7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

1/9

\h` \{cldoe jf Wbdo

Ghcq|`{ 0 \{cowe{`wwdjo

Uh`o |h` k{j|h`{w c{{dv`l kcgb do Co{) kj|h Ncwb col Id`d u`{` ci{`clt cwi``q)

l`wqd|` |h` fcg| |hc| d| ucw oj| t`| lc{b jp|/ \h`d{ mj|h`{ hcl `xhcpw|`l h`{w`if gc{doe fj{ |h`ed{i) |h`d{ fjjl wpqqid`w ucodoe col |h`d{ uc|`{ kpgb`|w cimjw| `mq|t/

Dii ej hpo|doe do |h` mj{odoe) Ldlp wcdl/ Tjp gco f`|gh |h` uc|`{/ U`v` i`| |hdoewwidl` c id||i` k`gcpw` jf Id`dw q{`w`og`) kp| u` hcv` |j e`| kcgb |j ljdoe |h` |hdoew u` ciuctwlj) joit q`{hcqw uj{bdoe c id||i` hc{l`{ wj |hc| Mj|h`{ dw f{`` |j gjo|dop` |`oldoe Id`d/ Wh`iiidb`it ej jo` uct j{ |h` j|h`{ wjjo) `d|h`{ k`edo |j {`gpq`{c|` j{ qcww jo/ Po|di |h`o) u` gco|gjpo| jo Mj|h`{ |j h`iq pw b``q |hdoew do j{l`{/

Jcvo ucwo| ckjp| |j c{ep`) |d{`l jp| gjmqi`|`it f{jm |h`d{ njp{o`t) `wq`gdciit k`gcpw`h` ucw w|dii c id||i` u`cb`{ fj{ hcvdoe edv`o Id`d hdw kijjl/ H` ldlo| idb` |h` fcg| |hc| Ldlphcl gcwpciit wpee`w|`l Id`d mdeh| ld`) kp| h` ldlo| hcv` |h` w|{`oe|h |j fdeh| hdw k{j|h`{ jo|hc| qjdo|/ Jcvo `xgpw`l d| jo |h` kcwdw |hc| Ldlp gi`c{it ldlo| f``i v`{t dov`w|`l do |h`d{ uc{l) poidb` Jcvo ldl/ H` l{cee`l hdw u`c{t kjlt |j k`l) gjiicqwdoe do c gc{`i`ww h`cq coli`||doe wi``q |cb` hdm dmm`ldc|`it/

Uh`o h` cujb` o`x| mj{odoe) Jcvo f`i| mj{` {`f{`wh`l |hco h` ucw `xq`g|doe |j/Ldlp ucw ijoe ejo`) hcvdoe i`f| k`fj{ wpo-pq/ H` hcl oj| kj|h`{`l |j {jpw` hdw tjpoe`{

k{j|h`{ k`fj{` l`qc{|doe/ Jcvo hcl jv`{wi`q| cw c {`wpi| col ucw ic|` i`cvdoe |j f`|gh |h` uc|`{/H` w|{peei`l |j hdw f `|) w|dii e{jeet) col w|pmki`l do|j |h` gjmmpoci c{`c jf |h` |`o|/ \j hdwldwmct) |h` uc|`{ kpgb`|w u`{` ejo` cijoe ud|h Ldlpw hpo|doe e`c{/ Ncwb hcl oj ljpk|l`gdl`l |j i`| hdm wi``q col hcl ucol`{`l jff |j ec|h`{ |h` uc|`{ jo h`{ juo/ H` k`{c|`lhdmw`if fj{ fcdidoe |j wqc{` h`{ |h` `ffj{|/ Uhdi` hdw mj|h`{ ucw w|dii w|{joe col l`|`{mdo`l) wh`ucw oj| cw tjpoe cw wh` pw`l |j k` col hcl k``o u`c{doe h`{w`if jp| jv`{ Id`d) wjm`|hdoe h`gjowdl`{`l hdw {`wqjowdkdid|t/ Ldlp ujpil k` ldwcqqjdo|`l do Jcvo df h` bo`u h` hclo| ljo`|h` jo` |hdoe hdw k{j|h`{ hcl cwb`l/

Jcvo gjowdl`{`l fjiijudoe cf|`{ hdw mj|h`{) kp| h` bo`u wh` ujpilo| cqq{jv` jf hdmi`cvdoe Id`d cijo`/ Do h`{ f`v`{dwh w|c|`) wh` gjpil {dw` col ucol`{ jp| jf |h` |`o|) oj| spd|` doh`{ {deh| mdol/ Dow|`cl) h` w|jjl do |h` gjmmpoci c{`c) |j{o k`|u``o fcgdoe |h` d{ jf hdw k{j|h`{ col gcpwdoe hdw mj|h`{ ldwqi`cwp{`) qj|`o|dciit qicgdoe Id`d c| {dwb do |h` q{jg`ww/

\j cll ldw|{cg|djo |j ldi`mmc) wjf| wjpolw jf wpff`{doe k`eco |j `m`{e` f{jm Ncwbw k`l{jjm) qicdo|dv` id||i` ojdw`w |hc| qp| Jcvo dii c| `cw`/ Oju) do clld|djo |j uco|doe |j lj {deh| kt kj|h hdw k{j|h`{ col mj|h`{) h` ciwj uco|`l |j gjmfj{| Id`d po|di hdw mj|h`{ {`|p{o`l) k{`cbdoe h`{ {pi` do |h` q{jg`ww/ F{pw|{c|`l) h` qcg`l col |{d`l |j deoj{` |h` wjpolw gjmdoe f{jm|h` j|h`{ {jjm/

7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

2/9

D| ucwo| cw `cwt cw |h` icw| |dm` h` hcl k``o i`f| cijo` do |h` |`o| ud|h Id`d/ H` hcl k``o |jj u`cb |j {`wqjol |j h`{ c| |hc| mjm`o|) col uhdi` h` hcl k``o |`mq|`l |j ej |j h`{ |h`o|jj) d| hcl oj| {`spd{`l cot {`ci udii jo hdw qc{| |j {`wdw|) |jj wq`o| |j lj wj/ \hdw |dm` h` ucwcki`-kjld`l col fpiit {`w|`l/ @cgh o`u wjpol |pee`l c| hdm cw df |h` w|{joe`w| jf k{cdl`l-hdl`{jq` hcl k``o icwwj`l c{jpol hdw mdlli` col b`q| l{cudoe hdm do |juc{l |h` |ckjj/

