The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems...

48
The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production Systems J. Taylor, M. Tang, C. Beddows, F.M. Quin, M.A. Stocking August 2003

Transcript of The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems...

Page 1: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

The Characterisation of Six NaturalResources Production Systems

J. Taylor, M. Tang, C. Beddows, F.M. Quin, M.A. Stocking

August 2003

Page 2: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

We wish to thank the following people and projects for supplying the photographs on the front cover:-

John Beeching, Man Fai Tang, projects R6675, R7180, R7872, R7877, R7974

DFIDThis document is an output from a programme funded by the UK Department for International Development(DFID) for the benefit of developing countries. The views expressed are not necessarily those of DFID.

Technical Editors Produced by:Duncan Barker – [email protected] Drakeloe Press, Milton Keynes

Page 3: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

Natural Resources Systems Programme

THE CHARACTERISATION OF SIX NATURALRESOURCES PRODUCTION SYSTEMS

J. Taylor, M. Tang, C. Beddows, F.M. Quin, M.A. Stocking

August 2003

Page 4: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography

6-1

6 BIBLIOGRAPHY

Adams R, M Adams, A Willens and A Willens, 1978. Dry Lands: Man & Plants. The ArchitecturalPress, London.

Agarwal A and S Narain (Eds.), 1999. The Citizens Fifth Report. Centre for Science & Environment,New Delhi.

Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, 1999. 1998 Statistical Yearbook of Bangladesh. Government ofBangladesh, Dhaka.

Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, 1999. Census of Agriculture – 1996. Government of Bangladesh,Dhaka.

Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, 2000, www.bangla.net/ndb/data-sheet/DEMO_DATA.htm

Bourn D and R Blench (eds), 1999. Can Livestock and Wildlife Co-exist? An InterdisciplinaryApproach. ODI, London.

Davis H, 1973. Tropical Africa: An Atlas for Rural Development. University of Wales Press, Cardiff.

Central Bureau of Statistics, 1991. Statistical Yearbook of Nepal 1991. Central Bureau of Statistics,Kathmandu.

Central Statistical Organisation Department of Statistics, 1998. Statistical Abstract India 1997.Government of India, New Delhi.

Census India, 2000. www.censusindia.net

CGIAR, 2000. www.cgiar.org/icrisat/text/pubs/ir97

CGIAR, 2000. www.cgiar.org/icrisat/text/research/nrmp/indpsystems.asp

CGIAR, 2000. www.cgiar.org/icrisat/text/research/nrmp/lgpind.asp

Economic Commission for Latin America & the Caribbean, 1999. Statistical Yearbook for LatinAmerica and the Caribbean. United Nations, New York.

Economist Intelligence Unit, 1993. Country Profile: Brazil. EIU, London.

Economist Intelligence Unit, 1998. Country Profile: Kenya. EIU, London.

Economist Intelligence Unit, 1999. Country Profile: Uganda. EIU, London.

Economist Intelligence Unit, 1998. Country Profile: Zimbabwe. EIU, London.

Europa Publications, 1997. Africa South of the Sahara. Europa Publications Ltd, London.

European Consortium for Agricultural Research in the Tropics, 1999. Formulation and Appraisal of aRegional Programme to Support Agricultural Research in Eastern Africa (Project No. 7ACP.RPR.699). Natural Resources Institute, Chatham.

Eurostat, 1992. Country Profile Uganda 1991. Office for the Official Publications of the EuropeanCommunities, Luxembourg.

Page 5: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography

6-2

FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for Agricultural Development. Report 2.Agroecological Regions of Bangladesh. BGD/81/035 Technical Report 2. Food and AgricultureOrganisation, Rome, Itlay.

FAO, 2000. www.fao.org

FAO/GIEWS, 2000. http://geoweb.fao.org/GBR/geoWEB

Funk and Wagnalls Knowledge Center, 2000. www.fwkc.com/encyclopedia/low/articles/

GeoCenter, 1994. World Country Map Series: 33264. India (North Eastern Region). Stuttgart.

GeoCenter, 1998. World Country Map Series: 33265. India (Southern Region). Stuttgart.

GeoCenter, 1998. World Country Map Series: 33281. South America (Northern Region). Stuttgart.

GeoCenter, 1998. World Country Map Series: Kenya. Stuttgart.

ICRISAT, 2000. www.cgiar.org/icrisat

International Travel Map, 1995. Zimbabwe (790). International Travel Maps, Vancouver.

International Travel Map, 1996. Uganda (936). International Travel Maps, Vancouver.

International Travel Map, 1998. Ghana (960). 2nd Edition. International Travel Maps, Vancouver.

International Travel Map, 1999. Nepal. 2nd Edition. International Travel Maps, Vancouver.

International Travel Map, 2000. Tanzania. International Travel Maps, Vancouver.

ISNAR, 2000. www.cgiar.org/isnar/programs/pmde/asti/index.htm

National Atlas & Thematic Mapping Organisation, 1996. Water Resources Development Atlas ofIndia. Government of India, Calcutta.

ODA, 1994. Overseas Development Administration: Renewable Natural Resources Research Strategy1995-2005. Final Report of the Research Task Force. May 1994.

ODG, 1982. Population & Health Facilities in Tanzania, Vol. 3 Regional Atlas. ODG, Norwich.

Tabor S, W Janssen & H Bruneau, 1998. Financing Agricultural Research: A Sourcebook. ISNARThe Hague.

Times Books, 1997. Times Atlas of the World: Comprehensive Edition. Times Books, London.

UN, 2000. www.un.org/Depts/unsd/demog/

UN, 1999. Demographic Yearbook 1997. United Nations, New York.

UN Dept of Economic and Social Affairs Statistics Division, 2000. Population and Vital Statistics,Series A, Vol. LII, No. 1.

UN Economic & Social Commission for Asia & the Pacific, 1981. Country Monograph Series No. 8:Population of Bangladesh. United Nations, New York.

UNDP, 1999. Human Development Report 1999, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Page 6: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography

6-3

University of Pennsylvania, 2000. www.sas.upen.edu/African_Studies/CIA_Maps/

University of Texas, 2000. www.lib.utexas.edu/Lib/PCL/Map_collection/

US Government Service, 2000. www.grid2.cr.usgs.gov.index.html

World Commission on Forests & Sustainable Development, 1999. Our Forests, Our Future.Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

World Health Organisation, 2000. www.who.int

Xist.org, 2000. www.xist.org

Yadav J and J Singh, 2000. Natural Resource Management for Agricultural Production in India.Indian Society of Soil Science, New Delhi.

Page 7: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

Production Systems Characterisation Appendices

App-1

APPENDICES CONTENTS

PageNotes on Appendices App-2

Appendix 1 Production System (PS) data and information App-4 to 21Master Summary Sheet, all Production Systems App-4

Country Characteristics for Specific PSs13:

Bangladesh App-5Bolivia App-6Brazil App-7Caribbean App-8Ghana App-9India App-10Kenya App-11Nepal App-13Tanzania App-14Uganda App-15Zimbabwe App-16Bangladesh Supplement App-17India Supplement App-19Nepal Supplement App-21

Appendix 2 App-22 to 28Characterisation Criterion Score Version 1 App-22Characterisation Criterion Score Version 2 App-23Characterisation Criterion Score Version 3 App-24Simple Scores Weighted 1 App-25Simple Scores Weighted 2 App-26Simple Scores Weighted 3 App-27

Simple Scoring

Simple Scoring Summary App-28Appendix 3 Relative Scoring (Double Counted) App-29 to 35

Relative Characterisation Score Version 1 App-29Relative Characterisation Score Version 2 App-30Relative Characterisation Score Version 3 App-31Relative Scores Weighted 1 App-32Relative Scores Weighted 2 App-33Relative Scores Weighted 3 App-34Relative Scores Summary App-35

Appendix 4 Adjusted Relative Scoring App-36 to 42

Adjusted Characterisation Score Version 1 App-36Adjusted Characterisation Score Version 2 App-37Adjusted Characterisation Score Version 3 App-38Adjusted Relative Scores Weighted 1 App-39Adjusted Relative Scores Weighted 2 App-40Adjusted Relative Scores Weighted 3 App-41Adjusted Relative Scores Summary App-42

13 / The specific Production Systems for each Target Country are identified with a red-filled column header cell.

Page 8: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

Production Systems Characterisation Appendices

App-2

NOTES ON APPENDICES

APPENDIX 1 – TARGET COUNTRY PS CHARACTERISTICSThe basic data and information for the characterisation criteria were assembled in one ExcelWorkbook with sheets assigned for each Target Country and their specified Production Systems (PSs)(see Appendix 1, pages App-5 to App-16 and supplementary sheets App-17 to App-21).

As explained in the main text (Section 3), the PSs are not rigid entities and determining their extent interms of land area is dependent on what limits (e.g., for rainfall, length of growing period, and/or soiltype) are applied. In some countries more than one definition of a specific PS was considered. Dataand information were assembled for these alternatives, designated in parenthesis (1), (2) etc. Whendata and information were combined for a specific PS across the relevant target countries, theseoptions were taken forward, leading to three possible versions for comparisons between PSs, assummarised in the table below.

The combined data and information for each PS definition that was considered are summarised in onePS Master Summary Sheet (see Appendix 1, page App-4).

Versions Production Systems

Version 1 HP(1) HS SA(1) FA(2) LW(1) PU

Version 2 HP(2) HS SA(2) FA(1) LW(2) PU

Version 3 HP(1) HS SA(1) FA(1) LW(3) PU

The different production system definitions that were applied in making PS combinations acrosscountries were:

HP(1) Uses narrower definition of the High Potential PS in India (keeping to land below 150 metreselevation) plus single definitions specific to Kenya and Bangladesh respectively.

HP(2) Uses wider definition of the High Potential PS in India (including land of 1-500 metreselevation) plus single definitions specific to Kenya and Bangladesh respectively.

HS Uses only one wider definition of the Hillsides PS for Bolivia (HS(3), see App-6) plus singledefinitions specific to Uganda and Nepal respectively. (Details of HS(1) and HS(2) are givenfor Bolivia on page App-6).

SA(1) Uses rainfall based definition of the Semi-Arid PS for Tanzania (300-900 mm rainfall) andtakes areas defined as dry and moist semi-arid in India plus a single definition for Zimbabwe.

SA(2) Uses LGP based definition of Semi-Arid PS for Tanzania (3-6 months) and takes areasdefined as dry and moist semi-arid and dry sub-humid in India plus a single definition forZimbabwe.

FA(1) Uses land area with 9-10 months LGP plus single definitions specific to Brazil and Nepalrespectively.

FA(2) Uses land area with 8 months LGP plus single definitions specific to Brazil and Nepalrespectively.

LW(1) Inland definition: Uses seasonally wetland areas of Bangladesh inland floodplains and LakeKyoga margins with its drainage line into Lake Victoria, Uganda.

LW(2) Definition best aligned with current LW geographic scope: Uses Bangladesh (inland andcoastal) and selected parts of the Caribbean region.

LW(3) Takes only the Bangladesh LWI (inland floodplains and coastal tidal floodplains).

PU Uses selected city regions of Ghana and India

Page 9: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

Production Systems Characterisation Appendices

App-3

APPENDIX 2 – SIMPLE SCORING

This annex utilises the summated data in the PS Master Summary Sheet of Appendix 1 (see pageApp-4) and generates data matrices of criteria by PSs for each version of the PS comparisons, asdefined in the table above (see page App-2). Within each PS version (see pages App-22 to App-24),the values for each criterion are ranked across the PSs by scoring the values on a scale of 1 to 6where:

6 = Greatest need (largest land area; most people; worst market feasibility [least roads &large towns]; worst potential [greatest distance to major outlets & leastproduction]; most acute poverty status [lowest GDP, literacy rate & childwt for ht]; weakest NR knowledge base [least funds and human resources)

1 = Least need (smallest land area; least people; best market feasibility; best potential;least acute poverty status; strongest NR knowledge base)

For each PS comparison version, the rank scores (called ‘simple scoring’) for each criterion areconverted to weighted scores for five weighting scenarios and a total weighted simple score isgenerated for each PS and each weighting scenario (see App-25 to App-27) where each total weightedsimple score (the Weighted Importance Score [WIS]) is calculated as:

WIS = ([score]x[weight]Criterion 1)+ ([score]x[weight]Criterion 2) ... +(([score]x[weight]Criterion 6)

All weighted simple score totals (for three PS versions by five weighting scenarios) are thensummarised and an overall assessment is made of the implications of these scores for proportionalbudget allocations to the PSs (see App-28).

APPENDIX 3 – RELATIVE SCORING

This annex uses the same data matrices as Appendix 2, App-22 to App-42, but ranks the data for eachcriterion using relative scoring. Because the simple scoring method assigns discrete rank scores (the‘need scale’ of 1 to 6), it does not do justice to criterion data that have numerically close values.Therefore Appendix 3 applies a relative scoring system in which a score of ‘1’ is assigned to the‘greatest need’ figure (i.e., the criterion value looking across PSs that had scored the highest rankscore on the 1-6 scale of need assessment). The criterion values for all other PSs are then expressed asa fraction relative to the criterion value of the PS scored as the ‘greatest need’ (see App-29 to App-31).

As with the simple scoring method, the proportional scores are then converted to weighted scores forthe same five weighting scenarios used in Appendix 2 (see App-32 to App-34). The total weightedscores (three PS versions by five weighting scenarios) are then summarised and an overall assessmentis made of the implications of the scores for proportional budget allocations to the PSs (see App-35).

APPENDIX 4 – RELATIVE SCORING (WITH CORRECTIONS FORDOUBLE COUNTING)

Two production systems are addressed in the target countries of Bangladesh and Nepal (see Appendix1, pages App-5 and App-13 respectively). This gives rise to double counting of the populations whencomparing in the HP and LW PSs (in the case of Bangladesh) and the HS and FA PSs (in the case ofNepal). In Appendix 4, corrections are applied for this double counting and the scoring is thenreworked following the relative scoring method that was applied in Appendix 3 (see pages App-36 toApp-38). As in Appendix 3, the proportional scores are then converted to weighted scores for the fiveweighting scenarios used in Appendix 2 (see App-39 to App-41). As in Appendices 2 and 3, the totalweighted scores are then summarised and an overall assessment is made of the implications of thescores for proportional budget allocations to the PSs (see App-42).

Grading to:

Page 10: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

MS

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

MA

ST

ER

SU

MM

AR

Y S

HE

ET

By

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

m (

PS

) d

efin

itio

n:

HP

(1)

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(1)

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

LW

(2)

LW

(3)

PU

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

521,

307

695,

117

278,

927

1,50

5,33

22,

242,

353

386,

480

374,

472

153,

362

187,

483

124,

149

Hum

an p

opul

atio

n: T

otal

268,

165,

453

348,

324,

325

18,2

34,5

2033

7,14

4,82

055

1,16

9,25

722

,558

,595

17,6

61,4

4888

,410

,065

103,

181,

200

98,0

55,2

00

42,8

46,2

39

R

ural

(m

etro

polit

an m

inus

city

pop

'tn fo

r P

UI)

201,

480,

731

260,

798,

296

14,9

13,8

9624

9,17

2,03

240

7,63

2,64

515

,685

,378

12,5

90,3

8070

,690

,251

79,7

70,3

0877

,463

,608

26,1

33,1

53

U

rban

66,6

84,7

2287

,526

,029

3,32

0,62

387

,972

,788

143,

536,

612

6,87

3,21

75,

071,

067

17,7

19,8

1423

,410

,892

20,5

91,5

9216

,713

,086

Mar

ket

infr

astr

uct

ure

:M

ean

road

den

sity

4.

174.

171.

673.

173.

502.

331.

674.

004.

334.

005.

00M

ean

mar

ket d

eman

d as

sess

men

t (la

rge

tow

ns/1

000

sqkm

of P

S)

0.10

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.03

0.10

0.11

0.21

0.11

0.14

n/a

Po

ten

tial

:A

sses

smen

t of e

xpor

t pot

entia

l (m

ean

max

dis

t.to

maj

or to

wn

[km

])13

3.33

133.

3396

.67

183.

3320

0.00

166.

6718

3.33

80.0

083

.33

100.

00n/

aLa

nd p

rodu

ctiv

ity p

oten

tial (

mea

n)4.

004.

172.

17

2.83

1.83

1.83

4.50

5.00

5.00

n/a

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

nal

dat

a):

Ave

rage

GD

P (

US

D p

er a

nnum

per

cap

ita,1

997)

(w

eigh

ted)

1452

1502

1556

1653

1644

2157

2301

1050

1160

1050

1667

Lite

racy

rat

e %

(19

97, w

eigh

ted)

51.3

151

.82

49.9

654

.60

54.4

554

.34

49.7

538

.90

40.1

938

.90

54.6

3H

arva

rd s

cale

dat

a:%

chi

ldre

n w

ith a

ccep

tabl

e w

eigh

t/hei

ght (

wei

ghte

d)56

.30

55.7

763

.42

55.4

055

.46

60.2

755

.78

57.0

058

.01

57.0

053

.38

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

bas

e (N

atio

nal

dat

a):

Deg

ree

leve

l of n

atio

nal r

esea

rche

rs (

1991

): %

BS

c86

.51

86.5

1D

egre

e le

vel o

f nat

iona

l res

earc

hers

(19

91):

% M

Sc

9.06

9.06

Deg

ree

leve

l of n

atio

nal r

esea

rche

rs (

1991

): %

PhD

4.43

4.43

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

(w

eigh

ted)

0.15

390.

1539

0.15

450.

1545

0.09

610.

0961

0.15

29N

R R

esea

rch

Sci

entis

ts (

1991

) pe

r P

S p

opul

atio

n24

9128

8918

8530

4914

877

249

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

109

66

74

6

data

not

ava

ilabl

eto

o fe

w d

ata

for

mea

ning

ful c

alcu

latio

n

Prim

ary

and

seco

ndar

y pa

ved

road

s.Sc

ale

5 =

den

se, 1

=sp

arse

.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fro

m U

ND

P 19

99.

Nat

iona

l dat

a on

ly.

Def

initi

on o

f 'la

rge'

is r

elat

ive

to t

he c

ount

ry.

Use

s na

rrow

er

defin

tion

of s

emi-

arid

for

Tan

zani

a an

d In

dia

plus

Zi

mba

bwe.

Use

s th

e w

ider

de

finiti

on o

f Bo

livia

n H

S pl

us

Uga

nda

and

Nep

al.

Use

s w

ider

de

finiti

on o

f In

dia

HP

plus

Ke

nya

and

Bang

lade

sh.

Use

s na

rrow

er

defin

ition

of

Indi

a H

P pl

us K

enya

an

d Ba

ngla

desh

.

Use

s w

ider

sem

i-ar

id d

efin

ition

fo

r In

dia

and

Tanz

ania

plu

s Zi

mba

bwe.

Use

s G

hana

la

nd a

rea

with

9

mth

s LG

P pl

us B

razi

l and

N

epal

.

Use

s G

hana

la

nd a

rea

with

8

mth

s LG

P pl

us

Braz

il an

d N

epal

.

Base

d on

wei

ghte

d av

erag

e fo

r G

hana

and

N

epal

onl

y

Base

d on

wei

ghte

d av

erag

e fo

r G

hana

and

Nep

al o

nly.

No

data

for

Tan

zani

a

No

data

for

Tan

zani

a.

No

data

for

N

epal

.

No

data

for

N

epal

.

No

data

for

Nep

al.

No

data

for

Nep

al.

No

data

for

Nep

al.

Scal

e: %

con

trib

utio

n to

nat

iona

l pr

oduc

tion:

5 =

80

- 10

0,4

= 6

0 -

80, 3

= 4

0 -

602

= 2

0 -

40, 1

= 0

-20

Key

agric

ultu

ral,

fore

stry

, to

uris

m e

tc

prod

ucts

.

No

data

for

Nep

al.

Use

s in

land

wet

land

s (B

angl

ades

h &

Uga

nda)

Use

s Ba

ngla

desh

onl

y

Wei

ghte

d av

erag

es b

y to

tal

hum

an p

opul

atio

n pe

r PS

with

in

each

app

licab

le t

arge

t co

untr

y.

LW a

s of

mid

-200

0. U

ses

Bang

lade

sh &

Car

ibbe

an

App-4

Page 11: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

BA

NG

LA

DE

SH

HP

HS

SA

FA

LW

(1)

LW

(2)

PU

Nat

ion

alS

ou

rce

No

tes

Nat

ion

al d

ata:

Land

are

a (k

m2)

1385

07E

SR

I 98

Dha

ka34

3031

2H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al12

2569

000

UN

mid

98

Khu

lna

6483

59

Rur

al

96

3392

34C

hitta

gong

1391

877

U

rban

2622

9766

HD

R d

ata

1999

PS

dat

a:N

at p

op12

2700

000

Land

are

a (k

m2)

1038

2710

3827

2032

2%

urba

n21

.4H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al77

8313

1577

8313

1520

2238

85

Rur

al

61

4867

3961

4867

3915

9768

69E

SR

I 98

1207

3220

0

Urb

an16

3445

7616

3445

7642

4701

6M

arke

t inf

rast

ruct

ure:

UN

ES

CA

P 1

981:

Roa

d de

nsity

(km

roa

ds p

er P

S o

n 5

pt s

cale

)4

44

Chi

ttago

ng H

ill T

ract

sM

arke

t dem

and

asse

ssm

ent (

tow

ns>

100

,000

pop/

100

0sqk

m o

f PS

)0.

1637

30.

1637

30.

