[J-286-1992] IN THE SUPREME COURT OF...
Transcript of [J-286-1992] IN THE SUPREME COURT OF...
[J-286-1992][J-286-1992]
ININ THETHE SUPREMESUPREME COURTCOURT OFOF PENNSYLVANIAPENNSYLVANIA
[JJ-28 [J 6-12-9]-INTH 2[EI18]S
NUUPRRMCO
FY
LNTTH 2Y VN2A1[IS 81DE-T8S
NUUPRRPP
IY 6URCM 6OY IY
IY 6
NOOCP TPY IY SP 2CO
NTE86 [OP S
ANDAND
[JJ-28 [J 6-12-9]-INTH 2[EI18]S
NUUPRRMCO
FY
NI[IH[E1 N[TI8HS
NUUPRRPP
IY 6URCM 6OY IY
IY 6
NTE86 [OP S
OPINIONOPINION
VE1-28 N99N]N 682-686 JPM S
MOOP PP OP COOOCMR UP
O UPP OP CO MOOCPY NORP Y PP
M PMC PP PR PP M 6URCM M LPMC
2OOPPS OPPMOP PPCP OMO NCC NOOCP P
UMOPR PUMCP MC LM 2Y VMCS 8 PS P MPY
P MOOCP MC OP [P 6URCM 2CPR [62 RP
PPUOC O OP LPMC 2OOPP TPUO MC TPPCMOCY P
6URCM M MP OP MP CC MC PPCMOC M
OP LPMC 2OOPPY NCC NOOCP MP O 2O OMO
P R CO COMOP MC OP PP MP RP O
VMC MC OP [62 O OP PP O 2OY P
MCOP OP PPO OP PP MC PP O MOOP
PP MC MPY
[ UP PP C URCM MOOP PRRPOORP
PP MCMRC OP OPOC PP C UUO OP MP O O P COP OMO O 2O PP MOOCP URCP M P C CPY S P MP CO C OP CC POP OP LPMC 2OOPP OP 6URCM MY MOOP PPCY 9MY S NY [P 6URCM 2CPR Y MRPY 9MY S NY [P 6URCM 2CPR Y 2MUPRRY 9MY S NY S POS PCPS EY1Y S 1Y2OY S ]Y8Y Y NRO P MP PP O PMRMOP OP PPCP UPPCOP PP OP LPMC 2OOPPS -C P 1RPPS 9MY S NY S POS PCPS EY1Y S 1Y2OY S ]Y8Y S P M P PCROPCP OP P C OPP
OP MO M OP UUOCO O PP OP PPMC OP OCPP C OP OPOCY MOOP PPCS UM [P 6URCM 2CPR Y MRPY UM [P 6URCM 2CPR Y 2MUPRRY UMY P PPCP PCO O UP POMR CO M UPUCPMCP OMO PPCP POMRP OP MP RMOC MC OP U RPM MC MOMOY [P 6URCM 2CPR Y APRY 9MY S NY -C P PRMCOY 9MY S NY S POS PCPS EY1Y S 1Y2OY S ]Y8Y Y I OP UPOOCP PP O POMR OP CO O PO PPCPY P POMR RMOC M P UPC RPR OMCOMR PPCPY [P 6URCM 2CPR Y MY 9MY S NY Y ]P 2MPY 9MY S NY 1MR 2MPY 9MY S NY Y
[P 6URCM 2CPR Y APRRPY 9MY S
NY S Y 1PP MR [P 6URCM 2CPR Y
1OPCY 9MY S NY MC [P 6URCM
2CPR Y 1MRRY 9MY S NY Y
PPPS C M MCP O OS P MP PPP OP
P C O MOOP MC O C O OP CC MC
V
PPCMOC OP LPMC 2OOPP MC OP 6URCM
MY
NCC NOOCP M MOOP O OP UMOP RM C
MC O MPP M UMOC M M RP UMOOCP C
]MCMOP 2COY 8PUO OPP UPPCY NCC NOOCP
M M C OP URCM CMOCY
LM 2Y VMC M MOOP O OP UMOP RM C Y
9 O PC MUUCOP M M PC UPCMOC PPPP C
