q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s...

106
q$}T7s8}j ]Bts{ Nssj 3B{R $t qs}}$t stI ]Bts{ BI !}s$Bt BP Y VB8${ 3B{ ${BR{B} Ak V8B 3s$I 7ZA8$I B Y {Yst${sj et$t$t $t }s$sj PZjhjj8t BP Y JZ$8tR PB Y I BP s{YjB BP 7{$t{ s Y V77V]<=7eqq7 yW7qyq=qe !3 qe]<W!N!pO FZt 1((( { o sRRs{YZRR ytR$Z BP q{YtBjBk 1((( Vjj $YR R%I VZYB {Yst${sj et$t$t sk 11 1((( ]$hIAk s8sj OBZ{PTqBZ8$ _BPRRB qYR$R 7Z}%$RB V{{}IAk _BPRRB etR p ]s%sjYB ]Ys$8st =tIsIZs qYR$R ]B88$

Transcript of q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s...

Page 1: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

q$}T7s8}j� ]Bt�s{� Ns���sj 3B�{�R $t qs}}$t� stI ]Bt�s{�

�BI� !}��s�$Bt BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}�

Ak

V8�B �� 3s�$I

7ZA8$���I �B �Y� ��{Yst${sj et�$t���$t�$t }s��$sj PZjhjj8�t� BP �Y� ��JZ$��8�t�R PB� �Y� I����� BP

s{Y�jB� BP 7{$�t{�

s� �Y�

�V77V]<=7eqq7 yW7qyq=qe !3 qe]<W!N!pO

FZt� 1(((

{o �sRRs{YZR���R ytR�$�Z�� BP q�{YtBjB�k 1(((� Vjj �$�Y�R ��R��%�I�

VZ�YB� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���{Yst${sj et�$t���$t�

�sk 11� 1(((

]���$h�I Ak� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��s8sj OBZ{�PTqBZ8$

_�BP�RRB�qY�R$R 7Z}��%$RB�

V{{�}��I Ak � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �_�BP�RRB� e�t�R� p� ]�s%sjYB

]Ys$�8st� =tI����sIZs�� qY�R$R ]B88$����

Page 2: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

q$}T7s8}j� ]Bt�s{� Ns���sj 3B�{�R $t qs}}$t� stI ]Bt�s{� �BI�

!}��s�$Bt BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}�

Ak

V8�B �� 3s�$I

7ZA8$���I �B �Y� ��{Yst${sj et�$t���$t�Bt �sk 11� 1(((� $t }s��$sj PZjhjj8�t� BP �Y�

��JZ$��8�t�R PB� �Y� I����� BP s{Y�jB� BP 7{$�t{�

VAR��s{�

qY$R �Y�R$R R��R BZ� �B htI �Y� ��js�$%� 8s�t$�ZI� BP {Bt�s{� stI �s}}$t� 8BI� js���sjRZ�Ps{� PB�{�R $t �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}�� 3$�R�� $� I�R{�$A�R �Y� ZR�R stI B}��s�$Bt BP�Y� $tR��Z8�t� stI PBjjBbR b$�Y st �-}jsts�$Bt BP �Y� t��I PB� RZ{Y s R�ZIk� qY� %���${sjIkts8${R BP �Y� V3� s�� �Y�t I��$%�I� V ��%$�b BP �Y� {Z���t� R�s�ZR BP �Y� j$���s�Z��Bt {Bt�s{� 8BI� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� 8BI�jR $R �Y�t }��R�t��I� qY� FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR�8BI�j $R {YBR�t stI �-}stI�I �B $t{jZI� �s}}$t� 8BI� B}��s�$Bt BP �Y� V3�� 3$tsjjk�R$8Zjs�$BtR s�� }��PB�8�I Ak {B8A$t$t� �Y� %���${sj Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3� b$�Y �Y� t�bjkI�%�jB}�I js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� 8BI�j� 7$8Zjs�$Bt ��RZj�R $tI${s�� �Ys� {Bt�s{� 8BI� RZ�Ps{�PB�{�R s�� sjbskR ���s��� �Yst �s}}$t� 8BI� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R� qs}}$t� 8BI� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�Rs�� sjRB PBZtI �B I�}�tI Bt R{st �s���

qY�R$R 7Z}��%$RB�U �s8sj OBZ{�PTqBZ8$q$�j�U _�BP�RRB�

1

Page 3: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

V{,tBbj�I�8�t�R

y bBZjI j$,� �B �Yst, _�BP�RRB� �s8sj OBZ{�PTqBZ8$ PB� }BR$t� �Y� JZ�R�$Bt BP RZ�Ps{�

$t���s{�$BtR $t �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}�� PB� $� YsR ��$}}�I 8k $t����R� stI �Y�$jj�I

8k {Z�$BR$�k� qY� B}}B��Zt$�k �B bB�, Bt �Y$R }�B`�{� YsR $8}�B%�I 8k ZtI��R�stI$t�

BP tstBR{sj� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R� 8BI�j$t� ��{Yt$JZ�R� 8BIsj stsjkR$R� �s�jsA\7$8Zj$t, stI

tZ8��${sj RBjZ�$Bt 8��YBIR� y bBZjI j$,� �B PZ��Y�� �Yst, _�BP�RRB� OBZ{�PTqBZ8$ PB�

sI%$R$t� 8� �Y�BZ�Y �Y$R k�s� jBt� }�B`�{� stI PB� sjjBb$t� 8� �B bB�, Bt �Y� ��{Ys��Bt${R

i�R�s�{Y NsAB�s�B�k:R {B8}Z���R bY${Y b��� �$�I Z} $t {BZt�j�RR YBZ�R BP R$8Zjs�$Bt�

y bBZjI j$,� �B �Yst, !Rs8sY ej i$Ps$ PB� R�$8Zjs�$t� {Bt%��Rs�$BtR Bt �Y� Ikts8${R

BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}�� <$R �-}��$�t{�I B}$t$BtR R��%�I �B �Z$I� 8stk BP 8k

��R�s�{Y $t$�$s�$%�R� y bBZjI j$,� �B PZ��Y�� �Yst, Y$8 PB� A�$t� s R�{BtI ��sI�� BP 8k

�Y�R$R� stI �$%$t� 8� 8Z{Y P��IAs{, Bt $��

�stk }�B}j� $t 8k }��RBtsj j$P� Ys%� Y�j}�I 8� $t }�BIZ{$t� �Y$R IB{Z8�t�� e�${ N$Z�

is8k VAZT�Ysj$j stI ej${$s VtI��RBt tB� Btjk }�B%$I�I s 8�{Yst${sj �t�$t���$t� PB�Z8

$t bY${Y y {BZjI �ABZt{�: 8k $I�sR AZ� sjRB }�B%$I�I 8B�sj RZ}}B�� stI �t{BZ�s��8�t�

�Y�BZ�Y 8stk Rj��}j�RR t$�Y�R� y �Yst, ��� Fs8�R 7Bj�8st stI ��� ��%$t �{NsZ�Yj$t PB�

%$��ZBR${jk ��s{Y$t� 8k h�R� {BZ�R�R $t _YkR${R stI ]Y�8$R��k� NsR�jk� y �Yst, 8k Ps�Y��

�BYR�t 3s�$I PB� R}s�,$t� 8k $t����R� $t }YkR${R s� s %��k kBZt� s���

n

Page 4: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]Bt��t�R

d yt��BIZ{�$Bt �

d�d s{,��BZtI � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

d�1 3Zt{�$Btsj$�k � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � d(

d�n 3�${�$Bt +Z�R�$BtR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � dd

d�; !%��%$�b BP V}}�Bs{Y � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � d1

1 V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}� *kts8${R dn

1�d �BI�j$t� !%��%$�b � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � dn

1�1 _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� *kts8${R � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � d;

1�n ]st�$j�%�� �s8 *kts8${R � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � dE

1�; 7�s�� 7}s{� i�}��R�t�s�$Bt BP V3� 7kR��8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � dM

1�x y8}j�8�t�s�$Bt yRRZ�R � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 1(

1�E *$&���t�$s�$Bt ��b��t qs}}$t� �BI� stI ]Bt�s{� �BI� � � � � � � � � � � 11

n V i�%$�b BP ]Z���t� WstBR{sj� Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� �BI�jR 1;

n�d qY� 3�${�$Bt _�BAj�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 1;

n�1 V _YkR${sj =tI��R�stI$t� sR�I Bt ]Bt�$tZZ8 ��{Yst${R � � � � � � � � � 1x

n�n BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�jR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 1E

n�n�d FBYtRBtT��tIsjjTiBA���R V��s ]sj{Zjs�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 1M

n�n�1 �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� V��s ]sj{Zjs�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 1M

n�n�n q$}T7Z�Ps{� ]Bt�s{� 7�$&t�RR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � n(

n�n�; N$8$�s�$BtR BP �Y� BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � n(

n�; V _YkR${sj =tI��R�stI$t� sR�I Bt _B��t�$sj 3Zt{�$BtR � � � � � � � � � � � nd

n�x _B��t�$sj et���k sR�I �BI�jR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � n1

n�x�d qY� ZjIZ8T]$�s{$ �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � nn

;

Page 5: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

n�x�1 pksjB�TqYB8sR �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � n;

n�x�n FBYtRBt stI GBBIYBZR� �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � nE

n�E !�Y�� V�B8${ 3�${�$Bt �BI�jR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � nM

n�E�d z�jB{$�k *�}�tIst� �BI�jR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � nM

n�E�1 !�Y�� �BI�jR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � n�

; e-}stR$Bt BP FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� �BI�j �B qs}}$t� �BI� ;(

;�d is�$Btsj� PB� 7�j�{�$Bt BP FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� ]Bt�s{� �BI� �BI�j � � � � ;(

;�1 *�%�jB}8�t� BP qs}}$t� �BI� �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ;d

;�n y8}j�8�t�s�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ;1

x 7$8Zj$t, Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� 7$8Zjs�$BtR ;;

x�d ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zj$t, �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ;;

x�d�d V3� z���${sj *kts8${R �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ;;

x�d�1 3�${�$Bt �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ;E

x�1 ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt _�B{�IZ�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ;�

x�n ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt i�RZj�R � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ;�

x�; qs}}$t� �BI� 7$8Zj$t, �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � x(

x�x qs}}$t� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt _�B{�IZ�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � xn

x�E qs}}$t� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt i�RZj�R � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � xn

x�� *$R{ZRR$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � x�

E ]Bt{jZR$BtR stI i�{B88�tIs�$BtR E(

E�d ]Bt{jZR$BtR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � E(

E�1 i�{B88�tIs�$BtR � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ed

E�n 3$tsj qYBZ�Y�R � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ed

V N$R� BP zs�$sAj�R E1

_s�s8����R PB� ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$BtR E�

] ]Bt�s{� �BI� �s�jsA 3$j�R E�

]�d 7$8Zjs�$Bt VZ�B8s�$Bt 7{�$}� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � E�

]�1 _s�s8���� 3$j� PB� V3� z���${sj *kts8${R �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �1

]�n ]B8}Z��{Bt�s{� 3Zt{�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��

x

Page 6: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]�; _s�s8���� 3$j� PB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � M(

]�x 3$tIR 3Zt{�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Md

* ]Bt�s{� �BI� �s�jsA 3$j�R Mn

*�d 7$8Zjs�$Bt VZ�B8s�$Bt 7{�$}� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Mn

*�1 _s�s8���� 3$j� PB� V3� qs}}$t� �BI� �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � MM

*�n ]B8}Z���s}}$t� 3Zt{�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �x

*�; 3$tI9 3Zt{�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��

*�x 3$tIR 3Zt{�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � d(d

e ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt b$�Y q�Z� Ns���sj Ws�Z�sj 3��JZ�t{k d(n

E

Page 7: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

N$R� BP 3$�Z��R

dTd V 7{Y�8s�${ BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � d(

1Td *BZAj� �sRRT7}�$t�T*sRY}B� VtsjB�k BP V3� 7kR��8 � � � � � � � � � � � � d;

1T1 V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� V3� $t qs}}$t� �BI� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 11

1Tn V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� V3� $t ]Bt�s{� �BI� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 1n

nTd V 7}Y��${sj sjj =tI�� ejsR�${ *�PB�8s�$Bt � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 1x

nT1 V qk}${sj 3�${�$BtT3B�{� *$R}js{�8�t� ]Z�%� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 1E

nTn WB�8sj 3B�{� *Z� �B ejsR�${ ]Bt�s{� stI VIY�R$Bt sR s 3Zt{�$Bt BP *$R�st{� 1�

nT; V �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� qk}� ]Bt�s{�U ejsR�${ ]Bt�s{� stI VIY�R$Bt � � � � � � 1�

nTx V %st I�� GssjR ABtI 3�${�$Bt ��{Yst$R8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � n1

nTE V 7{Y�8s�${ BP �Y� ZjIZ8T]$�s{$ �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � nn

nT� V3� ]st�$j�%�� $t ]Bt�s{� �BI� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � n�

nTM yjjZR��s�$%� e-s8}j� BP FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � nM

xTd V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}� �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � ;x

xT1 V 7{Y�8s�${ BP �Y� ]Bt�s{� �BI� _y* ]Bt��Bjj�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ;x

xTn V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� ]Bt�s{� �BI� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � ;E

xT; i�RZj�R BP 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� 7$8Zjs�$BtR PB� 3$%� ]st�$j�%�� *�4�{�$BtR � � � � � ;M

xTx V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}� qs}}$t� �BI� �BI�j � � xd

xTE V jB{, *$s��s8 BP 7��sIk 7�s�� 7Ys,�� $8B�}Y 7Ys,�� i�R}BtR� � � � � x1

xT� V jB{, *$s��s8 BP Ns���sj *kts8${R �BI�j q$8� ]sj{Zjs�$Bt � � � � � � � x1

xTM V jB{, *$s��s8 PB� qs}}$t� �BI� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j � � � � � � � � � � � � � x1

xT� WB�8sj 3B�{�� N�tts�I FBt�R *$R�st{� stI 3�${�$Bt 3B�{� PB� s qk}${sj qs} x;

xTd( <B�$9Bt�sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� PB� dx qs}R sR s 3Zt{�$Bt BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA�

*$R}js{�8�t� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � xx

Page 8: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

xTdd Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� sR s 3Zt{�$Bt _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� *$R}js{�8�t� PB�

zs�k$t� z�jB{$�$�R � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � xE

xTd1 3�${�$Bt 3B�{� PB� dx qs}R sR s 3Zt{�$Bt BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� *$R}js{�8�t� x�

xTdn WBtI$8�tR$Btsj _jB� BP Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� stI WB�8sj 3B�{� � � � � � � x�

eTd i�RZj�R BP Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� 7$8Zjs�$BtR PB� 3$%� ]st�$j�%�� *�4�{�$BtR d(n

M

Page 9: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]Ys}��� d

yt��BIZ{�$Bt

d�d s{,��BZtI

qY� $t%�t�$Bt>dH BP �Y� s�B8${ PB�{� 8${�BR{B}� wV3�D $t d�ME R$�t$h{st�jk $8}�B%�I �Y�

sA$j$�k �B R{st RZ�Ps{�R s� �Y� tstB8���� R{sj�� k ZR$t� �Y� I�4�{�$Bt BP s ht� �$}}�I

{st�$j�%��� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R {st A� 8�sRZ��I �B I����8$t� �Y� RZ�Ps{� }�Bhj�� _�$B� �B �Y�

V3�� R{stt$t� �Ztt�j$t� 8${�BR{B}�R b��� ZR�I �B s{Y$�%� tstBR{sj� ��RBjZ�$Bt� 7{stt$t�

�Ztt�j$t� 8${�BR{B}k� YBb�%��� bsR j$8$��I �B `ZR� {BtIZ{�$%� 8s���$sjR A�{sZR� $� 8�sRZ��I

�Ztt�j$t� {Z���t�� k 8�sRZ�$t� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R� �Y� V3� }�B%$I�I s Zt$JZ� A�t�h� $t $�R

sA$j$�k �B R{st s 8Z{Y ���s��� %s�$��k BP 8s���$sjR >1H�

qY$R %s�$��k YsR B}�t�I Z} s b�sj�Y BP ��R�s�{Y $t A$BjB�k� B}�${R� 8s���$sj R{$�t{�

stI ��$ABjB�k� yt A$BjB�k� V3� R{stR Ys%� A��t }s��${Zjs�jk ZR�PZj� y� YsR RYBbt �Y�

$t���s{�$BtR BP j$%$t� {�jjR� !t s 8Z{Y R8sjj�� R{sj�� R$t�j� R��stIR BP *WV Ys%� A��t {Ys�T

s{���$9�I >nH stI �Y� IB{,$t� 8�{Yst$R8 BP {B8}j�8�t�s�k st�$ABIk stI st�$��t }s$�R YsR

A��t I�8BtR��s��I >;Hd� yt �Y� h�jI BP B}�${R� RZ�Ps{� {Ys�s{���$9s�$Bt $R A�{B8$t� $t{��sRT

$t�jk $8}B��st� sR j�tR� �Bj��st{�R I�{��sR� $t �&B��R �B 8$t$8$9� R{s����$t�� qY� V3�

YsR sjRB RYBbt I$��{� s}}j${s�$BtR $t �Y� {Bt�s{� j�tR� $tIZR��k� N�tR� j$P� {st A� $8}�B%�I

stI RZ�Ps{� I�P�{�R 8$t$8$9�I bY�t �Y� V3� $R ZR�I sR s JZsj$�k {Bt��Bj s}}s�s�ZR� qY�

h�jI BP 8s���$sj R{$�t{� YsR sjRB A�t�h��I ���s�jk P�B8 s ���s� I�sj BP �-}��$8�t�sj Is�s

}�B%$I�I Ak �Y� V3�� V� h�R�� �Y� V3� bsR ZR�I PB� 8B�}YBjB�k R�ZI$�R� AZ� bsR js���

ZR�I �B $t%�R�$�s�� �Y� tstBR��Z{�Z�� BP 8stk }Bjk8��R >xH� VjRB IZ� �B �Y� I$��{� 8�{YstT

d]BjB� $8s��R BP RB8� V3� R{stR {st A� PBZtI s� Y��}U\\bbb�I$�{B8

Page 10: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

${sj {Bt�s{�� �Y� V3� {st �$%� $tR$�Y�R $t�B �Y� tstB8�{Yst${R BP �Y� 8s���$sj >EH� y� $R

�Y�R� tstB8�{Yst${R �Ys� YsR B}�t�I �Y� h�jI BP ��$ABjB�k �B $t{jZI� �tstB��$ABjB�k:� qY�

{st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt $t YB�$9Bt�sj I$��{�$BtR sjjBb PB� PB�{� 8�sRZ��8�t�R b$�Y s ��RBjZ�$Bt

t�%�� A�PB�� s{Y$�%�I� qY�R� 8�sRZ��8�t�R {st A� ZR�I �B 8s,� I�IZ{�$BtR Bt tstBR{sj�

P�${�$Bt� e-}��$8�t�sj 8�sRZ��8�t� s� �Y� s�B8${ R{sj� YsR sjjBb�I �Y� h�jI BP ��$ABjB�k

�B s����RR$%�jk }Z�RZ� �Y� ��Z� }YkR${sj AsR$R PB� P�${�$Bt�

d�1 3Zt{�$Btsj$�k

V�B8${ PB�{� 8${�BR{B}k YsR YsI 8B�� RZ{{�RR �Yst B�Y�� 8${�BR{B}k ��{Yt$JZ�R A�{sZR� BP

$�R RZ}��$B� I�R$�t� 3$�Z�� dTd RYBbR s R{Y�8s�${ BP s �k}${sj s�B8${ PB�{� 8${�BR{B}�� qbB

Sample Surface

Photo-detector

Laser

Cantilever

Probe

Image

PiezoelectricActuator

Topographic Data

Feedback Signal

Control Signal

Controller

BimorphShaker

3$�Z�� dTdU V 7{Y�8s�${ BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}�

{B8}Bt�t�R 8s,� Z} �Y� }�$t{$}j� }s��R BP �Y� s�B8${ PB�{� 8${�BR{B}�� V }$�9B�j�{��${

�ZA� s{�R sR st �j�{��${sjjk {Bt��Bjj�I s{�Zs�B� $t �Y� %���${sj I$��{�$Bt� k A�tI$t� �Y�

}$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� $� sjRB }�B%$I�R s {BtR�st� js���sj %�jB{$�k PB� R{stt$t�� qY� V3�

{st�$j�%�� $R s��s{Y�I �B �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� y� $R BP��t 8sI� BP R$j${Bt stI {Bs��I b$�Y

s ��4�{�$%� {Bs�$t� BP �BjI� y�R �$} $R %��k RYs�}� BP��t Ys%$t� s �sI$ZR BP {Z�%s�Z�� BP ��t

d(

Page 11: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

tstB8����R� 7Z{Y s RYs�} sR}��$�k sjjBbR PB� s %��k ht� ��RBjZ�$Bt BP �Y� R{stt�I RZ�Ps{��

_�$B� �B R{stt$t�� �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� $R R�� �B s %Bj�s�� �Ys� {B���R}BtIR �B s }s��${T

Zjs� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt� !t{� R{stt$t� A��$tR� s{JZ$R$�$Bt BP s RZ�Ps{� $8s�� B{{Z�R Ak

{Bt��Bjj$t� �Y$R I�4�{�$Bt� Vt $tP�s��I jsR�� RY$t�R j$�Y� s� �Y� {st�$j�%��:R ��4�{�$%� RZ�Ps{��

V }jsts� }YB�BI���{�B� 8�sRZ��R �Y� }BR$�$Bt stI $t��tR$�k BP �Y� ��4�{��I j$�Y� A�s8� qY�

}BR$�$Bt $R I�}�tIst� Z}Bt �Y� {st�$j�%��:R I�4�{�$Bt bY${Y $R $t �Z�t I�}�tIst� Z}Bt �Y�

PB�{� Bt �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$} stI �Y� RZ�Ps{� }�Bhj�� qY� }YB�BI���{�B� BZ�}Z� $R �Y�t ZR�I

sR s P��IAs{, R$�tsj bY${Y $R R�t� �B s {Bt��Bjj�� �Ys� s���8}�R �B 8s$t�s$t �Y� I�4�{�$Bt

Bt �Y� {st�$j�%�� Ak R�tI$t� {Bt��Bj R$�tsjR �B s{�Zs�� %���${sjjk �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� qY�

%Bj�s�� BP �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� $R ZR�I �B {BtR��Z{� st $8s�� BP �Y� RZ�Ps{��

qY$R 8BI� BP B}��s�$Bt $R {sjj�I {Bt�s{� 8BI� stI bsR �Y� h�R� 8��YBI BP B}��s�$Bt

BP �Y� s�B8${ PB�{� 8${�BR{B}�� VR V3� ��{YtBjB�k 8s�Z��I� $� bsR PBZtI �Ys� PB� RB8�

s}}j${s�$BtR {Bt�s{� 8BI� ��RZj��I $t Y�s%k I�PB�8s�$Bt stI R�%��� Is8s�� �B �Y� Rs8}j�

RZ�Ps{�� qY$R ��RZj�R $t s I$8$t$RY�I $8s�� s{{Z�s{k� qB sII��RR �Y$R $RRZ�� s �s}}$t� 8BI�

BP B}��s�$Bt bsR I�%�jB}�I� V A$8B�}Y RYs,�� bsR sII�I �B �Y� �tI BP �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${

�ZA�� y�R }Z�}BR� $R �B R$tZRB$Isjjk I�$%� �Y� {st�$j�%�� %���${sjjk t�s� $�R ts�Z�sj P��JZ�t{k�

qY� {st�$j�%�� PB� 8BR� BP $�R s8}j$�ZI� ��8s$tR b�jj sAB%� �Y� Rs8}j� RZ�Ps{�� AZ� �BZ{Y�R

�Y� Rs8}j� %��k A�$�4k� VR �s}}$t� 8BI� R{st $R }��PB�8�I� �Y� {st�$j�%��:R s8}j$�ZI�

$R 8�sRZ��I PB� P��IAs{,� V R8sjj�� s8}j$�ZI� ��RZj�R P�B8 s }�s, $t �Y� Rs8}j� RZ�Ps{�

{sZR$t� st Z}bs�I 8B�$Bt BP �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA��

d�n 3�${�$Bt +Z�R�$BtR

qY� }�$8s�k sI%st�s�� BP �s}}$t� 8BI� $R �Ys� $� j$8$�R �Y� s8BZt� BP �$8� �Ys� �Y�

{st�$j�%�� �$} $R $t {Bt�s{� b$�Y �Y� RZ�Ps{�� bY$j� ����$�%$t� s R$8$js� s8BZt� BP Is�s sABZ�

$�� qY$R� YBb�%��� IB�R tB� j�sI �B stk I$��{� {Bt{jZR$BtR sABZ� �Y� ��js�$%� 8s�t$�ZI�

BP sR}��$�k �B RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R $t AB�Y 8BI�R� ]���s$tjk� s {B8A$ts�$Bt BP �s}}$t� 8BI�

{BtI$�$BtR {st j�sI �B tB�8sj PB�{�R �Ys� s�� �JZsj B� ���s��� �Yst {Bt�s{� 8BI� tB�8sj

PB�{�R� qY� }�$8s�k I$&���t{� A��b��t �s}}$t� stI {Bt�s{� 8BI� $R �Y� ��js�$%� IZ�s�$Bt

$t bY${Y �Y� Rs8}j� stI sR}��$�k s�� �-}BR�I �B �Y�R� RZ�Ps{�R�

VR �Y��� s�� JZ�R�$BtR b$�Y �Y� ��js�$%� 8s�t$�ZI� BP tB�8sj PB�{�R $t AB�Y 8BI�R BP

B}��s�$Bt� �Y��� s�� JZ�R�$BtR Bt �Y� ��js�$%� 8s�t$�ZI� BP js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R sR b�jj�

dd

Page 12: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

7$8$js� tB�8sj PB�{�R RYBZjI ��RZj� $t R$8$js� YB�$9Bt�sj PB�{�R� V� �Y� Rs8� �$8�� R$8$js�

js���sj PB�{�R RYBZjI ��RZj� $t R$8$js� YB�$9Bt�sj I�4�{�$BtR BP �Y� {st�$j�%��� y� $R Zt{j�s� sR

�B bY��Y�� �Y� A�$�P {Bt�s{� �$8� bBZjI sjjBb PB� �Y� PZjj 8s�t$�ZI� BP �Y$R I�4�{�$Bt� qY�

�jsR�${ }�B}���$�R BP �Y� V3� {st�$j�%�� 8$�Y� sjRB }jsk s �Bj� $t �Y� 8s�t$�ZI� BP �Y���

PB�{�R� qY� 8s�t$�ZI� BP �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� �&�{�$%�jk A�{B8�R Bt� �k}� BP 8�sRZ�$t�

�Y� s{{Z�s{k BP �Y� R{st stI YBb b�jj �Y� Rs8}j� $R }��R��%�I sP��� 8�sRZ��8�t��

d�; !%��%$�b BP V}}�Bs{Y

qY$R �Y�R$R b$jj s���8}� �B stRb�� �Y�R� JZ�R�$BtR Bt YB�$9Bt�sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R $t �Y� s�B8${

PB�{� 8${�BR{B}�� yt }s��${Zjs�� YBb s�� �Y�k ��js��I �B tB�8sj PB�{� s� �Y� tstBR{sj�2 yR

�Y� ��js�$BtRY$} I$&���t� $t �s}}$t� stI {Bt�s{� 8BI�R2 �stk R��}R� YBb�%��� t��I �B A�

�s,�t A�PB�� �Y�R� JZ�R�$BtR {st A� }�B}��jk stRb���I� qY� tB�8sj PB�{� Bt �Y� {st�$j�%��

�$} b$jj I�}�tI Bt �Y� Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3�� ]Ys}��� 1 b$jj I��$%� �Y� �JZs�$BtR BP 8B�$Bt

