Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN...

27
Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs September 5, 2016 Cecilia Lee Supervisor: Mr. Yongping Zhai SDAS/SDCC Asian Development Bank Azerbaijan, China, India, Indonesia, Myanmar, Philippines, Thailand, Vietnam

Transcript of Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN...

Page 1: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

ReviewofRetailElectricityTariffs

September5,2016CeciliaLee

Supervisor:Mr.Yongping ZhaiSDAS/SDCC

AsianDevelopmentBank

Azerbaijan,China,India,Indonesia,Myanmar,Philippines,Thailand,Vietnam

Page 2: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

ConcernsoverretailelectricitypricingintheDevelopingMemberCountries(DMCs)

1.FinancialLosses

2.EnergyInefficiency

3.Fossilfuelsubsidyfor

electricitygeneration

2Photocredit:ADBPhotoLibrary

Page 3: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Source:Enerdata

Japan

US

3

Page 4: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

54% 18%

13%

10%

5% Philippines-Meralco's RetailTariffin2015

Generation

DistributionCharges

Taxes,Subsidies

Transmission

SystemLoss

78%

13%

9%

Thailand-EGAT'sRetailTariffin2012

Generation

Distribution&RetailTransmission 61%

26%

13%

BreakdownofGenerationforEGAT'sRetailTariffin

2012PowerPurchasingPriceFuelCost

InvestmentCapital,etc.4

Page 5: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Cross-SubsidybetweenIndustrialandResidentialUsers

• Industrial=Residential– Azerbaijan

• Industrial>Residential– China,India,Myanmar,

Indonesia

• Residential>Industrial– Thailand,Philippines,Vietnam

5

Page 6: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Azerbaijan

• Industry=Residential:US$0.059/kWh(2015)-generation&transmission:US$0.046/kWh(78%)-distribution:US$0.013/kWh(22%)

• Limitedunbundlingforaseparatedistributioncompany(butin2006,returnedtostatehands)->now,largelyverticallyintegratedmonopoly

• Energyutilitiesdonotfullyrecoverthecost• Untargeteduniversalsubsidy fromtheverylowinput

priceofgas(83%ofinstalledcapacity)– unabletoefficientlyhelpwhoneedsthesupportmost

6

Page 7: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Azerbaijan

• ADBProject,ApprovedinAugust2016– PreparingaPowerSectorFinancialRecoveryPlan

-TechnicalAssistanceSpecialFund($1.2m)

<ProjectOutputs>1. Realcostofelectricitysupplycalculation2. Newtariffstructure3. Financialrecoveryroadmap4. Publicinformationcampaign

7

Page 8: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

• Industry (US$0.10/kWh)>Residential(US$0.077/kWh)in2013

• Cross-subsidizationforresidential (industrialsectorpaysathigherelectricityrate)

• Significantdiversityofratesandratestructuresacrossprovinces

• Nolifelinetariff– Butthelowestincomehouseholdgroup(~US$3/daypercapita)receives10-15kWhfreepermonth

=40millionhouseholds,equalto10%ofthetotalnationalpopulation(NDRC,2012)

China

8

Page 9: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

China• StrictregulationbytheNationalDevelopmentandReformCommission(NDRC),partoftheCentralGov’t

• Retailpricessettocontrolinflationandasdevelopmentpolicy

• October2010:athree-tierelectricitypricingsystemfortheresidentialsectorintroduced,transitioningfromtheflatpricingsystem– Sofar,itisnotclearwhethertheincreasedpricefromthereformisabletorecoverthecost,andifitisnot,towhatextentthesurplusordeficitexists(IISD,2015)

9

Page 10: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

India

10

Page 11: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

India• Industrial (US$0.091/kWh)>Residential (US$0.07/kWh)in2015

• Heavysubsidizationtoagricultureandresidentialusers-mainobstacletorapiddeploymentofdistributedrooftopsolar

• Tariffandsubsidyreformneeded-poorfinancialhealthofthedistributionsector(operatinglosses:overUS$10bnannually)impactstheentirepowersectorsustainabilityinIndiae.g.PPAshavelimitedbankability

• Highlevelsofnontechnicallosses(theft)isaseriousproblem:aUS$4bnsmart-metercapitalinvestmentprogramapprovedinNov2014(inNewDelhi,nontechnicallosses45%->7%inthe1st yearofimplementingtheSmartMeter)

11

Page 12: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Indonesia

Source:IEA,EnergyOutlookIndonesia.2015.OriginalSource:Directorate-GeneralofElectricity(2014b),“ElectricitypolicydevelopmentinIndonesia”,presentationtoIEA,MinistryofEnergyandMineralResources,Jakarta.

