8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

1/19

Lo|`dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg

Xsf|fmw

\loww Gogfb|om

MK\K/Jfs`dbkc K|wsoxet|dl| Lfmwfs

X-O- Cou 688

Ckwkzdk" DB :86;8

; Dmwsogvlwdom

Kmd|owsoxdf| dm wef Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg %L@C$ lksst km fmos`ov|

k`ovmw oj dmjos`kwdom kcovw wef fksbt vmdzfs|f Wef kmd|owsoxt |xflwsv` gf-

xfmg| |fm|dwdzfbt om lbo|f wo k goyfm lo|`oboadlkb xksk`fwfs|" |o`f oj qedle

ekzf mfzfs cffm `fk|vsfg cfjosf Fuxfsd`fmw| ozfs wef mfuw gflkgf qdbb efbx v|

fuwsklw wef|f xksk`fwfs|" wfkledma v| mow ombt kcovw wef fksbt vmdzfs|f" cvw kb|o

kcovw xet|dl| kw vmxsflfgfmwfg fmfsadf| Qf ksf wsvbt bdzdma dm wef Aobgfm Kaf

oj Lo|`oboat

Omf oj wef gkmafs| oj wef kaf d| wekw qf ksf wf`xwfg wo damosf wef xsf|fmw

gkwk kmg sfbt woo `vle om wef jvwvsf Wed| qovbg cf k |ek`f" jos evmgsfg| oj

dmgdzdgvkb| ekzf xvw dm lovmwbf|| ev`km-tfks| cvdbgdma |wkwf-oj-wef-ksw dm|wsv-

`fmw|" `kndma xkdm|wkndma oc|fszkwdom| kw sf`owf xbklf| om kmg o wef abocf

Dw |ff`| vmjkds wo damosf kbb wef gkwk wekw ek| cffm wknfm wo gkwf |d`xbt cflkv|f

wefsf qdbb cf `osf kmg cfwwfs gkwk dm wef jvwvsf

Dm wed| |xdsdw" D qovbg bdnf wo `knf wef jobboqdma lbkd`|9

; Qf vmgfs|wkmg wef wefost oj L@C kmd|owsoxdf|

3 V|dma wed| vmgfs|wkmgdma" qf qdbb cf kcbf wo fuwsklw jso` jvwvsf oc|fszk-

wdom| fuwsf`fbt kllvskwf `fk|vsf`fmw| oj kcovw wfm lo|`oboadlkb xksk`-fwfs|

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

2/19

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

3/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

|oom k| dw| qkzfbfmawe cflo`f| lo`xkskcbf wo wef eosdyom Mow |vsxsd|dmabt"

fkle qkzfbfmawe o|ldbbkwf| qdwe k gdfsfmw xfsdog kmg xek|f Wef qkzfbfmawe

qedle qdbb fuedcdw wef bksaf|w kmd|owsoxdf| d| wef omf qeo|f k`xbdwvgf d| bksaf|w

kw wef wd`f oj sflo`cdmkwdomJdavsf ; dbbv|wskwf| jovs |mkx|eow| dm wef fzobvwdom oj k xkswdlvbksbt d`xoswkmw

`ogf" omf qeo|f k`xbdwvgf xfkn| kw sflo`cdmkwdom Fksbt om %wox xkmfb$ kw

sfg|edjw| bksafs wekm ;86" wef qkzfbfmawe oj wed| `ogf qk| bksafs wekm wef eosdyom

|dyf Wefsfjosf" bdwwbf fzobvwdom woon xbklf9 wef xfswvsckwdom| boon fuklwbt k| weft

gdg qefm weft qfsf s|w |fw goqm gvsdma dmffikwdom Kw y ;87" fzobvwdom cfadm|"

kmg wef k`xbdwvgf| oj cowe wef eow kmg lobg |xow| gflsfk|f" |o wekw" k| |eoqm

dm wef |flomg xkmfb" wefsf d| k wd`f kw qedle wef xfswvsckwdom| zkmd|e %jos wed|

`ogf$ K cdw bkwfs %wedsg xkmfb$ weft |eoq vx kakdm> wed| wd`f" wef xsfzdov| eow

|xow| ksf moq lobg |xow| kmg zdlf zfs|k %lo`xksf wef s|w kmg wedsg xkmfb|$ Wef

k`xbdwvgf lomwdmvf| wo asoq vmwdb dw xfkn| kw sflo`cdmkwdom %cowwo` xkmfb$Jdavsf ; |eoq| cvw omf `ogf dm wef vmdzfs|f K `ogf qdwe k |bdaewbt |`kbbfs

qkzfbfmawe qdbb xfkn woo |oom9 dw| k`xbdwvgf qdbb sfkle k `kud`v` cfjosf sf-

lo`cdmkwdom kmg qdbb cf `vle |`kbbfs kw wef lsvldkb sflo`cdmkwdom wd`f Wefsf-

josf" sfbkwdzf wo wef `kud`kb `ogf |eoqm dm Jda ;" kmd|owsoxdf| om |`kbbfs |lkbf|

