7/31/2019 The Distortion of Medicine, the Standard of Care, and Medical Community Norms - DeLuca; 2008.

1/3

Alex DeLuca, M.D., MPH; War on Doctors/Pain Crisis; 2008-12-30.

Revised: 2009-01-27 (footnote #4 inserted); 2009-02-19 (footnote #1 inserted).

Permalink: http://doctordeluca.com/wordpress/archive/distorted-confused-med-standards/

In fields of medicine involving controlled substances, especially addiction medicine and pain medicine,the doctor-patient relationship has become distorted. This distortion is complex and can be gross or

subtle. Examples include a blanket refusal to prescribe controlled substances even when clearly indicated,

or selecting less effective and more toxic non-controlled medications when a trial of opioid analgesicswould be in the best interests of a particular patient.

One manifestation of this distortion is the chilling effect the chilling effect is the withdrawal, for fear

of litigation or loss of livelihood, by physicians, from the appropriate treatment of pain.1

The chilling

effect on appropriate pain management leads inexorably to the national problems of the undertreatment of

pain2

and the shortage of physicians knowledgeable and experienced in opioid therapy for chronic pain,

and willing to provide this legitimate professional service. At the very least, some degree of suspicion andmistrust will surely arise in any medical relationship involving controlled substances.

3

In most medical fields we could say: How most reputable physicians practice approaches the

(textbook) standard of care. For common medical conditions (not involving controlled substances) the

quality of care most physicians provide is fairly close to the medical standard of care which is what the

textbooks say one should do, and which is generally in line with core medical ethical obligations such asholding the interests of the individual patient before you above all other interests, patient confidentiality,

etc. For example, the care a person would receive for an acute asthma attack is pretty much the same no

matter what ER he walked into, and that care would be pretty much by-the-book.

This is NOT true in the fields of addiction and pain medicine. For example, modern pain management

textbooks universally recommend titration to effect (simplistically: gradually increasing the opioid dose

until the pain is relieved or until untreatable side effects prevent further dosage increase) as the procedure

by which one properly treats chronic pain with opioid medications.4

Yet the overwhelmingly physicians

in America do not practice titration to effect, or anything even vaguely resembling it, for fear of

becoming high dose prescriber targets.

In pain medicine we have the deeply disturbing situation that what most doctors do (medical community

norm) is at odds with, and clearly below, the medical standard of care. Literally, in the treatment of

chronic pain, an ethical physician attempting to practice in good faith, according to the clinical literature,is an outlier deviating from how most reputable physicians would practice.

For a stark example, Brown and colleagues reported, at a National Institute on Drug Abuse symposium in

April 2001, on a survey they developed that measured the prescribing practices for benzodiazepines andfor opioid analgesics by groups of physicians in response to variations of a single presented case. The

physicians prescribing decisions were then compared with recommendations from a panel of pain

management experts. They found that while the expert panel recommended that virtually all patients with

http://doctordeluca.com/wordpress/http://doctordeluca.com/wordpress/archive/distorted-confused-med-standards/http://doctordeluca.com/wordpress/archive/distorted-confused-med-standards/http://doctordeluca.com/wordpress/

7/31/2019 The Distortion of Medicine, the Standard of Care, and Medical Community Norms - DeLuca; 2008.

2/3

[common idiopathic back pain] who do not respond to other treatments be given an opioid analgesic, only

20% of physicians said they would actually write that prescription.5

Where some medical board investigators and prosecutors err, in cases involving opioid prescribing, is inconfusing or conflating the concepts: medical standard of care, on the one hand, and community

norms of medical practice, on the other. Physicians willing to testify that they couldnt conceive of

writing this or that prescription, or that the defendants prescriptions were absurd or outrageous oroutside the bounds of legitimate medical practice are often not in fact testifying to the medical standard

of care, but rather to what they conceive of as the medical community norm what they think most

reputable physicians in the community would do.

