알뛰세르와 엘스터의 맑스 해석양식에 대한 비판적 검토

Post on 10-Aug-2015

45 views 0 download

description

Ciritique de la manière d''interprétation par Althusser et de Elster de Marx

Transcript of 알뛰세르와 엘스터의 맑스 해석양식에 대한 비판적 검토

Daum | |

(1)

| |

[] Franco 2010.11.03 14:34

| http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330

* 1998 * Franco

-

/ / (, )Profile

1. . , , , . , ' ' ' ' . 1960 , 1980 . ' ' - '' - , ' ' , . / '' ' ' . , . . , , ? , , ? . . . . ' ' . '/ / ' , ' ' . .

Category (401) Los Juegos (1) Brain / Philosophy(16)

& (3) (1) (1) , (4)

(24) (18) Twit Daily (49) Art / Act (2) Collection () (15) Composer Biography(3)

Collection ( ) (5)

2. - ' ' ' ' . , . . (A. Giddens) (P. Sztompka) , , . / .

Collection () (2) Collection (/ ) (1) (1) , (36)

. (11) & (4)

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

/ . / , / , / . . / . ' ' ' ' , . , / . . , ' ' . ' ' '' . 1960 (J.P. Sartre) -(C. Levistrauss) (, 1983: 142-145; Anderson, 1993: 35-41). < > , . , , , .

, (14)

- Body / Health

Recent visitor baccharis Yui 2013 chaplin knife 21105

my route , , , , ' ', '', ' ' . . , , (social formations) / , . ' ' , '(supports)' (Althusser, 1976: 200-201). ' ' , ', ' ', ' . '' . ' ', ' ' , ' ' . (supports, Tr ger) . !

' ' ' ' , ' ' (Giddens, 1991b: 57, 78). , , (, 1992: 57; Giddens, 1991b: 101). () , ' ' . (P. Anderson) ' ' ' ' . , ' ', ' '. (Anderson, 1993: 33-9, 61). , . ' ' ' ' . '' (Mouzelis, 1995: 130-31). ' ' ' ' . , ' ' ' ' . (Althusser, 1976: 94-5). , , . , (Althusser, 1991c: 116). ' ' . ' ' . " , " . , " " (Marx, 1973: 265). . , . ,

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

, . (Marx, 1989a: 6). . , . , . . , . . . '' . " , '' " . "( ) '' , , ' ' '' ' ', '' , . "(Althusser, 1977b: 174, 180). / , . ' ' . , - - . , '', '' . ( , , , ) (Althusser, 1976: 95). '' . . , . . '/' . . . , , , . " " , . , (Althusser, 1976: 46-47). 1970 . , . '' (, 1991b: 167). . . , , , . , . . (Elster, 1985a: 4-5; 1992: 33-4). - , , , , - . " , "(Elster, 1982a: 454; 1990a: 46). . . , . , (Elster, 1990a: 47; 1992: 35). " " . . . , , , . , , , , , , , . , , , , . , " , , " (Elster, 1992: 14, 213-28). , , , , ,

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

. , , . " , " . , (Elster, 1992: 14-6). . " - - - , , , - . ... , , , "(Elster, 1985a: 5). { } { } , . . " , . . ." . {} , (Elster, 1985a: 4). (Atomism) . , . ' ' (Elster, 1985a: 6; 1989a: 13n). '' '' , ' ' . . '(powerful)' . . , (Elster, 1989a: 13). . . . . , (Elster, 1985a: 6). , . . , . , . (1993a: 49-50). , . , . . , , . , . , . , (Elster, 1982a: 464; 1992: 39). , , (free-rider) . . . . . . , . (Elster, 1982a: 465-78; 1985a: 15-6; 1989a: 126). ' ' . " , ." . " . "(Elster, 1992: 40; 1993a: 43) . . , , . ,

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

, . . , , . . /(P. Berger & C. Offe) , . ' ' . , , . , (Berger & Offe, 1982). ( ) . , " " . , . , . , . . , ' ' . , , .

' ' . (social formations) / ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' . , . ' ' / / . . / /

, , . . . , . . , , . , .

3. , , . , . , , . . . . . , (Callinicos, 1991: 127-8).

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

, " " . . . , , . , . , (Elster, 1992: 81-2). , . . . , , . , , , . . (Elster, 1985a: 129-31; 1992: 81-3, 99). . . ' ' . {} '' (Marx, 1989a). , " ." . . (Marx, 1989a: 653-67). , . . , . ? . . , ? . . . , . ? '' . ' ' ' ' ' ' . ( ) ( ) , (Marx, 1989a: 43-58). " . , "(Marx, 1989a: 409). 5 , 6 , 7 , ( ) ( , ) . '' . , . , ... , . , (Marx, 1990: 208-9). , . '' , . , . . " , " (Elster, 1985a: 141). . , . , . , . ,

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

(Marx, 1990: 221). , . . (Marx, 1990: 222). , , , , , . . , ' ' ', ' . , , . . . , , , , , , , . , .

