Workforce Roundtable Report - NoVA Roadmap to Success Report
TP-2 Report Roadmap
Transcript of TP-2 Report Roadmap
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
1/43
TP-2 Report
RoadmapTowards a Written Deliverable
Welcome to the TP-2 Report Roadmap, a blueprint designed todevelop a tightly edited and extremely well-written andacademically researched document.
2007
Sha na Pand a
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
2/43
Contents
0 REPORT CONSOLIDATION PROCEDURES AND TASKS .......................... .........5
CHAPTERMANAGERS/RESEARCH DIRECTORS PLEASE READ THIS CHAPTER
BEFORE YOU BEGIN .................................................................................... 5
1.0 NOTES: ................................................................................................................... 5
1.1 INSTRUCTIONSFORCHAPTERMANAGERS..................................................................... 5
0.1 REPORT STATUS........................................................................................................6
0.2 CHAPTERMANAGEMENT WORKBREAKDOWN STRUCTURE............................................ .6
0.3 PART I: BUILDINGTHE CHAPTERFRAMEWORK..............................................................7
0.4 PART II: PROCEDUREFORPULLING TOGETHERA PROPERCHAPTER................................. 8
0.5 REPORT COMPLETION WORKBREAKDOWN STRUCTURE................................................ 11
0.6 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY WORKBREAKDOWN STRUCTURE............................................... 12
1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................... ............13
1.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES......................................................................................... 13
CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION .................................................... ...........................14
CHAPTER 2 THE PLAN/OVERVIEW (MAKE IT CLEAR TO THOMAS
THAT THIS IS AN INTRODUCTION TO OUR ENTIRE REPORT, NOT JUST
THE TWO TECHNICAL CHAPTERS) ............................................... .......................15
2 PROJECT G.A.S. P.U.M.P ...................................................................... ...................17
2.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES......................................................................................... 17
3 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. ARCHITECTURE & ITS OPTIMIZATION: STORAGE ...........18
3.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES......................................................................................... 18
CHAPTER 3 THE DETAILS .................................................................... ................18
4 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. ARCHITECTURE & ITS OPTIMIZATION: DELIVERY ...... .. .21
4.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES......................................................................................... 21
CHAPTER 4 TO MAXIMIZE THE PERFORMANCE, DURABILITY &
UTILITY OF OUR PRODUCT .......................................................... ..........................21
5 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. THE BUSINESS PLAN .................................................. ..............23
5.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES......................................................................................... 23
[JUN NEEDS DATA FROM STORAGE AND DELIVERY THE NUMERICAL
SOLUTIONS (E.G. WRT STORAGE & DELIVERY, BY-PRODUCTS, MARKET
DEMAND BEFORE HE CAN COME UP WITH NUMBERS] .................................23
CHAPTER 5 THE BUSINESS CASE ................................................................... ...23
6 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. - THE POLITICO-LEGAL PERSPECTIVE ....... ........................25
6.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES......................................................................................... 25
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
3/43
CHAPTER 6 OVERCOMING THE POLITICAL & LEGAL BARRIERS
(CHANGE TITLE) ......................................................................................................... 25
7 CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS ............................... ...........................27
7.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES......................................................................................... 27
CHAPTER 7 CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS (SHOULD BE A
GRAND SYNTHESIS) .................................................................................... ............27
8 EXTRAS ............................................................................................ ..........................28
8.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES......................................................................................... 28
8.2 STUDENT PREFACE.................................................................................................. 28
12 TEAM MEMBER NAMES & AFFILIATION .......................................................33
14 ACKNOWLEDGMENT TRACKER ................................................................... ....34
15 ACRONYM TRACKER .......................................................................... .................35
16 PROOF OF PERMISSION SHEET FOR USE OF COPYRIGHTED FIGURES
................................................................................................................... ......................37
17 REQUEST FOR PERMISSION OF USE FORM ............................................... ....39
APPENDIX TRACKER ........................................................................................... .....40
18 INDEX OF TERMS TO BE CROSS-REFERENCED ...........................................41
19 9 REFERENCES .................................................................................... ................43
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
4/43
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
5/43
_____________________________________Chapter 0
0 Report Consolidation
Procedures and Tasks
Chapter Managers/ResearchDirectors PLEASE READ THISCHAPTER BEFORE YOU BEGIN
1.0Notes:
1. If you only read 2 sections, make sure it is this one and the oneyou are in charge of. These are cross-referenced within the Tableof Contents and the Work Breakdown Structure table, so hitctrl+click to get there without scrolling through the document.
2. So far I have only copy-and-pasted the outline with minor editsinto the relevant sections. EXPECT THESE TO CHANGE QUITE ABIT.
3. The research submissions are compiled in a separate documentcalled Compiled Submissions round 1.
4. Let me know if you have questions!
1.1Instructions for Chapter Managers
Welcome to the wonderful world of Chapter Management! ;)
Basically, in order to pull together a first rough draft for Tuesday, I amputting you all in charge of a chapter for Tuesday (see next section forChapter assignments). It is a lot of work, so make sure you contract it
out i.e. delegate in order to meet your deadline! If you are too busy,delegate the Chapter Manager role to someone in your group to takecare of it but you are still responsible for having something forme by Tuesday, April 21, 2007.
