Materials and Methods: Animals: -Yorkshire pigs (Sus scrofa), castrated males, n=98, body mass range...

1
Materials and Methods: Animals: -Yorkshire pigs (Sus scrofa), castrated males, n=98, body mass range 17-23 kg Groups: 1) Untreated controls (C) 2) Surgical controls (SC) * : injected with 60 mL saline into caecum and large intestine 3) Treated animals (T) * : injected with varying volumes (12- 83 mL) and activities (200- 2200 mol CH 4 /min) of Methanobrevibacter smithii into the caecum and large intestine * Surgery performed under anesthesia, abdomen opened to allow access to caecum and large intestine. Animals studied immediately after recovery. Dive simulation: -Chamber pressurized to 22, 24, or 26 bar (88-94%H 2 , 0.3- 0.5 bar PO 2 ) for 30, 120, 150, 180, or >1100 min. -Decompression rate 0.45, 0.9, or 1.8 bar/min to 11 bar; animals observed for 1 hr for DCS - Euthanized in chamber on confirmation of DCS or at end of hour. Measurements: -Chamber gases analyzed by gas chromatography for H 2 , O 2 , He, N 2 , and CH 4 -CH 4 output rate (mol CH 4 /min) from the chamber was used as an indicator of the CH 4 production rate from pigs. -Severe symptoms of DCS included: walking difficulties, fore and/or hind limb paralysis, falling, convulsions. Results: Fig. 1) Total activity injected was positively correlated (P<0.01) with the CH 4 release rate from all dives. Fig. 2) The DCS incidence increased with increasing time at constant pressure. Fig. 3) The DCS incidence increased with increasing decompression rate. Fig. 4) The DCS incidence did not increase with increasing ambient pressure, contrary to what is commonly found in DCS research. Fig. 5) The DCS incidence decreased with increasing methanogenic activity injected. Abstract: Biochemical decompression, the facilitation of decompression by biochemically eliminating some inert gas stored in divers’ tissues, was demonstrated in pigs during simulated H 2 dives (Fahlman et al., FASEB J. 13:A408, 1999). Data were compiled to create a model of decompression sickness (DCS) risk to determine gas kinetics during decompression. To simulate a H 2 dive, pigs (n=98, 19.61.4 kg) were placed in a dry chamber and compressed to varying pressures (22, 24, or 26 atm) for 2.5 or 3 h. Subjects were decompressed at different rates (0.45, 0.9, or 1.8 atm/min) to 11 atm, and observed for 1 h. The DCS incidence in control animals increased with time at pressure and with increasing decompression rate. Contrary to expectations, there was no correlation between DCS and pressure. Pigs receiving intestinal injections of the H 2 -metabolizing microbe, Methanobrevibacter smithii, had a DCS incidence that was half that of controls on a similar dive. From the complete data set, a probabilistic model will be created that will include parameters on risk assessment, gas kinetics, and H 2 metabolism. This model will allow us to predict the advantage of biochemical decompression for H 2 dives in general. (Support: ONR 603706N 0096 133 1703). Introduction: We have previously reported that H 2 metabolizing microbes in the intestines of pigs significantly reduced the decompression sickness (DCS) incidence during simulated H 2 dives in a pig model. Evidence suggests that pigs have a native gut flora of microbes that metabolize a sufficient amount of H 2 in the tissues to reduce DCS incidence (Kayar et al., 1999, FASEB. J, 13:A408). This microbial activity, which converts H 2 to C H 4 , was enhanced by injecting cultures of Methanobrevibacter smithii , resulting in a significantly greater reduction in DCS incidence (Fahlman et al., 1999, FASEB J, 13: A408). To further explore biochemical decompression in the pig, we have collected data from a variety of hyperbaric H 2 exposures. Since the amount of gas breathed by a diver that becomes dissolved in the diver’s tissues is a function of the pressure of the gas and the duration of elevated pressure, the data set includes exposures of varying lengths of time and pressures. The data set also includes hyperbaric exposures of varying decompression rates. We will use these data to create a mathematical model that predicts the 453.2 Predicting Decompression Sickness Risk from H 2 Dives Using Conventional vs. Biochemical Decompression in Pigs A. Fahlman, S.R. Kayar, P. Tikuisis, W.C. Lin and W.B. Whitman. Naval Med. Res. Center, Bethesda, MD 20889; Carleton Univ., Ottawa, ON, K1S 5B6; DCIEM, Toronto, ON M3M 3B9 and Dept. Microbiology, Univ. of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602. Conclusions: Increasing time at elevated pressure and increasing decompression rate increased DCS incidence, suggesting that elevated tissue gas burden increases DCS risk. Exposure to elevated pressures did not lead to increased DCS incidence, probably because the native H 2 metabolizing microbes were removing some of the tissue H 2 , thus masking a pressure dependency. Increasing activity injected decreased the DCS incidence, implying that H 2 metabolism decreased the tissue gas burden. Tim e atC onstantPressure (m in) 30 120 150 P(DCS) 0 20 40 60 80 100 n=10 n=4 n=8 n=20 D C S Incidence in C ontrolA nim als w ith V ariable Tim e at24.1 atm 30 120 150 180 D C S Incidence vsD ecom pression R ate in C ontrolA nim alsat24.1 atm for 3 h D ecom pression R ate (atm /m in) 0.46 0.90 1.80 P(DCS) 0 20 40 60 80 100 n=9 n=20 n=7 D C S Incidence in C ontrolA nim alsasa Function ofTotalA m bientPressure Am bientPressure (atm ) 22.3 24.1 25.7 P(DCS) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 n=11 n=9 n=7 Total Activity Injected ( m oles C H 4 /m in) 0 500 1000 1500 2000 P(DCS) 0.00 0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00 Estim ated R egression Line 95% C onfidence Lim its Probability ofD C S asa Function of TotalA ctivity ofM ethanogensInjected Total Activity Injected ( m oles C H 4 /m in) 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 CH 4 Release Rate ( m oles CH 4 /min) 0 50 100 150 200 C SC T CH 4 R elease R ate asa Function ofTotal A ctivity Injected in A nim alsat24.1 atm Results: Fig 1. Fig 3. Fig 2. Fig 4. Fig 5.

