Melvin Hale vs Emporia State University Amended Federal Lawsuit 1/21/16

7/24/2019 Melvin Hale vs Emporia State University Amended Federal Lawsuit 1/21/16

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melvin-hale-vs-emporia-state-university-amended-federal-lawsuit-12116 1/99

OB YJL \BOYLI SYKYLS IOSYQOCY CE\QY

IOSYQOCY EH @KBSKS

F\Q_ YQOKD ILNKBI

Cksl Be. ;<-9?9=-SKC-@MS

SLCEBI KNLBILI CENWDKOBY

CENLS BE] Wdkobtohh Nldvob Jkdl, Wre Sl, kbi her jos Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kmkobst

Ilhlbikbts, stktls kbi kddlmls ks heddews6

ILNKBI HEQ F\Q_ YQOKD

Wdkobtohh ilnkbis k fury trokd eb kdd ossuls rkosli jlrlob.

ILSOMBKYOEB EH WDKCL EH YQOKD

Wdkobtohh jlrlay rlqulsts tjkt tjl trokd eh tjos ckusl al jldi ob Yepl`k, @kbsks.

NLDXOB JKDL, WjI,

Wdkobtohh

v.

LNWEQOK SYKYL \BOXLQSOY_ (LS\)0 FKC@OLXOLYYO, ob jlr ckpkcoty ks Obtlron Wrlsoilbt ehLS\0 IKXOI CEQIDL, ob jos ckpkcoty ks Wrevesteh LS\, F\I_ KBILQSEB, ob jlr ckpkcoty ks

Lxlcutovl Iorlcter eh Junkb Qldktoebs kt LS\0M]LB KDLZKBILQ, ob jlr ckpkcoty ks Ilkb ehtjl Scjeed eh Doarkry & Obhernktoeb Nkbkmlnlbtkt LS\0 CJQOS JEEXLQ, ob jos ckpkcoty ks Cjolheh Wedocl kt LS\0 ILAQK QOYYMLQS, ob jlrckpkcoty ks Kssostkbt te tjl Ilkb eh tjl Scjeed ehDoarkry kbi Obhernktoeb Nkbkmlnlbt kt LS\0@LXOB FEJBSEB ob jos ckpkcoty ks LS\ MlblrkdCeubsld kbi ks Ce-Iorlcter eh tjl @ecj Clbtlr herDlkilrsjop kbi Ltjocs kt LS\0 kbi QK_ DK\ALQob jos ckpkcoty ks JQ Splcokdost kt LS\, kbi IELS

; te ;77, Ilhlbikbts.

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ; eh ??



1

OBYQEI\CYOEB

;. Yjos os kb kctoeb sll`obm obfubctovl kbi lquotkadl rldolh her iknkmls ckusli ay

ilhknktoeb kbi hkdsl domjt obvksoeb eh provkcy ubilr @kbsks dkw0 k voedktoeb eh doalrty obtlrlsts

ubilr tjl Heurtllbtj Knlbinlbt0 ilprovktoeb eh preplrty obtlrlsts wotjeut iul preclss ubilr

tjl Heurtllbtj Knlbinlbt0 wrebmhud tlrnobktoeb ks rltkdoktoeb her tjl romjt te splk` hrlldy

ubilr tjl Horst Knlbinlbt0 kbi rltkdoktoeb kbi wrebmhud tlrnobktoeb ubilr Yotdl XOO eh tjl Covod

Qomjts Kct. K romjt te sul dlttlr os lxplctli sjertdy hren tjl LLEC.

1. Ks slt hertj ob nerl iltkod aldew, Ilhlbikbts, puadosjli hkdsl rlprlslbtktoebs kaeut

Wdkobtohh wjocj k rlksebkadl plrseb weudi hobi jomjdy ehhlbsovl – tjkt jl, kb Kssostkbt Wrehlsser

ob tjl Scjeed eh Doarkry kbi Obhernktoeb Nkbkmlnlbt (SDON), hkdsldy cdkonli tjkt k jktl cronl

eccurrli eb cknpus ob Kprod 17;<. Ilhlbikbts hurtjlr cdkonli tjkt Wdkobtohh‟s cebtrkct te wer` ob

k tlburl-trkc` pesotoeb ob tjl \bovlrsoty sjeudi al tlrnobktli, her knebm etjlr tjobms, stktobm jos

aldolh tjkt k debm tonl Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty lnpdeyll wks tjl jomjdy preakadl susplct ob tjl

wrotobm eh tjl rkcokd sdur.

3. Eb Ectealr ;1, 17;<, Wdkobtohh wks tedi tjkt jos lnpdeynlbt wotj LS\ weudi al

tlrnobktli kt tjl lbi eh tjl hkdd slnlstlr lbiobm ob Ilclnalr 17;< ubdlss jl kmrlli te k slt eh

ilnkbis wjocj obcduili suanottobm k dlttlr eh rlsombktoeb ay Ectealr 37, 17;< ob wjocj jl

weudi stktl jos rlsombktoeb wks lhhlctovl Nky ;=, 17;8. Wdkobtohh ioi bet kcclpt tjl tlrns eh tjl

dlttlr kbi rlhusli te rlsomb.

9. Wdkobtohh obvotli kbi kccenpkboli kb kmlbt hren tjl Yepl`k ehhocl eh tjl Hlilrkd

Aurlku eh Obvlstomktoeb (HAO) eb k teur eh tjl sclbl eh tjl jktl spllcj obcoilbt kt LS\ SDON eb

Ilclnalr 1, 17;<, kbi obtreiucli skoi kmlbt te Ilhlbikbts Ceridl kbi Fejbseb, te SDON

Mrkiuktl Kssostkbt Aroimoi Qllvls, kbi te SDON Obtlron Ilkb Norkj Iew.

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml 1 eh ??



3

<. Wdkobtohh rlclovli k dlttlr eh tlrnobktoeb hren LS\ Wrevest Ikvoi Ceridl iktli

Ilclnalr ;9, 17;<.

YJL WKQYOLS

8. Wdkobtohh Nldvob Jkdl os k rlsoilbt eh Lnperok, Dyeb Ceubty, @kbsks. Kt kdd tonls

rldlvkbt jlrlte, Wdkobtohh wks kb Kssostkbt Wrehlsser kt Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty. Jl mrkiuktli

wotj k iecterktl hren tjl \bovlrsoty eh Ckdoherbok, Des Kbmldls ob Nkrcj 17;9.

=. Ilhlbikbt LNWEQOK SYKYL \BOXLQSOY_ (—LS\„) os k @kbsks Stktl obstotutoeb eh

jomjlr dlkrbobm lstkadosjli ks @kbsks Bernkd Scjeed ob ;:83 ob Lnperok, @kbsks, wotj k currlbt

lbreddnlbt eh evlr 8,777 stuilbts.

:. Ilhlbikbt FKC@OL XOLYYO os tjl iudy kppeobtli Obtlron Wrlsoilbt eh LS\ kbi os

suli ob jlr ckpkcoty ks sucj.

?. Ilhlbikbt IKXOI CEQIDL os tjl iudy kppeobtli Wrevest eh LS\ kbi os suli ob jos

ckpkcoty ks sucj.

;7. Ilhlbikbt F\I_ KBILQSEB os tjl iudy kppeobtli Lxlcutovl Iorlcter eh Junkb

Qldktoebs kt LS\ kbi os suli ob jlr ckpkcoty ks sucj.

;;. Ilhlbikbt M]LB KDLZKBILQ os tjl iudy kppeobtli Ilkb eh SDON kt LS\ kbi os

suli ob jlr ckpkcoty ks sucj.

