IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ......

21
! !"#$%&’ )* !’) +,--- %./&!*!%$&!)0 )0 12’!0.’’ #./*)/"$0%. "#$%&’(#)*& ,&-.&/01. ! #12 3#*&$%& 45#&1 6 !"#$%&’#(% *+(,-.#/0% 1% 2-0$+#" 3"’(#(0( 14516#"#’(&+(#-" %( 1% 7%’(#-" *%"(&% 8"(&%9&#’%:8"$#&-""%6%"( ;.+<% 1%’ =->%"’? @ A @BCD 2-0$+#":.+:E%0$% A%.F#06 @ G%. H IBJK@LKCMKDCKMM N+O H IBJK@LKCMKDBKJC 8:6+#. H P%’(%6-"(Q6+&PK0<.K+<KR% J G%. H IBJK@LKCMKS@KTU N+O H IBJK@LKCMKDBKJC 8:6+#. H ’V+%"Q6+&PK0<.K+<KR% $1’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ustainability at the Millenium: Globalization, Competitiveness and the Public Trust January 21-25, 2001 Ninth International Conference of Greening of Industry Network Bangkok

Transcript of IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ......

Page 1: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!

!"#$%&'()*(!')(+,---(%./&!*!%$&!)0()0(12'!0.''#./*)/"$0%.

"#$%&'(#)*&+,&-.&/01.!+#12+3#*&$%&+45#&16

!"#$%&'#(%)*+(,-.#/0%)1%)2-0$+#"3"'(#(0()14516#"#'(&+(#-")%()1%)7%'(#-"*%"(&%)8"(&%9&#'%:8"$#&-""%6%"(;.+<%)1%')=->%"'?)@)A)@BCD)2-0$+#":.+:E%0$%)A%.F#06@G%.)H)IBJK@LKCMKDCKMM)N+O)H)IBJK@LKCMKDBKJC8:6+#.)H)P%'(%6-"(Q6+&PK0<.K+<KR%

JG%.)H)IBJK@LKCMKS@KTU)N+O)H)IBJK@LKCMKDBKJC8:6+#.)H)'V+%"Q6+&PK0<.K+<KR%

$1'&/$%&

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

E1+ .8&+ :01.&P.+ 0?+ %1.&$1#.%01#*+ #:.%<%.%&-+ 0?+ .8&+ 0$9#1%-#.%01-+ #12+ %1+ .8&+ -;%$%.+ 0?+ 9*0@#*-.#.)-+0?+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.C+5&+2&<&*0;+#1+%1.&$1#.%01#*+:0/;#$#.%<&+#1#*>-%-C+;0%1.%19+0).805+#12+.0+58#.+&P.&1.+%1<&-./&1.+%1+E4F!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01+$&#**>+8&*;-+.8&+0$9#1%-#.%01-#12+@$%19-+%1+$&.)$1-A

78&+ $&-&#$:8+ %-+ @#-&2+ 01+ #1+ %1.&$1#.%01#*+ -)$<&>+ :012):.&2+ %1+ O)$0;&#1+ #12+ Q-%#1:0)1.$%&-A+78&+/&#-)$&/&1.+%1-.$)/&1.+%-+#+-.#12#$2%-&2+=)&-.%011#%$&+/#%*&2+.0+#+-#/;*&0?+:&$.%?%&2+0$9#1%-#.%01-+%1+.8&+2%??&$&1.+:0)1.$%&-A4&<&$#*+2%/&1-%01-+#$&+%1<&-.%9#.&2+%1+.8&+;0.&1.%#*+%/;#:.-+0?+E4F!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01+010$9#1%-#.%01-R+ 0;&$#.%01#*+ :0-.-C+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ %/;#:.-C+ %1-)$#1:&+ $#.&-C+ :0/;&.%.%<&#2<#1.#9&C+:0$;0$#.&+#12+/#$S&.%19+%/#9&C+-.#S&80*2&$-D+-#.%-?#:.%01AAA

345(6789:;(E4F+!LJJJC+@)-%1&--+;&$?0$/#1:&C+-0:%#*+:0//%./&1.C+O)$0;&C+Q-%#A

Sustainability at the Millenium: Globalization, Competitiveness and the Public TrustJanuary 21-25, 2001 Ninth International Conference of Greening of Industry Network Bangkok

Page 2: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

6

+<! !0&/)=2%&!)0

T>+ .8&+ !UVJD-C+ .8&+ :01:&$1+ ?0$+ .8&+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ 2&9$#2#.%01+ @&9#1+ .0+ #;;$0#:8+ #+ .$)&%1.&$1#.%01#*+ /#--+ /0<&/&1.A+ Q+ @&*%&?+ #;;&#$&2+ .8#.+ 01*>+ 90<&$1/&1.+ 5#-+ :#;#@*&+ 0?-0*<%19+&1<%$01/&1.#*+ #12+ -0:%#*+ ;$0@*&/-A+78&+ ?%$-.+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+/0<&/&1.+5#-+ .8&1:&1.$&2+ 01+ F-$%&"6%"() &%F0.+(#-"'+ #-+ .8&+ <&8%:*&+ ?0$+ :8#19&A+ E1+ .8&+ !UKJ-C+ .8&-&$&9)*#.%01-+ :01-%-.&2+ %1+ *%1&#$C+ $&#:.%<&C+ &12'0?';%;&+ #;;$0#:8&-C+ &/;8#-%-%19+ ;0**).%01:01.$0*+ #12+ #28&$&1:&+ .0+ *&9%-*#.%<&+ -.#12#$2-A+ B0.8%19+ &1:0)$#9&-+ :0/;#1%&-+ .0+ 90@&>012+:0/;*%#1:&+5%.8+.8&+*#5A

F<&$+ .%/&C+ .8&+9$05%19+:01:&$1+ .0+/#%1.#%1+#12+ %/;$0<&+ .8&+=)#*%.>+0?+ .8&+ &1<%$01/&1.#12+.0+;$0.&:.+8)/#1+8&#*.8+8#-+*&2+0$9#1%-#.%01-+.0+#--)/&+#+*#$9&$+$&-;01-%@%*%.>+0?+.8&%$#:.%<%.%&-A+($0'#:.%<&+?%$/-+2&-%$&2+.0+2&/01-.$#.&+.0+$&9)*#.0$-+#12+0.8&$+-.#S&80*2&$-+.8#.:01.%1)0)-+ %/;$0<&/&1.+ %1+ .8&+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ #$&#+ :#1+ @&+ #:8%&<&2+ /0$&+ &??&:.%<&*>.8$0)98+ $-.0"(+&>) +99&-+<,%'A+ E1+ .8&+ *#.&+ !UWJ-C+ :02&-+ 0?+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ /#1#9&/&1.;$#:.%:&C+ ;#$.1&$-8%;+ ;$09$#/-C+ -&*?'$&9)*#.%01C+ :02&-+ 0?+ :012):.-C+ &1<%$01/&1.#*#9$&&/&1.-+&/&$9&2+#-+.00*-+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;0*%:>A+Q+1)/@&$+0?+/#X0$+:0/;#1%&-+8#2#*$&#2>+@)%*.+-.$019+&??&:.%<&+->-.&/-+?0$+/#1#9%19+.8&%$+&1<%$01/&1.#*+#:.%<%.%&-A+"0-.+0?.8&/+ 8#<&+ -8051+ 0).-.#12%19+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ $&-)*.-+ 5%.8+ .8&%$+ %12%<%2)#*+ /#1#9&/&1.#;;$0#:8+G4)12&$*#12C+!UUVHA

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

O/@$#:&2+ @>+ 0<&$+ 01&+ 8)12$&2+ :0)1.$%&-C+ #20;.&2+ @>+ -0/&+ 0?+ .8&+ *#$9&-.+/)*.%1#.%01#*:0$;0$#.%01-+ %1+ .8&+50$*2C+ E4F+!LJJJ+ %-+:01-%2&$&2+ %1:$&#-%19*>+#-+ #+<%.#*+ :0/;01&1.+0?.8&+%1.&$1#.%01#*+@)-%1&--+:0//)1%.>A

B&<&$.8&*&--C+805+%/;0$.#1.+:0)*2+-&&/+.8&+<#*)&+0?+Y:01?0$/#1:&Y+.0+-):8+-.#12#$2-+#1210$/-C+ /#1>+ 0$9#1%-#.%01-+ #$&+ -.%**+ 8&29%19C+ )1-)$&+ 58&.8&$+ .8&+ @&1&?%.-+ 0?%/;*&/&1.#.%01+#$&+50$.8+.8&%$+.%/&C+$&-0)$:&-+#12+#..&1.%01A+Z%/%.#.%01-+#12+:#<&#.-+&P%-.C.8#.+:#1+&P;*#%1+$&-&$<#.%01-+0?+0$9#1%-#.%01-A

I01-&=)&1.*>C+%1+0$2&$+.0+)12&$-.#12+.8&+2%??&$&1.+;0%1.-+0?+<%&5+$&*#.&2+.0+E4F+!LJJJC+0)$-.)2>+#%/-+#.+ ;0%1.%19+0).+805+ #12+ .0+58#.+ &P.&1.+ %1<&-./&1.+ %1+ E4F!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01$&#**>+8&*;-+0$9#1%-#.%01-+#12+R&#"F')#")&%(0&"'A+"0$&+;$&:%-&*>C+.8%-+$&-&#$:8+%1<&-.%9#.&-58%:8+ #:.%<%.%&-+ #$&+ 2&<&*0;&2+ @>+ :&$.%?%&2+ :0/;#1%&-+ #12+ 58%:8+ @&1&?%.-+ #$&+ 0@.#%1&2.8$0)98+E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01A

78&+;#;&$+%-+2&<&*0;&2+01+.8&+?0**05%19+-.$):.)$&A+78&+$&-&#$:8+.8&0$&.%:#*+?$#/&50$S+%-2&.#%*&2+%1+(#$.+6R+.8&+E4F+!LJJJ+?&#.)$&-+#12+$&=)%$&/&1.-+#$&+;$&-&1.&2+?%$-.+?0**05&2+@>#+*%.&$#.)$&+$&<%&5+#@0).+.8&+;0.&1.%#*+:0-.-+#12+@&1&?%.-+#--0:%#.&2+5%.8+E4F+:&$.%?%:#.%01A78&+$&-&#$:8+/&.8020*09>+:01:*)2&-+ .8%-+-&:012+;#$.A+78&+&/;%$%:#*+#1#*>-%-+#12+$&-)*.-

Page 3: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

[

#$&+2%-:)--&2+%1+(#$.+[A+\%1#**>C+.8&+:01:*)-%01+9%<&-+#1+0<&$<%&5+0?+.8&+;$%1:%;#*+*&#$1%19#-+5&**+#-+.8&+;$%1:%;#*+*%/%.#.%01-+0?+.8%-+$&-&#$:8A

><! &?.)/.&!%$@(*/$".A)/3

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`$S&>C!UUV_+a#**#:&'b01&-C+!UUWHA

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

\)$.8&$/0$&C+.8%-+-.#12#$2+8#-+@&&1+5$%..&1+.0+#::0//02#.&+2%<&$-&+9&09$#;8%:#*C+:)*.)$#*#12+ -0:%#*+ :012%.%01-A+ 78%-+ 0??&$-+ .8&+ #2<#1.#9&+ 0?+ ?#:%*%.#.%19+ %1.&$1#.%01#*+ .$#2&C+ -%1:&E4F+ %-+ #;;*%:#@*&+ %1+ #**+ :0)1.$%&-A+ "0$&0<&$C+ #**+ 0$9#1%-#.%01-+ ?$0/+ #1>+ .>;&G/#1)?#:.)$%19C+ -&$<%:&C+ 90<&$1/&1.-+2&;#$./&1.H+ #12+#1>+ -%c&+ :0)*2+ #-S+ .0+@&+ :&$.%?%&2E4F+!LJJJA

N05&<&$C+ .8&+ -.#12#$2+ %1<0*<&-+ -:&;.%:%-/+ ?$0/+ ;)@*%:+ #2<0:#:>+ 9$0);-+ #12+ .8&&1<%$01/&1.#*+ :0//)1%.>C+ 58%:8+ 8#<&+ @&&1+ *#$9&*>+ &P:*)2&2+ ?$0/+ ;#$.%:%;#.%01+ %1+ .8&2&<&*0;/&1.+0?+ .8&+ -.#12#$2A+40/&+&1<%$01/&1.#*+ 9$0);-+ #12+:01-)/&$-+ 0?.&1+ $#%-&+ .8&$%-S+0?+#@)-&R+.8&>+20+10.+@&*%&<&+.8#.+E4F+!LJJJ+50)*2+*&#2+.0+%/;$0<&2+&1<%$01/&1.#*;$0.&:.%01A+ \%$-.*>C+ E4F+ %-+ #+/#1#9&/&1.+ -.#12#$2+ #12+ 10.+ #+ ;&$?0$/#1:&+ -.#12#$2C+ .8%-0??&$-+.8&+;0--%@%*%.>+.0+:0/;#1%&-+.0+)-&+E4F+:&$.%?%:#.%01+01*>+#-+#+90R.#<)&%.+(#-"')(--.5%.80).+#1>+#--)$#1:&-+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+@&1&?%.-+G($%19*&+#12+\%.c9&$#*2C+!UUWHA+4&:012*>CE4F+!LJJJ+20&-+10.+ $&=)%$&+-)??%:%&1.+;)@*%:+2%-:*0-)$&+0?+ ?%$/-D+&1<%$01/&1.#*+ %/;#:.-A78&+*&<&*+0?+-.#S&80*2&$+%1<0*<&/&1.+%-+*&?.+.0+.8&+2%-:$&.%01+0?+.8&+?%$/+#12+.8%-+:0)*2+@&01&+0?+.8&+-.#12#$2+2$#5@#:S-A

E1+ .8&+ ?0**05%19+ ;#$.-C+ .8&+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ $&=)%$&/&1.-+ 5%**+ @&+ 2&.#%*&2+ #12+ .8&+ &P%-.%19*%.&$#.)$&+ #@0).+ .8&+ ;0.&1.%#*+ @&1&?%.-+ #12+ :0-.-+ #--0:%#.&2+ 5%.8+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ 5%**+ @&-)//#$%-&2A+ 78&+ *#-.+ ;#$.+ ;$&-&1.-+ 0)$+ :0/;*&.&+ $&-&#$:8+ ?$#/&50$S+ #-+ 5&**+ #-+ 0)$/&.8020*09>A

Page 4: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

L

><+<!(!')(+,---(84BCD84E4FG:

E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01+$&=)%$&-+?$0/+:0/;#1%&-+.8&+?)*?%*/&1.+0?+2%??&$&1.+#:.%<%.%&-+.8#.:#1+@&+-)//#$%-&2+@>+.8&+.&1+?0**05%19+9$0);-+0?+#:.%01-R

• ! 78&+ :$&#.%01+ 0?+ #1+ %"$#&-"6%"(+.) 9-.#<>C+ -);;0$.&2+ @>+ -&1%0$+ /#1#9&/&1.C+ 58%:8%1:*)2&-+ #+ d:0//%./&1.e+ .0+ :0/;*%#1:&+ @0.8+ 5%.8+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ *#5-+ #12+ 5%.8;$&<&1.%01+0?+;0**).%01A

• ! 78&+%2&1.%?%:#.%01+0?+#**+$&*&<#1.+%"$#&-"6%"(+.)+'9%<('+ .8#.+/#>+#$%-&+01+.8&+-%.&+#12:01-&=)&1.*>+ .8&+ 2&:*#$#.%01+ 0?+ :0/;#1>D-+ ;$%/#$>+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ -R[%<(#$%'+ #12(+&F%('C+.80-&+.8#.+:#1+8#<&+/0-.+&1<%$01/&1.#*+%/;#:.-A

• ! 78&+ :$&#.%01+ 0?+ #1) 8"$#&-"6%"(+.) W+"+F%6%"() Y>'(%6+ GO"4H+ .8#.+ %1:*)2&-+ #18"$#&-"6%"(+.)W+"+F%6%"();&-F&+6)Gf+.8&+;*#1+.0+#:8%&<&+-;&:%?%:+90#*-+#12+.#$9&.-.8#.+ 2&-:$%@&-+ .8&+ /&#1-+ .0+ $&#:8+ .80-&+ 0@X&:.%<&-H+ #12+ .8#.+ &-.#@*%-8&-+ ;$0:&2)$&-C50$S+ %1-.$):.%01-C+ #12+ :01.$0*-+ .0+ &1-)$&+ .8#.+ %/;*&/&1.#.%01+ 0?+ .8&+ ;0*%:>+ #12#:8%&<&/&1.+0?+.#$9&.-+:#1+@&:0/&+#+$&#*%.>A

• ! 78&) #69.%6%"(+(#-") +"1) -9%&+(#-"+ 0?+ .8&+ O"4+ G805+ .8&+ ;$09$#/+ 90&-+ %1+ ;$#:.%:&C2&-%91#.%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+$&-;01-%@*&C+@&1:8/#$S%19+#:.%<%.%&-gHA

• ! 78&+ #"(%&"+.) +"1) %O(%&"+.) <-660"#<+(#-"+ 0?+ .8&+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ ;0*%:>A+ 78&+ %1.&$1#*:0//)1%:#.%01+&1#@*&-+;&0;*&+%1+.8&+0$9#1%-#.%01+.0+@&+#5#$&+0?+.8&%$+$&-;01-%@%*%.%&-C0?+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.#*+%/;#:.-+0?+?%$/D-+#:.%<%.%&-+#12+.8&+%/;0$.#1:&+0?+:01?0$/%19+.0.8&+ ?%$/D-+ O"4g+ 78&+ &P.&$1#*+ :0//)1%:#.%01+ &1#@*&-+ &P.&$1#*+ -.#S&80*2&$-G:0//)1%.>C+:01-)/&$-gH+.0+@&+#5#$&+0?+.8&+:0/;#1>+&1<%$01/&1.#*+:0//%./&1.A

• ! 78&+ 1-<06%"(+(#-"+ #@0).+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ %--)&-C+ #@0).+ ;$0:&2)$&-+ ?0$+ 8#12*%19&/&$9&1:%&-g

• ! 78&)(&+#"#"F+;$0<%2&2+?0$+50$S&$-+5%.8+;0.&1.%#*+&1<%$01/&1.#*+%/;#:.-C• ! 78&)-9%&+(#-"+.)<-"(&-.C+58%:8+%1<0*<&-+.8&+%2&1.%?%:#.%01+0?+0;&$#.%01-+#12+#:.%<%.%&-C#--0:%#.&2+5%.8+-%91%?%:#1.+&1<%$01/&1.#*+#-;&:.-+#12+.8&+2&<&*0;/&1.+0?+;$0:&2)$&-C58%:8+/%1%/%-&+.8&+$%-S+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+%/;#:.-A

• ! 78&)<,%<P#"F)+"1)<-&&%<(#$%)+<(#-"'R+&-.#@*%-8%19+;$0:&2)$&-+.0+/01%.0$+#12+/&#-)$&0;&$#.%01-+#12+#:.%<%.%&-+.8#.+8#<&+-%91%?%:#1.+%/;#:.+01+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.C+&-.#@*%-8%19#12+ /#%1.#%1%19+ ;$0:&2)$&-+ ?0$+ ;$&<&1.%19+ .8&+ $&:)$$&1:&+ 0?+ 101+ :01?0$/#1:&C&-.#@*%-8%19+&1<%$01/&1.#*+$&:0$2'S&&;%19+;$0:&--&-+#12+;&$%02%:++01#('+0?+.8&+O"4+.0&1-)$&+ .8#.+ %.+ %-+ &??&:.%<&+ %1+ 0;&$#.%01-+ #12+ .8#.+ .8&+ ->-.&/+ :01.%1)&-+ .0+ ;&$?0$/+ %1#::0$2#1:&+5%.8+$&*&<#1.+$&9)*#.%01-+#12+-.#12#$2-A

• ! 78&) W+"+F%6%"() &%$#%V+ 0?+ .8&+ ->-.&/+ .0+ &1-)$&+ .8#.+ %.+ %-+ -)%.#@*&+ #12+ &??&:.%<&+ %10;&$#.%01-A

78&-&+2%??&$&1.+#:.%<%.%&-+5%**+@&+%1<&-.%9#.&2+%1+0)$+$&-&#$:8+%1+0$2&$+.0+&<#*)#.&+.0+58%:82&9$&&+:&$.%?%&2+:0/;#1%&-+ %/;*&/&1.+ .8&-&+!J+2%??&$&1.+ .>;&-+0?+ #:.%<%.%&-+#12+58%:8+0?.8&-&+#:.%<%.%&-+#$&+;$%0$%.%-&2+#12+%1<&$-&*>+*&--+&/;8#-%-&2A

><><!(14F4HDG:(IF9(J7:G:(7H(!')(+,---(J48GDHDJIGD7F

T&1&?%.-+#12+:0-.-+0?+E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01+#$&+0?.&1+#2/%..&2+5%.80).+;$00?A+"#1#9&$-#12+ :01-)*.#1.-+ ;$&-&1.&2+ .8&/+ #-+ 90%19+ 5%.80).+ -#>%19A+ 40/&+ #).80$-+ -):8+ #-+ (&$$>b081-01+G!UUKH+#$9)&R+ h#X)>-0)V+#() X-&)9&--X) (,+() 3YZ)@CLLL) #')$#(+.)+"1)%XX%<(#$%)R%X-&%F%((#"F)#"$-.$%1?)\]^)>-0)V#..)R%)R>9+''%1)+"1)-0(<.+''%1_A

Page 5: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

i

N05&<&$C+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ %-+ 0?.&1+ :%.&2+ @>+ @)-%1&--+ #-+ <%#@*&+ #12+ &??%:%&1.#*.&$1#.%<&-+ .0+ $&9)*#.%01-A+j&.+ %1+ ;$#:.%:&C+ -):8+ #;;$0#:8+ %/;*%&-+ ?0$+/0-.+ :0/;#1%&-+ #:01-%2&$#@*&+ &??0$.+ %1+ .&$/-+ 0?+ 8)/#1C+ ?%1#1:%#*+ #12+ .&:81%:#*+ $&-0)$:&-+ GT%012%+ &.+ #*AC!UUWHA

T#-&2+ 01+ *%.&$#.)$&+ $&<%&5C+ 7#@*&+ !+ ;$&-&1.-+ 2%??&$&1.+ ;0.&1.%#*+ @&1&?%.-+ #12+ :0-.-+ .8#./#1#9&$-C+:01-)*.#1.-+#12+$&-&#$:8&$-+#**0:#.&+;$&:%-&*>+.0+.8&+E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01+0$9&1&$#**>+.0+<0*)1.#$>+&1<%$01/&1.#*+#;;$0#:8&-A

7#@*&+!A((0.&1.%#*+:0-.-k@&1&?%.-+0?+)-%19+E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01<!EKIJG:(7H(!')(+,---(7F; #7:DGDL4(DEKIJG:(MICGN78:O 04PIGDL4(DEKIJG:

MICGN78:O#/)=2%&!)0

O1&$9>+:01-)/;.%01 `%10<#"F+G4)12&$*#12+l+(#.1&>+l+T#>*%-+&.+#*Am+lT%012%+&.+#*A+l+T&*c+&.+#*AmH

a#-.&+/#1#9&/&1. `%10<#"F+G(#.1&>+l+T%012%+&.+#*A+'+T&*c+&.+#*AmHE110<#.%01 N-'(%&)#""-$+(#$%)'-.0(#-"'+G($%19*&+l+T%012%+&.+#*A+l

b081-01H($02):.%<%.> 3"<&%+'#"F)10%)(-)9&-<%'')<-"(&-.'+Gb081-01+l+T%012%

&.+#*AHT)-%1&--+%1.&$$);.%01+'+n&2&-%91C

$&50$S+'+7%/&+.0+/#$S&.`%10<#"F+G4)12&$*#12H

F$9#1%-#.%01#*+#12+/#1#9&$%#*&??%:%&1:>

3"<&%+'#"F+Gb081-01+l+T%012%+&.+#*A+l+EE4oC+p*0@#*p$&&1+4.#12#$2-H

E1:%2&1.-+#12+*%#@%*%.%&- `%10<#"F)GEE4oC+p*0@#*+p$&&1+4.#12#$2-H"01%.0$%19+0?+:0/;*%#1:& *-"(#"0-0'+Gb081-01+l+T%012%+&.+#*AHO1<%$01/&1.#*+;$0.&:.%01 3"<&%+'#"F+G($%19*&+l+,%1-&**#+l+T%012%+&.+#*AH E-)1#&%<()#69+<(

GI0$@&..l+B#-8mH"$/3.&!0Q

p*0@#*+/#$S&.+0;;0$.)1%.%&- ;-'#(#$%)X+<(-&+G(#.1&>+l+T0$98%1%+#12+3%:%1%lb081-01+l+4)12&$*#12+'+EE4oC+p*0@#*+p$&&1

4.#12#$2-HI0/;&.%.%<&+#2<#1.#9& 7+#"%1+G,%1-&**#+'+(#.1&>'+T&*c+&.+#*AmH

4#*&- 3"<&%+'#"F+Gb081-01+'+T&*c+&.+#*AmH"#$S&.#@%*%.>+0?+:0/;#1>D-+;$02):.- 3"<&%+'#"F+Gb081-01+'+T&*c+&.+#*AmHI0$;0$#.&+%/#9&+#12+90025%** 3"<&%+'#"F+G4.0&--&$l($%19*&+l+,%1-&**#+l+(#.1&>+l

p*&:S/#1+#12+,$).+l+4)12&$*#12+l+b081-01+l+T%012%&.+#*A+'+T&*c+&.+#*Am'+EE4oC+p*0@#*+p$&&1+4.#12#$2-H

E1.&$1#*+#12+&P.&$1#*+.$#1-;#$&1:> 3"<&%+'#"F+Gp&*@&$+&.+#*AmH 2+<P)-X)(&+"'9+&%"<>Ga#**#:&'b01&-mH

*!0$0%.I0-.-+%1+0;&$#.%19+#12+/#.&$%#*- *-'(')'+$#"F'+Gb081-01+l+T`$S&>m+#12+B#2#qml

4)12&$*#12+l+(#.1&>+l+T%012%+&.+#*A+l+T&*c+&.+#*AmH3"<&%+'#"F+GT#>*%-m+la#**&>m+#12+a8%.&8&#2m

'+T%012%+&.+#*AHI0-.-+2)&+.0+.8&+*&<&*+0?+?0$/#*%.>+k

o0:)/&1.-+k+T)$&#):$#:>369-&(+"()<-'('

G4)12&$*#12+l+(#.1&>'T%012%+&.+#*AH

n&-#*&+<#*)&+0?+:0/;#1>D-+;$0;&$.>#--&.-

A%((%&)&%'+.%)$+.0%+G($%19*&H

Z&<&*+0?+$%-S-+G2)&+.0+/)*.%;*&+#12:01?*%:.%19+&1<%$01/&1.#*

$&9)*#.%01-H

W#"#6#'+(#-"+Gp&*@&$+&.+#*Am+l+4)12&$*#12+'+T&*c+&.#*AmH

T#$$%&$-+.0+%1.&$1#.%01#*+.$#2& `%10<#"F+G($%19*&+l+,%1-&**#+l+b081-01HO1<%$01/&1.#*+*%#@%*%.%&- W#"#6#'+(#-"+G4)12&$*#12+l+p*&:S/#1+#12+,$).+l

b081-01+l+T&*c+&.+#*AmH

Page 6: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

V

($&-:$%;.%<&+$&9)*#.%01-+#12$&9)*#.0$>+@)$2&1-

`%10<#"F+G4)12&$*#12+l+($%19*&+l+(#.1&>6H

($0?%.#@%*%.> 3"<&%+'#"F+Gb081-01HE1-)$#1:&+;$&/%)/- 2-V%&+G4)12&$*#12+l+($%19*&+l+(#.1&>+l+,%1-&**#+l

b081-01+'+T&*c+&.+#*AmHQ::&--+.0+?%1#1:%#*+:#;%.#* N+<#.#(+(%)/0+.#X>#"F)X-&)R0'#"%'').-+"'+G($%19*&+l

(#.1&>+l+b081-01+l+T&*c+&.+#*AmH480$.'.&$/+;$0?%.- =%<&%+'#"F)\T&*c+#12

4.$#11&9#$2m[HZ019'.&$/+;$0?%.- 3"<&%+'#"F+GT&*c+&.+#*AmH

\%1#1:%#*+%1:&1.%<&-+?$0/90<&$1/&1.-

3"<&%+'#"F+G4)12&$*#12H

')%!$@(%)""!&".0&O/;*0>&&+#5#$&1&--+#@0).

