04-luksut

9 2554

The Study of Analysis of Curriculum about ASEAN in Primary school Level, Secondary school Level and High school Level of each Country

in ASEAN Nations

Mr.Preecha Monkong

Bureau of Academic Affairs and Educational Standards

Office of the Basic Education Commission

Ministry of Education

July 9th, 2011

.. 2558 (.. 2015) .. 2544-2554 42 9 1. 5 6 2. 3. 2 3.1 .6 3.2 (A Level)

Abstract The Study of Analysis of Curriculum about ASEAN in Primary school Level, Secondary school Level and High school Level of each Country in ASEAN Nations has as the objectives to find out the study of teaching and learning about ASEAN of each country in ASEAN Nations and to prepare readiness for Thai youth to ASEAN Community in 2015. The study of analysis was studied by content analysis of 42 documentaries as relatives with ASEAN in home and abroad. There were propagated in 2001-2011 and also study of 9 countries such as: Brunidarussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, lao, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam. As for Burma, I did not find any data, it caused of political problems. The results of the studies are: 1. Primary School Level Brunidarussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, lao, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam had curriculum of ASEAN in Social Study and Geography; there are clearly indicators. Except in Geography of Brunidarussalam were not indicators. There were studied Lao Language and literature in Lao .Vietnam were studied integrated with Civil Education. As for Kingdom of Thailand called Social Study is Social study Religion and Culture. The differences were Singapore had learned ASEAN Charter in Grade 5-6.On the other hand, the other countries were not. 2. Secondary School Levels Bruniedarussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao, Malaysia, Singapore and Kingdom of Thailand has learned ASEAN Curriculum in Geography,History,Social Study,Economics, English Literature and Art ; there were clearly indicators.Except Bruniedarussalam in Geography and history did not have any indicator. Indonesia were studied about ASEAN in Economics. As for Singapore, had been studied about ASEAN in English Literature and Art. There were obviously indicators. 3. High School Level Cambodia,Indonesia,Lao,Malaysia,the Philippines and Singapore has studied about ASEAN curriculum in History,Geography,Social Study, Art and Culture and Ethics . There were obviously indicators. Except Singapore were studied about ASEAN in two levels: 3.1 High School Level or the twelveth Grade, had studied in History, Social Study and English Literature; clearly indicators. 3.2 A level or preparatory university had also learned in Social Study, History and English Literature; obviously indicators.

9 (ASEAN Community) .. 2558 ( ) .. 9 2554

1 1 1 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 4 5 5 7 2544 7 2551 7 3 10 10 11 4 12 1 1

13

2

18

3

25

2 4 () 34 5 (

) 36

6 ()

38

7 ()

39

8 ()

40

() 9

() 42

10 ()

44

11 ( )

45

3 12

46

13

48

14

50

5 52 61 () 64 65 67 70 73 76 Surin stress Aseans need for Education 77 P.M. denies truec signed 79 Asean meet brokers deal over border 81 Wage peac like we wage war 83 86

1

1

( .2551 : 23) ( .. 2552 : 2) (www.mfo.go.th/asean) (Bureau of International Cooperation. 2010 : 3-4) (Bureau of Internationl Cooperation. 2010 : 8-9) ( . .) ( . 2544 : 10) (UNDP. 2550 : 13-1) .. 2558

1. 2.

2 1. .. 2544 - 2554 2. 1) 2) 3)

1. 2.

3

2

1. (ASEAN) " " "Association of Southeast Asian Nations" 8 2510 (..1967 ) (Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN Secretariat. 2001 : 9) .. 2510 5 6 7 2527 7 28 2538 23 2540 30 2542 10 ( . . .) (ASEAN) 2 VISA (. 2549 : 76) 1.1 (ASEAN Declaration) (Bangkok Declaration) 8 ..2510 5 (Association of Southeast Asian Nations.ASEAN Secretariat. 2009 : 37) ( . 2552 : 8) 13 2550 ..2558 (..2015) ( . 2552 : 35) "" (Association of Southeast Asian Nations. 2009 : 58) 2551 2552 2552 23 - 25 2552 . .. 2551 2555 ( . 2552 : 17-19)

4

1.2 (ASEAN Charter) 13 2550 2558 (..2015) (intergovernmental organization) ( . 2552 : 62-63) 13 55 (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) 2 3 ( .. 2 - 37) 15 2551 10 14 28 - 1 2552 ( .. ...) 10 ( ) ( . 2552 : 9) (Bangkok Post. 2554 : 3) 1.3 (ASEAN Political - Security Community) ( . 2553 : 28) (ASEAN Political - Security Community Blueprint) 3 ( . . ...)

