��������������������������������� � !�������"�#%$'&)(*$+��, ".-0/2143�5

6 78789*:

132 ��4 �+560��878���9�:4;2 0(4=?=@�$4 4;0��A�$�#B(��4C0D�8!@!>���E���@�����$4F4 �G�+�H!>�����/�������$4F���$IJ�8!C�K4 ���$4#7A�����K7L087=@�$4 7&B80(���90M�+*-,87N0�OPB�0�73�8!>�+4 ���$4#7&=@�$�+560�4

ÑâÑ

V WYXRZ�[-\-]

ÑâÑâÑ

ÑâÁ

^`_ba a cedPfg

�CÙIþRÙIçhÞIÛÙnþRÙn×Pö¯Ü hÛ�CüïÜêé|þRüIÜ hi�j k ×Pö¯çhà�ñéÞöêÛà?× jl ÝçaüIÚ«Û«þBÛ«×Ö�ÛçaÙïÜ m

n-oqp r ÀÏÐÆìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo un-oqp�oqp v É�w ÀÏÐÌÄyxvÍÏÀ{zIÉ�w ÉkÃVìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À*¿kÀ

NPO | o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo un-oqp�o}n á Ô�~�ÃkÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÑâÃ�¿[ÑÇÐÌìPÀlÃ�Ð�Â6skÅÇÀÏÐ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo n-o}n r ÀlÉkÊÊÒÔÏÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~à o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopN

n-o}n-oqp r ÂMt ÑÇÐ�ÐÌÑÇÎ~à ¿kÀ�Åw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃìPÎ~ÅâËIÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅÇÀ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopNn-o}n-o}n ø Î~ÃÂaÊ�t�À oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopN

n-o} r ÀlÉkÊãÔlÁ~ÂaÅâÉ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGop�pn-o}-oqp ÀlÊ¿kÀ Å ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ*¿kÀ Åw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃìPÎ~ÅâËIÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅÇÀ�ÅâÀ�Ê�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄãÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÌÑTzIÉ�À o&oGop�pn-o}-o}n Ã�ÀÂaÅâÄÒÀlÊÌÃ�ÂaÄÌÑâÁïÀ�ÅÇÀ Ê�Âaì�ìPÎ~ÊÌÄ¿[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅ oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopNnn-o}-o} r w ÀcÊÒÊÒÀlÉkÊ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopNn

n-o á ÀlúÊÒÔÏпiw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[Ñ'teÂaÄÒÑâÎà o&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopNn-o oqp ìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã2Ê�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄãÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄ

r0o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopN

n-o o}n ìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãr r ÂaÉ�ÐÒÐÌÑ�ìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�À*¿kÀ 1 zIÉ�À Åw Î~à ÁïÀcÉ�Ä o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGop(n-o} á Ô�~�ÃkÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃóÅÇÎ~úÑTzïÉ�À oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGop(

n-o}-oqpMaxNP0

oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGop(n-o}-o}n

MaxSNP0o&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopN

n-o}-o} r Î~úÑTzïÉ�À*ÀlÄÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGopNn-o} ù�ÀlÄÒпkÀ�ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐ�À o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGon�

n-o}-oqp r À ìkÊÌÑâÃ�ÍlÑâìPÀ*¿kÀ�ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGon�Á

n-o}-o}n r Â2Ã�Î~ÄÒÑâÎ~ÿkÀÍÏÎ$t ìkÅÇÔlÄÌÉ�¿kÀ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGon�n-o}-o} r Â3ÀlÊ�t�ÀlÄÌÉkÊÒÀ o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGon@u

n-ou ÃkÑâÄÒÔÀlÃIÄÌÊÒÀ�ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ o&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGon@un-ou�oqp ë ÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÍÏÎ~ÃIÄÌÑâÃIÉ�ÀÏÐ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGon@un-ou�o}n ë ÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ðã Ã�ÀÏÐ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGon�

@9¡ £¢9¤¥- ;¦¨§ ©�ª

« ¬ �qöêÛ«þôéqþ ÚàÞÖ�ÚtØ?ÖkçhÖ�×PöêÛ « m-oqp v É�ÀlÅTzIÉ�ÀÏÐÍÏÎ~Ã�ÍÏÀlìkÄÒÐ o&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo@u

-oqp�oqp v É�w ÀÏÐÌÄyxvÍÏÀ{zIÉ�w ÉkÃóÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#t�À¥¿kÀ ÊÒÀÏÍ�ä�ÀlÊÒÍ�ä�À*ÅâÎIͯÂaÅÇÀ | o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo@u-oqp�o}n Î~ÑÇÐÌÑâÃ�ÂaúÀÏÐhxsPÎ~ÊÌÃ�ÔÏÐ oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo¡�

-o}n r ÀÏÐÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀÏÐGLO[R]

o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo¡�-o} kÀ(t ìkÅÇÀÏÐÐÒÑqt ìkÅÇÀÏЪìPÎ~ÉkÊÆÁïÎ~ÑÇÐÌÑâÃ�ÂaúÀÏÐ p xsPÎ~ÊÌÃ�ÔÏÐ o&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo®�-o r Ñqt ÑâÄÒÀ*¿kÀÏÐÆÁÎ~ÑÇÐÌÑâÃ�ÂaúÀÏÐ

hxsPÎ~ÊÌÃ�ÔÏÐ o&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo¡Eu

-o} ë ÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÆìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÊÌÁÂaÃIÄÆÅw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎNnÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃÅÇÎIͯÂaÅÇÀ oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo®�-o}-oqp Ê�ÔlÐ�ÀlÊÌÁÀlÊÆÅÇÀ�ÁïÎ~ÑÇÐÌÑâÃ�ÂaúÀ oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo®�-o}-o}n r Â2ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍcÄÒÑâÎ~Ã

o ºH» ÅÇÀÏÐÆÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐ�ÀÏÐGLO[R]

ÐÒÀ�ÐÒÑâÄÌÉ�ÀlÃIÄyxvÀlÅâÅÇÀÏÐ | o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGou¶ o oqpGLO[R]

ÀlĪÅÇÀÏÐÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀÏÐÆ¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGou$ o o}n

GLO[R]ÀlĪÅÇÀÏÐÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀÏЪÅÇÎ~úÑTzIÉ�ÀÏÐ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGou$

o o} v É�ÀlÅâÅÇÀÉkÃkÑâÄÒÔ¿�ÂaÃ�ÐÆÄÒÎ~Ékļ¯Â | o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo¸u$ o} ë ÔÏͯÂaìkÑâÄÌÉkÅ ÂaÄÌÑ'°¿kÀÏЪÊÒÔÏÐÌÉkÅâÄ�ÂaÄÒÐ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo�² õ ßÖ�×qØ�ÙIà?×qÜ�Ú¹½âÖ�×qØ?ÚÙóñqÙ:�éÙ ¾ «

-oqp r  ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐ�ÀPLS

¿�ÀlÐÆìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐã¿kÀ ÊÒÀÏÍ�ä�ÀlÊÒÍ�ä�ÀÅÇÎIͯÂaÅÇÀ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGoF�-oqp�oqp á À�Å ÂW¿[Ñ ÍlÉkÅâÄÒÔ*¿kÀ¿kÔlÄÒÀlÊ�t ÑâÃ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃÂ|Ú+ÃnþRÙïÜ ñ|ÙóܯÖ[öêÛÜNÄÖ�ÛܯÖ#Â|Û«Ú«Ûö¯üÙïöeÚÙIéqçaÜ à«-oqp r ÀÏÐÆìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐã¿kÀÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÐy{ÂaÑÇÐ�Â6skÑâÅâÑâÄÒÔÀlÃIÄÌÊÒÀÀlÉ- o&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN�

-oqp�oqp Ê�ÔlÐ�ÀlÃIÄ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à o&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN�-oqp�o}n Ç Î~É�п�ÂaÃ�ÐÆÅÇÀ�tÁµ(t�À*Ð�Â~Í oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN�

-o}nGLO

ÀcÄãÂ~ÐÒÐÒÎIÍlÑÇÔÏÐ oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN�-o}n-oqp Î~ÑÇÐÌÑâÃ�ÂaúÀÏÐÈt ÑâÊÒÎ~ÑâÊÒÐÀlÄÆÅ ÂWÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐ�À

CGLO[R]o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN�

-o}n-o}n º ìkÄÌÑqteÂeÂaÅâÄÒÔlÊÒÔÏÐÀlÄGGLO[R]

o&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;p�pN-o}n-o} É Ñ'�ÂaúÀ�Î~É

CGGLO[R]o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo;p�pNn

-o} á ÔÏÍlÅâÑâÃ�ÂaÑÇÐÒÎ~ÿkÀÏЪìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐã¿kÀÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÐy{ÂaÑÇÐ�Â6skÑâÅâÑâÄÒÔGte¶nÑqt¥É#t ÀlÃGLO

oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;p�pN-o}-oqp Ã�À�Î~ìkìPÎÐÌÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿkÀ�ìkÅâÉ�ÐÆÀlÃnÄÌÊÒÀ�Ê�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÐÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÑTzïÉ�À�ÀlÄ¿[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅ oGo&o&oGo;p�pN-o}-o}n

MaxSatÀlÄCGLO

oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o;p�pN-o}-o}

Maxk − SatÀlÄGLO

o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o;p�pN-o}-o

Maxk − SatÀlÄCGLO

o&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o;p�pN-o}-o}

MaxNAE k − SatÀlÄGLO

oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oCp�pN-o}-o}

Maxk − SatÀlÄGCGLO

o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oCp�pN-o r ÀÏÐÆìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐã¿kÀÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÐy{Â~ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à ¿kÀÍÏÎ~ÃIÄÌÊ�ÂaÑâÃIÄÒÀÏÐãÍÏÎ~Ã$�ÌÎ~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑâÁÀÏÐ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;p�pN

-o oqp ÃVìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À*¿[Ñ ÍlÑâÅÇÀ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;p�pN-o o}n ÀlÊÒЪÅÇÀ pËʶ ¿[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅ oqoqoDo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pNn�n

ÁnÑâÑ

-o o} ìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à pËÊ$Yo&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pNn�-o} r Ñqt ÑâÄÒÀÏÐã¿kÀ�Åw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�À

GLOoGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pNn@u

-o}-oqp pËÊ$ ÅÇÀGt�ÀlÑâÅâÅÇÀlÉkÊã¿kÀ CGLO ìPÎ~ÉkÊ Max 2− CCSP o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oCpNn@u-o}-o}n pËÊ$ ÅÇÀGt�ÀlÑâÅâÅÇÀlÉkÊãÀÏÐÌìPÎ~ÑâÊ¿kÀ CGLO[δ] ìPÎ~ÉkÊ Max 2− CCSP o&o&oGo&o&o&oCpNn�-o}-o} pËÊ$n ÅÇÀGt�ÀlÑâÅâÅÇÀlÉkÊã¿kÀ GLO ìPÎ~ÉkÊ MaxNAE 2− Sat o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oCpN�-o}-o pËÊ$ ÅÇÀGt�ÀlÑâÅâÅÇÀlÉkÊãÀÏÐÌìPÎ~ÑâÊ¿kÀ GLO[δ] ìPÎ~ÉkÊ MaxNAE 2− Sat o&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN-p-o} ë ÔÏͯÂaìkÑâÄÌÉkÅ ÂaÄÌÑ'°¿kÀÏЪÊÒÔÏÐÌÉkÅâÄ�ÂaÄÒÐ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN-pm �OüIñ|éqÞöêÛà?×qÜ ñ|Ö�×Ü

GLO[δ]Ùö

APX[δ]j�«

-o} ë ÔÏͯÂaìkÑâÄÌÉkÅ ÂaÄÌÑ'°¿kÀÏЪìkÊÌÑâÃ�ÍlÑâì�ÂaÉ-VÊÒÔÏÐÒÉkÅâÄ�ÂaÄÒÐ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN�³

δ−Ö#�Þ�qçaà�hÛ«þRÖ[öêÛà?× ñé

TSPab ß «;à-¯ j m j-oqp r w ÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#teÀ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pËu�p-oqp�oqp r À n xvÍÏÎ~ÉkìkÅ ÂaúÀ*ÑâÃkÑâÄÌÑ ÂaÅ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pËu$n-oqp�o}n Ê�Ôcì?ÂaÊ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃWÅ ÂWÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÒÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿ[ÉVÄÒÎ~ÉkÊ oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pËu$-oqp�o} r ÂWÐ�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�ÔÏÀ oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pËu$-oqp�o Ý ÁÂaÅâÉ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿkÀ�Å ÂWÐ�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

T̃oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pËu$

-oqp�o} Ý ÁÂaÅâÉ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿkÀ�Åw Î~ìkÄÌÑqt¥É#t o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pËu�u-oqp�o} Ý ÁÂaÅâÉ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿiw ÉkÃ�ÀìkÑâÊÒÀ�Ð�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~à o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pËu�u

-o}n á Ã�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ�ÅâÑqt ÑâÄÒÀ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo;pN�nj�Æ ÝXÙïçaÜN�°ÙïÞöêÛK�PÙïÜ j ¾C²è æ é|Ûñ|Ù ñ|ÙïÜÁ�|çhà>Â|Ú+ÃIþBÙïÜ çaÙI×qÞà?×Pö¯çaüïÜ j ³ «÷ æ é|Ûñ|Ù ñ|ÙïÜ�ñ|ü@â×qÛöêÛà?×qÜ l Æ ²

ã oqp`r ÀÏÐ"Î~Ã�¿kÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄÒÐ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n��ã o}när ÀÏÐÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀÏÐ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n��

ã o}n-oqp ´ Å Â~Ð�ÐÒÀÏÐÆ¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[Ñ'teÂaÄÒÑâÎà o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n��ã o}n-o}n ´ Å Â~Ð�ÐÒÀÏÐÆ¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑÇÀÏÐÆì�ÂaÊÆÅ ÂWÅÇÎ~úÑqzIÉ�À o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n�@uã o}n-o} ´ Å Â~Ð�ÐÒÀÏÐÆ¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[Ñ'teÂaÄÒÑâÎÃóÅÇÎIͯÂaÅÇÀ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n�@u

ã o} ë ÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n��ã o}-oqp Ê�Î~ìkÊÌÑÇÔlÄÒÔÏÐÊÒÀ(teÂaÊ/zïÉ�Â6skÅÇÀÏÐ o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n��ã o}-o}n ë ÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÆÊÒÀ(teÂaÊ/zïÉ�Â6s�ÅâÀÏÐ o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n��

ã o år ÀÏÐÆìkÊÌÑâÃ�ÍlÑâìPÀÏÐÅÇÎIͯÂaÉ- o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n-p�pã o} ÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐãì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑÇÍlÉkÅâÑÇÀlÊÒÐ oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo&o&oGo#n-pNn

÷ Û+Â|Ú«Ûà�Ø?çhÖ#�ßqÛÙ l;j ²

Ñ'

æ ga gçféèdPga gÖêìëéí

º ÃxÂVìPÀlÉ¡î«Î~Ã�ìkÊÒÀlÃ�¿RìPÀlÉ>ï�Åw ÎIÍÏͯÂ~ÐÌÑÇÎ~î¿kÀeÊÒÀ(t�ÀlÊÒÍlÑÇÀlÊ¥ÅÇÀÏÐ*úÀlÃ�Ð3zIÉkÑ ìPÎ~ÉkÊÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄ2ÐÒÎ~ÃnÄÅð ì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑÇÀìkÊÒÀlÃ�ÂaÃIÄÒÀ�¿kÀWÁïÎ~ÄÌÊÒÀWÁIÑÇÀ ÅÇÀÏÐ�úÀlÃ�Ð{ñzIÉkÑÎ~à “ �Á�$�K%T0 ” ÄÒÎ~É�Ð�ÅÇÀÏÐR��Î~ÉkÊÒÐ ÍÏÀlÉ-DzïÉ�w Î~ÃBÂVÂaÉ0ÄÒÔlÅÇÔlìkä�Î~Ã�ÀÍ�ä�Â$zIÉ�À ÐÒÀ(teÂaÑâÃ�À ÍÏÀcÉ#Ex{ÅðWÀlÃ�ÍÏÎ~ÊÒÀGzIÉ�ÀXÅw Î~Ã%ÁïÎ~ÑâÄ"zIÉ�ÀlÅTzïÉ�ÀÏЪÐ�Î~ÑÓÊ�Ð�ÀlÄÆÍÏÀlÉ-Ex{ÅðWÀlÃ-~�Ã:MzIÉkÑÅw Î~Ã%ìPÀlÃ�ÐÒÀÐÒÎ~ÉkÁïÀlÃIÄ�òÅÇÀÏаúÀlÃ�ÐzïÉ�ÀªÅw Î~ÃeÍlÊÒÎ~ÑÇÐÒÀÆÄÒÎ~É�аÅÇÀÏÐ;�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐ ÅÇÀÏÐ Â6t ÑÇÐ ¿kÉ�zïÉ�Î~ÄÌÑÇ¿[ÑÇÀlà ÅÇÀÏаìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�ÀÏÐt¿kÀªÄÒÎ~É$��Î~ÉkÊÒÐskÊÒÀ�#òÂaÉ�ÐÒÐÌÑÑâÃ�¿kÔlìPÀlÃ�¿�ÂaÃnÄ2ÀlÄì�ÂaÊy«Î~ÑÇÐ*¿[ÑÇÐÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄ3zïÉ�À Åw Î~ÃRìkÉ�ÑâÐ�ÐÒÀ·µlÄÌÊÒÀ Î~ÃRÁnÑâÄ�ÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐ3%ìkÅâÉ�ÐÌÑÇÀlÉkÊÒÐÀlÄ%Ê�ÂaÊÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ ÄÌÊÒÎ~ìEÊ�ÂaÊÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ Î~ÃEìkÊÒÀlÃ�¿ ÅÇÀ

ÐÒÀlÉkÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄãÍÏÎ~ÃIÄÌÊÌÑqskÉ�Ô3 ÍÏÀ�ÄÌÊ�¯Á~ÂaÑâÅ¿kÀ�ÄÌä�åÏÐÒÀ teÂaÑÇÐÆìPÀlÊ�t ÑÇпkÀ�ÅÇÀÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄÌÊÌÉkÑâÊÒÀ o á ÎIÍlÄÒÎ~Ê�ÂaÃIÄÒÐ ��À ÁïÎ~É�ÐÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÒÀlÑâÅâÅÇÀ*ÈÔlÊ/ü$t�ÀìPÎ~ÉkÊÐÒÀÏЪÑÇ¿kÔÏÀÏÐÈteÂaÑâÐãÂaÉ�ÐÒÐÒÑ�ìPÎ~ÉkÊÆÅ Â2ìkÊÒÔÏÍlÑÇÀlÉ�Ð�À�ÊÌÑâúÉ�ÀlÉkÊã¿kÀ�Ð�ÀÏÐ�ÊÒÀlÅÇÀÏÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀÏÐÅýÇ Î~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒпiw ÉkÃ2ìPÎ~ÑâÃIÄ¿kÀ�ÁIÉ�ÀtìkÊÒÎ6ÀÏÐÒÐÌÑÇÎ~ÃkÃ�ÀlÅ t�ÀlÊÒÍlÑ ÑÇÀlÊÌÅâÉkÑâúÑ ´ ÊÒÀÏÐ�ÍÏÀlÃ#öÏÑkÀlÄ ÑâúúÎõþÂaÃkÃWìPÎ~ÉkÊÅÇÀlÉkÊ ÍÏÎ$t ìPÀlÃ�¿[ÑâÉ#t ÐÌÑ-s�ÑâÀlÃeÎ~ÊÌúïÂaÃ�ÑâÐ�ÔÆÀlÄ°ÐÒÑ-skÑÇÀlÃ�ÑâÃ-Î~Ê�t�ÔÂaÉ zïÉ�ÀcÅ��ÌÀRt�ÀªÐÒÉkÑÇÐÊÒÀlìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÔ3î«ÀlÄ ÍÏÎ~ÃIÄÌÑâÃIÉ�ÀlÊ�ÂaÑ

¿kÀ�ÅÇÀõ{ÂaÑâÊÒÀ вÂaÃ�ЪÅw Î$t3skÊÒÀ¿iw ÉkÿkÎ~ÉkÄÒÀËïÒteÂaÑâÃIÄÒÀÏÐÀlÄÈteÂaÑâÃIÄÒÀÏÐ"Î~ÑÇÐ�ýqýqý ÀlÃ�Î~Ã�ÐyxvÀlÃ? ìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃIÄWÂaÉ-RÊÒÀ(t�ÀlÊÒÍlÑâÀ(t�ÀÏÃIÄÒÐWÎ ÍlÑÇÀlÉ-ézIÉkÑ ÁIÑÇÀlÃkÃ�ÀlÃIÄWÐÒÀ�ìkÅ Â~ÍÏÀlÊ¥Åð ÍÏÎ$t·t�À�¼¯Â ì�ÂaÊÒÍÏÀRzIÉ�w ÂaìkÊÒåÏÐÄÒÎ~ÉkÄ|ÅÇÀ�ÄÌÊ�¯ÁÂaÑâÅ[ÀlÄÅ ÂÁnÑÇÀ ÐÌÉkÊÌÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÀlà ÍÏÀÒzIÉkÑ[ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÍÏÀlÊÌÃ�À�ÉkÃ2ÄÌÊ�¯ÁÂaÑâÅk¿kÀtÅÇÎ~ÃkúÉ�À�ä�ÂaÅÇÀcÑâÃ�ÀÄÒÀlÅ ÅÇÀ ÄÌÊ�¯ÁÂaÑâÅ¿kÀ ÄÌä�åÏÐ�À Ã�À�ìPÀlÉkÁïÀlÃIÄÆì�Â~Ð ä�Î~Ãkà µlÄÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ µlÄÌÊ�À ÄÒÎ~Ä�ÂaÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄX¿[ÑÇÐÒÐÒÎIÍlÑÇÔÏÐ oÈïÔlÊ/ü$t�ÀO¿kÀ�Ã�Î~ÉkÁïÀ¯ÂaÉ ìPÎ~ÉkÊ2ÐÒÎ~Ã�ÀlÃIÄÌä�Î~É�ÐÌÑ Â~Ð�t�À вÂM�ÌÎ~ÑÇÀe¿kÀ�ÁnÑÓÁnÊÒÀ�ìPÀlÊ�teÂaÃ�ÀlÃIÄÒÀCÀlÄ¥ÍÏÎ$t·t¥ÉkÃkÑ'xͯÂaÄÌÑâÁïÀ Ñqt ìkÊÒÀÏÐ�ÐÌÑÇÎ~ÃkÃ�ÂaÃIÄÒÀò|Í�w ÀÏÐÌÄ¥ÉkÃBúïÂaÊ/¼ÏÎ~Ã�ä�Î~ÊÒÐ2¿[É�ÍÏÎ$t·t¥Ékà ÉkÃ�úïÂaÊÒÐ*ÁnÊ�ÂaÑqt�ÀlÃIÄ2Ôlì�ÂaÄ�ÂaÃIÄ� Å ÂÍlÉkÊÌÑÇÎÐÌÑâÄÒÔOì�ÂaÊyÎ~ÑÇÐ3teÂaÅtìkÅ Â~ÍÏÔÏÀ�teÂaÑÇÐ2Í�w ÀÏÐÒÄ¥ìPÎ~ÉkÊM¼¯Â:zIÉ�w Î~Ã�Åw ÂaÑqt�À teÂaÅâúÊÒÔúîÀcÄWÍÏÀeÃ�w ÀÏÐÌÄ¥ìPÎ~ÉkÊÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄì�Â~ÐãÊÌÑÇÀlÃ>ïÐ�·Â$¼ÏÎ~ÃÇ Î~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐXÐ�Î~ÉkÊÌÑ ÂaÃIÄXÑâÅ|ÀÏÐÌÄãìPÎ~ÉkÊsPÀ¯ÂaÉ�ÍÏÎ~Ékì%¿kÀÅ ÂGsPÎ~ÃkÃ�ÀãäIÉ#t�ÀlÉkÊ�¿�ÂaÃ�ÐtÅÇÀÏÐs�ÉkÊÒÀ¯ÂaÉ- ÄÒÎ~É���Î~ÉkÊÒÐ�¿[ÑÇÐÌìPÎ~ÃkÑqskÅÇÀXÍ�w ÀÏÐÌÄ�ÍÏÀcÅâÉkÑPÁÀlÊÒÐÐzIÉkÑ�ÄÒÎ~ÉkÄ¿kÎIÍlÄÒÎ~Ê�ÂaÃIÄCÐÒÀVÄÒÎ~ÉkÊÌÃ�À:zIÉ�ÂaÃ�¿£ÑâÅXÂôÉkà ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À ÉkÃ�À:zIÉ�ÀÏÐÌÄÌÑÇÎ~à oÒv É�ÀlÅÇÐ�zIÉ�À ÐÒÎ~ÑÇÀlÃIÄeÃ�ÎÐO¯ÁïÀlÃkÑâÊÒÐÊÒÀÏÐÌìPÀÏÍlÄÌÑ'Ð �(w ÀÏÐÌìPålÊÒÀ&zIÉ�À Ã�Î~É�ÐÆÍÏÎ~ÃnÄÌÑâÃIÉ�ÀlÊÒÎ~Ã�Ð ÄÌÊÒåÏÐÆÅÇÎ~ÃkúÄÒÀ(t ì�Ð ¿kÀ�ÍÏÎ~ÅâÅ Â6sPÎ~ÊÒÀlÊXÀlÃóÂ6t ÑâÄÌÑÇÔ oÉ ËnÊÌÑ Â6t zïÉkÑtÂ%ÄÒÎ~É$��Î~ÉkÊÒÐ*Ê�ÂaÑÇÐÒÎ~ÃBÀlÄ*¿kÀ�{ÂaÑâÄ ÀÏÐÌÄ*¿iw À�[ÍÏÀlÅâÅÇÀlÃIÄ¥ÍÏÎ~Ã�Ð�ÀlÑâÅ@ò ÀlÅâÅÇÀeÀÏÐÌÄÅÇÂVìPÀcÊ�ÐÒÎ~ÃkÃ�À�Å ÂìkÅâÉ�ÐtÔLzïÉkÑâÅâÑqskÊÒÔÏÀ ¿kÎ~ÄÒÔÏÀ¿[ÉeìkÅâÉ�Ð ¿iw Â~ÐÒÐÒÑâÐ�À ¿kÀªÊÒÀÏÍlÉkÅ?ÐÒÉkÊ°Å Â ÁnÑÇÀÆÀlÄ ¿kÀÍlÅ ÂaÑâÊÌÁÎêËIÂaÃ�ÍÏÀzIÉ�ÀP�ÌÀÆÍÏÎ~ÃkÃ�ÂaÑÇÐÒÐÒÀ oá ÀlÊÌÊÌÑÇålÊÒÀ�ÐÒÀÏÐÂaÑâÊÒÐ|ìPÔlÊÒÀ(t ìkÄÒÎ~ÑâÊÒÀÏÐHî+teÂaÑÇÐPzIÉ�ÀtÁïÎ~ÉkÅÇÀ(ö(x{ÁÎ~É�Ð ÍÏÎ$t·t�ÀØ�ÌÀtÅÇÀ�¿[ÑÇÐ�ÂaÑÇÐ|ÑâÅ[Ë¥Âã¿kÀ�ÍÏÀlÅ ÂHzIÉ�ÀlÅTzIÉ�ÀÅâÑâúÃ�À ÀlÅâÅÇÀ2Â�ÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐãÊ�ÂaÑÇÐÒÎ~Ã>ï Å ÂÁskÊÌÑâÅâÅ ÂaÃIÄÒÀ É ËIÊÌÑ Â6t ÀÏÐÌÄãÉkÃ�À*ìPÀlÊÒÐ�Î~ÃkÃ�À*ÄÒÊÒåÏÐ ÂaúÊÒÔ¯Â6skÅÇÀ�e¿[ÑÇÐÒÍlÉkÄÒÀlÊÀlÄÆÄÒÎ~É$��Î~ÉkÊÒÐHWÅ�w ÂaÑÇ¿kÀ*À ͯÂ~ÍÏÀ*¿kÀÏЪúÀlÃ�ÐzïÉkÑ�Åw ÀlÃIÄÒÎ~ÉkÊÒÀlÃnÄ o

r ÂaÉkÊÒÀlÃIÄYî+tÁµ(t�ÀôÐÌÑXÍÏÀlÅ Â�¿kÔlìPÀlÃ�¿E¿kÀÏÐ�Î~ÑÇÐ ÑâÅHÂaÉkÄV¯ÁïÎ~É�ÀlÊ8ïO¯ÁïÀlÍzIÉkÑãÃ�Î~É�ÐV¯ÁïÎ~Ã�ÐOÊÒÔlÉ�ÐÒÐÌÑGì�ÂaÊÌÄ�ÂaúÀlÊÆìkÊÒÎ6«Î~Ã�¿kÔ(t�ÀlÃIÄÀlÄÈzïÉkÑ;tw ÂMsPÀ¯ÂaÉ�ÍÏÎ~ÉkìÂaìkìkÊÌÑÇÐ tw ÂWÍlÀlÊÌIJÂaÑÓÃ�À�t�ÀlÃnÄ"{ÂaÑâÄ�ìkÊÒÎ~úÊÒÀÏÐÒÐÒÀlÊÆÀlÃ�t�ÀÊÒÔlÁïÔlÅ ÂaÃIÄ ¿kÀÏÐ Í�ä�ÎÐÒÀÏÐ ÐÌÉkÊt�Î~Ñ'xtÁµ(t�À ÀlÄzïÉ�ÀP�(w ÂaÑqt�ÀÐ�ÂaÃ�аÍÏÎ$t ìkÄÒÀlÊtÀlÃ�Ä�ÂaÃIÄzIÉ�À�ìPÀlÊÒÐ�Î~ÃkÃ�ÀÆÍlÉkÅâÄÌÑâÁïÔÏÀ ÑâÃIÄÒÀlÅâÅâÑâúÀlÃIÄÒÀ ÍlÉkÊÌÑÇÀlÉ�ÐÒÀÀlÄÎ~ÉkÁÀlÊÌÄÒÀGskÑÇÀlÃ:zIÉ�w ÑâÅÐNw ÂaÄÌÄ�Â~Í�ä�À�ÄÌÊÒÎ~ìóÐÒÎ~ÉkÁïÀlÃIÄHWÐÒÀ ÅÇÀͯÂ~Í�ä�ÀlÊHWÅâÉkÑ'xtÁµ(t�À oá Å ËBÂÂaÉ�ÐÒÐÒÑ r ÂaÊÌÊÌËzIÉkÑtÃ�w Î~É#skÅâÑÇÀ{�ÒÂ6teÂaÑÇÐ2ÐÒÀÏÐ¥ÍlÅÇÀ�Ð úÃ�åÏÐMzIÉkÑ zïÉ�ÂaÃ�¿®ÀlÅâÅÇÀeÃ�w ÀÏÐÌÄ¥ì�Â~Ð2ÀlÃ~�ÿkÀ*ÄÌä�åÏÐ�À¥ÀÏÐÌÄõzIÉ�ÀlÅTzïÉ�w ÉkÃô¿kÀ*ÄÌÊÒåÏÐHÊÒÔLzIÉ�ÀlÃIÄ�Â6skÅÇÀ ��� ï�ï ÈïÂaÅ ÂaÅ|ìPÎ~ÉkÊ ÐÒÎ~ÃôÂ6t�Î~ÉkÊ Ð²ÂaÃ�ÐìkÉ�¿�ÀcÉ�Ê û�¯Á ÀlÄÅÇÀÏÐtìkÊÒÔÏÍlÑÇÀlÉ�ÐÒÀÏÐ�¿[ÑÇÐ�ÍlÉ�ÐÒÐÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÒzIÉ�ÀÃ�Î~É�Ð�¯ÁïÎ~Ã�Ð�ÀlÉ�ÀÏÐ�ÀlÃ�Â~ÍÏÀ�x¹¶x�{Â~ÍÏÀ�î«ÐÒÎ~ÉkÁïÀlÃkÑâÊ�¿kÀGù�ÂaÊÌúïÂ6t�ÀlÅâÅÇÀËï ÅÇÀ�¿kÎ~ÃIÄqÅw ÀÏÐÌìkÊÌÑâÄ|ÀlÄÅw Â~ÐÌìkÑâÊ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃóîÅw ÑâÃ�ÐÌìkÑâÊ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à | ïÐÌÑïÊÌÑÇÍ�ä�À ÁÎ~É�ÐìkÅ ÂaÑâÊ�ÂaÑâÄPÆÐËw ÑqteÂaúÑÓÃ�ÀcÊÆÐÒÀ°ÊÒÀlÄÌÊÒÎ~ÉkÁïÀcÊÂaÉÍÏÎ~Ñâà ¿iw ÉkÃ�ÀXÄ�Â6s�ÅâÀ&¥ìkäkÑâÅÇÎÐÒÎ~ìkä�ÀlÊ� É�Ð�zïÉ�w ÂaÉ�sPÎ~ÉkÄÆ¿kÀXŠ¥ÃIÉkÑâÄ ø ÅâÑqt8ÀlĪÐ�Î~Ã%À ͯÂ~ÍlÑâÄÒÔ ÐÒÎ~à ÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�À¿[ÑâÊÒÀÏÍlÄÒÀ oø ÑâÅâÅâÑ Â6tezïÉkÑqÀÏÐÌÄìPÎ~ÉkÊHsPÀ¯ÂaÉ�ÍÏÎ~Ékìô¿�ÂaÃ�Ðt�Î~ÃÔÏ¿[É�ÍÏÂaÄÒÑâÎ~Ãt¥É�ÐÒÑÇͯÂaÅâÀ ´ ÔÏÍlÑâÅâÀ¥úÊ��~ÍÏÀ3ÁzIÉkÑ ��À*Ð�ÂaÑÇÐÄÒÎ~ÉkÄtÎ~É�ìkÊÒÀÏÐ�zïÉ�ÀÐÌÉkÊ°ÅÇÀÏÐ É ÂêËï ÑÇÀlÊÌÊÒÀìPÎ~ÉkÊtÐÒÎ~Ã�ÄÒÀ(t ìPÔlÊ�Â6t�ÀlÃIÄ�ÄÒÎ~É$��Î~ÉkÊÒÐÒÂaìkìkÊÒÀlÃ�¿[ÊÒÀ ÐÌÑ�ÍlÉkÊÒÑâÀlÉ-ÀlÄqÁnÑ' teÂaÅâúÊÒÔ�Ð�ÂÍÏÔlÅÇå(skÊÒÀtÄÒÀlÃ�¿�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ"ÆúïÂhùÀlÊ Å ÂÆúÔlÃ�ÔlÊÒÀlÉ�ÐÒÀ Ý ÅÇÔtìPÎ~ÉkÊ|вÂR{Â$¼ÏÎ~Ã2¿iw ÂaÑqt�ÀlÊ°ÂaÉMzIÉ�Î~ÄÌÑÇ¿[ÑÇÀlÃÀlÄ ø Ä�Ôcì�ä�ÂaÃ�ÀXìPÎ~ÉkʪÐ�Â&{Â$¼ÏÎ~ÃV¿kÀãÅÇÀ{ÂaÑâÊÒÀX¿[ÑÇÐ�ÍcÊ�åcÄ�À�t�ÀlÃnÄ ÂaÉkÅìPÎ~ÉkÊ�ÅÇÀÏÐ�ÁïÀlÑâÅâÅÇÔÏÀÏÐ�¿[É pN Â~Î$÷kÄ�ÐÒÉkÊ�¿kÀÏÐÂ~ÍÏÍÏÎ~ÊÒ¿kÐ�¿kÀ ë á á�º��H¨ á ´ äkÊÌÑÇÐÒÄÌÑâÃ�ÀìPÎ~ÉkÊ�вÂÐÌìPÎ~ÃIÄ�ÂaÃ�Ô�ÄÒÔ ÐÒÎ~ÃOÃ�ÂaÄÌÉkÊÒÀlÅ ÐÒÎ~ÃeÊÌÑâÊÒÀãÀlÄ�ÐÒÎ~Ã%Â6t�Î~ÉkÊ¿kÀÏÐÂaÉkÄÒÊÒÀÏÐ oÇ ä�Î$teÂ~Ð ÐÒÎ~É�Ð�Åw ÑâÃ��É�ÀlÃ�ÍÏÀ�¿[É zIÉ�ÀlÅE�Lw ÂaÑPúÊ�ÂaÃ�¿[Ñ ÀlÄ�Ð�ÂaÑâÄyxvÎ~ÃM�ÒÂ6teÂaÑÇÐ�ÐÌÑPÉkÃ3�ÌÎ~ÉkÊ�Î~ÃVÐÒÀãÊÒÀlÄÌÊÒÎ~ÉkÁïÀlÊ�ÂÂaÉkÄÒÎ~ÉkÊã¿iw ÉkÃ�ÀÍÏÎ$t ìPÎÐÌÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã:t¥É�ÐÌÑÇͯÂaÅÇÀ |´ ÔlÅâÑâÃ�À&te ÍÏÎ~É�ÐÌÑâÃ�À�ìkÊÒÔ�ÔcÊ�ÔlÀ ì�ÂaÊÒÍÏÀ&zIÉ�w ÀlÅâÅÇÀÀÏÐÌĪìkÅâÉkÄ/ü~ÄÈteÂWìPÀlÄÌÑâÄÒÀ*Ð� ÉkÊ or ÂÂ6t ÑâÅâÅÇÀ0ÀlÄ�t�ÀÏÐCì�ÂaÊÒÀlÃIÄÒÐ ÀlÃIÁïÀlÊÒÐ�zIÉkÑÒ��ÀÃ�ÀôÐÒÉkÑÇÐCì�Â~Ð%ÄÒÎ~É$��Î~ÉkÊÒÐ%ÄÌÊÒåÏÐM��É�ÐÌÄÒÀ��ÌÀ

