvij mankar

xVHxatbMNinCIvitEdlCabMNinsMxan;bMputsRmab;kargar. kñúgkarGegátqñaM2011 rbs; HRINC

nieyaCkelIsBI 70° )anraykarN_BIkarxVHxatCacm,gnUvbMNinRKb;RKgkñúgenaHnieyaCk 36°

raykarN_BIkarxVHxatbMNinRKb;RKgfñak;kNþal nigbMNinEpñkGPi)alkic© ehIynieyaCk 34°

raykarN_BIkarxVHxatbMNinbuKÁlikCMnaj. kñúgcMeNambMNinCIvitEdlmanPaBlM)akkñúgkar

EsVgrknieyaCk)ankMNt;BIbMNinCIvitmYycMnYnEdlkñúgenaH mannieyaCk 52° )ankMNt;BI

\riyabfkargarrbs;nieyaCitminmanCMnajnieyaCk 45° )anelIkeLIgBIbMNinkñúgkarseRmc

citþrbs;nieyaCitmanCMnajminc,as;las; nignieyaCk 64° )anelIkeLIgBIbMNinviPaKrbs;

nieyaCitCMnaj. bEnßmBIenHeTot nieyaCkmankart¥ÚjEt¥rBIkarlM)akkñúgkarEsVgrknieyaCit

EdlmanbMNinviC¢aCIv³c,as;las; nigmanbMNinmUldæan dUcCa Gkçrkmµ nigkarKNnaelxnBVnþ.

edIm,IedaHRsaybBaðaxVHxatbMNin nieyaCkCaeRcInpþl;karbNþúHbNþalpøÚvkar b:uEnþeKmankar

lM)akkñúgkarEsVgrksßab½nbNþúHbNþal EdlmanKuNPaB. karGegáteFVIeLIgsRmab;Éksar

eKalneya)ayenH )anbgðaj[eXIjfa nieyaCk 55° pþl;karbNþúHbNþaldl;nieyaCitrbs;

xøÜn y:agehacNas;Bak;kNþalénnieyaCitTaMgGs; cMENknieyaCkCaeRcIneTotpþl;karbNþúH

bNþaldl;kmøaMgBlkmµrbs;xøÜnEtmYycMnYntUcb:ueNÑaH ¬karGegátrbs; HRINC qñaM2011¦.

karGegátenHk¾bgðajEdrfa nieyaCkcMnYn 64° CYbRbTHnwg]bsKÁF¶n;F¶rkñúgkarEsVgrksßab½n

bNþúHbNþalEdlmanKuNPaB. edIm,IedaHRsaybBaðaenH nieyaCkTamTarB½t’manbEnßm rYmTaMg

B½t’man sþIBIsßab½nbNþúHbNþalkargarKuNPaBrbs;mCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ lT§PaB

pþl;bMNinCak;lak; nigKuNPaBsaklviTüal½y RBmTaMgmanbMNgbegáItTMnak;TMngCamYysakl

viTüal½yeTotpg.

RbeTskm<úCaRbQmnwg]bsKÁcm,gkñúgkarpþl;bMNinenAdMNak;kaldMbUgénvdþCIvit Edlcab;epþIm

BIkarGPivDÆkumartUc. PsþútagBIkarGegátbgðajfa kmµviFIGPivDÆn_kumartUcEdlmanRbsiT§PaB

pþl;GtßRbeyaCn_CaeRcIn pÞúymkvij BikarPaBenAv½yekµg KWmankarlM)ak nigRtÚvcMNayfvika

eRcInkñúgkarBüa)al. eTaHCay:agenHkþI enARbeTskm<úCabBaðakarxVHGaharUbtßmÖF¶n;F¶renAEtral

dal nigCH\T§iBlGviC¢manelIkarGPivDÆbBaØasµartIrbs;kumar nigskþanuBlbMNinnaeBlGnaKt.

kgVHGaharenAkñúgRKÜsareFVI[GRtasikSa nigbBa©b;karsikSamankRmitTab.

karGb;rMbzmsikSabgðajBIPaBexSaykñúgkarbBa©b;karsikSa nigkarsikSaTUeTA. eKalneya)ay

rdæaPi)al)anbegáInGRtacuHeQµaHcUleronenAkRmitbzmsikSarhUtdl; 95° kñúgqñaM2009¼2010

enATUTaMgTIRkug nigtMbn;CnbT. eTaHbICay:agNa sisSe)aHbg;karsikSaenAbzmsikSaman

kRmitx<s;EdlkñúgenaHGRtaRtÜtfñak;man 11° nigGRtae)aHbg;karsikSaman 49°. mUlehtu

sRmab;karmincUleron nigkare)aHbg;ecalkarsikSa KWmanTMnak;TMngcm,geTAnwgsßanPaBRKÜsar

rYmman PaBRkIRkkareFVIkargarpÞH nigkarrkR)ak;cMNUl ¬CamUlehtucm,gEdlkumarGayu 6 qñaM

dl; 11 qñaM cMnYn 13° min)ancUleron¦ RBmTaMgkarKitfa kumarenAv½yekµgenAeLIy eTaHbICa

RKb;GayupøÚvkarcUleronk¾eday ¬54°¦ b¤mincg;cUleron ¬17°¦. mUlehtuénkarmincUleron

esckþIsegçb

Page 13: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

3

b¤KitfaGayuekµgeBkminGaccUleronenaH qøúHbBa©aMgBIbBaðacMeBaHkumartUc rYmTaMgkarGPivDÆ

yWtyav nigexSaybBaØaedaysarEtkarxVHxatGaharUbtßmÖ b¤kat;bnßyskmµPaBxYrk,al edaysar

xVHkarbNþúHbNþalsµartIRKb;RKan;enAdMNak;kaldMbUgénCivit. elIsBIenH viBaØasaRbLgvay

témøsisSfñak;CatielImuxviC¢aPasaExµr nigKNitviTüafñak;TI3 TI6 nigTI9 bgðajfa lT§pl

sikSamUldæanrbs;sisSenAmankRmitTabenAeLIy eTaHbImankarelIkkm<s;k¾eday. vtþman

niglkçN³sm,tþirbs;RKÚbeRgón KWCa]bsKÁcm,gmYy.

vtþmansikSaenAkRmitmFümsikSa nigkarGb;rM nigbNúþHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ ¬TVET¦

enAmankRmitTab nigRbQmnwgkarmin[témøelIkarsikSa. GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronmankRmitTab

enAeLIy EdlmanRbEhl 32° enAkRmitmFümsikSabzmPUmi 12° enAkRmitmFümsikSa

TutiyPUmi nigticCag 6° sRmab;karGb;rM nigbNúþHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ ¬EMIS qñaM2010 nig CSES qñaM2009¦ sisSticCag Bak;kNþalbBa©b;karGb;rMmFümsikSarbs;xøÜn.

mUlehtusRmab;karmincUleron nigkare)aHbg;ecalkarsikSa KWbBaðaEpñkhirBaØvtßú edaysisS

52° min)ancUleronmFümsikSabzmPUmi nigsisS 2 PaK 3 min)ancUleronmFümsikSa

TutiyPUmi KWCasisSsßitkñúgPaBRkIRkEdlRtÚvEsVgrkR)ak;cMNUl nigeFVIkargarpÞH ¬CSES

qñaM2009¦. RksYgGb;rM yuvCn nigkILa ¬MoEYS¦ )anTTYlsÁal; nigcab;epþImpþl;CMnYy

hirBaØvtßúdl;RKÜsarsRmab;[kUnbnþkarsikSa. müa:geTot eTaHbICamantRmÚvkarKMnitpþÜcepþIm

bnÞan;k¾eday k¾karcMNayticsRmab;vis½yGb;rMenAEtCabBaðaraMgsÞHdl;KMnitpþÜcepþImenHdEdl.

elIsBIenHTsSn³RKÜsarEdlKitfa kar[kUn²bnþkarsikSanwgeFVI[)at;bg;hirBaØvtßúPøam²enaH

ekIteLIgedaykarmin[témøelIsikSa edaysarminTTYl)anB½t’manGMBIcMNUlhirBaØvtßúEdlkUn

Gacrk)an RbsinebIkUnGacbnþkarsikSadl;kRmitmFümsikSa nigkarGb;rM nigkarbNþúHbNþal

bec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³. ]TahrN_ cMNUlhirBaØvtßúnwgekIn 60° sRmab;sisSbnþkarGb;rM nig

bNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³enAkRmitmFümsikSaeRbóbeFobeTAnwgkarGb;rMbzmsikSa

nigcMNUlekIn 112° sRmab;sisSbnþkarGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalbec©keTseRkaybBa©b;mFüm

sikSa eRbóbeFobeTAnwgkarGb;rMmFümsikSabzmPUmi b:uEnþsisSEdlmancMNab;GarmµN_cuHeQµaH

cUleronvKÁGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³manRtwmEt 17° b:ueNÑaH. CalT§pl vtþmansikSaTab

enAkRmitmFümsikSaGMBavnav[mankmµviFIsRmab;»kaselIkTI2 nigkarbNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§.

CacugeRkay kñúgkarbegáItbMNinkRmitx<s; RbeTskm<úCaRbQmnwgkarsikSamuxviC¢aEdlminTak;Tg

nwgTIpSarkargar EdlenHCabBaðacm,gxøaMgCagbBaðaGRtacuHeQµaHcUleronfñak;]tþmsikSa Edl

mankRmitTabeTAeTot. RKwHsßan]tþmsikSarbs;RbeTskm<úCapþl;CMnajdl;sisSbBa©b;karsikSa

rYmman CMnajKNenyü hirBaØvtßú nigRKb;RKg ¬sisSfñak;briBaØabRtcMnYnBak;kNþalcuHeQµaH

cUleronmuxviC¢aTaMgenHenAqñaMsikSa 2009¼ 2010¦ eRbóbeFobeTAnwgmuxviC¢avisVkmµsIuvil ¬1/5°

kñúgcMeNamsisScuHeQµaHcUleronfñak;briBaØabRt¦ nigmuxviC¢aviTüasa®sþ nigbec©kviTüa ¬0/1°

kñúgcMeNamsisScuHeQµaHcUleronfñak;briBaØabRt¦. eTaHbICavis½yksikmµ nigesdækic©CnbT

eRkABIEpñkksikmµ Cavis½ysMxan;sRmab;elIkkm<s;k¾edayk¾mansisSRtwmEt 2/3° b:ueNÑaH

EdlsikSamuxviC¢aTak;TgnwgcMeNHdwgkñúgvis½yTaMgenH. Tak;TinnwgkarbkRsaybBaðaenH karGegát

esckþIsegçb

Page 14: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

4

elIyuvCnnaeBlfµI²enHbgðajfa sisSminmankaryl;dwgc,as;BIbMNinEdlCatRmÚvkarrbs;

nieyaCkeT nigman]bsKÁkñúgkarTTYlB½t’manEdlGacTukcitþ)ansþIBIkarsikSa nig»kasTTYl

)ankargar.

CarYm buBVehtuénkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNinrbs;RbeTskm<úCa bgðaj[eXIjenA

EpñkB½t’man nigkarsRmbsRmÜl RBmTaMgkarpþl;hirBaØb,Tan visalPaB nigKuNPaBénvis½y

Gb;rM. nieyaCkmankarxVHxatmeFüa)aykñúgkarbgðajBItRmÚvkarrbs;xøÜnelIbMNinCak;lak; nig

\T§iBlelIeKalneya)ayGPivDÆn_bMNin. karBRgwgRkumKN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal ¬NTB¦

edIm,Ipþl;lT§PaBdl;Rkúmh‘un bBa¢ÚntRmÚvkarrbs;xøÜneTArdæaPi)al nigkarbNþúHbNþaldl;

eKalbMNg skmµPaBGnuvtþbnÞan; karbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;eBlGnaKt

1> karTTYl)anB½t’man • elIkkm<s;smtßPaBkñúgkarRbwkSakargar nigesvaEsVgrkkargar

• eRbIR)as;RbB½n§pSBVpSayB½t’manedIm,Ibgðaj BI»kassikSa nig kargar nigkarelIkkm<s;karGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³

• elIkkm<s;smtßPaBrbs;TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargar nigPaBCaédKUCamYyvis½yÉkCn

2> visalPaB {PaBcenøaHenAkRmitkNþal}

• b®Ba¢abkmµviFIGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalbec©keTsnigviC¢aCIv³Edlman KuNPaBl¥

• BRgwgsmtßPaBrbs;KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþalkñúgkMENTRmg;kñúgkMENTRmg;karGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþal nieyaCk

• BicarNaelImeFüa)ayCMruj[nieyaCkcMNayelIkarbNþúHbNþalkmøaMgBlkmµrbs;xøÜn

3> KuNPaB nigPaBBak;B½n§nwgTIpSar

• cab;epþImbegáIncMnYnsßab½n bNþúHbNþalbMNin rYmman mCÄmNÐl bNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§ edaykar shkarCamYy]sSahkmµkñúgRsúk

• kMENTRmg;kmµviFIsikSamFümsikSa edIm,IelIkkm<s;karbeRgónviTüasa®sþ KNitviTüa visVkmµ nigmuxviC¢a bec©keTsepSgeTot PaBCashRKin nigbMNinCIvit

• BRgwgkarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;shKmn_ nigsalaeronEdlCaEpñkmYyéndMeNIrkarvimCÄkar nigvishmCÄkar

4> RbsiT§PaBhirBaØb,Tan • BRgIkviFIsa®sþpþl;hirBaØb,Tan tRmg;TisRKÜsar edIm,IGRta Kg;vgSénkarsikSa

• begáInkarcMNayelIbTGnþraKmn_ EdlmankarcMNaytictYcenAdMNak;kaldMbUgénvdþCivit

• EsVgrkviFIsa®sþhirBaØb,Tannana edIm,ICMruj[mankarelIkTwkcitþ cMeBaHsßab½nEdlmanlT§plbNþúHbNþal l¥kñúgcMeNamsßab½nbNþúHbNþalbMNin rYmTaMgRKwHsßan ]tþmsikSa.

EpnkarskmµPaBGPivDÆn_bMNin ³ skmµPaBGnuvtþPøam² nigkarbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;eBlGnaKt

esckþIsegçb

Page 15: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

5

shKmn_ GacmantYnaTIy:agsMxan;kñúgkaredaHRsaybBaðaTak;TgnwgB½t’man. cMENkEpñkpÁt;pÁg;

vijmanbuBVehtuénbBaðamYycMnYn dUcCa bBaðaRbQmkñúgkarRKb;RKgFnFantamrebobmYyEdl

elIkTwkcitþdl;GñkbMeBjkargarl¥ nigmankarTTYlxusRtÚvelIlT§pl bBaðaRbQmkñúgkarbeRgón

bMNinCIvit nigCMnajbec©keTs nigP¢ab;TMnak;TMngrvagsalaeron nig]sSahkmµ[kan;EtCitsñiT§

edIm,IelIkkm<s;KuNPaB nigTMnak;TMngtRmÚvkarTIpSar. elIsBIenH buBVehtuTaMgenHrab;bBa©Úl

TaMgbBaðaRbQmkñúgkarbnþpþl;CMnYydl;RKÜsar edIm,IerobcM[kumar)ancUleron. cugeRkay

TIpSarbMNinTTYlrgplb:HBal;y:agxøaMgBIsßab½nTIpSarEdlminmanKuNPaB ¬dUcCa ynþkarsRmb

sRmÜlesvaEsVgrkkargarkarFanaKuNPaB karpþl;GaCJab½NÑ bTb,BaØtþi nigkarTTYlsÁal;

KuNPaBGb;rM¦ edIm,IP¢ab;TMnak;TMngrvagtRmÚvkar nigkarpþl;bMNin. sßab½nTIpSarminGacrYm

bBa©Úlkñúgvis½yÉkCn)aneT edaysarEtlkçN³plRbeyaCn_saFarN³TaMgenaH.

karbMeBjKMnitpþÜcepIþmEpñkeKalneya)aykMBugdMeNIrkar dUcenH EpnkarskmµPaBbMNinrbs;

RbeTskm<úCa caM)ac;RtÚvedaHRsay]bsKÁcm,gsRmab;bMNin edIm,IQaneTAseRmcbMNgR)afña

rbs;xøÜn. edayskmµPaBenHCaskmµPaBGaTiPaBbnÞan; rdæaPi)alGacsRmbsRmÜllT§PaB

TTYl)anB½t’mankñúgTIpSarbMNin BRgIkGnþraKmn_tRmg;TisRKÜsar edIm,IelIkkm<s;GRtaKg;vgSén

karsikSa nigBRgwg»kassikSaelIkTI 2 RBmTaMgkarGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³.

edIm,IerobcMmUldæanRKwHsRmab;eBlGnaKt rdæaPi)alKYrBRgIkhirBaØb,TansRmab;karGPivDÆ

kumartUc BRgwgkarGPivDÆsßab½n nigCMruj[mankarelIkTwkcitþcMeaHsßab½nbNþúHbNþalEdlman

KuNPaBl¥ rYmman RKwHsßan]tþmsikSaCaedIm. taragxageRkamenH segçbBIskmµPaBEdl)an

elIkeLIgsRmab;eFVIkarBicarNa.

esckþIsegçb

Page 16: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

6

1

RbeTskm<úCa)ancab;epþImbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;BiBiFkmµesdækic© nigesdækic©plitkmµ. eRkayBI

ekItmanvibtþi rdæaPi)alminRtwmEtcab;yk»kasry³eBlxøIsRmab;karsþaresdækic©eLIgvijenaHeT

EfmTaMgdMeNIrkaryuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCaeTAdl;dMNak;kalbnÞab; dUcCakareq<aHeTArk ³

k¦ kareFVIBiBiFkmµesdækic© Ep¥kelI]tþmPaBeRbóbeFobEdlmanRsab; nig x¦eFVIbc©úb,nñPaB

TayC¢TanedIm,IbegáIn]tþmPaBeRbóbeFobeRkABIkarbBa©ÚleKaKRTBüdI sßanPaByuT§sa®sþPUmisa®sþ

nigkmøaMgBlkmµEdlmantémøTab.

]bsKÁbMNinEdlmanRsab;rbs;RbeTskm<úCa nigPaBlem¥ógeTArk]sSahkmµGtiBlkmµEdl

manbMNinTabb:HBal;dl;yuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTs. R)ak;ebovtSr_ nigéføedImBlkmµTab

edaysarEtkarpÁt;pÁg;kmøaMgBlkmµEdlKµanCMnajy:ageRcInenaH CH\T§iBlelI]sSahkmµCaeRcIn

RbePTkñúgRbeTskm<úCa. plitkmµGtiBlkmµ EdlmanbMNinTabRtÚv)anBRgIkedaykarnaMecj

plitplsemøókbMBak;tamrdUvkalmancMnYn 88° énkarnaMecjrbs;RbeTs. kñúgry³eBld¾xøI

RbeTskm<úCamankarrMBwgTukfanwgbnþTak;Taj]sSahkmµGtiBlkmµmanbMNinTab EdlGacRbkYt

RbECgkñúgmUldæanéføedImBlkmµTab. edaysarRbeTskm<úCamanmUldæanFnFanmnusSman

kRmitTabenaH ninñakarenHbgá[dMeNIrrbs;xøÜnmanPaByWty:avkñúgkarqøg[putBIksikmµeRbIR)as;

2 sRmab;karBiPakSa sUmemIlÉksarrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak ¬qñaM2010 A¦ yuT§sa®sþctuekaNrbs;RbeTskm<úCa edIm,IPaBrIk

ceRmInkargar smFm’ nigRbsiT§PaB epþatelIvis½ymYycMnYn dUcCa ³ ksikmµ RbB½n§Twk nigFarasa®sþ ehdæarcnasm<½n§KmnaKmn_

GKÁisnI karGPivDÆFnFanmnusS ]sSahkmµGtiBlkmµ nig]sSahkmµplitGaharsRmab;naMecj eTscrN_ eRbg ]sµ½n

FmµCati nigEr:epSg²eTot bec©kviTüaB½t’man¼KmnaKmn_ nigCMnYj.

3 rdæaPi)al)ankMNt;vis½yGaTiPaBcMnYn19 Edlcat;TukCaEpñkényuT§sa®sþsmahrNkmµCMnYjrbs;xøÜn ³ Rsaebor RKab;sVaycnÞI

dMLÚgeQI eBat Clpl Es,keCIg kat;edr karciBa©wmstV Ggár ekAs‘U sURt sENþkesog EpøeQI nigbEnø plitpleQI

smaKmhtßkmµFunRsal eTscrN_ esvaBlkmµ ¬rYmTaMgkarsagsg;¦ esvaTak;TgnwgkardwkCBa¢Ún dMeNIrkarGaCIvkmµ¼

esvatamRbB½n§GIuneFIeNt.

4 bBaðaRbQmEpñksRmbsRmÜl nigB½t’man sßitkñúg]bsKÁbIsMxan;² TnÞwmnwgbBaðaRbQménFnbRmug nigtémøGKÁisnI nigPsþúPar

EdlraraMgPaBrIkceRmInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa ¬FnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2010 A¦. bBaðaRbQmEpñkFnbRmugsMedAelIRbB½n§Gn;-

exSayrbs;RbeTskm<úCa kñúgkaredaHRsayCemøaH nigkarRbqaMgGMeBIBukrlYy. témøGKÁisnIx<s; nigéføedIm nigPsþúPar Edlmin

GacTukcitþ)an ¬rYmTaMgCMnYj¦ raraMgshRKinBIkarcUlrYmkñúgKeRmagEdlGacdMeNIrkar)an.

yuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTs km<úCa TamTar[manbMNinl¥ RbesIrCagmun

Page 17: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

7

bec©keTsGn;fy Furkic©ksikmµ htßkmµFunRsal nigeTscrN_ edIm,Ieq<aHeTArkkareRbIR)as;

bec©kviTüakan;EtTMenIb. CalT§pl PaByWty:avenHeFVI[b:HBal;dl;Twkcitþrbs;nieyaCit¼sßab½n

pþl;kargarkñúgkarcMNayfvikaelIkarbNþúHbNþalbMNin.

karelIkkm<s; nigkareFVIBiBiFkmµrcnasm½<n§]sSahkmµCYbRbTHnwgbBaðaRbQmCaeRcInenAEpñk

sRmbsRmÜl nigB½t’man. CaBiess karbraC½yBIkarTTYlB½t’man nigkarsRmbsRmÜlTIpSar

raraMgshRKinPaB nigkarbegáItGaCIvkmµfµI EdlenHnwgGacCYybegáItkargarkñúgvis½yfµITak;Tgnwg

vis½yesdækic©. karGegátGMBIkareFVIGaCIvkmµedayFnaKarBiPBelakbgðajfa cMNat;fñak;RbeTs

km<úCasßitkñúgelxerogTI 147 kñúgcMeNamRbeTscMnYn 183 enAqñaM2010 eday)anelIkeLIgfa

5 vismPaBR)ak;cMNUlkñúgRbeTskm<úCamankRmitx<s;eTAtamsþg;datMbn; edaymanemKuN Gini Qandl; 45°.

sRmab;Tinñn½y sUmemIlTinñn½ymUldæantamdanPaBRkIRkenAtMbn;GasIubUBa’.

6 RsedognwgTinñn½yrbs;viTüasßanCatisßitipgEdr ¬qñaM2010¦ karGegátRbCasa®sþ nigsuxPaBkm<úCa ¬qñaM2011¦ bgðajBIkar

Føak;cuHénGRtapþl;kMeNItsrubBI 4/0 kñúgqñaM2000 dl; 3/0 kñúgqñaM2010.

yuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa TamTar[manbMNinl¥RbesIrCagmun

EpnkarskmµPaBGPivDÆn_bMNin ³ skmµPaBGnuvtþPøam² nigkarbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;eBlGnaKt

karpþl;bMNin tRmÚvkarbMNin

PaKryénnieyaCitminman

CMnajEdlraykarN_

edayRkúmh‘un ¬°¦*

Rkúmh‘unpþl;karbNþúHbNþal

pøÚvkardl;nieyaCit ¬°¦

Rkúmh‘unraykarN_fa

bMNinkmøaMgBlkmµ

KWCa]bsKÁcm,g ¬°¦

km<úCa 25/7 48/3 15/5

\NÐa 36/3 15/9 14/5

\NÐÚensIu 20/4 4/7 4/5

saFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüRbCamanitLav >> 11/1 18/7

ma:eLsIu 65/0 50/1 20/2

en)a:l; 35/8 8/8 5/9

)a:KIsßan 19/1 6/7 8/1

éf 83/5 75/3 38/8

evotNam 20/8 43/5 8/9

PaKrymFümsRmab;RbeTsEdl)an

eRCIserIs

38/3 29/4 15/0

PaKrymFümBiPBelak 33/7 34/1 26/1

RbPB ³ karGegátshRKasrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2006 dl;qñaM2009. sRmab;viFIsa®sþkñúgkarKNna sUmemIlFnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2011.kMNt;smÁal; ³ *sRmab;RbeTsmYycMnYnTinñn½ykarGegát qñaM2006 dl;qñaM2007 epþatelIPaKrynieyaCitEdlminmanCMnajkñúgvis½y]sSahkmµEtb:ueNÑaH.

