Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62...
Transcript of Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62...
![Page 1: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
June 14 2000 MEMORANDUM TO: Stuart A. Richards, Director
Project Directorate IV & Decommissioning Division of Licensing Project Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
FROM: Stewart N. Bailey, Project Manager, Section 2 Project Directorate III Division of Licensing Project Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
/RA/
SUMMARY OF THE JUNE 1, 2000, MEETING WITH FRAMATOME ON INCREASING THE BURNUP LIMIT ON MARK-BW FUEL ASSEMBLIES
On June 1, 2000, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff met with Framatome Cogema Fuels, Inc. (FCF), to discuss a future submittal to increase the burnup limit on Mark-BW fuel assemblies to 62 GWD/MTU. FCF's Mark-B fuel is currently licensed to 62 GWD/MTU, but the Mark-BW fuel, which seems slightly higher in temperatures, is limited to 60 GWD/MTU. The submittal would include a revision of Topical Report BAW-1 0186, "Extended Burnup Evaluation," and a clarification of Topical Report BAW-1 0227, "Evaluation of Advanced Cladding and Structural Material (M5) in PWR Fuel."
FCF and the staff discussed (1) the fuel performance data that FCF has taken since the last revision of BAW-1 0186, which set the current burnup limits, (2) the comparison between the performance of Zircalloy 4 cladding and M5 cladding, and (3) other design considerations of increasing the burnup limit. The staff asked FCF, in its submittal, to clarify the effects of using M5 cladding and/or M5 structural material. The staff also noted that the majority of the data for the Mark-BW fuel was limited to approximately 53 GWD/MTU, so that increasing the Mark-BW burnup limit to 62 GWD/MTU would rely on an extrapolation of the available data and on the similarity of the Mark-BW fuel to the Mark B fuel, which has data at higher burnup levels.
A list of those attending the meeting is provided as Attachment 1. The non-proprietary slides used by FCF during the meeting are provided as Attachment 2.
Project No. 693
Attachments: 1. List of Meeting Attendees 2. FCF's Non-Proprietary Slides
cc w/atts: See next page DISTRIBUTION: E-Mail J. Zwolinski (RidsNrrDlpm) S. Black (RidsNrrDIpm) S. Richards (RidsNrrDlpmLpdiv) A. Mendiola (RidsNrrDIpmLpdiii-2) S. Dembek (SXD) RidsNrrLAEPeyton RidsNrrPMSBailey RidsOgcMailCenter RidsAcrsAcnwMailCenter R. Caruso M. Chatterton S. Wu K. Landis Accession No. ML00371
OFFICE PDIV-2/PM PDIV-2/LA PDIV-2/SC
NAME SBailey:lc E' y SDembe
DATE 4//_ _ 4 00 i// -/O 1
DOCUMENT NAME: G:\PDIV-2\B&Wog\MTS000601.WPD OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
Hard Copy PUBLIC PD IV-2 r/f
![Page 2: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
B&W Owners Group
cc:
Mr. Guy G. Campbell, Chairman B&WOG Executive Committee Vice President - Nuclear FirstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station 5501 North State Rt. 2 Oak Harbor, OH 43449
Ms. Sherry L. Bernhoft, Chairman B&WOG Steering Committee Florida Power Corporation Crystal River Energy Complex 15760 West Power Line St. Crystal River, FL 34428-6708
Mr. J. J. Kelly, Manager B&W Owners Group Services Framatome Technologies, Inc. P.O. Box 10935 Lynchburg, VA 24506-0935
Mr. F. McPhatter, Manager Framatome Cogema Fuels 3315 Old Forest Road P.O. Box 10935 Lynchburg, VA 24506-0935
Mr. R. Schomaker, Manager Framatome Cogema Fuels 3315 Old Forest Road P.O. Box 10935 Lynchburg, VA 24506-0935
Mr. Michael Schoppman Licensing Manager Framatome Technologies, Inc. 1700 Rockville Pike, Suite 525 Rockville, MD 20852-1631
Project No. 693
![Page 3: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
FRAMATOME COGEMA FUELS, INC. MEETING ON INCREASING MARK-BW FUEL BURNUP LIMIT
JUNE 1. 2000
AFFILIATIONNAME
Stewart Bailey Ralph Caruso Muffet Chatterton Shih-Liang Wu Garry Garner Frank McPhatter Rick Williamson John Willse Millan Straka Ian Rickard
NRC/NRR/DLPM NRC/NRR/DSSA/SRXB NRC/NRR/DSSAISRXB NRC/NRR/DSSA/SRXB FCF FCF FCF FCF NUSIS Westinghouse
Attachment 1
![Page 4: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
NRC/FCF Meeting on Mark-BW Burnup Limit
Rockville, Maryland
C. F. McPhatter
June 1, 2000
cfm6_OOnrc.ppt
![Page 5: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Agenda
"Introduction and Background for Increasing Mark BW Burnup Limit
" Presentation of Data
"Discussion
"UConclusion
cfm6_OOnrc.ppt
![Page 6: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
I Objectives
EAgree that the proposed burnup limit for the Mark-BW fuel is justified
U Develop plan for providing documentation and obtaining NRC approval
cfm6.OOnrc.ppt
![Page 7: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
I Reference Documents
*BAW-10153P, Extended Burnup Evaluation, April 1986
* BAW-10172P, Mark-BW Mechanical Design Report, SER, December 1989
*BAW-10186P-A, Rev. 1 Extended Burnup Evaluation, April 2000
* BAW-1 0227P-A, Evaluation of Advanced Cladding and Structural Material (M5TM) in PWR Reactor Fuel, February 2000
cfm6_OOnrc.ppt
![Page 8: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
I Background
lThe SER for BAW-10153P-A allows burnups up to 45 GWd/mtU batch average for Mark-B fuel
nThe SER for BAW-1 01 72P allows burnups up to 60 GWd/mtU rod average for Mark-BW fuel
"EThe SER for BAW-10186P allows burnups of 60 GWd/mtU and 62 GWd/mtU rod average for MarkBW and for Mark-B fuel respectively
1The SER for BAW-1 0227P allows burnups of 60 GWd/mtU and 62 GWd/mtU rod average for MarkBW and for Mark-B fuel respectively
cfm6_OOnrc.ppt
![Page 9: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Demonstration Of The Ability For The Mk-BW Fuel Assembly To
_ Achieve 62 GWd/mtU Pin Burnup
* Show sufficient data has been obtained to demonstrate accuracy of models to 62 GWd/mtU
* Show that the data is well behaved so that the models are reliable design tools to 62 GWd/mtU
TF o C RA'ATO CM E T E C H M 03 L 0> C- I IE
![Page 10: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW
"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison
"* Mk-B and Mk-BW are very similar designs that perform in a consistent manner
"* Key data that justifies the new limit "* Fuel rod oxide "* Irradiation experience
"* Fuel assembly growth
"* Shoulder Gap "* Guide tube oxide "* Fuel Rod Reliability
OFRAMAL ,TCM E T E C H N C0 L C> 4S
---
![Page 11: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Fuel Rod Oxide No Longer Limits Burnup With M5 Cladding
Maximum Oxide Thickness vs Burnup
-- 0 ----- o.- --
0 0
0 00
1? .0.. . 0• 8 0 0 Zr-4 0 So 0 49 80 l 0 0
0•0 • 0 0 0000 0 0
0 0 6 00
0 10
4k
o North Anna M5M5
10000 20000 30000 40000 50000
Burnup, MWd/mtU
E
U) a)
Ia) Cu .'2_ x 0 X
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
00 60000 70000
T E C H MN o kLTG, M I ES
![Page 12: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
M5 Has Low Sensitivity To Duty
U.0
Zy4 - 5 cycles 56 GWd/tU
U mu
Eu
U.,.
U E
Eu U
IU
E it
M5 - 6cvcle
0I - ____
0 500 1000 1500
63 GWd/tU*1..
2000 2500 3000 35004000
100
90 1
80-
70-
�V2
4)
60
50
40
20
10
ai1S
IFRA.MATO C E "T E C 1 M C L - : G E
Im
0_
Altitude (mam)
![Page 13: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Additional Data Obtained Since Topical Representative Of High
BurnuD CvclesMk-BW Data
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200
In-Core Exposure, EFPE
1400 1600 1800 2000 2200
J'F RA. M AT C ME T E C HI N O kL G I E S
1T7~
60
50
40
IA
30
20
10
0
![Page 14: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Additional Data Obtained Since Topical Representative Of High
Burnup CyclesMk-B And Mk-BW Data
60
501 - _ _ _ _ _ _ _
40
30
20
'OF0_
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
In-Core Exposure, EFPD
1600 1800 2000 2200
F RA^mA~cr ME
E "0
4 I,1
Ilk qv' Mk-B And Mk-BW Data
![Page 15: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Fuel Assembly Growth Data Matches Model
Mk-BW Fuel Assembly Growth Zircaloy 4
0.06
0.05 -... ..
0.03
0.02 1
0.01 ..
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
Fuel Assembly Burnup, GWdlmtU
0.7 0.8 0.9 1
T AE M AH T C> MI E T E CH N C LC0 G E S
-j
-J
4) ci
0
I (D
0.04 . ...
![Page 16: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
I7 Mk-BW And Mk-B Fuel Assembly Growth Data are Consistent
Mk-BW And Mk-B Fuel Assembly Growth Zircaloy 4
0.06 -- ------- • ----------- ___ _. . ._
0.05
S0.04 '"
0.03
,D 0.02 ..
0.01
0 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
Fuel Assembly Burnup, GWdImtU
FR AýMATO M E T E C H M O L C P I E S
![Page 17: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Shoulder Gap Data Well Behaved With Excess Margin Available
Mk-BW Minimum Shoulder Gap Zircaloy 4
2.5000 ...--
2.0001
1.500
1.000 .......
0.500 - . . . .
0.000
0.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
Fuel Assembly Bumup, GWdlmtU
1�1
(U S E
oE
E°E
50.0 60.0
OF RA.MAATC)M E T E C H -4 31C) L. C> C) I E S
-- ---------
10.0
![Page 18: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Shoulder Gap Data Well Behaved With Excess Margin Available
Mk-BW And Mk-B Minimum Shoulder Gap Zircaloy 4 ............ .
2.000 . - -..- --
10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0
Fuel Assembly Burnup, GWd/mtU
2.500
0)
E E r.,
1.500
1.000
0.500
0.000 k
0.060.0
IF RAMATCM E TEC HN 0 L 0 0 I E S
L
![Page 19: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Guide Tube Oxide Thickness Data Demonstrates Significant Margin
Guide Tube Oxide Thickness Zircaloy 4
35
30
25
20--
15 . .
10
5
0
20 30 40
Fuel Assembly Burnup, GWdlmtU
50 60
F PRAAAT C M E T E C H M C> L 0 G I E S
0
n 10
------------- -- - -- --------
I ý
![Page 20: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Coolant Activity
0
0
0 0
0a
(4ciIgm)
0
ANO
CR3
DB I
Oc I
Oc 2
Oc 3
TMI
Cat 1
Cat 2
Mc 1
Mc 2
Seq I
Seq 2
j
0
+ 0 0
K
0
-U 0 0 fu
0
0I
I>
00 110
I
![Page 21: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Failure Rate For Mark-BW Fuel By Year Of Manufacture
1 No Look
U Creep
EL Unknown
U Fretting
N Debris
AN-
Year Of Manufacture
F RAEHMATO cIA E T E C H H• 0, L 0 G I E S
InJI
w
'I
LO 8
6
4
2
0
---1
![Page 22: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Conclusion
"* Mk-BW fuel assembly has performed well through 53 GWd/mtU
"* Sufficient data exists to verify design models are accurate to a fuel rod burnup of greater than 62 GWd/mtU
"* Models provide the tools to design a fuel assembly capable of irradiation to 62 GWd/mtU, rod average
I'F RAAhATC>M E T E C H N CD L 01 r-
![Page 23: Summary of June 1, 2000 meeting with Framatome Cogema ... · Justification For Burnup Limit Of 62 GWd/mtU For Mk-BW"* Data will be presented for both the MK-BW and the Mk-B for comparison](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042414/5f2ee5db3bad47288e1b1559/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
F Conclusion
" On, the basis of the information presented today the proposed burnup limit for Mark-BW fuel is justified
"1 Define process for obtaining NRC review and approval of the proposed limit
cfm6_OOnrc.ppt