Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 1
MBA Global Economy
Session 1B
Foundations of Modern Trade Theory
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 2
Introduction
Basis for tradeWhy do nations export and import?
Terms of tradeGains from international trade
Specific to production and consumption
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 3
Modern Trade Theory Historical Development
The MercantilistsConcern: Regulation of domestic and international affairs to promote national interestsSolution: Strong foreign-trade sector
Favorable trade balanceAdvocated government regulation of trade
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 4
Historical Development……..
Criticism of Mercantilist policies David Hume’s price-specie-flow doctrine
Favorable trade balance possible only in the short run; over time it would automatically be eliminated
Adam Smith’s “The Wealth of Nations”Challenged the static view of wealthDynamic view
International trade increases the level of productivity within a country, which in turn increases world output
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 5
Why Nations Trade: Absolute Advantage
Adam Smith Free trade and international division of laborCost differences govern movement of goodsProductivities of factor inputs represent the major determinant of production costDetermination of competitiveness from the supply side of the marketConcept of cost: Labor theory of value
Labor is the only factor of production and is homogeneousCost depends on labor requirements
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 6
Why Nations Trade…………..
Principle of absolute advantage Import goods in which a nation has an absolute cost disadvantageExport those goods in which it has an absolute cost advantage(Example: Table 2.1)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 7
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 8
Why Nations Trade……….
David Ricardo: Comparative advantageMutually beneficial trade can occur even when one nation is absolutely more efficient in the production of all goods
Less efficient nation: Specialize in and export the good in which it is relatively less inefficientMore efficient nation: Specialize in and export that good in which it is relatively more efficient
Examples of comparative advantages (Table 2.2)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 9
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 10
Why Nations Trade?
Assumptions of Ricardo’s model:World consists of two nations, each using a single input to produce two commoditiesLabor is the only input Labor can move freely among industries within a nation but is incapable of moving between nationsLevel of technology is fixed for both nationsCosts do not vary with level of production and are proportional to the amount of labor used
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 11
Why Nations Trade……….
Assumptions of Ricardo’s model (cont.):Perfect competition prevails in all marketsFree trade occurs between nationsTransportation costs are zeroFirms make production decisions to maximize profits; consumers maximize satisfaction through consumption decisionsThere is no money illusionTrade is balanced, no flows of money between nations
Comparative-advantage principle (Table 2.3)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 12
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 13
Production Possibilities Schedules
Used to explain comparative advantage Shows production combinations of two goods when all factor inputs are used most efficiently Illustrates the maximum output possibilitiesMarginal rate of transformation (MRT)
Amount of one product a nation must sacrifice to get one additional unit of the other product
Hypothetical production possibilities schedules for the U.S and Canada: (Figure 2.1)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 14
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 15
Trading Under Constant-Cost Conditions
Principle of comparative advantage under constant opportunity costs
Basis for trade and direction of tradeGains from trade
Two reasons for constant costs:Factors of production are perfect substitutes for each otherAll units of a given factor are of the same quality
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 16
Trading Under Constant-Cost Conditions…….
Basis for trade and direction of tradeRelative costs (Figure 2.1)
Point A – U.S: 40 autos and 40 bushels of wheat Point Al
– Canada: 40 autos and 80 bushels of wheatRelative cost of producing an additional auto
0.5 bushels of wheat for the United States 2 bushels of wheat for Canada
Direction of tradeUnited States specializing in and exporting autos Canada specializing in and exporting wheat
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 17
Trading Under Constant-Cost Conditions…….
Production gains from specializationRefer (Figure 2.1)
United States moves from production point A to B, totally specializing in auto productionCanada totally specializes in wheat production by moving from Al to Bl
Summary of production gains (Table 2.4a)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 18
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 19
Trading Under Constant-Cost Conditions……..
Consumption gains from trade (Figure 2.1)Specialization and trade
Achieve consumption points outside domestic production possibilities schedules
Terms of trade: Rate at which its export product is traded for the other country’s export product
Determines the set of post-trade consumption points Defines the relative prices at which two products are traded
Trading possibilities line: Line tt represents the international terms of trade for both countries
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 20
Trading Under Constant-Cost Conditions……
Consumption gains from trade (Figure 2.1)
Trade triangle: The triangle BCD (BlC
lD
lfor Canada)
showing the U.S. Exports (along the horizontal axis), Imports (along the vertical axis), and Terms of trade (the slope)
Consumption gains from trade for each country and the world as a whole (Table 2.4b)Complete specialization
Exception: One of the countries is too small to supply the other with all of its needs
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 21
Trading Under Constant-Cost Conditions……
Distributing the gains from tradeDomestic cost conditions (Figure 2.2)
Domestic cost ratios set the outer equilibrium terms of trade
Domestic cost-ratio line: The no-trade boundary
International terms of trade has to be better than or equal to the rate defined by domestic price lineRegion of mutually beneficial trade is bounded by cost ratios
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 22
Absolute Advantage Matters For Wages
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 23
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 24
Trading Under Constant-Cost Conditions…..
Equilibrium terms of tradeMill’s theory of reciprocal demand
Within the outer limits of the terms of trade, the actual terms of trade is determined by the relative strength of each country’s demand for the other country’s product (Figure 2.2)
Importance of being unimportantLarger nation attains fewer gains from trade while the smaller nation attains most of the gains
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 25
Trading Under Constant-Cost Conditions…….