Transcript of Materials and Methods: Animals: -Yorkshire pigs (Sus scrofa), castrated males, n=98, body mass range...

Page 1: Materials and Methods: Animals: -Yorkshire pigs (Sus scrofa), castrated males, n=98, body mass range 17-23 kg Groups: 1) Untreated controls (C) 2) Surgical.

Materials and Methods:Animals:

-Yorkshire pigs (Sus scrofa), castrated males, n=98, body mass range 17-23 kg

Groups:1) Untreated controls (C)

2) Surgical controls (SC)* : injected with 60 mL saline into caecum and large intestine

3) Treated animals (T)*: injected with varying volumes (12-83 mL) and activities (200-

2200 mol CH4/min) of Methanobrevibacter smithii into the caecum and large intestine*Surgery performed under anesthesia, abdomen opened to allow access to caecum and

large intestine. Animals studied immediately after recovery.

Dive simulation:-Chamber pressurized to 22, 24, or 26 bar (88-94%H2, 0.3-0.5 bar PO2) for 30, 120,

150, 180, or >1100 min.

-Decompression rate 0.45, 0.9, or 1.8 bar/min to 11 bar; animals observed for 1 hr for

DCS

- Euthanized in chamber on confirmation of DCS or at end of hour.

Measurements:-Chamber gases analyzed by gas chromatography for H2, O2, He, N2, and CH4

-CH4 output rate (mol CH4/min) from the chamber was used as an indicator of the CH4

production rate from pigs.

-Severe symptoms of DCS included: walking difficulties, fore and/or hind limb paralysis,

falling, convulsions.

Results:Fig. 1) Total activity injected was positively correlated (P<0.01) with the CH4

release rate from all dives. Fig. 2) The DCS incidence increased with increasing time at constant pressure.

Fig. 3) The DCS incidence increased with increasing decompression rate.

Fig. 4) The DCS incidence did not increase with increasing ambient pressure,

contrary to what is commonly found in DCS research.

Fig. 5) The DCS incidence decreased with increasing methanogenic activity

injected.