5 1. 2. (. . 2551 : 8) 3. ASEAN+3 ( . 2552 : 54) 1.4 (ASEAN Economic Community) 2558 ( . . 2551 : 9) (ASEAN Economic Community Blueprint) 4 1. ( . 2554 : 10) 0% 2553 2558 2553

2. ( ) (Association of Southeast Asian Nations. 2009 : 58-61)

3. (SMEs) (Initiative for ASEAN Integration - IAI)

4. ( . 2552 : 10) ( . 2552 : 56-58)

6

AFTA (AFTA) .. 2553 1 .. 2553 .. 2558 ( : : ...) 1.5 (ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community) (Functional cooperation) .. 2558 ( . 2554 : 69) (ASEAN Identity) (ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community Blueprint) 6

1. (Human Development) 2. (Social Welfare and Protection) 3. (Social Justice and Rights) 4. (Environmental Sustainability) 5. (Building an ASEAN Identity) 6. (Narrowing the Development Gap)

(Senior Officials Meeting) (Ministerial Meeting) (ASEAN Socio-Cultural Community Council) ( . . 2552 : 1-3)

( )

1.5.1 (Association of Southeast Asian Nations. 2009 : 80-81) 1.5.2 ( . . 2552 : 5)

7

1.5.3 ( . .2552:29-31) ( . 2553 : 26) 1.5.4 ( . 2553 : 18-30) 1.6 6.1 2544 4 2 .2.1 : .2.2 : 3 .3.2 : 4 .4.2 : .4.3 : 5 .5.1 : ( . .2544 : 26-28) 6.2 2551 3 2 .2.1 : " .2 "

8 .4 - 6 " " " 3 .3.1 : " " .3.2 : .4 - 6 " WTO, NAFTA, EU, IMF, ADB, OPEC, FTA, APEC 4 .4.2 : .5 " .6 " " .1 " " ( . . 2551 : 20-26)

9 2544 2551

10

3

1. .. 2544 - 2554 2. 3. 3.1 42

/ 1. //

6 14.30

2. 24 57.14 3. 7 16.66 4. 5 11.90

42 100

22 2553 16 2554

11

3.2 2551

1. 1.

2. 3. 4.

2. 1. 2. 3. AFTA

3. 1. 2. 3. 4.

3.3 3.2

3.4 3 .. 3.5 (Content Analysis) (Interpretation) 3 2551

4

3 1 2 3

13

1 1-3

1

/ (.1-.6)

.6

- - - - -

-

.3

-

.5

- - ( 9-15)

- -

.6

-

14

1 ()

/ (.1-.6)

.6

- - 2

- -

.5

-

.6-.7

-

.1-.6

-

15

1 ()

/ (.1-.6)

.1-.2

-

.3-.6

-

.1-.3

.. 2553

-

.5-.6

- - - - -AFTA () - - +3 +6

- - .. 2510

16

1 ()

/ (.1-.6)

.5

-

.6

-

-

-

.1-.3 ()

-

.4-.5 ()

()

-

17

1 1. .6 2 .3 .5 .6

3. .6

4. .5 .6 .7

5. .1-.6

6. .5 .6 AFTA +3 +6 .1-.6 .1-.3

7. .5 .6 .5 .6

8. ( ) .1-.3 .4 .5

18

2

/ (.1-.3)

.1

-

.2

- () -

-

.1

- 1 5 -

- 1-5 - /

.2

- : -

-

19

2 ()

/ (.1-.3)

()

- -

.3

- 1 2

- 1 2 -

.3

-

- -

- -

20

2 ()

/ (.1-.3)

.1

-

.3

- - - ASEAN, AFTA, NAFTA, ADB, EFTA, APEC, EU, UN

- - -

.3

- - - -

- -

21

2 ()

/ (.1-.3)

()

.3 ()