N.B.: There is a lot to be done, so I will try to assist you asmuch as possible. I have identified my general role within thechapters as noted in the table entitled Report IntegrationDuties.
N.B.-2: For SUBMISSIONS: Only send me your sections, not the entire
document!! Delete the rest.
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
6/43
0.1Report Status
Research Group Status
Drivers & Constraints ~80%
Storage 20% (aiming for 100% byThursday, April 26)
Transport Unknown
Practical Implementation 50-60%
Tuesday, April 24, 2007 9AM Deliverables from Groups:
Complete & edited detailed synopses for each chapter from eachchapter manager
Submit to me what you have in terms of ACTUAL chapter contentat this point so I know what you are
Wednesday, April 25, 2007 9AM Deliverables
Edited & complete synopses from Shawna & Brian (?)
0.2Chapter Management Work BreakdownStructure
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actuallynamed GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePageAllocation
Chapter 1: Introduction Dag &Shawna
3
Chapter 2: Project G.A.S. P.U.M.P. Rodolphe &Shawna
20
Chapter 3: G.A.S. P.U.M.P. Architecture &Its Optimization: Storage
Dave20
Chapter 4: G.A.S. P.U.M.P. Architecture &Its Optimization: Delivery
Thomas20
Chapter 5:G.A.S. P.U.M.P. The Business Jun25
Chapter 6:G.A.S. P.U.M.P. - The Politico-Legal Perspective
Jun & Shawna15
Chapter 7: Conclusions &
Recommendations
Shawna6
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
7/43
Chapter 8: Extras (Table ofContents/Figures/Tables, Appendices,Index, Acronyms, Acknowledgments,Disclaimer, Authors List)
Shawna25
TOTAL Approx.150
0.3Part I: Building the Chapter Framework
1. Shawna Assembles Chapter Objectives: I will start filling in theChapter Objectives in list format based on the outline,submissions and presentations you gave on Wednesday, notingwhich group is doing what. It is up to you to build the chaptersynopsis around it.
Please note that within the objectives:a. Missing content is hi-lighted in yellow;
b. New content that has been assigned to a group ishi-lighted in turquoise
c. Redundant content is hi-lighted in pink
d. Research that has been determined to be COPY ANDPASTED is high-lighted in green. This is a huge problemand you, as RDs, are responsible for dealing withthis. Andreea & Violetta have determined that all 4research group submissions were heavily guilty of
this. If this is not dealt with, I am reporting the offendingparties to faculty, NO EXCEPTIONS. (note: well deal with itinternally first if possible)
e. Chapter Managers: You are responsible for filling in thegaps, meeting with the other groups to determine who willcover the redundancy identified within your group andde-plagiarizing. Contact Shawna and let her know whenyou have addressed these so she can update thisdocument.
2. Chapter Managers Build Chapter Synopsis: Fill in the ChapterSynopsis in as much detail as you can. Please see the Synopsisexample that I am working on for the Introduction to see what Iwant (included at the end of this document). Basically, thesynopsis is a blueprint as to the content and organization ofeach chapter. Include headings if you can.
Example:
Chapter 1: Introduction - Synopsis & Objectives
Shawna fills in Objectives:
Within this chapter, we will state the following:
As part of this discussion, we will define the scope of our
project, stating:
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
8/43
(i) How we defined this topic, summarizing ourprevious work and defending the decision tomove away from Helium-3
(ii) Justify the decision to disclude Low Lunar Orbitand limit the discussion to the Lunar surface
(iii) Our focus is on Hydrogen, Oxygen and H2O, butwe will explore uses for by-products in laterchapters, as part of our business case.
(iv) The timeframe to which our project applies
So whoever is in charge of this section builds theSynopsis around these Objectives, for example:
This chapter is intended to set the stage for our report.Specifically, it will start on the broad scope of humanlunar exploration, what it was (a space-race for glory andnational superiority, what it has become (lunar missions
driven by scientific and economic return) and how wehave evolved to the current framework (what drivers ledus there? Mention science and the emergence of privatesector interest in field). From here, we will explore theneeds of the current framework (multiple needs: e.g.sustainable base, lunar transport, extraction process forfuels, fuel itself), leading into a specific discussion on theimportance of transport & fuel, what research has beenconducted thus far and concluding by exposing theexisting literature gap that our report will address,allowing us to underline the importance of meeting this
need, thereby explaining why our report is relevant andtimely
3. Where to Find the Content: For your reference, I compiled thesubmissions you gave me this week in a single 137-pageddocument. The content has been roughly ordered withinchapters according to our outline. The full outline is at thebeginning of the document while each chapter is also precededby the outline content for that specific chapter.
0.4Part II: Procedure for Pulling Together a
Proper ChapterPlease follow the procedure outlined below for making it a polishedproduct.
N.B.: When submitting to the faculty, include this list aschecklist to inform them as to the chapters progress, so theyknow what level of feedback to give you (i.e. if you have onlycompleted the first 3 steps, indicate as such so they dontream you for something that seems like patchwork).
