The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index...

22
The Spy Who Never Came Back rAmdctr;edfront] lorlly;mning book by HENRHURT (i()( )1\ II( )Ni

Transcript of The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index...

Page 1: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

The Spy Who Never Came Back

rAmdctr;edfront] lorlly;mning book by

HENRHURT

(i()( )1\ II( )Ni

Page 2: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SH

AW

N

Th

e Sp

y W

ho

Never

Cam

e Back

BY

HE

NR

Y H

UR

T

When U

S. intelligence of-

ficials asked Nicholas Shadrin

to become a spy, he refused.

A form

er Soviet naval captain w

ho had defected six years before, he w

as now happily

married, an A

merican citizen w

ho had earned a master's

degree in engineering and was w

orking on his Ph.D

. in international affairs.

For close to a year, he continued to refuse requests that he

become a double agent. O

nly when his friend, A

dm. R

ufus

Taylor, form

er director of Naval Intelligence, began to exert

pressure—"tw

isted his arm," in the w

ords of one FBI agent—

did Shadrin agree to undertake the assignm

ent.

For years, S

hadrin played the nerve-racking role, in the

belief that he was serving this country as a double agent. B

ut he

was m

uch more than a double agent. H

e was actually a paw

n

in a chess game of espionage that w

as far more dangerous than

he could have imagined.

Then, one night in 1975, he suddenly disappeared. H

is

friends, his wife, w

ere frantic. Could A

dmiral T

aylor help? A

close associate of 25 years telephoned Taylor. "N

ick who?" the

admiral replied. "S

hadrin? I never heard of him."

196

HE

VIS

IT T

O V

IEN

NA

WaS

a welco

me d

iversio

n fo

r N

icholas and Ew

a Shadrin.

Nicholas

They

were o

n th

eir way

to

Austria, fo

r a long-p

lanned

Christm

as skiing vacation. A m

onth

prio

r to th

eir dep

arture N

ick h

ad

men

tioned

to E

wa (p

ronounced

Eva) th

at he w

ould

com

bin

e their

vacatio

n w

ith a b

usin

ess appoin

t-

ment in V

ienna. She w

as delighted. S

mall an

d en

ergetic, w

ith o

live

skin

and in

tense d

ark ey

es, Dr.

Blanka E

wa S

hadrin had established a successful private dental practice

in the Virginia suburbs near W

ash-

ington, D.C

. Nicholas G

eorge Shad-

rin, h

er husb

and, w

as a wid

ely

acclaimed lecturer at the N

aval War

College, as w

ell as a former analyst

and co

nsu

ltant fo

r the O

ffice of

Naval Intelligence. W

ith a Ph.D

. in

international affairs and a master's

degree in engineering, Shadrin w

as

emplo

yed

by th

e Defen

se Intelli-

gence Agency (D

IA), w

here he was

consid

ered am

ong th

e best in

his

field. More than six feet, tw

o inches

tall, he p

ossessed

a com

man

din

g

charm and presence that invariably

won him

acceptance in almost any

milieu

. His co

mpan

y an

d co

unsel

were so

ught b

y so

me o

f the m

ost

importan

t peo

ple in

Wash

ingto

n's

military and intelligence com

munity.

Seventeen years earlier, w

hen fate

first intertw

ined

the liv

es of N

ick

and Ew

a, he had been Capt. N

ikolai

Fedorovich A

rtamonov, the young-

est comm

anding officer of a destroy-

er in Soviet naval history. In 1958, at

the age of 3o, during a tour of duty in Poland, he m

et a lovely girl named

Ew

a Gora, w

ho was 21 and in her

last year of medical school. T

hey fell

wildly in love. In June 1959 they fled across the

Baltic S

ea in a sm

all launch

and

sought asylum in S

weden. T

heir dar-

ing escap

e from

com

munism

was

heralded around the world. A

year

later Nick

and E

wa w

ere married

and living in the United S

tates. It w

as around 3 p.m. on D

ecem-

ber 1

8, 1

975, w

hen

the S

had

rins

checked into Vienna's H

otel Bristol,

across th

e street from

the V

ienna

Opera H

ouse. After a show

er and a

light lu

nch

, Nick

explain

ed to

his

wife that he w

ould leave at 5 p.m. for

a business appointment that w

ould

include dinner. His m

eeting was to

be with the sam

e person he had seen

on earlier occasions when they had

traveled abroad. Nick said the m

an

was a R

ussian who had been w

ork-

ing for the United States for 25 years.

Shadrin told E

wa he w

as to meet his

friend o

n th

e steps o

f the V

otiv

-

kirche, a large church in clear sight

of the US

. consulate. T

hat was all N

ick Shadrin told his

wife. A

gregarious, ebullient man,

Shad

rin w

as inten

sely p

rivate in

oth

er respects. It d

id n

ot o

ccur to

Ew

a to question him about his w

ork.

She assum

ed the meetings he had in

foreign cities were som

ehow related

to his work for the D

IA.

When N

ick left, Ew

a went out to

stroll the snowy streets of V

ienna.

She retu

rned

about 6

:2o p

.m.; 3

0

minutes later her telephone rang. It

was A

nn Martin, a w

oman E

wa had

'97 "S

HA

DR

IN: T

HE

SP

Y W

HO

NE

VE

R C

AM

E B

AC

K," C

OP

YR

IGH

T T

1981 S

y T

HE

RE

AD

ER

'S D

IGE

ST

AS

SO

CIA

TIO

N. IN

C..

WIL

L B

E P

UB

LIS

HE

D B

Y R

EA

DE

R'S

DIG

ES

T P

RE

SS

, 1221 A

VE

. OF

TH

E A

ME

RIC

AS

. NE

W T

OR

R. N

.Y. 1

0020.

PH

OT

O. P

AG

E 1

95. W

ILLIA

M S

ON

NT

AG

Page 3: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SHA

DR

IN: T

HE

. SPY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

BA

CK

met in W

ashington ten days earlier. Jam

es Wooten, one of N

ick's clos-est friends, had brought A

nn Martin

to the Shadrin hom

e on Decem

ber 8 specifically for her to m

eet Ew

a. Miss

Martin

had

som

ethin

g to

do w

ith

Nick

's upco

min

g V

ienna m

eeting,

Ew

a was told. E

wa w

as fond of Jim

Wooten

, but sh

e had

found M

iss M

artin to be remote, even cold.

That night ih V

ienna, Ann M

artin said

that sh

e was at th

e Imp

erial H

otel, five minutes aw

ay. She w

ant-ed

to co

me to

Ew

a's hotel ro

om

im

mediately and w

ait there for Nick.

"Of course," replied E

wa, thinking

that perhaps Miss M

artin would un-

bend a hit in a one-on-one setting. A

nn

Martin

was n

early six

feet tall, v

ery th

in, w

ith straig

ht b

row

n

hair. She w

ore no makeup and had

little to say. Ew

a soon saw that any

hope she had for warm

ing up Miss

Martin

was silly

, and sh

e was re-

lieved when N

ick finally came back

after to:3o, in obvious good spirits. A

fter he greeted them, M

iss Martin

got out a pen and pad and motioned

toward the bathroom

. Nick sm

iled at E

wa an

d w

ent in

to th

e bath

room

w

ith Miss M

artin, where, behind the

closed door, they talked in muffled

voices fo

r ten m

inutes. S

oon after-

ward the w

oman left.

Ew

a kn

ew th

at this trip

was th

e m

ost im

po

rtant N

ick h

ad ev

er un

-dertak

en. H

e had

told

her p

rior to

their trip that if everything cam

e off w

ell, he could expect important ad-

vances in his professional life. "N

ick was jubilant," says E

wa. "I

hav

e nev

er seen h

im h

app

ier. His

198

meetin

g m

ust h

ave b

een trem

en-

dously successful."

Waiting for N

ick T

HE

NE

XT

MO

RN

ING

Nick indicat-

ed that the whole day w

as theirs. He

had

one m

ore m

eeting w

ith th

e R

ussian

, bu

t that w

ou

ld n

ot tak

e place until tom

orrow, S

aturday. And

on Sunday they w

ould be off to Mrs.

The S

hadrins spent Friday shop-

ping. But at som

e point toward the

end

of th

e even

ing

, Ew

a beg

an to

notice that N

ick had become increas-

ing

ly p

reoccu

pied

. Befo

re bed

he

took a Valium

pill. Ew

a had never know

n him to seem

this tense. T

he next day they shopped again, but in the afternoon N

ick rested. He

men

tioned

several tim

es that h

e needed to be com

pletely relaxed. At

6 p.m. he got up and dressed.

After slip

pin

g o

n h

is jacket, h

e h

and

ed E

wa a card

. "Th

is is the

number to call if anything happens,"

he said. The num

ber would put her

in touch with A

nn Martin.

That night, E

wa w

ent to the op-era, an

d w

hen

she retu

rned

to th

e hotel, she settled dow

n to read. She

told

herself th

at she w

ou

ld w

ait until 1:3o a.m

. before calling Ann

Martin. T

he d

eadlin

e was q

uick

ly u

po

n

her. Ew

a reached for the telephone. T

here w

as no an

swer. A

deep

and

frightening chill swept through her.

At 1:55 she tried again. T

his time

Ann M

artin answered.

"Have you tried to call before?"

the wom

an asked. These w

ere her first w

ords. Ew

a said she had. Miss

If you're looking to save energy in your laundry room

, you don't have to go so far as w

ashing clothes by hand. B

ut you may w

ant to think about saving your sm

all loads until you have a full one. B

ecause both your washing m

achine and dryer use the sam

e amount of energy

whatever you put in them

. So if even only a third of your norm

al w

ashes are small ones, you can save quite

a bit of money over a year by com

bining them

into full ones. T

hat's just one of the things Atlantic

Richfield is suggesting people do.T

here are lots of others.

The im

portant thing is that if everyone picked at least one thing,and stuck to it, our country w

ould save a load of energy and m

oney. It m

ay sound like a small idea,because

it's so simple. B

ut we think it can pay som

e pretty big dividends.

For all of us.

Page 4: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SH

AD

RIN

: TH

E S

PY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

BA

CK

A AT ITS BEST

Light. Smooth. Im

ported Canadian M

ist. The w

hisky thee becominglonerica's favorite C

anadian.

Martin explained that she had been

having dinner with friends and had

just returned. "N

ick h

as no

t com

e back

," said

Ew

a. T

here w

as a mo

men

t's silence,

and then Ann M

artin said, "It's late, but there's no reason to w

orry. Call

me w

hen he comes in."

For the next 31/2 hours, E

wa w

ait-ed. W

hat had been a joyful Christm

as holid

ay w

as turn

ing in

to a n

ight-

mare. E

ach time she heard the eleva-

tor, she would hold her breath and

listen, h

op

ing

it wo

uld

stop

at her

floor and the footsteps would com

e her w

ay. They never did.

Fin

ally, at 5

:3o a.m

., Ew

a tele-phoned

Miss M

artin ag

ain. "N

ick

hasn't come yet," she said. M

atter-of-factly

, Miss M

artin said

that th

ere w

as still noth

ing to

worry

about.

How

ever, she would "cable W

ash-ington" w

ith the information.

As d

aylig

ht b

roke, A

nn M

artin

arrived. She assured E

wa that N

ick w

ould

pro

bab

ly retu

rn at an

y m

o-

men

t. Mean

while, sh

e said, th

e A

merican

emb

assy w

as check

ing

w

ith all hospitals and the police in case there had been an accident.

Ann M

artin was in and out for the

next two days. T

here was no new

s fro

m th

e check

of h

osp

itals and

police. S

he told Ew

a to be patient, that the U

.S. governm

ent was w

ork-ing for a resolution. N

ever over the day

s they

were to

geth

er did

she

mak

e a sing

le gestu

re of w

armth

, except to offer a curious condolence: "D

on't worry, you'll get used to it."

Th

rou

gh

tears Ew

a loo

ked

up

at 200

Miss M

artin's impassive face. It w

as a m

oment she w

ould never forget. T

uesd

ay m

orn

ing A

nn M

artin

suggested

that E

wa b

ook p

assage

on Wednesday to W

ashington, via F

rankfurt. An engaging older gen-

tleman from

the midw

estern United

States h

ad b

een d

ispatch

ed fro

m

Washington to escort her hom

e, she ex

plain

ed. H

is nam

e was B

ruce.

She g

ave E

wa th

e impressio

n sh

e w

ould find Bruce a com

forting trav-el com

panion. B

ut th

e cold

aloofn

ess of A

nn

Martin w

as quickly surpassed by the alm

ost sullen taciturnity of the non-descript m

an called Bruce. O

n the flight to F

rankfurt he and Ew

a did not sit together. T

hey did sit together on the long flight from

Frankfurt to

Washington, but never once did they

hav

e a substan

tive co

nversatio

n.

Bru

ce spen

t his tim

e readin

g an

d

staring ahead, while E

wa sat quietly,

trying to suppress her tears. A

bout 1

:3o p

.m. o

n C

hristm

as E

ve they arrived at Dulles Interna-

tional Airport and w

ere met by Jim

W

ooten. On the drive from

the air-port to

the S

hadrin

s' hom

e in

M

cLean, V

a., Wooten and E

wa sat in

the back talking quietly. Bruce sat

in fro

nt.

Wooten

explain

ed th

at the g

ov-

ernment's w

orking theory on Nick's

disappearance was that he had been

kidnapped by the Soviets. H

e told E

wa that the strongest possible steps

were being taken to bring about his

pro

mpt retu

rn. S

ecretary o

f State

Henry K

issinger had agreed to see A

natoly Dobrynin, the S

oviet am-

IMP

OR

I ED

By F

T;P

IRIT

TIT

LT

D N

Y,N

Y. C

AN

AD

IAN

WH

ISK

Y- A

OLU

ND

50 P

FT

CH

I : t 19

79

Page 5: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

BO

OK

SE

CT

ION

S

HA

DR

IN: T

HE

SP

Y W

HO

NE

VE

R C

AM

E B

AC

K

bassa

dor to

the U

nite

d S

tate

s, the

next day. W

oote

n to

ld E

wa g

ently

that

som

e re

solu

tion

mu

st be

fou

nd

ur-

ge

ntly b

eca

use

he

be

lieve

d it like

ly th

e S

ovie

ts w

ou

ld e

xe

cu

te N

ick

with

in 4

8 h

ours. H

e re

min

ded h

er

that th

e S

ovie

ts had p

lace

d N

ick under a death sentence follow

ing his defection 16 years earlier.

As th

e ca

r neare

d th

e S

hadrin

hom

e, W

oote

n to

ld E

wa it w

as e

x-tre

me

ly imp

orta

nt th

at sh

e te

ll no

o

ne

wh

at h

ad

ha

pp

en

ed

. Th

e o

nly

hope in

gettin

g N

ick back w

as in

m

akin

g su

re n

oth

ing le

ake

d to

the

pre

ss. An

y pu

blish

ed

acco

unt co

uld

hopelessly tangle negotiations.