qdbb cf |vxxsf||fg @ozdma wo fzfm |`kbbfs |lkbf|" qf qdbb mg k |fsdf| oj xfkn|

kmg wsovae| lossf|xomgdma wo `ogf| qeo|f k`xbdwvgf| ksf fdwefs bksaf os |`kbb

kw sflo`cdmkwdom

Km d`xoswkmw {vf|wdom wo cf sf|obzfg d| kw qekw kmavbks |lkbf qdbb wef|f dm-

eo`oafmfdwdf| |eoq vx? Lom|dgfs Jda 3 qedle kakdm gfxdlw| wef wf`xfskwvsf

fbg kw gflovxbdma jso` wef `ogf lossf|xomgdma wo wef s|w xfkn Kbb xeowom|

k adzfm gd|wkmlf jso` v| qdbb sfkle v| wogkt Wed| gd|wkmlf gfmf| k |vsjklf ojbk|w |lkwwfsdma %qedle d| iv|w k ldslbf dm wef wqo gd`fm|dom| gfxdlwfg efsf" cvw

k |xefsf dm wef sfkb vmdzfs|f$ Wed| d``fgdkwfbt |fw| wef kmavbks |lkbf lossf-

|xomgdma wo wef qkzfbfmawe |eoqm" %qkzfbfmawe/gd|wkmlf wo bk|w |lkwwfsdma

|vsjklf$ Dj wef vmdzfs|f d| ffikw" wefm xeowom| wskzfb dm |wskdaew bdmf| k| gfxdlwfg

ct wef cowwo` xkwe| dm Jda 3 Dm km oxfm vmdzfs|f" xeowom wskiflwosdf| gdzfsaf k|

dbbv|wskwfg ct wef wox xkwe| Wefsfjosf" wef gd|wkmlf wo wef bk|w |lkwwfsdma |vsjklf

d| `vle bksafs wekm dm k ffikw vmdzfs|f Wef kmavbks |lkbf lossf|xomgdma wo wed|

s|w xfkn d| wefsfjosf |`kbbfs dm km oxfm vmdzfs|f wekm dm k ffikw omf

Wef |xflwsv` oj kmd|owsoxdf| qdbb wefsfjosf ekzf k |fsdf| oj xfkn| kmg wsovae|"

qdwe wef s|w xfkn |eoqdma vx kw bksafs kmavbks |lkbf| dm k ffikw vmdzfs|f wekm dm kmoxfm vmdzfs|f Jdavsf < |eoq| wef kmd|owsoxt |xflwsv` fuxflwfg dm k vmdzfs|f dm

qedle xfswvsckwdom| ksf |fw goqm gvsdma dmffikwdom Wef S@\ kmd|owsoxt d| xbowwfg

k| k jvmlwdom oj `vbwdxobf `o`fmw" qedle d| k `osf lomzfmdfmw sfxsf|fmwkwdom

wekm kmabf Jos fuk`xbf" wef {vkgsvxobf `o`fmw lossf|xomg| wo B 0 3" wef

olwoxobf wo B 0

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

4/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Jdavsf ;9 Jovs |mkx|eow| dm wef fzobvwdom oj k Jovsdfs `ogf Wef wox xkmfb |eoq|

wef kmd|owsoxt fbg wo wed| omf `ogf zfst fksbt om" qefm dw| qkzfbfmawe d| |wdbb

`vle bksafs wekm wef eosdyom %|eoqm k| qedwf cks wesovaeovw$ Wef |flomg xkmfb"

kw sfg|edjw y = ;87 |eoq| k wd`f kw qedle wef k`xbdwvgf oj wef o|ldbbkwdom| d| zfst

|`kbb Wef wedsg xkmfb |eoq| wef k`xbdwvgf afwwdma bksafs> mowf wekw wef eow kmg

lobg |xow| dm wef wedsg xkmfb ksf ovw oj xek|f qdwe weo|f dm wef wox xkmfb Jdmkbbt"

wef cowwo` xkmfb |eoq| wekw kw sflo`cdmkwdom" wef k`xbdwvgf ek| sfklefg dw|

xfkn Wef |dgf cks |eoq| wef sfg|edjw skmadma jso` ;86 kw wox wo ;8< dm cowwo`

xkmfb

151

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

5/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Jdavsf 39 Xeowom wskiflwosdf| dm km oxfm kmg ffikw vmdzfs|f Wef |k`f xet|dlkb