S VMC M PP M MC NOMCO 6OO NOOCP C
9RMPRUMS M M 6PUO NOOCP O OP NOOCP PCPMR
[PS MC M MC MOOCP O OP 9R EORO 2 CS M
PRR M PC C UMOP UMOP MO M PM MC M MRY
P MOP M S S VMC M UPCP OP
UMOP RM M UP P PM PPOP 1PUOPP S
Y [P 6URCM 2CPR Y VMCY 9MY S
NY Y -C S VMC POP M M PPPP O
CPCOMOP C UPUMC PCOMOPPCO M M RPCP MOOCPY
9 O S NCC NOOCP M MMCOP O VMC
M M PC UPCMOC PPPP UMR O NCC
NOOCP PC UPCMOC UMOPY -C RMOP S VMC
P O NCC NOOCP OP U RO VMC
C UMOOPS OO UMS M M UMMRPMR NCC
NOOCPY VMC CMOP OMO O MMCPPCO R PRU
VMC OM PCO O OP RM MC MO C OMCC
PCOMOPPCO MOOCP RPCPY -COMRRS VMC P
O O OPP M M PPY NCC NOOCP OPOP OMO P
V
MP VMC O MP P OMO P CP PP RPCO OMO P
M C CR M M UMMRPMR MC CO M MC MOOCPY NO C OP
M NCC NOOCP PC MP MMP OP COPCO OP
M N MOC MCP [UCC PM UPCP MOOCP
PCY N CRS NCC NOOCP MP M UPCP
MOOCP R MO M CMR UMMRPMR R S CRP
COPPC OP RPCO OMCC CMOC RPCO
CPOMC RPMR PPM MC UPUMCS CP UP CS RPMR
PCOY RP VMC M C M M UMMRPMR C NCC
NOOCP P POPPC VMCM MC M S
VMC CMP CO MUUPM C MC P CS C NCC
NOOCP RPMR OMOCP C RPMR CP MS MC OP
OPRPUCP PP MCPP CR PPPCP O NCC NOOCP
CMPY JCMRRS NCC NOOCP CMOP OMO P S C MOS
UPP VMC POPPC VMCM MC M S MC
PM MRR VMC MOC M M UMMRPMRY
[C MC PCCC C IPP S NCC NOOCP
URO RPMR PP O VMCY NCC NOOCP M MCRPP
OMO O M UUPY NCC NOOCP OPOP OMO C
IPP P URO M PP O VMCY NO OP OPS P
CO P O UMPCO M M PPUROOC MMCPPCOS O MOP M
UPCMOC OMCOMR OP MC PP U P VMCY
-C PPMR OP COMCPS VMC M UM CP MRO
NCC NOOCP CMOP OMO P CO POR MO P
UMPCOY -C MC PPCOS VMC PPP PP NCC
NOOCPY
V
-O CO OP RPM OP UPPCO URCM MOC M
COMOPY -O P MUUPM OMO M PC UPCMOC RPCOS
8RMCP TPRRS PMP PCMCOP O POP VMC
NCC NOOCP O MC RP M URMCOY NO OP
OP TPRR COMRR PO O VMCS P M M PP M
UUO U MOC UPURP UPO O OP PC
UPCMOC OPY -O MR MUUPM OMO PPMR OP RMMCO
PP PP O U MC PP PUPPCOP VMC MC
NCC NOOCPY -C MC PPCOS MOP TPRR COMOP P
URCM MOCS MUU MOPR CCP OP OP MPY
NOP COC O CPOMOCS OP [62 RP MP
MMCO O NCC NOOCP MC VMCY O PUPO O
VMCS OPC POMR RMOC PP MRRPP 6URCM TRP
N S S MC 6URCM TRP N MC
6URCM TRP N 6URCM TRP N MC
6URCM TRP N MC Y PP POMR RMOC MC
P MMOPP M OP CMO P UMOP RMS MPUOC
PURPCO C PC UPCMOC MOOP MC MOOCP M