&1<%$01/&1.C+.8&%$+%1%.%#.%<&-+0$-)99&-.%01-A

3"<&%+'#"F+GT#>*%-+&.+#*Am+l+b081-01H

78&+5#>+&/;*0>&&-+;&$?0$/+.8&%$.#-S-

W-&%)<-&&%<()+"1)%XX#<#%"()V+>+GT%012%+&.+#*A+l+T&*c&.+#*AmH

O/;*0>&&+.)$10<&$ `%10<#"F+Gb081-01HO/;*0>&&+$&:$)%./&1. N+<#.#(+(%+Gb081-01H

I$&2%@%*%.>+#/019+-.#S&80*2&$-+#12-.#S&80*2&$-+:01?%2&1:&

3"<&%+'#"F+GT0$98%1%+#12+3%:%1%+l+b081-01H I012%.%01-+.0+@&+:$&2%@*&G4)12&$*#12L+l+($%19*&iH

I0'0;&$#.%01+#/019+@)-%1&--C&1<%$01/&1.#*%-.-C+;)@*%:+#12k0$

$&9)*#.0$-

A%((%&+Gb081-01+l+4)12&$*#12+l+p*&:S/#1+#12+,$).+lT%012%+&.+#*A+l+T&*c+&.+#*AmH

m+78&-&+#).80$-+2&-:$%@&+@&1&?%.-+#12+:0-.-+0?+).%*%-#.%01+0?+<0*)1.#$>+#;;$0#:8&-+%1+&1<%$01/&1.#*+#$&#A78&>+20+10.+;0%1.+0).+.8&+;#$.%:)*#$+&??&:.-+0?+E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01A

Q-+ -8051+ %1+ 7#@*&+ !C+ /0-.+ 0?+ .8&+ #).80$-+ :01:*)2&+ .0+ ;0-%.%<&+ %/;#:.-+ 0?+ E4F+ !LJJJ:&$.%?%:#.%01+01+@)-%1&--+;&$?0$/#1:&A+N05&<&$C+#+?&5+;0%1.-+*&#2+.0+:01.$0<&$-%&-+-):8+#-.8&+E4F+!LJJJ+%1?*)&1:&+01+:0-.-+#12+01+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;$0.&:.%01A

78&+&??&:.+ 0?+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+01+:0-.-+ %-+ 10.+ -0+ &<%2&1.+ #12+ %.+5%**+ @&+ %1.&$&-.%19+ .0+ -&&+ .8&$&-)*.-+ 0?+ 0)$+ $&-&#$:8+ 01+ .8%-+ .0;%:A+ E12&&2C+/#1#9&$-+/#>+ &P;&:.+ :0-.+ -#<%19-+ G&1&$9>-#<%19-C+ 8%98&$+ ;$02):.%<%.>_+ 4)12&$*#12C+ !UUV_+ b081-01C+ !UUKH+ @).+ .8&+ E4F+ !LJJJ:&$.%?%:#.%01+@$%19-+#*-0+#22%.%01#*+:0-.-+2)&+.0R• ! .8&+ #2/%1%-.$#.%<&+ #12+ ?%1#1:%#*+ @)$2&1-+ GS&&;%19+ );2#.&2+ 20:)/&1.#.%01C+ 5$%.%192&.#%*&2+ ;$0:&2)$&-C+ .$#%1%19+ &/;*0>&&-+ 580+ ;&$?0$/+ .#-S-+ 5%.8+ %/;0$.#1.&1<%$01/&1.#*+%/;#:.-gHC

• ! .8&+ 1&:&--#$>+ %1'2&;.8+ #1#*>-%-+ 0?+ .8&+ :0/;#1>+ %.-&*?+ G%1.&$1#*+ #)2%.-HA+ E1+ 9&1&$#*C/#1#9&$-+20+10.+8#<&+ .8&+ .%/&+#12+ .8&+ .&:81%:#*+ $&-0)$:&-+ .0+:#$$>+0).+-):8+#1#*>-%-#12+$&*>+01+:0-.*>+0).-%2&+#--%-.#1:&C

• ! .8&+.&:810*09%:#*+/&#-)$&-+.8#.+8#<&+.0+@&+.#S&1+?0$+9)#$#1.&&%19+.8&+%/;$0<&/&1.+0?&1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&+GT%012%+&.+#*AC+!UUWHg

E1+.8&+-#/&+5#>C+#+*0.+0?+/#1#9&$-C+$&-&#$:8&$-+#12+:01-)*.#1.-+$&:0//&12+.8&+E4F+!LJJJ:&$.%?%:#.%01+ #-+ #+ /&#1-+ ?0$+ #:8%&<%19+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ ;$0.&:.%01+ #12+ $&2):%19+ ;0**).%01G&A9AC+ I0$@&..+ #12+,%$-:8C+ !UUUHC+ @).+ -0/&+ 0.8&$+ $&-&#$:8&$-C+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ 9$0);-+ #12:01-)/&$-+ 20)@.+ %.A+ b&11%?&$+B#-8+ G!UUWH+ ?0$+ %1-.#1:&+ :012):.&2+ #+ -.)2>+ .0+ #--&--+ ?%$/&1<%$01/&1.#*+ ;&$?0$/#1:&+ 0<&$+ .%/&+ #12+ .8&+ %/;#:.+ 0?+ #20;.%01+ 0?+ n&-;01-%@*&+ I#$&;$09$#/-+01+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&A+48&+?0)12+&<%2&1:&+.8#.+?%$/-+.8#.+;#$.%:%;#.&+%1n&-;01-%@*&+ I#$&+ #$&+ %/;$0<%19+ .8&%$+ $&*#.%<&+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ ;&$?0$/#1:&+ /0$&+ -*05*>

Page 7: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

K

.8#1+101'/&/@&$-A+78%-+=)%.&+ #/#c%19+ $&-)*.+ -80)*2+@&+ .&-.&2+ %1+ .8&+ :#-&+0?+ E4F+!LJJJ:&$.%?%:#.%01A

Q?.&$+.8%-+*%.&$#.)$&+$&<%&5C+%.+-&&/-+0@<%0)-+.8#.+.8&$&+%-+#+:*&#$+1&&2+?0$+:#$&?)*+&<#*)#.%010?+ 805+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ 20&-+ %1?*)&1:&+ @)-%1&--+ ;&$?0$/#1:&A+ 78#.D-+ 58>+ .8%-$&-&#$:8+5%**+%1<&-.%9#.&+:0-.-+#12+@&1&?%.-+0?+.8#.+:&$.%?%:#.%01A

><R<(.EKD8DJIS(84:4I8JN(E4GN797S7P578&+/&#-)$&/&1.+%1-.$)/&1.+%-+#+-.#12#$2%-&2+/0%'(#-""+#&%+ .0+@&+/#%*&2+ .0+#+-#/;*&+0?:&$.%?%&2+ 0$9#1%-#.%01-+ %1+ L+ Q-%#1+ :0)1.$%&-+ GN019+ ,019C+ "#*#>-%#C+ 4%19#;0$&C+ #1278#%*#12H+ #12+W+O)$0;&#1+ :0)1.$%&-+ GT&*9%)/C+\$#1:&C+r,C+p&$/#1>C+B0$5#>C+45&2&1CE.#*>C+#12+4;#%1HA+78&+=)&-.%011#%$&+5$%..&1+%1+O19*%-8+:01-%-.-+0?+Ki+%.&/-+#12+%-+2%<%2&2%1.0+6+;#$.-A

78&+?%$-.+;#$.+0?+0)$+=)&-.%011#%$&+Gs)&-.%01+!+→+LUH+%1:*)2&-+%.&/-+:01:&$1%19+#:.%<%.%&-)12&$.#S&1+@>+:&$.%?%&2+:0/;#1%&-+%1+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.#*+#$&#A+78&-&+2%??&$&1.+#:.%<%.%&-+#$&$&9$0);&2+ %1+ !J+ :#.&90$%&-+ .8#.+ #$&+ @$%&?*>+ ;$&-&1.&2+ %1+ 7#@*&+ 6+ #12+ %1-;%$&2+ ?$0/+ .8&-.$):.)$&+ 0?+ .8&+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01A+ 78&+ 0@X&:.%<&+ 0?+ .8%-+ ?%$-.+ ;#$.+ %-+ .0+ 8%98*%98.58%:8+ 0?+ .8&-&+ 9$0);-+ 0?+ #:.%<%.%&-+ #$&+ &/;8#-%-&2+ @>+ :&$.%?%&2+ :0/;#1%&-C+ #12+ %?2%??&$&1:&-+&P%-.+#/019+:0)1.$%&-A

7#@*&+6R+o&-:$%;.%01+0?+.8&+2%??&$&1.+#-;&:.-+.8#.+5%**+@&+/&#-)$&2+%1+.8&+?%$-.+;#$.+0?+.8&+=)&-.%011#%$&A#$/&'()*(&?.T2.'&!)00$!/.

$'#.%&'(&)(".$'2/.

78&+O1<%$01/&1.#*+;0*%:>s)&-.%01+!+→+V

• ! I0//%./&1.+.0+:0/;*%#1:&+5%.8+#;;*%:#@*&+*#5-+#12+.0+:01.%1)#*+%/;$0<&/&1.C• ! E1.&9$#.%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+%1+@)-%1&--+-.$#.&9>C• ! O??0$.+.0+&P.&$1#*+:0//)1%:#.%01A

78&+;*#11%19R'+O1<%$01/&1.#*+#-;&:.-'+F@X&:.%<&-+#12+.#$9&.-

s+K+→+!J

• ! E2&1.%?>+&1<%$01/&1.#*+#-;&:.-+0?+#:.%<%.%&-+5%.8+&1<%$01/&1.#*+ %/;*%:#.%01-+.8#.+:#1@&+:01.$0**&2+0$+%1?*)&1:&2+@>+.8&+:0/;#1>C

• ! o&$%<&+0@X&:.%<&-+#12+.#$9&.-+:01-%-.&1.+5%.8+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;0*%:>C• ! I01-%2&$+*&9#*+#12+0.8&$+$&=)%$&/&1.-C+.8&+<%&5-+0?+%1.&$&-.&2+;#$.%&-g

O1<%$01/&1.#*+"#1#9&/&1.->-.&/

s+!!+→+6J

• ! o&-%91#.%01+0?+$&-;01-%@%*%.%&-+#.+&#:8+*&<&*+0?+.8&+0$9#1%-#.%01C• ! "&#1-+G.%/&C+@)29&.H+#12+.%/&?$#/&+.0+#:8%&<&+0@X&:.%<&-A

E/;*&/&1.#.%01+#120;&$#.%01s+6!+→+6L

• ! n&-0)$:&-+&--&1.%#*+.0+.8&+%/;*&/&1.#.%01+#12+:01.$0*+0?+.8&+O"4+G8)/#1+$&-0)$:&-C.&:810*09>C+?%1#1:%#*+$&-0)$:&-C+.%/&HC

• ! \$&=)&1:>+0?+$&;0$.-+01+O"4+;&$?0$/#1:&+.0+.0;+/#1#9&/&1.A7$#%1%19s+6i+→+6W

• ! o&.&$/%1&+.8&+*&<&*+0?+&P;&$%&1:&C+:0/;&.&1:&+#12+.$#%1%19+1&:&--#$>C• ! 7$#%1+&/;*0>&&+#@0).+.8&+%/;0$.#1:&+0?+:01?0$/%19+.0+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;0*%:>+#12

%.-+;$0:&2)$&-AI0//)1%:#.%01s+6U+→+[i

• ! E1.&$1#*+:0//)1%:#.%01C• ! OP.&$1#*+:0//)1%:#.%01+5%.8+%1.&$&-.&2+;#$.%&-A

o0:)/&1.#.%01s+[V+→+[W

• ! o&-:$%@&+;$0:&2)$&-C+%1-.$):.%01-C+&/&$9&1:>+$&-;01-&-C• ! o0:)/&1.-D+#<#%*#@%*%.>+#12+*0:#.%01+#12+;&$%02%:#**>+$&<%&5&2A

F;&$#.%01#*+:01.$0*s+[U+→+LL

• ! ($0:&2)$&-+.0+/%1%/%-&+.8&+$%-S+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+%/;#:.-C• ! 4.%;)*#.%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+:$%.&$%#+?0$+.8&+0;&$#.%01#*+;$0:&--C• ! I0//)1%:#.%01+0?+;$0:&2)$&-+#12+$&=)%$&/&1.-+.0+-);;*%&$-+#12+:01.$#:.0$-A

I8&:S%19+#12+:0$$&:.%<&#:.%01

s+Li+→+LW

• ! "&#-)$&-+#12+:01.$0*-C+#)2%.-C• ! o&.&:.%01+0?+101':01?0$/#1:&-C• ! I0$$&:.%<&+#12+;$&<&1.%<&+#:.%01-A

n&<%&5+#12+%/;*&/&1.#.%01s+LU

• ! \$&=)&1:>+0?+.0;+/#1#9&/&1.+$&<%&5A

Page 8: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

W

78&+-&:012+;#$.+0?+.8&+=)&-.%011#%$&+Gs)&-.%01+iJ+→+KVH+8#-+.8&+0@X&:.%<&+.0+&<#*)#.&+.8&&:010/%:+ #12+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ $&-)*.-+ 0@.#%1&2+ @>+ :0/;#1%&-+ .8#1S-+ .0+ .8&+ &1<%$01/&1.#*:&$.%?%:#.%01A+ a&+ 5#1.+ .0+ 9%<&+ -0/&+ @&..&$+ #$9)/&1.-+ .0+ :0/;#1%&-+ .8#.+ 2&-%$&+ .0+ 9&.%1<0*<&2+%1+.8&+:&$.%?%:#.%01+;$0:&--A+E.+%-+10.+-)??%:%&1.+.0+-#>+d8<-:8XX#<#%"()<-69+"#%')+&%R%((%&) 6+"+F%1) <-69+"#%') +"1) R%((%&) 6+"+F%1) <-69+"#%') +&%) (,%) 6-'() '0<<%''X0.eGb081-01C+!UUKHA+E/;#:.-+0?+E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01+01+:0/;#1%&-D+;$02):.%01+Gst+iJ+→iVR+%1:$&#-&2+&??%:%&1:>C+$&2):%19+5#-.&gHC+?%1#1:&+Gst+VL+→+VKR+:0-.-+-#<%19C+%1:$&#-&2;$0?%.-gHC+/#$S&.%19+Gst+iK+→+V[R+:0$;0$#.&+%/#9&C+:01-)/&$-+-#.%-?#:.%01gH+#12+-0:%#*:0//%./&1.+ Gst+ VW+→+ KiR+ ;$&-&$<&+ &1<%$01/&1.C+ -.#S&80*2&$-D+ -#.%-?#:.%01gH+ 5%**+ @&%2&1.%?%&2+#12+/&#-)$&2A

\%9)$&+ !+ -)//#$%-&-+ 0)$+ :0/;*&.&+ $&-&#$:8+ ?$#/&50$SC+ %1:*)2%19+ .8&+ ;0--%@*&+ #:.%<%.%&-;).+ %1.0+ ;*#:&+ @>+ :0/;#1%&-+ 2)&+ .0+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ #12+ .8&+ ;0.&1.%#*+ %/;#:.-+ 0?+ .8&:&$.%?%:#.%01+01+?0)$+2%/&1-%01-+0?+@)-%1&--+;&$?0$/#1:&+G;$02):.%01C+ ?%1#1:&C+/#$S&.%19#12+-0:%#*+:0//%./&1.HA

Page 9: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

U

\%9)$&+!R+F)$+:0/;*&.&+$&-&#$:8+?$#/&50$S

\%1#1:&"#$S&.%19

40:%#*+:0//%./&1. ($02):.%01

(0*%:> F@X&:.%<&-+#12+.#$9&.-

O1<%$01/&1.#*+"#1#9&/&1.4>-.&/

E/;*&/&1.#.%01+#120;&$#.%01

7$#%1%19

I0//)1%:#.%01 o0:)/&1.#.%01 F;&$#.%01#*+:01.$0*

I8&:S%19+#12+:0$$&:.%<&#:.%01

n&<%&5+#12%/;*&/&1.#.%01

• ! \)*?%**+%.-+-0:%#*+:0//%./&1.• ! N&*;+;$&-&$<&+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.• ! 70;+/#1#9&/&1.+-#.%-?#:.%01• ! 4#.%-?>+&1<%$01/&1.+0$9#1%-#.%01-• ! 4#.%-?>+1#.%01#*+$&9)*#.0$-• ! 4#.%-?>+%1.&$1#.%01#*+$&9)*#.0$-• ! 4#.%-?>+*#@0$+)1%01-• ! Q;;&#$+#-+#+$0*&+/02&*

• ! I0$;0$#.&+%/#9&• ! E1:$&#-&2+/#$S&.+-8#$&• ! B&5+/#$S&.