;1. Ilhlbikbt CJQOS JEEXLQ os tjl iudy kppeobtli Cjolh eh Wedocl kt LS\ kbi os

suli ob jos ckpkcoty ks sucj.

;3. Ilhlbikbt ILAQK QOYYMLQS os tjl iudy kppeobtli Kssostkbt te tjl Ilkb eh SDON

kbi os suli ob jlr ckpkcoty ks sucj.




9

;9. Ilhlbikbt @LXOB FEJBSEB os tjl iudy kppeobtli Mlblrkd Ceubsld eh LS\, kbi

tjl Ce-Iorlcter eh Yjl @ecj Clbtlr her Dlkilrsjop kbi Ltjocs, kbi os suli ob jos ckpkcoty ks

sucj.

;<. Ilhlbikbt QK_ DK\ALQ os tjl iudy kppeobtli JQ Splcokdost kt LS\ kbi os suli ob

jos ckpkcoty ks sucj.

;8. Wdkobtohh iels bet `bew tjl trul bknls kbi ckpkcotols eh tjl ilhlbikbts suli

hoctotoeusdy ks IELS ; te ;77 (—IEL ILHLBIKBYS„) kbi wodd knlbi tjos Slcebi Knlbili

Cenpdkobt te rlhdlct sucj obhernktoeb ks ot os ksclrtkobli. Wdkobtohh kddlmls tjkt tjl IEL

ilhlbikbts krl, lkcj, slpkrktldy er ob mreups, ob senl nkbblr rlspebsoadl her tjl kcts

cenpdkobli eh jlrlob. Wdkobtohh hurtjlr kddlmls tjkt tjl IEL ILHLBIKBYS wlrl tjl kmlbts,

lnpdeylls er rlspebsoadl obiovoiukds er lbtotols ob rlsplct te tjl kddlmktoebs slt hertj ob tjos

Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt.

Furosioctoeb kbi Xlbul

;=. Yjos kctoeb krosls ubilr tjl Cebstotutoeb eh tjl \botli Stktls kbi tjl prevosoebs eh

91 \.S.C. § ;?:3 kbi Yotdl XOO. Yjl furosioctoeb eh tjos ceurt os obve`li pursukbt te 1: \.S.C. §§

;33; kbi ;393(k), pursukbt te 91 \.S.C. § ;?:3, kbi pursukbt te Yotdl XOO.

;:. Yjl Ceurt jks plrsebkd furosioctoeb evlr Ilhlbikbts alckusl tjl ubdkwhud kcts kbi

cebiuct cenpdkobli eh jlrlob eccurrli wotjob tjl Stktl eh @kbsks.

;?. Xlbul os preplr ob tjos Ceurt pursukbt te 1? \.S.C. § ;3?;Pa^ alckusl k suastkbtokd

pkrt eh tjl kcts kbi cebiuct movobm rosl te Wdkobtohh‟s obfury cdkons eccurrli ob Lnperok, Dyeb,




<

@kbsks, wjocj dols wotjob tjl Iostroct eh @kbsks kbi alckusl Ilhlbikbts trkbskct ausoblss wotjob

tjl Iostroct eh @kbsks.

HKCYS CENNEB YE KDD CK\SLS EH KCYOEB

17. Wdkobtohh wks lbmkmli ob jos eriobkry iutols, kttlbiobm k hkcudty nlltobm, ks kb

Kssostkbt Wrehlsser eb Kprod :, 17;<, wjlb jl rlclovli k tlxt nlsskml hren jos wohl Kbmldock

Jkdl, wje wks tjl Kssostkbt te tjl Ilkb her Nkr`ltobm.

1;. Yjl tlxt nlsskml obiocktli tjkt tjl ehhocl eh k stuilbt wje wer`li wotj Kbmldock

jki allb lbtlrli kbi clrtkob tjobms jki allb tknplrli wotj, kbi tjkt tjl weri —BOMMKV„ jki

allb scrkwdli eb tjl betlpki eb tjl stuilbt‟s ils` . K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh tjlsl tlxt

nlsskmls os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot K te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli

ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob. Yjl ieer te tjl stuilbt‟s provktl ehhocl, decktli ob k rlnetl krlk eh tjl

doarkry scjeed eb tjl heurtj hdeer bet bernkddy vosotli ay strkbmlrs, wks heubi ubdec`li.

11. Wdkobtohh kbi jos wohl wlrl tjl sedl adkc` lnpdeylls eh SDON.

13. Wdkobtohh os ebl eh ebdy twe tlburl-trkc` adkc` hkcudty kt LS\.

19. LS\ jks be tlburli adkc` prehlssers.

1<. Yjl Ilkb eh SDON, Mwlb Kdlxkbilr, wks obhernli eh tjl obcoilbt eb Kprod :, 17;<

ay tjl Wdkobtohh kbi jos wohl, Kbmldock Jkdl. Yjl Ilkb prenosli te dee` obte tjl sotuktoeb.

18. Yjl stuilbt wks cebtkctli ay Kbmldock eb k rlmudkr aksos heddewobm tjl obcoilbt her k

stktus, aut tjl stuilbt obiocktli tjkt tjl Ilkb ioi bet kpprekcj jlr kaeut tjl obcoilbt her nerl

tjkb twe nebtjs, kbi ebdy tjlb khtlr tjl Wdkobtohh kbi jos wohl jki kpprekcjli tjl Wrevest kbi

tjl LS\ Wedocl.

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml < eh ??



8

1=. Khtlr nerl tjkb twe nebtjs, wotj be kctoeb ay tjl Ilkb, Wdkobtohh kbi jos wohl

cebtkctli tjl Wrevest, Ikvoi Ceridl kbi tjl jlki eh Junkb Qlseurcls, Fuiy Kbilrseb eb Fubl

;< te slt up k tonl te ioscuss tjl sotuktoeb. K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh tjos lnkod os kttkcjli ks

Lxjoaot A te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob. Kt

k nlltobm eb, er kaeut Fubl 37, 17;<, Ir. Ceridl obiocktli tjkt jl jki tkd`li arolhdy wotj Ilkb

Kdlxkbilr, kbi tjkt sjl jki tedi jon tjkt sjl jki tkd`li wotj tjl mrkiuktl stuilbt tjl iky eh tjl

obcoilbt, kbi tjkt tjl stuilbt sllnli te al fust hobl. Yjos cdkon os ubtrul.

1:. Ob Fubl 17;<, Kbmldock cebtkctli ]lbiy Ckrdseb, k bktoebkddy kccdkonli herlbsoc

jkbiwrotobm lxknoblr, kbi pkoi jlr te lxknobl k jomj rlsedutoeb pjetemrkpj eh tjl lpotjlt, kbi

tjl jkbiwrotobm eh tjl Ilkb‟s Kssostkbt, Ilark Qottmlrs. Eb er kaeut Fubl ?, 17;<, Kbmldock

rlclovli k ckdd hren Ckrdseb rlqulstobm nerl sknpdls eh Ilark Qottmlrs jkbiwrotobm, wjocj wlrl

prevoili. Eb er kaeut Fubl ;?, 17;<, Kbmldock rlclovli k ckdd tjkt wlbt te veoclnkod hren

Ckrdseb stktobm tjkt sjl jki rlclovli tjl kiiotoebkd jkbiwrotobm sknpdls, aut tjkt ob jlr lxplrt

epoboeb, Ilark Qottmlrs, tjl Ilkb‟s Kssostkbt, wks stodd tjl nest preakadl kutjer eh tjl rkcokd sdur

heubi ob tjl stuilbt‟s betlaee` , kbi rktli ot kt k cebhoilbcl dlvld eh lomjt eb k bobl-peobt sckdl.