Page 18: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

8

kargargayRsYlkargareragcRk nigGñkbBa¢am:asIun nigGñktemøIgyanynþsib,kmµksikmµ rukçaRbmaj; nigensaTGñkpþl;esva nigGñklk;CMnYykarGñkbec©keTsGñkCMnajGñkRKb;RKgkgkmøaMgRbdab;GavuF0%

minmankarGb;rMbzmsikSa

mFümsikSabzmPUmi

mFümsikSaTutiyPUmi

TEVT mFümsikSa

TEVT bBa©b;mFümsikSamhaviTüal½y

srub ¬mFüm¦

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

rUbPaBTI1 ³ muxrbrEp¥ktamkarGb;rMkñúgcMeNamGñkEdlmanGayucenøaHcab;BI 20 dl; 29 qñaM qñaM2009

RbPB ³ karGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa (CSES) qñaM2009

00 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronkRmitmFümsikSa ¬PaKrydul¦

ksikm

µ témøb

Enßm ¬P

aKryé

nplit

plkñúg

Rsuks

rub¦

RbeTsmYyPaKbI ¬51¦EdlBwgEp¥kxøaMgelIvis½yksikmµ

y = 68.95e-0.029x

R2 = 0.4465

km<úCa

rUbPaBTI 2 ³ karcuHeQµaHcUleronmFümsikSa nigksikmµ KWCaEpñkmYyénplitplkñúgRsúksrub

RbPB ³ sUcnakrGPivDÆn_BiPBelak qñaM2010

karbegáItGaCIvkmµenARbeTskm<úCaRtÚvkarkarcMNayeRcIn. karGegátbriyakasvinieyaK)an

kMNt;fa GPi)alkic© eKalneya)ay bTb,BaØtþi nigrdæ)al GmCamYyGRtaBn§ nigkareRbIR)as;

GKÁisnI KWCa]bsKÁcm,gsRmab;karGPivDÆ.

kñúgTIpSarkargar bBaðaRbQmEpñkB½t’man nigkarsRmbsRmÜlcat;TukCabBaðakgVHxatbMNinruaMér:

nigbMNinelIslub. salamCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalsisS nigkmµsikSakarI hak;bIdUcCaCab;kñúg

KMrUvinieyaKEdlbnþeFVI[manGtulüPaBbMNin. xN³eBlesdækic©epþatkarykcitþTukdak;elI

yuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa TamTar[manbMNinl¥RbesIrCagmun

Page 19: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

9

7 sRmab;karviPaK sUmemIl Di Gropello nig Sakellariou ¬qñaM2010¦. RbeTsEdl)aneFVIkarGegát rYmman RbeTskm<úCa cin

\NÐÚensIu m:ugehÁalI hVIlIBIn éf nigevotNam. karsikSakMNt;nieyaCitEdlmanCMnajfaCanieyaCit EdlmankarGb;rMmFüm

sikSaTutiyPUmi nigkarGb;rMx<s;CagenH.

plitkmµEdlmanbMNinTab tRmÚvkarbMNinkRmitx<s;kñúgvis½y nigkargarEdl)aneRCIserIs

minGacQaneTAseRmc)anRsbeBlCamYyKñaenaHEdr. karxVHxatB½t’man nigkarsRmbsRmÜl

TIpSarCaEpñkénbBaðaCarcnasm½<n§.

CaBiessCagenHeTAeTot bBaðaRbQmkñúgkarGPivDÆrbs;RbeTskm<úCa rYmman PaBRkIRk nig

kMeNInvismPaB. RKÜsareRcInCag 2 PaK 3 kñúgbBa©PaKRKÜsarmancMNUlTabbMputEdlman

CIvPaBBwgEp¥kelIksikmµ nigvismPaBenAtamtMbn;CnbT KWCaktþacm,génkMeNInvismPaBkñúg

RbeTskm<úCa. karviPaKbgðajfa karkat;bnßyPaBRkIRk nigkarpøas;bþÚrninñakarénkMeNInvism

PaB GacnaM[mankarelIkkm<s;vis½yksikmµ nigbeBa©jkmøaMgBlkmµ[bnþkargarepSg²eTot

eRkABIvis½yksikmµ. kareFVIkargarepSg²eTot TamTar[manTIpSar kargarviC¢aCIv³ shRKinPaB

nigmanlT§PaBTTYl)anesvasaFarN³mUldæanRbkbedaysmFm’ dUcCa esvaGb;rM nigesva

EfTaMsuxPaB. tRmÚvkarTIpSarTaMgenHk¾GacKaMRTkarrIkceRmInnaeBlGnaKtrbs;RbeTspgEdr.

karCYbRbTHnwgbBaðaRbQmTaMgenH nigkarGPivDÆbMNinmUldæan[)anRKb;RKan;mansar³sMxan;

kñúgkarTTYlsÁal;BIskþanuBlrbs;yuvCnCaeRcIn rbs;RbeTskm<úCakñúgkarcUlrYmkñúgkmøaMgBlkmµ.

RbCaCnRKb;GayueFVIkar)anekIneLIgBI 54° kñúgqñaM1998 rhUtdl; 62° kñúgqñaM2008 ktþaenH

)anekIteLIg edaysarEtkMeNIncMnYnyuvCn ¬viTüasßanCatisßiti qñaM2010¦. eTaHbICaRbeTs

km<úCakMBugEteq<aHeTArkkarbBa©b;GnþrkalRbCasa®sþ nigGRtapþl;kMeNItmankarFøak;cuHBI 5/3

kñúgqñaM1998 dl; 3/1 kñúgqñaM2008 k¾eday ¬dUecñHPaKryéncMnYnkumarmankarFøak;cuHkñúg

TsvtSr_knøgmk¦ k¾mankarrMBwgfa nwgmankarhUrcUlnUvkmøaMgBlkmµCaeRcInCabnþbnÞab;. bMNin

nwgkMNt;BIsmtßPaBrbs;yuvCnkñúgkarcUlrYmkñúgkargarplitkmµ b¤shRKinPaB.

bMNinnwgman\T§iBlelI»kaskargarnaeBlGnaKtrbs;RbeTskm<úCa. edayRbCaCn 56° man

GayueRkam 25 qñaM kñúgqñaM2008 enaHsmtßPaBrbs;yuvCnbc©úb,nñkñúgkarTTYl)anbMNinnwgman

\T§iBlelIlT§plesdækic© nig»kasrIkceRmInrbs;RbeTskm<úCanaeBlGnaKt. CaBiess

kareRbIR)as;bec©kviTüa nigkarGPivDÆbMNinkñúgCIvitkargarGackMNt;)antamry³mUldæanbMNin

Edl)anGPivDÆenAdMNak;kaldMbUgénCIvit. karGb;rMmankRmitkñúgcMeNamyuvCnEdlcUlrYmkñúg

kmøaMgBlkmµrbs;RbeTskm<úCa raraMgvisalPaBkñúgkarbegáItkargarEdlGacTTYlyk)anRBm

TaMgkarelIkkm<s;]sSahkmµ nigkarpøas;bþÚrbec©kviTüanaeBlGnaKt.

eTaHbICabMNinminEmnCa]bsKÁcm,graraMgdl;PaBrIkceRmInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa kñúgbriyakas

bc©úb,nñk¾eday b:uEnþbMNinenHnwgman\T§iBlelIlT§plesdækic©rbs;RbeTskm<úCanaeBlGnaKt.

karvaytémøbriyakasvinieyaKenAqñaM2009 )anbgðajfa Rkúmh‘unkñúgRbeTskm<úCa)ancat;

yuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa TamTar[manbMNinl¥RbesIrCagmun

Page 20: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

10

cMNat;fñak;bMNinfaCa]bsKÁsMxan;bMputlMdab;elx 9 kñúgcMeNam]bsKÁTaMg 18 EdlraraMg

karrIkceRmIn ¬FnaKarBiPBelakqñaM2009¦. eTaHbICay:agenHkþI PaKryénRkúmh‘unEdlray

karN_fa bMNinCa]bsKÁcm,graraMgkarrIkceRmInenAkñúgkarGegátenH )anekIneLIgBI 6/5° dl;

15/5° kñúgkarGegátRsedogKñaenAqñaM2003. Rkúmh‘un)anbgðajkarykcitþTukdak;elIbMNin

ehIymanRkúmh‘unmYykñúgcMeNamRkúmh‘unBIrpþl;karbNþúHbNþaldl;nieyaCitrbs;xøÜn ¬taragTI

1¦. tamry³bTBiesaFn_bgðajfa karGb;rMmanTMnak;TMngy:agCitsñiT§CamYykargarepSg²

eRkABIkargarksikmµ ¬rUbPaBTI 1¦ nigkarGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSapþl;KuNtémøkan;Etx<s;bEnßm

elIplitplksikmµ ¬rUbPaBTI 2¦ dUecñH RbsinebIminmankarGPivDÆTan;eBlevlaeT karxVHxat

bMNinmUldæannwgraraMgsmtßPaBrbs;RbeTskm<úCakñúgkarGPivDÆesdækic©rbs;xøÜn nigkøayCaRbeTs

EdlmanR)ak;cMNUlkNþalnaeBlGnaKt.CaeRcInTsvtSr_knøgmkenH RbeTskm<úCa)anelIk

km<s;bMNinkmøaMgBlkmµrbs;xøÜnEdlkmøaMgBlkmµenHmankarrIkceRmInyWtCageK ebIeRbóbeFob

CamYyRbeTsdéTeTotkñúgtMbn;GasIubUBa’. Cak;Esþg RbeTskm<úCa nigm:ugehÁalI CaRbeTscMnYn

BIrKt; Edl)aneFVIkarGegátkñúgtMbn; bgðaj[eXIjBIPaKryénkarQb;RTwgrbs;nieyaCitCMnaj

kñúgcMeNamnieyaCitEdlmanR)ak;cMNUl ¬tamry³kMeNInPaKryénnieyaCitmankarGb;rMkRmit

]tþmsikSaGackat;bnßyplb:HBal; edaysarkarFøak;cuHPaKryénnieyaCitmankarGb;rMkRmit

mFümsikSaTutiyPUmienARbeTskm<úCa¦. enAcenøaHqñaM1997 nigqñaM2007 buBVlaPR)ak;QñÜl

mantulüPaB edayminrab;bBa©ÚlR)ak;cMNUlsRmab;nieyaCitEdlbBa©b;karGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSa

ehIytulüPaBenHCaRbPBénkarminpøas;bþÚrbMNin. buBVlaPR)ak;QñÜl]sSahkmµkñúgGMLúgqñaMenH

mancMnYnelIsBIbuBVlaPR)ak;QñÜlbMNinedayelIkeLIgfa buBVlaP]sSahkmµCaktþaCMrujd¾sMxan;

énPaBxusKñarvagR)ak;QñÜlkñúgvis½yesdækic©. pÞúyeTAvij r)aybuBVlaP]sSahkmµkan;Etx<s;

bgðajfa mankarEbgEckTIpSarkargarkan;EteRcInenARbeTskm<úCaCagRbeTsepSg²eTotEdl

)aneFVIkarGegátenAkñúgtMbn; ¬Di Gropello nig Sakellariou qñaM2010¦.

karxVHxatbMNinruaMér:CH\T§iBlGviC¢manelIkarvinieyaKpÞal;rbs;breTs nigkarnaMeTArkPaBrIk

ceRmInénbec©kviTüa. kñúgkarGegátbriyakasvinieyaKqñaM2007 bgðajfaRkúmh‘unbreTsenA

RbeTskm<úCacMnYn 22° ¬eRbobeFobnwgcMnYnmFüm 15/5° énRkúmh‘unTaMgGs;¦ )anbBa¢ak;fa

bMNin KWCa]bsKÁ {F¶n;F¶r b¤F¶n;F¶rbMput} kñúgkareFVIGaCIvkmµrbs;BYkeK. kñúgkarvinieyaKpÞal;BI

breTsmanTMnak;TMngviC¢manCamYynwgkareRbIR)as;bec©kviTüaTMenIb nigkmøaMgBlkmµEdlman

CMnajenaH karvinieyaKpÞal;BIbreTsfµIRtÚvkarcMNaysRmab;»kaskargar. elIsBIenHTinñn½y

TTYl)anBIRbeTskm<úCa nigRbeTsdéTeTotenAtMbn;GasIubUBa’bgðajfa Rkúmh‘unEdlGñkRKb;RKg

mankarGb;rMx<s; ¬tMNagGñkRKb;RKgEdlmankarGb;rMx<s;CagmFümsikSa¦ manTMenareRCIserIs

buKÁlikEdlmankarGb;rMx<s;pgEdr ¬Almeida qñaM2009¦.

RbeTskm<úCamankarrMBwgTukfa nwgQaneTAdMNak;kalbnÞab;énkarGPivDÆenAeBlEdl]tþmPaB

eRbóbeFobénéføedImkmøaMgBlkmµTabrbs;xøÜnRtÚv)aneRbIR)as;Gs; ehIyR)ak;QñÜlcab;epþIm

ekIneLIg. KMrUEbbenH ekItmanenARKb;TIpSaresdækic© EdlmansßanPaBR)ak;cMNUlx<s; nig

esdækic©EdlTamTarcMeNHdwgx<s;. RbsinebITIpSarkargardMeNIrkarRbkbedayRbsiT§PaBenaH

yuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa TamTar[manbMNinl¥RbesIrCagmun

Page 21: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

11

nwgbgðaj[eXIjBIGnþrkalenH tamry³kartemøIgR)ak;QñÜlrbs;nieyaCitEdlmanbMNinTab

enAeBlElgmannieyaCitEbbenH ehIykarbegáInR)ak;QñÜlenH Rkúmh‘unnwgpþl;karvinieyaKCa

TunbEnßm nigbegáIntRmÚvkarnieyaCitEdlmanCMnaj. karbegáInTunnaMmknUvbec©kviTüafµIEdlnaM

[mankarpøas;bþÚrbec©keTsEdlmanPaBlem¥ógelICMnaj. enAeBlenaH esdækic©rbs;RbeTs

km<úCanwgpøas;bþÚrBIkarRbkYtRbECgelImUldæanénR)ak;QñÜlTab eTACakarRbkYtRbECgelImUldæan

énplitPaBx<s;. KMrUenH)anekIteLIgCabnþbnÞab;enARbeTskUer: étv:an; nighugkug ehIy

bc©úb,nñenH eKeXIjmanKMrUEbbenHenAextþkVagtug nigextþdéTeTotenAtamtMbn;eqñrxagekIt

rbs;RbeTscin.

karrg;caMrhUtseRmc)ancMNucGnþrkalenH edIm,IGnuvtþskmµPaBelIrebobvar³bMNin bNþal

[manPaByWty:avkñúgkarbegáIteKalneya)aysßab½n nigkarGPivDÆsmtßPaBEdlCatRmÚvkar

sRmab;esdækic©sm½yTMenIb. karbegáIteKalneya)ay sßab½n nigkarGPivDÆsmtßPaB edIm,I

sRmbsRmÜlkarGPivDÆbMNin TamTar[maneBlevlaRKb;RKan;. enAqñaM1980 RbeTskUer:

)ancab;epþImksagsmtßPaB énRbB½n§Gb;rMkRmit]tþmsikSaeRtómTukCamunsRmab;tRmÚvkar

Cak;Esþgrbs;sisSbBa©b;karsikSakRmit]tþm. edayBicarNaelItRmÚvkareBlevla eTaHbICa

bMNinEmnEmnCacMNucsMxan;kñúgrebobvar³ énbriyakasvinieyaKbc©úb,nñrbs;RbeTskm<úCak¾eday

k¾rdæaPi)alenAEtnUvbnþGnuvtþrebobvar³sþIBIbMNin edIm,IbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;esdækic©BiBiF

kmµ nigesdækic©plitkmµ.

bMNinkmøaMgBlkmµ nwgsRmbsRmÜlkarGnuvtþyuT§sa®sþGPivDÆn_esdækic©rbs;RbeTskm<úCa.

karelIkkm<s;bMNinkmøaMgBlkmµnwgCMruj[mankareFVIBiBiFkmµesdækic©kñúgry³eBlmFüm nig

PaBrIkceRmInén]tþmPaBeRbóbeFobrbs;RbeTskm<úCakñúgry³eBlyUr. karrIkceRmInTaMgenH

nwgCYysRmÜldl;karelIkkm<s;ExSsgVak;témørbs;Rkúmh‘unkm<úCa nigbegáInshRKinPaB RBm

TaMgkarbegáItshRKasFuntUc nigmFümedayKaMRT[mankarbegáItkargar. bMNink¾GacCYy

elIkkm<s;vis½yksikmµ nigbegáIntémøbEnßmenAtamenAkEnøgplit nigTIpSarlk;plitpl

tamry³karRKb;RKgdI nigFnFanFmµCatiRbkbedaynirnþrPaB nigtamry³karpøas;bþÚrkmøaMg

BlkmµBIvis½yksikmµeTA]sSahkmµ nigesvakmµEdlnaMmknUvR)ak;cMNUlx<s;. elIsBIenH

bMNinnwgCYyrdæaPi)alkñúgkarRKb;RKgesdækic© nigsRmbsRmÜlPaBrIkceRmIn nigpþl;mUldæan

RKwHd¾rwgmaMsRmab;esvasgÁm nigrdæ)alsaFarN³ EdlmanRbsiT§PaBkñúgbriyakasvimCÄkar

kñúgRbeTskm<úCa.

yuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa TamTar[manbMNinl¥RbesIrCagmun

Page 22: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

12

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsb manlkçN³dUcemþc?edIm,IviPaKBIPsþútagEdlmansþIBIkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNinkñúgRbeTskm<úCa EpñkenH

bgðaj[eXIjBIsßanPaBekItecjBIkarrMBwgTukrbs;nieyaCk nigsßab½nbNþúHbNþalCMnaj

CaBiess minRtwmEtepþateTAelIRbB½n§Gb;rMEtmYyenaHeT. EpñkenHbgðajBIGtulüPaBbMNin

sMxan;²CaeRcIn Edlnwgb:HBal;dl;vis½yesdækic©naeBlxagmux. CacugeRkay EpñkenHk¾bgðaj

BIbuBVehtucm,génkarxVHxat nigPaBminRsbEdlTak;TgnwgkarbraC½yTIpSar nigcg¥úlbgðajBI

skmµPaBsMxan;²edIm,IedaHRsaybBaðaenH.

eTaHbICakarxVHxatbMNin minEmnCa]bsKÁF¶n;F¶r

b:HBal;dl;lT§plénPaBrIkceRmInk¾eday k¾

karxVHxatbMNin enAEtekIneLIgCabnþbnÞab;enA

tamvis½yCak;lak;. nieyaCk)ancg¥uúlbgðaj

BIGtulüPaBCarcnasm<½n§kñúgkarpþl;bMNin rYm

TaMgbBaðaBak;B½n§ nwgkarxVHxatsisSbBa©b;kar

bNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ eRbóbeFobeTAnwgsisS

bBa©b;karsikSakRmit]tþmsikSa nigkarxVHxat

y:agxøaMgnUvsisSbBa©b;karsikSakRmitbriBaØabRt

{edaymanbMNinRtwmRtÚv}. enAqñaM2008 kar

GegátnieyaCkcMnYn 220 nak; rbs; CAMFEBA

¬qñaM2008¦ bgðajfamannieyaCkcMnYn 13°

b:ueNÑaH EdlÉkPaBfabNþasisSbBa©b;karsikSa

kRmitbriBaØabRt manbMNinRtwmRtÚv {TaMgRsug

b¤esÞIrEtTaMgRsug} sRmab;TIpSarkargar cMENk

nieyaCk 11° )an[dwgfa yuvCnminman

bMNinRtwmRtÚveqøIytbnwgkargarenaHeT. kñúg

karGegátelIvis½y EdlmankarrIkceRmInxøaMg

cMnYn 3 eRkABIvis½yksikmµ ¬dUcCa vis½y

RbGb;TI1 ³ etI {bMNinCIvit} KWCaGVI?

CaTUeTA bMNin {CIvit} sMedAelIsmtßPaB

nig\riyabfbuKÁl Edlpþl;lT§PaBdl;

buKÁlkñúgkaredaHRsaytRmÚvkar nigbBaða

RbQmnanakñúgCIvPaBRbcaMéf¶Rbkbeday

RbsiT§PaB. ]> karedaHRsaybBaðaKMnit

écñRbDit karR)aRs½yTak;Tg nigkareFVI

kargarCaRkúm.

eyagtamr)aykarN_GPivDÆn_BiPBelak

qñaM2007 ¬FnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2006¦

bMNinCIvitGacEbgEckCaBIrRkúm ³ k¦

bMNinénkarKit mandUcCakarRtiHriHBicarNa

nigkarKitRbkbedaykarécñRbDit nig

x¦ bMNinxagGakb,kiriya rYmman PaB

]sSah_Büayam PaBm©as;karelIxøÜnÉg

kareFVIkargarCaRkum nigsmtßPaBsRmuH

sRmÜlCemøaH nigkarRKb;RKghaniP½y.

2>1 etInieyaCkRbQmnwgkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNinGVIxøH?

2

Page 23: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

13

kat;edr eTscrN_ nigsMNg;¦ manRkúmh‘un

mYykñúgcMeNamRkúmh‘uncMnYn 5 )anraykarN_

fa sisSbBa©b;karbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ ¬mann½y

fa CasisSTTYl)ankarbNþúHbNþalsRmab;

kargarCak;lak;¦ manbMNinsMxan;²kñúgkarGnuvtþ

kargarrbs;xøÜn (HRINC qñaM2010).

karGegátepSgeTotbgðajBIPaB minsmRsbén

bMNin. kñúgkarGegátfµImYyelInieyaCk 78 nak;

rbs; HRINC ¬qñaM2011¦ nieyaCk 73° )an

raykarN_fa sisSbBa©b;karsikSakRmit]tþm

sikSa BMumanbMNinRtwmRtÚvenaHeT ¬TnÞwmnwgenaH

nieyaCk 12° niyayfa cMnYnsisSbBa©b;

karsikSakRmit]tþmsikSa minTan;mancMnYn

RKb;RKan;enAeLIy¦. nieyaCk 62° )ankt;

smÁal;eXIjfa sisSbBa©b;karbNþúHbNþal

viC¢aCIv³ minmanbMNinRtwmRtÚveqøIytbnwgkargar

enaHeT ¬cMENknieyaCk 38° )anelIkeLIg

fa sisSbBa©b;karbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³mancMnYn

tictYcNas;¦. elIsBIenHnieyaCk 31°

kt;smÁal;eXIjfa karbNþúHbNþal b¤kar

elIkkm<s;kmøaMgBlkmµ KWCakarlM)akmYy

EdlkargarenH GacbNþalmkBIKuNPaBTabénkmµviFIbNþúHbNþal nigPaBTn;exSayénmUldæan

bMNinsRmab;karbNþúHbNþalbEnßm karGegátelIRkúmh‘unnaMmuxeKcMnYn 24 rbs; HRINC ¬qñaM 2010¦ )anbgðajfa nieyaCk 63° yl;eXIjfa karEsVgrkbMNinsmRsbtamtRmÚvkar

TIpSarmankarlM)akCagmun. eTaHbICaKµankarraraMgRbtibtþikarkargarnaeBlbc©úb,nñrbs;

Rkúmh‘unk¾eday k¾karxVHxatbMNinbec©keTsbgáPaBsµúRKsµajdl;kareRbIR)as;bec©kviTüafµI nig

bec©kviTüaplitkmµ. ]TahrN_ rdæaPi)al)anTTYlsÁal;bBaðaTaMgenHkñúgevTikaesdækic©km<úCa

qñaM2011 nigr)aykarN_fµI²mYy EdlecjpSayedayviTüasßanCatisßiti ¬qñaM2010¦.

karGegátrbs;nieyaCkmYycMnYnbgðajfa RbeTskm<úCakMBugRbQmnwgkarxVHxatbMNinRKb;RKg.

tamry³B½t’man)anbgðajfa bMNinEdlxVHxatbMput nigbMNinEdlnieyaCkyl;eXIjfaCa

]bsKÁcm,genaH KWbMNinRKb;RKgCan;x<s;. kñúgkarGegátqñaM2011 rbs; HRINC nieyaCkelIsBI

8 FnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2010 x nig HRINC qñaM2011. karGegátedayRbúgRby½tñsþIBInieyaCk nignieyaCit caM)ac;RtÚvpþl;

PsþútagEdlGacTukcitþ)anTak;TgnwgvisalPaB nigRbePTCak;lak;énkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNin.