- ..2488-2513 -

.3

- -

-

.3

2 ..2518

-

.2

-

22

2 ()

/ (.1-.3)

.2

" ( ) () ()

-

( )

-

- ..2462 .. 2514 -

- ( .. 2462 - ..2514)

-

( ) ()

-

23

2 ()

/ (.1-.3)

.1

- - -

- -

2 1. .1 .2

2. .1 1-5 .2 .3 1 2

3. .3 ASEAN, AFTA, NAFTA, ADB, EFTA, APEC, EU, UN

4. .3 .3

24

.3 2 ..2518

5. .2

6. .2 ( ) () ( ) .. 2462-2514 ( ) ()

7. .1

25

3

/ (.4-.6)

.4

- - / ( 16-18) -

- 20

.5

: 1. : - - - - 2 - 2 - 2. : - 2 - 2 - - 3. : - - - - - 4. : - - - - - -

- 2 2 - - - -

26

3 ()

/ (.4-.6)

()

.6

: 1. - - - ( ) 2. - - -

- - - - 20

.4

-

- -

.5

- ()

27

3 ()

/ (.4-.6)

()

.6

/ 2 /

- - -

EU, APEC

- - - (Eludcidate)

28

3 ()

/ (.4-.6)

1-5

- HIV, AIDS, STDs - - ( ( )

29

3 ()

/ (.4-.6)

() .5

- - -

.6

- 2 ..2493 .. 2518 - SEATO

- - - - SEATO ASEAN

.5

-

.5

-

()

.6

-

30

3 ()

/ (.4-.6)

.4 1. ( ) - - - - 2. / - - - / - / 3. - - - - 4. ASEAN, APEC, ARF

-

..2413 .. 2510

- -

.6

: - - - (AFTA) (ARF) -

-

31

3 ()

/ (.4-.6)

100 3 ; (Island Voice) ; (Hartland) ; (Off Center)

-

:

-

A Level ..2443-..2540

- -

-

32

3 1. .4 16-18 .5 .6

2. .4 .5 .6

3. 1-5 .5 .6 2 .. 2493 .. 2518 SEATO

4. .5 .6

5. .4 ASEAN APEC ARF

33

6. 2 .6 6.1 .6 .. 2413 - ..2510 (AFTA) (ARF) 3 (Island Voice) (Hartland) (Off Center) 1 6.2 (A Level) .. 2443 - .. 2540

34

2 4-8

4 () /

.3/.5 .6 .1 - .6 .5-.6 .5/.6 .1-.3/.4-.5

.3 "" .5 - - ( 9-15)

- -

-

- - - - -AFTA () + 3 + 6

.5 - -

.1-.3 "" " "

.6

- -

.4-.5 - ()

35

4 .5 .6 (AFTA) +3 +6

.3 .5 ( ) .6 .1- .6 .5 .6

.1-.3 .4-.5

36

5 (

)

/ .6 .6 .5 .1-.3

- - - - -

-

-

- - .6-.7

-

- - - ..2553

- - - .1-.2/.3-.6

38

6 ()

/ .1/.2 .3 .2

.1 - 1 5 - .2 - : -

- - - - - ..2488-2513 -

- " ( ) () ()

39

6 7 ()

7

/ .1 .3 .2

- -

40

8 () / .2 .3 .1/.3 .3 .1

- () -

- 1 2 - -

.1 - .3 - - ASEAN AFTA NAFTA ADB EFTA APEC EU UN

- 2 ..2518

- ..2462 - ..2514

- - -

41

8

ASEAN, AFTA, NAFTA ADB 1 2

42

9 ()

/ .4 - .6 .4 - .6 .6 .5 - .6 .4 /

.4

- / ( 16-18) .5 - ; : : .6 - : 1. - - () 2. -

.4 - .6 2

- 2 ..2493 .. 2518 - SEATO

.5 - .6 -

1. ( ) - - - - 2. / - - - / - / 3. - - c - - 4. ASEAN, APEC, ARF

- ..2413 - .. 2510 ( A Level) ..2443-..2540

43

9 SEATO ASEAN APEC ARF

44

10 ()

10 .1-.4 .5 ( 2 )