K trul kbi kccurktl trkbscropt eh tjos veoclnkod os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot C te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi

Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob. Ckrdseb wodd blli kiiotoebkd

sknpdls eh jkbiwrotobm te krrovl kt k cebcdusovl iltlrnobktoeb.

1?. Eb, er kaeut, Fudy ;, 17;<, Wdkobtohh kbi jos wohl wlbt te tjl Lnperok Stktl

\bovlrsoty Wedocl Ilpkrtnlbt, kbi hodli k cenpdkobt kaeut tjl obcoilbt wotj Ehhoclr Flrrei

Scjunkbb, kbi prevoili jon wotj tjl obhernktoeb movlb ay Ckrdseb, kbi ks`li tjl Lnperok

Stktl \bovlrsoty Wedocl Ilpkrtnlbt te cebtkct jlr.




=

37. Lkrdy tjl heddewobm nerbobm Ehhoclr Scjunkbb ckddli Wdkobtohh kbi rldkyli tjl

nlsskml tjkt ob tjl epoboeb eh Wedocl Cjolh Cjros Jeevlr, be cronl jki eccurrli, be hernkd

rlpert weudi al tk`lb, kbi tjkt be pjysockd obvlstomktoeb eh tjl sclbl weudi al cebiuctli.

3;. Lkrdy ob Fudy, LS\ Obtlron Wrlsoilbt Fkcòl Xoltto obstructli JQ splcokdost Qky

Dkualr te prevoil jlr wotj k provktl rlpert eb tjl jktl spllcj obcoilbt.

31. Ob tjl Kssecoktli Wrlss stery tjkt are`l eb Fudy 1?, 17;<, tjl provktl rlpert tjkt Qky

Dkualr wks weròbm eb her Ir. Xoltto suiilbdy wks ckddli kb —obvlstomktoeb„ wotj rlsudts tjkt

weudi al nkil kvkodkadl te tjl puadoc, cknpus kbi te tjl nliok. Yjos os tjl lxkct eppesotl eh

wjkt Dkualr ckddli jos rlpert wjlb Wdkobtohh kbi etjlrs nlt wotj jon.

33. Eb Slptlnalr ?, Fkcòl Xoltto kbi LS\ Mlblrkd Ceubsld @lvob Fejbseb rldlksli tjl

rlsudts eh Qky Dkualr‟s —obvlstomktoeb„ wotj k stktlnlbt tjkt skoi ob pkrt tjkt —be jktl cronl jki

eccurrli.„ K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh tjos lnkod os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot I te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi

Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob. Yjl heddewobm iky Ir. Xoltto

prevoili k heddew up stktlnlbt tjkt rlki ob pkrt —]jodl tjl \bovlrsoty cebcduili be jktl cronl

eccurrli, O wkbt te nk`l ot cdlkr tjkt Lnperok Stktl os bet joiobm aljobi tjl dlmkd ilhobotoeb eh k

jktl cronl.„ K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh tjos lnkod os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot L te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi

Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob.

39. Ob tjl sknl iecunlbt rlhlrlbcli ob tjl prlcliobm pkrkmrkpj (Lxjoaot L), Ir. Xoltto

tee` ossul wotj Ckrdseb‟s lxplrt epoboeb. Ir. Xoltto wretl6 —]jodl ot jks allb puadocdy stktli

tjkt sjl PIlark Qottmlrs^ os tjl nest do`ldy susplct kcceriobm te k bktoebkddy `bewb herlbsoc

jkbiwrotobm lxplrt, be lvoilbcl jks allb preiucli te suppert tjkt stktlnlbt.„ Hurtjlr, ot os

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml = eh ??



:

preadlnktoc, oh bet onpessoadl, kt tjos peobt te cebiuct k hernkd jkbiwrotobm tlst movlb tjkt tjl

weri bew lxosts ebdy ks k pocturl eb k cldd pjebl.„ Aetj stktlnlbts Xoltto nkil krl hkdsl.

3<. Ob k nevl nlkbt te quldd kdd iosslbt, Ir. Xoltto cebcduili jlr stktlnlbt wotj tjl

heddewobm6 —Yjlrlherl, Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty os tk`obm tjos eppertuboty te hernkddy kbi

puadocdy lxeblrktl Ilaaol Qottmlrs eh kby wrebm-ieobm ob tjos nkttlr. O sedocot yeur suppert te

ie tjl sknl (Lxjoaot L).„

38. Lkrdolr, eb er kaeut Fudy =, Ilkb Kdlxkbilr kdse iospkrkmli tjl crlilbtokds eh

Ckrdseb. Kdlxkbilr stktli6 —O cjlc`li eb tjkt jkbiwrotobm lxplrt. Sjl os tjl horst ebl tjkt peps

up, kbi O ieb‟t kc`bewdliml PCkrdseb^ ks k jkbiwrotobm lxplrt. Oh yeu slbt jlr k iohhlrlbt tjobm

te kbkdyzl, sjl weudi kdwkys sky tjl sknl tjobm. K trul kbi kccurktl trkbscropt eh tjos

ioscussoeb os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot H te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli

ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob.

3=. Eb Slptlnalr ;<, 17;<, Wdkobtohh kbi jos wohl cebiuctli k pretlst nkrcj kt LS\ ob

wjocj evlr ;1< plepdl pkrtocopktli. Yjl ossuls wlrl tjl jkbidobm kbi eutcenl eh tjl

—obvlstomktoeb,„ kbi tjl trlktnlbt eh tjl Jkdl‟s ay tjl \bovlrsoty. K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh k

Auddltob stery cevlrobm tjl nkrcj os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot M te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili

Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob. Yjl wlasotl os www.nkrcjeblnperok.cen.

3:. Eb Slptlnalr ;8, 17;<, Ir. Xoltto slbt Wdkobtohh k dlttlr eutdobobm cebiotoebs her

cebtobuli lnpdeynlbt kt LS\. Ebl cebiotoeb wks tjkt —Wdkobtohh ossul k rltrkctoeb eh yeur

kccusktoeb eh Ilaaol Qottmlrs ks tjl kutjer eh tjl rkcokd sdur ubdlss yeu prevoil tjl \bovlrsoty

wotj crlioadl, suastkbtovl lvoilbcl tjkt Ns. Qottmlrs os tjl plrpltrkter.„ K trul kbi kccurktl

cepy eh tjos lnkod os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot J te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml : eh ??



?

obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob. Xoltto cebcduili ay stktobm6 —Wdlksl ubilrstkbi tjkt tjlsl

lxplctktoebs cebstotutl tjl cebiotoebs eh yeur lnpdeynlbt, kbi krl bebblmetokadl. Hkodurl te

nllt tjln wodd rlsudt ob ioscopdobkry kctoeb up te kbi obcduiobm tlrnobktoeb.„

CE\BY O

HKDSL DOMJY OBXKSOEB EH WQOXKC_

3?. Wdkobtohh jlrlay kiepts, rl-kddlmls, kbi obcerperktls ay rlhlrlbcl tjl kddlmktoebs

cebtkobli ob pkrkmrkpjs ; tjreumj 3: kaevl.

97. Wdkobtohh os k scolbtost, kbi ks sucj, movls suastkbtokd crlilbcl te scolbtohoc nltjeis

sucj ks herlbsoc jkbiwrotobm lxknobktoeb.

9;. Ay ilnkbiobm tjkt Wdkobtohh rltrkct jos epoboeb eb wje kutjerli tjl rkcokd sdur, aksli

eb herlbsoc scolbcl, LS\ seumjt te ilprovl kbi pubosj Wdkobtohh eh kbi her hrllien eh spllcj,

kbi ilnebstrktli nkdocl tewkris Wdkobtohh, kbi ay se ieobm, lbceurkmli etjlrs te ie tjl sknl.

