Accessible Learning design, implementation and...
Transcript of Accessible Learning design, implementation and...
Accessible Learning design, implementation and accreditation
WP3:Developmentofthetraining,assessmentandaccreditation
R3.2ALdiatrainingprogramme:
Descriptionofmethodologiesandtools
Developedby
FondoFormacionEuskadiwww.ffeuskadi.net
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
Projectinformation
Projectacronym: ALdia
Projecttitle: Accessible Learning Design implementation and
Accreditation
Agreementnumber: 2015-3425/001-001
ProjectReferenceNumber: 562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD
Sub-programmeorKA: Key Action 3: Support for policy reform - Initiatives for
policyinnovation
Projectwebsite: www.aldia-project.eu
Authoringpartner: FondoFormacionEuskadi
Reportversion: 2.0
Dateofpreparation: 02.12.2016
Documenthistory:Date Version Author(s) Description10.10.2016 1.0 MartaPalacio Draftversion02.12.2016 2.0 MartaPalacio Incorporatedfeedbackfrompartners
andconclusionsofthedesignmeetingsonv.1.0.
©ALdia–AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation2016WiththesupportoftheErasmus+ProgrammeoftheEuropeanUnion.Disclaimer:TheEuropeanCommissionsupportfortheproductionofthispublicationdoesnotconstituteendorsement of the contents which reflects the views only of the authors, and theCommissioncannotbeheldresponsibleforanyusewhichmaybemadeoftheinformationcontainedtherein.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
Tableofcontents 1.Introduction..........................................................................................................................1
2.ObjectivesoftheALdiatrainingprogramme:descriptionofmethodologiesandtools.......3
3.ALdialearningapproachandmethodology..........................................................................5
3.1.ALdialearningapproach..................................................................................................5
3.2.ALdiaMethodology.........................................................................................................6
4.SharingthebackgroundknowledgeofALdiapartners.......................................................10
4.1.Methodologies..............................................................................................................10
4.2.Tools.............................................................................................................................14
5.Designmeetingsgeneraloverview.....................................................................................21
5.1.ItalianDesignGroup–Keyfindings..............................................................................21
5.2.SpanishDesignGroup–Keyfindings............................................................................23
5.3.GreekDesignGroup–Keyfindings..............................................................................25
6.References...........................................................................................................................27
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
1
1.Introduction
ThisdocumenthasbeendevelopedwithintheframeworkoftheALdia-AccessibleLearning
Design implementation and Accreditation project. ALdia is a project co-funded by the
European programme Key Action 3: Support for policy reform - Initiatives for policy
innovation.
ThemainobjectiveoftheALdiaprojectistoreducedisparitiesinlearningoutcomesaffecting
learnersfromdisadvantagedbackgroundsandtomainstreamtheequalaccessprinciplesand
practicesintoalleducationsectorsandlevelsinEuropeandbeyond.TheALdiaprojectaims
to establish new knowledge and explore the feasibility of a new accreditation that will
prepare and deploy theHE and VET education professionalworkforce for equity, diversity
andinclusionthroughtheuseofnewandcreativepedagogiesandtools.ALdiaactivitiesare
expectedtosupportpeoplewithdisabilitiestoobtainhigherqualificationsandfacilitatetheir
transition to the labourmarket. To this direction, ALdia will design and develop aMOOC
(Massive Open Online collaborative Course) to prepare the education professionals for
equity,diversityandinclusioninlearningprocessandcertifythemwiththequalificationsof
inclusiveeducation.
TheALdia training programme:Description of methodologies and tools is a deliverable of
WP3“Developmentofthetraining,assessmentandaccreditation”,which isthecentralWP
totheprojectimplementationasitwilldeliverthemajorprojectresults:
• Eighttrainingmodules,
• Eightself-assessmenttests
• Thirty-twopeer-assessmentassignments
• Onefinalexam
The trainingmodulesarebasedon the findingsof thepreviousWP2todevelop innovative
and flexible techniques that respond to specific education needs and promote inclusive
learningandequality.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
2
The programmewill abide by the EuropeanQualifications Framework for lifelong learning
(EQF) and the European Credit System for Vocational Education and Training (ECVET)
standards.
The main objective of this WP is firstly to define the ALdia training, assessment and
accreditationframework,takingintoconsiderationtheoutputsofthepreviousWP2inorder
toturnthetargetgroups’specificneedsintospecificlearningoutcomes;secondlytodevelop
thetrainingmaterial,eightALdiatrainingmodulestoremoveorreduceinadvertentbarriers
whichpreventdisabledstudentsfromsuccessfullyparticipatingincoursesandprogrammes
of study; and finally, design the assessment and accreditation, in order to assess the
competencesacquiredbythetrainees.
To this purpose, the WP3 will deliver, apart from the training modules (R3.3) and the
assessment exams (R3.4), different documents that are directly linked between them and
withthenexttasks:
• ALdiatrainingprogramme:descriptionofmethodologyandtools(R3.2),
• ALdiatrainingprogramme–aguide(R3.5),
• ALdiaprogramme-trainers’guide(R3.6),
• ALdiaprogramme-trainee’sguide(R3.7).
DuringthisWPthefocusgroupsineachcountrywillbeaskedtomeetagaininordertogive
their opinions on the ALdia training methodology and tools. Their members will include
experiencededucationandaccreditationprofessionals,whocancontributetothedefinition
ofthemostappropriatetrainingandassessmentpedagogicalapproaches.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
3
2.ObjectivesoftheALdiatrainingprogramme:descriptionofmethodologiesandtools
The main goal of this document is to be a concrete and useful instrument providing a
commonbackgroundofmethodologyandtools tobeadoptedbypartners in thedesignof
theALdiaTrainingProgrammefortheeffectivetrainingofthetargetgroups.
Thedocumentisstructuredintotwomainsections:
• ThefirstoneaimsatdefiningtheALdia learningapproachandmethodologywithin
theALdiaConsortium.
• The second section consists in a common understanding of the meaning of
methodologyandacollectionofpracticalexamplesoftoolsprovidedbypartnersas
patrimonytobeusedamongtheentireConsortium.
Themain beneficiarieswithin the ALdia project are both theHigh Education professionals
andVocationalandEducationalTrainingproviderswhoarethetargetgroupofALdiatraining
programme.Nevertheless,thisdocumentcouldbeusedbyallthoseinvolvedindealingwith
amethodologicalapproachinthedevelopmentofthetrainingcourse.
Themainchallengehighlightedbythisdocumentistofindtheappropriatemethodologyand
tools that respond to the target group's specific needs in terms of skills to prepare the
education professionals for equity, diversity and inclusion in learning process and certify
themwiththequalificationsofinclusiveeducation.
