Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA...

24
1 Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis Ales Stempihar, IIBA Chapter Slovenia president bachelor of computer science, economy, certified CompTIA Project + member of IIBA, PMI, IPMA IAF Wien, 8.5.2014 Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar Stakeholder analysis is not just about collecting the requirements through asking the right questions. Personally, I believe that first and foremost it is an emphatic approach to people to gain their trust (in vision, goals and other people) so they support the project. 2 Starting point

Transcript of Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA...

Page 1: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

1

Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis

Ales Stempihar, IIBA Chapter Slovenia presidentbachelor of computer science, economy, certified CompTIA Project +

member of IIBA, PMI, IPMA IAF

Wien, 8.5.2014

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Stakeholder analysis

is not just about collecting the requirements through asking the right questions.

Personally, I believe that first and foremost it is

an emphatic approach to people to gain their trust

(in vision, goals and other people) so they support the project.

2

Starting point

Page 2: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

2

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

IntroIntroIntroIntro eeeexercisexercisexercisexerciseIntroIntroIntroIntro eeeexercisexercisexercisexercise Introduce yourself to others through

your views on empathy and trust

First, split into two groups

1. 1. 1. 1. 1.…

2. 2. 2. 2. …

Then write/draw down (2 min)

What do you believe empathy is?

What do you believe trust is?

Introduction: 1. name, company, country, role to 2. and vice versa ;

1. talk to 2. about empathy (2 min); 2. repeats what 1. told;

2. talk to 1. about trust (2 min); 1. repeats what 2. told

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Presentation of Aleš ŠtempiharMy introduction - Who is Aleš Štempihar� Education: IT, economy, project management, change management

� 20+ years in business / 6 years with IIBA / 15+ years with projects� 15+ BA and 50+ other projects / 100+ trainings / 60+ articles� Some knowledge and approaches: IIBA - BABOK, BSC (Kaplan,

Norton), PMI-PMBOK, Agile (Scrum), BPM, IAF, Adizes, Kotter, IMA

� Organizer of "Advanced business approaches" BA conference (4x) and "Project management in practice" conference (5x)

� Co-author of the BA book “Future-proof business approaches: Make

your organization sustainably competitive” (2010)

� My business card introduce me as a “Business integrator”� First of all the founder and still the only)

IIBA Slovenia Chapter President from 2009 (the 7th chapter in Europe)

Page 3: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

3

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Empathy

5

Trust =competency * reliability * transparency-----------------------------------------------------

own interests

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 6

The four types of trust

Page 4: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

4

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Help me help you

7

He needs empathy He needs trustBA Stakeholder

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

What else does a BA need ?

8

Page 5: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

5

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

STAKEHOLEDER ANALYSIS

how to engage stakeholders with THE CHANGE

9

the beginning of the project

the end result of the project

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 10

Page 6: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

6

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 11

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 12

Page 7: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

7

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 13

� Why do we need Stakeholder analysis

� Who are the stakeholders

� IIBA and stakeholders

� How to identify the stakeholders (with exercise)

� What is the stakeholders matrix (with exercise)

� Which questions must the BA consider

� regarding stakeholder interests (with exercise)

� How to define the project vision (with exercise)

� Q&A

Agenda

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 14

– It reinforces customer orientation – the customer perspective in the project.

– Discovering the supporters/opponents/passives -> active partnership

– Important for ensuring a realistic project scope and deadlines -> preventing scope creep and standstills during the project execution -> project balance

– Risk recognition

– Awareness and testing of assumptions

Why do we need Stakeholder analysis (1/3)

Page 8: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

8

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 15

– Defining the business success before the project and establishing it after the project.

– Stakeholder synergy promotes project and business success

– Strategy realization – connects the stakeholders with the strategy

Why do we need Stakeholder analysis (2/3)

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Why do we need Stakeholder analysis (3/3)

1. We miss something.

2. We only see a part of the situation.

3. We leave something out.

4. We do not consider consequences or views of others in our thinking.

5. We do not list alternatives.

Five common errors in thinking orproject preparation:

Page 9: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

9

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Who or what is Stakeholder ?