91. LS\ kddlmls tjkt Ilark Qottmlrs ehhlrli te tk`l k pedymrkpj kbi k jkbiwrotobm tlst te

prevl jlr obbeclbcl, aut LS\ obsostli tjkt sjl bet. Xoltto tjlb lxeblrktli Qottmlrs kbi tedi tjl

werdi bet te cebsoilr jlr k susplct kt kdd, kbi kssurli tjl puadoc tjkt sjl jki betjobm te ie wotj

wjkt jkpplbli.

93. LS\ `bews tjkt oh Ilark Qottmlrs os cebcdusovldy sjewb te al tjl kutjer eh tjl sdur

cebcdusovldy, tjl rlsudts eh tjlor —obvlstomktoeb,„ wjocj ildoalrktldy omberli herlbsoc lvoilbcl,

weudi al obvkdoiktli, kbi tjl rlputktoeb eh tjl obstotutoeb weudi al akidy seodli.

99. Ay cdkonobm tjkt be jktl cronl eccurrli kbi tjkt tjlrl wlrl be vkdoi obstkbcls eh

rkcokd ioscronobktoeb ob SDON iurobm tjl 17;9-17;< scjeed ylkr, LS\ pertrkyli Wdkobtohh ks k

dokr kbi k hrkui. Yjl stuilbt blwspkplr, tjl Auddltob, wretl k scktjobm lioterokd cenpkrobm

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ? eh ??



;7

Wdkobtohh kbi jos wohl te tjl Aey ]je Croli ]edh. Bunlreus sonodkr cennlbts wlrl nkil ay

rlkilrs eh tjl Auddltob kbi etjlr ebdobl blws vlbuls wjlrl tjl stery wks pestli. K trul kbi

kccurktl cepy eh tjos stery os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot O te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi

os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob. Yjl mlblrkd stery kaeut tjlor lxplrolbcls wks ckrroli ay tjl

Kssecoktli Wrlss ks k Aom Stery, aetj alherl kbi khtlr tjl se-ckddli rlsudts, kbi ot wks volwli

obtlrbktoebkddy. K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh tjos lnkod os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot F te Wdkobtohh s

Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob.

9<. Ilhlbikbts seumjt te aedstlr tjl vkdoioty eh tjlor —obvlstomktoeb„ ay cdkonobm tjkt ot

wks rlvolwli ay twe obilplbilbt lbtotols, blotjlr eh wjocj jks allb nkil kvkodkadl her obquory.

Ilhlbikbts kdse hkdsldy cdkonli tjkt rlvolwlrs ioi kb obilplbilbt obvlstomktoeb.

98. Wdkobtohh jks suhhlrli slvlrl lnakrrkssnlbt, mrlkt lnetoebkd pkob, kbmuosj, kbi mrolh

eh nobi ks k rlsudt eh Ilhlbikbts‟ kctoebs, wjocj wlrl woddhud kbi rlc`dlss.

9=. Ilhlbikbts jkvl prlslbtli Wdkobtohh wotj cebiotoebs her cebtobuli lnpdeynlbt tjkt

onpdy tjkt Wdkobtohh jks hkodli te plrhern jos iutols, ylt Ilhlbikbts jkvl hkodli te heddew

Ilhlbikbts ewb preclssls her kifuiocktobm fea plrhernkbcl ossuls, kbi kt be tonl jkvl prevoili

Wdkobtohh k herun ob wjocj te ioscuss jos plrhernkbcl..

9:. Wdkobtohh wks movlb k dlttlr eh tlrnobktoeb ay LS\ Wrevest Ceridl eb Ilclnalr ;9,

17;<.

9?. Ks k iorlct rlsudt eh tjlsl kctoebs ay Ilhlbikbts, Wdkobtohh jks suhhlrli rlkd kbi

kctukd iknkmls te al iltlrnobli kt trokd.

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ;7 eh ??



;;

CE\BY OO

ILHKNKYOEB

<7. Wdkobtohh jlrlay kiepts, rl-kddlmls, kbi obcerperktls ay rlhlrlbcl tjl kddlmktoebs

cebtkobli ob pkrkmrkpjs ; tjreumj 9? kaevl.

<;. Yjl kuiolbcl her Ilhlbikbt‟s cennlbts kbi cebiuct wks obtlrbktoebkd. Liuckters,

rlslkrcjlrs kbi prkctotoeblrs ob tjl holdis eh doarkry, liucktoeb kbi krcjovls wje `blw Wdkobtohh

ehhlrli dlttlrs eh suppert her Wdkobtohh te tjl \bovlrsoty kbi te tjl Knlrockb Doarkry Kssecoktoeb.

K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh ebl sucj dlttlr os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot @ te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi

Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob. K dlttlr wks slbt te tjl

kinobostrktoeb hren Adkc` hkcudty kbi stkhh kt LS\. K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh tjos dlttlr os

kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot D te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl

jlrlob.

<1. Wdkobtohh rllbtlrli tjl fea nkr`lt ob 17;9 kt soxty ylkrs edi khtlr cenpdltobm k

Nkstlrs ob Doarkry & Obhernktoeb Scolbcl kbi k WjI ob Obhernktoeb Stuiols kt \CDK. Wdkobtohh

wks tjl horst ob jos cejert eh slvlb te ilhlbi jos iosslrtktoeb kbi te cenpdltl jos iecterkd ilmrll.

<3. Ilhlbikbts `blw tjkt tjly wlrl ckusobm jkrn te Wdkobtohh‟s rlputktoeb, aut tjly kctli

wotj tetkd iosrlmkri ay purvlyobm hkdsl kbi obcenpdltl sterols, kbi ay sjoldiobm Ilark Qottmlrs.

<9. Ilhlbikbts rldlksli k hkdsl stktlnlbt rlmkriobm jktl cronls tjkt cdlkrdy sjews

prlvkrocktoeb. Jktl cronls obcduil k splctrun eh ehhlbsls, mlblrkddy stkrtobm wotj vkbikdosn,

mrkhhoto kbi jktl spllcj. K trul kbi kccurktl cepy eh tjos stktlnlbt os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot N te

Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob.

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ;; eh ??



;1

<<. Ilhlbikbts omberli alst prkctocls ob kiirlssobm jktl cronls. Yjl Kctoeb Nkttlrs

premrkn kt tjl \bovlrsoty eh ]oscebsob os kb lxknpdl eh alst prkctocls. K trul kbi kccurktl

cepy eh tjos premrkn os kttkcjli ks Lxjoaot B te Wdkobtohh s Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt kbi os

obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob.

<8. Ks k iorlct rlsudt eh jos kctovotols te eatkob fustocl, Wdkobtohh jks dest bunlreus

suppertlrs, kbi LS\ jks osedktli tjl Wdkobtohh hren jos ceddlkmuls ay hercobm jon te wer` hren

jenl, ilbyobm jon hkcl-te-hkcl ceursls wotj stuilbts. Kdd eh Wdkobtohhs‟ cdkssls krl bew

ldonobktli.

<=. Ay Ilhlbikbts kctoebs, Wdkobtohh wks movlb ubrlksebkadl kbi jomjdy eaflctoebkadl

puadocoty tjkt kttroautli te jon cjkrkctlrostocs, cebiuct er aldolhs tjkt krl hkdsl, kbi ob se ieobm

jkrnli tjl meei rlputktoeb tjkt tjl Wdkobtohh wer`li jkri te kttkob.