Åw äIÉ#t ÑâÅâÑâÄÒÔ Å ÂÐÌÑqt ìkÅâÑÇÍlÑâÄÒÔ o$á ÅÇÐ|Î~ÃIÄqÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐ|ÔlÄÒÔtÅð ÅÇÀtÐÒÎ~ÃIÄ|ÀlÃ�ÍÏÎ~ÊÒÀ�ÂaÉ$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒ¿iw äIÉkÑkÀlÄqÅÇÀtÐÒÀlÊÒÎ~ÃIÄ|ÄÒÎ~É$��Î~ÉkÊÒÐÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐ teÂaÅâúÊÒÔ:t�ÀÏÐOÐ�ÂaÊÒͯÂ~Ð/t�ÀlÐŨt�ÀÏÐeì�ÂaÊÒÀlÃIÄÒÐ t�ÀlÊÒÍlÑãìPÎ~ÉkÊeÄÒÎ~ÉkÄC¿iw µlÄÌÊÒÀ ÁïÎ~É�Ð oÉ ÀÏÐeúÊ�ÂaÃ�¿kÐyxì�ÂaÊÒÀlÃIÄÒÐ É ÑÇÍ�ä�ÀlÅâÑâÃ�À É ÂaÊÌÑÇÀcÄÒÄÒÀóÀlÄOÈÀ¯ÂaázïÉkÑÐ�Î~ÃIÄ�ÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐOÐÌÑÆìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃIÄ�ÐeÀlÄ�zIÉkÑÀlÃKÎ~ÃIÄOÐÌÉ#skÑã¿kÀÏÐÍÏÎ~Ékì�Ð o ùXÊ�ÂaÃ�¿�xt�ålÊÒÀ teÂ

nÑâÁ

æ � í��åa � í

���! #"%$&�´ ÀlÄÌÄÒÀCÄÌä�åÏÐÒÀCÐNw ÑâÃ�ÐÒÍlÊÌÑâÄW¿�ÂaÃ�Ð2ÅÇÀOͯÂ~¿[ÊÒÀ%¿kÀeÅw �8!�!>���NI$�+�Á��������4!#�$%('$4>�$�����$%T0��$�:!>�K��0�=�0�7�B/�$7 ¿kÀÏÐ

!>�����(%q,(�Á0�7�=$� ) BL�K%T087õ=Å2 ��!C���K���K7(�������$4óB/���Á�(�K4>�@��$�K��0 zïÉkÑ?ÐÒÀÆ¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÀÆìPÎ~ÉkÊt¿kÎ~É#s�ÅâÀãÎ$s-�ÌÀÏÍlÄÌÑ' ¿kÀ"«Î~ÉkÊÌÃkÑâÊ0�4ú�90(�!>7Ò!-��%*'$4>�$�����$% ¿kÀÏÐÆÐ�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð =�03.L�-�$%)���9��+@�$����4

sPÀlÄ@��ÀÏÀlÃA��Î~ÊÒÐÒÄ�ÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã%Á~ÂaÅâÉ�À ÂaÃ�¿%Î~ìkÄÌÑqteÂaÅÁ~ÂaÅâÉ�À o-Ç äkÑÇÐ�ÄÌä�ÀÏÐÌÑÇÐÐÎïÍlÉ�Ð�Î~ÃCÄ@��ÎMteÂaÑâÃCÃ�Î~ÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÅIÄÌä�À=$� -H0��/0�4>�����$%Ø��������� �ªäkÑÇÍ�äÑÇÐXÂB��Â¯Ë Î6°ÀlÁ~ÂaÅâÉ�ÂaÄÌÑâÃkúCÄÌä�À*Ð�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐHzIÉ�ÂaÅâÑâÄËóÂaÃ�¿ ÄÌä�À %q�NB��$%P�8!C���+�Á�$% ���.'�ªäkÑÇÍ�äxÊÒÀ�ÀlÊÒÐ2ÄÒÎôÂ

p

G HJILKNMPORQDS T

U êìëYfé_WVX�åè ëédP_eê

r w Î$s-��ÀlÄ%¿kÀ

n

¿iw ÉkÃ�ÀHt ÑÇÐÒÀãÀlÃA� ÉkÁnÊÒÀXÂaÑÇÐÒÔÏÀXÀlÄ�¿iw ÉkÄÌÑâÅâÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã%Ê�ÂaìkÑÇ¿kÀ Â*ÔlÄÒÔÅÇÎ~ÃkúÉ�À(t�ÀlÃIÄÆÔcÄÒÉ�¿[ÑÇÔÏÀXÀlÄ�À�[ìkÅÇÎ~ÑâÄÒÔÏÀãÄ�ÂaÃIÄì�ÂaÊÅâÀÏÐÍ�ä�ÀlÊÒÍ�ä�ÀlÉkÊ�ÐØzIÉ�Àì�ÂaÊ ÅÇÀÏÐÎ~ìPÔlÊ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃkÃ�ÀlÅÇÐ o$´ ÑâÄÒÎ~Ã�Ð ìPÎ~ÉkÊÑâÅâÅâÉ�ÐÌÄÌÊ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã¥ÉkÃ�ÀP{Â6t�ÀlÉ�ÐÒÀ°ÐÒÎ~É�Ðyx�Â6t ÑâÅâÅÇÀ¿iw Î~ìkÄÌÑqteÂ�ÅÇÎIͯÂaÉ-MÎ~Ê�t�ÔÏÀÆ¿kÀÏаÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Шte¶[ÑqteÂaÅÇÀÏÐ ÀlÄt ÑâÃkÑqteÂaÅÇÀÏÐ�ÉkÃ�ÀÆÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃÁte¶[ÑqteÂaÅÇÀ{î �/0�7!iUt ÑâÃkÑqteÂaÅÇÀËïÀÏÐÌÄÉkÃRìkÅâÉ�ÐúÊ�ÂaÃ�¿ î �/0879!iU ìkÅâÉ�ÐìPÀlÄÌÑâÄ8ï�ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ�ÁIÑÇÐ�x¹¶x{ÁIÑÇÐ*¿kÀ Åw ÑâÃ�ÍlÅâÉ�ÐÌÑÇÎ~ÃBÊÒÀÏÐÌìPÀÏÍlÄ�ÂaÃIÄÉkÃ�ÀÍÏÀlÊÌÄ�ÂaÑâÃ�ÀìkÊÒÎ~ìkÊÌÑÇÔlÄÒÔ o

´ ÀlìPÀlÃ�¿�ÂaÃIÄ Å ÂôÃ�Î~ÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃK¿kÀVÊÒÀÏÍ�ä�ÀlÊÒÍ�ä�ÀóÅÇÎIͯÂaÅÇÀóÀÏÐÌÄ�ìkÅâÉ�Ð�ÊÌÑÇÍ�ä�ÀzIÉ�w ÑâÅÆÃ�w Ë®ì�ÂaÊ�Â0/ÇÄ ìkÉkÑÇÐ�zïÉ�w ÀlÅâÅÇÀ¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔÅâÑÇÀlÉ�¿[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÒÐtÄËnìPÀÏÐt¿kÀÆÊÒÔÏÐ�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð�îÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#t�ÀÏЪÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�ÔÏÐ�¿kÀÄËIìPÀ �Á0L���=*-0(�E���ð7(����.L�#0¯ÁïÀÏÍ*ÅÇÀ*Ä�Â6sPÎ~É !#�$%*'$4C�$�����$��I ¯ÁïÀÏÍ*Å ÂeÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀ GLO c p�pd ïÂaÑâÃ�ÐÌÑÞzIÉ�w}e¿[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÒÀÏÐ ¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð ¿kÀ¥ÍÏÀzIÉ�ÀÐÒÎ~ÃIÄ ¿iw ÉkÃ�À*ì�ÂaÊÌÄÆÉkÃóÁïÎ~ÑÇÐÌÑâÃ�ÂaúÀ*ÐÌÉkÊÆÉkÃóÀlÃ�Ð�À(t3skÅÇÀ*¿kÀÐ�Î~ÅÓÉ�ÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð3îÃ�Î~ÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿkÀ %q�ËB/��% ���9� ï ¿�w ÂaÉ�ÄÌÊÒÀì�ÂaÊÌÄÆÅ Â�t�ÔlÄÌä�ÎI¿kÀ¿�w ÔlÁÂaÅâÉ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿkÀÍÏÀÏÐÆÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð3î«Ã�Î~ÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãó¿iw �8!;���K�Á�$%)�+�9� ï o

{�67õ�����$5¶�$��I·78���H%T087��8!;���K�Á�M%q�ËB/�$��I·7#2 �+4%)��7R!#0L���+�Ò=�0873�8!C���+�·��%q�NB��$��I�7N0����$���Ð=E� ô S���4C0�����4 4C0G7L�$% �-�����$4ú����7N0�4#7{=�0{%�2 �8!@!>���ËI$�K�Á�������$4CUfe8%7#2 ��+$���Þ=@�$4>B�=Å2 �E4C0õ�8!@!>�/�NB�*#07������-BL�����/0�%+%q0G=@�$4#7"%T0È7L0�4 7��gÁ�+%>087��P=@�$4#7"%q�{4C�����E�/0õ=Ø2 ��4{!>������%T,���0�=�0+@�$�/�$4�$4ñ%'��.(�#�$% ���9��=�0È7L087H�8!C���+�Á�{%'�ËB��$��IihØ�K4C=��9! 0�4>=@���M��0�4>�Þ=$��B��$�H!#�$���90(�Á0(4�$�E74;2 �-���K%)�K7(�$4#7M!-�$7ó%/2 �8!C���K�Á�$%)���9�%'�ËB��$%T0Á!-�$���:%'�?B��$4#7(���8�#BL�����$4=�0ú�/�$4#7�$%j+@�$���+�+*E�Á0�73�8!@!>���ËB�*-�87{�Á�$�K7&B��$����03�$�-���+%Å=�0MB��$���@BN�9���8�K7(�@�����$4Y=�0�7Ò!>�/����%T,���087M=�0

NPOU

��6 ZRZ `95#4lkR\�mn��57o!pq4r\o!_

Î~ÉkÊ�ÔlÁÂaÅâÉ�ÀlÊ Å ÂúzIÉ�ÂaÅâÑâÄÒÔV¿kÀÏÐ�ÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ðe¿kÔlÄÒÀlÊ�t ÑâÃ�ÔÏÀÏÐ�ì�ÂaÊ�ÅÇÀÏÐ�ÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#t�ÀÏÐ�t ÑÇÐeÂaÉ-®ìPÎ~ÑâÃIÄÒÐ Å ÂCÍÏÎ$t·t¥ÉkÃ�ÂaÉkÄÒÔ�ÐÒÍlÑÇÀlÃIÄÌÑ'~

!C������%T,���0M=E0&�Á�NI��K���ð7L�������$4 !>���E��%q,(��0M=�0{���K4wyx p�oqp �Á0�78���/0M=Å2 �8!@!>���NI��K�Á�������$4Rλ ≥ r

Î~ìkÄÌÑqteÂaÅÇÀAî B.,NU Ä�Â6skÅÇÀ¯ÂaÉ p�oqp ï oÅá Å°ÀÏÐÌÄÍÏÀlÊÌÄ�ÂaÑâÃ�Ð*ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ*ìPÎ~ÉkÊÅÇÀÏÐ/zIÉ�ÀlÅÇÐ�Å Â%ìPÀcÊÒÄÌÑâÃ�ÀlÃ�ÍÏÀe¿kÀ�ÍlÀ Ê�Âaì-xìPÎ~ÊÌÄÐNw Ñqt ìPÎÐÒÀWÃ�ÂaÄÌÉkÊÒÀlÅâÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ oÞ´ ÑâÄÒÎ~Ã�Ð�ìPÎ~ÉkÊÀ�[À(t ìkÅÇÀWÅÇÀWìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À�¿kÀWÍÏÎ~ÉkÁïÀlÊÌÄÌÉkÊÒÀ ¿kÀ ÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐ MinV C zIÉkÑkÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÑÇÐÌÄÒÀª¿�ÂaÃ�ÐÉkà úÊ�Âaìkä�ÀÆÐÌÑqt ìkÅÇÀÈ ¿kÔlÄÒÀlÊ�t ÑâÃ�ÀlÊ ÉkÃ�ÐÒÎ~É�ÐyxvÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀÆ¿kÀªÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐ Â~¿�x�ÒÂ~ÍÏÀlÃIÄÈ2ÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÒÀÂaÊ/µlÄÒÀ�¿[ÉVúÊ�Âaìkä�ÀGzIÉkÑ�ÐÒÎ~ÑâĪ¿kÀ Ä�ÂaÑâÅâÅÇÀ�t ÑâÃkÑqt¥É#t o r À�t�ÀlÑâÅâÅÇÀlÉkÊãÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#t�À*ÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�ÔCÊ�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄ¥ÍlÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄ*ÍÏÎ~ÃkÃIÉRìPÎ~ÉkÊ*ÍÏÀWìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À ÀlÃ0ìkÊÒÎ~ìPÎÐ�ÂaÃIÄ¥ÍÏÎ$t·t�À�ÍÏÎ~ÉkÁïÀcÊÒÄÌÉkÊÒÀ ÅÇÀÏÐÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐÀ�[ÄÌÊÒÔ(t ÑâÄÒÔÏпkÀÏÐ*ÂaÊ/µlÄÒÀÏÐ*¿iw ÉkÃRÍÏÎ~ÉkìkÅ ÂaúÀ·te¶[ÑqteÂaÅ Â~ÐÒÐÌÉkÊÒÀ ¿kÀ ¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÀlÊÉkÃ�À ÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÂaÉ0ìkÅâÉ�пkÀlÉ-Î~ÑÇЪìkÅâÉ�ÐÆúÊ�ÂaÃ�¿kÀ{zIÉ�À�Åw Î~ìkÄÌÑqt¥É#t o;º Ê ã Î~ÅâÅÇÎ$s#z~Ðt�Î~ÃIÄÌÊÒÀ*¿�ÂaÃ�Ð c n6�d zIÉ�À !>�/087L.(�#0���$�-� úÊ�Âaìkä�À¥Â~¿�xt�ÀlÄtÉkÃOÍÏÎ~ÉkìkÅ ÂaúÀãì�ÂaÊyÂaÑâÄ Í�w ÀÏÐÌÄyx¹¶xv¿[ÑâÊÒÀõzïÉ�ÀÆÅ Â�ì�ÊÒÎ$s�Â6skÑâÅâÑâÄÒÔõzïÉ�w ÉkÃOúÊ�Âaìkä�Àõ n ÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐ�ÍÏÎ~ÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÃkÃ�ÀÉkÃTÍÏÎ~ÉkìkÅ ÂaúÀó¿kÀVÄ�ÂaÑâÅâÅÇÀ

bn/2cÄÒÀlÃ�¿£ìkÊÒÀÏÐ�zïÉ�À Ð�÷kÊÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄeÁïÀcÊ�Ð p îÉkÃKÍlÎ~É�ìkÅ ÂaúÀ ì�ÂaÊyÂaÑâÄOÔlÄ�ÂaÃIÄ�ÉkÃ

ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀO¿iw ÂaÊ/µlÄÒÀÏÐ2¿kÀlÉ- ¿kÀlÉ-0Ã�Î~îÂ~¿6�ÒÂ~ÍÏÀlÃIÄÒÀÏÐ3zIÉkÑ°ÊÒÀÏÍÏÎ~ÉkÁnÊÒÀ�Ä�Î~É�ÐÅÇÀÏÐ¥ÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐ¥¿[ÉBúÊ�Âaìkä�ÀËï o ÃóÍÏÀ�ͯÂ~Ð ìkÊÒÀlÃ�¿[ÊÒÀ�ÅÇÀÏÐÆÐ�Î$t·t�ÀlÄÒпiw Ékà ÍÏÎ~ÉkìkÅ ÂaúÀ&te¶[ÑqteÂaÅ Í�w ÀÏÐÌÄ ÂaÉVìkÑâÊÒÀ ìkÊÒÀlÃ�¿[ÊÒÀÉkà ÍÏÎ~ÉkìkÅ ÂaúÀte¶[Ñqt¥É#tFÐ�Î~ÑÓÄ !>�/0�7(.(� 0�7|{��/0���0�4

xvÍÏÎ~ÅÇÎ~Ê�Â6skÅÇÀÏÐ c �n0d zïÉ�ÂaÃ�¿

ÂaÅâÄÒÀlÊÌÃ�ÂaÄÌÑâÁïÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ2¿kÀÏÐÊÒÔÏÐÒÉkÅâÄ�ÂaÄÒÐÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑ'Ð3%ÉkÃBÊ�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄ*ìkÉkÑÇÐM%Åw ÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀòqÂaÉ�ÐÒÐÒÑ ÂaÄÌÄÌÑâÊÒÎ~Ã�Ð�x{Ã�Î~É�Ð*Åw ÂaÄyxÄÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãó¿[ÉVÅÇÀÏÍlÄÒÀlÉkÊÐÌÉkʪÍÏÀ ìPÎ~ÑâÃIÄ ÍÏÂaÊÆÑÓÅ ¿kÀlÁnÊ�ÂWÐÒÀõt�Î~ÃIÄÌÊÒÀlÊÆìkÊÌÉ�¿kÀlÃIÄzIÉ�ÂaÃIÄ¥Åw ÑâÃIÄÒÀlÊÌìkÊÒÔlÄ�ÂaÄÌÑ Î~ÿkÀÏÐÊÒÔÏÐÌÉkÅâÄ�ÂaÄÒÐÀlÃó«Î~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃAzïÉ�w ÑâÅÇÐÐÒÎ~ÑÇÀlÃIÄÔlÃ�Î~Ã�ÍÏÔÏÐÆìPÎ~ÉkÊÆÉkÃ�ÀGt�ÀÏÐÌÉkÊÒÀÎ~É ìPÎ~ÉkÊÆÅw ÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀ o o"D\v6y4#5]o Z 5]�! ro!pq4r�

ìkÊÒåÏÐÉkÃ�ÀÁskÊÒålÁïÀÁt ÑÇÐÒÀ�ÀlÃ�ÍÏÎ~Ã�¿[ÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð¥ì�ÂaÊ*ÉkÃ�À�ìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃIÄ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~îÐÒÉ�ÍÏÍcÑâÃ�ÍlÄÒÀO¿[Ét�Î~Ã�¿kÀe¿kÀ�Åw Âaì-xìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃRìPÎ~ÅâËnÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅÇÀ Ã�Î~É�Ðì�Â~ÐÒÐÒÎ~Ã�п�ÂaÃ�Ð�ÅÇÀ ÁIÑ'�¿[ÉBÐÌÉ$�ÌÀlÄ�ÀlÃB¿[ÑÇÐÒÍlÉkÄ�ÂaÃIÄÄÒÎ~ÉkÄ*¿iw Â6sPÎ~ÊÒ¿B¿kÀÏÐÎ~ìkÄÌÑqteÂ2ÅÇÎIͯÂaÉ-Oì�ÉkÑÇÐ�ÀlÃVÐNw ÑâÃIÄÒÔlÊÒÀÏÐ�Ð�ÂaÃIÄÆÂaÉ%ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À�¿kÀXÁïÎêËïÂaúÀlÉkʪ¿kÀ ÍÏÎ$t·t�ÀlÊÒÍÏÀ o>´ ÀXÐ�Î~ÃIÄ�Åð2¿kÀlÉ-ÂaÄÌÄÌÑâÄÌÉ�¿kÀÏÐÐskÑÇÀlÃC¿[ÑÓù�ÔcÊ�ÀcÃnÄÒÀÏÐtìkÉkÑÇÐ/zïÉ�À¿�ÂaÃ�Ð ÅÇÀÆìkÊÒÀ(t ÑÇÀlÊ�ͯÂ~Ð ÑâÅPÐNw ÂaúÑâÄt¿kÀÆìPÔlÃ�ÔlÄÌÊÒÀlÊ�¿�ÂaÃ�Ð Å Â�Ã�ÂaÄÌÉkÊÒÀã¿kÉìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀWìPÎ~ÉkÊÔlÄÌÉ�¿[ÑÇÀlÊÐ�ÂeÊÒÔ¯Â~ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃRÐ�Î~É�ÐXÉkÃôÄÌÊ�ÂaÑâÄÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄúÔlÃ�ÔlÊÌÑTzïÉ�À ¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�Ô Ä�ÂaÃ�¿[ÑÇÐGzIÉ�ÀW¿�ÂaÃ�Ð ÅÇÀÐÒÀÏÍÏÎ~Ã�¿ Î~ÃAÂaÑâÄXÐÒÉ#skÑâÊ ÂaÉ

u

G HJILKNMPORQDS

f � da dêåc dPfégÖí

| o! Z 57` 3 _F$&o! � Ú Ú :¦9TÍ#¶i(¥#ÍLP¦bð¦?Ï@¤�ÑÒ¢Ó> ÍÎÔ¨Í

NPO r ÀÏÐ�ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐÆ¿iw Î~ìkÄÌÑqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃzIÉ�ÀãÅw Î~ÃVÐNw ÂaÄÌÄ�Â~Í�ä�ÀG¥ÊÒÔÏÐÒÎ~É�¿[ÊÒÀ ÐÒÎ~ÃIÄ�ÅÇÀãìPÀlÃ�¿�ÂaÃIÄ �8!C���K���K7(�������$4

¿kÀÏÐXìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ�¿kÀ2¿kÔÏÍlÑÇÐÌÑÇÎ~Ã0¿kÀNP

o> Ãì�ÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀΠÀÏÐÌÄ Í¯ÂaÊ�Â~ÍlÄÒÔlÊÌÑÇÐÒÔ2ì�ÂaÊ Åw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ

IΠ¿kÀ2ÐÒÀÏÐ

ÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀÏÐ Åw ÉkÃkÑÇÎ~à SolΠ = ∪I∈IΠ ¿kÀÏÐ|ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀÏÐ SolΠ(I) ¿kÀÏÐ|ÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐqÊÒÔ¯ÂaÅâÑÇÐ�Â6skÅÇÀÏÐÂ~ÐÒÐÒÎIÍlÑÇÔÏÀÏÐÂaÉ-ÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀÏÐI ¿kÀtÅ ÂÈ«Î~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃÁÎ~ìkÄÌÑqt ÑÇÐÒÀlÊ mΠ ÐÌÉkÊ|ÍÏÀÏÐÀcÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀÏÐÀlÄ¿[ÉWÐÒÀlÃ�Ð optΠ ¿kÀ Åw Î~ìkÄÌÑqt ÑÇвÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãî �Á�NI$�+���ð7L��������4 Î~É ���+4 �+�M�K7(�@�����$4 ï o ÂaÊÅ ÂWÐÌÉkÑâÄÒÀ Î~à Ã�Î~ÄÒÀlÊ� |I| Å ÂWÄ�ÂaÑâÅâÅÇÀ¿kÀ�Åw ÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ I o

Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7�j#NPO ÃVìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À

Π¿kÀ

NPOÀÏÐÒĪÉkÃzIÉ�Â~¿[ÊÌÉkìkÅÇÀlÄ

(IΠ, SolΠ,mΠ, optΠ)zïÉkÑ�ÁïÔlÊÌÑ'~�À

(i) IΠÀÏÐÌĪÊÒÀÏÍÏÎ~ÃkÃ�ÂaÑÇÐÒÐ�Â6skÅÇÀ*Àlà ÄÒÀ(t ì�ÐÆìPÎ~ÅâËnÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅqÀcÃ

|I|

(ii) ∃ pΠìPÎ~ÅâËnà ü$t�À

t.q. ∀I ∈ IΠ, ∀s ∈ SolΠ(I), |s| ≤ pΠ(|I|)

(iii) ∀I, ∀s,Î~à вÂaÑâÄÆ¿kÔÏÍlÑÇ¿kÀlÊãÀlÃVÄÒÀ(t ì�ÐÆìPÎ~ÅâËnÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅqÀlÃ

|I|ÐÌÑsÀÏÐÌĪÊÒÔ¯ÂaÅâÑÇÐ�Â6skÅÇÀìPÎ~ÉkÊ

I ;

(iv) mΠ : IΠ × SolΠ → NÀÏÐÌÄÍÏÂaÅÇÍlÉkÅ Â6skÅÇÀ¥ÀlÃVÄÒÀ(t ì�ÐÆìPÎ~ÅâËnÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅqÀlÃ

|I| ;

(v) optΠ ∈ {min,max}.

Ã�ÀôÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀR¿iw Ékà ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀRÀÏÐÌÄ Í¯ÂaÊ�Â~ÍlÄÒÔlÊÌÑÇÐÒÔÏÀRì�ÂaÊ ¿�ÀlÐóÎ$s-��ÀlÄÒÐ ¿iw ÉkÃ�ÀRÍÏÀlÊÌÄ�ÂaÑâÃ�ÀBÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀÀlÃÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã0ÀlÃIÄÌÊÒÀ2ÀlÉ-ÀlÄX¿kÀÏÐãÁÂaÅÇÀlÉkÊÒÐãÃIÉ#t�ÔlÊÌÑTzIÉ�ÀÏÐ�òPÎ~Ã

Å ÂV¿kÔ�~�Ã�ÑÓÄÒÑâÎ~îìkÊÒÔÏÍÏÔÏ¿kÀlÃIÄÒÀeÃ�Î~É�Ð2ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÎ~Ã�Ð2¿kÀlÉ-Dt�ÎI¿[Ñ'~�ͯÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐWÍÏÎ~ÉkÊ�Â6t·t�ÀlÃIÄ{{ÂaÑâÄÒÀÏÐ*¿�ÂaÃ�Њ¥ÅâÑâÄÌÄÒÔlÊ�ÂaÄÌÉkÊ�À o á w É�Ã�ÀXì�ÂaÊÌÄ ÑâÅ ÀÏÐÌÄ�ÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐ�ìPÎÐ�ÐÌÑqskÅÇÀ ¿kÀ�ÐÌÉkìkìPÎÐÒÀlÊÈzïÉ�w ÑâÅ À�nÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ ÉkÃVÍÏÎI¿�ÂaúÀGskÑâÃ�ÂaÑâÊÒÀ¿kÀÏÐ ¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔlÀÏÐ�¿[ÉeìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀHzïÉkÑ�Ð�Î~ÑâÄ°Ê�ÂaÑÇÐÒÎ~ÃkÃ�Â6skÅÇÀãÀlÄt¿kÀR{ÂaÑâÄ zIÉ�ÀªÅÇÀÏÐ Á~ÂaÊÌÑ Â6skÅÇÀÏÐt¿[ÉeìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀãÐÒÎ~ÑÇÀlÃIÄ

ÐÒÀ*ÁÔlÊÌÑ'~�ÀlÊ ÀlÃÄÒÀ(t ì�Ð|V |2

oCv É�ÂaÃnÄG�ÅÇÂeÁ~ÂaÅÇÀlÉkÊ ¿iw ÉkÃ�À2ÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~à ¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔÏÀ¥ì�ÂaÊ mWIS(I, s) = d · s ÀlÅâÅÇÀCÐÒÀOͯÂaÅÇÍlÉkÅÇÀ%ÀlîÉkîÄÒÀ(t ì�Ð ÂaÉ®ìkÅâÉ�Ðlog(dmax) × |V |

oÞ Ã-~�à Åw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀCÁnÑÇ¿kÀOÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄÒÑÓÄÒÉ�ÀOÉkÃ�ÀÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~à ÄÌÊÌÑâÁnÑ ÂaÅÇÀ�ìPÎ~ÉkÊÆÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÒÀ�ÑâÃ�ÐÒÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ¿[É ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À o

� Ú   ¡�¢s£ �9¤¤?ó@ÔÐ¥6"Í#v6 CÑÒ¢Ír� Î~É�ÐÅw ¯ÁÎ~Ã�ÐãÔlÁïÎEzIÉ�Ô*ÀlÃóÑâÃIÄÌÊÒÎI¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à ÔlÄ�ÂaÃIÄX¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔÏÀ*ÉkÃ�ÀÑâÃ�ÐÒÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ I ¿iw ÉkÃóìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À ¿kÀlÉ-ÁÂaÅÇÀlÉkÊÒÐÆì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑÇÍlÉkÅâÑÇålÊÒÀÏÐXÃ�Î~É�ÐÑâÃIÄÒÔlÊÒÀÏÐÒÐÒÀlÃIÄìPÎ~ÉkÊÅ Â ÊÒÔÏÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

pN

« o!"R5l57�! #`9_�"¬4r\�`9pr w ÑÇ¿kÔ¯ÂaÅÐÒÀlÊ�ÂaÑâÄ ¿kÀ¥Ð�¯ÁïÎ~ÑâÊãÊÒÔÏÐÒÎ~É�¿[ÊÒÀ¥ÅÇÀÏÐãìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ�¿kÀ

NPOÀlÃÄÒÀ(t ì�ÐXìPÎ~ÅâËIÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅ@òCteÂaÅâä�ÀlÉ-x

ÊÒÀlÉ�ÐÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ Å ÂWìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÎ$t ìkÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃÀÏÐÒÄR«Î~ÊÌÄÒÀ¿kÀ�ìPÀlÃ�ÐÒÀlÊzIÉ�À P 6= NP Î~ÉóÀlÃ�ÍÏÎ~ÊÒÀ PO 6= NPO Î » PO ÁïÀlÊÒÐÌÑÇÎ~Ã%Î~ìkÄÌÑqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à ¿kÀXŠ¥ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀP ¿kÔÏÐÒÑâúÃ�ÀãÅw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3s�ÅâÀ�¿kÀÏÐ�ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐÆ¿kÀ NPO zIÉ�ÀãÅw Î~Ã%вÂaÑâÄÊÒÔÏÐÒÎ~É�¿[ÊÒÀóÀlÃTÄÒÀ(t ì�ÐeìPÎ~ÅâËnÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅ oR´ w ÀÏÐÌÄ�ìPÎ~ÉkÊ/zIÉ�Î~ÑãÎ~ÃKÀÏÐÒÐ�ÂaÑÇÀ ¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�ÀlÊ%ÐÒÀlÉkÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ teÂaÑÇÐCÂaÉt ÑÇÀlÉ- ÍlÀÏÐÆìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐã¿[Ñ ÍlÑâÅÇÀÏÐ o

� ! Ú ÌÈ ¡®¥�$¤¤çÔÍ?¢�T ;ÐÏ@¤

p�p

@² o!"R5³��v69_�"R6C4]\`9p� © Ú ´Í ÏúÔÍ?¢9 7Ð¥-ÍÎÔÍ?¢�T ;ÐÏ@¤

pNn

� ©   · ÍΠi¢��Í Ï¸ C@�ÕÅÍDµR¢9ÍéÏ@ ;"¤ÅÏ�AÔЧ¹ ¢ Ï�Í#Ø�9Í

pN

7(��% �-������4Î���=$�ð7(��$4>B80�S%q��!>�+�/0�7L�$%)�������$4 ïãÄ�ÂaÃ�¿[ÑÇÐ&zIÉ�ÀWÅw ÀlÊÌÊÒÀlÉkÊGÂaÑâÄ�ÊÒÔ�ÔlÊÒÀlÃ�ÍÏÀ�CÅ Âñt ÑâÃkÑqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿkÀ Š¥ìPÀlÊÌÄÒÀÁî =��ð7(��$4>B80{SÁ%/2 �8!C���+�M��� ï o-r À�skÉkÄÆÀÏÐÌĪ¿kÎ~Ã�Í�¿kÀ ÄÌÊÒÎ~ÉkÁïÀlÊÆ¿kÀÏÐÆÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#t�ÀÏÐÆúïÂaÊ�ÂaÃIÄÌÑÇÐ�Ð�ÂaÃIÄÉkà Ê�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄÆÅÇÀ�ìkÅâÉ�ÐÆìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�À¿kÀ p ÉkÃ�ÀÀlÊÌÊÒÀlÉkÊÅ Â2ìkÅâÉ�ÐÆìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�À¿kÀ ìPÎÐ�ÐÌÑqskÅÇÀ oVü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7�j�Æ: ÊÌÊÒÀlÉkÊÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑâÁÀø Î~ÑÇÀlÃIÄ

ΠÉkÃ%ì�ÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À�¿kÀ

NPOÀcÄAÉkà ÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#t�À¥ÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�Ô ìPÎ~ÉkÊ

Π Åw ÀlÊÌÊÒÀlÉkÊÆÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑâÁÀ�¿kÀ AÐÌÉkÊ ÉkÃ�À2ÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀI ÊÒÀÏÐÒìPÀlÍlÄÌÑâÁïÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄìPÎ~ÉkÊ Å Â�t�ÀÏÐÌÉkÊÒÀ ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÌÑTzIÉ�ÀWÀlÄ Å Â�t�ÀÏÐÌÉkÊÒÀW¿[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅâÅÇÀ ÀÏÐÌÄ¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔÏÀì�ÂaʪÅÇÀÏÐÆÊ�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÐ�

εAΠ(I) = 1− ρAΠ(I) =

{βΠ(I)− λA(I)

βΠ(I)

ÐÒÑoptΠ = max,

λA(I)− βΠ(I)

λA(I)

ÐÌÑâÃ�Î~à }

ÀlÄηAΠ (I) = 1− δ

AΠ (I) =

|λA(I)− βΠ(I)|

|ωΠ(I)− βΠ(I)|.