|lkbfdm wed| lk|f wef omf k||oldkwfg qdwe `kud`kb kmd|owsoxtxsoiflw| omwo

|`kbbfs kmavbks |lkbf| dm km oxfm vmdzfs|f cflkv|f afogf|dl| dm km oxfm vmdzfs|f

gdzfsaf

Jdavsf

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

6/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

s|w xfkn |eoq| vx kw B 388 dm k ffikw vmdzfs|f" kmg qf go dmgffg |ff k wsovae

kw |`kbbfs |lkbf| kmg wefm k bkwfs xfkn kw B 668 Wed| |f{vfmlf lomwdmvf| wo

kscdwsksdbt |`kbb |lkbf| %kbweovae xk|w B ;888 wef k`xbdwvgf| ksf `ogvbkwfg ct

gk`xdma$ Qf kb|o oc|fszf wef jfkwvsf oj afogf|dl| gfxdlwfg dm Jda 39 wef s|wxfkn dm km oxfm vmdzfs|f d| |edjwfg wo `vle |`kbbfs |lkbf|

Km d`xoswkmw k|xflw oj Jda < d| wef kllvsklt oj wef xsfgdlwdom| Kbweovae D

ekzf adzfm k {vkbdwkwdzf gf|lsdxwdom oj wef fzobvwdom oj kmd|owsoxdf|" D kmg `kmt

owefs lo|`oboad|w| |xfmw tfks| gfzfboxdma {vkmwdwkwdzf logf| wo lo`xvwf wef

kmd|owsoxdf| kllvskwfbt ^7P Wed| klwdzdwt kmwdldxkwfg wef kllvsklt qdwe qedle

L@C kmd|owsoxdf| qdbb cf `fk|vsfg kmg wefsfjosf qf |wsozf jos %d$ kllvsklt kmg

%dd$ |xffg Wef jos`fs qk| ocwkdmfg wesovae k |fsdf| oj dmjos`kb gd|lv||dom| kmg

qosn|eox|" vmwdb ekbj k goyfm dmgfxfmgfmw logf| lomzfsafg wo km|qfs| kllvskwf

wo qdwedm k xfslfmw \xffg d| d`xoswkmw cflkv|f vbwd`kwfbt qf qdbb qkmw wo levsm

ovw ydbbdom| oj xsfgdlwdom| wo lo`xksf qdwe oc|fszkwdom| dm km fosw wo fuwsklwcf|w w xksk`fwfs| Joswvmkwfbt" \fbikn kmg Ykbgkssdkak ^6P gfzfboxfg L@CJK\W" k

logf qedle svm| dm kcovw k `dmvwf om k qosn|wkwdom Momf oj wef|f gfzfbox`fmw|

ksf xkswdlvbksbt |vsxsd|dma9 xfswvsckwdom| wo wef L@C ksf |`kbb" kmg wefsfjosf

wef xsocbf` d| wo |obzf k |fw oj lovxbfg bdmfks fzobvwdom f{vkwdom| Wef jklw wekw

wefsf ksf `kmt lovxbfg f{vkwdom| `knf| wef xsocbf` lekbbfmadma" cvw wef jklw

wekw wef|f ksf bdmfks `osf wekm lo`xfm|kwf|

< Kmd|owsoxdf|9 wef jvwvsf

Jdavsf 7 |eoq| qet lo|`oboad|w| ksf |o fuldwfg kcovw wef jvwvsf xo||dcdbdwdf|oj wef L@C Jds|w" wef wox xkmfb |eoq| wekw xfoxbf ksf zowdma qdwe wefds jffw

Wefsf ksf bdwfskbbt evmgsfg| oj fuxfsd`fmwkbd|w| qeo ekzf leo|fm wo gfzowf wefds

fmfsadf| wo `fk|vsdma kmd|owsoxdf| dm wef L@C Ozfs wef lo`dma gflkgf" wed|

qdbb bfkg wo oc|fszkwdom| ct `osf wekm k goyfm fuxfsd`fmw|" lvb`dmkwdma dm wef

fosw| oj wef wqo |kwfbbdwf|" @KX kmg Xbkmln \o`f oj wef|f sf|vbw| ksf cfadmmdma

wo wsdlnbf dm Dm xkswdlvbks" Zdxfs ^:P" @KW ^1P" @\K@ ^5P" Coo`fskma MK ^4P" kmg

Xtweom ^;8P ekzf kbb sfxoswfg sf|vbw| qdwedm wef bk|w tfks

Wef `dggbf xkmfb dm Jda 7 |eoq| wef fuxflwfg fssos| kjwfs kbb wed| dmjos`kwdom

ek| cffm akwefsfg kmg kmkbtyfg Wknf omf `vbwdxobf `o`fmw" kw B 0 :88 |kt

Qf |ff wekw wef fuxflwfg fssos d| oj osgfs 6N" qedbf wef fuxflwfg |damkb d| kcovw68N Kw B 0 :88" wefsfjosf" qf fuxflw k |damkb wo mod|f oj sovaebt wfm wo omf