12

• Indonesiahasbeenbringingtheelectricitytariffupwithperiodicaladjustmentsaccordingtoapredeterminedtimetablesince2013

Page 13: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Indonesia• Industrial(US$0.073/kWh)>Residential(US$0.057/kWh)in

2015• UnbundledPowerSector• Majorelectricitysubsidyreformpostponed– InJuly2016,PTPLN(Indonesia’sstateownedelectricitycompany,monopolyondistribution)estimatesUS$1.3bn coststokeepprovidingelectricitytoenduserswithoutthereformuntiltheendof2016

– Thereformisexpectedtoexcludenon-poorhouseholdsinthe900VAconnectionclass,whichwouldreducesubsidyrecipientsinthatclassfrom22millionhouseholdsto4millionhouseholds

Source:GSI,IISD.IndonesiaApprovesRevised2016Budget:Subsidyupdate.26July2016.13

Page 14: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Indonesia

• Lowruralelectrificationrate:66%(Urban:94%)• Since2015,PTPLNpublishesadjustedtariffseverymonthbasedon

anevaluationontheIDR―US$exchangerate,theIndonesianCrudePriceandtheinflationrate (Source:GSI/IISD)

14

Page 15: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Myanmar• State-ownedsingle-buyermodel/Verticallyintegrated

• Dependsonvolatilehydropowerandoldgas-firedpowerplants

• Heavilysubsidizedelectricity– Industrial(US$0.086/kWh)>Residential(US$0.034/kWh)in2015

-Gov’tcovers72%ofthetariffbysubsidy– Thelowesttariffamongthestudiedcountries:US$0.034/kWh(Philippines(highest):US$0.2/kWh)

– ThelowelectricitypricesthreatenfiscalcapacityanddonotattractIPPs

15

Page 16: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Myanmar• LowestelectrificationrateamongASEANcountries

-Urban(60%)&Rural(18%)• 50%electrificationratetargetby2020 and100%by2030– Gradualtariffsubsidyreformmustbeconducted– PrivateinvestmentsneededinadditiontotheloansfromtheMDBsandaidfrombilateralODAs• ADB:PowerTransmissionImprovementProject(US$80m)• WorldBank:ElectricPowerProject(US$140m)

16

Page 17: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

54%

18%

13%

10%

5%

PhilippinesMeralco's RetailTariffin2015

Generation

DistributionCharges

Taxes,Subsidies

Transmission

SystemLoss

17

Page 18: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

PhilippinesMeralco

August2016RateofSchedule

Meralco publishesmonthlyrates<July2016>

GenerationCharge*:4.0604LifelineRateSubsidy**:0.062

GenerationCharge* DistributionCharge LifelineRateSubsidy** LifelineDiscount SeniorCitizenResidential perkWh perkWh perkWh % perkWh0to20kWh 3.8560 1.0012 100

21-50 3.8560 1.0012 5051-70 3.8560 1.0012 3571-100 3.8560 1.0012 20101-200 3.8560 1.0012 0.076 0.0001201-300 3.8560 1.3183 0.076 0.0001301-400 3.8560 1.6175 0.076 0.0001Over400 3.8560 2.1387 0.076 0.0001

18

Page 19: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Philippines• Firstintroducedin1987,IPPsprovide44%ofthetotalinstalledelectricitycapacity– ControversialIPPcontractsledtoextremelyhighelectricity

prices(IEA,2015)tolimittheimpactonpublicfinances(WorldBank,2016)“legacycost”