1. Read the Chapter Synopsis.
2. Access the research submissions and pull together the
appropriate content to reflect the Synopsis. N.B. It is up to the
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
9/43
Chapter Manager to ensure that the content reflects thissynopsis.
3. Integrate the research material in a logical and coherentmanner, taking care to eliminate redundancies.
4. Add the essential chapter elements: Introduction, Conclusion,transition paragraphs, discussion, etc.
5. Hi-light research gaps and changes youd like to see in theChapter Synopsis and resubmit to the Report Manager and PFs,who will review the changes and reassign gaps to theappropriate research group.
6. Once you have a chapter that reads coherently, POLISH IT bytaking it through the edits outlined below. N.B.: Do notattempt to carry all these edits out on your own.Delegate these tasks out to other TP members, give thema deadline that allows you to complete your own work on
time, and note which TP member is in charge of what.Report Integration Duties Work Breakdown Structure
Task Description Responsibility Deadline
PART I
ChapterObjectives
Create a technical list ofspecific content thechapter needs to address
Shawna
Chapter
Synopsis
A summary of how the
chapter will be organizedto incorporate andpresent the objectives
Chapter 1: Dag &
Shawna
Chapter 2:Rodolphe
Chapter 3: Dave
Chapter 4: Thomas
Chapter 5: Jun
Chapter 6: Jun &Shawna
Chapters 7&8:
Shawna
PART II
Transformation fromResearchGroupSubmissioninto ReportMaterial
Take the patchwork ofresearch groupsubmissions and weave ittogether into a coherentand complete chapterthat flows with anintroduction, conclusion
and discussion
[Unknown;Suggested TPmembers: Shawna,Scotty Rocket,Brian, Renee,
Thiago, Dag]
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
10/43
ContentAudit
Read and edit the Chapterfrom beginning to end forflow and readability,ensuring that the chapterdoes not seem like a
patchwork
LanguageTechnicalEdit
Edit for spelling,grammar, punctuationand sentence structure.
FormattingTechnicalEdit
Check that the workcomplies with theformatting specificationwith respect to font,margins, spacing,indentation, etc.
ReferenceEditing
Check that citations thatappear in the text appearin the final reference listand vice-versa. Checkthat formattingspecifications are met.Randomly cross-checkreferences to check forcopy-and-pasting. Notewhere citations areneeded and/or are
excessive.
NumericalEdit
Edit any data, calculations& equations; double-check both the equationsas well as the finalformatting of thenumbers. Also check thatSI units have been usedthroughout and that anyconversions have beendone accurately.
Figures &GraphicsEdit
Check that all figures arelegible, relevant in gray-scale, and add value tothe text. Check that thecorrect captioningprotocol has beenfollowed for figures &tables and that thecontent of the figures andtables are both accurateand relevant to the text.
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
11/43
Appendices,Acronyms,Indexing &Acknowled
gmentsEdit
Acronyms: ensure thatthe acronyms that havebeen defined appearmore than once in thetext, are commonacronyms and also thatany acronyms in theacronym list appear in thetext.Index: Check that indexedterms that are relevant.Acknowledgments: Checkthat persons listed for theacknowledgments listhave contributedsignificantly to thedevelopment of the
project and research.Appendices: Check thatany appendices listed forinclusions actually appearin the final report, andhave been thoroughlyedited.
Global EditforReadability
Once you have completedthe above, assign a TPmember to read yourChapter and the Chapters
immediately precedingand following for flow,consistency andredundancy.
N.B.:The RM andPFs will bereading throughthe entire
document toaudit it as well.
0.5Report Completion Work BreakdownStructure
[For Shawnas Reference Only]
Task Completion
Strategy
Progress as of
[Date]Executive Summary [See below]Cover DesignMission StatementProject NameOnline Accessibility toResearch SubmissionsAppendicesIndexAcronyms TableGlobal Formatting
Table of Contents,Figures, Tables
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
12/43
Extra pages: Titlepage, copyright page,etc.Acknowledgments
Table
Student PrefaceFaculty PrefaceAuthorship TableAbstractGlobal Reference EditGuide to the ReportStructure for theReader [JFssuggestion; for us todecide Shawna]
0.6Executive Summary Work BreakdownStructure
[For Scott & Shawnas Reference Only]
Task Completion Strategy Progress as of [Date]
Template Design
Title Page Design
CD Cover Design
Text Creation &Integration
Figures Integration
Text Editing
Global Edit of Layout,Text & Figures
Submission to Facultyfor Feedback 3 daysbefore deadline
Submission to JoelHermann
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
13/43
_____________________________________Chapter 1
1 Introduction
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actuallynamed GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePage
Allocation
Chapter 1: Introduction Dag &Shawna
3
1.1Synopsis & Objectives [Note to self: define headings within this chapter: Make this a broadoverview; have a diagram of where we progress; look at previousreports introductions; talk about Why the Moon the Symposium andthis is our solution also distinguish what goes into the StudentPreface and what goes into the intro]
[Make the report direction and content clear]This chapter is intended to set the stage for our report [and to whatextent the project itself?]. Specifically, it will start on the broad scopeof human lunar exploration, what it was (talk about the Cold-War era a space-race for glory and national superiority, what it has become(lunar missions driven by scientific and economic return but keep itbrief! 1-2 sentences max!) and how we have evolved to the currentframework (what drivers led us there? Mention science and theemergence of private sector interest in field). From here, we willexplore the needs of the current framework (multiple needs: e.g.sustainable base, lunar transport, extraction process for fuels, fuel
itself), leading into a specific discussion on the importance of transport& fuel (and how they are necessary for ALL these activities), whatresearch has been conducted thus far (here we bring our mini-litreview) and concluding by exposing the existing literature gap that ourreport will address, allowing us to underline the importance of meetingthis gap, thereby explaining why our report is relevant and timely.
