Template 773 San Marin Drive, Suite 2115, Novato, CA 94998 P: 415-899-0700 F: 415-899-0707 ENVIRON...

42
Template Template 773 San Marin Drive, Suite 2115, Novato, CA 94998 P: 415-899-0700 F: 415-899-0707 www.environcorp.com ENVIRON International Corporation Novato, California Status Updates Isoprene Comparisons from Using Different Sources of PAR Conference Call on December 14, 2011 Western Biogenic Emission Inventory Improvement

Transcript of Template 773 San Marin Drive, Suite 2115, Novato, CA 94998 P: 415-899-0700 F: 415-899-0707 ENVIRON...

TemplateTemplate773 San Marin Drive, Suite 2115, Novato, CA 94998 P: 415-899-0700 F: 415-899-0707

www.environcorp.com

ENVIRON International CorporationNovato, California

Status Updates

Isoprene Comparisons from Using Different Sources of PAR

Conference Call on December 14, 2011

Western Biogenic Emission Inventory Improvement

773 San Marin Drive, Suite 2115, Novato, CA 94998 P: 415-899-0700 F: 415-899-0707 www.environcorp.com

Status Update

Western Biogenic EI Improvement Project

• Comparisons of emission inventories from SMOKE BEIS v3.14, MEGAN v2.04, MEGAN v2.10 for July 3 – 18, 2008 and January 3 – 18, 2008, with new WRF data

o No change to previous conclusion to use MEGAN v2.10

o Most results are presented at the end as “extra slides”

• Investigating isoprene emission and Photosynthetically Active Radiation (PAR) data from WRF and satellite

o Example results are presented today.

o Recommend using satellite PAR data for 2008 emission inventories

• Starting to evaluate WRF performance for cloud fraction

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

Average Isoprene Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Domain: 36km

VOC, CO, NO2, etc.

Photosynthetically Active Radiation

(PAR)

Cloud

WRF Solar Radiation VS satellite PAR

MEGAN Model

WRF to MEGAN

PAR = 0.5 x SRAD

Where

• 0.5 is assumed that ½ of solar radiation is in 400-700nm band

• SRAD is solar radiation (w/m2)

Satellite to

MEGAN• From GEWEX/GCIP and GEWEX Americas Prediction Project (GAPP)

• Satellite reports PAR data used directly in MEGAN

• Pinker, et al., shows good performance between satellite and ground stations

Pinker, et al., 2003, Surface radiation budgets in support of the GEWEX Continental-Scale International Project (GCIP) and the GEWEX Americas Prediction Project (GAPP), including the North American Land Data Assimilation System (NLDAS) project

MEGAN v2.10WRF/MCIP

Average Isoprene Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

MEGAN v2.10Satellite

DifferenceWRF/MCIP - Satellite

PARWRF/MCIP

PARSatellite

PARWRF/MCIP - Satellite

Domain Total = 7353 kg/hr km2 Domain Total = 4735 kg/hr km2 Difference = 2618 kg/hr km2 (55%)

WRF Solar Radiation VS satellite PAR

PAR = 0.5 x Short Wave Radiation

Problem?

Satellite PAR

0.5

0.45 0.425 0.4

http://www.atmos.umd.edu/~srb/par/Figure03.htm

PAR is defined as radiation with wavelength between 400 and 700 nm

Conversion Factor for Short Wave Radiation to PAR

• Conversion Factor varies spatially and temporally

• Use Conversion Factor of 0.45 for this study

MEGAN v2.10WRF/MCIP

Average Isoprene Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

MEGAN v2.10Satellite

DifferenceWRF/MCIP - Satellite

PARSatellite

PAR Difference (%)WRF/MCIP – Satellite

Domain Total = 4735 kg/hr km2 Difference = 1769 kg/hr km2 (37%)

PARWRF/MCIP

Domain Total = 6504 kg/hr km2

MEGAN v2.10WRF/MCIP

Average Isoprene Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

MEGAN v2.10Satellite

DifferenceWRF/MCIP - Satellite

PARWRF/MCIP

PARSatellite

PAR Difference (%)WRF/MCIP - Satellite

Domain Total = 135.6 kg/hr km2 Domain Total = 91.06 kg/hr km2 Difference = 44.54 kg/hr km2 (49%)

