Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection...

32
Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation B e n n y . E k l u n d @ l u l . s e

Transcript of Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection...

Page 1: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealthClinical Data Access

Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road

to new national legislation

Benny.E

[email protected]

Page 2: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Internet banking and Health Internet banking and Health Care in the same wayCare in the same way

Benny.E

[email protected]

Page 3: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

A system that can be considered as analogous to

Internet banking, but for health care

Page 4: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Why haven’t such services been rolled out in large scale in the

health care?

1. The average age of patients are significant higher for patients compared with the most active bank customers.

2. Information about a bank customer’s bank account is much more structured compared to a medical record.

3. It has not earlier been available secure and cost effective solutions.

4. Banks are in a better position to charge their customers for those services

Page 5: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Med. Record, Hosp

Medical Record, GP

Drugs

Fees

Future Visits

Safe “e-mail” to GP

Change of GP

Transportation

Booking transp.

Encyclopedia, Drugs

Encyclopedia, Med.

Patients requests of future functions

Page 6: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Trying to answer questions like

• Which groups of patients benefits most?

• Which kind of services has the strongest demand?

• What kind of technical solutions are most suitable?

• What is the best layout and logic is best for the user?

Page 7: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Patient view on Health Care?

The medical professional must be a partner instead of someone who make all the decisions

Page 8: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 9: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 10: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 11: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 12: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Can patients understand?

Page 13: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Elderly can’t use Internet

Page 14: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Distribution of Age 0

.01

.02

.03

Den

sity

0 20 40 60 80 100Ålder

Histogram över användare av hälso- och sjukvårdskonto juli 2003

0.0

05.0

1.0

15.0

2D

ensi

ty

0 20 40 60 80 100Ålder

Histogram över listade personer oktober 2002

Page 15: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

§The Swedish Data Inspection Board

Page 16: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 17: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 18: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 19: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 20: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.
Page 21: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

New legislation in Sweden 1:st July 2008

• Possible to interconnect different EHR:s

• Patients has the right to refuse

• Patients may block certain parts of the EHR

• Patient may directly access EHS via Internet

Page 22: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

How many doctors can access your Medical Record?

1999: 2-4 Doctors

Page 23: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

How many doctors can access your Medical Record?

2006:

1000 Doctors

Page 24: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

How many doctors can access your Medical Record?

2011:

30.000 Doctors

Page 25: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Patient controlled access

A coming future!

Page 26: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Four possible statements:

Most possible access!

Keep it as it is!

I’m opening at the GP:s surgery!

I open up myself from home!

Page 27: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Why those efforts?

• Sooner or later there will be a demand

Page 29: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

“People often overestimate what will happen in the next two years

and underestimate what will happen in ten.” Bill Gates

Page 30: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Balance

Medical Safety

vs

Privacy

Page 32: Overcoming Legal Challenges to eHealth Clinical Data Access Confronting the Swedish Data Protection Board and the road to new national legislation Benny.Eklund@lul.se.

Possible set of services:

• Book or rebook a visit• Pay a visiting fee• Examine the medical record• Put a question to their GP• Fill out a Health Declaration Form• Print out drug and lab list before an travel abroad• Change GP (when moving or similar)• Update phone number and name of close relative• Mask or block sensitive data• Track the referral