ThisreporttakesintoaccountthepreviousALdiareports1wherewehavedefinedtheneeds
of studentwith disabilities fromGreece, Spain and Italy in both higher education andVET
sectors, and the technical and contextual requirements for the ALdia virtual e-learning
platform (the general layout of the Platform, the Users and their involvement, Moodle’s
technical aspects regarding Accessibility Specifications and sets the learning design
specifications).
1R2.2SupportingstudentswithdisabilityinHEandVET:aneedsanalysis,developedbyFourElements,2016.R2.3ALdiaTrainingandCertificationStrategy,developedbyCESIE,2016.R2.4SpecificationsoftheALdiaVirtualLearningEnvironment,developedbyUPRC,2016.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
4
Apartfromthat,thisreporttakesunderconsiderationtheoutcomesofthedesignmeetings
organizedwithexperiencededucationandaccreditationprofessionalsinthethreecountries
(R3.1:Designmeetingsontrainingpedagogyandtools).
Anotherchallengeconsists ingivingthebasis tocreateanoverallhomogeneityofcontents
despite the diversity among all the consortium partners. Therefore, diversity should be
pointedoutasaresourceinfavourofthehomogeneity.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
5
3.ALdialearningapproachandmethodology
3.1.ALdialearningapproach
Basedonthisneedsanalysis,AldiaMassiveOpenOnlinecollaborativeCourse(MOOC)willbe
designedandimplementedforHEandVETeducationprofessionalsfromSpain,Greeceand
Italytodiscussandgainadeeperunderstandingofemergingtrendsinpromotingequityand
inclusion fordisabledstudents, includingmethodology,bestpracticesandpractical,hands-
onapplicationoftraditionalandblendedclassroomtechniques.
TheALdiaMOOCwillgiveeducationprofessionalsinthethreepartnercountriesandbeyond
theopportunitytolearn,practice,discussandsharehowtodesignandimplementaccessible
lectures and trainings. In this way, the ALdia project will promote the development of
learningenvironmentsthatfosterinclusionanddiversity.
Itssuccessfulcompletioncanlead–forthelearnersthatwishtodoso-toanALdiaoutcome-
orientedcertificate(basedontheEQF/ECVETframework)thatwillbeofferedatalowcost.
TheALdiacertificatewillgivetheopportunitytothetraineestobecomeALdiatrainers.
TheALdialearningapproachisbasedoninnovativeconstructivistandcollaborative
principles.
- Constructivistlearningenvironmentsaredesignedtofacilitatealearner’sconstruction
ofnewknowledge.
- Collaborativelearningtakesconstructivismfurtherbyplacinglearnersinthecentreof
theeducationprocess.
Thedevelopmentofcollaborativeteachingandlearningpedagogiesareusedintworespects:
a) theALdiatrainingmethodologyandpracticewillbeusingallthecollaborativelearning
techniques available for virtual learning systems. More specifically, Discussions
Forums, Chats,Wiki andWorkshopswill be available. Traineeswill have access to a
‘practice area’ in the ALdiaMOOCwhere theywill be able to share their accessible
learning designs. Assessment will be performed through weekly peer-assessment
(amongothers).
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
6
b) TheaccessiblelearningdesignthatwillbetaughtbytheALdiatrainingwillincorporate,
where appropriate, collaborative teaching techniques. Collaborative learning can be
particularlybeneficialinadiversifiedteachingenvironmentandcanpromotetolerance
and combat discrimination. The aim of the ALdia training material, taught in eight
modulesistoremoveorreduceinadvertentbarriers,whichpreventdisabledstudents
fromsuccessfullyparticipatingincoursesandprogrammesofstudy.
3.2.ALdiaMethodology
Learning thus becomes an active process, which can be furthered by the use of new
technologiesandtheinternet.ParticipantscanattendtheALdiaMOOCastheywishandthey
can create their own schedule according to their specific needs. The reason to use this
approachanswerstomanyreasons:
- thereisasignificantamountofcontenttobedeliveredtoalargenumberoflearners;
- learnerscomefromgeographicallydispersedlocations;
- learnershavelimitedmobility;
- learnershavelimiteddailytimetodevotetolearning;
- learnersdonothaveeffectivelisteningandreadingskills;
- learnershaveatleastbasiccomputerandInternetskills;
- learnersarerequiredtodevelophomogeneousbackgroundknowledgeonthetopic;
- learnersarehighlymotivatedtolearnandappreciateproceedingattheirownpace;
- contentmustbereusedfordifferentlearners’groupsinthefuture;
- trainingaimstobuildcognitiveskillsratherthanpsychomotorskills;
- thecourseaddresseslong-termratherthanshort-termtrainingneeds;
- thereisaneedtocollectandtrackdata.
TheALdiaMOOCwillbeavirtuallearningenvironmentapplyinganassortmentoftoolsthat
can be used for constructivist and collaborative learning, including discussion forums,wiki
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
7
andworkshops.ALdia trainingmaterialwill useunconventional learning resources (games,
videos,software,etc.),althoughspecificcarewillbegivenforthembeingaccessible. Itwill
alsoallowfortheflexibleaccessanduseof informationandresourcesatatime,placeand
pacethatissuitableandconvenienttoindividuallearners.
Thecoursewillbeoffered through theALdiaVirtual LearningPlatform (VLP).Theplatform
will be built on the latest version of the popular LearningManagement SystemMoodle2.
(See report R2.4 “Specifications of the ALdia Virtual Learning Environment” for further
specifications).
Moodle is a free open source software used for e-learning projects and distant education
withthespecificitytocreateonlinecoursestoachievespecificlearningobjectives.Itallowsa
virtual learning environment encouraging the learners to contribute to the educational
experienceandbeingactivepartof a learningvirtual community. It allows toorganise the
learningprogramintosectionsandmodulesguaranteeingasequentialityofactivities.Thee-
learningthroughtheMoodlePlatformcanbeintegratedwithmanyusefulonlinetools,finda
listofthesetoolsbelow:
• BSCW (https://public.bscw.de/pub) is a collaborative platform in which you can
store, share andmanage files (documents, pictures etc.). Youwill be able to grant
password-protected access to friends and colleagues; create arbitrary numbers of
teams; invitenewmemberssimplybyemail;manageappointments,contacts,tasks
andnotes;useversioningandchangereportstomonitordistributedprocesses;stay
aware of your teammates' activities; create and publish blogs; use polls to sample
your teammates' opinions; send automatic reminders of events to remember and
thingstodo.