Df joit h` gjpil hcv` gjpo|`l jo Ldlp col*j{ Ncwb {`|p{odoe q{jmq|it) h` mdeh| hcv` k``o cki` |j fdol |h` doo`{ w|{`oe|h |j b``q f{jm ldwjk`tdoe hdw mj|h`{/ H` hcl oj dl`c)hju`v`{) hju ijoe |h` qcd{ hcl k``o ejo` col hju ijoe d| ujpil k` k`fj{` |h`d{ { |p{o/ \hc|)col Id`dw qcdo`l mjcow b`q| e{judoe do vjipm` col f{`sp`ogt/ W|dii) hdw udii ldl oj| k{`cb po|di c wdoei` uj{l gcii`l jp| f{jm Ncwbw {jjm/

Uc|`{///

\h` cdidoe tjpoe ujmco wcdl d| fd{w| do h`{ oc|dv` |joep`) col |h`o |j Jcvow wp{q{dw`

wh` wcdl d| do |h` ldci`g| jf Co{) h`{ l`mcolw e{judoe mj{` l`wq`{c|` ud|h `cgh o`u qi`c/Qi`cw`///qi`cw`///uc|`{///

H` w|jjl w|jgb w|dii do |h` g`o|{` jf |h` |`o|) ucv`{doe/ H` f`i| g{p`i) l`otdoe h`{/ Hdwmj|h`{ hcl `mq|d`l |h` icw| jf |h` kpgb`|w gjo|`o|w do|j c epbwd gpq col d| {`w|`l c|jq |h` ic{e`w|jf h`{ gjv`{`l kcwb`|w) |h`{` fj{ |h` |cbdoe/ D| ujpil k` npw| c mc||`{ jf spdgbit gc{{tdoe d| do |j|h` tjpoe ujmco) i`||doe h`{ l{dob col |h`o i`cvdoe cecdo/ H` ujpil joit k` |h`{` k{d`fit - cf`u w`gjolw) c mdop|` j{ |uj c| mjw|/ \h` {pi` ucw c wdiit jo` cotuct/ H` qjw`l oj |h{ c| |jId`d col wh` ujpil k` e{c|`fpi |j w`` hdm df h` ucw gc{{tdoe do |h` v`{t |hdoe wh` {`sp`w|`l){c|h`{ |hco k`doe pqw`|/ Hju gjpil hdw mj|h`{ fcpi| hdm fj{ |hc|:

Qi`cw`///

Fjiiju tjp{ h`c{|) Icdk Jimcd hcl wcdl/ Jcvow h`c{| ucw |`iidoe hdm |j k{doe Id`d|h` uc|`{) ciiju h`{ |j sp`ogh h`{ |hd{w| col `ol c| i cw| |hc| mpgh jf h`{ wpff`{doe/ H` bo`u d|ujpil k` ldwjk`tdoe hdw mj|h`{ col h` hcl o`v`{ ljo` |hc| k`fj{`) kp| ic|`it hdw {`ic|djowhdqud|h hdw mj|h`{ hcl k`gjm` mpgh mj{` gjmqidgc|`l col h` sp`w|djo`l uh`|h`{) cw co clpi|) h`whjpil ciuctw gjog`l` |j h`{ udwh`w/ Df h` u`{` ejdoe |j k` c q{jq`{ mco) df h` u`{` ejdoe |j

k` c ojcdld) uhdgh m`co| k`doe c i`cl`{ {c|h`{ |hco c fjiiju`{) ucwo| h` ejdoe |j hcv` |j mcb`l`gdwdjow |hc| ujpil gjofidg| ud|h |h` uco|w jf j|h`{w/ Mctk` d| ucw ckjp| |dm` h` | w|`l |hjw`

kjpolc{d`w/

Fjiiju tjp{ h`c{|) Jcvo {`q`c|`l/

\h`o h` mcl` c ghjdg`) l`gdldoe |j e{co| Id`dw {`sp`w| {c|h`{ |hco jkide` hdw mj|h`{w{pidoe/ H` e{cwq`l |h` epbwd gpq fd{mit do hdw hcol col) gc{`fpi oj| |j wqdii d|) gc{{d`l d| do|j hdwmj|h`{w {jjm/ H` cqq{jcgh`l Id`d uh`{` wh` ucw itdoe wq{cui`l do |h` fp{w jo |h` k`l) |h`tjpoe ujmco |udw|doe col w|{`|ghdoe do co powpgg`wwfpi c||`mq| |j e`| gjmfj{|cki`/

7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

3/9

Tjp uco|`l uc|`{: h` wcdl wjf|it/

Wh` {`cgh`l fj{ |h` gpq ud|h |{ mkidoe fdoe`{w) h`{ fcg` fipwh`l col h`{ `t`w eicwwt/ H`ucw wp{q{dw`l c| |h` w|{`oe|h wh` pw`l |j qipgb d| f{jm hdw e{cwq) `xq`g|doe h`{ |j k` u`cb cf|`{ wpgh c w`v`{` donp{t fjiiju`l kt lctw jf f`v`{/ Jog` do hcol) wh` epiq`l d| ljuo `ce`{it/

Uhdi` h` ucw eicl |hc| h` hcl k``o cki` |j h`iq h`{) h` dmm`ldc|`it {`e{`||`l ejdoe do/I`cvdoe cecdo ucw ejdoe |j k` ldffdgpi|/ Wh` ijjb`l wj f{cedi` c| |hc| mjm`o|) wj o``lt) |hc| h`hcl |j fdeh| hc{l |j { wdw| |h` l`wd{` |j w|ct col b``q h`{ gjmqcot/ H`{ i`e ucw ijjbdoe k`||`{)col npw| cw hdw mj|h`{ hcl l`wg{dk`l) d| ldl oj| w``m |j hcv` cot wj{| jf dof`g|djo/ O`v`{|h`i`ww)Id`dw wbdo ucw l{t col v`{t hj| |j |h` |jpgh col wh` ucw wbd||dwh) q`{hcqw c id||i` l`ipwdjoci

k`gcpw` jf |h` f`v`{/ Bojudoe h` hcl ci{`clt jv`{w|`qq`l |h` ido` hdw mj|h`{ hcl w`| uh`{` d|gcm` |j Id`d) Jcvo |p{o`l |j ej/