[N.B.: In addition to external literature, here we will also specificallyrefer to past ISU design projects and wha will allow us to develop andhow other areas have been extensively covered: for example the 2000MSS Team Project designed a lunar surface transport system entitledAutonomous Lunar Transport Vehicle while the 2006 Masters class
extensively explored in-situ resource extraction and utilization withFERTILE Moon. NOTE TO SELF, FINISH THIS.
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
14/43
This will lead us in into the discussion of what we will be specificallyaddressing: facilitating post-storage accessibility to specificpropellants necessary for lunar mobility: Hydrogen, Oxygen & H2O. Aspart of this discussion, we will define the scope of our project, stating:
(i) How we defined this topic, summarizing our previous work
and defending the decision to move away from Helium-3(ii) Justify the decision to exclude Low Lunar Orbit and limit the
discussion to the Lunar surface
(iii) Our focus is on Hydrogen, Oxygen and H2O, but we willexplore uses for by-products in later chapters, as part of ourbusiness case.
(iv) The timeframe to which our project applies
In the next section, we will expand upon the drivers, taking into
account:(i) The Exploration roadmaps of the major space agencies
(ii) (Note to self: Place in Chapter 2)
(iii) NOTE: When elaborating upon the plan, talk more aboutBrians idea about analogizing to Earth gas stations.
(iv) NOTE: Look into what other reports have done for otherintroductions and model this upon that
CHAPTER 1 - Introduction
A. Introduction: Setting the Stage for the Project Scopea. What is the purpose of this report? Why is there a need?
What are the drivers? (To be determined)i. Why do we need Oxygen and Hydrogen, who needs
it, in what format and in what quantity? (D&C)b. The timeframe of the project (Seun, D&C)c. Plans & Roadmaps of the major Agenciesd. What has been done? Explain extraction here (D&C)
i. Refer to previous ISU reports (Use the spreadsheeton shared drive that refers to how previous reportsrelate to our project)
ii. Mapping the location of Oxygen and Hydrogendeposits (Wale, D&C)
iii. Identifying the difficulties involved with location(sun exposure, eclipse frequency, temperaturevariations, etc) (Wale, D&C)
iv. Identifying the exploitation methods possible(Hubert, D&C)
v. Identifying the production methods possible(Hubert, D&C)
e. Gap Analysis (To be determined)i. What is missing in this frame work?ii. A Market Analysis, seeking to (D&C):
1. Identify the Customers and their nature2. Evaluate their demand, needs and interest
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
15/43
3. Brief overview of constraints (this isexplained in more detail in the relevant
Technical, Legal and Business sections)f. Definition of Scope & Justification (D&C & PI)
i. What is includedii. What is excluded (include Helium-3, Low Lunar
orbit, and explain why)g. Limitation to Storage, Transport & Delivery of HOx (D&C)
i. Product & Service Overview (Carlos, Kieran, Isra,PI ) [Note this is different from the detaileddescription to be provided in the Business AnalysisSection]
CHAPTER 2 The Plan/Overview (make it clear to Thomas thatthis is an introduction to our entire report, not just the twotechnical chapters)
A. Our proposed solutioni. Definition of mission development Phase (PI)
1. Exposition of typical mission architecturesand where we fit into it
a. How many infrastructures will weneed? (including the factory storage,delivery, gas station, etc.)
b. What about Launch Vehicles?c. Description of the Lunar Surface
2. Where our customers (agencies/companies)plan to land (Seun, D&C)
3. With what vehicles (Dimitrios, D&C)4. With which accuracy (Dimitrios, D&C)5. Which resources (Oxygen/Hydrogen) they
need (Dimitrios, D&C)6. For which purposes (Dimitrios, D&C)7. In what format (gases/liquid) (Dimitrios,
D&C)8. In which quantity (volume/mass) (Dimitrios,
D&C)9. Of which quality (purity) (Dimitrios, D&C)
a. Assumptions (Which groups will be taking part inthis?)
i. Assumption of reliable technology for extraction,production & supply (D&C)
ii. Not storing gaseous form, no density (Stor.)