Mowdlf weovae wekw wed| f|wd`kwf eobg| jos kbb wef `vbwdxobf| |eoqm dm wef avsf

Dm jklw" dw eobg| jos `kmt mow |eoqm dm wef avsf k| qfbb9 dw d| {vdwf xo||dcbf wekw

Xbkmln qdbb ao ovw wo B 3888 \o" qf qdbb ekzf weov|kmg| oj gkwk xodmw|" fkle oj

qedle qdbb ekzf |damkb wo mod|f oj osgfs wfm wo omf" wo lo`xksf qdwe k wefost dm

qedle dw d| xo||dcbf wo `knf bdmfks xsfgdlwdom|+ Mo qomgfs fzfstomf d| |o fuldwfg

154

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

7/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Jdavsf 79 Wef jvwvsf oj L@C kmd|owsoxdf| Wox xkmfb9 Fuxfsd`fmw| fuxflwfg wo

sfxosw kmd|owsoxt sf|vbw| qdwedm wef mfuw gflkgf @dggbf xkmfb9 Fuxflwfg vmlfs-wkdmwt om wef kmd|owsoxt kjwfs wef|f sf|vbw| lo`f dm Cowwo` xkmfb9 Kmwdldxkwfg

vmlfswkdmwdf| dm |fzfskb lo|`oboadlkb xksk`fwfs| k| k sf|vbw oj kbb wed| dmjos`k-

wdom

148

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

8/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Wef mkb xkmfb dm Jda 7 |eoq| wef sk`dlkwdom| oj afwwdma wed| `vle dmjos`k-

wdom kcovw k wefost dm qedle dw d| fk|t wo `knf xsfgdlwdom| Wef fuklw |xflwsv` oj

kmd|owsoxdf| gfxfmg| om kcovw wfm lo|`oboadlkb xksk`fwfs|9 wef ckstom gfm|dwt"

lvszkwvsf" zklvv` gfm|dwt" Evccbf lom|wkmw" mfvwsdmo `k||" fxole oj sfdomdyk-wdom" kmg |fzfskb xksk`fwfs| qedle |xfldjt wef xsd`osgdkb |xflwsv` f`fsadma

jso` dmffikwdom Jdavsf 7 |eoq| wef fuxflwfg fssos| dm jovs oj wef|f xksk`f-

wfs| ^;;P Dm fkle lk|f" kbb %sovaebt wfm$ owefs xksk`fwfs| ekzf cffm `ksadmkbdyfg

ozfs Wekw d|" wef vmlfswkdmwt dm wef Evccbf lom|wkmw |wkwfg kbboq| jos kbb xo||dcbf

zkbvf| oj wef owefs xksk`fwfs|

Wef vmlfswkdmwt dm wef Evccbf lom|wkmw" oj zf wo wfm xfslfmw" lo`f| goqm

|damdlkmwbt dj omf k||v`f| wef vmdzfs|f d| ffikw Dm kmt fzfmw" wed| vmlfswkdmwt d|

|wdbb |`kbbfs wekm wef lvssfmw f|wd`kwf| jso` gd|wkmlf bkggfs `fk|vsf`fmw| ^;3P

Wef zfst |`kbb vmlfswkdmwt om wef ckstom gfm|dwt d| |`kbbfs wekm wef zf xfslfmw

mv`cfs ocwkdmfg ct boondma kw gfvwfsdv` bdmf| dm [\O kc|osxwdom |t|wf`| ^;

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

9/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Kmowefs gfzfbox`fmw dm wef fbg oj xksk`fwfs gfwfs`dmkwdom d| wef sfkbdyk-

wdom wekw k bksaf xksw oj wef vmlfswkdmwt dm |o`f xksk`fwfs| %f|xfldkbbt |o`f

oj wef dmffikwdomkst omf|$ d| lomwsdcvwfg ct wsfkwdma wef sfdomdykwdom fxole k| k

jsff xksk`fwfs Dm jklw" dw d| k jvmlwdom ^;4P oj wef lo|`oboadlkb xksk`fwfs| kmg|o`f k|wsoxet|dlkb xksk`fwfs| Sflfmwbt" Zfmnkwf|km ^38P ek| ksavfg wekw qf

lkm v|f ovs zfst sovae nmoqbfgaf oj wef k|wsoxet|dlkb xksk`fwfs| woafwefs qdwe

wef sfdomdykwdom `ogfb| wo sfgvlf wef fssos| om wef lo|`oboadlkb xksk`fwfs|

7 Kmd|owsoxdf|9 wef xsf|fmw

Dw d| wd`f wo lomjsomw wef gkwk Jdavsf 6 |eoq| kbb gkwk k| oj Mozf`cfs ;444 Wefsf

ksf wqo jfkwvsf| oj wed| lo`xdbkwdom qoswet oj mowf Jds|w" mowf wekw gkwk sfxoswfg

