INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT
Transcript of INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin« Erasmus University, Rotterdam, 31.01. 2001, page n° 1 »
Drs. Ir. Derrick-Philippe GOSSELINDrs. Ir. Derrick-Philippe GOSSELIN
INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT
INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT
Erasmus University, RotterdamJanuary 31, 2001
Erasmus University, RotterdamJanuary 31, 2001
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 2 »
CONTENTCONTENT
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 3 »
CONTENTCONTENT
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 4 »
IssuesIssues
50% of all surveyed International and National
Account Programmes originally failed to meet their Company’s
Target Objectives
50% of all surveyed International and National
Account Programmes originally failed to meet their Company’s
Target Objectives
Source: Yankee group 1994
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 5 »
Reasons for Failure (1)Reasons for Failure (1)
1. Lack of Senior Management Support2. Too many Accounts3. No experience (Business Management/Culture)4. Account Management Concept not understood
in the Company: Sales versus Marketing versus account management
5. Seen as Elitist by other sales departments6. Company copies from competition without
understanding the requirements, culture, systems, resource allocation, functional interaction, etc…
1. Lack of Senior Management Support2. Too many Accounts3. No experience (Business Management/Culture)4. Account Management Concept not understood
in the Company: Sales versus Marketing versus account management
5. Seen as Elitist by other sales departments6. Company copies from competition without
understanding the requirements, culture, systems, resource allocation, functional interaction, etc…
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 6 »
Reasons for Failure (2)Reasons for Failure (2)
7. Company has no long term commitment to account management.
8. Account Management remains a sales program (ST) an not an account managementprogramme (LT).
9. Product and Price strategy dominate over marketing and Value creation for the customer.
10. Account Management Programme remains undefined on Priorities and implementation.
11. Companies want results too fast12. Conflict in compensation versus Objectives
7. Company has no long term commitment to account management.
8. Account Management remains a sales program (ST) an not an account managementprogramme (LT).
9. Product and Price strategy dominate over marketing and Value creation for the customer.
10. Account Management Programme remains undefined on Priorities and implementation.
11. Companies want results too fast12. Conflict in compensation versus Objectives
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 7 »
CONTENTCONTENT
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 8 »
Definition of Account Management (1)
Definition of Account Management (1)
Important Customer (1982)
Important Customer (1982)
Large, Big Major Account (1976)
Large, Big Major Account (1976)
National Account (1980)
National Account (1980)
KEY CLIENT KEY CLIENT KEY CLIENT KEY CLIENT (1992)(1992)(1992)(1992)KEY CLIENT KEY CLIENT KEY CLIENT KEY CLIENT (1992)(1992)(1992)(1992)
International Account (1994)
International Account (1994)
Worldwide Account (1998)Worldwide Account (1998)
Multinational Account (1998)
Multinational Account (1998)
GLOBAL GLOBAL GLOBAL GLOBAL STRATEGIC STRATEGIC STRATEGIC STRATEGIC ACCOUNT ACCOUNT ACCOUNT ACCOUNT (1999)(1999)(1999)(1999)
GLOBAL GLOBAL GLOBAL GLOBAL STRATEGIC STRATEGIC STRATEGIC STRATEGIC ACCOUNT ACCOUNT ACCOUNT ACCOUNT (1999)(1999)(1999)(1999)
Strategic Strategic Strategic Strategic Account Account Account Account (1999(1999(1999(1999----2000)2000)2000)2000)
Strategic Strategic Strategic Strategic Account Account Account Account (1999(1999(1999(1999----2000)2000)2000)2000)
Are those different names for the same phenomena?Are those different names Are those different names for the same phenomenafor the same phenomena??
Global Key Account (1996)Global Key Account (1996)Global Key Account (1996)Global Key Account (1996)Global Key Account (1996)Global Key Account (1996)Global Key Account (1996)Global Key Account (1996)
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 9 »
Definition of Account Management (2)
Definition of Account Management (2)
There is no concensus on the definitions but 3 main characteristics are common on Account ManagementThere is no concensus on the definitions but 3 main
characteristics are common on Account Management
Relational Relational StrategicStrategicmarketingmarketing
CommercialCommercial
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 10 »
Definition of Account Management (2)
Definition of Account Management (2)
key accounts are customers representing a large potential or actual sales volume as well in money terms as
in percentage of the total revenues. Sometimes they are the most profitable
customers
key accounts are customers representing a large potential or actual sales volume as well in money terms as
in percentage of the total revenues. Sometimes they are the most profitable
customers
Commercial focusCommercial focus
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 11 »
Definition of Account Management (2)
Definition of Account Management (2)
key accounts expect special and specific treatment and services: inventory management, logistics,
special prices, reporting, customer applications and solutions. Key accounts will centralise the purchase
from different geographic area’s and will involve different departments and different skills
key accounts expect special and specific treatment and services: inventory management, logistics,
special prices, reporting, customer applications and solutions. Key accounts will centralise the purchase
from different geographic area’s and will involve different departments and different skills
Relational focusRelational focus
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 12 »
Definition of Account Management (2)
Definition of Account Management (2)
key accounts can be selected because of their status, market leader position,
as ref. to open new markets, for diversification, technological
leadership, because they are or will invest.