UP R PP M M PPPPS MC OP MC RPMR PP
POPPC MC MOOCP MC M CCMOOCPY N O NCC NOOCPS
O MRRPP OMO P RMOP OP MP P U C MC
MC MPOOC VMC CMO P UMOP RMS PC MMP
PP P PPCP P O CMOP OMO M UMO P UMO PP PP CUM RPCO
VMC MC NCC NOOCP P MC MOP O OP URMCMCO O PCP URCM UPPCY
V
JJ JJ
JJ
AA DD
AA AA
DD RR -12-12AA
JJ TT
DD RR 1-121-12AA 66
CC
HARRYHARRY CC JACSONJACSON
TT JJ
SS JJ
TT
PP
CC
PP JJ PP SS AA EE JJ DD CC NN 88 19891989 TT FF 199199 TT JJ FF FF
66 199199 CC HH CC JJ AA JJ
JJ FF JJ PP SS JJ TT
[J-286-1992][J-286-1992] -- 66 --
M OPOP OMO P PO O VMC C M PMP
URPMP O MOOCP P MC UP OMO
VMC R MO C MC UPCMOC PCPO
PCOMOPY 9P RS C [OP S VMC M MOP M
OP PPPP C M PC UPCMOC MPY NO OP OP
O COMR PPOCS VMC POP OMO M POMC
9Y PPCP ACS 8 PS O PUPPCO CP M M
URPMP O PCO M M PRR MMP OP
MO OMO VMC M CP UPCC O CO MP M P M
COPPOP CR C PROY P URMC M O MP VMC MRR
OP PCOPPCP RPMR MC PPR MP AC MP MRR
UR MUUPMMCP MC PPOP MRR MR PCOY
NOP OP 9POOC 2OMOC M RPY M OPOP
OMO VMC PPCP OMO M P AC MC UPP U PY
NUUMPCORS M URP PPRUP C PPOC AC PRP C
POOC M PMC C OP UPOOCY -C MC PPCOS C VR S S
OP MOP OP CMR PMC C OP 9POOC 2OMOCS M
PUPPCOP PR O VMC UPPCO C OP Y 9 O
OMO PMCS VMC MC M PO O PP M OPOC C
UUO OMOCY M OPOP OMO VMC MP O
MP OP PPPP OMO P COPCP O OMO M CP MC OMO
P MCOP PCPO OMOPY JOPPS M OPOP
OMO O OMOPPCO M MRPY M PPCOR PPP MC MM
VMC PR MP O PM O OP UPUMMOC CP UMMP MY PPPS P PP C M MCOC O PPOY
V
MUU MOPR SY -O - C UOP M O M
UM VMCY M OPOP OMO P UM VMC OP
MMS SS RP VMC CMOP OMO P PPP C
CP OP MMS O MOP PPP M O S MP
UC PM UPCMR PCUY
6URCM TRP N OMOP OMO M RMP MRR CO
8CMP C CO CRC CPOS MS PPOS PUPPCOMOCY
8CMP C CO OMO UP MR O OP MCOMOC OPY
8CMP C MC OP CO OMO MPPR PRPO C OCP O UMOP RMY
NOP PP OP OPOC O M MC VMCS P MP
CCP OMO M M P PRP OCP MC OMO OPPP
OPP OMCOMR PPCP O UUO O MRRPP POMR
RMOCY
VMC MO OMO P CP PP M M PPPP C M
PC UPCMOC MP MC MRO P PCP MOOPCC M
PMC O PUPO O M PRMOP MOOPS P MPUO M
OPOC OMO VMC MOOPCY LP MR MO PPC
SS PO RM OMO OP CP M MP UC PM UPCMR
PCUY JCMRRS P MO CC M O CP
UMMP MC CRP OUP O PCP P PP MOP M C
RMOC OPOC OMOC PMCY -C OPP
PUPOS VMC C PPCOMR MO M OPOC
P 2P 9PCMR TPUCRO M PURMP OP TRP 9PCMR 2CO PPOP NUR S Y