9 naeBlfµI²enH mCÄmNÐlGPivDÆn_bMNinkm<úCa )ankMNt;BIGaTiPaBelIkarbNþúHbNþalrbs;nieyaCky:agl¥itl¥n;faCaEpñkén

karsikSamYyEdlRtÚvrkSakarsm¶at; edayelIkeLIgBIcMNucsMxan;²énbMNinTMnak;TMngrvagbuKÁlbMNinFnFanmnusS nigTMnak;TMng

viC¢aCIv³ bMNinEpñklk; nigTIpSar bMNinFurkic© nigKitelx nigbMNinRKb;RKghirBaØvtßú.

bMNinCIvitxagGakb,kiriiyamYycMnYneTot

dUcCa kareKarBeBlevla nigkareFVIkargar

CaRkum Gaceron)anenAeBlbMeBjkargar.

pÞúyeTAvij PaBCam©as;karelIxøÜnÉg KW

caM)ac;RtÚvEtmantaMgBIkumarPaBmkem:øH.

bMNin énkarKitGaceron)ankñúgsßab½n

Gb;rM dUcCa salaeron nigmCÄmNÐl

bNþúHbNþal.

GkSrsa®sþnaeBlbc©úb,nñenH kMNt;BI

sar³sMxan;énbMNinCIvit TaMgkñúgdMeNIrkar

énkarGPivDÆmUlFn mnusS nigCaktþa

kMNt;lT§plénkarsikSanigkargar.

CaTUeTA bMNin {CIvit} bMeBjbEnßmelI

CMnaj {bec©keTs} EdlCasmtßPaBEpñk

bec©keTsTak;Tgnwgkargar nigskmµPaB.

]TahrN_ CMnajbec©keTs rYmman dMeNIrkar

eRKÓgma:sIun nigGkçrkmµkMuBüÚT½r. CMnaj

TaMgenHmanPaBgayRsYlkñúgkarGegát

nigkMNt;brimaN nigGacbeRgón)anenA

tamsalaeron b¤kEnøgeFVIkar.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 24: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

14

70° )anraykarN_BIkarxVHxatCacm,gnUvbMNinRKb;RKgkñúgenaHnieyaCk 36° raykarN_BI

karxVHxatbMNinRKb;RKgfñak;kNþal nigbMNinEpñkGPi)alkic© ehIynieyaCk 34° raykarN_

BIkarxVHxatbMNinbuKÁlikCMnaj. nieyaCkcMnYn 64° KitfakarxVHxatbMNinRKb;RKg KWCa]bsKÁ

cm,g nieyaCkcMnYn 48° Kitfa karxVHxatbMNinRKb;RKgfñak;kNþalCa]bsKÁcm,geday

ELknieyaCkcMnYn 50° Kitfa karxVHxatbMNinEpñkGPi)alkic© nigbMNinbuKÁlikCMnajeTIbCa

]bsKÁcm,g. kñúgsßab½nrdæ)al nigvis½yrdæ)alsaFarN³k¾RbEhlCaxVHxatbMNinRKb;RKg

pgEdr CaBiess kñúgdMeNIrkarGnuvtþRbB½n§vimCÄkar nigvishmCÄkarEdlTamTar[manbMNin

TUlMTUlaysRmab;viPaK nigGnuvtþeKalneya)aykñúgvis½ysaFarN³.

bnÞab;mk nieyaCkelIkeLIgBIIkarekIneLIgtRmÚvkarrbs;nieyaCit EdlminmankareqøIytb

enAeLIy rYmman bMNinCIvit nigbMNinbec©keTs. ¬sRmab;esckþIlm¥itBIbMNinCIvit sUmemIl

RbGb;TI1.¦ kñúgRbB½n§Gb;rMcab;BIfñak;Tabdl;fñak;x<s; minmankarpþl;bMNinCIvit nigbMNinbec©k

eTs[)anRKb;RKan;eT rYmTaMgkñúgkarbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³pgEdr. CaBiess nieyaCkkMNt;fa

bMNinCIvit KWCabMNinsMxan;bMputEdlnieyaCitPaKeRcInmankarxVHxat. kñúgkarGegátrbs;

CAMFEBA qñaM2008 nieyaCkcMnYn 76° )anyl;eXIjfa nieyaCitEdl)anbBa©b;karsikSa

min)anTTYlkarbNþúHbNþalRKb;bMNinenaHeT CaBiess bMNinCIviteRkABIsmtßPaBbec©keTs

Edlmansar³sMxan;kñúgkarGnuvtþkargar. kñúgcMeNambMNinCIvit EdlmanPaBlM)akkñúgkarEsVg

rknieyaCk)ankMNt;BIbMNinCIvitmYycMnYn EdlkñúgenaH mannieyaCk 52° )ankMNt;BI\riyabf

kargarrbs;nieyaCitminmanCMnajnieyaCk 45° )anelIkeLIgBIbMNinkñúgkarseRmccitþrbs;

nieyaCitmanCMnajminc,as;las; nignieyaCk 64° )anelIkeLIgBIbMNinviPaKrbs;nieyaCit

CMnaj. nieyaCkCaeRcIn k¾)ant¥ÚjEt¥rBIPaBxVHxatbMNinkñúgPaBCaGñkdwknaM ¬sRmab;buKÁlikCa

GñkRKb;RKg¦ bMNinedaHRsaybBaða nigbMNinkñúgkarR)aRs½yTak;Tg. eRkABIenH yuvCneRkA

salaRbQmnwgPaBxVHxatd¾F¶n;F¶rénbMNinCIvit ehIymannieyaCkcMnYn 89° )anbgðajBIPaB

lM)akkñúgkareFIVkarCamYyyuvCneRkAsalaedaysarBYkeKmanGakb,kiriyaminsmrmü.

bnÞab;mk nieyaCkelIkeLIgBIPaBlM)akkñúgkarEsVgrknieyaCitEdlmanbMNinviC¢aCIv³ nigkargar

Cak;lak;. dUc)anelIkeLIgkñúgr)aykarN_rbs;FnaKarBiPBelak ¬qñaM2010 x¦ bMNinBak;B½n§

nwgPasabreTs B½t’manviTüa kat;edr CagtRbB½n§Twk CageQI nigCagEdk KWsuT§EtCabMNin

EdlmantRmÚvkarx<s; b:uEnþbMNinTaMgenHmanPaBlM)akkñúgkarEsVgrk. kñúgvis½ybdisNæarkic©

nieyaCkelIkeLIgBIPaBlM)akkñúgkarEsVgrkemcugePA GñkTTYlePJóv nigGñkRKb;RKgEpñkGahar

nigePsC¢³. kñúgvis½ykat;edr muxtMENgEpñklk; nigkat;edr KWCabMNinEdlmanPaBlM)ak

kñúgkarEsVgrk. cMENkkñúgvis½ysMNg;vij mankarlM)akkñúgkareRCIserIsnieyaCitCaCageQI

CagtRbB½n§Twk CagEdk nigCagGKÁisnI.

bEnßmBIenHeTot nieyaCkmankart¥ÚjEt¥rBIkarlM)akkñúgkarEsVgrknieyaCit EdlmanbMNinviC¢a

CIv³c,as;las; nigmanbMNinmUldæan dUcCa Gkçrkmµ nigkarKNnaelxnBVnþ. enHbgðaj[

eXIjBIGRtaGkçrkmµTab EdlmancMnYn 77/6° énRbCaCnkm<úCaGayu 15 qñaM nigelIsBIenH

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 25: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

15

¬GRtaGkçrkmµmancMnYn 87/5° kñúgcMeNamRbCaCnmanGayucab;BI 15-24 qñaM¦ EdleFIV[

RbsiT§PaBénkarbNþúHbNþalenAdMNak;kalbnÞab;mankarFøak;cuH.

edIm,IedaHRsayPaBxVHxatbMNinmYycMnYn nieyaCkCaeRcIn)ancUlrYmpþl;karbNþúHbNþalpøÚvkar.

CAMFEBA ¬qñaM2008¦ )anbgðajfa nieyaCkxitxMRbwgERbgpþl;karbNþúHbNþalbMNinsMxan;

dUcteTA ³ bMNinbec©keTs bMNinkñúgkarseRmccitþ nigedaHRsaybBaðabMNinkñúgkarR)aRs½y

Tak;TgkargarCaRkúm nigPaBCaGñkdwknaMbMNinEpñkTIpSar bMNinEpñklk; nigbMNinpþl;esva.

bMNinTaMgenHminmanbeRgónkñúgsalaeron nigmCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³eT. karGegáteFVI

eLIgsRmab;ÉksareKalneya)ayenH )anbgðaj[eXIjfa nieyaCk 55° pþl;karbNþúH

bNþaldl;nieyaCitrbs;xøÜn y:agehacNas;Bak;kNþalénnieyaCitTaMgGs; cMENknieyaCk

CaeRcIneTot pþl;karbNþúHbNþaldl;kmøaMgBlkmµrbs;xøÜnEtmYycMnYntUcb:ueNÑaH ¬karGegát

rbs; HRINC qñaM2011¦. edIm,Ipþl;karbNþúHbNþalEbbenH)an CaTUeTA nieyaCk 53°

eRbIR)as;kmµviFIkñúgRkúmh‘unrbs;xøÜn nieyaCk 43° eRbIR)as;sßab½nbNþúHbNþalkñúgRsuk

ehIymannieyaCk 27° eRbIR)as;sßab½nbNþúHbNþalbreTs CaBiess sRmab;fñak;RKb;RKg

Can;x<s;. nieyaCkmanbMNgpþl;karbNþúHbNþaldl;nieyaCitNaEdlmanbMNinmUldæan.

karxVHxatsßab½nbNþúHbNþall¥ bgáCa]bsKÁdl;karpþl;karbNþúHbNþalrbs;shRKas. tamry³

karGegátrbs; HRINC qñaM2011 nieyaCkcMnYn 64° )ankMNt;fa karxVHxatsßab½nbNþúH

bNþall¥ KWCa]bsKÁcm,gEtmYyKt;kñúgkarpþl;karbNþúHbNþal[)aneBjeljdl;nieyaCit.

]bsKÁcm,gdéTeTot rYmman éføbNþúHbNþalx<s; karminmaneBlevlaRKb;RKan; GRtapøas;bþÚr

buKÁlikx<s; nigkarxVHxatB½t’man sþIBI»kasTTYl)ankarbNþúHbNþal. ]bsKÁTaMgenHkøayCa

bBaðaF¶n;F¶rcMeBaHshRKasxñattUc nigmFüm ebIeRbóbeFobnwgshRKasxñatFM dUcmanbgðaj

kñúgkarGegátbriyakasvinieyaK. ninñakarEbbenHekItmankñúgRbeTsCaeRcInEdlepþatsMxan;elI

esdækic©eRkARbB½n§. edIm,IedaHRsayPaBxVHxatbMNinnieyaCk TamTar[mankarpþl; B½t’man

bEnßm rYmman B½t’mansþIBImCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalkargar KuNPaBénmCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþal

viC¢aCIv³ karmanbMNinCak;lak; nigKuNPaB saklviTüal½y RBmTaMgmanbMNgbegáItTMnak;TMng

CamYysaklviTüal½y ¬sUmemIlrUbPaBTI 3¦.

B½t’manbEnßmsþIBImCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalkargarB½t’manbEnßmsþIBIKuNPaBénmCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³Cak;lak;

B½t’manbEnßmsþIBItRmUvkarTIpSar nigkarpÁl;bMNinCak;lak;kñúgRbeTskm<úCaB½t’manbEnßmsþIBIKuNPaBmhaviTüal½yCak;lak;

karbegáItTMnak;TMngCamYymhaviTüal½yCak;lak;tamry³smaKmnieyaCkkarksagTMnak;TMngpÞal;CamYymhaviTüal½yCak;lak;

epSg²B½t’manbEnßmsþIBIkmµsikSa nigGaharUbkrN_

B½t’manbEnßmsþIBI»kasTTYlkarbNþúHbNþalenAeRkARbeTsdMbUnµansþIBIrebobkMNt;BItRmUvkarbMNinEdlmansar³sMxan;sRmab;Rkumh‘uneyIg

kareFIV[manPaBgayRsYlkñúgkareRCIserIsbuKÁlikBIRbeTsdéTeTot0% 20% 30% 40%10% 50% 60%

rUbPaBTI 3 ³ dMeNaHRsayrbs;nieyaCkEdl)anelIkeLIg edIm,IedaHRsayPaBxVHxatbMNin

RbPB ³ karGegátrbs; HRINC km<úCa ExmIna qñaM2011.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 26: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

16

2>2 etIPaBxVHxatkñúgkarpþl;bMNinsßitenARtg;Na?

Rkbx½NÐGPivDÆn_bMNinkñúgvdþþCIvit Edlcab;epþImBIkarGPivDÆkumartUcrhUtdl;eBlmankargar

CYybegáIt[mankarviPaKelIbBaða nigeKalneya)ayGPivDÆn_bMNin. Rkbx½NÐenHEbgEckvdþ

CIvitrbs;mnusSmñak;²CaeRcIndMNak;kalxus²Kña ³ edaycab;epþImBIdMNak;kalmUldæandMbUgén

karGPivDÆkumartUc nigkarGb;rMmUldæansRmab;CYy[buKÁlmñak;²TTYl)anbMNinkñúgkarbMeBj

kargar. bnÞab;mkCadMNak;kalmuneBlbMeBjkargar EdlCaeBlnieyaCitkMBugeronsURtBIbMNin

viC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTs edIm,IbMeBjkargardMbUgrbs;xøÜntamry³karhat;eroneFIVkar kareron

enAtamsalaeron nigmCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþal. cugeRkay CadMNak;kalksagsmtßPaB[

)anx<s;enAkEnøgeFVIkar nigdMNak;kaleronsURtbMNinfµI²EdlCaeBlnieyaCitkMBugbegáInsmtßPaB

bMNinrbs;xøÜn nigeronsURtbMNinfµI² edIm,IbMeBjkargarkñúgTIpSarkargarEdlmankarpøas;bþÚr.

kñúgdMNak;kalnImYy²rYmman Rbtibtþikr eKalneya)ay RbPBhirBaØb,Tan nigynþkarRtÜtBinitü

karbMeBjkargarxus²KñasRmab;karGPivDÆbMNin.

RbeTskm<úCaRbQmnwg]bsKÁcm,gkñúgkarpþl;bMNinenAdMNak;kaldMbUgénvdþCIvit Edlcab;epþIm

BIkarGPivDÆkumartUc. karbegáItmUldæan

k¦ bMNinsRmab;kumartUc ³ bBaðaRbQmnwgGaharUbtßmÖ nigkarelIkTwkcitþ

karyl;dwgCaGnþrCatiBIsar³sMxan;énkarGPivDÆkumartUc ¬ECD¦ kñúgkarbegáItmUldæansRmab;

kareronsURteBjmYyCIvitmankarekIneLIgCabnþbnÞab;. elak Jame Heckman CaebkçCn

C½ylaPIBanrgVan;NUEbl nigebkçCnC½ylaPIBanrgVan;NUEbldéTeTot )anbgðajfa karGPivDÆ

kumartUc KWCaTRmg;cMNayEdlmanRbsiT§PaBbMputkñúgkarvinieyaKmUlFnmnusS ebIeRbóbeFob

nwgkarvinieyaKeTAelIkarGb;rMkRmitbzmsikSa b¤karGb;rMkñúgkRmitbnþbnÞab;eTot. lT§plTaMgbI

énkarGPivDÆkumartUcmansar³sMxan;cMeBaHkarGPivDÆnaeBlGnaKtkñúgCIvit ³ ¬1¦ karGPivDÆ

ragkay nigsuxumalPaB ¬2¦ karGPivDÆbBaØasµartI ¬3¦ karGPivDÆsgÁm-citþsa®sþ.

eKalneya)ay nigkmµviFIGPivDÆn_kumartUc Gacman\T§iBlpÞal;eTAelIlT§pléndMNak;kal

GPivDÆn_TaMgenH nigpþl;GtßRbeyaCn_dl;kumar nigsgÁm.

PsþútagBIkarGegátbgðajfa kmµviFIGPivDÆn_kumartUcEdlmanRbsiT§PaBpþl;GtßRbeyaCn_CaeRcIn.

Psþútag)anbgðajfa GnþraKmn_tamry³karepþatkarykcitþTukdak;elIsuxPaB nigcMeNHdwg

mata GaharUbtßmÖkumar nigskmµPaBelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆbBaØasµartI nigsgÁmcitþsa®sþrbs;

kumartUc ¬dUcCa karEfTaMedayykcitþTukdak; nigkareRbIR)as;Pasal¥ nig»kasTTYl)ankar

EsVgyl;¦ pþl;plviC¢mandl;kareRtómxøÜncUleron niglT§plsikSakñúgCIvitrbs;kumareday

begáIt)ansgÁmmYyd¾rwgmaM k¾dUcCakarTTYl)anGtßRbeyaCn_pÞal;xøÜnBIkarvinieyaKEbbenH

¬karGegátrbs; Alderman qñaM2011 nig Barnett qñaM2008¦. pÞúymkvij PsþútagGnþrCati

bgðajfa BikarPaBenAv½yekµg KWmankarlM)ak nigRtÚvcMNayfvikaeRcInkñúgkarBüa)al.

10 ]TahrN_ sUmemIlkarelIkeLIgrbs; Heckman, Stixrud nig Urzua ¬qñaM2005¦. CaTUeTAkarGPivDÆkumartUccab;epþImBIeBl

EdlkumarmanGayucab;BIR)aMmYydl;R)aMbIqñaM.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 27: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

17

rUbPaBTI 4 ³ PaKrykumar¼yuvCnFøab;)ancUleron rs;enAkñúgRKÜsarman nigminmanGahar

RKb;RKan; qñaM2009

40

60

80

100

6 8 10 12

rs;enAkñúgRKYsarmanGaharRKb;RKan;rs;enAkñúgRKYÜsarminmanGaharRKb;RKan;

14 16 18 20 24

Age

RbPB ³ karKNnaEp¥kelITinñn½y)anmkBI CSES qñaM2009

kMNt;smÁal; ³ KMrUGegát epþatelIkarGegáttamdancMnYn 22>914 krNI sRmab;Gñkrs;enAkñúgRKÜsarmanGaharRKb;RKan;

nig 4>576 krNIsRmab;Gñkrs;enAkñúgRKÜsarminmanGaharRKb;RKan;

kgVHGaharenAkñúgRKÜsar eFVI[GRtasikSa nigbBa©b;karsikSamankRmitTab

karGegátRbCasa®sþ nigsuxPaBkm<úCa qñaM2010 bgðajfa PaKryénkumarRkin suxPaBexSay

nigxVHTm¶n;enAeBlmanGayu 59 ExdMbUg enAEtmankRmitx<s; EdlkñúgenaH kumarRkinmancMnYn

40° kumarexSaycMnYn 11° nigkumarxVHTm¶n;cMnYn 28° kñúgqñaM2010. PaKryTaMgenH

mankRmitdUcKñanwgkarGegátkñúgqñaM2005 b:uEnþsRmab;krNIkumarRkin EdlbNþalmkBIkarxVH

GaharUbtßmÖF¶n;F¶renaH KWmankRmitx<s;kñúgqñaM2010 ebIeRbóbeFob nwgqñaM2005. kñúgBiPBelak

karxVHGaharUbtßmÖ nigkarelIkTwkcitþmin)anRKb;RKan; bNþal[manPaBGn;fykñúgkarGPivDÆ

bBaØakare)aHbg;karsikSa bBaðaGakb,kiriya nigCalT§pl KWbraC½ykñúgCIvit.

karminmanGaharRKb;RKan;kñúgRKÜsar k¾CaktþarYmpSMEdleFVI[GRtasikSa nigGRtabBa©b;karsikSa

mankRmitTabpgEdr ¬rUbPaBTI 4¦. eyagtam karGegátesdækic©sgÁmkic©km<úCa ¬CSES¦

kñúgcMeNamkumarcMnYnR)aMnak; mankumarmñak;rs;enAkñúgRKÜsarminmanGaharRKb;RKan;. kumarTaMgenH

man»kastictYckñúgkarsikSa nigbBa©b;karsikSa. kñúgcMeNamkumarmanGayucab;BI 6-17 qñaM

kumarcMnYn 20° Edlrs;enAkñúgRKÜsarminmanGaharRKb;RKan; min)ancUleron ebIeRbóbeFob

eTAnwgRKÜsarmanGaharRKb;RKan;manEtkumarcMnYn 8° b:ueNÑaH ehIyPaKryenHmanlkçN³

RsedogKñaeTAnwgPaKryyuvCnGayucab;BI 18-22 qñaM EdlkñúgenaH yuvCn 21° mkBIRKÜsar

minmanGaharRKb;RKan; ehIy 8° mkBIRKÜsarmanGahar RKb;RKan;. kñúgcMeNamkumarGayucab;

BI 15-17 qñaM Edl)ancUleron manEtkumarrs;enAkñúgRKÜsarminmanGaharRKb;RKan;cMnYn 52°

b:ueNÑaH Edl)ancUleronnaeBlfµI²enH ebIeRbóbeFobeTAnwgkumarrs;enAkñúgRKÜsarmanGahar

RKb;RKan;cMnYn 61°. TMnak;TMngrvagGahar nigkarGb;rM k¾man\T§iBlenARKb;CMnan;pgEdr ³

kñúgcMeNamGñkpþl;bTsmÖasn_GayuelIsBI 15 qñaM Edlrs;enAkñúgRKÜsarminmanGaharRKb;RKan;

cMnYn 59° min TTYl)ankarGb;rM.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 28: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

18

karGb;rMkRmitmetþyüsikSa nigkmµviFIpSBVpSaytamshKmn_kMBugmankarekIneLIg b:uEnþenAman

kRmitenAeLIy. GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronenAkRmitmetþyüsikSakñúgRbeTskm<úCa )anekIneLIg

esÞIrEtBIrdgkñúgTsvtSr_cugeRkayenH edaymanGRtacuHeQµaHcUleronsrubenAkRmitmetþyü

sikSarhUtdl; 13°. karekIneLIgenH edaysarEtmankarcuHeQµaHcUleronTaMgenARKwHsßan

Gb;rMÉkCn nigsaFarN³EdlkñúgenaH GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronenARKwHsßanGb;rMÉkCnesµInwg

30° énkarpþl;esvaGb;rMkñúgqñaM2008¼2009 ebIeRbóbeFobeTAnwgqñaM2000¼2001 mancMnYn

20°. eTaHCay:agenHkþI GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronmetþyüsikSaenAEtmankRmitTab ebIeRbóbeFob

eTAnwgGnþrCati. GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronsrubenAkRmitmetþyüsikSaekIneLIgelIsBI 45° enA

TUTaMgBiPBelak nigRbEhl 44° kñúgRbeTscin nig\NÐÚensIu nig 88° kñúgRbeTséf.

edayELkkmµviFIGPivDÆn_ kumartUc rYmTaMgkmµviFIpSBVpSaytamshKmn_ edIm,IelIkkm<s;kar

pþl;GaharUbtßmÖ nigkarGnuvtþkarEfTaMkumarkMBugEtsakl,gGnuvtþ nigvaytémø.

x¦ karGb;rMkRmitbzmsikSa³ GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronekIneLIg b:uEnþGRtabBa©b;karsikSa nigkarsikSaFøak;cuH

eKalneya)ayrbs;rdæaPi)alkñúgkarseRmc)ankarpþl;karGb;rMmUldæanCaskl)anTTYleCaKC½y

kñúgkarbegáInGRtacuHeQµaHcUleronBitCaBiessenAkRmitbzmsikSa. GRtacuHeQµaHcUleron

BitenAkRmitbzmsikSa ekIneLIgcab;BIeRkam 83° kñúgqñaM2000¼2001 rhUtCitdl; 95°

kñúgqñaM2009¼2010. eyagtamTinñn½yrbs;RbB½n§RKb;RKgB½t’manGb;rMGRtacuHeQµaHcUleron

ekIneLIgTaMgkñúgtMbn;RbCMuCn tMbn;CnbT nigtMbn;dac;Rsyal. karekIneLIgenH edaysarman

karcuHeQµaHcUlerony:ageRcInkñúgRKwHsßanGb;rMsaFarN³EdlmansisSbzmsikSarhUtdl; 99°.

eTaHbIy:agNa GRtasisSmin)anbBa©b;karGb;rMkRmitbzmsikSaenAEtCabBaðaRbQm. eyagtam

karGegátesdækic©sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009 kumarmñak;kñúgcMeNamkumardb;nak;Gayucab;BI

6-17 qñaM minEdl)ancUleron. kñúgcMeNamsisSGayucab;BI 15-19 qñaM mansisScMnYnEt

71°bu:eNÑaH )anbBa©b;karGb;rMkRmitbzmsikSa ¬sRmab;sisS)anbBa©b;karGb;rMkRmitbzm

sikSaGayucab;BI 20-24 qñaM mancMnYn 69°¦. kñúgcMeNamsisSminEmnCnCatiExµr nigcam

sisSGayucab;BI 15-19 qñaM cMnYnticCag 22° nigsisSGayucab;BI 20-24 qñaM cMnYn 19°

)anbBa©b;karGb;rMkRmitbzmsikSa. GVIEdlCaRbPBénkþIRBÜy)armÖenaH KWnaeBlfµI²enH GRta

cuHeQµaHcUleronrYmenAkRmitbzmsikSa)anekIneLIg RsbeBlEdlGRtabBa©b;karsikSaFøak;cuH.