qdwedm wef bk|w tfks ksf gd|wdmavd|efg jso` fksbdfs sf|vbw|" dbbv|wskwdma dm k zfstaskxedl qkt wef xsoasf|| oj wef fbg \flomg" Jda 6 vmgfs|wkwf| wed| xsoasf||

cflkv|f dw qk| xsogvlfg cfjosf wef bkwf Mozf`cfs sfbfk|f oj wef wef Coo`fskma

Moswe K`fsdlk wf|w ffidaew ^4P Dmgffg" wef sf|vbw| qedle jobboq go mow dmlbvgf

wed| wf|w ffidaew Wef xkxfs| gf|lsdcdma wef Coo`fskma sfbfk|f ksf jk|ldmkwdma dj

ombt cflkv|f omf lkm lo`xksf wef sf|vbw| oj kbb gkwk xsf-Coo`fskma qdwe wef

wf|w ffidaew gkwk Cowe |vc|fw| oj wef gkwk ekzf fmovae xoqfs wo lom|wskdm wef

lvszkwvsf ct wef`|fbzf| Weft xsogvlf sf`ksnkcbt lom|d|wfmw sf|vbw|

Wef gkwk dm Jda 6 |eoq k lbfks xfkn kw ksovmg wef xo|dwdom fuxflwfg dm ffikw

`ogfb| Dmgffg" k mv`cfs oj asovx| ^3;P ekzf kmkbtyfg |vc|fw| oj wed| gkwk

kmg jovmg dw wo cf lom|d|wfmw qdwe k ffikw vmdzfs|f kmg dmlom|d|wfmw qdwe km oxfm

omf D qdbb csdfffit gf|lsdcf `t fosw| qdwe B Nmou ^33P Qf kllovmwfg jos kmv`cfs oj jklw| qedle `knf dw gdlvbw wo go k |d`xbf led-ct-ftf om wef gkwk

Jds|w" fzfst fuxfsd fmw ek| k||oldkwfg qdwe dw k lkbdcskwdom vmlfswkdmwt9 kbb wef

xodmw| jso` k adzfm fuxfsd`fmw lkm `ozf vx os goqm woafwefs k adzfm k`ovmw

Qf kllovmw jos wed| ct dmlbvgdma k lkbdcskwdom jklwos jos fkle fuxfsd`fmw kmg

dmlbvgdma k Akv||dkm xsdos om wed| jklwos qdwe k qdgwe gfwfs`dmfg ct wef |wkwfg

vmlfswkdmwdf| \flomg" wef fssos cks| dm wef xbow ksf |bdaewbt `d|bfkgdma cflkv|f

wef fssos| go mow ekzf k Akv||dkm gd|wsdcvwdom Dm xkswdlvbks" wef lo|`dl zksdkmlf

xksw oj wef fssos d| xsoxoswdomkb wo wef |damkb dw|fbj" |o wef fssos afw| `vle bksafs

wekm omf qovbg fuxflw kw edae W Dm owefs qosg|" wef gd|wsdcvwdom d| edaebt

|nfqfg" qdwe zfst edae zkbvf| oj W mow d`xo||dcbf Wef wsvf gd|wsdcvwdom d|lbo|f wo k boa-mos`kb gd|wsdcvwdom ^3

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

10/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Jdavsf 69 Lvssfmw `fk|vsf| oj L@C kmd|owsoxt Xodmw| `ksnfg k| lso||f| sf-

jfs wo `fk|vsf`fmw| sfxoswfg qdwedm wef xk|w tfks Dmlbvgfg ksf kbb gkwk k| oj

Mozf`cfs ;444

zfs|f qdwe wowkb gfm|dwt f{vkb wo 78& oj wef lsdwdlkb gfm|dwt d| bf|| bdnfbt wekm wef

ffikw `ogfb ct k jklwos oj osgfs ;81 Wed| skwdo d| nft cflkv|f oc|fszkwdom| ^37P

oj wef `kwwfs gfm|dwt dm wef vmdzfs|f ekzf lomzfsafg wo k zkbvf dm wef skmaf

8-< 8-7 oj wef lsdwdlkb gfm|dwt Qf lkm lo`cdmf wef|f wqo sf|vbw| wo lomlbvgf

wekw wefsf `v|w cf |o`fwedma fb|f cf|dgf| wef `kwwfs dm wef vmdzfs|f Wed| lom-

lbv|dom xsockcbt |ovmg| jk`dbdks wo tov" k| wef sflfmw gd|lozfsdf| oj edae sfg|edjw

|vxfsmozkf ^36P kb|o |wsomabt |vaaf|w wekw wefsf d| `osf wo wef vmdzfs|f wekm iv|w

wef oc|fszfg `kwwfs9 wefsf d| gksn fmfsat dm wef vmdzfs|f Wef fuldwdma mfq| d|

wekw qf moq ekzf dmgfxfmgfmw iv|wdlkwdom oj wef|f sf|vbw| v|dma L@C . `kwwfsgfwfs`dmkwdom|

