8/9/2019 What is Difference Between Shiya & Sunni

1/2

WHAT IS THE BASIS OFSHIAH-SUNNI DISCORD?

By: Dr. Israr Ahmad

The following paragraphs about Shiah-Sunni differences are written from a Sunni perspective;Shiah Muslims may not agree with all of it.

The history of the Shiah-Sunni Conflict is almost as old as that of the Muslim Ummah. Only 25years after the death of the Prophet (saw), internal discord and a series of civil wars started.This has been referred to in the history books as the Al-Fitnatul Kubra or the Great Discord.What was the cause of this internal conflict?

Every revolution is followed by counter-revolutionary movements, which seek to overthrow

the new order and to revert back to the previous system. Many of these counter-revolutionary

movements were dealt with by the first Caliph , Abu Bakr (raa) . However, there were still twogroups who openly resented both Islam and the Prophet of Islam, and these were the Jews of

Arabia and the Persians . The Jews were angry because they were expecting the final prophet to be

one of the Israelites , and they could never accept and reconcile themselves with the fact that he

turned out to be someone from the Gentiles . (The envy of the Jews of Madinah is mentioned in

Surah Al-Baqarah . It is also mentioned there that they refuse to believe in the Prophet even after

recognizing him as the promised one, only because of their jealousy and arrogance). The other

group that never accepted the ascendancy of Islam were the Persians , who developed a special

hatred towards the second Caliph , Umar (raa), under whose era Iran was conquered. Indeed, it wasa Persian man who killed Umar (raa).

During the later years of the Caliphate of Uthman (raa) an underground conspiracy was

hatched, led by Abdullah Ibn Saba , a Jew who had outwardly converted to Islam, in order to

produce political unrest. The conspiracy succeeded, mainly because a lack of proper

communication facilities in those days made the spread of rumors against the Khalifah rather easy.

This resulted in a rebellion against Uthman (raa) on various fabricated charges of nepotism, and he

was martyred in the course of the rebellion. In this chaotic situation, Ali (raa) became the next

Caliph . A disagreement arose among the Muslims about the killers of Uthman (raa). Some

demanded that the killers, who were hiding among the supporters of Ali (raa), must be punished

immediately. Ali (raa) was of the opinion that we need some sort of order and peace to return

before we can do this. These two groups were known as the Shiah of Uthman and the Shiah of

Ali meaning the pro-Uthman and the pro-Ali parties. As you can see, this was a purely political

disagreement, not a religious one. The Shiah of Uthman later became known as the Sunni and

the Shiah of Ali became just Shiah.

The Shiah community has four points of distinction as compared to the Sunni Muslims. The

first is the school of jurisprudence they follow, which is Fiqh Jafari, and it is just like Fiqh Hanafi,

or Maliki etc., except that Mutah or temporary marriage is considered lawful by the Fiqh Jafari,

whereas it is prohibited in all the Sunni schools . The second is the Shiah belief in the infallible

8/9/2019 What is Difference Between Shiya & Sunni

2/2

Immamate , which means that only a genuine Imam who will be a direct descendent of Ali (raa)

and Fatima (raa), can authentically lead the Muslims. The Sunnis believe, on the other hand, that

the trait of infallibility no longer exists after the termination of Prophethood. There are a number

of divisions among the Shiah , e.g., the Twelvers believe that the 12 th Imam disappeared and

went into seclusion somewhere 870 A.D., and that he will reappear to lead the Muslims (the

promised Mahdi) . The Sunni Muslims , on the other hand, believe that the promised Mahdi will

be a normal human being, an Arab Muslim who will lead the struggle for the domination of Islam

sometime in the future. Thirdly, whereas the Shiah community believes that the first three Caliphs,

Abu Bakr (raa) and Umar (raa) and Uthman (raa), were usurpers, and that only Ali (raa) was the

rightful successor of the Prophet, the Sunnis believe that all four of the Khulafa were rightfully

chosen by the Muslims and none of them was a usurper. Fourthly, the Shiahs accept only those

Ahadith (traditions of the Prophet (saw)) which are transmitted by the household of the Prophet

(Ahl Al-Baiyt) by which they mean Ali (raa), Fatima (raa), and their two sons, Hasan (raa) and

Husain (raa) and their descendants; they refuse to accept the traditions which are transmitted bymost of the other Companions (Sahaba) of the Prophet (saw).

It may be noted that Sunni scholars have criticized the beliefs of the Shiahs for hundreds

of years, and have written a very large number of books to refute the Shiah beliefs. Some scholars

have even declared the Shiahs to be kafirs . However, there has been no consensus on this, i.e.,

there has been no collective verdict of apostasy (Kufr) against the Shiahs (as was given in the

case of the Qadiyani community), and therefore the Shiahs too are considered Muslims,

despite their having beliefs which are against those of mainstream Sunni Islam.

Finally, note that during the early centuries of Islam, Shiism was synonymous with anattitude of uprightness on the part of the descendants of Ali (raa) and Fatima (raa) , and their

courage to speak out against the rulers and to resist their unjust actions even in the face of

oppression. The present sectarian version of Shiism is a later development which took shape

especially during the rule of the Safavid dynasty in Iran (1501-1732). The Safavids wanted to

foster a distinct religious identity in Iran so as to maintain the populations loyalty in the conflict

against the powerful Sunni Ottoman Empire , and for this purpose they had imported Shiah Ulama

from Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon and provided them with wealth and power. This distinction between

the Alavid and the Safavid versions of Shiism was emphasized by Dr. Ali Shariati . According to

some analysts, the Iranian revolution has revived the Alavid Shiism , and the Safavid Shiism is on

the decline. According to them, the stress is now gradually shifting towards the dynamic teachings

of Islam and the Muslim Ummahs unity , rather than hairsplitting on historical, doctrinal, or juristic

matters. If this happens, it would be very beneficial for the Muslim Ummah .

Courtesy: www.tanzeem.org

O U R R E V O L U T I O N I S T H E E X P L O S I O N O F L I G H TSCHOOL OF ORTHOEPY QUR'AN & THEOLOGY EDUCATION

Chammer Dori, Near Dasil Masjid, Zaina Kadal, Srinagar 190002, Jammu & Kashmir Tel: 2472359 - Mob: 9906547498, 9419976544 - www.soqte.org - email: soqte70@yahoo.com