4. , , . , , , , (Elster, 1992: 97, 99). . " , ", " " . , . . " , . , ... "(Elster, 1985a: 167; 1992: 97, 224). ' ' , . . (market exploitation) , (J. Roemer) . (wealth) , . , . " , , , ." (Elster, 1985a: 167-72; 1992: 117). . , . , . ' ' , (Elster, 1992: 109). . , . , , . , . . . . . , . " " . . , . " "(Marx, 1990: 1010). . " ,

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

." " , "(Marx, 1989a: 276, 681). . , , , . . (Marx, 1989a: 675-84; 1990: 1003-25), [ ] (Marx, 1989a: 680; 1990: 1015). . ' ' ' ' , (Althusser, 1991a: 22-8). . () . , , . , . . , , . , . , . . " " . " , ' ' " (Elster, 1985a: 141). . , . , . . , (Elster, 1992: 98-9). . . , " " . . " " . , , , . {} 19 (Elster, 1992: 100-2). , , . , (Elster, 1992: 112, 117). " . , , ' ' ? , "(Elster, 1992: 224). , . , . " , [ ] . "(Marx, 1990: 1009-10). , . . . , . , .

5. , . . " . ... , . . ,

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

. "(Elster, 1985a: 133-4; 1992: 84-5). . . . (Marx, 1989a: 409-11). . " . , , , "(Marx, 1990: 169). , " " . '' ' ' . , , . , (Marx, 1990: 1021). ( ) . . , (maximization) . {} (Marx, 1973: 283) . . . {} ' (fixed coefficients of consumption)' . , . , . (Elster, 1985a: 11-2). . " . (place-holders) ." ' ' , . (Elster, 1985a: 12-3). " " . " , "(Elster, 1992: 87). . , , . ' ' , , . " . "(Marx, 1989a: 48, 216). , , . {} . , . . . . , . . . ' ' . , . " '' . '' '' "(Althusser, 1991a: 211). , ( ) . . , , . " . . . ." " [ ] "(Marx, 1990: 1086, 1088).

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

, (, ) . " ( '') . ." . " , . - - . "(Althusser, 1991a: 205-6). . , , , . '' , . . '' '' , '1' '2' . " , . , , "(Althusser, 1991a: 209-10). . " () ." " ( ), . , '' '' "(Althusser, 1991a: 211). , . , '' ' ' '' . ' ' , , (Althusser, 1991a: 213).

6. . . , , , , , , . , , , , . . . (Althusser, 1977b: 145-81), (Elster, 1992: 80-119). , , . , , (Elster, 1992: 224). . , . , , . . . . , . . . , / , . , . , , , .

(1993), [ ], { } 7, . (1991a), [ : ], {} 5, 1991 4.