Abstract: Biochemical decompression, the facilitation of decompression by

biochemically eliminating some inert gas stored in divers’ tissues, was demonstrated in pigs during simulated H2 dives (Fahlman et al., FASEB J. 13:A408, 1999). Data were compiled to create a model of decompression sickness (DCS) risk to determine gas kinetics during decompression. To simulate a H2 dive, pigs (n=98, 19.61.4 kg) were placed in a dry chamber and compressed to varying pressures (22, 24, or 26 atm) for 2.5 or 3 h. Subjects were decompressed at different rates (0.45, 0.9, or 1.8 atm/min) to 11 atm, and observed for 1 h. The DCS incidence in control animals increased with time at pressure and with increasing decompression rate. Contrary to expectations, there was no correlation between DCS and pressure. Pigs receiving intestinal injections of the H2-metabolizing microbe, Methanobrevibacter smithii, had a DCS incidence that was half that of controls on a similar dive. From the complete data set, a probabilistic model will be created that will include parameters on risk assessment, gas kinetics, and H2 metabolism. This model will allow us to predict the advantage of biochemical decompression for H2 dives in general. (Support: ONR 603706N 0096 133 1703).

Introduction:We have previously reported that H2 metabolizing microbes in

the intestines of pigs significantly reduced the decompression

sickness (DCS) incidence during simulated H2 dives in a pig

model. Evidence suggests that pigs have a native gut flora of

microbes that metabolize a sufficient amount of H2 in the tissues

to reduce DCS incidence (Kayar et al., 1999, FASEB. J,

13:A408). This microbial activity, which converts H2 to C H4,

was enhanced by injecting cultures of Methanobrevibacter

smithii, resulting in a significantly greater reduction in DCS

incidence (Fahlman et al., 1999, FASEB J, 13: A408).

To further explore biochemical decompression in the pig, we

have collected data from a variety of hyperbaric H2 exposures.

Since the amount of gas breathed by a diver that becomes

dissolved in the diver’s tissues is a function of the pressure of the

gas and the duration of elevated pressure, the data set includes

exposures of varying lengths of time and pressures. The data set

also includes hyperbaric exposures of varying decompression

rates.

We will use these data to create a mathematical model that

predicts the probability of DCS (P(DCS)) from any hyperbaric

H2 exposure and activity of methanogens. H2 metabolism is

hypothesized to reduce the net tissue gas burden before and

during decompression, and therefore will decrease the P(DCS)

for the dive. The model will be based on the hypothesis that the

amount and rate of ambient pressure reduction during the

decompression phase determines the outcome.

453.2Predicting Decompression Sickness Risk from H2 Dives Using Conventional vs. Biochemical

Decompression in Pigs

A. Fahlman, S.R. Kayar, P. Tikuisis, W.C. Lin and W.B. Whitman. Naval Med. Res. Center, Bethesda, MD 20889; Carleton Univ., Ottawa, ON, K1S 5B6; DCIEM,

Toronto, ON M3M 3B9 and Dept. Microbiology, Univ. of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602 .

Conclusions:

•Increasing time at elevated pressure and increasing

decompression rate increased DCS incidence, suggesting

that elevated tissue gas burden increases DCS risk.

• Exposure to elevated pressures did not lead to

increased DCS incidence, probably because the native

H2 metabolizing microbes were removing some of the

tissue H2, thus masking a pressure dependency.

• Increasing activity injected decreased the DCS

incidence, implying that H2 metabolism decreased the

tissue gas burden.

• We conclude that a model using time at elevated

pressure, total ambient pressure, decompression rate,

and H2 metabolism by methanogens would be a useful

prediction tool for P(DCS) from any H2 dive.

Time at Constant Pressure (min)30 120 150

P(D

CS

)

0

20

40

60

80

100

n=10

n=4

n=8

n=20

DCS Incidence in Control Animals with Variable Time at 24.1 atm

30 120 150 180

DCS Incidence vs Decompression Rate in Control Animals at 24.1 atm for 3 h

Decompression Rate (atm/min)0.46 0.90 1.80

P(D

CS

)

0

20

40

60

80

100

n=9

n=20n=7

DCS Incidence in Control Animals as a Function of Total Ambient Pressure

Ambient Pressure (atm)22.3 24.1 25.7

P(D

CS

)

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

n=11

n=9

n=7

Total Activity Injected (moles CH4/min)

0 500 1000 1500 2000

P(D

CS

)

0.00

0.25

0.50

0.75

1.00Estimated Regression Line95% Confidence Limits

Probability of DCS as a Function of Total Activity of Methanogens Injected

Total Activity Injected (moles CH4/min)

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500

CH

4 R

ele

ase

Rate

(m

ole

s C

H4/

min

)

0

50

100

150

200C

SC

T

CH4 Release Rate as a Function of Total Activity Injected in Animals at 24.1 atm

Results:

Fig 1.

Fig 3.

Fig 2.

Fig 4.

Fig 5.