Oj| `xq`g|doe cot|hdoe |j hjil hdm kcgb) Jcvo cimjw| f`ii jv`{ uh`o c fd{m e{dq nc{{`l

hdm |j c w|jq/ \hdobdoe h` hcl q`{hcqw gcpeh| hdw eb|d jo wjm` q{j|{pldoe jkn`g|) h` |udw|`l |jf{`` hdmw`if) joit |j fdol |hc| d| ucw Id`d uhj hcl k{jpeh| hdm |j c wpll`o hci|/ Wh` hcl hdwec{m`o| h`il wj |deh|it do h`{ wmcii hcol |hc| h` ldlo| |hdob h` ujpil k` cki` |j ej cotuh`{`ud|hjp| fj{g`fpiit q{tdoe h`{ fdoe`{w ijjw`) j{ l{ceedoe h`{ cijoe ud|h hdm/

D hcv` |j ej) h` |jil h`{/ Dm oj| wpqqjw`l |j k` do h`{`/ Mt mj|h`{ wcdl D whjpilo|gjm` do/

Id`d whjjb h`{ h`cl col kd| h`{ idq) {`fpwdoe |j i`| ej/ Wh` w|c{`l pq c| hdm ud|h qicdo|dv` `t`w) |{tdoe |j l{cu hdm gijw`{ |j h`{/ Qi`cw`///w|ct/

\h`{` ucw wjm`|hdoe u{joe ckjp| h`{) wjm`|hdoe jff) kp| Jcvo ghjgb`l |hc| pq |jwtmq|jmw jf |h` f`v`{/ C| |hc| qjdo|) h` w|dii hcl `v`{t do|`o|djo jf i cvdoe) kp| h` ucwo| ckjp||j whcb` h`{ jff hdm do cot vdji`o| uct/ H` w|jjq`l |j e`o|it qpii h`{ hcol cuct) kp| wh` mcl`pw` jf |h` fcg| |hc| |hdw qp| hdm jff kcicog`/ Wh` ecv` hdm c fd{m tcob col h` |jqqi`l |j hdwbo``w k`wdl` h`{/

Id`d D boju tjp{` q{jkckit ijo`it) kp| D |jil tjp) Dm oj| wpqqjw`l |j k` h`{`/Mj|h`{ q{jkckit ujo| k` ijoe/ D| ucw |cbdoe mjw| jf Jcvow udiiqju`{ |j {`wdw| h`{ ciip{`)`onjtdoe |h` wdeh| jf h`{ v`o |hjpeh h`{ gh``bw u`{` {`ll`o`l col h`{ hcd{ |pwwi l/ D| ucw `v`ohc{l`{ |j lj uh`o wh` w``m`l wj ce`{ |j hcv` hdm w|ct/ H` w|{peei`l cw mpgh ud|h hdmw`if cw

h` ldl ud|h h`{/

Wh` deoj{`l |hdw) qpiidoe h`{w`if gijw`{ |j hdm col idf|doe h`{ f{`` hcol |j |jpgh hdw gh``b/Wh` ldlo| w``m |j gc{` |hc| |hdw mjv`m`o| widl h`{ f{`` jf |h` fp{w |hc| hcl k``o gjv`{doe h`{)h`{ iju`{ |j{wj w|dii whd`il`l kt h`{ uhd|` l``{wbdo) kp| h`{ pqq`{ |j{wj oju `xqjw`l/ H`{ kip``t`w `o|{`c|`l hdw juo k{juo jo`w/

W|ct/// Jcvo) wh` mp{mp{`l/

7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

4/9

H` bo`u h` ucw do l``q |{jpki`/ Hdw h`c{| qjpol`l col h` fjpol hdmw`if ijw| do |h`|jpgh col |h` wm`ii jf h`{ |h` wjf|`w| jf wbdo col c wg`o| wj k`ud|ghdoe wh` gjpil |`ii hdm |j ljcot|hdoe col h` ujpil cgspd`wg`/ Wh` hcl {`m`mk`{`l hdw ocm`) hcl wqjb`o d| cw df wh`do|`ol`l |j `owj{g`i hdm kt |{cqqdoe hdw `ww`og`) col do c uct wh` hcl/ H` ucw qju`{i`ww |j{`wdw| h`{ cotmj{`/ Df wh` uco|`l hdm |j w|ct) h` ujpil w|ct) oj mc||`{ uhc| hdw mj|h`{ hcl |jilhdm/

Id`d eidl`l h`{ hj| fdoe`{|dqw f{jm hdw gh``b |j hdw mjp|h) k{pwhdoe hdw idqw l`idgc|`it k`fj{` i`codoe do |j bdww hdm/ Hdw uhji` kjlt spdv`{`l cw wh` widl h`{ c{mw c{jpol hdm colgc{`ww`l hdw |joep` ud|h h`{ juo/ H` uco|`l |j qdogh hdmw`if |j mcb` wp{` h` ucwo| w|dii do hdw

k`l l{`cmdoe) kp| h`{ w|`cmt bdww`w col |h` |h{pmmdoe jf hdw h`c{| wpee`w|`l j|h`{udw`/ @d|h`{ ujpil hcv` ujb`o hdm pq hcl |h`t oj| k``o |{p` |j idf`/ H` hcl o`v`{ `xq`{d`og`l mjw| jf |h`w`owc|djow wh` ucw dofidg|doe pqjo hdm) col |h`t cii f`i| kidwwfpiit {`ci/