<:. Yjl kddlmktoebs nkil kmkobst Wdkobtohh ay Ilhlbikbts wlrl jomjdy ehhlbsovl kbi

weudi al cebsoilrli jomjdy ehhlbsovl ay kby rlksebkadl plrseb.

<?. Wdkobtohh lkrbli jos iecterktl kt hren \CDK kt k cest ob lxclss eh $1<7,777. Ob

puadosjobm hkdsl stktlnlbts kaeut Wdkobtohh, Ilhlbikbts kctli wotj rlc`dlss iosrlmkri, crlktobm k

sltakc` kbi hobkbcokd jkrisjop her Wdkobtohh, donotobm huturl lkrbobms kbi upwkri neaodoty.

87. Ob k dlttlr kbi k plrsebkd nlltobm eb Ectealr ;1, 17;< Wdkobtohh wks tedi ay LS\

Wrevest Ikvoi Ceridl te rlsomb er al tlrnobktli. Wdkobtohh pedotldy rlhusli.

8;. Wdkobtohh wks movlb k dlttlr eh tlrnobktoeb ay LS\ Wrevest Ceridl eb Ilclnalr ;9,

17;<.




;3

81. Ks k iorlct rlsudt eh tjlsl kctoebs, Wdkobtohh jks suhhlrli rlkd kbi kctukd iknkmls te al

iltlrnobli kt trokd.

OOO. CE\BY YJQLL

DOALQY_ OBYLQLSY

83. Wdkobtohh jlrlay kiepts, rl-kddlmls, kbi obcerperktls ay rlhlrlbcl tjl kddlmktoebs

cebtkobli ob pkrkmrkpjs ; tjreumj 81 kaevl.

89. Yjl Iul Wreclss prevosoebs eh tjl Heurtllbtj Knlbinlbt rlquorl tjkt rlvolw eh

dkws onpkctobm romjts illnli hubiknlbtkd krl kbkdyzli usobm tjl stroct scrutoby stkbikri eh

rlvolw. ]ksjobmteb v. Mduc`salrm , <1; \.S. =71, =;? (;??=)0 Ldrei v. Aurbs, 91= \.S. 39=, ?8

S.Ct. 18=3 (;?=8).

8<. Yjl Iul Wreclss prevosoebs eh tjl ;9tj Knlbinlbt rlcembozl k doalrty obtlrlst ob

ebl‟s rlputktoeb kbi meei bknl. Wdkobtohh jks ilnebstrktli jew Ilhlbikbt‟s cebiuct6 ;)

onpumbli jos meei bknl, rlputktoeb, jeber kbi obtlmroty, 1) tjl stktlnlbts nkil wlrl hkdsl, 3)

tjl stktlnlbts eccurrli ob tjl ceursl eh tlrnobktobm Wdkobtohh kbi herlcdesli etjlr lnpdeynlbt

eppertubotols, kbi 9) tjlsl ilhknktery stktlnlbts wlrl puadosjli. Wdkobtohh jks nlt ots aurilb

te prevl Heurtllbtj Knlbinlbt doalrty obtlrlsts. Sll Ikrr v. Yewb eh Yldduroil, 9?< H.3i ;193,

;1<< (;7tj Cor. 177=), ]oscebsob v. Cebstkbtoblku, 977 \.S. 933 (;?=;), Aekri eh Qlmlbts v.

Qetj, 97: \.S. <89 (;?=1).

88. Ebl blli ebdy cebsoilr Fustocl Stlwkrt‟s dkbmukml ob cebcurrlbcl ob Qeslbadktt te

sll tjl fuiocokddy cebclptukdozli mreubiobm eh rlputktoeb ob plrsebkd iomboty6 —Yjl romjt eh k nkb

te tjl pretlctoeb eh jos ewb rlputktoeb hren ubfustoholi obvksoeb kbi wrebmhud jurt rlhdlcts be

nerl tjkb eur aksoc cebclpt eh tjl lsslbtokd iomboty kbi wertj eh lvlry junkb alobm - k cebclpt




;9

kt tjl reet eh kby ilclbt systln eh erilrli doalrty„ Qeslbadktt v. Aklr , 3:3 \.S. =<, ?1 (;?88)

(Stlwkrt, F., cebcurrobm).

8=. Ob Nebrel v. Wkpl, tjl neilrb wktlrsjli § ;?:3 cksl, tjl Ceurt jki nkil cdlkr tjkt

tjl lxostlbcl eh k stktl ckusl eh kctoeb wks be akr te rkosobm k § ;?:3 suot ob hlilrkd ceurt6 —Ot os

be kbswlr tjkt tjl Stktl jks k dkw wjocj oh lbhercli weudi movl rldolh. Yjl hlilrkd rlnliy os

suppdlnlbtkry te tjl stktl rlnliy, kbi tjl dkttlr blli bet al horst seumjt kbi rlhusli alherl tjl

hlilrkd ebl os obve`li.„ 38< \.S. ;8=, ;:3 (;?8;).

8:. Ilhlbikbts kctoebs wlrl obtlbtoebkd kbi rlc`dlss kbi mreubili ob nkdocl, kdtjeumj

nkdocl os bet k blclsskry cenpeblbt eh ilhknktoeb wjlb tjl Wdkobtohh os bet k puadoc homurl.

Ilhlbikbts huddy obtlbili te lbmlbilr puadoc rlkctoeb kmkobst Wdkobtohh ay cjkrkctlrozobm Wdkobtohh

ks prehlssoebkddy ubhot, k hkdsl prepjlt, k tlddlr eh tkdls kbi k seeb-te-al hernlr lnpdeyll.

8?. Yjl jkrn tjkt os ckusli wjlb stktl kcters, wotjeut iul preclss eh dkw, dkald kbi

stomnktozl obiovoiukds ks wrebmielrs tjus rubs nerl illpdy tjkb sonpdy blmktovldy onpkctobm

ebl‟s secokd stkbiobm. \bcjkddlbmli stomnktoc obfury kdse hrustrktls obiovoiukd sldh-obvlbtoeb, kbi

ob tjkt slbsl ilprovls tjl obiovoiukd eh doalrty wotjeut iul preclss eh dkw.

=7. Alherl puadocdy pestobm ilhknktery obhernktoeb kaeut Wdkobtohh, Ilhlbikbts wlrl

rlquorli te movl Wdkobtohh betocl eh tjl obtlbt te pest sucj obhernktoeb, kbi te prevoil Wdkobtohh k

jlkrobm her tjl eppertuboty te prlslbt Wdkobtohh‟s soil eh tjl nkttlr, sll Cebstkbtoblku v. Mrkmlr ,

371 H. Supp. :8;, :89 (L.I. ]os. ;?8?). Yjl Suprlnl Ceurt khhornli tjos rudobm ob lxpdocot

tlrns6 —]jlrl k plrseb‟s meei bknl, rlputktoeb, jeber, er obtlmroty os kt stk`l alckusl eh wjkt

tjl mevlrbnlbt os ieobm te jon, betocl kbi kb eppertuboty te al jlkri krl lsslbtokd




;<

(Cebstkbtoblku, 977 \.S. kt 93=). Ob tjos cksl, Ilhlbikbts wlrl obtlbt eb sodlbcobm Wdkobtohh‟s

eaflctoebs te tjlor bkrrktovl, kbi lvlb wlbt se hkr ks te puadocdy lxeblrktl tjl ebdy susplct.

=;. Ks k iorlct rlsudt eh tjlsl kctoebs, Wdkobtohh jks suhhlrli rlkd kbi kctukd iknkmls te

al iltlrnobli kt trokd.