/ .5 .6

- 1-5 ( () .5 -

: - - - (AFTA) (ARF) -

- (

45

11 (/

) / .5 .6/ .5

/

-

-

- .6 100 3 ; (Island Voice) ; (Hartland) ; (Off Center) :

-

11

46

3 12

(AFTA)

( )

.6 - - - - - - .3 - - - - - - -

.5 - - - - - - - .6 - - - - - - -

.6 - - - - - - - .5 - - - - - - -

.6-.7 - - - - - - - .1-.6 - - - - - - -

.1-.2 - - - - - - - .3-.6 - - - - - - -

.1-.3 - - - - - - - .5-.6 - - - -

.5

- - - - - - -

.6

- - - - - - -

.1-.3

())

- - - - - - -

.4-.5

()

- - - - - - -

47

12 - - .5-.6 - (AFTA) - - - ( ) - -

48

13

(AFTA)

( )

.1 - - - - - -

.2 - - - - - - - - .1 - - - - - - - -

.2 - - - - - - - .3

- - - - - - -

.3 - - - - - - - - .1 - - - - - - -

.3

- - - - - -

.2 - - - - - - .3 - - - - - - -

.3 - - - - - - .3 - - - - - - -

.2 - - - - - - - .2 - - - - - - -

.1

- - - - - - -

49

13 - - - (AFTA) - - - ( ) - -

50

14

(AFTA)

( )

.4 - - - - - - -

.5 - - - - - - - .6 - - - - - - -

.4 - - - - - - - .5 - - - - - - .6 - - - - - - -

- - - - - - -

- - - - - - - .5 - - - - - - - .6 - - - - - - -

.5 - - - - - - - .5 - - - - - - .6 - - - - - - -

.4 - - - - - - - .6 - - - - - - -

- - - - - - -

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

51

14 - - - (AFTA) - - - - .5 .6

52

5

.. 2558 (..2015) (Content Analysis) 9

1.

1.1 1.1.1 .6

1.1.2 .3 .5 .6 1.1.3 .6 1.1.4 .5 .6 .7 1.1.5 .1-6 1.1.6 .5 .6 AFTA +3 +6 .1-.6

53

.1-.3 1.1.7 .5 .6 .5 .6 1.1.8 ( ) .1-.3 .4 .5

1.2 1.2.1 .1 .2 1.2.2 .1 1-5 .2 .3 1 2 1.2.3 .3 ASEAN, AFTA, NAFTA, ADB, EFTA, APEC, EU UN 1.2.4 .3 . 3

54

.3 2 .. 2518 1.2.5 .2 1.2.6 .2 ( ) () ( ) .. 2462-2514 ( ) () 1.2.7 .1 1.3 1.3.1 .4 16- 18 .5 .6 1.3.2 .4 .5 .6

55

1.3.3 1-5 .5 .6 2 .. 2493 .. 2518 SEATO 1.3.4 .5 .6 1.3.5 .4 ASEAN, APEC ARF 1.3.6 2 .6 (1) .6 .. 2413 - ..2510 (AFTA) (ARF) 3 (Island Voice) (Hartland) (Off Center) 1 (2) (A Level) .. 2443 - .. 2540

56

2.

2.1 2.1.1 .5 .6 (AFTA) +3 +6 2.1.2 .3 .5 2.1.3 ( ) .6 2.1.4 .1-.6 2.1.5 .5 .6 2.1.6 .1-.3 .4-.5

2.2 2.2.1

57

2.3 2.3.1 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.4 2.4.1 2.4.2 2.4.3 2.5 2.5.1 2.5.2 ASEAN, AFTA, NAFTA ADB 2.5.3 2.5.4 2.5.5 1 2 2.5.6

58

2.6 2.6.1 2.6.2 2.6.3 SEATO 2.6.4 2.6.5 ASEAN, APEC, ARF 2.6.6

2.7 2.7.1 .1-.4 .5 2.7.2 ( 2 )

2.8 3.

59

3.1 3.1.1 .5-.6 .6 .5-6

3.1.2

3.1.3 .5 .6 3.1.4 (AFTA)

3.1.5 3.1.6 3.1.7 ( ) 3.1.8

3.1.9

3.2 3.2.1 3.2.2 3.2.3 (AFTA) 3.2.4 3.2.5 3.2.6 ( ) 3.2.7 3.2.8

3.3 3.3.1

60

3.3.2 3.3.3 (AFTA) 3.3.4 3.3.5 3.3.6 3.3.7 .5 .6

1. .5 .6 (.) 2 .. 2558

2.

