Constraining Substorm Onset from Space- and Ground-Based Observations
Jan. 29, 2008 substorm event (0200-0350 UT) Waves/particles
description
Transcript of Jan. 29, 2008 substorm event (0200-0350 UT) Waves/particles
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
O. Le Contel(1), A. Roux (1), P. Robert(1), C. Jacquey(2), M. Berthomier(1), T. Chust(1), B. Grison(1), V. Génot(2), J.-A. Sauvaud(2), P. Louarn(2), G. Fruit(2), B. Lavraud(2), V. Angelopoulos(3), D. Sibeck(4),C. Chaston(5), C. Cully(6), R. Ergun(6), J. Bonnell(5), J. Mc Fadden(5), K.-H. Glassmeier(7), U. Auster(7), C. Carlson(5), D. Larson(5), S. Mende(5), H. Frey(5), C. T. Russell(3), E. Donovan(8), I. Mann(9), H. Singer(10)
Jan. 29, 2008 substorm event (0200-0350 UT)Waves/particles
(1) CETP, CNRS/UVSQ/UPMC, France(2) CESR, CNRS, France(3) IGPP, UCLA, USA(4) GSFC, NASA, USA(5) SSL, UCB, USA, (6) LASP, CU, USA(7) TUBS, Germany(8) University of Calgary, Canada(9) University of Alberta, Canada(10) NOAA/SEC, Colorado, USA
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Locations in GSM 0200-0350 UT
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Overview in GSM
4 dipolarisations:N°3 (Main substorm) observed first on Thd considering the start ofthe increase of the energetic ion pressure(cf. C. Jacquey):
1) 0222 UT2) 023720 UT3) 025011 UT (Main substorm)4) 030517 UT Vx > 0 Earthward flow in averageVy < 0 in some cases …Signatures on ion density on Thb and Thc can be observed before near-earth dipolarisation
1 2 3 4
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Thc, X~ - 20 RE, 0200-3300 UT
Thc in the mid tail
Filter banks dataSmall magnetic activity and electric activity in the mid-tail related to 1, 2 No electromagnetic activity for the main substorm (event 3) and event 4.
Density variations suggest vertical motions or/and thickness variations of the current sheet
Ion velocity variations notably changes of sign have to be analysed from distribution functions: - beam like structures at high and low energy
- Boundary motionPS Lobe
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Thd, X~ - 10 RE, 0200-3300 UT
Filter banks dataStrong magnetic and electric activity around 3 Hz, 12 Hz, 48 Hz
The electromagnetic activity starts after the start of the increase of the energetic ion pressure local activity associated with the local dipolarisation
Accelerated electrons
Thd near-earth s/c
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Zoom Thd, X ~ - 10 RE : 0220-0232 UT
Thd Electromagnetic and electrostatic
emissions in the range3Hz-12 Hz
during dipolarisation
Accelerated electrons
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Thd, particle burst : 0216-0235 UT
Dipolarisation
Vx,i,e > 0 Earthward
Vy,i < 0Vy,e << 0Jy > 0 and e- heatingWhistler emissions?
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Thd, particle burst : 0224-0228 UT
Whistler emissions:
Right-hand circularlyPolarised
Degree of polarisation ~ 1
Angle of propagation ~ 0
Ellipticity ~ + 1
Helicity ~1
Emissions during and after the local dipolarisation
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
The, particle burst : 0224-0228 UT
Emissions before and during the local dipolarisation
Début dipolarisation sur Thd
Whistler emissions:
Right-hand circularly Polarised
Degree of polarisation ~ 1
Angle of propagation ~ 0
Ellipticity ~ + 1
Helicity ~1
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
The data in GSM 0224-0228 UT
Preliminary calculationsOf the Poynting vector
E.B0 = 0 assumedE and B low-pass Filtered below 10 Hz
S = (ExB)/mu0Sz > 0 S|| >0
Away from the equatorSource very localized
Bz
e-
Ne
Ve
Te
E
B
S
S_mfa
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Zoom 0225-0226 UT
E ~ 0.3 mV/mB ~ 0.2 nTE/B ~ 1500 km/s
S ~ 5.e-8 -1.e-7 W/m2
Fce ~ 424 Hz (15 nT)Fci ~ 0.23 Hzk||2c2/2 = 2pe/(ce) (Helliwell, 1965)Or /(k ||vA) ~ (/ci)1/2 ~ 10-14For f ~20 - 50 Hz VA ~ 375 km/s (n0~1. p/cm3)
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
The data ESA e- data
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
August 17, 2003 event(Le Contel et al., ICS8)
STAFF-SC (burst mode, 450 s/s)
Wave Polarisation 0.35-180 Hz
Waves between 40 Hz to 180 Hz
have a right-hand circular polarization (excentricity ~0 blue color)
With a wave vector parallel to B ( ~0, blue color)
Whistler waves ci< < ce (li>l>le)(fce ~ 400 Hz and fci ~ 0.2 Hz for Bo ~ 15 nT)
k||2c2/2 = 2
pe/(ce) (Helliwell, 1965)
Or /(k ||vA) ~ (/ci)1/2 ~ 14
(1654 – 1703 UT)
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
August 17, 2003 event(Le Contel et al., ICS8)
Small scale current structure : 1657-165730
Observed close to equator |Bx| ~ 5 nTLarge By values ~ -25 to -30 nT (1s)Almost same Bx, Bz for all s/cBut different By
Parallel current of electron scale < 200km Observations of whistler waves f~40-180 Hz:• Large Bz(t) oscillations ~ +- 1 nT • Large Ey(t) ~ +- 2 mV/m
E ()/ B () 20000 km/s ~ 10VA
On C1, C2 and C3 but not on C4
propagation within the current structure
See also Stenberg et al., AG, 2005 aboutWhistler emissions close to the magnetopauseAnd Zhang et al., JGR, 1999 (magnetotail)
Bx
By
Bz
B
Vx,i,e
Vy,i,e
Jy,i,e
Jx,i,e
Ey 30-180 Hz
1657301657
Bz 30-180 Hz
THEMIS SWT, UCLA April 9-11, 2008
Summary/questions
Small or no electromagnetic or electrostatic activity detected by mid-tail s/c Strong electromagnetic activity on near-earth s/c Whistler emissions before, during and after the local dipolarisation Poynting vector directed away from equator and earthward not so far from the source which has to be very localized Role of these whistler emissions in the substorm onset? Can we use these emissions to track the onset region? Relation of these emissions with ground-based observationsTo be continued