key accounts can be selected because of their status, market leader position,
as ref. to open new markets, for diversification, technological
leadership, because they are or will invest.
Strategic marketing Strategic marketing focusfocus
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 13 »
Definition of Account Management (3)
Definition of Account Management (3)
❏ We believe there are 3 different processes at work which are not identified as such in practice, creating a lot of confusion,mismanagement and failures.
❏ We believe there are 3 different processes at work which are not identified as such in practice, creating a lot of confusion,mismanagement and failures.
Long Term Strategic
Dynamic/InteractiveProactiveCompetitive
Advantage
Strategic Account
Management
Mid TermMarketing
Static/Supplier driven
OffensiveCoordination/Relational
Key Account Management
Short Term Sales
Static/ Supplier driven
DefensivePerformanceKey Account Selling
Time FocusBehaviourObjectiveNatureProcess
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 14 »
Current views onAccount Management
Current views onAccount Management
Confusion and Failure on account management is due among others
to the non recognition of 3 different processes implemented
in an increasing complex environment due to globalization.
Confusion and Failure on account management is due among others
to the non recognition of 3 different processes implemented
in an increasing complex environment due to globalization.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 15 »
Current views onAccount Management
Current views onAccount Management
Scop
eSc
ope
Tim
e Fo
cus
Tim
e Fo
cus Strategic
ManagementStrategic Account
Management
Relationship Management
Key Account Management
Sales Management
Key Account Selling
GlobalGlobalInterInter
nationalnationalRegionalRegionalNationalNational
LocalLocalFocusFocusProcessProcess
ComplexityComplexity
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 16 »
CONTENTCONTENT
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 17 »
Origins of Account ManagementOrigins of Account Management
❏ Key account management emerged at the end of 1950 in the US because of environmental changes which are still valid today:
! Increased concentration of buying companies! Increased geographic dispersion of buyers of same company! Increased pressure on costs and communication! Increased desire to develop partnerships! Increased complexity of buyers operation
❏ Key account management emerged at the end of 1950 in the US because of environmental changes which are still valid today:
! Increased concentration of buying companies! Increased geographic dispersion of buyers of same company! Increased pressure on costs and communication! Increased desire to develop partnerships! Increased complexity of buyers operation
Assign one person: Key account manager to handle interface with customer from a sales
point of view.
Assign one person: Key account manager to handle interface with customer from a sales
point of view.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 18 »
History of Account ManagementHistory of Account Management
❏ 1950: Originally conceived to manage Big Sales to Big Accounts. (Dow Chemicals – Sears).
❏ 1960: A place to put non-promotable Senior Sales people.
❏ 1970: Not used anymore, no value over standard procurement procedures.
❏ 1980: More important as more revenues controlled by fewer accounts.
❏ 1990: Become very important as pure product strategy difficult to maintain. Effects of TQM, Standardization, Downsizing, Globalization, Strategic Alliances, etc…
❏ 1950: Originally conceived to manage Big Sales to Big Accounts. (Dow Chemicals – Sears).
❏ 1960: A place to put non-promotable Senior Sales people.
❏ 1970: Not used anymore, no value over standard procurement procedures.
❏ 1980: More important as more revenues controlled by fewer accounts.