0;;0$.)1%.%&-• ! 4#*&-• ! ($02):.+;$%:&• ! a%2&$+;$&--+:0<&$#9&• ! I)-.0/&$+-#.%-?#:.%01

• ! n&2):&2+-0*%25#-.&+k+5#.&$+)-&+0$+#%$'&/%--%01-

• ! n&:>:*%19+0?+/#.&$%#*-+%1.&$1#*+.0+.8&:0/;#1>

• ! 4)@-.%.).%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#**>=)&-.%01#@*&+/#.&$%#*-

• ! E1.$02):.%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.+:$%.&$%01%1+.8&+:80%:&+0?+-);;*%&$-

• ! O:0';#:S#9%19• ! "0$&+&1<%$01/&1.#**>+?$%&12*>

.$#1-;0$.#.%01+;0*%:>+%1+.8&+:0/;#1>• ! E/;$0<&/&1.+%1+;$02):.%<%.>

• ! I0-.+-#<%19• ! Z019+.&$/+;$0?%.• ! 480$.+.&$/+;$0?%.• ! T#1S+*0#1-+k+0.8&$

%1<&-./&1.-

!')(+,---t t

t t

t

Page 10: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!J

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o)&+ .0+ .8%-C+5&+2&:%2&2+ .0+)-&+ .8%-+ L';0%1.+-:#*&A

o#.#+ #1#*>-%-+ 8#-+ @&&1+ 2&<&*0;&2+ 5%.8+ 4(44A+ r-)#*+ )1%<#$%#.&+ #12+ @%<#$%#.&+ -.#.%-.%:#*;$0:&2)$&+8#<&+@&&1+)-&2A+o&-:$%;.%<&+#1#*>-%-+9%<&-+#1+0<&$<%&5+0?+.8&+-#/;*&+#1-5&$-_;$%1:%;#*+ :0/;01&1.+ #1#*>-%-+ ;&$/%.-+ .0+ %2&1.%?>+ ?#:.0$-+ .8#.+ -)//#$%-&+ %1?0$/#.%01:01.#%1&2+ %1+ .8&+ =)&-.%011#%$&_+ :0$$&*#.%01+ #1#*>-%-+ #12+ $&9$&--%01+ #1#*>-%-+ #$&+ )-&2+ %10$2&$+ .0+ #1#*>-&+ .8&+ ;0.&1.%#*+ $&*#.%01+ &P%-.%19+ @&.5&&1+ #:.%<%.%&-+ ;).+ %1.0+ ;$#:.%:&+ #12$&-)*.-+0@.#%1&2A

R<! /.'2@&'($0=(=!'%2''!)0

Q+ .0.#*+ 0?+ 6Ui+ )-#@*&+ =)&-.%011#%$&-+ 5&$&+ $&.)$1&2A+ 7#@*&+ [+ 2&-:$%@&-+ .8&+ -#/;*&:0/;0-%.%01A

7#@*&+[R+B)/@&$+0?+$&-;01-&-+%1+&#:8+:0)1.$>A%7CFG8D4: 0CEU48(7H

84:K7F:4:?7FP(37FP !W"ISI5:DI LL'DFPIK784 6W&NIDSIF9 [V14SPDCE V*8IFJ4 6i23 VJ

Q48EIF5 Li0786I5 6J'6494F 6!!GIS5 W'KIDF !L&7GIS >VW

p*0@#**>C+ Q-%#1+ #12+ O)$0;&#1+ @)-%1&--+ #1-5&$+ .0+ .8&+ -&.+ 0?+ =)&-.%01-+ 5%.8+ #+ -%/%*#$;#..&$1R+10+-.#.%-.%:#*+2%??&$&1:&-+#;;&#$&2+@&.5&&1+Q-%#1+#12+O)$0;&#1+@)-%1&--&-VA+78&2%-.$%@).%01-+0?+$&-;01-&-+#$&+<&$>+-%/%*#$R+#1-5&$-+#$&+:01:&1.$#.&2+#$0)12+.8&+]+Q9$&&+^#12+]+4.$019*>+Q9$&&+ +0;.%01-+%1+&#:8+;#$.+0?+.8&+=)&-.%011#%$&A

\0$+.8&+?%$-.+;#$.+0?+.8&+=)&-.%011#%$&+G:01:&$1%19+.8&+#:.%<%.%&-+;).+%1.0+;*#:&+@>+:&$.%?%&2:0/;#1%&-HC+ .0+ -0/&+ &P.&1.+ %.+ %-+ 10.+ -)$;$%-%19+ .8#.+ :0/;#1%&-+ ;$&-&1.+ #+ /%1%/)/+ 0?#:.%<&1&--R+-%1:&+.8&>+#$&+#**+E4F':&$.%?%&2C+.8&>+#20;.+:0/;#$#@*&+]+@&8#<%0)$-+ A

\0$+ .8&+ -&:012+ ;#$.+ 0?+ .8&+ =)&-.%011#%$&+ G@&1&?%.-+ 0?+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01HC+ #**+ .8&$&-;012&1.-+ :01-%2&$+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ #-+ #+ 50$.858%*&+ %1<&-./&1.+ 5%.8+ #+ *0.+ 0?@&1&?%.-+ %1+ .8&+ L+ 2%/&1-%01-+ %1<&-.%9#.&2+ G?%1#1:&C+ /#$S&.%19C+ ;$02):.%01+ #12+ -0:%#*:0//%./&1.HA

Page 11: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!!

E?+ 0)$+ -)$<&>+ :0)*2+ *&#2+ .0+ %1.&$;$&.+ .8#.+ .8&+ $&-;012&1.-+ #$&+ =)%.&+ #:.%<&+ %1+ .&$/-+ 0?O1<%$01/&1.#*+ "#1#9&/&1.+ 4>-.&/-C+ #12+ .8#.+ .8&>+ -&&/+ .0+ ;&$:&%<&+ ;0-%.%<&:01-&=)&1:&-+0?+.8&+E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01C+5&+8#<&+.0+S&&;+%1+/%12+#+;0.&1.%#*+@%#-+2)&.0+ .8&+ #2/%1%-.$#.%01+ ;$0:&2)$&A+ Q-+ )-)#*+ %1+ -):8+ #+ -)$<&>+ 5%.8+ -&*?+ -&*&:.%01+ 0?+ .8&$&-;012&1.-+ #12+ ;&$:&;.%01-+ .8#.+ :#110.+ @&+ <&$%?%&2C+ 5&+ -80)*2+ #<0%2+ .0+ 9&1&$#*%-&d0<&$&-.%/#.&2e+$&-)*.-eA

E12&&2C+ .8&+ ;0;)*#.%01+ %-+ =)%.&+ 80/09&1&0)-+ G:&$.%?%&2+ :0/;#1%&-+ 01*>HC+ :0/;#1%&-+ .8#.:0)*2+ 8#<&+ d@#2e+ $&-)*.-+ 0?+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ /#>@&+ $&?$#%1&2+ .0+ -&12+ .8&=)&-.%011#%$&+ @#:S+ G#).0-&*&:.%01+ @%#-H+ #12+ 2)&+ .0+ d-0:%#*+ 2&-%$#@%*%.>e+ %1+ -):8+ .0;%:-C$&-;012&1.-+:#1+;$0<%2&+d@&..&$e+#1-5&$C+d1%:&$e+<%&5+.8#1+.8&+$&#*+:#-&+'+.8#.+5&+:#110.:8&:S+'A

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

R<+<!($FIS5:D:(7H(GN4(HD8:G(KI8G(7H(GN4(BC4:GD7FFID84(;(IJGDLDGD4:(KCG(DFG7(KSIJ4(U5J48GDHD49(J7EKIFD4:

\%9)$&+ 6R+ Q<&$#9&+ 2&9$&&+ 0?+ #9$&&/&1.+ 5%.8+ .8&+ %/;*&/&1.#.%01+ 0?+ .8&+ !J+ #:.%<%.%&-+ ;$&-&1.&2+ %1+ .8&=)&-.%011#%$&+G!+f+-.$019*>+#9$&&C+6+f+Q9$&&HA

\%9)$&+ 6+ ;$&-&1.-+ .8&+ #<&$#9&+ $&-;01-&-+ 9%<&1+ @>+ :0/;#1%&-+ #@0).+ .8&+ !J+ 9$0);-+ 0?#:.%<%.%&-+.8#.+:#1+@&+)12&$.#S&1+;#$#**&*+.0+E4F+:&$.%?%:#.%01A+78&+)-&2+9$0);%19+;$0:&2)$&

" "#$ % %#$ & &#$

'()*+,

-.'/+0.

(12/+0*3/.

/4!.5678

('/9-0*(:.

09-*:*:;

+(44<:*+-0*(:

=(+<4/:0-0*(:

+(:09()

+>/+?

/@ABCD-6EF

Page 12: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!6

%-+.0+:01-%2&$+?0$+&#:8+$&-;012&1.+.8&+#<&$#9&+0?+.8&+#1-5&$-+8&+8#2+9%<&1+.0+.8&+=)&-.%01-*%1S&2+.0+.8&+9$0);A

Q<&$#9&+/&#-)$&-+#$&+#**+%1+.8&+#$&#+0?+#9$&&/&1.+*0:#.&2+@&.5&&1+.8&+#*.&$1#.%<&+4.$019*>Q9$&&+ #12+ Q9$&&A+ Q**+ .8&-&+ $&?*&:.+ #+ d;0-%.%<&e+ ;&$:&;.%01+ 0$+ &<#*)#.%01C+ @).+ 5&+ 5%**&18#1:&+.8&+2%??&$&1:&-A

78&+d$#1S%19e+0?+;$%0$%.%&-+%-+=)%.&+-%/%*#$+%1+Q-%#1+#12+O)$0;&#1+@)-%1&--&-A+F;&$#.%01#*:01.$0*+#:.%<%.%&-+-&&/+10.+ .0+@&+ .8&+;$%0$%.%&-+9%<&1+@>+ .8&+:0/;#1%&-A+ E1+ .8&+ -#/&+5#>C0@X&:.%<&-C+ .#$9&.-+ #12+ :0//)1%:#.%01+ #$&+ 10.+ -0+ 5&**+ 2&<&*0;&2A+ 78&-&+ #$&+ .8&+ *#-.d#:.%<%.%&-e+58&$&%1+.8&+:0/;#1>+d-;&12+-0/&+.%/&+0$+&1&$9>+0$+/01&>eA+F1+.8&+:01.$#$>C.8&+ :0/;#1%&-+ #$&+/0$&+ %1<0*<&2+ %1+ 20:)/&1.#.%01C+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ ;0*%:>+ #12+ :8&:S%19#12+:0$$&:.%<&+#:.%01-A

\)$.8&$+ #1#*>-%-+ 8#-+ @&&1+ 201&+ .8$0)98+ ;$%1:%;#*+ :0/;01&1.+ #1#*>-%-+ 5%.8+ 3QnE"Qu$0.#.%01A+78#.+;&$/%.-+ .0+ %2&1.%?>+ ?#:.0$-+ .8#.+ -)//#$%-&+ %1?0$/#.%01+ :01.#%1&2+ %1+ .8&+LU?%$-.+ %.&/-+ 0?+ 0)$+ =)&-.%011#%$&A+ n&-)*.-+ 0?+ .8%-+ #1#*>-%-+ %-+ #+ .50+ ?#:.0$-+ -.$):.)$&+ .8#.&P;*#%1-+VKv+0?+.8&+<#$%#1:&[email protected]+%1+Q-%#+#12+%1+O)$0;&+G7#@*&+LHA

7#@*&+LR+($%1:%;#*+:0/;01&1.+#1#*>-%-+01+.8&+?%$-.+;#$.+0?+.8&+=)&-.%011#%$&+G#:.%<%.%&-HQS7UISS5 $:DI .C87K4$JGDLDGD4:

\#:.0$+! \#:.0$+6 \#:.0$+! \#:.0$+6 \#:.0$+! \#:.0$+6(0*%:> JALK! -<W+X JALVK -<W>Y JALKi -<W-XQ-;&:.- JAL6U -<ZY> JALiU -<ZWZ JALJW -<ZVVF@X&:.%<&- JA!V6 -<VWR JA!VW -<VWR JA!iU -<VWRO"4 -<ZYX JAL6i -<ZV JAL![ -<ZYZ JAL[[

F;&$#.%01#*+:01.$0* -<XY, JA!WU -<XV JA6JL -<XXV JA!KK7$#%1%19 -<XW, JA[K -<XZW JA[Vi -<X,Z JA[KL

I0//)1%:#.%01 -<X,> JA6L6 -<XW+ JA6[[ -<XRW JA6LWo0:)/&1.#.%01 -<XZR JA6i[ -<X,X JA6KL -<XX, JA6[W

I01.$0* -<ZYV JA[V -<ZY> JA[LW -<ZVW JA[VUI8&:S%19+#12

:0$$&:.%<&+#:.%01--<Y>W JA6U6 -<Y>, JA6U[ -<Y>Z JA6U!