• TWIDDLA(http://www.twiddla.com)isafree,web-basedmeetingplayground
• Padlet(http://padlet.com)toolforavirtualcollaborationwall
• Googlegroups(https://groups.google.com/forum/#!overview)
2AcronymforModularobject-orienteddynamiclearningenvironment(source:thefreeencyclopediaWikipedia)
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
8
Collaborativecreationofdocuments:
• Google Drive is a file storage and synchronization service provided by Google
consisting of collaborative text-editing, spreadsheet and presentation tools.
(http://www.google.com/intl/es/drive/about.html)
• Wikis are collaborative websites which allow users to add, modify or delete the
contentviaawebbrowser.ThemostcommonexampleofawikiisWikipedia,alsoan
unmatchedexampleofcollaboration.Someexamplesofwikitoolsare:
• Pbworks(http://pbworks.com)
• Mediawiki(http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/MediaWiki)
Collaborativemindmapsarealsoagoodwaytoshareideas,brainstormordevelopanidea
collaboratively.Someexamplesofcollaborativemindmappingtoolsare:
• Mind42:Collaborativeweb-basedtool,withunlimitedsimultaneoususers,tocreate
mindmaps.(http://mind42.com)
• Mindmeister(http://www.mindmeister.com)
• Cmaptools(http://ftp.ihmc.us)
• Bubbl.us(www.bubbl.us)
• Videconferencescanbeusedforonlinemeetingsatadistanceatacertaintimefora
selectedgroupofpeople.Someofthevideoconferencingtoolsyoumayfindusefulin
yourclassroomare:
• Flashmeeting(http://fm.ea-tel.eu/fm)
• OpenMeetings(http://code.google.com/p/openmeetings)
• BigBlueButton(http://bigbluebutton.org)
• Skype(http://www.skype.com/intl/pl/home)
• WiZiQ(http://www.wiziq.com)
• GoogleHangouts(http://www.google.com/+/learnmore/hangouts)
• AdobeConnect(http://www.adobe.com/products/adobeconnect.html)
Blogs are often sites for individual online publishing, but they have potential for
collaborationandgroupworkthankstothepossibilitytohavemorethanoneauthorand
tocommentonwhatwaspublished.Popularblogging toolsyoumayconsiderusingwith
yourstudentsare:
• Blogger(www.blogger.com)
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
9
• Wordpress(http://wordpress.com)
Socialnetworkingsites:Nowadayssocialnetworksareoneofthemostusedonlinetoolsin
everyday life as well as work. They allow users to stay in touch with the others, share
information easily and make contacts with people - these characteristics can be used for
online collaboration of a group of classmates on a task, sharing of the results of their
practical work with the community asking for feedback or ideas for solutions, as well as
contacting remote students and teachers studying the same vocational subject, with a
different perspective and from a different context. All this provides opportunity for
collaborative learningandgroupworkandcanenrich the learningprocess. It ispossible to
joinasocialnetwork thatalreadyexists (e.g.Facebook, inwhichyoucancreateyourwork
group)orcreateyourownnetwork(withSocialgo,Elggetc.).
• Facebook(www.facebook.com)
• SocialGO(http://www.socialgo.com)
• Elgg(http://elgg.org)
Othertools,suchasvirtualdesks(e.g.www.dropbox.com)orsocialmediasites,aredesigned
forresourcesharing,whichcanbeveryusefulwhenworkingonalearningactivityinagroup.
Socialmediasitesareusedtosharemediaobjects(video,images,audio,slidesetc.),butas
the name implies, they include intensive social interaction between the users. Once a
resource is published online it can be collaboratively analyzed, commented on and ideas
further developed. Examples of tools belonging to that group and bearing potential for
classroomuseare:
• Video:YouTube(www.youtube.com)
• Slides:Slideshare(www.slideshare.com)
• Pictures:Flickr(http://www.flickr.com)
• Webpages:Diigo(https://www.diigo.com)
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
10
4.SharingthebackgroundknowledgeofALdiapartners
4.1.MethodologiesAfteran investigationamongallpartners, FondoFormacionEuskadiextrapolated themain
idearelatedtomethodologies(intheALdiavirtuallearningenvironmentcontext)thatwants
to be addressedwithin the ALdia project. Themethodologies here shownaims at being a
systemofprinciples,astructuredapproachforalearningobjectivethatconsistsinpreparing
theeducationprofessionalsforequity,diversityandinclusioninlearningprocessandcertify
themwiththequalificationsofinclusiveeducation.
Takingintoaccountthedifferentdefinitionsofmethodologiesprovidedbythepartners,we
adoptthefollowingdefinitionofmethodology,withintheALdiaprojectframework:
The theoretical analysis of themethods thatwill be used, in order to describe the specific
proceduresortechniques,appliedtothefieldofthestudy.Italsoincludestheprinciplesthat
willworkasabasementforthestudy.Therefore,itresponsestohowtoteach.
Hereare shown theMethodologies thatpartnersbelieve couldbepartof thepedagogical
backgroundoftheALdiaTrainingCourse:
Methodology’sname e-learningBackground Importantauthorss:ToniBatesyAlbertSangrà,JulioCaberoDescription onlinelearningFieldsofimplementation TrainingingeneralLinkstoALdiaproject ItisscheduledaMOOCintheprojectandthisconceptisunderstoodasa
typeofe-learningReferences http://www.uoc.edu/portal/es/elearncenter/
http://www.uoc.edu/rusc/3/1/dt/esp/cabero.pdf
Methodology’sname LearningObjectsBackground WileyDescription ReusableonlinecontentasabasisforteachingFieldsofimplementation TrainingingeneralLinkstoALdiaproject ThecontentsoftheALdiaMOOCcouldbelearningobjectsReferences http://www.reusability.org/read/
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
11
Methodology’sname SignificantlearningBackground Constructionism
CollandZabalzaDescription TheMOOClearningmustbeinterestingforusers,byprovidingsomequality
totheirtraining.Fieldsofimplementation TrainingingeneralLinkstoALdiaproject ThetheoreticalbasisofthetrainingintheMOOCcouldbetheAS.References http://www.saladeprofes.cl/se-dice/831-constructivismo-y-el-aprendizaje-
significativo.html
Methodology’sname CognitivelyGuidedInstruction(CGI)Background Constructivism,Piaget,VygotskyDescription
Alearningapproachinwhichtheeducatorusesstrategicallyplacedprompts,cues,questions,directexplanations,andmodelingtoguidestudentthinkingandfacilitateanincreasedresponsibilityforthecompletionofatask
Fieldsofimplementation InadultlearningLinkstoALdiaproject Inadultlearning,thismethodologyactivatesthemechanismforcooperative
learningclimate,sequentialactivitiesforachievingtheobjectives,formulationoflearningobjectivesbasedonthediagnosedneedsandinterests.