Tinñn½yrbs;RbB½n§RKb;RKgB½t’manGb;rMbgðajfa GRtabBa©b;karsikSaenAkRmitbzmsikSa

ekIneLIgx<s;bMputRtwm 90° kñúgqñaM2005¼2006 nigFøak;cuHRtwm 83° kñúgqñaM2009¼2010.

elIsBIenH sisSe)aHbg;karsikSaenAkRmitbzmsikSamankRmitx<s;EdlkñúgenaH GRtaRtÜtfñak;

man 11° nigGRtae)aHbg;karsikSaman 49°. dUecñH GVIEdlCabBaðaRbQmnaeBlGnaKt

minRtwmEtCabBaðakñúgkarelIkkm<s;GRtabBa©b;karsikSasRmab;sisSEdlkMBugsikSa b:ueNÑaHeT

EtEfmTaMgCabBaðakñúgkarbMeBjtRmÚvkarbMNinbEnßmrbs;yuvCnEdlmin )anbBa©b;karGb;rMkRmit

bzmsikSa.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 29: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

19

taragTI 2 ³ PaKrykumarenAeRkAsala nigmUlehtuénkarmincUleron qñaM2009

metþyüsikSa¬3-5qñaM¦

bzmsikSa¬6-11qñaM¦

mFümsikSabzmPUmi

¬12-14qñaM¦

mFümsikSa TutiyPUmi

¬15-17qñaM¦

srub¬6-17qñaM¦

PaKrysisSminEdl)ancUleron 84/3 14/7 4/8 6/2 9/9

PaKrysisSEdl)ancUleron b:uEnþminEmneBlfµI²enH

1/1 1/4 10/9 40/3 14/7

mUlehtuEdlsisSmincUleron b¤minEdl)ancUleron

minmancMNab;GarmµN_kñúgkarsikSa 2/0 16/8 18/3 12/4 14/8

karsikSaminl¥ 2/1 4/1 16/1 17/2 12/7

minmansalaeronsmrmü¼ salaeronsßitenAq¶ayBIpÞH

0/9 6/7 4/7 3/0 4/5

minmanRKÚbeRgón¼smÖar³sikSa 0/4 2/4 2/0 0/9 1/6

cMNayx<s;kñúgkarsikSa >> >> 0/2 0/2 0/1

RtÚvcUlrYmcMENkkñúgkarrkR)ak;cMNUl pÁt;pÁg;RKÜsar

0/1 0/7 14/3 27/9 16/6

RtÚvCYyeFVIkargarpÞH 0/1 1/9 14/3 15/9 11/0

RkIRkxøaMg 1/0 10/5 23/5 17/6 16/2

enAekµgeBk 93/1 53/5 2/2 0/8 18/6

cMnYnkarGegáttamdan 2>839 1>186 595 1>793 3>574

RbPB ³ karKNnaEp¥ktamTinñn½y)anmkBIkarGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009.

11 sRmab;Tinñn½yrbs;RbeTsCaeRcIneTot sUmemIlsUcnakrGPivDÆn_BiPBelak ¬qñaM2010¦.

12 GayucUleronpøÚvkarrbs;RbeTskm<úCaenAkRmitbzmsikSa KWRsbeTAtamkarGnuvtþrbs;GnþrCati

13 EMIS qñaM2009

mUlehtusRmab;karmincUleron nigkare)aHbg;ecalkarsikSa KWmanTMnak;TMngcm,geTAnwg

sßanPaBRKÜsar. kñúgcMeNamkumarGayucab;BI 6-11qñaM EdlmincUleron KWedaysarEt

bBaðacm,g ³ k¦ minmansalaeron RKÚbeRgón nigsmÖar³RKb;RKan; ¬9°¦ x¦ PaBRkIRk kareFIV

kargarpÞH nigkarrkR)ak;cMNUl ¬13°¦ K¦ RBmTaMgkarKitfa kumarenAv½yekµgenAeLIy

eTaHbICaRKb;GayupøÚvkarcUleronk¾eday ¬54°¦ b¤mincg;cUleron ¬17°¦. mUlehtuénkarmin

cUleron b¤KitfaGayuekµgeBk minGaccUleronenaH qøúHbBa©aMgBIbBaðacMeBaHkumartUcrYmTaMgkar

GPivDÆyWty:av nigexSaybBaØa edaysarEtkarxVHxatGaharUbtßmÖ b¤kat;bnßyskmµPaBxYrk,al

edaysarxVHkarbNþúHbNþalsµartIRKb;RKan;enAdMNak;kaldMbUgénCivit. taragTI 2 BiBN’na

BIesckþIlm¥it Edl)anmkBIkarGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 30: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

20

CacugeRkay kþI)armÖenAEtmancMeBaHlT§plénkarsikSa. elIsBIenH viBaØasaRbLgvaytémø

sisSfñak;CatielImuxviC¢aPasaExµr nigKNitviTüafñak;TI 3 TI 6 nigTI 9 bgðajfa lT§plsikSa

mUldæanrbs;sisSenAmankRmitTabenAeLIy eTaHbImankarelIkkm<s;k¾eday. müa:geTot

ktþaRKÚbeRgón nigsmtßPaBRKÚbeRgónenAEtCa]bsKÁ. kñúgkarGb;rMkRmitbzmsikSa pleFob

sisSnigRKÚ manGRtaelIsrhUtdl; 49° EdlenHCaGRtax<s; ebIeyagtamsþg;daGnþrCati

nigelIkRmitmFümkñúgcMeNamRbeTsmancMNUlTabkñúgtMbn; ¬rUbPaBTI 4¦. kñúgTsvtSr_

knøgmk PaKry RKÚbeRgónEdlmankarGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSaTutiyPUmi b¤]tþmsikSa )anekIn

eLIgcab;BI 29° dl; 50°. eTaHbIy:agNa RKÚbeRgóncMnYn 46° TTYl)ankarGb;rMRtwmkRmit

mFümsikSabzmPUmi nig 4° TTYl)ankarGb;rMRtwmkRmitbzmsikSa EdlenHbgðaj[eXIjBI

karxVHxatsmtßPaBRKb;RKan;kñúgkarbeRgón ¬RbB½n§RKb;RKgB½t’manGb;rM¦.

K¦ karGPivDÆbMNinsMxan;²kñúgkarGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSa nigkarGb;rMbNþúHbNþal viC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTs (TVET)³ GRtasikSa nigkaryl;dwgBIGtßRbeyaCn_énkarsikSaenAmankRmitTab

tamry³kareRbóbeFobeTAnwgkarGb;rMkRmitbzmsikSa karcuHeQµaHcUleronenAkRmitmFümsikSa

ekIneLIgyWtcab;BIqñaM2007 nigenAEtmankRmitTabkñúgeBlbc©úb,nñ. eyagtamTinñn½yrbs;

RbB½n§RKb;RKgB½t’manGb;rM GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronBitenAkRmitFmümsikSabzmPUmimanGRta

RbEhl 32° kñúgqñaM2009¼2010 edaymanGRtacuHeQµaHcUleronxusKñarvagtMbn;RbCMuCn

¬48°¦ nigtMbn;CnbT ¬29°¦ nigtMbn;dac;Rsyal ¬11°¦. GRtaenHmankRmitTab ebI

eRbóbeFobeTAnwgGRtacuHeQµaHcUleronCaGnþrCati ¬rUbPaBTI 5¦. tamkar)a:n;sµanGRtacuH

eQµaHcUleronBitenAkRmitmFümsikSaTutiyPUmimanGRtaRbEhl 12°. kñúgcMeNamsisSGayu

cab;BI 20-24qñaM sisSticCag 6° cUlrYmkarGb;rMbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTseRkABI

enHmansisScMnYnEtmYyPaKbIb:ueNÑaH cUlrYmkñúgkarGb;rMbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTs

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSa ¬karGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009¦.

rUbPaBTI 5 ³ pleFobsisS nigRKÚenAkRmitbzmsikSa nigmFümsikSakñúgtMbn;GasIubUBa’

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%pleFobsisS nigRKÚ enAkRmitbzmsikSa

pleFobsisS nigRKÚ enAkRmitmFümsikSa

50%

Brunei DarussalamMalaysia

High income

Thailand

Macao SAR, China

IndonesiaChina

East Asia & Paci�cJapan

SingaporeVietnam

Korea, Rep.

Myanmar

Timoe-LesteLao PDR

Philippines

Low income

CAMBODIA

RbPB ³ EdStats ¬Tinñn½ycugeRkaybMput kñúgqñaM2005-2009¦.

kMNt;smÁal; ³ GasIubUBa’ nig)a:sIuhVik sMedAelIRbeTskMBugGPivDÆn_b:ueNÑaH.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 31: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

21

GRtabBa©b;karsikSaTab nigCeRmIstictYckñúg

karGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSaenAEtCabBaðaRbQm

cm,g. GRtabBa©b;karsikSaenAkRmitmFüm

sikSabzmPUmimanGRtaRbEhl 49° kñúg

qñaM2007-2010. kñúgqñaM 2009 kumarGayu

cab;BI 15-19qñaM cMnYnEt 29° nigyuvCn

Gayucab;BI 20-24 qñaM cMnYn 36° b:ueNÑaH

)anbBa©b;karsikSary³eBl 9 qñaM b¤eRcInCag

enH yuvCnGayucab;BI 20-24 qñaM cMnYnEt

17° )anbBa©b;karsikSary³eBl12 qñaM b¤

eRcInCagenH nigcMnYnticCag 2° )anTTYl

viBaØabnbRtGb;rMbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ nig

bec©keTs ¬karGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic© km<úCa

qñaM2009¦. pÞúyeTAvij bc©úb,nñ RkumGayuEdlmansiT§iTTYl)ankarGb;rMcMnYn 99° kñúgRbeTs

cinTTYl)ankarGb;rMmUldæanEdlmanry³eBl 9 qñaM. GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronkñúgkarGb;rMbNþúH

bNþalviC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTsenAkRmitmFümsikSakñúgRbeTskm<úCa manGRtaTabbMputkñúgtMbn;

GasIuEdlbgðaj[eXIjfa karGb;rMbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTs minEmnCaCeRmIssmRsb

b¤CaCeRmIsEdlTak;TajcMNab;GarmµN_sisSenaHeT. GRtaTabénkarbBa©b;karsikSaenAkRmit

mFümsikSa nigCaBiessGRtabBa©b;karsikSakñúgkarGb;rMbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTs

enAEtCa]bsKÁkñúgbegáInnieyaCitCMnajkñúgRbeTskm<úCa. Tak;TinnwgbBaðaenH bTBiesaFn_Ca

GnþrCatielIkeLIgfa karpþl;[mankarGb;rM bNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTs EdlCaCeRmIs

sRmab;sisSmFümsikSaGacCYybegáInGRtaKg;vgS nigGRtabBa©b;karsikSa nignaM[mankar

RbkYtRbECgesdækic©.

mUlehtusRmab;karmincUleron nigkare)aHbg;ecalkarsikSa KWbBaðaEpñkhirBaØvtßú. dUcman

bgðajkñúgtaragTI 2 sisScMnYn 52° EdlmincUleronmFümsikSabzmPUmi KWedaysar

PaBRkIRkPaBcaM)ac;kñúgkarrkR)ak;cMNUl nigkarCYyeFVIkargarpÞHEdlCamUlehtucm,g. tam

r)aykarN_bgðajfa sisScMnYnBIrPaKbIEdlsßitkñúgRkumGayuxagelI min)ancUleronmFüm

sikSaTutiyPUmi edaysarEtmUlehtuTaMgenH ¬karGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009¦.

RksYgGb;rM yuvCn nigkILa ¬G>v>y>k¦ )aneRtómrYcCaeRsckñúgkaredaHRsaybBaðahirBaØvtßúenH

tamry³karpþl;kmµviFIGaharUbkrN_ nigpþl;CMnYyhirBaØvtßúdl;RKÜsarsRmab;[kUnbnþkarsikSa.

enATUTaMgBiPBelak kmµviFIEbbenHanCYyCMruj[sisSRtLb;cUleronvij edayeKeXIjmankar

ekIneLIgénGRtacuHeQµaHcUleron ¬Filmer nig Schady qñaM2009¦. müa:geTot eTaHbICa

mantRmÚvkarKMnitpþÜcepþImbnÞan;k¾eday k¾karcMNayticsRmab;vis½yGb;rMenAEtCabBaðaraMgsÞHdl;

KMnitpþÜcepþImenHdEdl EdlmanGRta 1/6° énplitplkñúgRsúksrubkñúgqñaM2007 ebIeRbób

14 ]TahrN_ sUmemIl Bishop nig Mane ¬qñaM2005¦ nig OECD ¬qñaM2010¦

rUbPaBTI 6 ³ GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronBitenAkRmit

bzmsikSa nigmFümsikSakñúgtMbn;GasIubUBa’

0102030405060708090

100

70 80

Lao PDR

Thailand

Korea, Rep.

Malaysia

Cambodia

90 100

GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronBitenAkRmitbzmsikSaGR

tacuHeQ

µaHcUle

ronBit

enAkRm

itmFüm

sikSa

RbPB ³ EdStats ¬Tinñn½ycugeRkaybMputkñúgqñaM 2005-2009¦.

kMNt;smÁal; ³ tYelxrbs; EdStats sRmab;RbeTskm<úCaxusKñaBI

tYelxrbs;RbB½n§RKb;RKgB½t’manGb;rM

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 32: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

22

15 lT§plGegát)anmkBI CSES qñaM 2009 nig HRINC qñaM 2011

16 sRmab;B½t’manlm¥it sUmGan CAMFEBA ¬qñaM 2008¦

rUbPaBTI 7 ³ R)ak;QñÜlRbcaMExtamkRmiténkarGb;rM nigRkumviC¢aCIv³ qñaM 2009 ¬KitCaerol¦

0%

minmankarGb;rM karGb;rMkRmit

bzmsikSa

karGb;rMkRmit

FmümsikSabzmPUmi

karGb;rMkRmitFmümsikSa

TutiyPUmi

Gb;rMbNþúHbNþal

bec©keTsnigviC¢aCIv³

kRmitmFüm

TVETpost-sec.

Gb;rMbNþúHbNþal

bec©keTsnigviC¢aCIv³

kRmiteRkaymFüm

3,000,000

2,500,000

2,000,000

1,500,000

1,000,000

500,000

kgkmøaMgRbdab;GavuFGñkRKb;RKgGñkCMnajviC¢aCIv³Gñkbec©keTsCMnYykarGñkpþl;esva nigGñklk;ksikrsib,krGñkdMeNIrkar nigdMeT,Igm:asuInviC¢aCIv³mUldæansrub

RbPB ³ karKNnaEp¥kelIkarGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM 2009

eFobnwg RbeTsCitxag dUcCa RbeTsbg;køaeds ¬2/4°¦ \NÐa ¬3/2°¦ \NÐÚensIu ¬3/5°¦

saFarNrdæ RbCaFibetyüRbCamanitLav ¬2/3°¦ m:aeLsIu ¬4/5°¦ evotNam ¬5/3°¦

nigRbeTséf ¬4/9°¦ ¬sUcnakrGPivDÆn_BiPBelak qñaM2010¦. RsedogKñaenHEdrlT§PaBrbs;

RksYgkargar nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³kñúgkarsRmbsRmÜldl;karbegáInkarGb;rMbNþúHbNþal

viC¢aCIv³ nigbec©keTspøÚvkarenAmankRmit.

TsSn³RKÜsarEdlKitfa kar[kUn²bnþkarsikSanwgeFVI[)at;bg;hirBaØvtßúPøam²enaHekIteLIg

edaykarmin[témøelIkarsikSa. B½t’manGMBIcMNUlhirBaØvtßúEdlkUnGacrk)an RbsinebIkUn

GacbnþkarsikSadl;kRmitmFümsikSa nigkarGb;rM nigkarbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³.

bBaðaenH GacraraMgRKÜsarmYycMnYnBIkar[témøx<s;elIkarGb;rMsRmab;karrkR)ak;cMNUlnaeBl

GnaKtEdlbBaðaenHEtgEtekItmankñúgRbeTskMBugGPivDÆn_. karvaytémøCak;EsþgelItémøén

karGb;rMkñúgRbeTskm<úCa kMBugbgðajBIplcMeNjEpñkesdækic©d¾l¥sRmab;GñkEdlbnþkarsikSa.

buBVlaPR)ak;cMNUlRbEhl 38° sRmab;sisSmankarGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSabzmPUmieFob

nwgbzmsikSa ehIyRbEhl 24° sRmab;sisSmankarGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSaTutiyPUmi

eFobnwgmFümsikSabzmPUmi ¬karGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009¦. cMNUlhirBaØvtßú

sRmab;sisSmankarGb;rMkRmitmFümsikSaTaMgGs; mankRmitRbhak;RbEhlnwgRbeTshVIlIBIn

b:uEnþmankRmitTabCagRbeTs\NÐÚensIu b¤RbeTséf ¬FnaKarBiPBelak 2010 x¦.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 33: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

23

17 sRmab;]TahrN_ nigkarviPaKnana sUmGankMNt;RtakargaryuvCnrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak

tamry³eKhTMB½r http://www.youth-employment-inventory.org/

kar)a:n;sµanxusPaKeRcIn KWTak;TgnwgR)ak;cMNUlsRmab;sisSEdlbnþkarGb;rM bNþúHbNþal

bec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³. cMNUlhirBaØvtßúnwgekIn 60° sRmab;sisSbnþkarGb;rM bNþúHbNþal

bec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³enAkRmitmFümsikSaeRbóbeFobeTAnwgkarGb;rMbzmsikSa nigcMNUlekIn

112° sRmab;sisSbnþkarGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalbec©keTseRkaybBa©b;kRmitmFümsikSa

eRbóbeFobeTAnwgkarGb;rMmFümsikSabzmPUmi.

Cak;Esþg karGegáttamRKÜsar nigkarGegátR)ak;ebovtSr_ nigplRbeyaCn_énvis½yÉkCn

naeBlfµI²enH RBmTaMgrUbPaBTI 6 bgðaj[eXIjfaR)ak;cMNUlsRmab;sisSEdlbnþkarGb;rM

bNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karGb;rMmFümsikSaesÞIrEtesµInwgR)ak;cMNUl

rbs;sisSEdlbnþkarsikSadl;fñak;]tþmsikSa ¬ehIyTTYl)anR)ak;cMNUleRcInCagenHbIdg

kñúgcMeNamGñkbec©keTs nigkargarEdlpSarP¢ab;nwgbuKÁlikCMnaj¦. sisSEdlmancMNab;

GarmµN_cuHeQµaHcUleronvKÁGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³manRtwmEt 17° b:ueNÑaH eFobnwg

sisS 30° EdlmancMNab;GarmµN_kñúgkarEsVgrkkargar ehIyeFobnwgsisS 50° eTot

Edlcg;bnþkarsikSaenAsaklviTüal½y bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karGb;rMenAviTüal½y. PaBxusKñaEbbenH

)anbgðajBIB½t’mansþIBITIpSarkargar nigkarbraC½yénkarsRmbsRmÜl ehIyRbEhlCakar

yl;xusénsgÁm EdlminKaMRTnwgkarGb;rM bNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ k¾fa)an.

vtþmansikSaTabenAkRmitmFümsikSaGMBavnav[mankmµviFIsRmab;»kaselIkTI 2 nigkarbNþúH

bNþaleRkARbB½n§. bTBiesaFn_CaGnþrCati)anelIk eLIgfa kmµviFI»kasCaelIkTIBIr CaBiess

kmµviFIEdlepþatsMxan;elIkarKaMRTCMnajshRKin nigkarrYmbBa©ÚlkarbNþúHbNþalkñúgfñak;eron

nigkEnøgeFVIkareFVI[mankarcMNaytic ehIymanplviC¢mancMeBaHTIpSarkargareTotpg. kñúg

RbeTskm<úCa karekIneLIgy:ageRcInnUvsßab½npþl;karbNþúHbNþalcRmúH )anpþl;karbNþúHbNþal

eRkARbB½n§ edIm,I[yuvCnEdle)aHbg;karsikSaeRtómxøÜnsRmab;eFVIkargarCaelIkdMbUg b¤begáIn

smtßPaB nigpþl;karbNþúHbNþalsaCafµIsRmab;buKÁlikv½ycMNas;. eTaHCay:agenHkþI vtþman

GñkcUlrYmkarbNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§enAmankRmitenAeLIy. kñúgcMeNamGñkEdlmanGayucab;BI

15-59 qñaM manEt 6° b:ueNÑaH EdlraykarN_fa Føab;)ancUlrYmkñúgfñak;bNþúHbNþaleRkA

RbB½n§ ¬kñúgcMeNamGñkEdlmanGayucab;BI 15-19 qñaM man 13° ehIyBIGayu 20-24 qñaM

man 9°¦ ¬karGegátesdækic©sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009¦. sRmab;GñkEdlFøab;cUleronfñak;

Gb;rMeRkARbB½n§GñkeqøIytbcMnYn 82° )aneronPasabreTs 6° eronCMnajkMuBüÚT½r 6° eronBI

CMnajviC¢aCIv³ nigRbEhl 3° eronBIGkçrkmµmUldæan. kñúgcMeNamGñkEdlmanGayucab;BI

15-19 qñaM GñkFøab;)ancUleronfñak;bNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§cMnYn 90° )aneronPasabreTs

¬karGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009¦.

eTaHCay:agNa k¾karbNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§ RBmTaMgkarGb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³

enAmandMeNIrkaryWty:avenAeLIy. Cak;EsþgkarbNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§ nigkarGb;rMbNþúH-

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 34: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

24

bNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³mankarxVHxatfvika EfmTaMgminmanKuNPaBsmrmü nigminsm

RsbeTAnwgtRmÚvkarTIpSarkargarenaHeT ¬FnaKarBiPBelak qñaM 2010 x¦. PaBcRmúHén

kmµviFIbNþúHbNþalTamTar[manTIpSarkargarmYy EdlsaksmeTAnwgGñkEsVgrkkargareFVI nig

nieyaCitEdlmanCMnajsmRsbnwgtRmÚvkarTIpSarkargar. kmµviFIenHpþl;PaBsMxan;dl;B½t’man

sþIBITIpSarkargar nigKuNPaBénGñkEsVgrkkargareFVI. TnwÞmnwgenH kmµviFIbNþúHbNþalsaFarN³

mYycMnYnxVHxatviBaØabnbRtEdlTTYlsÁal;edaynieyaCk. bc©úb,nñenH Rkbx½NÐKuNvuDÆiCati

sRmab;kMNt;sþg;dasmtßPaBEdlbegáIteLIgeday MLVT nwgCYyKaMRTdl;RbB½n§viBaØabnbRt

EdlmanPaBcaM)ac;. elIsBIenH KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal ¬NTB¦ shkarCamYy

rdæaPi)al tMNagmkBIvis½y]sSahkmµ nigGgÁkarepSg² RtÚv)anbegáIteLIgsaCafµIkñúgqñaM2006

edIm,IBinitüemIlkarbegáIt nigkarGnuvtþeKalneya)aysþIBIkarGb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nig

viC¢aCIv³ RBmTaMgpþl;Rkbx½NÐGPi)alkic©mYysRmab;eFVIsuxdumnIykmµelIshKmn_pþl;karbNþúH

bNþalepSg². eTaHCay:agenHkþI dMeNIrkarkñúgkarbegáItsþg;da lkçN³sm,tþi nigkarGnuvtþ

karvaytémømanPaByWty:av.

karbeRgónbMNinCIvit. karbeRgónCMnajGnuvtþ nigbMNinCIvit tRmÚv[manrYcCaeRsckñúgkmµviFI

sikSa ¬ehIyCakarTamTarrbs;nieyaCkdUcEdl)anbgðajxagelI¦. eTaHCay:agenHkþI sala

eronmYycMnYnxVHRKÚbeRgónEdlRtÚv)anbNþúHbNþal edIm,IbeRgónbMNinGnuvtþ nigbMNinCIvit.