Î~ÉkÊÆÅÇÀÏÐÆ¿kÀlÉ-%ʲÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÐ Åw ÀlÊÌÊÒÀlÉkÊãÀÏÐÌĪÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐH2ÁÂaÅÇÀlÉkÊ¿�ÂaÃ�ЪÅw ÑâÃIÄÒÀlÊÌÁÂaÅâÅÇÀ [0, 1] o

ÁïÀÏÍ ÍÏÀÏÐÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#t�ÀÏÐXÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�ÔÏÐÀlĪÅw ÔlÁÂaÅâÉ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãó¿kÀ�ÅÇÀlÉkÊÆÍÏÎ$t ìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÀ(t�ÀlÃnÄãÐÌÉkÊÆ¿[ÑÓùÔlÊÒÀlÃnÄÒЪìkÊÒÎ6xskÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐãÎ~ÃIÄÆÃ�ÂaÄÌÉkÊÒÀlÅâÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄXÔ(t�ÀlÊÌúÔ*¿kÀÏÐÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀÏпiw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎNnÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎÃzïÉkÑ ÊÒÀlúÊÒÎ~ÉkìPÀlÃIÄãÅÇÀÏЪìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏпkÀ

NPOÐÒÀlÅÇÎ~Ã¥ÅÇÀlÉkÊ|¿kÀlúÊÒÔt¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂ6skÑâÅâÑâÄ�Ô~Í�w ÀÏÐÌÄ|ÍlÀÐzIÉ�À°Ã�Î~É�ÐqìkÊÒÎ~ìPÎÐÒÎ~Ã�пiw ÔlÁÎEzIÉ�ÀlÊPÆìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃIÄ o

¥º » o!¼

p(

�À¿?  ÁúÐÏ@¤=�=�0r).

r Â�{Â6t ÑâÅâÅÇÀ(Ar)0≤r�$������%Å0(4|I|ÀlÄ 0�4 1

1− r).

r Â{Â6t ÑâÅâÅÇÀ(Ar)0≤r

pN

Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7�j�¿: ø ÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀG~�ÃkÑÇÀ Ã�ÀãÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀH~�ÃkÑÇÀ

S = (U ;R)ÐÌÉkÊ�ÉkÃCÄËIìPÀXÐÌÑqt ÑâÅ ÂaÑâÊÒÀH~�ÃkÑ

S = (n1, ..., ni, ..., nk)ÀÏÐÌÄ�Å Â*¿kÎ~Ã�Ã�ÔÏÀ

¿iw ÉkÃ�ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ·~�ÃkÑUÂaìkìPÀlÅÇÔ�ÉkÃkÑâÁïÀlÊÒÐ*ÀlÄ*¿iw ÉkÃ�ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ

R = (r1, ..., ri, ..., rk)¿kÀ

kÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð

ÐÌÉkÊUÁïÔlÊÌÑ'~?ÂaÃIÄÆìPÎ~ÉkÊÆÄÒÎ~ÉkÄ

iri ⊆ Uni

oSÀÏÐÒÄÈzïÉ�ÂaÅâÑ'~�ÔÏÀ*¿kÀ

SxvÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀ�~�ÃkÑÇÀ o

ÈI�0(�!C%q0 n-oqp U ÃôúÊ�Âaìkä�ÀG(V,E)

ÀÏÐÌÄ ÉkÃ�À ÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀM~�ÃkÑÇÀ�ÐÌÉkÊ ÅÇÀWÄËnìPÀWÐÌÑqt ÑâÅ ÂaÑâÊÒÀ�~�ÃkÑS = (2) ¯ËIÂaÃIĪìPÎ~ÉkÊÆÉkÃkÑâÁïÀlÊÒÐÆÅw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ

VÀlĪìPÎ~ÉkÊÐ�ÀcÉ�ÅâÀ�ÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃóÅw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ

EÐÌÉkÊ

V 2o

Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7�j m MaxNP0 ÃóìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À

Π¿kÀ&te¶[Ñqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãô¿kÀ

NPÀÏÐÌÄã¿�ÂaÃ�ÐãÅ Â�ÍlÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀ

MaxNP0ÐNw ÑâÅqÀ�[ÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ*¿kÀlÉ- ÄËnìPÀÏÐ

ÐÌÑqt ÑâÅ ÂaÑâÊÒÀÏÐP~�ÃkÑÇÐIÀlÄS ÉkÃ�ÀÒÎ~Ê�t¥ÉkÅÇÀ φ ¿[É ìkÊÒÀ(t ÑÇÀlÊ Î~ÊÒ¿[ÊÒÀªÐ�ÂaÃ�ÐzIÉ�ÂaÃIÄÌÑ'~�ͯÂaÄÒÀlÉkÊtÀlÄ¿kÀlÉ-WÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÒÄ�ÂaÃIÄÒÀÏÐ

kÀlÄ` ÄÒÀlÅÇÐÈzIÉ�À ÅÇÀÏÐÆÎ~ìkÄÌÑqteÂ�¿kÀ Π ìPÀlÉkÁÀlÃIĵlÄÌÊÒÀÀ�[ìkÊÌÑqt�ÔÏÐÐÒÎ~É�ЪŠÂM«Î~Ê�t�À

βΠ(I) = maxS|{x ∈ Uk / ∃y ∈ U `, φ(I, S, x, y)}|

Î »IÀÏÐÌÄÆÉkÃ�À

IxvÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀG~�ÃkÑÇÀ¿iw ÉkÃkÑâÁïÀlÊÒÐ

UÀlÄSÉkÃ�ÀSxvÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀG~�ÃkÑÇÀ¿kÀGtÁµ(t�À�ÉkÃkÑâÁïÀcÊ�Ð

Uo

r ÂeÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀI¿kÔÏÍlÊÌÑâÄãÅÇÀÏÐãÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀÏÐX¿[Éì�ÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À

Π Å ÂeÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀ S ÅÇÀlÐXÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð ÐÌÉkÊ I Å ÂÎ~Ê�t¥ÉkÅÇÀφÅÇÀÏÐÆÍÏÎ~Ã�¿[ÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ðã¿kÀ�ÊÒÔ¯ÂaÅâÑÇÐ�Â6skÑâÅâÑâÄÒÔ*¿kÀÏÐÆÐ�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�п[ÉVìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À o

ÈI�0(�!C%q0 n-o}n UMaxSat

Ã�ÀôÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀI = (X,C)

¿[É.ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀMaxSat

ÀÏÐÌÄVÅ Âx¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔÏÀB¿iw Ékà ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3s�ÅâÀX =

{x1, x2, ..., xn}¿kÀ%ÁÂaÊÌÑ Â6skÅÇÀÏÐÁskÑâÃ�ÂaÑâÊÒÀÏÐeÀlÄe¿iw ÉkÃTÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ

C = {c1, c2, ..., cm}¿kÀ ÍlÅ ÂaÉ�ÐÒÀÏÐe¿[ÑÇÐyx

�ÌÎ~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑâÁÀÏÐXÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄÌÊÌÉkÑâÄÒÀÏÐXÐÌÉkÊãÅw ÀlÃ�Ð�À(t3skÅÇÀL = {x1, x2, ..., xn} ∪ {x̄1, x̄2, ..., x̄n}

¿kÀÏÐÅâÑâÄÌÄÒÔlÊ�ÂaÉ- o> Ã�ÀÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃeÀÏÐÌÄÉkÃ�ÀÂhùÀÏÍlÄ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

T¿kÀÏÐÁ~ÂaÊÌÑ Â6skÅÇÀÏÐ

xi Î~É� p ÀlÄÅÇÀ�ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ ¿kÔlÄÒÀlÊ�t ÑâÃ�ÀlÊ

ÉkÃ�À�ÄÒÀlÅâÅÇÀ*Âhù�ÀÏÍlÄ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã:zIÉkÑ Ð�ÂaÄÌÑÇÐ�Â~ÐÒÐ�ÀXÉkÃVÃ�Î$t3s�ÊÒÀGte¶[Ñqt¥É#t'¿kÀÍlÅ ÂaÉ�ÐÒÀÏÐ�

βΠ(I) = maxT∈{0,1}n

|{i = 1, ...,m / TÁÂaÅâÑÇ¿kÀ

ci}|.

ÐÒÐÒÎIÍlÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð ÂaÉ-�ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀÏÐXÀlÄ

CÅÇÀÏÐWÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀÏÐ ¿kÀOÁÂaÊÌÑ Â6skÅÇÀlÐ

UXÀlÄ

UCÀlÄWÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÒÑÇ¿kÔlÊÒÎ~Ã�Ð

Åw ÉkÃkÑâÁïÀlÊÒÐ"~�ÃkÑU = UX ∪ UC

o Ç Î~ÉkÄÒÀ�ÑâÃ�ÐÒÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀIìPÀlÉkĵlÄÌÊÒÀ¿kÔÏÍlÊÌÑâÄÒÀ*¿kÀ�{Â$¼lÎ~ÃóÐÒËIÃIÄÌä�ÔlÄÌÑTzIÉ�À�ì�ÂaÊÆÅÇÀÏÐ

ÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐGskÑâÃ�ÂaÑâÊÒÀÏÐpÀlÄnÐÌÉkÊ

UX × UC¿kÔ�~�Ã�ÑâÀÏÐ�ì�ÂaÊ

“p(x, c) ⇔ x ∈ c”ÀlÄ

“n(x, c) ⇔ x̄ ∈ c”zIÉkÑPÄÌÊ�Â~¿[ÉkÑÇÐÒÀlÃIÄ�Å Â*ìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃ�ÍÏÀ ¿kÀÏÐ�ÅâÑÓÄÒÄÒÔlÊ�ÂaÉ-C¿�ÂaÃ�Ð�ÅÇÀlЪÍlÅÇÂaÉ�ÐÒÀÏÐ�ò�zIÉ�ÂaÃIĪÂaÉ-CÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐT ÀlÅâÅÇÀãÃ�À ÐÒÎ~ÃIÄÊÌÑÇÀlÃ0¿kÀ2ìkÅâÉ�Ð�zIÉ�w ÉkÃ�À2ÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã0ÉkÃ�ÂaÑâÊÒÀWÐÒÉkÊ

UXo; ÑâÃ�ÐÌÑ ìPÎ~ÉkÊ ÅÇÀÏÐXÄËnìPÀÏÐ ÐÌÑqt ÑâÅ ÂaÑâÊÒÀÏÐõ~�ÃkÑÇÐ I = (2, 2)ÀlÄ

S = (1) ÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÎ~ìkÄÌÑqt¥É#t ¿kÀ MaxSat ìPÀlÉkÄÐNw ÔÏÍlÊÌÑâÊÒÀ*¿kÀ Å ÂMÂ$¼ÏÎ~ÃóÐÌÉkÑâÁÂaÃIÄÒÀ

β(U ; p, n) = maxT|{c ∈ U / ∃x ∈ U, (p(x, c) ∧ T (x)) ∨ (n(x, c) ∧ ¬T (x))}|.

ÿ 0��Á�$��.(� 0 n-oqp U Ç ÀlÅâÅÇÀGzIÉ�w ÀlÅâÅÇÀ�ÀÏÐÌĪ¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑÇÀ Å ÂWÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀ MaxNP0 ÊÒÀlúÊÒÎ~ÉkìPÀ�Ã�ÂaÄÌÉ�ÊÒÀlÅÓÅÇÀ(t�ÀÏÃIÄã¿kÀÏÐ�ìkÊÒÎ6xskÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐÆìPÎ~ÅâËnÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄHsPÎ~ÊÌÃ�ÔÏпkÀNPO

MaxNP0 ⊆ NPO − PB.

pN

� ª  MaxSNP0Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7�j ¾

MaxSNP0 Ã¥ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀΠ¿kÀÐte¶nÑqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�¿kÀ

NPOÀÏÐÌÄ|¿�ÂaÃ�ÐqÅ ÂãÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐ�À

MaxSNP0ÐNw ÑâÅ[À�nÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ�¿kÀlÉ-*ÄËnìPÀÏÐ

ÐÌÑqt ÑâÅ ÂaÑâÊÒÀÏÐ"~�ÃkÑÇÐIÀlÄS ÉkÃ�ÀõÎ~Ê�t¥ÉkÅÇÀ φ ¿[É ìkÊÒÀ(t ÑÇÀlÊÎ~ÊÒ¿[ÊÒÀвÂaÃ�Ð"zIÉ�ÂaÃIÄÌÑ'~�ͯÂaÄÒÀlÉkÊãÀlÄÆÉkÃ�À�ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃnÄÒÀ

k Ä�ÀcÅÇÐzIÉ�À ÅÇÀÏÐÆÎ~ìkÄÌÑqteÂ�¿kÀ Π ìPÀlÉkÁïÀlÃIĵlÄÌÊÒÀÀ�[ìkÊÌÑqt�ÔÏÐÐÒÎ~É�ЪŠÂM«Î~Ê�t�À

βΠ(I) = maxS|{x ∈ Uk / φ(I, S, x)}|

Î »IÀlÄSÐÒÎ~ÃIÄÆÊÒÀÏÐÌìPÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄãÉkÃ�À

IÀlÄÆÉkÃ�À

SxvÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀÏÐ"~�ÃkÑÇÀÏпiw ÉkÃkÑâÁïÀlÊÒÐ

Uo

ÈI�0(�!C%q0 n-o} UMax IS −B

r À ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀMax IS−B

ÀÏÐÌÄ|Å ÂÆÊÒÀÏÐÌÄÌÊÌÑÇÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à ¿[É¥ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À�¿kÀ�ÐÌÄ�Â6skÅÇÀÐte¶nÑqt¥É#t ¿kÀÏÐqúÊ�Âaìkä�ÀÏпkÀ%¿kÀlúÊÒÔ�sPÎ~ÊÌÃ�Ô%ì�ÂaÊ

B Í�w ÀÏÐÒÄyx¹¶xv¿[ÑâÊÒÀózIÉ�ÀCÄÒÎ~ÉkÄ ÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄeÂaÉkÊ�Â0ÂaÉxìkÅâÉ�Ð B ÁïÎ~ÑÇÐÌÑâÃ�Ð o á ÂaÃ�ÐWÅÇÀ%ͯÂ~ÐúÔlÃ�ÔlÊ�ÂaÅ ¿kÔÏÍlÊÌÑâÁ~ÂaÃIÄ°ÉkÃWúÊ�Âaìkä�À G ì�ÂaÊÐ�Î~à ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀª¿iw ÂaÊ/µlÄÒÀÏÐ Å ÂãìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÆ¿kÀªÐÌÄ�Â6skÑâÅâÑâÄÒÔRte¶[Ñqt¥É#tìPÀlÉkÄÐNw ÔÏÍlÊÌÑâÊÒÀ

β(V ;E) = maxW⊆V

|{w ∈ V / W (w) ∧ (∀v ∈ V, E(v, w)⇒ ¬W (v))}|

Î »V¿kÔÏÐÌÑâúÃ�ÀÆÅw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀã¿kÀÏÐtÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐt¿kÀ

Go�´ ÀlÄÌÄÒÀ"Î~Ê�t¥ÉkÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÂaÑÇвÂaÃIÄ°ÑâÃIÄÒÀlÊÌÁïÀlÃkÑâÊ ÉkÃ�zIÉ�ÂaÃIÄÌÑ'~#x

