Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

25
CLAVECILLA Radio System v. Hon. Agustin Antillon Facts: 1.New Cagayan Grocery (NECAGRO) filed a complaint for damages against Clavecilla Radio system. They alleged that Clavecilla omitted the word NOTin the letter addressed to NECAGRO for transmittal at Clavecilla Cagayande Oro Branch. 2.NECAGRO alleged that the omission of the word notbetween the word WASHED and  AVAILABLE altered the contents of the same causing them to suffer from damages. 3.Clavecilla filed a motion to dismiss on the ground of failure to state a cause of action and improper venue. 4.City Judge of CDO denied the MTD. Clavecilla filed a petition for prohibition with preliminary Injunction with the CFIpraying that the City Judge be enjoined from furthe r proceeding with the case because of improper venue. 5.CFI   dismissed the case and held that Clavecilla may be sued either in Manila (principal office) or in CDO (branchoffice). 6.Clavecilla appealed to the SC contending that the suit against it should be filed in Manila where it holds its principaloffice. Issue:WON the present case against Clavecilla should be filed in Manila where it holds its principal office. Held:YES It is clear that the case from damages is based upon a written contract. Under par. (b)(3) Sec. 1 Rule 4 of the New Rules of Court, when an action is not upon a written contract then the case should be filed in the municipality where the defendant or any of the defendant resides or maybe served upon with summons. In corpo. Law, the residence of the corporation is the place whe re the principal office is established. Since Clavecilla’s  

Transcript of Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

Page 1: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 1/25

Page 2: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 2/25

Page 3: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 3/25

Page 4: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 4/25

Page 5: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 5/25

Page 6: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 6/25

Page 7: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 7/25

Page 8: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 8/25

Page 9: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 9/25

Page 10: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 10/25

Page 11: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 11/25

Page 12: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 12/25

Page 13: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 13/25

Page 14: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 14/25

Page 15: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 15/25

Page 16: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 16/25

Page 17: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 17/25

Page 18: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 18/25

Page 19: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 19/25

Page 20: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 20/25

Page 21: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 21/25

Page 22: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 22/25

Page 23: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 23/25

Page 24: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 24/25

Page 25: Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

8/13/2019 Conflicts case digest Corp. & Contract

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conflicts-case-digest-corp-contract 25/25