PaKryénRKÚbeRgónmFümsikSaGmCamYymFümsikSaTutiyPUmi b¤]tþmsikSa )anekIneLIgBI

40° dl; 71° kñúgTsvtSr_knøgeTA. RsbeBlmankarelIkkm<s;lkçN³sm,tþiRKÚbeRgónmYy

cMnYnenAEtxVHxatCMnajkñúgkarbeRgónbMNinCIvit. Cak;Esþg RKÚmYycMnYnGacRtÚvkarCMnajkñúg

kareRbIR)as;viFIsa®sþbeRgónepSg² ]TahrN_ karsikSaCaRkum kareFVIbTbgðajedaysresr

nigpÞal;mat; karsEmþgerOg niglMhat;edaHRsaybBaðaCaRkum edIm,IbegáItCMnajGnuvtþ nig

bMNinCIvitrYmpSMnwgkmµviFIsikSaEdlmanRsab;.

X¦ karbegáItbMNinsRmab;kRmit]tþm ³ minRsbtamtRmÚvkarkRmit]tþm karGb;rM]tþmsikSa

KWedIm,IbMeBjtRmÚvkarsRmab;]sSahkmµnaeBlbc©úb,nñ nig]sSahkmµfµI². karGb;rMenHGac[

nieyaCitbegáInCMnajrbs;xøÜn nigedIrTnÞwmnwgkarpøas;bþÚrbec©kviTüa. RKwHsßan]tþmsikSamYycMnYn

mansar³sMxan;sRmab;karRsavRCav nigkarGPivDÆRBmTaMgCYyepÞr nigEksRmÜlbec©kviTüanana

edIm,IbMeBjtRmÚvkar]sSahkmµkñúgRsúk. RKwHsßanTaMgenaH KWmansar³sMxan;sRmab;kareq<aHeT

Akan;sgÁmmYyEdlmanesdækic©eCOnelOn.

GRtacuHeQµaHcUleron]tþmsikSasrubkñúgRKwHsßansaFarN³ nigÉkCnkñúgRbeTskm<úCa)anekIn

eLIgy:agqab;rh½skñúgTsvtSr_knøgmk ebIeTaHCa cab;epþImBIkRmitTabbMputk¾eday. eBlfµI²

enHRkumGayucUleron]tþmsikSacMnYn 5° )ancuHeQµaHcUleronkRmit]tþmsikSakñúgenaHburs

cMnYn 7° nig®sþIcMnYn 4°. GRtacuHeQµaHcUleronTaMgenHmanRtwmEtmYyPaKbIb:ueNÑaH kñúgbNþa

RbeTskMBugGPivDÆn_epSg²kñúgtMbn; ¬rUbPaBTI 7¦ b:uEnþ GRtaenHsmRsbeTAnwgesdækic©

GtiBlkmµnaeBlbc©úb,nñ nigPaBxusKñaénR)ak;QñÜl.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 35: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

25

bBaðaRbQmF¶n;F¶rnwgkarsikSamuxviC¢a EdlminTak;TgnwgTIpSarkargar. sßab½n]tþmsikSarbs;

RbeTskm<úCapþl;CMnajdl;sisSbBa©b;karsikSarYmman CMnajKNenyü hirBaØvtßú nigRKb;RKg

¬sisSfñak;briBaØabRtcMnYn 46° cuHeQµaHcUleronmuxviC¢aTaMgenHenAqñaMsikSa 2009¼10¦

eFobeTAnwgmuxviC¢avisVkmµsIuvil ¬mancMnYn 1/5° kñúgcMeNamnisSitEdl)ancuHeQµaHcUl

eronfñak;briBaØabRt¦ nigmuxviC¢aviTüasa®sþ nigbec©kviTüa ¬mancMnYn 0/1° kñúgcMeNamnisSit

cuHeQµaHcUleronfñak;briBaØabRt¦. elIsBIenH smamaRtnisSitCanarIkñúgmuxviC¢avisVkmµ viTüasa®sþ

nigbec©kviTüamankRmitTabbMput ¬sRmab;B½t’manlm¥it sUmemIltaragTI 4¦. eTaHbICavis½y

ksikmµ nigesdækic©CnbT eRkABIEpñkksikmµCavis½ysMxan;sRmab;elIkkm<s;k¾eday k¾man

sisSRtwmEt 2/3° b:ueNÑaH EdlsikSamuxviC¢aTak;TgnwgcMeNHdwgkñúgvis½yTaMgenH. PaKry

énnisSitbBa©b;karsikSakñúgmuxviC¢aTak;Tgnwgvis½yksikmµ Gb;rM ¬rYmman Kruekaslü¦ visVkmµ

plitkmµ nigsMNg;enAmankRmitTab ebIeRbóbeFobnwgbreTs ¬rUbPaBTI 8¦. PaBminsm

RsbrvagbMNinkRmit]tþm nigtRmÚvkarTIpSar kan;Etbgðaj[eXIjc,as; ¬FnaKarBiPBelak

qñaM2010 K¦.PaBKµankargareFVI nigkarxVHxatkargarsRmab;nisSitbBa©b;karsikSa KWCakþIkgVl;

mYyedaymannisSitbBa©b;karsikSacMnYn 10° RtÚv)anraykarN_fa sßitkñúgsßanPaBeFVIkargar

eday {minmanR)ak;kéRm} nignisSitbBa©b;karsikSaEdlmanGayu 29 qñaM nigekµgCagenHcMnYn

5° RtÚv)anraykarN_fa KµankargareFVI ¬karGegátesdækic© sgÁmkic©km<úCa qñaM2009¦.

cMnYnnisSittictYcEdlbBa©b;karsikSaEpñkvisVkmµ nigviTüasa®sþ RBmTaMgcMnYnnisSitPaKtic

EdlbBa©b;karGb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ edaymankarbNþúHbNþalbnÞab;BI

mFümsikSanwgraraMgsmtßPaBrbs;RbeTskm<úCa kñúgkarelIkkm<s;mUldæanvis½yksikmµ nig

]sSahkmµrbs;xøÜn. karsikSarbs;FnaKarBiPBelak ¬2010 x¦ )an)a:n;sµanfa Ep¥kelI

lMnaMénkarGPivDÆnaeBlbc©úb,nñ RbeTskm<úCanwgCYbRbTHPaBelIslubénnisSitbBa©b;karsikSa

fñak;]tþmEpñkBaNiC¢kmµ nigc,ab;RsbeBlEdlenAEtmankarxVHxatnisiStbBa©b;karsikSaEpñk

visVkmµ nigviTüasa®sþ. elIsBIenH PaBexSay\tQb;QrkñúgkarbNþúHbNþalRKÚbeRgón nig

karsikSamuxviC¢aEdlTak;Tgnwgvis½yEdlCatRmÚvkar enaHGaceFVI[raMgsÞHdl;kic©xitxMRbwgERbg

kñúgkarelIkkm<s;smtßPaBénRbB½n§Gb;rM nigbNþúHbNþal.

rUbPaBTI 8 ³ GRtacuHeQµaHcUlerondulkñúgkRmit]tþmsikSa EdlEbgEcktameynD½r

srub®sþIburs

km<úCa

Lav

\NÐÚensIu

cin

éf

100 20 30 40 50 60

RbPB ³ viTüasßansßitiGgÁkar UNESCO ¬qñaM 2009 b¤qñaMcugeRkaybg¥s;¦

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 36: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

26

bBaðaTak;TgnwgB½t’man nigkarsRmbsRmÜl )anBnül;BIGtulüPaBCarcnasm<½n§kñúgkarGb;rM]tþmsikSa.

karGegátelIyuvCnnaeBlfµI²enH )anbgðaj[eXIjfa nisSitmYycMnYnmin)anyl;c,as;BI

bMNinEdlCatRmÚvkarrbs;nieyaCkeT. ]TahrN_ mannisSitEt 7° b:ueNÑaH EdleCOfa

bBaðaRbQmFMbMputrbs;xøÜn KWsßab½npþl;karGb;rMmin)anbeRgónbMNinEdlRtwmRtÚv ¬xN³Edl

yuvCnEdlmankargareFVIcMnYn 16° eCOfa bBaðaenH KWCabBaðaRbQmd¾FMbMputrbs;BYkeK¦

¬HRINC qñaM2011¦. elIsBIenH karGegátmYycMnYneTot)anbgðaj[ eXIjfa nwgman]bsKÁ

kñúgkarTTYlB½t’manEdlGacTukcitþ)ansþIBIkarsikSa nig»kasTTYl)ankargar ¬rUbPaBTI 9¦.

Cak;Esþg yuvCnminTTYl)anB½t’manEdlpþl;edayrdæaPi)al nignieyaCkenaHeT ehIyviFIsa®sþ

KaMRTpøÚvkar dUcCakarRbwkSaeyabl;sþIBIkargar hak;dUcCaenAmanPaBTn;exSay ¬HRINC qñaM2011

nig CAMFEBA qñaM2008¦. karEckrMElkB½t’man nigkarsRmbsRmÜl hak;bIdUcCamanPaB

lM)akedaysarEtRbtibtþikrrdæ nigÉkCnmYycMnYn RtÚv)anP¢ab;eTAnwgkarGb;rMkRmit]tþmsikSa

rYmman RksYgrbs;rdæaPi)alcMnYnR)aMbYn nigTIPñak;garTaMgLay Edlpþl;esvaGb;rMkRmit]tþm

sikSa GmCamYyRKwHsßanÉkCn EdleFVIRbtibtþikareRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;RksYgGb;rM yuvCn

nigkILa. lT§PaBTTYl)antictYcnUvB½t’manEdlKYr[eCOCak; nigkarKaMRTpøÚvkar rYmpSMbEnßm

elIkarBwgEp¥kelIbNþajeRkARbB½n§kñúgkareFVIkarseRmccitþelIkarsikSa nigkargar KWCabBaða

d¾samBaØ EdlEtgEtekItmaneLIgkñúgbNþaRbeTskMBugGPivDÆn_ rYmCamYyplb:HBal;y:ag

F¶n;F¶relITIpSarkargar.

18 kMNt;RtakargaryuvCnrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak manenAeKhTMB½r http://www.youth-employment-inventory.org/

muxviC¢a b¤vis½yEdlminCak;lak;viTüasa®sþsgÁm BaNiC¢kmµ c,ab;esvakmµviTüasa®sþsil,³ nigmnusSsa®sþsuxaPi)alvisVkmµ plitkmµ nigsMNg;Gb;rMksikmµ

0%

Lao PDR

Brunei Darusalam

Myanmar

Korea, Rep.Japan

Malaysia

Hong Kong SAR, ChinaVietnam

Indonesia

Cambodia

10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%

100%

rUbPaBTI 9 ³ PaKryénsisSbBa©b;karGb;rM]tþmsiikSatammuxviC¢aCaGnþrCati

RbPB ³ EdStats ¬qñaMcugeRkaybg¥s; EdlGacrk)anGMLúgqñaM 2005-2009¦

kMNt;smÁal; ³ RkúmmuxviC¢aEdlrYmbBa©ÚlKña KWEp¥kelIcMNat;fñak;muxviC¢aEdlbegáIteLIgkñúgkRmg sMNYrEdl)anRbmUlBIviTüasßansßitirbs;GgÁkar UNESCO ¬qñaM2009¦

³ karGb;rM ¬karbNþúHbNþalRKÚ beRgón viTüasa®sþGb;rM¦ sil,³ nigmnusSsa®sþ ¬sil,³ mnusSsa®sþ¦ viTüasa®sþsgÁm BaNiC¢kmµ nigc,ab; ¬viTüasa®sþsgÁm nig

viTüasa®sþsikSaBIGtþcritmnusS sarB½t’man nigB½t’manviTüa BaNiC¢kmµ nigrdæ)al c,ab;¦ viTüasa®sþ ¬viTüasa®sþBit rUbviTüa KNitviTüa nigsßiti karKitelx¦

visVkmµ plitkmµ nigsMNg; ¬visVkmµ nigCMnYjvisVkmµ plitkmµ nigkarEkécñ sßabtükmµ nigsMNg;¦ ksikmµ ¬ksikmµ rukçaRbmaj; nigensaT bsuBüa)al¦ suxaPi)al

¬suxPaB esvasgÁm¦ nigesvakmµ ¬esvakmµpÞal;xøÜnesva dwkCBa¢Ún karBarbrisßan esvasnþisux¦.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 37: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

27

RbPB ³ KNnaedayEp¥kelITinñn½yRbB½n§RKb;RKgB½t’manGb;rM

taragTI 3 ³ muxviC¢aEdlnisiStbriBaØabRtsikSakñúgqñaMsikSa 2009¼2010

muxviC¢asikSa PaKry cMnYnnisSit PaKryénnisiStRsI

KNenyü nigKNenyühirBaØvtßú 13/0° 20>978 74/7°

hirBaØvtßú nigFnaKar 11/0° 17>760 41/1°

RKb;RKgBaNiC¢kmµ nigBaNiC¢kmµ rYmnwgkarRKb;RKgepSg² 10/3° 16>694 36/4°

Pasa nigGkSrsa®sþGg;eKøs 11/3° 18>325 54/4°

RKb;RKg nigRKb;RKgTUeTA 7/2° 11>640 28/2°

viTüasa®sþkMuBüÚT½r nigviTüasa®sþepSg²EdlTak;TgnwgkMuBüÚT½r 6/4° 10>323 7/4°

evC¢sa®sþ Kilanubdæak eraKsa®sþkumar Tnþsa®sþ nig»sfsa®sþ 5/8° 9>407 46/8°

c,ab; nignItisa®sþ 5/4° 8>787 22/4°

esdækic© nigmuxviC¢aEdlCab;Bak;B½n§ 5/3° 8>485 34/9°

Gb;rM nigmuxviC¢aEdlCab;Bak;B½n§ 2/4° 3>808 29/1°

ksikmµ rYmman ensaT nigrukçaRbmaj; RBmTaMgGPivDÆn_CnbT 2/3° 3>753 29/1°

GkSrsa®sþExµr nigviTüasa®sþ 1/7° 2>794 43/6°

TIpSar nigRKb;RKgTIpSar 1/7° 2>694 26/5°

eTscrN_ nigsNæaKar nigbdisNæarkic© 1/7° 2>771 39/3°

visVkmµsMNg;sIuvil 1/5° 2>371 1/7°

viTüasa®sþsgÁmepSg² ¬rdæ)alsaFarN³ viTüasa®sþneya)ay nigsgÁmviTüa¦

1/4° 2>310 39/5°

sßabtükmµ nigrcnabøg; 1/3° 2>058 21/3°

KNitviTüa 1/3° 2>071 21/5°

CIvviTüa nigKImIviTüa 0/9° 1>386 40/8°

visVkmµ nigmuxviC¢aEdlCab;Bak;B½n§ 0/9° 1>399 4/5°

sil,³ mnusSsa®sþ nigPasa TsSn³viC¢a nigsasna 0/8° 1>306 30/9°

RKb;RKgFnFanmnusS 0/6° 991 17/0°

rUbviTüa 0/6° 908 24/3°

bsuBüa)al nigbsueBTü 0/5° 879 19/1°

PasaepSg² ¬PasakUer: Cb:un )araMg nigéf¦ 0/5° 873 47/1°

PUmiviTüa 0/3° 476 39/9°

RbvtþiviTüa 0/3° 558 32/8°

viTüasa®sþ nigbec©kviTüa 0/1° 201 6/0°

muxviC¢aepSg² ¬eyaFa bNÐitsPanKr)al.l.¦ 3/4° 5>510 33/0°

srub 100/0° 161>516 39/4°

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 38: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

28

srubnisiStyuvCnEdlmankargareFVI

karpþl;eyabl;BImitþPkiþ nigmatabita

eKhTMB½r

GtßbTkaEst nigTsSnavdþI

mCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³

Pñak;gareRCIserIsbuKÁlik

saklviTüal½ynana

RKUbeRgónviTüal½y

GgÁkarminEmnrdæaPi)al

Tivakargar

naykdæanrdæaPi)alnana

smaKmnieyaCit

epSg²

50%

47%43%

59%

43%43%

42%

34%35%

29%

30%31%

27%

28%27%

35%

12%

23%24%

21%

22%21%

25%

12%12%

10%

11%11%

14%

3%2%

4%

62%66%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%

24%28%

rUbPaBTI 10 ³ RbPBB½t’mansþIBIkarsikSa nigkargar

RbPB ³ karGegátelIyuvCnEdl)anGnuvtþeLIgeday HRINC km<úCa kñúgExmIna qñaM2011.

hirBaØb,TansRmab;karGb;rM]tþmsikSarYmcMENkdl;karpøas;bþÚr. karcMNayrbs;rdæaPi)alelI

karGb;rM]tþmsikSamankRmitTabRtwmEt 0/1°b:ueNÑaH ehIy)anepþatsMxan;eTAelIkarBRgIk

karGb;rMCaCagyuT§sa®sþ nigKuNPaBénkarGb;rM ¬FnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2010 K¦. ]btßmÖ

FnsaFarN³ GaceFVI[mankarEkERbplcMeNjénvis½yesdækic©ÉkCnsRmab;muxviC¢aTak;Tg

nwgviTüasa®sþsgÁm. kñúgmuxviC¢aEdlsm,ÚrEbbTaMgenH éføsikSax<s;GacCYysRmÜldl;pl

RbeyaCn_TIpSary:agmanRbsiT§PaBsRmab;karvinieyaKCalkçN³buKÁl. pÞúymkvij muxviC¢a

dUcCa visVkmµ viTüasa®sþ nigKNitviTüa EdlminsUvmankareBjniymenaH minTTYl)ankar

ykcitþTukdak;elIyuT§sa®sþ nigFnFanEdlcaM)ac;kñúgRbB½n§Gb;rMTaMgmUlenaHeT ebIeTaHCa

muxviC¢aTaMgenH mansar³sMxan;sRmab;karrIkceRmInénesdækic©rbs;RbeTskm<úCak¾eday.

edaysarEtkarcMNaytictYcrbs;rdæaPi)alelIvis½yGb;rM rYmnwgcMnYnyuvv½yy:ageRcInEdl

minTTYl)an sUm,IEtkarGb;rMkRmitmUldæanpgenaH lT§plrkeXIjTaMgenH)anbgðajBItRmÚvkar

bnÞan;edIm,IBinitüeLIgvijnUvkarEbgEckkarcMNayelIvis½yGb;rMkñúgRbeTskm<úCa RBmTaMgerobcM

saCafµInUvGaTiPaBnanasRmab;kareRbIR)as;FnFanrbs;rdæ.

19 karyl;dwgBImUlehtuénkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNin TamTar[mankarBinitüemIlTIpSarEdlmanskþanuBl nigkar

braC½yénGPi)alkic©EdlbegVógtRmÚvkar nigkarpþl;bMNinBI {kRmitl¥bMputénsgÁm} nigb:HBal;dl;PaBsmRsbrvagtRmÚvkar

bMNin nigkarpþl;bMNinkñúgTIpSarkargar. karbraC½ymYycMnYn Cab;Bak;B½n§nwgrcnasm<½n§énRbB½n§Gb;rM nigkarbNþúHbNþal

ehIymYycMnYneTotTak;Tgnwg]bsKÁ EdlbuKÁlmñak;²CYbRbTHkñúgkarTTYl)anB½t’man nigR)ak;km©IehIymYycMnYneTot CaFmµta

qøúHbBa©aMgBIPaBexSayéncMeNHdwgkñúgRKÜsar. lkçN³sm,tþiCak;lak;énTIpSarplitpl nigkargar k¾GacCH\T§iBldl;shRKas

kñúgkarpþl;R)ak;elIkTwkcitþsRmab;nieyaCittamCMnajCak;lak; b¤nieyaCitEdlmankarbNþúHbNþal nignieyaCit[manCMnaj

kan;Etx<s;.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 39: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

29

2>3 etIkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNinkñúgRbeTskm<úCa bNþalmkBImUlehtuGVIxøH?

mUlehtuénkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNinkñúgRbeTskm<úCa bgðaj[eXIjenAEpñk

B½t’man nigkarsRmbsRmÜl. karbraC½yénkarpþl;B½t’man nigkarsRmbsRmÜl KWCabBaðaBit

kñúgTIpSarkargar ¬EpñktRmÚvkar¦ nigTIpSarCMnaj. cMENkEpñkpþl;tRmÚvkarmUlehtumanPaB

sµúKsµajCagenH. rUbPaBTI 10 bgðajBIesckþIsegçbBImUlehtucm,g² Edl)ankMNt;kñúg

ÉksareKalneya)ayenH.

kñúgEpñktRmÚvkar shRKasmYycMnYnhak;bIdUcCaxVHxatmeFüa)aykñúgkarbMeBjtRmÚvkarrbs;

xøÜn. karbgðajBIR)ak;QñÜl hak;bIdUcCaminTan;RKb;RKan;. m:üagvijeTot shRKasmYycMnYn

hak;dUcCaminmanRbsiT§PaBkñúgkarbgðajBItRmÚvkarrbs;xøÜnsRmab;bMNinCak;lak; nig\T§iBl

elIeKalneya)ayGPivDÆn_bMNinenaHeT. dUcEdl)anbgðajxagelIpllM)akrbs;shRKas

TaMgenaH kñúgkarsRmbsRmÜlkarbNþúHbNþalsRmab;nieyaCitrbs;xøÜn k¾)anKUsbBa¢ak;BI

mUlehtuEdlTak;TgnwgbBaðaB½t’manpgEdr. karENnaMrbs;KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal

¬NTB¦ CamYysmaCikPaBmkBIvis½yÉkCn KWkarpþl;ynþkarmYyEdlGac[shRKasnana

Bnül;bgðajBItRmÚvkarrbs;xøÜnsRmab;bMNinCak;lak;TaMgLaydl;rdæaPi)al nigshKmn_pþl;

karbNþúHbNþal. kñúgbNþaRbeTsepSgeTot Cajwkjab;KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal

EtgEtcUlrYmkñúgkarBinitüeLIgvijelIeKalneya)ayrbs;rdæaPi)alsRmab;karGb;rM nigkar

bNþúHbNþalRBmTaMgkarEbgEckhirBaØvtßúsaFarN³sRmab;eKalbMNgenHpgEdr. karBRgwg

RkúmKN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal ¬NTB¦ edIm,Ipþl;lT§PaBdl;Rkúmh‘un bBa¢ÚntRmÚvkarrbs;

xøÜneTArdæaPi)al nigkarbNþúHbNþaldl;shKmn_ GacmantYnaTIy:agsMxan;kñúgkaredaHRsay

bBaðaTak;TgnwgB½t’man.

cMENkEpñkpþl;tRmÚvkarvij bNþúMénmUlehtu KWTak;TgnwghirBaØb,Tan KuNPaB nigvisalPaB

énkarGb;rM nigkarbNþúHbNþal. bBaðaRbQmkñúgkarRKb;RKgFnFantamrebobmYyEdlelIk

Twkcitþdl;GñkbMeBjkargarl¥ nigmankarTTYlxusRtÚvelIlT§pl bBaðaRbQmkñúgkarbeRgón

bMNinCIvit nigCMnajbec©keTs ¬niglkçN³sm,tþiRKÚbeRgón nigkarbNþúHbNþalTUeTA¦ nig

P¢ab;TMnak;TMngrvagsalaeron nig]sSahkmµ[kan;EtCitsñiT§edIm,IelIkkm<s;KuNPaB nigTMnak;

TMngtRmÚvkarTIpSar. elIsBIenH buBVehtuTaMgenHrab;bBa©ÚlTaMgbBaðaRbQmkñúgkarbnþpþl;CMnYy

dl;RKÜsaredIm,IerobcM[kumar)ancUleron. bBaðaRbQmTaMgenH TamTar[mankarepþatkar

ykcitþTukdak;[)anm:t;ct; ehIybBaðaTaMgenHGacmankareqøIytbepSg²KñakñúgRKb;dMNak;kal

nImYy²énvdþCIvit. eKalneya)aynwgtRmÚv[kMNt;BItYnaTITaMgvis½ysaFarN³ nigÉkCnkñúg

karEbgEckkarpþl;hirBaØb,Tan KuNPaB nigvisalPaBénkarGb;rM nigkarbNþúHbNþal.