[Figures & Tables:
Timeline of our proposed project(Seun, D&C)
Lunar maps identifying zones of future hotspots of activity(Seun, D&C)
Quantification of customer needs (Seun, D&C
This section will include a Lunar Map IDing Deposits & by-products (Wale, D&C)
This section will include a Lunar Map IDing proposed productionsites (Wale, D&C)
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
16/43
This section will include a database encompassing all Oxygenand Hydrogen exploitation and production methods according todesired QUANTITY and LOCATION (Hubert, D&C)]
B. Explanation of Approach & Methods for Technical Design (Stor. &
Trans.) (This section needs development)a. The Data (Trans.)i. input standards for sample day in the life of a
refuelling company on Earthb. Models (Trans.)
i. requirements for inputs to set the stage predictions of production, storage and product userlocations, other customer requirements
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
17/43
_____________________________________Chapter 2
2 Project G.A.S. P.U.M.P
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actuallynamed GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePage
Allocation
Chapter 2: Project G.A.S. P.U.M.P. Rodolphe20
2.1Synopsis & Objectives
NOTE: When elaborating upon the plan, talk more about Brians ideaabout analogizing to Earth gas stations
(what are the technical & economic drivers for this)
(start with a diagram)
(define & rationalize the project based on this)
(basically have this section as detailed background information aboutour project)
(assumptions, drivers & consumptions)
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
18/43
_____________________________________Chapter 3
3 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. Architecture &
Its Optimization: Storage
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actually
named GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePage
Allocation
Chapter 3: G.A.S. P.U.M.P. Architecture &Its Optimization: Storage
Dave20
3.1Synopsis & Objectives
Update from Dave:
STORAGE
Abstract1. Introduction1.1 Problem Identified2. Challenges and Potential Solutions2.1. Technologies to Address3. Short Term Solution3.1 LSAM Modifications3.2 Operational Usage4. Long Term Solution5. Discussion and Conclusions
CHAPTER 3 The Details
A. Gap 1: Storage
[D&C will output storage vehicle specifications to Stor.]
[Figures:
Table of Tanks for different uses]a. Introduction (Dave, Stor.)b. Materials
i. Hydrogen (LH2) (Scott, Stor.)
ii. Oxygen (LO2) (Alma, Stor.)iii. Form of storage (water?) (Dave, Stor.)
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
19/43
iv. Liquid 02 and H2 tanks (fixed and mobile) (Scott,Alma, Stor.)
v. (Construction? Lifetime? Strength?) (To bedetermined)
vi. Table of Tanks for different uses: (To be determined)
TankCapacity
TankUsage
TankMaterial
Duration ofStorage
TankShape
Reliability
Designed forAtmosphere/Vacuum
c. Subsystems
i. Outgassing / Venting / Boil Off (Liquid volatiles can't
be stored in open topped craters? Can they? (Notyet assigned, Stor.)
ii. Thermal Control (Not yet assigned, Stor.)iii. Standardized Interfaces (valves, mechanisms)
(Andreea, Stor.)iv. Storage Specifications (To be determined)
1. Design (Calculated capacity, chosenmaterials)
2. Capacity3. Location [To be defined later by Stor.]
vii. Other Issues
1. Quality Control (Not yet assigned, Stor.)2. Maintenance (Not yet assigned,
Stor.)B. Heading 2 Gap 2: Delivery & Distribution Design (Trans.)
[D&C will output delivery vehicle specifications to Trans.]
[Allocation of Trans. Researchers to be inputted]
a. Introduction & Possible Alternativesi. Fixed Infrastructureii. Aerial VS ground ways.iii. Supporting carriage (rail, conveyor, gondola)
b. Mobile Platformsi. Wheeled vehiclesii. Tracked Vehiclesiii. Ballistic Vehiclesiv. Walkersv. Hoppers
c. Criteria for Selection and Trade-Space Analysis
i. Costii. Matching of Customer Needs (delivery time andfrequency, volumes required)
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
20/43
iii. Level of Autonomyiv. Technical Readiness and Feasibility
d. Design Parametersi. eg. distance between storage facilities and product
usersii. Energy Supplyiii. Propulsion Alternativesiv. Otherv. [From Shawna: Put a note for content to include:
criteria used as inputs for the system optimizationtool & reasons for selection]
e. Design of the Delivery Systemi. Propulsion Systemii. Energy Supply Systemiii. Communication Systemiv. Tank & Interface
v. Other
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
21/43
_____________________________________Chapter 4
4 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. Architecture &
Its Optimization: Delivery
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actually
named GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePage
Allocation
Chapter 4: G.A.S. P.U.M.P. Architecture &Its Optimization: Delivery
Thomas20
4.1Synopsis & Objectives
CHAPTER 4 To Maximize the Performance, Durability & Utilityof Our Product
A. Trade-off Studies & Options for System Optimization (Stor. &Trans.)
a. Optimization as a Design Aid; Using Optimization forOperations (Stor. & Sport)
i. Purpose of optimization: Needed to overcomelimitations of current technology, maximizeperformance, etc. (Which group will do this?)
ii. how [computer] modeling is useful for thisapplication to choose between disparate [storageand] delivery systems (fixed and mobile, mannedand unmanned)
b. Location Optimization (Stor.)i. methods for comparing storage locations based on
predicted production facility and customer locationsc. The Engine: Preferred Algorithms
i. describes algorithms suitable for continuoussurface with fixed and moving locations
d. Route Optimization (Trans.)i. methods for comparing delivery system designs
based on predicted routese. Trade-offs for Financial, Technical, Mass & Performance
Optimization (formerly: Optimization Applied to theBusiness Case) (Stor. & Trans.)