ͯÂaÄÒÀlÉkÊ°¿�ÂaÃ�ÐÅÇÀ�ìkÊÒÔÏ¿[ÑÇͯÂaÄ ÀlÅâÅÇÀ�Ã�À�ìPÀlÊ�t�ÀlÄì�Â~пiw ÔlÄ�Â6skÅâÑâÊ°Åw Âaìkì�ÂaÊÌÄÒÀlÃ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ¿kÀ Max IS MaxSNP ÀlÄ�¿iw ÂaÑâÅâÅÇÀlÉkÊÒÐ�ÅÇÀãìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À�¿kÀXÐÌÄ�Â6skÑâÅâÑâÄÒÔõte¶[Ñqt¥É#tJÃ�w Âaìkì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑÇÀlÃIÄ"tÁµ(t�ÀXì�Â~Ð"*Š¥ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀMaxNP

o ÃÊÒÀlÁ~ÂaÃ�Í�ä�À ¿�ÂaÃ�ÐÅÇÀ*ͯÂ~Ðã¿kÀ*¿kÀlúÊÒÔÏÐHsPÎ~ÊÌÃ�ÔÏÐì?ÂaÊ B ÑâÅq¿kÀlÁIÑÇÀlÃIÄãìPÎÐÒÐÌÑqskÅÇÀ*¿iw Î$s�Ð�ÀlÊÌÁÀlÊ G Ã�Î~ÃóìkÅâÉ�Ðì�ÂaÊtÐÒÎ~ÃOÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀã¿iw ÂaÊ/µlÄÒÀÏÐ teÂaÑâÐtì�ÂaÊ Åw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀã¿kÀÏаÅâÑÇÐÒÄÒÀÏÐ ¿iw Â~¿6�ÒÂ~ÍÏÀlÃ�ÍÏÀã¿kÀÐÒÀÏÐ ÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐÅïÐÒÎ~ÑâÄ ÅÇÀÄËnìPÀ�ÐÒÑqt ÑÓÅ ÂaÑâÊÒÀG~�ÃkÑ

I = (B + 1) Ékà úÊ�Âaìkä�À G Ã�w ÀÏÐÌÄãÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀ&zIÉ�À�Å ÂW¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔlÀ*¿iw ÉkÃÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ V ¿kÀÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐMîÅw ÉkÃkÑâÁÀlÊÒÐ�ï�ÀlÄã¿iw ÉkÃ�ÀÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃΓ : V B+1 → {0, 1}

î«ÐÒÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀG~�ÃkÑÇÀ*¿iw ÉkÃkÑâÁÀlÊÒÐVÐÌÉkÊIï

¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑÇÀªì�ÂaÊΓ(w, v1, ..., vB) = 1

ÐÌÑ�ÀlÄÐ�ÀlÉkÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ°ÐÒÑ{v1, ..., vB}

ÀÏÐÌÄskÑÇÀlà Åw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀÆ¿kÀÏаÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐÂ~¿6�ÒÂ~ÍÏÀlÃIÄÒÐÆÂaÉ ÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄ

wî«ÐÌÑ

vÂ3t�Î~ÑâÃ�ÐÆ¿kÀ

BÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐ Î~ÃV¿[ÉkìkÅâÑTzIÉ�À Åw Ékà ¿kÀ ÐÒÀÏÐ�ÁïÎ~ÑÇÐÌÑâÃ�Ð8ï o- ÅÇÎ~ÊÒÐÅÇÀ�ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À*ÐNw ÔÏÍlÊÌÑâÄ�

β(V ; Γ) = maxW|{(w, v1, ..., vB) ∈ V

B+1 / W (w) ∧ (¬W (v1) ∧ ... ... ∧ ¬W (vB))}|

Î »WÀÏÐÒÄeÉkÃKÐÒÎ~É�Ð�xvÀcÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ¿kÀóÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐúî

SxvÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍcÄÒÉkÊÒÀ~�ÃkÑÇÀ¿iw ÉkÃkÑâÁïÀlÊÒÐ

VìPÎ~ÉkÊOÅÇÀ ÄËnìPÀó~�ÃkÑ

S É î p ï�ï o á ÀXÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÒÀ�ÐÒÎ~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~à W Î~ÃV¿kÔÏ¿[ÉkÑâĪÅÇÀ ÐÒÎ~É�Ð�xvÀcÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ ÐÒÄ�Â6skÅÇÀ W ′ ⊆W ¿kÀÏЪÐÒÎ$t·t�ÀlÄÒÐ w ¿kÀW

zIÉkÑ�ÁïÔlÊÌÑ'~�ÀlÃIÄã¯ÁïÀÏÍ ÅÇÀlÉkÊÆÅâÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ¿iw Â~¿6�ÌÂ~ÍÏÀlÃ�ÍÏÀÅ ÂM«Î~Ê�t¥ÉkÅÇÀφÂ~ÐÒÐÒÎIÍlÑÇÔÏÀ

W (w) ∧ (¬W (v1) ∧ ... ... ∧ ¬W (vB)) ,

pËu

pN

r ÀÏÐ%ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀÏÐ�zIÉ�ÀÃ�Î~É�Ð%ÁÀlÃ�Î~Ã�ÐV¿iw ÔlÁÎEzIÉ�ÀlÊVÐÒÎ~ÃIÄ%À�kÍlÅâÉ�ÐÌÑâÁïÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄV¿kÔÏ¿[ÑÇÔÏÀÏÐ ÂaÉ-KìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ ¿kÀte¶[Ñqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à teÂaÑÇÐ ÅÇÀlÐ ¿kÔ�~�Ã�ÑÓÄÒÑâÎ~Ã�ÐtÔLzIÉkÑâÁ~ÂaÅÇÀlÃIÄÒÀÏÐtÀ�nÑÇÐÒÄÒÀlÃIÄ°Ã�ÂaÄÌÉkÊÒÀlÅâÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄtìPÎ~ÉkÊ ÅÇÀÏаìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ�¿kÀt ÑâÃkÑqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à ÀlÄÐtÁµ(t�ÀìkÅâÉ�Ð�ïÑâÅPÀ�nÑÇÐÌÄÒÀÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÒÀÉkÃ�ÀäkÑÇÔlÊ�ÂaÊÒÍ�äkÑÇÀ ¿kÀãÍcÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀÏÐ ÅÇÎ~úÑTzIÉ�ÀÏÐ�ÀlÃÁÎ~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃC¿kÉÃ�Î$t3skÊÒÀ¥¿kÀ{zIÉ�ÂaÃIÄÌÑ'~�ͯÂaÄÒÀlÉkÊÒÐX¿kÀlÁÂaÃIÄÅ Â�Î~Ê�t¥ÉkÅÇÀ*¿[ÉóìkÊÒÀ(t ÑÇÀlÊXÎ~ÊÒ¿[ÊÒÀ

φÀlÄÅw ÂaÅâÄÒÀlÊÌÃ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ2¿kÀ*ÍÏÀlÉ-�xvÍlÑ@ò

ÍÏÀÏÐX¿[ÑÓùÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄ�ÀlÐ ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀÏÐ ÅÇÀlÉkÊÒÐãÅâÑÇÀlÃ�ÐXÀlÄãÅÇÀlÉkÊ�ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[Ñ'teÂaÄÒÑâÎ~Ã0ÐÒÎ~ÃnÄÃ�Î~Ä�Â6t·t�ÀlÃIÄ�ÔlÄÌÉ�¿[ÑÇÔÏÀÏÐ ¿�ÂaÃ�Ð c �idÀlÄ c 6�d9o� ª © ÌȤ�ÙØ¥P¦¨ÍÎÍ#A ;Ï�¤

pN

ÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ¿kÀMax 3− Sat

o-á ÅÇÐÒ«Î~ÃIÄÆÔlúïÂaÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄÆÅ Â2ìkÊÒÀlÉkÁÀ�¿kÀ Å ÂWÍÏÎ$t ìkÅÇÔlÄÌÉ�¿kÀ¿iw ÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀÏÐÆìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐÄÒÀlÅÇÐ

Max IS − BîìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À2¿[ÉÐÒÄ�Â6skÅÇÀ3�¿kÀlúÊÒÔ{sPÎ~ÊÌÃ�ÔËï MaxCut îìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À2¿kÀ*ÍÏÎ~ÉkìPÀ{te¶[Ñ'xt¥É#t�¿�ÂaÃ�ÐÉkÃ�úÊ�Âaìkä�ÀËïÎ~ÉeÀlÃ�ÍÏÎ~ÊÒÀ

Max 2−Sat ì�ÂaÊÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃOÐÒÑqt ìkÅÇÀÈ ì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑâÊ ¿kÀ Max 3−Sat oá ÀlìkÉkÑÇÐ ¿�ÂaÃ�Ð c �id ÅÇÀÏÐÆÔlúïÂaÅâÑâÄÒÔÏÐÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅâÑÇÐÒÄÒÀÏÐMaxSNP0

E= APX − PB

ÀlÄMaxSNP0

P= APX

Î~ÃIÄ%ÔlÄÒÔÔlÄ�Â6skÅâÑÇÀÏÐYîÉkÄÌÑâÅâÑÇÐ�ÂaÃIÄCÃ�Î~Ä�Â6t·t�ÀlÃIÄVÅâÀÊÒÔÏÐÌÉkÅâÄ�ÂaÄAPX − PB

P= APX

¿kÀ ´ ÊÒÀÏÐÒÍÏÀlÃ#öÏÑ ÀlÄÇ ÊÒÀlÁnÑÇÐ�Âaà c n�id ïC~ÍÏÀlÅ ÂãÃ�Î~É�Ð ÂaìkìkÊÒÀlÃ�¿ ÀlÃIÄÌÊÒÀÆÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀ zïÉ�w ÑâÅkÀ�[ÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ�ÉkÃ�À P x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãe¿kÀ�Ä�Î~ÉkÄìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂ6skÅÇÀ32Ê�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄãÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄõ2Ékà ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À*¿kÀ Å Â ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀ

MaxSNP0o

´ Î~Ã�ÍÏÀlÊÌÃ�ÂaÃIÄMaxNP

ÀlÄ ÐÒÎ~ÃeÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂ6skÑâÅâÑâÄÒÔ Î~Ã�ìPÀlÉkÄ ÍlÑâÄÒÀlÊ°Åw ÑâÃ�ÍlÅâÉ�ÐÌÑÇÎ~ÃO¿kÀ MaxNP0 ¿�ÂaÃ�ÐAPX {ÂaÑâÄW¿kÔ(t�Î~ÃIÄÌÊÒÔV¿�ÂhÃ�Ð c u¶�d ì�ÂaÊWÅÇÀñskÑ ÂaÑÇÐ ¿kÀÏÐ�tÁµ(t�ÀÏÐ�ÂaÊÌúÉ#t�ÀlÃIÄÒÐÁzïÉ�ÀOìPÎ~ÉkÊWÅw ÑâÃ�ÍlÅâÉ�ÐÌÑÇÎ~à ¿kÀMaxSNP0

¿�ÂaÃ�ÐAPX

ò?¿[ÉìPÎ~ÑâÃIÄX¿kÀ*ÁnÉ�À*¿kÀ*Å ÂeÍÏÎ$t ìkÅÇÔlÄÌÉ�¿kÀ ÅÇÀÏÐXÂaÉkÄÒÀlÉkÊÒÐXÃ�À*ì�ÂaÊÌÁIÑÇÀlÃkÃ�ÀlÃIÄXì�Â~ÐeÉkÃ

n�

º Ê þãÎ~Å ÂaÑâÄÌÑÇЪÀlÄ Ç ä�Âi�nÉkÊRt�Î~ÃIÄÌÊÒÀlÃIÄÆ¿�ÂaÃ�Ð c �id zIÉ�À Min 3−CCSP ÀÏÐÌÄ MinΣ0 xvÍÏÎ$t ìkÅÇÀlĪìPÎ~ÉkÊ�Å ÂPx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã:î«ÍÏÎ$t·t�À

Max 3−SatìPÎ~ÉkÊ

MaxΣ0ï teÂaÑÇÐÃ�Î~à ÂaìkìkÊ�ÎNnÑqteÂ6skÅÇÀÈÊ�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄ°ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄîÄ�ÂaÃ�¿[ÑÇÐ&zIÉ�À

Max 3 − SatÀÏÐÒÄ&CÍÏÀH�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[Ñqt�ÔÁ

1/1.249 ≥ 0, 8 c 0d ïCò�ÀlÃút�Î~ÃIÄÌÊ�ÂaÃIÄ*¿�ÂaÃ�Ðc -pd Å Â NPO − PB xvÍÏÎ$t ìkÅÇÔlÄÌÉ�¿kÀW¿kÀ Min 3 − CCSP ÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑâÁïÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ�ÂaÉ- E x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð þ Å ÂaÉ�Í��{ÂaÑâĪŠÂ2ìkÊÒÀlÉkÁïÀ¿kÀ�Åw ÑâÃ�ÍlÅâÉ�ÐÌÑÇÎ~ÿkÀ ÄÒÎ~ÉkÄ

NPO − PB¿�ÂaÃ�Ð

MinΣ0P o

@Î Ï mÐoy4r ÑkRoÒ8>_�69 # ro� Ó! Ú ÌÈÍ?Ï�@¥#9"ÍéÔÍÎÏ ¢ ÔЦ¥�@9¤¤á ÂaÃ�Ð|ÉkÃ�À�ÁÎ~ÅÇÎ~ÃIÄÒÔ�¿iw ÉkÃkÑ'~�ͯÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�¿kÀÏÐ|ÄÌʲ¯Á~ÂaÉ-¥ìkÊÒÎ~ìPÎÐÒÔÏаÂaÉWÐÌÉ$�ÌÀlÄ|¿kÀÏÐ|ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�аÀlÄ¿iw ä�Î$t�Î~úÔ�x

Ã�ÔlÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãó¿kÀÏЪÃ�Î~Ä�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð Ã�Î~É�ЪÉkÄÌÑâÅâÑÇÐÒÀlÊÒÎ~Ã�Ъì�ÂaÊyÎ~ÑÇÐÆ¿kÀÏЪÐÒÑâúÅÇÀÏÐ�Ã�Î~à ÍÏÎ~ÃIÁïÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃkÃ�ÀlÅÇÐÆìPÎ~ÉkÊ¿kÔÏÐÌÑâúÃ�ÀlÊÅÇÀÏÐ�ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð�ò Ã�Î~É�Ð�Ã�w ¯ÁïÎ~Ã�ÐÍÏÀlìPÀlÃ�¿�ÂaÃIÄ*ì�Â~Ð�Åw Â6t3skÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�¿kÀWìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃIÄÒÀlÊ{zIÉ�ÀlÅTzïÉ�À Í�ä�ÎÐ�À ¿kÀWÃ�Î~É-xÁïÀ¯ÂaÉ oNr ÀìkÊÒÑÓÃ�ÍcÑâìPÀt¿kÀ°ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã2¿iw ÉkÃ*ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À

Π�ÉkÃ*ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À

Π′ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÑÇÐÌÄÒÀÐ�ÊÒÀlúïÂaÊÒ¿kÀlÊ t�ÎI¿[ÉkÅÇÎÉkÃ�À ìPÀlÄÌÑâÄÒÀ ÄÌÊ�ÂaÃ�ÐyÎ~Ê�teÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à ÅÇÀXìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À Π ÍÏÎ$t·t�À Ékà ͯÂ~Ð�ì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑÇÍlÉkÅâÑÇÀlÊ¿kÀ Π′ o ø Ñ�Š¥ÄÌÊ�ÂaÃ�ÐyÎ~Ê�te¶xÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÀÏÐÌÄ*ìPÎ~ÅâËIÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅÇÀCÀlÄ{zIÉ�À Åw Î~îÐ�ÂaÑâÄÊÒÔÏÐ�Î~É�¿[ÊÒÀeÎ~É®ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[Ñqt�ÀlÊ

Π′ÀlÃRÄ�À�t ì�Ð*ìPÎ~ÅâËIÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅ Î~ÃÐ�ÂaÉkÊ�ÂVÂaÅÇÎ~ÊÒÐÊÒÔÏÐÒÎ~É�¿[ÊÒÀ�Î~ÉBÂaìkìkÊÒÎIÍ�ä�ÀlÊ

Π%ÐÒÎ~Ã0ÄÒÎ~ÉkÊ ÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐÀlÃ0ÄÒÀ(t ì�ÐìPÎ~ÅâËIÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅ oÅr Â%ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�Í�xÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃóÀÏÐÌÄÂaÑâÃ�ÐÌÑ ÉkÃót�ÎêËïÀlÃó¿kÀ ÄÌÊ�ÂaÃ�ÐÒìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÀlÊÆÉkà ÊÒÔÏÐÌÉkÅâÄ�ÂaÄ¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

n-p

R = (f, g)¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑ ì�ÂaÊÅ

f : IΠ → IΠ′ , g : SolΠ′(f(IΠ)) → SolΠ,

I 7→ I ′ s′ ∈ SolΠ′(f(I)) 7→ s ∈ SolΠ(I)

ÀlĪìPÎ~ÉkʪÅÇÀLzïÉ�ÀlÅ�ÑâÅ À�nÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ�¿kÀlÉ-CìPÎ~ÅâËIà ü$t�ÀpfÀlÄpg

zIÉkÑÁïÔlÊÌÑ'~�ÀlÃIĪìPÎ~ÉkʪÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÒÀ ÑâÃ�ÐÒÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀI¿kÀ

IΠÅÇÀÏÐ

ìkÊÒÎ~ìkÊÌÑÇÔlÄÒÔÏÐ�

(i) f(I)ÐÒÀ�ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄÌÊÌÉkÑâÄÀlà ÄÒÀ(t ì�Ð

pf (|I|)

(ii) ∀s′ ∈ SolΠ′(f(I)), g(s′)ÐÒÀ�ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÒÄÌÊÌÉkÑâÄÀlà ÄÒÀ(t ì�Ð

pg(|f(I)|).

