Interaction study of Pasteurella multocida with culturable ...
REVIEW OF LITERATURE - Shodhgangashodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/772/9/09...REVIEW OF...
Transcript of REVIEW OF LITERATURE - Shodhgangashodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/772/9/09...REVIEW OF...
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
CHAPTER 3
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.1 Culturable Aerobic Heterotrophic Bacteria
Microorganisms present in coastal waters carry out many ecologically
important functions. The primary role of the heterotrophic bacteria is to serve as
carbon source to a variety of grazers and to decompose and mineralize
dissolved and particulate organic matter. They play an important role in the
utilization of organic carbon in the sea (Porneroy, 1974; Azam et ai., 1983;
Ducklow et a/., 1993). Changes in microbial activities caused by changes in
environmental conditions may therefore, cause significant impact on coastal
marine ecosystems.
2.2 Effect of temperature
Temperature is one of the most important factors which is known to
influence the growth and metabolism of aquatic organisms. Kinne (1 970)
reported that an increase in temperature of sea water resulted in an increased
rate of metabolism of the organisms and a reduction of its dissolved oxygen
content.
Information on the impact of thermal effect on marine and estuarine
organisms in temperate waters abounds literature (Videau et a!,, 1979; En'ckson
and Hawkins, 1980; Margreay et a/., 1981; Hall et at., 1982.; Sellner and Kachur,
1987; Langford, 1990; Karas, 1992; Mallin et al., 1994). Like wise, there are
extensive studies describing the distribution of bacterial densities depending on
changes in water temperature, salinity, abundance of nutrients, and physico-
chemical parameters (Jorgensen and Des Marais, 1988; Henneke and d e
Lange, 1990; Fong ef a/., 1993).
Choi et al., (2002) investigated the effects of thermal effluents on HNF
near Hadong Power Station, Korea. Additionally they have carried out
manipulation experiments at relatively high temperature (40°C). Increased
temperature had somewhat inhibiting effects on bacterial abundance and
bacterial population. After 1 h of exposure at 4U°C, bacterial abundance was
reported to decrease substantially (21 % reduction) compared to the control and
was still lower after 2 h of incubation. Further, they were of the view that thermal
effluents inhibited bacterial production and HNF grazing rates and abundance.
The increase in bacterial production, HNF abundance and HNF grazing rates
with distance from the power station were reported to be more pronounced in
summer than winter.
On the other hand Jiao et a/., (2005) while studying the dynamics of
autotrophic picoplankton and heterotrophic bacteria in the East China Sea,
reported that no correlations existed between temperature and heterotrophic
bacteria either in the winter or in the summer.
2.3 Nitrate reducing bacteria
Nitrogen is a major element of many biological metabolites and structural
molecules (amino acids, proteins, nucleic acids). In the marine environment, the
availability of nitrogen often is believed to be key in limiting growth and
productivity (Ryther and Dunstan, 1 971 ). Both f resh water and marine studies
have shown that bacteria may rely on both N H ~ + and NO< for growth and
biomass synthesis and overall they may be significant consumers of inorganic
nitrogen. Mean consumption values of 30% and 40% have been reported for
N H ~ and NO; respectively (Kirchrnan, 2000). Bacterial NOY assimilation is not
a pathway currently considered in pelagic carbon and nitrogen cycle models
(Fasham et al., 1990; Bissett et a/., 1999; Haupt ef al., 1999). Nitrogen can be
lost from ecosystems through the activities of microorganisms that use oxidized
forms of nitrogen as electron acceptors. Paerl and Zehr (2000) reported
bacterial respiration that results in the release of nitrous oxide and N2 gas and
nitrogen fixation to balance this loss.
Denitrifiers utilize nitrate and nitrite as respiratory substrates they can
respire using these oxides of nitrogen as electron acceptors in place of oxygen,
in the process converting, nitrate and nitrite to nitric oxide and nitrous oxide, and
finally to dinitrogen gas (Tiedje, 1988). Although denitrification involves several
semi independent steps that need not function together all the time, denitrifiers
begin the sequence with nitrate and produce varying amounts of the other
products depending on the environmental conditions (Ferguson, 1994).
Ogilvie et a/., (1 997) have studied NRB from estuarine sediments and
reported that the patterns of seasonal dominance within the NRB community
were due to the differential effects of temperature on the affinities for NO3 of the
summer and winter NRB populations.
2.3.1 Molecular identification of nitrate reducing bacteria
Of late molecular approaches have been successfully used to detect and
characterize bacteria and the genes that are important in several aspects of the
nitrogen cycle, including nitrification, dentrification, and nitrogen fixation (Scala
and Kerkhof, 1988; Zehr and McReynolds, 1989; Kirshtein ef al., 1991 ; Voytek
and Ward, 1995; Voytek et a]., 1997; Zehr and Paerl, 1997; Zehr and Hiorns
1998; Scala and Kerkhof 1999; Voytek et al., 1999; Zani et a!., 2000). Allen et
al., (2001) have employed a PCR approach to construct a database of nasA
genes to detect the genetic potential for heterotrophic bacterial nitrate utilization
in marine environments. A nested PCR primed by four degenerate
oligonucleotides was used (Gregory ef al., 2000) to amplify fragments of the
narG gene from Pseudomonas sp.