References http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0883035505800059http://www.ascd.org/publications/books/111017/chapters/[email protected]
Methodology’sname Case-basedlearningBackground
PioneeredinthemedicalschoolprogramatMcMasterUniversityinHamilton,Ontario,Canadainthelate1960sbyHowardBarrows.Itcanbeconsideredasaconstructivistapproachtoinstruction.
Description Withcase-basedteaching,studentsdevelopskillsinanalyticalthinkingandreflectivejudgmentbyreadinganddiscussingcomplex,real-lifescenarios.
LinkstoALdiaproject Themethodaddressestheneedsofboththeteachersandtheadministratives,becausetheywillbecriticallyengagedwithspecificcircumstancesofaccessibility.Thestudyofcaseswillhelpthemtoidentifyproblemsastheyperceivethemandthusformulatestrategiesandgeneratepossiblesolutionsforauthenticscenarios.
References http://edutechwiki.unige.ch/en/Case-based_learninghttp://www.gla.ac.uk/schools/medicine/mus/coursecontributingopportunities/casebasedlearning/http://www.nea.org/assets/img/PubThoughtAndAction/TAA_01Sum_05.pdf
Methodology’sname Self-assessmentBackground
SocialLearningTheory–Bandura,1978Schunk&Zimmerman,1994–Self-regulatedlearning
Description Studentself-assessmentinvolvesstudentsinevaluatingtheirownworkandlearningprogress.
LinkstoALdiaproject
Throughself-assessment,theparticipantsintheALdiatrainingwillbeableto:
• identifytheirownskillgaps,• seewheretofocustheirattentioninlearning,• setrealisticgoals,
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
12
• revisetheirwork,(leectures/administrativeservices)• tracktheirownprogress• decidewhentomovetothenextlevelofthecourse.
Duetoitsgreatimpactonstudentperformance—inbothclassroomassessmentsandlarge-scaleaccountabilityassessments—themethodwillempowerstudentstoguidetheirownlearningandinternalizethecriteriaforjudgingsuccess.
References
http://www.edutopia.org/blog/self-assessment-inspires-learning-lori-desautelshttp://www.assessmentforlearning.edu.au/professional_learning/student_self-assessment/student_strategies_enhance.htmlhttp://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ815370.pdfhttps://www.reading.ac.uk/engageinassessment/peer-and-self-assessment/self-assessment/eia-self-assessment.aspxhttp://www.itari.in/categories/ability_to_learn/self_efficacy_an_essential_motive_to_learn.pdf
Methodology’sname OpendiscussionDescription Qualitydiscussioninvolvespurposefulquestionspreparedinadvance,
assessment,andstartingpointsforfurtherconversationswithinthetraineesandopportunitiesforreflection.Afterlecturethisisthemostfrequentlyusedteachingstrategywithmanybenefits,becauseithelpsthestudentstounderstand,reflectonandapplywhattheyhavelearnt.
LinkstoALdiaproject Traineeswillsharetheirexperienceandreflectonmanyaccessibilityissues.Onlinediscussionisalessthreateningenvironmentfortraineestoparticipate.
References https://www.brown.edu/about/administration/sheridan-center/teaching-learning/effective-classroom-practices/discussions-seminars/facilitatinghttp://www.cmu.edu/teaching/designteach/teach/instructionalstrategies/discussions.htmlhttp://www.edutopia.org/blog/rethinking-whole-class-discussion-todd-finleyhttp://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/brief/v7n2/sec3.htm
Methodology’sname ActionlearningBackground
Therootsofactionlearningcanbetracedto actionresearch,aconceptandtermoriginatedbyKurtLewininthe1940s(Weisbord,1987).ReginaldW.Revanspioneeredtheconceptsofactionlearningmorethan50yearsagothroughtheuseofin-depthresearchandworkincoalmines,hospitals,andotherindustries.HewasinvitedtotryouthistheoriesinBelgiumthatledtoanupturnintheBelgianeconomy.
Description Actionlearningiscontinuousprocessoflearningandreflectionwiththeintentionofgettingsomethingdone.Itdoesnotuseprojectwork,jobrotation,oranyformofasimulationsuchascasestudiesorbusinessgames.Learningiscenteredaroundtheneedtofindasolutiontoarealproblem.Mostactionlearningprocessestakefromfourtoninemonthstocomplete.
Fieldsofimplementation AllLinkstoALdiaproject Teamsoflearnerswithdiversebackgroundsconductfieldprojectson
problemsrequiringuseofskillslearnedinformaltrainingsessions(whattheyhavelearntintheelearninglearningpreviously)
References http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/hrd/media/action_learning.html
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
13
Methodology’sname Self-DirectedLearningBackground thenotionofSDLadvocatedherereflectsMalcolmKnowlesdefinitionof
SDL:“Initsbroadestmeaning,’self-directedlearning’describesaprocessbywhichindividualstaketheinitiative,withourwithouttheassistanceofothers,indiagnosingtheirlearningneeds,formulatinglearninggoals,identifyhumanandmaterialresourcesforlearning,choosingandimplementappropriatelearningstrategies,andevaluatinglearningoutcomes.”(Knowles,1975,p.18)
Description OfprimaryconcerninthisdefinitionofSDListhefactthelearnertakes1)theinitiativetopursuealearningexperience,and2)theresponsibilityforcompletingtheirlearning.Oncetheinitiativeistaken,thelearnerassumescompleteresponsibilityandaccountabilityfordefiningthelearningexperienceandfollowingitthroughtoitsconclusion.Thisdoesnotprecludeinputfromothers,butthefinaldecisionisthelearner’s.Self-directiondoesnotmeanthelearnerlearnsaloneorinisolation.
Fieldsofimplementation AllLinkstoALdiaproject Intermsofe-learning,thefactthatlearnerscandeterminewhichmodulesor
scenariostoreviewisalsofrequentlytoutedasself-directedlearning.Thefactthatthelearnerhasachoiceandmakesadecisiontoselectthisorthatmoduledependingonher/hisinterests.
References http://www.selfdirectedlearning.org/what-is-self-directed-learning
Methodology’sname ReciprocalMaieuticApproach(RMA)Background TheRMAisapopulardialecticmethodologyofresearchandself-analysis
developedbyDaniloDolcifromtheconceptofSocrates’maieutic.Itderivesfromtheancientgreek“μαιευτικός”thatliterallystandsforthemidwifeart:eacheducationalactislikegivingbirthtoalltheinsidepotentialsoftheindividualwhowantstolearn.