αααα(%87FUIJN JAU!6V JAKiUW JAU![L JAKVJi JAU!6! JAKiU[[(7H(LI8DIFJ44\KSIDF49

L[AKLLv 6[A[!Lv LLA!v 66AUW6v L[AiLLv 6[Ai6iv

&7GIS(LI8DIFJ44\KSIDF49

ZX<-WY[ ZX<-Y>[ ZX<-ZV[

78&+?%$-.+ ?#:.0$+ .8#.+&P;*#%1-+LLv+0?+<#$%#1:&+ %-+8%98*>+:0$$&*#.&2+5%.8+F(OnQ7EFBQZQI7E3E7EO4+;).+%1.0+;*#:&+#?.&$+.8&+-.$#.&9>+2&-%91C+-):8+#-+#:.%<%.%&-+0?+20:)/&1.#.%01C.$#%1%19C+10/%1#.%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+$&-;01-%@*&C+;*#11%19AAA

78&+ -&:012+ ?#:.0$+ %-+ /):8+ /0$&+ $&*#.&2+ .0+ 47nQ7OpEI+ QI7E3E7EO4+ -):8+ #-+ .8&&-.#@*%-8/&1.+0?+:0/;#1>D-+&1<%$01/&1.#*+0@X&:.%<&-C+.8&+&<#*)#.%01+0?+:0/;#1>+%/;#:.-01+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.C+.8&+&19#9&/&1.+.0+$&-;&:.+#**+&1<%$01/&1.#*+$&9)*#.%01-g

Q.+ .8&+ 9*0@#*+ *&<&*C+ $&9%01+ *&<&*+ #12+ :0)1.$>+ *&<&*C+ 10+ -.#.%-.%:#*+ 2%??&$&1:&+ 8#-+ @&&12&.&:.&2R+ .8&+ )12&$*>%19+ ?#:.0$-+ #$&+ .8&+ -#/&C+ &P;*#%1%19+ 1&#$*>+ .8&+ -#/&+ ;0$.%01+ 0?<#$%#1:&KA

Page 13: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

![

R<><!($FIS5:D:(7H(GN4(:4J7F9(KI8G(7H(GN4(BC4:GD7FFID84(;(UC:DF4::(K48H78EIFJ4

o%??&$&1:&-+@&.5&&1+O)$0;&+#12+Q-%#+#12+2%??&$&1:&-+@&.5&&1+;&$:&%<&2+:01-&=)&1:&-+#$&<&$>+-/#**C+#-+%**)-.$#.&2+%1+7#@*&+iA+N05&<&$+@&1&?%.-+%1+.8&+-0:%#*+:0//%./&1.+2%/&1-%01-&&/+.0+@&+-*%98.*>+@&..&$+.8#1+%1+.8&+;$02):.%01C+/#$S&.%19+#12+?%1#1:&+2%/&1-%01-A+78%-:#1+ @&+ &P;*#%1&2+ ;#$.*>+ @>+ .8&+ ?#:.+ .8#.+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ 9%<&-+ /0$&+ -0:%#*+ #12;0-%.%<&+ <%-%@%*%.>+ .0+ .8&+ :&$.%?%&2+ :0/;#1>+ #12+ .8&1+ 8#-+ /0$&+ %1?*)&1:&+ 01+ .8&+ -0:%#*:0//%./&1.+%12%:#.0$-+.8#1+01+0.8&$+2%/&1-%01-A+78&+*05&$+*&<&*+0?+#9$&&/&1.+%-+01+.8&?%1#1:%#*+ 2%/&1-%01C+/#>@&+ @&:#)-&+ #+ *019&$+ .%/&+ 80$%c01+ %-+ 1&:&--#$>+ ?0$+/#1#9&$-+ .0&<#*)#.&+?%1#1:%#*+&??&:.-+0?+:&$.%?%:#.%01A

7#@*&+iR+E4F+!LJJJ+%/;#:.-+01+.8&+L+2%/&1-%01-+0?+@)-%1&--+;&$?0$/#1:&G\$0/+!+f+-.$019*>+#9$&&+.0+L+f+-.$019*>+2%-#9$&&H

!F(.C87K4](84:K7F:4:J4FG849(I87CF9(;

!F($:DI](84:K7F:4:J4FG849(I87CF9(;

#879CJGD7F !AU! !AU6"I8^4GDFP !AWW !AWU*DFIFJ4 !AUW 6AJ!

'7JDIS(J7EEDGE4FG !AiK !AiK

($%1:%;#*+ :0/;01&1.+ #1#*>-%-+ 5%.8+ 3QnE"Qu+ $0.#.%01+ 8#-+ @&&1+ 201&+ 01+ .8&+ 6V+ %.&/-#@0).+:0-.-+#12+@&1&?%.-+#--0:%#.&2+5%.8+E4F+:&$.%?%:#.%01A+Q-+5&+%2&1.%?>+.8&0$&.%:#**>+?0)$)12&$*>%19+ ?#:.0$-+ G-0:%#*C+/#$S&.%19C+;$02):.%01+ #12+ ?%1#1:&+ ?#:.0$-HC+5&+ ?0$:&+4(44+ .0S&&;+#+?0)$'?#:.0$+-.$):.)$&A+n&-)*.-+0?+.8%-+#1#*>-%-+#$&+;$&-&1.&2+%1+7#@*&+VA

7#@*&+VR+($%1:%;#*+:0/;01&1.+#1#*>-%-+01+.8&+-&:012+;#$.+0?+.8&+=)&-.%011#%$&+G@&1&?%.-H!G4E: *IJG78(+ *IJG78(> *IJG78(R *IJG78(,

#/)=2%&!)0($0:&--+F;.%/%-#.%01+.0+$&2):&+5#-.&

#12+#%$+&/%--%01-JA[!U JA6LL -<W,R JA!!J

E1.&$1#*+$&:>:*%19 JAJWK JA!V -<X,R JA!UV4)@-.%.).%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#**>

=)&-.%01#@*&+/#.&$%#*-JA6V[ JA6V6 -<,+, JA6V6

O1<%$01/&1.#*+:$%.&$%01+%1+:80%:&+0?-);;*%&$-

JAJVK JA[VW JA6VL -<Z>R

O:0';#:S#9%19 'JAJKU 'JAJ!6 JAi[! -<WWXO1<%$01/&1.#**>'?$%&12*>+.$#1-;0$.#.%01 JA!VU JA6[U JAJ[W -<XXV

E/;$0<&/&1.+%1+;$02):.%<%.> JAJ6V -<,WX JA!VW JA[JV"$/3.&!0QI0$;0$#.&+%/#9& -<,Y> -<,>R JA!L 'JAJUL

E1:$&#-&+%1+/#$S&.+-8#$&- JA!JU -<YVZ JAJ6V JA!i6B&5+/#$S&.+0;;0$.)1%.%&- JAJKL -<YZV JAJ6K JA!!!

4#*&- JAJW! -<YW- JA!L6 JA!Li($02):.+;$%:& JA!W6 -<ZY+ JA!V JA[Li

a%2&$+;$&--+:0<&$#9& JA6JU -<,V, JA![[ JA!KVI)-.0/&$+-#.%-?#:.%01 JA6i[ -<ZXW JA!UW JAJi[

*!0$0%.I0-.+-#<%19 -<W,Y JA![V -<,Y, JAJ6L

Z019+.&$/+;$0?%. JALL[ JA[L -<W>X JAJLi480$.+.&$/+;$0?%. JA[VW JAJ[[ -<ZW, 'JAJJW

T#1S+*0#1-+#12+0.8&$+%1<&-./&1.- JA6Li JA6JK JAJiW -<WY,')%!$@(%)""!&".0&\)*?%*+%.-+-0:%#*+:0//%./&1. -<Z>Z JA!JU JA6LW JAJKU

Page 14: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!L

N&*;-+;$&-&$<&+.8&+&1<%$01/&1. -<X>X JAJ!V JA!WL JA!JK70;+/#1#9&/&1.+-#.%-?#:.%01 -<X+W JAJWV JA6iU 'JAJJU

4#.%-?>+&1<%$01/&1.#*+0$9#1%-#.%01- -<XZ> JAJJ! JA!W! JA6[64#.%-?>+1#.%01#*+$&9)*#.0$- -<XV, JA![i JAJV! JA!Ki

4#.%-?>+%1.&$1#.%01#*+$&9)*#.0$- -<XZ> JA!K! JA!VK JA!!W4#.%-?>+*#@0)$+)1%01- -<ZR+ JA[!V 'JAJ!K JA[WLQ;;&#$+#-+#+$0*&+/02&* -<XRW JA6V[ JAJ![ 'JAJJ!

αααα(%87FUIJN JAUJJ6 JAWW6W JAKL[L JAVU[U[(7H(LI8DIFJ4(4\KSIDF49 6!AJ[Uv !KAVV6v !JA[Viv UAJ!6v&7GIS(LI8DIFJ4(4\KSIDF49 WY<-XY[

78&+.50+?%$-.+?#:.0$-+.8#.+&P;*#%1&2+.8&+@%99&-.+;#$.+0?+.8&+<#$%#1:&+$&;$&-&1.+$&-;&:.%<&*>.8&+-0:%#*+#12+/#$S&.%19+2%/&1-%01-C+1&#$*>+5%.8+#**+.8&+%.&/-+.8&0$&.%:#**>+:80-&1+%1+.8&=)&-.%011#%$&+2&-%91+?0$+.8&-&+.50+2%/&1-%01-A

78&+ .50+ *#-.+ ?#:.0$-+ #$&+ /0$&+ 2%??%:)*.+ .0+ %1.&$;$&.R+ .8&>+ $&;$&-&1.+ #+ /%P+ 0?+ %.&/-.8&0$&.%:#**>+*%1S&2+.0+.8&+;$02):.%01+2%/&1-%01+#12+.0+.8&+?%1#1:%#*+2%/&1-%01+0?+@)-%1&--;&$?0$/#1:&A

Q-+ ?0$+ .8&+ ;$&<%0)-+ ;$%1:%;#*+ :0/;01&1.+ #1#*>-%-C+ 10+ -.#.%-.%:#*+ 2%??&$&1:&+ #;;&#$&2@&.5&&1+$&9%01-+#12+@&.5&&1+:0)1.$%&-A

R<R<!(%7884SIGD7F:(U4G644F(IJGDLDGD4:(KCG(DFG7(K8IJGDJ4(IF9(UC:DF4::(K48H78EIFJ4

7#@*&+K+9%<&-+.8&+:0$$&*#.%01+/#.$%P+@&.5&&1+.8&+!J+9$0);-+0?+#:.%<%.%&-+%1<&-.%9#.&2+%1+.8&=)&-.%011#%$&+#12+.8&+L+2%/&1-%01-+0?+@)-%1&--+;&$?0$/#1:&A

7#@*&+KR+I0$$&*#.%01D-+@&.5&&1+#:.%01-+#12+$&-)*.-$'!$ .2/)#.$%&!_!&!.'

#/)=2%&< "$/3< *!0$0%. ')%!$@ #/)=2%&< "$/3< *!0$0%. ')%!$@

(FZEIj JCLU[ JC6KW JC[Ji JCL[V JCLKK JC6K[ JC[6W JCL[[Q4(OI74 -]WZZ JC[J! JC6WJ JCL!J -]WZ+ JC[6W JC6UL JCLJU

FTbOI7E3O4 JCLKW JC[6W JC6L6 JC[!V JCLKV JC[J6 JC6[V JC[JWO"4 -]WX+ JC6UJ JCL[! JCLUV -]WYX JC[Li JCLVV -]W>Z

F(OnQ7EFB JCLWK JC[!K JC[i! JCLVV JCLKL JC[[W JC[iK JCLK67nQEBEBp -]Z,+ JCL6L JCL!V -]W,V -]ZWV JCLL! JCL6W JCi[6IF""rBEI -]WXR JCLLU JCL6L JCLK! -]WX> JCLV! JCLKJ JCLWWoFIr"OB7A -]W-Y JC[W6 JCL6! -]W,Y JCLUU JC[WK JCL!6 -]WR+IFB7nFZ -]X-V -]WZ- -]W>Z -]W-, -]X-Z -]WZV -]WRV -]W-ZINOI, -]Z,X JCL!! JCLWL -]WZR -]ZWY JCLiL -]W-R -]WXZ

Q**+.8&-&+:0$$&*#.%01-+#$&+-%91%?%:#.%<&+#12+;0-%.%<&+#12+.8&>+#$&+$&#**>+:0/;#$#@*&+@&.5&&1Q-%#+#12+O)$0;&A+a%.80).+#1>+:#)-#*+#--)/;.%01C+5&+:#1+-#>+.8#.+]+.8&+8%98&$+.8&+#:.%<%.>C.8&+8%98&$+.8&+$&-)*.-+ A

I0$$&*#.%01-+ #$&+ 8%98&$+ ?0$+ .8&+ ;$02):.%01+ #12+ .8&+ -0:%#*+ 2%/&1-%01-+ 0?+ @)-%1&--;&$?0$/#1:&+ .8#1+ ?0$+/#$S&.%19+ #12+ ?%1#1:&A+ 78%-+ :#1+ @&+ &P;*#%1&2+ @>+ .8&+ ?#:.+ .8#.+ .8&&??&:.-+0?+#:.%<%.%&-+)12&$.#S&1+@>+:0/;#1%&-+.0+@&+:&$.%?%&2+#$&+%1.&$1#**>+2%$&:.*>+0@-&$<&2G:*&#$+ &??&:.+ 01+ ;$02):.%01H+ #12+ &P.&$1#**>+ <%-%@*&+ G:*&#$+ &??&:.+ 01+ -0:%#*+ 2%/&1-%01HAI01<&$-&*>C+:01-&=)&1:&-+01+/#$S&.%19+#12+?%1#1:%#*+$&-)*.-+:0)*2+1&&2+*019&$+.%/&+.0+@&%2&1.%?%&2+#12+#$&+/#>@&+*&--+&<%2&1.+.0+@&+0@-&$<&2+@>+.8&+$&-;012&1.-A

Page 15: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!i

7#@*&+ W+ ;$&-&1.-+ .8&+ *%1S-+ .8#.+ 8#<&+ @&&1+ -.#.%-.%:#**>+ &-.#@*%-8&2+ @&.5&&1+ &*&/&1.-+ 0?&1<%$01/&1.#*+#:.%01-+#12+/#1#9&/&1.C+ #12+:01-&=)&1:&-+0?+ E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01+01@)-%1&--+;&$?0$/#1:&A+78&+?%9)$&-+9%<&1+%1+.8&+7#@*&+K+#$&+ .8&+&-.%/#.&2+:0&??%:%&1.-+ ?0$.8&+*%1&#$+$&*#.%01+@&.5&&1+.8&+d$&-)*.e+%12%:#.0$+#12+.8&+#:.%<%.%&-+/&1.%01&2+%1+.8&+-#/&:&**-A