� Î~ÄÒÎ~Ã�Ð�ì�ÂaʪÐÒÎ~É�ÍlÑÇЪ¿iw À�nä�ÂaÉ�ÐÌÄÌÑâÁnÑâÄÒÔ�zIÉ�ÀXÍÏÀlÄÌÄÒÀ ¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃVÊÒÀÏÐÌÄÒÀãÁÂaÅâÑÇ¿kÀXìPÎ~ÉkÊ�ÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÒÀ À�nÑâúÀlÃ�ÍÏÀ�¿kÀÍÏÎ$t ìkÅÇÀ�[ÑâÄÒÔ�îÅ ÂaÃkúïÂaúÀÏÐã¿kÔÏÍlÑÇ¿�Â6skÅÇÀÏÐ ÂaÅâúÎ~ÊÌÑâÄÌä#t�ÀÏÐì�Ð�ÀlÉ�¿kÎ6x{ìPÎ~ÅâËIÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÉ# oqoqo ï o Ã�À�ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ìPÀlÊ�t�ÀlÄ2¿kÎ~Ã�ÍO¿kÀe¿kÔlÄÒÀlÊ�t ÑâÃ�ÀlÊ·%Åw ÂaÑÇ¿kÀO¿kÀ�Å Â�«Î~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

g¿kÀÏÐ*Ð�Î~ÅÓÉ�ÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð*ìPÎ~ÉkÊ

ICì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑâÊ¿kÀWÐ�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÐÌÉkÊ

f(I)o ø ÀlÅÇÎ~ÃRÅ�w ÀÏÐÒì�Â~ÍÏÀ ¿kÀ2ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ*¿�ÂaÃ�Ð�ÅÇÀLzïÉ�ÀlÅ°Î~Ã0Ð�À2ÐÒÑâÄÌÉ�ÀWÀlÄ�ÅÇÀlÐ

ÃkÑâÁïÀ¯ÂaÉ-O¿kÀÊÒÔÏÐ�Î~ÅâÉkÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�zIÉ�ÀÅw Î~ÃCÁïÀlÉkÄtìPÎ~ÉkÁïÎ~ÑâÊ�ÄÌÊ�ÂaÃ�ÐÌìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÀlʪ¿iw ÉkÃCìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀGÉkÃVÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀ ÍÏÀcÊÒÄ�ÂaÑâÃ�ÀÏÐìkÊÒÎ~ìkÊÌÑÇÔlÄÒÔÏÐ�Ð�ÀlÊÒÎ~ÃIÄ ÊÒÔÏÍlÅ Â6t�ÔÏÀÏÐ�ÂaÉOÍÏÎ~ÉkìkÅÇÀã¿kÀÈ«Î~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð(f, g)

o á ÂaÃ�Ð Åw ÀÏÐÒì�Â~ÍÏÀNPO

¿kÀÏÐ ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏпiw Î~ìkÄÌÑqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à Î~à ¿kÎ~ÑâÄìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÊÌÁïÀlÊÅw Î~ìkÄÌÑqteÂaÅâÑâÄÒÔÆÎ~É�¿[É�t�Î~ÑâÃ�ÐÉkà ÍÏÀlÊÌÄ�ÂaÑâÃ�ÃkÑâÁÀ¯ÂaÉ�¿kÀ�ìPÀlÊyÎ~Ê�teÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ o Î~ÉkÊ Å Â�öêÛ«þBÖ�ÚÛö¯ü ~�Ãx¿iw ÔlÁIÑâÄÒÀlÊ ¿iw ¯ÁïÎ~ÑâÊ·óìkÊÒÔÏÍlÑÇÐÒÀlÊWÅÇÀÏÐWÐÒÀlÃ�Ð2¿�w Î~ì�ÄÌÑqt ÑâвÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à ¿kÀÏÐ2ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ�teÂaÃkÑâìkÉkÅÇÔÏÐ Ã�Î~É�ÐÉkÄÌÑâÅâÑÇÐÒÀlÊÒÎ~Ã�ÐWì�ÂaÊWÅ Â

n�n

á Å[À�nÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ�¿[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÒÀÏÐÞ{Â$¼ÏÎ~Ã�пkÀ�ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄÌÊÒÉkÑâÊÒÀ�ÉkÃ�À�ÄÒÀlÅÓÅÇÀ�ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÀlÄÃ�Î~Ä�Â6t·t�ÀlÃIÄ°ÍÏÀlÅâÅÇÀ�ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÑÇÐÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄ2Ñqt ìPÎÐ�ÀlÊH2Å ÂWÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

R¿iw µlÄÌÊÒÀ32Å ÂM«Î~ÑÇÐ"t�Î~Ã�Î~ÄÒÎ~Ã�À¥ÀlÄÆÐÌÉkÊ��ÌÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁÀ o

Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7ðl���87L0���560(�{%q��5¶�$%T0����{�/0�%q�����+560M=�0�7�7L�$%)�������$4#7 Ã�À ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

R = (f, g)ÀÏÐÌÄÈt�Î~Ã�Î~ÄÒÎ~Ã�À*ÐÌÑ ÀlÅâÅÇÀ�ÁÔlÊÌÑ'~�À∀I ∈ IΠ, ∀(s′1, s

′2) ∈ SolΠ′(f(I)),

vΠ′(f(I), s′1) º vΠ′(f(I), s

′2)⇒ vΠ(I, g(s

′1)) º vΠ(I, g(s

′2)).

ÿ 0��Á�$��.(� 0 n-o}n U�ø Ñ R ÀlÐÒÄ"t�Î~Ã�Î~ÄÒÎ~Ã�À¥ÂaÅÇÎ~ÊÒÐs′∗ ��!C���K����� 78���

SolΠ′(f(I)) ⇒ g(s′∗)

�8!C���+���E� 78�E�g(SolΠ′(f(I))).Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7ðl «: ë ÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃÐÌÉkÊ���ÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁïÀ !#�$���3B��$�E5Ë�8�+�{%q087G7(��% �-������4#7{=�0{%�2 �K4#7(��$4>B803=�03=E�9!#�$���

Ã�À ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃR = (f, g)

ÀÏÐÌÄÐÌÉkÊ���ÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁïÀ�ÐÌÑ ÀlÅâÅÇÀ�ÁïÔlÊÌÑ'~�À∀I ∈ IΠ, SolΠ(I) = g(SolΠ′(f(I))).

ÿ 0��Á�$��.(� 0 n-o} U�ø Ñ R ÀlÐÒÄ"t�Î~Ã�Î~ÄÒÎ~Ã�À*ÀlÄÐÌÉkÊ���ÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁïÀÂaÅÇÎ~ÊÒÐs′?Î~ìkÄÌÑqt¥É#t ¿kÀ

f(I) ⇒ g(s′?)Î~ìkÄÌÑqt¥É#t ¿kÀ

I.

ÑâÃ�ÐÌÑ Ã�Î~É�ÐìPÎ~ÉkÁïÎ~Ã�Ð ¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑâÊ ÉkÃ�À PO x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃOì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑÇÍlÉkÅâÑÇålÊÒÀͯÂaÊ�Â~ÍlÄÒÔlÊÌÑÇÐ�ÔÏÀÆì�ÂaÊ ¿kÀlÉ-WìkÊÒÎ~ìkÊÌÑÇÔ�xÄÒÔÏÐR{Â~ÍlÑâÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄÑÇ¿kÀlÃIÄÌÑ'~?Â6skÅÇÀÏÐ�Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7ðl#¯¤

MSx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

ø Î~ÑÇÀlÃIÄΠÀlÄ

Π′¿�ÀcÉ# ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐt¿kÀ

NPO Î~Ãe¿[ÑâÄÐzIÉ�À Π ÐÒÀ MS x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[ÉkÑâÄR Π′ ÀlÄtÎ~Ã�Ã�Î~ÄÒÀ ΠMS∝ Π′ÐNw ÑâÅ À�[ÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ ÉkÃ�À�ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃR = (f, g)

¿kÀΠΠ′

zïÉkÑ ÁÔlÊÌÑ'~�À(i) R

t�Î~Ã�Î~ÄÒÎ~Ã�À(ii) R

ÐÌÉkÊ���ÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁïÀ.

Ýçaà

n�

º Ã

n6

ÿ 0��Á�$��.(� 0 n-o} U ÅÇÀ%ͯÂ~Ð R1 = R2 = ρ ÊÒÀlÁIÑÇÀlÃIÄ�Å Âô¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃTìkÊÒÔÏÍÏÔÏ¿kÀlÃIÄÒÀ Î~ÊÌÑâúÑâÃ�ÀlÅâÅÇÀ ¿kÀ%Å ÂAx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à o ÃÎ{ÂaÑÇÐ�ÂaÃIÄWÁ~ÂaÊÌÑÇÀlÊ ÅÇÀlÐ ÍÏÎ~Ã�¿[ÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐeÐÌÉkÊWÅÇÀÏÐM«Î~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð

f g ÀlÄ c Î~Ãxì�ÂaÊÒÍÏÎ~ÉkÊÌÄ�Åw ÀÏÐÒÐÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅÆ¿kÀÏÐÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÆÉkÄÌÑâÅâÑÇÐ�ÔÏÀÏÐÆÀlÃóÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃóìPÎ~ÅâËIÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅÇÀ oC´ Î$t·t�Àlà ¼ÏÎ~Ã�Ðì�ÂaÊÆÅÇÂPx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à ÔlúïÂaÅÇÀ�xt�ÀlÃIÄ¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑÇÀ*¿�ÂaÃ�Ð c u$nid ÀlÄÈzIÉkÑ�ìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÊÌÁïÀ ÅÇÀÏÐÐÒÍ�ä�Ô(teÂ~пiw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎNnÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎà oVü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7ðl m

Px{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

ø Î~ÑÇÀlÃIÄΠÀlÄ

Π′¿kÀlÉ-ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ|¿kÀ

NPO Î~Ã¥¿[ÑâÄØzIÉ�À Π ÐÒÀ P x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[ÉkÑâÄP Π′ ÀlÄ|Î~Ã*Ã�Î~ÄÒÀ Π P [R1,R2]∝ Π′ÐNw ÑâÅÀ�[ÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ�ÉkÃ�ÀÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃR = (f, g)

ÀlÄÉkÃ�ÀG«Î~Ã�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãc : [0, 1]→ [0, 1]

zIÉkÑ ÁïÔlÊÌÑ'~�ÀlÃIÄìPÎ~ÉkÊã¿kÀlÉ-t�ÀÏÐÌÉkÊÒÀÏпiw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

R1, R2 ∈ {ρ, δ}

P1 c(r) = 1 ⇒ r = 1

P2(R1, R2) ∀I ∈ IΠ, ∀s′ ∈ SolΠ′(f(I)), R2Π′(f(I), s′) ≥ c(r)⇒ R1Π(I, g(s′)) ≥ r.Ýçaà

n�

ÁÂaÃIÄ¿kÀÍlÅÇÎ~ÊÒÀÅÇÀÍ�ä�ÂaìkÑâÄÌÊÒÀ¥¿kÀÏÐÆÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐXÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÌÑTzIÉ�ÀÏÐ Ã�Î~É�ÐÆìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃIÄÒÎ~Ã�ÐÅ Â L x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à ÑâÃ-xÄÌÊÒÎI¿[ÉkÑâÄÒÀªÀlÄÀ�[ìkÅÇÎ~ÑâÄÒÔÏÀ�¿�ÂaÃ�ÐÅÇÀ�ͯÂ~¿[ÊÒÀ�¿kÀÏÐÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀÏÐ|ÅÇÎ~úÑTzïÉ�ÀÏÐMaxNP

ÀlÄMaxSNP

ÀlÄzIÉkÑkÂã¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔÅâÑÇÀlÉ:W¿kÀÏЪÊÒÔÏÐÌÉkÅâÄ�ÂaÄÒÐÆÀÏÐÒÐ�ÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅÇЪ¿kÀ�ÍÏÎ$t ìkÅÇÔlÄÌÉ�¿kÀ oC´ Î~à ¼lÉ�À¿�ÂaÃ�ЪÅÇÀ�skÉkÄÆ¿kÀ ìPÎ~ÉkÁïÎ~ÑâʪÄÌÊ�ÂaÃ�ÐÌìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÀlÊÆÅÇÀÏÐÐÒÍ�ä�Ô(teÂ~пiw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à Š L x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍcÄÒÑâÎ~à ¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑÇÀ¿�ÂaÃ�Ð c u¶�d ìkÊÒÔÏÐ�ÀlÊÌÁÀ�Åw ÀlÊÌÊÒÀlÉkÊÊÒÀlÅÇÂaÄÌÑâÁïÀ oVü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7ðl ³

Lx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

ø Î~ÑÇÀlÃIÄΠÀlÄ

Π′¿kÀlÉ-BìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ ¿kÀ

NPOÄÒÀlÅÇÐ�zïÉ�À

optΠ = optΠ′ Î~Ãx¿[ÑâÄ2ìPÎ~ÉkÊ2ÅÇÀÏÐ2Ê�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÐÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÌÑTzIÉ�ÀãÀlÄ�¿[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅ;zIÉ�ÀΠÐÒÀLx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[ÉkÑâÄGî �/0�7!iU ÐÒÀ

L[δ]x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[ÉkÑâÄ8ïÒ

Π′ÀlÄ�Î~ÃCÃ�Î~ÄÒÀ

ΠL∝Π′

î �/0�7!iUΠ

L[δ]∝ Π′

ï�ÐËw ÑâÅÇЪÁÔlÊÌÑ'~�ÀlÃIÄìPÎ~ÉkÊ¿kÀlÉ-VÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄÒÀÏÐα1 > 0

ÀlÄα2 > 0

L1 ∀I∈IΠ, βΠ′(f(I)) ≤ α1βΠ(I) (resp.¿[Ñ Â6t

Π′(f(I)) ≤ α1¿[Ñ Â6t

Π(I))

L2 ∀I∈IΠ, ∀s′∈SolΠ′(f(I)), |mΠ(I, g(s′))−βΠ(I)| ≤ α2|mΠ′(f(I), s

′)−βΠ′(f(I))|.

Ýçaà�/��7L0���5¶�$4�$4>B80�S

Xo

ÃWìkÊ�Î$skÅÇå�t�ÀΠ¿kÀ

YÀlÐÒÄ°¿[ÑâÄ

YxvÍÏÎ$t ìkÅÇÀlÄtÐÌÑkÄÒÎ~ÉkÄ°ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÆ¿kÀ

YÐÒÀXx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[ÉkÑâÄÐ

Π~Åw ÑÇ¿kÔÏÀÆÀÏÐÌĨzIÉ�À

ÐÌÑ?Î~ÃeìkÊÒÎ~ÉkÁïÀìPÎ~ÉkÊ�ÐÒÀlÉkÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄtÅw ÉkÃC¿kÀãÍÏÀÏÐ ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ�ÍlÎ$t ì�ÅâÀlÄÒÐ�ÐÒÎ~ÃCÂaìkì�ÂaÊÌÄÒÀlÃ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀG�Å ÂÍlÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀX ÂaÅÇÎ~ÊÒÐÆÎ~Ã%Åw Â2ìkÊÒÎ~ÉkÁÔ ìPÎ~ÉkʪÄÒÎ~ÉkĪìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À�¿�À

Yò[ÀlĪÐÌÑ

XÀÏÐÌÄ�ÉkÃVÐ�Î~É�ÐyxvÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ�¿kÀ

YÂaÅÇÎ~ÊÒÐ

XÀlÄ

YÍÏÎ��Ã�ÍlÑÇ¿kÀlÃIÄ o

Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7T«

n�

ø Î~ÑÇÀlÃIÄXÀlÄY¿kÀlÉ-CÍcÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀÏÐ�¿kÀXìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏЪ¿kÀ

NPOÀlÄXÉkÃ�ÀãÊ�Ôl¿kÉ�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã%ìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÊÌÁÂaÃIÄ�Åw Âaìkì�ÂaÊÌÄÒÀ�x

Ã�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ{X

YxvÍ

= {Π ∈ Y / ∀Π′ ∈ Y, Π′X∝Π}.

ÂaÊy«Î~ÑÇÐ:îúÔlÃ�ÔlÊ�ÂaÅÇÀ(t�ÀÏÃIÄ�zïÉ�ÂaÃ�¿X ⊆ Y

ÀlÄÁzIÉ�w ÑâŪÃ�w ËxÂ

= B��$�H!>%T0(��!#�$���%q�L=¹�/�/=$�#BL������4 oË Ã*ÐÒÍ�ä�Ô(teÂÆ¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎNnÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã¥ìPÎ~ÅâËnÃ�Î$t Ñ ÂaÅïìPÎ~ÉkÊqÍÏÀìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À

¿iwAPX

ìPÎ~ÉkÊÌÊ�ÂaÑâÄXÂaÑâÃ�ÐÌÑŵlÄÌÊÒÀ�ÄÌÊ�ÂaÃ�ÐÌìPÎÐÒÔ�ì�ÂaÊLx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãú2ÄÒÎ~ÉkÄãÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀ�ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À*¿kÀ�Å Â ÍlÅÇÂ~Ð�ÐÒÀ o

MinDFNSî :�K4 �+���E�^Ø&�K��0�BN�90�=ÐÙØ0�0�=��/�@BÚÁ&�Ë=�0RÌi0(� ï

∈ APX − hÀlÄMinFNS

î A�K4 �¶=���E�ÙÅ0�0/=��/�@B1Úó&�Ë=�0~Ì;0(� ï

∈ APX − c %T087�B��67ñ�$����0�4>�9�87ñ0(�õ4>�$4J�$���0�4������%T,���0ó=Å2 0(4�=

7L0(�Á�(%q0����+4 �+�M��� =�0�7(�$����0(�+7Á�/0(����E��7(�$4>�APX

= =$� ) B(�+%q087G!-���E��%q�P=¹�/��=��-BL�����$4shõ�Á�$�ð7Á%q0�B��67

4>�$4A�$����0(4���NI��K�Á����%T0{S����8!�!-�$�(�B/�$4 7���$4

n@u

� Ó! © ÌÈ ÜÛyÍ Ï�¡Í#@¦¨Ï@Íø Î~ÑâÄ

YÉkÃ�ÀãÍlÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀ¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃVÀlÄ

XÉkÃ�ÀÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�zIÉ�ÀlÅÇÍÏÎ~à zïÉ�À¨òIÎ~Ã%ÂaìkìPÀlÅâÅÇÀ«ÀlÊ�t�ÀlÄÌÉkÊÒÀ

¿kÀYìPÎ~ÉkÊ

XÅw ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ

YX ¿kÀÏЪìkÊ�Î$skÅÇå�t�ÀÏÐHzIÉkÑ ÐÒÀ

Xx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[ÉkÑÇÐÒÀlÃIÄõ2Ékà ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À*¿kÀ

Yo

Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7T«>lf ÀlÊ�t�ÀlÄÌÉkÊÒÀø Î~ÑâÄ

YÉkÃ�ÀÍcÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀ�¿kÀ�ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐã¿kÀ

NPOÀlÄXÉkÃ�À�ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã&

YX= {Π ∈ NPO / ∃Π′ ∈ Y, Π

X∝Π′}.