BP �Y� V3� $t AB�Y �s}}$t� 8BI� stI {Bt�s{� 8BI�R� !t{� �Y$R YsR A��t IBt�� �Y� �Y�R$R

RY$P�R $�R PB{ZR �B ZtI��R�stI tstBR{sj� RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$BtR� V R��Bt� ZtI��R�stI$t� BP YBb

YB�$9Bt�sj PB�{�R B{{Z� stI YBb �Y�k I�}�tI Z}Bt tB�8sj PB�{�� }BR$�$Bt� %�jB{$�k s8Bt�

B�Y�� V3� }�B}���$�R $R ��JZ$��I� ]Ys}��� n {BtIZ{�R s j$���s�Z�� ��%$�b BP ��{�t� 8BI�jR

Bt �Y� ts�Z�� BP RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R $t �Y� V3�� ]Ys}��� ; {YBBR�R s R$t�j� 8BI�j P�B8 �YBR�

}��R�t��I� y� �tRZ��R �Ys� �Y� 8BI�j s}}j$�R �B AB�Y �s}}$t� stI {Bt�s{� 8BI�� ]Ys}���

22 A�$t�R �Y� V3� Ikts8${R �B���Y�� b$�Y �Y� 8BI�j $t�B s R$t�j� 7$8Zj$t, 8BI�j�

d1

Page 13: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]Ys}��� 1

V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}�

*kts8${R

1�d �BI�j$t� !%��%$�b

Ns��� {Ys}���R b$jj RYBb �Ys� YB�$9Bt�sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R s� �Y� tstBR{sj� I�}�tI Bt �Y�

}BR$�$Bt stI %�jB{$�k BP �Y� }�BA�� yt �RR�t{�� �$}TRs8}j� $t���s{�$BtR $t �Y� V3� $R {BZ}j�I

�B �Y� ��R� BP �Y� V3� RkR��8 Ikts8${R� V���8}�R �B ZtI��R�stI �Y�R� $t���s{�$BtR $t �Y�

V3�� �Y���PB��� ��JZ$�� s �BBI ZtI��R�stI$t� BP �Y� V3� $t AB�Y {Bt�s{� stI �s}}$t�

8BI�R� qY$R {Ys}��� b$jj �-}js$t �Y� V3� RkR��8 Ikts8${R RB �Ys� s ���s��� ZtI��R�stI$t�

BP V3� tstBR{sj� RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$BtR s�� s{Y$�%�I js����

VR I$R{ZRR�I $t ]Ys}��� d� �Y� V3� {BtR$R�R BP s }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� s A$8B�}Y RYs,���

stI s {st�$j�%�� A�s8 �Ys� Ys%� Ikts8${R $t YB�$9Bt�sj stI %���${sj I$��{�$BtR� k �-}jB�$t�

�Y� Ikts8${R $t �Y� %���${sj I$��{�$Bt� �Y$R {Ys}��� b$jj I$&���t�$s�� A��b��t �s}}$t� stI

{Bt�s{� 8BI�� qY� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� stI �Y� {st�$j�%�� s�� $tI�}�tI�t�jk 8BI�j�I sR

8sRRTR}�$t�TIsRY}B� RkR��8R� qY� A$8B�}Y RYs,�� s{�R sR s I$R}js{�8�t� RBZ�{� �8A�II�I

A��b��t �Y� �bB RkR��8R� 3$�Z�� 1Td RYBbR s ��s}Y${sj ��}��R�t�s�$Bt BP �Y� 8BI�j�I

RkR��8�

dn

Page 14: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

3$�Z�� 1TdU *BZAj� �sRRT7}�$t�T*sRY}B� VtsjB�k BP V3� 7kR��8

1�1 _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� *kts8${R

!Ys�s stI OBZ{�PTqBZ8$ >�H R�s�� �Y� {BtR�$�Z�$%� ��js�$Bt PB� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�R�

mNt 6F

;�

uU{ )

mNt dbo� Qnd

Qnd g�

uU{mNt �F

o�

uU{ w1�dD

qY� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�:R �JZs�$Bt BP 8B�$Bt $R �Y�t PBZtI �Y�BZ�Y PB�{� Asjst{� >�H�

'�\�[F� L K� �F� b\�o�(1F�(1q�

)\�o�QndwpL bp7D

~F�&wq� b U�D w1�1D

V}}�tI$- V {Bt�s$tR s j$R� BP %s�$sAj�R stI Rk8ABj I�ht$�$BtR� qY$R }s��$sj I$&���t�$sj

�JZs�$Bt {st A� RBj%�I Ak s}}jk$t� �Y� 8��YBI BP R�}s�s�$Bt BP %s�$sAj�R� qY� RBjZ�$Bt

$R s }�BIZ{� BP �bB ���8R �Ys� �$�Y�� I�}�tI Bt �$8� B� }BR$�$Bt RZ}��$8}BR�I PB� �%��k

s}}j${sAj� %$A�s�$Bt 8BI��

F�wq�, 0D ) 3z)d

�zwq�Dx�zw0D w1�nD

qY� ABZtIs�k {BtI$�$BtR s�� I�R{�$A�I sR h-�I s� �Y� �B} stI I����8$t�I Ak PB�{� Asjst{�

s� �Y� AB��B8� �s�Y�8s�${sjjk�

F� ) (Mq�)(

-_LqQ(1F�(101

L K�(F�(0

L\�o�(F�(q�

)\�o�QndpL bp7

~F�Mq�)U� w1�;D

d;

Page 15: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

qY�k �$%� st $tht$�� tZ8A�� BP R$tZRB$Isj 8BI� RYs}�R �z bY��� 4z $R st s�A$��s�k

{BtR�st� sRRZ8�I �B �JZsj Bt� stI � )�

o�

'��

�z ) 4z R$t

w��zq��

Ww1�xD

qY� ts�Z�sj P��JZ�t{$�R ��z s�� PBZtI Ak tZ8��${sjjk RBj%$t� �Y� ��stR{�tI�t�sj �JZs�$Bt

A�jBb���zU��

�st

w��zU��

W)'�\�U�-_LqQ

w1�ED

qY� �$8� I�}�tI�t� }B��$Bt BP �Y� RBjZ�$Bt� x�zw0D� PBZtI $t eJZs�$Bt w1�nD {st A� PBZtI Ak

RBj%$t� s R�{BtI B�I�� B�I$ts�k I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt �Ys� I�R{�$A�R s 8sRRTR}�$t�TIsRY}B�

RkR��8�

E�z[x�z L ��z �x�z L >�zx�z ) <�z w1��D

y� b$jj A� sRRZ8�I �Ys� �Y� {B8}j��� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� ��R}BtR� b$jj A� IB8$ts��I Ak `ZR�

$�R h�R� 8BI� ��R}BtR�� qY� h�R� 8BI� 8BIsj 8sRR $R�

E� )

8 U�

(

'�\�1�wq�DQq� L

8 U�

(

-_LqQ1�wq�D&wq� b U�DQq� w1�MD

7ZAR�$�Z�$t� PB� �Y� h�R� 8BI� RYs}� stI $t����s�$t� B%�� �Y� j�t��Y BP �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${

�$%�R�

E� ) '�\�

^U�1

b �

;��R$t

w1��U��

W�L-_LqQ R$t

1

w��U��

Ww1��D

qY� 8BIsj Is8}$t� PB� �Y� h�R� 8BI� $R }�B}B��$Btsj �B �Y� {st�$j�%�� }B��$Bt BP �Y� 8BIsj

8sRR� qY� {BtR�st� K� $R �Zt�I �B s���� b$�Y �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R�

�� ) K�

^U�1

b �

;��R$t

w1��U��

W�w1�d(D

qY� 8BIsj R�$&t�RR PB� �Y� h�R� 8BI� {B8�R P�B8 �Y� I�ht$�$Bt BP �Y� ts�Z�sj P��JZ�t{k

PB� s 8�{Yst${sj RkR��8�

>� ) E��1� w1�ddD

qY� Btjk PB�{�R Bt �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� s�� IZ� �B �Y� $8}BR�I %Bj�s��� qY� 8BIsj

�-{$�s�$Bt ���8 $R�

<� )

8 U�

(

�\�o�QndwpL bp7D

~F�&wF b U�DQq� w1�d1D

dx

Page 16: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

7ZAR�$�Z�$t� PB� �Y� h�R� 8BI� RYs}� stI $t����s�$t� B%�� �Y� j�t��Y BP �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${

�$%�R�

<� ) ��8~F� w1�dnD

GY��� ��8 $R s {BtR�st� I�ht�I sR�

��8 )\�o�QndwpL bp7D

R$t

w��U��

Ww1�d;D

G$�Y �Y� 8sRR� Is8}$t�� R�$&t�RR� stI �-{$�s�$Bt ���8R I�ht�I� �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�:R

Ikts8${R s�� PZjjk I�ht�I� qY� PB{ZR {st tBb RY$P� �B �Y� Ikts8${R BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� A�s8�

1�n ]st�$j�%�� �s8 *kts8${R

*�R{�$A$t� �Y� Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3� {st�$j�%�� ��JZ$��R R}�{$sj {s��� �{sZR� $� $R s��s{Y�I

�B �bB Ikts8${ {B8}Bt�t�R� �Y� RYs,�� stI �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� s ��js�$%� I$R}js{�8�t�

{BB�I$ts�� RkR��8 $R $t��BIZ{�I� qY� I$R}js{�8�t� BP �Y� RYs,��� FX� $R ��js�$%� �B �Y�

}$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� stI �Y� I$R}js{�8�t� BP �Y� {st�$j�%��� F�� $R $t �Z�t ��js�$%� �B �Y�

A$8B�}Y RYs,��� W��j�{�$t� �Y� A�tI$t� 8B8�t� IZ� �B �st��t�$sj PB�{�R� �Y� �JZs�$Bt BP

8B�$Bt BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� $R PBZtI �Y�BZ�Y PB�{� Asjst{� >MH� qY� PBjjBb$t� I��$%s�$Bt b$jj

A� PB� �Y� ��t��sj �s}}$t� 8BI� {sR�� ]Bt�s{� 8BI� Ikts8${R s�� s I���t��s�� PB�8 BP

�s}}$t� 8BI� Ikts8${R�

'\�(1wF� L FX L F�D

(01L K�F

(wF� L FX L F�D

(0Lo�{

(;F�(q;�

)

}Bz b KX

(wF� L FX L F�D

(0

]&wq� b UD

w1�dxD

qY$R PB�8 BP �Y� }s��$sj I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt $R tB� {BtIZ{$%� �B s RBjZ�$Bt� �$t�$t� �Y�

RYs,�� stI }$�9B�j�{��${:R s{{�j��s�$Bt stI %�jB{$�k ���8R �B �Y� �$�Y� YstI R$I� �$%�RU

'\�[F�LK�F �F�Lo�{(;F�(q;�

) >BzbKXw �F�L �FXL �F�DH&wq�bUDb'\�[FXb'\�[F�bK�F �FXbK�F �F� w1�dED

VR $t �Y� }��%$BZR R�{�$Bt� �Y� }s��$sj I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt $R RBj%�I Ak �Y� 8��YBI BP

R�}s�s�$Bt BP %s�$sAj�R�

F�wq�, 0D ) 3z)d

zwFDxzw0D w1�d�D

dE

Page 17: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

qY��� s�� PBZ� ABZtIs�k {BtI$�$BtR� qY� �tI BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� s��s{Y�I �B �Y� A$8B�}Y

RYs,�� YsR tB I$R}js{�8�t� stI s YB�$9Bt�sj RjB}�� qY� �$} BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� YsR tB RY�s�

PB�{� B� A�tI$t� 8B8�t�� �s�Y�8s�${sjjk� �Y$R {st A� R�s��I sR�

F� ) (Mq�)( (F�(q�

) (Mq�)((1F�(1q�

) (Mq�)U (nF�(nq�

) (Mq�)U w1�dMD

qY� ABZtIs�k {BtI$�$BtR I����8$t� �Y� PBjjBb$t� $tht$�� R��$�R BP 8BI� RYs}�R�

zwq�D ) b R$tw�zq�D L R$tYw�zq�D L z w{BRw�zq�Db {BRYw�zq�DD w1�d�D

qY� {BtR�st� z $R I�ht�I b$�Y s {B8A$ts�$Bt BP PBZ� ��$�BtB8���${ PZt{�$BtR�

z )

wR$tw�zUD L R$tYwzUD

{BRw�zUD L {BRYw�zUD

Ww1�1(D

qY� bs%� tZ8A��� �z� $R PBZtI Ak RBj%$t� �Y� ��stR{�tI�t�sj �JZs�$Bt A�jBbU

{BRw�zUD {BRYw�zUD L d ) ( w1�1dD

qY� �$8� I�}�tI�t� }B��$Bt BP �Y� RBjZ�$Bt� xz �B �Y� _*e {st A� PBZtI Ak RBj%$t� s

R�{BtI B�I�� B�I$ts�k I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt �Ys� I�R{�$A�R s 8sRRT R}�$t�TIsRY}B� RkR��8�

E�z[xz L Kz �xz L >Fzx ) <z w1�11D

VR $t �Y� }��%$BZR R�{�$Bt� $� b$jj A� sRRZ8�I �Ys� �Y� {st�$j�%�� ��R}BtR� b$jj A� IB8$ts��I

Ak $�R h�R� 8BI� BP %$A�s�$Bt� qY� 8BIsj 8sRR BP �Y� h�R� 8BI� $R �$%�t Ak�

E� )

8 U

(

'\�wq�DQq� w1�1nD

qY� Is8}$t� ���8� K�F� $R �Zt�I �B �-}��$8�t�sj Is�s� stI �Y� R�$&t�RR ���8 $R �$%�t Ak�

>�F ) o�{

8 U

(

X(1wq�D

(?1

~1

Qq� w1�1;D

d�

Page 18: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

Vjj �Y� �-���tsj PB�{�R {st A� jZ8}�I $t�B s R$t�j� �-{$�s�$Bt ���8�

< )

8 U

(

>wBz b K�F �F� b K�F �FXD&wq� b UDb '\�[F� b '\�[FX b K�F �F� b K�F �FXH Qq� w1�1xD

qY� �-{$�s�$Bt {st A� ��b�$���t $t st �sR$jk ZRsAj� PB�8�

< ) bw'\�[F� L '\�[FX L K�F �F� L K�F �FXD

8 U

(

Qq� LwUD>Bz b KXw �F� L �FXDH w1�1ED

qY� �-{$�s�$Bt ���8 ��%�sjR �Y� {BZ}j�I ts�Z�� BP eJZs�$Bt w1�11D� �PB�� RBj%$t� $�� �Y�

!*e R�s��I $t eJZs�$Bt w1��D t��IR �B A� }Z� $t s 8B�� RZ$�sAj� PB�8�

[F� ) b ��E�

�F� b >�E�

F� L��8

E�~F� w1�1�D

7ZAR�$�Z�$t� �Y$R ��RZj� $t�B eJZs�$Bt w1�11D �$%�R�

E�[x L K�F �x L >Fx )

^'\�

X��E�

�F� L>�E�

FX b >�8E�

~F�

~b '\�[FX b K�F �F� b K�F �FX

� 8 U

(

Qq�

L1wUD>Bz b KXw �F� L �FXDH w1�1MD

qY$R !*e {st A� b�$���t RB �Ys� sjj 8BIsj I$R}js{�8�t�R� %�jB{$�$�R� stI s{{�j��s�$BtR s��

��}js{�I b$�Y �Y�$� ��sj �JZ$%sj�t�R�

E�[F� L K�F �F� L >FF� )

^'\�

X��E�

�F� L>�E�

F� b >�8

E�~F�

~b '\�[FX b K�F �F� b K�F �FX

�wUD

8 U

(

QF

L1wUD>Bz b KXw �F� L �FXDH w1�1�D

qY� B�I$ts�k I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$BtR R�s��I $t eJZs�$BtR w1�1�D stI w1�1�D PZjjk I�R{�$A� �Y�

Ikts8${R BP �Y� s�B8${ PB�{� 8${�BR{B}� RkR��8� 7�{�$Bt 1�; PB{ZR�R Bt I�R{�$A$t� sjj BP

�Y� �JZs�$BtR $t s {BY���t� R�s�� R}s{� ��}��R�t�s�$Bt�

1�; 7�s�� 7}s{� i�}��R�t�s�$Bt BP V3� 7kR��8

qY� �JZs�$BtR BP �Y� h�R� �bB R�{�$BtR BP �Y$R {Ys}��� {st tBb A� Zt$h�I $t�B s R�s��TR}s{�

��}��R�t�s�$Bt� qY� R�stIs�I PB�8 $R

�� ) \� L4` w1�n(D

dM

Page 19: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

r ) g� L;` w1�ndD

=R$t� �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$} I$R}js{�8�t� stI %�jB{$�k� stI �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� I$R}js{�8�t�

stI %�jB{$�k sR R�s��R� �Y� R�s�� R}s{� PB�8 $t eJZs�$Bt w1�n(D {st A� �-}stI�I �B�

mNNNNNNNt

�F�

[F�

�F�

[F�

uUUUUUUU{)

mNNNNNNNt

( d ( (

b>�FE�

b K�FE�

'\�>�E�E�

$ U( Qq�

E�

p'\�

��E�

b K�FQ $ U

( Qq� b 1KX

E�

( ( ( d

( ( b >�E�

b ��E�

uUUUUUUU{

mNNNNNNNt

F�

�F�

F�

�F�

uUUUUUUU{

L

mNNNNNNNt

( ( ( (

b'\���8

E�E�

$ U(Qq� b1

E�

'\�

E�

$ U( Qq� b K�F

E�

$ U(Qq� b 1KX

E�

( ( ( (

��8

E�( ( (

uUUUUUUU{

mNNNNNNNt

~F�

Bz

[FX

�FX

uUUUUUUU{w1�n1D

qY� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}� ZR�R �Y� {st�$j�%�� I$R}js{�8�t� PB� P��IAs{, $t AB�Y �s}}$t�

stI {Bt�s{� 8BI�� eJZs�$Bt w1�ndD {st �Y�t A� b�$���t sR�

F� )

}d ( ( (

]mNNNNNNNt

F�

�F�

F�

�F�

uUUUUUUU{

w1�nnD

V tBtTI$8�tR$Btsj tB�s�$Bt $R tBb $t��BIZ{�I�

R ) F�bw;ED R� ) F�b;E RX ) FXb;E

�R ) �F�bw;E��FD �R� ) �F�bw;E��FD �RX ) �FXbw;E��FD

[R ) [F�bw;E�1�FD [R� ) [F�bw;E�

1�FD [RX ) [FXbw;E�

1�FD

�~F� ) ~F� �Bz ) Bzbw1$�pyD

w1�n;D

qY� tBtTI$8�tR$Btsj PB�8 $8}�B%�R P�sR$A$j$�k� V I$8�tR$Btsj PB�8 {sZR�R tZ8A��R �B

A�{B8� %��k R8sjj� {B8}s�sAj� �B {B8}Z��� s{{Z�s{k �Bj��st{�R� <�t{� s tBtI$8�tR$Btsj

��}��R�t�s�$Bt b$�Y js���� tZ8A��R YsR ���s��� s{{Z�s{k� qY� R�s�� R}s{� ��}��R�t�s�$Bt $t

d�

Page 20: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

tBtTI$8�tR$Btsj PB�8 $RU

mNNNNNNNt

�R

[R

�R�

[R�

uUUUUUUU{)

mNNNNNNNNt

( d ( (

b >�FE��1�F

b K�FE���F

'\�>�E�E��1�F

$ U(Qq�

$ U

( Qq�

E���F

p'\�

��E�

b K�FQb KX

E���F

( ( ( d

( ( b >�E��1�F

b ��E���F

uUUUUUUUU{

mNNNNNNNt

R

�R

R�

�R�

uUUUUUUU{

L

mNNNNNNNt

( ( ( (

b '\�>�8E�E��1�F;E

$ U( Qq� b $jp

E��1�F;E

'\�

E�

$ U( Qq� b K�F

E���F

$ U( Qq� b KX

E���F

( ( ( (

��8

E��1�F;E( ( (

uUUUUUUU{

mNNNNNNNt

�~F�

�Bz

[.X

�.X

uUUUUUUU{w1�nxD

R )

}d ( ( (

]mNNNNNNNt

R

�R

R�

�R�

uUUUUUUU{

w1�nED

1�x y8}j�8�t�s�$Bt yRRZ�R

VR R�s��I $t ]Ys}��� d� �Y� %���${sj V3� Ikts8${R $t �Y� �JZs�$BtR sAB%� b$jj A� $8}j�T

8�t��I sR 7$8Zj$t, 8BI�jR� qY� {Z���t� PB�8 ��RZj�R $t s R$8Zjs�$Bt �Ys� {s}�Z��R �Y� PZjj

��stR$�t� stI R��sIk R�s�� ��R}BtR�� �{sZR� �s}}$t� 8BI� R$8Zjs�$BtR Ys%� s {BtR�st�

RYs,�� s8}j$�ZI� stI P��JZ�t{k� RYs,�� ��stR$�t�R {st A� ��}js{�I b$�Y �Y� RYs,�� R��sIk

R�s�� ��R}BtR�� qY$R R��} sjRB %sR�jk $8}�B%�R �Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt R}��I� yt B�I�� �B IB �Y$R� �Y�

R��sIk R�s�� RBjZ�$Bt 8ZR� A� stsjk�${sjjk PBZtI� qY� V3� {st�$j�%�� �JZs�$Bt BP 8B�$Bt

{st A� ��b�$���t sR�

E���F[R L K�F��F �R L >�FR ) \dR� L\1 �R� L\n�~F� L\;

�Bz L\x[.X L\E

�.X w1�n�D

qY� R��sIk RBjZ�$Bt BP �Y� I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt sAB%� $R �Y� RZ}��}BR$�$Bt BP �Y� R$- PB�{$t�

���8R�

Rw+zD ) Rdw+zD L R1w+zD L Rnw+zD L R;w+zD L Rxw+zD L REw+zD w1�nMD

1(

Page 21: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

qY� RYs,�� I$R}js{�8�t� $R �Y�t I�ht�I sR�

.Xw+zD )FX;E

R$t

w�Q��F

+z

Ww1�n�D

qY� RYs,�� %�jB{$�k $R PBZtI Ak I$&���t�$t� �Y� }��%$BZR �JZs�$Bt�

�.Xw+zD )FX�Q;E��F

{BR

w�Q��F

+z

Ww1�;(D

7$8$js�jk� �Y� RYs,�� s{{�j��s�$Bt $R�

[.Xw+zD ) b FX�1Q

;E�1�FR$t

w�Q��F

+z

Ww1�;dD

qY�R� �JZs�$BtR {st A� ZR�I sR PB�{$t� $t}Z�R $t RBj%$t� PB� �Y� R��sIk R�s�� ��R}BtR�� qY�

R��sIk R�s�� ��R}BtR� IZ� �B �Y� RYs,�� s{{�j��s�$Bt A�{B8�R�

Rxw+zD ) b \xFX�1Q

.;E�1�FR$t

w�Q��F

+z L *X

Ww1�;1D

qY� {B�^{$�t� \x $R �$%�t Ak�

\x ) '\��1�F

8 U

LQq� w1�;nD

. $R �$%�t Ak�

. )�w>�F bE��1QD

1 L wK�F�QD1 w1�;;D

stI *X ��}��R�t�R �Y� RkR��8 }YsR� st�j��

*X ) �st�dX

K�F�Q>�F bE��1Q

~w1�;xD

qY� ��R}BtR� IZ� �Y� RYs,�� %�jB{$�k $R PBZtI $t s R$8$js� PsRY$Bt�

REw+zD )\EFX�Q.;E��F

{BR

w�Q��F

+z L *X

Ww1�;ED

bY��� \E $R �$%�t Ak�

\E ) bK�F��F8 U

(

Qq� b KX��FwUD w1�;�D

!t{� �Y� R��sIk R�s�� ��R}BtR�R Ys%� A��t PBZtI� �Y�k t��I �B A� $tR����I As{, $t�B 8BI�j:R

R�s�� %�{�B�� qY$R BP {BZ�R� ��JZ$��R �Y� R��sIk R�s�� %�jB{$�k ��R}BtR�R sR b�jj� qY� %�jB{$�k

1d

Page 22: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

��R}BtR� IZ� �B �Y� RYs,�� s{{�j��s�$Bt $R PBZtI Ak I$&���t�$s�$t� eJZs�$Bt w1�;1D�

�Rxw+zD ) b \xFX�nQ

.;E�n�F{BR

w�Q��F

+z L *X

Ww1�;MD

qY� %�jB{$�k ��R}BtR� IZ� �B �Y� RYs,�� %�jB{$�k $R PBZtI R$8$js�jkU

�REw+zD ) b \EFX�1Q

.;E�1�FR$t

w�Q��F

+z L *X

Ww1�;�D

1�E *$&���t�$s�$Bt ��b��t qs}}$t� �BI� stI ]Bt�s{� �BI�

qY� Ikts8${R R�s��I $t 7�{�$Bt 1�; s}}jk �B �Y� V3� PZt{�$Bt$t� $t AB�Y �s}}$t� stI

{Bt�s{� 8BI�� VR �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� {��s��R s {BtR�st� js���sj %�jB{$�k� �Y� A$8B�}Y

RYs,�� %���${sjjk �-{$��R �Y� {st�$j�%�� t�s� $�R ts�Z�sj P��JZ�t{k� qY� V�B8${ 3B�{� �$T

{�BR{B}� ��R}BtIR �B �Y� RZ�Ps{� }�Bhj� Ak 8�sRZ�$t� �Y� �$} I$R}js{�8�t� stI {sj{Zjs�$t�

�Y� �BB� 8�st RJZs�� �$} s8}j$�ZI�� qY� ���B� A��b��t �Y� s{�Zsj i�7 �$} s8}j$�ZI� stI

�Y� I�R$��I �$} s8}j$�ZI� $R P�I �B s _y* {Bt��Bjj�� bY${Y $t �Z�t %���${sjjk s{�Zs��R �Y�

}$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� 3$�Z�� 1T1 RYBbR s R{Y�8s�${ BP �Y� {Bt��Bj jBB}� =tj$,� $t �s}}$t�

Cantilever Tip DisplacementRMS Tip Amplitude Set Point

x' = Ax+Bu y = Cx+Du

State-Space

Calculate_RMS_Amplitude

K*Kd(s)

Ki(s)

PID Controller

3$�Z�� 1T1U V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� V3� $t qs}}$t� �BI�

8BI�� �Y� A$8B�}Y RYs,�� IB�R tB� �-{$�� �Y� V3� {st�$j�%�� $t {Bt�s{� 8BI�� <�t{��

�Y� Btjk I$&���t{� A��b��t �s}}$t� 8BI� Ikts8${R stI {Bt�s{� 8BI� Ikts8${R $R �Y� ��T

8B%sj BP �Y� �Y$�I stI PBZ��Y �-{$�s�$Bt ���8R P�B8 �Y� ` 8s��$- $t eJZs�$Bt w1�nxD� qY�

}$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� {��s��R s {BtR�st� js���sj %�jB{$�k stI �Y� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt ��R}BtIR

$t }�B}B��$Bt �B $�R R�$&t�RR� qY� ���B� A��b��t �Y� s{�Zsj {st�$j�%�� �$} }BR$�$Bt stI �Y�

I�R$��I I�4�{�$Bt $R R�t� �B s _y* {Bt��Bjj�� bY${Y $t �Z�t s{�Zs��R �Y� %���${sj 8B�$Bt BP

�Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� 3$�Z�� 1Tn RYBbR s R{Y�8s�${ BP V3� B}��s�$Bt $t {Bt�s{� 8BI��

11

Page 23: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

Cantilever Tip DisplacementDeflection Set Point

x' = Ax+Bu y = Cx+Du

State-Space

K*Kd(s)

Ki(s)

PID Controller

3$�Z�� 1TnU V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� V3� $t ]Bt�s{� �BI�

1n

Page 24: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]Ys}��� n

V i�%$�b BP ]Z���t� WstBR{sj�

Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� �BI�jR

yt ]Ys}��� 1� �Y� %���${sj Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3� b��� I�R{�$A�I� qY$R {Ys}��� b$jj R��,

�B AZ$jI Z}Bt �Y$R PBZtIs�$Bt Ak �-}js$t$t� �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� Bt �Y� {st�$j�%�� $t��BIZ{�I

�s�j$��� VII$�$Btsjjk� $� b$jj �Y�t RYBb YBb tstBR{sj� P�${�$Bt $R 8B�� {B8}j�- �Yst $t �Y�

8s{�BR{sj�� W�b 8BI�jR I�R{�$A$t� �Y�R� PB�{�R stI �Y�$� ��js�$BtRY$}R b$jj A� $t��BIZ{�I

stI I�%�jB}�I�

n�d qY� 3�${�$Bt _�BAj�8

GY�t st BA`�{� $R }ZRY�I s{�BRR s RZ�Ps{�� $� P��jR s I$RR$}s�$%� PB�{� B}}BR$�� �B �Y� I$��{�$Bt

BP 8B�$Bt {sjj�I P�${�$Bt� sR${ }YkR${R �R�sAj$RY�R I�k P�${�$Bt �B A� }�B}B��$Btsj �B �Y�

tB�8sj PB�{� Bt s ABIk�

BW ) Bz wn�dD

qY� }�B}B��$Btsj$�k {BtR�st�� ,tBbt sR �Y� {B�^{$�t� BP P�${�$Bt� %s�$�R PB� %s�k$t� }s$�R

BP 8s���$sjR� VII$�$Btsjjk� �Y� {B�^{$�t� BP P�${�$Bt $R I$&���t�$s��I PB� R�s�${ stI ,$t��${

{BtI$�$BtR� qY��� $R tB 8��YBI �B {sj{Zjs�� �Y� {B�^{$�t� BP P�${�$Bt s }�$B�$� ytR��sI

�t�$t���R ��jk Bt st �-��tR$%� R�� BP �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R� <Bb�%��� �Y$R $R Btjk s RZ$�sAj�

RBjZ�$Bt PB� 8s{�BR{sj� }�BAj�8R�

qY� tB�$Bt BP WB�8sj 3B�{� $R %��k I$&���t� s� �Y� tstBR{sj�� �s{�BR{sj� }�BAj�8R BP��t

Ys%� Bt� IB8$ts�$t� PB�{� j$,� ��s%$�k �Ys� sjjBb s R$8}j� {sj{Zjs�$Bt BP �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�

1;

Page 25: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�Y�BZ�Y PB�{� Asjst{�� V� �Y� tstBR{sj�� YBb�%��� �Y� PB�{� Asjst{� $R 8B�� {B8}j${s��I

A�{sZR� s {Bt�jB8��s�� BP s}}j$�I� sIY�R$Btsj� �j�{��BR�s�${ s8Bt� B�Y�� PB�{�R s�� $t%Bj%�I

$t �Y� PB�{� Asjst{�� qY$R {B8}j${s��R �Y� P�${�$Btsj PB�{� {sj{Zjs�$Bt� y� $R JZ$�� {j�s� �Ys�

s t�b P�${�$Bt 8BI�j $R t��I�I �B I�sj b$�Y }�BAj�8R �Ys� $t%Bj%� %��k R8sjj {Ys�s{���$R�${

j�t��YR�

n�1 V _YkR${sj =tI��R�stI$t� sR�I Bt ]Bt�$tZZ8��{YstT

${R

GY�t st BA`�{� BP stk R$9� stI RYs}� {Bt�s{�R s }jsts� RZ�Ps{�� �Ys� BA`�{� I�PB�8R RZ{Y

�Ys� $� YsR s ��sj s��s BP {Bt�s{�� qY$R s��s I$&��R P�B8 �Y� s}}s��t� s��s BP {Bt�s{�� 3B�

�-s8}j�� $t �Y� {sR� BP s R}Y��${sj Asjj $t {Bt�s{� b$�Y �Y� ��BZtI� �Y� s}}s��t� s��s BP

{Bt�s{� $R $tht$��R$8sj� wqY� $t���R�{�$Bt BP s R}Y��� stI s }jst� $R s R$t�j� }B$t��D yt ��sj$�k�

YBb�%��� �Y� Asjj �jsR�${sjjk I�PB�8R �B {��s�� s {$�{Zjs� s��s BP {Bt�s{� �Ys� I$R��$AZ��R �Y�

PB�{�R Bt �Y� Asjj �B s }��RRZ��� 3$�Z�� nTd RYBbR st �jsR�${ R}Y��� $t {Bt�s{� b$�Y s }jsts�

RZ�Ps{�� qY� ts�Z�� BP �Y� I�PB�8s�$Bt I�}�tIR Bt �Y� 8s���$sj }�B}���$�R� �Y� ��B8���k

stI �Y� s}}j$�I PB�{�R� 7Z{Y st $t���s{�$Bt $R I�R{�$A�I $t <���9 ]Bt�s{� qY�B�k >�H�

Fn

3$�Z�� nTdU V 7}Y��${sj sjj =tI�� ejsR�${ *�PB�8s�$Bt

3�${�$Bt s� �Y� 8${�B stI �Y� tstBR{sj�� {st A� %$�b�I sR �Y� �st��t�$sj stsjB�k �B �Y�

I�R{�$}�$Bt sAB%�� Vt s}}j$�I PB�{� $t �Y� �st��t�$sj I$��{�$Bt b$jj {��s�� st $t���Ps{$sj

RY�s� R���RR Bt �Y� BA`�{�� 3B� ��js�$%�jk R8sjj PB�{�R� �Y� P�${�$Btsj RY�s� R���RR $R �jsR�${�

1x

Page 26: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

78sjj I$R}js{�8�t�R IZ� �B �Y� �st��t�$sj PB�{� I$Rs}}�s� Z}Bt $�R ��8B%sj� VR ���s���

PB�{�R s�� s}}j$�I� �Y� P�${�$Btsj RY�s� R���RR $t{��sR�R� AZ� �%�t�Zsjjk {st tB� 8s$t�s$t �Y�

R���t��Y BP �Y� {Bt�s{�� V� s {�$�${sj PB�{�� �Y� P�${�$Bt ��s{Y�R s 8s-$8Z8 stI �Y� BA`�{�

��stR$�$BtR P�B8 R8sjj R{sj� �jsR�${ 8B%�8�t� �B js��� R{sj� Rj$I$t�� qY� PB�{�TI$R}js{�8�t�

{Z�%� $R RYBbt $t 3$�Z�� nT1�

Displacement

FrictionForce

3$�Z�� nT1U V qk}${sj 3�${�$BtT3B�{� *$R}js{�8�t� ]Z�%�

n�n BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�jR

�stk tstBR{sj� P�${�$Bt 8BI�jR ��jk Bt �Y� BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j }�B}BR�I �s�j$��

$t �Y� {�t�Z�k� y� sRR���R �Ys� �Y� PB�{� BP j$8$�$t� P�${�$Bt $R }�B}B��$Btsj �B �Y� ��sj s��s

BP P�${�$Btsj {Bt�s{� >d(H�

BW ) +�\W wn�1D

qY� }�B}B��$Btsj$�k {BtR�st� +� $R �Y� �&�{�$%� $t���Ps{$sj RY�s� R���t��Y bY${Y $R �$%�t Ak

>ddH�

+� ) 1

wd

+yLd

+X

W�d

wn�nD

qB I����8$t� �Y� ��sj s��s BP {Bt�s{�� BbI�t stI qsAB� ZR�I <���9$st ]Bt�s{� qY�B�k�

qY� ��B8���k BP �Y� V3� {st A� 8BI�j�I sR s R}Y��${sj sR}��$�k Bt s }jsts� RZ�Ps{�� qY�

1E

Page 27: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

<���9$st ��RZj� �$%�R �Y� �sI$ZR BP s��s BP {Bt�s{� sR >�H�

y )

wnBzpy

;o

Wdbn

wn�;D

e� �Y� �&�{�$%� $t���Ps{$sj OBZt�:R �BIZjZR� $R �$%�t Ak �Y� PBjjBb$t��

o )

Xdb "1yoy

Ldb "1XoX

~�d

wn�xD

VIY�R$Bt stI RZ�Ps{�R s�� t��j�{��I $t <���9$st ]Bt�s{� qY�B�k� VR j�t��Y R{sj�R I�{��sR�

$t�B �Y� tstB8���� �st��� PB�{�R IZ� �B sIY�R$Bt A�{B8� $t{��sR$t�jk R$�t$h{st� >d1H� <���9

]Bt�s{� qY�B�k A�{B8�R tB jBt��� RZ^{$�t� $t }�B%$I$t� st s{{Z�s�� s��s BP {Bt�s{� PB�

�Y� BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j�

_�$B� �B htI$t� s 8BI�j �Ys� $t{B�}B�s��R sIY�R$Bt $t $�R s��s {sj{Zjs�$Bt� $� $R $8}B��st�

�B ZtI��R�stI �Y� }YkR${sj A�Ys%$B� BP sIY�R$Bt� VIY�R$Bt I�s8s�${sjjk s&�{�R �Y� tB�8sj

PB�{�R Bt �Y� sR}��$�k� VR �Y� sR}��$�k s}}�Bs{Y�R �Y� RZ�Ps{�� $� h�R� �-}��$�t{�R s ��tR$j��

s���s{�$%�� PB�{�� =}Bt {Bt�s{�� �jsR�${ {Bt�s{� IB8$ts��R� stI �Y� PB�{� Bt �Y� sR}��$�k

A�{B8�R {B8}��RR$%�� VR �Y� sR}��$�k $R }Zjj�I P�B8 �Y� RZ�Ps{�� sIY�R$Bt {Bt�$tZ�R �B }Zjj

�Y� sR}��$�k �B �Y� RZ�Ps{� >dnH� VIY�R$Bt� �Y���PB��� IB�R tB� I�}�tI Bt �Y� s}}j$�I PB�{��

ytR��sI� �Y� �&�{� $R s tBtj$t�s� PZt{�$Bt BP �Y� Y�$�Y� B%�� �Y� RZ�Ps{�� 3$�Z�� nTn RYBbR

s ��s}Y BP �Y� �jsR�${ stI sIY�R$Btsj tB�8sj PB�{� sR s PZt{�$Bt BP Y�$�Y� B%�� �Y� RZ�Ps{��

0

Distance

Force

3$�Z�� nTnU WB�8sj 3B�{� *Z� �B ejsR�${ ]Bt�s{� stI VIY�R$Bt sR s 3Zt{�$Bt BP *$R�st{�

1�

Page 28: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

n�n�d FBYtRBtT��tIsjjTiBA���R V��s ]sj{Zjs�$Bt

qY� FBYtRBtT��tIsjjTiBA���R wF�iD ]Bt�s{� qY�B�k $R s {Bt�$tZZ8 8BI�j BP �Y� }YkR${R

BP �jsR�${ sIY�R$%� {Bt�s{�R >d;H� qY� �Y�B�k $t{B�}B�s��R sIY�R$Bt �B }�B%$I� st $8}�B%�I

{sj{Zjs�$Bt BP �Y� ��sj s��s BP {Bt�s{�� 3B� s }s�sABj${ sR}��$�k� F�i �Y�B�k �$%�R �Y� ��sj

s��s BP {Bt�s{� �B A� >dnH

\W ) $

}npy

;o

wBz L n$py� L

�E$py�Bz L wn$py�D

1

W]1bnwn�ED

qY� I$&���t{� A��b��t s R}Y��${sj stI s }s�sABj${ sR}��$�k $t ��sj s��s BP {Bt�s{� $R t��T

j$�$Aj� >dxH� Z�tR� <BZR�Bt� ]s�}${, stI ��{YsjR,� ZR� s t�s� h�jI R{stt$t� B}�${sj 8$T

{�BR{B}� �B 8�sRZ�� P�${�$Bt� qY� $tR��Z8�t� }�B%$I�R st sI%st�s�� B%�� �Y� V3� Ak

I�{BZ}j$t� �Y� tB�8sj stI P�${�$Bt PB�{� bY$j� 8s$t�s$t$t� tstB8���� j�t��Y R{sj�R� stI st

sR}��$�k Bt }jsts� RZ�Ps{� ��B8���k� qY�k ��}B�� st �-{�jj�t� s����8�t� A��b��t �-}��$T

8�t�sj P�${�$Bt 8�sRZ��8�t�R stI s F�i AsR�I BbI�tTqsAB� P�${�$Bt {sj{Zjs�$Bt�

n�n�1 �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� V��s ]sj{Zjs�$Bt

qY� �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� w�*D �Y�B�k I�R{�$A�R {Bt�s{�R $t bY${Y sIY�R$Btsj stI �jsR�${ {Bt�s{�

PB�{�R s�� {B8}s�sAj� >dEH� V I$8�tR$Btj�RR }s�s8���� * �B%��tR �Y� ��stR$�$Bt P�B8 s }Z��jk

I�k �jsR�${ <���9$st {Bt�s{� �B Bt� $t bY${Y sIY�R$Bt IB8$ts��R $t s F�i �k}� {Bt�s{��

* )

X;py�

1

o1FnL

~dbn

wn��D

F�i �Y�B�k $R 8BR� s}}j${sAj� bY�t * k x stI sIY�R$Bt IB8$ts��R �Y� sR}��$�k �B RZ�Ps{�

$t���s{�$Bt� <���9$st �Y�B�k }�B%$I�R �Y� A�R� 8BI�j bY�t * c (3d stI I�k �jsR�${ {Bt�s{�

$R 8BR� R$�t$h{st�� qY� �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� �Y�B�k }�B%$I�R st $t���8�I$s�� �Y�B�k PB� bY�t

* z d� qY� 8BI�j {Bt%����R �B <���9$st ]Bt�s{� qY�B�k sR sIY�R$Bt �t���k s}}�Bs{Y�R

9��B stI {Bt%����R �B �Y� F�i 8BI�j sR $� �-{��IR �Y� �jsR�${ {Bt�s{� �t���k� Nst�9� !:7Y�s�

stI G�jjstI s��Z� �Ys� �Y� �* �Y�B�k $R 8BR� s}}�B}�$s�� PB� st V3� b$�Y s RYs�} �$}

>d1H�

qY� �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� �Y�B�k {st A� RZ88s�$9�I sR st �&B�� �B s{{Z�s��jk htI �Y� s��s

BP �jsR�${ {Bt�s{� stI �Y� s��s BP sIY�R$Btsj $t���s{�$Bt� 3$�Z�� nT; RYBbR �Y� �sI$ZR BP

�jsR�${ {Bt�s{�� y� stI �Y� �sI$ZR BP sIY�R$Btsj $t���s{�$BtR �� qY� �bB �sI$$ {st A� PBZtI

1M

Page 29: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

a

c

3$�Z�� nT;U V �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� qk}� ]Bt�s{�U ejsR�${ ]Bt�s{� stI VIY�R$Bt

Ak R$8Zj�st�BZRjk RBj%$t� eJZs�$BtR wn�MD stI wn��D >d1H�

�y1

1

}w�1 b 1D {BR�dwdb�D L

��1 b d

]L;1�y

n

}��1 b 1 {BR�dwdb�Db � L d

]) d wn�MD

�hy L �h� ) �yn b �y1}�

�1 b d L �1 {BR�dwdb�D

]wn��D

� $R �Y� �s�$B BP � �B y� qY� PB�{� IZ� �B �jsR�${ {Bt�s{�� hy� stI �Y� PB�{� IZ� �B sIY�R$Bt�

h�� s�� �$%�t Ak >d1H�

hy );oyn

npyh� ) b1�L>�1 {BR�dwdb�D L y

0�1 b y1H wn�d(D

�y� ��� �h stI s�� tBtTI$8�tR$Btsj }s�s8����R I�ht�I sR >d1HU

�y ) yp

;oE$�p1

y

Qdbn�� ) �

p;o

E$�p1y

Qdbn�hy,� ) hy,�

1$�py ) 1�L

p�py

n1$�o1

Q wn�ddD

G$�Y �bB I$&���t� $t���Ps{$sj �sI$$� $� A�{B8�R I$^{Zj� bY${Y Bt� RYBZjI A� ZR�I $t �Y�

BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j� e-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R RZ���R� st $t���8�I$s�� �&�{�$%� �sT

I$ZR K� �B%��t�I Ak s tZ8��${sj b�$�Y�$t� Ps{�B� ��

K ) �L �w�b yD wn�d1D

1�

Page 30: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

e8}$�${sj ��RZj�R RYBb �Ys� � $R s}}�B-$8s��jk �JZsj �B (3;� qY� BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt $R

�Y�t �$%�t AkU

BW ) +$K1 wn�dnD

n�n�n q$}T7Z�Ps{� ]Bt�s{� 7�$&t�RR

qY� BbI�tTqsAB� 8BI�j bY�t ZR�I b$�Y <���9� F�i� B� �* ]Bt�s{� qY�B�k }�B%$I�R

s �BBI I�R{�$}�$Bt BP Rj$I$t� P�${�$Bt� �{sZR� 8BR� �st��t�$sjjk s}}j$�I PB�{�R s�� ���s�

�tBZ�Y �B $t$�$s�� js��� R{sj� Rj$I$t�� �Y� BbI�tTqsAB� 8BI�j sjBt� RZ^{�R $t I�R{�$A$t�

�Y� P�${�$Bt PB�{�� yt RB8� {sR�R� Btjk R8sjj �st��t�$sj PB�{�R s�� s}}j$�I stI �Y� P�${�$Btsj

PB�{� IB�R tB� ��s{Y $�R Z}}�� j$8$�� yt �Y�R� {sR�R� P�${�$Bt $R s �k}� BP �jsR�${ I�PB�8s�$Bt

$t RY�s�� qY� P�${�$Bt PB�{� $R >d1HU

BW ) 1+K1

mt{BR�d

CH�db

w1t?

+K

W1

IOL

w1t?

+K

WXdb

w1t?

+K

W1~u{ wn�d;D

bY��� t� �Y� $t���Ps{$sj RY�s� 8BIZjZR� $R �$%�t Ak�

t )

w1b "dty

L1b "1tX

W�d

wn�dxD

eJZs�$Bt wn�d;D $R {B88Btjk R$8}j$h�I Ak sRRZ8$t�U wdD �Y��� $R tB Rj$} s� �Y� }��$}Y��k BP

�Y� {Bt�s{� s��s� w1D �Y��� $R tB {BZ}j$t� A��b��t tB�8sj PB�{� stI P�${�$Bt� qY� R$8}j$h�I

P�${�$Bt PB�{� A�{B8�R >d1H�

BW ) MKt? wn�dED

n�n�; N$8$�s�$BtR BP �Y� BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j

*�R}$�� s RBZtI PBZtIs�$Bt $t {Bt�$tZZ8 8�{Yst${R� �Y� BbI�tTqsAB� P�${�$Bt 8BI�j YsR

$�R j$8$�s�$BtR $t }��I${�$t� �Y� P�${�$Bt PB�{� $t st V3� R{st� qY� }�$8s�k I$^{Zj�k $R �Ys�

$� $R Zt{j�s� bY��Y�� s {Bt�$tZZ8 8�{Yst${R 8BI�j s}}j$�R $t �Y� R$t�j� tstB8���� �st���

V ; t8 �sI$ZR BP {Bt�s{� s��s {B���R}BtIR �B sABZ� d(( s�B8R� G$�Y RB P�b s�B8R� �Y�

s%��s�� �&�{� BP AZj, }�B}���$�R j$,� RY�s� R���t��Y� OBZt�:R 8BIZjZR� RY�s� �BIZjZR 8sk

tB jBt��� A� sR R�s�$R�${sjjk %sj$I >d�H� G$�Y d(( s�B8R� �Y� %s�$s�$BtR $t AZj, }�B}���$�R

IZ� �B ��s$t R$9� s�� $8}B��st� sR b�jj� VII$�$Btsjjk s� �Ys� R{sj�� $� $R Ztj$,�jk �Ys� �Y�

�&�{�$%� %sjZ�R BP �Y� AZj, }�B}���$�R bBZjI A� �Y� Rs8� sR �Y�$� 8s{�BR{sj� {BZt���}s��R�

n(

Page 31: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

qY� BbI�tTqsAB� P�${�$Bt 8BI�j bBZjI ��JZ$�� �-}��$8�t�sj %sjZ�R PB� �Y� AZj, }�B}���$�R

PB� �%��k {B8A$ts�$Bt BP Rs8}j� stI sR}��$�k 8s���$sjR� �B��B%��� $� $R Ztj$,�jk �Ys� �Y�R�

�&�{�$%� %sjZ�R bBZjI A� s{{Z�s��jk 8�sRZ��I�

qY� t��I PB� �&�{�$%� %sjZ�R BP AZj, }�B}���$�R A�$t�R sABZ� stB�Y�� I$^{Zj�k� 7�{�$Bt

n�1 $t��BIZ{�I �Y� t��I �B 8BI�j P�${�$Bt RB �Ys� $� $R ,tBbt s }�$B�$� GY$j� AZj, }�B}���$�R

s�� sRRZ8�I sR PZtIs8�t�sj $t �Y� 8s{�BR{sj�� �Y�k {st tB� A� %$�b�I sR RZ{Y $t �Y�

tstBR{sj� bY�t �Y�k s�� {Bt�$tZsjjk A�$t� 8�sRZ��I� VII$�$Btsjjk� �Y� �sZ�$RT *Z�Isj�

8BI�j ��JZ$��R � sR st �-}��$8�t�sj �Zt$t� Ps{�B�� qY$R $R A�{sZR� �Y� 8BI�j IB�R tB�

{s}�Z�� �Y� ��Z� }YkR${sj ts�Z�� BP �Y� P�${�$Bt� 3B� �-s8}j�� �Y� I$8�tR$Btj�RR tZ8A�� *

RYBZjI tB� A� t��I�I sR s R�j�{�$Bt Ps{�B� BP �Y��� I$R�$t{� {Bt�s{� �Y�B�$�R� qY� }YkR${sj

ts�Z�� BP s Rj$I$t� sR}��$�k Bt s }jsts� RZ�Ps{� YsR tB� {Yst��I� stI Y�t{� s R$t�j� 8BI�j

{s}�Z�$t� �Y� ��Z� }YkR${sj ts�Z�� BP tstBR{sj� {Bt�s{� RYBZjI RZ^{��

NsR�jk� �Y� BbI�tTqsAB� 3�${�$Bt 8BI�j $R s R�s�${ 8BI�j� y� IB�R tB� $t{jZI� �Y�

Ikts8${ ts�Z�� BP �Y� V3�� y� IB�R tB� }��I${� bY��Y�� P�${�$Bt $R �Y� Btjk �k}� BP RZ�Ps{�

$t���s{�$Bt BP �Y��� s�� B�Y��R sR b�jj� ]BZ}j$t� A��b��t �Y� 8B�$Bt BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$}

stI �Y� P�${�$Bt PB�{� $R sjRB tB� �-}js$t�I� yt �Y� t�-� R�{�$BtR� s t�b }s�sI$�8 b$jj A�

ZR�I �B 8BI�j �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R sR �Y�k ��js�� R}�{$h{sjjk �B �Y� V3�� Vt s�B8${ %$�b b$jj

A� ZR�I �B �-}jB�� �Y� }YkR${sj ts�Z�� BP �Y�R� PB�{�R stI stk Ikts8${ {BZ}j$t� A��b��t

�Y� V3� stI �Y� RZ�Ps{��

n�; V _YkR${sj =tI��R�stI$t� sR�I Bt _B��t�$sj 3Zt{�$BtR

_��%$BZRjk� �Y� $t���s{�$Bt A��b��t s }jsts� RZ�Ps{� stI st s}}�Bs{Y$t� sR}��$�k bsR I�T

R{�$A�I sR s {B8A$ts�$Bt BP sIY�R$Bt stI �jsR�${ I�PB�8s�$Bt� Vj���ts�$%�jk� �Y�R� $t���s{T

�$BtR {st A� I�R{�$A�I Bt st s�B8${ R{sj�� V� s RZ^{$�t�jk {jBR� I$R�st{�� s���s{�$%� %st

I�� GssjR ABtIR PB�8 A��b��t �Y� sR}��$�k stI �Y� RZ�Ps{�� GY�t st sR}��$�k s}}�Bs{Y�R

�Y� RZ�Ps{�� tZ8��BZR $t{��sR$t�jk s���s{�$%� %st I�� GssjR ABtIR PB�8 >dMH� 7�� 3$�Z��

nTx� zst I�� GssjR ABtIR s�� $t���s�B8${\8Bj�{Zjs� $t���s{�$BtR �Ys� B{{Z� IZ� �B �stIB8

%s�$s�$BtR $t �Y� �j�{��Bt I�tR$�k BP tBtT}Bjs� 8Bj�{Zj�� GY$j� �s{Y ABtI $R sABZ� ��t }��T

{�t� sR R��Bt� sR s {Y�8${sj ABtI� �Y� {Z8Zjs�$%� s���s{�$%� }B��t�$sj BP �Y� %st I�� GssjR

ABtIR B%�� s tstBR{sj� s��s {st A� %��k R$�t$h{st� >d�H� qY�R� %st I�� GssjR ABtIR PB�8

�Y� s�B8${ AsR$R BP sIY�R$Bt� 3B� �Y$R ��sRBt� �Y� �&�{�R BP sIY�R$Bt s�� 8B�� }�B8$t�t�

nd

Page 32: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

z+

3$�Z�� nTxU V %st I�� GssjR ABtI 3�${�$Bt ��{Yst$R8

s� R8sjj j�t��Y R{sj�R�

VR �Y� sR}��$�k s}}�Bs{Y�R �Y� Rs8}j� RZ�Ps{� PZ��Y��� s ��}ZjR$%� PB�{� IB8$ts��R� qY$R

$t���s{�$Bt {B8�R P�B8 �Y� �j�{��${ ��}ZjR$Bt BP �Y� ��R}�{�$%� �j�{��Bt {jBZIR� qY� }YkR${sj

A�Ys%$B� BP �Y� %st I�� GssjR ABtIR stI �Y� �j�{��Bt {jBZI ��}ZjR$Bt {st A� I�R{�$A�I Ak

�Y�$� �t���k� Ns�� $t �Y� d��Y {�t�Z�k� N�tts�I stI FBt�R {s}�Z��I �Y�R� �bB Zt$%��Rsj

}Y�tB8�ts $t s R$t�j� }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt >1(H�

~F ) ;6

^wFLF

Wd1

bwFLF

WE�

wn�d�D

FL stI 6 s�� N�tts�ITFBt�R }s�s8����R �Ys� 8ZR� A� �-}��$8�t�sjjk 8�sRZ��I PB� %s�k$t�

}s$�R BP 8s���$sjR� qs,$t� �Y� t��s�$%� I$��{�$Btsj I��$%s�$%� b$�Y ��R}�{� �B F �$%�R �Y�

PB�{� A��b��t �Y� �bB ABI$�R sR s PZt{�$Bt BP �Y�$� R�}s�s�$Bt�

Bz ) b(~F(F

) 1;6

^1

XFd1LFdn

~b

XFELF�

~�wn�dMD

V}}�B}�$s��jk� eJZs�$Bt wn�dMD $R �Y� 8s�Y�8s�${sj �JZ$%sj�t� BP 3$�Z�� nTn�

n�x _B��t�$sj et���k sR�I �BI�jR

y� $R $8}B��st� �B }sZR� A�PB�� }�B{��I$t� �B 8s,� }�B}�� I�ht$�$BtR� 3�${�$Bt PB�{� $R

s I$RRs}s�$%� PB�{� �Ys� s{�R B}}BR$�� �B �Y� I$��{�$Bt BP 8B�$Bt� yt �Y� 8s{�BR{sj�� I�k

n1

Page 33: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

P�${�$Bt $R BP��t I�R{�$A�I sR �Y� Btjk YB�$9Bt�sjjk s{{�$t� PB�{�� yt �Y� tstBR{sj�� �Y$R $R tB�

t�{�RRs�$jk �Y� {sR�� WZ8��BZR RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$BtR {st {B8A$t� �B PB�8 s t�� YB�$9Bt�sjjk

s{��$t� PB�{�� qY$R �st��t�$sj PB�{� {st A� s}}�B-$8s��I Ak YstIj$t� $� $t s 8��YBI R$8$js�

�B �Y� Bt� ZR�I PB� �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�� V }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt $R BA�s$t�I� stI �Y� t�� js���sj

PB�{� $R $�R t��s�$%� I$��{�$Btsj I��$%s�$%� b$�Y ��R}�{� �B �Y� R{stt$t� I$��{�$Bt� qY� ZR�

BP s }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt b$�YBZ� stk sII$�$Btsj �t���k ��stRP�� 8�{Yst$R8R� B� I$RR$}s�$%�

PB�{�R $8}j$�R s {BtR��%s�$%� PB�{� bY${Y Ak I�ht$�$Bt $R I$&���t� P�B8 P�${�$Bt� qY$R IB�R

tB� �-{jZI� �Y� �-$R��t{� BP B�Y�� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R bY{Y 8sk A� {BtR��%s�$%� stI

Y�t{� I�R{�$A�I Ak }B��t�$sj PZt{�$BtR� �stk }B��t�$sj PZt{�$BtR BP %s�k$t� s{{Z�s{k stI

{B8}j�-$�k Ys%� A��t }�B}BR�I �B I�R{�$A� �Y�R� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R� qY� PBjjBb$t� R�{�$Bt

RZ88s�$9�R RB8� BP �Y�8�

n�x�d qY� ZjIZ8T]$�s{$ �BI�j

ZjIZ8 stI ]$�s{$ }�B}BR�I s 8BI�j PB� st sR}��$�k Rj$I$t� Bt s }jsts� RZ�Ps{�� y� s{{BZt�R

PB� s R$t�j� s�B8 $t �Y� sR}��$�k $t���s{�$t� b$�Y $tI$%$IZsj s�B8R $t �Y� RZ�Ps{�� 3$�Z��

nTE �$%�R s �BBI R{Y�8s�${ BP �Y� �s�$Btsj� A�Y$tI �Y� 8BI�j� �stk $t���s{�$BtR {Bt��$AZ��

... ...

xp kcx

Fn

kx

(x , z )c

kz

k'x

i i+1 i+2

Substrate

3$�Z�� nTEU V 7{Y�8s�${ BP �Y� ZjIZ8T]$�s{$ �BI�j

�B �Y� B%��sjj }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt� qY� sR}��$�k s�B8� �Y�BZ�Y �Y� {st�$j�%��� YsR st �jsR�${

}B��t�$sj �B �Y� ��R� BP �Y� V3� w>�?D� VII$�$Btsjjk� �s{Y BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� s�B8R Ys%� st

�jsR�${ }B��t�$sj �B �s{Y B�Y��� qY$R }B��t�$sj $t{jZI�R R�$&t�RR IZ� �B %���${sj {B8}��RT

R$Bt s�s$tR� �Y� RZAR��s�� w>FD� YB�$9Bt�sj I$R}js{�8�t� ��js�$%� �B �Y� RZAR��s�� >?� stI

nn

Page 34: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

YB�$9Bt�sj I$R}js{�8�t�R ��js�$%� �B �s{Y B�Y�� >I?� NsR�jk� �Y��� $R s }B��t�$sj A��b��t �Y�

sR}��$�k s�B8 stI �%��k RZ�Ps{� s�B8� *�ht$t� s {BB�I$ts�� %�{�B� n�� ) w?�, FD� �Y� �B�sj

}B��t�$sj $R �Y�t �$%�t Ak�

~x )37

~?7wMn�� b n�7MD L d

1>�?w?� b ?�D

1 L37

d

1>?w?7 b ?7,(D

1 L BzF

L37

d

1>I?>w?7Ld b ?7Ld,(Db w?7 b ?7,(DH

1 L37

d

1>FwF7 b F7,(D

1 wn�d�D

qY� $t���s{�$Bt }B��t�$sj A��b��t �Y� sR}��$�k stI $tI$%$IZsj s�B8 $R I�R{�$A�I Ak s

N�tts�ITFBt�R _B��t�$sj b$�Y 6)(�M;�z stI FL)1�xE #Vd� Bz s{{BZt�R PB� �Y� �-���tsjjk

s}}j$�I tB�8sj PB�{�� y� $R sjRB �$%�t Ak

Bz )37

}(~F7(F

])

37

>FwF7 b F7,(D wn�1(D

G$�Y �Y� }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt I�R{�$A�I sAB%�� �Y� �JZs�$Bt BP 8B�$Bt BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$} $t

�Y� - I$��{�$Bt A�{B8�R >1dH�

E[?� L37

(~?7(?�

L Bz(F�(?�

L >�w?� b ?�D ) ( wn�1dD

qY� ZjIZ8 stI ]$�s{$ 8BI�j �YB�BZ�Yjk $t{B�}B�s��R 8stk BP �Y� }���$t�t� �t���$�R� y�

I��$%�R �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� P�B8 st �-��tR$%� R�� BP �t���k RZ88s�$BtR� qY$R ��RZj�R $t

s 8s�Y�8s�${sj I�R{�$}�$Bt �Ys� {s}�Z��R �Y� JZsj$�s�$%� ts�Z�� BP tstBR{sj� RZ�Ps{� $t���T

s{�$BtR� y� I�R{�$A�R �Y� R�${,TRj$} A�Ys%$B� RB8��$8�R BAR��%�I $t {Bt�s{� 8BI� R{stR� y�

sjRB }��I${�R s PB�{� �Ys� $R s� �$8�R b�s�j�RR stI sI$sAs�${� qY� 8BI�j I�R{�$A�R I$RR$}s�$Bt

sR st �t���k ��stRP�� P�B8 �Y� sR}��$�k s�B8 �B �Y� %$A�s�$Btsj �t���k BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� s�B8R�

qY� %$A�s�$Bt BP s�B8R $R �Y� �JZ$%sj�t� BP Y�s� �t���k �Ys� {st tB� A� ��{B%���I�

n�x�1 pksjB�TqYB8sR �BI�j

pksjB� stI qYB8sR }�B}BR�I s R$8}j�� �bB I$8�tR$Btsj RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$Bt 8BI�j PB� �Y�

V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}�� y� R�$jj ZR�R st �t���k }B��t�$sj �B I����8$t� �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{��

AZ� $� IB�R tB� s{{BZt� PB� �Y� �&�{�R BP �Y� $tI$%$IZsj s�B8R BP �Y� RZ�Ps{�� ytR��sI� $�

dyt 7�{�$Bt n�;� �Y� N�tts�ITFBt�R }B��t�$sj bsR I�R{�$A�I sR �Y� %���${sj I$R�st{� sbsk P�B8 s }jsts�RZ�Ps{� BP s�B8R� y� sjRB �JZsjjk I�R{�$A�R �Y� }B��t�$sj $t s �sI$sj I$��{�$Bt sbsk P�B8 Bt� B� 8stk s�B8R�

n;

Page 35: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

RZ88s�$9�R �Y� RsbT�BB�Y A�Ys%$B� b$�Y s {B8A$ts�$Bt BP R$tZRB$IR �Ys� s{� sR 3BZ�$��

R��$�R ���8R� qY� RZ�Ps{� �B sR}��$�k }B��t�$sj $t �Y� js���sj I$��{�$BtR $R �$%�t sR >11HU

~?r ) yd

}{BR

w1$

q?�

WL {BR

w1$

qr�

W]L y1 {BR

w1$

q?�

W{BR

w1$

qr�

Wwn�11D

VR $t �Y� }��%$BZR 8BI�j� �Y� YB�$9Bt�sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $R �$%�t Ak �Y� I$��{�$Btsj I��$%s�$%�

b$�Y ��R}�{� �B �Y� R{stt$t� I$��{�$Bt�

nB?r ) b(~?r(?�

|?b (~?r(r�

|r wn�1nD

�{sZR� �Y$R �Y�R$R $t%�R�$�s��R RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R $t `ZR� Bt� I$��{�$Bt� �Y� RZ�Ps{� sR}��$�k

}B��t�$sj $R ��IZ{�I PB� s Bt� I$8�tR$Btsj R{stU

~? ) yn {BR

w1$

q?�

WL y; wn�1;D

7$8$js�jk� �Y� �st��t�$sj PB�{� A�{B8�R s }Z�� R$tZRB$IU

B? ) B R$t

w1$

q?�

Wwn�1xD

qY� �$} Rs8}j� $t���s{�$Bt sjBt� IB�R tB� I�R{�$A� �Y� YB�$9Bt�sj 8B�$Bt BP �Y� V3�

{st�$j�%��� y�R Ikts8${ R�sA$j$�k I�}�tIR Bt �Y� �B�sj �t���k BP �Y� RkR��8 bY${Y $t �Z�t

I�}�tIR Bt �Y� I�PB�8s�$Bt BP �Y� {st�$j�%��� yP �Y� {BB�I$ts�� %�{�B�R s�� {Yst��I �B

$t{jZI� `ZR� YB�$9Bt�sj I$��{�$Bt� n�� ) w?�, r�D� �Y�t

~x ) ~?r Ld

1wn�� b n��D�wn�� b n��D wn�1ED

qY� Ikts8${R R�sA$j$�k {BtI$�$BtR s�� �Y�t I�ht�I sR �Y� PBjjBb$t�U

(~x(?�

|?L(~x(r�

|r ) ( wn�1�D

�d,1 w ( wn�1MD

�d,1 s�� �Y� �$��t%sjZ�R BP �Y� <�RR$st (1~x b(?�(r� >1dH�

!%�� �Y� {BZ�R� BP s �k}${sj V3� {Bt�s{� 8BI� R{st� �Y� R�sA$j$�k {BtI$�$BtR s�� tB�

sjbskR 8��� VR s ��RZj� �Y� V3� RYBbR s ���Zjs� RsbT�BB�Y }s����t BP ZtR�sAj� $���%��R$Aj�

nx

Page 36: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

`Z8}R� qY� 8BI�j sjRB I�R{�$A�R �Y� sI$sAs�${ ts�Z�� BP �st��t�$sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R� pksjB�

stI qYB8sR }��R�t� �%$I�t{� $t bY${Y �Y�$� 8BI�j s����R b$�Y �-}��$8�t�sj V3� R{stR�

qY� 8BI�j sjRB s����R b$�Y �Y� ZjIZ8 stI ]$�s{$ 8BI�j� AZ� I�R{�$A�R �Y� }Y�tB8�ts

8B�� RZ{{$t{�jk�

n�x�n FBYtRBt stI GBBIYBZR� �BI�j

FBYtRBt stI GBBIYBZR� }�B}BR�I s Bt� I$8�tR$Btsj 8BI�j %��k R$8$js� �B �Ys� BP pksjB�

stI qYB8sR� V }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt $R R�$jj ZR�I �B I����8$t� �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� s ��B8���${

{BtR��s$t� $R sII�I �B }��I${� �Y� B{{Z���t{� BP �Y� ZtR�sAj� Rj$}R BP �Y� {st�$j�%��� stI

�Y� js���sj Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3� s�� $t{jZI�I sR b�jj� qY� 8BI�j $R AZ$j� Z}Bt s %s�$��k

BP RBZ�{�R {Bth�8$t� �Y� R$tZRB$Isj ts�Z�� BP �Y� js���sj }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt� �YBt� stI

qB8st�, �$%� �Y� $t���s{�$Bt }B��t�$sj AsR�I Z}Bt h�R� }�$t{$}j�R {sj{Zjs�$BtR >1nH� yt

stB�Y�� s��${j�� �Y�k� b$�Y qYB8sR� R�s�� �Ys� PB� s �$%�t tB�8sj PB�{� �Y� $t���s{�$Bt

}B��t�$sj $R >1;H�

~? ) ~ {BR

w1$

qX

Wwn�1�D

qY� �st��t�$sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $R �Y�t PBZtI �B s���� b$�Y �Y� Bt� I$8�tR$Btsj pksjB� stI

qYB8sR ��RZj� PBZtI $t eJZs�$Bt wn�1xD� V ht� I$R�$t{�$Bt $R 8sI�� YBb�%��� FBYtRBt

stI GBBIYBZR� R�s�� �Y� �st��t�$sj PB�{� I�}�tIR Bt �Y� Rj$} I$R�st{�� X� stI tB� �Y�

{st�$j�%�� }BR$�$Bt� ?�� qY� I$&���t{� A��b��t �Y� �bB I$R}js{�8�t�R $R {sZR�I Ak �Y�

js���sj {Bt�s{� R�$&t�RR BP �Y� RZ�Ps{�� qY� �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R� YBb�%��� IB tB� RYBb s

js���sj R$tZRB$Isj PB�{�� qY$R $R A�{sZR� $� $R {BZ}j�I �B �Y� js���sj 8B�$Bt BP �Y� V3��

qB {s}�Z�� �Y� {BZ}j$t�� FBYtRBt stI GBBIYBZR� 8BI�j �Y� V3� js���sj Ikts8${R sR s

8sRRTR}�$t�TIsRY}B� RkR��8� qY� �JZs�$Bt BP 8B�$Bt BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$} $R�

E[?� L K�? �?� L >�??� ) B R$t

w1$

qX

Wwn�n(D

yt sII$�$Bt �B �Y� Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3�� �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$} 8ZR� PBjjBb �Y� ��B8���${

{BtR��s$t� A�jBb >d�H�

X ) ?� b ?� b ?X wn�ndD

nE

Page 37: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

λl

kcx

ks

bcx

m

θ

x =vt

xsxc s

xc xs

3$�Z�� nT�U V3� ]st�$j�%�� $t ]Bt�s{� �BI�

FBYtRBt stI GBBIYBZR� $t��BIZ{� s tBtTI$8�tR$Btsj tB�s�$Bt�

C ) Xbq �� ) ?�bq �X ) ?Xbq

�� ) ?Xbq B� ) B?bB + ) ��?0

�� ) q>�?bB �X ) q>XbB

) K�?��?b1>�?

wn�n1D

=R$t� �Y� {Bt%�t�$Bt sAB%� eJZs�$BtR wn�n(D stI wn�ndD s�� ��b�$���tU

R$tw1$CD ) ��

�[�� L 1 ��� L��

=wn�nnD

C ) �� b�� b wdb�XD R$tw1$CD wn�n;D

7$8Zj�st�BZRjk RBj%$t� eJZs�$BtR wn�nnD stI wn�n;D �$%�R s Zt$JZ� ��s{� PB� �Y� RZ�Ps{�

PB�{� $t �$8� ��s{�� 3$�Z�� nTM �$%�R s �k}${sj ��RZj� BP �Y� 8BI�j� =tI�� R�sAj� {BtI$�$BtR�

�Y� PB�{� PBjjBbR s R$tZRB$I �B�s��I sABZ� �Y� B�$�$t� VR b$�Y B�Y�� 8BI�jR� �Y$R PB�{� $R

{B8}j���jk {BtR��%s�$%�� _��$BI${jk� YBb�%��� �Y� {st�$j�%�� A�{B8�R ZtR�sAj� stI Rts}R

P�B8 s Y$�Y �B s jBb s P�${�$Bt PB�{�� qY�R� ZtR�sAj� Rj$}R s�� $���%��R$Aj� stI sjRB {sZR�

Is8}�I BR{$jjs�$Bt BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� sR $� {Bt�$tZ�R As{, Bt $�R R�sAj� }s�Y� k {BZ}j$t�

n�

Page 38: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 20.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Nondimensional Piezoelectric Tube Displacement Xp

Nondim

ensionalFrictionForceFc

3$�Z�� nTMU yjjZR��s�$%� e-s8}j� BP FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� �BI�j

�Y� V3� Ikts8${R �B �Y� PB�{� I��$%�I P�B8 �Y� $t���s{�$Bt }B��t�$sj� �Y� 8BI�j $R sAj� �B

{s}�Z�� �Y� Rsj$�t� P�s�Z��R BP �Y� �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R� y� RYBbR AB�Y �Y� sI$sAs�${ ts�Z��

BP �Y� t�� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� sR b�jj sR �Y� RsbT�BB�Y RYs}� %s�$s�$BtR�

n�E !�Y�� V�B8${ 3�${�$Bt �BI�jR

GY$j� $� $R {j�s� �Ys� �Y� 8BI�jR AsR�I Bt �Y� $t���Ps{$sj }B��t�$sj {s}�Z�� 8stk BP �Y�

P�s�Z��R BP �Y� �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R $� $R tB� {j�s� bY��Y�� RB8� BP $t���Ps{$sj $t���s{�$BtR

s�� t��j�{��I� yt }s��${Zjs�� �Y� 8BI�jR sAB%� t��j�{� stk I�}�tI�t{� Bt �Y� {st�$j�%��

%�jB{$�k�

n�E�d z�jB{$�k *�}�tIst� �BI�jR

qY��� RBZ�{�R BP %�jB{$�k I�}�tI�t� P�${�$Bt Ys%� A��t }�B}BR�I� qY� h�R� P�${�$Bt RBZ�{�

$R IZ� �B �j�{��B8s�t��${ %s�$s�$BtR A��b��t �Y� V3� {st�$j�%�� �$} stI �Y� RZ�Ps{�� qY�

R�{BtI $R IZ� �B st �-{Yst�� BP �j�{��BtR A��b��t �Y� �bB ABI$�R� qY� jsR� $R IZ� �B

�Y� �-{Yst�� BP }YBtBtR� Vjj BP �Y�R� 8BI�jR s�� I��$%�I I$��{�jk P�B8 h�R� }�$t{$}j�R

stI k$�jI P�${�$Bt %sjZ�R Bt �Y� B�I�� BP }${BW�b�BtR >dMH� e-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R RYBb �Y�

nM

Page 39: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

P�${�$Bt 8�sRZ��8�t�R s�� Bt �Y� B�I�� BP tstBW�b�BtR� qY�R� %�jB{$�k I�}�tIst� 8BI�jR�

�Y���PB��� I�R{�$A� $tR$�t$h{st� }s��R BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� �B sR}��$�k $t���s{�$Bt�

n�E�1 !�Y�� �BI�jR

qY� 8BI�jR sAB%� �$%� s �BBI I�R{�$}�$Bt BP �Y� {Z���t� R�s�� BP �Y� j$���s�Z�� Bt �Y�

js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $t �Y� V3�U $t���s{�$BtR PB� s R$t�j� sR}��$�k Bt s }jsts� RZ�Ps{��

qY$R� YBb�%��� $R Btjk s RZAR�� BP �Y� j$���s�Z�� Bt tstBR{sj� $t���s{�$BtR� �Z{Y s���t�$Bt

YsR A��t �$%�t �B hj8�I B� JZsR$TI�k RZ�Ps{�R� yt sII$�$Bt� 8BI�jR Ys%� A��t }�B}BR�I �Ys�

$t{jZI� 8Zj�$}j� sR}��$�$�R $t {Bt�s{� b$�Y s RZ�Ps{�� qY� R�s�� stI �s�� I�}�tIst� 8BI�j

I�R{�$A�R P�${�$Bt PB� s 8Zj�$}j� {Bt�s{� $t���Ps{� >1xH� *kts8${ P�${�$Bt 8BI�jR �Ys� {B%��

s b$I� %s�$��k BP j�t��Y R{sj�R Ys%� sjRB A��t }�B}BR�I >1EH� y� $R Ztj$,�jk� YBb�%��� �Ys�

RZ{Y 8BI�jR b$jj �jZ{$Is�� �Y� ts�Z�� BP RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$BtR sR �Y�k s}}jk I$��{�jk �B �Y�

V3��

n�

Page 40: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]Ys}��� ;

e-}stR$Bt BP FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR�

�BI�j �B qs}}$t� �BI�

]Ys}��� n �-}js$t�I �Y� }YkR${sj ts�Z�� BP tB�8sj� js���sj RZ�Ps{� stI P�${�$Btsj PB�{�R ZR$t�

�Y��� }s�sI$�8RU {Bt�$tZZ8 8�{Yst${R� s�B8${ }B��t�$sj PZt{�$BtR stI h�R� }�$t{$}j�R� y�

sjRB I�R{�$A�I s %s�$��k BP {Bt�s{� 8BI� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� 8BI�jR� !t� 8BI�j }�B}BR�I

Ak FBYtRBt stI GBBIYBZR� R��8�I }s��${Zjs�jk }�B8$R$t� PB� PZ��Y�� �Y�B���${sj bB�,�

qY$R {Ys}��� b$jj AZ$jI Z}Bt �Y$R PBZtIs�$Bt Ak �-}stI$t� �Y� FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� {Bt�s{�

8BI�j �B �s}}$t� 8BI��

;�d is�$Btsj� PB� 7�j�{�$Bt BP FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� ]Bt�s{�

�BI� �BI�j

!P sjj �Y� 8BI�jR I�R{�$A�I $t ]Ys}��� n� �Y� FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� ]Bt�s{� �BI� �BI�j

bsR 8BR� RZ$�sAj� PB� PZ��Y�� stsjkR$R� y� YsI 8stk s���s{�$%� P�s�Z��R� 3$�R�� $�R R$tZRB$Isj

$t���s{�$Bt }B��t�$sj $R s����I Z}Bt Ak 8stk RBZ�{�R $t{jZI$t� Bt�R b$�Y h�R� }�$t{$}j�R

�k}� I��$%s�$BtR� 7�{BtI� �Y� 8BI�j s����R b$�Y s %sR� }B��$Bt BP �Y� �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R�

y� RYBbR �Y� R�${,TRj$} ts�Z�� BP tstBR{sj� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R stI }��I${�R s PB�{� �Ys� {st

A� {BtR��%s�$%�� NsR�jk� �Y� 8BI�j {s}�Z��R �Y� I�}�tI�t{� BP �Y$R PB�{� Bt �Y� V3�

}�B}���$�R� �stk 8BI�jR YsI �Y�R� P�s�Z��R� AZ� tBt� b��� sR b�jj I�%�jB}�I� y� $t{jZI�I

s {B8}j��� I�R{�$}�$Bt BP �Y� YB�$9Bt�sj Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3� stI �Y� �Bj� �Ys� �Y� RZ�Ps{�

$t���s{�$BtR }jsk $t $�� NsR�jk� ,�k �JZs�$BtR stI }s�s8���� %sjZ�R b��� R�s��I RZ{Y �Ys�

;(

Page 41: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�Y� 8BI�j j�t� $�R�jP �B ��}�BIZ{�$Bt stI $8}j�8�t�s�$Bt�

;�1 *�%�jB}8�t� BP qs}}$t� �BI� �BI�j

qY� �-}stR$Bt BP s {Bt�s{� 8BI� 8BI�j j$�R Bt Bt� sRR���$BtU �Y� PB�8 BP �Y� RZ�Ps{�

$t���s{�$Bt }B��t�$sj $R �Y� Rs8� PB� AB�Y 8BI�R BP V3� B}��s�$Bt� qY� }B��t�$sj PZt{�$BtR

}�B}BR�I I�}�tI Bt 8s���$sj }�B}���$�R stI ��B8���k BP �Y� Rs8}j� stI �Y� }�BA�� qY�

}YkR${sj R$�Zs�$Bt BP st sR}��$�k 8B%$t� sAB%� s }jsts� RZ�Ps{� $R �Y� Rs8�� stI �Y���PB��

�Y� }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt 8ZR� A� �Y� Rs8��

eJZs�$Bt wn�d�D R�s��R �Y� N�tts�ITFBt�R }B��t�$sj sR s PZt{�$Bt BP Y�$�Y�� yt �Y�

8�st�$8�� eJZs�$Bt wn�1xD RZ88s�$9�R �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� 8BI�jR b$�Y s }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt

�Ys� $R R$tZRB$Isjjk I�}�tI�t� Bt js���sj I$R}js{�8�t�� V �s}}$t� 8BI� js���sj RZ�Ps{�

PB�{� 8BI�j AsR�I Bt }B��t�$sj PZt{�$BtR ��JZ$��R s I�}�tI�t{� Bt tB� `ZR� Bt� AZ� AB�Y

I$��{�$BtR� qY� I$^{Zj�k A�{B8�R {B8A$t$t� �Y� �bB }B��t�$sjR RZ{Y �Ys� �Y� �JZs�$BtR

��8s$t ��Z��

V R�{BtI sRRZ8}�$Bt $R 8sI�U �Y� Btjk bsk �Ys� �Y� js���sj }BR$�$Bt s&�{�R �Y� $t���T

s{�$Bt }B��t�$sj $R $t �Y� R$tZRB$Isj 8stt�� I�R{�$A�I �s�j$��� qY� Btjk B�Y�� bsk �B s&�{�

�Y� }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt $R Ak 8s,$t� ~ I�}�tIst� Bt YB�$9Bt�sj }BR$�$Bt� stI �Y$R bBZjI

j�sI �B s tBtTR$tZRB$Isj P�${�$Bt PB�{� bY${Y $R {Bt��s�k �B �-}��$8�t�sj A�Ys%$B�� �{sZR�

~ $R tB� s PZt{�$Bt BP js���sj }BR$�$Bt �Y�t $� 8ZR� A� s PZt{�$Bt BP %���${sj }BR$�$Bt�

~?F ) ~ F {BR

w1$X

q

Ww;�dD

y� $R ��sRBtsAj� �B �JZs�� ~ �B ~ wFD PBZtI Ak �Y� N�tts�I FBt�R }B��t�$sj� qY$R j�s%�R

st $t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�� qY� $t���s{�$Bt }B��t�$sj {Bt�$tZ�R �B %s�k s� �Y� js��${� R}s{$t�� bY$j�

�Y� 8s�t$�ZI� BP �Y� %s�$s�$Bt $R I�}�tIst� Z}Bt �Y� Y�$�Y� sAB%� �Y� RZ�Ps{��

~?F ) ;6

^wFLF

Wd1

bwFLF

WE�{BR

w1$X

q

Ww;�1D

!t{� �Y� $t���s{�$Bt }B��t�$sj $R ,tBbt� �s,$t� �Y� t��s�$%� I��$%s�$%� b$�Y ��R}�{� �B �Y�

YB�$9Bt�sj I$��{�$Bt �$%�R �Y� P�${�$Bt PB�{�U

B? ) b(~?F(X

) ;61$

q

^wFLF

Wd1

bwFLF

WE�R$t

w1$X

q

Ww;�nD

;d

Page 42: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

qY� 8s-$8Z8 js���sj PB�{� B PB� s �$%�t %���${sj }BR$�$Bt A�{B8�RU

B ) ;61$

q

^wFLF

Wd1

bwFLF

WE�

w;�;D

;�n y8}j�8�t�s�$Bt

VR b$�Y �Y� V3� 8BI�j� �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j ��JZ$��R RB8� }��}s�s�B�k R��}R �B

�sR� �Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt }�B{�RR� VR b�$���t �Y� {Z���t� 8BI�j YsR tB bsk BP $t���Ps{$t� b$�Y �Y�

V3� Ikts8${R 8BI�j� y� �s,�R s N�tts�ITFBt�R I$R�st{� sR st $t}Z�� qY$R �k}� BP I$R�st{�

$R %��k I$&���t� P�B8 �Y� %���${sj }�BA� Rs8}j� I�PB�8s�$Bt I�ht�I $t �Y� V3� 8BI�j� 3B�

�-s8}j�� �Y� V3� 8BI�j {st I�R{�$A� s {Bt�s{� 8BI� b$�Y s 9��B I�PB�8s�$Bt� V 9��B

N�tts�ITFBt�R I$R�st{� 8�stR �Y� tZ{j�$ BP �bB s�B8R s�� $t �Y� Rs8� }js{�� qY$R tBtT

}YkR${sj ��RZj� {sZR�R st $tht$�� }B��t�$sj stI PB�{�� ytR��sI� �Y� N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{�

$R Bt �Y� B�I�� BP st�R��B8R� qB RBj%� �Y$R I$R{��}st{k $t I$R�st{�R� �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� P�B8

�Y� V3� 8BI�j� stI tB� �Y� %���${sj }BR$�$Bt $R ZR�I sR st BZ�}Z�� qY� N�tts�ITFBt�R

PB�{� PZt{�$Bt PBZtI $t eJZs�$Bt wn�dMD $R �Y�t RBj%�I PB� �Y� {B���R}BtI$t� I$R�st{�d� yt

�Y$R bsk� �Y� �bB Ikts8${ 8BI�jR s�� $t���Ps{�I b$�Y �s{Y B�Y���

=R$t� �Y� N�tts�I FBt�R }B��t�$sj stI PB�{� PZt{�$BtR �B $t���Ps{� �Y� %���${sj Ikts8${R

stI P�${�$Bt 8BI�jR {sZR�R PZ��Y�� $8}j�8�t�s�$Bt $RRZ�R� 3$�R�� $� ��JZ$��R �Ys� �Y� PZt{T

�$BtR A� Ps$�jk s{{Z�s��� yt B�I�� �B sRRZ�� �Y$R� �bB R��}R b��� �s,�t� 3$�R�� $� bsR sRRZ8�I

�Ys� �Y� �JZ$j$A�$Z8 I$R�st{� A��b��t �bB s�B8R BP 1�xE #VbBZjI A� R$8$js� PB� st sR}��$�k

Bt s }jsts� RZ�Ps{�� yt�Z$�$%�jk� �j�{��Bt {jBZIR RYBZjI {sZR� ��}ZjR$Bt s� s R$8$js� I$R�st{��

stI Y�t{� �Y� B�Y�� $t���s�B8${ PB�{�R RYBZjI s}}jk s� R$8$js� I$R�st{�R� !t{� �Y� �JZ$j$AT

�$Z8 I$R�st{� bsR PBZtI� eJZs�$Bt wn�dMD bsR I$&���t�$s��I �B htI �Y� I$R�st{� s� bY${Y

�Y� 8$t$8s B{{Z�R� qY� PZt{�$Bt bsR �%sjZs��I s� �Ys� I$R�st{� �B �$%� �Y� 8$t$8Z8 PB�{��

qY� 6 �t���k }s�s8���� bsR �Y�t �Zt�I RZ{Y �Ys� �Y� 8$t$8Z8 N�tts�I FBt�R PB�{� bsR

�JZs��I �B s 8$t$8Z8 tB�8sj PB�{� PBZtI P�B8 s �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� {sj{Zjs�$Bt $t s �s}}$t�

8BI� R$8Zjs�$Bt�

i�}�s��Ijk RBj%$t� b$�Y ht� ��RBjZ�$Bt �Y� N�tts�ITFBt�R PB�{� PZt{�$Bt ZR$t� tZ8��${sj

8��YBIR ��JZ$��R RB8� {s��� 3$�R�� �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� R��} R$9� t��IR �B A� Ps$�jk R8sjj� qY$R $R

�tRZ��I Ak �$�Y��t$t� �Y� �Bj��st{� Bt �Y� I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt RBj%��� qY$R R��} $8}�B%�R

dqY� �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� 8BI�j ZR�I �B {sj{Zjs�� tB�8sj PB�{� $t �Y� V3� 8BI�j %��k {jBR�jk s}}�B-$8s��R�Y� N�tts�ITFBt�R 3B�{�� y� $R �Y���PB�� ��sRBtsAj� �B �JZs�� �Y� �bB PB�{�R�

;1

Page 43: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

{Bt%����t{� BP �Y� �BB� htI$t� sj�B�$�Y8� qY� t�-� R��} $8}�B%�R �Y� s{{Z�s{k BP �Y�

sj�B�$�Y8� VR b�$���t� �Y� PZt{�$Bt �s$R�R s tZ8A�� Bt �Y� B�I�� BP st�R��B8R �B �Y�

t��s�$%� �Y$����t�Y }Bb��� qY$R R�%���jk ��R� �Y� �s�jsA\8s{Y$t� �Bj��st{�� ytR��sI BP $�R

{Z���t� PB�8 eJZs�$Bt wn�dMD {st A� ��b�$���t sR�

BzFL ) 1;6�1Jdn b J�

=w;�xD

ZR$t� �Y� {Yst�� BP %s�$sAj�U J ) FLbF� yt �Y$R bsk� {sj{Zjs�$BtR {st ��8s$t 8Z{Y ���s���

�Yst 8s{Y$t� �Bj��st{�R�

qY� jsR� $RRZ� BP $8}j�8�t�s�$Bt YsR �B IB b$�Y �Y� �$8� $t}Z� BP �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R

8BI�j� yt {Bt�s{� 8BI�� �Y� V3� 8BI�j �$8� $R �Y� Rs8� sR �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j

�$8�� qY$R $R A�{sZR� �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$} $R sjbskR $t {Bt�s{� b$�Y �Y� RZ�Ps{�� qY$R $R tB�

�Y� {sR� $t �s}}$t� 8BI�� ytR��sI R}�{$sj {s�� YsR �B A� �s,�t �B Btjk $t}Z� �Y� �$8�R $t

bY${Y �Y� �$} YsR �BZ{Y�I IBbt� !t{� �Y� {Bt�s{� �$8�R s�� PBZtI� �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R

8BI�j {st {sj{Zjs�� �Y� ��js�$%� I$R}js{�8�t�� stI RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R bY�t $t {Bt�s{��

;n

Page 44: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]Ys}��� x

7$8Zj$t, Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{�

7$8Zjs�$BtR

]Ys}��� 1 I�%�jB}�I s 8BI�j BP �Y� V3� Ikts8${R $t �Y� %���${sj I$��{�$Bt� ]Ys}��� n

PBZtI st s}}�B}�$s�� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� 8BI�j PB� �Y� V3� $t {Bt�s{� 8BI�� stI ]Ys}��� ;

�-}stI�I $� �B �s}}$t� 8BI�� qY$R {Ys}��� b$jj s���8}� �B }Z� sjj BP �Y$R �B���Y�� $t�B s

R$t�j� R$8Zjs�$Bt AsR�I Z}Bt �Y� V3� B}��s�$Bt }s�s8����R� 3$�R�� �Y� 7$8Zj$t, 8BI�jR

PB� AB�Y {Bt�s{� stI �s}}$t� 8BI�R b$jj A� JZsj$�s�$%�jk �-}js$t�I� 7�{BtI �k}${sj ��s{�R

$t AB�Y 8BI�R BP B}��s�$Bt b$jj A� }��R�t��I� NsR�jk� {Bt{jZR$BtR b$jj A� 8sI� sABZ� �Y�

��js�$%� 8s�t$�ZI� BP P�${�$Bt $t �Y� �bB 8BI�R�

x�d ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zj$t, �BI�j

x�d�d V3� z���${sj *kts8${R �BI�j

qY� %���${sj Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3� 8s,�R Z} �Y� h�R� }B��$Bt BP �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� 7$8Zj$t,

8BI�j� qY� AjB{, I$s��s8 RYBbt $t 3$�Z�� xTd $R AZ$j� Z}Bt s 7$8Zj$t, �s}}$t� 8BI�

R$8Zjs�$Bt >1�H� qY� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�T{st�$j�%�� 8BI�j AjB{, �t{B8}sRR�R �Y� R�s�� R}s{�

��}��R�t�s�$Bt PBZtI $t eJZs�$Bt w1�nxD� qY� RYs,�� $t}Z�R s�� ��8B%�I RB �Ys� Btjk �Y�

h�R� �bB ���8R BP �Y� $t}Z� %�{�B� s�� ZR�I� qY� RkR��8 {sj{Zjs��R �Y� sARBjZ�� %���${sj �$}

}BR$�$Bt PB� �Y� �{B8}Z��{Bt�s{�: PZt{�$Btd bY${Y ZR�R �Y� �sZ�$R *Z�Isj� 8BI�j �B {sj{ZT

js�� tB�8sj PB�{� s8Bt� B�Y�� }YkR${sj JZst�$�$�R >1�H� qY� sARBjZ�� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt $R

dqY� �s�jsA ]BI� PB� �Y� PZt{�$Bt $R $t V}}�tI$- ]�n�

;;

Page 45: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�Y�t RZA��s{��I P�B8 �Y� R��}B$t� �B {��s�� st ���B� R$�tsj R�t� �B �Y� {Bt��Bjj��� 3$�Z�� xT1

RYBbR �Ys� �Y� {Bt��Bjj�� $R {B8}BR�I BP `ZR� s _y* {Bt��Bjj�� stI �Y� $t$�$sj }$�9B�j�{��${

�ZA� {B88stI %Bj�s���

Contact Mode AFM

Vertical Dynamics

computecontact

sample/tip force

q

States

Sample shape

y_s

Sample Height

x' = Ax+Bu

y = Cx+Du

Piezoelectric Tube-

Cantilever Model

In1 Out1

PID Controller

fn

Normal Force

Mux

Mux

bb

Effective Radius of Contact Demux

delta

Deformation Distance

f_d

Contact &

Damping Force

Cantilever Deflection

Set Point

y_cant

Cantilever Deflection

K

Cantilever &

Piezo Rel. Disp.

2

56

4

4

44

4

3$�Z�� xTdU V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}� �BI�j

1

Out1

u

piezo control voltage

ypo*D*k_p/k_pv

initial piezo

voltage-pi_gain(s-pi_zero)

s

PI Controller

1

In1

3$�Z�� xT1U V 7{Y�8s�${ BP �Y� ]Bt�s{� �BI� _y* ]Bt��Bjj��

qY� 8BI�j sAB%� YsR 8stk ZR�PZj P�s�Z��R� y� sjjBbR �Y� ZR�� �B {Bt��Bj �Y� {st�$j�%��

I�4�{�$Bt R�� }B$t�� y� sjRB sjjBbR PB� R{stR BP %s�k$t� Rs8}j� RYs}�R� y� sjRB {s}�Z��R

��stR$�t�R BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� stI }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� IZ� �B %s�$s�$BtR $t �Y� Rs8}j� RZ�Ps{��

3B� �Y� }Z�}BR�R BP �Y$R $t%�R�$�s�$Bt� �s{Y BP �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� R$8Zjs�$BtR b$jj Ys%� �Y�

;x

Page 46: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

Rs8� }s�s8���� %sjZ�R �-{�}� Bt�U �Y� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt R�� }B$t�� Vt s�B8${sjjk 4s�

RZ�Ps{� b$jj A� R{stt�I �s{Y �$8�� qY� R$8Zjs�$Bt b$jj A��$t s� s Y�$�Y� BP n(( tstB8����R

sAB%� �Y� RZ�Ps{� stI b$jj �Zt Zt�$j �Y� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt R��}B$t� $R ��s{Y�I� V� �Ys�

}B$t�� �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j R$8Zjs��R �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{��

x�d�1 3�${�$Bt �BI�j

�{sZR� �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� $R {BtR�st� PB� {Bt�s{� 8BI� R{stR BP s�B8${sjjk 4s� RZ�Ps{�R�

�Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt }�B{�IZ�� $R ���s�jk R$8}j$h�I� qY� N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{� t��I Btjk A�

{sj{Zjs��I Bt{� sP��� �Y� R��sIk R�s�� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt $R ��s{Y�I� qY� V3� js���sj

Ikts8${R 8BI�j {st �Y���PB�� A� I�{BZ}j�I P�B8 �Y� V3� %���${sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j�

qY� �st��t�$sj PB�{� }B��$Bt BP �Y� 7$8Zj$t, 8BI�j R$8}jk $8}j�8�t�R eJZs�$BtR wn�nnD

stI wn�n;D� 3$�Z�� xTn RYBbR $�R AjB{, I$s��s8� qY� {�t��sjjk jB{s��I AjB{, {Bt%�kR �Y�

S

Slip Distance

finds

Y

Piezoelectric TubeDisplacement

trav

NondimesionalVelocity

Nondimensionaltime

Mux

Memory

x' = Ax+Buy = Cx+Du

Lateral Dynamics ofAFM Cantilever

Fc

Surface Force

sin(2*pi*u) X

Cantilever TipDisplacement

Lateral DynamicsAFM Model

3$�Z�� xTnU V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� ]Bt�s{� �BI� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j

R$tZRB$Isj I�}�tI�t{� BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� Bt Rj$} I$R�st{�� y� s{�R sR �Y� $t}Z� �B �Y� R�s��

R}s{� ��}��R�t�s�$Bt BP �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R BP �Y� V3� {st�$j�%��� qY� tBtI$8�tR$Btsj

�$8� $R 8Zj�$}j$�I Ak �Y� tBtI$8�tR$Btsj R{st %�jB{$�k� ��s%� �B �$%� �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�

}BR$�$Bt� qY� {st�$j�%�� }BR$�$Bt $t {B8A$ts�$Bt b$�Y �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� }BR$�$Bt $R �Y�t

ZR�I sR �Y� $t}Z� �B �Y� �htIR:1 PZt{�$Bt bY${Y ZR�R s tZ8��sj �BB� htI$t� sj�B�$�Y8 �B

BZ�}Z� �Y� Rj$} I$R�st{�� qY� 8�8B�k AjB{, s$IR $t $�R PZt{�$Btsj$�k Ak ZR$t� �Y� BZ�}Z� sR

�Y� t�b �Z�RR PB� �Y� RBjZ�$Bt�

qY� 8BI�j B}��s��R RZ{Y �Ys� s R{stt$t� %�jB{$�k BP �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� js���sjjk

R����{Y�R �Y� {st�$j�%��� yt B�Y�� bB�IR� �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� }ZjjR �Y� {st�$j�%�� A�Y$tI

$�� qY$R {sZR�R �Y� {st�$j�%�� I$R}js{�8�t�� ?�� �B A� }BR$�$%� PB� s }BR$�$%� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� stI

1qY� �s�jsA ]BI� PB� �Y� PZt{�$Bt $R $t V}}�tI$- ]�x

;E

Page 47: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

%${� %��Rs� qY�R� P�s�Z��R b$jj A�{B8� }s��${Zjs�jk $8}B��st� $t stsjk9$t� �Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt

��RZj�R�

x�1 ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt _�B{�IZ��

qY� R$8Zjs�$Bt $R �Zt Ak �-�{Z�$t� s PZjjk sZ�B8s��I �s�jsA R{�$}� �Ys� �ZtR 7$8Zj$t,

8BI�jR� {Yst��R �Y� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt� stI Rs%�R }���$t�t� ��RZj�Rn� y� h�R� �-�{Z��R s

}s�s8���� hj� �Ys� $t$�$sj$9�R �Y� 8BI�j;� qY� %sjZ�R BP �Y� }s�s8����R s�� RZ88s�$9�I $t

V}}�tI$- � qY� R{�$}� �Y�t {sjjR �Y� V3� %���${sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j� �{sZR� �Y� R�s��

R}s{� �JZs�$BtR I�R{�$A� s PBZ��Y B�I�� j$t�s� I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt b$�YBZ� I$R{Bt�$tZ$�$�R�

�s�jsA:R �BI�;x: I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt RBj%�� $R RZ^{$�t� PB� s{Y$�%$t� s {Bt%���$t� RBjZ�$Bt�

qY� I�PsZj� �Bj��st{�R s�� ZR�I A�{sZR� BP �Y� tBtI$8�tR$Btsj ts�Z�� BP �Y� 8BI�j� qY�

�s�jsA R{�$}� �Y�t �-�{Z��R �Y� R�{BtI }s�s8���� hj� bY${Y $t$�$sj$9�R �Y� P�${�$Bt 7$8Zj$t,

8BI�jx� qY� hj� htIR �Y� N�tts�ITFBt�R I$R�st{� P�B8 �Y� R��sIk R�s�� tB�8sj PB�{��

qY� ��8s$t$t� P�${�$Bt 8BI�j }s�s8����R s�� $t$�$sj$9�I� qY� R{�$}� �Y�t {sjjR �Y� P�${�$Bt

8BI�j� �{sZR� �Y� P�${�$Bt 8BI�j $R s tBtj$t�s� R�{BtI B�I�� I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt b$�Y

I$R{Bt�$tZ$�$�R� �s�jsA:R �BI�1nR: I$&���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt RBj%�� $R ZR�I� VR A�PB��� �Y� I�PsZj�

�Bj��st{�R s�� ZR�I stI �Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt $R �Zt PB� 1b0�y8 tBtI$8�tR$Btsj �$8� Zt$�R� yt �Y$R

bsk� $� $R �tRZ��I �Ys� �Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt �ZtR PB� �bB PZjj R$tZRB$I }��$BIR�

x�n ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt i�RZj�R

qY� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� {st A� PBZtI PB� s %s�$��k BP B}��s�$t� {BtI$�$BtR ZR$t� �Y� 7$8Zj$t,

8BI�jR I�R{�$A�I sAB%�� qY� 8BI�j R�s��R �Ys� �Y� P�${�$Bt PB�{� I�}�tIR Bt �bB }s�s8����RU

�Y� tBtI$8�tR$Btsj {st�$j�%�� stI {Bt�s{� R�$&t�RR�R� qY� %sjZ� BP �� $R %s�$�I Ak {Yst�$t�

�Y� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt R�� }B$t� B� $t B�Y�� bB�IR Ak {Yst�$t� �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�� 3$%�

R$8Zjs�$BtR b��� �Zt s� h%� I$&���t� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt R�� }B$t�R� qsAj� x�d RYBbR �Y�

I�4�{�$Bt� tB�8sj PB�{�� stI tBtI$8�tR$Btsj R�$&t�RR�R PB� �s{Y BP �Y� h%� R$8Zjs�$BtR�

]Bt�s{� R�$&t�RR�R� $t s{�Zsj$�k� I�}�tI Z}Bt eJZs�$Bt wn�dED� e&�{�$%� tstBR{sj� RY�s�

8BIZj$ %sjZ�R s�� tB� �sR$jk s��s$tsAj�� ytR��sI� �Y� {Bt�s{� R�$&t�RR bsR �R�$8s��I sR

nqY� �s�jsA {BI� PB� �Y$R R{�$}� $R PBZtI $t V}}�tI$- ]�d�;qY� �s�jsA {BI� PB� �Y$R }s�s8���� hj� $R PBZtI $t V}}�tI$- ]�1�xqY� �s�jsA {BI� PB� �Y� }s�s8���� hj� $R $t{jZI�I $t V}}�tI$- ]�;�

;�

Page 48: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

Ys%$t� s %sjZ� �Y��� PBZ��YR �Ys� BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� R�$&t�RR� 3$�Z�� xT; RYBbR �Y� �st��t�$sj

WZ8A�� *�4�{�$Bt wzED WB�8sj 3B�{� w ]D ]st�$j%�� 7�$&t�RR ]Bt�s{� 7�$&t�RR

d d(( d��MnM n��;n1 1��x�;

1 1x( ;��xM� d;��(( dd��xn

n x(( ���dMn ��;dME x�xE;(

; �x( d;�M�� ;����� n��n;M

x d((( d��MnE n��E;n 1�M1n1

qsAj� x�dU _s�s8����R PB� ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� 7$8Zjs�$BtR

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

x 10-9

3

2

1

0

1

2

3

4x 10

-6

LateralSurface

Force(N

ewtons)

Piezoelectric Tube Position (Meters)

1

2

3

4

5

3$�Z�� xT;U i�RZj�R BP 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� 7$8Zjs�$BtR PB� 3$%� ]st�$j�%�� *�4�{�$BtR

PB�{� ��RZj�R PB� h%� I$&���t� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt R�� }B$t�RE� q�s{� d RYBbR �Y� {sR� BP s

R8sjj tB�8sj PB�{�� 7j$} I$R�st{� $R t�s�jk $I�t�${sj �B }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� }BR$�$Bt stI Y�t{�

�Y� ��s{� RYBbR �Y� R$tZRB$Isj I�}�tI�t{� BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� Bt �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�:R

}BR$�$Bt� qY� PB�{� $R �t�$��jk {BtR��%s�$%� A�{sZR� �Y� s%��s�� P�${�$Bt BP s R$tZRB$Isj ��s{�

B%�� s }��$BI $R 9��B� GY�t �Y� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt $R $t{��sR�I �B 1x( tstB8����R� �Y�

P�${�$Bt ��s{�R jBR�R $�R R$tZRB$Isj Rk88���k� AZ� ��8s$tR {BtR��%s�$%�� !t �Y� IBbtbs�I

E3B� }Z�}BR�R BP $jjZR��s�$t� }YkR${sj 8�{Yst$R8R� �Y� js���sj P��JZ�t{k BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� bsR I�{��sR�IAk s Ps{�B� BP n( PB� �Y� }�BIZ{�$Bt BP 3$�Z�� xT;� Vjj tZ8��${sj ��RZj�R� YBb�%��� ZR� �Y� s{�Zsj {st�$j�%��P��JZ�t{k� V}}�tI$- e RYBbR stI I$R{ZRR�R �Y� ��s}Y${sj ��RZj�R PB� �Y� s{�Zsj {st�$j�%�� P��JZ�t{k�

;M

Page 49: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

RjB}�� �Y� ��B8���${ {BtR��s$t� I�R{�$A�I Ak eJZs�$Bt wn�nnD PB�{�R s �s}$I I�{��sR� $t

js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� }�� Zt$� �$8�� _YkR${sjjk� sR �Y� R$tZRB$Isj }B��t�$sj A��$tR �B I�{��sR�

�Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� �Y� {st�$j�%�� stI RZ�Ps{� R}�$t� �-��tR$Bt A��$tR �B I�{��sR� sR b�jj�

qB 8��� �Y� ��B8���k {BtR��s$t�� �Y� Rj$} I$R�st{� �s}$Ijk $t{��sR�R stI �Y���Ak PZ��Y��

I�{��sR$t� �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� qY$R �}BR$�$%�: P��IAs{, 8�{Yst$R8 {st sjRB A� I�R{�$A�I

�t�����${sjjk� VR �Y� Rj$} I$R�st{� stI js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $t{��sR�� �Y� RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$Bt

}B��t�$sj s{{Z8Zjs��R $t �Y� {st�$j�%�� stI {Bt�s{� R}�$t�R� VP��� �Y� R}�$t� ��s{Y�R $�R

8s-$8Z8 }B��t�$sj� $� A��$tR �B ��stRP�� �t���k �B �Y� RZ�Ps{�� qY$R ��stRP�� $R I����8$t�I

Ak �Y� RZ�Ps{�:R }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt stI �Y� RZ�Ps{� R}�$t�:R {BtR�$�Z�$%� ��js�$Bt� GY�t �Y�

R�{BtI I$��{�$Btsj I��$%s�$%� BP �Y� }B��t�$sj PZt{�$Bt $R j�RR �Yst �Y� {Bt�s{� R�$&t�RR� �Y�

�$} }BR$�$Bt ��8s$tR R�sAj�� �s�Y�8s�${sjjk�

b(1~?F(?1

� >X wx�dD

eJZ$%sj�t�jk� FBYtRBt stI GBBIYBZR� R�s�� �Ys� R�sA$j$�k $R 8s$t�s$t�I bY�t �Y� tBtI$T

8�tR$Btsj {Bt�s{� R�$&t�RR $R ���s��� �Yst 1$�

yt q�s{� n� �Y� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt $R x(( tstB8����R� qY� tBtI$8�tR$Btsj {Bt�s{�

R�$&t�RR $R x�xE;( stI sR �-}�{��I �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$} }BR$�$Bt $R ZtR�sAj�� *Z�$t� �Y� Rj$}

}�B{�RR� �Y� RZ�Ps{� R}�$t� {st tB� ,��} Z} b$�Y �Y� �s}$I I�{��sR� $t �Y� RZ�Ps{� }B��t�$sj�

VR s ��RZj�� �t���k $R ��stRP����I �B �Y� {st�$j�%�� bY��� $� $R jBR� $t �Y� PB�8 BP Is8}�I

BR{$jjs�$Bt� et���k $R sjRB ��stRP����I �B �Y� RZ�Ps{� $t �Y� PB�8 BP }YBtBtR� V 8�sRZ��

BP �Y$R �k}� BP �t���k I$RR$}s�$Bt {st A� 8sI� Ak {B8}s�$t� �Y� 8s-$8Z8 stI 8$t$8Z8

RZ�Ps{� PB�{� PB� �s{Y ��s{�� qsAj� x�1 RYBbR �Y�R� ��RZj�R� yt �Y� h�R� �bB ��s{�R� IZ�

WZ8A�� Ey?B?w ]D E7zB?w ]D 0 NBRR

d �n��M( T�n��M( (�((((�L(((

1 d�((xd Td�((x( 1�x�Mn�T((n

n 1�(dM� T1�(d�� ;�(xM��T((1

; n�((�; T1����� ��EnE��L(((

x n���Mx T1��dE( n�d�nn�L((d

qsAj� x�1U �s-$8Z8 stI �$t$8Z8 3B�{�R PB� ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$BtR

�B �Y� R�sA$j$�k {BtI$�$Bt� �Y� 8s-$8Z8 stI 8$t$8Z8 P�${�$Bt PB�{�R s�� $I�t�${sj b$�Y$t

R$8Zjs�$Bt �Bj��st{�R� yt �Y� �Y$�I ��s{�� �Y� RkR��8 $R `ZR� A�kBtI �Y� R�sA$j$�k {BtI$�$Bt

;�

Page 50: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

stI �Y� 8s�t$�ZI� BP �Y� 8$t$Z8 RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $R s R8sjj }��{�t�s�� j�RR �Yst �Y� 8s�t$�ZI�

BP �Y� 8s-$8Z8 js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� V I�s8s�${ {Yst�� B{{Z�R PB� �Y� PBZ��Y ��s{�� Vj8BR�

M0 BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� 8s�t$�ZI� $R jBR� IZ� �B �Y� Rj$} }�B{�RR stI sj8BR� n10 BP �Y�

RZ�Ps{� PB�{� 8s�t$�ZI� $R jBR� PB� �Y� hP�Y R$8Zjs�$Bt�

yt����R�$t�jk� �Y� jsR� ��s{� RYBbR s 8$t$8Z8 RZ�Ps{� PB�{� 8s�t$�ZI� R8sjj�� �Yst �Y�

��s{� `ZR� A�PB�� $�� qY�R� jBRR�R ��RZj� $t st $t{��sR� $t �Y� s%��s�� P�${�$Bt RZ�Ps{� PB�{�

B%�� s js��${� R}s{$t�� yt B�Y�� bB�IR� PB� $t{��sR$t� tB�8sj PB�{� �Y� RZ�Ps{� R�B��R st

$t{��sR$t� s8BZt� BP �t���k�

x�; qs}}$t� �BI� 7$8Zj$t, �BI�j

qY� �s}}$t� 8BI� R$8Zjs�$Bt $R R$8$js� �B �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� R$8Zjs�$Bt $t �Ys� $� AZ$jIR

Z}Bt ej i$Ps$:R �s}}$t� 8BI� R$8Zjs�$BtR� AZ� YsR 8stk $8}j�8�t�s�$Bt P�s�Z��R $t bY${Y

�Y� �bB I$&�� >1�H� qY� 8s$t I$&���t{� $R �Ys� �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j $R {BZ}j�I �B �Y�

%���${sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j $t�B s R$t�j� V3� �s}}$t� 8BI� 7$8Zj$t, 8BI�j� 3$�Z�� xTx RYBbR

YBb �Y� AjB{, I$s��s8 $t����s��R �Y� �bB 8BI�jR $t�B s R$t�j� 8BI�j �Ys� htIR �Y� %sjZ�R

PB� �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� qY� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA�T]st�$j�%�� �BI�j $R $I�t�${sj �B �Y�

Bt� ZR�I $t �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� 8BI�j� yt sII$�$Bt �B $�R Ikts8${R� �Y� R��sIk R�s�� A$8B�}Y

RYs,�� ��R}BtR� $R sII�I� 3$�Z�� xTE RYBbR YBb �Y� ��RZj�R BP eJZs�$BtR w1�;1D� w1�;ED�

w1�;MD stI w1�;�D s�� RZ}��$8}BR�I stI sII�I �B �Y� R�s�� R}s{� ��R}BtR�� qY� R�s��R s��

ZR�I sR $t}Z�R �B �Y� :{B8}Z���s}}$t�: PZt{�$Bt bY${Y 8Z{Y j$,� �{B8}Z��{Bt�s{�: ZR�R �Y�

�sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� 8BI�j �B {sj{Zjs�� �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� s8Bt� B�Y�� }YkR${sj JZst�$�$�R�� qY�

PZt{�$Bt sjRB ZR�R s Y$� {�BRR$t� AjB{, �B htI bY�t �Y� {st�$j�%�� %�jB{$�k $R 9��B� qY$R $R

ZR�I $t {sj{Zjs�$Bt BP �Y� �BB� 8�st RJZs�� {st�$j�%�� s8}j$�ZI� bY${Y $R �Y�t RZA��s{��I

P�B8 �Y� R��}B$t� �B {��s�� st ���B� R$�tsj R�t� �B �Y� {Bt��Bjj��� qY� {Bt��Bjj�� �s,�R �Y�

Rs8� PB�8 sR �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� {Bt��Bjj�� AZ� ZR�R s I$&���t� %sjZ� PB� �Y� _y* �s$t �B

8s$t�s$t R�sA$j$�k� qY� �]B8}Z���s}}$t�: PZt{�$Bt sjRB {sj{Zjs��R �Y� �$8� $t bY${Y �Y�

{st�$j�%�� �$} YsR $t$�$sjjk ��BZ{Y�I IBbt: �B �Y� RZ�Ps{�� �qBZ{Y�I IBbt: $R I�ht�I sR

P��j$t� �Y� sIY�R$Bt stI �jsR�${ $t���s{�$BtR BP �Y� RZ�Ps{�� +Zst�$�s�$%�jk� �Y$R $R I�ht�I

�qY� �s�jsA ]BI� PB� �Y� PZt{�$Bt $R $t V}}�tI$- *�n

x(

Page 51: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

computetapping

sample/tip force

K

t_c

Touchdown Times

Tip Amplitude Set Point

In1 Out1

Steady State Bimorph Shaker Response

q

States & Bimorph Response

q1234

States

Sample shape

y_s

Sample Height

y_rms

RMS TIP AMPLITUDE

x' = Ax+Bu

y = Cx+Du

Piezoelectric Tube-

Cantilever model

In1 Out1

PID Controller

fn

Normal Force

frictime

Nondimensional Surface

Contact Time

Mux

Mux

Mux

Tstar

Maximum Possible

Surface Force

z

Lennard-Jones Distance

Hit Crossing

In1

In2 Out1

Surface ForceModel

Fc

Surface Force

findz

Extract L-J

Distance

bb

Effective Radius of Contact

Demux

Demux

delta

Deformation Distance

In1 Out1

Contact Time Calculation

f_d

Contact &

Damping Force

K

Cantilever &

Piezo Rel. Disp.

y_bi

Bimorph Position

2

4

4

4

4

4

4

4

4

4

7

4

4

8

2 2

2

3$�Z�� xTxU V jB{, *$s��s8 BP �Y� V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}� qs}}$t� �BI� �BI�j

$t �Y� �sZ�$R *Z�Isj� 8BI�j $t ���8R BP �Y� I�PB�8s�$Bt I$R�st{� & sRU

& k &L wx�1D

&L $R �Y� I�PB�8s�$Bt I$R�st{� s� �Y� {Bt�s{� s��s $R 9��B� qY� �BZ{YIBbt �$8� $R ZR�I �B

I$��{�jk {sj{Zjs�� �Y� �$8� $t �Y� P�${�$Bt 8BI�j� 3$�Z�� xT� RYBbR YBb �Y� {sj{Zjs�$Bt $R

}��PB�8�I $t �Y� ]Bt�s{� q$8� ]sj{Zjs�$Bt jB{,� qY� �$8� $t���%sj $t bY${Y �Y� {st�$j�%��

YsR A��t $t {Bt�s{� $R 8Zj�$}j$�I Ak s �s$t �Ys� h�R� I$8�tR$Btsj$9�R �Y� �$8�� stI �Y�t

tBtI$8�tR$Btsj$9�R $� b$�Y ��R}�{� �B �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j� qY� Rb$�{Y �-$R�R RZ{Y

�Ys� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� {sj{Zjs�$BtR s�� Btjk }��PB�8�I bY�t $t {Bt�s{�� qY� BZ�}Z� BP �Y� AjB{,

�B���Y�� b$�Y �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� {sj{Zjs�$Bt $R ZR�I sR st $t}Z� �B �htI9: PZt{�$BtM� qY�

PZt{�$Bt� ZtI�� �Y� {BtI$�$Bt BP $t���s{�$t� b$�Y �Y� RZ�Ps{�� h�R� tZ8��${sjjk htIR �Y�

N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{�� stI �Y�t ZR�R $� �B {sj{Zjs�� �Y� s8}j$�ZI� BP �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{�

MqY� �s�jsA {BI� PB� �Y$R PZt{�$Bt $R $t V}}�tI$- *�;�

xd

Page 52: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

1

Out1

q6

q5

q6dot

q5dot

Mux

-A6*x_s*omega_d*cos(omega_d/omega*u+Phi)/(D*Z*omega)

-A5*x_s*omega_d^2*sin(omega_d/omega*u+Phi)/(D*Z*omega^2)

-1*A6*x_s*omega_d^2*sin(omega_d/omega*u+Phi)/(D*Z*omega^2)

-A5*x_s*omega_d^3*cos(omega_d/omega*u+Phi)/(D*Z*omega^3)

K

1

In1

4 4

3$�Z�� xTEU V jB{, *$s��s8 BP 7��sIk 7�s�� 7Ys,�� $8B�}Y 7Ys,�� i�R}BtR�

1

Out1Switch

-K-

Gain

0

1

In1

3$�Z�� xT�U V jB{, *$s��s8 BP Ns���sj *kts8${R �BI�j q$8� ]sj{Zjs�$Bt

PB�{� PZt{�$Bt� B�Y %sjZ�R s�� R�t� �B �Y� 7$8Zj$t, �t%$�Bt8�t�� qY� 8s-$8Z8 RZ�Ps{�

PB�{� �B���Y�� b$�Y �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j �$8� s�� ZR�I sR $t}Z�R �B �Y� P�${�$Bt 8BI�j

bY${Y $R RYBbt $t 3$�Z�� xTM� V tBtI$8�tR$Btsj {BtR�st� ��}��R�t�$t� �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�

1

Out1

XSY

Mux finds

Geometry Constraint

trav

sin(2*pi*u)

x' = Ax+Bu

y = Cx+Du

AFM Lateral

Dynamics Model

2

In2

1

In13

3$�Z�� xTMU V jB{, *$s��s8 PB� qs}}$t� �BI� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j

%�jB{$�k $R ZR�I �B {sj{Zjs�� �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� }BR�$Bt� y�� �B���Y��� b$�Y �Y� {st�$j�%��

�$} }BR$�$Bt $R ZR�I sR st $t}Z� �B �Y� �htIR: PZt{�$Bt�� qY� �htIR: PZt{�$Bt ZR�I $t �s}}$t�

�qY� �s�jsA {BI� PB� �Y$R PZt{�$Bt $R V}}�tI$- *�x�

x1

Page 53: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

8BI� R��%�R �Y� Rs8� PZt{�$Bt sR $�R {Bt�s{� 8BI� {BZt���}s��� y�� YBb�%��� 8ZR� sjRB

s{{BZt� PB� �Y� �$8� %s�k$t� ts�Z�� BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� s8}j$�ZI�� qY� PZt{�$Bt sjRB Btjk

B}��s��R bY�t �Y� {st�$j�%�� $R $t���s{�$t� b$�Y �Y� RZ�Ps{�� qY� Rj$} I$R�st{� $� {sj{Zjs��R $R

�Y�t ZR�I �B {sj{Zjs�� �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� bY${Y $R ZR�I �B �-{$�� �Y� R�s�� R}s{� ��}��R�t�s�$Bt

BP �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R BP �Y� {st�$j�%���

qY� �s}}$t� 8BI� 7$8Zj$t, 8BI�j YsR 8stk BP �Y� ZR�PZj P�s�Z��R PBZtI $t �Y� {Bt�s{�

8BI� 7$8Zj$t, 8BI�j� zs�k$t� Rs8}j�R RYs}�R {st A� R$8Zjs��I� stI ��stR$�t�R BP �Y�

{st�$j�%�� stI }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� s�� {s}�Z��I� y� sjRB sjjBbR �Y� ZR�� �B {Bt��Bj �Y� �BB�

8�st RJZs�� {st�$j�%�� s8}j$�ZI� R�� }B$t� stI �Y� A$8B�}Y RYs,�� s8}j$�ZI�� �Z{Y j$,�

�Y� }��%$BZR $t%�R�$�s�$Bt� s�B8${sjjk 4s� RZ�Ps{�R b$jj A� R{stt�I �s{Y �$8�� V A$8B�}Y

RYs,�� s8}j$�ZI� BP Bt� tstB8���� bsR ZR�I $t {B8A$ts�$Bt b$�Y s �BB� 8�st RJZs��

{st�$j�%�� s8}j$�ZI� BP ;1�;1E tstB8����R�

x�x qs}}$t� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt _�B{�IZ��

N$,� �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� R$8Zjs�$BtR s PZjjk sZ�B8s��I �s�jsA R{�$}� bsR b�$���t �B $t$�$sj$9�

stI ��}�s��Ijk �Zt R$8Zjs�$BtR� {Yst�� R$8Zjs�$Bt }s�s8����R� stI Rs%� }���$t�t� ��RZj�R�

3$�R�� s }s�s8���� hj� �Ys� $t$�$sj$9�I AB�Y %���${sj stI js���sj Ikts8${R 8BI�jR bsR �-�T

{Z��I� qY� �s}}$t� 8BI� 7$8Zj$t, 8BI�j bsR �Zt PB� x( tBtI$8�tR$Btsj �$8� Zt$�R b$�Y

�Y� js���sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j 8s,$t� {sj{Zjs�$BtR PB� �Y� bYBj� �$8�� qY$R �Zt {s}�Z��R �Y�

RZ�Ps{� PB�{� A�Ys%$B� PB� s}}�B-$8s��jk �Y� h�R� hP���t �s}R BP �Y� ��stR$�t� ��R}BtR�� i�jT

�%st� Is�s bsR Rs%�I stI s R�{BtI R$8Zjs�$Bt $t bY${Y R{st %�jB{$�k bsR %s�$�I P�B8 h%�

�B hP�k 8${�BtR }�� R�{BtI bsR �Zt� qY� R$8Zjs�$Bt bsR �Zt PB� �Y� Rs8� j�t��Y BP �$8��

AZ� Btjk Is�s PB� �Y� h�R� �s} bsR Rs%�I� qY� jsR� R$8Zjs�$Bt {s}�Z��I �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{�

PB�{� A�Ys%$B� BP �Y� V3� $t $�R �s}}$t� 8BI� R��sIk R�s��� �BI�1nR: bsR {YBR�t sR �Y� I$PT

P���t�$sj �JZs�$Bt RBj%�� A�{sZR� $� }�B%�I �B A� 8B�� �BAZR� �Yst �BI�;x: $t {Bt�s{� 8BI�

R$8Zjs�$BtR� V ��js�$%� stI st sARBjZ�� �Bj��st{� BP d(�; stI d(�E bsR ZR�I ��R}�{�$%�jk�

x�E qs}}$t� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt i�RZj�R

3�B8 �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� R$8Zjs�$BtR� $� bsR �-}�{��I �Ys� �Y� �s}}$t� 8BI� P�${�$Bt PB�{�

bBZjI I�}�tI }�$8s�$jk Z}Bt �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� �-}��$�t{�I Ak �Y� {st�$j�%��� qY� }�s,

tB�8sj PB�{� bsR PBZtI �B %s�k R$�t$h{st�jk P�B8 �s} �B �s} B%�� �Y� {BZ�R� BP �Y� �s}}$t�

xn

Page 54: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

8BI� ��stR$�t�� ytR��sI BP �Ztt$t� 8stk R$8Zjs�$BtR� �Y� Is�s P�B8 �Y�R� �s}R BP %s�k$t�

tB�8sj PB�{� b��� ZR�I� 3$�Z�� xT� RYBbR s }jB� BP �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�� N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{��

stI RZ�Ps{� PB�{� sR s PZt{�$Bt BP �$8� PB� �k}${sj �s}� VR �-}�{��I� �Y� }jB� RYBbR s RYs�}

1.25 1.3 1.35 1.4 1.45 1.5 1.55 1.6 1.65

x 10-6

0

0.5

1x 10

-5

Norm

alForce(N

)

1.25 1.3 1.35 1.4 1.45 1.5 1.55 1.6 1.65

x 10-6

2.2

2.4

2.6

2.8

3x 10

-10

Len

nard

Jones

Distance

(m)

1.25 1.3 1.35 1.4 1.45 1.5 1.55 1.6 1.65

x 10-6

1

0

1

2

3x 10

-9

Surface

Force(N

)

Time (Seconds)

3$�Z�� xT�U WB�8sj 3B�{�� N�tts�I FBt�R *$R�st{� stI 3�${�$Bt 3B�{� PB� s qk}${sj qs}

$t{��sR� stI I�{��sR� $t �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� sR s PZt{�$Bt BP �$8�� y�� YBb�%��� IB�R tB� RYBb

�Y� t��s�$%� tB�8sj PB�{� %sjZ�R A�{sZR� �Y�k s�� %��k R8sjj $t ��js�$Bt �B �Y� 8s-$8Z8

tB�8sj PB�{� %sjZ�R� WZ8��${sjjk� �Y� Is�s RYBbR s 8$t$8Z8 tB�8sj PB�{� %sjZ� BP T11�E�;

tstBW�b�BtR bY$j� �Y� 8s-$8Z8 $R M�(M�M 8${�BW�b�BtR� GY�t �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� A�{B8�R

}BR$�$%�� �Y� N�tts�I FBt�R $R s� $�R �JZ$j$A�$Z8 I$R�st{� BP 1�xE#V� _�$B� �B �Ys� %sjZ�� �Y�

N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{� $R ���s��� �Yst �Ys� stI Y�t{� %���${sjjk }ZjjR Bt sR}��$�k� VP���

�Ys� %sjZ�� ��}ZjR$Bt �tRZ�R stI �Y� R8sjj N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{� {sZR�R st Z}bs�I }ZRY

Bt �Y� sR}��$�k� V{{B�I$t� �B �Y� 8BI�j� �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� j$,� �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�� $R s�

h�R� t��s�$%�� qY� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� sR �-}�{��I� �Y�t �$R�R RYs�}jk b$�Y �Y� $tR�st�st�BZRjk

�$R$t� tB�8sj PB�{�� y�� YBb�%��� ��8s$tR �Y��� B�I��R BP 8s�t$�ZI� R8sjj�� �Yst �Y� tB�8sj

PB�{�� qY� ��js�$%� 8s�t$�ZI�R BP �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� stI �Y� tB�8sj PB�{� $t �s}}$t�

8BI� {st A� {B8}s��I �B �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� PBZtI $t �Y� �Y$�I ��s{�� qY���� �Y� }�s,

RZ�Ps{� PB�{� bsR 1�(dM� 8${�BW�b�BtR PB� s R$8$js� tB�8sj PB�{� BP ���dMn 8${�BW�b�BtR�

x;

Page 55: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

yt B�Y�� bB�IR� R$8$js� }�s, tB�8sj PB�{�R j�sI �B js���sj PB�{� %sjZ�R �Ys� s�� �Y��� B�I��R

BP 8s�t$�ZI� R8sjj��� qY$R ��RZj� B{{Z�R IZ� �B �Y� js���sj PB�{�:R R$tZRB$Isj I�}�tI�t{� Bt

Rj$} I$R�st{�� yt �s}}$t� 8BI�� %��k j$��j� Rj$} YsR B{{Z��I stI RB �Y� R$t� PZt{�$Bt R��%�R

�B R�%���jk j$8$� �Y� %sjZ� �B bY${Y �Y� P�${�$Bt PB�{� {st �$R��

qY� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� sR s PZt{�$Bt BP }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� }BR$�$Bt bY$j� $t {Bt�s{�

b$�Y RZ�Ps{� $R RYBbt $t 3$�Z�� xTd(� qY� h�R� hP���t �s}R BP s R$8Zjs�$Bt s�� RYBbt� es{Y

�s} RYBbR s ��s{� BP R$8$js� RYs}� sR $t 3$�Z�� xT�� V� �Y� �tI BP �s{Y �s}� �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${

�ZA� }BR$�$Bt ���Z�tR �B 9��B RB �Ys� �s{Y �s} 8s�{Y�R �Y� {BtI$�$Bt BP 9��B js���sj PB�{� s�

9��B Rj$} I$R�st{�� VR {st A� R��t� �Y� 8s-$8Z8 }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA� I$R}js{�8�t� $R d�Ex11

}${B8����R� qY$R $R 8Z{Y j�RR �Yst �Y� j�t��Y BP s js��${� {BtR�st�� qY� $t{��sR$t� RZ�Ps{�

PB�{� �&�{� P�B8 �Y� R$tZRB$I $R Btjk s}}s��t� $t �Y� h�R� YsjP BP �Y� {Bt�s{� �$8�� yt �Y�

R�{BtI YsjP� �Y� {st�$j�%�� �$} $R sj��sIk 8B%$t� Z}bs�IR� sbsk P�B8 �Y� RZ�Ps{�d(�

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8

x 10-12

0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3x 10

-9

Piezoelectric Tube Position (meters)

LateralSurface

Force(N

ewtons)

3$�Z�� xTd(U <B�$9Bt�sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� PB� dx qs}R sR s 3Zt{�$Bt BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA�*$R}js{�8�t�

!t� bsk �B $t{��sR� �Y� RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$Bt $R Ak $t{��sR$t� �Y� {Bt�s{� �$8� IZ�$t�

d( �{sZR� �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $t R$8Zjs�$Bt $R Btjk {sj{Zjs��I ZtI�� �Y� {BtI$�$Bt & k &L� �Y� hP���tPB�{� ��s{�R }��8s�Z��jk R�B} sR B}}BR�I �B ���Z�t$t� As{, �B 9��B� yt B�Y�� bB�IR� $P �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�{sj{Zjs�$BtR YsI A��t }��PB�8�I PB� sjj {BtI$�$BtR� �Y� 8BI�j bBZjI RYBb �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� ���Z�t$t� �B9��B�

xx

Page 56: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�s}}$t�� qY$R {st A� s{Y$�%�I Ak $t{��sR$t� �Y� %�jB{$�k BP �Y� }$�9B�j�{��${ �ZA�� 3$�Z��

xTdd RYBbR h%� ��s{�R PB� %s�k$t� R{st %�jB{$�$�R� qY� %�jB{$�k stI }�s, RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$Bt

PB�{� PB� �s{Y ��s{� $R RZ88s�$9�I $t qsAj� x�n

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

x 10-11

0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3x 10

-8

Piezoelectric Position (meters)

LateralSurface

Force(N

ewtons)

3$�Z�� xTddU Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� sR s 3Zt{�$Bt _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� *$R}js{�8�t� PB� zs�kT$t� z�jB{$�$�R

WZ8A�� 7{st z�jB{$�k EbX �s- -y?B?z]

d x 1�E1(d

1 d( x�1nE�

n 1( d(�;�1

; n( dx��(n

x x( 1E�d;�

qsAj� x�nU �s-$8Z8 stI �$t$8Z8 3B�{�R PB� ]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$BtR

qY� h�Z�� RYBbR s I$��{� {B���js�$Bt A��b��t R{st R}��I stI js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� ytT

{��sR$t� �Y� R{st �s�� �$%�R 8B�� �$8� PB� �Y� js���sj Ikts8${R �B B{{Z� ��js�$%� �B �Y�

%���${sj Ikts8${R� qY� Rj$} I$R�st{� �Y�t s{{Z8Zjs��R PZ��Y�� {sZR$t� s js���� RZ�Ps{�

PB�{�� yP �Y� R{st �s�� b��� $t{��sR�I A�kBtI x( 8${�BtR }�� R�{BtI� $� $R �-}�{��I �Ys�

��s{�R R$8$js� �B �YBR� BP {Bt�s{� 8BI� bBZjI A��$t �B s}}�s��

qYZR Ps�� sjj �Y� �s}}$t� 8BI� ��RZj�R Ys%� I�R{�$A�I �s����RR$%�: �s}R sRRB{$s��I b$�Y

xE

Page 57: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

��stR$�t�R BP �Y� %���${sj Ikts8${R 8BI�j� yt �s}}$t� R��sIk R�s��� �s{Y $tI$%$IZsj �s} YsR

j�RR BP st $8}s{� Bt �Y� RZ�Ps{� �Yst RB8� �s}R �Ys� B{{Z� IZ�$t� �Y� ��stR$�t�� V{{B�I$t�jk�

}�s, tB�8sj PB�{�R s�� R8sjj sR b�jj� 3$�Z�� xTd1 RYBbR s }�s, tB�8sj PB�{� BP ME�n1x

tstBW�b�BtR PB� s �k}${sj �s} $t R��sIk R�s�� �s}}$t� 8BI� B}��s�$Bt BP �Y� V3�� y� $R

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5

x 10-7

0

5

10x 10

-8

Norm

alForce(N

)

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5

x 10-7

2.2

2.4

2.6

2.8

3x 10

-10

Len

nard

Jones

Distance

(m)

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5

x 10-7

2

1

0x 10

-10

LateralSuface

Force(N

)

3$�Z�� xTd1U 3�${�$Bt 3B�{� PB� dx qs}R sR s 3Zt{�$Bt BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� *$R}js{�8�t�

�bB B�I��R BP 8s�t$�ZI� j�RR �Yst ��k}${sj: �s} $t �Y� ��stR$�t� �s} RYBbt �s�j$��� qY�

N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{� R�s��R s� t�s�jk �Y��� st�R��B8R stI I�{��sR�R sR �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�

$t{��sR�R� y�� YBb�%��� IB�R tB� ��s{Y �Y� �JZ$j$A�$Z8 I$R�st{� BP FL ) 13xE#\� qY$R s}}�s�R

�B {sZR� �Y� R��8$t�jk }�{Zj$s� ��RZj� BP s RZ�Ps{� PB�{� �Ys� $R t��s�$%� B%�� �Y� �t�$��

{Bt�s{� �$8� BP �Ys� �s}� qY� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� R��8$t�jk sIIR �B �Y� {st�$j�%�� �t���k

b$�Y �%��k �s}� yt sII$�$Bt� �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� s}}�s�R �B tB� `ZR� A� t��s�$%�� AZ� $�

$R sjRB t��s�$%� PB� R8sjj }BR$�$%� tB�8sj PB�{�R sR b�jj�

x�� *$R{ZRR$Bt

qY� %sj$I$�k BP �Y� 8BI�j stI $�R R$8Zjs�$Bt ��RZj�R RYBZjI A� sR{���s$t�I Ak {B8}s�$t�

$� �B �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R� yt �Y�$� sAR�t{�� ��t��sj {B88�t�R Bt �Y� $t�Z$�$%�t�RR BP �Y�

8BI�j {st A� 8sI�� 3$�R�� �Y� {Bt�s{� 8BI� R$8Zjs�$Bt ��RZj�R b$jj A� I$R{ZRR�I� W�-��

x�

Page 58: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�Y� �s}}$t� 8BI� ��RZj�R s�� ��%$�b�I� NsR�jk� s 8s�Y�8s�${sj s����8�t� $R }�B}BR�I �B

�-}js$t �Y� }��R�t{� BP $t�Z$�$%� sR b�jj sR {BZt���$t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R�

yt {Bt�s{� 8BI�� �-}stI$t� �Y� FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� 8BI�j �B Ys%� s Y�$�Y� I�}�tI�t{�

j�I �B $t�Z$�$%� R$8Zjs�$Bt ��RZj�R BP �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� p��s��� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$BtR

{sZR�I ���s��� tB�8sj PB�{�R bY${Y b��� $t �Z�t ��4�{��I $t RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R BP ���s��� 8s�T

t$�ZI�� qY� �-}stR$Bt sjRB I$I tB� I�R��Bk �Y� R$tZRB$Isj ��s{� ZR�I �B I�R{�$A� �Y� js���sj

R�${, Rj$} RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R BP��t 8�sRZ��I $t js���sj PB�{� V3� 8�sRZ��8�t�R�

yt �s}}$t� 8BI�� �Y� ��RZj�R s�� j�RR {j�s�� GY���sR $t RB8� $tR�st{�R �Y�k s}}�s� �B

�$%� $t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R� $t B�Y��R �Y�k s}}�s� �B �$%� {BZt��� $t�Z$�$%� Bt�R� 3B� �-s8}j��

�s����RR$%�: �s}R u Bt�R b$�Y s ��js�$%�jk js��� tB�8sj PB�{� k$�jI�I �Y� $t�Z$�$%� ��RZj� BP

s }BR$�$%� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�� VtB�Y�� $t�Z$�$%� ��RZj� PBZtI PB� �s}}$t� 8BI� bsR �Ys� �Y�

8s�t$�ZI� BP �Y� RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $t{��sR�I b$�Y %�jB{$�k� 7�s��I $t stB�Y�� bsk� �Ys� IZ� �B

$t{��sR�I {Bt�s{� �$8�� $t j$8$� BP $t{��sR$t� R{st R}��I� �s}}$t� 8BI� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�

A�Ys%$B� ��tI�I �Bbs�IR {Bt�s{� 8BI� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� A�Ys%$B�� G$�Y �Y�R� $t�Z$�$%�

��RZj�R� �Y� 8BI�j:R R$8Zjs�$BtR R��8 �B }��I${� {BZt���$t�Z$�$%� PB�{�R sR b�jj� 3B� �-s8}j��

t��s�$%� tB�8sj PB�{�R R��8 �B �$%� t��s�$%� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R� qY� 8BI�j sjRB s}}�s�R

�B }��I${� t��s�$%� js���sj RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$BtR PB� R8sjj }BR$�$%� tB�8sj PB�{�R� qY� 8$- BP

$t�Z$�$%� stI {BZt���$t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R 8sk RZ���R� B}��s�$t� ���$BtR $t bY${Y �Y� 8BI�j $R

$t%sj$I stI {BtI$�$BtR $t bY${Y $� $R %sj$I�

�{sZR� BP �Y� 8$-�Z�� BP R��8$t�jk $t�Z$�$%� stI {BZt���$t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R� $� bsR Yk}B�YT

�R$9�I �Ys� �Y� 7$8Zj$t, {BI� s{{Z�s��jk R$8Zjs��R ���$BtR BP �Y� 8BI�j �Ys� $t��$tR${sjjk

Ys%� {BZt���$t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R� qB �s$t $tR$�Y� $t�B �Y$R Yk}B�Y�R$R� s 8s�Y�8s�${sj $t%�R�$�sT

�$Bt BP �Y� tB�8sj stI js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� PZt{�$BtR bsR }��PB�8�I� VR R�s��I }��%$BZRjk�

�Y� tB�8sj PB�{� PZt{�$Bt $R I��$%�I P�B8 �Y� N�tts�I FBt�R }B��t�$sj stI �$%�t Ak eJZsT

�$Bt wn�dMD� qY� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� PZt{�$Bt $R �$%�t Ak eJZs�$Bt w;�nD� qY� }B$t� BP 9��B

js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� Ak $tR}�{�$Bt B{{Z�R s� FL� qY� }B$t� BP 9��B tB�8sj PB�{� {st A� RBj%�I

sj��A�s${sjjk �B A� ES1� qY� RBZ�{� BP �Y� {BZt���$t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R R��8 �B R��8 P�B8 �Y�

Ps{� �Y�R� �bB tZ8A��R s�� I$&���t�� 3$�Z�� xTdn RYBbR �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� stI �Y� tB�8sj