3. - (.) (.) - (.)

4. ( .) .. 2554 .. 2554

61

, . . (2552 ). (FTA). : .

, . . (2551 ). . :

.

-------------. . (2550). . 2546-2548. : .

--------------. . Thailand Education Hub and Spirit of ASEAN. .... ...

(UNDP), . (2550). 2550.. : .

, . . (2551). .: .

. (2553 ). . 2. : .

(Image). (2549). . 19 9. .

, . . . (2552). . : .

------------. . . (2546 ). -. : .

. (2552). . . : .

------------. (2553). . : .

------------ .(2552). . : .

, . . (2552). . : .

. (2554). . 14 1 - .

62

, . (2553). . (The Success of ASEAN Defance Ministrys Meeting). : .

, . (2544). 2544. : (...).

, . (2550 ). . .

, . (2551). 2551. : .

-----------. (2554). : . .

. (2553). - . 2. : .

, . . ( 2552 ). (..2009-2015). : .

-----------. . (2546 ). 2020 : . : .

------------. . (2551). . :

------------ .. . . ...

-------------.. (The ASEAN Charter)....

Association of Southeast Asian Nations. (2009). Road Map for and ASEAN Community

2000- 2015. One Vision, One Identity, One Community. ASEAN Secratariat Printed in Indonesia.

Association of Southeast Asian Nations. (2001). Annual Report 2000-2001.Printed in Indonesia. ASEAN Secretariat.

ASEAN Curriculum Assessment Project . (March, 2009). A Preliminary Summary of ASEAN Studies Content in Primary and Secondary School Curriculum and Instructional Materials of ASEAN Member States. USAID From the American People. International Development. United Stated Agency.

Bangkok Post. (2011). February 25th, Natioal Column. Page 3.

63

Bureau of International Cooperation. Office of the Permanent Secretary. (2010). Ministry of Education. Highlight Activities of Presidents of SEAMEO Council. (H.E.Mr.Jurin Laksanawisit).Ministry of Education of Thailand. April 2000-January 2010. Ministry of Education Thailand. (2002). Basic Education Curriculum B.E. 2544 (A.D.2001)

Bangkok : Kurusapa press.

Kao Kim Hourn. (2000). Aseans Non-Interference Policy Priciples Under Pressure?London : ASEAN academic Press.

Lee S. Shulman. (2004). The wisdom of Practise, Eassay on Teaching, Learning, and Learning to Teach. New York : USA.

www.aseansec.org (Data ; December 5th, 2010) www.aseanvision.com (Data ; February 25th, 2010) www.mof.go.th/asean (Data ; March 16th, 2011) www.m-culture.go.th (Data ; September 9th, 2010) www.15thaseansummit.org (Data ; October 10th, 2010) www.14thaeansummit.org (Data ; April 3rd,2010)

65

(special fields vital)

200 10

.. 2558 (..2015) 582 10

66

15 6

6

27 2552

67

(22 .. 2554) ( ) (Unesco) (Unesco) ( )

( ) 10

68

( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) 2 (UN Security Council) ( ) ( )

69

21 2554

70

: (It is what it is) (A ceasefire is a ceasefire) (as long as thing quiet) : ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

71

( ) 15 () ( ) (disputed area) 25 90 ( ) ()

72

(UNSC) 23 2554

73

:

.. 2554 ( .. 2011) "" ( )

74

"" (UNSC) 7-8 UNSC "UNSC " UNSC " " " " " "

75

.. 2542 ..2551 22 2554

77

Surin stresses Asean's need for education Skills in language, special fields vital

Published: 27/10/2009 at 12:00 AM Newspaper section: News

Thailand is being urged to develop the potential of graduates in specialised fields to facilitate Asean's one-market, one-community policy.