� Î~É�Ð Àlå¯ÁÎ~Ã�пkÔ ��ª¿[ÑÇÐÒÍlÉkÄÒÔ ÂaÉ�ì�ÂaÊ�ÂaúÊ�Âaìkä�À n-o}-o} ÅÇÀÏÐ;ÀlÊ�t�ÀlÄÌÉkÊÒÀÏÐ MaxSNP0P ÀlÄ MaxNP0P¿kÀÏÐ ÍlÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀÏÐ ÐÌËnÃIÄ�¶nÑTzIÉ�ÀÏÐMaxSNP0

ÀlÄMaxNP0

ìPÎ~ÉkÊ Å ÂPx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã¥ÍÏÎ��Ã�ÍlÑÇ¿kÀlÃIįÁÀÏÍŠªÍcÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀ

¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃAPX

¿kÀÏÐìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐÂaì�ìkÊÒÎNnÑqteÂ6skÅÇÀÏЪÊ�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄ|ÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÒÄ�ÂaÃIÄqìPÎ~ÉkÊqÅÇÀ°Ê�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄ|ÍlÅ Â~ÐyxÐÌÑTzIÉ�À o ´ ÀlÄÌÄÒÀÔlúïÂaÅâÑâÄÒÔ�¿�À ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐ�ÀÏЪÐÌÑâúÃkÑ'~�À Ã�Î~Ä�Â6t·t�ÀlÃIÄHzIÉ�À ÐÌÑÉkà Ð�ÀcÉ�ÅìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À¿kÀ

NPOzIÉkÑ�Ð�Î~ÑâÄ

MaxSNPxv¿[Ñ ÍlÑâÅÇÀ°ìPÎ~ÉkÊÅ Â

P Å Â L Î~ÉÅ Â E x{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃWÂ~¿-t�ÀlÄ ÉkÃ*ÐÒÍ�ä�Ô(teÂÂaÅÇÎ~ÊÒÐ�Ä�Î~ÉkÄ ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À ¿kÀÅ Â�ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐ�ÀAPX

Â~¿-t�ÀlÄtÔlúïÂaÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄtÉkÃeÐÒÍ�ä�Ô(te ÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ�¿[ÑâÄ� ��43!>������%T,���0 MaxSNP =y=$� ) BL�K%T0ìPÎ~ÉkÊ ÄÒÎ~ÉkÄÒÀ%ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à ìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÊÌÁÂaÃIÄ ÅÇÀÏÐ ÐÒÍ�ä�Ô(teÂô¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎNnÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎÃTÐÒÀlÊ�ÂAPX

=y=$� ) BL�K%T0 ÄÒÎ~É$�ÌÎ~ÉkÊÒÐÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑâÁïÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ"�ÉkÃ�ÀÄÒÀlÅâÅÇÀÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~à o#º Ê PTAS ÀÏÐÌÄ ÉkÃCÐÒÎ~É�ÐyxvÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀìkÊ�Î~ìkÊÒÀã¿iwAPX &t�Î~ÑâÃ�ÐzIÉ�ÀPÃ�w ÔlúïÂaÅÇÀ

NP°ÐÒÎ~É�Ð�Åw äIËnìPÎ~ÄÌä�åÏÐÒÀÍÏÎ~ÃIÄÌÊ�ÂaÑâÊÒÀ Î~ÃTìPÎ~ÉkÊÌÊ�ÂR¿[ÑâÊÒÀó¿kÀ ÄÒÎ~ÉkÄeìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�À:t�Î~ÃIÄÌÊÒÔ

MaxSNPxv¿[Ñ ÍlÑâÅÇÀúzIÉ�w ÑâÅãÃ�w ÀÏÐÌÄCì�Â~ÐCÐÒÍ�ä�Ô(teÂaÄ�Â6skÅÇÀ o´ ÀÏÐCÔlúïÂaÅâÑâÄÒÔÏÐ%ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3s�ÅÓÑÇÐÒÄÒÀÏÐ Àlà t�ÀlÄÌÄ�ÂaÃIÄVÀlÃÊÒÀlúïÂaÊÒ¿O¿kÀÏÐtÍlÅ Â~Ð�ÐÒÀÏÐtÐÌËIÃIÄ�¶[ÑTzIÉ�ÀÏÐHî =@�$4>�Ø%T087¨!>�����(%q,(�Á0�7¨! 0���560�4>�Þ7N0>,L�$���M��%T0��7(�$�E7��4C0GB80��(��$�K4;0&0�I�=

!>�/0�7�78���$4 ïÆÀlÄãÉkÃ�À¥ÍlÅ Â~ÐÒÐÒÀ¥¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ãî =@�$4�����(%q,���087·�$4>�"�L�9�M�Á�$4���NI$�+�Á����%T087!#�$�E�{�E44 �+560/�$�A=Ø2 �8!�!>���NI$�+�Á��������4ú=@��4 4C� ï ÐÒÎ~ÃIÄÆ¿iw ÉkÃ�À�ÊÌÑÇÍ�ä�ÀÏÐÒÐÒÀ�ÑâÃ�ÍÏÎ~ÃIÄÒÀÏÐÌÄ�Â6skÅÇÀ o

�Ý 2�Þ pD\«4r�Òo!pq4#57o Z 57` 3 _F$&o! � Û Ú ß ¢ ԦХ�@¤¤vó¥-¤¤Ø@¥P¦¨Ír

� Î~É�ÐÆìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃIÄÒÎ~Ã�ÐÆÑÇÍlÑÅÇÀlÐÆÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐX¿kÀ ø Ñqt�Î~à ÍÏÎ~à ¼lÉ�ÀÏÐÆìPÎ~ÉkÊìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÊÌÁïÀlÊÆÅÇÀÏÐÆÊ�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄÒÐMî«ÔlÁÀlÃ-xÄÌÉ�ÀlÅâÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄtÂ~ÐÌË�t ìkÄÒÎ~ÄÌÑTzIÉ�ÀÏÐ8ï|¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎNnÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à ͯÂaÊ ¿iw ÉkÃ�À�ì�ÂaÊÌÄ Í�w ÀÏÐÌÄÉkà Î~ÉkÄÌÑâÅkìkÊÒÔÏÍlÑÇÀlÉ-·zïÉkÑ[Ã�Î~É�ÐÐÒÀlÊ�Â�Î~ÊÌÄÉkÄÌÑâÅÇÀ2ÂaÉÍ�ä�ÂaìkÑâÄÌÊÒÀ u teÂaÑÇÐãÐÌÉkÊÌÄÒÎ~ÉkÄãì�ÂaÊÒÍÏÀ3zïÉ�w ÀlÅâÅÇÀÏÐXÍÏÎ~Ã�ÐÌÄÌÑâÄÌÉ�ÀlÃIÄXÉkÃóìkÊÒÀ(t ÑÇÀlÊãì�Â~ÐÁïÀlÊÒÐÅ ÂÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~î Ã�À�ÀlÃnÄÌÊÒÀ ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ ÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃézIÉkÑÃ�Î~É�ÐÑâÃIÄÒÔlÊÒÀÏÐÒÐÒÀlÊ�ÂVÄÒÎ~ÉkÄì�ÂaÊÌÄÌÑÇÍlÉkÅâÑÇålÊÒÀ(t�ÀÏÃIÄ2¿�ÂaÃ�ÐÅÇÀͯÂ~¿[ÊÒÀ¿kÀ�Åw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÿ[ÑÓù�ÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅâÅÇÀ oVü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7T«

n�

a > 0 b ≥ 0 a′ > 0 ÀlÄ b′ ≥ 0 ÅÇÀÏÐÆìkÊÒÎ~ìkÊÌÑÇÔlÄÒÔÏÐÐÒÉkÑâÁ~ÂaÃIÄÒÀÏÐÅC1 ∀I ∈ IΠ, ∀s ∈ SolΠ(I),

mΠ′(f(I), g′(s))

{≥ 1/a×mΠ(I, s)− b

ÐÌÑoptΠ = max

≤ 1/a×mΠ(I, s) + bÐÌÑâÃ�Î~Ã

C2 ∀I ∈ IΠ, ∀s′ ∈ SolΠ(f(I)),

mΠ(I, g(s′))

{≥ 1/a′ ×mΠ′(f(I), s

′)− b′ÐÌÑoptΠ = max

≤ 1/a′ ×mΠ′(f(I), s′) + b′

ÐÌÑâÃ�Î~Ãr ÀWìkÊÒÎI¿[ÉkÑâÄ

a × a′ÀÏÐÌÄ*ÂaìkìPÀlÅÇÔ 0/I8!#�$4#78���$4 ¿kÀ Å ÂCÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã&òÐÌÑ

b = b′ = 0 Å ÂCÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÀÏÐÌÄ¿[ÑâÄÒÀ ���87L�$%)�E��0�4

n�

® �/0(�E560 �ìPÎ~ÉkÊ¿�ÀcÉ#%ìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏп�À�te¶[Ñqt ÑÇÐ�ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãë ÀlìkÊÒÀlÃ�ÂaÃIÄÆÅÇÀÏЪÃ�Î~IJÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�пkÀ�Å Â2ìkÊÒÀlÉkÁïÀ�ìkÊÒÔÏÍÏÔÏ¿kÀlÃIÄÒÀ Î~ÃÂWì�ÂaʪäIËnìPÎ~ÄÌä�åÏÐÒÀ

mΠ′(f(I), s′) ≥ r × βΠ′(f(I)) + (1− r)× ωΠ′(f(I)),

ÀlÄÆÑâÅ�ÁnÑÇÀlÃIÄβΠ′(f(I)) ≥

1

aβΠ(I)−b, mΠ(I, s) ≥

1

a′mΠ′(f(I), s

′)−b′, ωΠ′(f(I)) ≥1

aωΠ(I)−b

⇓

mΠ(I, s) ≥1

a′

[r

(1

aβΠ(I)− b

)+ (1− r)

(1

aωΠ(I)− b

)]−b′ ≥ rβΠ(I)+(1−r)ωΠ(I)−

b

a′−b.

ë À(teÂaÊ/zïÉ�Î~Ã�ÐÅzIÉ�w ¯ÁÀÏÍÉkÃ�À°À�nì�ÂaÃ�ÐÌÑÇÎ~Ã*ÐÒÄÌÊÌÑÇÍlÄÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ ÑâÃ-ÔlÊÌÑÇÀlÉkÊÒÀÐ p Î~Ã�Ã�ÀìPÎ~ÉkÊÌÊ�ÂaÑâÄÊÌÑÇÀlÃ*ÍlÎ~Ã�ÍcÅâÉkÊ�ÀÂeìkÊÌÑÇÎ~ÊÌÑ o ÂaÊ Å ÂOÐÌÉkÑâÄÒÀ Î~Ã

�

ÍÏÀ·zïÉ�ÀWÃ�Î~É�Ð�ìkÊÒÔÏÐÒÀlÃIÄÒÎ~Ã�ÐÀÏÐÒÄ ÉkÃ�ÀWÊÒÀÏÐÌÄÌÊÌÑÇÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃB¿kÀWÅ ÂCÃ�Î~ÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã0ìkÅâÉ�Ð�úÔlÃ�ÔlÊ�ÂaÅÇÀ�¿iw ÔLzIÉkÑâÁ~ÂaÅÇÀlÃ�ÍÏÀ�ÐÒÎ~É�Ð�ÅÇÀÊ�ÂaìkìPÎ~ÊÌÄã¿[ÑÓùÔlÊÒÀlÃIÄÌÑÇÀlÅq¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑÇÀ*¿�ÂaÃ�Ð c 6�d9oVü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7T« ¯¤

AFx{ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃÎ~É ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

-p

® �/0(�E560 �ÍÏÎ~Ã�Ð�ÔLzïÉ�ÀlÃ�ÍÏÀ*¿[ÑâÊÒÀÏÍlÄÒÀ¿kÀ�Å Â2ìkÊ�Î~ìPÎÐÌÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~à n-oqp�p¦á ÅIÀ�[ÑÇÐÌÄÒÀt¿kÀÏÐqÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð|ìkÅâÉ�ÐqÑâÃIÄÌÑqt�ÀÏÐ|ÀlÃ�ÍÏÎ~ÊÒÀ�ÀlÃIÄÌÊÒÀtìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ zïÉkÑIÃ�Î~É�ÐqìPÀlÊ�t�ÀlÄÌÄÌÊÒÎ~ÃIÄìkÅâÉ�ÐqÄ�ÂaÊÒ¿¿kÀ¥Ê�ÂaìkìkÊ�ÎïÍ�ä�ÀcÊ Ã�Î~ÃôìkÅâÉ�Ð ÐÒÀlÉkÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ�ÅâÀlÉkÊ�¿kÀlúÊÒÔW¿iw ÂaìkìkÊÒÎN[ÑqteÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~à teÂaÑÇÐXÅÇÀlÉkÊ�ÐÌÄÌÊÌÉ�ÍlÄÌÉkÊÒÀ�tÁµ(t�ÀòÍ�w ÀÏÐÌÄÍÏÀGzIÉkÑit�Î~ÄÌÑâÁïÀ�ÅÇÀÏÐÆ¿kÀlÊÌÃkÑÇålÊÒÀÏÐã¿kÔ�~�ÃkÑâÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�Ð o

Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7T« ² ë ÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã:skÑ ��ÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁïÀ Ã�À ÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã

R = (f, g)ÀÏÐÌÄÈskÑ ��ÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁïÀ�ÐÒÑ ÀlÄÆÐÒÀlÉkÅÇÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄãÐÌÑ

∀I ∈ IΠ, g|SolΠ′ (f(I))ÀÏÐÌĪÉkÃ�ÀGskÑ �ÌÀÏÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ãó¿kÀ

SolΠ′(f(I))ÐÌÉkÊ

SolΠ(I).Vü@â×|Û öêÛàP× l7T«�È�«)J4C0 ÀlÃIÄÌÊ�ÀW¿kÀlÉ-óì�ÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀlÐ

ΠÀlÄ

Π′¿kÀ

NPO Ã�Î~ÄÒÔÏÀ ΠAF⇒ Π′ ÀÏÐÌÄÉkÃ�À Ê�Ôl¿kÉ�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃR = (f, g)

 Ã�ÀGskÑ ��ÀÏÍlÄÌÑâÁïÀ o ø w ÑâÅ À�[ÑÇÐÌÄÒÀ�¿kÀlÉ-CÊÒÔÏ¿[É�ÍlÄÌÑÇÎ~Ã�ÐÈ«Î~ÊÒÄÒÀ(t�ÀcÃnÄã Ã�ÀÏÐ Åw É�Ã�À¿kÀΠΠ′ Åw ÂaÉkÄÌÊÒÀª¿kÀ Π′ Π Î~ÃWÃ�Î~ÄÒÀlÊ� ΠAF⇔ Π′ ÀlÄÅÇÀÏÐìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ Π Π′ Ð�ÀlÊÒÎ~ÃIÄ¿[ÑâÄÒÐ ��)J4C0���0�4����+$���$����087�%)�K4C�/�$�+�/087&0(4:5¶�$�����E��%q0�7{���+5¶�$%T0�4>�9087 Ã�Î~ÄÒÔÏÐ MaxPL{0, 1} ÀlÄ MinPL{0, 1} ÐÒÎ~ÃIÄãÅâÑÇÔÏÐXì�ÂaÊãÉkÃ�À¥ÊÒÀlÅ ÂaÄÌÑÇÎ~ÃAÎ~ÊÌÄÒÀ(t�ÀlÃIÄ� Ã�À oC Ã�À*ÑâÃ�ÐÌÄ�ÂaÃ�ÍÏÀ

I¿kÀ*ÄÒÀlÅÇÐãìkÊÒÎ$skÅÇå(t�ÀÏÐ�ÀÏÐÌÄãÅ Âe¿kÎ~ÃkÃ�ÔÏÀ ÐÌÉkÊ�Ékà ÀlÃ�ÐÒÀ(t3skÅÇÀ

X¿kÀ

nÁÂaÊÌÑ Â6skÅÇÀÏÐ¥ÁÂaÅÇÀlÉkÊÆ¿�ÂaÃ�Ð

{0, 1} ¿iw ÉkÃVÁïÀÏÍlÄÒÀlÉkÊÆÎ$s-�ÌÀlÍlÄÌÑ' c WÍÏÎïÀ ÍlÑÇÀlÃIÄÒ