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
22/43
i. leads back to the business plan and how thismethod will help management with risk assessmentand predictions
ii. Groups, please note the change to thissections title it will require more analysis S.
B. Technical Risk Assessment & Mitigation Strategies (Stor. &Trans.)
a. Intro to Risks considered (Stor. & Trans.)b. Reliability & Maintenance Operations
i. System design lifeii. Failure prediction and mitigation through planned
maintenancec. Health & Safety Issues
i. Health Monitoring (Sensors, Gauges) (William, Stor.)
ii. Managing Human Safety on the Road (Trans.)iii. describes specific hazards to astronaut health from
cargo and delivery system and mitigation strategies[Note: this section may be unnecessary if wechoose un-crewed transportation]
iv. Environmental Issues (Spill Management) (Laure-Helene, Stor. & UNKNOWN from Trans. who?)
1. describes potential for harm to the lunarenvironment and mitigation, specificallyspills, ground-breaking and wastemanagement
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
23/43
_____________________________________Chapter 5
5 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. The Business
Plan
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actually
named GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePage
Allocation
Chapter 5:G.A.S. P.U.M.P. The BusinessPlan
Jun25
5.1Synopsis & Objectives
[Jun needs data from Storage and Delivery the numericalsolutions (e.g. wrt Storage & Delivery, by-products, marketdemand before he can come up with numbers]
CHAPTER 5 The Business Case
A. Business Analysisa. Business Case Assumptions (Henrik, Kenneth, PI)
i. Private Companiesii. National Government and Private Corporate Entityiii. Multinational Government and Private Corporate
Entityiv. Multinational Government, Private and Venture
Capitalv. Agencies
vi. IAC (Note to PI please clarify what you mean)b. Consider their evolution over time (Note to PI please
clarify what you mean)c. Marketing Analysis (D&C & PI)
i. Industry Overview (Sebastian, D&C & Pierre, PI)1. Perform a Competitors Analysis
d. Detailed Description of Products/By products/Service/Spin-off definition (as opposed to general description in theintroduction) (PI & D&C)
i. Product definition: H2, O2, H2O (Carla, Kieran andIsra)
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
24/43
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
25/43
_____________________________________Chapter 6
6 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. - The Politico-
Legal Perspective
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actually
named GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePage
Allocation
Chapter 6:G.A.S. P.U.M.P. - The Politico-Legal Perspective
Jun & Shawna15
6.1Synopsis & Objectives
CHAPTER 6 Overcoming the Political & Legal Barriers (changetitle)
A. Barriers to Implementation (D&C) (change title to somethingmore along the lines of Short overview of the ExistingLegal Regime))
a. Policy (Violetta, Carlos, PI)i. Objective of the policyii. Political issuesiii. Economiciv. Scientificv. Societal (Kieran)
vi. Private involvement policy issuesb. Politico-Legal Considerations
i. Property rights vs. national propertyii. International Legislation (e.g. OST, Moon Treaty)
(Pierre, D&C)iii. National Trade & Export control regulations. ITAR as
an example (Pierre, D&C)B. LEGAL PROPOSAL (Violetta, Carlos, PI)
a. International Cooperationi. Company structureii. Equity share and funds
b. Commercial utilityi. Short overview of the existing legal regime for
Lunar resources exploitation
c. Enabling legality of the projecti. Exclusively scientific purposes exploitation
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
26/43
ii. Adoption of temporary national legislationiii. Amendment of the Outer Space Treatyiv. Ratification of the Moon agreement, Establishment
of international regime for exploitation of resourcesv. New treaty for exploitation of lunar resources
d. Establishing the framework of contracts awarded to sub-contractors (Eg for Production) (Pierre, D&C)
i. Sample Contract to be awarded to sub-contractors(PI)
C. Business Law (PI) (change title to something morereflective, e.g. Other Legal Considerations)
i. Liabilityii. Insuranceiii. Warranteeiv. Taxesv. Contracts (Models) (P. Imp & Pierre, D&C)
1. Clients
2. Sub-contractorsvi. Certification (PI)
c. Ethical Considerationsi. Planetary Protection Issues
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
27/43
_____________________________________Chapter 7
7 Conclusions &
Recommendations
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actually
named GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePage
Allocation
Chapter 7: Conclusions &Recommendations
Shawna6
7.1Synopsis & Objectives
CHAPTER 7 Conclusions & Recommendations (Should be a grandsynthesis)
A. Conclusion: The Result (Writer To be determined)a. Summary of Needs, Technical Plan, Legal/Technical
Constraints, Plans to overcome Constraints, Benefits)b. Future Directions & Recommendationsc. Concluding Statement
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
28/43
29
_______________________________________Chapter 8
8 Extras
Chapter Title
Note: These are only working titlesonly! Our project is not actuallynamed GAS PUMP!