The narGHJl genes encoding the membrane-bound nitrate reductase
had been described from the Gram negative bacterium E. coli (Blasco et a/.,
1990) and the Gram positive bacterium B. subfilis (Hoffman et al., 1995). The
genes narZYMV encoding an isoenzyme of the E. coli nitrate reductase was
described by Blasco et a/., (1990).
nap provides the biochemical apparatus allowing nitrate respiration to
proceed in the presence of oxygen. In other cases nap is known to catalyse the
first step of an anaerobic denitrification pathway (Berks eta/., 1995; Bedzyk and
Ye, 1999). Flanagan (1999) used PCR based protocol for the detection of the
napA gene encoding the catalytic subunit of nap.
2.4 16s rDNA sequencing
The 16s rDNA gene encodes an RNA molecule that gives structure to
the small subunit of the eubacterial ribosome. The sequence of this gene
serves as a popular model for studies of bacterial evolution and taxonomy. The
DNA sequences of thel6S rDNA gene of many clinical and environmental
isolates are available over the internet through the National Center for
Biotechnology Information and the Ribosomal Database Project. These sites
also provide search algorithms to compare new sequences with their database
(Olsen, 1986).
2.4.1 Phylogenetic relationship
One major issue that haunts microbiologists is how to tackle the
identification of microorganisms. According to Hillis and Dixon (1 991 ) molecular
identification techniques involving the sequencing of the prokaryotic 16s rRNA
gene are useful in establishing coherent phylogenetic relationships at the
species level or higher. However Normand et at., (1996) were of the view that it
often lacks accuracy in discriminating strains within the same species and
sometimes even different species within the same genus (Martinez et a/., 2001).
2.5 Occurrence of P. ruthenica, Staphylococcus sp. and Bacillus sp.
Palaniappan and Krishnamurthy (1 985) reported that Bacillus sp. was
dominant in both water and sediment samples of the Bay of Bengal and Arabian
sea. Prabu et a/., (1991) reported that 7% of the total bacterial counts from Bay
of Bengal were constituted by Bacillus sp. Cavallo et al., (1999) have invariably
encountered Bacillus sp. in t h e Mar Piccolo of Taranto (lonian sea, Italy).
However, Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa were reported
to be occasionally found in water and sediment during the sampling period from
October 1996 to September 1997.
Pujalte et a/., (1999) in their studies on the seasonal fluctuations of the
main heterotrophic bacterial groups in Mediterranean sea water samples
observed Pseudoalteromonas sp . to be predominantly present at higher
temperature regimes.
2.6 Heat shock proteins
HSPs play a key role in cellular metabolism under all growth conditions,
assisting the folding, assembly and translocation of cellular proteins (Craig et
a/., 1993; Georgopoulos and Welch, 7 993; Hartl et al., A 994).
Ellis (1996) defined molecular chaperones as 'proteins that assist the
correct non-covalent assembly of other protein-containing structures in v i m but
are not permanent components of these structures when they are performing
their normal biological functions. However, Hendrick and Hartl (1 993)
alternatively defined HSP as a molecular chaperone that binds to and stabilizes
an otherwise unstable conformer of another protein, and by controlled binding
and release of the substrate protein facilitates its correct fate in vivo, be it
folding, oligomeric assembly, transport to another sub cellular compartment, or
controlled switching between activelinactive conformations. The precise nature
of peptide binding and the factors involved appeared to be chaperone
dependent, whereas ATP binding is important for the release of HSP9O
peptides (Grenert et a/., 1999). Pockley (2001) had reasons to believe that not
all stress proteins function as molecular chaperones and all those that fulfilled
an essential intracellular role and in the extracellular compartment, have t h e
capacity to mediate the induction of peptide-specific immunity.
Besides heat shock, other physiological stimuli also lead to the synthesis
of heat shock proteins. HSP synthesis in Listeria mesenteroides was found to
be stimulated in response to ethanol treatment. Ethanol induced HSPs in
diverse organisms as E. coii, yeast and mammalian cells (Travers and Mace,
1982; Lindquist, 1986). Production of heat shock proteins GroEL (65 kDa) and
DnaK (75 kDa) by Enterococcus faecium at temperature above 52°C was
identified by western blotting analysis (Laskowska et al., 2003). Cold shock
(exposure to 10°C) also was found to induce GroEL and DnaK homologues of
L. mesenteroides. Laskowska et a/., (2003) have reported the induction of DnaK
and DnaJ, CipB and IPB AIB HSPs in E. coli cells by trimethoprim.