OX. CE\BY HE\Q

I\L WQECLSS

=1. Wdkobtohh jlrlay kiepts, rl-kddlmls, kbi obcerperktls ay rlhlrlbcl tjl kddlmktoebs

cebtkobli ob pkrkmrkpjs ; tjreumj =; kaevl.

=3. Wrecliurkd iul preclss nky al onpdocktli wjlblvlr tjl mevlrbnlbt tjrlktlbs te

tk`l k dohl, doalrty er preplrty obtlrlst hren kb obiovoiukd. Oh k puadoc lnpdeyll jks k cebtrkct kbi

os tlrnobktli ob tjl noiidl eh tjkt cebtrkct plroei wotjeut kby `obi eh k jlkrobm, tjlb tjkt nky

cebstotutl k preplrty obtlrlst trommlrobm precliurkd iul preclss pretlctoebs.

=9. Kdtjeumj iul preclss tedlrktls vkrokbcls ob precliurl "kppreproktl te tjl bkturl eh

tjl cksl,„ Nuddkbl v. Clbtrkd Jkbevlr Yrust Ce., 33? \.S. 378, 3;3 (;?<7), ot os bebltjldlss

pessoadl te oilbtohy ots cerl mekds kbi rlquorlnlbts.

=<. Horst, "Pp^recliurkd iul preclss rudls krl nlkbt te pretlct plrsebs bet hren tjl

ilprovktoeb, aut hren tjl nostk`lb er ubfustoholi ilprovktoeb eh dohl, doalrty, er preplrty" Ckrly

v. Wopjus, 93< \.S. 19=, 1<? (;?=:). Yjus, tjl rlquorli ldlnlbts eh iul preclss krl tjesl tjkt

"nobonozl suastkbtovldy ubhkor er nostk`lb ilprovktoebs" ay lbkadobm plrsebs te cebtlst tjl aksos

upeb wjocj k Stktl prepesls te ilprovl tjln eh pretlctli obtlrlsts. Hulbtls v. Sjlvob, 97= \.S.

8=, :; (;?=1).

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ;< eh ??



;8

=8. Ilhlbikbts tjrlktlbli te tlrnobktl Wdkobtohh oh jl ioi bet rltrkct aldolhs aksli eb

herlbsoc scolbcl, wjodl crlktobm kbi iosplrsobm hkdsl kbi nosdlkiobm bkrrktovls rlmkriobm Wdkobtohh

kbi nyroki ksplcts eh tjl eromobkd obcoilbt.

==. Ilhlbikbts rlhusli te kc`bewdliml tjl lrrer eh tjlor bkrrktovls er te heddew Yotdl XOO

precliurls her rlpertobm kbi obvlstomktobm rlperts eh rkcokd aoks.

=:. Ilhlbikbt Fkc`ol Xoltto rlhusli kdd rlqulsts ay Wdkobtohh te nllt wotj jon plrsebkddy

te ioscuss tjl jktl cronl er tjl —obvlstomktoeb,„ aut Xoltto nlt wotj Qottmlrs nerl tjkb ebcl.

=?. Ob Wkud v. Ikvos, tjl \.S. Suprlnl Ceurt rudli tjkt rlputktoebkd jkrn kdebl wks

obsuhhocolbt te trommlr k cebstotutoebkd romjt te precliurkd iul preclss, sll Wkud v. Ikvos, 919 \.S.

8?3, =;1 (;?=8). Ebdy oh senl nerl tkbmoadl dess (l.m., cebcurrlbt dess eh mevlrbnlbt

lnpdeynlbt) kccenpkbols stktl-ckusli stomnktoc jkrn iels k cebstotutoebkd romjt te precliurkd

iul preclss krosl (Oi. kt =7;). Yjlsl corcunstkbcls krl huddy nlt ay tjl woddhud kbi rlc`dlss

cebiuct eh tjl Ilhlbikbts.

:7. Ilhlbikbts‟ stomnktozobm rlnkr`s wlrl nkil ob tjl ceursl eh Wdkobtohh‟s tlrnobktoeb

kbi tjus nllt tjl —stomnk- pdus„ stkbikri.

:;. Yjkt Wdkobtohh jks, kbi os, suhhlrobm rlputktoebkd jkrn os ubilbokadl, ks lvoilbcli ob

Lxjoaots E, W, [, Q, S, kbi Y, wjocj krl obcerperktli ay rlhlrlbcl jlrlob.

:1. Wdkobtohh wks tjrlktlbli wotj tlrnobktoeb ob k dlttlr hren Wrevest Ceridl iktli

Ectealr ;1, 17;<, ks lvoilbcli ob Lxjoaot \, wjocj os obcerperktli jlrlob ay rlhlrlbcl.

:3. Wdkobtohh wks betoholi eh jos tlrnobktoeb ob k dlttlr hren Wrevest Ceridl iktli

Ilclnalr ;9, 17;<, ks lvoilbcli ob Lxjoaot X, wjocj os obcerperktli jlrlob ay rlhlrlbcl.




;=

:9. Ks k iorlct rlsudt eh tjlsl kctoebs, Wdkobtohh jks suhhlrli rlkd kbi kctukd iknkmls te al


X. CE\BY HOXL

HQLLIEN EH SWLLCJ

:<. Wdkobtohh jlrlay kiepts, rl-kddlmls, kbi obcerperktls ay rlhlrlbcl tjl kddlmktoebs

cebtkobli ob pkrkmrkpjs ; tjreumj :9 kaevl.

:8. Ilhlbikbts voedktli Wdkobtohh‟s Horst Knlbinlbt mukrkbtlls eh hrllien eh spllcj ay

tlrnobktobm Wdkobtohh her nkrcjobm kbi splk`obm eut kmkobst rkcokd ioscronobktoeb kbi k jktl

spllcj obcoilbt tjkt wlbt ubkiirlssli.

:=. Wdkobtohh wks rltkdoktli kmkobst, suaflctli te k jestodl wer`obm lbvorebnlbt,

tjrlktlbli wotj tlrnobktoeb, kbi hobkddy wks tlrnobktli her lxlrcosobm hrllien eh spllcj.

::. Ks k iorlct rlsudt eh tjlsl kctoebs, Wdkobtohh jks suhhlrli rlkd kbi kctukd iknkmls te al


XO. CE\BY SOZ

QLYKDOKYOEB & ]QEBMH\D YLQNOBKYOEB

:?. Wdkobtohh jlrlay kiepts, rl-kddlmls, kbi obcerperktls ay rlhlrlbcl tjl kddlmktoebs

cebtkobli ob pkrkmrkpjs ; tjreumj :: kaevl.

?7. Kcceriobm te Yotdl XOO kb lnpdeylr nky bet horl, ilnetl, jkrkss er etjlrwosl

"rltkdoktl" kmkobst kb obiovoiukd her hodobm k cjkrml eh ioscronobktoeb, pkrtocopktobm ob k

ioscronobktoeb preclliobm, er etjlrwosl eppesobm ioscronobktoeb, ylt Ilhlbikbt LS\ ioi lxkctdy

tjkt, prenptobm Wdkobtohh te hodl k ioscronobktoeb cdkon wotj tjl @kbsks Junkb Qomjts

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ;= eh ??



;:

Cennossoeb (@JQC). Wdkobtohh jks rlqulstli k Qomjt-te-Sul Dlttlr hren tjl LLEC ks

lvoilbcli ob Lxjoaot ], wjocj os obcerperktli jlrlob ay rlhlrlbcl.