Description RMAisaprocessofcollectiveexplorationofpossibleproblemsolutionandalternativepathsthatdepartsfromtheexperienceandtheintuitionofindividuals.Thisapproachpromotesasenseofresponsibilityinthecommunitiesandindividualsandcanbedefinedasa“collectiveexplorationprocessthatconsidersindividuals’experienceandintuitionasareferencepoint”.DaniloDolci’sRMA,asaresult,isbasedonthesharingprocessofanswering,exploringandcreating.Asthenameitselfrecalls,theRMAisa“reciprocal”processbetweenatleasttwopeopleanditnormallydevelopswithinagroup,withapersonwhostartsaskingsomequestionsandotherpeoplewhosearchfortheanswerstogetherandmakeothercloseexaminations.Inanintensedialoguethatstandsforanewwayofeducationbasedonincreasingindividuals’andgroup’screativity,themaieuticalprocessconcentratesonthecapacityofpeoplepotentialtodiscovertheirvitalinterestsandfreelyexpresstheirownreflectionsbasedbothontheirexperiencesandtheirpersonaldiscoversandonthechoralverificationoftheproposals.
Fieldsofimplementation OneofthemainadvantagesofRMAistheabilitytoapplyitindifferentareas,justbecauseitisamethodologythatservesmainlytobringthestudent’sknowledgetolightusingthedialogueasadialecticaltool.TherearenolimitstotheapplicationofthismethodandtheDaniloDolci
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
14
philosophy,clarifythatpeople'sknowledgecanarisefromexperienceanditssharing,andthenrequiresmainlyreciprocityincommunication.
LinkstoALdiaproject ThecentralaimoftheAldiaprojectistomainstreamtheequalaccessprinciplesandpracticesintoalleducationsectorsandlevels.InthissensetheRMAisaddressablewiththeprojectbecauseitallowsthetrainertoestablishacloserrelationwithlearnersactivatingimportantcompetencesandvaluesas:learningtounderstand,groupprocesses,respectfortheother,learntobeactiveandinvolvedinsociety,developmoreself-esteemandawarenesstobecreative.Theuseofthisapproachprovidesadeepsharingbetweenthepeopleinvolved,andthisachievementisonlypossibleifpermitanequalaccesstoallkindoflearners.
References ManualinEnglish,RECIPROCALMAIEUTICAPPROACHInadulteducation,EditedbyAmicoDolciandFaustoAmico.http://cesie.org/media/EDDILI_manual_EN.pdf
4.2.Tools
This section is dedicated to present practical examples of specific toolsmatchingwith the
mainprinciplesandaspectsoftheALdiamethodologylistedabove:supportingastepbystep
learning process and promoting a participatory approach. All examples were provided by
partnersaccordingeachone'sexperienceandtheycanbeaddressedtothemainobjectiveof
ALdiatrainingprogramme.Therefore,itisveryimportanttoremindthattheywillhavetobe
adoptedaccordingtheeachspecifictrainingcontext,consideringaspectssuchasthecultural
peculiaritiesofeachcountrywherethetrainingtakesplace,thepersonalitiesofthetrainer
andthegroupoftrainees.
Hereisdescribedthedifferentdefinitionsoftoolsprovidedbythepartners:
TOOLDEFINITIONSAtoolisaresourcethathelpstoimplementamethodology.Inabroadsenseandinthefieldof the integration the ICT in the classroom,a toolmay refer toboth the softwareand thehardware.Toolmust be used to refer to something unitary and specific, such as a named test, or adevicetodoresearchwith.An educational tool is a program used to carry out a specific activity in an effective way.These tools supplement the learning materials, promoting creativity, collaboration andproblemsolving.AToolisasystembywhichitispossibletoachievespecificprojectobjectivesorfacilitatethe
implementationofsomeactivities.Thesetoolscanbespecificallydesignedtoolsor regular
productivitytoolsthatcanbeadoptedforprojectmanagementwork.Theexactdefinitionof
a pedagogical tool varies by age and education level, but virtually anything can be a
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
15
pedagogicaltoolintherightcircumstances.It isnormalfortheamountoftrainingrequired
tousedifferenttoolstovary,butnolimitsexistonwhatmightbeapedagogicaltool;itisup
totheeducatororstudenttomakeconnectionsbetweenthetoolandconceptsorfactstobe
learned.For instanceCapacitybuildingisoneofCESIE’smilestonesas itworksasatoolfor
the development of knowledge, skills and capabilities of individuals and organisations
through training, acquisition of new resources, strategies, conceptual frameworks and
organisational attitudes. Also Critical thinking is a system that entails many kinds of
pedagogicaltools,includingdevelopingwell-reasoned,persuasiveargumentsandexamining
conceptsor situations frommultipleperspectives, includingdifferent cultural perspectives.
Thedefinitionofatoolinvolvesacarefulevaluationofthetargetgroup,andforthisyoucan
choosepracticalortheoreticalelementsincaseyouneedamoredirectormorestructured
approach. Technology has played a major role in this advancement and the use of some
instruments such as online platforms can facilitate the meeting and sharing of useful
elements to all users and increase the chances of reaching the prefixed targets. As
mentioned before, the RMA is a “reciprocal” process between at least two people and it
normallydevelopswithinagroup,withapersonwhostartsaskingsomequestionsandother
people try to find the answers together andmakeother close examinations. Themaieutic
workshopneedseverybodytoquestionanduncoverthemselves infrontoftheothers,and
with the others to start a common research path of analysis, testing and creative co-
education. For this typeof activity, themain tools aredictatedby thearrangementof the
classroombythetimeeveryonehastousetoexpresstheirthoughtsandmediationprovided
by the facilitator. A major concern with pedagogical tools is that not all individuals have
accesstothesameitems.Thisusuallyisduetoeconomicrestrictions.Forthisreasoninthe
samewaypedagogicaltoolsvarybysubject,theyalsovarybyeducationallevel.
The following tables contain the information about the tools/methods suggested by the
ALdiapartners,whichcouldbeusedduringthedevelopmentandtheimplementationofthe
ALdiatrainingprogramme.Thetoolsproposedbypartnerscanbeusedacrossthedifferent
modules:
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
16
SIMULATIONEXERCISESANDROLEGAMESVIRTUALCLASSROOMSWEBCASTINGCREATIONTOOLSSLIDESHARETOOLSSHAREFILESTOOLSQUIZE-BOOKCREATIONTOOLSGLOSSARYONLINEQUIZZESINTERACTIVEACTIVITIESFEEDBACKQUESTIONNAIRES(TOBEEMBEDDEDONMOODLE)COLLABORATIVETOOLS(WIKIS)COMMUNITYFEATURES(DISCUSSIONFORUMS)TUTORIALS
Eachtableshowsmaininformationsuchas:
• Thenameofthetool
• Abriefdescription
• Numberofpeople,materialsandtimeneeded
• LinkstoALdiaproject
• Websites of reference and the provider partners to search for more detailed
information
Tool’sname SIMULATIONEXERCISESANDROLEGAMESDescription
Simulationexercisesandrole-playgameshelpyouaccuratelyassesshowindividualsperformintheareascentraltoeverydaybusinesslife.Theseexercisessimulatework-relatedtasksinabusinessenvironment,enablingyoutoassessaparticipant'scompetenciesinarealisticsettingbutthroughasafeenvironmentwherefailureisjustamatteroflearningandthere'sspaceforitandforfeedbackandimprovement.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Dependingontheactivityandaimsofthelearningprocess,butitcaninvolvefeworalotofpeople.