7#@*&+WR+4.#.%-.%:#*+*%1S-+@&.5&&1+#:.%<%.%&-+#12+@&1&?%.-$:DI(`(.C87K4 $:DI .C87K4

'7JDIS o0:)/&1.#.%01JA!i!W

*DFIFJ4 O"4JA!W

I0//)1%:#.%01JA!VI01.$0*JA[V

I01.$0*JA[VK

I01.$0*JA[iL

"I8^4GDFP O"4JA6i

I0//)1%:#.%01JA6UI01.$0*JALU

O"4JA[6W

I0//)1%:#.%01JA[6

I0//)1%:#.%01JA6KI01.$0*JALK

#879CJGD7F Q-;&:.-JAJU

7$#%1%19JA!KI01.$0*JA[6

7$#%1%19JA6

I8&:SJA!W

Q**+.8&+:0&??%:%&1.-+#$&+;0-%.%<&+58%:8+/&#1-C+d.8&+/0$&+.8&+:0/;#1>+%-+%1<0*<&2+%1+#:.%010$+#:.%<&C+.8&+@&-.+$&-)*.+.8&+$&-;012&1.+0@-&$<&-+%1+.8&+@)-%1&--+2%/&1-%01eA+Z&.D-+#1#*>-&&#:8+@)-%1&--+;&$?0$/#1:&+2%/&1-%01+-&;#$#.&*>R

Y-<#+.)<-66#(6%"(H+F1+.8&+9*0@#*+*&<&*WC+.8&+2&<&*0;/&1.+0?+20:)/&1.#.%01+G01+5#-.&C+01&1<%$01/&1.#*+ /#1#9&/&1.+ ;$0:&2)$&-+ #12+ 01+ -;&:%?%:+ ;$0:&2)$&-+ 8&*;-+ ?0$+ -0:%#*:0//%./&1.H+ %-+ $&*#.&2+ .0+ .8&+ -0:%#*+ 2%/&1-%01+ 0?+ ;&$?0$/#1:&A+ E1+ ?#:.C+ 20:)/&1.#.%01;$0<%2&-+ %1?0$/#.%01+ .0+ .8&+ 2%??&$&1.+ -.#S&80*2&$-+ G%1.&$1#*+ #12+ &P.&$1#*H+ #12+ .8&-&+ :#1@&:0/&+/0$&+-#.%-?%&2A

N#"+"<%H+ T&%19+ #:.%<&+ %1+ O"4+ 5%**+ :012):.+ .0+ ;0-%.%<&+ ?%1#1:%#*+ $&-)*.-A+ 78%-+ :#1+ @&:0/@%1&2+?0$+-.%**+@&..&$+ ?%1#1:%#*+ $&-)*.-+5%.8+:0//)1%:#.%01+#12+:01.$0*+ #:.%<%.%&-A+78&/0-.+ %1?*)&1:%19+&*&/&1.+8&$&+%-+ .8&+0;&$#.%01#*+:01.$0*+#12+%.-+:0/;01&1.-A+ E1+Q-%#+#12O)$0;&C+01*>+.8%-+&*&/&1.+%1?*)&1:&-+.8&+?%1#1:%#*+$&-)*.-A

W+&P%(#"FH+ O"4+ #:.%<%.%&-+ -&&/+ .0+ 8#<&+ ;0-%.%<&+ :01-&=)&1:&-+ 01+ /#$S&.%19AI0//)1%:#.%01+%-+0?+:0)$-&+#+.00*+?0$+&18#1:%19+/#$S&.%19+-;&:%?%:#.%01-+#12+0;&$#.%01#*:01.$0*+ #:.%<%.%&-+ 8#<&+ .8&+ d8%98&-.e+ *&<&*+ 0?+ %1?*)&1:&A+ I0//)1%:#.%01+ %1?*)&1:&+ 01/#$S&.%19+$&-)*.-+%-+0@-&$<&2+%1+Q-%#+#12+O)$0;&A+78&+Q-%#1+#12+O)$0;&#1+-;&:%?%:%.%&-+#$&-&&1+.8$0)98+.8&+?#:.+.8#.+%1+Q-%#C+-.%**+.8&+O"4+#:.%<%.%&-+#$&+-&&1+#-+%1?*)&1:%19+;0-%.%<&*>.8&+/#$S&.%19+$&-)*.-+@).+2&<&*0;%19+.8&+0;&$#.%01#*+:01.$0*+20&-+10.+-&&/+.0+9&.+#1+%/;#:.

Page 16: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!V

01+ /#$S&.%19A+ 78%-+ %-+ .8&+ :01.$#$>+ %1+ O)$0;&C+ 58&$&+ 0;&$#.%01#*+ :01.$0*+ %-+ #:.%<&+ 01/#$S&.%19+#12+58&$&+O"4+20&-+10.+-&&/+.0+8#<&+#1>+%1?*)&1:&A

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

,<! %)0%@2'!)0

E1+ .8&+ :01.&P.+ 0?+ %1.&$1#.%01#*+ #:.%<%.%&-+ 0?+ .8&+ 0$9#1%-#.%01-+ #12+ %1+ .8&+ -;%$%.+ 0?+ 9*0@#*-.#.)-+ 0?+ .8&+ &1<%$01/&1.C+5&+ 2&<&*0;&2+ #1+ %1.&$1#.%01#*+ :0/;#$#.%<&+ #1#*>-%-C+ ;0%1.%190).+ 805+ #12+ .0+ 58#.+ &P.&1.+ %1<&-./&1.+ %1+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ $&#**>+ 8&*;-+ .8&0$9#1%-#.%01-+ #12+ @$%19-+ %1+ $&.)$1-A+ 78%-+ %1.&$1#.%01#*+ #1#*>-%-+ 2%??&$-+ ?$0/+ /0-.+ 0?&P%-.%19+-.)2%&-+.8#.+8#<&+@&&1+$&#*%-&2+%1+#+<&$>+*%/%.&2+-:0;&+G$&9%01#*+0$+1#.%01#*H+5%.8:0/;#1%&-+?$0/+-;&:%?%:+-&:.0$-+0?+#:.%<%.%&-+G:8&/%:#*-C+&*&:.$%:+).%*%.>gHA

O--&1.%#**>+ &/;%$%:#*C+ .8&+ $&-&#$:8+5#-+ :012):.&2+ .8$0)98+=)&-.%011#%$&-+ .8#.+ 8#<&+ @&&1/#%*&2+.0+#+-#/;*&+0?+:&$.%?%&2+:0/;#1%&-+?$0/+Q-%#1+#12+O)$0;&#1+:0)1.$%&-A+7&1+9$0);-0?+#:.%<%.%&-+)12&$.#S&1+@>+:&$.%?%&2+:0/;#1%&-+8#<&+@&&1+#1#*>-&2+#-+5&**+#-+?0)$+@)-%1&--;&$?0$/#1:&+ 2%/&1-%01-+ %1+ 0$2&$+ .0+ &<#*)#.&+ .8&+ ;0.&1.%#*+ %/;#:.-+ 0?+ E4F+!LJJJ:&$.%?%:#.%01+01+0$9#1%-#.%01-A

T&?0$&+ 2$#5%19+ :01:*)-%01-+ ?$0/+ .8%-+ #1#*>-%-C+ *&.D-+ $&/%12+ .8&+ *%/%.-+ 0?+ .8%-+ &/;%$%:#*-.)2>A

,<+<!(@DEDGIGD7F:

78%-+$&-&#$:8+8#-+.0+@&+:01-%2&$&2+#-+&P;*0$#.0$>+5%.8+#**+.8&+*%/%.#.%01-+0?+#1+&P;*0$#.0$>;$0:&--A

78&+.#$9&.+;0;)*#.%01+%-+/#2&+0?+:&$.%?%&2+:0/;#1%&-A+o)&+.0+.8#.C+5&+:#1+&P;&:.+.0+8#<&=)%.&+,-6-F%"%-0')&%'9-"'%'C+#.+*&#-.+%1+.8&+?%$-.+;#$.+0?+.8&+=)&-.%011#%$&A

78&+=)&-.%011#%$&+5#-+@#-&2+01+9%&<%9(#-"')+"1)-9#"#-"'H+.8&+<#*%2%.>+:#110.+@&+:8&:S&2C5&+ 8#<&+ .0+ ;).+ .$)-.+ %1+ $&-;012&1.-A+ N05&<&$C+ &-;&:%#**>+ %1+ -):8+ #+ .0;%:C+ $&-;012&1.-50)*2+#<0%2+9%<%19+@#2+%/#9&+0?+.8&%$+:0/;#1>+#12+.8&+@%#-+0?+dR%((%&)%'(#6+(#-"e+:#1+@&%/;0$.#1.A

I01:&$1%19+.8&+:01-&=)&1:&-+0?+.8&+E4F+!LJJJ+:&$.%?%:#.%01+01+@)-%1&--+2%/&1-%01-C+-0/&$&-;012&1.-+ :0)*2+ #1-5&$+ 2)&+ .0+ .8&%$+ %O9%&#%"<%C+ 0.8&$+ :0)*2+ 8#<&+ #1-5&$&2+ 01+ X0(0&%%O9%<(+(#-"'A+ 78%-+ :0)*2+ 9%<&+ #+ <&$>+ 2%??&$&1.+ %/#9&+ 0?+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ %/;#:.-+ 01;&$?0$/#1:&A

\)$.8&$/0$&C+.8&+-#/;*&+8#-+@&&1+:01-.%.).&2+5%.8+.8&+=)&-.%011#%$&-+.8#.+:#/&+@#:SA+78&$&-;012&1.-D+#).0'-&*&:.%01+:#1+*&#2+.0+@%#-A

Page 17: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!K

,<><!(@4I8FDFP:

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

Z%1S%19+d#:.%01-e+#12+d$&-)*.-eC+01*>+;0-%.%<&+$&*#.%01-+8#<&+@&&1+?0)12A+a8#.+:#1+@&+.8&2%/&1-%01C+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ ;$0<%2&-+ 0$+5%**+ ;$0<%2&+ $&-)*.-C+ *&#2%19+ .0+ @)-%1&--;&$?0$/#1:&A+78%-+ *%1S+ %-+8%98&$+ %1+($02):.%01+ #12+40:%#*+ 2%/&1-%01-A+F1+01&+8#12C+ .8&&??&:.+01+.8&+;$02):.%01+$&-)*.-+:#1+@&+)12&$-.002+@>+.8&+?#:.+.8#.+@&%19+:&$.%?%&2+$&=)%$&--0/&+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ #:.%01-+ .0+ .8&+ ?%$/A+ Q+ -80$.'.&$/+ <%&5+ 0?+ .8&-&+ #:.%01-+ %-+ %1+ .8&;$02):.%01+#$&#A+F1+.8&+0.8&$+8#12C+.8&+&??&:.+01+.8&+-0:%#*+#-;&:.+:#1+@&+&P;*#%1&2+@>+.8&?#:.+.8#.+:0//)1%:#.%01+#12+%1?0$/#.%01+#$0)12+.8&+:0/;#1>+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&*&#2-+.0+-.#S&80*2&$-D+-#.%-?#:.%01A

E1+Q-%#+#-+%1+O)$0;&C+#:.%01-+$&*#.&2+.0+20:)/&1.#.%01+#12+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;0*%:>+2&-%91+#$&;$%0$%.>C+ @).+ .8&+ 0;&$#.%01#*+ :01.$0*C+ .8&+ 2&?%1%.%01+ 0?+ 0@X&:.%<&-+ #12+ .#$9&.-+ #12:0//)1%:#.%01+#$&+10.+-0+/):8+2&<&*0;&2UA

\%1#**>C+5&+:0)*2+;$0;0-&+#+-%/;*&+*%1&#$+/02&*+*%1S%19+.8&+@)-%1&--+$&-)*.-+2%/&1-%01-+.0.8&+ d&1<%$01/&1.#*+ #:.%01-e+ 2&<&*0;&2+ @>+ .8&+ :0/;#1>A+ 78%-+ /02&*+ %-+ #+ ?%$-.+ -.&;+ ?0$?)$.8&$+%1<&-.%9#.%01+@).+#.+.8%-+*&<&*+0?+%1?0$/#.%01+5&+0@-&$<&+.8#.R• ! o0:)/&1.#.%01+ 8#-+ #+ ;0-%.%<&+ %/;#:.+ %1+ -0:%#*+ :0//%./&1.+ 0?+ .8&+ :0/;#1>A+ 78%-+ %-$&*&<#1.+ #-+ .8$0)98+ #:.%01-+ 0?+ 20:)/&1.#.%01C+ .8&+ :0/;#1>+ ?)*?%*-+ %.-+ -0:%#*:0//%./&1.C+-#.%-?>%19+%.-+-.#S&80*2&$-A

• ! Q:.%01-+#12+:8#$#:.&$%-.%:-+ $&*#.&2+ .0+O1<%$01/&1.#*+"#1#9&/&1.+4>-.&/C+ #:.%01-+0?:0//)1%:#.%01+ #12+ 0;&$#.%01#*+ :01.$0*+ @0.8+ *&#2+ .0+ &18#1:&/&1.+ 0?+ ?%1#1:%#*+ #12/#$S&.%19+ $&-)*.-A+ 78&+ 0;&$#.%01#*+ :01.$0*+ 8#-+ .8&+ 8%98&-.+ %/;#:.+ %1+ .8%-+ $&*#.%01A+ E.-&&/-+1#.)$#*+ .8#.+0;&$#.%01#*+:01.$0*+ .8#.+0;.%/%-&-+/#.&$%#*+:01-)/;.%01C+;)$:8#-&C0$9#1%-&-+@&1:8/#$S-C+g+8#-+ %1?*)&1:&+01+:0-.-+#12+;$0?%.-C+ %1:$&#-&+ -#*&-C+ ;$0<%2&-1&5+/#$S&.-+0;;0$.)1%.%&-C+g

• ! 7$#%1%19C+ 0;&$#.%01#*+ :01.$0*+ #12+ #1#*>-%-+ 0?+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ #-;&:.-+ 8#<&+ ;0-%.%<&%1?*)&1:&+%1+.8&+;$02):.%01+#$&#A+Q9#%1C+.8&-&+$&*#.%01-+#$&+10.+-)$;$%-%19_+.8&-&+#:.%01-@&%19+=)%.&+.&:81%:#*+:0)*2+8#<&+%1?*)&1:&+%1+;$02):.%01A

• ! E1+ Q-%#+ #12+ %1+ O)$0;&C+ 0;&$#.%01#*+ :01.$0*+ %/;$0<&-+ ?%1#1:%#*+ $&-)*.-+ #12:0//)1%:#.%01+%-+%/;0$.#1.+?0$+%/;$0<%19+/#$S&.%19A

• ! 40/&+2%??&$&1:&-+#;;&#$&2+@&.5&&1+Q-%#+#12+O)$0;&C+%1+.&$/-+0?+?#:.0$-+0?+%1?*)&1:&-R10+/02&*+:0)*2+@&+;$0;0-&2+?0$+&P;*#1#.%01+0?+-0:%#*+:0//%./&1._+/#$S&.%19+$&-)*.--&&/+ .0+ @&+ %1?*)&1:&2+ @>+ O"4+ #:.%<%.%&-+ #12+ 10.+ @>+ 0;&$#.%01#*+ :01.$0*+ %1+ Q-%#1@)-%1&--+@).+.8%-+%-+.8&+:01.$#$>+%1+O)$0;&#1+@)-%1&--_+;$02):.%01+$&-)*.-+:0)*2+10.+@&/02&**&2+ %1+Q-%#+ @).+ %1+O)$0;&C+ .$#%1%19+ #12+ :8&:S%19+ #12+ :0$$&:.%<&+ #:.%01-+ #$&+ 0?%1?*)&1:&A

78%-+ &/;%$%:#*+ #1#*>-%-+ 01+ .8&+ :01-&=)&1:&-+ 0?+ E4F+ !LJJJ+ :&$.%?%:#.%01+ 01+ @)-%1&--;&$?0$/#1:&+9#<&+-0/&+?%$-.+%1-%98.-+?0$+.8&+&=)#.%01R+d@&..&$+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.