❏ 1990: Become very important as pure product strategy difficult to maintain. Effects of TQM, Standardization, Downsizing, Globalization, Strategic Alliances, etc…
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 19 »
Why will it become more important ?(1)Why will it become
more important ?(1)
❏ Changing perception of Purchasing
!Now seen as a business process and not longer as o narrow specialized function
!Purchasing must as a business function analysethe fully integrated activities of Engineering, Production, Operations, Finance, Marketing and sales, Quality cost control within the overall business and management strategy
❏ Changing perception of Purchasing
!Now seen as a business process and not longer as o narrow specialized function
!Purchasing must as a business function analysethe fully integrated activities of Engineering, Production, Operations, Finance, Marketing and sales, Quality cost control within the overall business and management strategy
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 20 »
Why will it become more important ?(2)Why will it become
more important ?(2)
❏ Reasons for changes in Purchasing
!More outsourcing!Change in Technology !Global competition!Shorter product life cycles!Speed: JIT, TQM, Mass Customization!Vendor reduction programs to reduce purchasing
costs
❏ Reasons for changes in Purchasing
!More outsourcing!Change in Technology !Global competition!Shorter product life cycles!Speed: JIT, TQM, Mass Customization!Vendor reduction programs to reduce purchasing
costs
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 21 »
Why will It becomemore important ? (3)
Why will It becomemore important ? (3)
❏ Importance of international account management will continue to increase because of 5 trends:
❏ Importance of international account management will continue to increase because of 5 trends:
Industry StructureIndustry StructureMaturity of Industrial MarketsMaturity of Industrial Markets
Importance of account
management
Importance of account
management
Technology ICT/ (E-com & e-business)Technology ICT/ (E-com & e-business)
GlobalisationGlobalisation
Increase in Buying PowerIncrease in Buying Power
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 22 »
Why will It becomemore important?
Why will It becomemore important?
More competitionMore complexityMore concentration thru M&AMore central purchasingMore Vendor reductionMore outsourcing Elimination low value activitiesHigher Speed
More competitionMore complexityMore concentration thru M&AMore central purchasingMore Vendor reductionMore outsourcing Elimination low value activitiesHigher Speed
Less but moreimportantsuppliers
Less but moreimportantsuppliers
Account managementis an efficient and effective process
to implement
Account managementAccount managementis an efficient and effective process is an efficient and effective process
to implementto implement
5 Trends5 Trends5 TrendsLess but more
importantcustomers
Less but moreimportantcustomers
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 23 »
Framework for International Account Management
Framework for International Account Management
NEED FORINTERNATIONAL
ACCOUNTMANAGEMENT
NEED FORNEED FORINTERNATIONALINTERNATIONAL
ACCOUNTACCOUNTMANAGEMENTMANAGEMENT
OrganizationStructure
Management Processes
People
Culture
OrganizationOrganizationStructureStructure
Management Management ProcessesProcesses
PeoplePeople
CultureCulture
InternationalServices
International Value Chain
International Marketing
Competitive Moves
InternationalInternationalServicesServices
International International Value ChainValue Chain
International International MarketingMarketing
Competitive MovesCompetitive Moves
ConsistentWorldwide Service
One Point Contact
Partnership
Outsourcing
International AccountManagementStructure
Compensation/Incentive System
Unifom PurchasePricing
ConsistentConsistentWorldwide Worldwide ServiceService
One Point ContactOne Point Contact
PartnershipPartnership
OutsourcingOutsourcing
International International AccountAccountManagementManagementStructureStructure
Compensation/Compensation/IncentiveIncentive SystemSystem
Unifom PurchaseUnifom PurchasePricingPricing
Global/Regional Drivers
Global Channels
Transferable Marketing
Lead Countries
Global Economies ofScale
High Product Development costs
Fast Changing Technology
Global Competitors
Global/Regional Drivers
Global Channels
Transferable Marketing
Lead Countries
Global Economies ofScale
High Product Development costs
Fast Changing Technology
Global Competitors
ImplementationImplementationOrganizationOrganizationResponceResponceIndustry Industry DriversDrivers
InternationalInternationalStrategyStrategy
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 24 »
CONTENTCONTENT
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 25 »
Issues in International Account Management
Issues in International Account Management
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other issues
" Advanced Research
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other issues
" Advanced Research
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 26 »
Issues in International Account Management
Issues in International Account Management
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 27 »
Distribution
Distribution
Types of International AccountsTypes of International Accounts
SupplierSupplierSupplier AccountManagerAccountAccountManagerManager ClientClientClient
TYPE 1: Very SimpleTYPE 1: Very Simple
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 28 »
Distribution
Distribution
Types of International AccountsTypes of International Accounts
SupplierSupplierSupplier AccountManagerAccountAccountManagerManager ClientClientClient
TYPE 2: SimpleTYPE 2: Simple