But w

hat ca

n I te

ll our frie

nds?

" asked E

wa.

"Tell them

you were ill and had to

com

e h

om

e e

arly," W

oote

n sa

id.

"Te

ll the

m th

at N

ick staye

d o

n to

ski."

It was a

cocke

yed e

xpla

natio

n,

Ew

a thought, but at least it suggest-ed that W

ooten and the government

seemed optim

istic about an early end to

the crisis. In

the h

ouse

, Woote

n

contin

ued. "S

ince y

ou'll fin

d o

ut

who w

e are soon enough," he said, "I m

ight a

s w

ell te

ll you n

ow

." He

expla

ined th

at th

e s

trange m

an

named B

ruce was actually an officer

with

the C

IA. (Y

ears

late

r, Ew

a

would learn that his nam

e was B

ruce S

olie

.) Woote

n id

entifie

d h

imse

lf as

an a

gent w

ith th

e F

BI.

"But w

hat w

as g

oin

g o

n in

Vie

n-

na?" crie

d E

wa.

Wo

ote

n w

ou

ld sa

y on

ly tha

t Nick

was w

orking honorably for his coun- 202

February

try, that his work w

as in the highest tra

ditio

n o

f patrio

tism.

A S

eries of M

eeting

s

TH

E N

EX

T S

EV

EN

DA

YS

w

ere as te

rrible

as a

ny E

wa S

hadrin

would

eve

r'know

. She w

as a

lone w

ith th

e

nu

mb

ing

be

lief th

at h

er h

usb

an

d

had been kidnapped by the Soviets.

In u

tter d

esp

air, s

he

fina

lly te

le-

phoned W

illiam

and M

ary L

ouise

H

ow

e fo

r con

sola

tion

an

d h

elp

. F

rom the S

hadrins' earliest days in th

e U

nite

d S

tate

s, the

Ho

we

s ha

d

opened their handsome W

ashington hom

e to them. A

s a senior electronics analyst for the O

ffice of Naval Intel-

lige

nce

(0m

), Bill H

ow

e w

as o

ne

of

the first to

debrie

f Shadrin

in 1

959.

Afte

r on

e o

f his e

arly se

ssion

s with

S

hadrin, he had told his colleagues: "If he is a typical S

oviet navy captain, the U

nited States is in deep trouble."

Fortunately S

hadrin was not typical;

he w

as p

erh

aps th

e b

est d

estro

yer

cap

tain

in th

e S

ovie

t na

vy. A

frien

dsh

ip h

ad d

eve

loped th

at

span

ned

t6 ye

ars. T

he

re w

ere

fre-

qu

en

t visits to e

ach

oth

er's h

om

es,

and the two couples even took trips

togeth

er. N

ick taught th

e H

ow

es'

son to

hunt a

nd fish

. Ew

a w

as th

e

How

es' dentist. When N

ick encoun-te

red

a sn

arl in

be

com

ing

a citize

n,

Mary L

ouise

How

e m

ove

d q

uickly

to h

ave

a frie

nd a

nd n

eig

hbor w

ho

was a

US

. Senato

r alle

viate

the

difficu

lty. E

wa's trem

ulous voice on the tele-phone th

at N

ew

Year's D

ay, 1

976,

insta

ntly

ale

rted

the

Ho

we

s th

at

something w

as terribly wrong. T

hey

19

81

listened in

.asto

nish

ment to

Ew

a's

story. B

ill How

e, who had spent 25 years

in va

rious a

reas o

f the in

tellig

ence

busin

ess, w

as a

ble

to m

ake

more

se

nse

out o

f the clu

es th

an E

wa

could. His counsel w

as to bring into th

e fo

ld o

f con

fide

nce

Ro

be

rt an

d

He

len

Ku

pp

erm

an

, mu

tua

l frien

ds

of the Shadrins' and the H

owes' w

ho had e

xcelle

nt co

nnectio

ns a

t the

State D

epartment.

At th

e tim

e o

f Shadrin

's disa

p-

pearance, Robert - K

upperm

an w

as

chie

f scien

tist for th

e A

rms C

on

trol

and D

isarm

am

ent A

gency. H

ele

n

Kupperm

an was an attorney for the

National A

eronautics and Space A

d-m

inis

tratio

n. T

he

y h

ad

me

t the

S

hadrins about eight years earlier. K

up

pe

rma

n w

as re

pe

ate

dly im

-pressed w

ith Shadrin's distinguished

connections. He recalls, for instance,

tha

t Sh

ad

rin in

trod

uce

d h

im to

A

dm

. Sta

nsfie

ld T

urn

er, w

ho la

ter

became director of the C

IA. K

upper-m

an a

lso w

as a

ware

of S

hadrin

's clo

se a

ssocia

tion w

ith A

dm

. Rufu

s T

aylor, who in the late '6os held the

second-highest positions at the CIA

and D

irk. K

up

pe

rma

n b

eg

an

callin

g p

er-

sonal friends in sensitive positions at th

e S

tate

Departm

ent. B

ut e

ven

those frie

nds w

ould

not te

ll him

a

nyth

ing

spe

cific. On

e d

id e

xpre

ss h

orro

r ove

r "the

go

vern

me

nts p

lac-

ing a

n A

meric

an c

itizen in

such

extre

me je

opard

y." Anoth

er to

ld

Ku

pp

erm

an

the

situa

tion

wa

s no

ne

of h

is busin

ess, a

ddin

g th

at "it is

a sad and hopeless case."

On January 6, at the urging of the

Ho

we

s an

d th

e K

up

pe

rma

ns, E

wa

te

lephoned W

oote

n. S

he to

ld h

im

that he must give her a better idea of

what N

ick h

ad b

een d

oin

g if h

e

expected her to continue putting off people w

ho were asking repeatedly

wh

en

Nick w

ou

ld b

e b

ack.

Th

at e

ven

ing

, pro

mp

tly at n

ine

, W

ooten arrived at the Kupperm

ans•' hom

e. B

ill and M

ary L

ouise

How

e

were there along w

ith Ew

a. They sat

aro

und th

e d

inin

g-ro

om

table

. W

oo

ten

told

the

ga

the

ring

tha

t during the sum

mer of 1966 S

hadrin h

ad

be

en

ap

pro

ach

ed

by a

So

viet

inte

llige

nce

ag

en

t in d

ow

nto

wn

W

ash

ingto

n. T

he a

gent p

ropose

d

that Shadrin go to w

ork as a spy for th

e S

ovie

t Un

ion

. Sh

ad

rin h

ad

sta

lled th

e a

gent a

nd re

porte

d th

e

approach to the FB

I. Im

mediately, an opportunity w

as seen to exploit the situation. T

he FB

I pro

pose

d th

at S

hadrin

pla

y alo

ng

with

the

So

viets.

According to the other five people

at th

e m

eetin

g th

at n

ight, W

oote

n

sta

ted

tha

t fot "c

lose

to a

ye

ar"

Sh

ad

rin re

fuse

d th

e F

BI's re

qu

est.

Fin

ally

, Woote

n s

aid

, Shadrin

's

friend and mentor A

dm. R

ufus Tay-

lor "twisted his arm

" and persuaded him

to co-operate. Nick's role w

as to pass C

IA-doctored inform

ation about the U

.S. N

avy to the Soviets.

Ove

r and o

ver, th

e sa

me q

ues-

tion a

rose

: how

could

som

eone a

s intelligent as N

ick Shadrin ever have

consented to become involved in a

dangero

us co

unte

rinte

lligence

op-

eration? The answ

er was alw

ays the 20

Page 6: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

Read w

hy Com

plete,with

its unique cleansing system,

gets dentures so dean you can actually feel the difference.

Run your tongue over your

dentures. If they don't feel really sm

ooth and fresh, try Com

plete®

Com

plete is unlike any other denture cleanser. Its unique cleansing system

contains sm

aller, rounded particles that clean aw

ay tough stains—plus

the stubborn film that tablets

can't touch. A

nd because Com

plete actu-ally polishes your dentures sm

oother, they feel cleaner, and stay cleaner longer, too.

Try C

omplete. A

nd feel the sm

ooth ,fresh difference it makes.

You can feel how w

ell it deans.

February

same: patriotism

and Rufus T

aylor. T

he five listeners were even m

ore in

credulo

us as W

ooten

describ

ed

how

Shad

rin h

ad b

een sen

t out o

f th

e cou

ntry

in th

e early '7

os o

n

missions to m

eet with the S

oviets. To

exp

erienced

min

ds lik

e tho

se of

Kupperm

an and How

e, the extreme

dan

ger o

f the b

asic operatio

n w

as m

agnified hundreds of times by al-

lowing S

hadrin to meet w

ith Soviet

agen

ts ou

tside o

f the co

un

try. H

e w

as, after all, living under a Soviet

death sentence. The slightest indica-

tion Shadrin w

as playing the Soviets

for fools could be his downfall.

Shadrin's first m

eeting with S

ovi-et agents outside of the country took place on a trip to M

ontreal in 1971, W

ooten said. Indeed, Ew

a recalled a "business m

eeting" Nick had during

their v

acation

in C

anad

a. Wo

oten

said that S

hadrin again met w

ith the S

oviets in Vienna in 1972. O

n that trip N

ick was aw

ay from the S

had-rin

s' ho

tel ov

ernig

ht, so

that th

e S

oviets had time to train him

in the use of sophisticated espionage equip-m

ent. A

gain

, Ew

a remem

bered

a "business m

eeting." A

few days after the gathering at

the K

up

perm

ans' h

ou

se, Wo

oten

dropped by to see E

wa. H

e brought another FB

I agen

t alon

g w

ith h

im.

Wooten

told

Ew

a that fo

llow

ing

Nick's m

eeting with the S

oviets in 1972, so

me esp

ionag

e equip

men

t had been sent by diplom

atic pouch to the S

oviet embassy in W

ashing-ton and had then been turned over to

Nick

by h

is K

GB

contact. T

he

FBI

thought it b

est to rem

ove th

e

1981

equipment now

that Nick w

as gone. E

wa readily agreed, though she

could not imagine w

hat could be in th

e house th

at she d

id n

ot k

now

ab

out. W

ooten

strode to

Nick

's study, reached unerringly for a par- ticu

lar book an

d flip

ped

it open

. E

wa saw

that the inside of the book w

as hollowed out, creating a cavity

where som

ething could be hidden. T

hen

Wooten

told

Ew

a that

somew

here in the attic there was a

radio

transm

itter. Listen

ing

to h

is d

escriptio

n, E

wa felt certain

she

would have noticed som

ething that size, but she had not. S

till, she took the m

en to the attic, but they could find nothing. T

hen Ew

a happened to

pick

up a b

ox o

f thin

gs sto

red

there th

at belo

nged

to o

ne o

f her

friend

s. Ben

eath th

at was a card

-board box w

hich Wooten instantly

recognized as containing the trans-m

itter. Wooten and his assistant car-

ried it downstairs and loaded it into

the trunk of Wooten's car.

A W

arning

BA

CK

IN

1959, soon after th

eir d

ramatic escap

e to S

wed

en, N

ick

and Ew

a were taken under the w

ing of an officer of the R

oyal Sw

edish N

avy, Cm

dr. Sven R

ydstrom, w

ho spoke excellent R

ussian and English.

Then

came so

me th

ree week

s of

interrogation by Sw

edish naval and intelligence officials. R

ydstrom in-

form

ed th

em th

at his g

overn

men

t w

ould do its best to accomm

odate them

in Sw

eden. How

ever, he ex-plained, because of its proxim

ity to S

oviet-controlled countries, Sw

eden

CA

N Y

OU

R IA

N I IIK

I .S

PA

SS

7111: LO

NG

UE

, II I

If your dentures don't pass the tongue test, take advantage of the coupon below

and start feeling the difference C

omplete

can make.

1 15 ( ST

OR

E C

OU

PO

N

1 0

"`C Om

m

etc

SA

VE

W O

N C

OM

PLE

TE

! NO

TICE 10 DEALER. You are authorized to redeem this coupon

for 15 cents plus 7 cents handling provided it is taken in paym

ent on any size of Com

plete. Mail to S

tubs Toiletry Products, Box 1336, C

linton, Iowa 52734. C

oupon will not be

honored and will be void w

hen presented by outside agencies. brokers or others w

ho are not retail distributors of our m

erchandise or specifically authorized by us to present coupons for redem

ption or when abused. prohibited, taxed or

otherwise restricted. N

ontransferable. Good only on item

specified above. Invoice covering purchase of sufficient stock to cover coupons presented for redem

ption must be

shown on request. C

ustomer m

ost pay any sales tax. Cash

value 1/20 or I cent. Coupon Expires D

ecember 31.1981.

23900 1

02247

204

205

Page 7: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SH.1D

RIN

: TH

E SP

Y W

HO

NE

VE

R C

AM

E B

AC

K

All You N

eed is B

ayerA spirin

.

MOUNT SI:HELENS APTierS

DEMOCRATSAFGHAV REPUBLICANS *3

* It is the m

ost corn-

plete, up-to-date Alm

anac m

oney can buy because it's the O

NL

Y A

lmanac that covers the

FU

LL

year of 1980. * It has special FO

CU

S articles that d

etail major even

ts of the year. * It is d

ivided

into forty

main

sections b

y alph

abet for easy referen

ce. * It high

-lights im

portant events of the year in each section. * It is 1980 C

OM

PL

ET

E in w

ords and pictures. SEN

D F

OR

IT!

SE

ND

NO

MO

NE

Y N

OW

! Sen

d yo

ur n

ame an

d ad

dress to

R

eader's Digest, D

ept. OS

7549-C, P

leasantville, N.Y

. 10570. W

e will b

ill you

later for $4.98 p

lus file p

ost-

age an

d ap

plicab

le state tax, If any. (P

rice and

po

st-age subject to change w

ithout notice. Order subject to

acceptance and credit approval by Reader's D

igest.) 112eadat

was a d

ifficult p

lace to relo

cate defecto

rs. Englan

d w

ould

also b

e recep

tive—

an o

ptio

n th

e Sw

edes

would expedite if the couple w

ished. It w

as Ew

a wh

o p

rop

osed

that

they

go

to th

e Un

ited S

tates, bu

t R

yd

strom

had

grav

e reservatio

ns.

"Th

e Am

ericans w

ill use y

ou

and

abandon you," he w

arned, according to E

wa. D

espite this cautionary note, E

wa approached the A

merican em

-bassy, and they w

ere granted politi-cal asylum

. T

he embassy m

ade arrangements

to fly

the co

up

le to F

rank

furt first.

There, U

.S. intelligence people took

them

to a h

ouse o

n th

e outsk

irts of th

e c

ity, w

here

their d

ays

were filled

with

interv

iews an

d

interrogations. B

oth

Nick

and E

wa w

ere giv

en

polygraph tests, and there were long,

seemingly pointless interview

s with

psychiatrists. After three w

eeks, they w

ere info

rmed

that th

ey h

ad b

een

cleared fo

r transfer to

the U

nited

S

tates. They arrived in W

ashington on A

ugust 22

, 1959, and were taken

to a "safe" house in Virginia.