MEGAN v2.10WRF/MCIP

Average Isoprene Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

MEGAN v2.10Satellite

DifferenceWRF/MCIP - Satellite

Domain Total = 19,642 kg/hr km2 Difference = 6,747 kg/hr km2 (34%)Domain Total = 26,389 kg/hr km2

MEGAN v2.10WRF/MCIP

Average Isoprene Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

MEGAN v2.10Satellite

DifferenceWRF/MCIP - Satellite

Domain Total = 80.11 kg/hr km2 Difference = 54.59 kg/hr km2 (68%)Domain Total = 134.7 kg/hr km2

Domain Average Isoprene Emission Domain: 4km

• Using WRF/MCIP PAR results in higher emission especially during the peak hours

• Day-to-day emission variations are due to cloud cover

Domain Average of Isoprene for July 3 - 18, 2008

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

07-0

3 :

00

07-0

3 :

12

07-0

4 :

00

07-0

4 :

12

07-0

5 :

00

07-0

5 :

12

07-0

6 :

00

07-0

6 :

12

07-0

7 :

00

07-0

7 :

12

07-0

8 :

00

07-0

8 :

12

07-0

9 :

00

07-0

9 :

12

07-1

0 :

00

07-1

0 :

12

07-1

1 :

00

07-1

1 :

12

07-1

2 :

00

07-1

2 :

12

07-1

3 :

00

07-1

3 :

12

07-1

4 :

00

07-1

4 :

12

07-1

5 :

00

07-1

5 :

12

07-1

6 :

00

07-1

6 :

12

07-1

7 :

00

07-1

7 :

12

07-1

8 :

00

07-1

8 :

12

kg/h

r-km

2

Avg-WRF/MCIP

Avg-Sat

4-km Domain

Domain Average of Isoprene for January 3 - 18, 2008

0

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.004

0.005

0.006

0.007

01-0

3 :

00

01-0

3 :

12

01-0

4 :

00

01-0

4 :

12

01-0

5 :

00

01-0

5 :

12

01-0

6 :

00

01-0

6 :

12

01-0

7 :

00

01-0

7 :

12

01-0

8 :

00

01-0

8 :

12

01-0

9 :

00

01-0

9 :

12

01-1

0 :

00

01-1

0 :

12

01-1

1 :

00

01-1

1 :

12

01-1

2 :

00

01-1

2 :

12

01-1

3 :

00

01-1

3 :

12

01-1

4 :

00

01-1

4 :

12

01-1

5 :

00

01-1

5 :

12

01-1

6 :

00

01-1

6 :

12

01-1

7 :

00

01-1

7 :

12

01-1

8 :

00

01-1

8 :

12

kg/h

r-km

2

Avg-WRF/MCIP

Avg-Sat

4-km Domain

WRF Solar Radiation VS satellite PAR under clear sky

ISOP WRF/MCIP ISOP Satellite Percent Difference

WRF/MCIP CCF Satellite CCF

Clear sky

• ISOP from WRF/MCIP PAR is higher up to 40%.

Summary

Western Biogenic EI Improvement Project

• The new WRF data do not change the conclusion to use MEGANv2.10 for 2008 biogenic inventory

• WRF/MCIP PAR results in > 30% higher isoprene emission than satellite PAR, especially during the peak hours

• Difference occurs under clear skies: not due to cloud fraction

• Calculating PAR as a fraction of WRF Short Wave radiation is part of the problem

• Recommend using satellite PAR data

• Limited satellite data coverage for Canada and Mexico not a major shortcoming for this project

• Working on converting satellite cloud fraction to a workable format for comparison with WRF/MCIP

Western Biogenics EI Improvement Project

Next Steps

• Proceed with 2008 inventory using satellite PAR data

o QA satellite PAR data to find and fill any data gaps

o Process biogenic emissions for all of 2008 for the 3 domains

• Proceed with cloud fraction analysis to assist with WRF evaluation

Extra Slides

• Comparisons between SMKBEIS 3.14, MEGAN 2.04, and MEGAN 2.10– Using PAR = 0.5 x SRAD