ClientClientClient
ClientClientClient
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 29 »
Distribution
Distribution
Types of International AccountsTypes of International Accounts
SupplierSupplierSupplier ClientClientClient
TYPE 3: DifficultTYPE 3: Difficult
ClientDivision BLocation A
ClientClientDivision BDivision BLocation ALocation A
ClientDivision ALocation B
ClientClientDivision ADivision ALocation BLocation B
ClientDivision ALocation A
ClientClientDivision ADivision ALocation ALocation A
AccountManagerAccountAccountManagerManager
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 30 »
Distribution
Distribution
Types of International AccountsTypes of International Accounts
SupplierSupplierSupplier AccountManagerAccountAccountManagerManager
ClientCentralClientClient
CentralCentral
TYPE 4: More DifficultTYPE 4: More DifficultSupplier Divisionproductline A
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductline Aline A
Supplier Divisionproductline B
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductline Bline B
Supplier Divisionproductline C
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductline Cline C
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 31 »
Distribution
Distribution
Types of International AccountsTypes of International Accounts
SupplierSupplierSupplier AccountManagerAccountAccountManagerManager
ClientCentralClientClient
CentralCentral
TYPE 5: ComplexTYPE 5: Complex
Supplier DivisionproductLine A
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductLine ALine A
Supplier DivisionproductLine B
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductLine BLine B
Supplier DivisionproductLine C
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductLine CLine C
ClientDivision ALocation A
ClientClientDivision ADivision ALocation ALocation A
ClientDivision ALocation B
ClientClientDivision ADivision ALocation BLocation B
ClientDivision BLocation A
ClientClientDivision BDivision BLocation ALocation A
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 32 »
Types of International AccountsTypes of International Accounts
SupplierSupplierSupplier AccountManagerAccountAccountManagerManager
ClientCentralClientClient
CentralCentral
TYPE 5: Real World ModelTYPE 5: Real World Model
Supplier DivisionproductLine A
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductLine ALine A
Supplier DivisionproductLine B
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductLine BLine B
Supplier DivisionproductLine C
Supplier Supplier DivisionDivisionproductproductLine CLine C
Distribution
Distribution
ClientDivision ALocation A
ClientClientDivision ADivision ALocation ALocation A
ClientDivision ALocation B
ClientClientDivision ADivision ALocation BLocation B
ClientDivision BLocation A
ClientClientDivision BDivision BLocation ALocation A
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 33 »
Cross Europe Account Management can be even more complex
Cross Europe Account Management can be even more complex
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 34 »
Can become very complex when moving to Global Account Management
Can become very complex when moving to Global Account Management
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 35 »
Types of International Account management
Types of International Account management
CONTINGENCY APPROACH
! There is no such thing as a standard approach toward an international account management organization:
!The account structure will depend on the complexity of both the supplier and the client organization.
!The added value will be creased thru focus on the integration of operations of processes of the supplier and the client.
CONTINGENCY APPROACH
! There is no such thing as a standard approach toward an international account management organization:
!The account structure will depend on the complexity of both the supplier and the client organization.
!The added value will be creased thru focus on the integration of operations of processes of the supplier and the client.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 36 »
Issues in International Account Management
Issues in International Account Management
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 37 »
Account RelationshipDevelopment Model
Account RelationshipDevelopment Model
ComplexComplex
Level ofInvolvementwith thecustomer
Level ofInvolvementwith thecustomer
SimpleSimple
Nature of the customer RelationshipNature of the customer Relationship
Synergetic AMSynergetic AMSynergetic AM
Early AMEarly AMEarly AM
Systems/SolutionsSystems/SolutionsTransactionTransaction
Mid-AMMidMid--AMAM
Partnership AMPartnership AMPartnership AM
Account Relationship Development Model of Millman
& Wilson (1994)
Account Relationship Development Model of Millman
& Wilson (1994)
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 38 »
Selection of International Accounts (1)Selection of International Accounts (1)
PartnershipJoint RelationPartnershipPartnership
Joint RelationJoint RelationComplexComplex
CustomerRelationshipComplexity
CustomerRelationshipComplexity
SimpleSimple
• Not all customers have same value• Volume is not the selection criteria• The more complex the product and the morecomplex the customer, the more chance thereis to build a partnership and create value
• Not all customers have same value• Volume is not the selection criteria• The more complex the product and the morecomplex the customer, the more chance thereis to build a partnership and create value
OpportunisticPrice Driven
OpportunisticOpportunisticPrice DrivenPrice Driven
Systems/SolutionsSystems/SolutionsTransactionTransactionProduct/Service ComplexityProduct/Service Complexity
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 39 »