TH

E D

EF

EC

TIO

N

of N

iko

lai Arta-

monov coincided w

ith a crucial peri-od in the developm

ent of the Soviet

navy—a period w

hen U.S

. Naval in-

telligence analysts were m

ore inter-ested

than

ever in

learnin

g S

ov

iet techniques and intentions. W

hile the U

nited States m

aintained a strong N

aval superiority, there was no ques-

tion

that th

e So

viets w

ere gain

ing

broadly and rapidly.

Fro

m th

e start the C

IA seem

s to have had little active interest in A

rta-m

onov. Spies have an insatiable hun-

ger for documents, and A

rtamonov

had

bro

ught n

ot a sh

red o

f pap

er w

ith h

im. W

hat h

e did

brin

g, o

f course, w

as a vast store of knowledge

about the Soviet navy. B

ut that alone seem

s not to have been sufficient for th

e CIA

to w

ant to

dev

elop A

rta-m

onov in

to o

ne o

f its ow

n re

-sources—

as it did with a num

ber of the im

portant defectors from S

oviet intelligence services.

And A

rtamonov seem

s to h

ave

had little interest in dealing with the

CIA

. More th

an sim

ply

hav

ing n

o

back

gro

un

d in

So

viet in

telligen

ce operatio

ns, A

rtamonov ap

pears to

have scorned the K

GB

officers he had k

no

wn

. Ind

eed, h

e rather clearly

thought the skills of his intelligence counterparts—

Am

erican or Soviet—

were crude com

pared with those of

highy trained military m

en. S

till, it was up to the C

IA to pass

judgment on the subject of A

rtamo-

nov's authenticity as a defector, his bona fides. T

he Soviets had becom

e increasingly skilled at sending out phony defectors w

ho, if accepted, could do enorm

ous damage.

The guards assigned to the safe

house were, in N

ick's eyes, not much

different from S

oviet security per-so

nn

el. Th

ey seem

ed slo

pp

y an

d

spent much of their tim

e watching

television. S

hadrin's toleration point for in-com

petence was exceedingly low

, an

d fin

ally, o

ne n

ight, h

e had

had

enough. H

e woke up in the m

iddle of th

e nig

ht an

d tip

toed

dow

n th

e 207

You get m

ore for your m

oney w

ith the R

eader% D

igest 1981 A

lmanac

and Yearbook!

"A

n m

eet to any p

enes w

ho w

ean to slay w

ell-!p

lowm

en In

fhb

sosapileated

world

. Th

e Into,.

madam

Is am to A

nd and wars to read."

—Seance B

arry M. G

oldwater

BaY

fr Just100% n &

wh

at do

ctors

recom

men

d m

ost.

bid you know there are other pain relievers that contain

drugs doctors do not recomm

end most for m

inor arthritis pain? B

ayer is 100% pure aspirin. A

nd aspirin is doctors' num

ber one drug of choice for arthritis pain. And m

illions use B

ayer again and again with no stom

ach upset. For

hours of reNef, all you need is B

ayer* Aspirin.

Read and follow

label direction

s.

Page 8: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SH

AD

RIN

TH

E S

PY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

BA

CK

steps. H

e fo

und th

ree o

f the

CIA

g

uard

s sou

nd

asleep at th

eir po

sts. C

arefully

he rem

oved

the b

ullets

from

each m

an's w

eapon. T

he n

ext

mo

rnin

g, after elicitin

g a few

corn

-m

ents fro

m th

e gu

ards ab

ou

t their

vig

ilant n

igh

t, Nick

gav

e back

the

amm

un

ition

.

Extrao

rdin

ary C

on

tributio

n

AB

OU

T T

EN

DA

YS

after Sh

adrin

's arrival, L

t. Cm

dr. Thom

as L. D

wyer

of th

e Office o

f Nav

al Intellig

ence

was n

otified

that h

e cou

ld b

egin

the

lon

g-term

deb

riefing

. Bill H

ow

e is p

ositiv

e that S

had

rin's b

ona fid

es had

been

accepted

by th

e CIA

at the

time th

ey tu

rned

him

ov

er to th

e O

NI. "T

here is n

o w

ay th

ey w

ould

expose senior analytical personnel to h

im if th

ey h

ad an

y q

uestio

ns," h

e says.

Shadrin w

as elated when told that

he w

ou

ld b

e meetin

g a N

avy m

an,

and fro

m th

e first mom

ent, D

wyer

and h

e go

ralong sp

lendid

ly. "It w

as as if th

ere were n

o lan

gu

age b

arrier w

ith T

om

Dw

yer," say

s Ew

a. "He

was so

gracio

us, so

friendly

, such

a gen

tleman

." W

ith h

is intro

ductio

n to

Dw

yer,

Shadrin began nine m

onths of steady d

ebriefin

g b

y th

e O

NI. T

he sco

pe

of S

had

rin's in

form

ation w

as stun-

ning—ranging from

technical aspects of m

issiles and co

mm

unicatio

n sy

s-tem

s to strateg

ic and tactical th

ink-

ing

of S

oviet m

ilitary lead

ers. At a

time w

hen

the S

ov

iet Un

ion

was

officially

den

igratin

g th

e impor-

tance of developing a global navy, in reality

, Shad

rin ex

plain

ed, it w

as 208

carefully

con

structin

g ju

st such

a cap

acity. S

had

rin also

con

tribu

ted

details about a secret Soviet decision

in February 1955 to adopt a doctrine

of surprise nuclear attack against the U

nited

States.

Th

e a

rea o

f Sh

ad

rin's g

reate

st im

med

iate con

tribu

tion

con

cerned

S

ov

iet anti-su

bm

arine tactics. "H

e co

uld

tell us h

ow

So

viet d

estroy

ers w

ere

go

ing

to re

act to

ou

r best

sub

marin

es," says D

wy

er. "Th

e in-

form

ation w

as invalu

able."

In fa

ct, in

the sp

ring

of 1

96

0,

Sh

adrin

wen

t to N

orfo

lk, V

a., for

anti-submarine m

aneuvers. The idea

was to let S

hadrin conduct simulated

warfa

re a

gain

st a so

phistic

ate

d

Am

eric

an

nu

cle

ar su

b. N

ot o

nly

w

ou

ld th

e officers ab

oard

the d

e-stroyer benefit from

seeing the way a

skilled

Soviet co

mm

ander h

ad b

een

trained

to resp

ond, b

ut th

e crew o

f th

e su

bm

arin

e w

ou

ld le

arn

from

observing his tactical finesse.

Nick

Shad

rin—

Cap

t. Nik

olai A

r-tam

onov again for a few hours—

took over the destroyer. N

ot long into the exercise, he had the subm

arine in the positio

n h

e wan

ted it. T

wo h

undred

feet b

elow

, the su

b ro

lled erratically

as sh

e spun an

d sp

ed fro

m th

e de-

stroyer. W

ith alm

ost in

stant p

reci- sio

n, S

had

rin's d

estroyer p

ush

ed

thro

ugh th

e w

ate

rs, keepin

g its

po

sition

on

the su

bm

arin

e. T

he

Am

erican N

avy

men

were d

eeply

im

pressed. F

or N

ick, it w

as child

's play

," say

s To

m D

wy

er. "He to

ld m

e the

sub w

as a fat, slow

-movin

g targ

et." A

t the e

nd o

f nin

e m

onth

s the

"A 20-MIN

UTE C

ALL A

NYW

HER

E IN TH

E CO

UN

TRY

WILL C

OST M

E ON

LY $3.33? WH

AT'S TH

E CA

TCH

?"

NiI C

atd

1 N

a b

idd

en

C,AS YMI Can

telephone v

isit with

out o

f state fam

ily and friend:: for 20 inimites foi $;i 33m

r le,s That includes tax

Ju

,t bc sure to dial direct when ram

s are lowest

K.

That's any tim

e Saturday incl S

unday t di 5mr, if you

avieo of ,e,. .+00

Tw

enty

min

utes isim

t an ex

amp

le An

d i

0,12.: 0 4

016;1

;, e

.- prefer. ;In

v n

ight after li ill 8

in th

e morn

ing

$3 :i3 is for the maxim

um di,tance. so

V'5

0

many of your calls m

ind rust li, s

, O

ti ros

440

00°̀

eto

4 4

,64Ok e

T

he chart 174.1(1W

gives you cte

ri;461,

many m

ore city to city prices 64 6.4

0;0

' I lav

e a nu

, visit.

0

,,00 9L,,,ss°,0 4

t. s'Oskte

e 0.1,c"I'te

0-1 0'e -,,6 10

s° 0'1.3%

44 00

5° v

6 01 0

, 0

B

ell S

ystem

Nh

l

En)

8111123En 031EICCIES30=

UZEICIUUEUIELE UCIENDIEL3GCOU3EIZ

U1103121103FE

UZ

IGII

03311038303111312 1 KG

01:1031011333:0103 0

30

31 :10E

011013111:13ECIUDEMECIUM

ESEIME

01103[1003311133113:11 13113 UM

EE

12110333

16 UM

UM

IN1EEIE1313313 3

Ell

UE

IUT

IMIE

I3 3 02 UZ

IMIU

DE

cio

na

nu

min

S

U 2 62 0

303033:1

33U

CIU

DO

LIE

CIU

: 10 / 1111 EU1 3 3' U

3E131031501:3131 1 3

'6 3

'2 U

3

'6 U3E

3 M

IUM

EICIU

ME1103E1131 1:11 0

3 : 010:13 Ito 3 4

3 33 3 .-2 ME

RE

Page 9: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

BO

OK

SE

CT

ION

F

ebruary 0

NE

VE

R C

AM

E B

AC

K

consensus among O

NI officials w

as that S

hadrin's contribution had been extraordinary. M

any senior analysts felt it w

as importan

t to b

ring h

im

into the ON

I in an official capacity, so that the U

nited States could continue

to benefit from his know

ledge. B

ut the ON

I had never hired a So-

viet defector, and there was som

e op-position to such a m

ove. In the end T

om

Dw

yer an

d B

ill How

e were

able to dispel these doubts, and Shad-

rin to

ok

a po

st in th

e Tran

slation

U

nit, although he was on call by the

various intelligence agencies of the g

ov

ernm

ent th

at mig

ht fin

d h

im

useful. W

ith a lump-sum

payment from

the C

IA for his m

onths of consulting services, S

hadrin made a dow

n pay-m

ent on a small house in A

rlington, V

a. An

d at last h

e and

Ew

a were

married. N

ick was pleased w

ith his job, and E

wa w

as planning to return to

den

tal scho

ol so

that sh

e cou

ld

practice d

entistry

in th

e Un

ited

States.

Of all th

ose w

ho

adm

ired N

ick

Sh

adrin

, no

on

e felt mo

re stron

gly

about him

than did Tom

Dw

yer. But

on

e thin

g w

orried

Dw

yer a g

rcat deal. F

or most of his career D

wyer

had

wo

rked

in N

aval in

telligen

ce. B

ut he had also known som

e of the people involved in C

IA counterintel-

ligence. He knew

something about

their instincts, their values, and the so

rts of situ

ation

s they

mig

ht b

e tem

pted to exploit. D

wyer felt that N

ick Shadrin w

as id

eally su

ited fo

r use in

a cou

nter-

intelligence operation. He knew

that 21

0

the C

IA

could

play

on S

had

rin's

fierce anti-Soviet attitudes, as w

ell as his p

atriotism

tow

ard th

e United

S

tates, in co

nv

incin

g h

im to

wo

rk

against the Soviets.

Brin

gin

g h

is thoughts in

to th

e open, D

wyer told S

hadrin to resist an

y su

ch o

vertu

re, no

matter h

ow

n

ob

le the u

ltimate g

oal m

igh

t ap-

pear. S

ov

iet cou

nterin

telligen

ce agents w

ere also highly skilled, he said

. Ev

en m

ore serio

us, D

wy

er w

arned, was his feeling that the C

IA

counterintelligence officers would

not necessarily have Shadrin's w

el-fare forem

ost in their minds.

Shadrin accepted D

wyer's w

arn-ing gravely, pensively.

The C

autious Spy

IN D

ECEMBER 1961, a S

oviet defec-tor nam

ed Anatoli M

. Golitsin ar-

rived in the United States. A

t the time

of his defection, he was a m

ajor in the K

GB

department that specialized in

clandestine activities abroad. His rev-

elations about Soviet penetration of

Western intelligence services w

ere to have thundering reverberations.

Golitsin's tales of penetration in

the French governm

ent were so seri-

ous that some of President C

harles de G

aulle's top advisers fell under suspi-cio

n. P

. L. T

hyrau

d d

e Vosjo

li, a high-ranking F

rench intelligence of-fic

er, la

ter a

sserte

d th

at G

olit-

sin ex

hib

ited "an

intricate g

rasp

of th

e inner w

ork

ings o

f Fren

ch

intelligence." G

olitsin

's leads to

uch

ed o

ther

countries. Kim

Phil by, the celebrated Soviet spy in B

ritish intelligence, was

1981 S

HA

DR

IN: T

HE

SP

Y W

H

exposed with his help. Inform

ation supplied by G

olitsin also contributed to the dow

nfall of Stig E

ric Wcnner-

strom, the Soviet spy w

hose treachery scandalized S

weden.

Golitsin also provided leads to a

high-level penetration of U.S

. intelli-gence. B

ut his leads were not suffi-

cient to bring about the exposure of any A

merican intelligence personnel.

Golitsin's living conditions w

ere alm

ost extravagant. He and his w

ife h

ad b

een g

iven

a fine h

ou

se in

Virg

inia. T

he

CIA

fu

rnish

ed h

im

with

a car and

a chau

ffeur. M

rs. G

olitsin had a maid.

Bu

t the

CIA

seem

ed u

nab

le to

offer him security. Intensely para-

no

id, G

olitsin

acqu

ired tw

o fierce

Germ

an shepherds that were often

at his side. Surely G

olitsin's tension w

as heightened by his wondering if

in fact h

e was d

ealing w

ith secret

Soviet agents operating in the C

IA.

Nor, at first, did the C

IA seem

able to

giv

e him

a friend. F

ortu

itously

, N

ick Shadrin had been feeling the

same tug for com

panionship with a

native Russian. T

he CIA

orchestrated th

e intro

ductio

n in

early O

Cto

ber

1962. F

rom the initial m

eeting the two

men got along w

ell. They shared a

love for long conversations, based on their intricate know

ledge of politics and history. A

nd both men had an

interest, fo

r differen

t reasons, in

G

erman shepherds.