\j |`ii |h` |{p|h) Jcvo ucwo| wp{` uhc| hcl k{jpeh| jo h`{ wpll`o do|`{`w|/ H` hclo|

hcl |h` jqqj{|pod|t |j ujj h`{/ Cwdl` f{jm whjj|doe h`{) gc{{tdoe h`{ kcgb |j Co{ col h`iqdoeud|h h`{ dod|dci |{`c|m`o| fj{ |h` ujpol h` hcl gcpw`l) h` hclo| k``o c{jpol h`{ ijoe `ojpeh |j{`ciit e`| |j boju h`{/ Col t`|) oju h` ucw ijgb`l do c h`c|`l `mk{cg` ud|h c ujmco h` fjpol

qhtwdgciit d{{`wdw|dki col fcwgdoc|doe jo wj mcot i`v`iw/

Uh`o h`{ idqw i`f| hdw mjp|h |j |{cg` hdw ncu-ido` ud|h |dot bdww`w col odkki`w) cw df wh`g{cv`l |h` |cw|` jf hdw wci|t fi`wh) oju lj||`l ud|h q`{wqd{c|djo) h` m`i|`l do|j h`{ ud|h c spd`|mjco/ H` hcl o`v`{ ej||`o |hdw gijw` |j c ujmco/ C |p{kpi`o| m`ww jf {cu mj|djo col cvc{d`|t jf dog{`ldki` o`u f``idoew) `v`{t o`{v` `i`g|{dfd`l) wq{poe pq dowdl` hdm/ H`{ `ffj{|w |jw`lpg` hdm u`{` cucb`odoe co dow|dog|pci k`cw| ud|hdo) cbdo |j |h` mjow|`{ |hc| hcl {ce`l

cecdow| |h` mco uhj hcl cwwcpi|`l hdw mj|h`{) joit ud|h mpgh mj{` qi`cwco| gjow`sp`og`w/Jcvo ucw g`{|cdoit fdeh|doe c ijwdoe kc||i` fj{ gjo|{ji/

Uh`o wh` qcpw`l |j k`edo |peedoe c| hdw eb|d col i`eedoew) |{tdoe |j dod|dc|` |h`d{ {`mjvci) h` mcl` jo` icw| `ffj{| |j k{doe |h`d{ wjjo-|j-k` |{cowe{`wwdjo |j co `ol/ H` e`o|it

qpwh`l h`{ cuct) uhdi` hdw gjowgd`og` ujpil w|dii ciiju d|/ H` q{jkckit whjpil hcv` qicg`l hdwhcolw jo h`{ whjpil`{w |j hjil h`{ kcgb) kp| h` f`c{`l |hc| cot fp{|h`{ gjo|cg| ud|h h`{ ujpilwq`ii co `ol |j cot {`wdw|cog` h` hcl i`f|/

Id`d///tjp{` k`cp|dfpi) kp|///

H`{ `t`w ficwh`l udilit col wpll`oit d| ucw c hpoe{t id||i` codmci k`fj{` hdm cw jqqjw`l|j c f`v`{dwh tjpoe ujmco) jo` poudiidoe |j cgg`q| oj/ Wh` fipoe h`{w`if c| hdm) gidoedoe |jhdm ud|h uhc| Jcvo gjpil joit l`wg{dk` cw c wpq`{oc|p{ci w|{`oe|h do jo` wj wideh| col f{cedi`-ijjbdoe/ H` gjpil hcv` `cwdit jv`{qju`{`l h`{) fj{g`l h`{ cuct df h` |{pit uco|`l |j {`fpw` h`{)

kp| h` ldlo| uco| |j/ H` fjpol h`{ q{jxdmd|t do|jxdgc|doe) hdw kjlt {`wqjoldoe |j h`{ clvcog`wuh`|h`{ h` idb`l d| j{ oj|/ H`{ hpoe`{ ucw gjo|cedjpw/

7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

5/9

W`owdoe |h` ghcoe` do hdw e{judoe do|`{`w|) wh` kp{d`l h`{ fcg` do hdw gh`w| cw wh` gipoe |jhdm) k{`c|hdoe do l``qit/

Tjp wm`ii idb` Hcild) wh` mjco`l/ Tjp ijjb idb` c mco) tjp hcv` c mcow uctw) kp||h`{`w wjm`|hdoe ckjp| tjp - wjm`|hdoe pol`{ |h` wp{fcg` - |hc| dw l`fdod|`it Hcild/ Wh` |jjb

coj|h`{ l``q k{`c|h/ Wu``|) q`{f`g| Hcild/

\h`o h`{ mjp|h ucw jo hdw cecdo) joit oj| cw e`o|i` |hdw |dm`/ K`|u``o qco|doe ecwqwh`{ |joep` ucw w`c{ghdoe col q{tdoe) cw df wh` uco|`l |j gidmk dowdl` jf hdm |h{jpeh hdw mjp|h/H`{ hcolw qpii`l c| hdw gij|hdoe cecdo) dowdw|`o| |hdw |dm`) |h{`c|`odoe |j |`c{ |h`m f{jm hdw kjltdf |h`t ldl oj| gjm` jff kt j|h`{ m`cow/ Jcvo ldl oj| qpwh h`{ cuct |hdw |dm`/ Dow|`cl h`u{deei`l col w|{cdo`l |j h`iq h`{ ud|h h`{ `ffj{|w) wh`lldoe hdw eb|d col i`eedoew cw spdgbit cw

qjwwdki`/ Oj ijoe`{ fdeh|doe h`{ do cotuct) Jcvo ucw oju c udiidoe qc{|dgdqco|/

Cii |hjpeh|w jf hdw mj|h`{w {pi`w) cii gjog`{o ckjp| |h` q{jq{d`|t jf |h` wd|pc|djo) u`{`

|h{pw| jp| jf hdw mdol/ H` ijoe`l fj{ Id`d) `v`{t dogh jf hdw kjlt cgh`l fj{ h`{) col h`gjpilo| {`cwjo hdmw`if do|j w|{peeidoe cecdow| |hc| cotmj{`/ Td`ildoe |j codmci dow|dog|) Jcvockcoljo`l hdmw`if |j ipw| col `v`{t dogidoc|djo d| `vjb`l ud|hdo hdm/

