Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA -...

43
A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands Why Preservation Matters Shan McNaughton, AIA McNaughton Architecture, Inc. Architect C-28575

Transcript of Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA -...

Page 1: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

A historical perspectiveon Architecture in Redlands

Why Preservation Matters

Shan McNaughton, AIAMcNaughton Architecture, Inc.Architect C-28575

Page 2: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Understanding our history is critical to progress.Architecture embodies our rich culture and history. When great buildings are removed or lost, our sense of place is changed irrevocably.If enough buildings are removed, a town loses its identity and soul.

Page 3: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Our historical heritage is embodied within the buildings of Redlands.The high style of architecture proves that our founders and benefactors were cultivated, sophisticated and magnanimous.They were interested in creating an architecturally and culturally rich town.

Following is a summary of some of our great buildings that are gone.Several were lost to fire, but most were intentionally demolished during the 1960’s and 1970’s modernist movement.

Our Heritage

Page 4: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

The Fisher Building1899 - 1964Mission Revival

Early 1900’s

Circa 1960

Circa 1940

Page 5: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Redlands Plaza1965-Modernist Style

City of Redlands Civic CenterPresent Day

1965

Page 6: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Historical Note:Mission Revival Architecture is the style that perhaps best defines early Redlands.

The Mission Revival Style was an architectural movement that began in the late 19th century. It was popular from 1899 – 1915.The style was inspired by the California Spanish Missions.

Characteristics of Original Style: • Courtyard design (for security)• massive adobe walls with broad unadorned plaster surfaces• Limited fenestration• Low pitched roofs• Non-flammable clay tile, thick roman arches springing from

piers• Exterior arcades, bell shaped gables

Revival:These elements were replicated in varying degrees in the new Mission Revival structures.There was a growing awareness of the actual missions fading into ruin and nostalgia for a simpler time.

Page 7: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

The Chandler Building1903 - 1972Mission Revival

Early 1900’s

Page 8: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

1960

Present day: Ed Hales Park

Page 9: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

The Casa Loma Hotel1896 - 1955Mission Revival

Early 1900’s

Page 10: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Stater Brothers Supermarket1956

Stater Brothers SupermarketPresent Day

1953

Page 11: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

The First National Bank of Redlands1914 - 1976Classical Revival

Circa 1920

Page 12: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

1976

1959

Redlands Mall Parking LotPresent Day

Circa 1950

Page 13: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Union Bank1887 – 1929Beaux-Arts Style

1903

Page 14: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Bank Of America1929 - 1959Art Deco

Page 15: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Keystone DrugstoreCirca 1980

Rexall DrugsCirca 1960Modernist Style

Darby’s RestaurantPresent Day

Page 16: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

La Posada Hotel1931 - 1975Spanish Colonial Revival

Page 17: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Circa 1966

Redlands MallPresent Day

Circa 1948

Page 18: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

West State Street

Circa 1904

Page 19: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

West State Street

Demolition Nov. 1974 Demolition Jan. 1975West State Street

Redlands MallPresent Day

Page 20: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Redlands City Hall1940-Renaissance Revival

Page 21: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.
Page 22: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Downtown RedlandsCirca 1970

Page 23: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

West State Street City BlockSanborn Map 1959

Page 24: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

First Presbyterian Church1900 - 1967Mission Revival

Page 25: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Re-built First Presbyterian Church1969- Modernist Style

Present Day

Page 26: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

First United Methodist Church1903 - 1967Mission Revival

Page 27: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Re-built First United Methodist Church1970- Modernist Style

Present Day

Page 28: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

A.K. Smiley Library1898-Mission Revival

Page 29: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

U.S. Post Office1935 -Mission / Moorish Revival

Page 30: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Mutual Orange Distributors Pure Gold Building1927 -Mission Revival

Page 31: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Historic YWCAPresently, The Cutler GroupMission Revival

Page 32: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Mission GablesRCMA Office HeadquartersMission Revival

Page 33: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Holt Residence1903-Mission / Moorish Revival

Page 34: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Burrage Mansion1901-Mission Revival

Page 35: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.

Burrage MansionPresent Day

Page 36: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.
Page 37: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.
Page 38: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.
Page 39: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.
Page 40: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.
Page 41: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.
Page 42: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.
Page 43: Why Preservation Matters: A historical perspective on Architecture in Redlands | Redlands, CA - McNaughton Architectural Inc.