Superior Court of New Jersey Appellate Division
Transcript of Superior Court of New Jersey Appellate Division
Superior Court of New Jersey
Appellate Division
MSW CAPITAL, LLC, Plaintiff-Respondent, vs. AZEEM H. ZAIDI, Defendant-Appellant.
Civil Action
Docket No. A-006370-11T1
On appeal from: Judgment of the Law Division, Special Civil Part, Monmouth
County Docket No. MON-DC-004774-12
Sat below:
Hon. James J. McGann, J.S.C.
APPENDIX VOLUME I OF II
OF DEFENDANT-APPELLANT, AZEEM H. ZAIDI Philip D. Stern & Associates, LLC 697 Valley Street, Suite 2d Maplewood, NJ 07040 (973) 379-7500 Attorneys for Defendant, Azeem H. Zaidi Philip D. Stern, on the brief
APPELLANT’S APPENDIX VOLUME I OF II
TABLE OF CONTENTS
(Following the order set forth in R. 2:6-1(a))
VOLUME I
(A) In Civil matters, the pretrial order and pleadings: Complaint ................................................................................................ 1a Answer ..................................................................................................... 2a (B) In Criminal matters, the indictment, accusation or complaint ... Not Applicable (C) Judgment or Order Sought to Be Reviewed Order Granting Summary Judgment ........................................................ 4a (D) Trial Judge’s Opinions or Statement of Facts and Conclusions of Law ..... None (E) Statement of Proceedings in lieu of record pursuant to R. 2:5-3(f) .......... None (F) Notice of Appeal ........................................................................................... 6a Appellant’s Civil Case Information Statement .......................................... 9a Appellant’s Court Transcript Request ........................ Not Applicable, see 8a Order Being Appealed ............................................................................ 15a (G) Transcript Delivery Certification prescribed R. 2:5-3(e) .... Not Applicable, see 8a (H) Unpublished Opinions .............................................................................. None (I) Other parts of the record (see, R. 2:5-4(a)) essential to proper consideration of the issues, including a statement of all items submitted to the court on summary judgment pursuant to R. 2:6-1(a)(1): Statement of All Items Submitted to the Court on Summary Judgment ........... 16a
Retrieved from JEFIS
Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment ........................................................ 21a Notice of Motion .................................................................................... 22a Statement of Material Facts ................................................................... 24a Certification in Support of Summary Judgment .......................... 25a Computer Generated Report of Financial Information ................ 26a
Exhibit A: Copies of 18 monthly billing statements .................... 27a Exhibit B: Defendant’s Answer .................................................... 28a Requests for Admissions Exhibit C: Defendant’s responses to Plaintiff’s Interrogatories ... 29a and Requests for Admissions 29a Proof of Mailing ..................................................................................... 43a
Defendant’s Opposition to Summary Judgment ............................................... 44a Certification of Azeem H. Zaidi ............................................................. 45a Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment .................................................... 46a Notice of Motion .................................................................................... 47a Certification of Azeem H. Zaidi ............................................................. 49a Plaintiff’s Response to Defendant’s Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment and Opposition to Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment ...... 50a
Cover Letter ........................................................................................... 51a Certification of Steven A. Lang, Esq. ...................................................... 52a Exhibit A: Plaintiff’s counsel’s letter to Defendant ...................... 55a Exhibit B: Defendant’s Substitution of Attorney .......................... 57a
Exhibit C: Notice of Motion and Proof of Service of Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment .............................. 59a
Exhibit D: JPMorgan Chase & Co. SEC Form 8-K ........................ 60a Exhibit E: Unpublished opinion, Atlas Equity, Inc. v. Chase Ban USA, N.A., 403 Fed.Appx. 190 (9th Cir. 2010). .................................... 94a
VOLUME II
Certification of Daryl J. Kipnis .............................................................. 99a Exhibit A: Defendant’s Answer (page one ONLY) ..................... 101a Exhibit B: Plaintiff’s Interrogatories .......................................... 102a Exhibit C: Defendant’s answers to Interrogatories .................... 102a Exhibit D: Plaintiff’s Requests for Admissions ........................... 102a Exhibit E: Defendant’s responses to Requests for Admissions ..................................................................... 102a Exhibit F: Defendant’s redacted Credit Report .......................... 103a Exhibit G: Unpublished opinion, Atlas Equity, Inc. v. Chase Bank USA, N.A., 403 Fed.Appx. 190 (9th Cir. 2010). .......................... 106a Exhibit H: Unpublished opinion, MBNA America Bank, N.A. v. Bibb, 2009 WL 1750220 (App. Div. 2009). ............................... 107a Supplemental Certification of Lawrence A. Whipple, Jr. ..................... 111a Exhibit A: July 18, 2011 Bill of Sale and Assignment ............... 114a Exhibit B: June 29, 2011 Bill of Sale ......................................... 116a Exhibit C: Periodic Account statement, closing date 8/12/09 .. 118a Exhibit D: Periodic Account statement, closing date 9/12/09 .. 121a Exhibit E: Periodic Account statement, closing date 10/12/09 124a Exhibit F: Periodic Account statement, closing date 11/12/09 . 127a
Exhibit G: Periodic Account statement, closing date 12/12/09 130a Exhibit H: Periodic Account statement, closing date 1/12/10 .. 133a Exhibit I: Periodic Account statement, closing date 2/12/10 ... 136a Exhibit J: Periodic Account statement, closing date 3/12/10 ... 141a Exhibit K: Periodic Account statement, closing date 4/12/10 .. 144a Exhibit L: Periodic Account statement, closing date 5/12/10 ... 149a Exhibit M: Periodic Account statement, closing date 6/12/10 . 152a Exhibit N: Periodic Account statement, closing date 7/12/10 .. 155a Exhibit O: Periodic Account statement, closing date 8/12/10 .. 160a Exhibit P: Periodic Account statement, closing date 9/12/10 .. 165a Exhibit Q: Periodic Account statement, closing date 10/12/10 170a Exhibit R: Periodic Account statement, closing date 11/12/10 175a Exhibit S: Periodic Account statement, closing date 12/12/10 . 180a Exhibit T: Periodic Account statement, closing date 1/12/11 .. 184a Affidavit and Assignment ..................................................................... 189a Proof of Mailing ................................................................................... 190a Defendant’s Reply to Plaintiff’s Opposition to Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment ........................................................................................................ 191a Proof of Service .................................................................................... 192a Defendant’s Substitution of Attorney .............................................................. 193a
1a
2a
3a
4a
5a
6a
7a
8a
9a
10a
11a
12a
13a
14a
15a
Page 1 of 5
PHILIP D. STERN & ASSOCIATES, LLC ATTORNEYS AT LAW 697 Valley Street, Suite 2d Maplewood, NJ 07040 (973) 379-7500 Attorneys for Defendant, Azeem H. Zaidi
MSW CAPITAL, INC., Plaintiff vs. AZEEM H. ZAIDI, Defendant.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY APPELLATE DIVISION
Civil Action
Docket No. A-006370-11 (MON-DC-4774-12)
STATEMENT OF ALL ITEMS SUBMITTED
TO THE COURT ON SUMMARY JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO
COURT RULE 2:6-1(a)(1)
Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment. June 14, 2012. (Da21)
1) Notice of Motion (Da22)
2) Statement of Material Facts (Da24), with the following attachments:
a) Certification in Support of Summary Judgment (Da25) – Certification by
Lawrence A. Whipple, Jr., Managing Director of MSW Capital, LLC with the
following attachments:
i) Computer Generated Report of Financial Information (Da26)
b) Exhibit A (Da27): Copies of 18 monthly billing statements for the subject
account
c) Exhibit B (Da28): Defendant’s Answer
d) Exhibit C (Da29): Defendant’s responses to Plaintiff’s Interrogatories and Request
for Admissions
16a
Page 2 of 5
3) Brief in Support of Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment
(*REDACTED*)
4) Proof of Mailing (Da43)
5) Proposed Order (*REDACTED*)
Defendant’s Objection to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment. June 25, 2012. (Da44)
1) Certification of Azeem H. Zaidi (Da45)
2) Brief of Defendant, Azeem H. Zaidi, in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary
Judgment (*REDACTED*)
Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment. June 29, 2012. (Da46)
1) Notice of Motion (Da47)
2) Certification of Azeem H. Zaidi (Da49)
3) Brief of Defendant, Azeem H. Zaidi, in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary
Judgment (*REDACTED*)
17a
Page 3 of 5
Plaintiff’s Response to Defendant’s Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment and Opposition to Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment. July 10, 2012. (Da50)
1) Cover Letter (Da51)
2) Plaintiff’s Brief in Response to Defendant’s Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for
Summary Judgment and Opposition to Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment
(*REDACTED*)
3) Certification of Steven A. Lang, Esq. (Da52) – with the following attachments:
a) Exhibit A (Da55): Plaintiff’s counsel’s January 27, 2012 letter to Defendant
b) Exhibit B (Da57): Defendant’s Substitution of Attorney
c) Exhibit C (Da59): Notice of Motion and Proof of Service of Defendant’s Motion
for Summary Judgment
d) Exhibit D (Da60): JP Morgan Chase & Co. SEC Form 8-K, Filed September 28,
2008
e) Exhibit E (Da94): Unpublished opinion, Atlas Equity, Inc. v. Chase Bank USA,
N.A., 403 Fed.Appx. 190 (9th Cir. 2010)
4) Certification of Daryl J. Kipnis (Da99) – with the following attachments:
a) Exhibit A (Da101): Defendant’s Answer (page one ONLY)
b) Exhibit B (Da102): Plaintiff’s Interrogatories