Page 18: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!W

5%**+*&#2+.0+@&..&$+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&C+%1:$&#-&2+&??%:%&1:>+#12+#+9$&#.&$+$&.)$1+01%1<&-./&1.eA

,<R<!(=D84JGD7F:(H78(HCGC84(84:4I8JN

E1+ #+ 1&P.+ -.&;C+ 5&+ ;*#1+ .0+ #2/%1%-.$#.&+ #12+ #2#;.+ .8&+ =)&-.%011#%$&+ .0+ 101+ :&$.%?%&2:0/;#1%&-+%1+0$2&$+ .0+9&.+#+:01.$0*+-#/;*&C+;$0<%2%19+/0$&+<#$%#@%*%.>+%1+.8&+-#/;*&+#12/#.&$%#*-+ .0+ %1?%$/+ 0$+ :01?%$/+ #).80$-+ G&A9AC+ B#-8C+ !UUWH+ 580+ :*#%/+ .8#.+ :&$.%?%&2:0/;#1%&-+ %/;$0<&+ .8&%$+ &1<%$01/&1.#*+ ;&$?0$/#1:&+ /0$&+ -*05*>+ .8#1+ 101+ :&$.%?%&2:0/;#1%&-A

$%30)A@.=Q.".0&'

78&+=)&-.%011#%$&+5#-+2&-%91&2+@>+($0?&--0$+()$@#+n#0+#12+($0?&--0$+T)$.+N#/1&$+?$0/.8&+Q-%#1+E1-.%.).&+0?+"#1#9&/&1.+GQE"C+"#1%*#C+78&+(8%*%;;%1&-HA78&+ 2#.#+ :0**&:.%01+ %1+ Q-%#+ 8#-+ @&&1+ 201&+ .8#1S-+ .0+ .8&+ :0**#@0$#.%01+ 0?+ .8&+ n&9%01#*E1-.%.).&+0?+O1<%$01/&1.#*+7&:810*09>+GnEO7C+4%19#;0$&HAa&+#*-0+5#1.+.0+#:S105*&29&+N019+,019+;$02):.%<%.>+I0)1:%*+?0$+.8&%$+#--%-.#1:&+?0$+.8&-)$<&>+:012):.&2+%1+N019+,019A

0)&.'

!+8..;Rkk555A=)#*%.>A:0A)Sk=)#*%.>kE4F!LJJJA8./*6+p0<&$1/&1.+5%**+%1-;&:.+*&--+?$&=)&1.*>+:&$.%?%&2+0;&$#.%19+)1%.-A[+ Q::0$2%19+ .0+ T&*cC+ 4$#11&9#$2+ &.+ #*A+ G!UUKHC+ .8&$&+ %-+ #+ 1&).$#**>+ 0$+ -*%98.*>+ 1&9#.%<&:0$$&*#.%01+@&.5&&1+&1<%$01/&1.#*+%1%.%#.%<&-+#12+-80$.'.&$/+;$0?%.-AL+E.+2&;&12-+01+.8&+:$&2%@%*%.>+0?+.8&+:&$.%?%:#.%01+;$0:&--+#12+0?+.8&+:&$.%?%&$-Ai+E.+2&;&12-+01+.8&+*&<&*+0?+-.#S&80*2&$-D+%1<0*<&/&1.+%1+.8&+;$0:&--AV+B0+-.#.%-.%:#*+2%??&$&1:&+#.+*&<&*+ivC+?0$+.8&+2%??&$&1.+.&-.-+.8#.+8#<&+@&&1+2&<&*0;&2AK+78%-+:#1+@&+2)&+.0+.8&+-#/;*&+*05+<#$%#@%*%.>+G-%1:&+#**+:0/;#1%&-+#$&+:&$.%?%&2+#12+8#<&.0+$&-;012+.0+.8&+-#/&+E4F+$&=)%$&/&1.-+#@0).+#:.%<%.%&-+.0+;).+%1.0+;*#:&HAW+B0+-;&:%?%:+%1?*)&1:&+#;;&#$&2+%1+Q-%#+#12+%1+O)$0;&AU+78&-&+:0//&1.-+#$&+9%<&1+?0$+#+/#$9%1#*+*&<&*A

/.*./.0%.'

T#>*%-C+ nAC+ I011&**C+ ZA+ #12+ \*>11C+ QAC+ *-69+">) '#a%?) %"$#&-"6%"(+.) &%F0.+(#-") +"1%<-.-F#<+.) 6-1%&"#a+(#-"H) N0&(,%&) +"+.>'#') +() (,%) .%$%.) -X) (,%) X#&6C+ T)-%1&--4.$#.&9>+#12+.8&+O1<%$01/&1.C+30*A+KC+;;A6Wi'6UVC+!UUWA

T&*cC+ \A+ C+ 4.$#11&9#$2C+ ZA+ &.+ #*AC+ 3"(%&"+(#-"+.) A0'#"%'') 8"$#&-"6%"(+.) A+&-6%(%&+@SSMCI#;;&*&1+#S#2&/%-S+?0$*#9C+F-*0+!UUKA

T%012%C+3AC+\$&>C+"A+#12+E$#*20C+\AC+8"$#&-"6%"(+.)6+"+F%6%"()'>'(%6)#69.%6%"(+(#-")R>YW8'H) 8!) %O9%&#%"<%) +"1) 9%&'9%<(#$%'C+ ;#;&$+ ;$&-&1.&2+ #.+ .8&+ K.8+ E1.&$1#.%01#*I01?&$&1:&+ 0?+ .8&+p$&&1%19+ 0?+ E12)-.$>+B&.50$S+ '+ (#$.1&$-8%;+ #12+ Z&#2&$-8%;) bT)%*2%19+#**%#1:&-+?0$+#+-)-.#%1#@*&+?).)$&C+n0/&C+B0<&/@&$+!V+!UUWA

Page 19: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

!U

T0$98%1%C+4A+#12+3%:%1%C+pAC+5#&9-&('?)8"$#&-"6%"()+"1)=%$%.-96%"(H)5<,#%$#"F)+)R+.+"<%R>)#69.%6%"(#"F)%"$#&-"6%"(+.)6+"+F%6%"()'>'(%6'C+\OO"+B&5-*&..&$C+1w!C+Q;$%*!UUWA

T`$S&>C+ (A+ #12+ B#2#qC+ QAC) G,%) %<-"-6#<') +"1) .+V) -X) $-.0"(+&>) +99&-+<,%') #"%"$#&-"6%"(+.)9-.#<>C+\OO"+B&5-*&..&$C+1w[C+!UUVA

I0$@&..C+ IA+ bA+ #12+ ,%$-:8C+ oAQAC+ 3"(%&"+(#-"+.) 1#XX0'#-") -X) 3YZ) SLLL) +"1) @CLLL<%&(#X#<+(#-"C+;#;&$+;$&-&1.&2+#.+.8&+K.8+E1.&$1#.%01#*+I01?&$&1:&+0?+.8&+p$&&1%19+0?E12)-.$>+ B&.50$S+ '+ (#$.1&$-8%;+ #12+ Z&#2&$-8%;+ l+ T)%*2%19+ #**%#1:&-+ ?0$+ #-)-.#%1#@*&+?).)$&C+n0/&C+B0<&/@&$+!UUWA

I0$@&..C+IA+bA+#12+,%$-:8C+oAQAC+G,%).#"P+F%)R%(V%%")3YZ)SLLL)+"1)3YZ)@CLLL+'(+"1+&1'H5") #"(%&"+(#-"+.) '(01>C+ I>@&$+ 50$S%19+ ;#;&$+ -&$%&-C+ 78&+ Q12&$-01+ 4:800*+ #.rIZQC+B0A+UU'!C+!UUUA

p&*@&$C+"AC+N#1?C+TA+#12+Nx.8&$C+4AC+8W5Y)#69.%6%"(+(#-")+()c#99)#")7%&6+">C+ p$&&1&$+"#1#9&/&1.+E1.&$1#.%01#*C+E--)&+!LC+Q;$%*+!UUVA

p*&:S/#1C+NA+#12+,$).C+nAC+E%#(,%&)#"(%&"+(#-"+.)"-&)'(+"1+&1H)G,%).#6#(')-X)3YZ)@CLL@)+'+") 3"'(&06%"() -X) 7.-R+.) *-&9-&+(%) 8"$#&-"6%"(+.) W+"+F%6%"(C+ p$&&1&$"#1#9&/&1.+E1.&$1#.%01#*C+E--)&+!LC+Q;$%*+!UUVA

EE4o+GE1.&$1#.%01#*+ E1-.%.).&+?0$+4)-.#%1#@*&+o&<&*0;/&1.HC+7.-R+.)7&%%")Y(+"1+&1'K) 3YZ@CLLL)+"1)Y0'(+#"+R.%)=%$%.-96%"(C+!UUVA

b081-01C+ (AC+ E4F!LJJJR+ G,%) R0'#"%'') W+"+F%&_') <-69.%(%) F0#1%) (-) %"$#&-"6%"(+.6+"+F%6%"(?)a%*&>+s)#*%.>+"#1#9&/&1.C+b081+a%*&>+y+401-C+E1:C+!UUKA

,&-.&/01.C+ "'(A+ #12+ j..&$8)-C+ TAOA+ &.+ #*AC+ G,%) #"(%&"+(#-"+.) A0'#"%'') 8"$#&-"6%"(+.A+&-6%(%&H) 8"$#&-"6%"(+.) 6+"+F%6%"() #") 80&-9%) +"1) '-6%) 5'#+") #''0%'C+ %1;$09$&--A

,%1-&**#C+ bAC+ 3YZ) @CLLL) '(+"1) X-&) %"$#&-"6%"(+.) 6+"+F%6%"(C+ ;#;&$+ ;$&-&1.&2+ #.Q$/01%c#:%01+ 2&*+ I0/&$:%0C+ E1.&$1#.%01#*+ >+ /&2%0+ Q/@%&1.&C+ T)&10-+ Q%$&-CQ$9&1.%1#C+4&;.&/@&$+K'U+!UULA

B#-8C+bAC+G,%)`-.%)-X)G&+1%)5''-<#+(#-"')#")3"10'(&#+.)G&+"'X-&6+(#-"C+#@-.$#:.+0?+#+;#;&$;$&-&1.&2+#.+.8&+K.8+E1.&$1#.%01#*+I01?&$&1:&+0?+.8&+p$&&1%19+0?+E12)-.$>+B&.50$S+'(#$.1&$-8%;+ #12+ Z&#2&$-8%;+ l+ T)%*2%19+ #**%#1:&-+ ?0$+ #+ -)-.#%1#@*&+ ?).)$&C+ n0/&CB0<&/@&$+!K+!UUWA

(#.1&>C+ QAC+ 8"$#&-"6%"(+.) 6+"+F%6%"(H) W+P#"F) +) d<.%+"_) #"$%'(6%"(C+ nEO7+ %1+ \0:)-C30*A+[C+5%1.&$+!UUKA

($%19*&C+ bA+ #12+ \%.c9&$#*2C+ "AC+ E+(#-"+.) 9-..0(#-") 9&%$%"(#-") &-0"1(+R.%H) 3'-@CLLLe-&PF&-09C+b#1)#$>+6W+!UUWA

nEO7kQO7+()@*%:#.%01C+8"$#&-"6%"(+.)W+"+F%6%"()#")5'#+)@SSMH)5)F0#1%)(-)3YZ)@CLLLC!UUKA

4.0&--&$C+(A"AC+A%>-"1)3YZ)@CLL@H)Z"(+&#-)c>1&-_')8"$#&-"6%"(+.)W+"+F%6%"()Y>'(%6Cp$&&1&$+"#1#9&/&1.+E1.&$1#.%01#*C+E--)&+!LC+Q;$%*+!UUVA

4)12&$*#12C+ 7AbAC+ 8"$#&-"6%"(+.) 6+"+F%6%"() '(+"1+&1') +"1) <%&(#X#<+(#-"H) =-) (,%>) +11$+.0%fC+p$&&1&$+"#1#9&/&1.+E1.&$1#.%01#*C+E--)&+!LC+Q;$%*+!UUVA

a#**#:&'b01&-C+bAC+G,%)0'%)-X)$-.0"(+&>)+99&-+<,%')+')%"$#&-"6%"(+.)9-.#<>) #"'(&06%"('C\OO"+B&5-*&..&$C+1w[C+o&:&/@&$+!UUWA

a#**&>C+BA+#12+a8%.&8&#2C+TAC+3(_')"-()%+'>)R%#"F)F&%%"C+ %1R+a&*?0$2C+nA+#12+4.#$S&>C+nAG&2-AHC+T)-%1&--+#12+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.C+O#$.8-:#1C+Z01201C+;;A+[V'LLC+!UUVA

a0*??C+nA+&.+#*AC+G,%)E-&1#<)A0'#"%'')8"$#&-"6%"(+.)A+&-6%(%&C+T&2$%?.φS010/&1-+\0$*#9CF-*0+!UUiA