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

Average Isoprene Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Domain: 36km

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average Isoprene Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

Isoprene – County Summary

Domain: 4km

SMKBEIS M04 M10 % (M04-B) % (M10-B) % (M10-M04)AZ Pima 123.25 224.40 263.22 82.1 113.6 17.3AZ Maricopa 110.10 319.45 335.87 190.1 205.1 5.1CO Boulder 6.85 23.91 16.93 248.9 147.0 -29.2CO Denver 3.43 4.91 1.27 43.1 -62.9 -74.0CO El Paso 22.35 48.05 17.81 115.0 -20.3 -62.9CO Teller 11.17 14.37 8.76 28.7 -21.6 -39.0NM Bernalillo 7.73 17.70 12.39 129.0 60.3 -30.0ID Bear Lake 26.23 27.28 20.83 4.0 -20.6 -23.7ID Bingham 72.08 45.53 14.52 -36.8 -79.9 -68.1ID Boise 2.54 16.93 5.21 565.9 104.9 -69.2UT Box Elder 53.11 86.41 36.92 62.7 -30.5 -57.3UT Davis 8.28 16.60 8.40 100.5 1.5 -49.4UT Salt Lake 18.34 37.22 24.98 102.9 36.2 -32.9UT Weber 23.23 39.72 24.07 71.0 3.6 -39.4UT Duchesne 32.46 62.92 43.71 93.8 34.7 -30.5UT Uintah 45.22 81.03 55.52 79.2 22.8 -31.5WY Carbon 93.55 138.91 78.71 48.5 -15.9 -43.3WY Teton 223.26 125.08 80.54 -44.0 -63.9 -35.6WY Laramie 6.22 72.21 13.68 1,061.7 120.1 -81.1WY Sublette 59.95 91.77 28.16 53.1 -53.0 -69.3WY Lincoln 88.31 110.64 32.43 25.3 -63.3 -70.7WY Sweetwater 74.06 71.05 38.95 -4.1 -47.4 -45.2WY Uinta 22.32 36.59 13.58 63.9 -39.1 -62.9

9,186 19,041 11,912 107.3 29.7 -37.4

State CountyIsoprene (tpd)

Domain Total

Note: Clark, NV is outside 4km domain.

Average Emission July 3-18, 2008

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average Monoterpene Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average Monoterpene Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

SMKBEIS M04 M10 % (M04-B) % (M10-B) % (M10-M04)AZ Pima 126.71 34.35 53.04 -72.9 -58.1 54.4AZ Maricopa 149.37 51.50 67.05 -65.5 -55.1 30.2CO Boulder 17.87 8.58 5.90 -52.0 -67.0 -31.3CO Denver 0.75 0.70 0.25 -5.5 -66.6 -64.6CO El Paso 17.30 8.44 7.03 -51.2 -59.3 -16.6CO Teller 7.56 4.83 4.00 -36.1 -47.1 -17.2NM Bernalillo 13.45 5.15 8.64 -61.7 -35.8 67.7ID Bear Lake 14.55 5.46 7.40 -62.4 -49.1 35.5ID Bingham 18.53 7.16 14.01 -61.4 -24.4 95.7ID Boise 19.63 6.97 8.07 -64.5 -58.9 15.8UT Box Elder 60.75 13.25 24.26 -78.2 -60.1 83.1UT Davis 2.98 2.44 2.13 -18.2 -28.5 -12.6UT Salt Lake 11.94 7.35 6.74 -38.4 -43.5 -8.3UT Weber 5.89 5.17 5.33 -12.3 -9.6 3.1UT Duchesne 47.17 16.14 23.62 -65.8 -49.9 46.3UT Uintah 65.70 19.11 40.58 -70.9 -38.2 112.4WY Carbon 93.75 32.04 47.30 -65.8 -49.5 47.6WY Teton 50.24 44.20 34.62 -12.0 -31.1 -21.7WY Laramie 8.62 7.12 4.65 -17.3 -46.0 -34.6WY Sublette 55.96 25.37 32.24 -54.7 -42.4 27.1WY Lincoln 52.23 23.72 30.33 -54.6 -41.9 27.9WY Sweetwater 98.60 10.11 61.89 -89.7 -37.2 512.0WY Uinta 17.28 6.45 11.27 -62.7 -34.8 74.8

9,584 4,382 5,602 -54.3 -41.5 27.8

CountyMonoterpene (tpd)

State

Domain TotalNote: Clark, NV is outside 4km domain.