ChapterManager
TentativePage
Allocation
Chapter 8: Extras (Table of
Contents/Figures/Tables, Appendices,Index, Acronyms, Acknowledgments,Disclaimer, Authors List, 1-pagedabstract & guide to Report Structure forReaders Use)
Shawna25
8.1Synopsis & Objectives
8.2Student Preface
GAS PUMP (General Architectural Structure: Procedures for Usage of MoonPropellants): The Big Picture
During the decades of the Cold War Era, the Space Race pushed humanityto farther frontiers, sending the first humans beyond the confines of theEarth, first to near-Earth space and low-Earth orbits, but eventually to theMoon itself.
Despite the initial pride and excitement stemming from these monumentalachievements, the magnitude of these large-scale ventures provedthemselves to be unsustainable, especially without the competition of the
Cold War as a driver. As a result, the post-Cold War decades bore witness to asignificant decline in interest in ambitious human ventures, amongst thegeneral public and by way of resulting decreases in dedicated funding andresources from national space agencies.
This trend has recently reversed itself as political will and public interest haveonce again come together to reignite an interest in human exploration of theMoon, this time coupled with scientific and economic drivers. For these
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
29/43
29
reasons, NASA, JAXA, and ROSKOSMOS, for example, have all described plansfor establishing a human presence on the Moon within the next 20 years.
Importantly, amidst these plans lies the emerging realization that these newvisions for lunar exploration necessitate pragmatic approaches andmeticulous planning if humanity is to move beyond the previous philosophy
of lunar exploration for thrill and achievement, and into an era of explorationfor scientific and economic gain.
The nature of this new exploration calls for elements necessary to sustainableexploratory missions and eventual lunar bases, including, for example, lifesupport systems, communication networks, mobility methods and reliablepower sources.
The space agencies varied reasons for returning to the Moon and theactivities planned on-site mean that reliable transportation will be a keyelement in navigating the Moon. This is a concept that is well-reviewed in theliterature in several aspects, but not so much in others. For example, the2000 ISU design project, Autonomous Lunar Transport Vehicle, was
dedicated to a lunar transport system for crew and cargo, while the 2006 ISUproject, FERTILE Moon, explored In-Situ Resource Utilization processes forenergy and fuel usage. However, gaps still exist in this field, both within theISU and the external literature.
Realistically, if exploration is to be carried out on a Moon-wide scale, thenbeyond the issue of simple and accessible transport systems and fuelacquisition lies the issue of propellant accessibility: after all, fuel is of no useif it cannot be properly stored and delivered.
The focus of the 2007 ISU design project, then, is exactly that: to design alunar propellant storage and distribution system that is safe, reliable, cost-effective and efficient. The value of this project is two-fold: firstly, thesystems, designed with the utmost care by referencing the existing literatureand experts in numerous fields, provide a fuel-accessibility architecture thatwill be crucial to the success of lunar exploration and mobility. Secondly, thisproject resists obsolescence owing to the development of a systems selectiontool that outputs a best system based on a comparison of existingtechnologies, qualities and assumptions hence it can be modified astechnology evolves to continue to generate the most capable and appropriatesystem for what is required of it.
It is the intent of the GAS PUMP design team that this project will be of theutmost value in supporting lunar exploration and mobility, serving as aninnovation to the future generations of lunar explorers who boldly andbrazenly dare to expand humanitys reach beyond the Earth.
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
30/43
29
9
10
11
Supporting Documents for ChapterWriting
TP-2 Masters 07
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
31/43
29
TABLE OF CONTENTS
0 REPORT CONSOLIDATION PROCEDURES AND TASKS ...................................... ...5
CHAPTERMANAGERS/RESEARCH DIRECTORS PLEASE READ THIS CHAPTER BEFORE
YOU BEGIN .......................................................................................................... 5
1.0 NOTES: ......................................................................................................................... 5
1.1 INSTRUCTIONSFORCHAPTERMANAGERS............... ............... ............................................. 5
0.1 REPORT STATUS.............................................................................................................. 6
0.2 CHAPTERMANAGEMENT WORKBREAKDOWN STRUCTURE................................................... 6
0.3 PART I: BUILDINGTHE CHAPTERFRAMEWORK.................................................................... 7
0.4 PART II: PROCEDUREFORPULLING TOGETHERA PROPERCHAPTER.......................... ............. 80.5 REPORT COMPLETION WORKBREAKDOWN STRUCTURE...................................................... 11
0.6 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY WORKBREAKDOWN STRUCTURE..................................................... 12
1 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................... ......13
1.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES............................................................................................... 13
CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION ................................................................ ..... ..... ...........14
CHAPTER 2 THE PLAN/OVERVIEW (MAKE IT CLEAR TO THOMAS THAT THIS
IS AN INTRODUCTION TO OUR ENTIRE REPORT, NOT JUST THE TWO
TECHNICAL CHAPTERS) ...................................................................................... ..... .....15
2 PROJECT G.A.S. P.U.M.P .................................................................................. ..... ..... ...17
2.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES............................................................................................... 17
3 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. ARCHITECTURE & ITS OPTIMIZATION: STORAGE .............. ...18
3.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES............................................................................................... 18
CHAPTER 3 THE DETAILS ............................................................................... ...........18
4 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. ARCHITECTURE & ITS OPTIMIZATION: DELIVERY ...............21