?;. Ob k rlclbt ilcosoeb, tjl Suprlnl Ceurt lxprlssdy rlflctli tjl LLEC's volw tjkt k

Yotdl XOO rltkdoktoeb pdkobtohh blli ilnebstrktl ebdy tjkt rltkdoktoeb wks ebl eh slvlrkd netovktobm

hkcters ob tjl lnpdeylr's ilcosoeb, obstlki ilcoiobm tjkt sucj k pdkobtohh nust prevl tjkt tjl

lnpdeylr's rltkdoktery netovl wks tjl "aut her" ckusl eh tjl kivlrsl lnpdeynlbt kctoeb. \BOX.

EH YLZ. SE\YJ]LSYLQB NLI. v. Bksskr , ;33 S. Ct. 1<;=, <=7 \.S., ;:8 D. Li. 1i <73

(17;3).

?1. Wdkobtohh ob tjl obstkbt dotomktoeb cdkons tjkt aut her jos ilnkbis tjkt Ilhlbikbts

kiirlss rkcokd ioscronobktoeb kbi k jktl spllcj obcoilbt kt LS\ tjkt jl weudi bet jkvl allb

suaflct te rltkdoktoeb er tlrnobktoeb.

?3. Ks k iorlct rlsudt eh tjlsl kctoebs, Wdkobtohh jks suhhlrli rlkd kbi kctukd iknkmls te al


XOO. W\BOYOXL IKNKMLS

?9. Wkrkmrkpjs ;-?3 krl obcerperktli jlrlob ay rlhlrlbcl.

?<. Yjl kcts kbi cebiuct eh Ilhlbikbts wks woddhud, wkbteb, rlc`dlss, kbi nkdocoeus, kbi

hurtjlr, sjews k cenpdltl kbi ildoalrktl obiohhlrlbcl te, kbi cebscoeus iosrlmkri her, tjl romjts

eh Wdkobtohh. Yjlrlherl, Wdkobtohh os lbtotdli te kb kwkri eh pubotovl er lxlnpdkry iknkmls ob kb

kneubt suhhocolbt te pubosj Ilhlbikbts er te iltlr Ilhlbikbts kbi etjlrs hren do`l cebiuct ob

tjl huturl.

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ;: eh ??



;?

]JLQLHEQL, aksli eb tjl herlmeobm, Wdkobtohh prkys tjkt tjos Ceurt mrkbt tjl rldolh

seumjt obcduiobm, aut bet donotli te, kctukd iknkmls te al iltlrnobli kt trokd, kbi kdd etjlr rldolh

illnli kppreproktl ay tjos Ceurt.

Qlsplcthuddy suanottli,

UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUNldvob Jkdl, WjI, Wdkobtohh

Kpplkrobm Wre Sl

W.E. Aex =19Lnperok, @S 88:7;

rllhrlsjGykjee.cen

?;8-8?7-=?1=

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ;? eh ??

mailto:[email protected]





CLQYOHOCKYL EH SLQXOCL

Cksl Be. ;<-9?9=-SKC-@MS

O jlrlay clrtohy tjkt O jkvl slrvli tjos Slcebi Knlbili Cenpdkobt eb Ilhlbikbts eb Fkbukry

17, 17;8. O plrsebkddy nkodli k cepy eh tjl iecunlbt ob tjl kaevl kctoeb ay horst cdkss nkod,

pestkml prlpkoi, kiirlssli te6

Kbbl Mlpheri Snotj

Kssostkbt Ktterbly Mlblrkd eh @kbsks

Nlnerokd Adim., 1bi Hdeer

;17 S] ;7tj Kvlbul

Yepl`k, @S 888;1-;<?=

O kn bet k pkrty te tjos nkttlr. O ilcdkrl ubilr tjl plbkdty eh plrfury tjkt tjl herlmeobm os trulkbi cerrlct.

/s/ Kbmldock M. Jkdl

8;< ]. ;<tj Kvl.

Lnperok, @S 88:7;




Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml 1; eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml 1< eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml 1= eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml 1: eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml 1? eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml <7 eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml <; eh ??



\peb yeur rlturb hren yeur ceedobm ehh plroei, tjl heddewobm eb-meobm cebiotoebs nust al nlt her yeur

cebtobuli lnpdeynlbt ks kb Kssostkbt Wrehlsser ob SDON6

O) Yjkt yeu wodd kc`bewdliml, kcclpt, al kwkrl eh, kbi cjkbml yeur aljkvoers tjkt krl ubkcclptkadl ob

tjl wer`pdkcl. Yjlsl aljkvoers obcduil, aut krl bet donotli te, rkosobm yeur veocl, kccusobm etjlrs

usobm obhdknnktery stktlnlbts, er lbmkmobm etjlrs ob k wky tjkt nky etjlrwosl al plrclovli ks

obtonoiktobm er auddvobz.

1) Yjkt yeu wodd ossul k rltrkctoeb eh yeur kccusktoeb ehIlaaol Qottmlrs ks tjl kutjer

eh

tjl rkcokd sdur

ubdlss yeu prevoil tjl \bovlrsoty wotj crlioadl, suastkbtovl lvoilbcl tjkt Ns. Qottmlrs os tjl

plrpltrkter.

3) Yjkt yeu wodd kmrll te heddew \bovlrsoty mrolvkbcl preclss kbi precliurls ob tjl huturl, sjeudi

sotuktoebs eccur tjkt wkrrkbt sucj kctoeb.

jl nkbiktery rlhlrrkd te tjl Hot Her Iuty Wremrkn tjreumj Jlkdtj[ulst, tjl Lnpdeyll Kssostkbcl

Wremrkn (LKW), os ob kccerikbcl wotj @.S.K. =<-1?9?(o) kbi @kbsks Kinobostrktovl Qlmudktoeb ;-?-;?

wjocj kutjerozl tjl kppeobtobm kutjeroty te rldolvl kb lnpdeyll hren iuty her tjl skhlty kbi pretlctoeb eh

plrsebs er preplrty kbi te pdkcl tjl lnpdeyll eb kinobostrktovl dlkvl wotj pky. _eu krl nkbiktli te

cebtkct CenWsycj, eur LKW prevoilr, be d tlr tj b beeb eb Nebiky, Slptlnalr 1;, 17;<. _eu nky

rlkcj CenWsycj kt tjos tedd-hrll bunalr - (:::) 1=<-;17<, Eptoeb =. Wdlksl rlhlr te yeur Cdolbt Qlceri

3<;;;1= wjlb yeu rlkcj k rlprlslbtktovl. Yjly wodd kssost ob rlhlrrobm yeu te k ceubslder te cenpdltl

tjl stlps eh tjl premrkn. Wdlksl al kivosli tjkt yeu nust somb tjl Kutjerozktoeb Hern6 Hernkd Qlhlrrkd

iecunlbt ay Slptlnalr ;:, 17;< kbi rlturb te JQ wotj k pestnkr` iktl eh Slptlnalr ;?,17;<. _eu

nust nllt tjl kaevl rlhlrrkd cebtkct ilkidobl kbi succlsshuddy cenpdltl kby rlquorlnlbts splcoholi ay

yeur ceubslder te al cenpdokbt wotj tjos lxplctktoeb.

Wdlksl ubilrstkbi tjkt tjlsl lxplctktoebs cebstotutl tjl cebiotoebs

eh

yeur lnpdeynlbt, kbi krl beb

blmetokadl. Hkodurl te nllt tjln wodd rlsudt ob ioscopdobkry kctoeb up te kbi obcduiobm tlrnobktoeb.

Nldvob, ay obvlstobm ob tjl stlps eutdobli kaevl, tjl \bovlrsoty dee`s herwkri te yeur cebtobuli

prehlssoebkd mrewtj ob SDON ks wldd ks kt Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty.

Sobclrldy,

Fkc`ol K. Xoltto

Obtlron Wrlsoilbt




Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml << eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml <= eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml <: eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml <? eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml =7 eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml =; eh ??