Surin: No one can live in isolation Asean secretary-general Surin Pitsuwan yesterday said the country's education system must also build a new generation of people with foreign language skills to enable them to compete on the global stage. Mr Surin spoke during a meeting of American Field Service Thailand volunteers on the developmental direction of youths under the Asean framework. About 200 people attended the meeting. Mr Surin said all 10 Asean countries have been gearing up to building an Asean community by 2015. Their main policy was to package markets in all Asean countries, populated by about 582 million people, into one market. The merger of the Asean markets into a single market would increase the region's bargaining power with other countries, Mr Surin said. "This planned merger will lead to crucial cooperation among 10 Asean countries, which will enable graduates in specialised fields which are in high demand, such as medical science, nursing, dentistry, engineering, architecture and accounting, to work freely in these countries," he said. "This cooperation will be systematically promoted in a bid to distribute quality people from top fields among member countries. "This will strengthen the region's market. Thus, producing future Asean youths should be in line with the region's one-market-one-community policy." Mr Surin urged agencies to develop the language skills of youths to enable them to compete with those from other countries.

78

Thai youths must be proficient in English language and another foreign language, he said. With language proficiency, the youngsters could effectively communicate with the world community. He said old beliefs that it was unnecessary for Thais to learn English or other foreign languages because the country did not rely on others were out of date. "No one can live in isolation these days," Mr Surin said. He saw it as necessary for Thailand to develop the language and vocational skills of youths to meet market demands. Thailand's capable human resources would also attract other countries to trade and invest in the country. In a regional view, the potential human resources would help boost Asean competitiveness among other regional blocs in the world, he said. The 15th Asean summit with its six dialogue partners ended in Hua Hin and Cha-am on Sunday. Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva said Asean must continue playing a constructive role in engaging with its external partners to maintain its centrality in the evolving regional architecture. Mr Abhisit said to embark on a new era of Asean cooperation the group must be certain that its meetings produce concrete outcomes to help address pressing issues affecting the well-being of the region's people. Asean groups Brunei, Burma, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam. Its six dialogue partners are China, Japan, South Korea, India, Australia and New Zealand. Bangkok Post Newspaper, October 27th,2009

79

PM denies truce signed Govt emphasises need for detailed negotiation


Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva denies a ceasefire agreement has been signed with Cambodia. The prime minister said again in his weekly broadcast address yesterday that his government believed that a lasting solution to the border dispute could only come through careful negotiation. Association of Southeast Asian Nations foreign ministers meet in Jakarta tomorrow to find ways to solve the border dispute, but Mr Abhisit said the regional grouping would only act as a coordinator and as a witness, as well as provide a facility for talks between Thailand and Cambodia. He and members of the cabinet, including the foreign, defence and the natural resources ministers, would be responsible for explaining the border situation to the world community so people could better understand the situation. Mr Abhisit said he had talked on the phone with Unesco director-general Irina Bokova about the problems arising from the listing of the Preah Vihear temple as a world heritage site. He said Unesco should suspend the process of listing the surrounding area until the border problem was settled. Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya said yesterday the proposed permanent ceasefire was unnecessary. Peace on the border could be achieved through existing bilateral mechanisms.

Abhisit: Asean to act as coordinator These include the Thai-Cambodian Joint Boundary Committee, the Thai-Cambodia General Border Committee and the Thai-Cambodian Regional Border Committee. Mr Kasit yesterday attended a meeting to discuss preparations for the Asean meeting in Jakarta tomorrow, which will be attended by all 10 member nations' foreign ministers.