PaBexSayEdlmanRsab;kñúgTIpSarbMNin)anqøúHbBa©aMgy:agc,as;BIsßab½nTIpSarEdlTn;exSay.

edIm,IP¢ab;tRmÚvkar nigkarpþl;tRmÚvkarénbMNinnana sßab½nTIpSarTaMgLaymanmuxgarsMxan;²

R)aMy:ag KW ³

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 40: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

30

• karsRmbsRmÜledIm,Idak;bBa©ÚlEpñkTaMgBIrénTIpSarkargar ¬tYnaTIrbs;KN³kmµaFikarCati

bNþúHbNþal¦

• esvaEsVgrkkargar edIm,Ipþl;eyabl;dl;GñkEsVgrkkargareFVI sþIBI»kaskargar nigTIkEnøg

EdlGacbNþúHbNþalbMNin ¬tYnaTIrbs;TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargarEdleTIbnwg

begáItfµI – NEA¦

• karFanaKuNPaB edIm,IkMNt;BIsþg;dabMNin nigeFVIetsþRBmTaMgeFVIkarbBa¢ak;BIbMNinTaMgenaH

¬tYnaTIrbs;Rkbx½NÐKuNvuDÆiCatiEdlsißteRkamkarGPivDƦ

• karpþl;GaCJab½NÑ nigbTbBa¢a edIm,IkMNt;sþg;daGb,brmasRmab;RKwHsßanbNþúHbNþal

bMNinÉkCnTaMgLay nigsRmÜldl;kic©karBarGñkeRbIR)as; nig

• karTTYlsÁal;KuNPaB edIm,Ipþl;B½t’mansþIBIKuNPaBénkarGb;rM nigkarbNþúHbNþalEdl

pþl;edaysala nigmCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþal.

• sßab½nTaMgenH sRmbsRmÜlRbtibtþikarénTIpSarbMNinEdlmanRbsiT§PaB ehIysßab½n

TIpSarminGac rYmbBa©Úlkñúgvis½yÉkCn)aneT edaysarEtlkçN³KuNPaBGb;rMrbs;sßab½n

saFarN³TaMgenaH. rdæaPi)alGacbMeBjcenøaHxVHxatenH)an nigedIrtYnaTIcm,gkñúgkarRtÜt

BinitülT§plénTIpSarkargar nigbegáIteKalneya)ay[)ansmrmü.

etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

Page 41: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

31etIPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigbuBVehtuénPaBminsmRsbmanlkçN³dUcemþc?

rUbP

aBTI

11

³ k

arkMN

t;BIm

Uleh

tuénk

arxVH

xat

nigP

aBm

insm

Rsb

énb

MNink

ñúgRb

eTs

km<úCa

RbP

B ³

Gñkn

iBn§

bBa

ðaRb

Qm

nwgka

rbgða

j

tRm

Ú vkar

sRm

ab;

bMN

inCMna

j

bBa

ðaRb

Qm

kñúg

kars

Rmb

sRm

Ül

karb

NþúHb

Nþal

karg

ar

bBa

ðaRb

Qm

kñúgka

reFVI[

man

\T§iBl

elI

eKal

ney

a)ay

GP

ivDÆn

_bMN

in

hirB

aØb,T

an

nigRb

siT§P

aB ³

bBa

ðaRb

Qm

kñúgka

rcMN

ay

FnFa

n Ed

l

beg

áIt[m

an

R)ak

;elIkT

wkcitþ

sRm

ab;ka

rGnuv

karg

arl

¥ nig

karT

TYlxus

RtÚv

KuNP

aB n

ig P

aBCa

b;Ta

k;Tg

nwgtR

mÚvk

ar

TIpSa

r ³

bBa

ða Rb

Qm

kñúgka

r

beR

gónb

MNin

CIvit

nig

bec

©keTs

nig

P

¢ab;TMn

ak;TMn

g s

alae

ron

nig

]sSa

hkm

µ[

kan;E

tCits

ñiT§

visal

PaB

nig]b

sKÁk

ñúg

karT

TYl)a

n ³

bBa

ðaRb

Qm

kñúgka

rCMruj

RKÜs

ar[

bnþ

bBa

¢ÚnkUne

TA

sal

aero

n

bBa

ðaRb

Qm

kñúgka

rbBa

©Úl

sh

Kmn_p

þl;ka

r

bN

þúHbN

þal

eTAk

ñúgeKa

led

A

yuT§s

a®s

þ

GP

ivDÆn

_Cati

bBa

ðaRb

Qm

kñúgka

rkMN

t;

tYnaT

Irbs

;vis½y

saF

arN

³ nig

ÉkCn

bBa

ðaRb

Qm

kñúgka

rBRg

wg

sßab

½nTIpS

ar

sRm

ab;ka

r

GP

ivDÆb

MNin

nig

sRm

bs

RmÜl

lT§P

aBTT

Yl)a

n

B½t’m

an

karxVHxat

EpñktRmÚvkar

etI]b

sKÁé

nbMN

inman

kare

kIneL

IgEdr

b¤eT

?eh

tuGIV)a

nCan

ieyaC

kminp

þl;l

kçxN

Ð nig»

kas

Rtwm

RtÚv?

TIpSarbMNin

etIB½t

’man

pþl;CUn

sßab

½n Rk

úmh

‘un nig

buKÁl

s

þIBIpl

cMeN

j n

igtém

øbMN

in G

acrk

)an

nigm

anKuN

PaB

Edr b

¤eT?

etITIp

Sare

bIkT

Ulay

[m

anka

rRb

kYtRb

ECgE

dr b

¤eT?

EpñkpÁt;pÁg;tRmÚvkar

ehtuG

IV)anC

aRb

B½n§G

b;rM

nigb

NþúHb

Nþal

m

inpþl

;bMN

intam

tRm

Úvkar

?

Page 42: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

32

mUldæanFnFanmnusSrbs;RbeTskm<úCa cg¥úlbgðajBIPaBxøaMgmYycMnYnEdlkm<úCaGacBRgwg)an.

kñúgdMNak;kalGtiBlkmµénkarGPivDÆnaeBlfµI² rYmnwgkarbegáItmUldæanRKwHénbMNin edIm,I

EsVgyl;BIyuT§sa®sþénkMeNInesdækic©rbs;xøÜn km<úCaRtÚvFana[mankarGPivDÆkumartUc[)an

smrmü rYmnwgkarbBa©b;karGb;rMmUldæan[)anRtwmfñak;TI 9 RbkbedayKuNPaBsRmab;yuvCn

TaMgGs;. karksagmUldæanRKwH edIm,IkarGPivDÆbMNinnaeBlGnaKtcaM)ac;RtÚvEp¥kelIRbsiT§PaB

nigsmFm’. RbsinebIminmankarbNþúHbNþalmUldæanRKwHRbkbedayKuNPaBl¥enaHeT enaHkar

bNþúHbNþalnieyaCitenAkñúgdMNak;kalvdþCIvit bnÞab;minGacTTYl)aneCaKC½yeLIy. enH KW

CayuT§viFImYyEdlRbeTscinFøab;ykmkGnuvtþ enAeBlRbeTscinBwgEp¥kelIesdækic©kñúgRbeTs

kñúgqñaM1979 ehIymanRbeTsmYycMnYneTotGnuvtþyuT§viFIenHEdr dUcCa RbeTsQIlI miksIukU

sigðbUrI nigkUer:xagt,Úg. RbeTsTaMgenHcab;epþImpþl;karGb;rMkRmitmUldæanRbkbedayKuNPaB

l¥edIm,IGPivDÆCMnajnieyaCitnaeBlGnaKt.

km<úCaKYrpþl;GaTiPaBbMNinmUldæanRbkbedayKuNPaB nigbMNinmuncUlbMeBjkargar Biess

bMNinTak;TgnwgKNitviTüa viTüasa®sþ nigvisVkmµ. kareFVIEbbenHtRmÚv[rdæaPi)aleFVIkargar

CaédKUCamYyGgÁkarminEmnrdæaPi)alkñúgkarpþl; nigKaMRThirBaØb,TansRmab;bMNinTaMgenH rYmman

bMNinkñúgkarGb;rMkRmit]tþmpgEdr. edaykarBRgwgsßab½nTIpSarEdlelIkkm<s;KuNPaB nig

TMnak;TMngénkarvinieyaKelIkarGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalkm<úCaGacbegáInlT§plkargarkñúgkar

cMNayCasaFarN³ nigÉkCn)an. eyageTAtamkarEbgEckCafµIkñúgkarcMNaypÞal;elIkarGb;rM

karbNþúHbNþal RBmTaMgkareFVIkargarCaédKUCamYysßanb½nbNþúHbNþalbMNinminEmnrdæaPi)al

edIm,IbMeBjtamtRmÚvkarsgÁmnUvbMNinmYycMnYn dUcCa karbNþúHbNþalBaNiC¢kmµ rdæaPi)al

GaceRbIR)as;FnFanrbs;xøÜneTAtamyuT§sa®sþ)anRbesIrCagmunkñúgkarbMeBjtRmÚvkarTIpSar nig

KaMRTdl;kareFVIBiBiFkmµesdækic©.

KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal ¬NTB¦ GnuvtþnUvKMnitpþÜcepþImd¾l¥Tak;TgnwgkarbegáItbMNinmun

TTYl)ankargar nigkareRbIR)as;bMNinTaMgenH. KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal ¬NTB¦ man

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþ sRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s; karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

3

Page 43: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

33

taragelx 4 ³ EpnkarskmµPaBGPivDÆn_bMNin CeRmIssRmab;km<úCa

eKalbMNg skmµPaBRtÚvGnuvtþbnÞan; karbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;eBlGnaKt

1 karTTYl)anB½t’man • elIkkm<s;smtßPaBkñúgkarRbwkSakargar nigesvaEsVgrkkargar

• eRbIR)as;RbB½n§pSBVpSayB½t’man edIm,IbgðajBI»kassikSa nigkargar nigkarelIkkm<s;karGb;rM bNþúHbNþal viC¢aCIv³

• elIkkm<s;smtßPaBrbs;TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargar nigPaBCaédKUCamYyvis½yÉkCn

2 visalPaB {PaBcenøaHenAkRmitkNþal}

• b®Ba¢abkmµviFIGb;rM bNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ Edlman KuNPaBl¥

• BRgwgsmtßPaBrbs;KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþalkñúgkMENTRmg;karGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalnieyaCk

• BicarNaelImeFüa)ayCMruj[nieyaCkcMNayelIkarbNþúHbNþalkmøaMgBlkmµrbs;xøÜn

3 KuNPaB nigPaBBak;B½n§TIpSar

• cab;epþImbegáIncMnYnsßab½nbNþúHbNþalbMNin rYmman mCÄmNÐl bNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§eday shkarCamYy]sSahkmµ kñúgRsúk

• kMENTRmg;kmµviFIsikSaenAkRmitmFümsikSa edIm,IelIkkm<s;karbeRgónviTüasa®sþ KNitviTüa visVkmµ nigmuxviC¢a bec©keTsepSgeTot PaBCashRKin nigbMNinCIvit

• BRgwgkarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;shKmn_ nigsalaeron EdlCaEpñkmYyéndMeNIrkarvimCÄkar nigvishmCÄkar

4 RbsiT§PaBhirBaØb,Tan • BRgIkviFIsa®sþpþl;hriBaØb,TantRmg;TisRKÜsar edIm,IrkSaGRta Kg;vgSénkarsikSa

• begáInkarcMNayeTAelIbTGnþraKmn_ EdlmankarcMNaytictYcenAdMNak;kaldMbUgénvdþCIvit

• EsVgrkviFIsa®sþhirBaØb,Tannana edIm,ICMruj[mankarelIkTwkcitþcMeBaHsßab½nEdlmanlT§plbNþúHbNþall¥ kñúgcMeNamsßab½nbNþúHbNþalbMNin nigRKwHsßan ]tþmsikSa

karykcitþTukdak;kñúgkarbegáIteKalneya)ay nigGPi)alkic©CaRbB½n§tamry³karGnuvtþkargar

Cak;EsþgedaykarbegáItsþg;da KuNvuDÆi nigkarGnuvtþkarvaytémø. enAqñaM2009 kñúgkarTTYl

sÁal;BItRmÚvkarTTYl)anB½t’man[kan;EtRbesIrenaH KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal)anbegáIt

TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargar ¬NTB¦ edIm,Ipþl;esvakargar nigesvaB½t’manTIpSarkargardl;

GñkEsVgrkkargareFVI nieyaCit nieyaCk sßab½nbNþúHbNþal nigsaFarNCnTUeTA. cugbBa©b;

KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal)an nigkMBugsRmbsRmÜlKeRmagBRgwgkarGb;rMbNþúHbNþal

bec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ ¬pþl;mUlniFiedayFnaKarBiPBelak¦. KeRmagenHbegáIteLIgkñúgeKalbMNg

begáItRbB½n§BRgIkkarbNþúHbNþalcRmúHeTAtamtRmÚvkar]sSahkmµ nigRsbeTAtamtRmÚvkar

bMNinmUldæan nigbMNinkRmitmFümenAkñúgvis½ysMxan;².

3>1 karbegáItEpnkarskmµPaBbMNin

karbMeBjKMnitpþÜcepIþmEpñkeKalneya)aykMBugdMeNIrkar dUcenH EpnkarskmµPaBbMNinrbs;

RbeTskm<úCacaM)ac;RtÚvedaHRsay]bsKÁcm,gsRmab;bMNin edIm,IQaneTAseRmcbMNgR)afña

rbs;xøÜn. edayskmµPaBenHCaskmµPaBGaTiPaBbnÞan; rdæaPi)alGacsRmbsRmÜllT§PaB

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 44: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

34

TTYl)anB½t’mankñúgTIpSarbMNin BRgIkGnþraKmn_ tRmg;TisRKÜsar edIm,IelIkkm<s;GRtaKg;vgS

énkarsikSa nigBRgwg»kassikSaelIkTI 2 RBmTaMgkarGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nig

viC¢aCIv³. edIm,IerobcMmUldæanRKwHsRmab;eBlGnaKt rdæaPi)alKYrBRgIkhirBaØb,TansRmab;kar

GPivDÆkumartUc BRgwgkarGPivDÆsßab½n nigCMruj[mankarelIkTwkcitþcMeBaHsßab½nbNþúHbNþal

EdlmanKuNPaBl¥ rYmman RKwHsßan]tþmsikSaCaedIm. taragelx 5 segçbBIskmµPaBEdl

)anelIkeLIgsRmab;karBicarNa nigEpñkenAsl;éncMNucenHpþl;B½t’manbEnßmeTot.

¬1¦ karsRmbsRmÜl[manlT§PaBTTYl)anB½t’mansþIBITIpSarbMNin

lT§PaBTTYl)anB½t’manRKb;RKan;begáIt[manRbsiT§PaBenAelITIpSarkargar nigpþl;plcMeNj

dl;nieyaCitk¾dUcCanieyaCk. karTTYl)anB½t’manRKb;RKan;tRmÚv[mankarBRgwgsßab½nTIpSar

Edl)anelIkeLIgenAcMNuc 2>3 EdlnwgcMNayeBleRcIn. eTaHCay:agNa skmµPaBeKaledA

GacCYyrujRcan]bsKÁcm,gecj)an[kan;Etrh½s. ]TahrN_ karcat;viFankarelIkkm<s;

esvakargar nigB½t’manTIpSarkargarsRmab;kargarkñúgesdækic©GnþrkalenAGWru:bkNþalenATsvtSr_

qñaM1990 )anpþl;[manPaKlaPy:ageRcInsRmab;karelIkkm<s;cl½tPaBénBlkmµ nigRbsiT§PaB

énkareRbIR)as;kmøaMgkargar.

k¦ skmµPaBEdlRtÚvGnuvtþbnÞan; edIm,IsRmbsRmÜldl;karTTYl)anB½t’manenAelITIpSar

kargar

edaysarskmµPaBenHCaskmµPaBGaTiPaBbnÞan; km<úCaKYrBicarNaelIviFankarnanaedIm,I

BRgwgsmtßPaBkñúgkarRbwkSakargar nigesvaEsVgrkkargar ehIyeRbIR)as;RbB½n§pSBVpSay

edIm,Ipþl;B½t’mansþIBIkarsikSa nig»kaskargar nigelIkkm<s;karGb;rM bNþúHbNþalbec©keTs

nigviC¢aCIv³ ³

skmµPaBTI1 ³ elIkkm<s;smtßPaBkñúgkarRbwkSakargar nigesvaEsVgrkkargar

saklviTüal½y nigRKwHsßanGb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³mYycMnYnbegáIt[

manGgÁPaBRbwkSakargar edIm,Ipþl;B½t’man sþIBIkargar karRbwkSakargar nigCMnYy

dl;sisSkñúgkarEsVgrkkargar. EteTaHCay:agNa karelIkkm<s;KuNPaBB½t’man

nigesvaEdlpþl;edayGgÁPaBTaMgenH KWRtÚvkarcMNayeBlevlaeRcInpgEdr. RksYg

kargar nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ nigRksYgGb;rM yuvCn nigkILa GacCYyBRgwg

smtßPaBrbs;GgÁPaBTaMgenH k¾dUcCabuKÁlBak;B½n§enARKwHsßanGb;rMbNþúHbNþal

bec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³pgEdr )antamry³karsRmbsRmÜl[mankarbegáItkmµviFI

bNþúHbNþalsRmab;buKÁlikpþl;RbwkSa ehIyk¾KYrmankarpþl;kargar esvakargar nig

sikçasalasþIBIkargarenAkRmitmFümsikSapgEdr. TIPñak;garCati muxrbr nigkargar

20 smaKmnieyaCkÉkCn dUcCa CAMFEBA b¤TIPñak;garRsavRCavkñúgRsúk GacCYykñúgkarGegátenH)an EdlGacbegáIt»kas

kargarkan;EtRcInkñúgkarbNþúHbNþal nigkarksagsmtßPaBrbs;yuvCn.

21 dUcEdl)anbBa¢ak;tamry³Rbsasn_rbs;naykrdæm®nþI h‘un Esn naykrdæm®nþIRbeTskm<úCaenARBwtþikarN_TaMgBIr.

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 45: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

35

KYrbegáItTMnak;TMng[)anrwgmaMgCamYyGgÁPaBpþl;RbwkSakargarEbbenH nigeFVIkar

sRmbsRmÜly:agskmµedIm,ITTYl)anB½t’manBak;B½n§TIpSarepSgeTot.

skmµPaBTI 2 ³ eRbIR)as;TUrTsSn_ nigviTüú edIm,IpSBVpSayB½t’mansikSa »kas

kargar nigkarelIkkm<s;karGb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³

rdæaPi)alGacelIkkm<s;PaBCaédKUrvagrdæ nigÉkCn kñúgkmµviFIviTüú nigTUrTsSn_

pSBVpSayCasaFarN³sþIBIkarGb;rM nig»kaskargaredayepþatelI]sSahkmµ nig

kargarEdlRbQmnwgkarxVHxatkmøaMg kargar\tQb;Qr ehIytYnaTIrbs; TVET

CaCeRmIsmYyd¾l¥bMputsRmab;karGb;rMenAsaklviTüal½y. kmµviFInana k¾GacTajyk

BIGIuneFIeNtEckcayCa DVDs/CDs enAÉevTikakargarRbcaMqñaM mCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþal

extþ shKmn_ evTikatamPUmi nigenAkEnøgepSgeTot EdlmanyuvCnRbmUlpþúMKña.

RbeTssigðburITTYl)aneCaKC½yy:agxøaMg kñúgkarelIkkm<s;karTTYlsÁal;rbs;RKwHsßan

Gb;rM bNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ tamry³meFüa)ayCaeRcIn nigeday

karvinieyaKy:ageRcInelIkarelIkkm<s;KuNPaBesvapþl;[. karvinieyaKTunmankar

KaMRTBIvis½yÉkCntamry³édKUÉkCnsaFarN³.

x¦ karbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;lT§PaBTTYl)anB½t’manenAelITIpSarkargareBlGnaKt

edIm,IbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;GnaKt rdæaPi)alKYrBicarNameFüa)ayl¥bMputkñúgkarBRgwg

smtßPaB nigPaBCaédKUCamYyvis½yÉkCn.

sRmab;GnaKt³ elIkkm<s;smtßPaBrbs;TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargar nigPaBCaédKU

CamYyvis½yÉkCn TIPñak;garCati muxrbr nigkargar RtÚvkarksagsmtßPaB nigPaBCa

édKUCamYyvis½yÉkCnenAkñúgvis½y 3sMxan; Tak;TgnwgkarTTYlxusRtÚvsMxan;²rbs;xøÜn

dUcteTAenH ³ ¬1¦ karRbmUl nigkarviPaKB½t’manTIpSarkargar ¬2¦ karbegáItRbB½n§B½t’man

TIpSarkargar nig ¬3¦ karpþl;B½t’mansþIBIesvaGb;rM nigkargar. TImYy edayeKarBeTAtam

karRbmUlviPaK nigpSBVpSayB½t’manTIpSarkargar TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargarGac

TMnak;TMngsßab½nbNþúHbNþalmUldæanenAkñúgKMrU nigkarGegátTIpSarkargar karbNþúHbNþal

mUldæan nigkRmitx<s;kñúgkarviPaKTinñn½y nigkarbNþúHbNþalrebobeFVIbTbgðaj karTMnak;

TMng nigkarpSBVpSayB½t’man.

TIBIr edIm,IEksRmÜl nigBRgwgRbB½n§B½t’manTIpSarkargarrbs;xøÜn TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr

nigkargarGacEsVgrkkarshkarCamYysmaKmnieyaCk nigsßab½nRsavRCavvis½yÉkCn.