Holmquist et al., (1993) reported induction of DnaK and GroEL
homologous proteins by heat shock and long term starvation in Vibrio
vulnificus, Vibrio sp. strain14 and Vibrio sp. DWI. In each Vibrio strain, 60 kDa
protein was reported to react with antibodies against E. coli - GroEL and two
proteins DnaK (69 kDa) and Sis 1 (60-62 kDa) reacted with antibodies against
E. COIL
2.7 Exopolysaccharides
Exopolysaccharides can be classified into two main groups viz., capsular
and slime polysaccharides, based on their general physical structures. Capsular
exopolymers are tightly bound to the cells forming an envelope, whereas slime
exopolymers are loosely bound to the cells and often diffuse into the immediate
environment. Capsular, complex extracellular polymorphic substances have
multiple industrial applications. For example Xanthomonas campestris,
produces xanthan gum which finds application in a number of different food and
industrial applications. Similarly marine biopolymers represent a vast resource
of untapped potential, for only a proportion of marine prokaryotes have been
cultivated (Sandford, 1 984).
EPS can function variously in surface adhesions, in protection from predation
and desiccation, in ionic interactions as enzyme stabilizers or concentrators as
storage or nutrient reserves and as dispersants to release bacteria from nutrient
spent surfaces (Dudrnan, 1977, Weiner et a/., 1995). Frolund et a/., (1995)
showed that EPS are composed of a variety of organic substances:
carbohydrates (Cescutti et al., 1999) and proteins (Dignac et a/., 1998) as major
constituents and humic substances (Frolund et al., 1995), uronic acids and
nucleic acids (Nielson et al., 1996) in minor quantities. Moreillo et al., (2003)
reported that EPS produced by Geobacillus sp. contains hexose: mannose:
Glucose and Galactose in the relative ratio of 0.5:0.0:0.3. EPS are usually
composed of high molecular weight capsular polysaccharides and have many
important functions in nature, including protecting parasitic organisms from
phagocytosis. Their major function in biofilm composition and physiology has
recently gained much attention (Poetra, 1996).
2.8 Properties of EPS
Rosenberg and co-workers (1983) have worked with several EPS with a
number of interesting properties. One group of EPS, isolated from bacteria that
colonize fish, was shown to have drag-reduction properties probably
responsible for enhanced fish mobility. Another type of EPS are ernulsan
(Zuckerberg et a/., 1979) produced most notably by Acinefobacter, believed to
adsorb oil-degrading bacteria from 'spent' hydrocarbon droplets (Rosenberg et
al., 1983). Applications for both of these polymers by industries including
petroleum and shipping are shown in Table I.
Table I. Biopolymers from marine bacteria with current or potential
commercial application*.
Polymer - - - - - - - -
Potential application(s)
Pigments
Polyesters
Complex polysaccharides Adhesions Underwater surface
and related extracellular coatings, bioadhesives
Polymeric substances Drag reducers Oil cleaning and viscosity
(EPS; normally capsular) Emulsan reduction.
Surfactant Dispersing agent,
grinding aid
Alg inate Food, textile, etc.
Metal-binding EPS
Melanins Biotechnology, reporter
gene, cosmetics, dyes,
colorings, sun screens
Poly 3-hydroxy Biodegradable plastics
(e.g., polyhydroxy
alkanates butyrate)
*Adopted from Weiner (1 997)
2.9 Mechanism of adhesion
It is generally accepted that one of the mechanisms by which
microorganisms adhere irreversibly to surfaces or substrata for survival and
growth is production of EPS (Sutherland, 1983; Read and Costerton, 1987; Abu
et a/., 1991). Polysaccharides may serve to anchor the producing bacteria to
substrata by participation of their polyhydroxy groups.
Two theoretical models have been proposed based on the colloid and
surface chemistry to evaluate and understand the interactions between the
surfaces. I. The DLVO (Derjaguin- Landau and Vewey - Overbeek) theory,
which takes into account the attractive Van der Walls interactions and repulsive
electrostatic interactions. 2. Thermodynamic models, in which the adhesive
interaction is treated as an equilibrium process and is described in terms of the
surface free energies of the bacterium substratum, and separating liquid.
2.10 Effect of carbon sources on EPS production
Linton (1990) reported that the amount of EPS production by organisms
was influenced by the carbon sources. Rodrigues and Bhosle (1991) have
reported that among various carbon sources such as glucose, fructose.
rnannitol and glycerol employed in the medium, glucose supported maximum
EPS production. However, Moriello et a/., (2003) reported that sucrose was the
best carbon source compared to glucose, fructose, galactose, trehalose,
mannose and cellobiose for maximal EPS production by Geobacillus sp.
Bacillus thermantarcticus was strongly induced for the production of EPS when
mannose was used as sole carbon source (Nicolaus et al., 2004).
2.1 1 EPS composition
Fletcher and Floodgate (1973) proposed the involvement of two
polysaccharides in t h e adhesive process of a marine pseudomonad. The first or
primary polysaccharide was believed to be produced in trace amounts and was
involved in t h e initial stages of adhesion, whilst the second or secondary
polysaccharide provided a firm attachment to the surface.
Sutherland (1 985) and Whitfield (1 988) reported that chemically,
bacterial EPS are highly heterogeneous polymers containing a number of
distinct monosaccharide and non-carbohydrate constituents, many of which are
strain specific and vary in size from l o 3 to 10'. Depending upon the
components of the repeat units, polysaccharides are usually negatively
charged, sometimes neutral or rarely positively charged (Tait et al., 1986) which
in turn can affect their capacity to interact with other polymers and cations
(Sutherland, 1990).