Shad

rin an

d G

olitsin

did

not

know that they also shared a bond as

Soviet defectors in w

hom C

IA coun-

terintelligence chief James A

ngleton had faith. Few

Soviet defectors had

ever w

on th

e trust o

f the ev

er- cautious A

ngleton. If S

hadrin was provoked over the

man

ner o

f the C

IA in dealing w

ith him

, he soon realized his complaints

were triv

ial. Leg

itimately

or n

ot,

Golitsin w

as developing a towering

resentment against the C

IA. H

e was

angry with their people, their m

eth-ods, w

hat he perceived to be their procedural inefficiency. In spite of exceedingly elaborate security m

eas-ures, he believed that at any m

oment

he could be plucked off the streets by the K

GB

. W

hat worried him

as much as his

personal protection was the C

IA's fail-

ure to get other intelligence agencies to follow

his leads. And the A

gency had m

ade no progress in rooting out its ow

n penetration by the Soviets

that Golitsin had pointed to.

(Nearly

20 y

ears later, Golitsin

recalled to R

eader's Digest that dur-

ing one of his final meetings w

ith S

had

rin, h

e warn

ed h

im th

at he

should order Ew

a to make no m

ore telep

ho

ne calls to

her p

arents in

P

olan

d. T

he im

plicatio

n w

as that

such calls would facilitate the S

ovi-ets' efforts to locate the S

hadrins and th

at indeed

these calls m

ay h

ave

played a role in Nick's dow

nfall.) F

inally, Golitsin told S

hadrin he co

uld

take n

o m

ore. H

e said h

e believed he w

ould be safer and hap-pier in E

ngland, and made plans to

leave in February 1963.

Golitsin

knew

how

much

the

Shadrins adm

ired his lovely home,

and insisted on selling it to them for a

211

Page 10: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SHA

DR

IN: T

HE

SPY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

BA

CK

price far b

elow

the m

arket v

alue.

Nick felt this w

ould be an improper

gift, and stoutly declined. Later, after

Sh

adrin

also refu

sed to

accept an

expensive color-T

V set, E

wa found it

one morning sitting on the doorstep.

Bu

t the m

ost lastin

g g

ift from

G

olitsin

was o

ne o

f the G

erman

shepherds w

hich served as a guard. S

had

rin w

as delig

hted

to h

ave th

e dog

and

imm

ediately

nam

ed it

Dzh

ulb

ars, after a Russian

dog

roughly comparable to L

assie in the U

nited States. Q

uickly, the dog be-cam

e kn

ow

n as Ju

lik. H

e wo

uld

rem

ain one of Shadrin's closest com

-panions for the next 13 years.

Som

etime after this, N

ick present-ed E

wa w

ith a snub-nosed, .38-cali-ber S

mith and W

esson and told her alw

ays to

carry it w

hen

she to

ok

Julik

walk

ing. H

e said h

e wan

ted

her to have the gun for her protec-tion as w

ell as to protect Julik in case he w

as attacked

by a larg

er dog.

When he took the dog out, S

hadrin occasionally—

in Ew

a s presence—strapped on a holster that housed his h

eavy

9-m

m. W

alther au

tom

atic. N

ick once explained to her that he, to

o, w

orried

about Ju

lik's b

eing

attacked.

Grow

ing Frustration

ON

E. O

F T

HE

GR

EA

TE

ST

professional p

leasures in

Nick

Sh

adrin

's first years at the O

ffice of Naval Intelli-

gence was his association w

ith Vice

Adm

iral Rufus L

. Taylor.

"I cou

ld n

ot tell y

ou

just w

hen

th

eir friendsh

ip started

,' says o

ne

Nav

al officer w

ith secu

rity clear-

212

ances, w

ho w

ork

ed acro

ss the h

all from

Nick's office. "B

ut I do know

that during those early years Taylor,

who w

as then in charge of the Intelli-gence D

ivision, would be in there for

an h

our at a tim

e talkin

g to

Nick

." T

he Naval officer, w

ho greatly ad-m

ired Shadrin, w

as constantly aware

of th

e thin

gs h

e wish

ed h

e cou

ld

discu

ss with

Nick

bu

t held

back

because S

hadrin did not have a secu-rity

clearance. H

e remem

bers th

at R

ufus Taylor had no such com

punc-tion. "It w

as quite routine for them

to be talking about classified Naval

intelligence,' he says. D

urin

g th

e early '6

os, S

had

rin's

valu

e to th

e Un

ited S

tates rang

ed

far beyond his consulting duties at the O

NI. H

e addressed mem

bers of the Joint C

hiefs of Staff about S

oviet naval strategy and capabilities. H

e briefed the com

manders at A

tlantic F

leet head

qu

arters and

on

several

occasions flew to H

awaii, w

here he gav

e briefin

gs at th

e Pacific F

leet headquarters.

More im

portant to Shadrin w

ere his frequent invitations to lecture at the N

aval War C

ollege. He delivered

his first lecture there on October 27,

i96

1. T

his an

d o

ther ap

pearan

ces w

on Shadrin glow

ing "Dear N

ick" letters o

f than

ks fro

m A

dm

. Stan

-field T

urner, who later becam

e presi-dent of the C

ollege. D

urin

g th

e first half o

f the '6

os

Shadrin's life w

as enriched by many

new

experien

ces and asso

ciations,

endearin

g frien

dsh

ips, an

d m

uch

huntin

g an

d fish

ing. B

ut slo

wly

S

hadrin's friends began to sense his

AD

VE

RT

ISE

ME

NT

Do you

kn

ow

w

hat you

r ab

ou

t b

od

y

kn

ow

s vitam

in C

? C

ut your arm. B

um your hand. B

reak a leg. N

one of these will heal properly w

ithout adequate vitam

in C along w

ith other essential nutrients. Nor w

ill severe bruises or w

ounds heal properly.

Sore throat. Earache. H

igh fever. A

ll can begin with an infection that overw

helms your

body's natural defenses. Vitam

in C, along w

ith other essential nutrients,optim

izes your body's natural capacity to resist illness and helps keep

your tissues healthy.

Up tight or up in sm

oke. W

ith both acute stress and heavy cigarette smoking, the

plasma levels of vitam

in C in your blood m

ay be lowered.

So, you could be robbing your body of this essential vitam

in without even know

ing it.

Up your iron.

Vitam

in C increases your body's ability to absorb iron

from food w

hen they are taken together. Iron is the m

ost comm

on deficiency in the diet, and may be related

to a loss of energy.. T

here are many reasons w

hy your body needs an adequate intake of vitam

in C. Y

et your body doesn't m

ake it. Vitam

in C m

ust come from

food or vitamin

supplements. So, eat a balanced diet. Y

ou can also look for fortified foods w

hen you shop or take a supplement

containing vitamin C

every day just to be sure. V

itamin C

omm

unications, Hoffm

ann-La R

oche Inc., N

utley, N.J. 07110

Vitam

ins. Something you can do for your health.

RCD 3276

Page 11: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

BO

OK

SEC

TIO

N

gro

win

g fru

stration o

ver th

e pro

-fessional lim

itations he faced with-

out a secu

rity clearan

ce. With

the

passage of time—

and his distancing from

the Soviet navy—

Shadrin's po-

tential as an analyst was increasingly

stunted

. His sto

re of k

now

ledge

could

not b

e replen

ished

with

the

fresh classified information that w

as b

eing

gath

ered o

n S

ov

iet nav

al technology.

On one occasion W

illiam H

owe

raised the issue with R

ufus Taylor,

who agreed to try to get a clearance

for Shadrin. T

he response was nega-

tive. N

o p

ruden

t security

agen

cy

cou

ld affo

rd to

risk th

e min

uscu

le ch

ance th

at Shad

rin w

as really a

Soviet agent.

In spite of his frustrations, Shadrin

gave outward signs that he continued

to en

joy h

is work

. He to

ok g

reat pride in E

wa's accom

plishments. S

he had quickly m

astered her dental pro-g

ram; h

er lang

uag

e skills ev

en ex

-ceeded his ow

n, and she was readily

com

patib

le with

her A

merican

pa-

tients and friends. B

ut S

had

rin d

id sp

eak to

his

friend

s abo

ut E

wa's su

ccess com

-pared w

ith his own. S

he was earning

more m

oney than he and had estab-lished herself in a life-long career. It deeply concerned N

ick that his own

professional life was strikingly less

successful. S

hadrin was w

orking at the ON

! under a five-year contract, expiring in

1965. H

e was th

e only

defecto

r ever to w

ork as a consultant for the O

NI,

and h

ad b

een co

nsisten

tly

praised for his exceptional contribu- 214

February

lions. B

ut h

is contract w

as not

renewed.

By this tim

e, the DIA

had

been

established and m

any functions of the O

NI w

ere being taken over by the new

agency. A job had been offered

to S

had

rin at th

e D

IA, b

ut it w

as in a departm

ent Shadrin felt w

as a catch-all for m

aladjusted defectors. S

had

rin w

as insu

lted. N

either h

e n

or h

is friend

s con

sidered

he w

as in

the sa

me le

ague w

ith o

ther

defectors. T

hen word cam

e that he had been given an extension of six m

onths on his

ON

I co

ntract. T

his w

as good

news, but he knew

there would be

no extension beyond that. A

fter the en

d o

f the ex

tensio

n,

Shadrin brooded for another three

months before taking the job w

ith the D

IA. It w

as less of a humiliation

than

failing

to d

raw a salary

. He

reported

for w

ork

in M

arch 1

966.

No doubt S

hadrin was gratified that

Adm

iral Taylor him

self had agreed to accept a job at the D

IA.

But T

aylor stayed there only brief-ly before accepting the second-high-est p

ositio

n in

the

CIA

. T

aylor's departure from

the DIA

must have

been

a great d

isappoin

tmen

t to

Shadrin.

Mysteries

EA

RL

Y O

NE

MO

RN

ING

in the spring o

f 19

66

the telep

ho

ne ran

g in

the

Wash

ing

ton

ho

me o

f Rich

ard M

. H

elms, w

ho had recently been ap-p

oin

ted d

irector o

f the C

IA. T

he

caller, wh

o cam

e to b

e kn

ow

n as

Igor, described himself as an officer

1981 SH

AD

RIN

: TH

E SP

Y W

HO

NE

VE

R C

AM

E B

AC

K

of th

e KG

B. Ig

or w

as goin

g to

be in

work

ed to

get h

im to

confess h

is

Wash

ing

ton

for o

nly

a few m

ore d

up

licity.*

m

onths, and he wanted H

elms to be

Thus it m

ust have been with spe-

aware o

f his d

esire to w

ork

for th

e cial urg

ency

that S

olie an

d T

urn

er U

nited States. F

ive hours later Igor reported to their superiors that Igor

and US

. intelligence officers, includ- had brought persuasive information

ing the CIA

's Bru

ce Solie, m

et at a which

certified th

at Nosen

ko w

as

safe house in

the W

ashin

gto

n area. n

ot a provocateur—

but, in fact, Was

In subsequent meetings they w

ere just who he claim

ed to be. In view of

joined by Bert T

urner of the S

oviet Counter-

intelligence Section of

the FB

I. T

he d

iversity

and

dep

th o

f Igor's in

for-

mation seem

ed extraor-din

ary, su

pportin

g h

is claim

that h

e held

a hig

h p

ositio

n w

ithin

th

e K

GB

w

hic

h a

s-tounded his A

merican

handlers in view of his

relatively

yo

un

g ag

e. H

e even

repo

rted o

n

current, sensitive activi- ties involving U

.S. in-

telligen

ce officers in

E

uro

pe, in

form

ation

that w

ould

not reach

C

IA

headquarte

rs th

rough n

orm

al chan

-nels for w

eeks. E

mbed

ded

in th

e blizzard

of in

- the reig

nin

g d

istrust o

f Nosen

ko at

formation w

as a clear message con- that tim

e, Igor's certification of No-

cerning Yuri N

osenko, a Soviet w

ho senko's bona fides might have been

had

defected

to th

e United

States in

expected

to set clan

gin

g th

e bells

early 1964 and who also claim

ed to of suspicion.

have been a KG

B officer. F

rom the

Perh

aps it d

id, b

ut ap

paren

tly

time N

osen

ko reach

ed A

merican

so

il, he h

ad fallen

under serio

us

suspicion. In fact Nosenko w

as even now

in detention while C

IA officers

Ew

a Shadrin at her home in M

cLean, V

a., in July 1977

• For a full account of the Nosenko case, see

Legend: The S

ecret World of Lee H

arvey Ouvaid, by

Edw

ard lay Epstein, R

eader's Digest. M

arch and

Ap

ril '78. 215

Page 12: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SH

,4D

RIN

: TH

E S

PY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

BA

CK

Igor's total package—if not entirely

convincing—w

as at least so intrigu-ing that few

were w

illing to discredit Ig

or ju

st becau

se of h

is messag

e ab

out N

osen

ko. M

oreo

ver, it ap

-pears that Igor w

on some pow

erful support to N

osenko's side, for only a few

months later a m

ajor directive w

ent out from H

elms to resolve the

Nosenko question. B

y early summ

er of 1966, with his

credib

ility at a crescen

do

, Igo

r dro

pped

his m

ost in

triguin

g n

ews.

He w

as, he said, in line to rise to one of the highest positions in the KGB—possibly becom

ing the head of the KGB's counterintelligence activities in the U

nited States.

Ho

wev

er, Igo

r exp

lained

, there

was a requirem

ent that had to be met

befo

re he co

uld

assum

e the n

ew

position. There w

as a Soviet defector

livin

g in

the U

nited

States w

hom

R

ussia regarded as extremely im

por-tant. In fact, the KGB had given Igor the assignm

ent of recruiting the de-fecto

r and

had

mad

e his p

rom

ised

new

job co

ntin

gen

t upon th

e suc-

cessful co

mpletio

n o

f this assig

n-

men

t. The d

efector's n

ame, said

Igor, w

as Nikolai A

rtamonov, now

know

n as Nicholas S

hadrin. (T

hough Igor's telephone call to R

ichard Helm

s may have opened a

new phase in his relationship w

ith the C

IA, it appears possible that he

had

been

dealin

g u

nder ex

tremely

covert conditions w

ith certain offi-cers of the counterintelligence staff since about M

arch 1964. One of his

bo

ldest su

gg

estion

s, accord

ing

to

one account, was a proposal that the

216

CIA assist him in recruiting A

natoli G

olitsin to redefect to Soviet ranks.