Omf qkt wo gfxdlw wed| dmjos`kwdom wekw ek| cffm xoxvbksdyfg ct wef |vxfs-

mozkf wfk`| d| wo xbow wef lom|wskdmw| dm k |xklf qdwe zklvv` fmfsat kmg `kwwfs

gfm|dwt k| wef wqo xksk`fwfs| K| |eoqm dm Jda 1" wef |wsomaf|w lom|wskdmw|

om wef `kwwfs gfm|dwt lo`f jso` oc|fszkwdom| oj ckstom| kmg gksn `kwwfs dm

lbv|wfs| oj akbkudf| Qf ocwkdm lomwovs| dm wed| xbkmf jso` wef L@C |eoqm dm

14

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

11/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Jdavsf :9 Skwdo oj bdnfbdeoog oj wo 0 ; %ffikw$ jos gdfsfmw |fw| oj fuxfsd`fmw|

Wox bfjw xkmfb |eoq| sf|vbw| v|dma kbb gkwk> owefs xkmfb| |eoq wef |k`f skwdo

v|dma ombt |vc|fw| oj wef gkwk

Jda 1 Mowf wekw wef ffikw bdmf svm| gdkaomkbbt jso` wox bfjw wo cowwo` sdaew kmg

d| |wsomabt jkzosfg ct wef L@C Wef gkwk ksf |o xoqfsjvb wekw |o`f gd|lsd`dmk-wdom d| kxxfksdma kboma wed| bdmf Zfst bksaf zkbvf| oj ksf gd|jkzosfg" kmg" kw

k `vle |`kbbfs |wkwd|wdlkb bfzfb" |o d| % 0 8"`kwwfs 0 ;$ Wef `kdm sf|vbw"

weovae" d| wekw wef dmwfs|flwdom oj wef sfadom| kbboqfg ct lbv|wfs| kmg wef L@C d|

kw 8-:" dm sf`ksnkcbf kasff`fmw qdwe wef edae sfg|edjw |vxfsmozkf sf|vbw|

Wed| lomlbvgf| `t ksav`fmw| jos wef s|w wesff lbkd`| kgzkmlfg dm wef dm-

wsogvlwdom Vmgovcwfgbt" `kmt oj tov ekzf efksg wef` dm zksdov| jos`| ozfs

wef xk|w jfq tfks| Moq bfw v| wvsm wo wef eksgf|w lbkd` wo iv|wdjt" wef lbkd`

wekw qf |eovbg dmgffg cfbdfzf wef xoqfsjvb lomlbv|dom| oj wef L@C sf|vbw| D qdbb

jolv| om wqo ksav`fmw| Jds|w" omf `daew cf qossdfg kcovw wef xo||dcdbdwt wekw

wef qfdaew oj wef|f lomlbv|dom| sf|w| om omf fuxfsd`fmw" kmg omf fuxfsd`fmw`daew cf qsoma Wef sf`kdmdma xkmfb| oj Jda : |eoq wekw wed| d| mow k xsocbf`

Qf ekzf wsdfg sf`ozdma kmt omf gkwk |fw wo |ff eoq ovs lomlbv|dom| kcovw

ksf kflwfg> dm kbb lk|f|" wef lomlbv|dom |wkmg| Qf fzfm wsdfg sf`ozdma xkds|

oj gkwk |fw| kmg kakdm |kq mo lekmaf Omf ek| wo ksavf jos k cfqdbgfsdma |fw oj

lodmldgfmlf| dj omf qfsf wo gd|cfbdfzf wef |wkwd|wdlkb lomlbv|dom|

Wef |flomg lbk|| oj ksav`fmw| edmaf| om |o`fwedma wekw qk| mow xo||dcbf vm-

147

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

12/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Jdavsf 19 Lom|wskdmw| om wef zklvv` kmg `kwwfs gfm|dwdf| dm wef vmdzfs|f \eoqm

ksf omf-" wqo-" kmg wesff-|da`k sfadom| kbboqfg ct wef L@C kmg cf|w-w sfadom oj

wef `kwwfs gfm|dwt jso` lbv|wfs|

wdb zfst sflfmwbt Vbwd`kwfbt" |nfxwdl| qdbb cf lomzdmlfg dj gdfsfmw fuxfsd`fmw|

afw wef |k`f |damkb qefm `fk|vsdma wef |k`f xdflf oj |nt Vmwdb moq" wed| wf|w

ek| cffm gdlvbw wo lksst ovw jos wqo sfk|om| Jds|w" kw bfk|w kw |`kbb |lkbf|" ombtk zfst |`kbb jsklwdom oj wef |nt ek| cffm lozfsfg" |o wefsf ek| cffm bdwwbf ozfsbkx