Terms-of-trade estimatesCommodity terms of trade (barter terms of trade)
Improvement: Rise in export prices relative to import prices over a time period Deterioration: Rise in import prices relative to export prices over a time period
Commodity terms of trade for selected countries (Table 2.5)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 26
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 27
Dynamic Gains from Trade
Effect of trade on growth rate and thus on the volume of additional resources
Higher output and income resulting in savings and consequent investments Better supplier match for importsEconomies of large-scale productionIncreased competition
Impact on productivity, quality, and prices
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 28
Global Competition
Productivity gains for US Iron Ore workersIncreased competitive pressure on U.S. iron ore producers in the 1980sWorkers agreed to changes in work rules that enhanced labor productivity
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 29
Changing Comparative Advantage
Comparative advantage can vanish if productivity growth lags
Pressure on producers to reinvent themselves
Case: Semiconductor industry in the U.S.
Production possibilities schedules, for computers and automobiles, of the U.S. and Japan under constant opportunity cost (Figure 2.3)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 30
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 31
Trading Under Increasing-Cost Conditions
Increasing opportunity costsConcave production possibilities schedule (Figure 2.4)
Principle of diminishing marginal productivitySupply factors as well as demand factors have to be considered
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 32
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 33
Increasing-Cost Trading Case
Process of specialization continues in both nations (Figure 2.5) until:
The relative cost of autos is identical in both nationsU.S. exports of autos precisely equal Canada’s imports of autos, and conversely for wheatProduction gains from specialization (Figure 2.6a)
Consumption gains from trade (Figure 2.6b)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 34
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 35
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 36
Partial Specialization
Reason for partial specializationIncreasing costs constitute a mechanism that forces costs in two trading nations to convergeWhen cost differentials are eliminated, the basis for further specialization ceases to exist
Highly probable that both nations will produce some of each good
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 37
Impact of Trade on Jobs
Standard trade theoryExtent to which an economy is open:
Influences the mix of jobs Can cause dislocation in certain areas or industriesHas little effect on the overall level of employment
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 38
Impact of Trade on Jobs…………
Principle of comparative advantageTrade influences the mix of jobs
Shifting of workers and capital to more productive industries
Data suggests little impact on the overall number of jobs (Figure 2.6)
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 39
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 40
Comparative Advantage Extended to Many Products
More than two productsRank goods by degree of comparative cost (Example: Figure 6.7)
Each country exports the product(s) in which it has the greatest comparative advantageEach country imports the product(s) in which it has greatest comparative disadvantage
Cutoff point between exports and importsDepends on the relative strength of international demand for the various products
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 41
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 42
Comparative Advantage Extended to Many Countries
More than two CountriesAdvantageous for a country to enter into multilateral trading relationships (Figure 2.8)
Surpluses with trading partners that buy its exportsDeficits with trading partners that supply low-cost items imported
Bilateral agreements that balance exports and imports would:
Reduce volume of trade and specialization Hinder movement of resources to their highest productivity
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 43
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 44
Exit Barriers
Exit barriers hinder the necessary market adjustmentsVarious cost conditions make lengthy exit a rational response Case: U.S. steel industry
Nature of labor costs and benefitsPenalties for terminating contractsExpenses associated with writing off assetsEnvironmental costs Low realization on sale of assets
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 45
Comparative Advantage: Job Outsourcing [Offshoring]
Movement of factors of production around the globe Weakens comparative advantageDevelopments that caused major changes:
Strong educational systems produce skilled workers in developing nations, who work at lower cost Internet technology New political stability that permits free movement of technology and capital
American workers will encounter direct world competition at almost every job category
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 46
Advantages of Outsourcing [Offshoring]
Reduced costs and increased competitivenessCreation of new export requirementsRepatriated earningsOther contentions:
U.S. companies will become less competitive if they cannot outsource jobs
This will weaken the economy and threaten more jobs
Job losses tend to be temporary Creation of new industries and products leading to more lucrative jobs for Americans
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 47
Outsourcing and the U.S. Automobile Industry
Ford Motor CompanyEarly days: Assembly lineEmergence of competition and increased sophistication requirements
Number of tasks outgrew number of operations in a plant
Outsourcing of non-core tasksExternal suppliers contribute about 70 percent of a Ford vehicle
Reduction in costs and improvement in quality
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 48
Problems of Outsourcing
Loss of jobs Declining demand for low-skilled American workersShift of demand for high-skilled workers to cheaper substitutes in Asia
Risks to wagesDeclining wages of low-skilled workers both in real terms and relative to the wages of skilled workers
Measures to lessen the adverse effects of people suffering job losses
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 49
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 50
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 51
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 52
US Share of World Output
30% –
25% –
20% –
15% –
10% –
5% –
0 –
1820 1870 1913 1950 1973 1998
Percentage of World Output
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 53
World Export & GDP Growth
500 –
450 –
400 –
350 –
300 –
250 –
200 –
150 –
100 –
Vo
lum
e
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
World Exports World GDP
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 54
Global Exports of Services
Sawyer, International Economics, 3rd ed. Pearson
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 55
Openness of Economies
Sawyer, International Economics, 3rd ed. Pearson
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 56
Openness of Economies….
Sawyer, International Economics, 3rd ed. Pearson
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 57
Openness of Economies….
Sawyer, International Economics, 3rd ed. Pearson
Session 1-09 MBA Global Professor Augustine H H Tan 58
Global Exports
Sawyer, International Economics, 3rd ed. Pearson
25% –
20% –
15% –
10% –
5% –
0% –1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
Exports as a Percent of GDP