Positioning Model of Gosselin & Heene (2000)Positioning Model of Gosselin & Heene (2000)Positioning Model of Gosselin & Heene (2000)
Captive Customers
Captive Customers
Transactional Customers
Transactional Customers
Strategic AccountsStrategic AccountsKey AccountsKey Accounts
Relationship willingness(Customer)
Relationship willingness(Customer)
Competence Leverage Willingness
(Supplier)
Competence Leverage Willingness
(Supplier)
H
HL
L
Not stable: Invest in specific
solutionsor managefor profit
Not stable: Invest in specific
solutionsor managefor profit
Invest in relationship
or reduceinvestments
Invest in relationship
or reduceinvestments
Selection of International Accounts (2)Selection of International Accounts (2)
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 40 »
Selection of International Accounts (3) Selection of International Accounts (3)
7 S Model of Gosselin7 S Model of Gosselin7 S Model of Gosselin
Do the supplier and customer have and do they agree on a common strategy for the long term?Strategic FitStrategic Fit
If volume is low value with the customer, your value could be very low as well?Significant Significant
Margin or Potential MarginSoundSound
Do we want to be seen as a partner with this customer? Do we putenough resources to get him?SustainableSustainable
Do you want this type of customer? Is it a reference for future business?SympathySympathy
Cultural compatibilitySynergySynergy
Size of the customer marketScale Scale
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 41 »
Selection of International Accounts (4)Selection of International Accounts (4)
Outsource these customersNNN
Marginal interesting do not investNYN
Increase volume if possibleIncrease volume if possibleYNYY
Keep and invest in those Keep and invest in those customerscustomers
YYYY
Important but not strategicYYN
Keep but Do not further investYNN
Increase volume and profitabilityIncrease volume and profitabilityNNYY
Keep but Increase profitabilityKeep but Increase profitabilityNYYY
Generic strategyGeneric strategyProfitableProfitableSignificantSignificantStrategicStrategic
Model of WhitneyModel of Whitney
Source: J. Withney, 1996, HBR
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 42 »
Selection of International Accounts (5)Selection of International Accounts (5)
Model of McDonaldModel of McDonaldModel of McDonald
Manage for cash/withdrawMaintain
SelectivelyInvest
Invest/Grow
Competitive strengthCompetitive strength
Customer AttractivenessCustomer Attractiveness
H
H
L
L
Model is Model is based on based on
the classic the classic McKinsey McKinsey
modelmodel
Key accountsKey accounts
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 43 »
Issues in International Account Management
Issues in International Account Management
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 44 »
The Principles ofAccount Management Process
The Principles ofAccount Management Process
Source: Senn & Zeier 2000
Winning andkeeping
Strategic Customers
Building Long-term RelationsBuilding Long-term Relations
Developing Consistent Products/ServicesDeveloping Consistent Products/Services
Providing a Network OrganizationProviding a Network Organization
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 45 »
Where do successful Companies perform better ?
Where do successful Companies perform better ?
Study conducted by the University of St.Gallen: Senn 1998 & 1999, Senn & Arnold 1999:• N = 200, CS = Customer Satisfaction. High-low pairs significantly different at .01 level• Avg. CS of High Performing Group = 79%, Avg. CS of Low Performing Group = 63%• Results based on supplier performance resp. customer satisfaction ratings by their key accounts
65 % 40 %
68 % 42 %
69 % 46 %
Building Long-term RelationsBuilding Long-term Relations
Developing Consistent Products & ServicesDeveloping Consistent Products & Services
Providing a Network OrganizationProviding a Network Organization
High Performers
(Avg. Performance)
High Performers
(Avg. Performance)
Low Performers
(Avg. Performance)
Low Performers
(Avg. Performance)Account Management ProcessesAccount Management Processes
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 46 »
Building the Framework (I)Combining Processes with Implementation
Building the Framework (I)Combining Processes with Implementation
Defining Goalsand Objectivestogether withStrategic Accounts
Step I Step II
Aligning BusinessProcesses betweenSupplier & Customer Organization
Step III
Leveraging Know-how and accelerating Learning Processes
Building Long-term RelationsBuilding Long-term Relations
Developing ConsistentProducts & ServicesDeveloping ConsistentProducts & Services
Providing a Network OrganizationProviding a Network Organization
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Source: Senn 1994 – 1999, Senn & Zeier 2000
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 47 »
Defining Goalsand Objectivestogether withAccounts
Building the Framework (II) Nine Areas to allocate Account Resources
Building the Framework (II) Nine Areas to allocate Account Resources
Step I Step II Step III
Aligning BusinessProcesses betweenSupplier & Customer Organization
Leveraging Know-how and accelerating Learning Processes
Building Long-term RelationsBuilding Long-term Relations
Developing ConsistentProducts & ServicesDeveloping ConsistentProducts & Services
Providing a Network OrganizationProviding a Network Organization
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Source: Senn & Zeier 2000
CustomersCustomers
SolutionsSolutions
PeoplePeople
RelationshipsRelationships
ProcessesProcesses
StructuresStructures
KnowledgeKnowledge
SystemsSystems
InformationInformation
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 48 »