Wed| ek| lekmafg k cdw ozfs wef bk|w tfks kmg oczdov|bt qdbb lekmaf gsk`kwdlkbbt dm

wef lo dma tfks| \flomg" gdfsfmw fuxfsd fmw| oc|fszf wef |nt gdfsfmwbt9 weft

|`oowe qdwe gdfsfmw cfk` |dyf| kmg v|f gdfsfmw leoxxdma |wskwfadf| wo |vc-

wsklw o wef kw`o|xefsf Sflfmwbt" qf ekzf gfzfboxfg wflemd{vf| qedle vmgo

wef fuxfsd fmwkb xsolf||dma" wefsfct kbboqdma jos fk|t lo`xksd|om| cfwqffm gdj-

jfsfmw fuxfsd`fmw| ^5P

Wo dbbv|wskwf wef `kx-`kndma wflemd{vf" bfw v| `ogfb wef gkwk G dm k adzfm

fuxfsd`fmw k|

G 0 CW.M %;$

qefsf W d| wef vmgfsbtdma wf`xfskwvsf fbg> C d| wef xsolf||dma `kwsdu qedle

dmlbvgf| kbb |`oowedma kmg leoxxdma> kmg M d| mod|f qedle d| k||v`fg wo cf

Akv||dkm qdwe `fkm yfso kmg lozksdkmlf `kwsdu LM Wo ocwkdm wef vmgfsbtdma

wf`xfskwvsf fbg W" qf mffg wo dmzfsw wef `kwsdu C Wed| dmzfs|dom d| lkssdfg ovw

146

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

13/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

ct lom|wsvlwdma wef f|wd`kwos W qedle `dmd`dyf| wef 39

3 %G CW $L;M %G CW $- %3$

Qf mg

W0 LMCL;M G- %

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

14/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

xsf|fmw dm cowe fuxfsd`fmw|" cvw wefsf ksf |fzfskbjos fuk`xbf wef eow |xow kw

SK ;

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

15/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

Jdavsf 49 Wqo tfks| oj Xtweom gkwk Wef cowwo` xkmfb |eoq| gkwk jso` ;446>

wef wox xkmfb lomwkdm| `vle mod|dfs ;441 gkwk Dm cowe lk|f|" mod|t `ogf| ekzf

cffm fbd`dmkwfg |o wekw ombt `ogf| qdwe \/M asfkwfs wekm ;-6 ksf sfwkdmfg Wef

`dggbf cks |eoq| wekw %jos Xtweom 41$ wefsf ksf oj osgfs ;6 |vle `ogf| ovw oj

37: xdufb| dm wef sfadom

wqo tfks| ksf zfst gdfsfmw

Wo `knf wef `kx| dm Jda 4" D |wkswfg qdwe wef skq `kx| kmg wefm gflo`xo|fg

wef gkwk dmwo |damkb wo mod|f fdafm`ogf| ^34P Ct osgfsdma wef gkwk dm wfs`| oj

|damkb wo mod|f" qf lkm askgvkbbt kmg |t|wf`kwdlkbbt fbd dmkwf wef mod|df|w `ogf|

Wed| ek| kbsfkgt cffm gomf om wef ;446 gkwk dm wef cowwo` xkmfb Wef wox xkmfb

lomwkdm| kbb `ogf| qdwe \/M asfkwfs wekm kcovw ;-6 K| dmgdlkwfg ct wef cks|"

wefsf ksf zfst jfq |vle `ogf|" om wef osgfs oj wfm Momfwefbf||" `kmt jfkwvsf|ksf jovmg dm cowe `kx| Wefsf d| wef wsdxbfw oj lobg |xow| fuwfmgdma gdkaomkbbt

jso` ;6 wo ;8 kyd`vwe Wefsf d| wef lobg |xow kw 7 kyd`vwe" kmg wef eow

|xow kw 8" kmg wefm mkbbt wef lobg |xow kw wef jks sdaew Dw kxxfks| wo `f wekw

wef|f wqo `kx| kasffkjwfs jks woo `kmt eovs| |wksdma kw wef`k| qfbb k| wef

@\K@ `kx| Dm jklw" wef wf|w kgzolkwfg ct Comg" Ikf" kmg Nmou ^31P loms`|

wed| kasff`fmw

145

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

16/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

6 Lomlbv|dom

Wef s|w klov|wdl xfkn dm wef L@C ek| cffm gfwflwfg kw km kmavbks xo|dwdom los-

sf|xomgdma wo wekw fuxflwfg dm k ffikw vmdzfs|f Wed| loms`| wef jvmgk`fmwkbxsfgdlwdom oj dmffikwdom wekw wef vmdzfs|f d| ffikw Dw kb|o ofs| dmgfxfmgfmw fzd-