Materialsneeded ComputerPaper,pensandbackgroundmusic.
Timeneeded Flexible,DependingontheexerciseReferences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trainingsimulation
http://www.dol.gov/odep/documents/TeachingSoftSkills.pdfhttps://www.coe.int/t/dg4/youth/Source/Resources/Publications/2009Manualforfacilitatorsen.pdf
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
17
Tool’sname VIRTUALCLASSROOMSDescription
Applicationsorsoftwarethatallowtocollaborationinavirtualclassroom.Theseprovideusersavarietyofdifferenttoolsincludingaudio,whiteboard,chatandscreensharing.ThemostpopularapplicationsincludeAdobeConnect(www.adobe.com/products/adobeconnect.html),ClickMeeting(www.clickmeeting.com)andSpreed(www.spreed.com).GoogleHangouts,partoftheGoogle+socialnetworkingserviceprovidesaspaceforliveonlinemeetingsbetweentrainersandlearners.Interactionandannotationtoolsallowtrainerstosharewhiteboards,presentations,documentsandmultimediafilesandtocommunicateinbothoralandwrittenmedia.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Allstudents
Materialsneeded ComputerandsoftwareAvirtualclassroommimicsatraditionalinstructor-ledclassroombyintegratingdifferenttypesofsynchronoustools,suchaswhiteboard,chat,audioconferenceorapplicationsharing.
Timeneeded FlexibleLinkstoALdiaprojects HighlyinteractiveAllowtopracticehighcognitiveperformancelevel(apply,
analyse)References http://www.adam-
europe.eu/prj/7398/prd/3/2/Collaborative%20Blended%20Learning%20Methodology%20ver.%201.pdf
Tool’sname WEBCASTINGCREATIONTOOLSDescription Thesearetoolsusedtoachieveamediapresentationdistributedoverthe
Internetusingstreamingmediatechnologytodistributeasinglecontentsourcetomanysimultaneouslisteners/viewers.Awebcastmayeitherbedistributedliveorondemand.Itoffersdatastreamsoftext-basedmessages,voiceandvideochattobesharedsimultaneously,acrossgeographicallydispersedlocations.Applicationsforwebconferencingincludemeetings,trainingevents,lectures,orpresentationsfromaweb-connectedcomputertootherweb-connectedcomputers.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Unlimited
Materialsneeded FastnetworkconnectionandacameraLinkstoALdiaproject AllthetraineesparticipatingintheALdiatraining,willbeengagedwiththe
useoflivevideo.Theywillbereachedatthesametimeandconductonlineseminar/communication.
References https://www.allbusiness.com/basic-tools-for-live-webcasting-14910319-1.html
Tool’sname SLIDESHARETOOLSDescription Hostingservicesthatallowsuserstouploadfiles(PowerPoint,PDF,
Keynote,orOpenDocumentpresentations),privatelyorinpublic.TheserviceallowsyoutouploadPowerPointandPDFslidedecksandthenconvertsthemtoaplayerthatcanbetaggedandmadepublic.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Unlimited
Materialsneeded NetworkconnectionLinkstoALdiaproject Traineeswillhavetheopportunitiestocommentandsharetheuploaded
content.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
18
Tool’sname SHAREFILESTOOLSDescription Cloud-basedtools,withmanyincludingstoragefacilitiestotrackall
transfers.Thesetoolsalsosaveyoufromthesetup,costandmaintenanceofrunningyourownhomeserver(VPN),andmakeiteasytouploadfilestosharewithfriendsorcolleagues,accessremotely(onanydevice),orstoreforlater.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Unlimited
Materialsneeded NetworkconnectionLinkstoALdiaproject Havingallfilesstoredonlinemakesiteasytostore,organize,andshare
them,soyoucanworkondocumentswithteammates,sharereportswithbusinesspartners,orconnectwithcustomers.Thefilesarealwaysuptodate,soeveryonehasaccesstothelatestversion.Thesetoolswillenhancecollaborationbetweenthetraineesanditwillkeeptheparticipantsuptodate.
References https://products.office.com/en/business/office-365-file-sharing-online-collaboration-toolshttp://mashable.com/2014/03/06/file-sharing-tools/#b1Cr3.XHEkqQ
Tool’sname QUIZDescription Itisanengaging,easyandfunwaytoprovideassessment.Itcantake
severalforms,suchastextquestions,multiplechoicequestions,imagequestions,multiplecorrectanswers,etc.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Unlimited
LinkstoALdiaproject Traineescanmaintainself-assessmentandcomebacktoimprovetheirscores.
References https://www.quiz-maker.com/http://www.educatorstechnology.com/2014/02/10-useful-web-tools-for-creating-online.html
Tool’sname E-BOOKCREATIONTOOLSDescription Onlinebooks,presentingcontentinamoreinteractiveway.Numberofpeopleinvolved
Unlimited
LinkstoALdiaproject Traineesareexpectedtobecomemoreengaged.References http://rockthedeadline.com/blog/content-marketing/tips-for-creating-an-
ebook-in-microsoft-word/http://www.thebookdesigner.com/2015/06/five-free-tech-tools-for-ebook-authors/
Tool’sname GLOSSARYDescription Abriefdictionaryforaspecificsubject.Traditionally,aglossaryappearsat
theendofabookandincludestermswithinthatbookthatareeithernewlyintroduced,uncommon,orspecialized.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Unlimited
LinkstoALdiaproject Creationofaccessibilityglossary.References https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glossary
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4629722/?arnumber=4629722
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
19
Tool’sname ONLINEQUIZDescription WithintheonlineplatformtheuseofQuizwillconsistinthepresentation
ofsomequestionnairesinordertocollectinformationabouttheneedsandtheperceptionoftheparticipants.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Dependsonthenumberoftrainers
Materialsneeded QuestionnairesTimeneeded 20minutesLinkstoALdiaproject TheuseofpracticalToolsismoreadvisableconcerningthenecessityto
implementtheactivitiesandshareitwithallthepartnersinvolved.Pedagogicalfocusisonbridgingthegapbetweenhistoricalstateofanactivityandthedevelopmentalstageofapersonwithrespecttothatactivity,inparticularthereshouldberealisationthatthedevelopmentofcontentalonedoesnotleadtomoreeffectivelearning,andthatthereisaneedtostructureandfosterlearningenvironmentstoenablecommunitiestodevelop.