Key success drivers Key success drivers
# Successful International Account Management goes beyond „traditional“ customer relationship and sales management.
# It is essential to assess the relevant business drivers and allocate account resources accordingly.
# Successful International Account Management goes beyond „traditional“ customer relationship and sales management.
# It is essential to assess the relevant business drivers and allocate account resources accordingly.
CustomersCustomers
SolutionsSolutions
PeoplePeople
RelationshipsRelationships
ProcessesProcesses
StructuresStructures
KnowledgeKnowledge
SystemsSystems
InformationInformation
Benchmarks from an International Research Project; Measures based on Industrial Supplier Performancerated by Key Accounts, n = 200; Senn & Arnold (1999), Thexis No. 4, University of St.Gallen.
Key Success DriversKey Success Drivers
Classic Focus Classic Focus
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 49 »
Issues in International Account Management
Issues in International Account Management
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 50 »
Role of the International Account Manager
Role of the International Account Manager
RoleRoleRole
AMAMSupplierSupplier CustomerCustomer
• Sales person• Product seller• Interface• Relationship?• Team player?• Administration • Co-ordinator
• Sales person• Product seller• Interface• Relationship?• Team player?• Administration • Co-ordinator
IssuesIssuesIssues
• Culture• Management
Support• Communication• Systems/Process• Turf wars• Authority• workload/focus• Credibility
• Culture• Management
Support• Communication• Systems/Process• Turf wars• Authority• workload/focus• Credibility
Traditional International Key Account SellingTraditionalTraditional International Key Account SellingInternational Key Account Selling
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 51 »
99Industry & Market KnowledgeIndustry & Market KnowledgeIndustry & Market Knowledge
22Global Team leadership & ManagementGlobal Team leadership & ManagementGlobal Team leadership & Management
1010Customer KnowledgeCustomer KnowledgeCustomer Knowledge
77Cultural EmpathyCultural EmpathyCultural Empathy
55Strategic Vision & PlanningStrategic Vision & PlanningStrategic Vision & Planning
33Business & Financial KnowledgeBusiness & Financial KnowledgeBusiness & Financial Knowledge
88Selling SkillsSelling SkillsSelling Skills
66Problem Solving CapabilitiesProblem Solving CapabilitiesProblem Solving Capabilities
44Relationship management skillsRelationship management skillsRelationship management skills
11Communication skillsCommunication skillsCommunication skills
International Account ManagerCompetences
International Account ManagerCompetences
Source: A. Millman & K. Wilson, 2000Source: A. Millman & K. Wilson, 2000
Importance RankingImportance Ranking1 = Most Important10 = Less Important1 = Most Important10 = Less Important
SellingSelling
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 52 »
International Account Manager:Competence Profile
International Account Manager:Competence Profile
Analyst
PoliticianCoordinatorStrategist
POLITICALENTREPRENEUR:
• Influence power• Take opportunities
POLITICALENTREPRENEUR:
• Influence power• Take opportunities
The International account manager must have the capability to solve problems for the customer and realize entrepreneurial opportunities thru the coordination and application of personal, team and organizational competences, withouthaving the full control over all resources.
The International account manager must have the capability to solve problems for the customer and realize entrepreneurial opportunities thru the coordination and application of personal, team and organizational competences, withouthaving the full control over all resources.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 53 »
Impact of the context onCompetences
Impact of the context onCompetences
pEEntrepreneur
peSales
PEPotential
CEO ?
PeRelational Manager
Degree of organisational Interdependence and Integration
Degree of organisational Interdependence and Integration
Levels of Organisational complexity
Levels of Organisational complexity
H
H
L
L P: Political E: EntrepreneurialP: Political E: Entrepreneurial
International AccountManagement
International AccountInternational AccountManagementManagement
Key AccountKey AccountManagementManagement
Key Account SellingKey Account Selling
Source: SAMA, K. Wilson, 2000
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 54 »
Issues in International Account Management
Issues in International Account Management
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Other Issues
" Advanced Research
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 55 »
Other IssuesOther Issues
❏ Organization structure: Who’s the Boss?❏ Cultural elements❏ New opportunities❏ Customer is no longer a Key account❏ Key Account Plan❏ Training❏ Internal Communication❏ Compensation plans❏ Role: Sales, BD or Executive Management?❏ Accountability: P&L or not?
