Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low...

68
Michael J. O’Donnell Purdue Extension Extension Educator, Organic and Diversified Agriculture (765) 284-8414 [email protected] www.purdue.edu/dffs/organicag February 19, 2020 Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to Organic Grain Production

Transcript of Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low...

Page 1: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellPurdue ExtensionExtension Educator, Organic and Diversified Agriculture(765) [email protected]/dffs/organicag

February 19, 2020

Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to Organic Grain Production

Page 2: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 3: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

www.purdue.edu/dffs/organicag

Page 4: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://www.ccof.org/press/michelob-ultra-pure-gold-launches-6-6-pack-program-support-organic-farming

Page 5: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

6 for 6-pack?

– Let’s do the numbers….– 43,560 sq. ft / acre 7,260 6-packs– 27.556 6-packs in a keg (1/2 bbl) 263 kegs per acre!– So, the next logical question…..

https://www.michelobultra.com/

Page 6: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

How many kegs of beer are consumed over a weekend at Purdue University?

Page 7: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://www.ccof.org/ccof-foundation/organic-transition-grants#eligibility

https://www.michelobultra.com/campaigns/contract-for-change.html

Page 8: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://thecounter.org/michelob-ultra-organic-beer-super-bowl/

Page 9: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

What is organic agriculture???

Slides adapted from:Dr. Joel Gruver, WIU

https://www.slideshare.net/jbgruver/history-of-organic-agriculture-14808475

Page 10: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 11: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 12: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 13: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 14: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 15: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 16: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 17: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 18: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 19: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 20: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 21: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 22: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

What is organic agriculture???

Slides adapted from:Dr. Joel Gruver, WIU

https://www.slideshare.net/jbgruver/history-of-organic-agriculture-14808475

Page 23: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

What is organic farming?“Organic farming is a production system which avoids or largely excludes the use of synthetically compounded fertilizers, pesticides, growth regulators and livestock feed additives.

To the maximum extent feasible organic farming systems rely on crop rotations, crop residues, animal manures, legumes, green manures, off-farm organic wastes, mechanical cultivation, mineral-bearing rocks, and aspects of biological pest control to maintain soil productivity and tilth, to supply plant nutrients, and to control insects, weeds and other pests.”

- USDA Study Team on Organic Farming, 1980

Page 24: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

What is organic agriculture?"Organic agriculture is an ecological production management system that promotes and enhances biodiversity, biological cycles and soil biological activity. It is based on minimal use of off-farm inputs and on management practices that restore, maintain and enhance ecological harmony.

‘Organic’ is a labeling term that denotes products produced under the authority of the Organic Foods Production Act.

The principal guidelines for organic production are to use materials and practices that enhance the ecological balance of natural systems and that integrate the parts of the farming system into an ecological whole. ... Organic food handlers, processors and retailers adhere to standards that maintain the integrity of organic agricultural products.

The primary goal of organic agriculture is to optimize the health and productivity of interdependent communities of soil life, plants, animals and people.“ ---USDA NOSB defn, Apr 1995

Page 25: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

7 CFR 205 – National Organic Program

http://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?SID=4afa25d8d8a865cd1938a45637e4d684&node=7:3.1.1.9.32&rgn=div5

Page 26: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

What is organic production?

• “Organic production [is] a production system that…respond[s] to site-specific conditions by integrating cultural, biological, and mechanical practices that foster cycling of resources, promote ecological balance, and conserve biological diversity” [§ 205.2].

Page 27: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

• “Organic is a labeling term for food or other agricultural products that have been produced according to the USDA organic regulations … Producers and handlers must meet these standards to use the word ‘organic’ or the USDA organic seal on food, feed, or fiber. – Is Organic an Option for Me?” USDA, August 2012

• “USDA Certified Organic products are grown and processed according to USDA’s national organic standards and certified by USDA-accredited … certification organizations.”–USDA AMS website

NOP is a Process Verification Program (PVP)

Page 28: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

International Standards

Page 29: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

What Lands May Be Certified as Organic?• Land must have been free

of prohibited substances for 3 years –

WHY 3 YEARS?

• If the land has been free of prohibited substances for at least 3 years, the operation may be eligible for immediate certification

• Both conventional and organic production may occur on the same operation

• Buffer zones may be required, if prohibited substances are used on adjacent lands

• There are no size requirements: both small and large farms are eligible for organic certification

Page 30: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Getting Certified under the National Organic Program (NOP)

Page 31: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Certifiers (18 Accredited Certifying Agents have clients in IN)

– A Bee Organic– CCOF– ECOCERT ICO– Global Organic Alliance– ICS– MOSA– MCIA– MOFGA– NICS– OEFFA– OneCert

– OnMark Certification– OTCO– OCIA– PCO– Pro-Cert– QAI– QCS

https://www.ams.usda.gov/services/organic-certification/certifying-agents

Page 32: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://attra.ncat.org/product/organic-certification-of-farms-and-businesses-producing-agricultural-products/

Page 33: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://attra.ncat.org/product/guide-for-organic-crop-producers/

Page 34: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

OTA, 2017

Page 35: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://ota.com/news/press-releases/20699

Page 36: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

“New records were made in both the organic food market and the organic non-food market. Organic food sales reached $47.9 billion, for an increase of 5.9 percent. Sales of organic non-food products jumped by 10.6 percent to $4.6 billion. The growth rate for organic continued to easily outpace the general market: in 2018, total food sales in the U.S. edged up just 2.3 percent while total non-food sales rose 3.7 percent.”