Igo

r exp

lained

that th

is wo

uld

do

m

uch to hasten his rise in the KGB. G

olitsin was considered too w

ise to be induced to play such a dangerous gam

e, but there is at least one report that the A

mericans countered Igor's

request with an offer to provide him

w

ith S

had

rin. A

round th

is time—

coincidentally or otherwise—

Shadrin

had the first hints that he was to be

turn

ed o

ut o

f his jo

b w

ith th

e ON

I. F

or close to a year, Shadrin resisted

furiously before accepting the job he so hated at the D

IA. It w

as only a few

weeks after S

hadrin finally went to

work at the DIA that Igor placed his

telephone call to Helm

s.) T

he Soviet U

nion, Igor informed

the A

merican

s, kn

ew th

at Sh

adrin

w

as miserab

le in h

is new

job

and

believ

ed th

at he sh

ould

be rip

e for

redefection. Igor himself, how

ever, w

as not so confident. Shadrin's ha-

tred o

f the S

ov

iet regim

e was to

o

great. B

ut, Ig

or su

gg

ested, th

e re-cru

itmen

t mig

ht b

e feasible w

ith a

little help

from

the FBI

and CIA. C

ould they arrange to have Shadrin

redefect, even as a ploy? If Shadrin

would just pretend to redefect, that

would be all Igor needed. M

ysteries hang like cobwebs over

wh

at hap

pen

ed n

ext, b

ut a sin

gle

certainty

emerg

es: a decisio

n w

as reached by the U

nited States to assist

Igor in

the recruitment of S

hadrin. M

oreover, Shadrin w

ould not even be tru

sted to

know

that Ig

or su

p-

po

sedly

was actin

g in

the u

ltimar'

interests of the United S

tates, to say

CV

O

FtesooniOl.9asstou 0" cer,etotesP3cn3N

ceeri 010‘ce.°°‘k

\Polled e)43ef‘ence eee,c1V

P1/4\1;

""*3

4C

sett% 06°.‘e5ikkosiout

tc 0

100

c000kil_aroiltose:o cat:kol e:ou ue a e

caco. cante

..sierdl‘cncjI4s "

wan

t to Jea l- k(ao g

7 OV

99.f° elAek

ec

20 PxiA

t CIO

VS' EV

-14 see523.5000

s ,fx. BOC1'3€2.5690

1.1

1

yoo OR

M .

Page 13: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

218 B

OO

K

no

thin

g o

f Igo

r's special m

ission

. It a

pp

ears th

at a

n in

gen

iou

s schem

e was devised to prevent S

had-rin

from

mak

ing an

outrig

ht re-

jection o

f the first S

oviet o

vertu

re —

wh

ile at the sam

e time m

akin

g

certain th

at he d

id n

ot k

no

w th

at th

e whole p

loy w

as bein

g m

aster-m

inded by the CIA

and FB

I. Appar-

ently he was inform

ed that there had been a sharp increase in the S

oviets' su

rveillan

ce of th

e build

ing

wh

ich

housed the DIA

offices. Shadrin w

as told that, w

hile a number of defec-

tors worked there, he w

as the only one w

ith sufficient stature to interest the S

oviets—thus the S

oviets might

make an approach to him

. If so, he sh

ou

ld av

oid

an o

utrig

ht rejectio

n

and report the approach to the FB

I. S

hadrin must have felt that som

e- SEC

TIO

N

h.b

ruary

one had been particularly prescient w

hen

, a few d

ays later, in

the late

summ

er of 1966, he was approached

by

Igo

r in a p

ub

lic place in

the

Washington area. S

hadrin reported the contact to the F

BI, w

hich suggest-ed that he play along.

Shadrin balked. T

his was precise-

ly the sort of dangerous counterintel-ligence operation T

om D

wyer had

warn

ed h

im to

avoid

. Only

when

A

dmiral T

aylor, Shadrin's respected

colleague, urged him to undertake

the assignment, did he consent.

A central question is w

hether US

. intelligence officials believed that Igor's overture w

as legitimate—

that he w

as not another in the series of su

spected

So

viet p

rov

ocatio

ns. A

burn

ing b

elief in Ig

or's b

ona fid

es w

ou

ld so

mew

hat m

itigate th

e ac-

1981 SH

AD

R1N

: TH

E S

PY

WH

countability of those men w

ho took custody of S

hadrin's future. B

ut James A

ngleton has told Ew

a S

had

rin's atto

rney

, Rich

ard C

opa-

ken, that he concluded that Igor was

a false defecto

r.* R

ichard

Helm

s distances him

self from the question

by explaining that he turned the case over to subordinates and is not sure w

hat happened after that. William

B

ranigan

, a top

FB

I counterintelli-gence offi cia

l who w

as in

on th

e

operation from the start, looks quiz-

zical when he says, "W

ho's Igor?"

*In a confidential meeting after S

hadrin . s disap-pearance, A

ngleton also told Copaken that from

the beginning the F

BI considered Igor a bona fide

Am

erican agent, thus explaining the FB

I's willing-

ness to take risks with S

hadrin to promote such an

important source. H

owever, neither A

ngleton nor C

opaken would confirm

or deny any aspect of this m

eeting.

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

BA

CK

219

William

Colby, a form

er CIA direc-to

r, says flatly

, "I don't recall th

e nam

e Igor at all." Bert T

urner and B

ruce Solie refuse to com

ment.

Only the passage of tim

e would

show w

hether Igor was acting under

control of Moscow

, or on his own and

in the interest of the United States. In

either case, Nicholas S

hadrin had not even a hint of the truth: that Igor—an

d p

erhap

s all of th

e K

GB

—k

new

that Shadrin w

as only pretending to b

e wo

rkin

g fo

r them

, that h

e had

- been duped and put to w

ork by the highest intelligence officials in the U

nited States.

Waiting for Igor

AS

IN E

VE

RY

TH

ING

regarding her h

usb

and

's wo

rk, E

wa h

ad o

nly

a v

agu

e no

tion

of w

hat w

as go

ing

AD

VE

RT

ISE

ME

NT

Helps Shrink Sw

elling O

f Hem

orrhoidal Tissues

Due T

o Inflamm

ation. R

elieves Pain A

nd Itch... G

ives prompt tem

porary relief in many cases

from hem

orrhoidal pain and itch W

hen hemorrhoidal tissues sw

ell, become

inflamed—

it can be very painful for the su

fferer. Bu

t doctors h

ave foun

d a re-

markably successful m

edication which is

so effective that it actu

ally help

s shrin

k

swelling of such tissues. A

nd it does more.

In many cases, it also gives prom

pt relief for h

ours from

the p

ain an

d itch

ing in

hem

orrhoidal tissues. T

his medication is obtainable w

ithout a prescription under th

e nam

e—P

repara-

tion H

O. T

ests by lead

ing d

octors on

hundreds of patients in New

York, W

ash-ington, D

.C. and at a large m

edical center verified P

reparation H gave sim

ilar suc-cessful results in m

any cases. W

hen

you con

sider P

reparation

H

offers so many benefits—

it's no wonder

millions of sufferers buy it each year. T

here's no other formula like P

repara-tion H

. Ointm

ent and suppositories. Use

only as directed.

AD

VE

RT

ISEM

EN

T

Now

... for control of bronchial asthm

a attacks during high-risk

colds and Wu season

Th

is winter, m

any who suffer from

bronchial asthm

a face a high risk of frequent attacks. A

mild cold, flu, or w

inter weather alone can

trigger an attack. D

on't be caught without P

rimatene for relief.

Prim

atene Mist is the fastest type relief know

n for sudden attacks. H

elps stop the attack, restores free breathing in as fast as 15 seconds. A

nd Prim

atene Tablets help keep attacks from

com

ing back for hours with the asthm

a relievers d

octors rescribe m

ost. Get P

rimaten

e toda .

Prim

atene ®

Mist helps stop attacks in seconds, P

rimatene T

ablets helps keep attacks from

coming back for hours.

Without Prim

ates. With Prim

atene

Prim

atene opens clogged breath- in

g tub

es, relaxes spasm

s. You

b

reathe freel . U

se as directed

.

Page 14: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

1981 SH

AD

RIN

: TH

E SP

Y W

HO

NE

VE

R C

AM

E B

AC

K

on. S

he d

oes recall th

at in th

e late '6os she becam

e aware of receiving

frequen

t telephone calls fro

m a

man nam

ed John Funkhouser, w

ho, though she did not know

it, was an

expert on Soviet naval affairs for the

CIA

. After exchanging pleasantries

with

Ew

a, Fu

nk

ho

user w

ou

ld ask

, "Is N

ick around?" He alw

ays called in

the ev

enin

g an

d fo

r on

ly th

e briefest of chats. F

unkhouser, who

concedes he lunched frequently with

Nick, has told E

wa that his associ-

atio

n w

ith S

had

rin w

as p

ure

ly

friendly, but several former C

IA offi-

cers have suggested that he was m

ost lik

ely

the c

onduit fo

r the

CIA

-approved inform

ation being passed on to the S

oviets. A

no

ther v

oice E

wa learn

ed to

know

was Jim

Wooten's. L

ike Funk-

houser, he telephoned Shadrin only

at home in the evening, and, as w

ith F

unkhouser, Ew

a did not meet him

face to face for m

any years. D

uring their first ten years in the U

nited States, the S

hadrins restricted th

eir travel p

rimarily

to th

eir new

country. B

ut in 1969 they made a 17-

day

Euro

pean

tour. P

erhap

s Nick

w

as so confident that he was duping

the Soviets that he no longer feared

reprisals. Also, form

er counterintel-ligence specialists confirm

that it is not uncom

mon for the S

oviets, after a p

eriod

of p

rolo

ng

ed co

ntact, to

su

gg

est that th

e sub

ject meet w

ith

them outside the U

nited States. S

uch a m

eeting

con

firms in

the S

ov

iets' m

inds the validity of their agent. (On

the 1969 trip, however, E

wa argues

con

vin

cing

ly th

at Nick

was n

ever

22

0

away

from

her lo

ng

eno

ug

h fo

r a m

eeting.) Follow

ing this came the

two know

n meetings, first in C

anada in 1971, then in V

ienna in 1972 when

he wasgone from

his hotel overnight. O

f course th

e majo

r reason fo

r sending S

hadrin into the espionage w

ars was to

enh

ance Ig

or's rise

through the ranks of the KG

B. S

ever-al m

on

ths after S

had

rin's recru

it-m

ent as a double agent, Igor's tour of duty in the U

nited States ended. T

his w

as followed by a long silence in the

CIA

's co

un

terintellig

ence o

ffice, bro

ken

only

in th

e early '7

os b

y a

cable fro

m Ig

or, tran

smitted

from

southern F

rance, indicating that he w

as trying to keep in touch. It was a

sign of life. But if A

ngleton's assess-m

ent of Igor was correct, then little

valid information w

as being gleaned from

the KG

B officer. Indeed, given

Angleton's position as counterintelli-

gence chief, his complete distrust of

Igor would have clouded the C

IA's

genuine acceptance of anything he provided.

Th

is was slim

pay

-back

for th

e years S

hadrin had invested as a dou-ble agent. Y

et after the clandestine delivery of the radio transm

itter—a

sop

histicated

piece o

f equ

ipm

ent

never before seen by the FBI—

Shad-rin

's han

dlers w

ere enco

urag

ed to

consider the operation secure. B

ut th

e transm

itter, accord

ing to

Jim

Wo

ote

n, w

as n

ev

er u

sed

. Tw

o

months after its delivery, S

hadrin's contact w

ith the Soviets m

ysteriously stopped.

Nearly tw

o years passed—until the

summ

er of 1974—before the S

oviets

made their reconnection. T

he phone rang; E

wa answ

ered—and the caller

hung up. This happened four or five

times w

ithin

3o m

inutes. F

inally

E

wa asked N

ick to take the next call if one cam

e. The phone rang. N

ick answ

ered. "H

is face sud

den

ly w

as very

strange as he listened," E

wa recalls.

"He responded in m

onosyllables." N

ick explained later that the caller w

as a Russian

emig

re, in n

eed o

f help

, who w

anted

to m

eet him

on

Lorcom

Lane in A

rlington, not far fro

m th

e Sh

adrin

s' ho

me. F

or rea-

son

s she is n

ot clear ab

ou

t, Ew

a begged him

not to go. Instead Nick

called Jim W

ooten and John Funk-

houser. Neither w

as at home. F

inally he reached a third person E

wa w

as not fam

iliar with. S

he did not hear the conversation, but N

ick decided not to m

ake the rendezvous. Much

later, Wooten explained to E

wa that

the caller was from

the KG

B.

In D

ecemb

er the S

oviets ag

ain

made contact—

this time by a cryptic

letter mailed from

Oxon H

ill, Md.

Intrig

ued

by th

e unfam

iliar return

address, E

wa opened and read w

hat she believes to be the first of these m

essages. It contained puzzling in-quiries into S

hadrin's health, coup-led w

ith phrases in Russian. W

hen a second letter arrived, w

hich Ew

a did not read, she asked N

ick about it. He

would not give her an answ

er. W

hile these events were occur-

ring, wrenching changes w

ere tak-ing place at the C

IA that w

ould have a fu

ndam

ental b

earing o

n th

e case involving S

hadrin and Igor. Helm

s had

resign

ed in

19

73

, soo

n to

be

replaced by William

Colby. U

nder the new

regime, the prevailing w

is-dom

was that operations such as the

one involving Shadrin and Igor w

ere convoluted schem

es of dubious val-u

e—u

nless, o

f cou

rse, An

gleto

n's

assum

ptio

n o

f Igor's falsity

had

sm

othered genuine operational op-portu

nities. In

his au

tobio

grap

hy,

Honorable M

en, Colby com

ments on

his review of the m

aze of counter-intelligence activities that flourished

- under Angleton's autocratic rule:

"I spent several long sessions do-in

g m

y b

est to fo

llow

his to

rtuo

us

theo

ries about th

e long arm

of a

po

werfu

l and

wily

K

GB

at w

ork

sending its false defectors to influ-ence and underm

ine Am

erican poli-cy. I confess that I couldn't absorb it, possibly because I did not have the requisite grasp of this labyrinthine subject, possibly because A

ngleton's explanations w

ere impossible to fol-

low, or possibly because the evidence

just didn't add up to his conclusions. A

t the same tim

e I looked in vain for som

e tangible results and found little or none. I did not suspect A

ngleton and his staff of engaging in im

proper activities. I just could not figure out w

hat they were doing at all."

On D

ecember 20, 1974, about the

time that S

hadrin was receiving the

letters from

Ox

on

Hill, A

ng

leton

retired at the request of C

olby. His

closest associates soon followed. Sud-

denly, the long era of Angletonian

do

min

ance w

as ov

er; the A

gen

cy

was rid of the cunning spym

aster and his "tortuous theories.' A

lmost im

- 221

BO

OK

SE

CT

ION

F

ebruary

Page 15: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

AD

VE

RT

ISE

ME

NT

HO

W T

O ST

AR

T

MA

RIN

AT

ING

AT

4:00 P.M.

AN

D SE

RV

E D

INN

ER

A

T 6:00 P.M.

I've discovered an easy, natural way to get

the same deep-dow

n flavor and tenderness I expect from

overnight marinating in just an hour.

BY

jEA

NN

ET

TE

FR

AN

K

SH

AD

RIN

: TH

E S

PY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

BA

CK

If y

ou're lik

e me y

ou p

robab

ly

have a tried-and-true recipe for m

eat marinade. T

he one I've al-w

ays used calls for all day or even overnight m

arinating. A

nd I thought if I cut short the m

arinating time, I w

ould give up a lot of flavor and tenderness.

But m

y mind w

as really changed at a friend's dinner party. T

hat night w

e were served a w

onderful mari-

nated round steak. I loved it and so did everyone else.