❏ Organization structure: Who’s the Boss?❏ Cultural elements❏ New opportunities❏ Customer is no longer a Key account❏ Key Account Plan❏ Training❏ Internal Communication❏ Compensation plans❏ Role: Sales, BD or Executive Management?❏ Accountability: P&L or not?
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 56 »
Issues in International Account Management
Issues in International Account Management
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Culture
" Advanced Research
" Types of Account Management
" Selection of International accounts
" Process & Resource allocation
" Competence
" Culture
" Advanced Research
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 57 »
Market Performance inStrategic Account Management
Market Performance inStrategic Account Management
Preliminary Research on Strategic Account Management at Ghent University, Department of Management and Organization (FEB) suggests with a high probability that:
Preliminary Research on Strategic Account Management at Ghent University, Department of Management and Organization (FEB) suggests with a high probability that:
Source: D.P. Gosselin, 2000
(*) Growth in % Customer Market Share and % of Company Portfolio sold to the Account
1. The market performance (*) of suppliers with a strategic customers is related to the PLC of the customer. This implies a process of dynamic allocation of resources: different relational behaviours at different times and the willingness to invest in specific and time related customers solutions using all available company competences.
2. The market performance of a supplier is higher with strategic selected customers if the supplier adjust his offer and performance according to the PLC of the customer’s Decision Units.
3. Market performance with strategic customers is higher if an explicit and recognized fit exists between the strategies of both the supplier and the customer.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 58 »
International Account Performance modelInternational Account Performance model
1. Scope of Account2. Communication3. Support Systems
1.1. Scope of Scope of AccountAccount2.2. CommunicationCommunication3.3. Support Support SystemsSystems
Experience of account manager
Experience Experience of of accountaccount managermanager
AccountPerformance
Efficiency and Sales GrowthPartnership with Customers
AccountAccountPerformancePerformance
Efficiency andEfficiency and Sales Sales GrowthGrowthPartnership with CustomersPartnership with Customers
Centralization of vendoractivities versus customer
Customer dependence on vendor
CentralizationCentralization of of vendorvendoractivitiesactivities versus versus customercustomer
Customer dependence Customer dependence on on vendorvendor
Mechanisms for enhancing information processing capacity
Mechanisms for enhancing information processing capacity
Factors affecting relative bargaining power of vendor
Factors affecting relative bargaining power of vendor
Model of Birkinshaw, Toulan and Arnold, 2001Model of Birkinshaw, Toulan and Arnold, 2001
Key element of Performance is
organisation innovation toincrease information
processing
Key Key element element of of Performance Performance isis
organisation innovation toorganisation innovation toincreaseincrease informationinformation
processing processing
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 59 »
CONTENTCONTENT
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 60 »
Key Success Factors#1
Key Success Factors#1
Visible an Tangible Top Management Support.
It must be part of the strategy to build a customer driven organisation
Visible an Tangible Top Management Support.
It must be part of the strategy to build a customer driven organisation
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 61 »
Key Success Factors#2
Key Success Factors#2
All elements of the organization must be
involved and educated in the International Account
management processes and must known the objectives.
All elements of the organization must be
involved and educated in the International Account
management processes and must known the objectives.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 62 »
Key Success Factors#3
Key Success Factors#3
The company must track progress on each account thru measurable milestone
activities
The company must track progress on each account thru measurable milestone
activities
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 63 »
Key Success Factors#4
Key Success Factors#4
In global or international account management Focus
on a limited number of accounts is essential to be
able to deliver what ispromissed.
Conflicts of resourceallocation.
Trust thru performance.
In global or international account management Focus
on a limited number of accounts is essential to be
able to deliver what ispromissed.
Conflicts of resourceallocation.
Trust thru performance.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 64 »
Key Success Factors#5
Key Success Factors#5
The international account manager must have the authority to commit the
company.
The international account manager must have the authority to commit the
company.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 65 »
Key Success Factors#6
Key Success Factors#6
Executive Management must be available for Relationship building.
Executive Management must be available for Relationship building.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 66 »
Key Success Factors#7
Key Success Factors#7
International Account Management is another
business: Need Separate communications channels
towards customer and internal.
International Account Management is another
business: Need Separate communications channels
towards customer and internal.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 67 »
Key Success Factors#8
Key Success Factors#8
First objective is to penetrate the account as High and as
Deep Possible. Cover all DMU:
Decision MakersInfluencersApprovers.