References G.Conole,M.Dyke,M.Oliver,J.Seale;“Mappingpedagogyandtoolsforeffectivelearningdesign”;ResearchandGraduateSchoolofEducation,HighfieldCampus,UniversityofSouthampton,SouthamptonSO171BJ,UKhttp://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.178.8474&rep=rep1&type=pdf
Tool’sname INTERACTIVEACTIVITIESDescription Theseactivitiescanincludeawiderangeoftoolsprovidedforwithinthe
Moodlesystem,suchascrosswords,submissionofessays,open-questionquestionnaires,trueorfalsequestionnairesetc.)
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Unlimited
LinkstoALdiaproject Theseactivitieshelpinvolvethelearnersthroughtheirpracticalengagementinactivetaskswhilehelpingthecourseprovidertomeasurelearners’achievements.
References
Tool’sname FEEDBACKQUESTIONNAIRESDescription Questionnairesaskingforusers’feedback.Thiskindofquestionnaires
representevaluationtoolswhichcanbeusedtoidentifythestrengthsandweaknessesofthecourseandtoimproveitinversion2.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
Unlimited
LinkstoALdiaproject Theseactivitieshelpinvolvethelearnersthroughtheirpracticalengagementinactivetaskswhilehelpingthecourseprovidertomeasurelearners’achievements.
References
Tool’sname COLLABORATIVETOOLS(WIKIS)Description WikisareaveryimportantfeatureinMOOCs.Theyarecollaborative
documentsallowinglearnerstoeditthesamedocument,adding/deletingpartsofit.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
LinkstoALdiaproject Theseactivitieshelpinvolvethelearnersthroughtheirpracticalengagementinactivetasks.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
20
References https://docs.moodle.org/24/en/Wiki_module
Tool’sname COMMUNITYFEATURES(DISCUSSIONFORUMS)Description CommunityisacriticalfeatureinMOOCs,asitallowsthelearnerstojointly
discussofproblemsrelatedtothelearningpathsandtofindsolutionsinacollaborativeway.Thesefeaturescanincludeforums,blogs,chatsetc.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
LinkstoALdiaproject Theseactivitieshelpinvolvethelearnersthroughtheirpracticalengagementinactivetasks.
References
Tool’sname TUTORIALSDescription Addingvideo-tutorialsisanicewaytoexplainwhatacourseisaboutinan
attractiveway.ItisverysimpletocreatenicetutorialsusingfreetoolssuchasPowToon.
Numberofpeopleinvolved
LinkstoALdiaproject Theseactivitieshelpinvolvethelearnersthroughtheirpracticalengagementinactivetasks.
References
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
21
5.Designmeetingsgeneraloverview
Three designmeetingswere held in all consortium countries: Spain, Italy andGreece. The
number of participants varies between 8 and 9 and the profile of the attendants are
composedofpersonsdesignatedbythepartnersandcarefullyselected.Thisvarietyallowsto
have represented our target group and so, to gather the opinions from the different
perspectives:
• DisabledStudents
• VET/HEprofessionalsworkingwithdisabledstudents
• Civilsocietyorganisationsworkingwithdisabledstudents
Themeetingshadanapproximateruntimefrom75to90minutesandwerecoordinatedby
one or more facilitators who were responsible for conducting the dialogue among the
participantsthroughvariousprojectrelatedquestions.
Thefindingsofthesemeetingsarepresentedbelowandtheirconclusionswillbeusedforthe
ALdiatrainingprogrammeandtrainingmodules.
5.1.ItalianDesignGroup–Keyfindings
To define a trainingmethodology focused on facilitating the access to learning paths by
disabledstudents,isneeded:
• Theoreticalknowledge:intermsofknowledgeaboutdisabilityandinhowtostructure
aninterventiontailoredtotheneedsthatarise.
• Knowledgeofthetoolsthatcanguaranteeequalaccesstoallcategoriesofstudents.
• Fundamentalpersonalattitudesareneeded:empathyandpatience.
• Tobe focusedon theneedof thestudentsand toproposeclearpatternsof learning
processes,thusdefiningtheobjectivestobeachieved.
• Totake intoaccounttheworkthatwillbe implementedbythetrainingproviderstaff
(tutors, teachers, etc.) with the families of the disabled person. The interventions
shouldalsoconsidertheneedsofthefamilies,tryingtofindadequatesolutionsforall
theactorsinvolved.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
22
Tochoosetherightpedagogicaltoolsfocusedonfacilitatingtheaccesstolearningpathsby
disabledstudentsisimportanttotakeintoaccountthefollowing:
• Itisgoodtousedifferenttools,itisuptotheeducatororstudenttomakeconnections
betweenthetoolandconceptsorfactstobelearned.
• Thedefinitionofatoolinvolvesacarefulevaluationofthetargetgroup.
• Online platforms (and in general structured IT for disabled people) and the practical
useofassistivetechnologiescanfacilitatethemeetingandsharingofusefulelements
toallusersand increasethechancesofreachingtheprefixedtargets.Attention!!We
should not overdo in using IT tools because they can also have a negative effect on
socialrelations.
Role playing is identified as a good practice of training methodology from the disabled
students´ point of view, encouraging group dynamics which can be very useful to achieve
effectiveresultsintermsoftraining.TheHE/VETprofessionalsconsiderthatsportisanother
methodology that allows peoplewith special needs to have equal access to the education
systemand canenhance their skills, social and communicatingabilities, aswell as improve
theiroverallhealthandwell-being.Alsomentoring,atutorwhoaccompaniesthestudentfor
theentireacademicperiod,isconsideredagoodpractice.
Some challenges are mentioned by disabled students in order to develop a training
programme for HE and VET professionals in special needs education based on the ECVET
principles,whichis:
• Tomatchstudentinterestswiththeneedsoffamiliesandtheuniversitystaff.Therole
ofthetutorasamediatorisfundamental.
• Thelackofgenuinenessandparticipants’resistancetoleavetheir“role”andtoexpose
themselvesinfrontofotherpeople.
The bureaucratic system within training providers was also recognised as challenging,
accordingtotheHE/VETprofessionals‘perception.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
23
5.2.SpanishDesignGroup–Keyfindings
Regarding the training methodology disabled students do not want the contents and
assessmentstobesimplifiedbutadapted,sothattheycanreachthemlikeotherpeers.From
HE/VETprofessionals‘perception:
• Institutionalplansthatspecifystrategiesandmethodologiestodesignconcreteactions
foraccessibilityareneeded.