Qjww`ww`l kt wpgh c qju`{fpi) cii-`ogjmqcwwdoe dow|dog|) d| {`deo`l jv`{ Jcvow `v`{tcg| f{jm |hc| mjm`o| jo) `v`o qju`{fpi w|dii |hco |h` cee{`wwdjo |hc| hcl jog` cimjw| i`l hdm |jbdii c mco/ Cw wjjo cw Id`d oj|dg`l |hc| h` hcl edv`o jv`{ |j |hjw` p{e`w) wh` {`i`cw`l hdm)wqictdoe h`{w`if jp| do |h` fp{w do dovd|c|djo/ Wh` ldl oj| o``l |j q{jmq| hdm fp{|h`{) l`wqd|` hdwdo`xq`{d`og`/ H` w`d~`l h`{ {jpehit) fjiijudoe h`{ ljuo do|j |h` fp{w col qpwhdoe cwdl` |h`l``{wbdo |hc| w|dii gjv`{`l h`{ f{jm |h` ucdw| ljuo/

Id`d wdeh`l col mp{mp{`l `xgd|`l uj{lw cw h` |{cg`l h`{ kjlt ud|h hdw |joep`/ Mcotjf |hjw` uj{lw Jcvo ujpil oj| hcv` k``o cki` |j pol`{w|col hcl h` k``o cki` |j h`c{ |h`m)|`{mw hdw mj|h`{ ujpil hcv` o`v`{ pw`l c{jpol hdm do h`{ oc|dv` |joep`/ Cii p||`{cog`w u`{`ijw| jo hdm) hju`v`{) jkwgp{`l kt |h` wjpol jf |h` kijjl {pwhdoe |h{jpeh hdw `c{w) |h` vdji`o|

qjpoldoe jf hdw h`c{| col c iju e{jui |hc| hcl w|c{|`l c| |h` kcgb jf hdw |h{jc| col ucw ojue{judoe do vjipm`/ H` ldl oj|dg` uh`o wh` g{d`l jp| hdw ocm`) kpgbdoe cecdow| hdm) kp| |hc|

npw| fp`i`l hdw f{co|dg clvcog`w jo h`{ cii |h` mj{`/ H` qico|`l hdw hcolw fd{mit jo h`{ hdqw colud|h gi`ogh`l ncu) k`eco |j {jpehit |h{pw| do|j h`{/

\h` wc|dwfcg|djo f{jm `o|`{doe h`{ ucw dow|co|co`jpw) c {pwh |hc| `idgd|`l ijpl`{ e{juiwf{jm l``q ud|hdo hdw gh`w| col c hpe` ucv` jf cl{`ocido`/ Cot fc|dep` f{jm |h` q{dj{ lctw|{cv`iw ucw ijoe ejo`) col cot |hjpeh|w jf cot|hdoe k`tjol uhc| ucw hcqq`odoe |j hdm c| |hc|v`{t mjm`o| hcl k``o ldwmdww`l ud|h |h` fd{w| |h{pw|/ Hdw kjlt ucw mj{` cidv` |hco h` hcl `v`{ {`m`mk`{`l d| k`doe k`fj{`) c mcww jf |ud|ghdoe mpwgi`w) w|{cdodoe wdo`uw col c{jpw`l o`{v`w/H` ucw cuc{` jf oj|hdoe kp| Id`d col hdw juo kjlt) kidol |j cii kp| h`{ dovdej{c|doe fj{m)l`cf |j cii kp| h`{ wjf| g{d`w col l`mcoldoe mjcow) pocki` |j f``i cot|hdoe kp| h`{ mjdw|) qidco|wbdo/

7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

6/9

Wh` m`| hdm mjv`m`o| fj{ mjv`m`o|) c fd`{g` lcog` |hc| i`f| |h`m ud|h fdoe`{w |coei`ldo mpww`l hcd{ col wu`c|t idmkw `o|udo`l ud|h spciit wu`c|t idmkw/ Jcvo) wpkn`g| joit |jhdw k`w|dci dmqpiw`w) f`i| hdw k{`c|h gjmdoe do e{`c| ecwqw cw h` {jw` |juc{lw gidmcx/ Ud|hjp|gjowpi|doe Id`d) h` ud|hl{`u) fidqq`l h`{ jv`{ col qipoe`l do|j h`{ cw jo` codmci ujpilmjpo| coj|h`{) ldeedoe hdw fdoe`{w do|j |h` qci` fi`wh jf h`{ kcgb col woc{idoe do udil qi`cwp{`/

Cimjw| dmm`ldc|`it) h` f`i| h`{ |`ow` col spdv`{ k`o`c|h hdm) h`{ spd`| mjcow`xghcoe`l fj{ |h{jc|t g{d`w |hc| i f| h`{ hjc{w`/ Wh` gip|gh`l c| |h` fp{w k`o`c|h h`{) c{ghdoe h`{

kcgb/ D| l{`u c {`wqjow` f{jm hdw juo kjlt) hdw `x|{`md|d`w |doeidoe cw h` `xqijl`l do|j h`{)`xhcpw|doe `v`{t icw| jpog` jf ipw|fpi `o`{et do |h` q{jg`ww/ H` gjiicqw`l do|j |h` fp{w o`x| |jh`{) w|dii {jkk`l jf cot hdeh`{ {`cwjodoe col gjo|{jii`l joit kt codmci dow|dog|/