80

A delegation led by army chief-of-staff Daopong Rattanasuwan was reported on Saturday to have signed a ceasefire agreement with Phnom Penh, whose team was headed by deputy army commander Hun Manet, the son of Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen. But Mr Kasit insisted the meeting on Saturday was not about negotiations. It was merely a discussion between military authorities and the results would be referred to higher authorities for a decision on what next step to take. The minister said no agreement had been reached and there were no binding effects from the talks. "It was only a discussion," he said. "It was like sending subordinates to meet for talks and having them report the results [to those in higher places]." Mr Kasit said any formal negotiations would involve the defence ministers of the two countries under the framework of the General Border Committee. Mr Kasit said he would emphasise Thailand's position at the Asean foreign ministers' meeting tomorrow that it wished to resolve the border conflict through bilateral mechanisms, including the Joint Boundary Committee, chaired by Asda Jayanama, the General Border Committee, led by Defence Minister Prawit Wongsuwon, and the Regional Border Committee, headed by 2nd Army chief Thawatchai Samutsakhon. "We will explain that the JBC, the GBC and the RBC have been making progress and they can continue to act in line with a UN Security Council resolution [supporting bilateral talks to settle the dispute]." The minister said he would also reaffirm Thailand's readiness to allow Asean to act as a facilitator in talks between Thailand and Cambodia. He said Mr Asda had written to ask the head of the Cambodian delegation to attend a Joint Boundary Committee meeting in Bangkok. Gen Prawit will also send a letter to ask his Cambodian counterpart, Gen Teah Banh, to hold a General Border Committee meeting in Cambodia in the middle of the year, Mr Kasit said. The joint committee focuses on border demarcation talks while the general committee involves border security arrangements, particularly a ceasefire, Mr Kasit said. He said Thailand is ready for talks under the framework set by the two committees, and it was up to Cambodia to decide whether it would enter the talks. He said Thailand would also ask Indonesia, as Asean chair, to send its representatives to observe the operations of Thai soldiers in the disputed area. He said the observers would stay with Thai soldiers on the Thai side of the border so they could see for themselves that Thailand was not the instigator of any violence. Bangkok Post Newspaper, February 21st,2011

81

Asean meet brokers deal over border Thailand, Cambodia agree to observers


JAKARTA : Asean foreign ministers have made headway towards easing the border conflict between Thailand and Cambodia, leading to sighs of relief all round. The most significant development yesterday was Thailand and Cambodia's agreement to invite Indonesia to deploy observers on both sides of the disputed border area. No mention was made of a ceasefire. In fact, the word did not appear once in the Asean chairman's statement issued at the end of the meeting that finished 90 minutes early. When asked whether what was agreed yesterday was in response to the call by the United Nations Security Council for a permanent ceasefire, Asean chair and Indonesian Foreign Minister Marty Natalegawa said: "It is what it is. A ceasefire is a ceasefire, as long as things are quiet."

Left to right: Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya, Vietnam Assistant Foreign Minister Pham Quang Vinh, Indonesia Foreign Minister Marty Natalegawa and Cambodia Foreign Minister Hor Namhong. Diplomatic sources said it was agreed as early as Saturday that a ceasefire would not be mentioned at the meeting. And the only reference to the situation on the ground was that Asean supported Cambodia and Thailand's commitment to avoid further armed clashes, as reflected in the initial high-level talks between military representatives from the two countries, most recently on Saturday. But the ministers welcomed the invitation of Thailand and Cambodia for observers from Indonesia, the Asean chair, to the respective sides of the affected areas of the border to observe the commitment of both sides to avoid further hostilities.

82

The observers' mandate is to assist and support the parties in respecting their commitment to avoid further fighting, by observing and reporting accurately and impartially complaints of violations and submitting findings to each party through Indonesia. Mr Marty, who has worked tirelessly to bridge the gap between the two countries, said the role of the observers had yet to be worked out but he would have a report sent to the foreign ministers of both Thailand and Cambodia in the next few hours. "Indonesia is ready to assign and deploy observers, the sooner the better. Over the next couple of hours I will send letters to spell out the modalities, their role and duties. This is not a peace-keeping or peace enforcement team," he said. Indonesian observers are not there to take responsibility to ensure there is a cessation of hostilities, he said, adding that the observers, both military and civilian, would be unarmed. Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya said both countries would wait for the details but it was expected that 15 observers would be sent to each side. He said Indonesia would study the experience of when Thai and Filipino troops were sent to help in Aceh and East Timor. Cambodian Deputy Foreign Minister and Foreign Minister Hor Namhong said the observer teams could use both helicopters and trucks and move around in and out of the disputed area. "The Asean chair said he will try his best to dispatch them soon and so far, 25 observers have been recruited," Hor Namhong said. A senior Asean official said the meeting ended 90 minutes early because much of the work and discussion had been done beforehand. The official quoted Mr Marty as saying at the meeting that both Thailand and Cambodia had national interests to safeguard. But they also have strong interests in the region to nurture. "This meeting is unique and historic because it shows that an Asean member country or countries can rely on other family members for help in times of trouble," the senior Asean official said. Mr Marty recalled the difference in atmosphere from the first time he spoke to Thailand and Cambodia about the bilateral dispute. Initially it was a process of absorbing their concerns but throughout there were peaceful intentions on both sides. There were no bad intentions. It was a challenge of communication. "We [Asean] can deliver when there is a problem among us if we have the commitment and hard work. There is still hard work ahead of us." Mr Marty said the outcome of the ministers' meeting would be shared with the UNSC and its support sought. Bangkok Post Newspaper, February 23rd,2011