V
JJ MP
JJ U P M CP
ODCODC
6URCM RR 1-1-
12A12A 66
EE JJ URPOP PM
U P UPCCY EE VMC CO MO M C
MMOC OPOC OP OMOC PMCS O OP
RPM OMO P CPOMP M P CO COOOP
OP UMOP RMY - M OMOC PMC M M
URO M VMC MP C PS OPC M O
CPPM VMC O MOOPC OP PMC LMC M MO RPMO
PO PM PUPPCP M M PC UPCMOC PPPPS ROORP
MC CRPP R P MCP MOOPCMCP MO M
URO PMCY [ PS OP P RMR CRC OMO
VMC M MC COPPOS O UPCMR MC CMCMRS C OP
UPPC MC OMO P M C MOOPCMCPY NR COPPO
OP MO OMO VMC MRP O RP O NCC
NOOCP POP C MUURMOC PCOMOPPCO MO OP
PMC PMC PCOMOPPCOY - VMC M CO CPOMC M
P POCMRP COS OPC R P MP CO
RP OMO CO C UUO PCOMOPPCO
1 M RMMCO RMOC P MCCO MC RR CO P
ORPMOPY 6MPCO MC POPP PUCP O MC POMR
RMOC MC CR RR P UP C OP O PP OMOCY
V
[P 6URCM CC TT
HH
CC --
NN JJ
FF
UP
P CP MOC PPUO MPCOY N CRS
MPUO OP PPCMOC OP 6URCM M MC P OMO
VMC P MP OP UMOP RMY LP MR PP
O UM OP O CPOMOC MC UPOC C O MOOPY
AMOYMODSAMOYMODS ATTORNEYATTORNEY
[62 M MRRPP OMO NCC NOOCP CUP O VMC
O MP NCC NOOCP MO M M CO C CPMRC MC
UPPCOC P VMC UMOP RM RP CP
UPCCY -O MRRPP OMO NCC NOOCP MOC
UP MRR RMOP 6URCM TRP NS 6URCM TRP
N MC 6URCM TRP N OP 2P 9PCMR
TPUCROY P U C OMOP OMO
N RMP R CO M M CCRMP C OP CMO P UMOP RMY
6URCM TRP NY
N RMP RM MRR CO MP RPMR PP O M CCRMP Y Y Y
6URCM TRP NY
V
AA --
DD RR -1-1AA
AA ODCODC
TT
ODCODC II
SS
AA AA
UPPCOP OO
URPMC MC PP MPPPCOS
PP OP PCO AA AA CP
OPY -C CP COMCPS M OCP CMOP OMO VMC CMP M
URMP C OP C OP NCC NOOCP P C
P PMRR PMCO MOP M PC VMC M
PCOMOPY -C MOS OMO OCP M C CPUOC OP OP
MP CRPY MO MP OCP PCP OMO NCC NOOCP
M UPPCO C M C O VMC M UOPCOMR PMR
MRUMOP RMY LPPS NCC NOOCP U P POMRP
COP C MCOC OMO MP PPOCY
PP MP O M P PMURP OP PPCP U P [62
URMP CO P POC OP PRO OP
OCPPY OO MPUOC OP OMCOMR PPCP M
CUM POPPC NCC NOOCP MC VMC U P OPP
OCPPS [62 MR O PPO O PCY 2RPMRS OP LPMC
2OOPP MC OP 6URCM M PP OP C PC O
MPUO OPOC [62 OCPPY O OP 2OOPP MC
V
OP 6URCM M C OP PRO [62 OCPP
RMCY [ CPUPCPCO PP OP P C O
CRCY N CRS P C C RMOC O PUPO O OP
MMOC OMO NCC NOOCP CUP MPP O MO
VMC C OP CMO P UMOP RMY
NCC NOOCP P MO OMO P C MO RPMO CP
MC URO M RPMR PP O VMCY LP MR MO OMO C
PPMR OP MC VMC M UM M PP OO PURO
