The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

102
Google Approved Paid Links Wil Reynolds Associate @wilreynolds http://www.flickr.com/photos/68751915@N05/6551534889/

description

Content Marketing is all the rage, and I'm a believer too. But lets be honest, SEO's need to promote content and also build links and social signals these days. So I gave my team $10,000 to "play with" and this presentation shares what we learned about paying to promote content across networks & across social sites like nRelate, Taboola, Zemanta, Twitter, LinkedIn.

Transcript of The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

Page 1: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

Google Approved Paid Links

Wil Reynolds Associate

@wilreynolds http://www.flickr.com/photos/68751915@N05/6551534889/

Page 2: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

$10,000 Dollars in “Play” Money

Page 3: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

$10,000 Dollars in “Play” Money

Page 4: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

$10,000 in Play Money

Page 5: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

5 @wilreynolds

Go Forth and Use $$ to Get Links

Page 6: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Eyeballs

http://www.flickr.com/photos/bayat/

Page 7: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Impressions

http://www.flickr.com/photos/bayat/

Page 8: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Attention

http://www.flickr.com/photos/theenmoy

Page 9: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Prayed, HARD

http://www.flickr.com/photos/theenmoy

Page 10: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

3 Outcomes

Page 11: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Win

http://www.flickr.com/photos/theenmoy/

Page 12: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Lose

http://www.flickr.com/photos/theenmoy/

Page 13: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds http://www.flickr.com/photos/theenmoy

Wait

Page 14: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

14 @wilreynolds

The Players

Page 15: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Losses

http://www.flickr.com/photos/eole

Page 16: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

“Not Im

pressed”

@wilreynolds

Page 17: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Zemanta

@wilreynolds

Page 18: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Zemanta

Page 19: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

19 @wilreynolds

HOW DO THEY GET PAID? Impressions, CPM

Page 20: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

20 @wilreynolds

HOW DO PUBLISHERS GET PAID? Content is “suggested” to bloggers

Page 21: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

21 @wilreynolds

IMPACT • 2-3 Clicks Avg • No “follow on” links • 8 Clients • $500/mo

Page 22: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

22 @wilreynolds

3 CHARACTERISTICS • Sites you would rarely visit • Low social signals • Lots of ads

Page 23: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Netw

ork: nRelate

Page 24: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Asset: Infographic

Page 25: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Asset: Infographic (looked like this)

Page 26: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

“Not Im

pressed”

@wilreynolds

Page 27: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Previous Successes

Page 28: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

I was VERY SKEPTICAL

Page 29: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

29 @wilreynolds

SPEND: $700 DAYS: 3 CPC: .30 CAPS: $50

Page 30: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

IMPRESSIONS: 8,883,291 CLICKS: 2,335 CTR: .0277% LINKS: 1 SOCIAL SHARES: 1*

Page 31: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

PAGES PER VISIT: 1.07 DURATION: 15 seconds BOUNCE RATE: 95.16

Page 32: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Lessons:

Page 33: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

No “Mad Scientist” Time

http://www.flickr.com/photos/johncarleton @wilreynolds

Page 34: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

Aggregate Traffic to Landing Page

** 6 weeks before test & 6 weeks after (June 28th –

September 30th)

34

Before During After

Traf

fic

Time

+112 total visits after referral traffic ended

Page 35: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

COST = $700 SETUP/WATCH TIME = $300

--------------------------- $1,000

Page 36: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

$1,000 per link - Not Impressed

Page 37: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Netw

ork: Tw

itter

Page 38: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Asset: Fantasy Football Name Generator

Page 39: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Previous Successes

Page 40: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

40 @wilreynolds

SPEND: $177 (Budget: $500) DAYS: 4 CPC: .49 CAPS: $100/Day

Page 41: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Outcome CAMPAIGN IMPRESSIONS CLICKS RETWEETS REPLIES FOLLOWS ENGAGEMENT

#FantasyFootball 3,876 185 6 0 1 4.95%

ESPN & Yahoo FF 6,149 161 1 1 0 2.65%

Page 42: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

LESSONS: • Low impression volume

+ 1 tweet = death • More than 1 tweet to promote • Offbrand = no new followers • $$ = Have a value of a

follower in mind • Who RT’ed it / Influencer?

Page 43: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

43 @wilreynolds

@HarrisNeifield + @AndrewMeyer8

Page 44: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

$177 / follower - Not Impressed

Page 45: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Wins

http://www.flickr.com/photos/johncarleton @wilreynolds

Page 46: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Netw

ork: nRelate

Page 47: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Asset: Infographic

Page 48: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Previous Successes

Page 49: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Previous Successes

Page 50: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

50 @wilreynolds

SPEND: $700 DAYS: 3 CPC: .30 CAPS: None

Page 51: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

IMPRESSIONS: 8,459,796 CLICKS: 2,343 CTR: .0277% LINKS: 7 SOCIAL SHARES: 1*

Page 52: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

LESSONS: • No time to test • Big Share Buttons at Top • A/B test asset title • Tech Gaming = Good nRelate • Get GA in order

Page 53: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

COST = $700 SETUP/WATCH TIME = $300

--------------------------- $1,000

Page 54: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

$124 per link - Not Bad

Page 55: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Netw

ork: nRelate

Page 56: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Asset: 3 articles w/ Infographic

Page 57: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

57 @wilreynolds

SPEND: $502.65 DAYS: 13 CPC: .15 CAPS: $50/Day

Page 58: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

IMPRESSIONS: 4,192,887 CLICKS: 3,351 CTR: .0799% LINKS: 11 SOCIAL SHARES: 1,000*

Page 59: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

3 Articles

ARTICLE CLICKS LINKS SOCIAL*

PC Gaming vs Console Gaming 304 1 --

Memes 352 1 --

DIY 1871 9 --

Page 60: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

COST = $502 SETUP/WATCH TIME = $300

--------------------------- $802

Page 61: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

$72.91 per link – Let’s Drink!

Page 62: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Netw

ork: Taboola

Page 63: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Asset: 5 Articles, Recognized Food Brand

Page 64: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Previous Successes

Page 65: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

65 @wilreynolds

SPEND: $1700 DAYS: 26 CPC: .15 CAPS: $75/Day

Page 66: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

IMPRESSIONS: 20,050,570 CLICKS: 11,006 CTR: .0549% LINKS: 82 SOCIAL SHARES: 1,000*

Page 67: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

5 Articles

ARTICLE CLICKS LINKS SOCIAL*

Beer Trend 2013 7372 10 77

“10 Best” Wine/Travel 1240 17 131

Sangria 658 9 129

Unusual Wines 472 15 166

100 Best Wine Restaurants 215 32 218

Page 68: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

68 @wilreynolds

Network: Taboola Audience knows your brand

Page 69: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

69 @wilreynolds

Network: Taboola Little impact

Page 70: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

70 @wilreynolds

Network: Taboola

Audience knows you, it doesn’t matter

Page 71: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

71 @wilreynolds

Network: Taboola

Highest Bounce Lowest PPVs Lowest Duration

Page 72: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

72 @wilreynolds

Network: Taboola

Should have paused it

Page 73: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

73 @wilreynolds

Network: Taboola

Next Time: Create a Micro-conversion

Page 74: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

MICRO CONVERSIONS: • Clicks on Share buttons by

Campaign (not social plugin) • Scroll to a certain point • Sign up for newsletter • Read Next Article

Page 75: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Make a BUSINESS Case

Page 76: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

SocialC

rawlytics

Page 77: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

A/B Asset Testing

RESULTS FRUITY OR FIZZY? 9 SIMPLE STEPS

Impressions 1,255,492 918,096

Clicks 658 494

CTR 0.0524% 0.0538%

Spend $98.70 $74.10

Page 78: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Referring Sites

RESULTS OUTCOMES

USA Today 67.21% Bounce

Bloomberg 1.76 PPV vs 1.2 Site Average

MyFox(city) 98% Bounce

Buzzfeed 97% Bounce

Page 79: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

0

10000

20000

30000

40000

50000

60000

70000

80000

90000

100000

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Before During After

Traf

fic

Time

Aggregate Traffic to Landing Page

79

+15,540 total visits after referral

traffic ended

** 6 weeks before test & 6 weeks after (June 27th – October 15th)

Page 80: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

LESSONS: • Get more like SEM • Next Buttons At Bottom • Additional Engagement • Clicks != Links (more research

coming)

Page 81: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

COST = $1700 SETUP/WATCH TIME = $300

--------------------------- $2,000

Page 82: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

$24.39 per link – Let’s Get Wasted!

Page 83: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Netw

ork: outbrain

Page 84: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Education Infographic

Page 85: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Previous Successes

Page 86: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Previous Successes

Page 87: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

87 @wilreynolds

SPEND: $194 DAYS: 2 CPC: .30 - .23 CAPS: $150/day

Page 88: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

IMPRESSIONS: 480,103 CLICKS: 647 CTR: .13% LINKS: TBD SOCIAL SHARES: ??

Page 89: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

5 headlines

ARTICLE CTR

How do employers view online degrees .21

What is the difference between an online and traditional degree .11

Are online degrees equal to traditional degrees .05

Are you employable with an online degree .04

What is the value of an online degree .04

Page 90: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

90 @wilreynolds

Page 91: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Testing 1,2,3 • Test Headlines before naming the

asset? • How do headlines impact

outcomes?

Page 92: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

You guys are ****** GOOD!

Page 93: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

93 @wilreynolds

To pull this off you need

Page 94: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Well rounded

Data + SEO + SEM + Social +

Analytics + Negotiator

Page 95: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

95 @wilreynolds

Hire someone for $40,000 a year to “get links”

Page 96: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

“Minions”

http://www.flickr.com/photos/mr-shtoopid

Page 97: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds Tunnel Vision

http://www.flickr.com/photos/jugbo

Page 98: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Need: Data Junkies Growth Hacker

Page 99: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Where Next? LinkedIn

Newsletters Banner Ads?

http://www.flickr.com/photos/tripwolf

Page 100: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

“Kill Minions”

http://www.flickr.com/photos/mr-shtoopid

Page 101: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

@wilreynolds

Share, or I’m asking him to find your stuff

http://www.flickr.com/photos/mr-shtoopid

Page 102: The $10,000 Paid Content + Paid Linking Test that is 100% Google Safe

About me.

@wilreynolds facebook.com/wilreynolds [email protected]

Wil Reynolds Founder