• IndependentElectricityRegulatoryBody• Ruralelectrificationremainslow:67%(Urban:94%)• Amongthestudiedcountries,onlyfully"unbundled"powersector usingprivatizedpowergeneratorsandindependentgridoperators– Unbundledcharges:mirrorstheindustrysupplychain,all

adjustmentsintheratesaregovernedbyRegulatoryMechanisms 19

Page 20: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

78%

13%

9% Thailand-EGAT'sRetailTariffin2012

Generation

Distribution&RetailTransmission

61% 26%

13%

BreakdownofGenerationforEGAT'sRetailTariffin

2012PowerPurchasingPriceFuelCost

InvestmentCapital,etc.20

Page 21: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Thailand

• Residential(US$0.12/kWh)>Industrial (US$0.084/kWh)in2015

• LifelineTariffexist• Independentelectricityregulatorybody• Electricitydistributionlargelymonopolizedby100%government-ownedElectricityGeneratingAuthorityofThailand(EGAT)

• Universalelectricityaccess-Urban(100%)&Rural(98%)

21

Page 22: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Thailand• Asof2015,theinstalledcapacitycomprisedof…– PrivateIPPs:60%– EGAT:40%

• Generationincreasinglyrelyingonimportednaturalgaswellaheadofcoal– Vulnerabletofluctuationsintheinternationalmarket->mightcauseunstableelectricitysupplyandpowersecurity

Source:AnnualReport2015.EGAT;DevelopmentProspectsoftheASEANPowerSector.InternationalEnergyAgency.2015.22

Page 23: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Vietnam• StrongestincreaseinelectricitydemandofallASEANcountriesinthepastdecade(IEA,2015)

• OnlyVietnamincreaseditsretailtariffsin2014-2015amongthestudiedcountries– Industrial(US$0.06->US$0.0648/kWh)– Residential(US$0.07->US$0.081/kWh)

• Reductionsincross-subsidies– Since2009,residentialelectricitytariffsincreasedtoeliminatethecross-subsidyfromcommercialandindustrialtowardsresidentialusers.

• NolifelineTariffSource:Enerdata;AFinancialRecoveryPlanforVietnamElectricity,WorldBank(2016)

23

Page 24: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

Vietnam• Vietnamhaslowtechnicallosses(e.g.theft),highlevelsofbillingandcashcollection,andlowlevelsofoperatingcosts

• Presentretailtariffsarebelowthecostofsupply– MustreachthecostrecoveryleveltoachievefinancialsustainabilityofEVN(VietnamElectricity(thelargestpowercompanyinVietnam))

– Recommendedtoincreasethetariffshigherthantherateofinflation

– Otherwise,EVN’sdebtwillbecome“unsustainable”

Source:AfinancialrecoveryplanforVietnamElectricity(EVN).WorldBank.201624

Page 25: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

AnalysisofReview• Costreflectivetariffiscrucialforlong-termfinancialsustainabilityofpowersector– Affordabilityisveryimportant,too– Electrificationrateandreliablepowerprovisionarecloselyrelatedtothecostrecoveryofenergycompanies

• WeakeningcurrencyofseveralDMCsisalsoamajorcontributoroftheirenergycompanies’debts

25

Page 26: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

AnalysisofReview• Subsidydesignforrenewableenergy– Forenergysecurityanddiversity– Forgreenhousegasemissionsreduction

• Cross-subsidymustbere-evaluated– Checkifitdetersnewprivateinvestments– Ensuremostvulnerable&poorestpopulationgetsupport(socialprotection)

• Transparentandindependentregulatorybody• Robustprivatesectorparticipationforinvestments

26

Page 27: Review of Retail Electricity Tariffs - k-learn.adb.org households to 4 million ... , PT PLN publishes adjusted tariffs every month based ... Residential per kWh per kWh per kWh % per

ThankYou

CeciliaLeeMasterofScience‘17,SchoolofNaturalResourcesandEnvironment

MasterofAppliedEconomics‘17UniversityofMichigan

[email protected]

27

Photocredit:OPIC.gov


IEEFA Unlocking Rooftop Solar in the Philippines August 2018...By comparison, rooftop solar costs PhP 2.50 per kWh (without financing expenses) to 5.3 per kWh (with financing expenses),