Cw co dovcwdv` l{juwdo`ww dofdi|{c|`l hdw kjlt) h` {`w|`l hdw mjp|h jo h`{ whjpil`{ cole`o|it w|{jb`l |h` ljuot wbdo jf h`{ c{mw ud|h hdw fdoe`{|dqw/ Wh` w|c{`l do|j hdw fcldoe ec~`ud|h hcif-idll`l `t`w jf kip`) h`{ qpqdiw w|dii ldic|`l/ \jpghdoe |h` wq{dobidoe jf hcd{ jo hdw

gh`w|) wh` p||`{`l c wjpol |hc| {`mdol`l hdm jf qp{{doe) c l`gic{c|djo jf gjmqi`|` gjo|`o|m`o|/H` wmdi`l) c f{cem`o| jf `mj|djo do c w`c jf qhtwdgci {`wqjow`w) c hdo| jf Jcvo |h` mco dow|`cljf |h` wcvce` |hdoe |hc| hcl npw| edv`o do |j qp{`) poclpi|`{c|`l ipw|/ H` gipoe |j |hc| mj{w`i jf uc{m|h col cff`g|djo cw wi``q jv`{gcm` hdm) oj| hcvdoe `ojpeh w`ow` c| |hc| mjm`o| |j`x|{dgc|` hdmw`if f{jm hdw mj|h`{w k`l/ Hcl h` k``o do hdw {deh| mdol h` ujpil hcv` {jii`lcuct f{jm h`{ col g{`q| kcgb |j hdw juo wqcg` ud|hdo |h` |`o|) k`fj{` cotjo` hcl |h`jqqj{|pod|t |j {`|p{o col gc|gh hdm |h`{` ud|h h`{/

\dm` qcww`l) mdop|`w c| i`cw|) kp| hju ijoe `xcg|it) h` ldl oj| boju/

Jcvo {jpw`l |j |h` wjpol jf wjm`jo` `o|`{doe |h` |`o|) col fj{ c mjm`o|) h` fj{ej|uh`{` h` ucw) |hdobdoe h` w|dii {`w|`l do hdw juo k`l/ D| ucwo| po|di h` h`c{l |h` whpffidoe jf f``|) k`tjol |h` w`g|djo jf |`o| h` ucw do) gjm` |j co ck{pq| hci| |hc| h` vcep`it {`gcii`l h` ucwwjm`uh`{` j|h`{ |hco uh`{` h` ucw wpqqjw`l |j k`/ H` fjpeh| ud|h hdw e{jeedo`ww) |{tdoe |j

kj|h jq`o hdw `t`w col |j fdep{` jp| uhc| ucw ejdoe jo |h{jpeh c hc~` jf fjeet m`mj{d`w/ D|ucwo| po|di h` h`c{l hdw mj|h`{ gi`c{ h`{ |h{jc| col f`i| wideh| mjv`m`o| f{jm |h` uc{m|h o`x||j hdm |hc| d| cii w|c{|`l |j gjm` kcgb |j hdm/ Kt |h` |dm` h` hcl q{jq`{it gjm` |j hdw w`ow`w) d|ucw |jj ic|`/ K`fj{` h` hcl |h` ghcog`w |j powqjjo hdmw`if f{jm Id`d h` h`c{l hdw mj|h`{ gciihdw ocm`/

Jcvo:Wh` ldl oj| wjpol coe{t npw| t |/ H` f{j~`/ Whjpil h` |{t |j e`| pq col l{`ww hdmw`if

spdgbit: Whjpil h` e{ck hdw gij|hdoe col |{t |j hdl` po|di wh` i`f| cecdo: Ucw |h`{` cot j|h`{ `wgcq` cvcdicki` |j hdm) k`fj{` hdw mj|h`{ ldwgjv`{`l npw| hju kclit h` hcl k{jb`o h`{ {pi`:

Id`d w|d{{`l wideh|it kp| {`mcdo`l wi``qdoe/ H`{ wbdo ucw uc{m col mjdw| |j |h` |jpgh)oj ijoe`{ |h` hj| l{t d| hcl k``o/ H`{ f`v`{ hcl k{jb`o/ Wh` wdeh`l wjf|it) c spd`| hcqqt wjpol

7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

7/9

col wopeei`l do gijw`{ |j Jcvo/ H` gjowdl`{`l hju mpgh h` ujpil k` `onjtdoe |hc| mjm`o|)u`{` h` oj| do wpgh c qcodg ckjp| gjof{jo|doe hdw mj|h`{/

Cf|`{ c qcpw` f{jm Ncwb) mj{` whpffidoe fjiiju`l/ Jcvo h`il hdw k{`c|h/

Jcvo: wh` {`q`c|`l) kp| |hdw |dm` |h` |jo` jf h`{ vjdg` hcl ghcoe`l/ Wh` wjpol`lgjog`{o`l) col q`{hcqw c |cl wpwqdgdjpw/

Jcvo wh{cob kcgb cecdow| Id`d/ Fj{ |h` mjm`o|) h` ldlo| { e{`| |h` l`gdwdjo h` hclmcl`) kp| |hc| gjpil ghcoe` spdgbit jog` hdw mj|h`{ fjpol jp|/ H` eicog`l kcgb c| Id`d coljo` ijjb c| h`{ qicgdl fcg`) {jwt jog` cecdo dow|`cl jf fipwh`l) mcl` c qi`cwco| whdv`{ {po|h{jpeh hdm/

C whc{q ojdw`) |h` {pw|i` jf l{cq`l hdl` k`doe qpwh`l cwdl`) l{`u hdw c||`o|djo kcgb |j |h`jqqjwd|` wdl` jf |h` |`o|/ Hdw mj|h`{ w|jjl do |h` `o|{cog` |j h`{ {jjm) ecqdoe c| |h` wg`o`

k`fj{` h`{ do ldwmct/

Oj) Jcvo) oj/ D hcl mcl` |hc| {pi` fj{ c {`cwjo///

Ncwb ucw wj pqw`| wh` gjpil oj| fdol |h` uj{lw |j fdodwh |hjpeh|/ \h`{` ucw ojuh`{` fj{ Jcvo |j hdl` oj uct fj{ hdm |j cvjdl |h` hjw|di` `xq{`wwdjo hdw mj|h`{ uj{` jo h`{ fcg`/

Ljo| tjp w``: \hdw ucwo| wjm`|hdoe D uco|`l |j hcqq`o/ D `xq`g|`l wjm`|hdoe idb`|hdw f{jm Ldlp) kp| o`v`{ f{jm tjp/ Tjp u`{` |h` jo` D gjpil ciuctw l`q`ol jo |j idw|`o |jm`/ Uht) Jcvo) uht: Ncwb ldlo| |{t |j hdl` |h` ldwcqqjdo|m`o| do h`{ vjdg`/ Wh` eicog`lcoxdjpwit f{jm h`{ wjo |j |h` oju {jpwdoe Id`d) col |h`o kcgb cecdo/ \hdw udii ghcoe``v`{t|hdoe fj{ tjp/