So I w

as amazed to discover that

the meat had m

arinated for only an hour.

My friend then told m

e she al-w

ays ad

ded

Adolp

h's M

eat Ten

-derizer to her favorite m

arinade. A

nd

this n

ot o

nly

mean

t she

could get as much delicious flavor as

when she m

arinated all night, but the m

eat was also juicier and m

ore

tender after it was cooked.

Well, I've used A

dolph's for years to tenderize various cuts of beef. So I know

how easy it is to use, how

well

it works and that it w

orks naturally, too. B

ecause its tenderizing ingre-dient com

es from the sim

ple, ordi-nary papaya m

elon. So I started adding A

dolph's every tim

e I made m

y own m

arinade (us-ing I capful to every cup of liquid) and then m

arinating as I usually do. B

ut just for an hour. S

ince I had such tasty results, I think you should try it too. A

fter all, if y

ou d

on't ag

ree, the A

dolp

h's

company w

ill refund your money.

Just send the cap to the address on the jar.

Bu

t I thin

k y

ou

'll find

that

Adolph's w

ill make your favorite

meat m

arinade work better and a

whole lot faster for you.

med

iately w

ork

was b

egun th

at w

ould

, in th

e w

ord

s of o

ne o

f C

olb

y's to

p o

peratio

ns o

fficers, "bring counterintelligence back into the A

gency." A

lready, there was increasing rec-

ognition of the legitimacy of S

oviet defector Y

uri Nosenko. H

elms, of

course, had lifted the initial restraint on N

osen

ko. H

ow

ever, th

at clear-an

ce had

been

only

enough to

get

Nosenko settled into A

merican life

as any other defector might 'be han-

dled. This, according to later state-

ments by H

elms, did not m

ean the C

IA considered N

osenko bona fide—o

nly

that it w

anted

to b

e rid o

f a seem

ingly intractable problem. B

ut this lukew

arm acceptance w

as not satisfactory to m

en like Bruce S

olie and others w

ho had become advo-

cates of Nosenko—

in part, no doubt, because of their belief in Igor's m

es-sage regarding N

osenko. G

oing much further than H

elms

ever en

visio

ned

, these ad

vocates

readdressed themselves to the N

o-senko case. A

lmost incredibly, they

and o

thers m

anag

ed to

brin

g N

o-

senko into the bosom of the A

gency as a highly paid regular consultant and lecturer on current S

oviet intelli-gence m

atters and personnel. Such a

drastic reversal in the Agency's poli-

cy constituted a flagrant repudiation o

f the n

early u

niv

ersal susp

icion

s held by the respected veterans w

ho had handled the N

osenko case just a few

years earlier. T

hen, with N

osenko's enthusias-tic acceptance established, the new

regim

e could turn to the resurrection

and genuine acceptance of Igor, who

had certified Noscnko. U

nder the old reign, C

IA counterintelligence offi-

cers had doubted Igor as seriously as they had N

osenko—though the Igor

case was a m

uch more closely held

secret. But w

ith the old guard gone and N

osenko exuberantly embraced,

it was tim

e to bring Igor back. S

om

etime in

19

75

Sh

adrin

was

ord

ered to

requ

est a meetin

g w

ith

his top contacts in Moscow

. It was

fortu

itous th

at the S

oviets th

em-

selves had so recently evinced fresh interest in a

reconnection with S

had- rin. D

espite the messages from

Oxon

Hill, som

e older hands might have

counseled that Shadrin's still-unex-

plain

ed b

reak in

contact w

ith th

e S

oviets w

as an u

rgen

t reason fo

r suprem

e caution. But caution w

as not a guiding light.

Finally, w

ord was relayed circu-

itously from M

oscow—

in a letter from

Oxon H

ill—that S

hadrin's top K

GB

contacts were w

illing to see him

again. Shadrin proposed S

pain as a m

eeting site, but the K

GB

rejected this and suggested H

elsinki. After

consultation with his A

merican han-

dlers, Shadrin dem

urred. Helsinki

was too dangerous. F

or reasons that rem

ain utterly baffling, Shadrin w

as ordered to counter-propose that the m

eeting

take p

lace in V

ienn

a, de-

scribed by one former C

IA officer as

"a snake pit of Soviet spies."

Th

e KG

B quickly accepted.

A Q

uestio

n o

f Su

rveilla

nce

IN E

AR

LY

DE

CE

MB

ER

1975, to

p

counterintelligence officers of the 223

Jeannette Frank is the author of The Modern M

eat Cookbook.

Page 16: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SH

.4DR

IN: T

HE

SP

Y W

HO

NE

VE

R C

AM

E R

AC

K

HOW TO BUY A 400 ACRE

DAIRY FARM IN M

ANHATTAN. C

IA

and F

BI g

athered

in a secret

meetin

g to

discu

ss Shad

rin's im

-pending rendezvous in V

ienna. The

highest C

IA

officer p

resent w

as G

eorge T. K

alaris, who had replaced

Angleton as chief of counterintelli-

gence. Accom

panying Kalaris from

his staff w

ere Leonard M

cCoy and

Cynthia H

ausmann, w

ho would be-

come know

n to Ew

a as Ann M

artin. B

ruce S

olie o

f the C

IA's O

ffice of S

ecurity was also there, along w

ith Jam

es Wo

oten

, William

Bran

igan

and others from

the FB

I. V

arious accounts of this meeting

are in sharp dispute about whether

there w

as discu

ssion

on

the ad

vis-

ability of providing surveillance for S

hadrin's contacts with the S

oviets in V

ienna. It was K

alaris who told the

gathering that the CIA

believed Igor w

ould make an appearance in V

ien-na. K

alaris also said that Bruce S

olie w

ould

be d

ispatch

ed to

Vien

na to

deal w

ith Igor since he had previous-ly

met h

im. C

ynth

ia Hau

sman

n

would

be sen

t to d

ebrief S

had

rin

after his meetings.

Late o

n o

ne b

itterly co

ld after-

noon a couple of weeks before they

were leaving for V

ienna, Nick m

o-tioned to E

wa that he w

anted her to step

into

the k

itchen

. His g

estures

were m

emorable to E

wa because on

rare occasio

ns N

ick w

ou

ld sh

ow

signs, such as this, of suspecting that their house w

as bugged. In the kitchen, N

ick whispered to

Ew

a that he wanted to go for a w

alk. O

utsid

e, he to

ld E

wa so

meth

ing

very im

portant had come up in his

work that w

ould make an enorm

ous 224

differen

ce in h

is pro

fessional life.

Crucial to this w

ere some business

meetin

gs set u

p in

Vien

na d

urin

g

their v

acation. N

ick d

id n

ot o

ffer specific details about his new

hori-zons, but he did say that at last, after 16 years, he w

as to get his security clearance. E

wa w

as ecstatic. A

t 9

:30

a.m

. on

Decem

ber 1

7,

Miss H

ausm

ann m

et with

the C

IA

station ch

ief in V

ienna. A

t som

e poin

t the statio

n ch

ief asked

her if

surveillance would be required for

the S

had

rin m

eeting. M

iss Hau

s-m

ann replied that it was thought in

Washington not to be necessary. F

ive years after Shadrin's disap-

pearanCe, a controversy continues to

simm

er over the question of surveil-lance. E

wa S

hadrin and her attorney, R

ichard Copaken, insist that the V

i-enna station w

as prepared to provide su

rveillan

ce un

til Miss H

ausm

ann

called it off. A

ccording to Copaken,

Miss H

ausm

ann h

as stated to

him

that the F

BI told her it did not w

ant surveillance. B

ut other sources indi-cate th

at the q

uestio

n w

as no

t an

explicit p

oin

t on th

e agen

da at th

e D

ecember m

eeting between the C

IA

and FB

I. O

ne so

urce at th

e meetin

g h

as stated

that p

ossib

ly th

e C

IA

said so

meth

ing

such

as, "Yo

u are n

ot

goin

g to

require su

rveillan

ce, are you?" In response, the F

BI m

en may

have indicated that they would not.

More than anything else, it appears

that the CIA

and FB

I failed to under-stand each other. T

hat, in any case, is the m

ost charitable explanation. S

had

rin's first m

eeting

, on

De-

Just b

ecause th

ere are no d

airy farm

s in M

anhattan

, doesn

't m

eany

ou

can't in

vest in

on

e with

ou

t leavin

g to

wn

. Becau

se no

m

atter ho

w far aw

ay th

at dairy

farm m

ay b

e, CE

NT

UR

Y 2

? is alw

ays clo

se by

. W

ith o

ver 7

,50

0 o

ffices thro

ug

ho

ut th

e U.S

. and

Can

ada, w

e hav

e a wid

e variety

of real estate in

vestm

ents to

choose fro

m. A

nd

our In

vestm

ent S

pecialists are in

constan

t touch

with

them

thro

ugh

ou

r Intern

ation

al Pro

perty

Data B

ank- an

d T

he R

eal Estate

Inv

estmen

t Jou

rnal?'

Our In

vestm

ent S

pecialists are ex

perien

ced p

rofessio

nals w

ho

receive o

ne o

f the m

ost co

mpreh

ensiv

e trainin

g p

rogram

s in th

e in

du

stry. P

lus th

ey are co

nstan

tly sh

arpen

ing

their m

arketin

g sk

ills th

rough th

e CE

NT

UR

Y 2

1 In

vestm

ent S

ociety

. If y

ou're co

nsid

ering in

vestin

g in

real estate, mail th

e coupon

tod

ay fo

r yo

ur free co

py

of o

ur n

ew In

vestm

ent B

roch

ure.

rM

aw send m

e your free Investment B

rochure.

NA

ME

AD

DR

ES

S

C

TrY

AM

ERIC

A'S IN

NA

BB

t 1 TOP SO

LER, C

BITU

RY 21"

Each

Office In

dsp

eatetly Ow

ned

and

Op

erated

I

7A 01981 C

entury 21 Real E

state Corporation as trustee for the N

AP

. 0 ns trademarks

I XII to: C

ENTU

RY 21 Investm

ent Offer

of Century 21 R

eal Estate Corp

ora

tion E

qual Housing opportunity.°

Lp.o. Box NB 703, E

l Paso, M

aas 79977 .11

ST

AT

E

ZIP

1

Page 17: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

cows NEXT

MO

NO IN

READER'S DIGEST

TO C

ATC

H A

KILLER

Like a shark patrolling a crow

ded beach, Ted

Bundy stalked, struck and w

as gone. His victim

s:

Young w

omen, m

ost of whom

he had raped,

strangled and bludgeoned. How

he was finally

caught is one of the most fascinating stories in

Am

erican criminal history. A

special feature.

THE

MIR

AC

LE O

F ED

DIE

RO

BIN

SO

N

His w

orld was one of darkness, silence and pain.

Then came the roll of thunder—

and a bolt of lightning that changed his life.

BEA

T INFLA

TION

WITH

REA

L ESTATE

Consider these tips from

three experts on how to

turn minim

al investments into big profits.

TOO

MA

NY C

AESA

REA

N B

IRTH

S? A

sharp increase in the number of C

aesarean

sections has raised new questions—

and con-

cerns—about this "em

ergency" procedure.

Watch for these and m

ore than 30 other articles and features, selected and condensed from

the best of current reading.

BO

OK

SEC

TIO

N

R.bruary

cember 1

8, w

as with

two v

eteran

Soviet diplom

ats, both of whom

he had m

et before. Mikhail K

uryshev had been attached to the S

oviet em-

bassy

in V

ienna d

urin

g S

had

rin's

1972 meeting there. T

he second So-

viet, Oleg A

lexeyevich Kozlov, had

been assigned to the Soviet em

bassy in W

ashington from 1968 until 1972.

He had been one of S

hadrin's Soviet

handlers. W

hatev

er transp

ired at th

e first m

eeting, it m

ade S

had

rin h

appy.

326

Ew

a Shad

rin h

as testified to

his

exuberance when he returned to the

hotel ro

om

that n

ight w

here M

iss H

ausm

ann d

ebriefed

him

. He d

id

relate to Miss H

ausmann that he had

been informed he had been prom

ot-ed to the rank of colonel in the K

GB

.

How

ever, after Miss H

ausmann left,

Shad

rin to

ld E

wa th

at he d

id n

ot

report his most im

portant informa-

tion to her—that he w

ould save this to tell Jim

Wooten.

Tw

o days later, when N

ick said

farewell to his w

ife for perhaps the last tim

e of their lives, Miss H

aus-m

ann attended a dinner party at the

home of a C

IA officer assisting in the

support for the Shadrin m

eetings—a

man

with

whom

Miss H

ausm

ann

had served at earlier posts. Accord-

ing to Miss H

ausmann, the dinner

party

lasted u

ntil

12:30 a.m

., at

which tim

e her host drove her back to a safe house. B

ut the host has a different story. A

ccording to an ac-count later provided to C

opaken by th

e Vien

na statio

n, th

e host states

that he left to drive Miss H

ausmann

home at m

idnight. In either case, she sh

ould

hav

e been

back

at the safe

house no later than 1 a.m.—

and as

early as 12:3o. B

ut Miss H

ausmann did not an-

swer the phone w

hen Ew

a Shadrin

made her first frantic call at 1:35 a.m

. A

t 1:55 a.m., w

hen Ew

a made her

second call, Miss H

ausmann's initial

qu

estion

—ev

en b

efore b

eing

told

S

had

rin h

ad n

ot retu

rned

—w

as w

hether Ew

a had tried to telephone earlier. W

hen

Ew

a said y

es, Miss

Hausm

ann stated only that she had been

attendin

g a d

inner p

arty. In

su

bseq

uen

t interv

iews w

ith E

wa

Shadrin's attorney, M

iss Hausm

ann has declined to explain her w

here-abouts for the disputed m

inutes—stating only that she w

ent directly fro

m th

e din

ner p

arty to

the safe

house. It is possible that the discrepancy

is academic, since apparently M

iss H

ausmann still did nothing. F

inally, the deputy chief of station raised the

alarm at C

IA headquarters at to a.m

. on Decem

ber 21, more than eight

hours after Ew

a Shadrin m

ade her first futile phone call. Im

mediately

cables began to go back and forth w

ith d

etails, questio

ns, su

ggested

answ

ers. T

heories flourish about what hap-

pened to Shadrin. M

ost are predicat-ed

on h

is bein

g k

idnap

ped

. Oth

er theories suggest that S

hadrin was a

KG

B agent all along—

that his defec-tion in 1959 w

as one of the Soviets'

best-handled provocations. Another

theo

ry p

resum

es that S

had

rin b

e-cam

e desperately disillusioned with

his professional life and took off on his ow

n for parts unknown to estab-

lish another life. T

he m

ost w

idely

accepted

of

these—one held w

ith apparent sin-

cerity by the FBI, C

IA and high gov-

ernment officials—

is that the K

GB

kid

nap

ped

him

and sp

irited h

im

back

to th

e Soviet U

nio

n. P

ropo-

nen

ts of th

is theo

ry p

ostu

late it w

ould serve the Soviet U

nion well if

the KG

B could trium

phantly exhibit S

hadrin to its personnel, proving it co

uld

reach in

to th

e heart o

f US

. intelligence and retrieve a defector.

