Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. ·...

37
1 Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University of Nova Gorica

Transcript of Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. ·...

Page 1: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

1

Recent results of thePierre Auger Observatory

Creusot Alexandrefor the Pierre Auger Collaboration University of Nova Gorica

Page 2: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

2

Outline

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

The Pierre Auger Observatory

Spectrum of ultra-high energy cosmic rays

Mass composition and hadronic interaction

Arrival directions

Page 3: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

3

Outline

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

The Pierre Auger Observatory

Spectrum of ultra-high energy cosmic rays

Mass composition and hadronic interaction

Arrival directions

Page 4: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

4

Scientific case

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Study of the ultra-high energy cosmic rays (UHECR)

determine the characteristics (flux, nature, energy)

identify the sources (cosmic ray astronomy)

understand the acceleration mechanisms

Page 5: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

5

The Pierre Auger Observatory

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Two sites:- Malargue (Argentina)- Lamar (USA)

Above 21019 eV south ~ 25 evt/year north ~ 200 evt/year

full sky coverage high statistic

Page 6: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

6

The Pierre Auger Observatory

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Two sites:- Malargue (Argentina)- Lamar (USA)

Above 21019 eV south ~ 25 evt/year north ~ 200 evt/year

full sky coverage high statistic

Page 7: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

7

The southern site

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Malargue (Argentina)

2004 => data2008 => completion

Page 8: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

8

The southern site

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Malargue (Argentina)

2004 => data2008 => completion

Page 9: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

9

Hybrid detection

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Detection of the extensive air shower (EAS) induced by UHECR with two methods

sampling at the ground level of the shower particles

Array of 1660 CherenkovDetectors (SD)

detection of the fluorescence light emitted by the air molecules after the shower

crossing

24 fluorescence telescopes in 4 sites (FD)

3000 km2

Page 10: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

10

Exposure

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

2000 trans-GZK cosmic rays in 10 years

Page 11: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

11

Hybrid detector

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

One example

Page 12: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

12

Surface array

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Measurement of the shower front

E ~ 2.701019 eV θ ~ 59.8° Φ ~ 38.8°

Lateral Distribution Function (LDF)

Page 13: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

13

Fluorescence telescopes

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Measurement of the longitudinal profil of the shower

E ~ 3.021019 eVθ ~ 59.6° Φ ~ 39.8°

Gaisser-Hillas Function

Page 14: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

14

Hybrid detector

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Surface array:

100% duty cycle angular resolution < 1° exposure

Fluorescence telescopes:

13% duty cycle angular resolution < 0.6° energy estimation (calorimeter)

Page 15: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

15

Outline

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

The Pierre Auger Observatory

Spectrum of ultra-high energy cosmic rays

Mass composition and hadronic interaction

Arrival directions

Page 16: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

16

Energy spectrum

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

exposure for both modes

increase of the energy range

SD above 1018.5 eV

FD above 1018 eV

calibration of the SD with hybrids

Combined spectrum (SD + hybrid)

Page 17: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

17

Energy spectrum

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

exposure for both modes

increase of the energy range

SD above 1018.5 eV

FD above 1018 eV

calibration of the SD with hybrids

Combined spectrum (SD + hybrid)

Page 18: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

18

SD energy spectrum

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Uncertainties flux ~ 5.8% energy resolution ~ 20%

Page 19: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

19

Hybrid energy spectrum

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Uncertainties flux ~ 10% at 1018 eV flux ~ 6% above 1019 eV energy resolution < 6%

Page 20: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

20

Combined energy spectrum

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

lg(EANKLE

/ eV) ~ 18.6

power law: below ~ 3.3 above ~ 2.6

lg(E1/2

/ eV) ~ 19.6

Uncertainties flux < 4% energy resolution ~ 22%

GZK suppression significant at 20 σ

Page 21: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

21

Outline

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

The Pierre Auger Observatory

Spectrum of ultra-high energy cosmic rays

Mass composition and hadronic interaction

Arrival directions

Page 22: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

22

Mass composition with hybrids

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Xmax

is in the view field => direct measurement

RMS(Xmax

) sensitive to nnucleons

and to the interaction length

d(Xmax

)/dlgE (elongation rate) sensitive to a change in the composition

One observable: the depth of maximum of the shower development (Xmax

)