MO MOCY N OP M COR OMOP
6URCM TRP N MC TRP 9PCMR 2CO Y U O OP MC UROOC PP POPPC M RMP MC M CCRMPY PP MC P C POC O OMO VMCS M M UPCP RMPS M CCRMP OC OP PMCC OP RPY P UUP O RPMR MCMOP O MCOMC M RMP CPUPCPCO UPCMR PCOS CMUPP CPOM RMOC O M UMO OP OMC RPCOY -C MOCS OP UUP O UOPO OP M MMCO OP CMO P UMOP RM UPC OP OP P CO PCP M UPPCOR RPCP O UMOPY P CR PPUOC O OP RP U OC MC PP O CCRMP OP UMPCO M RM CO M UO MC URMC C CCRMP PURPP OP MP C OP UO PMCP OP RMPS R PPY P PPUOC OMCMRP PMP OPP
C PO RC POPPC M UP PP MC M UP UMPCO O M CCRMPY -C O MPS OMO P PR UPPCOY
TPUO MC TPPCMOC OP 6URCM M OP 1UPP
2O 9PCCRMCMS UMP Y
RP OPP COMCP MC M RPMR PP MP RPMR C
RMOC 6URCM TRP NS P MP CMCO
NCC NOOCP MPUOMCP PUCRO MC
MMCP OMO MOC RR CO P C OP OPY -O
RPM OMO NCC NOOCP M OMOP UMC
V
VMC CMCMR COC MOP OMC MC PR COPCOY
JOPPS OP PP PP UM MOP OP UP UPCC M
PCPS PO PP MR PCOMOPPCO PY P MP MOP
O NCC NOOCP MMCP OMO OPP RR P C OP
PCPS PPUC C C OMO P MP CO CCC MOCY
LPPS P MPP O OP LPMC 2OOPP MC OP 6URCM
M OMO C RO NCC NOOCP PPRCPS
UPMOC MC CRPP URCM PS M UMOP
PUMC C PY N CRS P MPUO OP PPCMOC
OP 6URCM M MC P OMO M UMOP PUMC P
PY JOPPS NCC NOOCP MR PP O UM OP
O CPOMOC MC UPOC C O MOOPY
Y VOP ]MPC CO UMOUMOP C OP CPMOC
P C O MPY
Y VOP JRMPO CO UMOUMOP C OP CPMOC
P C O MPY
Y VOP 9MUMM RP M 2C C MC 6PCOC
[UCCY
V
[J-28J611-[J-28J611-
9]9] I]NI]N THESNUNTHESNUN PRHSIPRHSI RMRM ENCCTOFYLC9LENCCTOFYLC9L
[JJ-28 [J 6-12-9]-INTH 2[EI18]S
NUUPRRMCO
FY
]LSSO]LSSO 2Y LN2V1[IS 81AE-T8S
NUUPRRPP
[JJ-28 [J 6-12-9]-INTH 2[EI18]S
NUUPRRMCO
FY
NI[IHD[E1 N[TI8HS
NUUPRRPP
IY 6URCM 6PO IY
IY 6
NOOCP TPY IY P 2CO
NTE86 [OP S
MC
IY 6URCM 6PO IY
IY 6
NTE86 [OP S
PRCPHSS9CVPRCPHSS9CV LCALCA 6-118I-I RE9C9RCRE9C9RC
USDUSD LE1-28 9N9N6NV[1 682-686 JPM S
- C C OP P C OP MO O M M 2Y
LMCY PPS - O PCO O OP UMOP PUMC PP
OP NCC NOOCPY
P MO M C OMO OP CO M 2Y
LMC M PP M O MMCO MPCOY HPOS OP
MOOCP MP MC MPOOP LMC C CR MO MCS
C MOS MP O U RP LMC O RMOP RP
COS UR O P UMOPR PUMCPY -C PS OP
NCC NOOCP M M CUMO MC R P PCP
P PPPR OMC PC PC M PP RMU C OP OY
NOOCP O P PP RMCO O CP OMO OP
O OP OP C OP RM UMOP RR
CMR MC C CMCP O OP RP OMO C MRR Y
L 9MP