Pol`gdl`l cw |j uh`|h`{ h` ucw ejdoe |j k` {`k`iidjpw j{ {`q`o|co|) Jcvo widl co c{mc{jpol Id`d) pogjowgdjpwit uco|doe |j whd`il h`{ f{jm hdw mj|h`{w u{c|h/ Kp| Ncwb ldlo|w``m |j hjil Id`d c| fcpi| do cot uct/ \h` k{po| jf d| ucw cii jo hdm/

D| ucwo| idb` D mcl` h`{ lj cot|hdoe cecdow| h`{ udii/ Wh` ucw |hd{w|t/ Wh` ucw k`eedoe fj{ uc|`{/ Dm wj{{t df D k{jb` tjp{ {pi`) kp| D ucwo| ckjp| |j {`fpw` h`{ |hc| mpgh/Uh`o D gcm` do) wh` |h{`u h`{w`if c| m`/ D ucwo| `xq`g|doe |hdw |j hcqq`o) d| npw| ldl) kp| wh`w|h` jo` uhj mcl` |h` clvcog`w jo m`/ Wh`w |h` jo` uhj k`ee`l m` |j w|ct col gipoe |j m`uh`o D |{d`l |j ej///

Jcvo w|jqq`l |h`{`) uc|ghdoe hdw mj|h`{ qcg` f{jm jo` wdl` jf |h` {jjm |j |h` j|h`{) cwwh` icm`o|`l |h` gp{{`o| w|c|` jf cffcd{w col {cmki`l do c uct/

D bo`u |hdw ujpil hcqq`o df jo` jf tjp gcm` do h`{` uh`o wh` ucw idb` |hc|/ D bo`utjp ujpilo| k` cki |j {`wdw|/ D|w do tjp{ kijjl) col tjp{ kijjl dw do h`{/ D| |{dee`{`lwjm`|hdoe/ \hdw dw xcg|it uhc| D uco|`l |j q{`v`o|/ D ucw hjqdoe df D w`o| tjp col Ldlp cuct

7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

8/9

fj{ |h` lct d| ujpil qcww) kp| d| ldlo|/ D whjpil hcv` bojuo k`||`{ |hco |j i`cv` `d|h`{ jf tjpcijo` h`{` ud|h h`{/ Uhc| c{` u` ejdoe |j lj oju:

Jcvo ucwo| wp{` df wh` uco|`l hdm |j cowu`{ j{ df wh` u`{` m`{`it |hdobdoe cijpl/Uhdi` hdw mj|h`{ gjo|dop`l |j qcg` col uj{{t) Id`dw `t`w jq`o`l col wh` ijjb`l c| Jcvo)

f{juodoe/ Wh` cqq`c{`l |j k` ldwj{d`o|`l/

D ljo| w`` hju |hdw dw wj u{joe/ D idb` Id`d) col Dm wp{` D gjpil e{ju |j ijv` h`{/ Df c ghdil gjm`w jf |hdw) Dii mc{{t h`{/ Dii k`gjm` c ojcdld col Dii |cb` gc{` jf h`{/ Tjp ljo|hcv` |j uj{{t) Mj|h`{/ Tjp ujo| k` jkidec|`l |j H`cdkmp j{ |j |h` {`w| jf Co{ cotmj{`) h`c{ep`l/ Dwo| |hc| uhc| tjp uco|`l: \hc| ucw uhc| Ldlp hcl wpee`w|`l/

Tjp |hdob |hdw dw ckjp| m`: Ncwb whjjb h`{ h`cl) cw|jpol`l/ \hdw hcw oj|hdoe |j ljud|h m`/ D o`v`{ w|ct l h`{` jp| jf cot jkidec|djo |j Co{ D ujpilo|/ D w|ct h`{` oju k`gcpw`jf tjp col Ldlp) col k`fj{` tjp) Jwbp/ Co{ hcw oj|hdoe iw` jf vcip` |j jff`{ m`/ D ecv` pq

wj mpgh |j gjm` h`{`) col tjpii k` cwbdoe Id`d |j lj |h` wcm`/ Tjp hcv`o| |hjpeh| |hdw|h{jpeh c| cii/ Uhc| ckjp| h`{ fcmdit: Tjp boju wh` mdww`w |h`m/ Col h`{ u`igjm` h`{`:H`cdkmp hcw mcl` d| gi`c{ wh` dwo| u`igjm` |j w|ct/ \hcobw |j tjp) wh`w h`cidoe spd|` spdgbitcol udii hcv` |j ej wjjo `ojpeh/ Wh`ii q{jkckit k` xq`g|`l |j ej ud|hdo |h` mjo|h/ Ldl tjpgjowdl`{ |hc|: Uhc| udii tjp lj |h`o:

Dii q`|d|djo H`cdkmp |j i`| h`{ w|ct) Jcvo wcdl/ Df h` mcb`w h`{ i`cv`) Dii ej ud|hh`{/ Uhc|`v`{ d| |cb`w/

Ncwb e{jco`l col l{`u do c {cee`l k{`c|h//

Cwwpmdoe wh` udii `v`o uco| |j w|ct) h` ujo| td`il |j tjp poi`ww tjp gjof`ww |hdwldwe{cg` |j whju wh` mct oju hcv` fcmdit |d`w |j Co{ col `v`o |h`o) h`ii l`mcol |hc| wh` k`wqd{d|-kjpol/ Wh` ujo| uco| |hc|) kp| tjpv` idb`it i`f| h`{ oj ghjdg`) H`cdkmp cwdl`/ Wh`iihcv` |j ej do w`c{gh jf M`colcwhw mcedg df wh` uco|w |j b``q cot ghdil jf tjp{w/ D ljo| |hdob tjp pol`{w|col hju w`{djpw |hdw dw) wh` |jil hdm/ Wh` wc| ljuo k`wdl` |h` {jjm `o|{cog`) h`{ fcg` l{cuo/ D ujpilo| udwh mt fc|` jo h`{/ D|w c l`gdwdjo D ujpilo| dmqjw` jo cotjo`){dwbdoe h`{ idf` v`{wpw {dwbdoe h`{ wcod|t/ \h` Hcild u`{` o`v`{ m`co| |j idv` |hdw uct/ \hc|wuht D |{d`l |j q{`v`o| |hdw/ Wh`ii o`v`{ k` |{pit hcqqt oju) oj mc||`{ uhc| wh` ghjjw`w/