MTP – County Summary

Domain: 4kmAverage Emission July 3-18, 2008

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average CO Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

Average CO Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average NOx Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average NOx Emission from July 3 to July 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

CO and NOx – County Summary

Domain: 4kmAverage Emission July 3 to July 18, 2008

SMKBEIS M04 M10 % (M04-B) % (M10-B) % (M10-M04)AZ Pima 145.57 45.50 56.31 -68.7 -61.3 23.8AZ Maricopa 174.92 61.04 78.16 -65.1 -55.3 28.1CO Boulder 8.61 7.77 3.62 -9.8 -57.9 -53.4CO Denver 1.35 1.36 0.29 1.1 -78.8 -79.1CO El Paso 18.73 13.64 3.38 -27.2 -82.0 -75.3CO Teller 4.78 3.76 1.49 -21.3 -68.9 -60.5NM Bernalillo 12.17 5.49 5.19 -54.9 -57.4 -5.5ID Bear Lake 11.76 7.78 5.15 -33.9 -56.2 -33.7ID Bingham 22.89 18.38 13.30 -19.7 -41.9 -27.6ID Boise 11.60 6.34 4.89 -45.4 -57.8 -22.9UT Box Elder 69.36 24.79 22.14 -64.3 -68.1 -10.7UT Davis 3.69 3.22 2.07 -12.7 -43.9 -35.8UT Salt Lake 10.66 8.94 5.43 -16.1 -49.0 -39.2UT Weber 6.58 7.70 4.47 17.0 -32.2 -42.0UT Duchesne 35.16 20.25 15.91 -42.4 -54.8 -21.4UT Uintah 59.05 23.89 26.43 -59.5 -55.2 10.6WY Carbon 73.36 41.33 31.46 -43.7 -57.1 -23.9WY Teton 33.82 31.88 18.38 -5.7 -45.6 -42.3WY Laramie 21.78 19.33 5.81 -11.2 -73.3 -69.9WY Sublette 41.79 25.78 21.02 -38.3 -49.7 -18.5WY Lincoln 39.58 25.80 20.53 -34.8 -48.1 -20.4WY Sweetwater 99.94 23.71 44.44 -76.3 -55.5 87.5WY Uinta 17.87 11.18 9.03 -37.5 -49.4 -19.2

10,834 6,752 4,462 -37.7 -58.8 -33.9

CO (tpd)State County

Domain Total

SMKBEIS M04 M10 % (M04-B) % (M10-B) % (M10-M04)AZ Pima 8.55 3.86 8.25 -54.8 -3.5 113.4AZ Maricopa 7.03 6.15 11.17 -12.5 58.7 81.5CO Boulder 0.89 0.60 0.40 -32.6 -55.1 -33.3CO Denver 0.36 0.15 0.09 -58.3 -75.5 -41.3CO El Paso 4.30 1.08 1.45 -74.8 -66.4 33.5CO Teller 0.23 0.18 0.17 -22.7 -27.7 -6.5NM Bernalillo 0.81 0.38 1.02 -52.4 25.8 164.1ID Bear Lake 0.93 0.55 0.66 -40.7 -29.7 18.4ID Bingham 5.20 2.16 1.34 -58.5 -74.1 -37.7ID Boise 0.21 0.31 0.40 47.9 94.7 31.6UT Box Elder 5.91 2.20 3.17 -62.9 -46.4 44.5UT Davis 0.58 0.30 0.17 -47.1 -69.7 -42.7UT Salt Lake 1.40 0.72 0.51 -48.9 -63.6 -28.8UT Weber 0.70 0.67 0.37 -3.7 -46.7 -44.6UT Duchesne 2.84 1.42 1.78 -49.8 -37.3 24.9UT Uintah 3.91 1.77 3.61 -54.7 -7.5 104.0WY Carbon 5.00 2.83 4.01 -43.3 -19.8 41.5WY Teton 1.04 1.40 1.25 34.8 20.6 -10.5WY Laramie 9.16 1.78 3.29 -80.6 -64.1 85.2WY Sublette 2.18 1.53 2.03 -29.8 -7.2 32.2WY Lincoln 2.44 1.57 1.96 -35.4 -19.7 24.3WY Sweetwater 4.26 1.98 6.52 -53.5 53.2 229.4WY Uinta 1.91 0.90 1.09 -53.2 -43.3 21.2

