AERAj2oo1ojMYfPjEICljCjMumjCP-IIj2016-17/Vol-I Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India

*****

AERA Building, Administrative Complex,

Safdarjung Airport, New Delhi - 110 003.

Date: 11.10.2017

Public Notice NO.31!2017-18

Sub: Comments/Submissions received from stakeholders on Consultation Paper No. 10/2017-18 dated 20.06.2017 in the matter of determination of Courier Cargo Operations in respect of Express Industry Council of India (EICI), Mumbai Airport for the second control period (01.04.2016-31.03.2021).

Attention of all concerned is invited to the Stakeholder Consultation Meeting held on 21.09.2017 in the office of AERA and the Public Notice No. 29/2017-18 dated 28.09.2017 issued by the Authority wherein, the Authority allowed the stakeholders to submit their comments on Consultation Paper No. 10/2017-18 dated 20.06.2017 on or before 05.10.2017. Further the Authority vide above mentioned Public Notice notified to keep the EICI Order No. 11/2017-18 dated 14.08.2017 in abeyance till 31.10.2017.

In response thereof, the Authority has received comments/submissions from the following stakeholders.

si No. Stakeholder Details

1. Cour iers ,I . . - "" " , ,,., O ~ I " r ' '-' 'J)S~ uCl<ll/ , JU ., I • I ( I tl ~ l .h .

2. Air Travelle rs Associa t i il (ATAl.

The comments / submissions received, as above, are attached for information of all concerned.

Raje~a AGM (Fin.)

Encl.: As above.

j

--3­

OF INDIA Ground Floor. 'B' Wing, Wilson House, Nagardas Road. Andheri ( ), Mumbai - 400 069. Tel.:+91 (022) 28 21 <~ 301

Mob . :+~!/~g~~91677 . Email:cai@ca i.india.com. Website:www.cai@cai-india.com

To, The Chairman Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India AERA Building Administrative Complex Safdarjung Airport New Delhi 110003

Dear Sir,

SUB: Request for Data for preparing submissions relating to AERA order no:11/2017-18

At the outset we would like to thank You for holding the stake holders meeting on 21/09/2017 and allowing The Couriers Association of .India to make their submissions towards the said order.

However we would like to point out that certain vital data needed to prepare our submissions is missing or not provided to the stakeh olders along with AERA order no 11/2017-18.

.­We would therefore request The Authority to furnish the following data which is an integral part on the working as to how AERA arrived at the MYTP for the present control period.

1. mber & Detail of Assets - (Regulatory Asset Base) of previous and current Control Period .

2. Bifurcated 1Scheme wise CAPEX for previous and current Control Period.

~:I J \ '1 3. Location-wise bifurcated OPEX as below for the FY 2011-2012 to FY 2016-2017 0-- ,a) Salaries.

b) Provident fund c) Employee welfare expenses. d) Overtime. e) Conveyance f) Medical Expense. e) Numbers and names of Employees. f) Repair & Maintenance.

M la..e....t.- g) Admin Expenditure . h) Advertisement. i) Legal Expend iture .

~') JJI Electricity & ~ater .

' 1<) House Keeping . I) Rent.

~..,. ,~'L¢. m) Licence fee.

k~ n) Royalty . 0) Internet.

~M C' '\ p) Cost of outsourced work - vendor wise detail s. ) q) Customs cost recovery .

r) Travelling Expenses s) Bank fees & Interest charges t) Depreciation

4. How did EICI calculate exact Fair Rate of Return as EICI is not having equity .

Incorporated as a limited company under sect ion 25 of the Comp anies Act. 1956.

-,­COURIERS ASSOCIATION OF I DIA - ) Ground Floor, 'B' Wing, Wilson House, Nagardas Road. Andheri ( ), Mumbai - 400 069. Tel.:+91 (022) 2821-3301 Mob.:+91 9920801677 , Email:cai@c i-india.com. WelJsilo:www.cai@cai-india.com

5. As per information available on MCA site, EICI has been ~Iing a consolidated balance sheet for its pan India operations but for purposes of MYTP they have submitted data specific to Mumbai operations . The Author ity has mentioned that they have gone through the audited balance sheet of EICI, to arrive at MYTP for Mumbai operation of EICI, if there is a separate audited balance sheet only for Mumbai operations the Authority is requested to share the same.

As The Authority can apprec iate it is difficult to prepare our submissions withou t this data we hereby humbly request the same to be provided at the earliest.

Thanking You

Yours Sincerely

~ha b rAhmed ~es i den l

Incorporated as a limited company under section 25 of the Companies Act. 1956.

- JO­

AIR TRAVELLERS ASSOCIATION (A 'no profit' Association and Voice of Air Travell~erS) ,~.~ r-, s- Website: www.airtravellersa ~ so ~iation.org '-"i '; ' (X

A IR TRA V ELL E RS A S S O C IATI O N Of -3)-0~ (J-<j) J.,) C-\""\ ; )C ~ ",Vi , <," \ ,\0

D.6 / 10/ )'1- 1\ L.\C\'S\' ;)T~~,,'2-4)t .. 5 'V\\ \

' l II , q·fl·llm'f mJ'ijl[) lilf-fJITW lm~

~1 1 1)' ; \Jill ~R. ~ ~-1 10003F: <; !. No : f\ TAr- i i J] - li3j l '\ ;) :~ \ " P I 26 . 20 l J TGf

~~~' ~~ . o:···..~ LT·i~~ · ,l · ·~....·..·········,',· ······'r h(: ( JI<J i r"llB I I

•b.:r-rI O I" ' " r-: t CO, l lnn· I I ' : ~ ""' 1,1" 'l C1I, ' V I .. v "'.

- '..L ..I 1:, . ,I \. ..'1 • . ·i _( I t . " : . .... (); . '\ ' -.J 'l lv m 1... I of ' l)cJi "C::J

/\ 1: F /\ ['l il il d in g , l\ci r ~ i l'l j ~ : I: I' ~J ::i vc~ Cn rn fJ l:.. ~· : y'( I'" l('l ~ '7\"'~;\1- 2;:C~~~J1~' \ "-,,} 'I' l! ::,j JU I'l ei '\II -pu r : , 1" ;1 1 J l)r.ltr:." \ / Uf.ihi ~ \J~,/'J t" ty$ I .

~3 u .j ,-:: ct : The Sta keholder (on~;u l ar ion IVie et ings fer Ex ~ ress Cargo perat lons of EXPf '., in d rj ~, t:y Cc u d l of Indta (El "1) in respect o f' Chha rrapati Sh iva ji lnt ~ nY t ic nal irpert ,

j\/iu n1 a l, f t.>!, j H; Sec u n d Con t ro l Pe io d (Ol ,04 .,Wl l) t o :!n . 3. 01 1 /

,'1 )15 I'; t o Ula n k yo u <.i9 L1 1n f CJJ in vi tin q us fOJ Stakeho lders Consult at ion tJ1 eet.inD i1 ,;'i :'! on :~ 1 , n '·) . 2017 a t :. 1..0 0 A 'M :11: fl,l::HA f3 ui!(ji nq, SC1fcJa l)u ng l \i r'[JOrt , l\JelA' De ih l.

·';\I e. w ou ld 11i> \: I:ke t o ciJ !w ey Vie w s o f I\V 5 Air: Trave llers Asso ciat ion ( Al A) to r k ind C· )!, :; i d t ~! ' ,' j!] , :,n ' ) l 'y'i) i! ( C li(! :

1. D (lCI'l," d :,c; jrj th ' t' d !,li1dt V !tilb:<11,.io n: / ~~ r h (~ 11', ,: , l rI t'i~ ;1 o n f"H th ." ini.re ase in the' tariff c1 <l if11 is due to decrease in r:.a paCl'lV ut il iZ;i \ i; 11 In

such Si tu ,I IL" 1 f. ICj should plao [o r adj usm w nt and redu ct ion of infrastructure expl~ I1 ~, ? '; .

/ ---Ttw w ,~ X r ri ~ IlSe5 ;) f C verv high at EIC- lvlum bai in com paris on to t heir own stat ions at ur fl(''i

1')C0:iC' 1S h .,' "lt: c the se I' x pe f1 S (~ ! i sl.ould ce rf~ d t:E.:( I.

/ it i ~:, 5 lJg l~e s t() j f h i l t t he hi;\I1dling ra tes may be rev ised annually in st ead of revising it ,:,Her :' !r 'I ,;;,

interva l v/ )id l becomes very high in comparison w it h the previous rel ies in vogue.

'V\j iC' once aqal l l i l!<c to l hank j\ Er,A and oth er st ake holders for giv inSj us t his opport : I(dl"y t. ~ !] '--;

il U -; of' s incere opr ruun UVll: t h is type of lntera ct lon will ultimately resu lt' In benefit.s 10 (l i t el l ;! c.istom ers .

------.. D ,L

./

Regd.Office: G-82, Ground Floor, Lajpat Nagar, New Delhi - 110024 Mailing Address: Post Box 6804, Punjabi Bagh, New Delhi - 110026

Phone: 011-64541718 Email: atahqdel@gmail.com