CaBiess TIPñak;garCati muxrbr nigkargarGacRtÜtBinitüKMrUTIpSarEdlmanenAkm<úCa

ehIyGacshkarCamYyRksYgGb;rM yuvCn nigkILa nigvis½yÉkCnkñúgkareFVIbc©úb,nñPaB

nigEksRmÜlKMrUpÁt;pÁg; nigtRmÚvkarkñúgkareRbIR)as;. sßab½nGnþrCati dUcCa GgÁkarBlkmµ

GnþrCatipþl;CMnYybec©keTsdl;RbeTskMBugGPivDÆn_ edIm,IseRmc)aneKalbMNgenH

tamry³karRbtibtþil¥CalkçN³GnþrCati TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargarGacshkar

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 46: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

36

CamYysalaeron nigsßab½nbNþúHbNþal edIm,IGnuvtþkarGegáttamdansþIBIlT§plTIpSar

kargarrbs;sisSnisitSbBa©b;karsikSa edayGaccab;epþImCaKeRmagsakl,g Edlman

sklviTüal½yFM²mYy b¤BIrcUlrYm.

edaybEnßmelIviFIsa®sþEdlmanTaMgenH TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargarGaceFVIkarGegát

tamry³ TUrs½BÞCaRbcaMCamYynieyaCk Edl)anpSBVpSayeRCIserIsbuKÁliktamtYnaTIkñúg

eKalbMNgkMNt;tYnaTIBi)akrk. cugbBa©b; TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargarGacecjpSay

sßitisegçbsþIBIkargarRbcaMqñaMtammuxviC¢a kargartammuxviC¢a nigtamsßab½n edIm,I[sisS

nisSiteTIbRbLgCab;GaceRCIserIssßab½nsRmab;TTYlkarGb;rM nigbNþúHbNþal nigmuxviC¢a

EdlRtÚveronbnþ. kic©xitxMpSBVpSayB½t’manEbbenH sMedAeTAelIRkumbIxus²Kña ³ RKwHsßan

Gb;rM nigsßab½nbNþúHbNþalbMNin nieyaCk Gñkpþl;karRbwkSa nigsisSnisitSEdlman

skþanuBl.

cugeRkayenH edIm,Ipþl;B½t’mansþIBIesvaGb;rM nigkargar TIPñak;garCatimuxrbr nigkargar

KYrBRgwg nigBRgIkkarpþl;B½t’mansþIBIkarGb;rM nig»kaskargar EdleBlbc©úb,nñenHminTan;

manPaBTUlMTUlayenAeLIy. kic©xitxMRbwgERbgenHCab;Tak;TgnwgPaBCaédKUCamYysßab½n

pþl;esvakargarkñúgvis½yÉkCn k¾dUcCaGgÁkarminEmnrdæaPi)alpgEdrEdlpþl;B½t’man

TaMgenH. eKalbMNgénkarpSBVpSayenH KWedIm,IbegáIteKhTMB½rkargartamRbB½n§eGLicRtÚnic

edIm,I[sisSnisSit nigGñkpþl;RbwkSaeRbIR)as;enAsalamFümsikSak¾dUcCanieyaCkpgEdr.

eKhTMB½renH manB½t’mansþIBIRKwHsßanGb;rM]tþmsikSa vKÁsikSanana nigkargarEdlP¢ab;eTA

RbB½n§B½t’manTIpSarkargarrbs;TIPñak;garCati muxrbr nigkargar.

¬2¦ karBRgIkvisalPaB {PaBcenøaHenAkRmitkNþal}

evTikaesdækic©km<úCa qñaM2011 nigsinñisITckçúvis½ykm<úCamanGaTiPaBBRgwg {PaBcenøaHenA

kRmitkNþal} énbMNin. karseRmc[mankarcuHeQµaHenAkRmitmFümsikSabzmPUmi rYmman

GRtacuHeQµaHTabxøaMgkñúgkarGb;rM bNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ edaymankarshkar

CamYynieyaCk KWRtÚvkarCacaM)ac;edIm,IerobcMcMnYnsisSCaeRcIn[TTYl)ankargar nigbegáIn

CMnajnaeBlGnaKt.

k¦ skmµPaBRtÚvGnuvtþbnÞan;kñúgkarBRgIkvisalPaB{PaBcenøaHenAkRmitkNþal}

edaysarskmµPaBenH CaskmµPaBGaTiPaBbnÞan; rdæaPi)alKYrb®Ba¢abkmµviFIGb;rMbNþúH-

bNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³[)anl¥ ¬ehIyBRgIk karpþl;hriBaØb,Tan tRmg;TisRKÜsar

dUcEdl)anelIkeLIgenAkñúgRbsiT§PaBhriBaØb,Tan¦.

22 karpþÜcepþImenH)anykmkeFVIkarsakl,g nigvaytémøeRkamKeRmagRTRTg;vis½yGb;rMenAkm<úCa ]btßmÖedayFnaKarBiPBelak

edIm,IRbmUl nigviPaKbTBiesaFn_matabita nigshKmn_ nigCMruj[matabitamankarykcitþTukdak;kan;EtxøaMg nigtRmÚv[man

karEklm¥BIsalaeron.

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 47: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

37

23 yuT§sa®sþKaMBarsgÁmCatikm<úCa TTYl)ankarGnum½tBIsemþcnaykrdæm®nþI nigkic©RbCuMKN³rdæm®nþIeBjGgÁ kñúgExmIna qñaM2011.

skmµPaBTI 1 ³ karb®Ba¢abkmµviFIGb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³[)anl¥km<úCa

)anpþl;kmµviFIGb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³l¥mYycMnYnrYcmkehIy mandUc

CavKÁsikSakMuBüÚT½renA CIST EdlGaceFVICaKMrUsRmab;karb®Ba¢ab nigBRgIkkmµviFI)an.

RksYgkargar nigbNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³ GackMNt;kmµviFIbNþúHbNþalCMnajEdlman

karTTYlsÁal;eRcInBInieyaCk nigBüayamdak;bBa©ÚlkmµviFIbNþúHbNþalenH enAsala

Gb;rMbNþúHbNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³rdæ b¤kñúgsßab½nbNþúHbNþalFM² EdlmansisS

cUleroneRcIn. edaymankarshkarCamYy]sSahkmµÉkCn RksYgkargar nig

bNþúHbNþalviC¢aCIv³GacvinieyaKelImCÄmNÐlmYy b¤eRcIn EdlGnuvtþ)anl¥kñúgtMbn;

mYycMnYnsRmab;karGb;rM bec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³enAkRmitmFümsikSa. skmµPaB

vinieyaKEbbenH GacbegáInkarcUlrYmrbs;yuvCnkñúgkarGPivDÆCMnajbec©keTs nig

viC¢aCIv³)anl¥ eTAtamtRmÚvkarrbs;shRKas]sSahkmµ. salaviC¢aCIv³bec©keTs

Cati (CONALEP) rbs;RbeTsmiksIukU pþl;KMrUd¾eCaKC½ymYy sRmab;karENnaMPaB

CaédKUrvagsala nigshRKas]sSahkmµ.

x¦ karbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab; {PaBcenøaHenAkRmitkNþal} enAéf¶xagmux

enAéf¶xagmux rdæaPi)alnwgBicarNaelImeFüa)ayfµI edIm,IBRgwgsmtßPaBrbs;KN³-

kmµaFikarCati bNþúHbNþal nigCMruj[nieyaCkcMNayelIkargarbNþúHbNþalnieyaCit.

EpnkarTI1 ³ BRgwgsmtßPaBrbs;KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal edIm,IeFVIkMENTRmg;

karGb;rM nigkarbNþúHbNþal epþatelInieyaCk

karBRgwgsmtßPaBrbs;KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþal RtÚvmankarerobcMsmaCikPaB

rbs;KN³kmµaFikarCati begáIntMNag nig\T§iBlnieyaCk RBmTaMgGPivDÆn_smtßPaB

rbs;elxaFikarrbs;KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþalpgEdr. karBRgwgenH k¾tRmÚv[

KN³kmµaFikarCatibNþúHbNþaledIrtYnaTIy:agskmµelIkargarCak;Esþg kñúgkarbegáIt

sþg;da KuNvuDÆi nigkarGnuvtþkarvaytémøbEnßmelIkarelIkkm<s;karbegáIteKalneya)ay

nigRbB½n§RKb;RKg[kan;EtTUlMTUlay. edIm,IelIkkm<s;kargarrbs;KN³kmµaFikarCati

bNþúHbNþal rdæaPi)alGacbgðajBIsUcnakrkargarsMxan;dl;KN³kmµaFikarCati

bNþúHbNþal nigRtÜtBinitüvDÆnPaBsmT§iplkargarrbs;xøÜn. KN³kmµaFikarCati

bNþúHbNþalkñúgRbeTsCaeRcInCMuvijBiPBelakmaneQµaHxus²Kña cMENktYnaTI nigkar

TTYlxusRtÚvk¾xusKñaEdr. elxaFikarEdlmaneKalCMhrrwgmaM KWCatYGgÁd¾sMxan;kñúgkar

pþl;GMNacdl;KN³kmµaFikarTaMgenH[GnuvtþtYnaTIEdl)ancat;taMg. KN³kmµaFikar

CatibNþúHbNþalGacpþl;[mankarerobcMrYmmYy edIm,IRtÜtBinitüsßab½nTIpSarepSg

eTotkñúgkarTTYl)anB½t’manTIpSarkargar esvakargar karFanaKuNPaB bTbBa¢a

karRtÜtBinitü nigkarbegáIteKalneya)ay.

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 48: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

38

EpnkarTI2 ³ BicarNaviFIsa®sþfµI kñúgkarCMrujnieyaCk[eFVIkarcMNayelIkarbNþúH-

bNþalnieyaCit

km<úCaminmankarrMBwgTukkñúgkarpþl;fvikasRmab;karbNþúHbNþal tamtRmÚvkarBIRbPB

saFarN³enaHeT. km<úCaRtÚvkarEbgEckfvika nigelIkkm<s;karcMNayÉkCntam

shRKas. shRKasFM²PaKeRcIn )anpþl;karbNþúHbNþaldl;nieyaCitrbs;xøÜnrYc

ral;ehIy ehIyshRKasCaeRcIneTot k¾mankarCMruj[pþl;karbNþúHbNþaldl;

nieyaCitpgEdr. ]TahrN_ RbeTsma:eLsIu nigsigðburI TTYl)aneCaKC½ykñúgkarCMruj

[shRKaspþl;karbNþúHbNþal tamry³RbB½n§elIkElgBn§elIR)ak;cMNUlrbs;

nieyaCk EdlmanRbsiT§PaBsRmab;shRKasxñatmFüm. bTBiesaFn_bgðajfa

RbB½n§elIkElgBn§elIR)ak;cMNUlrbs;nieyaCkGnuvtþ edaymUlniFisRmab;karbNþúH-

bNþalfñak;Cati manRbsiT§PaBEdlnieyaCkmantYnaTIsMxan;kñúgkarRKb;RKg nig

eKalneya)ayrbs;xøÜn. pÞúyeTAvij \NTanBn§darelIkarGb;rM nigkarbNþúHbNþal

GacmanRbsiT§PaBsRmab;Rkúmh‘untUc² EdlTTYl)anBIkarelIkElgBn§ edaysar

karcMNayeTAtamlkçxNÐc,ab;.

¬3¦ karbegáInKuNPaB nigTMnak;TMngTIpSarkñúgkarGPivDÆbMNin

edIm,IelIkkm<s;TMnak;TMng nigKuNPaBkñúgkarGPivDÆbMNin km<úCaRtÚveFVIkMENTRmg;salaeron nig

mCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþal RBmTaMgkarpSarP¢ab;eTAnwg]sSahkmµpgEdr. kMENTRmg;salatRmÚv

[ ¬1¦ EkERbkmµviFIsikSa[eTACakmµviFIsikSaEp¥kelIkarksagsmtßPaB nigepþatkarykcitþTuk

dak;elIlT§plbNþúHbNþal[)aneRcInCagFnFansRmab;begáInRbsiT§PaB nigkarTTYlxusRtÚv

¬2¦ EkERbviFIsa®sþénkarbeRgónBIRKÚmCÄmNÐleTACasisSmCÄmNÐl edayCYysisS nig

kmµsikSakarI [køayCaGñkbgðat;beRgónyUrGEgVg ¬3¦ eRbIR)as;viFIsa®sþénkarbeRgón Edl

GPivDÆbMNinCIvit EdlCatRmÚvkarrbs;]sSahkmµ nigshRKin edIm,IGPivDÆvis½yÉkCn nig

kat;bnßyPaBRkIRk nig ¬4¦ BRgwgkarRKb;RKgsalaeron nigmCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþal edIm,IelIk

km<s;RbsiT§PaB nigkareqøIytbeTAnwgkarERbRbÜlTIpSarenAtammUldæan. ]TahrN_ RbeTs

GU®sþalI nigsigðburI manbTBiesaFn_y:ageRcInTak;TgnwgkMENTRmg;TaMgenH. RbeTscink¾kMBug

sakl,geRbIR)as;kBa©b;fvikay:ageRcInsRmab;kMENTRmg;kñúgsalaeron enAtambeNþayeqñr

xagekIt. elIsBIenHeTAeTot manRbeTsCaeRcIn)anpþl;bTBiesaFn_l¥² sþIBIkarpSarP¢ab;

salaeronCamYy]sSahkmµ. yuT§sa®sþTTYl)aneCaKC½y rYmbBa©ÚlKMrURbeTsCb:unCamYy

salaeron Edldak;bBa©ÚlsisSkñúgvis½y]sSahkmµenAeBlbBa©b;karsikSa ehIyKMrURbeTs

sigðburI eRbIR)as;bBaðaplitkmµ]sSahkmµsRmab;karbNþúHbNþal. KMrUsalaeron nig]sSahkmµ

rbs;RbeTsGaløWm:g;vij mankMENTRmg;karbNþúHbNþalBIrEpñk yuT§sa®sþeRbIR)as;kñúgshrdæ

GaemrikCamYysßab½nkargar Edlpþl;karsikSaEp¥kelIkargarPaBCaédKUrbs;sala CONALEP CamYy]sSahkmµsRmab;mU:DulenARbeTsmiksuIkU karGb;rMenAmFümsikSaEp¥kelIkarksag

smtßPaB b¤ Senai nig Senac enARbeTseRbsuIl mCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþaldwknaMedaynieyaCk.

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 49: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

39

k¦ skmµPaBRtÚvGnuvtþbnÞan; edIm,IelIkkm<s;KuNPaB nigPaBBak;B½n§nwgTIpSar

enAeBlmankarbnþkic©xitxMRbwgERbgrbs;RksYgGb;rM yuvCn nigkILa nigRksYgbNþúHbNþal

viC¢aCIv³ kñúgkarbegáItkMENTRmg;[)anTUlMTUlay nigkarksagsmtßPaBenaH rdæaPi)alGac

cab;epþImbegáIncMnYnmCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§[)anqab; edaymanshkarCamYy

]sSahkmµkñúgRsúk.

skmµPaBTI1 ³ cab;epþImbegáIncMnYnsßab½nbNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§ edaykarshkar

CamYy]sSahkmµkñúgRsúk

karepþatelItMbn;GPivDÆn_ nigvis½ylUtlas;sMxan;²xagEpñkesdækic© rdæaPi)alGac

begáIt[manédKUkñúgtMbn; rvag]sSahkmµ nigsßab½nbNþúHbNþalbMNin rYmman

mCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalkñúgRbB½n§ nigeRkARbB½n§ RBmTaMgsalaeronpgEdr. PaBCa

édKUTaMgenH GaccUlrYmcMENkpþl;tYnaTIdl;]sSahkmµkñúgkarRKb;RKgsßab½nbNþúH-

bNþal nigkarRKb;RKgesvabNþúHbNþalrbs;xøÜn. tamsalaeron k¾dUcCamCÄmNÐl

bNþúHbNþalhirBaØb,TansaFarN³ nigÉkCn GacCYyEklm¥karRKb;RKg karbeRgón

eRKÓgbrikçar nigsmÖar³sikSa. bTBiesaFn_kargar nigkarbNþúHbNþal GacrYmbBa©Úl

Kña edIm,IelIkkm<s;KuNPaB nigPaBCab;Tak;Tgkñúgkarpþl;karbNþúHbNþal. RbeTs

m:UrIs TTYl)aneCaKC½ykñúgkareRbIR)as;yuT§sa®sþenH edIm,IbeRmIdl;tMbn;esdækic©

sMxan;². elIsBIenHeTot karbegáIt nigGnuvtþyuT§sa®sþbMNintamtMbn;rbs;rdæaPi)al

kñúgtMbn; edaymankarshkarCamYynieyaCk nigsßab½nbNþúHbNþalbMNinkñúgtMbn;

Gacpþl;GtßRbeyaCn_tamry³karsñak;enAkñúgsalaeron nigkarTTYl)ankaryl;dwg

bec©keTs edIm,I[køayCakmµkrCMnaj.

x¦ karbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;karelIkkm<s;KuNPaB nigPaBBak;B½n§nwgTIpSarenAéf¶xagmux

enAéf¶xagmux km<úCanwgRtÚveFVIkMENTRmg;kmµviFIsikSaenAkRmitmFümsikSa nigBRgwgkar

TTYlxusRtÚvrbs;shKmn_ nigsalaeronpgEdr.

EpnkarTI1 ³ kMENTRmg;kmµviFIsikSamFümsikSa edIm,IelIkkm<s;karbeRgónmuxviC¢a

viTüasa®sþ KNitviTüa visVkmµ nigmuxviC¢abec©keTsepSgeTot PaBCashRKin nig

bMNinCIvit

tamry³karRtÜtBinitüelIyuT§sa®sþGPivDÆn_esdækic©km<úCa RksYgGb;rMxitxMRbwgERbg

CafµI edIm,IEksRmÜlkmµviFIsikSa CaBiesskarepþatkarykcitþTukdak;elImuxviC¢a

bec©keTsvij nigEkERbviFIsa®sþbeRgón[kan;EtTMenIbCagmun. karxitxMRbwgERbgenH

epþatkarykcitþTukdak;elIkarbNþúHbNþalRKÚbeRgón EdlGacbMeBjbEnßmelIkar

elIkkm<s;kmµviFIbeRgónKNitviTüaenAfñak;dMbUgrbs;RksYgGb;rM yuvCn nigkILa enA

kRmitbzmsikSa. enAkRmit]tþmsikSa k¾mankarrBRgwgkmµviFIsikSa y:agehacNas;

enARKwHsßan ]tþmsikSamYyEdrxagEpñkviTüasa®sþ KNitviTüa visVkmµ nigbec©kviTüa

B½t’man EdlGacsakl,g nigelIkykyuT§sa®sþmkBicarNakñúgkareFVIkMENTRmg;

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 50: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

40

enA]tþmsikSanaeBlxagmux. bTBiesaFn_kñúgkarelIkkm<s;viFIsa®sþþbeRgónKNitviTüa

nigviTüasa®sþ[kan;EtRbesIreLIg TTYl)anBIRbeTsmYycMnYn dUcCa hVaMgLg; nig

sigðburI ehIyfµI²enHBITIRkúgesogéhenARbeTscin.

krNIsikSaCak;Esþg nigkargarKeRmagGacykmkeRbIR)as;sRmab;CamUldæankñúgkar

sakl,g edIm,ICaCMnYykñúgkarGPivDÆbMNin shRKin. pÞúyeTAvijkmµviFIsikSaEbbenH

k¾Gacykmkdak;bBa©ÚlenAfñak;mFümsikSa nig]tþmsikSa b:uEnþtamry³bTBiesaFn_

GnþrCati kmµviFIsikSaenHCab;Tak;Tgy:agxøaMgeBldak;bBa©ÚleTAkñúgkmµviFIsikSaenA

sßab½nbNþúHbNþaleRkARbB½n§ Edl[mnusSeBjv½ysBVéf¶kMBugmankargareFVI nig

eFVIkar[GñkepSgseRmcbMNgkñúgkarebIkCMnYjedayxøÜnÉgenaH. kmµviFITaMgenHGac

pþl;CaviFIsa®sþd¾mansar³RbeyaCn_dl;Gñk Edlcg;køayCashRKinkñúgkarelIkkm<s;

lT§pleFVICMnYj. Tak;TgnwgbMNinCIvit kmµviFIsikSaenAkRmitmFümsikSa Gacsakl,g

beRgónemeronsþIBIbMNinCIvittUc²epSgeTot ehIyk¾KYrmankarRtÜtBinitü nigvaytémø

elIkarsakl,genH muneBlykmkdak;bBa©ÚlenAkñúgkmµviFIsikSaenaH.

EpnkarTI2 ³ BRgwgkarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;shKmn_ nigsalaeron EdlCaEpñkmYyén

dMeNIrvimCÄkar nigvishmCÄkar

dMeNIrkarvimCÄkar nigvishmCÄkar EdlkMBugEtbnþGnuvtþenAkm<úCaenaH pþl;»kaskñúg

karelIkkm<s;ÉkraCüPaB nigkarTTYlxusRtÚvral;lT§plénkarGb;rMenAkRmitmUldæan.

kñúgbribTvimCÄkar nigvishmCÄkar nigkMENTRmg;rdæ)alfñak;Cati RksYgGb;rM yuvCn

nigkILa GacshkarCamYyRksYgepSgeTotkñúgkarkMNt;BItYnaTI nigmuxgarsRmab;

karRKb;RKgfñak;eRkamCati. EpñkCaeRcIndUcCa karRtÜtBinitü karvaytémø karRKb;RKg

kargar karEbgEckmuxgar[)ansmrmüenAfñak;RKb;RKgepSg² Tak;TgnwgkarGb;rM

suxaPi)al nigvis½ysgÁmepSgeTot GacCYysRmÜl[karRKb;RKgmanlT§plkan;Et

RbesIreLIgkñúgbribTvimCÄkar. yuT§sa®sþrYmenARKb;vis½y GacCYysRmÜldl;kar

ksagsmtßPaB EdlcaM)ac;sRmab;m®nþIRKb;RKgfñak;eRkamCati nigbuKÁliksikSa.

BiessCagenHeTot eKalkarN_ENnaMsþIBIkarRKb;RKgsala rYmbBa©ÚlTaMgKMnitpþÜc

epþImkarsakl,gpgenaH dUcCa KMnitpþÜcepþImbegáItb½NÑr)aykarN_salaeronGac

CMruj[shKmn_ nigRkúmRbwkSaXuM cUlrYmkñúgkarRtÜtBinitükargarsala nigbegáIt

EpnkarskmµPaB edIm,IelIkkm<s;karRKb;RKgkarbeRgónrbs;RKÚ.