• Thetrainingshouldbeassociatedwithanawarenessraisingplanandaneducationin
values,sinceattitudes,voluntarism,etc.influenceintheaccessibility.
• ThemethodologyintroducedbytheEducationLaw-LOGSE(GeneralOrganicLawofthe
Education Systemof 1990) based onmeaningful learning, analysis of previous ideas,
continuousassessmentandlearningtolearn,isstillevaluatedpositively.
Somepedagogicaltoolsareproposedbydisabledstudents:
• Textadaptedforcommunicationalternativesystems:Brailleorothers.
• ModulatedFrequencyfortheteacherandstudentwithhearingimpairment.
• Designofadaptedandflexibleactivities.
• AccessibleWebs.
• Preferredspacesintheclassroomsandmoreaccessibleclassrooms.
• Timeflexibilityforaccomplishmentanddeliveryoftasksandworks.
• Non-significantcurricularadaptationsintermsofmethodologyandevaluationtools.
On other hand, the HE/VET professionals propose the following to facilitate the access to
learningpathsbydisabledstudents:
• ICTasaworkingtoolandaccesstocommunication.
• Mentoringprotocolsandmethodologicalactions.
• ContinuosTraining.
• Expertsupportandadviceonthesubject.
• Moretimedevotedtothesestudents.
• Reductionofteacher-studentratio(smallergroups).
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
24
Thefollowingbarriersorneedsarehighlighted:
• Lessonsandmaterialsarenotaccessible.
• Teachersneedmoretime,desire,attitude,etc.
• Teachingstafftraining.
• Participationofthedisabledstudentsinthetrainingprocess.
• Carriedoutcooperativelearning.
• Clarify:accessibilityisnottosimplifythecurriculum;accessibilityistoadaptit.
Thereareaspectsorchallengestokeepinmindwhendesigningatrainingproposal:
• InclusionofICT.
• Educationinvalues.
• Cooperativework.
• Peertutoring.
• Sharedleadership.
• Collaborationamongteachers.
• Greaterinvolvementofstudentsintheaccessibility.
• Aspectsoftheso-calleduniversaldesign.
• Includethevoiceofthoseinvolved:thestudents.
The students consider that a training programme for HE and VET professionals in special
needseducationbasedontheECVETprinciplesshouldcontainsnecessary:
• Descriptionoftheeducationalneedsofthedifferentdisabilities.
• Analysisofcommunicationsystemsanddidacticandtechnologicalresourcestousein
differentdisabilities.
• Approachesandtypeofevaluationadaptedtotheeducationalneedsofthedifferent
disabilities.
TheHEandVETprofessionalsproposethefollowing:
• Knowledgeandanalysisoftheeducationalneedsofthedifferentdisabilities.
• Knowledge and implementation of the communication systems and didactic and
technologicalresourcesthatarerequiredinthedifferentdisabilities.
• Knowledgeandapplicationofevaluationcriteriaandinstrumentsadaptedtodifferentdisabilities.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
25
5.3.GreekDesignGroup–Keyfindings
In Greece, apart from the design meeting, were carried out 2 separate interviews with
experts(Mrs.MariaEmmanouil,memberofAccessibilityUnit forStudentswithDisabilities,
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, and the Professor Polatoglou, from
AristotelionUniversityofThessaloniki)duetotheycouldn´tattendthemeeting.
Fromthedisabledstudents‘pointofview,thetrainingmethodologyshouldbepersonalized
and customized on the specific characteristics and needs of each disability. Also the
pedagogicaltoolsshouldbesuitablydesigned.
TheHE/VETprofessionalsthinkthatitwillbeveryhelpfultoconsiderthefollowingelements
when develop a training programme for HE and VET professionals in special needs
education:
• thecasebasedexperiences,
• livespeechesofstudentswithdisabilities,
• videosmadebystudentswithdisabilities,whichexplaintheirneeds,
• experientialseminars,
• groupforum
Methodologicallyspeaking, inface-to-facelessons,professorsandtrainersshouldmakethe
lessonmoreinteractiveandadopttechniquesoflearningactivationinordertotransformthe
lessonintomoreparticipatoryforallstudents,includingthosewithdisability.
They propose the following tools in order to promote accessibility in the various types of
disability:
• BSCW,
• TWIDDLA,
• Padlet,
• Googlegroup,
• Skype,
• WiZiQ
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
26
• Wordpress,
• Elgg
HEandVETprofessionalsconsiderthattheeducationalmaterial/contentdon´tneedgreat
changes;itcouldremainthesame,butadjustingittotheseveraltypesofdisability,inorder
to become accessible for students with disabilities. The interactive educational material
wouldaddresstheneedsofstudentswithdisabilities,aslongas,itisdesignedaccordingthe
UDLmodeltofacilitateaccessibility.
Regardingchallenges,thedisabledstudentsdeclarethattherearemanydifferentdisabilities
that have different and varied needs. Therefore a training programme for HE and VET
professionals in special needs education, should cover holistically all these different
categoriesandbridgeanygapsinthemeaningofaccessibleeducation.Inthesamesense,HE
andVETprofessionalsthinktheyshouldreceiveatrainingthatwillrangeinvariousformsof
disability,coveringallthedifferentdisciplinesandhavingpracticalapplication.Theybetfora
trainingpedagogybasedoncasebasedlearningwithlivespeechesandvideosfromstudents
withdisabilities.Participantscoulddevelopanalytic,collaborative,andcommunicationskills
andthewillseetheoryinpractice.
The group identifies some good practices in University and VET center and considers that
more good practices of special education from all universities and VET centers should be
collected, in order to encourage cooperation between them and exchange the expertise,
meanwhile the students with disability are supported in order to respond better in their
academicresponsibilities.Alsothedevelopmentofvolunteerismamongpeersandstudents,
should be encouraged from the HE and VET professors to facilitate accessibility to the
studentswithdisabilities.
ALdia-AccessibleLearningDesignimplementationandAccreditation(562155-EPP-1-2015-1-ES-EPPKA3-PI-FORWARD)
27
6.References
Bibliography
- R2.2SupportingstudentswithdisabilityinHEandVET:aneedsanalysis,developed
byFourElements,2016.
- R2.3ALdiaTrainingandCertificationStrategy,developedbyCESIE,2016.
- R2.4SpecificationsoftheALdiaVirtualLearningEnvironment,developedbyUPRC,
2016.
- R2.1Designmeetingsontrainingpedagogyandtools,developedbyCESIE,Four
Elements,UPRCandUA,2016.