There also w

as a feeling that some

resolution was im

minent, w

hether it be a parading of a broken S

hadrin befo

re the w

orld

to d

enounce th

e W

est, or simply leaking w

ord that he had been executed. In no case w

as a

resounding silence expected.

Messag

e F

rom

Mo

sco

w

WH

EN

EW

A R

ET

UR

NE

D 1

0 W

ash-ington, Jim

Wooten explained that

Secretary of S

tate Henry K

issinger 227

1981

SHA

DR

IN: T

HE

SPY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

RA

CK

Page 18: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SH.9D

RIN

.• TH

E SP

Y W

HO

NE

VE

R C

AM

E B

AC

K

was at that m

oment in W

ashington prep

aring to

speak

priv

ately w

ith

Soviet A

mbassad

or A

nato

ly D

o-

bry

nin

about S

had

rin's retu

rn. B

ut

Kissinger did not get around to talk-

ing to

Dobry

nin

until Jan

uary

5.

Dobrynin denied any know

ledge of S

hadrin. By then E

wa had confided

in William

and Mary L

ouise How

e, and the follow

ing evening there was

the m

eeting w

ith th

e How

es and

Wooten at the hom

e of Robert and

Helen K

upperman.

Quietly, the H

owes and the K

up-perm

ans began contacting everyone they knew

in government, including

those who could help get a hearing

in the White H

ouse. B

ut n

o p

lan w

as forth

com

ing

from P

resident Gerald F

ord's staff. It also w

as clear the CIA

was not in

any h

urry

to fo

rmulate a strateg

y.

Oth

er officials, w

hile sy

mpath

etic, obviously w

ere getting nowhere. A

puzzled E

wa S

hadrin began to real-ize th

at noth

ing h

ad b

een d

one.

Fin

ally, o

n F

ebru

ary so

, 1976,

after consu

ltation w

ith th

e How

es and the K

uppermans, E

wa S

hadrin co

nclu

ded

that h

er husb

and h

ad

been abandoned by the US

. govern-

ment. R

eluctantly, she retained the services of R

ichard Copaken, a part-

ner in

the W

ashin

gto

n law

firm o

f C

ovington and Burling.

While th

e How

es and th

e Kup-

permans provided critical m

oral sup- port, Jim

Wooten w

as the bedrock of E

wa S

hadrin's faith that Nick w

ould be returned safely. B

ut his loyalty to

her w

as view

ed d

ifferently

by h

is ow

n su

perio

rs. The first sto

rm

228

clouds were spotted around F

ebru-ary 1, w

hen he informed E

wa that

Kissin

ger, w

ho b

y th

en h

ad m

ade

several unsuccessful inquiries to the S

oviets, had written a letter to the FB

I

in which he indicated that one of its

agents had undercut Mrs. S

hadrin's faith

in K

issinger's effo

rts. That

agent, clearly, was W

ooten. Wooten

told Ew

a that he remained com

mit-

ted to helping her, but he added that he hoped he w

ould not have to retire early.

On F

ebru

ary 1

7, E

wa S

had

rin

asked Wooten to brief C

opaken on N

ick's disappearance. Wooten read-

ily agreed. F

or one hour the attorney ques-tioned W

ooten about various aspects of the case. T

he FBI m

an was helpful.

Tow

ard th

e end o

f the m

eeting

Copaken asked W

ooten how long it

took the FBI to convince S

hadrin to w

ork

as a double ag

ent. "O

h, I

suppose a couple of days," Wooten

replied. "B

ut, Jim," E

wa said, "you told us

at our meeting at the K

uppermans'

that it took close to a year to persuade N

ick and that Rufus T

aylor got him

to d

o it."

"Ew

a," said Jim W

ooten evenly, "I did not tell you these things."

Tw

elve d

ays later, o

n F

ebru

ary

29, Jam

es Wooten abruptly retired

from the F

BI. H

e was 52 years old.

Ew

a was beginning to grasp the

magnitude of the troubles she faced.

One o

f the first o

rders o

f busin

ess w

as to get in touch with A

dm. R

ufus

Taylor to learn m

ore about the role he p

layed

in recru

iting h

is friend

SH

AD

RIN

: TH

E S

PY

WH

Shadrin into the double operation.

William

How

e had known T

aylor for som

e 25 years, and he was w

ell aw

are of th

e close asso

ciation b

e-tw

een Taylor and S

hadrin. H

owe called T

aylor, by then re-tired, to ask him

about his old friend

Nick S

hadrin. "Nick w

ho? "Adm

iral T

aylo

r said to

How

e. "Shad

rin? I

never heard of him."

Incredulous, How

e insisted that it w

as impossible that T

aylor could not rem

ember S

hadrin. Finally T

aylor conceded that he had know

n Shad-

rin, but vehemently denied he had

had anything to do with recruiting

him.

Already, telephone calls w

ere go-in

g o

ut fro

m th

e govern

men

t to

peo

ple w

ho h

ad k

now

n S

had

rin.

Col. B

ernard

Weltm

an, S

had

rin's

boss at the DIA

and a great admirer,

was to

ld, "S

tay aw

ay fro

m E

wa

Shadrin." A

nother associate at the

DIA

telephoned a number of people

and told them never to discuss the

case with anyone.

Copak

en an

d E

wa tried

every

avenue. W

ith the unofficial assist-ance of the S

tate Departm

ent, Copa-

ken attempted to set up exchanges of

Soviet spies held by the United States

or allies for Shadrin. N

one succeed-ed, either because the U

nited States

would not co-operate, or the S

oviet U

nio

n d

id n

ot h

ave S

had

rin, o

r chose to deny having him

.*

• To this day C

opaken vigorously asserts that

Secre

tary o

f Sta

te K

issinger a

nd W

hite

House

officials purposefully undermined C

opaken's ef-

forts to

effe

ct a su

ccessfu

l exch

ange. In

um

.

Kissinger described C

opaken's charges as "an irre-

sponsible distortion: .

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

RA

CK

Finally, on D

ecember 3, 1976—

nearly one year after Shadrin's dis-

appearance—P

resident Ford sent a

letter to Soviet party leader L

eonid B

rezhnev, asking for assistance in having S

hadrin returned to his wife.

Brezhnev replied that records had

been consulted in Moscow

and he

could report that Shadrin had never arrived at the V

otivkirche for his sec-ond m

eeting with the Soviets.

Copaken w

as stunned. It was one

thing for the Soviets to convey this

- info

rmatio

n in

form

ally. B

ut h

ow

could B

rezhnev speak with such con-

fidence? How

could he know that

there was no surveillance by the C

IA

of the meeting? W

hat minion in the

KG

B w

ould dare risk responsibility for advice to B

rezhnev that might

later be th

e basis fo

r pollu

ting h

is ch

annel o

f trust to

the U

.S. P

resi-dent—

especially when there w

ere so m

any other things that could have

been said? T

hese questions—all basically un-

answerable—

contributed to the grim

susp

icions th

at were b

egin

nin

g to

concern E

wa S

hadrin and her attor-ney. W

as it possible, they wondered,

that the United S

tates—even at the

hig

hest lev

els—knew

much

more

about Shadrin's disappearance than

was being adm

itted? The suspicion

fed the already growing feeling that

maybe the enem

y was in W

ashing-ton instead of M

oscow—

that it some-

how

served

US

. intellig

ence p

ur-

poses to

abort S

had

rin's seco

nd

meeting w

ith the Soviets.

Or, of course, the K

GB

could have

picked up Shadrin on his w

ay to the 231

Page 19: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

GE

T T

HA

T

LA

VO

RIS

C

LE

AN

-JU

ST

-LE

F

TH

E-D

EN

TIS

T

FE

EL

ING

E

ven th

e le

adin

g m

outh

w

ca

n't c

lea

n y

ou

r bre

ath

bette

r than L

avoris

.' It's

the

nu

mb

er o

ne

sin

gle

mouth

wash fo

rm

use

d b

y d

en

tists

.

mouthw

ash/gargle PICK YOUR PICK-ME-UP

OL

A

OR V

IVA

RIN

If you're like m

ost people, you enjoy a cup of good, hot coffee or an ice cold cola. T

hey taste

gre

at,

and g

ive y

ou th

e lift y

ou w

ant.

But if, a

s the d

ay w

ears o

n, yo

u

som

etim

es fin

d y

ours

elf h

avin

g

co

ffee

or c

ola

just fo

r the

lift, yo

u

really

should

know

about V

ivarin

.

Viv

arin

is th

e

ge

ntle

pick-m

e-u

p.

The a

ctiv

e in

gre

die

nt th

at m

akes

Viv

arin

so e

ffectiv

e is

the c

affe

ine o

f tw

o cu

ps o

f coffe

e ( o

r about six g

lasse

s of co

la) in

one e

asy to

take

table

t. N

ext tim

e y

ou w

ant a

lift, pic

k

Viv

arin

. It co

nvenie

nt, in

expensiv

e

and it re

ally

work

s.

Read label for directions.

SH

AD

RIN

: TH

E S

PY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

BA

CK

F

ebruary

meeting. P

erhaps that was w

hy the K

GB

co

uld

so co

nfid

ently

advise

Brezh

nev

to rep

ly as h

e had

. But

whatever w

as behind the message, it

was com

pelling evidence that Shad-

rin never reached the meeting site.

The S

tonew

all

PA

RT O

F THE

FRU

STR

ATIO

N fo

r CO

-pak

en an

d th

e agony fo

r Ew

a was

the continuing confusion over just w

hat Nick's role had been. D

uring the first days, w

hen Ew

a was in the

han

ds o

f Miss H

ausm

ann, sh

e be-

lieved

Nick

had

been

an in

no

cent

Am

erican citizen

snatch

ed o

ff the

streets by his former S

oviet masters.

Tw

o m

onth

s later, when

Copa-

ken

entered

the case, th

ere was a

general -acknowledgm

ent of what

Jim W

ooten had first told Ew

a—that

Nick

was p

erform

ing a p

atriotic

duty for the United S

tates by serving the

FB

I and C

IA as a d

ouble ag

ent

working against the S

oviets. But just

wh

at Nick

was su

pp

osed

to h

ave

been doing as a double agent was far

from clear.

Then

, in th

e sprin

g o

f 1978, a

writer w

ho had spent several years conducting research on the subject of possible S

oviet penetration of the C

IA telephoned C

opaken. The w

rit-er's research

had

taken

him

to a

number of form

er intelligence and counterintelligence officers. O

ne of his sources m

entioned the Shadrin

case, almost as an aside, and said that

the secret key to it all might be the

presence in 1966 of a Soviet agent

named Igor.

The w

riter had

heard

about th

e

/98/

Shadrin case and knew

that Richard

Copaken w

as the attorney helping E

wa S

hadrin. He w

ent to Copaken

and told him about the existence of

Igor and the role he had played in the recru

itmen

t of S

had

rin. C

opak

en

was electrified. It w

as the overlay that could m

ake all of the patterns fit. H

e beseeched the writer to tell

him

his so

urce. T

he w

riter would

o

nly

agree to

try to

con

vin

ce the

source to talk to Copaken.

A few

days later Copaken and the

source met in a private hom

e in the W

ashington area, where they spent

several hours discussing Igor.* O

n April I, 1978, C

opaken called E

wa S

had

rin. H

e told

her th

at it appeared they w

ere the victims of a

staggerin

g d

eceptio

n b

y th

e US

. governm

ent—that there w

as new evi-

dence that Nick S

hadrin had been com

promised w

ith the Soviets from

the first m

oment he agreed to w

ork as a double agent. N

ick Shadrin had

not been approached out of the blue by the Soviets; he had been set up for the

KG

B by the A

mericans, slow

ly ripened, and then sent to V

ienna for the final plucking by the S

oviets. E

very latent suspicion and hostil-ity E

wa S

hadrin had for bureaucrats and governm

ent officials came to the

surface. She felt she had been a fool

to b

elieve an

yth

ing to

ld to

her b

y

Geo

rge B

ush

, form

er head

of th

e C

IA, his successor S

tansfield Turner,

FB

I director Clarence K

elley, Henry

Kissin

ger, W

hite H

ouse o

fficials

*C

opak

en h

as refused

to co

nfirm

or d

eny th

e

sequen

ce of ev

ents, b

ut R

eader's D

igest h

as con-

firmed

this w

ith its o

wn so

urces.

23

3

GIV

E Y

OU

R LE

TTER

S

A S

PE

CIA

L rin

utio

, TO

O.

With your ow

n personalized stationery horn the m

akers of lovorls.®

Correct for every

occasion. Fine quality, with

handsome deckle edge.

Personalized in script style type, royol blue Ink on cream

y w

hite or soft blue paper. 50 sheets and 25 envelopes (sheet size: 515" x 7W

) O

nly

$2

95 w

ith o

ne

proof of purchase

Clearly print personalization nam

e and address, shipping nam

e and address (If different) and choice of white or blue

stationery color. Send with $2.95 (check or m

oney order) and the ounce designation from

front label of any size Unrolls to

tAV

OR

IS STATIO

NER

Y, P.O

. Box 784 450 North C

apitol Ave.,

Indianapolis, Indiana, 45206. Void w

here prohibited, taxed or restricted by law

. Please allow 4-6 w

eeks for delivery. EXPIRES A

UG

UST

31, 1981. 0 1980 Rich.dson-M

errell

Page 20: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SP

RE

AD

TH

E W

OR

D

WIT

H R

EP

RIN

TS

%A

DE

RS

frequently tell us how gratifying it is to pass along copies of

especially interesting or useful articles to friends, church congregations, volunteer groups, em

ployees, nursing homes, schools, etc. R

eprints available from

the February 1981 issue:

Channel O

ne: Turning O

n Turned-O

ff T

een-Agers

Strategic Minerals: T

he Invisible War

C

an Nicotine H

elp Smokers Q

uit?

If I Were Starting M

y Family A

gain

Is Our Jury System

Working?

H

ow A

rtificial Light A

ffects Your H

ealth

Prices: to

for $

3; 2

5 fo

r $35; m

oo for $48.

Postage and handling charges included in orders of moo or less.

Write: R

eprint Editor, R

eader's Digest, Pleasantville, N

.Y. to57o.

Page 29

pag

e 81

$6; 5

o fo

r $9;

Page 94

page 102 page 126

page 131 W

O

for $

15; S

oo fo

r

1981 B

OO

K SE

CT

ION

F

ebruary S

HA

DR

IN T

HE

SP

Y W

HO

NE

VE

R C

AM

E R

AC

K

23 4

William

G. H

ylan

d an

d Z

big

niew

B

rzezinski, James W

ooten, George

Kalaris. O

ne of the first people Ew

a called after learn

ing ab

out Ig

or w

as Jim

Wo

oten

at his retirem

ent h

om

e in

Arizo

na. "W

e hav

e learned

abo

ut

the S

oviet ag

ent w

ho ask

ed fo

r N

ick," she said. Wooten's initial re-

action was one of apparent befuddle-

men

t. Cau

tiou

sly, W

oo

ten tried

to

lead Ew

a to reveal additional infor-m

ation. When E

wa asked if W

ooten k

new

abo

ut th

e So

viet ag

ent, h

e replied, "If I w

ere aware, I could not

comm

ent." How

ever, within a few

m

inu

tes Wo

oten

had

clearly co

n-

firmed E

wa's inform

ation. F

rom

the start W

ooten

was in

-tensely interested in finding out how

E

wa S

hadrin had learned about Igor.

