UKSG, 29-31 March 2004 SUNCAT Briefing Session UKSG Conference March 29-31 2004 .
UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: actors, bystanders,...
-
Upload
uksg-connecting-the-knowledge-community -
Category
Education
-
view
412 -
download
0
Transcript of UKSG Conference 2016 Breakout Session - The Predatory Publishing Phenomenon: actors, bystanders,...
THE PR
EDATORY
PUBLIS
HING
PHENOMEN
ON
A C T O R S , B Y S TA N D E R S , C
O N S E Q U E N C E S
REGINA ROMANO REYNOLDSDIRECTOR, U.S. ISSN CENTERLIBRARY OF CONGRESSUKSG, BOURNEMOUTH, 2016
BEALL’S DEFINITION
PREDATO
RY
“predatory” publishers—those that unprofessionally exploit the gold open-access model for their own profit. These publishers use deception to appear legitimate, entrapping researchers into submitting their work and then charging them to publish it.
J. Beall, The Scientist Aug 1, 2012
PREDATORY PRACTICES DESCRIBED BY BEALL*
• Attracting revenue by deceiving their authors, their readers, and/or those trying to evaluate the scholarly achievements of their authors.
• Honesty (does it falsely claim editorial board members or impact factors?)
• Business practices (does it engage in spam solicitations or steal content from reputable journals?), and
• Transparency (does it hide author charges until after manuscript acceptance or hide its content from search engines?). https://www.ufv.ca/media/assets/research/workshops/Criteria-for-Determining-Predatory-Publishers.pdf
WHO ARE THE PREDATORS?
•
PREDATORS?• Beall’s list? —controversial• Many publishers, open access or not? • Large commercial and society publishers? • Academics who edit predatory journals or
serve on their boards? • Academia’s“publish or perish” requirement?• Authors knowingly publishing in journals that
have names similar to well known journals?• Publishers who employ deceptive practices
solely to reap profits?
WHO IS BEING PREYED ON?
PREY?
Authors?
Scholars in DevelopingCountries?
Libraries?The Public?
THE DARK SIDE OF OPEN ACCESS:
TRUE TALES FROM THE U.S. ISSN CENTER
GOOGLE MAPS PHOTO:LOCATION OF A PUBLISHING OFFICE
GIVEN BY PUBLISHER TO NLM
THE DEVELOPMENT OF ACTIVE PREDATORY OPEN ACCESS JOURNALS FROM 2010-2014
Shen and Bjork, BMC Medicine(2015) 13:230
LONGEVITY?
LONGEVITY OBSERVATIONS (INFORMAL STUDIES BY KAREN ROSS, PROQUEST METADATA LIBRARIAN IN THE U.S. ISSN CENTER)• 77 journals from Beall’s list (from 22 publishers
chosen at random) were checked for continued existence (start dates between 2007 – 2015) • 50 were still in existence although some had
changed titles• Many of their earliest issues had fewer than 5
articles; • Now most had 10 – 12 articles per issue
• Beall’s list of ca 900 titles was checked to determine if the publisher URL was still in existence• 145 had non-working URLs, with perhaps 15 of
those changed URLs• Ca. 14% of the web sites could not be found
Informal conclusion: Far from disappearing as some might have thought, questionable publishers and their journals are largely persisting
PREDATO
RY
PUBLIS
HER?
SHOULD WE RETIRE THE TERM?
RICK ANDERSON
Acting in bad faith?
QuestionablePublisher?
Scam
publisher?
IT’S NOT SIMPLY “GOOD GUYS” VS. “BAD GUYS”
CONTINUUM
Clueless
AmateurDeceptive
Fraudulent
IT’S COMPLICATED!
ACTORS: ENABLERS, BYSTANDERS, IMPROVERS?
Academics
Peer reviewe
rs
Traditional
publishers
Governments
ISSN centers
Libraries & librarians
Professional
organizations
ECONOMIC REALITIES
Ease of Internet publishingGovernment mandates for open
accessGrowing numbers of scholars worldwide
Library support for open accessRequirement in developing
countries to publish in “international journals”Selectivity by mainstream
publishers
Growing numbers of authors + pressure to publish + ease of online publishing
= marketing opportunity publishing opportunity
Moral Panic?
A moral panic is a feeling of fear spread among a large number of people that some evil threatens the well-being of society. A Dictionary of Sociology defines a moral panic as "the process of arousing social concern over an issue – usually the work of moral entrepreneurs and the mass media.
Wikipedia
JOHN DUPUIS (CONFESSIONS OF A SCIENCE LIBRARIAN)• Is the “moral panic” over “predatory
publishing” overshadowing the failings of peer review and the subscription model?
• Retraction Watch examples• Should peer review be abolished?• Should journals be abolished in favor
of something like physics preprints?
MIGHT THE BLANKET LABEL “PREDATORY:”
HARM THE CAUSE OF OPEN ACCESS?
INHIBIT PUBLISHING IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES?
DEPRIVE SCIENCE AND SCHOLARSHIP OF DISCOVERIES AND INSIGHTS?
HOW CAN QUALITY OPEN ACCESS PREVAIL?