2.12 EPS purification
In recent years there has been a growing interest in the isolation and
identification of new marine polysaccharides that might have wider applications
in many industrial sectors. Many workers (Boyle and Reade, 1983; Read and
Costerton, 1987; Rodrigues and Bhosle, 1991 ; Bejar et a/., 1996) have shown
that monomeric sugar constituents present in EPS, bonding properties, group
distribution etc., greatly influence the physical and chemical properties of the
EPS.
In all the methods described by Abu et a/., (1991 ), Vincent et a/., (1994)
and Moriello et a/., (2003) the bacterial cells were pelleted by centrifugation and
the EPS in the supernatant was precipitated by addition of 95% ethanol. For
purification and characterization the EPS was subjected to gel filtration
chromatography and GC analysis.
2.13 Viscometric analysis of the EPS
Ha et al., (1991) reported that the apparent viscosity of the EPS from
Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens strains decreased by only 50 to 60%, when the shear
rate was increased from 20 to 1000 s"'.
Vincent et al., (1 994) noted that the EPS produced by Alteromonas strain
HYD 1545 was a polyelectrolyte and the viscosity of its solutions depended on
the ionic strength. The decrease in viscosity observed with increasing NaCl
concentrations and the effect of ca2' in decreasing the viscosity at low ca2'
concentrations were thus claimed to support a model in which the
polysaccharide carries anionic groups.
Bejar et a/., (I 996) reported that a moderately hemophilic eubacterium
Vibrio eurihalina produced EPS that showed pseudoplastic non-newtonian
behaviour quite resistant to high ionic strength and temperature. Rheological
behaviour of the EPS was reported to depend on sugar residues, linkage
pattern and occurrence of intra and intermolecular interactions. They also
reported that viscosity and pseudo plasticity of the polymer solutions were
influenced by the nutritional conditions in which the microorganism was grown.
Vicente-Garcia et a/. , (2004) reported that the cyano bacterium Phormidium 94a
synthesized EPS that showed Newtonian behavior at lower EPS concentrations
and pseudoplastic nature at higher concentrations.
2.14 Effect of ionic concentration on the viscosity of EPS
The EPS produced by HYDI-1545 strains showed stabilization and
increase in viscosity with increase in calcium chloride concentrations d u e to
inter molecular bonds or the polymer conformational change. Decrease in
viscosity due to addition of sodium chloride to EPS solution was reported by
van den Berg et a/., (1 995) for the EPS produced by Lactobacillus sake 0-1.
Calvo et a/., (1998) have studied the effects of monovalent and divalent
cations on the rheological behaviour of Halomonas eurihalina EPS and showed
the highest viscosity value. A loss of sulfate content seemed to correlate with
the increase in viscosity. Addition of hydrophobic substrates to culture media
were reported to lead to changes in chemical composition and emulsifying
activity of the EPS.
2.1 5 Structural studies
Compositional and structural studies of pure EPS produced by different
microorganisms can shed more light on the mechanism involved in the
adhesion process. FTl R spectra of EPS produced by Alteromonas macleodii
subsp. fiiensis exhibited a broad 0-H stretching variation (Raguenes et a/.,
1996). Based on FTlR spectral analysis Abu eta/., ('l991) reported that the EPS
produced by S. colwelliana contained polyhydroxy compounds. Ha et a/. , (1 991 )
reported that FTlR spectrum of the EPS produced by Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens
strains (F2d, CF3, CF3a, CFS, and H l Ob) exhibited a broad 0-H stretching, a
minor C-H stretching and several C-0 stretching and COOH structure. The
FTl R spectrum of the EPS produced by Pseudomonas alcaligenes showed
strong peaks for 0-H stretching, C=O stretching and C-0 stretching, indicating
t h e presence of these functional groups in the EPS. Vincente- Garcia et a/.,
(2004) have reported that the IR spectrum of the EPS produced by Phormidium
9423 exhibited OH stretching and CH stretching frequency and carboxylated
group. Similar observation was also reported by Nichols et al., (2004) in an
Antarctic marine bacterium Pseudoalteromonas sp.
Abu et a/., (1991) reported that EPS produced by S. co/welliana
predominantly consisted of glucose. EPS produced by V. fischeri was shown
(Rodrigues and Bhosle, 1991) to consist of glucose, galactose, mannose,
arabinose and rhamnose in t h e ratio of 3.4:3.7:1.5:0.6:0.7. Bejar ef al., (1 996)
noted that the relative sugar composition of the EPS produced by H. eurihalina
was greatly influenced by the composition of the growth medium. The EPS
contained rhamnose and glucose, mannose in a lower proportion and an
unknown additional compound. Wai et a/., (1998) analysed the EPS produced
by V. cholerae and reported it to be composed of N-acetyl D glucosarnine, D-
mannose, 6-deoxy D-galactose and D-galactose in the molar ratio of
7.4:10.2:2.4:3.0. EPS produced by A. infernus was found to be composed of
galactose, glucose, rhamnose, mannose, glucoseUA galactoseUA, lactose
glucoseUA in the ratio of I 5.2: 16.3:0.2:0.0: 10.9:6.3:0.0 (Raguenes et a/. ,
2003). Nichols et a/., (2004) have reported that EPS produced by Geobacillus
sp. isolate CAM 2005 and isolate CAM 036 composed of arabinose, ribose,
rhamnose, fructose, galactose A, mannose, galactose, glucose, galactoseNAc
in the molar ratio of 1.0:0.3:1 . I :0.4:6.4:0.3:13.3:12.8:0.1 and 1.0:0.0:0.0:7.2:
5.8:0.4:6.1:2.6 respectively.
2.16 Biofilms
Biofilms can be regarded as microbial consortia in which different
microbial strains and species efficiently cooperate in order to protect
themselves against environmental stresses, and to facilitate efficient nutrient
uptake and utilization. Most often, biofilms are unwanted and related to diverse
problems as microbially induced corrosion of oil-rigs and food, drinking water
contamination, (Notermans e f a/., 1991 and Flint et a/., 1997) dental caries and
periodontal diseases (Marsh and Martin, 1992) and a variety of biomaterial
centered infections in man, pipelines and reduced heat transfer efficiency,
(Turetgen, 2004). Biofilms most often help in nutrient cycling of carbon and
minerals such as N, P and sulphur ions. In microorganisms capable of nitrogen
fixation, biofilms protect the nitrogenase enzyme from inactivation by
atomospheric oxygen (Chan et a/., 1997; Bazylinski et al., 2000).
Bacterial colonization is known to occur on both living and non living
surfaces like contact lenses, ship hulls, dairy and petroleum pipelines, rocks in
streams and all varieties of biomedical implants and transcutaneous devices
(Costerton et a/., 1987; Carpentier and Cerf, 1993; Elder et a/., 1995; Costerton
eta/ . , 1995; 1999). In many circumstances, the surface might also be a nutrient
source, such as cellulose in the paper industry.
2.17 Mechanism of biofilm formation
Gottenbos et al., (2000) have described various steps involved in the
formation of biofilm. The mechanisms involved are: 1. When organic matter is
present, a conditioning film of adsorbed components is formed on the surface
prior to the arrival of the first organisms. 2. Microorganisms are transported to
the surface through diffusion, convection, sedimentation or active movement. 3.
Initial microbial adhesion occurs. 4. Attachment of adhering microorganisms is
strengthened through exopolymer production and unfolding of cell surface
structures. 5. Surface growth of attached microorganism and continued
secretion of exopolymers. 6. Localized detachment of biofilm organisms caused
by occasionally high fluid shear or other detachment forces operative. Three
basic ingredients of biofilm reported are microbes, EPS and surface. If one of
these components is removed from the mix, a biofilm does not develop.
By using phase-contrast microscopy to analyze a collection of mutants
that are defective for surface attachment, flagella and type-lV pili were shown to
play important roles in the early events in biofilm development by P. aeruginosa.
These observations are consistent with previous studies that strongly hinted at
the roles of these cell surface structures in the adhesion of bacteria to a wide
variety of surfaces (De Wager et a/., 1987; Doig et a/., 1988; Ramphal et a/.,
1991 ; Simpson et a/., 1992; Prince, 1992; Grant et a/., 1993; Fletcher, 1996;
Smyth eta/., 1996). In addition to flagella and pili, Makin and Beveridge, (1996)
have reported that changes in lipopolysaccarides result in altered attachment
behavior. In particular, it was shown that in P. aeruginosa strains that make two
types of lipopolysaccarides (A and B band), loss of B-band LPS by mutation
reduced attachment to hydrophilic surfaces and increased attachment to
hydrophobic surfaces.
Watnick et a/., (1999) reported that V. cholerae require flagella-mediated
motility, the mannose-sensitive type-lV pilus encoded by the mshA locus, and
synthesis of the major EPS to form a wild-type biofilm. Further, they have
shown that flagella and type-IV pili were not absolutely required for initial
attachment to the surface, but they greatly facilitated this process in
V. cholerae.
Recent studies by Cramton (1999) and colleagues have shown that
S. aureus, like S. epidermidis, has the ica locus, which encodes the functions
required for intracellular adhesion. These data suggest that the early stages in
biofilm formation may be similar between these two organisms.
Enterococci are important pathogens in device-related infections and like
other Gram-positive organisms, the formation of enterococcal biofilms on
medical implants is an increasing clinical issue (Barie et a/., 1990; Stickler et a/.,
1993; Venditti et a/., 1993). As for other organisms, growth in a biofilm confers
Enterococcus sp. with an increased resistance to antibiotics (Foley and Gilbert,
1997).
2.18 Surface conditioning
Primary contact generally occurs between an organism and a
conditioned surface and the hydrophobicity of the latter can vary greatly
depending on the molecules in the conditioning film. Wang et a/., (1993)
demonstrated that primary adhesion of S. epidermidis to polyethylene disks was
enhanced in the presence of surface-activated platelets and reduced by
adsorbed plasma proteins relative to uncoated polyethylene. Using
polymethylmethacrylate as a substratum, Herrmann et a/., (1988) showed that
the adhesion of coagulase-negative Staphylococci was enhanced when the
surface was coated with various plasma proteins, including fibronectin.
A net repulsion between two surfaces can be overcome by specific
molecular interactions mediated by adhesins located on structures extending
from the cell surface, such as pili (An et al., 2000; Boland et a/., 2000). The
longevity of primary adhesion was reported to depend on the sum total of all
these variables, but surface chemistry pushed the equilibrium in favor of
adhesion by predicting that organic substances in solution did concentrate near
a surface and that microorganisms tended to congregate in nutrient-rich
environments.
2.19 Biofilm estimation
Biofilm formation may be determined in several different ways but most
frequently it was done by the tube test (Christensen eta/., 1982; 1985) in which
the bacterial film lining a culture tube is stained with a cationic dye and visually
scaled, or by the microtiter plate test (Christensen et a/., 1985) in which the
optical density of the stained bacterial film is determined spectrophotometrically.
Stepanovic ef a/., (2000) have quantified the biofilm formation of
Staphylococcus sp. using tube test and microtiter plate test wells. The growth of
31 coded Listeria monocytogenes strains were measured by their growth in
PVC microtiter plate wells and biofilm formation was indirectly assessed by
staining with 1% crystal violet and measuring crystal violet absorbance, using
destaining solution. Since cellular growth rates and final cell densities did not
correlate with biofilm formation, they have indicated that differences in biofilm
formation under the same environmental conditions were not due to growth rate
differences (Djordjevic etal., 2002). Vasudevan ef al., (2003) have reported that
the individual strains of S. aureus varied in their biofilm forming ability on the
microtiter plate wells. Narisawa et a/., (2005) estimated biofilm formation by the
cell number of E. coli in microtiter plate wells.
2.20 Structure of biofilms
With the advent of inexpensive high-speed computers and increasingly
sophisticated software, great strides have been made leading to transformation
of traditional microscopic observation into the discipline of analytical imaging. Of
the many recent digital imaging devices now available, CLSM. (Shotton, 1989)
has proven particularly well suited for the study of microbial biofilms. CLSM
allows the nondestructive, in situ analysis of living, fully hydrated biofilms
without the need for harsh chemical fixation or embedding techniques. This
feature, coupled with the ability to digitally extract optical thin sections from
specific biofilm locations, free from out-of-focus optical interference, permits the
direct examination of complex xy and xz spatial and chemical relationships that
exist between bacteria, their extracellular products, and their environment
(Wilson, 1990).
Of late, CLSM is increasingly used to provide detailed information on cell
morphology, cellular metabolism, cell phylogeny, microenvironment chemistry,
as well as the physical architecture and chemistry of the biofilm matrix and
associated polymers. Earlier studies using both light and electron microscopy
had suggested that microbial biofilms were heterogeneous in structure (Bakke
and Olson, 1986; Costerton ef a/., 1995). The episcopic nature of CLSM also
enables the examination of biofilms cultivated on non transparent surfaces
(Lawrence et a/., 1991 ; Caldwell et a/., 1992).
2.20.1 Biofilm architecture
The biofilm "architecture" (Lawrence et a/., 1991), is often species-
specific for pure-culture biofilms, as well as substrate-specific for certain
microbial consortia (Wolfaardt et at., 1994). Notably, heterogeneous biofilm
architecture does not appear to be the sole function, or the result, of mixtures of
different organisms with variable growth habits inhabiting a similar niche. Pure-
culture biofllms also accommodate many of the heterogeneous features found
in mixed-culture biofilms, suggesting a fundamental relationship between biofilm
structure and in situ function (Venugopalan eta/. , 2005). Many workers (Korber
et a/., 1993; 1993; 1994; 1994; Lawrence and Korber, 1994) have claimed that
basic functional requisites underlie biofilm structure, and that structural diversity
actually reflects the adaptation of unicellular organisms to a diverse range of
physical, chemical, and communal circumstances on surfaces.
2.20.2 Biofilm thickness and Coverage analysis
Lawrence et a/., (1991) in their elegant studies have shown that
variability in the distribution of biomass of 24 h P. fluorescens, P. aeruginosa,
and V. parahaemolyticus biofilms was governed by the tendency for biofilm
bacteria to form aggregates at different horizontal and vertical sites and the
area of highest cell density varied among different species. P. aeruginosa
biofilm was characterized by a dense cell mass located near the biofilm base,
whereas V. parahaemolyticus biofilm exhibited an inverted pyramid structure,
with the most biofilm biomass located nearest the biofilm-liquid interface.
Significantly, studies of this nature (Lawrence et a/., 1991; Korber ef a/., 1992;
Korber ef a/., 1994) have repeatedly confirmed that living biofilms were highly
hydrated, with 50-90°h of the total area at each sectioning depth consisting
either of polymer and / or void space.
Sectional analyses of each biofilm layer ( I-pm thickness) carried out by
Takenaka ef a/., (2001) demonstrated the three dimensional development of
biofilms and revealed that the biofilms were 9 pm in height after 12 h. The
biofilm thickness of Citrobacter sp. on glass slides showed 10.5 pm after 72 h,
45.3 pm after 96 h and 121.8 pm after 120 h measured by CLSM (Allan ef a/.,
2002).