The Reasonable Physician Standard. While drug war prosecutors invariably attempt to confuse juries

and journalists, and usually succeed, regarding this crucial difference between the medical standard of

care and community norms of medical behavior, that difference is in fact very clearly drawn, as amatter of both medical ethics and precedence in criminal law. As Ben Rich explains in Medical Custom

and Medical Ethics: Rethinking the Standard of Care (citation/abstract full text PDF):

When credible evidence has been presented that not just a particular physician, or anisolated, retrograde group of them, but a majority of the profession has failed to adopt

practices that would materially reduce patient suffering, courts may properly conclude, in

the tradition of great justices like Holmes and Hand, that a reasonable physician would not

practice in this way and those who do should be called to account for the adverse

consequences such practice has on the well-being of patients.6

(emphasis mine)

Footnotes

1. The Dissembling DEA and The Myth of the Chilling Effect, a section ofWar on Drugs, War on Doctors,and the Pain Crisis in America DeLuca, 2004.

2. Chronic Pain in America: Roadblocks to Relief a study conducted by Roper Starch Worldwide forAmerican Academy of Pain Medicine, American Pain Society and Janssen Pharmaceutica, 1999. From

the Conclusions section: The majority of those with the most severe pain do not have it under control

and untreated pain or pain not under control has a significant unfavorable impact on the sufferers

quality of life.

3. It is important to note that much of the public health damage here is caused not by the doctorsaccused of wrongdoing, rather it is caused by doctors-in-good-standing who, faced with a patient in

pain and therefore at risk of triggering an investigation, modify their treatment in an attempt to avoid

regulatory attention. For a fuller discussion of these issues see Footnote #1.

4. Fine PG, Portenoy RK. A Clinical Guide to Opioid Analgesia. McGraw-Hill Healthcare InformationPrograms. Revised 2004.

5. See: Vastag, B. Mixed Message on Prescription Drug Abuse, JAMA, 2001.

6. BEN A. RICH (2005). Medical Custom and Medical Ethics: Rethinking the Standard of Care. CambridgeQuarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 14, pp 27-39.

doi:10.1017/S0963180105050048Citation/abstract Full Text PDF

http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?aid=274995http://doctordeluca.com/Library/Pain/MedCustomEthicsStandCare05.pdfhttp://doctordeluca.com/Library/Pain/MedCustomEthicsStandCare05.pdfhttp://www.doctordeluca.com/Library/WOD/WOD-PCA060404cWeb.htm#DissemblingDEAhttp://doctordeluca.com/Library/WOD/WOD-PCA060404cWeb.htmhttp://doctordeluca.com/Library/WOD/WOD-PCA060404cWeb.htmhttp://www.ampainsoc.org/links/roadblocks/http://www.ampainsoc.org/links/roadblocks/http://www.stoppain.org/pcd/content/forpros/opioidbook.asphttp://www.doctordeluca.com/Library/WOD/MixedMessagePrescripDrugAbuse01.htmhttp://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?aid=274995http://doctordeluca.com/Library/Pain/MedCustomEthicsStandCare05.pdfhttp://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?aid=274995http://doctordeluca.com/Library/Pain/MedCustomEthicsStandCare05.pdfhttp://www.doctordeluca.com/Library/WOD/WOD-PCA060404cWeb.htm#DissemblingDEAhttp://doctordeluca.com/Library/WOD/WOD-PCA060404cWeb.htmhttp://doctordeluca.com/Library/WOD/WOD-PCA060404cWeb.htmhttp://www.ampainsoc.org/links/roadblocks/http://www.stoppain.org/pcd/content/forpros/opioidbook.asphttp://www.doctordeluca.com/Library/WOD/MixedMessagePrescripDrugAbuse01.htmhttp://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?aid=274995http://doctordeluca.com/Library/Pain/MedCustomEthicsStandCare05.pdf

7/31/2019 The Distortion of Medicine, the Standard of Care, and Medical Community Norms - DeLuca; 2008.

3/3