“Almost 6 percent (5.7 percent) of the food sold in this country is now organic.”

Page 37: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

http://www.organic-world.net/yearbook/yearbook-2018.html

Page 38: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

How much land in the U.S. is certified organic?

Page 39: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020OTA, 2017

Page 40: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 41: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 42: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

770 certified organic operations (May 2018). • 573 crops. • 405 livestock. • 117 handling.

847 (May 2019).

917 (Feb 2020).

Page 43: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Organic product sales in Indiana 2016

Page 44: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Torres, Purdue HO-280-W

Page 45: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Mercaris 2018 Organic Acreage Reportshows continued growth in organic field crop

acres in Indiana420 operations on 43,219 acres in 2016

(USDA) increased to 540 operations on 57,648 acres in 2018

(Mercaris)

29% increase in operations and 33% increase in acreage

from 2016-2018

Page 46: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 47: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 48: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 49: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://www.ams.usda.gov/market-news/organic

Milk, egg, chicken, produce, cotton, grain, retail

Page 50: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 51: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Page 52: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

UPDATE

Page 53: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://mercaris.com/farmers

Page 54: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

https://ag.purdue.edu/commercialag/Pages/Resources/Finance/Financial-Analysis/Comparison-of-Organic-and-Conventional-Crop-Rotaions.aspx

Page 55: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

C-B-W Organic

Corn/Soybean/Wheat Organic Rotation

Corn T Soy Wheat T Wheat Org Corn Org SoyOrg

Wheat Rotation

Gross Return 728.75 381.18 435.02 335.53 1184.24 827.79 559.13 759.05Variable Cost 459.73 225.19 189.23 193.10 353.90 208.45 193.10 260.09Contribution Margin 269.02 155.98 245.78 142.43 830.34 619.33 366.03 498.96Fixed Cost 316.64 376.83 309.09 351.73 432.86 400.06 374.96 388.58

Earnings -47.62 -220.85 -63.30 -209.29 397.48 219.27 -8.93 110.39

Percent of Acres 6.7% 3.3% 10.0% 10.0% 26.7% 23.3% 20.0% 100.0%

Langemeier, 2019

year 1 year 2 year 3 year 4 year 5C 67% 33% 0% 0% 0%T 33% 67% 67% 33% 0%O 0% 0% 33% 67% 100%

Page 56: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/future-of-food/organic-farming-crops-consumers/?fbclid=IwAR2kGf6YVilbSLPuYPhBDRuimV_WtnDWCpt6OMp0euNCpIrzU_1oXjEdodI

Nov 20, 2018

Page 57: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

It takes a high level of skill and will to be a successful organic

farmer!

Dr. J Gruver

Page 58: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Barriers to Transition

– Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years– Initial cost increase and learning period– Retooling and new equipment; storage– Market uncertainty– Lender support through transition years– Risk management options – Support network– Barriers “between the ears”

Page 59: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Shift in mindset –• Not input substitution

• Organic mgmt. is not prescriptive: Site and management specific

• “What about the cropping system allows a given pest to thrive or find a niche? Identify it and ‘close the door!’” – Klaas Marten

• Redirect annual chemical costs to equipment (and labor / management)

• “You’ll need more than just financial reasons” –Carmen Fernholz

• Not an abandonment of technology

Page 60: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Source: Canadian Organic Growers

Page 61: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Source: Canadian Organic Growers

Page 62: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Transition considerations

• Timing of transition (year 3 crop certified)

• Plan rotation to hit highest premium crop (corn?) in year 1 of certification

• Whole farm, Phased, Split/Parallel

Page 63: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

USDA Programs to support organic

• Organic Certification Cost-Share Program (USDA FSA)

• USDA NRCS programs – CAP 138 and EQIP

• Federal Crop Insurance covering organic commodity production (USDA RMA)

Page 64: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

https://www.raboag.com/news/rabo-agrifinance-designs-industrys-first-organic-transition-loan-offering-54

Page 65: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling
Page 66: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling
Page 67: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Considerations with transition– Build a support network, attend meetings– Study the NOP standard– Develop a record keeping system– Find an ACA– Develop a business plan for navigating transition,

find a lender that understands organic– Don’t bet the farm– Transition your best fields first– Explore / identify markets– Diversify your crop rotation– Develop holistic and adaptive approach to weed and

fertility management

Page 68: Successful Transitions: Considerations in Transitioning to ......Access to information – Low yields during first 3+ years – Iitial cost increase and learning periodn – Retooling

Michael J. O’DonnellFebruary 19, 2020

Thank YouMichael J. O’Donnell

Extension Educator, Organic and Diversified AgriculturePurdue Extension(765) [email protected]

"The real Arsenal of Democracy is a fertile soil, the fresh produce of which is the birthright of the nations."

-- Sir Albert Howard