IEEFA Unlocking Rooftop Solar in the Philippines August 2018...By comparison, rooftop solar costs PhP 2.50 per kWh (without financing expenses) to 5.3 per kWh (with financing expenses),

gutami.com · Web viewStel dat je per jaar ongeveer 3.500 kWh aan elektriciteit verbruikt, waarvan 2.000 kWh tijdens de piekuren en 1.500 kWh tijdens de daluren. Je kan er dan voor

gutami.com · Web viewStel dat je per jaar ongeveer 3.500 kWh aan elektriciteit verbruikt, waarvan 2.000 kWh tijdens de piekuren en 1.500 kWh tijdens de daluren. Je kan er dan voor

Presentatie energie besparende motoren en drives …...IE2 verbruik : 74.070 kWh per jaar Besparing van 2.325 kWh per jaar International Efficiency TOEPASSINGEN LD P - Portfolio Besparing

Presentatie energie besparende motoren en drives …...IE2 verbruik : 74.070 kWh per jaar Besparing van 2.325 kWh per jaar International Efficiency TOEPASSINGEN LD P - Portfolio Besparing

NERSA APPROVED TARIFFS · NERSA APPROVED TARIFFS GAUTENG PROVINCE Name of licensee & Percentage Increase Domestic Low (c/kWh) Block1 (0-50 kWh) Block2 (50-350 kWh Block3 (350-600

NERSA APPROVED TARIFFS · NERSA APPROVED TARIFFS GAUTENG PROVINCE Name of licensee & Percentage Increase Domestic Low (c/kWh) Block1 (0-50 kWh) Block2 (50-350 kWh Block3 (350-600

Wake Electric Membership Corporation · All kWhs (EV Discount: 10:00pm – 6:00am) 8.7 ¢ per kWh All kWhs (Solar Discount: 10:00am – 2:00pm) 8.7 ¢ per kWh MINIMUM MONTHLY CHARGE

Wake Electric Membership Corporation · All kWhs (EV Discount: 10:00pm – 6:00am) 8.7 ¢ per kWh All kWhs (Solar Discount: 10:00am – 2:00pm) 8.7 ¢ per kWh MINIMUM MONTHLY CHARGE

Welcome | Southeastern Indiana REMC...B-5 General Electric Service Approved: July 16, 2018 Effective: October 1, 2018 per kWh per kWh per kWh per kWh First 1,000 kWh over 1,000 kWh

Welcome | Southeastern Indiana REMC...B-5 General Electric Service Approved: July 16, 2018 Effective: October 1, 2018 per kWh per kWh per kWh per kWh First 1,000 kWh over 1,000 kWh

WRBU Business Plan Draft sp 090417 · Annual operation (10% down time) 330 days Power produced 3,722,000 kWh per year Electricity price $0.07 per kWh Subtotal: $ 260,540 14% Biochar

WRBU Business Plan Draft sp 090417 · Annual operation (10% down time) 330 days Power produced 3,722,000 kWh per year Electricity price $0.07 per kWh Subtotal: $ 260,540 14% Biochar

Public Health Benefits per kWh of Energy Efficiency and ...

Public Health Benefits per kWh of Energy Efficiency and ...

NERSA APPROVED TARIFFSnersa.org.za/Admin/Document/Editor/file/Electricity...NERSA APPROVED TARIFFS KWA-ZULU NATAL PROVINCE Name of licensee & Percentage Increase Domestic Low (c/kWh)

NERSA APPROVED TARIFFSnersa.org.za/Admin/Document/Editor/file/Electricity...NERSA APPROVED TARIFFS KWA-ZULU NATAL PROVINCE Name of licensee & Percentage Increase Domestic Low (c/kWh)

Photovoltaic - Common Energy Supply for the Future · Solar cells. Solar modules. ... The technology roadmap to reduce cost per kWh Cost per kWh $ $$ $$$ Scale Integration . Volume

Photovoltaic - Common Energy Supply for the Future · Solar cells. Solar modules. ... The technology roadmap to reduce cost per kWh Cost per kWh $ $$ $$$ Scale Integration . Volume

KWH Mirka - KWH Group€¦ · KWH Mirka KWH Invest KWH kort KWH-koncernen utvecklar, producerar och marknadsför plastprodukter och slipmaterial globalt samt bedriver serviceverksamhet

KWH Mirka - KWH Group€¦ · KWH Mirka KWH Invest KWH kort KWH-koncernen utvecklar, producerar och marknadsför plastprodukter och slipmaterial globalt samt bedriver serviceverksamhet

Photovoltaic Solar Panel Installation Estimated 119,000 kWh per year.

Photovoltaic Solar Panel Installation Estimated 119,000 kWh per year.

PowerPoint Presentation - Sustainable Design for Saguaro ......Dome Design. Earth Tubes. Energy Sources • AVG 29.2 kWh/day per home • These homes ~ 25 kWh/day per home • 1 sq.

PowerPoint Presentation - Sustainable Design for Saguaro ......Dome Design. Earth Tubes. Energy Sources • AVG 29.2 kWh/day per home • These homes ~ 25 kWh/day per home • 1 sq.

JERSEY HARBOURS TARIFFS 2021 · 2020. 12. 8. · JERSEY HARBOURS TARIFFS 2021. COMMERCIAL TARIFFS 2021 Valid from 1 January 2021 SHIP CHARGE Per Call < 500 GT N/A 501 - 1,000 GT

JERSEY HARBOURS TARIFFS 2021 · 2020. 12. 8. · JERSEY HARBOURS TARIFFS 2021. COMMERCIAL TARIFFS 2021 Valid from 1 January 2021 SHIP CHARGE Per Call < 500 GT N/A 501 - 1,000 GT

TARIFFS MOBILE O2 and Vodafone. TARIFFS O2 Business Sharer (Core tariff) Parent Tariff Inclusive UK Mins Per Month Inclusive Texts Per Month Handsets.

TARIFFS MOBILE O2 and Vodafone. TARIFFS O2 Business Sharer (Core tariff) Parent Tariff Inclusive UK Mins Per Month Inclusive Texts Per Month Handsets.

GSHI Letterhead - Cover Letter...$ 18.63 $0.41 $0.79 $0.04 $/kWh 0.0093 $/kWh 0.0002 $/kWh (0.0003) $/kWh 0.0035 $/kWh (0.0014) $/kWh 0.0009 $/kWh 0.0059 $/kWh 0.0043 $/kWh 0.0036

GSHI Letterhead - Cover Letter...$ 18.63 $0.41 $0.79 $0.04 $/kWh 0.0093 $/kWh 0.0002 $/kWh (0.0003) $/kWh 0.0035 $/kWh (0.0014) $/kWh 0.0009 $/kWh 0.0059 $/kWh 0.0043 $/kWh 0.0036

Helping Change the Way Clients Produce Energy · Energy Charge $0.07306 / kWh 16,425 kWh $1,200 9,555 kWh $698 Total Cost per Month: $1,504 $1,002 Benefits to the Environment AND

Helping Change the Way Clients Produce Energy · Energy Charge $0.07306 / kWh 16,425 kWh $1,200 9,555 kWh $698 Total Cost per Month: $1,504 $1,002 Benefits to the Environment AND

Feed-in tariffs for Tasmania - Alternative technology · (27.785c/kWh) for electricity fed back into the grid from small (

Feed-in tariffs for Tasmania - Alternative technology · (27.785c/kWh) for electricity fed back into the grid from small (

City of Power ANDERSON, INDIANA - IN.govRate LP $1,860 Per~KVA Decrease $0,001203 Per-KWH Decrease Rate LP Off Peak $1.790 Per-KVA Decrease $0.002749 Per-KWH Decrease Rate CL $0,006714

City of Power ANDERSON, INDIANA - IN.govRate LP $1,860 Per~KVA Decrease $0,001203 Per-KWH Decrease Rate LP Off Peak $1.790 Per-KVA Decrease $0.002749 Per-KWH Decrease Rate CL $0,006714

WATER & ELECTRICITY TARIFFS 2017 - AADC · VILLA fils/kWh 7.84 AED/1,000 litres 26.8 Average daily consumption up to 5,000 litres/day Average daily consumption up to 200 kWh/day

WATER & ELECTRICITY TARIFFS 2017 - AADC · VILLA fils/kWh 7.84 AED/1,000 litres 26.8 Average daily consumption up to 5,000 litres/day Average daily consumption up to 200 kWh/day