c) Exhibit C (Da102): Defendant’s answers to Plaintiff’s Interrogatories
d) Exhibit D (Da102): Plaintiff’s Requests for Admissions
e) Exhibit E (Da102): Defendant’s responses to Plaintiff’s Requests for Admissions
f) Exhibit F (Da103): Defendant’s redacted January 25, 2012 Credit Report
18a
Page 4 of 5
g) Exhibit G (Da106): Unpublished opinion, Atlas Equity, Inc. v. Chase Bank USA,
N.A., 403 Fed.Appx. 190 (9th Cir. 2010)
h) Exhibit H (Da107): Unpublished Opinion, MBNA America Bank, N.A. v. Bibb,
2009 WL 1750220 (App. Div. 2009)
5) Supplemental Certification of Lawrence A. Whipple, Jr. (Da111) – with the
following attachments:
a) Exhibit A (Da114): July 18, 2011 Bill of Sale and Assignment
b) Exhibit B (Da116): June 29, 2011 Bill of Sale
c) Exhibit C (Da118): Periodic Account statement, closing date 8/12/09
d) Exhibit D (Da121): Periodic Account statement, closing date 9/12/09
e) Exhibit E (Da124): Periodic Account statement, closing date 10/12/09
f) Exhibit F (Da127): Periodic Account statement, closing date 11/12/09
g) Exhibit G (Da130): Periodic Account statement, closing date 12/12/09
h) Exhibit H (Da133): Periodic Account statement, closing date 1/12/10
i) Exhibit I (Da136): Periodic Account statement, closing date 2/12/10
j) Exhibit J (Da141): Periodic Account statement, closing date 3/12/10
k) Exhibit K (Da144): Periodic Account statement, closing date 4/12/10
l) Exhibit L (Da149): Periodic Account statement, closing date 5/12/10
m) Exhibit M (Da152): Periodic Account statement, closing date 6/12/10
n) Exhibit N (Da155): Periodic Account statement, closing date 7/12/10
o) Exhibit O (Da160): Periodic Account statement, closing date 8/12/10
p) Exhibit P (Da165): Periodic Account statement, closing date 9/12/10
q) Exhibit Q (Da170): Periodic Account statement, closing date 10/12/10
19a
Page 5 of 5
r) Exhibit R (Da175): Periodic Account statement, closing date 11/12/10
s) Exhibit S (Da180): Periodic Account statement, closing date 12/12/10
t) Exhibit T (Da184): Periodic Account statement, closing date 1/12/11
6) Affidavit and Assignment (Da189): Affidavit of Paul Libretta, Vice President of Main
Street Acquisition Corp.
7) Proof of Mailing (Da190)
Defendant’s Reply to Plaintiff’s Opposition to Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment. July 12, 2012. (Da191)
1) Reply Brief of Defendant (*REDACTED*)
2) Proof of Service (Da192)
20a
21a
22a
23a
24a
25a
26a
SUBSTITUTION PAGE
Page One ONLY of the periodic account statements with the following closing dates for Chase account ************8736, which were attached here as Exhibit A to the Statement of Material Facts submitted with Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, appear at the pages listed below:
1/12/11 .......................................................................................................... 185a 12/12/10 ........................................................................................................ 181a 11/12/10 ........................................................................................................ 176a 10/12/10 ........................................................................................................ 170a 9/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 166a 8/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 161a 7/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 156a 6/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 153a 5/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 150a 4/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 145a 3/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 142a 2/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 137a 1/12/10 .......................................................................................................... 134a 12/12/09 ........................................................................................................ 131a 11/12/09 ........................................................................................................ 128a 10/12/09 ........................................................................................................ 125a 9/12/09 .......................................................................................................... 122a 8/12/09 .......................................................................................................... 119a
27a
SUBSTITUTION PAGE
The Defendant’s Answer, which was attached here as Exhibit B to the Statement of Material Facts submitted with Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment, appears at Da2.
28a
29a
30a
31a
32a
33a
34a
35a
36a
37a
38a
39a
40a
41a
42a
43a
44a
45a
46a
47a
48a
49a
50a
51a
52a
53a
54a
55a
56a
57a
58a
SUBSTITUTION PAGE
The Notice of Motion and Proof of Service for Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment, which was attached here as Exhibit C to the Certification of Steven A. Lang, Esq. submitted with Plaintiff’s Reply to Defendant’s Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment and Opposition to Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment, appears at Da47.
59a
60a
61a
62a
63a
64a
65a
66a
67a
68a
69a
70a
71a
72a
73a
74a
75a
76a
77a
78a
79a
80a
81a
82a
83a
84a
85a
86a
87a
88a
89a
90a
91a
92a
93a
94a
95a
96a
97a
98a