Wooten

indicated

to E

wa th

at the

emerg

ence o

f such

info

rmatio

n

could bring about the death of one of th

e mo

st valu

able ag

ents w

ork

ing

for A

merican intelligence.

Later, W

ooten told Ew

a he was

sure that the source of her informa-

tion must be Jam

es Angleton, w

ho had doubted Igor. E

wa said that she

did not believe it was A

ngleton and did not know

the source. A

few d

ays after h

e learned

of

Igor's role, Copaken advised the Jus-

tice and S

tate dep

artmen

ts of h

is inform

ation, which, if true, show

ed w

ithout q

uestio

n th

at he an

d E

wa

Shad

rin h

ad b

een d

eceived

by th

e highest officials in the U

nited States.

On A

pril 19, 1978, Copaken w

as called

to th

e Justice D

epartm

ent,

where he w

as informed that a deci-

sion had been reached to make no

further attempt to assist E

wa S

had-rin

and

to d

ecline an

y in

qu

iries about Igor. H

enceforth, the FBI and

CIA

directors—

both of whom

had offered full co-operation to E

wa in

the past—w

ould no longer see her or her attorney.

On M

ay 24, 1978, as a last resort, C

op

aken

turn

ed to

the S

enate In

- tellig

ence C

om

mittee. In

a letter req

uestin

g a fo

rmal in

vestig

ation

, C

opaken told the comm

ittee: "The

callous disregard for her feelings that has been exhibited by the U

S. gov-

ernm

ent is n

ot in

keep

ing

with

its responsibility to the fam

ily of a man

who served it so valiantly for so m

any years."

Nearly

three m

on

ths later, th

e com

mittee's chairm

an, Birch B

ayh, responded by thanking C

opaken for his interest and advising him

that the com

mittee "has been w

orking on the S

hadrin case for over a year and will

con

tinu

e to d

o so

as a part o

f its oversig

ht d

uties." T

o E

wa th

is re- sponse w

as the final evidence of an uncarin

g, self-p

rotectiv

e and u

n-

truthful bureaucracy. A

lso that spring, Copaken w

rote to P

resident Jimm

y Carter, asking

him

to m

eet with

Mrs. S

had

rin.

Carter refu

sed, b

ut in

structed

the

Intelligence Oversight B

oard (IOB

) to review

the case. O

n April 16, 1979, C

opaken re-ceiv

ed a

lette

r from

Robert L

. K

euch, Deputy A

ssistant Attorney

General of the U

nited States. K

euch review

ed the scope of various gov-ern

men

t investig

ations in

to w

hat happened to S

hadrin and then noted that the lots investigation alone took "m

ore th

an fiv

e mo

nth

s and

in-

volved both the detailed review of

large n

um

bers o

f docu

men

ts and

files of, an

d th

e interv

iews w

ith,

more than 8o w

itnesses. None of the

investigations disclosed evidence of any hostile action against M

r. Shad-

rin by the U.S. governm

ent, any of its agencies or agents."

Ew

a Shadrin had

not expected anything m

uch different. She then

asked if she could see the IOB

report. H

er request was rejected. E

wa had

no

mo

re reason

to b

elieve in

this

investigation than to believe in the in

tegrity

of th

e countless o

fficials w

ho had deceived her. A

s for K

euch

's letter itself, it failed to address crucial points such as the governm

ent's use of Shadrin

in th

e Ig

or o

pera

tion

, wh

ich

am

ounted to gross malfeasance to-

ward an A

merican citizen.

Copaken believes it w

as impossi-

ble for the lOB

to find that there was

no wrongdoing. If, in fact, the Soviets

did abduct Shadrin, then the w

rong-d

oin

g is o

bv

iou

s—th

e lack o

f any

surveillance, the disappearance of M

iss Hausm

ann for an hour, the fact th

at she w

as not at th

e emerg

ency

n

um

ber an

d d

id n

ot im

med

iately

notify Washington. S

omehow

, some-

thing very wrong w

as done; other-w

ise Shadrin w

ould not have been lost.

An O

pen Book

IN

TH

E S

PR

ING

OF

1978, with all

hope of government help gone, C

o- 235

Page 21: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

RO

OK

SE

CT

ION

F

ebruary 1981

SH

AD

RIN

: TH

E S

PY

WH

O N

EV

ER

CA

ME

RA

CK

pa

ken

ha

d b

eg

un

effo

rts to a

cqu

ire

info

rma

tion

un

de

r the

Fre

ed

om

of

Info

rmatio

n A

ct. The g

ove

rnm

ent

initially responded that it would take

many m

onth

s to p

ull to

geth

er th

e

Shadrin files even to review

them for

possible release under the law.

A year later, R

eader's Digest be-

cam

e in

tere

sted in

the ca

se a

nd

launch

ed a

suit a

gain

st the g

ove

rn-

ment seeking access to the S

hadrin file

s, a

lso c

iting th

e F

reedom

of

Information A

ct. The m

agazine's at- to

rne

ys rem

inded th

e g

ove

rnm

ent

that the 10B had conducted a detailed

revie

w o

f "larg

e n

um

bers o

f docu

-m

ents

and file

s" o

n th

e S

hadrin

case—

and that the government obvi-

ously already had all of the material

at hand. Y

et m

onth

s passe

d w

ith th

e C

IA

seemingly unable to process any of

its volu

min

ou

s files o

n th

e S

ha

drin

m

atter. At one point Judge R

obert J. W

ard

said

in a

ton

e o

f am

aze

me

nt:

"How

does o

ur in

tellig

ence

agency

work? N

o wonder w

e have problems

overseas. You have so m

any files by the tim

e you find them, the situation

ha

s com

e to

fruitio

n. H

as th

e b

u-

reaucra

cy gotte

n so

monum

enta

l th

at b

efo

re th

e e

lephant ca

n m

ove

, the crisis is upon us?"

In th

e e

nd

, the

go

vern

me

nt p

ro-

duced n

oth

ing b

ut h

undre

ds o

f new

spaper clippings from the files of

the

CIA

an

d F

BI—

plu

s hu

nd

red

s of

pages of documents in w

hich almost

every single letter oftype—even dates—

had been blacked out. A

s a la

st reco

urse

, atto

rneys fo

r R

eader's Digest requested that judge

236

Ward

revie

w a

gove

rnm

ent-p

re-

pare

d su

mm

ary o

f the d

ocu

ments

which

the C

IA h

ad re

fuse

d to

pro

-duce. T

he CIA

maintained that even

this index could not be considered in o

pe

n co

urt. W

ith g

rea

t relu

ctan

ce,

Judge W

ard

agre

ed to

revie

w th

e

ind

ex in cam

era. O

n A

ug

ust zo

, 198o, a

sole

mn

Jud

ge

Wa

rd ca

lled

in a

ttorn

eys fo

r this m

agazine and the government.

He stated that in review

ing the sum-

ma

ries o

f classifie

d d

ocu

me

nts, h

e

had made one assum

ption: the gov-ernm

ent's summ

aries are "accurate and fa

ir." Judge W

ard

rendere

d h

is ju

dgm

ent th

at re

lease

of th

e d

ocu

-m

ents d

escrib

ed in

the su

mm

arie

s w

ould

"serio

usly co

mpro

mise

our

fore

ign

inte

llige

nce

-ga

the

ring

op

er-

atio

ns a

nd

certa

in a

spe

cts of o

ur

fore

ign re

latio

ns."

He then added: "If it w

ere ancient histo

ry from

a clo

sed b

ook, I w

ould

h

ave

no

pro

ble

m w

ith th

e m

atte

r; but it is n

ot, a

nd th

at is w

here

my

problem lies, and that is even though

many of the events occurred a num

-ber of years ago. B

ut I would regard

the book as still being open, and that is w

ha

t trou

ble

s me

."

TH

E F

AT

E of N

ick Shadrin m

ay never be kn

ow

n. T

he m

ost like

ly source

fo

r an e

ventu

al a

nsw

er is so

me fu

-ture defector from

the KG

B—

unless, of course, E

wa S

hadrin is correct in her sta

unch

belie

f that th

ere

are

U

.S. o

fficials w

ho h

ave

know

n a

ll along exactly w

hat happened to her husband.

Wh

ile th

e C

IA re

fuse

s to d

iscuss

the S

hadrin

case

, its positio

n o

n

Agency responsibility for defectors is

clear. Robert W

. Gam

bino, the direc- to

r of th

e C

IA's O

ffice o

f Se

curity,

made th

e fo

llow

ing sta

tem

ent to

a

Congre

ssional co

mm

ittee in

1979:

"The A

gency assumes an aw

esome

responsibility when it takes under its

win

g a

ny d

efe

ctor. If b

od

ily ha

rm

were

to co

me to

a d

efe

ctor in

ad-

eq

ua

tely p

rote

cted

by o

ur se

curity

officers, there would be a devastating

imp

act o

n a

ll po

ten

tial d

efe

ctors."

Tw

o fo

rmer d

irecto

rs of C

entra

l In

tellig

ence, in

com

mentin

g to

R

eader's Digest, agree that S

hadrin's loss affects the clim

ate for defection. S

ays R

icha

rd H

elm

s: "Th

e w

orst

fea

ture

of th

e ca

se w

as p

erm

itting

S

hadrin to travel to a city in Europe

where

the K

GB

could

contro

l the

environment. P

otential Russian de-

fectors would understand a double-

agent operation, so I would have to

say that the loss of Shadrin is discour-

agin

g m

ostly in

the se

nse

of fa

ulty

trad

ecra

ft on

the

Am

erica

ns' p

art."

Willia

m C

olb

y, who w

as d

irecto

r of C

entral Intelligence at the time of

Shadrin's disappearance, declares,

"The h

andlin

g in

Vie

nn

a w

as ce

r-ta

inly d

eficie

nt—

esp

ecia

lly the a

b-

sence

of a

ny co

unte

rsurve

illance

m

easures." And he expressed con-

cern that Shadrin's loss w

ould create "psychological disincentives to S

ovi-ets considering defection."

Co

lby a

dd

ed

: "In th

e c

lose

d

world of S

oviet society and especially th

e K

GB

, it is very m

uch

in th

eir

inte

rest to

indica

te th

at d

efe

ction

leads to

frustra

tion, p

unish

ment o

r degradation, and we know

that they actively prom

ote such impressions.

Whether the S

oviets internally por- tray S

hadrin's disappearance as a re

sult o

f their o

wn a

ction, w

hich

I doubt, or as the inevitable fate of one w

ho leaves their service, does not m

ake a great difference. The effect

of either on potential Soviet defec-

tors is certainly depressing." P

erhaps the most disturbing as-

pe

ct of th

e sto

ry, five ye

ars a

fter

Shadrin has vanished, is the cryptic

Com

ment b

y Judge W

ard

that th

e

case remains an open book, that it

ap

pe

ars

to h

ave

"on

go

ing

rel-

evance." Authoritative observers in-

terpret this as an indication that Igor continues to be regarded as a bona fid

e a

gent w

orkin

g in

the K

GB

for

the United S

tates. T

ho

se w

ho

do

ub

t Igo

r's cred

en

-tia

ls are

appalle

d b

y this p

rosp

ect.

Th

ey re

ga

rd Ig

or a

s on

e o

f a n

um

-b

er o

f fals

e d

efe

cto

rs, in

clu

din

g

No

sen

ko, w

ho

ha

ve se

du

ced

an

d

confu

sed se

nsitive

ele

ments o

f our

intelligence services for more than 15

years. E

ven if Ig

or h

ad b

een a

true

defe

ctor, so

me p

oin

t out, th

e n

ew

s stories that began to appear in 1978, te

lling o

f his a

ppro

ach

to th

e C

IA,

would

have

seale

d h

is fate

in M

os-

cow. If he w

ere still dealing with the

CIA

or the FB

I, his every move w

ould he controlled by the K

GB

. Yet, others

be

lieve

tha

t Igo

r is a tru

e d

efe

ctor,

who has escaped K

GB

detection, pro-vid

ed

us w

ith va

lua

ble

info

rma

tion

on a continuing basis, and serves to this day as a spy for the U

nited States.

In the absence of any solution, one 237

Page 22: The Spy Who Never Came Back - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index Files/S... · 2011. 12. 10. · SHADRIN: THE. SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK met in Washington

SHADRIN: THE SPY WHO NEVER CAME BACK

dreadful question must remain: did a situation develop on December 18-2o, 1975, that presented our intel-ligence officials with a terrible dilemma, one that demanded the decision either to lose Igor or to sacrifice Shadrin?

"That is not something that mat-ters to me," says Ewa Shadrin. "If Nick had been a spy—if they had told him the truth about the danger that he was in—perhaps it would be dif-ferent. But if they killed Nick, or let Nick be kidnapped or killed to save Igor, there is no reason good enough to justify it."

In the end, there is only one certainty: Ewa Shadrin has been the victim of one of the greatest decep-tions the American government has ever perpetrated on one of its citi-zens. The calculated lies reach all the way to the top of the government.

She is convinced that, in truth, no effort was ever made to find out about her husband. That is why President Ford, in a meeting with her, stared at her sullenly, silently. It is why President Carter refused to see her at all.

Of all her tribulations, Ewa Shad-rin faced nothing quite so cruel as the realization that some of Nick's best friends had been in the van-guard of the deception. It was the spring of 1978, when she first learned about Igor, that the horrible reality began to seep into her brain. Over the telephone, she found herself crying, screaming at Jim Wooten:

'But i fyou knew about Igor, how could you not tell Nick?"

"If Nick had known the truth," replied Wooten calmly, "he could never have played his role."

Cta

Signs of Life SIGN posted at a London airport: "There jst isnt engh spce on the pster

to xpin all the finand srvces Ntnl Wstmster Bnk can ofr yr bznes." —Tourist Talk

IN FRONT OF A RESTAURANT: "Our executive chef is the wizard of aahs."

—Contributed by Dolly A. Wiltiey

OUTSIDE A GYM in Pawtucket, R.I.: "Closed on Sundays to Let the Soul Catch Up With the Body." —Fanny Fanny World

AT A SKI RESORT: "Beware—Icicles Are Eavesdroppers." —Mrs. Thomas Bohen in Catholic Digest

ON A BAR in New York City: "The Opinions of the Political Savants Seated at the Bar Are Not Necessarily Those of the Bartender."

—Norton Mockridge, United Feature Syndicate

238