2.21 Biofilm formation on metallic and non metallic surfaces
Sonak and Bhosle (1 995) reported the growth of biofilm formation on four
surfaces. The number of Vibrio cells attached to aluminum panels was
reportedly high, probably because of the roughness of the aluminum panels. It
was their observation that rough surfaces being more conducive always
supported better bacterial attachment than smooth surfaces. Bott (1993)
reported that electro polished stainless steel and fluorinated enzyme propylene
and glass tubes were less amenable to biofilm growth than untreated stainless
steel 31 6.
The biofilm formation of L. monocytogenes on both hydrophilic (stainless
steel) and hydrophobic (Polytetrafluroethylene, PTEF) surfaces at different
temperature and growth phases was analyzed (Chavant et a/., 2002) and the
biofilm growth was reported to be faster on the hydrophilic surfaces compared
to hydrophobic surfaces and were negatively correlated with growth
temperature.
Martino et a/., (2003) reported that the Klebsiella pneumoniae (F. 3051)
reference strain expressing only type I fimbriae adhered slightly to glass and
polystyrene. K. pneumoniae IA 565 and CF3 3097 reference strains producing
type 1 and type 3 fimbriae showed efficient adherence to both glass and
polypropylene and biofilm formation on polystyrene. A correlation was observed
between adherence properties to glass or polypropylene and biofilm
development on polystyrene indicating that bacterial adherence to non
biological surfaces constituted the first step in K. pneumoniae biofilm
development.
2.22 Chlorine
Chlorine is generally used as a powerful popular disinfectant and is
easily available for control of bacterial growth in drinking water and cooling
water systems. Sodium hypochlorite is the oldest and most widely used of the
chlorine compounds employed in chemical disinfection. It has been shown
experimentally that the bactericidal action of chlorine releasing agents results
from an oxidative interaction with the sulfydryl groups on certain enzymes in the
cell membrane or protoplasts.
Chlorine is known to exert disruptive effects on subcellular processes
(Haas and Gould, 1979) including the following (i) in vitro formation of
chlorinated derivatives of purine and pyrimidine nucleotide bases (Dennis et a/.,
1979). (ii) oxidative decarboxylation of amino acids (Pereira et a/., 1973) and
other naturally occurring carboxylic acids (Larson and Rockwell., 1979). (iii)
lnhibition of enzymes in void in intermediatory metabolism (Camper and
Macfeters, 1979). (iv) lnhibition of protein biosynthesis (Benarde et al., 1967) (v)
Introduction of single and double stranded lesions in the bacterial chromosome
(Shih and Lederberg, 1976). (vi) Production of bacterial mutations. (vii)
lnhibition of membrane mediated active transport processes and respiration
activity (Camper and Mcfeters, 1979) and (viii) Uncoupling of oxidative
phosphorylation accompanied by leakage of macromolecules from the cell
(Wenkobachar et a/., 1975; 1977).
2.22.1 influence o f added chlorine on detachment of P. ruthenica cells
Pitts et a/., (2003) developed a quantitative spectrometric method to
measure the removal and killing efficacy of antibiofilm agents using the
respiratory indicator 5-cyano-2, 3-ditolyl tetrazolium chloride. The percentage
reductions at 100 and 1000 mg/l concentrations were significantly greater than
at the 1 mg/l concentration for both Pseudomonas and Staphylococcus biofilm.
2.22.2 Biofilm detachment and viable counts
Both for P. aeruginosa and S. epidermidis the analysis of variance
reportedly showed that the mean log reductions at the 100 and I000 mg/l were
statistically significantly greater than at the 1 mgll concentration. Gilbert ef a/.,
(2001) used two cationic biocides phenoxy ethanol and cetrimide for removal of
biofilm grown in microtiter plate wells by end turbidity endpoint and viable count
method. Pitts et a/., (2003) reported that sodium hypochlorite was used for the
removal of biofilm attached to the microtiter plate by viable count method. The
conventional log reduction response based on viable cell counts provided
essentially the same trends as the percentage reduction in respiratory dye 5-
cyano-2-3 ditolyl tetrazolium chloride absorbance.
2.23 Observations of biofilm detachment by CLSM
Takenaka et a/., (2001) reported that when 12 h old biofilms were
exposed to ciprofloxacin at minimum bactericidal concentration of 6.26 pglml for
90 min, all the organisms were killed, but some organisms in 24 h old biofilms
with thicker and denser structure were still alive after exposure for 120 min.
Lindsay ef a/., (2002) reported the differential efficacy of a chlorine
dioxide against single and binary biofilms of a dairy associated Bacillus cereus
and P. fluorescens. In their work the survival of P. fluorescens M2 cells after
exposure to chlorine dioxide was observed to be enhanced by the presence of
B. cereus in binary biofilms. However, 5. cereus apparently showed increased
susceptibility to chlorine dioxide in the presence of P. fluorescens.
According to Ren et a/., (2002) furanone was found to inhibit both the
growth of B. substilis and its swarming motility in a concentration dependent
way. In addition, as shown by CLSM, furanone was reported to inhibit the
biofilm formation of B. substilis. At 40 pg ml-', furanone decreased the biofilm
thickness by 25%, decreased the number of water channels, and reduced the
percentage of live cells by 63%.