Page 23: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

23

Mass composition with hybrids

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

the mean mass increases with energy

if the extrapolations of the hadronic models are correct

Page 24: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

24

Mass composition with SD

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Method: use of the shower front

t1/2

=> discriminate between muonic and electronic components

Nμ/N

em => age of the shower (and X

max)

Xmax

=> primary mass composition

signal rise time

Page 25: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

25

Mass composition with SD

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

method: asymmetry in t1/2

between upstream and downstream stations (non-vertical showers)

r: distance to the coreζ: azimuth in the shower plane

almost independent of Nμ

calibration with Xmax

Page 26: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

26

Mass composition with SD

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

mean mass seems to increase with energy

Page 27: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

27

Hadronic interaction

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Proton-air cross section

Method fixed energy and stage of development use the shower characteristics to estimate the frequency of the 1st interaction as a function of the shower zenith (penetration in atmosphere) assuming an exponential decay, estimate the interaction length and cross section compare to models

Shower characteristics SD =>N

e, N

μ

FD =>Xmax

Influential parameters flux of cosmic rays

mass composition

shower to shower fluctuations (ΔX1)

frequency of shower with Ne after ΔX

2

energy of the shower (Nμ or X

max)

detector resolution

Page 28: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

28

Hadronic interaction

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Model dependence

Exponential decay (k factor)

Λ = k × λint

large uncertainty on the asymptotic

k depends on the hadronic model

FD => 7%

SD => 28%

Unfolding Xmax

distribution

better accuracy (no ΔX2)

less model dependent

(R.Ulrich et al., arXiv:0906.0418)

Page 29: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

29

Hadronic interaction

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Model dependence

Exponential decay (k factor)

Λ = k × λint

large uncertainty on the asymptotic

k depends on the hadronic model

FD => 7%

SD => 28%

Unfolding Xmax

distribution

better accuracy (no ΔX2)

less model dependent

Page 30: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

30

Hadronic interaction

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Model dependence

Exponential decay (k factor)

Λ = k × λint

large uncertainty on the asymptotic

k depends on the hadronic model

FD => 7%

SD => 28%

Unfolding Xmax

distribution

better accuracy (no ΔX2)

less model dependent

SD: k = 0.40 × model (± 0.11)FD: k = 0.97 × model (± 0.07)

Page 31: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

31

Outline

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

The Pierre Auger Observatory

Spectrum of ultra-high energy cosmic rays

Mass composition and hadronic interaction

Arrival directions

Page 32: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

32

Arrival directions

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

1st January 2004 – 26th May 2006

angular distance: 3.1°

maximal redshift: 0.018 (75 Mpc)

minimal energy: 55 EeV (57 EeV)

9/14 correlating events

Prescription

Page 33: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

33

Arrival directions

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

27th May 2006 – 31st August 2007

9/13 correlating events

isotropy rejection > 99%

Period II

(Auger, Science 318 (2007) 938)

Period III

1st Sept. 2007 - 31st March 2009

8/31 correlating events

still signal, but weaker (II + III)

isotropy rejection > 99% (II + III)

Page 34: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

34

Arrival directions

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Likelihood ratio

Compatible with

anisoptropy

Page 35: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

35

Arrival directions

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

Signal monitoring

Compatible with

anisotropy

pdata

= 0.38 ± 0.07

Page 36: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

36

Summary and outlook

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

GZK suppression

energy spectrum characteristics

mean mass of the primary increasing with energy

correlation between the arrival directions and the closest AGNs

Data from 2004 up to 2009

Update of the data set

cross section proton-air

models for hadronic interaction

See other Auger presentations about radio detection, neutrinos and photons

In the near future

Page 37: Recent results of the Pierre Auger Observatorycreusot/Presentations/ARENA... · 2013. 4. 30. · Pierre Auger Observatory Creusot Alexandre for the Pierre Auger Collaboration University

37

Alexandre Creusot for the Pierre Auger collaboration

BACK-UP SLIDES