H`{ uj{lw |u`cb`l co `c{id`{ ldwqi cwp{` do Jcvo/ [`k`iidjo ujo jv`{) { q`o|`og`

fj{ej||`o fj{ |h` mjm`o|/

Df tjp uco|`l m` |j pol`{w|col tjp{ gjog`{ow) mctk` tjp whjpil hcv` whc{`l |h`m/Mctk` tjp whjpil hcv` cowu`{`l |h` sp`w|djow |hc| D hcl fj{ tjp dow|`cl jf wh{jpldoe`v`{t|hdoe do w`g{`gt/ Hju gco tjp hcv` `xq`g|`l m` col Ldlp |j mcb` |h` q{jq`{ l`gdwdjowdf tjp {`fpw`l |j b``q pw q{jq`{it dofj{m`l:

7/30/2019 The Trading of Skin - Chapter 5

9/9

Ncwb q``{`l c| hdm f{jm pol`{ g{`cw`l k{ju/ Kt k`id`vdoe tjp ujpil {`wq`g| mtudwh`w/ Kt |hdobdoe tjp ujpil k` udiidoe |j cgg`q| |hc| D joit uco| uhc|w k`w| fj{ tjp coltjp{ k{j|h`{ /// col Id`d) |jj/ Dv` idv`l `ojpeh t`c{w |j k` udw`{ fj{ d|/

Id`d hcl e{juo f{pw|{c|`l c| h`c{doe h`{ ocm` m`o|djo`l w`v`{ci |dm`w kp| oj| k`doe

cki` |j pol`{w|col uhc| ucw k`doe wcdl) mj|h`{ col wjo gjov`{wdoe do |h` ldci`g| jf Co{/Ldwqi`cw`l) wh` qpwh`l h`{w`if cuct f{jm Jcvo k`o`c|h |h` fp{w) u{cqqdoe h`{w`if do h`{ l``{wbdo jog` cecdo) fj{ gjmfj{|/ Wh` fcvjp{`l h`{ i`e cw wh` ldl wj) |h` w|d|gh`l ujpol jo h`{ i`e w|dii |`ol`{) kp| ch` j|h`{udw` wh` cqq`c{`l fdo` oj wdeo jf cot f`v`{/ Jcvo {`cgh`l fj{ h`{) kp| wh` kc||`l hdw hcol cuct) ijjbdoe d{c|` c| |h` e`w|p{`/

D gco| idv` pol`{ tjp{ |hpmk fj{`v`{) Jcvo wcdl) {`|p{odoe hdw c||`o|djo |j hdw mj|h`{ col {`cghdoe fj{ hdw gij|hdoe/ D cqq{`gdc|` tjp{ epdlcog` col D ljo| ljpk| tjp{ udwljm kp|tjp hcv` |j i`| m` mcb` mt whc{` jf l`gdwdjow col ciiju m` |j mcb` mt whc{` jf mdw|cb`w/

Tjp ci{`clt mcb` mj{` |hco tjp{ whc{` jf mdw|cb`w col |hdw jo` dw co `wq`gdciit kdejo`/ D joit uco|`l |j wqc{` tjp |h` qcdo |hc| udii gjm` f{jm |hdw/ Tjp mct w`` d| cw c ki`wwdoe) kp| Id`d udii w`` d| cw c gp{w`/

Jcvo ldlo| uco| |j k`id`v` |hc|/ Hclo| Id`d k``o |h` jo` |j dod|dc|` |hdoew k`|u``o|h`m: Col |h` joit {`cwjo h` hcl {`wqjol`l |j h`{ qi`cw do |h` fd{w| qicg` ucw k`gcpw` h` ucwljdoe npw| cw Icdk Jimcd hcl {`sp`w|`l/ Hdw mj|h`{ o``l`l |j boju |hc|/

D| ucwo| npw| c mc||`{ jf ldwjk`tdoe tjp) Mj|h`{/ D ucw h``ldoe c hdeh`{ qju`{) |h`uct c ejjl ojcdld whjpil) h` `xqicdo`l/ D ucw ljdoe cw D ucw |jil |j lj c| |h` wd`dld u`|{cv`ii`l |j) |h` jo` uh`{` u` wcg{dfdg`l Fc|h`{w cwh`w/ D ucw idw| odoe |j Icdk Jimcd/

Fj{ wjm` {`cwjo) |hdw hcl c q{jfjpol `ff`g| jo Ncwb/ Wh` k`eco |j g{t/ \h` joit j|h`{ |dm` Jcvo hcl w``o hdw mj|h`{ u``q ucw uh`o hdw fc|h`{ hcl ld`l/ H`{ |`c{w u`{` `ojpeh |jwhcm` Jcvo) f``idoe epdi|t cw c {`wpi| jf |h`m/ Uhc| gjpil h` hcv` wcdl j{ ljo` |hc| ucw |hc|cufpi:

\j gjmqidgc|` mc||`{w) |hdw ucw uh`o Ldlp ghjw` |j {`|p{o f{jm |h` hpo|/ Do {`wqjow`|j |h` wjpol jf hdw mj|h`{w ldw|{`ww) h` ghjw` |j k{`cb h`{ {pi` cw u`ii) qpwhdoe hdw uct do|j h`{ {jjm/ H` |jjb jo` ijjb c| hdw mj|h`{ u``qdoe) cijoe ud|h Id`d col c {`l-fcg`l Jcvohplli`l pol`{ |h` fp{w) k`fj{` |p{odoe hdw fpii c||`o|djo |j hdw k{j|h`{ ud|h co cggpwc|j{t w|c{`/

Jh) K{j|h`{) Ldlp wcdl) hdw vjdg` e{dm/ Uhc| hcv` tjp ljo` |hdw |dm`: