.... 12/09

. .

() . ..

2010

, (Arthur Schopenhauer) .

. .

. : (Argumentum ad hominem), (Argumentum ad Ignorantiam), (Argumentum ad verecundiam), (Argumentum ad populum), (Argumentum ad baculum), (Ignoratio Elenchi), (Accident), (Converse Accident), (Fallacy of Equivocation), (Amphiboly), (Composition), (Division).

( ) . .

, .

, , (strategic narrative narrative leadership) .., .

ii

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -iii- "" -1- "" -5- "" -12- "" -20- ""- -- -24- -v-

iii

,

.

.

,

.

, ,

/

.

1,

:

) (proof)

(.. )

) (

)1

,

1 , . , , 2002.

iv

,

) (stratagem),

,

.

.

, ,

2,

,

. ,

.

,

( )

.

2 Rahim, A., 'A measure of styles of handling interpersonal conflict', Academy of Management Journal', 1983, Vol.26, N.2, .368-376.

1

, ,

,

.

,

,

, , .

, ,

(),

, ,

.

, .

3 ,

,

, (

). a priori

, ,

.

, a posteriori,

3 Schopenhauer Arthur, . , Printa, 2008. Saunders Bailey, he Art of Controversy and other posthumous papers by Arthur Schopenhauer, Swan Sonnenschein & CO. Lim., , 1896. .

2

.

-,

.

,

.

,

.

, ,

4.

.

. ,

.

. ,

,

. ,

,

.

,

4 , - . . , . 2008. . 130 .

3

.

,

,

.

, ,

,

, .

, , ,

, ,

, , .

,

5.

,

,

(

), .

-.

(Contra negantem principia non est disputandum)6.

-

. : ) ad rem ( res-), ,

) ad hominem ex concessis

5 . , , 2002.

4

. : ) , -

) , , .

,

,

, , ,

.

.

.

.

,

. 13

, ,

112 6 (

).

6 David H. Fischer Historian Fallacies New York: Harper & Row, 1979.

5

( )

.

,

.

.7

.

.

modus ponens modus

tollens8, .

(

)

9.

(Argumentum ad hominem):

, 7 Baggini, Julian & Fosl, Peter S. : (. ), , 2005..

8 , . . ... 2009

9 Irving Copi Carl Cohen . Introduction to logic, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall 1998.

6

(ad hominem)10,

.

.

ad hominem

. ( ex concessis)

,

,

.

(Argumentum ad Ignorantiam):

,

.

(

) ,

.

. ,

, ,

.

10 ( -ad hominem). (ex concessis) ( , , ) .

7

(Argumentum ad verecundiam):

,

,

.

.

,

.

(Argumentum ad populum):

.

,

,

. ,

, . Bertrand Russell

, . ,

,

.11

(Argumentum ad baculum):

,

.

(ad baculum )

.

416 ..

11 Bertrand Russell Marriage and Morals New York: Liveright, 1929.

8

: , ,

.

,

( ) (

), ,

.

(Ignoratio Elenchi):

.

.

,

,

.

(Petitio Principii):

.

(.. ),

, , .

,

.

. David Hume ,

9

.

(Accident):

. ..

.

secundum quid ( ),

,

,

.

(Converse

accident):

.

, .

.

(Argumentum non causa pro causa):

.

,

, ,

.

post hoc ergo proper hoc ,

, .

(Fallacy of Equivocation):

10

.

12,

. .

,

.

,

.

,

,

.

,

, .

; .

.

. ,

,

.

,

13.

(Amphiboly):

, ,

. ,

,

,

, .

12 : . . . 13 Richard Robinson, An atheists Values Oxford University Press, , 1964, . 121

11

(accent), 14,

,

, ..

.

.

(Composition):

, ..

.

.

, , ,

(Division): T ,

,

,

.. , ,

.

14 Copi I. M. & Cohen C, Introduction to logic, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall 1998.

12

( )

(

).

.

) ( 4)

, ,

.

) ( 7) (

- ),

,

. ,

.

) ( 8) ,

(

).

.

13

) ( 10)

,

,

.

) ( 12)

. ,

,

, .

:

,

, .

) ( 13-14-15)

,

,

- -

.

( )

. ,

(

)

. ,

14

.

.

) ( 18-23)

,

, ,

(mutatio

controversiae). ,

. ,

.

.

) ( 19)

, ,

,

.

,

, ,

,

. ,

,

(status controversiae)

) ( 22) ,

.

,

,

.

15

) ( 25)

,

,

.

(exemplum in contrarium, instantia).

: ) )

)

.

) ( 28)

. argumentum ad auditores

, :

.

) ( 32)

, .

,

, , ...

) ( 35)

.

. ,

-

, -

16

.

(argumentum ab utili).

) ( 36)

,

.

.

15.

) ( 38)

.

. argumentum ad personam

argumentum ad hominem : ad hominem

, ad personam

,

.

,

.

:

, .

.

15 O Victor Goldsmith Vicar of Wakefild.

17

:

, , .

,

.

(Slippery Slope):

,

.

,

.

.

.

. ,

,

,

,

. ,

.

..

, .

,

.

,

, .

.

18

(

). ,

,

.

,

.

. ,

,

.

,

,

.

16,

.

,

.

( ) .

, ,

.

,

.

16 P=>Q

19

,

.

.

(soundness) :

(sound) , , (, , ).

(valid) , , :

(1) ,

.

(2)

.

(3)

.

, (invalid) 17.

17 , . . ... 2009

20

, .

.

.

. ,

(expanding pie)18.

, ,

, ,

19. Francois de Callieres,

18 ,

, 19.

18 ( ) . 19 Franois de Callires, The Practice of Diplomacy, translation of "De la manire de ngocier avec les souverains," London: Constable & Co, 1919. . 43

21

.

, ,

, 20.

,

.

, - ,

-

.

.

, ,

/.

.

.

,

.

, .

, , , , .

, . 20 Umberto Eco, Daniele Del Giudice, Gianfranco Ravasi, , , 2006.

22

, , .

, .

, ,

,

.

.

,

.

,

. ,

70.

2000

.

,

.

,

,

.

.

(strategic narrative narrative

leadership).

23

,

.

David Boje

.

, ()

.

21.

.

Ohio Jeffrey D. Ford

,

22.

,

.

21 Boje, D. Leadership is theatre! 4 2008 http://business.nmsu.edu/~dboje/388/leadership_theatre_book.html 2005 . 12 22 Ford, J. (1999). Organizational change as shifting conversations. Journal of Change Management, 12, (6), 480-500 http://www.hsdinstitute.org/learn-more/library/articles.html

24

,

( 9)23.

, . (symbolic or formal logic)

.

.

-

- (

). ,

.

.. .

23 Umberto Eco, Daniele Del Giudice, Gianfranco Ravasi, , , 2006 .17.

25

,

..,

.

,

(De inventione 1,1)24

24 Umberto Eco, Daniele Del Giudice, Gianfranco Ravasi, , , 2006 .17.

v

-

1. , . . ... 2009.

2. , . , , 2002.

3. , . , , 2004.

4. Baggini, Julian & Fosl, Peter S. : . . , , 2005.

5. Copi I. M. & Cohen C, Introduction to logic, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall 1998.

6. Eco Umberto, Daniele Del Giudice, Gianfranco Ravasi, . , , 2006.

7. , - . . , . 2008.

8. ., ., ., - , 2007.

9. Saunders Bailey, he Art of Controversy and other posthumous papers by Arthur Schopenhauer, Swan Sonnenschein & CO. Lim., , 1896.

10. Schopenhauer Arthur, . , Printa, 2008.

11. Boje, D. Leadership is theatre! 4 2008 http://business.nmsu.edu/~dboje/388/leadership_theatre_book.html (2005)

12. Ford, J. (1999). Organizational change as shifting conversations. Journal of Change Management, 12, (6), 480-500 http://www.hsdinstitute.org/learn-more/library/articles.html