Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON...

23
WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON [email protected] Telecommunications & Health Science Dr. Sheila Johnston Neuroscience Consultant, London [email protected]

Transcript of Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON...

Page 1: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Telecommunications & Health Science

Dr. Sheila JohnstonNeuroscience Consultant, London

[email protected]

Page 2: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

A. Industry Health SpokespersonMichaela Reeh 1997-2000

B. Industry Association FMKC. Independent Science Consultant

SAJ 1996– (ICO’96-99)ABC= Sciencefaqs, August 2000

Page 3: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

eight divisions of information• Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum, SQ&A• Abstracts:Q&A WHO criteria, weight of evidence,• Bioeffects: Keydoc, Keyspeech, 6 generic class:human• Position Statements, • Standards, Key doc, by country, added files• Weblinks: govt, operators, science, expert reports• WHO EMF Project studies data base: user friendly• Worldwide Funding Agencies.

Page 4: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

The RF Bioeffects being Researched

RF Bioeffects• Cancer-epidemiology• Cancer-in vivo in

vitro• Genotoxicity• Nervous system• Thermal • Anecdotal• Interference

Scientific Reviews• Elwood, J. M. ‘99.• Harrison ‘97• Brusick, D. ‘98. • Hermann D. M.. ‘97.• NRPB 4: 5 ‘93. (‘99) • Bergquist et al, ‘97.• Medical Devices

Agency, ’97, UK

Page 5: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Sciencefaqs updateHOT ISSUES UPDATE• 16/Oct/2001 Germany: SSK Limits and precaution-measures --• 24/Sep/2001 Summary, Mobile Phones is there a Health Risk? IBC --

20/Sep/2001 The Daily Telegraph, England, 19/09/01 Page18 : Science: “Is Cancer a call away?” --

BULLETIN BOARD UPDATE• 19/Oct/2001 The 3G GHz Signal: A Review of Relevant Cognitive

Research Source: Sheila Johnston Ph.D. Details next slide• 16/Oct/2001 Grenzwerte und Vorsorgemaßnahmen zum Schutz der

Bevö lkerung vor elektromagnetischen Feldern --• 30/Sep/2001 SAR Initiatives in the USA. IBC Conf: London 09/01 J.

Basile VP Ext & Ind. Rel. CTIA –• 14/Sep/2001 Update on WHO EMF Project 1996- 2006. Dr Mike

Repacholi Helsinki --

Page 6: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

The 3G GHz Signal: A Review of Relevant Cognitive Research

• Review of effects on cognition from exposure to MW radiation. • The special focus is the 3 GSM signal around 2 GHz• Molecular mechanisms of memory storage are highly conserved.• Complex memory depends on simplest molecular mechanisms. • Spatial memory processes in animals extrapolated to humans.• Presently, no reliable scientific evidence that microwave signals of

guideline limits, including 2 GHz, signals could interfere with cognition.

• Research on microwave exposure effects on memory processes draws on molecular memory processes & related signalling & genetic factors from previous invertebrate & vertebrate research:

• Including cognition, neurotransmitters, receptors, genes & glia & nitric oxide, a possible retrograde messenger for Hebbian associative firing .

Page 7: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 8: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 9: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 10: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 11: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 12: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 13: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 14: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 15: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 16: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 17: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 18: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Page 19: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Consolidation of LT memory is involves 3 processes:

• 1. gene expression, • 2. new protein synthesis and • 3. growth or pruning of synaptic

connections.

Page 20: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

cAMP-PKA-CREB pathway in STM & LTM storage.

4 mutations can cause a defect in the cAMP cascade: • 1.Inducible control over gene expression • 2. Block the action of PKA needed to learn even STM• 3. Over expression of repressor CREB-2 prevents the cAMP

activated genes, & selectively blocks LTM with out interfering with STM.

• 4. Over expression of CREB results in LTM even with a training procedure that usually only produces only STM.

Page 21: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Mossy fiber terminals in CA3 release glutamate. • CA3, NMDA receptors minor role in synaptic plasticity. • LTP depends on Ca2+ influx into the presynaptic cell

(granule cell terminal) after the tetanus.• LTP in the mossy fiber pathway is non associative. • LTP does not require simultaneous firing in both the

postsynaptic CA3 cell & presynaptic dentate cell to adequately depolarise the CA3 postsynaptic cell, a feature called non associativity.

The Mossy Fiber Terminals: Long-Term Potentiation(CA3)

Page 22: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Schaffer Collateral & Perforant Pathways: Long-Term Potentiation (CA1)

LTP in CA1 cells has characteristics distinct from CA3Glutamate must bind to the postsynaptic NMDA receptor & the

membrane potential of the postsynaptic cell must be sufficientlydepolarised by cooperative firing of several afferent axons to expel Mg2+ from the mouth of the channel.

The Schaffer NMDA collateral pathway requires simultaneous firingin both postsynaptic CA1 & presynaptic CA3 cells to adequately depolarise the postsynaptic CA1 cell, a feature called associativity.

To initiate Ca2+ influx into the postsynaptic cell a strong presynaptic input sufficient to fire the postsynaptic cell is required.

Recent pharmacological and genetic experiments have identified nitric oxide (NO) a gas that diffuses from cell to cell as one of the possible retrograde messengers involved in LTP.

Page 23: Telecommunications & Health Science · WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001 SHEILA JOHNSTON sajohnston@btclick.com eight divisions of information • Members Dialogue: BB, Hot issue, Forum,

WHO EMF PROJECT SEOUL OCT 2001

SHEILA [email protected]

Conclusion• EEG studies are inconclusive & difficult to interpret. • Recent human cognitive studies have not followed the

WHO criteria for good research.• Animal spatial memory researchers (UK, Brooks, Japan

& France) found no effect of RF exposure on spatial memory at or below guideline limits.

• Recent recordings in hippocampal studies suggest no effects of RF on long-term potentiation, and thus explicit memory.

• Further research of RF on cognition will focus on the molecular mechanism of memory.