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

(1991b), [ , ], { } 12, 1991 . (1991c), [ ], Callinicos, N., { }, . (1992), { }, . (1987), [, , - ], { } 1. (1994), [J. Elster ], , { }, . (1989), { }, . (1989), [ ], { } 53, , . (1994), [ ], . (1993), [ - ], { } 5, . (1992), [ ], { }, . (1993), [ ], { } 7, . (1995), [Jon Elster ' ' ], . (1991a), [ ], {} 5. (1991b), [ ], {} 4, , . (1991), [ , ], { }, . (1992), [ '' ], { }, 14, . (1994), [, ], {} 28 , . (1993), [ (1)], { } 7, . (1992), [ }, { } . (1995), [: ], , { }, . (1998), [ ], . (1983), [ ], , { }, . Alexander, J.(1993), { }( ), . Alexander, J.(1987), [Action and Its Environments], J.C. Alexander et als., eds., {The Micro-Macro Link}, Univ. of California Press. Alexander, J. et als. eds.(1987), {The Micro-Macro Link}, Univ. of California Press. Althusser, L.(1967), {Philosophie et philosophie spontan e des savants}, , { }(1992a), . Althusser, L.(1971), {Lenin and Philosophy and other essays}, NLB, , { }(1992b), . Althusser, L.(1972), [Sur le rapport de Marx Hegel], Masp ro, , [ ](1987), { } 6. Althusser, L.(1973), [The Conditions of Marx's Scientific Discovery - On the New Defination of Philosophy], Theoretical Practice, No.7-8, January. Althusser, L.(1976), {Essays on Self-Criticism}, NLB. Althusser, L.(1977a), {For Marx}, London: New Left Books(NLB). Althusser, L.(1977b), {Reading Capital}, London: Verso, , { }(1991a), . Althusser, L.(1977c), [Introduction: Unfinished History], Lecourt, D., {Proletarian Science?}, NLB. Althusser, L.(1977d), [On the Twenty-Second Congress of the French Communist Party], New Left Review, No.104. Althusser, L.(1978a), [The Crisis of Marxism], Marxism Today. Althusser, L.(1978b), [What Must Change in the Party], New Left Review, No.109. Althusser, L.(1993), { }( ), . Althusser, L.(1991b), { }( ), . Althusser, L.(1991c), [ ], E. Balibar et als, { }( ), . Althusser, L.(1992d), [{ } (1978)], { }( ), . Althusser, L.(1992c), { }( ), . Althusser, L.(1996), { }(/ ), . Anderson, P.(1993), [ ], { }(/ ), . Anderson, P.(1987), { }( ), . Balibar, E.(1979), [The Basic Concepts of Historical Materialism], {Reading Capital}, London: Verso, , [ ](1984), . Balibar, E.(1989), { }( ), , 1989. Berger, J. & Offe C.(1982), [Functionalism VS. Rational Choice?: Some Questions Concerning the Rationality of Choosing One or the Other], {Theory and Society} 11, 1982. Birnbaum, P. & Leca, J.(1990), [introduction], P. Birnbaum, & J. Leca, eds., {Individualism: Theories and Methods}, Clarendon Press. Callinicos, A.(1989), { }( ), . Callinicos, A.(1991), { }( ), . Eliott, G.(1987), {Althusser: The Detour of Theory}, London: Verso, { }, Elster, J. & Hylland, A.(1986), [Introduction], J. Elster & A. Hylland, eds., {Foundations of social choice theory}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1978), {Logic and society}, Chichester: Wiley. Elster, J.(1979), {Ulysses and the Sirens: Studies in rationality and irrationality}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1980), [Reply to Comments], {Inquiry} 23. Elster, J.(1982a). [Marxism, Functionalism, and Game Theory: The Case for Methodological Individualism], {Theory and Society} 11. Elster, J.(1982b), [Belief, Bias, and Ideology] in M. Hollis & S. Lukes, eds., {Rationality and Relativism}, Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press,

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

Elster, J.(1983a), {Explaining Technical Change}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1983b), {Sour grapes: Studies in the subversion of Rationality}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1983c), [Reply to Comments}, {Theory and Society} 12. Elster, J.(1985a) {Making sense of Marx}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1985b), [Introduction], J. Elster, ed., {The Multiple self: Studies in Rationality and Social Change}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1985c), [Deception and self-deception in Stendhal], J. Elster, ed., {The Multiple self: Studies in Rationality and Social Change}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1986a), {An Introduction to Karl Marx}, Cambridge Univ. Press, / , {, }(1992), . Elster, J.(1986b), [The market and the forum: three varieties of political theory], J. Elster, & A. Hylland, eds., {Foundations of social choice theory}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1986c), [Marxism, Functionalism, and Game Theory], in J. Roemer, ed., Analytical Marxism, Cambridge. Elster, J.(1989a), {Nuts and bolts for the social sciences}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1989b), {The cement of society: A Study of Social Order}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1989c), [Marxism and individualism], in M. Dascal and O. Gruengaard, eds., {Knowledge and Politics}, Boulder: Colo. Westview Press. Elster, J.(1989d), {Solomonic judgements: Studies in the limitations of rationality}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Elster, J.(1990a), [Marxism and Methodological individualism], P. Birnbaum and J. Leca, eds.(1986), {Individualism}, Claredon Press, Oxford. Elster, J.(1993a), [], edited by J. Elster, { }(/ ), . Elster, J.(1993b), {Political Psychology}, Cambridge Univ. Press. Ferry, L. & Renaut, A.(1990), {French Philosophy of the Sixties}, The University of Massachusetts Press, , {68 }(1996), . Foucault, M. et als.(1994b), { }( ), . Foucault, M.(1994a), { }, . Giddens, A.(1976), {New Rules of Sociological Method}, Basic Books, Inc. Giddens, A.(1979), : | : : .

0 | 0

... (0)

. .

1

top

' '

2010-11-03 14:34:30

Franco's blog is powered by Daum

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]

http://blog.daum.net/juanperon/330[10/02/2013 00:11:36]