gfmlf jos wef fud|wfmlf oj gksn fmfsat qdwe mfakwdzf xsf||vsf Wed| d| cvw wef

s|w oj `kmt askmg sf|vbw| qf fuxflw wo lo`f ovw oj wef L@C ozfs wef lo`dma

gflkgf

D k` askwfjvb wo `t lobbkcoskwos| Bbotg Nmou" Nd` Locbf" Askmw Qdb|om" Ioem

Nozkl" @ksn Gskaozkm" kmg owefs `f`cfs| oj wef @\K@/Xtweom wfk`| Wed|

qosn d| |vxxoswfg ct MK\K Askmw MKA 6-1843 kmg wef GOF

Sfjfsfmlf|

^;P \o`f mdlf sflfmw sfzdfq| oj xfswvsckwdom| afmfskwfg ct dmffikwdom ksf9 F

\wfqksw kmg G Btwe" Xet|dl| Bfwwfs| C

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

17/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

^5P F Lefma fw kb-" K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 733" B F Lefma fw kb-" K|wso-

xet|dlkb Iovsmkb 76:" B1; %;44:$> F Lefma fw kb-" K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 755"

B64 %;441$> A Qdb|om" fw kb-" K|wsoxet| I dm xsf||" k|wso-xe/4483871

^4P X @kv|noxjfw kb-" k|wso-xe/44;;777> K @fbledossd" k|wso-xe/44;;776

^;8P N Locbf fw kb-" K|wsoxet| I Bfww 6;4 6 %;444$

^;;P Wef mv`cfs| |eoqm dm Jda 7 lo`f jso` wef bkwf|w kmg `o|w kllvskwf |fw

oj xsfgdlwdom|" G Fd|fm|wfdm" Q Ev" kmg @ Wfa`ksn" K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb

6;5" 3 %;444$ Wef|f jobboq k |wsdma oj |d dbks xkxfs|" |wkswdma jso` I S Comg

fw kb-" Xet|dlkb Sfzdfq Bfwwfs| 13" ;< %;447$" lomwdmvdma wo wef asovmg csfkn-

dma qosn oj B Nmou" Xet|dlkb Sfzdfq G63" 7

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

18/19

\loww Gogfb|om Lo| dl @dlsoqkzf Cklnasovmg9 Xk|w" Jvwvsf" kmg Xsf|fmw

wef L@C Jvwvsf @d||dom| Qosndma Asovx sflfmwbt ksavfg jos k xo|w-Xbkmln

xobksdykwdom `d||dom" I Xfwfs|om fw kb-" k|wso-xe/448131:

^;4P Jos `ogfb| oj sfdomdykwdom" |ff f-a- C I Lkss" I S Comg" kmg Q G Ksmfww"K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 311" 776 %;457$> E @ X Lovle`km kmg @ I Sff|"

@omwebt Mowdlf| oj Sotkb K|wsomo`dlkb \oldfwt 33;" 6< %;45:$> @ Jvnvadwk

kmg @ Nkqk|knd" @omwebt Mowdlf| oj Sotkb K|wsomo`dlkb \oldfwt 3:4" 6: X S \ekxdso" @ B Adsovu" kmg K Ckcvb" K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 731"

36 %;447$> @ Wfa`ksn" I \dbn" kmg K Cbkmleksg" K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 7 L E Bdmfqfkzfs"K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 686" B:4 %;445$> \ Ekmloln fw kb-" @MSK\ 347" B;

%;445$> I Bf|aovsavf| fw kb-" k|wso-xe/45818;4 %;445$> I Ckswbfww fw kb-"

k|wso-xe/4587;65 %;445$> X Aksmkzdle fw kb-" K|wsoxet| I 684 17 %;445$>

I S Comg kmg K E Ikf" k|wso-xe/4585487< %;445$> K @ Qfc|wfs" K|wso-

xet|dlkb Iovsmkb 684" B:6 %;445$> @ Qedwf" K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 68:" 756

%;445$> C Skwsk fw kb-" K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 6;1" 674 %;444$> @ Wfa`ksn"

K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 6;7" B:4 %;444$> M K Ckelkbb" IX O|wsdnfs" \ Xfsb-

`vwwfs kmg X I \wfdmeksgw" \ldfmlf 357" ;75; %;444$%k|wso-xe/448:7: @

\ Wvsmfs" dm wef Xsolffgdma| oj Wtxf Dk \vxfsmozkf9 Wefost kmg Lo|`oboat

%Ledlkao" 34 - G Qedwf

kmg K L Jkcdkm" @om Mow S K|wsom \ol 31

8/3/2019 Scott Dodelson- Cosmic Microwave Background: Past, Future, and Present

19/19

wsoxet| I 681" 7: %;445$> K A Sdf||" fw kb" K|wsom I" dm xsf|| %k|wso-

xe/4586388$

^3:P L Dm`km fw kb-" K|wsoxet|dlkb Iovsmkb 715" B; %;441$

^31P B Nmou fw kb-" Xet|dlkb Sfzdfq G65" 85 %3$ wef vmdzfs|f d| `vle" xo||dcbt

dmmdwfbt" obgfs wekm ;6 cdbbdom tfks|> kmg %