2,209 650 1,067 -70.5 -51.7 64.0

State CountyNOx (tpd)

Domain Total

Note: Clark, NV is outside 4km domain.

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

Average Isoprene Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Domain: 36km

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average Isoprene Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average Monoterpene Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average Monoterpene Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average CO Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

Average CO Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average NOx Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 36km

SMK-BEIS v3.14 MEGAN v2.04(old) MEGAN v2.10(new)

MEGAN(old) – SMKBEIS MEGAN(new) – MEGAN(old)

Average NOx Emission from January 3 to 18, 2008 Domain: 4km

MEGAN(new) – SMKBEIS

CO and NOx – County Summary

Domain: 4kmAverage Emission January 3 to 18, 2008

SMKBEIS M04 M10 % (M04-B) % (M10-B) % (M10-M04)AZ Pima 4.86 7.16 4.61 47.6 -5.1 -35.7AZ Maricopa 3.00 6.51 4.56 116.6 51.9 -29.9CO Boulder 0.02 0.09 0.03 417.9 52.7 -70.5CO Denver 0.00 0.01 0.00 687.5 -8.4 -88.4CO El Paso 0.06 0.28 0.05 346.4 -16.1 -81.2CO Teller 0.01 0.10 0.02 916.2 98.2 -80.5NM Bernalillo 0.09 0.21 0.07 138.4 -20.8 -66.8ID Bear Lake 0.01 0.01 0.00 -20.2 -72.3 -65.3ID Bingham 0.02 0.03 0.00 73.8 -99.2 -99.5ID Boise 0.01 0.01 0.00 -50.8 -92.8 -85.4UT Box Elder 0.12 0.17 0.01 43.1 -92.5 -94.8UT Davis 0.00 0.01 0.00 157.4 -94.1 -97.7UT Salt Lake 0.01 0.05 0.00 327.0 -56.7 -89.9UT Weber 0.01 0.01 0.00 125.4 -87.0 -94.2UT Duchesne 0.08 0.08 0.02 8.5 -70.4 -72.7UT Uintah 0.09 0.10 0.02 9.6 -82.3 -83.8WY Carbon 0.14 0.12 0.02 -18.5 -84.3 -80.7WY Teton 0.17 0.03 0.01 -80.0 -93.0 -64.9WY Laramie 0.03 0.13 0.01 377.1 -77.4 -95.3WY Sublette 0.05 0.03 0.01 -37.6 -87.4 -79.8WY Lincoln 0.05 0.04 0.00 -18.9 -91.2 -89.2WY Sweetwater 0.18 0.09 0.00 -48.3 -99.3 -98.6WY Uinta 0.03 0.03 0.00 -6.3 -88.0 -87.2

80 144 62 80.5 -22.9 -57.3

State CountyIsoprene (tpd)

