When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores:...

32
When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City, Clean Waters Program. Stephen White, EIT – Philadelphia Water Department Chris Bergerson – Philadelphia Water Department

Transcript of When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores:...

Page 1: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City, Clean Waters Program.

Stephen White, EIT – Philadelphia Water Department Chris Bergerson – Philadelphia Water Department

Page 2: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

GREEN CITY,CLEAN WATERS The City of Philadelphia’s Program for Combined Sewer Overflow Control

$2.4 Billion Investment over the next 25 years

Green Stormwater Infrastructure

Traditional Infrastructure

Adaptive Management

$1.67 Billion

$354 million

$420 Million

Page 3: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

PWD’s initial plan for performing monitoring of natural and engineered systems associated with our Green City, Clean Waters program and addresses the monitoring and assessment of surface waters, groundwater, rainfall, CSO discharges, sewer flows, and green infrastructure performance.

Green City, Clean Waters Comprehensive Monitoring Plan

Consent Order & Agreement: Deliverable III Submitted to: PA DEP December 1, 2012

Page 4: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Why Monitor Green Infrastructure 1. Evaluate Green Infrastructure Performance

2. Inform Future Designs

3. Inform Maintenance

4. Compliance

Page 5: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

How are Monitoring Sites & Activities Selected?

Coordination with Pilot Program

Identifies •Stormwater Management Practice (SMP) type •Variables (or Conditions) in projects •Questions about the projects and how variables impact SMP effectiveness

Page 6: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

SMPTypeId SMPTypeName 1 Stormwater Tree Trench 2 Stormwater Planter 3 Stormwater Bumpout 4 Rain Garden 5 Stormwater Basin 6 Infiltration/Storage Trench 7 Pervious Paving 8 Swale 9 Stormwater Wetland

12 Other

SMP Type of Monitored SMP(s)

SMP Type of PWD’s SMP(s)

Page 7: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Continuous Water Level Monitoring

Page 8: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Infiltration & Slow Release

Image by Louis Cook (PWD)

Page 9: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 10: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Continuous Water Level Monitoring Sites

Page 11: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Barometric Sensor Network

Page 12: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

ASTM C1701/C1701M – 09 Standard Test Method for Infiltration Rate of In Place Pervious Concrete

Surface Infiltration Rate Testing of Pervious/Porous Surfaces

Page 13: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Simulated Runoff Test (SRT)

Page 14: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Simulated Runoff Test 1801120130530

Page 15: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Simulated Runoff Testing Sites

Surface Infiltration Rate Testing of Pervious/Porous Surfaces

&

Page 16: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Data Management Model

Page 17: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

SRT 1801120130530

•Estimated recession rate for SRT is 178 cf/hr •Volume of water applied 459 CF

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

0.000

0.200

0.400

0.600

0.800

1.000

1.200

1.400

1.600

1.800

Cum

ulat

ive

Flow

in (C

F)

Wat

er L

evel

(FT)

SRT 1801120130530 Reese Street Tree Trench (PennVEST) SMP# 180-1-1

Corrected Water Depth (ft) Field Notes Sump Depth Totalizer Reading

Page 18: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 19: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 20: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 21: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 22: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 23: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 24: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 25: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,
Page 26: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Soil Surface Infiltration Rate

Falling Head Tests ASTM Standards – ASTM D3385 and D5093

Page 27: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Low Cost GSI Monitoring Sensors

• What if we have to monitor hundreds of GSI sites?

• Budget and manpower constraints

• This is the 21st century

• Applications for both green and gray infrastructure

• Potential use in STEM education

Page 28: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

STEM Education: Solar Sunflower

Page 29: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

STEM Education: Snakes on a Playground

Nebinger Elementary School

Page 30: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Ping Floyd – The Well

Page 31: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Ping Floyd v2.0, a.k.a. Pong Floyd • Infrared distance

sensor • Range up to 5 meters • Compatible with slotted

observation well • Detects ping pong balls

floating at the bottom of the well

• Logs water level data to SD memory card

Page 32: When it Rains it Stores - University | Villanova University€¦ · When it Rains it Stores: Methods for Monitoring Green Stormwater Infrastructure from Philadelphia's Green City,

Thanks to PWD Everyone in the Office

of Watersheds

Questions? Contributors Jason Cruz Alexandra Atiyeh Alex Warwood Matthew Fritch Tommy Thompson Edward Lennon James Knighton