83

Wage peace 'like we wage war' Asean chair confident of solving border row


JAKARTA : Asean chairman and Indonesian Foreign Minister Marty Natalegawa believes in adopting an incremental and step-by-step approach to help Thailand and Cambodia move towards a peaceful resolution to their border dispute.

"I don't think it is impossible to find a solution," he told the Bangkok Post in an exclusive interview on the eve of the informal Asean foreign ministers meeting here today. Indonesia also stands ready to send observers to either side of the disputed border area. Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya said on Sunday Thailand would ask Indonesia to send representatives to observe the operations of Thai soldiers. The observers would stay with Thai soldiers on the Thai side of the border. Cambodia has asked for Asean observers. Mr Marty met his Cambodian counterpart, Hor Namhong, and Mr Kasit after they arrived in the Indonesian capital last night. The Indonesian foreign minister said he aimed to create a comfortable atmosphere for both sides and wants to facilitate conditions for the two countries to resolve their differences. "I am not pessimistic," he said.

84

He said the decision by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) urging Thailand and Cambodia to sort out their problems peacefully and to seek Asean assistance was a reality check for all sides, even Asean. Mr Marty said meetings with his Cambodian and Thai counterparts on Feb 7 and Feb 8, respectively, helped the situation. He believes that had the meetings not taken place prior to the UNSC talks, "we would be in a situation of being told what to do". The Indonesian foreign minister said although the UNSC had set no deadlines as to when progress needed to be made, "I am keen to report to the UNSC earlier rather than later. I am talking weeks, not months"." Mr Marty said he has been in constant contact with Hor Namhong and Mr Kasit and was aware of the spectrum of views. "I don't think it is impossible to find a solution," he said, adding that Indonesia stood ready to be part of any modality that leads to a resolution. He pointed out that Indonesia was not shy to ask for Asean assistance. "As a country, we are open enough to ask for help from our friends," he said, referring to the time Thailand was asked for assistance when Indonesia faced problems with separatist movements in East Timor and Aceh. The Asean chair said that the more substantive issue for today's meeting was the negotiation process. "I don't think Thailand is averse to having Indonesia involved if we proceed incrementally, step by step. "We are aware of the sensitivities," he said. In his letter inviting the Asean foreign ministers to the urgent meeting today, Mr Marty referred to the need for a higher commitment to the ceasefire and the possibility of enhanced communications between Thailand and Cambodia to prevent the outbreak of fresh incidents. He said Asean could be an intermediary in such communications and that today's talks would touch on this issue as well. Mr Marty indicated he was aware that Cambodia wished to have a ceasefire formalised at the Asean foreign ministers' meeting, but would sooner see evidence of a genuine commitment rather than the mere signing of documents. "The region is under the spotlight and there are positive expectations internationally. We have to wage peace like we wage war," he said, adding that a solution was not easy as both countries had their own dynamics. Mr Marty said he understood that the dispute must be solved bilaterally and peacefully, "but I want to tell my colleagues, use Asean".

85

He added: "Asean is not the panacea, but we can create conditions that can help solve the problem. "We need to proceed quickly and nip this at the bud." Mr Marty said that while he remained focused on the key issues for today's meeting, "I am already looking ahead past tomorrow". "The solution does not have to be either/or, but can be bilateral, regional or global, all working and complementing each other." Meanwhile, Asean secretary-general Surin Pitsuwan said yesterday today's meeting was a reminder of Asean's past achievements. "We have reasons to be optimistic," he said, noting that member states assisted in the restoration of law and order in East Timor when the people fought for independence from Indonesia in 1999, and helped Burma to open up for international assistance after the devastation of Cyclone Nargis in May 2008.

Bangkok Post Newspaper, February 22nd, 2011

..

..

04-luksut

Documents

Transcript of 04-luksut