LZJOAOY —E„




LZJOAOY —W„




Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml =< eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml == eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml =: eh ??



LZJOAOY —[„

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml =? eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml :7 eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml :; eh ??



LZJOAOY —Q „




LZJOAOY —S„




Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml :< eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml := eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml :: eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml :? eh ??



LZJOAOY —Y„

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ?7 eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ?; eh ??



LZJOAOY —\„




NWEQO SY Y

\B X QS Y_

• hho l

khY WQEXESY

Ectealr ;1, 17;<

Nldvob Jkdl, Wj.I.

Kssostkbt Wrehlsser

Scjeed

eh

Doarkry kbi Obhernktoeb Nkbkmlnlbt

JKBI ILDOXLQLI

Ilkr Ir. Jkdl,

Cknpus ex9

; @lddemm Cor

Lnperok @kbsks

88: ; <9

81 39; <;=

www lnperok l

_eu jkvl movlb be obiocktoeb se hkr tjkt yeu obtlbi te kcclpt tjl ubovlrsoty s cebiotoebs her yeur

cebtobuli lnpdeynlbt ks Kssostkbt Wrehlsser ob tjl Scjeed

eh

Doarkry kbi Obhernktoeb

Nkbkmlnlbt, ks slt hertj ob Ir. Xoltto s dlttlr te yeu iktli Slptlnalr ;8, 17;<.

Oh

tjkt

os

yeur

ilcosoeb eb tjos nkttlr, Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty lxtlbis tjl heddewobm ehhlr ks kb kdtlrbktovl6

Yjl ubovlrsoty os woddobm te cebtobul yeur lnpdeynlbt ks kb Kssostkbt Wrehlsser ob tjl Scjeed

eh

Doarkry kbi Obhernktoeb Nkbkmlnlbt tjreumj tjl lbi

eh

tjl 17;<-17;8 kckilnoc ylkr ubilr tjl

heddewobm cebiotoebs6

• Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty wodd cebtobul te pky yeur skdkry kbi alblhots tjreumj tjl lbi

eh

yeur 17;<-;8 kckilnoc ylkr kppeobtnlbt, aut wodd kssomb yeu

be

obstructoeb er etjlr

hkcudty eadomktoebs iurobm Sprobm Slnlstlr 17O

• _eu wodd rlsomb yeur currlbt hkcudty pesotoeb wotj Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty wotj kb

lhhlctovl iktl

eh

Nky ;=,17;8, wotj wrottlb betocl

eh

yeur rlsombktoeb suanottli

be

dktlr

tjkb Ectealr 37, 17;<0

• _eu wodd cebtobul obstructobm yeur currlbt ceursl deki tjreumj tjl lbi

eh

tjos slnlstlr

(Hkdd 17;<) ks os lxplctli

eh

kby nlnalr

eh

tjl hkcudty0

• _eu wodd cebtobul te kaoil ay tjl tlrns

eh

tjl ceedobm ehh plroei ks tjly kppdy te yeu0

• _eu wodd irep kbi wkovl kby kbi kdd cdkons

eh

kby typl er ilscroptoeb tjkt yeu jkvl er

nky jkvl kmkobst Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty, kby kinobostrkter, hkcudty nlnalr, er stkhh

nlnalr

eh

Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty, er tjl @kbsks Aekri

eh

Qlmlbts0

• _eu wodd tk`l iewb tjl wlasotl 4nkrcjeblnperok.cen2

be

dktlr tjkb O O 6<? p.n.,

Ectealr 1= 1 ;< kbi wodd bet almob er ckusl te almob kby succlsser er rldktli wlasotls

cebtkobobm tjl sknl er suastkbtokddy sonodkr cebtlbt0

;

Kb Eppertuboty

Lnpde




• _eu wodd nk`l be hurtjlr puadoc cennlbts e kby typl er ilscroptoeb

ob

kby hernkt

wjktselvlr cebclrbobm nlbtoebobm er rlhlrrobm te Ilark Qottmlrs

Yjl ilkidobl her kcclptkbcl

e

tjos ehhlr os cdesl

e

ausoblss eb Hroiky Ectealr ;8 17;<

Wdlksl nk`l yeur rlspebsl iorlctdy te nl Hkodurl eb yeur pkrt te rlspebi ay tjl ilkidobl wodd

al cebsoilrli ks yeur rlflctoeb e tjos ehhlr

yeu kcclpt tjos ehhlr k wrottlb kmrllnlbt wodd al prlpkrli slttobm eut tjl kaevl cebiotoebs

Kby voedktoeb e tjos kmrllnlbt nkil alherl tjl lhhlctovl iktl e yeur rlsombktoeb wodd

tlrnobktl tjos kmrllnlbt onnlioktldy kbi lotjlr pkrty wodd al hrll te pursul kby dlmkd rlceursl

er rlnliy ot nky jkvl ks k rlsudt

e

sucj k tlrnobktoeb

Ir Jkdl pdlksl `bew tjkt tjos ehhlr

os

netovktli

ay

kb jeblst ilsorl eb eur pkrt

te

rlkcj kb

kmrllnlbt ]l urml yeu

te

movl ot tjeumjthud cebsoilrktoeb

Sobclrldy

Ikvoi

W

Ceridl

Wrevest kbi Xocl Wrlsoilbt her Kckilnoc Khhkors

C

Fkc`ol Xoltto Obtlron Wrlsoilbt

Fuiy Kbilrseb Lxlcutovl Iorlcter e Junkb Qlseurcls

@lvob Fejbseb Mlblrkd Ceubsld




LZJOAOY —X„

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ?< eh ??



Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ?= eh ??



LZJOAOY —]„

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ?: eh ??



Ir. Nldvob Jkdl

W.E. Aex =19

Lnperok, @S 88:7;

Fel ]odseb

Lqukd Lnpdeynlbt Eppertuboty Cennossoeb

;111 Sprucl St # :.;77

St Deuos, NE 83;73

LLEC Cksl #1:I-17;8-777;=

@kbsks Junkb Qomjts Cennossoeb Cksl #3:198-;8

Fkbukry 17, 17;8

S\AF6 QOMJY-YE-S\L DLYYLQ

Ilkr Fel,

Yjkb` yeu her tjl obhernktoeb yeu prevoili. Ks O nlbtoebli, O kn rlqulstobm k romjt-te-sul dlttlr se

tjkt O ckb kii Lnperok Stktl \bovlrsoty te ny cenpdkobt ob Hlilrkd Ceurt. Aetj ny wohl kbi O hodli

cenpdkobts wotj tjl @JQC rlmkriobm rkcokd ioscronobktoeb kt LS\, kbi ob aetj obstkbcls LS\ rlhusli te

cebsoilr nlioktoeb, kbi tjl tonl her tjkt jks cenl kbi mebl.

Ny cksl ob Hlilrkd Ceurt ob Yepl`k os # ;<-cv9?9=-SKC-@MS.

O ubilrstkbi tjkt tjos jks te al rlvolwli ay tjl Ilpkrtnlbt eh Fustocl alckusl LS\ os k stktl lbtoty, aut

O ie jepl tjkt O ckb rlclovl k romjt-te-sul dlttlr ks seeb ks pessoadl.

Qlmkris,

Cksl <6;<-cv-79?9=-SKC-@MS Iecunlbt ;3 Hodli 7;/1;/;8 Wkml ?? eh ??

Melvin Hale vs Emporia State University Amended Federal Lawsuit 1/21/16

Documents

Transcript of Melvin Hale vs Emporia State University Amended Federal Lawsuit 1/21/16