Lomander et a/., (2004) examined the effectiveness of chlorine as a
killing and or biofilm removal agent on stainless steel surfaces of three different
morphologies. They have found that overall the growth trends of the biofilm on a
polished stainless steel surface followed those on a scribed surface.
2.24 Planktonic biofilrn inhibition
Cochran et al., (2000) reported that biofilm of P. aeruginosa attached to
alginate gel beads in sparse, thin biofilm exhibited reduced susceptibility to
monochloramine and hydrogen peroxide compared with same plantkonic cells
of the microorganisms. Disinfection rate coefficient for planktonic bacteria
averaged 0.551 mg I-' ml-' for monochloramine. The corresponding values for
24 h old biofilms reportedly were 0.291 mg/l and 9.2 X l o 5 mg-' mi-' for
monochloramine and hydrogen peroxide respectively. They have reported no
correlation between biofilm susceptibility and biofilm initial area cell density.
While studying the efficacy of alkaline hypochlorite and chlorosulfamates
on two species of biofilms of P. aeruginosa and K. pneumoniae, Stewart eta/. ,
(2001) observed superior penetration by chlorosulfamate due to reduced
reaction with constituents of the biofilm. Poor biofilm killing despite
measurement of effective typical penetration of the antimicrobial agent into the
biofilm, they claimed, demonstrated that bacteria in the biofilm were protected
by some mechanism other than simple physical shielding by the biofilm matrix.
Turetgen (2004) compared the efficacy of free residual chlorine and
monochloramine against biofilms in model and full scale cooling towers and
reported that monochloramine was significantly more effective than free chlorine
against cooling water biofilm. Scher ef a/., (2005) investigated the role of a
biofilm at the inter surface between air and pellicle in the susceptibility of
S. enferica serovar typhimurium to stress conditions. They reported that pellicle
cells were significantly more resistant to chlorination, wherein surrounding
matrix conferred protection against the reactive sodium hypochlorite.
2.25 Biofilm detachment by chemical biocide
Ortho-phthalaldehyde (OPA) is a new type of disinfectant that is claimed
to have a highly potent bactericidal and sporicidal activity (McDonnel and
Russel, 1999; Cabrera-Martinez ef a/, 2002). Simes ef a/., (2003) used OPA to
control biofilms formed by P. fluorescens on stainless steel surfaces. The higher
concentrations of OPA and longer exposure were needed to inactivate
P. fluorescens than planktonic populations, thus denoting that sessile bacteria
have a reduced susceptibility to OPA.
2.26 Biofilm detachment by laser treatment
The impact of laser assessment in a biofilm forming bacterium
Pseudoalteromonas carrageenovora was studied by Nandakumar et a/., (2003)
using flow cytometric system and the results revealed that in a flowing system,
low power pulsed larger irradiations could reduce the bacterial attachment
eventhough it did not cause significant mortality.
Bott (2000) demonstrated that control of biofilm formation and the
removal of established biofilms on the inside of tubes could be achieved by
ultrasound technology.
2.27 Effect of copper complexes on biofilm formation
Copper and copper alloys have long been successfully used in marine
applications because of good mechanical strength and workability, corrosion
resistance, good thermal conductivity and resistance to macro fouling.
Application includes distribution and piping systems, heat exchangers and
intake screens (Moreton and Glover, 1980; Blunn, 1987; Kirk, 1987; Little et a/.,
1996).
Teitzel and Parsek, (2003) reported the effect of heavy metals copper,
lead and zinc on biofilm and planktoinc P. aeruginosa. It was reported that
biofilms were anywhere from 2 to 600 times more resistant to heavy metal
stress than free swimming cells. When planktonic cells at different stages of
growth were examined it was found that logarithmically growing cells were more
resistant to heavy metals than stationary phase cells. However, biofilm were
observed to be more resistant to heavy metals than either stationary phase or
logarithmically growing planktonic cells. The exterior of the biofilm was
preferentially killed after exposure to elevated concentrations of copper and the
majority of the swimming cells were near the substratum. A potential
explanation offered by Teitzel and Parsek. (2003) for this phenomenon was that
the extracellular polymeric substances that encase a biofilm may be responsible
for protecting cells from heavy metal stress by binding the heavy metals and
retarding their diffusion within the biofilm.
Barranguet eta/. , (2000) while studying effects of heavy metal on aquatic
biofilms, showed that Cu affects the physiology of phototrophic organisms.
Massieux et a/., (2004) investigated the effects of copper on the structure and
physiology of fresh water biofilm microbial communities. For this purpose,
biofilms that were grown during 4 weeks in a shallow, slightly polluted ditch
were exposed to the copper concentrations. Denaturing gradient gel
electrophoresis revealed changes in the bacterial community in all aquaria. The
extent of change was related to the concentration of copper applied, indicating
that copper directly or indirectly caused the effects. However, they were of the
opinion that copper did affect the physiology of the phototrophic community, as
evidenced by the fact that a decrease in photosynthetic activity was detected in
the treatment with the highest copper concentration.