Page 20: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

6J

$##.0=!a(;(/4:4I8JN(BC4:GD7FFID84<

#7SDJ5 n6[R+O"4+$&;0$.-+%1:*)2&+.8&+#/0)1.-+0?+&1&$9>+#12+5#.&$+)-&2C.8&+5#-.&+@&%19+9&1&$#.&2+@>+.8&+:0/;#1>C+#12+.8&+$&-)*.%19+:0-.-A

n!R+F)$+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;0*%:>+#22$&--&-+-;&:%?%:+%/;#:.-+0?+0)$#:.%<%.%&-+G#%$k5#.&$+;0**).%01C+-0*%2+5#-.&C+;$02):.+%/;#:.-C+&.:HA

&8IDFDFP

n6R+F)$+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;0*%:>+%-+?0:)-&2+01+;$&<&1.%19+;0**).%01#.+.8&+-0)$:&+.8$0)98+@&..&$+0;&$#.%19+;$#:.%:&-C+#12+10.+X)-.+01.$&#.%19+5#-.&-+.0+:0/;*>+5%.8+90<&$1/&1.+-.#12#$2-A

n6iR+O/;*0>&&-+#$&+.$#%1&2+.0+@&+:0/;&.&1.+%1+.8&+@&-.&1<%$01/&1.#*+;$#:.%:&-+#;;$0;$%#.&+?0$+.8&%$+;0-%.%01-G;$02):.%01C+#::0)1.%19C+/#$S&.%19C+2&-%91C+&.:AH

n[R+a&+#$&+:0//%..&2+.0+:0/;*%#1:&+5%.8+.8&+/0-.+-.$%19&1.-.#12#$2-+0?+#**+.8&+:0)1.$%&-+%1+58%:8+5&+0;&$#.&C+10.+X)-.+.0+.8&*0:#*+-.#12#$2:<

n6VR+O/;*0>&&-+#$&+&1:0)$#9&2+.0+-.#>+);'.0'2#.&+01+.8&+@&-.&1<%$01/&1.#*+;$#:.%:&-+%1+.8&%$+;$0?&--%01-+.8$0)98+;$0?&--%01#*#--0:%#.%01-C+.$#2&+X0)$1#*-C+/&&.%19-C+&.:A

nLR+F)$+?$#/&50$S+?0$+-&..%19+#12+$&<%&5%19+&1<%$01/&1.#*0@X&:.%<&-+#12+.#$9&.-+%-+%1.&9$#.&2+5%.8+0)$+-&..%19+0?+@)-%1&--0@X&:.%<&-+#12+.#$9&.-A

n6KR+7$#%1%19+%1:*)2&-+/&.802-+?0$+#1#*>-%19+;$0:&--&-+#12%2&1.%?>%19+0;;0$.)1%.%&-+?0$+%/;$0<&/&1.A

niR+a&+#$&+;#$.%:)*#$*>+?0:)-&2+01+:0//)1%:#.%19+0)$&1<%$01/&1.#*+;0*%:>+.0+0)$+50$S&$-+580-&+0;&$#.%01-+8#<&+-0/&&1<%$01/&1.#*+%/;#:.A

n6WR+Q**+&/;*0>&&-+8#<&+#.+*&#-.+@#-%:+.$#%1%19+%1+.8&+:01:&;.-+0?&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.A

nVR+a&+/#S&+#1+#:.%<&+&??0$.+.0+:0//)1%:#.&+0)$+&1<%$01/&1.#*;0*%:>+.0+;)@*%:+9$0);-+.8#.+#$&+:01:&$1&2+#@0).+0)$&1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&A

%7EECFDJIGD7F

.FLD87FE4FGIS(I:K4JG: n6UR+O/;*0>&&-+/&&.+$&9)*#$*>+.0+2%-:)--+&1<%$01/&1.#*;&$?0$/#1:&A

nKR+F)$+->-.&/+.0+%2&1.%?>+&1<%$01/&1.#*+#-;&:.-+%1:*)2&-%2&1.%?%:#.%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+:0-.-+:$&#.&2+@>+0)$+&1<%$01/&1.#*%/;#:.-A

n[JR+O1<%$01/&1.#*+#::0/;*%-8/&1.-+#$&+;)@*%:%-&2+5%.8%1+.8&:0/;#1>A

nWR+a&+-&.+0@X&:.%<&-+#12+.#$9&.-+?0$+%/;$0<%19+0)$+;$02):.%01#12+-&$<%:&+;$0:&--&-+.0+$&2):&+.8&+)-&+0?+$&-0)$:&-+#12+.8&9&1&$#.%01+0?+5#-.&-A

n[!R+Q5#$2-+#$&+9%<&1+?0$+9002+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&A

)Ub4JGDL4:(IF9(GI8P4G: n[6R+a&+;)@*%-8+#+;)@*%:+$&;0$.+01+0)$+&1<%$01/&1.#*;&$?0$/#1:&A

nUR+a&+-&.+0@X&:.%<&-+#12+.#$9&.-+?0$+%/;$0<%19+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.#*2&-%91+0?+0)$+;$02):.-A

n[[R+a&+/#%1.#%1+$&9)*#$+:01.#:.+5%.8+<#$%0)-+&1<%$01/&1.#*/#1#9&/&1.+0$9#1%-#.%01-A

n!JR+a&+-&.+0@X&:.%<&-+#12+.#$9&.-+.0+%/;$0<&+0)$+/&#-)$&/&1.+0?&1<%$01/&1.#*+:0-.-A

n[LR+a&+-)@-:$%@&+.0+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+;)@*%:#.%01-A

.FLD87FE4FGIS("IFIP4E4FG('5:G4E n[iR+a&+/#%1.#%1+#+;0-%.%<&+&1<%$01/&1.#*+$&*#.%01-8%;+5%.8&P.&$1#*+9$0);-+-):8+#-+.8&+:0//)1%.>+#12+.8&+90<&$1/&1.A

n!!R+78&+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+;$09$#/+%-+#+5&**'2&?%1&2#12+5%2&*>+$&:091%-&2+;$09$#/+%1+0)$+:0/;#1>A

=7JCE4FGIGD7F

n!6R+78&+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+;$09$#/+%-+:0/;$&8&1-%<&C:0<&$%19+0)$+-);;*%&$-C+;$02):.%01C+;$02):.-C+#12+5#-.&/#1#9&/&1.A

n[VR+a&+/#%1.#%1+20:)/&1.#.%01+.8#.+2&-:$%@&-+58&$&C+58&1+#12805+/):8+5#-.&+%-+9&1&$#.&2+?$0/+0)$+;$0:&--&-A

n![R+a&+S105+#@0).+#12+)-&+.8&+-&$<%:&-+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*/#1#9&/&1.+#--%-.#1:&+0$9#1%-#.%01-A

n[KR+o0:)/&1.#.%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+;$0:&2)$&-+%-&#-%*>+#<#%*#@*&+.0+#**+&/;*0>&&-A

n!LR+O1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&+%-+#+-;&:%?%:+$&-;01-%@%*%.>+0?+#-&1%0$+&P&:).%<&A

n[WR+o0:)/&1.#.%01+0?+-;&:%?%:+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;$0:&2)$&-+%-*0:#.&2+#.+.8&+-;&:%?%:+;$0:&--&-+58&$&+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.#*;$0@*&/-+G*%S&+5#-.&+0$+.0P%:+:8&/%:#*+)-&H+0::)$A

n!iR+O1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&+%-+%1:*)2&2+%1+X0@+;&$?0$/#1:&&<#*)#.%01-+0?+#**+&/;*0>&&-+580-&+50$S+8#-+0$+:0)*2+8#<&+#-%91%?%:#1.+%/;#:.+01+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.A

)K48IGD7FIS(J7FG87S

n!VR+O#:8+/#X0$+?)1:.%01+0?+.8&+:0/;#1>+G;$02):.%01C#::0)1.%19C+/#$S&.%19C+&.:AH+8#-+-0/&01&+580+S105-+#@0).&1<%$01/&1.#*+#-;&:.-+0?+.8#.+;#$.%:)*#$+?)1:.%01A

n[UR+a&+8#<&+-;&:%?%:+:$%.&$%#+?0$+805+/):8+5#.&$+#12+0.8&$/#.&$%#*-+-80)*2+@&+)-&2+?0$+&#:8+-.&;+%1+0)$+;$0:&--&-A

n!KR+40/&01&+%1+.8&+:0/;#1>+8#-+.8&+-;&:%?%:+$&-;01-%@%*%.>+0?-.#>%19+);+.0+2#.&+01+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+%--)&-+#12/&.802-A

nLJR+78&$&+#$&+@&1:8/#$S-+?0$+;$0:&--+&1<%$01/&1.#*;&$?0$/#1:&+.8#.+5&+.$>+.0+:01-.#1.*>+%/;$0<&+0$+&P:&&2A

n!WR+a&+%1:*)2&+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+#-+#+-;&:%?%:+%.&/+%10)$+@)29&.+;*#11%19A

nL!R+F)$+;)$:8#-%19+2&;#$./&1.+#;;*%&-+&1<%$01/&1.#*+:$%.&$%#58&1+:01-%2&$%19+1&5+;)$:8#-&-A

n!UR+a&+;*#1+#8&#2+?0$+#.+*&#-.+.50+>&#$-+%1+&1<%$01/&1.#*/#1#9&/&1.A

nL6R+a&+%1?0$/+0)$+-);;*%&$-+#@0).+0)$+&1<%$01/&1.#*+90#*-+#12#-S+.8&/+.0+;$0<%2&+/0$&+&1<%$01/&1.#**>+?$%&12*>+;$02):.-A

n6JR+4.#??+%-+9%<&1+#2&=)#.&+.%/&+.0+20+.8&%$+&1<%$01/&1.#*+.#-S-_.8&-&+.#-S-+#$&+10.+X)-.+#22&2+01.0+58#.+.8&>+#$&+#*$&#2>+20%19A

nL[R+a&+&<#*)#.&+0)$+-);;*%&$-M+&1<%$01/&1.#*+;&$?0$/#1:&A

!EKS4E4FGIGD7F(IF9(7K48IGD7F nLLR+I01.$#:.0$-+580+50$S+?0$+)-+/)-.+:0/;*>+5%.8&1<%$01/&1.#*+;$0.&:.%01+$&=)%$&/&1.-A

n6!R+O1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+%-+#+$&9)*#$+%.&/+01+.8&+#9&12#?0$+.0;+/#1#9&/&1.+:0//%..&&+/&&.%19-A

%N4J^DFP(IF9(J7884JGDL4(IJGD7F

n66R+O"4+;&$?0$/#1:&+%-+$&;0$.&2+.0+.0;+/#1#9&/&1.+#.+*&#-.&<&$>+=)#$.&$A

nLiR+a&+/&#-)$&+0)$+)-&+0?+1#.)$#*+$&-0)$:&-+#12+9&1&$#.%01+0?5#-.&-+%1+.8&+;$02):.%01+;$0:&--&-C+10.+X)-.+#.+.8&+&12+0?+.8&2%-:8#$9&+;%;&A

Page 21: IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ...IMPACTS OF ISO 14000 CERTIFICATION ON BUSINESS ... ... !6

6!

nLVR+a&+S105+805+/):8+0)$+5#-.&-+:0-.+)-A 3!6R+($02):.+;$%:&AnLKR+a8&1+.8%19-+90+5$019+0$+20+10.+/&&.+0)$+&P;&:.#.%01-C+5&8#<&+#+?0$/#*+;$0@*&/'-0*<%19+#;;$0#:8+.0+&1-)$%19+%.+20&-+10.8#;;&1+#9#%1A

3![R+a%2&$+;$&--+:0<&$#9&A

nLWR+F)$+&1<%$01/&1.#*+/#1#9&/&1.+->-.&/+#)2%.+*00S-+#.+.8&$&#-01-+58>+;0**).%01+%-+:$&#.&2C+#-+5&**+#-+.8&+5#>+5&+/#1#9&+%.A

3!LR+I)-.0/&$+-#.%-?#:.%01A

/4LD46(IF9(DEKS4E4FGIGD7F *DFIFJ4nLUR+70;+/#1#9&/&1.+$&9)*#$*>+$&<%&5-+0)$+&1<%$01/&1.#*;&$?0$/#1:&+#12+%1:*)2&-+%.+%1+;*#11%19+?0$+.8&+?).)$&A

3!iR+I0-.+-#<%19A

#879CJGD7F 3!VR+Z019+.&$/+;$0?%.A3!R+4%91%?%:#1.+0;.%/%-#.%01+0?+;$0:&--&-+.0+$&2):&+-0*%25#-.&k5#.&$+)-&+0$+#%$'&/%--%01-A

3!KR+480$.+.&$/+;$0?%.A

36R+n&:>:*%19+0?+/#.&$%#*-+%1.&$1#*+.0+.8&+:0/;#1>A 3!WR+T#1S+*0#1-k0.8&$+%1<&-./&1.A3[R+4)@-.#1.%#*+-)@-.%.).%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.#**>+=)&-.%01#@*&/#.&$%#*-A

'7JDIS(J7EEDGE4FG

3LR+78&+%1.$02):.%01+0?+&1<%$01/&1.+:$%.&$%01+#-+#+-%91%?%:#1.?#:.0$+%1+.8&+:80%:&+0?+-);;*%&$-A

3!UR+\)*?%*+%.-+-0:%#*+:0//%./&1.A

3iR+O:0';#:S#9%19+:01:&;.+%1+.8&+:0/;#1>A 36JR+N&*;+;$&-&$<&+.8&+&1<%$01/&1.A3VR+Q+:8#19&+?0$+/0$&+&1<%$01/&1.#**>+?$%&12*>+.$#1-;0$.#.%01;0*%:>+%1+.8&+:0/;#1>A

36!R+70;+/#1#9&/&1.+-#.%-?#:.%01A

3KR+E/;$0<&/&1.+%1+;$02):.%<%.>A 366R+4#.%-?>+&1<%$01/&1.+0$9#1%-#.%01-A"I8^4GDFP 36[R+4#.%-?>+1#.%01#*+$&9)*#.0$-A

3WR+I0$;0$#.&+%/#9&A 36LR+4#.%-?>+%1.&$1#.%01#*+$&9)*#.0$-A3UR+E1:$&#-&2+/#$S&.+-8#$&A 36iR+4#.%-?>+*#@0)$+)1%01-A3!JR+B&5+/#$S&.+0;;0$.)1%.%&-A 36VR+Q;;&#$+#-+#+$0*&+/02&*A3!!R+4#*&-A