SOME DOAJ BASIC REQUIREMENTSURL must go straight to the journal home
pageAll content free without delays or embargos
“Business information pages” available at journals’ URL, not a
central pageJournal must have a dedicated web siteAt least one ISSNHome page must “demonstrate that care has
been taken to ensure high ethical and professional standards.” (Principles of
Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing)Editor and editorial board with
contact informationClear description of quality control system
(editorial or peer review) All publishing charges clearly stated
Open access policy clearly stated
PRINCIPLES OF TRANSPARENCY AND BEST PRACTICE IN SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING• Based on DOAJ requirements with some additions:
•Responsibility to identify and prevent papers giving evidence of research misconduct• Journal name should be unique and not misleading or easily confused with another journals•Solicitation of manuscripts should be appropriate, well targeted and unobtrusive
• Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)• Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ)• Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association (OASPA)• World Association of Medical Editors (WAME)
ROLE OF THE LIBRARIAN
A TALE OF TWO LIBRARIES: LC ISSN AND NLM
ISSN APPLICATION INSTRUCTIONS FROM ISSN.ORG
d) We reserve the right to refuse an ISSN assignment if it is
considered that misleading information has been provided by the requestor or printed/displayed on the publication regarding, for instance: the place of publication (publisher’s address), the members of the editorial board, the referencing by indexing services or databases, the participation in digital preservation programs or the authorship of the articles provided.
e) We also reserve the right to revoke an ISSN if it subsequently comes to light that misleading information has been provided.
WHY ASSIGN ISSN AT ALL?• ISSN is first and foremost an identifier—
these publications need to be identified and distinguished from same or similar titles
• ISSN does not indicate quality or legitimacy any more than your social security number indicates that you are a good citizen
• ISSN helps to track these publications and see patterns, such as what has been presented about longevity and ubiquity
ISSUES OF LIFE OR DEATH
U.S. NATIONAL LIBRARY OF MEDICINEEXCERPTS FROM COLLECTION DEVELOPMENT STATEMENT
A journal should demonstrate:quality of editorial workthe publisher and/or sponsoring organization’s history and corporate structure longevityrecord of performance regarding such issues as:
quality of publications, experience in scholarly publishing, involvement with the scientific community; disclosure of an adherence to print and online
publication standards, promotion of editorial integrity and independence.
NLM STRIVES FOR “GEOGRAPHIC HETEROGENEITY”
other periodicals—those that are not sources of original research—must be primarily biomedical in content to be considered for selection. The Library may make exceptions [for] geographic heterogeneity. For example, NLM may select basic science or social science journals from developing countries which often have little or no medical publishing per se.
ROLES ACADEMIA CAN PLAY?Raise awareness of
predatory practices and low quality journals
Assess publish or perish requirements
Assess value of open access journals
Evaluate journal quality vs. prestige
Scrutinize journal service as editors or on editorial
boards
Online publishing is also redefining traditional notions of academic prestige….
What this article describes as predatory journals may well in the future be seen as simply a natural part of the market. … A new era of due diligence is dawning for academics…
Keith McNaught, Journal of Electronic Publishing
Vol. 18, issue 3
IS PREDATORY PUBLISHING A NATURAL CONSEQUENCE OF
OPEN ACCESS?
IS SCI-HUB A CONSEQUENCE OF SUBSCRIPTION ONLY
ACCESS?
WHERE DOES THE FUTURE OF SCHOLARLY COMMUNICATION
LIE?
…the problems caused by predatory journals are rather limited and regional and believe that the publishing volumes in such journals will cease growing in the near future. Open access publishing is rapidly gaining momentum… this should create better opportunities for researchers from countries where predatory publishing is currently popular, to get published in journals of higher quality, in particular since most journals have a policy to waive APC’s for authors from developing countries.
Shen and Bjork
TEMPORARY INCONVENIENCE; PERMANENT IMPROVEMENT?
Thank [email protected]
ARTICLES CITEDRick Anderson, “Should we Retire the Term,
“Predatory Publishing?” The Scholarly Kitchen, May 11, 2015
J. Beall, “Predatory Publishing,” The Scientist, August 1, 2012
John Dupuis, “Some perspecitve on ‘predatory’ open access journals, Confessions of a Science Librarian, March 31, 2015
Keith McNaught, “The Changing Publication Practices in Academia: Inherent Users and Issues in Open Access and online Publishing and the Rise of Fraudulent Publications,” Journal of Electronic Publishing, Vol. 18, Issue 3: on Access, Summer 2015
Cenyu Shen and Bo-Christer Bjork, “Predatory” open access: a longitudinal study of article volumes and market characteristics,” BMC Medicine (2015) 13:230
RESOURCESBeall’s list : https://scholarlyoa.com/publishers/DOAJ: https://doaj.org/ISSN International Centre: www.issn.orgNL M: https://www.nlm.nih.gov/Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association:
http://oaspa.org/Principles of Transparency:
http://publicationethics.org/news/principles-transparency-and-best-practice-scholarly-publishing-revised-and-updated
ROAD: http://road.issn.orgThink Check Submit: http://thinkchecksubmit.org/