17

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 18

Who are the stakeholders

Stakeholders are people or/and groups of people within the organization and outside of it whose interests are connected to the business influences to the project / solution.

Page 10: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

10

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Savings Opportunities

Two types of stakeholders according to their perceptions of the project

1995:“A project is a problemscheduled for solution”,J.M. Juran

2005:“A project is a collection of value, scheduled for realization”, D.J. Anderson

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 20

BABOK and stakeholders

Page 11: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

11

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 21

BABOK v3 from business Need to business Value for each Stakeholder

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

IIBA, PMI and stakeholders

Page 12: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

12

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Analytic pre-phase of the project

23

Business NeedStrategic plan for the projectStakeholder AnalysisBusiness Case

Project organization and project rolesProject plan (project charter)Report on project progressProject changesFinal report

Requirementdocument

Pre-project

Project

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 24

Define the project team

Page 13: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

13

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 25

� Why do we need Stakeholder analysis

� Who are the stakeholders

� IIBA and stakeholders

� How to identify the stakeholders (with exercises)

� What is the stakeholder matrix (with exercises)

� Which questions must the BA consider regarding stakeholder interests (with exercises)

� How to define the project vision (with exercises)

� Q&A

Agenda

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 26

Identification and analysis of stakeholders�The business analyst and sponsor define the stakeholders

�The BA team completes the list in a moderated workshop: the name of the project is written in the middle, the stakeholders are listed and they are included in a Stakeholder map.

Page 14: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

14

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 27

There are many different ways to visualize the stakeholders

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 28

There are many different ways to visualize the stakeholders

Page 15: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

15

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 29

There are many different ways to visualize the stakeholders

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 30

Page 16: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

16

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

ExerciseExerciseExerciseExerciseExerciseExerciseExerciseExercise Chose the projectIdentify the stakeholdersVisualize them

Help yourself with BABOK v2 Onion diagram approach: first external, then internal.

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 32

What is the stakeholder matrix

Stakeholder maps are visual diagrams that depict the relationship of stakeholders to the solution and to one another. There are many different forms of stakeholder maps.

•BABOK v2: matrix mapping the level of stakeholder influence against the level of stakeholder

•There are other forms as well

Page 17: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

17

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 33

There are many different versions of stakeholder matrices out there

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 34

There are many different versions of stakeholder matrices out there

Page 18: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

18

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 35

There are many different versions of stakeholder matrices out there

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 36

There are many different versions of stakeholder matrices out there

Page 19: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

19

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 37

There are many different versions of stakeholder matrices out there

http://svprojectmanagement.com/

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 38

Case: diabetes

Page 20: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

20

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 39

Case: co-working

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Place the stakeholders

into a matrix

Page 21: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

21

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 41

Which questions must the BA consider regarding stakeholder interests

What does everyone have to gain / why do we need this project - what’s in it for him ?

What can they expect from the project? What interests can they have?

How will this influence them - what does this mean to

he/she/them?

What can they loose? How does this (change) affect me?

What are the common

interests for all stakeholders ?

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Consider the interests of 3

most important stakeholders

Page 22: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

22

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Exercise Define common interests –

this is the foundation of

project vision

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

The lessons learned in this workshop

44

Page 23: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

23

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

The goal is

45

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar

Don’t forget to visualize and to use some humor

46

Page 24: Stakeholder analysis for avoiding paralysis - BA Campba-camp.org/.../05/Stakeholder-analysis-for-avoiding-paralysis-Ales... · Title (Microsoft PowerPoint - Stakeholder analysis for

24

Stakeholder analysis for not to be paralyzed

Copyright, Askit d.o.o. 2014, all slides are copyright material by Aleš Štempihar 47

Thank you - Q&A

[email protected]

Mail me if you want photos