First objective is to penetrate the account as High and as
Deep Possible. Cover all DMU:
Decision MakersInfluencersApprovers.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 68 »
Key Success Factors#9
Key Success Factors#9
The compensation of the Account Management Program
must not compete with the field sales force compensation
plan or with any other group that must support them.
The compensation of the Account Management Program
must not compete with the field sales force compensation
plan or with any other group that must support them.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 69 »
Key Success Factors#10
Key Success Factors#10
International Account Managers must have a broad cross cultural experience and
must act more as business executives than as sales
executives.
International Account Managers must have a broad cross cultural experience and
must act more as business executives than as sales
executives.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 70 »
CONTENTCONTENT
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
❏ Issues in Account Management
❏ Definitions of Account Management
❏ Why Account Management?
❏ Issues in International Account Management
❏ Key Success Factors: lessons from experience
❏ Conclusions
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 71 »
Conclusions (1)Conclusions (1)
❏ 5-7 times more easy and cost effective to grow the existing customer base.
❏ Value of a “Strategic Relationship” is worth 15% price increase.
❏ Select customers on “Relationship” potential, strategic fit and your willigness to invest in specific competence leverage
❏ The major issues in International Account Management are related to Cultural skills.
❏ 5-7 times more easy and cost effective to grow the existing customer base.
❏ Value of a “Strategic Relationship” is worth 15% price increase.
❏ Select customers on “Relationship” potential, strategic fit and your willigness to invest in specific competence leverage
❏ The major issues in International Account Management are related to Cultural skills.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 72 »
Conclusions (2)Conclusions (2)
❏ Building a customer focused organisation for competitive advantage in business markets implies to manage a customer base thru strategic account management
❏ The International account manager should coordinate the dynamic resource allocation and solution adjustment related to the PLC of the customer: This is a top management function.
❏ Top management should understand their role, the change impact, investments and process implications needed to introduce Strategic account management: It takes time, money, vision and leadership to succeed.
❏ Building a customer focused organisation for competitive advantage in business markets implies to manage a customer base thru strategic account management
❏ The International account manager should coordinate the dynamic resource allocation and solution adjustment related to the PLC of the customer: This is a top management function.
❏ Top management should understand their role, the change impact, investments and process implications needed to introduce Strategic account management: It takes time, money, vision and leadership to succeed.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 73 »
Conclusion (3)Conclusion (3)
International Account Management is a contingency
approach:No one best way to solve the
problem.
International Account Management is a contingency
approach:No one best way to solve the
problem.
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 74 »
References (1)References (1)
❏ SAMA: Strategic Account Management Association : http://www.nams.org
❏ Research on Strategic Account management Ghent University: http://studwww.rug.ac.be/~dgosseli
❏ Research on Sales & Account Management Erasmus University: http://www.erasmusforum.nl/index.html
❏ Sales Research Trust of Dr. Kevin Wilson: http://www.sales-research-trust.org
❏ Derrick-Philippe GOSSELIN: [email protected]
All rights reserved © 2001, D.P. Gosselin.« Rotterdam, Erasmus University, 31.01. 2001, page n° 75 »
References (2)References (2)
❏ Lewis, J.D. (2000) « Trusted Partners, How Companies build Mutual Trust and Win Together », Free Press: New York
❏ Verbeke, W and Nagy, J. (2000) « Adaptief en Strategisch Accountmanagement », Samsom: Alphen a/d Rijn, Netherlands.
❏ McDonald, M. and Rogers, B. (1998) « Key Account Management », Butterworth Heinemann: Oxford, UK.
❏ Day, G.S. (1999) « The Market Driven Organization », Free Press: New York
❏ Trompenaars, F. and Hampden-Turner, C. (1997) « Riding the waves of culture », 2 edition, Nicholas Brealey Publishing: London
❏ Lewis, J.D. (2000) « Trusted Partners, How Companies build Mutual Trust and Win Together », Free Press: New York
❏ Verbeke, W and Nagy, J. (2000) « Adaptief en Strategisch Accountmanagement », Samsom: Alphen a/d Rijn, Netherlands.
❏ McDonald, M. and Rogers, B. (1998) « Key Account Management », Butterworth Heinemann: Oxford, UK.
❏ Day, G.S. (1999) « The Market Driven Organization », Free Press: New York
❏ Trompenaars, F. and Hampden-Turner, C. (1997) « Riding the waves of culture », 2 edition, Nicholas Brealey Publishing: London