4.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES............................................................................................... 21
CHAPTER 4 TO MAXIMIZE THE PERFORMANCE, DURABILITY & UTILITY OF
OUR PRODUCT ..................................................................................................... ..... ..... ...21
5 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. THE BUSINESS PLAN .............................................................. ..... ...23
5.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES............................................................................................... 23
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
32/43
29
[JUN NEEDS DATA FROM STORAGE AND DELIVERY THE NUMERICAL
SOLUTIONS (E.G. WRT STORAGE & DELIVERY, BY-PRODUCTS, MARKET
DEMAND BEFORE HE CAN COME UP WITH NUMBERS] .......................... ..... ..... ...23
CHAPTER 5 THE BUSINESS CASE .................................................. ......... ..... ...........23
6 G.A.S. P.U.M.P. - THE POLITICO-LEGAL PERSPECTIVE ................... ..... ..... ..... ...25
6.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES............................................................................................... 25
CHAPTER 6 OVERCOMING THE POLITICAL & LEGAL BARRIERS (CHANGE
TITLE) .......................................................................................................................... ..... ...25
7 CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS .......................................... .............. ..... ...27
7.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES............................................................................................... 27
CHAPTER 7 CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS (SHOULD BE A GRAND
SYNTHESIS) ............................................................................................ ............... ...........27
8 EXTRAS ........................................................................................................ ............... .....28
8.1 SYNOPSIS & OBJECTIVES............................................................................................... 28
8.2 STUDENT PREFACE........................................................................................................ 28
12 TEAM MEMBER NAMES & AFFILIATION ....................................... .............. ..... ...33
14 ACKNOWLEDGMENT TRACKER ................................................. ..... .............. ..... ...34
15 ACRONYM TRACKER ...................................................................................... ...........35
16 PROOF OF PERMISSION SHEET FOR USE OF COPYRIGHTED FIGURES .. .. .37
17 REQUEST FOR PERMISSION OF USE FORM ............................. ..... .............. ..... ...39
APPENDIX TRACKER ......................................................................... ......... .............. .....40
18 INDEX OF TERMS TO BE CROSS-REFERENCED .............................. .............. .....41
19 9 REFERENCES ............................................................................................... ...........43
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
33/43
29
12 Team Member Names & Affiliation
Research Group: ______________________Instructions:Please have all team members fill in the table below exactly as they wouldlike the information to appear in the report.
Name Country Degree University
13
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
34/43
29
14 Acknowledgment Tracker
Research Group: ______________________Instructions:Fill in the Names & Affiliation/Positions of internal & external individuals whohave played a key role in the development of your work.
Acknowledgment Name Position & Affiliation
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
35/43
29
15 Acronym Tracker
Research Group: _____________________
Instructions:
1) Define all acronyms the first time they appear in text ONLY IF THEYARE USED MORE THAN ONCE
2) Use only COMMON acronyms; DO NOT MAKE UP YOUR OWN
3) Verify that each acronym appears in the final version of the text
4) Add rows/delete letters as needed. LEAVE AN EMPTY ROW BETWEEN
THE LAST ACRONYM AND THE NEXT LETTER. MAKE SURE ONLY THELETTER ITSELF IS BOLDED. (See AU example below)
A
AU Astronomical Unit
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
36/43
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
37/43
29
16 Proof of Permission Sheet for Use of Copyrighted Figures
Research Group: ______________________Instructions:
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
38/43
29
It is imperative that we obtain permission for all figures and images weborrow, therefore please be impeccable with your permissions tracking byfilling in this sheet.
Figure/Image
Source PermissionDetails:
Request SentIn?
By Whom?
PermissionGranted?
Proof ofPermission Handed
in toShawna?
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
39/43
29
17 Request for Permission of Use Form
Dear Permissions Editor:
I request permission to use the material specified below from (title ofpublication) in a section of a handbook (give title and name of editor) which Iam preparing, and in future editions or revisions thereof, to be published by(name of publisher).
In particular, I request permission to use [Title, author, and what is to bereprinted].
It is understood, of course, that full credit will be given to your publication,either as a numbered reference in the bibliography, where the citation will begiven in full, or as a footnote or credit line (from (authors name), (title ofbook), (publisher and place), (date of publication), (page numbers)).
Your prompt consideration of this request will be appreciated. For yourconvenience, a release form is given below. The duplicate is for your files.
Yours sincerely,
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------I hereby grant permission for the use of the material requested above.Signature .. Date ..Publisher ..
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
40/43
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
41/43
29
18Index of Terms to be Cross-Referenced
Research Group: ______________________Instructions:
1) Like many previous reports, we will be including an index if our 150-page allowance permits. Therefore, please include list of all terms youwish to appear in the final index, so that we may cross-reference later.
2) Make sure that the term actually appears in your final draft.
3) Add rows/delete letters as needed. LEAVE AN EMPTY ROW BETWEENTHE LAST ACRONYM AND THE NEXT LETTER. MAKE SURE ONLY THE
LETTER ITSELF IS BOLDED.A
Astronomical Unit
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
42/43
29
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z
-
8/15/2019 TP-2 Report Roadmap
43/43
19 9 References