8365

3re

gion

- 2

0% o

f pop

Ass

essm

ent o

f exp

ort p

oten

tial (

mid

poi

nt o

f PS

to m

ajor

city

[km

])10

010

010

0La

nd p

rodu

ctiv

ity p

oten

tial

5

55

Pov

erty

sta

tus:

Ave

rage

GD

P (

US

D p

er a

nnum

per

cap

ita,1

997)

1050

1050

1050

1050

UN

DP

1999

L

itera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, nat

iona

l)38

.938

.938

.938

.9U

ND

P19

99

Har

vard

sca

le d

ata

%

chi

ldre

n w

ith a

cept

able

wei

ght/h

eigh

t to

age

5757

57N

R k

now

ledg

e ba

seN

R k

now

ledg

e ba

se (

Deg

ree

leve

l of n

atio

nal r

esea

rche

rs)

: % B

Sc

%

MS

c

% P

hDA

gric

ultu

ral R

esea

rch:

No

of s

cien

tists

(19

91)

1650

1650

1650

S

hare

of G

DP

to A

g R

(19

91)

0.11

0.11

0.11

Cal

cula

tions

for

wei

ghts

on

sum

mar

y pa

ge: G

DP

8172

2880

750

8172

2880

750

2123

5079

250

L

it30

2763

8154

3027

6381

5478

6709

126.

5

Wei

ght/h

eigh

t44

3638

4955

4436

3849

5511

5276

1445

GD

P n

atio

nal

1.28

697E

+11

1.28

697E

+11

1.28

697E

+11

GD

P o

n A

g14

1567

195

1415

6719

514

1567

195

Sci

per

1 m

illio

n na

tiona

l pop

ulat

ion

13.4

6180

519

13.4

6180

519

13.4

6180

519

Sci

per

PS

pop

ulat

ion

1047

.75

1047

.75

272.

25W

eigh

ted

degr

ee B

Sc

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

MS

cW

eigh

ted

degr

ee P

hD

Sam

e ar

ea a

s H

P.Th

e in

land

flo

odpl

ain.

Co

asta

l tid

al

flood

palin

& C

hitt

agon

g re

gion

exc

lude

d.

All l

and

belo

w 1

00m

ele

vatio

n.

Live

lihoo

ds a

re p

redo

min

atel

y re

late

d to

th

e LW

I.

Sam

e ar

ea a

s LW

I.Al

luvi

al a

rea

supp

ortin

g la

rge

popu

latio

n.

75%

of

tota

l lan

d ar

ea

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fro

m

UN

DP

1999

.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

UN

DP

1999

.

63.5

% o

f to

tal p

opul

atio

n to

ex

clud

e H

ill T

ract

reg

ion

of

Chitt

agon

g di

stric

t an

d th

e co

asta

l zon

e.

79%

of

popu

latio

n ac

cord

ing

to H

DR d

ata.

21%

of

popu

latio

n ac

cord

ing

to H

DR

data

.

63.5

% o

f to

tal p

opul

atio

n to

exc

lude

Hill

Tra

ct r

egio

n of

Chi

ttag

ong

dist

rict

and

the

coas

tal z

one.

79%

of

popu

latio

n ac

cord

ing

to H

DR d

ata.

21%

of

popu

latio

n ac

cord

ing

to H

DR d

ata.

UN

list

ed c

ities

of

>10

0,00

0: B

aris

al, Co

mill

a,

Dha

ka, D

inaj

pur,

Jam

alpu

r,

Jess

ore,

Khu

lna,

M

ymen

sing

h, N

aoga

on,

Nar

ayan

ganj

, N

awab

ganj

, Pa

bna,

Raj

shab

i, Ran

gpur

, Sa

idpu

r, T

anga

il, T

ongi

.

UN

list

ed c

ities

of

>10

0,00

0: B

aris

al, Co

mill

a, D

haka

, D

inaj

pur,

Jam

alpu

r, J

esso

re, Kh

ulna

, M

ymen

sing

h,

Nao

gaon

, N

aray

anga

nj, N

awab

ganj

, Pa

bna,

Raj

shab

i, Ran

gpur

, Sa

idpu

r, T

anga

il, T

ongi

.

Roa

d de

nsity

sca

le:

5=de

nse,

1=

spar

se.

Hei

ght/

wei

ght

only

.

1991

dat

a.

Bang

lade

sh B

urea

u of

Sta

tistic

s 19

99 li

nk

http

://w

ww

.ban

gla.

net/

ndb/

dat

a-sh

eet/

DEM

O_D

ATA.

htm

Coas

tal a

rea

-- t

he G

ange

s Ti

dal

Floo

dpla

in (

incl

udes

Kul

na S

unde

rban

s an

d sa

line

area

s of

the

You

ng M

eghn

a Riv

er F

lood

plai

n.

15%

of

tota

l lan

d ar

ea.

16.5

% o

f to

tal p

opul

atio

n

79%

of

popu

latio

n ac

cord

ing

to H

DR d

ata.

21%

of

popu

latio

n ac

cord

ing

to H

DR d

ata.

UN

list

ed c

ities

of

>10

0,00

0: B

aris

al, Co

mill

a,

Dha

ka, D

inaj

pur,

Jam

alpu

r, J

esso

re, Kh

ulna

, M

ymen

sing

h, N

aoga

on, N

aray

anga

nj, N

awab

ganj

, Pa

bna,

Raj

shab

i, Ran

gpur

, Sa

idpu

r, T

anga

il, T

ongi

.

75%

of

tota

l lan

d ar

ea.

App-5

Page 12: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

BO

LIV

IAH

PH

S (

1)H

S (

2)H

S (

3)S

AF

AL

WP

UN

atio

nal

So

urc

eN

ote

sN

atio

nal

dat

a:La

nd a

rea

(km

2)10

9035

3E

SR

I 98

La P

az99

2592

Coc

haba

mb

4580

00P

otos

i11

8000

Hum

an p

opul

atio

n: T

otal

7950

000

UN

mid

98

Suc

re14

9000

El A

lto52

7000

Tar

ija10

4000

R

ural

2997

150

S C

ruz

8330

00O

ruro

1940

00

Urb

an49

5285

0V

alle

ys te

mpe

rate

and

sub

trop

ical

100

0-35

00m

2132

87km

2 19

.4%

of l

and

area

PS

dat

a:34

2806

9 po

p 53

.4%

of t

otal

Land

are

a (k

m2)

7789

110

5694

1835

8520

2081

1 ur

ban

31.4

% o

f tot

alH

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al42

1350

014

0725

8 ru

ral 2

1.9%

of t

otal

R

ural

2464

500

Sou

rce:

CID

in

Urb

an17

4900

0M

arke

t inf

rast

ruct

ure:

CID

dat

a (1

994)

:R

oad

dens

ity (

km r

oads

per

PS

on

5 pt

sca

le)

12

3T

otal

pop

6420

792

Mar

ket d

eman

d as

sess

men

t (to

wns

> 1

00,0

00po

p/ 1

000s

qkm

of P

S)

0.05

677

0.03

268

Urb

an p

op36

9484

6A

sses

smen

t of e

xpor

t pot

entia

l (m

id p

oint

of P

S to

maj

or c

ity [k

m])

150

150

150

Rur

al p

op27

2594

6La

nd p

rodu

ctiv

ity p

oten

tial

2P

over

ty s

tatu

s: A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)28

8028

8028

8028

80U

ND

P19

99H

DR

dat

a 19

99

Lite

racy

rat

e %

(19

97, n

atio

nal)

83.6

83.6

83.6

83.6

UN

DP

1999

Nat

pop

7800

000

H

arva

rd s

cale

dat

a%

urba

n62

.3

% c

hild

ren

with

acc

epta

ble

wei

ght/h

eigh

t to

age

9393

93N

R k

now

ledg

e ba

seN

R k

now

ledg

e ba

se (

Deg

ree

leve

l of n

atio

nal r

esea

rche

rs)

: % B

Sc

17.4

17.4

17.4

ES

RI 9

876

4831

5

% M

Sc

5454

540.

4

% P

hD28

.628

.628

.6A

gric

ultu

ral R

esea

rch:

No

of s

cien

tists

(19

91)

115

115

115

S

hare

of G

DP

to A

g R

(19

91)

0.02

0.02

0.02

Cal

cula

tions

for

wei

ghts

on

sum

mar

y pa

ge: G

DP

1213

4880

000

L

it35

2248

600

W

eigh

t/heo

ght

3918

5550

0G

DP

nat

iona

l22

8960

0000

0G

DP

on

Ag

4579

200

Sci

per

1 m

illio

n na

tiona

l pop

ulat

ion

14.4

6540

881

Sci

per

PS

pop

ulat

ion

60.9

5W

eigh

ted

degr

ee B

Sc

20.0

1W

eigh

ted

degr

ee M

Sc

62.1

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

PhD

32.8

9

Sub-

syst

em 1

: 10

00-

2000

m a

ltitu

de.

Subt

ropi

cal v

alle

ys.

Rai

nfal

l 100

0-30

00m

m

Sub-

syst

em 2

: 2

000-

3500

m a

ltitu

de.

Tem

pera

te v

alle

ys.

Rai

nfal

l 400

-100

0mm

.

Syst

em 3

: 10

00-3

500m

alti

tude

.Va

lley

AEZ

as d

istin

ct f

rom

the

lo

wla

nds

and

the

altip

lano

.Su

m o

f su

b-sy

stem

s 1

& 2

.

7% o

f to

tal l

and

area 10

% o

f to

tal l

and

area

.17

% o

f to

tal l

and

area

.Co

mpa

re w

ith

CID

dat

a gi

ving

213

287

sq k

m a

nd

19%

of

land

are

a fo

r th

is

zone

.

53%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

(199

4 CI

D d

ata)

app

lied

to

1998

UN

est

imat

e fo

r to

tal

popu

latio

n.

31%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

(199

4 CI

D d

ata)

app

lied

to U

N d

ata.

22%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

(199

4 CI

D d

ata)

app

lied

to U

N d

ata.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fro

m

UN

DP

1999

.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

U

ND

P 19

99.

No

maj

or

tow

ns in

ta

rget

are

a.

Maj

or t

owns

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Coch

abam

ba, La

Pa

z, P

otos

i, Sa

nta

Cruz

, Su

cre,

Tar

ija.

Maj

or t

owns

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Coch

abam

ba, La

Pa

z, P

otos

i, Sa

nta

Cruz

, Su

cre,

Tar

ija.

Roa

d de

nsity

sca

le:

5=de

nse,

1=

spar

se.

App-6

Page 13: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

BR

AZ

ILH

PH

SS

AF

AL

WP

UN

atio

nal

So

urc

eN

ote

sN

atio

nal

dat

a:La

nd a

rea

(km

2)85

0712

8E

SR

I 98

Bel

em12

0000

0H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al16

1790

000

UN

mid

98

San

tare

m22

6618

R

ural

3300

5160

Man

aus

8099

14

Urb

an12

8784

840

Por

to V

elh o

2020

11C

uiab

a27

9651

PS

dat

a:G

oian

ia99

0000

Land

are

a (k

m2)

2379

27B

rasi

lia15

6770

9H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al37

6969

8C

uriti

ba17

0000

0

Rur

al

71

3781

Sao

Pau

lo15

1750

00

Urb

an30

5591

7B

elo

Hor

izo

2950

000

Mar

ket i

nfra

stru

ctur

e:R

io d

e Ja

ne10

1500

00R

oad

dens

ity (

km r

oads

per

PS

on

5 pt

sca

le)

1S

anto

s10

6500

0M

arke

t dem

and

asse

ssm

ent (

tow

ns>

100

,000

pop/

100

0sqk

m o

f PS

)0.

0252

2A

sses

smen

t of e

xpor

t pot

entia

l (m

id p

oint

of P

S to

maj

or c

ity [k

m])

300

HD

R d

ata

1999

Land

pro

duct

ivity

pot

entia

l 1

Nat

pop

1637

0000

0P

over

ty s

tatu

s: A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)64

8064

80U

ND

P19

99%

urba

n79

.6

Lite

racy

rat

e %

(19

97, n

atio

nal)

8484

UN

DP

1999

H

arva

rd s

cale

dat

aE

SR

I 98

1515

2540

0

% c

hild

ren

with

acc

epta

ble

wei

ght/h

eigh

t to

age

NR

kno

wle

dge

base

NR

kno

wle

dge

base

(D

egre

e le

vel o

f nat

iona

l res

earc

hers

) : %

BS

c94

22P

op o

f sta

tes

1990

EIU

Tar

get a

rea

%

MS

c4.

30.

2R

ondo

nia

8893

3 pe

r sq

km

% P

hD1.

7A

cre

1096

7137

81A

gric

ultu

ral R

esea

rch:

No

of s

cien

tists

(19

91)

2097

Am

azon

as41

7pl

us c

ities

S

hare

of G

DP

to A

g R

(19

91)

0.09

Ror

aim

a20

02C

alcu

latio

ns fo

r w

eigh

ts o

n su

mm

ary

page

: GD

P24

4276

4304

0P

ara

120

L

it31

6654

632

Am

apa

5002

W

eigh

t/hei

ght

0C

ities

1993

UN

GD

P n

atio

nal

1.04

84E

+12

Bel

em12

9759

2G

DP

on

Ag

9435

5928

0m

anau

s10

7827

7S

ci p

er 1

mill

ion

natio

nal p

opul

atio

n12

.961

2460

6C

arei

roS

ci p

er P

S p

opul

atio

n48

.859

9833

5S

anta

rem

2774

82W

eigh

ted

degr

ee B

Sc

1971

.18

Itaitu

ba10

2852

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

MS

c90

.171

Alta

mira

1204

41W

eigh

ted

degr

ee P

hD35

.649

Mac

apa

1792

73T

ot30

5591

7

East

ern

Amaz

ioni

a fr

om B

elem

to

Man

aus.

Low

land

cor

ridor

alo

ng A

maz

on a

nd t

ribut

arie

s.In

tera

ctio

n of

tem

pera

ture

, el

evat

ion

and

agric

ultu

ral

activ

ity.

Low

land

for

est

clea

ranc

e zo

ne.

3% o

f to

tal l

and

area

.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fr

om U

ND

P 19

99.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

UN

DP

1999

.

Base

d on

pop

ulat

ion

dens

ity

of 3

peo

ple

per

sq k

m f

or

targ

et a

rea.

Base

d on

tot

al o

f U

N d

ata

for

citie

s w

ith m

ore

than

100

,000

inha

bita

nts:

Bel

em, M

anau

s,

Sant

arem

, It

aitu

ba, Al

tam

ira

and

Mac

apa.

Tota

l of

estim

ated

rur

al a

nd

urba

n po

pula

tions

.2%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

Tow

ns >

100,

000

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Alta

mira

, Be

lem

, It

aitu

ba,

Mac

apa,

Man

aus,

San

tare

m.

Roa

d de

nsity

sca

le:

5=de

nse,

1=

spar

se.

1991

dat

a.

App-7

Page 14: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

1T

AR

GE

T C

OU

NT

RY

PS

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

TIC

S

CA

RIB

BE

AN

HP

HS

SA

FA

LW

PU

Nat

ion

alS

ou

rce

No

tes

Nat

ion

al d

ata:

CA

RE

Land

are

a (k

m2)

25

82

70

Use

DF

ID d

efin

itio

n o

f C

ari

bb

ea

n?

?H

um

an

po

pu

latio

n:

To

tal

57

01

00

0F

rom

DF

ID-R

NR

RS

-NR

SP

Rep

ort R

7111

Rur

al

L

WI

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms:

So

urc

e C

IA W

orl

d F

act

bo

ok

19

96

Urb

anS

tate

Are

a (k

m2)

Po

pR

oa

ds

Pa

ved

No

t p

ave

dA

ng

uill

a9

11

00

00

10

56

54

0P

S d

ata:

An

tigu

a &

B4

40

66

00

02

50

Land

are

a (k

m2)

63

33

4B

arb

ad

os

43

02

57

00

01

65

01

58

26

8H

um

an

po

pu

latio

n:

To

tal

51

26

00

0B

VI

15

01

30

00

11

3

R

ural

23

06

70

0C

aym

an

Is

26

03

50

00

40

63

04

10

2

U

rban

28

19

30

0D

om

inic

a7

50

83

00

07

80

39

33

87

Ma

rke

t in

fra

stru

ctu

re:

Gre

nada

34

09

50

00

10

40

63

84

02

Ro

ad

de

nsi

ty (

km r

oa

ds

pe

r sq

km o

f P

S o

n 5

pt

sca

le)

5G

uya

na

21

49

70

71

20

00

79

70

59

07

98

0M

ark

et

de

ma

nd

ass

ess

me

nt

(to

wn

s> 1

00

,00

0p

op

/ 1

00

0sq

km o

f P

S)

0.0

47

37

Jam

aic

a1

09

90

25

95

00

01

87

00

13

10

05

60

0A

sse

ssm

en

t o

f e

xpo

rt p

ote

ntia

l (m

id p

oin

t o

f P

S t

o m

ajo

r ci

ty [

km])

50

Mo

nts

err

at

10

01

30

00

26

92

03

66

La

nd

pro

du

ctiv

ity p

ote

ntia

l 5

St

K &

N2

69

41

00

03

20

13

61

84

Po

vert

y st

atu

s: A

vera

ge

GD

P (

US

D p

er

an

nu

m p

er

cap

ita,1

99

7)

48

69

48

69

St

Lu

cia

62

01

58

00

01

21

06

31

14

7

Lite

racy

rat

e %

(19

97,

natio

nal)

83

.48

3.4

St

V &

G3

40

11

80

00

10

40

32

07

20

H

arva

rd s

cale

dat

aT

& T

51

30

12

72

00

08

32

04

25

24

06

8

% c

hild

ren

with

acc

epta

ble

wei

ght/

heig

ht t

o ag

e9

2T

urks

& C

43

01

40

00

12

12

49

7N

R k

no

wle

dg

e b

ase

Su

b t

ota

l2

35

31

05

48

20

00

42

29

4N

R k

no

wle

dg

e b

ase

(D

eg

ree

le

vel

of

na

tion

al

rese

arc

he

rs)

: %

BS

c

% M

Sc

Gu

yan

a a

d1

71

97

63

56

00

0

% P

hDT

ota

l6

33

34

51

26

00

0A

gri

cultu

ral

Re

sea

rch

: N

o o

f sc

ien

tists

(1

99

1)

Sha

re o

f G

DP

to

Ag

R (

1991

)K

ing

sto

n7

00

kC

alc

ula

tion

s fo

r w

eig

hts

on

su

mm

ary

pa

ge

: G

DP

24

95

84

94

00

0G

eorg

etow

n20

0k

Lit

42

75

08

40

0P

of

Sp

ain

Wei

ght/h

eigh

t4

71

59

20

00

Vario

us d

efin

ition

s of

Car

ibbe

an:

ie s

mal

l isl

ands

of th

e CA

RIF

ORU

M c

ount

ries,

CAR

ICO

M p

lus

UK

depe

nden

cies

.D

efin

ition

use

d is

the

latt

er b

ut e

xclu

ding

the

CAR

ICO

M m

embe

rs B

aham

as, H

aiti

and

Surin

ame.

The

coun

trie

s/st

ates

/ter

ritor

ies

incl

uded

her

e ar

e th

eref

ore:

Angu

illa,

Ant

igua

& B

arbu

da, B

arba

dos,

BV

I, C

aym

an I

s., D

omin

ica,

Gre

nada

, G

uyan

a, J

amai

ca, M

onts

erra

t, S

t Ki

tts

& N

evis

, St

Luc

ia, St

Vi

ncen

t &

the

Gre

nadi

nes,

Trin

idad

& T

obag

o, T

urks

& C

aico

s Is

.

Targ

et a

rea:

all

of is

land

s an

d co

asta

l zon

e of

mai

nlan

d G

uyan

a.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fr

om U

ND

P 19

99.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

UN

DP

1999

.

Dat

a fr

om N

RSP

R71

11.

Dat

a fr

om N

RSP

R71

11.

Base

d on

sim

ple

aver

age

ofad

ult l

itera

cy d

ata

avai

labl

e (in

depe

nden

t sta

tes

only

)

Wei

ghte

d av

erag

e fo

r G

DP

data

ava

ilabl

e (in

depe

nden

t st

ates

onl

y).

Wei

ghte

d av

erag

e fo

r G

DP

data

ava

ilabl

e (in

depe

nden

t st

ates

onl

y).

Base

d on

sim

ple

aver

age

of

adul

t lite

racy

dat

a av

aila

ble

(inde

pend

ent s

tate

s on

ly).

Tota

l for

tar

get co

untr

ies

min

us 8

0% o

f Guy

ana

land

are

a.To

tal f

or tar

get co

untr

ies

min

us 5

0% o

f Guy

ana

popu

latio

n.

Aver

age

55%

urb

an fo

r ta

rget

cou

ntrie

s fo

r w

hich

da

ta is

ava

ilabl

e.

100k

m for

coa

stal

G

uyan

a,

50km

for

Jam

aica

. 10-

25km

fo

r sm

all i

slan

ds.

Tow

ns >

100,

000

in tar

get ar

ea:

Geo

rget

own,

Kin

gsto

n, P

ort of

Sp

ain.

Siz

e of

mai

n to

wns

var

y ac

cord

ing

to the

siz

e of

the

isla

nd.

This

val

ue is

ver

y di

stor

ted

by the

la

nd a

rea

from

mai

nlan

d G

uyan

a.

20%

50%

Km o

f ro

ads

(all

clas

ses)

for

tar

get

coun

trie

s pe

r sq

km. C

are,

fig

ure

incl

udes

to

tal r

oads

for

Guy

ana

but

tar

get ar

ea

only

incl

udes

coa

stal

zon

es.

Figu

re o

f 44,

542k

m o

f roa

ds u

sed.

5 o

n sc

ale

Dat

a on

ly a

vaila

ble

for:

Dom

inic

a 90

%G

rena

da 9

8%Ja

mai

ca 9

3%Tr

inid

ad &

Tob

ago

90%

Aver

age

take

n fo

r Ja

mai

caan

d T&

T on

ly b

ecau

se o

f re

lativ

e po

pula

tion

size

.

1991

dat

a.

App-8

Page 15: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

1T

AR

GE

T C

OU

NT

RY

PS

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

TIC

S

GH

AN

AH

PH

SS

AF

A (

1)F

A (

2)L

WP

UN

atio

nal

So

urc

eN

ote

sN

atio

nal

dat

a:La

nd a

rea

(km

2)23

9981

ES

RI 9

8A

ccra

1.2

50.0

00H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al19

1620

00U

N m

id 9

8U

N d

ata

1970

50%

R

ural

1211

0384

Acc

ra

5641

94(7

8349

8)

Urb

an70

5161

6K

umas

i26

0286

(345

117)

Sek

ondi

9187

4(16

0868

)P

S d

ata:

Land

are

a (k

m2)

6712

355

115

HD

R D

ata

1999

Hum

an p

opul

atio

n: T

otal

6831

315

1934

168

3768

000

Nat

pop

1870

000

R

ural

4317

391

1222

394

1280

889

%ur

ban

36.8

U

rban

2513

924

7117

7424

8711

1M

arke

t inf

rast

ruct

ure:

ES

RI 9

816

6980

90R

oad

dens

ity (

km r

oads

per

sqk

m o

f PS

on

5 pt

sca

le)

53

5M

arke

t dem

and

asse

ssm

ent (

tow

ns>

100

,000

pop/

100

0sqk

m o

f PS

)0.

1489

80.

1814

4E

urop

a 19

84 d

ata

Sce

nario

1S

cena

rio 2

Ass

essm

ent o

f exp

ort p

oten

tial (

mid

poi

nt o

f PS

to m

ajor

tow

n [k

m])

100

150

Wes

tern

1158

Land

pro

duct

ivity

pot

entia

l1

1C

entr

al11

42P

over

ty s

tatu

s: A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)16

4016

4016

4016

40U

ND

P19

99G

Acc

ra14

31

Lite

racy

rat

e %

(19

97, n

atio

nal)

66.4

66.4

66.4

66.4

UN

DP

1999

Eas

tern

1681

30%

504.

3

Har

vard

sca

le d

ata

Vol

ta12

1250

%60

630

%36

3.6

%

chi

ldre

n w

ith a

ccep

tabl

e w

eigh

t/hei

ght t

o ag

e73

7347

NR

kno

wle

dge

base

(D

egre

e le

vel o

f nat

iona

l res

earc

hers

) : %

BS

c30

3030

Ash

anti

2090

100%

2090

%

MS

c45

4545

Bro

g-A

hafo

1207

100%

1207

25%

301.

75

% P

hD25

2525

Nor

ther

n11

6550

%58

2.5

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h: N

o of

sci

entis

ts (

1991

)27

827

827

8U

pper

E77

3

Sha

re o

f GD

P to

Ag

R (

1991

)0.

30.

30.

3U

pper

W43

8T

otal

1229

744

07.3

1247

.85

Cal

cula

tions

for

wei

ghts

on

sum

mar

y pa

ge: G

DP

1120

3356

600

3172

0347

0061

7952

0000

plus

55%

1906

0.35

6831

.315

1934

.168

L

it45

3599

316

1284

2872

225

0195

200

Tar

gets

for

PU

I

Wie

ght/h

eigh

t49

8685

995

1411

9422

7.5

1770

9600

0ci

ty 8

4pl

us 5

5%m

etro

98

GD

P n

atio

nal

3142

5680

000

3142

5680

000

3142

5680

000

Acc

ra86

7459

1344

561

2218

000

unab

le to

find

G

DP

on

Ag

9427

7040

9427

7040

9427

7040

Kum

asi

3762

4958

3186

7000

00es

timat

e fo

r A

ccra

Sci

per

1 m

illio

n na

tiona

l pop

ulat

ion

14.5

0788

018

14.5

0788

018

14.5

0788

018

Tam

ale

1359

5221

0725

.630

0000

figur

e is

incr

ease

dS

ci p

er P

S p

opul

atio

n99

.107

8994

928

.060

6703

454

.665

6925

2T

ema

1315

2820

3868

.425

0000

1984

Gre

ater

Acc

ra

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

BS

c83

.483

.483

.4T

akor

adi}

6148

495

300.

230

0000

data

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

MS

c12

5.1

125.

112

5.1

Sek

ondi

}31

916

4946

9.8

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

PhD

69.5

69.5

69.5

1604

588

2487

111

3768

000

plus

55%

2487

111.

4

Base

d on

LG

P of

9 m

ths.

Sele

cts

area

whe

re c

limax

ve

geta

tion

is f

ores

t, t

hat

has

been

/is

vario

usly

cle

ared

for

ag

ricul

ture

.

Base

d on

LG

P of

8 m

ths.

Se

lect

s th

e ec

olog

ical

tr

ansi

tion

zone

fro

m s

avan

na

to f

ores

t as

the

clim

ax

vege

tatio

n co

ver,

bot

h va

rious

ly c

lear

ed a

nd u

sed

for

agric

ultu

re.

28%

of

land

are

a.23%

of

land

are

a.

Accr

aKu

mas

iTa

mal

eTe

ma

Seko

ndi-

Tako

radi

ww

w.u

n.or

g/D

epts

/uns

d/d

emog

/288

.htm

1970

dat

a

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

UN

DP

1999

.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fr

om U

ND

P 19

99.

Base

d on

per

cent

age

of la

nd a

rea

occu

pyin

g ta

rget

are

a.Po

pula

tion

figur

es f

rom

pro

vinc

ial

1984

dat

a in

crea

sed

by 5

5% t

o re

flect

nat

iona

l pop

ulat

ion

grow

th

1984

-98.

36%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

Base

d on

per

cent

age

of la

nd a

rea

occu

pyin

g ta

rget

are

a.Po

pula

tion

figur

e fr

om p

rovi

ncia

l 198

4 da

ta

incr

ease

d by

55%

to

refle

ct g

row

th in

nat

iona

l po

pula

tion

1984

-98.

10%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

36.8

% b

ased

on

natio

nal d

ata.

HD

R

1999

Maj

or t

owns

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Kum

asi,

Suny

ani,

Obu

sai,

Bakw

ai, H

o, B

erek

um, G

awso

, Ba

kwai

, H

ahoe

, Kp

andu

.

Tow

ns in

tar

get

area

: Sa

laga

, Ki

ntam

po, Ye

ndi,

Bim

bila

, D

unba

i, Ke

te

Krac

hi, Kw

adjo

krom

, Ye

ji, B

ole,

Saw

la.

Accr

a, K

umas

i, Se

kond

i-Ta

kora

di, Ta

mal

e, T

ema.

19

84 c

ensu

s da

ta in

crea

sed

by 5

5% o

r 19

98 e

stim

ates

fr

om F

WKC

enc

yclo

pedi

a.20

% o

f po

pula

tion.

1984

cen

sus

'city

' dat

a sc

aled

up

by 5

5% t

o re

flect

gen

eral

pop

ulat

ion

incr

ease

.

Diff

eren

ce b

etw

een

city

and

m

etro

polit

an p

opul

atio

ns =

pe

ri-ur

ban.

Prim

ary

and

seco

ndar

y pa

ved

road

s.Sc

ale

5 =

den

se, 1=

spar

se.

1993

dat

a -

wei

ght/

age

only

.

1991

dat

a.

Scal

e: %

con

trib

utio

n to

na

tiona

l pro

duct

ion:

5 =

80

-10

04

= 6

0 -8

03

= 4

0 -6

02

= 2

0 -

401

= 0

-20

App-9

Page 16: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

IND

IAH

P(1

)H

P(2

)H

SS

A (

1)S

A (

2)F

AL

WP

UN

atio

nal

So

urc

eN

atio

nal

dat

a:La

nd a

rea

(km

2)30

8928

2E

SR

I 98

Hum

an p

opul

atio

n: T

otal

9709

3300

0U

N m

id 9

8

Rur

al

70

4897

358

U

rban

2660

3564

2

PS

dat

a:La

nd a

rea

(km

2)30

9929

4837

3910

2726

016

2048

7H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al16

9002

378

2491

6125

032

2700

313

5284

7173

839

0782

38.9

8

Rur

al

12

5061

760

1843

7932

523

8798

232

3910

6908

624

8522

64

Urb

an43

9406

1864

7819

2583

9020

8113

7402

652

1422

5975

Mar

ket i

nfra

stru

ctur

e:R

oad

dens

ity (

km r

oads

per

PS

on

5 pt

sca

le)

55

45

5M

arke

t dem

and

asse

ssm

ent (

tow

ns>

100

,000

pop/

100

0sqk

m o

f PS

)0.

0193

60.

0206

70.

0165

50.

0191

3A

sses

smen

t of e

xpor

t pot

entia

l (m

id p

oint

of P

S to

maj

or c

ity [k

m])

200

200

200

200

Land

pro

duct

ivity

pot

entia

l 3

3.5

3

Pov

erty

sta

tus:

Ave

rage

GD

P (

US

D p

er a

nnum

per

cap

ita,1

997)

1670

1670

1670

1670

1670

1670

UN

DP

1999

L

itera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, nat

iona

l)53

.553

.553

.553

.553

.553

.5U

ND

P19

99

Har

vard

sca

le d

ata

%

chi

ldre

n w

ith a

ccep

tabl

e w

eigh

t/hei

ght t

o ag

e54

5454

5454

NR

kno

wle

dge

base

NR

kno

wle

dge

base

(D

egre

e le

vel o

f nat

iona

l res

earc

hers

) : %

BS

c

% M

Sc

0.3

%

PhD

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h: N

o of

sci

entis

ts (

1991

)48

3048

3048

3048

3048

30

Sha

re o

f GD

P to

Ag

R (

1991

)0.

150.

150.

150.

150.

15C

alcu

latio

ns fo

r w

eigh

ts o

n su

mm

ary

page

: GD

P

2.82

234E

+11

4.16

099E

+11

5.38

91E

+11

8.82

548E

+11

6526

0659

097

L

it90

4162

7223

1333

0126

875

1726

4466

746

2827

3237

983

2090

6857

85

Wei

ght/h

eigh

t91

2612

8412

1345

4707

500

1742

5816

902

2853

7473

852

2110

2249

05G

DP

nat

iona

l1.

6214

6E+

121.

6214

6E+

121.

6214

6E+

121.

6214

6E+

121.

6214

6E+

12G

DP

on

Ag

2432

1871

6524

3218

7165

2432

1871

6524

3218

7165

2432

1871

65S

ci p

er 1

mill

ion

natio

nal p

opul

atio

n4.

9745

9659

94.

9745

9659

94.

9745

9659

94.

9745

9659

94.

9745

9659

9S

ci p

er P

S p

opul

atio

n84

0.71

8654

912

39.4

7670

716

05.3

0388

2628

.933

711

194.

3984

747

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

BS

cW

eigh

ted

degr

ee M

Sc

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

PhD

Inte

ract

ion

of r

ainf

all,

soils

, el

evat

ion.

D

ry a

nd m

oist

sem

i arid

: LG

Ps 9

0-15

0 da

ys, 50

0-10

00m

m.

Bas

ed o

n IC

RIS

AT L

GP

NRM

Pro

gram

me

data

.

Indo

-gan

getic

pla

in z

one.

Low

ele

vatio

n Bi

har

& e

aste

rn

UP.

Sugg

este

d ap

proa

ch w

as t

o se

lect

2 'm

ega'

, 2

larg

e, 2

med

ium

and

2

smal

l citi

es. An

alys

is o

f th

e 19

91 c

ensu

s da

ta s

how

s th

at t

here

w

ere

300

citie

s w

ith p

opul

atio

n gr

eate

r th

an 1

00,0

00 a

ccou

ntin

g fo

r 21

7 m

illio

n of

Ind

ia's

peo

ple.

Ci

ties

sele

cted

:Ag

ra, Ba

ngal

ore,

Bom

bay,

Cal

cutt

a, K

hara

gpur

, H

yder

abad

, H

ubli-

Dha

rwad

and

Shi

llong

.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fro

m

UN

DP

1999

.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

U

ND

P 19

99.

Inte

ract

ion

of r

ainf

all,

soils

, el

evat

ion.

As

for

Sce

nario

1 p

lus:

Dry

sub

hum

id:

LGP

150-

180

days

, 10

00-1

200m

m.

Base

d on

ICR

ISAT

LG

P N

RM

Pro

gram

me

data

.

Base

d on

app

rox.

% o

f st

ate

land

are

a fa

lling

with

in t

he

targ

et a

rea

and

appl

ying

the

sa

me

perc

enta

ges

to t

he

1991

sta

te c

ensu

s da

ta. Th

e to

tal w

as t

han

incr

ease

d by

14

% t

o re

flect

the

diff

eren

ce

betw

een

the

1991

cen

sus

and

the

UN

mid

199

8 es

timat

e.33

% o

f to

tal p

opul

atio

n.

Base

d on

app

roxi

mat

e pe

rcen

tage

of

stat

e la

nd f

allin

g w

ith t

he t

arge

t ar

ea a

nd a

pply

ing

the

sam

e pe

rcen

tage

to

the

1991

sta

te c

ensu

s da

ta.

The

tota

l was

the

n in

crea

sed

to r

efle

ct t

he d

iffer

ence

bet

wee

n th

e 19

91 c

ensu

s da

ta a

nd t

he U

N m

id 1

998

estim

ate.

54

% o

f to

tal

popu

latio

n.

74%

, fr

om n

atio

nal

data

. Se

e no

tes

for

indi

vidu

al s

tate

ru

ral/ur

ban

data

74%

, fr

om n

atio

nal d

ata.

Ref

er t

o no

tes

for

indi

vdua

l st

ate

rura

l/ u

rban

dat

a.

Met

ropl

itan

area

pop

ulat

ion

for

8 se

lect

ed c

ities

.To

tal i

ncre

ased

by

14%

to

refle

ct in

crea

se in

gen

eral

po

pula

tion.

Not

e: u

rban

isat

ion

rate

m

ay b

e hi

gher

tha

n po

pula

tion

grow

th r

ate.

Tota

l for

'city

' pop

ulat

ions

fo

r se

lect

ed c

ities

fro

m

1991

cen

sus

data

in

crea

sed

by 1

4% t

o re

flect

gen

eral

pop

ulat

ion

incr

ease

.

'Per

i-urb

an' p

opul

atio

n.D

iffer

ence

bet

wee

n m

etro

polit

an a

nd c

ity

popu

latio

ns.

Indo

-gan

getic

pla

in z

one.

Low

ele

vatio

n Bi

har

& E

aste

rn U

P,

high

er e

leva

tion

wes

tern

UP,

Har

yana

& P

unja

b.In

tera

ctio

n of

soi

l typ

e an

d ra

infa

ll

Base

d on

75%

of

popu

latio

n of

Bih

ar a

nd 6

0% o

f U

ttar

Pr

ades

h, in

crea

sed

by 1

4% t

o re

flect

pop

ulat

ion

incr

ease

in 1

991

cens

us d

ata.

17

% o

f to

tal p

opul

atio

n.

Base

d on

75%

of

popu

latio

n Bi

har,

80%

of

UP,

90%

of

Har

yana

, 90

% o

f Pu

njab

and

100

% o

f D

elhi

UT.

Incr

ease

d by

14%

to

refle

ct g

ener

al

incr

ease

in p

opul

atio

n.26

% o

f to

tal

popu

latio

n.

74%

rur

al f

rom

nat

iona

l sta

tistic

s. A

rea

incl

udes

citi

es o

f Pa

tna,

Ben

ares

, G

orak

pur,

Luc

know

, Al

laha

bad

and

Kanp

ur.

74%

rur

al f

rom

nat

iona

l sta

tistic

s. A

rea

incl

udes

citi

es o

f Pa

tna,

Ben

ares

, G

orak

pur,

Luc

know

, Al

laha

bad,

Kan

pur,

Agr

a, B

arei

lly, D

elhi

& N

ew D

elhi

.

Citie

s >

500,

000

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Agra

, Ah

med

abad

, Am

ritsa

r, B

anga

lore

, D

elhi

, G

wal

ior,

Jai

pur,

Ka

npur

, Ko

ta, Lu

ckno

w, Lu

dhia

na, M

adra

s. M

adur

ai, M

ysor

e, S

olap

ur, Ti

ruch

chira

ppal

li,

Vado

dara

.

Wid

er d

efin

ition

tar

get

area

in

clud

es a

dditi

onal

citi

es:

Alla

haba

d, B

arei

lly, Be

nare

s,

Bhop

al, Bo

mba

y, C

hand

igar

gh,

Gor

akhp

ur, H

yder

abad

, M

adra

s, N

agpu

r, P

atna

, Pu

ne,

Sura

t, V

aran

asi.

Citie

s >

500,

000

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Alla

haba

d,

Bena

res,

G

orak

hpur

, Ka

npur

, Lu

ckno

w, Pa

tna.

Addi

tiona

l citi

es >

500,

000

in

expa

nded

tar

get

area

: Ag

ra,

Amrit

sar,

Bar

eilly

, D

ehli.

Roa

d de

nsity

sca

le:

5=de

nse,

1=

spar

se.

Wei

ght/

age

only

.

App-10

Page 17: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

No

tes

– In

dia

Sta

teP

op 9

1ru

ral

SA

(1)

SA

(2)

HP

(1)

HP

(2)

Tam

il N

5585

966

%60

%33

515.

490

%50

273.

1C

alcu

tta11

1000

00K

arna

taka

4497

769

%70

%31

483.

975

%33

732.

75K

anpu

r18

7500

0A

nd. P

.66

508

73%

60%

3990

4.8

80%

5320

6.4

Pat

na10

2500

0M

ahar

ash.

7893

761

%50

%39

468.

575

%59

202.

75D

elhi

7200

000

Mad

hya

P.

6618

177

%25

%16

545.

2570

%46

326.

7B

enar

es92

5000

Guj

arat

4131

066

%60

%24

786

70%

2891

7N

Del

hi27

3036

Raj

asth

an44

006

77%

40%

1760

2.4

40%

1760

2.4

Luck

now

1060

000

Utta

r P

. 13

9112

80%

40%

5564

4.8

75%

1043

3460

%83

467.

280

%11

1289

.6Ja

ipur

1025

000

Bih

ar86

374

87%

050

%43

187

75%

6478

0.5

75%

6478

0.5

Ahm

edab

a d24

0000

0H

arya

na16

464

75%

40%

6585

.650

%65

85.6

90%

1481

7.6

Nag

pur

1302

000

Pun

jab

2028

270

%40

%81

12.8

50%

1014

190

%18

253.

8B

omba

y99

5000

0D

elhi

9421

10%

100%

9421

100%

9421

100%

9421

Pun

e17

7500

0C

hand

i gar

gh64

210

%0

100%

642

Hyd

erab

ad27

5000

0V

isha

kha p

a60

3630

2830

70.4

546

3571

.714

8247

.721

8562

.5A

mrit

sar

2948

4414

% in

crea

se32

2700

.313

5284

71.7

1690

02.4

2491

61.3

Man

galo

re30

6078

Ban

galo

re29

5000

0M

adra

s44

7500

091

cen

sus

8463

0374

%

Coc

hin

6828

3698

UN

est

9709

33M

adur

ai96

0000

incr

ease

14

%H

ubli-

Dha

r w64

8298

Ran

dom

sel

ectio

n fo

r P

UH

DR

dat

a 19

9919

91C

ity

Met

ro14

%in

c(C

)14

%in

c(M

)A

reas

qkm

Nat

pop

9662

0000

0A

gra

8917

9094

8063

1016

640.

610

8079

1.82

%ur

ban

27.4

Ban

galo

re26

6008

841

3028

830

3250

0.32

4708

528.

3236

6B

omba

y99

2589

112

5962

4311

3155

15.7

1435

9717

ES

RI 9

889

4608

700

Cal

cutta

4399

819

1102

1918

5015

793.

6612

5649

86.5

852

Kha

ragp

ur17

7989

2648

4220

2907

.46

3019

19.8

8H

yder

abad

2964

638

4344

437

3379

687.

3249

5265

8.18

217

Hub

li-D

har

6482

9875

0000

7390

59.7

285

5000

Shi

llong

1317

1922

3366

1501

59.6

625

4637

.24

Tot

al21

8002

3234

2791

5724

8522

64.5

3907

8239

estim

ate

ww

w.u

n.or

g./D

epts

/uns

d/de

mog

/356

.htm

1991

dat

a

App-11

Page 18: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

KE

NY

AH

PH

SS

AF

AL

WP

UN

atio

nal

So

urc

eN

ote

sN

atio

nal

dat

a:La

nd a

rea

(km

2)58

0367

ES

RI 9

8N

airo

bi12

8620

0H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al29

0080

00U

n m

id98

Mom

basa

4423

69

Rur

al

20

1895

68R

ural

pop

70%

Bou

rn/B

lenc

h

Urb

an88

1843

2P

op d

en50

per

km2

Bou

rn/B

lenc

h

PS

dat

a:H

DR

dat

a 19

99La

nd a

rea

(sqk

m)

1075

51N

at p

op28

4000

0H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al21

3317

60%

urba

n30

.4

Rur

al

14

9322

32

Urb

an63

9952

8E

SR

I 98

2583

5250

Mar

ket i

nfra

stru

ctur

e:R

oad

dens

ity (

km r

oads

per

PS

on

5 pt

sca

le)

3.5

EIU

198

8 da

taT

arge

t%

New

tgt

Mar

ket d

eman

d as

sess

men

t (to

wns

> 1

00,0

00po

p/ 1

000s

qkm

of P

S)

0.11

157

Cen

tral

3117

14.5

3117

100

3117

Ass

essm

ent o

f exp

ort p

oten

tial (

mid

poi

nt o

f PS

to m

ajor

tow

n [k

m])

100

Nya

nza

3507

16.4

3507

100

3507

Land

pro

duct

ivity

pot

entia

l 4

Wes

tern

2544

11.9

2544

100

2544

Pov

erty

sta

tus:

Ave

rage

GD

P (

US

D p

er a

nnum

per

cap

ita,1

997)

1190

1190

UN

DP

1999

R V

alle

y49

8223

.230

0060

2989

.2

Lite

racy

rat

e %

(19

97, n

atio

nal)

79.3

79.3

UN

DP

1999

Eas

tern

3769

17.6

2500

7026

38.3

H

arva

rd s

cale

dat

a

% c

hild

ren

with

acc

epta

ble

wei

ght/h

eigh

t to

age

72C

oast

1829

8.5

1000

5510

05.9

5N

R k

now

ledg

e ba

se (

Deg

ree

leve

l of n

atio

nal r

esea

rche

rs)

: % B

Sc

50N

airo

bi13

256.

20

0

% M

Sc

42N

Eas

tern

371

1.7

00

%

PhD

821

444

100

1566

815

801.

45A

gric

ultu

ral R

esea

rch:

No

of s

cien

tists

(19

91)

819

plus

35%

2894

921

179

2133

1.76

S

hare

of G

DP

to A

g R

(19

91)

0.5

Cal

cula

tions

for

wei

ghts

on

sum

mar

y pa

ge: G

DP

2.53

85E

+10

L

it16

9160

8568

w

eigh

t/hei

ght

1535

8867

20G

DP

nat

iona

l3.

452E

+10

GD

P o

n A

g17

2597

600

Sci

per

1 m

illio

n na

tiona

l pop

ulat

ion

28.2

3359

07S

ci p

er P

S p

opul

atio

n60

2.27

2181

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

BS

c40

9.5

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

MS

c34

3.98

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

PhD

65.5

2

18%

of

land

are

a.

Inte

ract

ion

of r

ainf

all,

LGP

and

soils

dat

a.Rai

nfal

l 900

mm

+, LG

P 7m

ths+

and

soi

l cla

sses

: Fe

rras

ol, Lu

viso

l, Ca

mbi

sol,

Nito

sol,

Vert

isol

, Ac

risol

, Pl

anos

ol a

nd A

ndos

ol.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fro

m

UN

DP

1999

.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

U

ND

P 19

99.

Area

of

grea

test

po

pula

tion

dens

ity is

the

ta

rget

are

a. G

uess

timat

e m

ade

as t

o w

hat

prop

rtio

n of

pro

vinc

ial p

opul

atio

ns

to in

clud

e

Area

of

grea

test

pop

ulat

ion

dens

ity

is t

he t

arge

t ar

ea. G

uess

timat

e m

ade

as t

o w

hat

prop

rtio

n of

pr

ovin

cial

pop

ulat

ions

to

incl

ude.

Se

e no

tes.

73%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

70%

of

popu

latio

n fr

om

natio

nal d

ata.

30%

of

popu

latio

n fr

om

natio

nal d

ata.

Tow

ns in

tar

get

area

: Ki

tale

, El

dore

t, K

isum

u,

Nak

uru,

Nai

robi

, M

omba

sa, Ka

kam

ega,

Bu

tere

, N

yeri,

Thi

ka,

Mer

u, M

acha

kos.

Den

sity

sca

le:

5=de

nse,

1=

spar

se.

1991

dat

a.

App-12

Page 19: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

NE

PA

LH

PH

SS

AF

AL

WP

UN

atio

nal

So

urc

eN

ote

sN

atio

nal

dat

a:La

nd a

rea

(km

2)14

7293

ES

RI 9

8K

athm

andu

3200

00H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al21

8430

00U

N m

id 9

8

Rur

al

19

4621

13H

DR

dat

a 19

99

Urb

an23

8088

7N

at p

op22

3000

00%

urba

n10

.9P

S d

ata:

Land

are

a (k

m2)

8143

081

430

ES

RI 9

819

9272

80H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al11

9575

8211

9575

82

Rur

al

10

6542

0610

6542

06

Urb

an13

0337

613

0337

6M

arke

t inf

rast

ruct

ure:

Roa

d de

nsity

(km

roa

ds p

er P

S o

n 5

pt s

cale

)1

1M

arke

t dem

and

asse

ssm

ent (

tow

ns>

100

,000

pop/

100

0sqk

m o

f PS

)0.

1228

00.

1228

0A

sses

smen

t of e

xpor

t pot

entia

l (m

id p

oint

of P

S to

maj

or c

ity [k

m])

100

100

Land

pro

duct

ivity

pot

entia

l 3.

5

Pov

erty

sta

tus:

Ave

rage

GD

P (

US

D p

er a

nnum

per

cap

ita,1

997)

1090

1090

1090

UN

DP

1999

L

itera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, nat

iona

l)38

.138

.138

.1U

ND

P19

99

Har

vard

sca

le d

ata

%

chi

ldre

n w

ith a

ccep

tabl

e w

eigh

t/hei

ght t

o ag

e53

53N

R k

now

ledg

e ba

seN

R k

now

ledg

e ba

se (

Deg

ree

leve

l of n

atio

nal r

esea

rche

rs)

: % B

Sc

17

% M

Sc

%

PhD

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h: N

o of

sci

entis

ts (

1991

)

Sha

re o

f GD

P to

Ag

R (

1991

)C

alcu

latio

ns fo

r w

eigh

ts o

n su

mm

ary

page

: GD

P13

0337

6438

013

0337

6438

0

Lit

4555

8387

4.2

4555

8387

4.2

W

eigh

t/heo

ght

6337

5184

663

3751

846

GD

P n

atio

nal

2380

8870

000

GD

P o

n A

g0

Sci

per

1 m

illio

n na

tiona

l pop

ulat

ion

Sci

per

PS

pop

ulat

ion

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

BS

cW

eigh

ted

degr

ee M

Sc

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

PhD

Land

in t

he r

ange

300

-250

0m e

leva

tion.

Inc

lude

s ce

ntra

l ban

d of

cou

ntry

and

hi

gher

ele

vatio

n va

lleys

of

Him

alay

a fo

othi

lls.

Take

s in

land

s ch

arac

teris

ed a

s lo

w, m

id a

nd h

igh

hills

and

the

alti

tude

lim

its

of s

tapl

e cr

ops

such

as

rice

and

pota

to.

55%

of

land

are

a.D

isto

rtio

n du

e to

to

pogr

aphy

.

55%

of

land

are

a.D

isto

rtio

n du

e to

to

pogr

aphy

.

Sam

e ar

ea a

s H

S pr

oduc

tion

syst

em.

Fore

st-a

gric

ultu

re in

terf

ace

mor

e lik

ely

in m

id a

nd h

igh

hills

reg

ion.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fro

m U

ND

P 19

99.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

U

ND

P 19

99.

Calc

ulat

ed f

rom

198

1 po

pula

tion

data

fro

m t

he

adm

inis

trat

ive

regi

ons

mos

t cl

osel

y ap

prox

imat

ing

to

the

targ

et a

rea

and

then

incr

eass

ing

the

tota

l by

45.6

% t

o re

flect

the

incr

ease

in t

he t

otal

pop

ulat

ion

from

the

198

1 da

ta s

et t

o th

e U

n m

id 1

998

estim

ate.

Calc

ulat

ed f

rom

198

1 po

pula

tion

data

fro

m t

he

adm

inis

trat

ive

regi

ons

mos

t cl

osel

y ap

prox

imat

ing

to t

he

targ

et a

rea

and

then

in

crea

ssin

g th

e to

tal b

y 45

.6%

to

refle

ct t

he

incr

ease

in t

he t

otal

po

pula

tion

from

the

198

1 da

ta s

et t

o th

e U

N m

id 1

998

estim

ate.

55%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

10.9

% o

f po

pula

tion

acco

rdin

g to

Hum

an

Dev

elop

men

t Rep

ort

1999

10.9

% o

f po

pula

tion

acco

rdin

g to

H

uman

D

evel

opm

ent

Rep

ort

1999

Line

ar m

easu

rem

ent

only

.

Line

ar m

easu

rem

ent

only

.

Mai

n to

wns

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Ilam

, D

hank

uta,

Sin

dhul

i, G

arhi

, Ch

arik

ot, Pa

tan,

Kat

ham

andu

, G

orkh

a, P

okha

ra,

Khor

pa.

Mai

n to

wns

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Ilam

, D

hank

uta,

Sin

dhul

i, G

arhi

, Ch

arik

ot, Pa

tan,

Ka

tham

andu

, G

orkh

a,

Pokh

ara,

Kho

rpa.

Wei

ght/

age

only

.

1991

dat

a.

App-13

Page 20: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

TA

NZ

AN

IAH

PH

SS

A (

1)S

A (

2)F

AL

WP

UN

atio

nal

S

ou

rce

No

tes

Nat

ion

al d

ata:

Land

are

a (k

m2)

9449

77E

SR

I 98

Dar

13

0000

0H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al32

1020

00U

N m

id 9

8R

ural

pop

75%

Bou

rn/B

lenc

h

Rur

al

23

8517

86P

op d

en30

per

km2

Bou

rn/B

lenc

h

Urb

an82

5021

4D

FID

def

initi

on o

fS

A z

one

= 4

00-1

20m

mP

S d

ata:

80-9

0% o

f Tan

zB

ourn

/Ble

nch

Land

are

a (k

m2)

2482

8239

2076

Citi

es:

Hum

an p

opul

atio

n: T

otal

8699

757

1695

2769

HD

R d

ata

1999

Dar

1096

R

ural

6524

818

1271

4576

Nat

pop

3140

0000

Mw

naza

252

U

rban

2174

939

4238

192

%ur

ban

25.7

Tab

ora

214

Mar

ket i

nfra

stru

ctur

e:M

beya

194

Roa

d de

nsity

(km

roa

ds p

er s

qkm

of P

S o

n 5

pt s

cale

)3

3E

SR

I 98

2838

6270

Tan

ga17

2M

arke

t dem

and

asse

ssm

ent (

tow

ns>

100

,000

pop/

100

0sqk

m o

f PS

)0.

0000

20.

0000

3Z

anzi

bar

133

Ass

essm

ent o

f exp

ort p

oten

tial (

mid

poi

nt o

f PS

to m

ajor

tow

n [k

m])

150

200

Dod

oma

85La

nd p

rodu

ctiv

ity p

oten

tial

23.

5E

urop

a P

rovi

nces

95

Sce

nario

1S

cena

rio 2

Pov

erty

sta

tus:

Ave

rage

GD

P (

US

D p

er a

nnum

per

cap

ita,1

997)

580

580

580

UN

DP

199

9A

rush

a16

4050

%82

050

%82

092

6.6

L

itera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, nat

iona

l)71

.671

.671

.6U

ND

P19

99D

ar16

510

100%

1651

1865

.63

H

arva

rd s

cale

dat

a0

%

chi

ldre

n w

ith a

ccep

tabl

e w

eigh

t/hei

ght t

o ag

e80

80D

odom

a15

0210

0%15

0250

%75

184

8.63

NR

kno

wle

dge

base

(D

egre

e le

vel o

f nat

iona

l res

earc

hers

) : %

BS

c44

44Ir

inga

1467

100%

1467

100%

1467

1657

.71

%

MS

c44

4439

Kag

era

1653

010

0%16

5318

67.8

9

% P

hD12

12K

ilim

anja

ro13

4550

%67

2.5

100%

1345

1519

.85

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h: N

o of

sci

entis

ts (

1991

)54

654

6Li

ndi

785

030

%23

5.5

266.

115

S

hare

of G

DP

to A

g R

(19

91)

Mar

a11

780

100%

1178

1331

.14

Mbe

ya17

9215

%26

8.8

50%

896

1012

.48

Cal

cula

tions

for

wei

ghts

on

sum

mar

y pa

ge: G

DP

5045

8590

6098

3260

5730

Mor

ogor

o15

2610

%15

2.6

40%

610.

468

9.75

2

Lit

6229

0260

112

1381

8225

Kig

oma

1043

00

0

Wei

ght/h

eigh

t69

5980

560

1356

2214

80M

twar

a10

790

80%

863.

297

5.41

6G

DP

nat

iona

l1.

8619

E+

101.

8619

E+

10M

wan

za22

8030

%68

415

%34

238

6.46

GD

P o

n A

g0

0P

emba

322

00

0S

ci p

er 1

mill

ion

natio

nal p

opul

atio

n17

.008

2861

17.0

0828

61P

wan

i77

40

40%

309.

634

9.84

8S

ci p

er P

S p

opul

atio

n14

7.96

7956

288.

3375

37R

ukw

a84

35%

42.1

50

0W

eigh

ted

degr

ee B

Sc

240.

2424

0.24

Ruv

uma

951

080

%76

0.8

859.

704

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

MS

c24

0.24

240.

24S

hiny

anga

2152

40%

860.

820

%43

0.4

486.

352

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

PhD

65.5

265

.52

Sin

gida

961

100%

961

70%

672.

776

0.15

1T

abor

a12

5715

%18

8.55

5%62

.85

71.0

205

Tan

ga15

905%

79.5

60%

954

1078

.02

Zan

ziba

r45

70

00

2824

876

98.9

1500

2.45

plus

13%

3192

0.24

8699

.757

1695

2.77

1695

2.77

Base

d on

300

-900

mm

ra

infa

ll pe

r an

num

. 25

-30

% o

f co

untr

y. C

ompa

re

with

300

-600

mm

: 5%

an

d 30

0-12

00m

m:

90%

Base

d on

LG

P 3-

6 m

ths.

Occ

upie

s no

rthe

rn

belt

alon

g Ke

nya

and

Uga

nda

bord

er,

cent

ral z

one

and

sout

hern

are

as b

orer

ing

Moz

ambi

que.

Occ

upie

s 40

-50%

of

coun

try.

Co

mpa

re w

ith 3

-4 a

nd 3

-5 m

ths:

are

as d

o no

t ta

ke in

sou

ther

n ar

eas.

26%

of

tota

l lan

d ar

ea

41%

of

tota

l lan

d ar

ea

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fro

m

UN

DP

1999

.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

UN

DP

1999

.Base

d on

pro

prot

iona

l allo

catio

n of

pro

vinc

ial

popu

latio

n da

ta a

ccor

ding

to

perc

enta

ge o

f th

e pr

ovin

ce t

hat

falls

with

in t

he t

arge

t ar

ea.

27%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

75%

acc

ordi

ng t

o na

tiona

l dat

a.25

% a

ccor

ding

to

natio

nal d

ata.

Base

d on

pro

port

iona

l allo

catio

n of

pr

ovin

cial

pop

ulat

ion

data

acc

ordi

ng

to t

he p

erce

ntag

e of

the

pro

vinc

e th

at f

alls

with

in t

he t

arge

t ar

ea.

53%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

75%

acc

ordi

ng t

o na

tiona

l dat

a.

25%

acc

ordi

ng t

o na

tiona

l dat

a.

Tow

ns in

tar

get

area

: D

odom

a, I

ringa

, Ko

ngoa

, Si

ngid

a, S

hiny

anga

, N

zega

.

Tow

ns in

tar

get

area

: D

ar e

sSa

laam

, M

wan

za, Ar

usha

, M

oshi

, D

odom

a, M

orog

oro,

O

rong

a, M

twar

a, L

indi

, M

iland

ani,

Song

ea, To

ndur

u.

Prim

ary

and

seco

ndar

y a

road

s bu

t no

t th

ose

clas

sifie

d as

a t

rack

or

a t

rail.

Scal

e 5=

dens

e, 1

=sp

arse

.

1991

dat

a.

App-14

Page 21: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

1T

AR

GE

T C

OU

NT

RY

PS

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

TIC

S

UG

AN

DA

HP

HS

SA

FA

LW

PU

Nat

ion

alS

ou

rce

No

tes

Nat

ion

al d

ata:

Land

are

a (k

m2)

2430

50E

SR

I 98

Kam

pala

46

0000

Hum

an p

opul

atio

n: T

otal

2102

9000

UN

mid

98

Rur

al p

op87

%B

ourn

/Ble

nch

R

ural

1825

3172

Pop

den

100 p

er k

m2

Bou

rn/B

lenc

h

Urb

an27

7582

8H

DR

dat

a 19

99P

S d

ata:

Nat

pop

2000

0000

Land

are

a (k

m2)

1391

249

535

%ur

ban

13.2

Hum

an p

opul

atio

n: T

otal

2063

438

1057

8750

R

ural

1795

191

9203

513

ES

RI 9

818

1443

60

Urb

an26

8247

1375

238

Mar

ket i

nfra

stru

ctur

e:E

uros

tat 1

990

data

Roa

d de

nsity

(km

roa

ds p

er P

S o

n 5

pt s

cale

)1

4T

arge

t are

a LW

Tar

get a

rea

HS

Mar

ket d

eman

d as

sess

men

t (to

wns

> 1

00,0

00po

p/ 1

000s

qkm

of P

S)

0.28

752

0.26

244

Dis

tric

tD

istr

ict

Por

tion%

Tar

get

T p

lus2

5%A

sses

smen

t of e

xpor

t pot

entia

l (m

id p

oint

of P

S to

maj

or to

wn

[km

])40

60R

akai

396

Mba

le74

330

222.

927

8.62

5La

nd p

rodu

ctiv

ity p

oten

tial

14

Mas

aka

849

Kap

chor

wa

9030

2733

.75

Pov

erty

sta

tus:

Ave

rage

GD

P (

US

D p

er a

nnum

per

cap

ita,1

997)

1160

1160

1160

UN

DP

1999

Mpi

gi84

0M

orot

o22

615

33.9

42.3

75

Lite

racy

rat

e %

(19

97, n

atio

nal)

6464

64U

ND

P19

99Lu

wer

o54

5K

otid

o23

515

35.2

544

.062

5

Har

vard

sca

le d

ata

Apa

c 43

2N

ebbi

293

3087

.910

9.87

5

% c

hild

ren

with

acc

epta

ble

wei

ght/h

eigh

t to

age

6868

0N

R k

now

ledg

e ba

se (

Deg

ree

leve

l of n

atio

nal r

esea

rche

rs)

: % B

Sc

2020

Lira

498

Bun

drib

ugy

161

4064

.480

.5

% M

Sc

4646

13S

orot

i61

2K

ases

e42

510

42.5

53.1

25

% P

hD34

34K

umi

306

Ruk

ungi

ri37

330

111.

913

9.87

5A

gric

ultu

ral R

esea

rch:

No

of s

cien

tists

(19

91)

Tor

oro

965

Kab

ale

536

100

536

670

S

hare

of G

DP

to A

g R

(19

91)

Igan

ga87

8B

ushe

nyi

678

5033

942

3.75

Kam

uli

449

Mba

rara

1000

1515

018

7.5

Cal

cula

tions

for

wei

ghts

on

sum

mar

y pa

ge: G

DP

2393

587.

512

2713

50Ji

nja

271

1650

.75

L

it13

2060

6770

40M

ukon

o77

1H

Spl

us25

%20

63.4

375

2063

.437

5

Wei

ght/h

eigh

t14

0313

.75

7193

55K

ampa

la65

1G

DP

nat

iona

l24

3936

4000

024

3936

4000

0T

otal

LW

8463

GD

P o

n A

g0

0T

otal

Ug

1687

2S

ci p

er 1

mill

ion

natio

nal p

opul

atio

npl

us 2

5%21

090

Sci

per

PS

pop

ulat

ion

LWpl

us25

%10

578.

75W

eigh

ted

degr

ee B

Sc

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

MS

cW

eigh

ted

degr

ee P

hD

Land

of

1500

-200

0m e

leva

tion.

Sc

atte

red

zone

aro

und

bord

ers

of

coun

try.

LG

Ps v

ario

us b

ut g

ener

ally

9-

10 m

ths.

Rai

nfal

l mai

nly

in 9

00-1

500

rang

e.

Base

d on

50k

m d

ista

nce

from

Lak

e Ky

ogya

an

d its

dra

inag

e lin

e to

Lak

e Vi

ctor

ia. LG

P in

thi

s zo

ne 9

-10

mth

s ex

cept

eas

tern

and

so

uthe

rn e

dges

. Rai

nfal

l 120

0mm

+ o

n m

ain

area

and

900

-120

0mm

in e

aste

rn

part

.

6% o

f la

nd a

rea.

20%

of

land

are

a.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fr

om U

ND

P 19

99.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te

1997

fro

m U

ND

P 19

99.

Calc

ulat

ed u

sing

gu

esst

imat

e pr

opor

tion

of la

nd a

rea

falli

ng

with

in t

arge

t ar

ea a

nd

appl

ying

sam

e pr

oprt

ion

to d

istr

ict

popu

latio

n da

ta. To

tal w

as

incr

ease

d by

25%

to

refle

ct d

iffer

ence

in

1990

Eur

osta

t da

ta a

nd

UN

mid

199

8 es

timat

e fo

r U

gand

a.10

% o

f to

tal

popu

latio

n.

87%

of

tota

l usi

ng

natio

nal d

ata.

13%

of

tota

l usi

ng

natio

nal d

ata.

13%

of

tota

l usi

ng

natio

nal d

ata.

87%

of

tota

l usi

ng n

atio

nal

data

. Ta

rget

are

a in

clud

es

Kam

pala

. En

tebb

e an

d Ji

nja

so m

ay n

eed

revi

sion

.

Targ

et a

rea

appr

oxim

ated

to

adm

inis

trat

ive

dist

ricts

for

whi

ch

Euro

stat

giv

e 19

90 p

opul

atio

n da

ta. To

tal i

ncre

ased

by

25%

to

refe

lect

diff

eren

ce b

etw

een

1989

an

d 19

98 U

N d

ata.

50%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

Mai

n to

wns

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Kaba

le, Ka

sese

, N

ebbi

, M

orot

o.

Mai

n to

wns

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Mas

aka,

Ent

ebbe

, Ka

mpa

la,

Bom

bo, Ji

nja,

Iga

nga,

To

roro

, M

bale

, So

roti,

Lira

, Bu

sem

batia

, M

bula

mut

i, N

amas

agal

i.

Roa

d de

nsity

sca

le:

5=de

nse,

1=

spar

se.

1998

dat

a.

App-15

Page 22: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

ZIM

BA

BW

EH

PH

SS

AF

AL

WP

UN

atio

nal

So

urc

eN

ote

sN

atio

nal

dat

a:ce

nsus

Land

are

a (k

m2)

3908

03E

SR

I 98

Har

are

8900

0011

8910

3H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al12

6850

00U

N m

id 9

8B

ulaw

ayo

4138

1462

1742

R

ural

Chi

ungw

iza

2479

12

Urb

anH

DR

dat

a 19

99N

at p

op11

2000

00P

S d

ata:

%ur

ban

33.2

Land

are

a (k

m2)

2297

90H

uman

pop

ulat

ion:

Tot

al57

4475

0E

SR

I 98

1110

6690

R

ural

3848

983

U

rban

1895

768

Cov

ered

popd

enM

arke

t inf

rast

ruct

ure:

Mat

..lan

dN10

0%11

to20

Roa

d de

nsity

(km

roa

ds p

er P

S o

n 5

pt s

cale

)2.

5M

at..l

andS

100%

11to

20M

arke

t dem

and

asse

ssm

ent (

tow

ns>

100

,000

pop/

100

0sqk

m o

f PS

)0.

0652

8M

ash.

.land

W10

%20

to29

Ass

essm

ent o

f exp

ort p

oten

tial (

mid

poi

nt o

f PS

to m

ajor

tow

n [k

m])

200

Mas

h..la

ndC

5%29

to33

Land

pro

duct

ivity

pot

entia

l 2

Mid

land

s60

%20

to29

Pov

erty

sta

tus:

Ave

rage

GD

P (

US

D p

er a

nnum

per

cap

ita,1

997)

2350

2350

UN

DP

1999

Mas

ving

o80

%33

to45

L

itera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, nat

iona

l)90

.990

.9U

ND

P19

99M

anic

alan

d10

%70

to86

H

arva

rd s

cale

dat

a

% c

hild

ren

with

acc

epta

ble

wei

ght/h

eigh

t to

age

97N

R k

now

ledg

e ba

se (

Deg

ree

leve

l of n

atio

nal r

esea

rche

rs)

: % B

Sc

60

% M

Sc

3023

%

PhD

10A

gric

ultu

ral R

esea

rch:

No

of s

cien

tists

(19

91)

291

S

hare

of G

DP

to A

g R

(19

91)

0.4

Cal

cula

tions

for

wei

ghts

on

sum

mar

y pa

ge: G

DP

1350

0162

500

L

it52

2197

775

W

eigh

t/hei

ght

5572

4075

0G

DP

nat

iona

l29

8097

5000

0G

DP

on

Ag

1192

3900

0S

ci p

er 1

mill

ion

natio

nal p

opul

atio

n22

.940

4808

8S

ci p

er P

S p

opul

atio

n13

1.78

7327

6W

eigh

ted

degr

ee B

Sc

174.

6W

eigh

ted

degr

ee M

Sc

87.3

Wei

ghte

d de

gree

PhD

29.1

Base

d on

3-5

mon

th L

GP.

Usi

ng t

he r

ainf

all d

ata

the

DFI

D d

efin

ition

of

SA a

s 40

0-12

00m

m

occu

pies

the

who

le c

ount

ry. Si

mila

rly, ta

king

a n

arro

wer

def

initi

on (

300-

600m

m)

faile

d to

incl

ude

the

arid

wes

tern

zon

e ar

ound

Bul

away

o/Vi

ctor

ia f

alls

. W

iden

ing

the

rang

e to

300

-900

mm

cov

ered

th

e en

tire

coun

try

exce

pt t

he e

aste

rn h

ighl

ands

, w

hich

als

o eq

uate

s to

the

3-6

mth

LG

P.Ta

rget

zon

e ro

ughl

y ha

lf co

untr

y: S

& W

and

sho

res

of L

Kar

iba.

59%

of

land

are

a.

'Rea

l GD

P pe

r ca

pita

' fr

om U

ND

P 19

99.

Adul

t lit

erac

y ra

te 1

997

from

U

ND

P 19

99.

Base

d on

25

pers

ons

per

sq

km f

or t

arge

t ar

ea.

45%

of

tota

l pop

ulat

ion.

33%

of

popu

latio

n ac

cord

ing

to n

atio

nal

data

.

Mai

n to

wns

in t

arge

t ar

ea:

Hw

ange

, Bu

law

ayo,

Gw

eru,

Kw

ekw

e, Z

vish

avan

e, M

asvi

ngo,

Vi

ctor

ia F

alls

,Lu

pane

, Ea

stno

r,

Beitb

ridge

.

Roa

d de

nsity

sca

le:

5=de

nse,

1=

spar

se.

1991

dat

a.

App-16

Page 23: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

Ban

glad

esh

Sup

plem

ent

TA

RG

ET

CO

UN

TR

Y P

S C

HA

RA

CT

ER

IST

ICS

Dis

trib

uti

on

of

Po

pu

lati

on

by

Zila

, Ru

ral &

Urb

an R

esid

ence

s 19

98 (

hu

man

po

pu

lati

on

in '0

00')

Sou

rce:

Ban

glad

esh

Bur

eau

of S

tatis

tics

Nat

iona

l Dat

a B

ank

http

://w

ww

.ban

gla.

net/n

db/d

ata-

shee

t/DE

MO

_DA

TA

.htm

Zil

aR

ura

lU

rban

To

tal

Zil

aR

ura

lU

rban

To

tal

Che

ckC

heck

Ban

gla

des

h96

354

2621

512

2569

1225

69

BA

RIS

AL

DIV

7265

1178

8443

8443

SY

LH

ET

DIV

6900

919

7819

7819

1B

argu

na79

090

880

35H

abig

anj

1592

167

1759

2B

aris

al20

8441

124

9536

Mau

lvi.B

azar

1429

152

1581

3B

hola

1455

238

1693

37S

unam

ganj

1803

175

1978

4Jh

alak

hati

646

109

755

38S

ylhe

t20

7642

525

015

Pat

uakh

ali

1258

170

1428

6P

irojp

ur10

3216

011

92K

HU

LN

A D

IV11

562

2959

1452

114

521

39B

ager

hat

1391

240

1631

CT

G.

DIV

.18

629

5265

2389

423

894

40C

huad

anga

670

251

921

7B

anda

rban

191

8027

141

Jess

ore

2057

360

2417

8B

.Bar

ia21

4934

224

9142

Jhen

aida

h13

3422

615

609

Cha

ndpu

r21

9715

823

5543

Khu

lna

1095

1264

2359

590

10C

hitta

gong

3229

2964

6193

44K

usht

ia15

0121

517

1611

Com

illa41

8350

846

9145

Mag

ura

753

7582

812

Cox

’s B

azar

1414

253

1667

46M

eher

pur

502

6256

413

Fen

i11

4313

512

7847

Nar

ail

630

8671

614

Kha

grac

hhar

i27

412

640

048

Sat

khira

1629

180

1809

1809

15La

ksm

ipur

1277

240

1517

16N

oakh

ali

2272

302

2574

17R

anga

mat

i30

015

745

7R

AJS

HA

HI D

IV25

677

4448

3012

530

125

49B

ogra

2709

388

3097

3097

50D

inaj

pur

2246

369

2615

2615

DH

AK

A D

IV26

321

1144

637

767

3776

751

Gai

band

ha20

6219

622

5874

518

Dha

ka70

167

3374

3452

Joyp

urha

t78

010

488

419

Far

idpu

r15

0619

817

0453

Kur

igra

m15

7426

618

4020

Gaz

ipur

1135

739

1874

54La

lmon

irhat

913

129

1042

1042

21G

opal

ganj

1088

102

1190

55N

aoga

on22

4923

724

8624

8622

Jam

alpu

r18

6827

321

4156

Nat

ore

1325

197

1522

1522

23K

isho

rega

nj22

5335

426

0757

Naw

abga

nj11

1224

513

5713

5724

Mad

arip

ur10

9211

412

0658

Nilp

ham

ari

1341

203

1544

1544

25M

anik

ganj

1192

124

1316

59P

abna

1825

371

2196

2196

26M

unsh

igan

j11

8914

213

3160

Pan

chag

arh

703

7677

977

927

Mym

ensi

ngh

3958

534

4492

61R

ajsh

ahi

1476

765

2241

28N

aray

anga

nj95

891

118

6962

Ran

gpur

2051

447

2498

29N

arsi

ngdi

1560

320

1880

63S

irajg

anj

2276

331

2607

30N

etro

kona

1789

182

1971

64T

haku

rgao

n10

3512

411

5931

Raj

bari

842

112

954

32S

haria

tpur

977

9510

7235

4A

ppro

xim

ate

popu

latio

n in

coa

stal

are

a18

447

33S

herp

ur11

5914

213

01A

ppro

x pr

opor

tion

of p

opln

in c

oast

al a

rea

1689

34T

anga

il30

5437

134

25A

ppro

x to

tal p

opul

atio

n in

coa

stal

are

a 20

136

App-17

Page 24: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

MS

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

MA

ST

ER

SU

MM

AR

Y S

HE

ET

1997

('0

00)

%S

A(1

)%

SA

(2)

%H

P(1

)%

HP

(2)

Ric

eM

aize

Whe

atT

otP

ulse

sB

anan

aS

ugar

cane

Cof

fee

Tea

P

otat

oM

ilkIN

DIA

7949

594

4162

476

2392

710

171

2826

8520

878

019

239

6373

7A

ndrh

a P

r60

8091

9578

55

640

920

1521

61

542

21A

run

Pr

140

489

509

111

4022

Ass

am33

9013

9521

256

514

9042

550

569

8B

ihar

5075

7569

1112

4841

8162

411

556

4415

7232

50G

oa12

875

955

36G

ujar

at60

7082

737

411

2486

312

4410

511

461

4459

Har

yana

4050

9018

6044

7350

547

8090

141

4062

Him

Pr

111

661

544

3367

112

166

3J&

K50

946

834

937

37

364

1K

arna

taka

7075

3019

1201

150

742

606

2491

814

55

251

3003

Ker

ala

932

2714

597

464

4662

2118

Mad

Pr

2570

5705

1151

6468

4122

458

2023

524

5048

Mah

aras

h50

7525

6333

889

824

4922

1746

656

7648

12M

anip

ur33

87

4141

1764

Meg

hala

ya11

921

62

612

122

54M

izor

am10

215

1211

91

9N

agal

and

185

312

167

120

2043

Oris

sa62

2620

05

1210

346

1574

9058

4P

unja

b40

5090

6768

307

1272

422

0886

2087

462

15R

ajas

tan

4040

118

808

5493

1519

1385

1951

03S

ikki

m22

5515

474

124

32T

amil

N60

9075

6387

360

2907

3457

616

114

127

3695

Trip

ura

466

25

533

757

7738

Utta

r P

r40

7560

8010

408

1470

2220

322

8038

1198

3079

1011

321

Wbe

ngal

1188

710

785

011

0113

1216

562

5832

50D

elhi

10

010

010

03

225

7C

hand

igar

gh10

01

39

Pri

mar

y p

rod

uct

ion

by

Sta

te b

y P

S:

SA

1R

ice

Mai

zeW

heat

Tot

Pul

ses

Ban

ana

Sug

arca

neC

offe

eT

ea

Pot

ato

Milk

And

rha

Pr

6.94

4.99

0.00

1.60

5.43

3.23

0.29

0.00

0.02

3.97

Guj

arat

0.62

2.38

1.08

2.16

7.34

2.23

0.00

0.00

1.44

4.20

Har

yana

0.94

0.19

4.71

0.91

0.00

1.14

0.00

0.00

0.29

2.55

Kar

nata

ka2.

668.

900.

172.

174.

176.

1748

.80

0.45

0.91

3.30

Mad

Pr

1.79

3.05

2.59

4.31

1.13

0.18

0.00

0.00

0.68

1.98

Mah

aras

h1.

611.

790.

725.

1210

.90

8.25

0.00

0.00

0.20

3.77

Pun

jab

3.41

1.30

8.15

3.69

0.00

1.22

0.00

0.00

1.82

3.90

Raj

asta

n0.

063.

423.

522.

540.

000.

200.

000.

000.

043.

20T

amil

N5.

710.

550.

000.

9017

.15

7.34

4.62

8.77

0.40

3.48

Utta

r P

r5.

246.

2314

.22

3.81

0.15

16.9

60.

000.

0016

.45

7.10

Del

hi

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.01

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.40

Tot

al28

.98

32.8

035

.14

27.2

346

.26

46.9

253

.70

9.22

22.2

437

.86

App-18

Page 25: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

1

Indi

a S

uppl

emen

tT

AR

GE

T C

OU

NT

RY

PS

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

TIC

S

Pri

mar

y p

rod

uct

ion

by

Sta

te b

y P

S:

SA

2R

ice

Mai

zeW

heat

Tot

Pul

ses

Ban

ana

Sug

arca

neC

offe

eT

ea

Pot

ato

Milk

And

rha

Pr

9.25

6.65

0.01

2.14

7.24

4.31

0.38

0.00

0.02

5.30

Bih

ar4.

356.

613.

351.

300.

571.

000.

000.

004.

092.

55G

ujar

at0.

732.

771.

262.

528.

562.

600.

000.

001.

684.

90H

arya

na1.

170.

235.

881.

140.

001.

430.

000.

000.

373.

19K

arna

taka

2.85

9.54

0.18

2.33

4.47

6.61

52.2

80.

480.

983.

53M

ad P

r5.

028.

537.

2512

.06

3.15

0.50

0.00

0.00

1.91

5.54

Mah

aras

h2.

422.

691.

087.

6816

.35

12.3

80.

000.

000.

305.

66P

unja

b4.

261.

6310

.18

4.61

0.00

1.52

0.00

0.00

2.27

4.88

Raj

asta

n0.

063.

423.

522.

540.

000.

200.

000.

000.

043.

20T

amil

N8.

560.

830.

001.

3525

.72

11.0

16.

9213

.15

0.59

5.22

Utta

r P

r9.

8211

.68

26.6

57.

150.

2831

.79

0.00

0.00

30.8

413

.32

Del

hi

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.01

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.40

Tot

al48

.49

54.5

859

.35

44.8

466

.34

73.3

559

.59

13.6

343

.07

57.6

9

HP

1R

ice

Mai

zeW

heat

Tot

Pul

ses

Ban

ana

Sug

arca

neC

offe

eT

ea

Pot

ato

Milk

Bih

ar6.

529.

915.

021.

960.

851.

500.

000.

006.

133.

82U

ttar

Pr

7.86

9.34

21.3

25.

720.

2225

.43

0.00

0.00

24.6

710

.66

Tot

al14

.38

19.2

626

.34

7.67

1.07

26.9

30.

000.

0030

.80

14.4

8

HP

2R

ice

Mai

zeW

heat

Tot

Pul

ses

Ban

ana

Sug

arca

neC

offe

eT

ea

Pot

ato

Milk

Bih

ar6.

529.

915.

021.

960.

851.

500.

000.

006.

133.

82H

arya

na2.

110.

4210

.59

2.06

0.00

2.58

0.00

0.00

0.66

5.74

Pun

jab

7.66

2.93

18.3

38.

310.

002.

740.

000.

004.

098.

78U

ttar

Pr

10.4

712

.46

28.4

37.

620.

3033

.91

0.00

0.00

32.8

914

.21

Del

hi

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.01

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.00

0.40

Tot

al26

.77

25.7

262

.37

19.9

51.

1540

.73

0.00

0.00

43.7

732

.95

SU

MM

AR

YR

ice

Mai

zeW

heat

Tot

Pul

ses

Ban

ana

Sug

arca

neC

offe

eT

ea

Pot

ato

Milk

SA

130

3235

2746

4754

922

38S

A 2

4855

5945

6673

6014

4358

HP

114

1926

81

270

031

14H

P 2

2726

6220

141

00

4433

App-19

Page 26: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 1

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

MS

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

MA

ST

ER

SU

MM

AR

Y S

HE

ET

Ro

ug

h c

orr

esp

on

den

ce o

f N

epal

tar

get

are

a p

op

ula

tio

n t

o s

om

e o

f th

e 75

ad

min

istr

ativ

e d

istr

icts

- 1

981

dat

aE

AS

TE

RN

CE

NT

RA

LW

ES

TE

RN

MID

WE

ST

ER

NF

AR

WE

ST

ER

NIla

m17

8356

Sin

dhul

i18

3705

Arg

hkha

ch15

7304

Dan

g D

eokh

uri

2663

93D

adel

dhur

a86

8853

Dha

nkut

a12

9781

Ram

echh

ap16

1445

Gul

umi

2381

13P

yuth

ang

1576

69D

oti

1531

35T

erha

thum

9254

2D

olak

hla

1505

76P

alap

a21

4442

Rol

pa16

8116

Bai

tadi

1791

36B

hojp

ur19

2689

Mak

awan

pur

2434

11B

aglu

ng21

5228

Jaja

rkot

9931

2A

chha

m18

5212

Uda

yapu

r15

9805

Kat

hman

du42

2237

Kas

ki22

1272

Sal

yan

1520

63B

ajur

a74

649

Kho

tang

2155

71D

hadi

ng24

3401

Tan

ahu

2234

38S

urkh

et16

6196

Okh

aldh

unga

1376

40K

havr

epal

anch

ok30

7150

Sya

ngja

2718

24D

aile

kh16

6527

Par

sa28

4338

Gor

kha

2312

92La

lipur

1843

41La

mju

ng15

2720

Bha

ktap

ur15

9767

Nuw

akot

2029

76

TO

TA

LS11

0638

425

4334

719

2563

311

7627

614

6098

582

1262

5

1981

Tot

al p

opul

atio

n fo

r N

epal

1500

0000

Reg

iona

l tot

al in

crea

sed

by 4

5.6%

1195

7582

1998

UN

est

imat

e fo

r N

epal

2184

3000

(Inc

reas

ed b

y 45

.6%

)

Agr

icul

ture

1989

/90

Ric

e M

tW

heat

Mt

Mai

ze M

tM

illet

Mt

Pot

ato

Mt

Sug

arca

ne M

tT

otal

3389

670

8549

6012

0099

022

4780

6718

1098

8300

EA

ST

ER

NIla

m23

260

5540

2310

035

6024

500

320

Dha

nkut

a17

810

3890

2970

079

1099

1084

0T

erha

thum

1825

015

2017

050

3170

1155

032

0B

hojp

ur28

470

2250

2772

053

1013

200

320

Uda

yapu

r25

850

5200

1590

011

6054

4012

50K

hota

ng23

580

1087

020

180

6830

1269

033

0O

khal

dhun

ga96

2017

6013

430

2930

1311

048

0C

EN

TR

AL

Sin

dhul

i25

750

6390

2314

027

5010

410

2000

Ram

echh

ap72

9042

9024

150

3000

1242

012

00D

olak

hla

5060

4410

7010

2000

1560

012

0M

akaw

anpu

r32

170

1037

033

990

5500

1800

0K

athm

andu

4424

013

120

1107

014

7011

420

Dha

ding

2980

072

0024

930

4800

1078

017

600

Agr

icul

ture

con

td19

89/9

0R

ice

Mt

Whe

at M

tM

aize

Mt

Mill

et M

tP

otat

o M

tS

ugar

cane

Mt

App-20

Page 27: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

1

Nep

al S

uppl

emen

tT

AR

GE

T C

OU

NT

RY

PS

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

TIC

S

CE

NT

RA

L co

ntd

Kha

vrep

alan

chok

3362

019

000

4347

016

8030

000

3800

Par

sa13

2870

2788

010

280

300

7440

5250

0La

lipur

1856

084

1010

710

1860

4320

Bha

ktap

ur25

440

7760

4710

8090

00N

uwak

ot38

230

8800

2967

037

5011

200

4200

WE

ST

ER

NA

rghk

hach

8680

5300

2167

020

3018

90G

ulum

i19

730

4730

3259

047

8033

6070

0P

alap

a20

950

7350

2596

054

8046

4098

0B

aglu

ng11

920

7320

2007

049

4052

00K

aski

4110

094

1022

400

1143

051

0070

0T

anah

u30

840

5330

3621

093

5032

0034

0S

yang

ja35

050

1165

049

300

2643

049

5031

50G

orkh

a31

980

5540

2815

011

040

1295

085

0La

mju

ng23

650

5680

2522

010

800

7820

720

MID

WE

ST

ER

ND

ang

Deo

khur

i91

840

2921

037

650

490

7600

Pyu

than

g11

700

9770

1565

026

9033

60R

olpa

8710

7720

1616

011

2075

00Ja

jark

ot58

4054

0012

880

2350

3000

Sal

yan

1102

015

100

3200

041

1045

00S

urkh

et17

260

2243

023

280

1910

4490

600

Dai

lekh

9000

6250

1431

030

5030

5030

0F

AR

WE

ST

ER

ND

adel

dhur

a12

070

9240

4970

3780

5180

750

Dot

i11

500

1132

020

550

1910

3570

150

Bai

tadi

7650

6530

8450

1360

5180

300

Ach

ham

6960

5940

7510

1980

4620

150

Baj

ura

5060

4140

1420

2190

3660

Tot

al, s

elec

ted

dist

ricts

9623

8034

4020

8266

1017

1280

3358

1094

970

%N

epal

28.3

940

.24

68.8

376

.20

49.9

99.

61

App-21

Page 28: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 2

- S

IMP

LE S

CO

RIN

G O

F P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

SY

STE

M B

Y E

AC

H C

HA

RA

CTE

RIS

ATI

ON

CR

ITE

RIO

N

PO

PU

LAT

ION

DO

UB

LE C

OU

NT

ED

FO

R B

AN

GLA

DE

SH

(HP

AN

D L

W) A

ND

NE

PA

L (H

S A

ND

FA

)

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

PU

521,

307

278,

927

1,50

5,33

237

4,47

215

3,36

20

53

64

21

201,

480,

731

14,9

13,8

9624

9,17

2,03

212

,590

,380

70,6

90,2

5142

,846

,239

52

61

43

4.17

1.67

3.17

1.67

4.00

5.00

25

45

31

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.11

0.21

1.00

53

64

21

133.

3396

.67

183.

3318

3.33

80.0

00.

004

35

52

14.

002.

172.

001.

834.

500.

002

34

51

61,

452

1,55

61,

653

2,30

11,

050

1,66

75

43

16

251

.31

49.9

654

.60

49.7

538

.90

54.6

33

42

56

156

.30

63.4

255

.40

55.7

857

.00

53.3

83

15

42

60.

1539

0.00

000.

1545

0.09

610.

0000

0.15

294

3.5

36

3.5

52,

491

01,

885

770

249

33.

54

63.

55

100

64

06

33.

55

63.

55

6b 6c5a 5b 5c 6a3a 3b 4a 4b

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

Pop

ulat

ion

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 1

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aR

ef

1 2

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

Market Feasibility Potential

Poverty status (National data)

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

m

anua

lly to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed

valu

es.

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

res

tric

ted

in c

ompa

rativ

e ad

vant

age

for

supp

ly (

see

land

pro

duct

ivity

po

tent

ial).

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept fo

r Pe

ri-U

rban

whe

re to

tal p

opul

atio

n w

as

used

.

KE

Y: 6

= G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

D, 1

= L

EA

ST

NE

ED

SH

AD

ED

CE

LLS

= A

VE

RA

GE

IN L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-22

Page 29: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 2

- S

IMP

LE S

CO

RIN

G O

F P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

SY

STE

M B

Y E

AC

H C

HA

RA

CTE

RIS

ATI

ON

CR

ITE

RIO

N

PO

PU

LAT

ION

DO

UB

LE C

OU

NT

ED

FO

R B

AN

GLA

DE

SH

(HP

AN

D L

W) A

ND

NE

PA

L (H

S A

ND

FA

)

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

LW

(2)

PU

695,

117

278,

927

2,24

2,35

338

6,48

018

7,48

30

53

64

21

260,

798,

296

14,9

13,8

9640

7,63

2,64

515

,685

,378

79,7

70,3

0842

,846

,239

51

62

43

4.17

1.67

3.50

2.33

4.33

5.00

36

45

21

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.10

0.11

1.00

52

64

31

133.

3396

.67

200.

0016

6.67

83.3

30.

004

36

52

14.

172.

172.

831.

835.

000.

002

43

51

61,

502

1,55

61,

644

2,15

71,

160

1,66

75

43

16

251

.82

49.9

654

.45

54.3

440

.19

54.6

34

52

36

155

.77

63.4

255

.46

60.2

758

.01

53.3

84

15

23

60.

1539

0.00

000.

1545

0.09

610.

0000

0.15

294

3.5

36

3.5

52,

889

03,

049

148

024

93

3.5

46

3.5

59

06

70

63

3.5

46

3.5

4

6b 6c

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

5a 5b 5c 6a3a 3b 4a 4b

Pop

ulat

ion

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aP

rod

uct

ion

Sys

tem

s, V

ersi

on

2R

ef

1 2

Market Feasibility

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Potential

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Poverty status (National data)

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

man

ually

to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed v

alue

s.

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

re

stric

ted

in c

ompa

rativ

e ad

vant

age

for

supp

ly (

see

land

prod

uctiv

ity p

oten

tial).

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept fo

r Pe

ri-U

rban

whe

re to

tal p

opul

atio

n w

a sus

ed

KE

Y: 6

= G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

D, 1

= L

EA

ST

NE

ED

SH

AD

ED

CE

LLS

= A

VE

RA

GE

IN L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-23

Page 30: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

2 -

SIM

PLE

SC

OR

ING

OF

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TEM

BY

EA

CH

CH

AR

AC

TER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

ION

P

OP

ULA

TIO

N D

OU

BLE

CO

UN

TE

D F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (H

P A

ND

LW

) AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

LW

(3)

PU

695,

117

278,

927

2,24

2,35

338

6,48

012

4,14

90

53

64

21

201,

480,

731

14,9

13,8

9640

7,63

2,64

515

,685

,378

77,4

63,6

0842

,846

,239

51

62

43

4.17

1.67

3.50

2.33

4.00

5.00

26

45

31

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.10

0.14

1.00

52

64

31

133.

3396

.67

200.

0016

6.67

100.

000.

004

26

53

14.

172.

172.

831.

835.

000.

002

43

51

61,

502

1,55

61,

644

2,15

71,

050

1,66

75

43

16

251

.82

49.9

654

.45

54.3

438

.90

54.6

34

52

36

155

.77

63.4

255

.46

60.2

757

.00

53.3

84

15

23

60.

1539

0.00

000.

1545

0.09

610.

0000

0.15

294

3.5

36

3.5

52,

889

03,

049

148

024

93

3.5

46

3.5

59

06

70

63

3.5

46

3.5

4

6b 6c

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

5a 5b 5c 6a3a 3b 4a 4b

Pop

ulat

ion

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aP

rod

uct

ion

Sys

tem

s, V

ersi

on

3

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Re

f

1 2

Market Feasibility

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Potential

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Poverty status (National data)

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

res

tric

ted

in c

ompa

rativ

e ad

vant

age

for

supp

ly (

see

land

pro

duct

ivity

po

tent

ial).

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

m

anua

lly to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed v

alue

s.

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept fo

r Pe

ri-U

rban

whe

re to

tal p

opul

atio

n w

as

used

.

KE

Y: 6

= G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

D, 1

= L

EA

ST

NE

ED

SH

AD

ED

CE

LLS

= A

VE

RA

GE

IN L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-24

Page 31: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

2 -

SIM

PLE

RA

NK

SC

OR

ING

RA

NK

SC

OR

ES

AN

D D

ER

IVE

D W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

BY

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M A

ND

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

ra

nk

sco

re,

me

an

ra

nk

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

ra

nk

sco

re (

usi

ng

Sce

na

rio

1 w

eig

hts

*)

for

ea

ch c

ha

ract

eri

satio

n c

rite

rio

n

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )5

.05

.00

.53

.03

.00

.36

.06

.00

.64

.04

.00

.42

.02

.00

.21

.01

.00

.10

.10

.10

.10

.10

.12

. P

op

ula

tion

5.0

5.0

19

.52

.02

.07

.86

.06

.02

3.4

1.0

1.0

3.9

4.0

4.0

15

.63

.03

.01

1.7

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

2

.05

.04

.05

.03

.01

.03

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t5

.03

.06

.04

.02

.01

.04

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

4.0

3.0

5.0

5.0

2.0

1.0

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

1.0

6.0

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)5

.04

.03

.01

.06

.02

.05b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

3.0

4.0

2.0

5.0

6.0

1.0

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

3.0

1.0

5.0

4.0

2.0

6.0

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

4.0

3.5

3.0

6.0

3.5

5.0

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S3

.03

.54

.06

.03

.55

.06

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S3

.03

.55

.06

.03

.55

.01

01

01

01

01

0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(1)

40

.25

HS

28

.35

SA

(1)

49

.25

FA

(2)

32

.55

LW

(1)

34

.05

PU

30

.55

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(1)

40

.50

HS

29

.60

SA

(1)

50

.83

FA

(2)

32

.13

LW

(1)

32

.97

PU

26

.30

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(1)

39

.50

HS

27

.60

SA

(1)

49

.83

FA

(2)

33

.13

LW

(1)

30

.97

PU

31

.30

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(1)

40

.83

HS

27

.60

SA

(1)

47

.50

FA

(2)

29

.80

LW

(1)

37

.30

PU

30

.30

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(1)

40

.17

HS

28

.60

SA

(1)

48

.83

FA

(2)

35

.13

LW

(1)

34

.97

PU

34

.30

1

1

11

13

11

34

.5

1.0

1.5

1

13

11

31

5.3

5.0

7.5

4.0

6.0

5.3

7.0

5.0

5.0

3.0

3.0

2.5

3.8

1.5

2.3

3.5

9.0

4.7

6.8

7.5

3.5

3.3

6.0

4.5

5.0

3.3

5.0

4.0

4.5

3.0

4.5

3.7

3.0

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

1.5

5.3

7.5

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

PU

3.5

1.5

5.5

4.5

3.5

5.3

4.5

6.8

3.3

5.0

6.0

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 1

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 2 Weights

Scenario 3 Weights

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 1

1.5

1.5

KE

Y:

6 =

GR

EA

TE

ST

NE

ED

, 1

= L

EA

ST

NE

ED

SH

AD

ED

CE

LLS

= A

VE

RA

GE

IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-25

Page 32: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

2 -

SIM

PLE

RA

NK

SC

OR

ING

RA

NK

SC

OR

ES

AN

D D

ER

IVE

D W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

BY

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M A

ND

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

ra

nk

sco

re,

me

an

ra

nk

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

ra

nk

sco

re (

usi

ng

Sce

na

rio

1 w

eig

hts

*)

for

ea

ch c

ha

ract

eri

satio

n c

rite

rio

n

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )5

.05

.00

.53

.03

.00

.36

.06

.00

.64

.04

.00

.42

.02

.00

.21

.01

.00

.10

.10

.10

.10

.10

.12

. P

op

ula

tion

5.0

5.0

19

.51

.01

.03

.96

.06

.02

3.4

2.0

2.0

7.8

4.0

4.0

15

.63

.03

.01

1.7

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

3

.06

.04

.05

.02

.01

.03

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t5

.02

.06

.04

.03

.01

.04

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

4.0

3.0

6.0

5.0

2.0

1.0

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

2.0

4.0

3.0

5.0

1.0

6.0

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)5

.05

.04

.01

.02

.03

.05b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

4.0

5.0

2.0

3.0

6.0

1.0

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

4.0

1.0

5.0

2.0

3.0

6.0

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

4.0

3.5

3.0

6.0

3.5

5.0

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S3

.03

.54

.06

.03

.55

.06

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S3

.03

.54

.06

.03

.54

.01

01

01

01

01

0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(2)

42

.00

HS

26

.20

SA

(2)

49

.25

FA

(1)

34

.45

LW

(2)

32

.55

PU

30

.55

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(2)

42

.67

HS

26

.87

SA

(2)

50

.83

FA

(1)

34

.70

LW

(2)

31

.97

PU

26

.30

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(2)

40

.67

HS

25

.87

SA

(2)

49

.83

FA

(1)

35

.70

LW

(2)

29

.97

PU

31

.30

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(2)

43

.33

HS

26

.20

SA

(2)

48

.17

FA

(1)

29

.70

LW

(2)

34

.30

PU

30

.97

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(2)

41

.33

HS

25

.87

SA

(2)

48

.17

FA

(1)

37

.70

LW

(2)

33

.97

PU

33

.63

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 2

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 2 Weights

Scenario 3 Weights

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 2

11

31 3

1.5

11

13

.55

.34

.77

.03

.75

.56

.09

.03

.35

.03

.55

.3

5.5

3.3

5.0

1.5

1

4.3

6.5

3.7

5.5

3.7

5.5

2.0

3.0

3.7

1.5

13

11

.52

.33

.55

.34

.56

.85

.07

.53

.04

.53

.55

.3

31

11

3.8

1.0

1.5

1.5

4.0

6.0

4.0

6.0

2.5

5.0

7.5

4.5

6.8

LW

(2)

PU

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

KE

Y:

6 =

GR

EA

TE

ST

NE

ED

, 1

= L

EA

ST

NE

ED

SH

AD

ED

CE

LLS

= A

VE

RA

GE

IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-26

Page 33: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

2 -

SIM

PLE

RA

NK

SC

OR

ING

RA

NK

SC

OR

ES

AN

D D

ER

IVE

D W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

BY

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M A

ND

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

ra

nk

sco

re,

me

an

ra

nk

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

ra

nk

sco

re (

usi

ng

Sce

na

rio

1 w

eig

hts

*)

for

ea

ch c

ha

ract

eri

satio

n c

rite

rio

n

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )5

.05

.00

.53

.03

.00

.36

.06

.00

.64

.04

.00

.42

.02

.00

.21

.01

.00

.10

.10

.10

.10

.10

.12

. P

op

ula

tion

5.0

5.0

19

.51

.01

.03

.96

.06

.02

3.4

2.0

2.0

7.8

4.0

4.0

15

.63

.03

.01

1.7

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.9

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

2

.06

.04

.05

.03

.01

.03

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t5

.02

.06

.04

.03

.01

.04

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

4.0

2.0

6.0

5.0

3.0

1.0

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

2.0

4.0

3.0

5.0

1.0

6.0

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)5

.04

.03

.01

.06

.02

.05b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

4.0

5.0

2.0

3.0

6.0

1.0

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

4.0

1.0

5.0

2.0

3.0

6.0

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

4.0

3.5

3.0

6.0

3.5

5.0

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S3

.03

.54

.06

.03

.55

.06

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S3

.03

.54

.06

.03

.54

.01

01

01

01

01

0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(1)

41

.25

HS

24

.95

SA

(1)

48

.75

FA

(1)

34

.45

LW

(3)

36

.05

PU

30

.05

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(1)

41

.17

HS

26

.03

SA

(1)

50

.50

FA

(1)

34

.70

LW

(3)

35

.30

PU

25

.97

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(1)

40

.17

HS

24

.03

SA

(1)

49

.50

FA

(1)

35

.70

LW

(3)

33

.30

PU

30

.97

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(1)

42

.83

HS

24

.70

SA

(1)

47

.17

FA

(1)

29

.70

LW

(3)

39

.30

PU

29

.97

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(1)

40

.83

HS

25

.03

SA

(1)

47

.83

FA

(1)

37

.70

LW

(3)

36

.30

PU

33

.30

* /

Sce

na

rio

1 i

s u

sed

as

an

exa

mp

le s

ho

win

g h

ow

th

e v

alu

es

for

the

to

tal

we

igh

ted

sco

res

of

ea

ch s

cen

ari

o w

ere

ge

ne

rate

d.

1.5

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 3

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(1)

3.0

LW

(3)

PU

4.5

1.0

1.5

5.0

7.5

4.5

6.8

3.5

5.3

4.0

6.0

31

11

3.0

4.5

3.0

4.5

4.5

6.8

5.0

7.5

2.0

3.0

3.5

5.3

1.5

13

11

4.3

6.5

3.3

5.0

3.3

5.0

2.0

3.0

5.0

7.5

3.0

4.5

1.5

11

31

3.3

5.0

3.5

5.3

3.7

5.5

6.0

9.0

11

3.5

5.3

4.7

7.0

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 3

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 2 Weights

Scenario 3 Weights

31

.51

KE

Y:

6 =

GR

EA

TE

ST

NE

ED

, 1

= L

EA

ST

NE

ED

SH

AD

ED

CE

LLS

= A

VE

RA

GE

IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-27

Page 34: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 2

- S

IMP

LE R

AN

K S

CO

RIN

G

PO

PU

LAT

ION

DO

UB

LE C

OU

NT

ED

FO

R B

AN

GLA

DE

SH

(H

P A

ND

LW

) A

ND

NE

PA

L (H

S A

ND

FA

)

WE

IGH

TE

D IM

PO

RT

AN

CE

SC

OR

ES

SU

MM

AR

Y B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

AN

D IM

PLI

CA

TIO

NS

FO

R N

RS

P's

BU

DG

ET

ALL

OC

AT

ION

S

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

PU

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

LW

(2)

PU

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(1)

LW

(3)

PU

40

.25

28

.35

49

.25

32

.55

34

.05

30

.55

42

.00

26

.20

49

.25

34

.45

32

.55

30

.55

41

.25

24

.95

48

.75

34

.45

36

.05

30

.05

51

63

42

51

64

32

51

63

42

40

.50

29

.60

50

.83

32

.13

32

.97

26

.30

42

.67

26

.87

50

.83

34

.70

31

.97

26

.30

41

.17

26

.03

50

.50

34

.70

35

.30

25

.97

52

63

41

52

64

31

52

63

41

39

.50

27

.60

49

.83

33

.13

30

.97

31

.30

40

.67

25

.87

49

.83

35

.70

29

.97

31

.30

40

.17

24

.03

49

.50

35

.70

33

.30

30

.97

51

64

23

51

64

23

51

64

32

40

.83

27

.60

47

.50

29

.80

37

.30

30

.30

43

.33

26

.20

48

.17

29

.70

34

.30

30

.97

42

.83

24

.70

47

.17

29

.70

39

.30

29

.97

51

62

43

51

62

43

51

62

43

40

.17

28

.60

48

.83

35

.13

34

.97

34

.30

41

.33

25

.87

48

.17

37

.70

33

.97

33

.63

40

.83

25

.03

47

.83

37

.70

36

.30

33

.30

51

64

32

51

64

32

51

64

32

40.2

528

.35

49.2

532

.55

34.0

530

.55

Mea

n S

core

per

P

S,

acr

oss

all

sce

na

rio

s

42.0

026

.20

49.2

534

.45

32.5

530

.55

Me

an

S

core

per

P

S,

acr

oss

all

sce

na

rio

s

41.2

524

.95

48.7

534

.45

36.0

530

.05

51

63

42

Sim

ple

ra

nk

acr

oss

P

Ss

51

64

32

Ra

nk

acr

oss

P

Ss

51

63

42

18.7

213

.19

22.9

115

.14

15.8

414

.21

Re

lativ

e

rank

a

cro

ss

PS

s

19.5

312

.19

22.9

116

.02

15.1

414

.21

Re

lativ

e

rank

a

cro

ss

PS

s

19.1

411

.58

22.6

215

.99

16.7

313

.94

WE

IGH

TE

D IM

PO

RT

AN

CE

SC

OR

ES

HP

HS

SA

FA

LW

PU

Mea

n S

core

per

PS

acr

oss

V1,

V2

& V

3, w

ith D

oubl

e C

ount

ing

41.1

726

.50

49.0

833

.82

34.2

230

.38

Mea

n S

core

per

PS

for S

cena

rio 4

acr

oss

V1,

2 &

3, w

ith D

oubl

e C

ount

ing

42.3

326

.17

47.6

129

.73

36.9

730

.41

Ove

rall

Impo

rtan

ce R

ank

base

d on

all

Sce

nario

s (

6 =

Gre

ates

t Nee

d)5

16

34

2

Impl

icat

ion

for

% B

udge

t Allo

catio

n19

.112

.322

.815

.715

.914

.1

Ove

rall

Impo

rtanc

e R

ank

base

d on

Sce

nario

4 (

6 =

Gre

ates

t Nee

d)5

16

24

3

Impl

icat

ion

for

% B

udge

t Allo

catio

n19

.912

.322

.313

.917

.314

.3

** /

Ran

k sc

ores

are

bas

ed o

n w

eigh

ted

scor

es v

alue

s re

ad to

sev

en d

ecim

al p

lace

s

5

To

tal

sco

re,

sum

fo

r a

ll cr

iteri

a &

PS

ra

nki

ng

, V

1**

1 2 3

Sce

na

rio

R

ef N

o.T

ota

l sc

ore

, su

m f

or

all

crite

ria

& P

S r

an

kin

g,

V2

**S

cen

ari

o

Ref

No.

4

3 4 5

To

tal

sco

re,

sum

fo

r a

ll cr

iteri

a &

PS

ra

nki

ng

, V

3**

1 2

KE

Y:

6 =

GR

EA

TE

ST

NE

ED

, 1

= L

EA

ST

NE

ED

App-28

Page 35: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

3 -

RE

LATI

VE

SC

OR

ING

OF

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TEM

BY

EA

CH

CH

AR

AC

TER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

ION

P

OP

ULA

TIO

N D

OU

BLE

CO

UN

TE

D F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (H

P A

ND

LW

) AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

PU

521,

307

278,

927

1,50

5,33

237

4,47

215

3,36

20

0.35

0.19

1.00

0.25

0.10

0.00

201,

480,

731

14,9

13,8

9624

9,17

2,03

212

,590

,380

70,6

90,2

5142

,846

,239

0.81

0.06

1.00

0.05

0.28

0.17

4.17

1.67

3.17

1.67

4.00

5.00

0.40

1.00

0.53

1.00

0.42

0.33

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.11

0.21

1.00

0.28

0.18

1.00

0.25

0.13

0.03

133.

3396

.67

183.

3318

3.33

80.0

00.

000.

730.

531.

001.

000.

440.

004.

002.

172.

001.

834.

500.

000.

460.

850.

921.

000.

410.

001,

452

1,55

61,

653

2,30

11,

050

1,66

70.

720.

670.

640.

461.

000.

6351

.31

49.9

654

.60

49.7

538

.90

54.6

30.

758

0.77

90.

712

0.78

21.

000

0.71

256

.30

63.4

255

.40

55.7

857

.00

53.3

80.

948

0.84

20.

964

0.95

70.

937

1.00

00.

1539

n/a

0.15

450.

0961

n/a

0.15

290.

625

0.71

90.

622

1.00

00.

719

0.62

92,

491

n/a

1,88

577

n/a

249

0.03

0.35

0.04

1.00

0.35

0.31

10n/

a6

4n/

a6

0.40

0.68

0.67

1.00

0.68

0.67

6c

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

5b 5c 6a 6b3b 4a 4b 5a

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 1

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aR

ef

1 2

Market Feasibility Potential

Poverty status (National data)

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

Pop

ulat

ion

(Ban

glad

esh

& N

epal

dou

ble

coun

ted)

3a

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

man

ually

to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed v

alue

s.

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

re

stric

ted

in c

ompa

rativ

e ad

vant

age

for

supp

ly (

see

land

pr

oduc

tivity

pot

entia

l).

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept fo

r Pe

ri-Urb

an w

here

tota

l pop

ulat

ion

was

use

d.

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-29

Page 36: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 3

- R

ELA

TIV

E S

CO

RIN

G O

F P

RO

DU

CTI

ON

SY

STE

M B

Y E

AC

H C

HA

RA

CTE

RIS

ATI

ON

CR

ITE

RIO

N

PO

PU

LAT

ION

DO

UB

LE C

OU

NT

ED

FO

R B

AN

GLA

DE

SH

(HP

AN

D L

W) A

ND

NE

PA

L (H

S A

ND

FA

)

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

LW

(2)

PU

695,

117

278,

927

2,24

2,35

338

6,48

018

7,48

30

0.31

0.12

1.00

0.17

0.08

0.00

260,

798,

296

14,9

13,8

9640

7,63

2,64

515

,685

,378

79,7

70,3

0842

,846

,239

0.64

0.03

71.

000.

038

0.20

0.11

4.17

1.67

3.50

2.33

4.33

5.00

0.40

1.00

0.48

0.71

0.38

0.33

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.10

0.11

1.00

0.29

0.19

1.00

0.28

0.26

0.03

133.

3396

.67

200.

0016

6.67

83.3

30.

000.

670.

481.

000.

830.

420.

004.

172.

172.

831.

835.

000.

000.

440.

850.

651.

000.

370.

001,

502

1,55

61,

644

2,15

71,

160

1,66

70.

770.

750.

710.

541.

000.

7051

.82

49.9

654

.45

54.3

440

.19

54.6

30.

776

0.80

40.

738

0.74

01.

000

0.73

655

.77

63.4

255

.46

60.2

758

.01

53.3

80.

957

0.84

20.

963

0.88

60.

920

1.00

00.

1539

n/a

0.15

450.

0961

n/a

0.15

290.

625

0.71

90.

622

1.00

00.

719

0.62

92,

889

n/a

3,04

914

8n/

a24

90.

050.

420.

051.

000.

420.

599

n/a

67

n/a

60.

670.

881.

000.

860.

881.

00

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Poverty status (National data)

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

Market Feasibility

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Potential

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aP

rod

uct

ion

Sys

tem

s, V

ersi

on

2

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Pop

ulat

ion

(Ban

glad

esh

& N

epal

dou

ble

coun

ted)

Re

f

1 2 3a 3b 4a 4b 5a 5b 5c 6a 6b 6c

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept fo

r Pe

ri-U

rban

whe

re to

tal p

opul

atio

n w

as

used

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

res

tric

ted

in c

ompa

rativ

e ad

vant

age

for

supp

ly (

see

land

pro

duct

ivity

po

tent

ial).

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

man

ually

to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed

valu

es.

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-30

Page 37: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

3 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

OF

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M B

Y E

AC

H C

HA

RA

CT

ER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

ION

P

OP

ULA

TIO

N D

OU

BLE

CO

UN

TE

D F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (

HP

AN

D L

W)

AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(1)

LW

(3)

PU

521,

307

278,

927

1,50

5,33

237

4,47

212

4,14

90

0.35

0.19

1.00

0.25

0.08

0.00

201,

480,

731

14,9

13,8

9624

9,17

2,03

215

,685

,378

77,4

63,6

0842

,846

,239

0.81

0.06

1.00

0.06

0.31

0.17

4.17

1.67

3.17

1.67

4.00

5.00

0.40

1.00

0.53

1.00

0.42

0.33

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.11

0.14

1.00

0.28

0.18

1.00

0.25

0.20

0.03

133.

3396

.67

183.

3318

3.33

100.

000.

000.

730.

531.

001.

000.

550.

004.

002.

172.

001.

835.

000.

000.

460.

850.

921.

000.

370.

001,

452

1,55

61,

653

2,30

11,

050

1,66

70.

720.

670.

640.

461.

000.

6351

.31

49.9

654

.60

49.7

538

.90

54.6

30.

758

0.77

90.

712

0.78

21.

000

0.71

256

.30

63.4

255

.40

55.7

857

.00

53.3

80.

948

0.84

20.

964

0.95

70.

937

1.00

00.

1539

n/a

0.15

450.

0961

n/a

0.15

290.

625

0.71

90.

622

1.00

00.

719

0.62

92,

491

n/a

1,88

577

n/a

249

0.03

0.35

0.04

1.00

0.35

0.31

10n/

a6

4n/

a6

0.40

0.68

0.67

1.00

0.68

0.67

6b 6c

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

5a 5b 5c 6a3a 3b 4a 4b

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aP

rod

uct

ion

Sys

tem

s, V

ersi

on

3

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Pop

ulat

ion

(Ban

glad

esh

& N

epal

dou

ble

coun

ted)

Re

f

1 2

Market Feasibility

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Potential

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Poverty status (National data)

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept fo

r Pe

ri-Urb

an w

here

tota

l pop

ulat

ion

was

use

d.

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

man

ually

to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed v

alue

s.

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

re

stric

ted

in c

ompa

rativ

e ad

vant

age

for

supp

ly (

see

land

pr

oduc

tivity

pot

entia

l).

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-31

Page 38: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

3 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

P

OP

ULA

TIO

N D

OU

BLE

CO

UN

TE

D F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (

HP

AN

D L

W)

AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ES

AN

D D

ER

IVE

D W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

BY

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M A

ND

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

re

lativ

e s

core

, m

ea

n r

ela

tive

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

re

lativ

e s

core

(u

sin

g S

cen

ari

o 1

we

igh

ts*)

fo

r e

ach

ch

ara

cte

risa

tion

cr

iteri

on

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )0

.35

0.3

50

.00

0.1

90

.19

0.0

01

.00

1.0

00

.01

0.2

50

.25

0.0

00

.10

0.1

00

.00

0.0

00

.00

0.0

00

.01

0.0

10

.01

0.0

10

.01

2.

Po

pu

latio

n0

.81

0.8

10

.32

0.0

60

.06

0.0

21

.00

1.0

00

.39

0.0

50

.05

0.0

20

.28

0.2

80

.11

0.1

70

.17

0.0

70

.39

0.3

90

.39

0.3

90

.39

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

0

.40

1.0

00

.53

1.0

00

.42

0.3

33

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t0

.28

0.1

81

.00

0.2

50

.13

0.0

34

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

0.7

30

.53

1.0

01

.00

0.4

40

.00

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

0.4

60

.85

0.9

21

.00

0.4

10

.00

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)0

.72

0.6

70

.64

0.4

61

.00

0.6

35b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

0.7

60

.78

0.7

10

.78

1.0

00

.71

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

0.9

50

.84

0.9

60

.96

0.9

41

.00

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

0.6

20

.72

0.6

21

.00

0.7

20

.63

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.03

0.3

50

.04

1.0

00

.35

0.3

16

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.40

0.6

80

.67

1.0

00

.68

0.6

71

.01

.01

.01

.01

.0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(1)

0.6

3H

S0

.42

SA

(1)

0.8

4F

A(2

)0

.53

LW

(1)

0.4

5P

U0

.29

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(1)

0.6

0H

S0

.41

SA

(1)

0.8

5F

A(2

)0

.48

LW

(1)

0.3

8P

U0

.25

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(1)

0.6

5H

S0

.43

SA

(1)

0.8

9F

A(2

)0

.56

LW

(1)

0.4

1P

U0

.22

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(1)

0.6

9H

S0

.44

SA

(1)

0.8

5F

A(2

)0

.50

LW

(1)

0.5

2P

U0

.37

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(1)

0.6

0H

S0

.40

SA

(1)

0.7

8F

A(2

)0

.56

LW

(1)

0.4

4P

U0

.32

* /

Sce

na

rio

1 i

s u

sed

as

an

exa

mp

le s

ho

win

g h

ow

th

e v

alu

es

for

the

to

tal

we

igh

ted

sco

res

of

ea

ch s

cen

ari

o w

ere

ge

ne

rate

d.

SA

(1)

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

PU

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 1

0.3

40

.05

0.5

90

.09

0.7

60

.11

0.6

2

HP

(1)

HS

0.0

90

.27

0.0

40

.18

0.0

30

.15

0.3

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.5

90

.09

0.6

90

.10

0.9

60

.14

1.0

00

.15

0.4

20

.06

0.0

00

.00

0.1

50

.10

.30

.10

.1

0.8

10

.12

0.7

70

.11

0.7

70

.12

0.7

30

.11

0.9

80

.15

0.7

80

.12

0.1

50

.10

.10

.30

.1

0.3

50

.05

0.5

80

.09

0.4

40

.07

1.0

00

.15

0.1

0.1

0.5

80

.09

0.5

30

.08

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

RE

LA

TIV

E S

CO

RE

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 1

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 2 Weights

Scenario 3 Weights

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

0.3

0.1

50

.1

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E I

N L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-32

Page 39: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

3 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

P

OP

ULA

TIO

N D

OU

BLE

CO

UN

TE

D F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (

HP

AN

D L

W)

AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ES

AN

D D

ER

IVE

D W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

BY

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M A

ND

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

re

lativ

e s

core

, m

ea

n r

ela

tive

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

re

lativ

e s

core

(u

sin

g S

cen

ari

o 1

we

igh

ts*)

fo

r e

ach

ch

ara

cte

risa

tion

cr

iteri

on

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )0

.31

0.3

10

.00

0.1

20

.12

0.0

01

.00

1.0

00

.01

0.1

70

.17

0.0

00

.08

0.0

80

.00

0.0

00

.00

0.0

00

.01

0.0

10

.01

0.0

10

.01

2.

Po

pu

latio

n0

.64

0.6

40

.25

0.0

40

.04

0.0

11

.00

1.0

00

.39

0.0

40

.04

0.0

20

.20

0.2

00

.08

0.1

10

.11

0.0

40

.39

0.3

90

.39

0.3

90

.39

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

0

.40

1.0

00

.48

0.7

10

.38

0.3

33

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t0

.29

0.1

91

.00

0.2

80

.26

0.0

34

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

0.6

70

.48

1.0

00

.83

0.4

20

.00

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

0.4

40

.85

0.6

51

.00

0.3

70

.00

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)0

.77

0.7

50

.71

0.5

41

.00

0.7

05b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

0.7

80

.80

0.7

40

.74

1.0

00

.74

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

0.9

60

.84

0.9

60

.89

0.9

21

.00

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

0.6

20

.72

0.6

21

.00

0.7

20

.63

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.05

0.4

20

.05

1.0

00

.42

0.5

96

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.67

0.8

81

.00

0.8

60

.88

1.0

01

.01

.01

.01

.01

.0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(2)

0.5

8H

S0

.43

SA

(2)

0.8

4F

A(1

)0

.48

LW

(2)

0.4

3P

U0

.30

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(2)

0.5

4H

S0

.41

SA

(2)

0.7

7F

A(1

)0

.43

LW

(2)

0.3

8P

U0

.25

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(2)

0.5

8H

S0

.42

SA

(2)

0.8

6F

A(1

)0

.51

LW

(2)

0.3

9P

U0

.21

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(2)

0.6

4H

S0

.45

SA

(2)

0.8

5F

A(1

)0

.47

LW

(2)

0.5

1P

U0

.38

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(2)

0.5

6H

S0

.42

SA

(2)

0.8

0F

A(1

)0

.52

LW

(2)

0.4

5P

U0

.36

* /

Sce

na

rio

1 i

s u

sed

as

an

exa

mp

le s

ho

win

g h

ow

th

e v

alu

es

for

the

to

tal

we

igh

ted

sco

res

of

ea

ch s

cen

ari

o w

ere

ge

ne

rate

d.

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

RE

LA

TIV

E S

CO

RE

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 2

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 2 Weights

Scenario 3 Weights

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

0.3

0.1

50

.10

.10

.10

.67

0.1

00

.74

0.1

10

.56

0.0

80

.95

0.1

40

.45

0.0

70

.67

0.1

0

0.1

0.1

0.3

0.1

0.1

50

.81

0.1

20

.15

0.1

0.8

40

.13

0.8

00

.12

0.8

00

.12

0.7

20

.11

0.9

7

0.1

50

.10

.30

.10

.39

0.0

60

.00

0.0

0

0.1

0.1

0.5

50

.08

0.6

60

.10

0.8

20

.12

0.9

20

.14

0.0

30

.15

0.3

0.1

0.0

70

.32

0.0

50

.18

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 2

0.3

40

.05

0.6

00

.09

0.7

40

.11

0.5

0

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

LW

(2)

PU

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E I

N L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-33

Page 40: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

AP

PE

ND

IX 3

- R

ELA

TIV

E S

CO

RIN

G

PO

PU

LAT

ION

DO

UB

LE C

OU

NT

ED

FO

R B

AN

GLA

DE

SH

(H

P A

ND

LW

) A

ND

NE

PA

L (H

S A

ND

FA

)

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ES

AN

D D

ER

IVE

D W

EIG

HT

ED

SC

OR

ES

BY

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M A

ND

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

re

lativ

e s

core

, m

ea

n r

ela

tive

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

re

lativ

e s

core

(u

sin

g S

cen

ari

o 1

we

igh

ts*)

fo

r e

ach

ch

ara

cte

risa

tion

cr

iteri

on

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )0

.35

0.3

50

.00

0.1

90

.19

0.0

01

.00

1.0

00

.01

0.2

50

.25

0.0

00

.08

0.0

80

.00

0.0

00

.00

0.0

00

.01

0.0

10

.01

0.0

10

.01

2.

Po

pu

latio

n0

.81

0.8

10

.32

0.0

60

.06

0.0

21

.00

1.0

00

.39

0.0

60

.06

0.0

20

.31

0.3

10

.12

0.1

70

.17

0.0

70

.39

0.3

90

.39

0.3

90

.39

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

0

.40

1.0

00

.53

1.0

00

.42

0.3

33

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t0

.28

0.1

81

.00

0.2

50

.20

0.0

34

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

0.7

30

.53

1.0

01

.00

0.5

50

.00

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

0.4

60

.85

0.9

21

.00

0.3

70

.00

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)0

.72

0.6

70

.64

0.4

61

.00

0.6

35b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

0.7

60

.78

0.7

10

.78

1.0

00

.71

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

0.9

50

.84

0.9

60

.96

0.9

41

.00

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

0.6

20

.72

0.6

21

.00

0.7

20

.63

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.03

0.3

50

.04

1.0

00

.35

0.3

16

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.40

0.6

80

.67

1.0

00

.68

0.6

71

.01

.01

.01

.01

.0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(1)

0.6

3H

S0

.42

SA

(1)

0.8

4F

A(1

)0

.53

LW

(3)

0.4

7P

U0

.29

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(1)

0.6

0H

S0

.41

SA

(1)

0.8

5F

A(1

)0

.49

LW

(3)

0.4

2P

U0

.25

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(1)

0.6

5H

S0

.43

SA

(1)

0.8

9F

A(1

)0

.56

LW

(3)

0.4

5P

U0

.22

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(1)

0.6

9H

S0

.44

SA

(1)

0.8

5F

A(1

)0

.51

LW

(3)

0.5

5P

U0

.37

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(1)

0.6

0H

S0

.40

SA

(1)

0.7

8F

A(1

)0

.56

LW

(3)

0.4

7P

U0

.32

* /

Sce

na

rio

1 i

s u

sed

as

an

exa

mp

le s

ho

win

g h

ow

th

e v

alu

es

for

the

to

tal

we

igh

ted

sco

res

of

ea

ch s

cen

ari

o w

ere

ge

ne

rate

d.

LW

(3)

PU

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 3

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(1)

0.7

60

.11

0.6

20

.09

0.3

40

.05

0.5

90

.09

0.3

10

.05

0.1

80

.03

0.1

50

.30

.10

.10

.1

0.5

90

.09

0.6

90

.10

0.9

60

.14

1.0

00

.15

0.4

60

.07

0.0

00

.00

0.1

50

.10

.30

.10

.1

0.8

10

.12

0.7

70

.11

0.1

20

.77

0.1

20

.73

0.1

10

.98

0.1

5

0.0

80

.15

0.3

50

.05

0.5

80

.09

0.4

40

.07

1.0

00

.15

0.1

0.5

8

0.7

80

.15

0.1

0.1

0.3

0.3

0.0

90

.53

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

RE

LA

TIV

E S

CO

RE

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 3

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 2 Weights

Scenario 3 Weights

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

0.1

0.1

0.1

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RIN

G R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E I

N L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-34

Page 41: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

3 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

SU

MM

AR

Y

P

OP

ULA

TIO

N D

OU

BLE

CO

UN

TE

D F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (

HP

AN

D L

W)

AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

WE

IGH

TE

D IM

PO

RT

AN

CE

SC

OR

ES

SU

MM

AR

Y B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

AN

D IM

PLI

CA

TIO

NS

FO

R N

RS

P's

BU

DG

ET

ALL

OC

AT

ION

S

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

PU

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

LW

(2)

PU

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(1)

LW

(3)

PU

0.6

30

.42

0.8

40

.53

0.4

50

.29

0.5

80

.43

0.8

40

.48

0.4

30

.30

0.6

30

.42

0.8

40

.53

0.4

70

.29

52

64

31

52

64

31

52

64

31

0.6

00

.41

0.8

50

.48

0.3

80

.25

0.5

40

.41

0.7

70

.43

0.3

80

.25

0.6

00

.41

0.8

50

.49

0.4

20

.25

53

64

21

53

64

21

52

64

31

0.6

50

.43

0.8

90

.56

0.4

10

.22

0.5

80

.42

0.8

60

.51

0.3

90

.21

0.6

50

.43

0.8

90

.56

0.4

50

.22

53

64

21

53

64

21

52

64

31

0.6

90

.44

0.8

50

.50

0.5

20

.37

0.6

40

.45

0.8

50

.47

0.5

10

.38

0.6

90

.44

0.8

50

.51

0.5

50

.37

52

63

41

52

63

41

52

63

41

0.6

00

.40

0.7

80

.56

0.4

40

.32

0.5

60

.42

0.8

00

.52

0.4

50

.36

0.6

00

.40

0.7

80

.56

0.4

70

.32

52

64

31

52

64

31

52

64

31

0.63

0.42

0.83

0.53

0.44

0.30

Mea

n S

core

pe

r P

S,

acro

ss a

ll sc

enar

ios

0.58

0.42

0.82

0.49

0.43

0.31

Mea

n S

core

pe

r P

S,

acro

ss a

ll sc

enar

ios

0.63

0.42

0.83

0.54

0.47

0.30

52

64

31

Sim

ple

ra

nk

acr

oss

P

Ss

52

64

31

Sim

ple

ra

nk

acr

oss

P

Ss

52

64

31

19.9

313

.25

26.3

816

.94

14.0

39.

48

Re

lativ

e

rank

a

cro

ss

PS

s 18

.82

13.9

026

.97

15.9

414

.13

10.2

4

Re

lativ

e

rank

a

cro

ss

PS

s 19

.71

13.1

026

.09

16.9

014

.83

9.38

WE

IGH

TE

D IM

PO

RT

AN

CE

SC

OR

ES

HP

HS

SA

FA

LW

PU

Mea

n S

core

per

PS

acr

oss

V1,

V2

& V

3, w

ith D

oubl

e C

ount

ing

0.61

0.42

0.83

0.52

0.45

0.30

Mea

n S

core

per

PS

for S

cena

rio 4

acr

oss

V1,

2 &

3, w

ith D

oubl

e C

ount

ing

0.67

0.44

0.85

0.49

0.53

0.37

Ove

rall

Impo

rtan

ce R

ank

base

d on

all

Sce

nario

s (

6 =

Gre

ates

t Nee

d)5

26

43

1

Impl

icat

ion

for

% B

udge

t Allo

catio

n19

.513

.426

.516

.614

.39.

7

Ove

rall

Impo

rtanc

e R

ank

base

d on

Sce

nario

4 (

6 =

Gre

ates

t Nee

d)5

26

34

1

Impl

icat

ion

for

% B

udge

t Allo

catio

n20

.013

.225

.314

.715

.711

.1

** /

Ran

k sc

ores

are

bas

ed o

n w

eigh

ted

scor

es v

alue

s re

ad to

sev

en d

ecim

al p

lace

s

55

33

44

22

Sce

na

rio

R

ef N

o.S

cen

ari

o

Ref

No.

To

tal

sco

re,

sum

fo

r a

ll cr

iteri

a &

PS

ra

nki

ng

, V

2**

To

tal

sco

re,

sum

fo

r a

ll cr

iteri

a &

PS

ra

nki

ng

, V

1**

To

tal

sco

re,

sum

fo

r a

ll cr

iteri

a &

PS

ra

nki

ng

, V

3**

11

KE

Y:

6 =

GR

EA

TE

ST

NE

ED

, 1

= L

EA

ST

NE

ED

App-35

Page 42: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

4 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

OF

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M B

Y E

AC

H C

HA

RA

CT

ER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

ION

A

DJU

ST

ED

PO

PU

LAT

ION

S F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (

HP

AN

D L

W)

AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

PU

521,

307

278,

927

1,50

5,33

237

4,47

215

3,36

20

0.35

0.19

1.00

0.25

0.10

0.00

170,

737,

361

9,58

6,79

424

9,17

2,03

27,

263,

278

39,9

46,8

8242

,846

,239

0.69

0.04

1.00

0.03

0.16

0.17

4.17

1.67

3.17

1.67

4.00

5.00

0.40

1.00

0.53

1.00

0.42

0.33

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.11

0.21

1.00

0.28

0.18

1.00

0.25

0.13

0.03

133.

3396

.67

183.

3318

3.33

80.0

00.

000.

730.

531.

001.

000.

440.

004.

002.

172.

001.

834.

500.

000.

460.

850.

921.

000.

410.

001,

452

1,55

61,

653

2,30

11,

050

1,66

70.

720.

670.

640.

461.

000.

6351

.31

49.9

654

.60

49.7

538

.90

54.6

30.

758

0.77

90.

712

0.78

21.

000

0.71

256

.30

63.4

255

.40

55.7

857

.00

53.3

80.

948

0.84

20.

964

0.95

70.

937

1.00

00.

1539

n/a

0.15

450.

0961

n/a

0.15

290.

625

0.71

90.

622

1.00

00.

719

0.62

92,

491

n/a

1,88

577

n/a

249

0.03

0.35

0.04

1.00

0.35

0.31

10n/

a6

4n/

a6

0.40

0.68

0.67

1.00

0.68

0.67

6b 6c

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

5a 5b 5c 6a3a 3b 4a 4b

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aP

rod

uct

ion

Sys

tem

s, V

ersi

on

1

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Pop

ulat

ion

Re

f

1 2

Market Feasibility

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Potential

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Poverty status (National data)

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept fo

r Pe

ri-Urb

an w

here

tota

l pop

ulat

ion

was

use

d.

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

res

tric

ted

in

com

para

tive

adva

ntag

e fo

r su

pply

(s

ee la

nd p

rodu

ctiv

ity p

oten

tial).

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

m

anua

lly to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed v

alue

s.

Hal

f Ban

glad

esh

HP

popu

latio

n de

duct

ed to

rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

LW

.

Hal

f Ban

glad

esh

LW p

opul

atio

n de

duct

ed to

rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

HP.

Hal

f Nep

al H

S po

pula

tion

dedu

cted

to rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

FA.

Hal

f Nep

al F

A po

pula

tion

dedu

cted

to rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

HS.

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-36

Page 43: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

4 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

OF

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M B

Y E

AC

H C

HA

RA

CT

ER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

ION

A

DJU

ST

ED

PO

PU

LAT

ION

S F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (

HP

AN

D L

W)

AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

LW

(2)

PU

695,

117

278,

927

2,24

2,35

338

6,48

018

7,48

30

0.31

0.12

1.00

0.17

0.08

0.00

260,

798,

296

9,58

6,79

440

7,63

2,64

510

,358

,275

49,0

26,9

3942

,846

,239

0.64

0.04

1.00

0.03

0.12

0.11

4.17

1.67

3.50

2.33

4.33

5.00

0.40

1.00

0.48

0.71

0.38

0.33

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.10

0.11

1.00

0.29

0.19

1.00

0.28

0.26

0.03

133.

3396

.67

200.

0016

6.67

83.3

30.

000.

670.

481.

000.

830.

420.

004.

172.

172.

831.

835.

000.

000.

440.

850.

651.

000.

370.

001,

502

1,55

61,

644

2,15

71,

160

1,66

70.

770.

750.

710.

541.

000.

7051

.82

49.9

654

.45

54.3

440

.19

54.6

30.

776

0.80

40.

738

0.74

01.

000

0.73

655

.77

63.4

255

.46

60.2

758

.01

53.3

80.

957

0.84

20.

963

0.88

60.

920

1.00

00.

1539

n/a

0.15

450.

0961

n/a

0.15

290.

625

0.71

90.

622

1.00

00.

719

0.62

92,

889

n/a

3,04

914

8n/

a24

90.

050.

420.

051.

000.

420.

599

n/a

67

n/a

60.

670.

881.

000.

860.

881.

00

Pop

ulat

ion

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aP

rod

uct

ion

Sys

tem

s, V

ersi

on

2R

ef

1 2

Market Feasibility

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Potential

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Poverty status (National data)

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

3a 3b 4a 4b 5a 5b 5c 6a 6b 6c

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

m

anua

lly to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed v

alue

s.

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept

for Pe

ri-U

rban

whe

re to

tal

popu

latio

n w

as u

sed.

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

res

tric

ted

in c

ompa

rativ

e ad

vant

age

for

supp

ly (

see

land

pro

duct

ivity

po

tent

ial).

Hal

f Nep

al F

A po

pula

tion

dedu

cted

to rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

HS.

Hal

f Ban

glad

esh

HP

popu

latio

n de

duct

ed to

re

mov

e do

uble

cou

ntin

g w

ith

inla

nd fl

oodp

lain

LW

.

Hal

f Nep

al H

S po

pula

tion

dedu

cted

to rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

FA.

Hal

f of B

angl

ades

h in

land

flo

odpl

ain

popu

latio

n de

duct

ed

to rem

ove

doub

le c

ount

ing

with

H

P.

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-37

Page 44: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

4 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

OF

PR

OD

UC

TIO

N S

YS

TE

M B

Y E

AC

H C

HA

RA

CT

ER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

ION

A

DJU

ST

ED

PO

PU

LAT

ION

S F

OR

BA

NG

LAD

ES

H (

HP

AN

D L

W)

AN

D N

EP

AL

(HS

AN

D F

A)

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(1)

LW

(3)

PU

521,

307

278,

927

1,50

5,33

237

4,47

212

4,14

90

0.35

0.19

1.00

0.25

0.08

0.00

170,

737,

361

9,58

6,79

424

9,17

2,03

210

,358

,275

46,7

20,2

3942

,846

,239

0.69

0.04

1.00

0.04

0.19

0.17

4.17

1.67

3.17

1.67

4.00

5.00

0.40

1.00

0.53

1.00

0.42

0.33

0.10

0.15

0.03

0.11

0.14

1.00

0.28

0.18

1.00

0.25

0.20

0.03

133.

3396

.67

183.

3318

3.33

100.

000.

000.

730.

531.

001.

000.

550.

004.

002.

172.

001.

835.

000.

000.

460.

850.

921.

000.

370.

001,

452

1,55

61,

653

2,30

11,

050

1,66

70.

720.

670.

640.

461.

000.

6351

.31

49.9

654

.60

49.7

538

.90

54.6

30.

758

0.77

90.

712

0.78

21.

000

0.71

256

.30

63.4

255

.40

55.7

857

.00

53.3

80.

948

0.84

20.

964

0.95

70.

937

1.00

00.

1539

n/a

0.15

450.

0961

n/a

0.15

290.

625

0.71

90.

622

1.00

00.

719

0.62

92,

491

n/a

1,88

577

n/a

249

0.03

0.35

0.04

1.00

0.35

0.31

10n/

a6

4n/

a6

0.40

0.68

0.67

1.00

0.68

0.67

6b 6c

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

popu

latio

n of

PS

NR

Res

earc

h S

cien

tists

(19

91)

per

1m p

opul

atio

n of

PS

5a 5b 5c 6a3a 3b 4a 4b

NR Knowledge Base (National

data)

% o

f GD

P to

Agr

icul

tura

l Res

earc

h (1

991)

Wei

ghte

d

Poverty status (National data)

Ave

rage

GD

P (U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)

Lite

racy

Rat

e %

(199

7, w

eigh

ted)

Har

vard

Sca

le D

ata

(% c

hild

ren

wei

ght/h

eigh

t)

Market Feasibility

Roa

d D

ensi

ty

Mar

ket D

eman

d A

sses

smen

t

Potential

Ass

essm

ent o

f Exp

ort P

oten

tial

Land

Pro

duct

ivity

Pot

entia

l

Pop

ulat

ion

Ch

arac

teri

sati

on

Cri

teri

aP

rod

uct

ion

Sys

tem

s V

ersi

on

3

Land

are

a (k

m2 )

Re

f

1 2

Char

acte

risat

ion

crite

rion

had

to b

e sc

ored

m

anua

lly to

acco

mm

odat

e th

e av

erag

ed v

alue

s.

Popu

latio

n ta

ken

as r

ural

exc

ept fo

r Pe

ri-Urb

an w

here

tota

l pop

ulat

ion

was

use

d.

PU h

as m

arke

ts b

ut is

res

tric

ted

in c

ompa

rativ

e ad

vant

age

for

supp

ly (

see

land

pro

duct

ivity

po

tent

ial).

Hal

f Ban

glad

esh

inla

nd L

W

popu

latio

n de

duct

ed to

rem

ove

doub

le c

ount

ing

with

HP.

Hal

f Nep

al F

A po

pula

tion

dedu

cted

to rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

HS.

Hal

f Nep

al H

S po

pula

tion

dedu

cted

to rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

FA.

Hal

f Ban

glad

esh

HP

popu

latio

n de

duct

ed to

rem

ove

doub

le

coun

ting

with

LW

.

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E IN

LIE

U O

F S

UIT

AB

LE D

AT

A

App-38

Page 45: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

4 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

W

ITH

AD

JUS

TE

D P

OP

ULA

TIO

NS

FO

R B

AN

GLA

DE

SH

(H

P A

ND

LW

) A

ND

NE

PA

L (H

S A

ND

FA

)

DE

RIV

ED

WE

IGH

TE

D S

CO

RE

S B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

AN

D C

HA

RA

CT

ER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

IA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

re

lativ

e s

core

, m

ea

n r

ela

tive

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

re

lativ

e s

core

(u

sin

g S

cen

ari

o 1

we

igh

ts*)

fo

r e

ach

ch

ara

cte

risa

tion

cr

iteri

on

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )0

.35

0.3

50

.00

0.1

90

.19

0.0

01

.00

1.0

00

.01

0.2

50

.25

0.0

00

.10

0.1

00

.00

0.0

00

.00

0.0

00

.01

0.0

10

.01

0.0

10

.01

2.

Po

pu

latio

n0

.69

0.6

90

.27

0.0

40

.04

0.0

21

.00

1.0

00

.39

0.0

30

.03

0.0

10

.16

0.1

60

.06

0.1

70

.17

0.0

70

.39

0.3

90

.39

0.3

90

.39

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

0

.40

1.0

00

.53

1.0

00

.42

0.3

33

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t0

.28

0.1

81

.00

0.2

50

.13

0.0

34

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

0.7

30

.53

1.0

01

.00

0.4

40

.00

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

0.4

60

.85

0.9

21

.00

0.4

10

.00

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)0

.72

0.6

70

.64

0.4

61

.00

0.6

35b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

0.7

60

.78

0.7

10

.78

1.0

00

.71

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

0.9

50

.84

0.9

60

.96

0.9

41

.00

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

0.6

20

.72

0.6

21

.00

0.7

20

.63

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.03

0.3

50

.04

1.0

00

.35

0.3

16

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.40

0.6

80

.67

1.0

00

.68

0.6

71

.01

.01

.01

.01

.0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(1)

0.5

8H

S0

.41

SA

(1)

0.8

4F

A(2

)0

.52

LW

(1)

0.4

0P

U0

.29

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(1)

0.5

5H

S0

.40

SA

(1)

0.8

5F

A(2

)0

.47

LW

(1)

0.3

4P

U0

.25

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(1)

0.6

0H

S0

.42

SA

(1)

0.8

9F

A(2

)0

.55

LW

(1)

0.3

7P

U0

.22

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(1)

0.6

4H

S0

.43

SA

(1)

0.8

5F

A(2

)0

.50

LW

(1)

0.4

8P

U0

.37

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(1)

0.5

5H

S0

.40

SA

(1)

0.7

8F

A(2

)0

.55

LW

(1)

0.4

1P

U0

.32

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 1

FA

(2)

LW

(1)

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

Scenario 2 Weights

PU

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 3 Weights

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

0.1

5

0.1

2

0.0

9

0.5

80

.09

0.9

60

.14

0.7

7

0.1

5

0.1

5

0.0

50

.11

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

0.0

5

0.3

4

0.3

5

0.7

6

0.4

4

0.1

0

0.7

70

.11

0.8

1

0.5

9

0.0

7

0.7

3

1.0

0

0.6

2

1.0

0

0.1

5

0.9

8

0.0

9

0.1

5

0.5

8

0.7

8

0.2

70

.04

0.4

20

.06

0.0

0

0.1

8

0.0

90

.53

0.0

8

0.5

90

.09

0.0

0

0.1

50

.11

0.1

2

0.6

9

0.1

2

0.0

30

.1

0.1

0.3

0.1

0.1

0.3

0.1

0.1

5

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

RE

LA

TIV

E S

CO

RE

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 1

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.3

0.1

0.1

0.3

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E I

N L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-39

Page 46: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

4 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

W

ITH

AD

JUS

TE

D P

OP

ULA

TIO

NS

FO

R B

AN

GLA

DE

SH

(H

P A

ND

LW

) A

ND

NE

PA

L (H

S A

ND

FA

)

DE

RIV

ED

WE

IGH

TE

D S

CO

RE

S B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

AN

D C

HA

RA

CT

ER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

IA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

re

lativ

e s

core

, m

ea

n r

ela

tive

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

re

lativ

e s

core

(u

sin

g S

cen

ari

o 1

we

igh

ts*)

fo

r e

ach

ch

ara

cte

risa

tion

cr

iteri

on

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )0

.31

0.3

10

.00

0.1

20

.12

0.0

01

.00

1.0

00

.01

0.1

70

.17

0.0

00

.08

0.0

80

.00

0.0

00

.00

0.0

00

.01

0.0

10

.01

0.0

10

.01

2.

Po

pu

latio

n0

.64

0.6

40

.25

0.0

40

.04

0.0

21

.00

1.0

00

.39

0.0

30

.03

0.0

10

.12

0.1

20

.05

0.1

10

.11

0.0

40

.39

0.3

90

.39

0.3

90

.39

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

0

.40

1.0

00

.48

0.7

10

.38

0.3

33

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t0

.29

0.1

91

.00

0.2

80

.26

0.0

34

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

0.6

70

.48

1.0

00

.83

0.4

20

.00

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

0.4

40

.85

0.6

51

.00

0.3

70

.00

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)0

.77

0.7

50

.71

0.5

41

.00

0.7

05b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

0.7

80

.80

0.7

40

.74

1.0

00

.74

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

0.9

60

.84

0.9

60

.89

0.9

21

.00

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

0.6

20

.72

0.6

21

.00

0.7

20

.63

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.05

0.4

20

.05

1.0

00

.42

0.5

96

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.67

0.8

81

.00

0.8

60

.88

1.0

01

.01

.01

.01

.01

.0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(2)

0.5

8H

S0

.43

SA

(2)

0.8

4F

A(1

)0

.48

LW

(2)

0.4

0P

U0

.30

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(2)

0.4

7H

S0

.34

SA

(2)

0.7

7F

A(1

)0

.36

LW

(2)

0.2

7P

U0

.18

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(2)

0.5

8H

S0

.42

SA

(2)

0.8

6F

A(1

)0

.50

LW

(2)

0.3

6P

U0

.21

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(2)

0.6

4H

S0

.45

SA

(2)

0.8

5F

A(1

)0

.46

LW

(2)

0.4

8P

U0

.38

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(2)

0.5

6H

S0

.42

SA

(2)

0.8

0F

A(1

)0

.51

LW

(2)

0.4

2P

U0

.36

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

RE

LA

TIV

E S

CO

RE

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 2

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 2 Weights

Scenario 3 Weights

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

LW

(2)

PU

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 2

HP

(2)

HS

SA

(2)

FA

(1)

0.3

20

.74

0.1

10

.50

0.0

70

.34

0.0

50

.60

0.0

90

.05

0.1

80

.03

0.1

50

.30

.10

.10

.1

0.5

50

.08

0.6

60

.10

0.8

20

.12

0.9

20

.14

0.3

90

.06

0.0

00

.00

0.1

50

.10

.30

.10

.1

0.8

40

.13

0.8

00

.12

0.8

00

.12

0.7

20

.11

0.9

70

.15

0.8

10

.12

0.1

5

0.4

50

.07

0.6

70

.10

0.5

60

.08

0.9

50

.14

0.6

70

.10

0.7

40

.11

0.3

0.1

50

.10

.10

.1

0.1

0.1

0.3

0.1

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E I

N L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-40

Page 47: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

A

PP

EN

DIX

4 -

RE

LAT

IVE

SC

OR

ING

W

ITH

AD

JUS

TE

D P

OP

ULA

TIO

NS

FO

R B

AN

GLA

DE

SH

(H

P A

ND

LW

) A

ND

NE

PA

L (H

S A

ND

FA

)

DE

RIV

ED

WE

IGH

TE

D S

CO

RE

S B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

AN

D C

HA

RA

CT

ER

ISA

TIO

N C

RIT

ER

IA

Fo

r e

ach

PS

, co

lum

ns

to t

he

rig

ht

spe

cify

re

lativ

e s

core

, m

ea

n r

ela

tive

sco

re a

nd

we

igh

ted

me

an

re

lativ

e s

core

(u

sin

g S

cen

ari

o 1

we

igh

ts*)

fo

r e

ach

ch

ara

cte

risa

tion

cr

iteri

on

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

Score

Mean

Weighted Mean

CH

AR

AC

TE

RIS

AT

ION

CR

ITE

RIA

1. L

and

area

(km

2 )0

.35

0.3

50

.00

0.1

90

.19

0.0

01

.00

1.0

00

.01

0.2

50

.25

0.0

00

.08

0.0

80

.00

0.0

00

.00

0.0

00

.01

0.0

10

.01

0.0

10

.01

2.

Po

pu

latio

n0

.69

0.6

90

.27

0.0

40

.04

0.0

21

.00

1.0

00

.39

0.0

40

.04

0.0

20

.19

0.1

90

.07

0.1

70

.17

0.0

70

.39

0.3

90

.39

0.3

90

.39

3.

Ma

rke

ting

fe

asi

bili

ty:

3a

. R

oa

d d

en

sity

0

.40

1.0

00

.53

1.0

00

.42

0.3

33

b.

Ma

rke

t d

em

an

d a

sse

ssm

en

t0

.28

0.1

81

.00

0.2

50

.20

0.0

34

. P

ote

ntia

l:4

a.

Ass

ess

me

nt

of

exp

ort

po

ten

tial

0.7

30

.53

1.0

01

.00

0.5

50

.00

4b

. L

an

d p

rod

uct

ivity

po

ten

tial

0.4

60

.85

0.9

21

.00

0.3

70

.00

5.

Po

vert

y st

atu

s (N

atio

na

l d

ata

):5a

. A

vera

ge G

DP

(U

SD

per

ann

um p

er c

apita

,199

7)0

.72

0.6

70

.64

0.4

61

.00

0.6

35b

. Li

tera

cy r

ate

% (

1997

, w

eigh

ted)

0.7

60

.78

0.7

10

.78

1.0

00

.71

5c.

Ha

rva

rd s

cale

da

ta (

% c

hild

ren

we

igh

t/h

eig

ht)

0.9

50

.84

0.9

60

.96

0.9

41

.00

6.

NR

kn

ow

led

ge

ba

se (

Na

tion

al

da

ta):

6a.

% o

f G

DP

to

Agr

icul

tura

l R

esea

rch

(199

1) W

eigh

ted

0.6

20

.72

0.6

21

.00

0.7

20

.63

6b

. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.03

0.3

50

.04

1.0

00

.35

0.3

16

c. N

R R

ese

arc

h S

cie

ntis

ts (

19

91

) p

er

1m

po

pu

latio

n o

f P

S0

.40

0.6

80

.67

1.0

00

.68

0.6

71

.01

.01

.01

.01

.0S

CE

NA

RIO

S F

OR

CR

ITE

RIA

WE

IGH

TIN

GS

Sce

nar

io 1

- E

qu

al w

eig

hti

ng

on

3-6

HP

(1)

0.5

8H

S0

.41

SA

(1)

0.8

4F

A(1

)0

.52

LW

(3)

0.4

2P

U0

.29

Sce

nar

io 2

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 3

HP

(1)

0.5

5H

S0

.40

SA

(1)

0.8

5F

A(1

)0

.48

LW

(3)

0.3

7P

U0

.25

Sce

nar

io 3

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 4

HP

(1)

0.6

0H

S0

.42

SA

(1)

0.8

9F

A(1

)0

.55

LW

(3)

0.4

0P

U0

.22

Sce

nar

io 4

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 5

HP

(1)

0.6

4H

S0

.43

SA

(1)

0.8

5F

A(1

)0

.50

LW

(3)

0.5

0P

U0

.37

Sce

nar

io 5

- In

crea

sed

wei

gh

tin

g o

n 6

HP

(1)

0.5

5H

S0

.40

SA

(1)

0.7

8F

A(1

)0

.55

LW

(3)

0.4

2P

U0

.32

* /

Sce

na

rio

1 i

s u

sed

as

an

exa

mp

le s

ho

win

g h

ow

th

e v

alu

es

for

the

to

tal

we

igh

ted

sco

res

of

ea

ch s

cen

ari

o w

ere

ge

ne

rate

d.

0.3

0.1

50

.10

.10

.10

.58

0.0

90

.53

0.0

80

.44

0.0

71

.00

0.1

50

.35

0.0

50

.58

0.0

9

0.1

0.1

0.3

0.1

0.1

50

.78

0.1

20

.15

0.1

0.8

10

.12

0.7

70

.11

0.7

70

.12

0.7

30

.11

0.9

8

0.1

50

.10

.30

.10

.46

0.0

70

.00

0.0

0

0.1

0.1

0.5

90

.09

0.6

90

.10

0.9

60

.14

1.0

00

.15

0.5

90

.09

0.3

0.1

Wei

gh

tin

g S

cen

ario

s

Scenario 1 Weights

Scenario 2 Weights

0.3

1

LW

(3)

PU

0.0

50

.18

0.0

30

.15

Pro

du

ctio

n S

yste

ms,

Ver

sio

n 3

HP

(1)

HS

SA

(1)

FA

(1)

Scenario 3 Weights

Scenario 4 Weights

Scenario 5 Weights

TO

TA

L W

EIG

HT

ED

RE

LA

TIV

E S

CO

RE

(A

LL

CR

ITE

RIA

) B

Y P

RO

DU

CT

ION

SY

ST

EM

S, V

ER

SIO

N 3

0.7

60

.11

0.6

20

.09

0.3

40

.05

FR

AC

TIO

NA

L S

CO

RE

S R

ELA

TIV

E T

O G

RE

AT

ES

T N

EE

DS

HA

DE

D C

ELL

S =

AV

ER

AG

E I

N L

IEU

OF

SU

ITA

BLE

DA

TA

App-41

Page 48: The Characterisation of Six Natural Resources Production … · Production Systems Characterisation, Section 6 Bibliography 6-2 FAO, 1988. Land Resources Appraisal of Bangladesh for

The Natural Resources Systems Programme (NRSP), of the UKDepartment for International Development, undertakes research on theintegrated management of natural resources. This encompasses thesocial, economic, institutional and biophysical factors that influencepeople’s ability to both use and maintain the productive potential of thenatural resource (NR) base over a relatively long timeframe. Theintended outcome of the research is that NR-related strategies forimproving people’s livelihoods, that are of proven relevance to poorpeople, will be delivered in forms that could be taken up by the poorthemselves and/or by development practitioners operating at a range oflevel’s, from grassroots to senior policy level.

HTS Development Limited Thamesfield House

Boundary Way Hemel Hempstead

HP2 7SR Tel: +44 (0)1442 214369

Email: [email protected] Website: www.nrsp.co.uk

Marine Resources Assessment Group Ltd47 Prince’s Gate

LondonSW7 2QA

Development Planning UnitThe Barlett

University College London9 Endsleigh Gardens

LondonWC1H 0ED