Domain Total

SMKBEIS M04 M10 % (M04-B) % (M10-B) % (M10-M04)AZ Pima 10.90 4.74 6.74 -56.5 -38.1 42.4AZ Maricopa 12.26 5.39 7.61 -56.1 -37.9 41.2CO Boulder 2.12 0.49 0.38 -76.8 -82.1 -23.0CO Denver 0.05 0.02 0.01 -64.1 -86.6 -62.7CO El Paso 1.75 0.45 0.53 -74.0 -69.4 17.6CO Teller 0.90 0.30 0.22 -66.8 -76.0 -27.7NM Bernalillo 1.30 0.49 0.75 -62.3 -42.5 52.5ID Bear Lake 1.12 0.06 0.05 -94.2 -95.7 -25.3ID Bingham 1.00 0.11 0.01 -89.5 -99.3 -92.9ID Boise 2.07 0.17 0.09 -91.7 -95.8 -49.8UT Box Elder 2.33 0.50 0.22 -78.6 -90.4 -55.3UT Davis 0.19 0.05 0.00 -73.2 -98.3 -93.7UT Salt Lake 0.90 0.18 0.04 -79.5 -95.4 -77.6UT Weber 0.29 0.04 0.01 -86.3 -96.6 -75.5UT Duchesne 3.21 0.43 0.33 -86.5 -89.6 -23.1UT Uintah 2.92 0.53 0.35 -82.0 -88.0 -33.3WY Carbon 5.81 0.99 0.50 -83.0 -91.5 -49.7WY Teton 4.77 0.72 0.49 -84.8 -89.7 -32.5WY Laramie 0.57 0.19 0.07 -66.7 -87.9 -63.6WY Sublette 3.80 0.37 0.27 -90.1 -92.9 -27.5WY Lincoln 3.76 0.28 0.19 -92.6 -95.0 -32.5WY Sweetwater 3.19 0.25 0.10 -92.2 -96.8 -59.2WY Uinta 0.97 0.17 0.06 -82.8 -94.2 -66.1

910 273 280 -70.0 -69.2 2.6

CountyMonoterpene (tpd)

State

Domain Total

Note: Clark, NV is outside 4km domain.

ISOP and MTP - County Summary

Domain: 4kmAverage Emission January 3 to 18, 2008

SMKBEIS M04 M10 % (M04-B) % (M10-B) % (M10-M04)AZ Pima 12.31 5.85 1.81 -52.5 -85.3 -69.0AZ Maricopa 13.32 5.95 1.95 -55.3 -85.3 -67.2CO Boulder 0.83 0.32 0.02 -61.9 -97.8 -94.3CO Denver 0.07 0.03 0.00 -50.6 -98.4 -96.7CO El Paso 1.36 0.48 0.03 -64.8 -97.7 -93.4CO Teller 0.48 0.20 0.01 -57.7 -97.8 -94.8NM Bernalillo 1.03 0.43 0.07 -58.1 -93.5 -84.4ID Bear Lake 0.77 0.06 0.00 -92.6 -99.7 -96.0ID Bingham 0.91 0.25 0.00 -72.4 -99.9 -99.8ID Boise 1.21 0.08 0.00 -93.6 -99.7 -95.6UT Box Elder 2.48 0.78 0.02 -68.6 -99.4 -98.0UT Davis 0.19 0.06 0.00 -65.6 -99.9 -99.7UT Salt Lake 0.62 0.20 0.00 -68.1 -99.6 -98.6UT Weber 0.28 0.07 0.00 -76.6 -99.8 -99.3UT Duchesne 1.94 0.37 0.02 -80.9 -99.2 -95.8UT Uintah 2.19 0.41 0.02 -81.3 -99.2 -95.8WY Carbon 3.61 0.73 0.02 -79.8 -99.5 -97.4WY Teton 2.34 0.31 0.02 -86.7 -99.3 -95.0WY Laramie 1.23 0.43 0.01 -64.5 -99.4 -98.3WY Sublette 2.31 0.22 0.01 -90.6 -99.6 -95.9WY Lincoln 2.26 0.23 0.01 -89.6 -99.7 -96.9WY Sweetwater 3.23 0.49 0.01 -84.7 -99.8 -99.0WY Uinta 0.87 0.19 0.00 -78.2 -99.7 -98.8