¬4¦ karBRgwgRbsiT§PaBhirBaØb,TankñúgkarGPivDÆbMNin

manbBaðaBIrekIteLIgenAeBlEbgEckkarcMNayeTAelIkarGPivDÆbMNin. bBaðaTImYy KWsþIBIrebob

ekorKrFnFankñúgvis½ysaFarN³ nigÉkCnenAdMNak;kalnImYy²énvdþCIvit ehIyTIBIr KWsþIBI

rebobcMNayFnFan EdlGacbegáIt[manR)ak;elIkTwkcitþsRmab;karbMeBjkargar)anl¥ nig

KNenyüPaBsRmab;lT§plkargar. bBaðaTaMgenH k¾ekItmanenAkñúgvis½yÉkCnepSgeTotpg

Edr ehIyminRtwmEtkarGPivDÆbMNinb:ueNÑaHeT kareqøIytbk¾tRmÚv[mankarpSarP¢ab;CamYy

eTAnwgeKalkarN_hirBaØb,TansaFarN³[)anl¥pgEdr dUcCaGñkEdlTTYl)anRbeyaCn_eRcIn

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 51: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

41

CageKKYrTTYlxusRtÚvelIkarcMNay. CaBiess kñúgkarGPivDÆbMNinTak;TgnwgkargarEdlRKÜsar

nigGñkeFVICMnYjGacdwgedaypÞal;BIRbeyaCn_énkarGPivDÆbMNin nigEckrMElkbnÞúkhirBaØvtßú.

k¦ skmµPaBRtÚvGnuvtþbnÞan;kñúgkarBRgwgRbsiT§PaBhirBaØb,Tan edIm,IkarGPivDÆbMNin

edaysarskmµPaBenHCaskmµPaBGaTiPaBbnÞan; rdæaPi)alKYrbegáInkarcMNayelIviFIsa®sþ

EbgEckfvika tRmg;TisRKÜsar[manRbsiT§PaB edIm,IrkSaGRtasikSaKg;vgS.

skmµPaBTI1 ³ BRgIkviFIsa®sþpþl;hirBaØb,TantRmg;TisRKÜsar edIm,IGRtaKg;vgSén

karsikSa

bTBiesaFn_d¾l¥rbs;km<úCakñúgkarGnuvtþkmµviFIGaharUbkrN_ edIm,IbegáInkarcuHeQµaH

cUleronenAmFümsikSa pþl;nUvemeronmansar³sMxan;bEnßmeTot. bTBiesaFn_TaMgenH

bgðajfa kmµviFICMnYyhirBaØvtßú CakmµviFImanRbsiT§PaB EdlGac[kumarenAbnþkar

sikSaeTot)an. kmµviFIRsedogKñaenHGacykmkBicarNasRmab;karGb;rM bNþúH-

bNþalbec©keTs nigviC¢aCIv³ edaymankarshkarCamYyvis½yÉkCnepSgeTotpg

Edr. bTBiesaFn_enARbeTsmYycMnYn dUcCa GaemrikLaTIn \NÐÚensuI nigbg;køaeds

)anbgðajBIPaBeCaKC½yénkmµviFITaMgenH kñúgkarCMruj[manGRtasikSaKg;vgS nig

bBa©b;kmµviFIsikSa.

x¦ karbegáItmUldæanRKwHsRmab;RbsiT§PaBhirBaØb,TanenAeBlGnaKt

enAéf¶xagmux rdæaPi)alRtÚvbegáInkarcMNayelIkarGnþraKmEdlcMNaytickñúgdMNak;kal

dMbUgénCIvitrbs;kumartUc nigrkviFIsa®sþEbgEckfvikaepSg² edIm,IbegáInR)ak;elIkTwkcitþ

cMeBaHlT§plkargarl¥kñúgcMeNamsßab½nbNþúHbNþalCMnaj rYmTaMgRKwHsßan]tþmsikSa

pgEdr.

EpnkarTI1 ³ begáInkarcMNayelIbTGnþraKmn_ EdlmankarcMNaytictYcenAdMNak;kal

dMbUgénvdþCIvit

edaykarbnþninñakarénkarbegáIncMNaysaFarN³elIkarGb;rM EdlCacMENkmYyén

plitplkñúgRsúksrub km<úCaRtÚveRbIR)as;FnFanEdlmanRsab; edIm,IEklm¥elIkar

erobcM[kumar[TTYl)anbMNinsRmab;eFVIkargar nigTTYl)anCMnajsRmab;kargardMbUg

ehIyk¾nwgtRmÚv[manfvikabEnßmpgEdr ]TahrN_ edIm,ITTYl)ansUcnakrénkarvivtþ

sMxan;rbs;RksYgGb;rM yuvCn nigkILa EdlmaneKalbMNg ¬1¦ BRgIkvisalPaB

énkarGb;rMedaycab;epþImkmµviFIGb;rMkumartUc nigkarbBa©b;fñak;enAkRmitbzmsikSa

elIkkm<s;KuNPaB nigRbsiT§PaBesvaGb;rM rYmman karkat;bnßyGRtaRtÜtfñak;kñúg

sala nigkarbegáInkarvaytémøsþg;dafñak;CatielIlT§plsikSarbs;sisS. eKaledA

cm,gBIrxagelIenH nwgKaMRTdl;karbNþúHbNþalRKÚbeRgón nigRbB½n§vaytémøfñak;Cati

k¾dUcCasmtßPaBrbs;RKÜsarRkIRkkñúgkar[kUnrbs;BYkeKcUleronpgEdr.

kñúgn½yenH karEbgEckhirBaØvtßúrbs;rdæaPi)al KYrepþatelIsar³sMxan;énkarGb;rMkumar

tUcsRmab;karGPivDÆmUlFnmnusS edIm,ITTYl)ansgÁmmanGñkecHdwg nigesdækic©

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 52: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

42

rIkceRmIn nigbegáInCMnYykñúgkarvinieyaK[manRbsiT§PaBcMNayelIkumartUc. bT-

BiesaFn_GnþrCati)anbgðajfa kareFVIEbbenHGacmanRbsiT§PaBtamry³kmµviFIepþat

elIkarKaMBarsgÁm dUcCa karepÞrsac;R)ak;edaymankarTTYlxusRtÚveTAvijeTAmkelI

karGPivDÆkumareRkamyuT§sa®sþKaMBarsgÁmCatikm<úCa. karepÞrsac;R)ak;TaMgenHGac

eFVIeTA)anGaRs½yelIkarcUlrYmkñúgGnþraKmn_énRbsiT§PaBcMNay rYmman GaharUbtßmÖ

suxPaB mata nigTark RBmTaMgkarGb;rMmatabita nigkumartUc ehIydUcKñaenHEdr

RKÜsark¾TTYl)ankmµviFIGaharUbkrN_eRkamlkçxNÐ[kUnbnþkarsikSaenAsalapgEdr.

EpnkarTI2 ³ EsVgrkviFIsa®sþEbgEckhirBaØb,Tannana edIm,ICMruj[mankarelIkTwkcitþ

cMeBaH

sßab½nEdlmanlT§plbNþúHbNþall¥ kñúgcMeNamsßab½nbNþúHbNþalbMNin rYmTaMg

RKwHsßan]tþmsikSa. kMENTRmg;EdlmaneCaKC½yenAfñak;GnþrCatimaneKaledA ¬1¦

karEbgEckfvikatamkargar ¬2¦ kareRbIR)as;mUlniFisRmab;GPivDÆn_bMNin Edlman

karRbkYtRbECg nig ¬3¦ karpþl;GMNacdl;GñkTTYlpltamry³kareRbIR)as;skçIb½Rt

nigRBwtþbRtsikSasRmab;karGPivDÆbMNin EdlcMNayeBlevlaeRcIn. tamry³

Pñak;garCMnajCati SENCE RbeTsQIlI )anCMruj[manesvaRbesIrCagmunBIsßab½n

bNþúHbNþalbMNinsaFarN³ nigÉkCntamry³karTTYl)anesvaTaMgenH edayman

karRbkYtRbECg. RbeTsGU®sþalI kMBugcat;viFankñúgkarbegáInkarRbkYtRbECg nig

Fana[manvKÁbNþúHbNþalBak;B½n§ edayeRbIR)as;skçIb½RtCak;lak;.

yuT§sa®sþpþl;hirBaØb,TantamtRmÚvkar )anpøas;bþÚrRkbx½NÐkarpþl;R)ak;elIkTwkcitþ

dl;kargar edaykarpþl;GMNacdl;GñkTTYlplénkarGPivDÆbMNin. sRmab;vis½y

saFarN³ viFIsa®sþTaMgenHCMruj[mankarepþatelIlT§plénkarbNþúHbNþal edIm,I

EksRmÜlkarcMNayelIvis½ysaFarN³. edaysarfa km<úCa)anGnuvtþknøgmkkñúg

kmµviFIskçIb½RteRkamKeRmag ADB TVET b¤kmµviFIGaharUbkrN_ eTIbmankarbegáIt

nigeFVIetsþelIkmµviFIsakl,gkñúgry³eBlmYyxøI edaymankarRtÜtBinitü nigvaytémø

y:aghµt;ct;elIRbsiT§PaBénkmµviFITaMgenH edIm,IseRmc)ankarbegáIteKalneya)ay

naeBlxagmux.

ynþkarhirBaØb,TansRmab;karGb;rM]tþmsikSa tRmÚv[mankarBRgwgRbsiT§PaB nig

tmøaPaB. edayehtufakarekIneLIgy:agqab;rh½sénkarGb;rMkRmit]tþmsikSa nig

CMnYyhirBaØvtßúsaFarN³tictYcenAtamRKwHsßan]tþmsikSa fvikaRbmUl)anBIRKwHsßan

saFarN³ nigÉkCn GacKaMRT[mannirnþrPaBhirBaØb,TanyUrGEgVg. RksYgGb;rM

yuvCn nigkILa nwgRtÚvvaytémøBIkareRbIR)as;FnFansRmab;karGb;rM]tþmsikSa nigkar

EkERbGaceFVI)antamry³ynþkarhirBaØb,TanEdlmanRsab;kñúgRKwHsßan]tþmsikSa.

3>2 karGnuvtþEpnkarskmµPaB nigkarBicarNaelIyuT§sa®sþ[)anTUlMTUlay

bTBiesaFn_TTYl)anBIRbeTskm<úCa nigRbeTsepSgeTotbgðajfa EpnkarskmµPaBKYrman

ry³eBlkMNt;rYm nigTsSn³RtwmRtÚv karRtÜtBinitünigbgðajBIlT§pl. sUcnakrkargarsMxan;²

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 53: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

43

KYrykmkkMNt; edIm,IeFVIkarRtYtBinitü. sUcnakrTaMgenH KYrbBa©ÚlcMNucedAsRmab;RtÜtBiniitü

nigsUcnakrénplb:HBal;cugeRkaytamkarvaytémøy:aghµt;ct;. karEbgEckkarTTYlxusRtÚv

c,as;las;kñúgkarGnuvtþ nigkarRtÜtBinitühµt;ct; nwgmansarRbeyaCn_dl;karGnuvtþskmµPaB

tameBlevlakMNt;. skmµPaBeRKagxagelIpþl;[manCeRmIsCak;lak; EdlGaceFVICaFnFan

sRmab;kic©BiPakSarvagrdæaPi)al nigPaKIBak;B½n§epSgeTotkñúgkarbegáItEpnkarskmµPaB.

edIm,IsRmÜldl;karBiPakSa nigkarGnuvtþ rdæaPi)alKYrbegáIt {shKmn_bMNin} mYy. shKmn_

GacbBa©Úlm®nþIfñak;kNþalkñúgRksYg nigvis½yÉkCn RBmTaMgTIPñak;garrdæaPi)alpgEdr. bT-

BiesaFn_GnþrCati)anbgðaj[dwgfa shKmn_EbbenH GacmanRbsiT§PaBkñúgkarelIkkm<s;kic©

BiPakSaeKalneya)ay nigGaceFVICatMNagkñúgkareFVIkMENTRmg;enAeBlGnuvtþ. shKmn_TaMg

enH maneKaledAbegáIteLIgeTAtameBlevlakMNt;NamYy edIm,IbMeBjtamtRmÚvkarkñúgeBl

Cak;lak; cUlrYmkñúgvKÁbNþúHbNþal nigEckrMElkkaryl;dwg nigpSBVpSaysMeNIkMENTRmg;kñúg

vis½yEdlBYkeKykcitþTukdak;.

cugeRkayenH edaymankarBicarNaelIrebobvar³énkarGPivDÆbMNinsRmab;ry³eBlmFüm

km<úCaGacGnum½tyuT§sa®sþrYmdUc)anelIkeLIgenAkñúgRkbx½NÐGPivDÆn_bMNinvdþCIvit ¬rUbPaBTI

11¦. Rkbx½NÐxagTsSn³samBaØmYyeQµaHfa bMNinedIm,ITTYl)ankargar nigplitPaB

(STEP) GacCYyGñkerobcMeKalneya)aybegáItRbB½n§ Edlpþl;bMNinnaMeTArkplitPaBx<s; nig

karrIkceRmInxøaMg. RsbeBlkm<úCaTMngCaTTYl)anlT§plx<s;bMput edaykarepþatelICMhanTaMg

bIdMbUgxagelI enaHkarbNþúHbNþalPaBCashRKin ¬eRkamCMhanTI 4¦ nigkarsRmbsRmÜl

[TTYl)anB½t’man ¬eRkamCMhanTI 5¦ Edl)anBiPakSaxagelI caM)ac;RtÚvEkERbCMnajeTACa

plitPaBkargar[manRbsiT§PaBvij. yuT§sa®sþrYm KYrEp¥kelIkarviPaK edayhµt;ct;BImUlehtu

énkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNin nigEp¥kelIkarvaytémøBIRbsiT§PaBéneKalneya)ay

nigskmµPaBEdl)anGnuvtþknøgmk.

RbPB ³ FnaKarBiPBelak ¬2010 X¦

karcab;epþImRtwmRtÚv * GaharUbtßmÖ

* karbMb:nR)aCJa nig

Gakb,kiriya

karGb;rMR)aCJamUldæan¼mFüm* sþg;dakarsikSa

* RKÚ

* FnFan

* brisßan eKarBbTbBa¢a

karbNþúHbMNinTak;Tgnwg kargar* vKÁbNþúHbNþalviBaØabnbRt

Can;x<s; nigBiess

* kmµviFI {skmµ} nig

bNþúHbNþalsRmab;

vis½yeRkARbB½n§

* karGb;rMviC¢aCIv³ nig

]tþmsikSa

* tYnaTIkñúgkarbNþúHbNþal

pþl;edayRkúmh‘un

* kareronsURteBjmYyCIvit

cMenHdwg B½t’man nvanuvtþn_ nigshRKas* PaBCaédKUrvag

saklviTüal½y nig

Rkúmh‘un¼]sSahkmµ

* ]btþmÖFn nvanuvtþn_¼

karbNþúHbNþal

* RbB½n§B½t’mansaFarN³

* karKaMRTkarGPivDÆ

cMeNHdwg

* karbNþúHbNþal nigKaMRT

shRKin

kareqøIytbkargar karpøas;bþÚrkargar nigkarEsVgrkkargar* sRmbsRmÜlkarTTYl)an

B½t’man ¬tRmÚvkarTIpSarkargar

sRmab;bMNinxusKña CMnYyEsVg

rkkargar RbB½n§TTYlsÁal;

KuNPaB¦

* sRmbsRmÜlkarxkxanTIpSar

rbs;RkumCak;lak; ¬]> yuvCn

®sþI Rkúmminrab;bBa©Úl¦

* c,ab;kargar edIm,IFanara:b;rg

sgÁm[manRbsiT§PaB

kMeNInplitPaB nigesdækic©rUbPaB 12 ³ RbB½n§KaMRTdl;karGPivDÆbMNinkñúgvdþCIvit

skmµPaB nigyuT§sa®sþsRmab;bMNin edIm,IelIkkm<s;karGPivDÆesdækic©km<úCa

Page 54: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

44

kMNt;smÁal;enH erobcMeLIgbnÞab;BIr)aykarN_rbs;FnaKarBiPBelakqñaM2010 sþIBIkarpþl;bMNinsRmab;smFm’

nigPaBrIkceRmIn nigbEnßmBIelIkMNt;smÁal; qñaM2010 rbs;FnaKarBiPBelaksþIBIkarGnuvtþyuT§sa®sþkMeNInrbs;

RbeTskm<úCaeRkayeBlmanvibtþi. kMNt;smÁal;enH Ep¥kelIkic©BiPakSakñúgebskkmµKaMBarsgÁmrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak

kalBIExvicäika qñaM2010 nigEp¥kelIkarCECkBiPakSaeKalneya)ayenAevTikaesdækic©km<úCa qñaM2011. kMNt;smÁal;enH

maneKalbMNgKaMRTrdæaPi)alkñúgkarkMNt;skmµPaB edIm,IedaHRsay]bsKÁCakatBVkic© nigkarRBagyuT§sa®sþbMNin

rbs;RbeTskm<úCasRmab;eBlGnaKt. sUmeFVIkarENnaMedaysYrCasMnYr nigpþl;eyabl;eTA Hana Brixi EdlCa

RbFanRkúmsRmab;kmµviFIKaMBarsgÁmrbs;FnaKarBiPBelakkñúgRbeTskm<úCa ([email protected]).

sRmab;karBiPakSa sUmemIlÉksarrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak ¬qñaM2010 a¦

yuT§sa®sþctuekaNrbs;RbeTskm<úCa edIm,IPaBrIkceRmInkargar smFm’ nigRbsiT§PaB epþatelIvis½ymYycMnYn dUcCa ³

ksikmµ RbB½n§Twk nigFarasa®sþ ehdæarcnasm<½n§KmnaKmn_ GKÁisnI karGPivDÆFnFanmnusS ]sSahkmµGtiBlkmµ nig

]sSahkmµplitGaharsRmab;naMecj eTscrN_ eRbg ]sµ½n FmµCati nigEr:epSg²eTot bec©kviTüaB½t’man¼KmnaKmn_

nigCMnYj.

rdæaPi)al)ankMNt;vis½yGaTiPaBcMnYn 19 Edlcat;TukCaEpñkényuT§sa®sþsmahrNkmµCMnYjrbs;xøÜn³ Rsaebor

RKab;sVaycnÞI dMLÚgeQI eBat Clpl Es,keCIg kat;edr karciBa©wmstV Ggár ekAs‘U sURt sENþkesog EpøeQI nig

bEnø plitpleQI smaKmhtßkmµFunRsal eTscrN_ esvaBlkmµ ¬rYmTaMgkarsagsg;¦ esvaTak;TgnwgkardwkCBa¢Ún

dMeNIrkarGaCIvkmµ¼esvatamRbB½n§GIuneFIeNt.

bBaðaRbQmEpñksRmbsRmÜl nigB½t’man sßitkñúg]bsKÁbIsMxan;² TnÞwmnwgbBaðaRbQménFnbRmug nigtémøGKÁisnI

nigPsþúParEdlraraMgPaBrIkceRmInrbs;RbeTskm<úCa ¬FnaKarBiPBelak qñaM2010 A¦. bBaðaRbQmEpñkFnbRmug

sMedAelIRbB½n§Gn;exSayrbs;RbeTskm<úCakñúgkaredaHRsayCemøaH nigkarRbqaMgGMeBIBukrlYy. témøGKÁisnIx<s; nig

éføedIm nigPsþúParEdlminGacTukcitþ)an ¬rYmTaMgCMnYj¦ raraMgshRKinBIkarcUlrYmkñúgKeRmag EdlGacdMeNIrkar)an.

vismPaBR)ak;cMNUlkñúgRbeTskm<úCamankRmitx<s;eTAtamsþg;datMbn; edaymanemKuN Gini Qandl; 45°. sRmab;

Tinñn½y sUmemIlTinñn½ymUldæantamdanPaBRkIRkenAtMbn;GasIubUBa’.

RsedognwgTinñn½yrbs;viTüasßanCatisßitipgEdr ¬qñaM2010¦ karGegátRbCasa®sþ nigsuxPaBkm<úCa ¬qñaM2011¦ bgðaj

BIkarFøak;cuHénGRtapþl;kMeNItsrubBI 4/0 kñúgqñaM2000 dl; 3/0 kñúgqñaM2010.

sRmab;karviPaK sUmemIl Di Gropello nig Sakellariou ¬qñaM2010¦. RbeTsEdl)aneFVIkarGegát rYmman RbeTs

km<úCa cin \NÐÚensIu m:ugehÁalI hVIlIBIn éf nigevotNam. karsikSakMNt;nieyaCitEdlmanCMnajfaCanieyaCitEdl

mankarGb;rMmFümsikSaTutiyPUmi nigkarGb;rMx<s;CagenH.

Éksareyag

Page 55: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

45

FnaKarBiPBelakqñaM2010 x nig HRINC qñaM2011. karGegátedayRbúgRby½tñsþIBInieyaCk nignieyaCit caM)ac;

RtÚvpþl;PsþútagEdlGacTukcitþ)anTak;TgnwgvisalPaB nigRbePTCak;lak;énkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNin.

naeBlfµI²enH mCÄmNÐlGPivDÆn_bMNinkm<úCa )ankMNt;BIGaTiPaBelIkarbNþúHbNþalrbs;nieyaCky:agl¥itl¥n;faCa

EpñkénkarsikSamYy EdlRtÚvrkSakarsm¶at;edayelIkeLIgBIcMNucsMxan;²énbMNinTMnak;TMngrvagbuKÁl bMNinFnFan

mnusS nigTMnak;TMngviC¢aCIv³ bMNinEpñklk; nigTIpSar bMNinFurkic© nigKitelx nigbMNinRKb;RKghirBaØvtßú.

]TahrN_ sUmemIlkarelIkeLIgrbs; Heckman, Stixrud nig Urzua ¬qñaM2005¦. CaTUeTA karGPivDÆkumartUccab;

epþImBIeBlEdlkumarmanGayucab;BIR)aMmYydl;R)aMbIqñaM.

sRmab;Tinñn½yrbs;RbeTsCaeRcIneTot sUmemIlsUcnakrGPivDÆn_BiPBelak ¬qñaM2010¦.

GayucUleronpøÚvkarrbs;RbeTskm<úCaenAkRmitbzmsikSa KWRsbeTAtamkarGnuvtþrbs;GnþrCati

EMIS qñaM2009

]TahrN_ sUmemIl Bishop nig Mane ¬qñaM2005¦ nig OECD ¬qñaM2010¦

lT§plGegát)anmkBI CSES qñaM 2009 nig HRINC qñaM 2011

sRmab;B½t’manlm¥it sUmGan CAMFEBA ¬qñaM 2008¦

sRmab;]TahrN_ nigkarviPaKnana sUmGankMNt;RtakargaryuvCnrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak

tamry³eKhTMB½r www.youth-employment-inventory.org/

kMNt;RtakargaryuvCnrbs;FnaKarBiPBelak manenAeKhTMB½r www.youth-employment-inventory.org/

karyl;dwgBImUlehtuénkarxVHxat nigPaBminsmRsbénbMNin TamTar[mankarBinitüemIlTIpSarEdlmanskþanuBl

nigkarbraC½yénGPi)alkic©EdlbegVógtRmÚvkar nigkarpþl;bMNinBI {kRmitl¥bMputénsgÁm} nigb:HBal;dl;PaBsmRsb

rvagtRmÚvkarbMNin nigkarpþl;bMNinkñúgTIpSarkargar. karbraC½ymYycMnYn Cab;Bak;B½n§nwgrcnasm<½n§énRbB½n§Gb;rM nig

karbNþúHbNþal ehIymYycMnYneTotTak;Tgnwg]bsKÁEdlbuKÁlmñak;² CYbRbTHkñúgkarTTYl)anB½t’man nigR)ak;km©I

ehIymYycMnYneTot CaFmµtaqøúHbBa©aMgBIPaBexSayéncMeNHdwgkñúgRKÜsar. lkçN³sm,tþiCak;lak;énTIpSarplitpl

nigkargar k¾GacCH\T§iBldl;shRKaskñúgkarpþl;R)ak;elIkTwkcitþsRmab;nieyaCittamCMnajCak;lak; b¤nieyaCitEdl

mankarbNþúHbNþal nignieyaCit[manCMnajkan;Etx<s;.

smaKmnieyaCkÉkCn dUcCa CAMFEBA b¤TIPñak;garRsavRCavkñúgRsúk GacCYykñúgkarGegátenH)an EdlGacbegáIt

»kaskargarkan;EtRcInkñúgkarbNþúHbNþal nigkarksagsmtßPaBrbs;yuvCn.

dUcEdl)anbBa¢ak;tamry³Rbsasn_rbs;naykrdæm®nþI h‘un Esn naykrdæm®nþIRbeTskm<úCaenARBwtþikarN_TaMgBIrkar

pþÜcepþImenH)anykmkeFVIkarsakl,g nigvaytémøeRkamKeRmagRTRTg;vis½yGb;rMenAkm<úCa ]btßmÖedayFnaKarBiPBelak

edIm,IRbmUl nigviPaKbTBiesaFn_matabita nigshKmn_ nigCMruj[matabitamankarykcitþTukdak;kan;EtxøaMg nigtRmÚv

[mankarEklm¥BIsalaeron.

yuT§sa®sþKaMBarsgÁmCatikm<úCaTTYl)ankarGnum½tBIsemþcnaykrdæm®nþI nigkic©RbCuMKN³rdæm®nþIeBjGgÁ kñúgExmIna

qñaM2011.

Éksareyag

Page 56: Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afñadocuments.worldbank.org/curated/en/443801468015068382/pdf/673490KHME… · Public Disclosure Authorized bMeBjbMNgR)afña Public Disclosure

THE WORLD BANKFnaKarBiPBelak113 mhavifIRBHneratþmraCFanIPñMeBjTUrs½BÞelx ³ +855 ¬0¦23 217 304eKhTMB½r ³ www.worldbank.org/kh