803 289 39 -64.0 -95.1 -86.5

CO (tpd)State County

Domain Total

SMKBEIS M04 M10 % (M04-B) % (M10-B) % (M10-M04)AZ Pima 3.79 0.46 0.47 -87.8 -87.6 1.0AZ Maricopa 3.07 0.55 0.61 -81.9 -80.0 10.9CO Boulder 0.24 0.02 0.01 -92.0 -97.5 -68.5CO Denver 0.10 0.00 0.00 -96.5 -99.1 -73.8CO El Paso 1.09 0.03 0.02 -97.1 -98.0 -31.7CO Teller 0.03 0.01 0.00 -71.0 -95.3 -83.9NM Bernalillo 0.25 0.03 0.03 -89.3 -89.6 -2.8ID Bear Lake 0.08 0.00 0.00 -95.8 -99.6 -91.2ID Bingham 0.71 0.03 0.00 -95.8 -100.0 -99.4ID Boise 0.03 0.00 0.00 -85.9 -98.5 -89.3UT Box Elder 0.84 0.06 0.01 -92.5 -99.3 -91.2UT Davis 0.13 0.01 0.00 -94.4 -100.0 -99.2UT Salt Lake 0.27 0.02 0.00 -94.2 -99.8 -95.8UT Weber 0.13 0.01 0.00 -94.2 -99.9 -99.0UT Duchesne 0.20 0.02 0.00 -90.3 -99.3 -92.5UT Uintah 0.29 0.02 0.00 -92.3 -99.1 -88.4WY Carbon 0.45 0.04 0.00 -90.3 -99.4 -94.0WY Teton 0.06 0.01 0.00 -79.7 -97.6 -88.1WY Laramie 2.25 0.04 0.01 -98.2 -99.6 -74.9WY Sublette 0.07 0.01 0.00 -84.9 -99.6 -97.1WY Lincoln 0.17 0.01 0.00 -91.6 -99.6 -95.8WY Sweetwater 0.28 0.04 0.00 -86.7 -99.5 -96.2WY Uinta 0.21 0.01 0.00 -93.3 -99.9 -98.0

551 24 16 -95.6 -97.1 -32.8

State CountyNOx (tpd)

Domain Total

Note: Clark, NV is outside 4km domain.

MEGAN v2.10(new)

Isoprene Emission and PFT Relationship - Slide 1 Domain: 36km

Broadleaf Deciduous Broadleaf Evergreen

Needle Leaf Deciduous Needle Leaf Evergreen Shrub

EF = 10000 µg/m2-hr EF = 10000 µg/m2-hr

EF = 600 µg/m2-hr EF = 4000 µg/m2-hrEF = 1 µg/m2-hr

MEGAN v2.10(new)

Isoprene Emission and PFT Relationship - Slide 2 Domain: 36km

Grass - Cold Grass - Warm

Crops Corn LAI

EF = 1 µg/m2-hrEF = 50 µg/m2-hr

EF = 200 µg/m2-hrEF = 1600 µg/m2-hr

MEGAN v2.10(new)

Monoterpene Emission and PFT Relationship - Slide 1 Domain: 36km

Broadleaf Deciduous Broadleaf Evergreen

Needle Leaf Deciduous Needle Leaf Evergreen Shrub

EF = 30 - 400 µg/m2-hr EF = 30 - 400 µg/m2-hr

EF = 70 - 500 µg/m2-hr EF = 50 - 300 µg/m2-hrEF = 40 – 510 µg/m2-hr

MEGAN v2.10(new)

Monoterpene Emission and PFT Relationship - Slide 2 Domain: 36km

Grass - Cold Grass - Warm

Crops Corn LAI

EF = 0.3 - 5 µg/m2-hrEF = 0.3 - 5 µg/m2-hr

EF = 0.3 - 5 µg/m2-hrEF = 0.3 - 5 µg/m2-hr

MEGAN v2.04 - Base

Bark Beetle Infestation - Monoterpene Domain: Denver – SIP 12km

Current Denver SIP

• 2008, MEGANv2.04

Bark Beetle

• Affecting needle leaf tree => MTP

• Sensitivity tests are based on 2006 meteorological data

• July - Monthly Average

2006 Bark Beetle - Base 2010 Bark Beetle - Base