PB�{�R }jB���I tBtI$8�tR$Btsjjk Bt �Y� Rs8� s-�R� y� RYBbR �Y��� I$R�st{� ���$BtR $t YBb

�Y� PZt{�$BtR ��js�� �B �s{Y B�Y��� !%�� �Y� $t���%sj� w(, FLD� �Y� �bB PZt{�$Bt s�� AB�Y

}BR$�$%�� qY� {B���R}BtIR �B �Y� $t�Z$�$%� ��RZj� BP s }BR$�$%� js���sj PB�{� PB� s }BR$�$%� tB�T

8sj PB�{�� !%�� �Y� $t���%sj >FL,ES1D� �Y� PZt{�$BtR s�� B}}BR$�� R$�t b$�Y �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�

xM

Page 59: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

1 1.1225

0

Nondimensional Distance (z/z0)

Nondim

ensionalForce(N

orm

al,Lateral)

3$�Z�� xTdnU WBtI$8�tR$Btsj _jB� BP Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� stI WB�8sj 3B�{�

A�$t� ���s��� �Yst 9��B� NsR�jk B%�� �Y� $t���%sj� >FL,�H� �Y� PZt{�$BtR s�� AB�Y t��s�$%��qY�R� �bB $t���%sjR {B���R}BtI �B �Y� {BZt���$t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R� qY$R 8s�Y�8s�${sj stsjkR$R

s}}�s�R �B �-}js$t �Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt ��RZj�R�

�s�Y�8s�${sjjk� �Y$R RZ���R�R �Ys� �Y� 8BI�j $�R�jP }�BIZ{�R RB8� ��RZj�R �Ys� s�� {BZtT

���$t�Z$�$%� bY$j� B�Y��R �Ys� s�� 8B�� $t�Z$�$%�� _YkR${sjjk� �Y$R stsjkR$R RZ���R�R �Ys� �Y�

8BI�j 8B�� s{{Z�s��jk I�R{�$A�R js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R bY�t �jsR�${ {Bt�s{� IB8$ts��R �Y�

tB�8sj PB�{�� y� PZ��Y�� RZ���R�R �Ys� AsR�I Bt $t�Z$�$Bt �Y� 8BI�j j�RR s{{Z�s��jk }��I${�R

js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R bY�t sIY�R$%� {Bt�s{� IB8$ts��R �Y� tB�8sj PB�{��

x�

Page 60: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]Ys}��� E

]Bt{jZR$BtR stI i�{B88�tIs�$BtR

E�d ]Bt{jZR$BtR

qY� FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� bsR ZR�I �B }��I${� �Y� R�${,TRj$} js���sj RZ�Ps{� }Y�tB8�ts 8�sT

RZ��I $t V3� PB�{� 8�sRZ�8�t�R� y� bsR sjRB �-}stI�I �B }��I${� �Y� I�}�tIst{� BP �Y�

js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� Bt �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�� yt �Y$R bsk� �Y� 8BI�j bsR I�%�jB}�I �B s}}jk �B

AB�Y �s}}$t� stI {Bt�s{� 8BI�� qY� R$8Zjs��I R�${, Rj$} A�Ys%$B� I�R{�$A�I Ak FBYtRBt

stI GBBIYBZR� bsR ��}�BIZ{�I PB� {Bt�s{� 8BI�� qY� 8s�t$�ZI� BP �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{�

PB�{� bsR PBZtI �B I�}�tI Bt �Y� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt\ tB�8sj PB�{� s}}j$�I Ak �Y� RZ�Ps{�

$t {Bt�s{� 8BI�� 7$8$js� ��RZj�R b��� R$8Zjs��I b$�Y ��R}�{� �B �s}}$t� 8BI� sR b�jj� �V�T

���RR$%�: �s}R �Ys� YsI js��� tB�8sj PB�{� }�s,R b��� PBZtI �B �$%� }BR$�$%� js���sj RZ�Ps{�

PB�{�R� 3B� R8sjj }BR$�$%� tB�8sj PB�{� }�s,R� sR b�jj sR PB� t��s�$%� tB�8sj PB�{� }�s,R� �Y�

��RZj�R s}}�s��I �B A� j�RR $t�Z$�$%�� qY� 8BI�j RZ���R�R �Ys� t��s�$%� tB�8sj PB�{�R j�sI

�B t��s�$%� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R� y� s}}�s�R �B RZ���R� �Y� Rs8� PB� R8sjj tB�8sj PB�{�R

sR b�jj� 3Z��Y�� 8s�Y�8s�${sj stsjkR$R BP �Y� 8BI�j RYBb�I �Ys� �Y� 8BI�j bBZjI }��I${�

j�RR $t�Z$�$%� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� ��RZj�R PB� s�B8${ I$R�st{�R ���s��� �Yst �Y� �JZ$j$A�$Z8

N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{�� qY� stsjkR$R sjRB RZ���R�R �Ys� �Y� 8BI�j bBZjI }��I${� $t�Z$�$%�

��RZj�R PB� s�B8${ I$R�st{�R j�RR �Yst �Y� �JZ$j$A�$Z8 N�tts�I FBt�R I$R�st{� B� $t B�Y��

bB�IR B%�� s ���$8� bY��� �jsR�${ {Bt�s{� IB8$ts��R �Y� tB�8sj PB�{�� V PZ��Y�� �s}}$t�

8BI� ��RZj� bsR �Ys� sR �Y� R{st %�jB{$�k $t{��sR�I �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $t{��sR�I �B

��R�8Aj� {Bt�s{� 8BI� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R�

E(

Page 61: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

E�1 i�{B88�tIs�$BtR

qY� 8BR� $8}B��st� ��{B88�tIs�$Bt $R �B ��RBj%� �Y� {BZt���$t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R �Ys� �Y�

8BI�j RZ���R�R� N$���s�Z�� I�R{�$A�R �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R BP js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R $t �Y�

���$8� BP }�$8s�$jk �jsR�${ {Bt�s{�� 7�ZI$�R $t%Bj%$t� t�s� {Bt�s{� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�

R�ZI$�R Ys%� tB� A��t PBZtI� VII$�$Btsjjk� �-}��$8�t�sj js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� R�ZI$�R PB�

�s}}$t� 8BI� Ys%� tB� A��t sR b�jj� yP s{{Z�s�� �-}��$8�t�sj ��RZj�R {st A� BA�s$t�I

���s�I$t� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R $t �Y$R �k}� BP B}��s�$Bt BP �Y� V3�� $� {st }�B%� �B A�

%��k ZR�PZj $t %sj$Is�$t� �Y� 8BI�j }�B}BR�I $t �Y$R �Y�R$R� yP RZ{Y Is�s $R tB� PB��Y{B8$t��

�Y� 8BI�j 8ZR� A� ��%$R�I �B �$%� 8B�� $t�Z$�$%� ��RZj�R� V ���s��� ZtI��R�stI$t� BP �Y�

RZ�Ps{� $t���s{�$BtR stI �Y�$� 8�{Yst$R8R b$jj A� ��JZ$��I�

E�n 3$tsj qYBZ�Y�R

qY$R �Y�R$R ZR�R s 8BI�j $t bY${Y 8stk tstBR{sj� RZ�Ps{� PB�{�R s�� jZ8}�I $t�B s R$t�j�

PB�{� bY${Y $t {Bt�s{� 8BI� �-}��$8�t�sjjk s}}�s�R �B A� I�R{�$A�I Ak R�${, Rj$} }Y�tB8�ts�

qY$R }Y�tB8�ts� YBb�%��� $R s {B8A$ts�$Bt BP 8stk I$&���t� $t���s{�$BtR� �s{Y Ys%$t� �Y�$�

Bbt }YkR${sj 8�{Yst$R8� yt B�I�� �B ��Zjk �s$t ,tBbj�I�� BP �Y� js���sj RZ�Ps{� PB�{� $t

�Y� V3� $� b$jj �%�t�Zsjjk A�{B8� $8}B��st� �B ZtI��R�stI d�D �Y� ZtI��jk$t� $t���s{�$BtR

$t%Bj%�I stI 1�D �Y� 8�{Yst$R8R Ak bY${Y �Y�k B{{Z�� 7Z{Y s 8��YBI 8$�Y� sjRB j�sI �B

s ���s��� ZtI��R�stI$t� BP �Y� ts�Z�� BP P�${�$Bt bY${Y $R }�BAsAjk `ZR� Bt� BP �Y� I$&���t�

$t���s{�$BtR �Ys� B{{Z� A��b��t �bB 8stk s�B8 ABI$�R�

Ed

Page 62: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

V}}�tI$- V

N$R� BP zs�$sAj�R

z 7$8}j$Pk$t� ]BtR�st�� 7�� eJZs�$Bt w1�1(

y ejsR�${ ]Bt�s{� V��s isI$ZR

yd,1,n,; yt���s{�$Bt _B��t�$sj BP pksjB� stI qYB8sR �BI�j 3BZ�$�� q��8R

�y WBtI$8�tR$Btsj$9�I ejsR�${ ]Bt�s{� V��s isI$ZR

\ 7kR��8 *kts8${R �s��$-

\d,1,n,; WBtI$8�tR$Btsj ]st�$j�%�� eJZs�$Bt BP �B�$Bt 3B�{$t� q��8R ]B�^{$�t�R

\x 7Ys,�� V{{�j��s�$Bt 3B�{$t� q��8 ]B�^{$�t�

\E 7Ys,�� z�jB{$�k 3B�{$t� q��8 ]B�^{$�t�

\� ]st�$j�%�� �s8 ]�BRRTR�{�$Btsj V��s

\W 3�${�$Btsj ]Bt�s{� e&�{�$%� V��s

\� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� ]�BRRTR�{�$Btsj V��s

K �sZ�$RT*Z�Isj� �BI�j 3�${�$Btsj ]Bt�s{� e&�{�$%� isI$ZR

K�? ]st�$j�%�� �s8 *s8}$t� ]B�^{$�t� $t Ns���sj *$��{�$Bt

K�F ]st�$j�%�� �s8 *s8}$t� ]B�^{$�t� $t z���${sj *$��{�$Bt

K� _$�9B�j�{��${ *s8}$t� ]B�^{$�t� qZt$t� ]BtR�st�

KX 7Z�Ps{� *s8}$t� ]B�^{$�t�

4 7kR��8 e-{$�s�$Bt �s��$-

4z Vt V�A$��s�k ]BtR�st�

� isI$ZR BP VIY�R$Bt V��s

�� WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj$9�I VIY�R$Bt V��s isI$ZR

��z t�Y �BI� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� �BIsj *s8}$t� ]B�^{$�t�

E1

Page 63: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

g 7kR��8 !Z�}Z� �s��$-

g� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� ]s}s{$�st{�

& ]st�$j�%�� q$} *�4�{�$Bt *$R�st{�

&L ���B ]Bt�s{� V��s ]st�$j�%�� *�4�{�$Bt *$R�st{�

Qnd _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� 7��s$tTzBj�s�� _�B}B��$Btsj$�k ]BtR�st�

; 7kR��8 !Z�}Z� e-{$�s�$Bt �s��$-

;E �sZ�$R *Z�Isj� WBtT*$8�tR$Btsj *$R}js{�8�t�

;� ej�{��${ *$R}js{�8�t�T]Ys���

6 N�tts�ITFBt�R _B��t�$sj _s�s8����

6F _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� 7��s$t

� is�$B BP VIY�R$Bt ]Bt�s{� isI$ZR �B ejsR�${ ]Bt�s{� V��s

o e&�{�$%� yt���Ps{$sj OBZt�R �BIZjZR

oy OBZt�R �BIZjZR BP VR}��$�k

oX OBZt�R �BIZjZR BP 7Z�Ps{�

o� OBZt�R �BIZjZR BP ]st�$j�%��

o� OBZt�R �BIZjZR BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA�

o� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� V}}j$�I ej�{��${ 3$�jI

B �s-$8Z8 Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{�

BW q$} 7s8}j� 3�${�$Bt 3B�{�

Bz 7Z�Ps{� �B ]st�$j�%�� q$} WB�8sj 3B�{�

�Bz WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj 7Z�Ps{� �B ]st�$j�%�� q$} WB�8sj 3B�{�

B? VR}��$�k �B 7Z�Ps{� Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{�

� VIY�R$Bt et���k _�� =t$� V��s

t e&�{�$%� yt���Ps{$sj 7Y�s� �BIZjZR

ty 7Y�s� �BIZjZR BP VR}��$�k

tX 7Y�s� �BIZjZR BP 7Z�Ps{�

{ ]st�$j�%�� �s8 7�{BtI �B8�t� BP yt���$s

>�? ]st�$j�%�� 7�$&t�R $t <B�$9Bt�sj *$��{�$Bt

>�Fz t�Y �BI� ]st�$j�%�� q$} �BIsj 7�$&t�RR $t z���${sj *$��{�$Bt

>�z t�Y �BI� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� �BIsj 7�$&t�RR

>X 7�$&t�RR BP 7Z�Ps{� $t Ns���sj *$��{�$Bt

>? 7Z�Ps{� V�B8R i�js�$%� �B 7ZAR��s�� V�B8R 7�$&t�RR $t Ns���sj *$��{�$Bt

En

Page 64: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

>I? 7Z�Ps{� V�B8R i�js�$%� �B es{Y !�Y�� 7�$&t�RR $t Ns���sj *$��{�$Bt

>F 7Z�Ps{� V�B8R i�js�$%� �B 7ZAR��s�� V�B8R 7�$&t�RR $t z���${sj *$��{�$Bt

� qY� 7�$&t�RR �s��$- BP �Y� V3� ]st�$j�%��

��8 _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� zBj�s�� _�B}B��$Btsj$�k ]BtR�st�

WBtI$8�tR$Btsj �sZ�$R *Z�Isj� _s�s8����

q 7Z�Ps{� Ns�${� ]BtR�st�

�z ]st�$j�%�� �s8 Gs%�tZ8A�� PB� t�Y �BI�

q� �*Z88k: zs�$sAj� i�}��R�t�$t� ]st�$j�%�� �s8 N�t��Y

q� �*Z88k: zs�$sAj� i�}��R�t�$t� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� N�t��Y

U ]st�$j�%�� �s8 N�t��Y

U� N�t��Y BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA�

]B�^{$�t� BP 3�${�$Bt

E e&�{�$%� ]st�$j�%�� �sRR $t �Y� <B�$9Bt�sj *$��{�$Bt

E�z t�Y �BI� ]st�$j�%�� q$} �BIsj �sRR $t z���${sj *$��{�$Bt

E�z t�Y �BI� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� �BIsj �sRR

-_LqQ �sRR BP ]st�$j�%�� stI $8B�}Y <BjI��

"y _B$RRBtR is�$B BP VR}��$�k

"X _B$RRBtR is�$B BP 7Z�Ps{�

z V 7$8}j$Pk$t� ]BtR�st�� 7�� eJZs�$Bt w1�x

D ��?z ]st�$j�%�� �s8 Ws�Z�sj 3��JZ�t{$�R $t z���${sj *$��{�$Bt

��F ]st�$j�%�� �s8 Ws�Z�sj 3��JZ�t{k $t <B�$9Bt�sj *$��{�$Bt

�Q *�$%$t� 3��JZ�t{k BP $8B�}Y 7Ys,��

��z _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� Ws�Z�sj 3��JZ�t{$�R

* WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj _s�s8���� i�}��R�t�$t� i�js�$%� G�$�Y�R BP ejsR�${$�k m VIY�R$Bt

*X _YsR� Vt�j� $t 7��sIk 7�s�� i�R}BtR� *Z� �B $8B�}Y 7Ys,��

�d, 1 qY� e$��t%sjZ�R BP �Y� qB�sj 7kR��8 _B��t�$sj

� �sZ�$R *Z�Isj� e&�{�$%� isI$ZR qZt$t� _s�s8����

z ]st�$j�%�� �s8 �BI�RYs}� PB� t�Y �BI�

�z _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� �BI�RYs}� PB� t�Y �BI�

hy 3B�{� *Z� �B ejsR�${ ]Bt�s{�

h� 3B�{� *Z� �B VIY�R$%� ]Bt�s{�

R WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj 8BIsj {st�$j�%�� �$} I$R}js{8�t�

E;

Page 65: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�R WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj �BIsj ]st�$j�%�� q$} z�jB{$�k

[R WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj �BIsj ]st�$j�%�� q$} V{{�j��s�$Bt

R� WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj �BIsj _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� *$R}js{8�t�

�R� WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj �BIsj _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� z�jB{$�k

[R� WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj �BIsj _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� V{{�j��s�$Bt

<z t�Y �BI� ]st�$j�%�� q$} e-{$�s�$Bt q��8

<�z t�Y �BI� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� �BIsj e-{$�s�$Bt q��8

' *�tR$�k BP ]st�$j�%�� �s8

'� *�tR$�k BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA�

n�� V ]BB�I$ts�� z�{�B� BP �Y� ]st�$j�%�� q$} wV�B8D

n�7 V ]BB�I$ts�� z�{�B� BP st V�A$��s�k 7Z�Ps{� V�B8

n�� V ]BB�I$ts�� z�{�B� BP �Y� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA�

py VR}��$�k ]Z�%s�Z�� isI$ZR

p7 _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� ytt�� isI$ZR

pL _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� !Z��� isI$ZR

�L �$t$8Z8 N�tts�I FBt�R 3B�{�

�F _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� 7���RR $t z���${sj *$��{�$Bt

X <B�$9Bt�sj �7j$}: I$R�st{�

+ FBYtRBtTGBBIYBZR� �BI�j WBtI$8�tR$Btsj q$8�

+y VR}��$�k 7Y�s� 7���t��Y

+� e&�{�$%� yt���Ps{$sj 7Y�s� 7���t��Y

+X 7Z�Ps{� 7Y�s� 7���t��Y

0 q$8�

0�y8 WBtI$8�tR$Btsj 7{st is��� Ns���sj z�jB{$�k

xz t�Y �BI� ]st�$j�%�� q$} �BIsj *$R}js{�8�t�

�xz t�Y �BI� ]st�$j�%�� q$} �BIsj z�jB{$�k

[xz t�Y �BI� ]st�$j�%�� q$} �BIsj V{{�j��s�$Bt

x�z t�Y �BI� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� �BIsj *$R}js{�8�t�

�x�z t�Y �BI� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� �BIsj z�jB{$�k

[x�z t�Y �BI� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� �BIsj V{{�j��s�$Bt

~ �s-$8Z8 yt���Ps{$sj _B��t�$sj $t Ns���sj *$��{�$Bt

~x qY� qB�sj _B��t�$sj ��b��t �Y� V3� ]st�$j�%��� �Y� 7Z�Ps{�

Ex

Page 66: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

~? qY� yt���Ps{$sj 7Z�Ps{� _B��t�$sj PB� s !t� *$8�tR$Btsj 7{st

~?r qY� yt���Ps{$sj 7Z�Ps{� _B��t�$sj PB� s qbB *$8�tR$Btsj 7{st

~F yt���Ps{$sj _B��t�$sj $t �Y� WB�8sj *$��{�$Bt

~F� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� zBj�s�� $t z���${sj *$��{�$Bt

�~F� WBtI$8�tR$Btsj �BIsj _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� zBj�s��

|? _�$8s�k 7{st *$��{�$Bt =t$� z�{�B�

?� ]st�$j�%�� q$} <B�$9Bt�sj *$R}js{�8�t�

?7 V�A$��s�k 7Z�Ps{� V�B8 <B�$9Bt�sj *$R}js{8�t�

?� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� <B�$9Bt�sj *$R}js{�8�t�

?X 7Z�Ps{� 7�$&t�RR <B�$9Bt�sj *$R}js{�8�t�

� 7kR��8 *kts8${R 7�s��R z�{�B�

[� 7kR��8 *kts8${R 7�s�� *��$%$�$%�R z�{�B�

|r 7�{BtIs�k 7{st *$��{�$Bt =t$� z�{�B�

r� ]st�$j�%�� q$} *$R}js{�8�t� $t �Y� 7�{BtIs�k 7{st *$��{�$Bt

F z���${sj *$��{�$Bt ��sRZ��I P�B8 7Z�Ps{�

F� ]st�$j�%�� q$} i�js�$%� *$R}js{�8�t�

�F� ]st�$j�%�� q$} z�jB{$�k

[F� ]st�$j�%�� q$} V{{�j��s�$Bt

FL N�tts�I FBt�R _B��t�$sj ]�$�{sj *$R�st{�

F� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� *$R}js{�8�t�

�F� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� z�jB{$�k

[F� _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� V{{�j��s�$Bt

FX $8B�}Y 7Ys,� i�js�$%� *$R}js{�8�t�

�FX $8B�}Y 7Ys,�� z�jB{$�k

[FX $8B�}Y 7Ys,�� V{{�j��s�$Bt

. 7$8}j$Pk$t� ]BtR�st� $t �Y� ]st�$j�%�� 7��sIk 7�s�� 7BjZ�$Bt w1�;;D

�.X WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj $8B�}Y 7Ys,�� z�jB{$�k

[.X WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj $8B�}Y 7Ys,�� V{{�j��s�$Bt

EE

Page 67: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

V}}�tI$-

_s�s8����R PB� ]Bt�s{� �BI�

7$8Zjs�$BtR

\� ]st�$j�%�� �s8 ]�BRRTR�{�$Btsj V��s �(�E1

K� _$�9B�j�{��${ *s8}$t� ]B�^{$�t� qZt$t� ]BtR�st� nx(((

KX 7Z�Ps{� *s8}$t� ]B�^{$�t� n e d(�d(Qnd _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� 7��s$tTzBj�s�� _�B}B��$Btsj$�k ]BtR�st� bd�d�Eb~oy OBZt�R �BIZjZR BP VR}��$�k dE�thy

oX OBZt�R �BIZjZR BP 7Z�Ps{� x�3Mthy

o� OBZt�R �BIZjZR BP ]st�$j�%�� dE�thy

o� OBZt�R �BIZjZR BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� dE�thy

� VIY�R$Bt et���k _�� =t$� V��s (3dObE1

U ]st�$j�%�� �s8 N�t��Y d1x E

U� N�t��Y BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� 1x3;EE

-_LqQ �sRR BP ]st�$j�%�� stI $8B�}Y <BjI�� (3x/

"y _B$RRBtR is�$B BP VR}��$�k (3n

"X _B$RRBtR is�$B BP 7Z�Ps{� (31�

' *�tR$�k BP ]st�$j�%�� �s8 1n((>/bEn

'� *�tR$�k BP _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� ��((>/bEn

py VR}��$�k ]Z�%s�Z�� isI$ZR ;(zE

p7 _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� ytt�� isI$ZR 13E�xEE

pL _$�9B�j�{��${ qZA� !Z��� isI$ZR n3d�xEE

E�

Page 68: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

FL N�tts�I FBt�R _B��t�$sj ]�$�{sj *$R�st{� 13xE#\

FX $8B�}Y 7Ys,� i�js�$%� *$R}js{�8�t� dzE

EM

Page 69: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

V}}�tI$- ]

]Bt�s{� �BI� �s�jsA 3$j�R

]�d 7$8Zjs�$Bt VZ�B8s�$Bt 7{�$}�

0 VZ�YB��I Ak !Rs8sY ej i$Ps$ |�

0 i�%$R�I Ak V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U R$8Zjs�$Bt |�

{j�s� sjj |�

{Bt�s{�}s�s8 |�

�ZtR)db*e>d�bE (��x�bE (�x�bE (�1x�bE (�d�bEH� |�

PB� $)dUx |�

Y�$�Y�)�ZtRw$D |�

R$8w�|Cv�u|��D |�

P�${�$Bt}s�s8 |� d(

R$8w�Q�%|�%Cv�D |�

$P $))d |�

3Pd(()3{eqR�s�� |�kd(()Oejs8AIs P� |�3td(()tB�8sjPB�{�e}$ebei� |�

�tI |�

$P $))1 |�

3P�x)3{eqR�s�� |�k�x)Oejs8AIs P� |�3t�x)tB�8sjPB�{�e}$ebei� |� 1(

E�

Page 70: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�tI |�

$P $))n |�

3Px()3{eqR�s�� |�kx()Oejs8AIs P� |�3tx()tB�8sjPB�{�e}$ebei� |�

�tI |�

$P $)); |�

3P1x)3{eqR�s�� |�k1x)Oejs8AIs P� |�3t1x)tB�8sjPB�{�e}$ebei� |� n(

�tI |�

$P $))x |�

3Pd()3{eqR�s�� |�kd()Oejs8AIs P� |�3td()tB�8sjPB�{�e}$ebei� |�

�tI |�

�tI |�

$)$Ld� |�

$P $))E |�

Rs%�w�|Cv�u|��� � � � |� ;(

�5Qg++�� �5vg++�� �mg++�� � � � |�

�5Q�x�� �5v�x�� �m�x��� � � |�

�5Qx+�� �5vx+�� �mx+��� � � |�

�5Q3x�� �5v3x�� �m3x��� � � |�

�5Qg+�� �5vg+�� �mg+�D |�

}jB�wkd((�3Pd((��/T�D |�

YBjI |�

}jB�wk�x�3P�x��BT�D |�

}jB�wkx(�3Px(���T�D |�

}jB�wk1x�3P1x��|T�D |� x(

}jB�wkd(�3Pd(���T�D |�

YBjI |�

�(

Page 71: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

kjsA�jw�5�%|�%Cv 5C�|� wW�d�CvRD�D |�

-jsA�jw�a%�:C�l�|��%| sYB� aCR%�%Cv w�����RD�D |�

�tI |�

}�$t� bI�}R{ {Bt�s{���RZj�R��}R

�d

Page 72: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]�1 _s�s8���� 3$j� PB� V3� z���${sj *kts8${R �BI�j

{jBR� sjj |�

�jBAsj tt qqd |�

tt)(� qqd)(� |�

0 VZ�YB��I Ak !Rs8sY ej i$Ps$ |�

0 i�%$R�I Ak V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U {Bt�s{�}s�s8 |�

0 |�

0V3� �s}}$t� 8BI� 8BI�j� yt{jZI�R �-��tR$Bt BP �ZA� stI {st�$j�%�� Ikts8${R� |�

0 �s8 *$8�tR$BtR stI _�B}���$�R |�

N)d1x�bE� 0j�t��Y BP A�s8 >8H |� d(

�BY)1n((� 0 I�tR$�k >,�b8�nH |�

bb)n(�bE� 0b$I�Y >8H |�

��)n�bE� 0�Y${,t�RR >8H |�

V)bbe��� 0{�BRRTR�{�$Btsj s��s >8�1H |�

e)d�E��dd� 08BIZjZR BP �jsR�${$�k >_sH |�

y)bbe���nbd1� 08B8�t� BP $t���$s >8�;H |�

tZd)(�n� 0_B$RRBt �s�$B |�

e)ebwdbtZd�1D� 0]B���{��I OBZt�:R �BIZjZR >_sH |�

0]Bt%���R ��RZj�R P�B8 }jst� R���RR w�Y${,t�RRccb$I�Y �B }jst� R��s$t |�

0w�Y${,t�RRcc b$I�YD |� 1(

j �)n�bE� 0�$} j�t��Y >8H |�

0 ]st�$j�%�� Ikts8${R |�

��)>d�M�x� ;�E�;� ��MxxH� 0pZ�RR PB� {Ys�s{���$R�${ �JZs�$Bt |�

�Bj)d�bE� 0�Bj��st{� PB� tZ8��${sj RBjZ�$Bt |�

PB� YY)dUn |�

js8AINwYYD)P9��Bw�|CRw0D~|CRXw0DKg����wYYD�d�bED� |�

0]Ys�s{���$R�${ eJZs�$Bt RBjZ�$Bt� |�

0p$%�R bs%�tZ8A�� PB� I$&���t� 8BI�R BP %$A�s�$Bt |�

�tI |�

js8AIs)js8AINbN� 0*$8�tR$Btj�RR bs%� tZ8A��� |� n(

�1

Page 73: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

- �)N� 0�$} }BR$�$Bt $R s� �tI BP {st�$j�%�� >8H |�

PB� $)dUd |�

}Y$w$D)w{BRwjs8AIsw$De- �Db{BRYwjs8AIsw$De- �DDewR$twjs8AIsw$DeNDL� � � |�R$tYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDLw{BRwjs8AIsw$DeNDL{BRYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDe� � � |�wR$tYwjs8AIsw$De- �DbR$twjs8AIsw$De- �D D� |�

0qY$R $R �Y� 8BI� RYs}� �JZs�$Bt |�

0qY� PBjjBb$t� {st A� %��$h�I Rk8ABj${jk P�B8 �Y� �-��s{��I 8BI� |�

0RYs}� �JZs�$Bt sAB%�� |�

I}Y$w$D)js8AIsw$DewwbR$twjs8AIsw$De- �DbR$tYwjs8AIsw$De- �DDe� � � |�wR$twjs8AIsw$DeNDLR$tYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDL w{BRwjs8AIsw$DeNDL� � � |� ;(

{BRYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDew{BRYwjs8AIsw$De- �Db{BRwjs8AIsw$De- �DDD� |�0I}Y$w-DbI-� qY� I��$%$�$%� b$�Y ��R}�{� �B �Y� j�t��Y BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� |�

0BP �Y� 8BI� RYs}�� |�

$t�� }Y$w$D)b1ew{BRwjs8AIsw$DeNDL{BRYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDbjs8AIsw$D� |�0 $t�����sj BP }Y$w-D P�B8 ( �B N |�

$t�� }Y$1w$D) wR$twjs8AIsw$DeNDLR$tYwjs8AIsw$DeNDD�1eN� |�0 $t����sj BP }Y$w-D�1 |�

$t�� I1}Y1w$D) wR$twjs8AIsw$DeNDLR$tYwjs8AIsw$DeNDD�1ejs8AIsw$D�;eN� |�0$t����sj BP wI1}Y$bI-�1D�1 |�

0 8BIsj }s�s8����R |� x(

8w$D)�BYeVe$t�� }Y$1w$D� 08BIsj 8sRR |�

,w$D)eeye$t�� I1}Y1w$D� 08BIsj R�$&t�RR |�

B8��sw$D)RJ��w,w$Db8w$DD� 08BIsj P��JZ�t{k |�

0 _$�9B�jBt�s�$Bt ��stRP�� PZt{�$Bt Ikts8${R |�

i B)(�((nd�x� 0BZ��� �sIZ$R BP }$�9B �ZA� >8H |�

i $)(�((1E�x� 0$tt�� �sIZ$R BP }$�9B �ZA� >8H |�

V })}$ewi B�1bi $�1D� 0]�BRR R�{�$Btsj s��s BP }$�9��ZA� >8H |�

�BY })��((� 0I�tR$�k BP }$�9B �ZA� 8s���$sj >,�b8�nH |�

Redd)dE�;�bd1� 0}$�9B 8�{Yt${sj X{B8}j$st{�" s� {BtR�st� �j�{��${ h�jI >8�1bWD |�

I nd)bd�d�bd1� 0}$�9B {BtR�st� >8bzH |� E(

A })nx(((� 0Is8}$t� {B�^{�$t� >W�Rb8�1H |�

� YBjI)(�x�bn� 08sRR BP �$} YBjI�� >,�H |�

�n

Page 74: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

s)RJ��wdb�BY }bReddD� 0V {BtR�st�� 7$8}j$h�R {BI�� |�

N })1x�;�bn� 0j�t��Y BP }$�9B �ZA� >8H |�

b }t)>d�1nMM�n�MM�MHesbN }� 0ts�Z�sj P��JZ�t{$�R >�sIbRH |�

07Bj%� b }teNbse�stwb }teNbsD)�BY }eV }eN }b� YBjI PB� b }t |�

PB� `)dUd |�

8 }w`D)�BY }eV }ewN }b1bsb;bb }tw`DeR$tw1eb }tw`DeN }bsDDL� � � |�

� YBjIewR$twb }tw`DeN }bsDD�1� 08BIsj 8sRR BP }$�9B �ZA� |�

, }w`D)b }tw`D�1e8 }w`D� 08BIsj R�$&t�RR BP }$�9B �ZA� |� �(

{ }w`D)A }e�BY }eV }ewN }b1bsb;bb }tw`DeR$tw1eb }tw`DeN }bsDD� |�

08BIsj Is8}$t� {B�^{�t� |�

, }%w`D)V }eI ndeR$twb }tw`DeN }bsDbReddbwi Bbi $D� |�

0$t}Z� �s$t �Ys� 8Zj�$}j$�R �Y� %Bj�s�� $t}Z� |�

}Y$ }w`D)R$twb }tw`DeN }bsD� 0qY� _$�9B 8BI�RYs}� |�

$t�� 9}Y$ }w`D)s�1bb }tw`D��1bN }ew R$twb }tw`DeN }bsDb� � � |�b }tw`DeN }bse{BRwb }tw`DeN }bsDD� |�

0$t����sj ( �B N } BP 9e}Y$ }w9D I9 |�$t�� }Y$ }1w`D)N }b1bsb;bb }tw`DeR$tw1eb }tw`DeN }bsD� |�

0$t����sj ( �B N } BP w}Y$ }w9DD�1 I9 |� M(

�tI |�

0 *s8}$t� PB� ]st�$j�%�� |�

+ s)x(� |�

0JZsj$�k Ps{�B� BP {st�$j%��� $t s$� )db1b9��s� 9��s)Is8}$t� �s�$B |�

A s)RJ��w,e8Db+ sb$t�� }Y$1w$D� |�

0s$� Is8}$t� {B�^{$�t� >W�Rb8�1H� P s)A seIk �B�sjw-��DbI� |�A {Bt�)n�bd(� |�

0�$}bRs8}j� {Bt�s{� Is8}$t� {B�^{$�t� >W�Rb8H� P {)A {eIk �B�sjw- R��DbI�� |�0- R UjB{s�$Bt BP �$} sjBt� {st�$j�%�� |�

A R)(� |� �(

0$t���tsj Is8}$t� {B�^{$�t� >2H� }�B}B��$Btsj �B 8s���$sj R��s$t �s��� |�

0P R)A ReI�1bI-�1w ye I�nk ��js�$%�w-��DbI-�1I� D� yU{st�$j�%�� 8B8�t� BP $t���$s |�$t���j }Y;}Yw$D)(� |�

0 $t����sj w I�;w }Y$w$D DbI-�;e}Y$w$D D P�B8 ( �B N |�

�;

Page 75: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

Aw$D)w A se$t�� }Y$1w$D L A Reye$t���j }Y;}Yw$DD� |�0 �&�{�$%� Is8}$t� {B�^{$�t� IZ� �B sjj �Y��� �k}�R BP Is8}$t� |�

0 |�

0}s�s8����R PB� �sZ�$R {Bt�s{� 8BI�j |�

b)(�1� 0RZ�Ps{� �t���k >Fb8�1H |�

id) ;(�b�� 0{st�$j�%�� }�BA� �sIZ$R BP {Z�%��Z�� >8H |� d((

i1);(�b�� 0Rs8}j� �sIZ$R BP {Z�%��Z�� >8H |�

i)wdbidLdbi1D�wbdD� 0ie*=]e* iV*=y7 |�

ed)d�E��dd� 0�$} OBZt� 8BIZjZR BP �jsR�${$�k |�

e1)x��M�d(� 0Rs8}j� 8BIZjZR BP �jsR�${$�k |�

tZ1)(�1�� 0_B$RRBt:R �s�$B BP Rs8}j� |�

e R��)w wdbtZd�1DbedLwdbtZ1�1Dbe1D�wbdD�0ie*=]e* �!*=N=7 !3 eNV7qqy]yqO |�

<)d�bd�� 0<s{,��8�t {BtR�st� >FH |�

9 B)1�xE�bd(� 0�JZ$j$A�Z$8 R�}s�s�$Bt $t N�tts�ITFBt�R }B��t�$sj >8H |�

�sZ)d� 0e&�{�$%� RY�s� R���t��Y BP 8s���$sj |�

8Z)wieb�1be R���1b9 B�nD�wdbnD� |� dd(

js8AI)d�dEe8Z� 0tBtI$8�tR$Btsj }s�s8���� |�

_ B)b1LMejs8AIew}$b1Db�b}$ew RJ��w;ejs8AI�;ew}$b1D�1L�e}$ejs8AIDb1ejs8AI�1ew}$b1DD� |�

I�j�s B)bMb�b}$ewRJ��w;ejs8AI�;ew}$b1D�1L�e}$ejs8AIDb1ejs8AI�1ew}$b1DD� |�

9��s B)I�j�s B b RJ��wb<eibEbw_ Be}$ebeiDDbw�e}$�1eb�1eibdEbe R���1D�wdbnD� |�

*)w�e}$�1eb�1eibdEbe R���1D�wdbnD� 0tBtI$8�tR$Btsj I$R}js{�8�t� P�B8 �sZ�$R {Bt�s{� 8BI�j�

t)�;� 0e&�{�$%� s��s b�$�Y�$t� Ps{�B� |�

0 7{st _s�s8����R |�

0 A$8B�}Y }s�s8����R - Rw�D) - R {BRwB8��s Ie�D |�- R)(� |�

B8��s I)(���neRJ��w,b8D� 0I�$%$t� P��JZ�t{k >�sIbRH |� d1(

k}B)�dej �b*� 0$t$�$sj }BR$�$Bt BP }$�9B �ZA� P��� �tI >8H |�

%)x�bE� 0R{st �s�� >8bRH |�

z)%b*bB8��s� 0tBtTI$8�tR$Btsj R{st �s�� |�

00s%��s�$t� }��$BI PB� i�7 %sjZ� BP 8�sRZ��I {s�$j�%�� s8}j$�ZI� ��js�$%� �B $�R AsR� |�

q);(bB8��s IeB8��s� |�}$ 9��B)b(�n� 0_y {Bt��Bjj�� 9��B |�

�x

Page 76: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

}$ �s$t)�x�bE� 0_y {Bt��Bjj�� �s$t $t �s}}$t� 8BI� |�

|�

0 WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj 7�s�� 7}s{� i�}��R�t�s�$Bt |�

0 R�s�� R}s{� 8BI�j� R�s��R s�� J� IJbI�� J}� J}bI� |� dn(

0 bY��� 8BIsj RBjZ�$Bt {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt)7Z8 I}Y$ $w-DeJw�DJ |�

0 stI PB� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt ) k} |�

$)d� 0h�R� 8BI� BP {st�$j�%�� stI }$�9B Btjk |�

03B� {js$�$h{s�$Bt _$�9B YsR 8 }� { }� , }� ]st�$j�%�� YsR 8w$D� ,w$D� A�&w$D |�

V Bj)>>( d ( (H� |�

>b,w$Db8w$DbB8��s�1� bAw$Db8w$DbB8��s�� � � |��BYeVb8w$De$t�� }Y$w$De, }b8 }bB8��s�1�� � � |�

w�BYeVb8w$De$t�� }Y$w$De{ }b8 }bA sb8w$De$t�� }Y$w$DDbB8��sH� |�( ( ( d� |�

>( ( b, }b8 }bB8��s�1� b{ }b8 }bB8��sHH� 0RZAR�$�Z��I k} Ikts8${R $t |� d;(

Bj)>>( (H� |�

>b�BYeVb8w$De$t�� }Y$w$De, }%b8 }bB8��s�1b* }Y$w$Db8w$De}$ebeibB8��s�1b*H� |�>( (H� |�

>, }%bw8 }eB8��s�1e*D (HH� |�

] J)>d ( ( (H� 0Jw�D sR BZ�}Z� |�

] -)>}Y$w$D ( ( (H� 0-w�D sR BZ�}Z�U k`w�D sR BZ�}Z�U ��j� |�

0I�P� s� �$} b����� }$�9B |�

] -s)>}Y$w$D ( d (H� 0-sw�D sARBjZ�� I�P�j�{�$Bt s� �$} |�

] IJ)I}Y$w$De] J� 0IJw�DbI- sR BZ�}Z�U RjB}� s� �$} |�

* Bj)(� |� dx(

�tI |�

0 7s8}j� RZ�Ps{� |�

-B)(b*� 0>8H |�

-d)nx�b�b*� 0>8H |�

kB)(b*� 0>8H |�

kd)x(��b�b*� 0>8H

�E

Page 77: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]�n ]B8}Z��{Bt�s{� 3Zt{�$Bt

PZt{�$Bt >RkR�-(�R����RH){B8}Z��{Bt�s{�w��-�Z�4s��N�q�}Y$�� � � |�

<�e R���9 B�8Z�js8AI�_ B�I�j�s B�9��s B�b�i�A {Bt��*�-B�� � � |�

-d�kB�kd�%�- R� B8��s�B8��s I�t�j �D |�

�jBAsj tt qqd |�

0 |�

0 0 G�$���t AkU !Rs8sY ej i$Ps$ |�

0 0 i�%$R�I AkU V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U {B8}Z��{Bt�s{� |�

0 |�

0 |� d(

$P 4s�))( 0 ���Z�t R��Z{�Z�� stI $t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R$9�R)R$8R$9�R� |�

R$9�R�WZ8]Bt�7�s��R)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ8*$R{7�s��R)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ8!Z�}Z�R)E� |�

R$9�R�WZ8yt}Z�R)x� |�

R$9�R�*$�3��I�Y�BZ�Y)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ87s8}j�q$8�R)1� |�

|�

RkR)R$8R$9�RwR$9�RD� |� 1(

|�

|�

-()>(�(H� 0$t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R��)> H� 0 R��$t� |�

�R)>( (�q (H� 0 R8s}j$t� w�$8��B&R��D }s$� PB� {Bt�$tZBZR stI I$R{���� R�s��R |�

R�� }s�s8w�{A��>R��-u�u��-(wdDD� 0 $t$�$sj$9� �B R�B�� R�s�� tB� d $t =R��*s�s |�

|�

�jR�$P sARw4s�D))d 0 ���Z�t I��$%s�$%�R BP R�s��R |�

|�

I-wd�dD)ZwdD�1� 0 $t����sj BP ��js�$%� I�j�{�$Bt BP {st�$j�%�� b�� }$�9B �B |� n(

��

Page 78: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

0A� ZR�I $t {B8}Z�$t� �8R BR{$jjs�$Bt s8}j$�ZI� |�

RkR)I-� |�

|�

�jR�$P 4s� )) 1 0 Z}Is�� I$R{���� R�s�� |�

|�

�jR�$P 4s� )) n 0 ���Z�tR RkR��8 R�s��R sR BZ�}Z�R $t %�{�B� RkR |�

I�j�s)ZwxDbZw1DbZwdD�0j �b*L |�$P I�j�sk(���xeI�j�s B� |�0 yt$�$sj �Z�RR |�

8)1x� |� ;(

ss)1x� |�

0$t$�$sj$9� |�

$)d� |�

Pw$D)d� �w$D)d� I8w$D)d� Isw$D)d� |�

|�

bY$j� sARwPw$DDk)d�bM m sARw�w$DDk) d�bM m sARwI8w$DDk)d�bM m sARwIsw$DDk)d�bM

$)$Ld� |�

Pw$D)js8AIess�1b1ew RJ��w8�1bdDLw8�1b1DesR�{w8DD L � � � |�

;ejs8AI�1essbnewdb8LRJ��w8�1bdDesR�{w8DDbd� |�

IPIs)js8AIessew RJ��w8�1bdDLw8�1b1DesR�{w8D DL � � � |� x(

;bnejs8AI�1ew db8LRJ��w8�1bdDesR�{w8D D� |�IPI8)js8AIess�1b1ew 8bRJ��w8�1bdD L 1e8esR�{w8DL� � � |�w8�1b1Db8bRJ��w8�1bdDDL� � � |�

;bnejs8AI�1essewbdL8esR�{w8DbRJ��w8�1bdDLdb8D� |�

0 $8}BR$t� I�j�s sR �Y� ,tBbt %s�$sAj� |�

�w$D)ss�1b;ejs8AIessbneRJ��w8�1bdDbI�j�s� |�I�Is)1ess b ;bnejs8AIeRJ��w8�1bdD� |�

I�I8)b;bnejs8AIesse8bRJ��w8�1bdD� |�

0RBj%$t� RkR��8 BP j$t�s� sj��A�s${ �JZs�$BtR |�

*3p)>IPIs IPI8�I�Is I�I8H� |� E(

)>bPw$D�b�w$DH� |�IsI8)*3pQ � |�

�M

Page 79: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

Isw$D)IsI8wdD� |�

I8w$D)IsI8w1D� |�

ss)ssLIsw$D� |�

8)8LI8w$D� |�

{{)8ess� |�AA)ssLtew{{bssD� |��tI |�

_)ss�nbjs8AIess�1ew RJ��w8�1bdD L8�1esR�{w8DD� |� �(

_ Is8}) bwA {Bt�ewZwnDLZw;DDDb}$bibb� |�|�

�jR�$P I�j�s c)(���xeI�j�s B� |�_)_ BewI�j�s BL9��s BD�1bwI�j�sL9��s BD�1� |�_ Is8})(� |�

8)(� |�

AA)(� |�

�tI |�

|�

k R)ZwxD� |� M(

RkR)>_ Is8}� |�

_� |�

AA� |�

k R� |�

I�j�s� |�

ZwdDH� |�

�jR� |�

RkR)> H� |�

�tI

��

Page 80: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]�; _s�s8���� 3$j� PB� 3�${�$Bt �BI�j

0 VZ�YB��I AkU V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U P�${�$Bt}s�s8 |�

0 FBYtRBt 3�${�$Bt _s�s8����R |�

�)d1� 0N�tts�I FBt�R et���k _s�s8���� >�zH |�

�z F)d�E(1d��nn�bd�� 0]Bt%��R$Bt 3s{�B� �zTkF |�

js8AIs P)d��xe9 B� 0Ns��${� ]BtR�st� >8H |�

9��s P)�d� 0*s8}$t� is�$B |�

,j)eeVbw;eND� 0]st�$j�%�� 7�$&t�RR |�

8j)�BYeVeNbn� 0e&�{�$%� ]st�$j�%�� �sRR |�

B8��s -)RJ��w,jb8jD� 0Ns���sj ]st�$j�%�� Ws�Z�sj 3��JZ�t{k |� d(

R�$P�s�)nb;� 0is�$B BP 7�$&t�RR�R |�

,{)R�$P�s�e,j� 0]Bt�s{� 7�$&t�RR |�

|�

RPt)R$9�wPtD� 07$9� BP WB�8sj 3B�{� z�{�B� P�B8 _��%$BZR 7$8Zjs�$Bt |�

RPt)RPtwdD� 07$9� BP WB�8sj 3B�{� z�{�B� |�

tB�8sjPB�{�)PtwRPtD� 0WB�8sj 3B�{� |�

PtR)tZ81R��wPtwRPtDe}$ebeiD� 0V 7��$t� BP �Y� *$8�tR$Btsj 3B�{� +Zst�$�k |�

�R)tZ81R��w�e�z FD� 0V 7��$t� PB� N�tts�I FBt�R _s�s8���� |�

9BR)tZ81R��w9 BD� 0V 7��$t� PB� N�tts�I FBt�R eJZ$j$A�$Z8 *$R�st{� |�

PZt{)>�3<~� �R �~w3~w0!�gpDTw0!��DDT� PtR �~� 9BRH� |� 1(

s)P9��BwPZt{�d�d�bED |�

9)9 Bbs� |�

qR�s�);e�ews�d1bs�EDe�z Fe1e}$bjs8AIs P |�0�s-$8Z8 3�${�$Bt 3B�{� |�

�{),{ejs8AIs PbqR�s� 0WBtI$8�tR$Btsj ]Bt�s{� 7�$&t�RR |�

�j),jejs8AIs PbqR�s� 0WBtI$8�tR$Btsj ]st�$j�%�� 7�$&t�RR |�

��s%)%bwjs8AIs PeB8��s -D� 0WBtI$8�R$Btsj }$�9B %�jB{$�k |�

M(

Page 81: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

]�x 3$tIR 3Zt{�$Bt

PZt{�$Bt >RkR�-(�R����RH)htIRw��-�Z�4s���{D |�

�jBAsj tt qqd |�

0 |�

0 0 G�$���t AkU V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U htIR |�

0 |�

0 |�

|�

$P 4s�))( 0 ���Z�t R��Z{�Z�� stI $t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R$9�R)R$8R$9�R� |� d(

R$9�R�WZ8]Bt�7�s��R)(� |�

R$9�R�WZ8*$R{7�s��R)(� |�

R$9�R�WZ8!Z�}Z�R)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ8yt}Z�R)1� |�

R$9�R�*$�3��I�Y�BZ�Y)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ87s8}j�q$8�R)d� |�

|�

RkR)R$8R$9�RwR$9�RD� |�

|�

0-()>( (H� 0$t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |� 1(

R��)> H� 0 R��$t� |�

�R)>( (H� 0 R8s}j$t� w�$8��B&R��D }s$� PB� |�

0 {Bt�$tZBZR stI I$R{���� R�s��R |�

�jR�$P 4s� ))d |�

RkR)(� |�

�jR�$P 4s� )) n 0 ���Z�tR RkR��8 R�s��R sR BZ�}Z�R $t %�{�B� RkR |�

,{R��$t�)tZ81R��w�{D� |�

O8$tZR�)tZ81R��wZwdDD� |�

PZt{)>O8$tZR� �T0TR%vw3~}%~0D]� ,{R��$t�H� |�

R)P9��BwPZt{�Zw1D�d�bED� |� n(

Md

Page 82: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

RkR)R� |�

�jR� |�

RkR)> H� |�

�tI |�

M1

Page 83: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

V}}�tI$- *

]Bt�s{� �BI� �s�jsA 3$j�R

*�d 7$8Zjs�$Bt VZ�B8s�$Bt 7{�$}�

0 VZ�YB��I Ak V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U R$8Zjs�$Bt |�

{j�s� sjj |�

�s}}$t�}s�s8 |�

�tI�$8�)x(� |�

R$8w��u}}%v��D |�

RP{)R$9�w3{D� |�

PB� $)dURP{ |�

$P 3{w$DK)( |�

}BRd)$� |� d(

A��s, |�

�tI |�

�tI |�

PB� $)$URP{ |�

$P 3{w$D))( |�

}BR1)$� |�

A��s, |�

�tI |�

�tI |�

q$8�)�bB8��s� |� 1(

Mn

Page 84: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

RZA}jB�wn�d�dD� |�

}jB�wq$8�w}BRdbn(U}BR1Ld(D�Ptw}BRdbn(U}BR1Ld(De}$ebeiD� |�s-$Rw>q$8�w}BRdbn(D q$8�w}BR1Ld(D ( d�bxHD� |�

kjsA�jw�WC�9ul 5C�|� wWD�D� |�

RZA}jB�wn�d�1D� |�

}jB�wq$8�w}BRdbn(U}BR1Ld(D�9w}BRdbn(U}BR1Ld(DD |�

s-$Rw>q$8�w}BRdbn(D q$8�w}BR1Ld(D 1�bd( n�bd(HD� |�

kjsA�jw�M�vvu�I FCv�R -%R�uv|� w9D�D� |�

RZA}jB�wn�d�nD� |�

}jB�wq$8�w}BRdbn(U}BR1Ld(D�3{w}BRdbn(U}BR1Ld(DD� |� n(

s-$Rw>q$8�w}BRdbn(D q$8�w}BR1Ld(D bd�b� n�b�HD� |�

kjsA�jw�5�%|�%Cv 5C�|� wWD�D� |�

-jsA�jw�s%9� w6�|CvIRD�D� |�

}�$t� �s}��RZj�Rd��}R |�

h�Z�� |�

}jB�wOejs8AIs P�3{D |�-jsA�jw�a%�:C�l�|��%| sYB� aCR%�%Cv w9����RD�D |�

kjsA�jw�5�%|�%Cv 5C�|� wW�d�CvRD�D |�

}�$t� �s}��RZj�R1��}R |�

Rs%� YsjP�Zt |� ;(

|�

{j�s� sjj |�

�s}}$t�}s�s8 |�

�ZtR)>x�bE d�bx 1�bx n�bx x�bxH� |�

PB� $)dUx |�

%)�ZtRw$D� |�

z)%b*bB8��s� |�

��s%)%bwjs8AIs PeB8��s -D� |�R$8w��u}}%v��D |�

$P $))d |� x(

3Pd)3{� |�

Od)Oejs8AIs P� |�

M;

Page 85: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

3td)Pte}$ebei� |��d)9� |�

q$8�d)�bB8��s� |�

�tI |�

$P $))1 |�

3P1)3{� |�

O1)Oejs8AIs P� |�3t1)Pte}$ebei� |� E(

�1)9� |�

q$8�1)�bB8��s� |�

�tI |�

$P $))n |�

3Pn)3{� |�

On)Oejs8AIs P� |�3tn)Pte}$ebei� |��n)9� |�

q$8�n)�bB8��s� |�

�tI |� �(

$P $)); |�

3P;)3{� |�

O;)Oejs8AIs P� |�3t;)Pte}$ebei� |��;)9� |�

q$8�;)�bB8��s� |�

�tI |�

$P $))x |�

3Px)3{� |�

Ox)Oejs8AIs P� |� M(

3tx)Pte}$ebei� |��x)9� |�

q$8�x)�bB8��s� |�

�tI |�

Mx

Page 86: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

RP{)R$9�w3{D� |�

PB� `)dURP{ |�

$P 3{w`DK)( |�

}BRdw$D)`� |�

A��s, |�

�tI |� �(

�tI |�

PB� `)`URP{ |�

$P 3{w`D))( |�

}BR1w$D)`� |�

A��s, |�

�tI |�

�tI |�

�tI |�

h�Z�� |�

Rs%� �s}}$t� |� d((

}jB�wOdww}BRdwdDbn(DU}BR1wdDLd(D�3Pdww}BRdwdDbn(DU}BR1wdDLd(D���T�D |�

YBjI |�

}jB�wO1ww}BRdw1Dbn(DU}BR1w1DLd(D�3P1ww}BRdw1Dbn(DU}BR1w1DLd(D��|T�D |�

}jB�wOnww}BRdwnDbn(DU}BR1wnDLd(D�3Pnww}BRdwnDbn(DU}BR1wnDLd(D���T�D |�

}jB�wO;ww}BRdw;Dbn(DU}BR1w;DLd(D�3P;ww}BRdw;Dbn(DU}BR1w;DLd(D��BT�D |�

}jB�wOxww}BRdwxDbn(DU}BR1wxDLd(D�3Pxww}BRdwxDbn(DU}BR1wxDLd(D��/T�D |�

YBjI |�

-jsA�jw�a%�:C�l�|��%| aCR%�%Cv w9����RD�D |�

kjsA�jw�5�%|�%Cv 5C�|� wW�d�CvRD�D |�

}�$t� bI�}R{ �s}��RZj�Rn��}R |� dd(

|�

{j�s� sjj |�

�s}}$t�}s�s8 |�

R���j�)n(((� |�

�tI�$8�)x(LR���j�� |�

R$8w��u}}%v��D |�

ME

Page 87: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

RP{)R$9�w3{D� |�

PB� $)dURP{ |�

$P 3{w$DK)( |�

}BRd)$� |� d1(

A��s, |�

�tI |�

�tI |�

PB� $)$URP{ |�

$P 3{w$D))( |�

}BR1)$� |�

A��s, |�

�tI |�

�tI |�

q$8�)�bB8��s� |� dn(

q$8�)q$8�bq$8�w}BRdbd(D� |�

RZA}jB�wn�d�dD� |�

}jB�wq$8�w}BRdbd(U}BR1Ld(D�Ptw}BRdbd(U}BR1Ld(De}$ebeiD� |�s-$Rw>q$8�w}BRdbd(D q$8�w}BR1Ld(D b(�;�b� d�b�HD� |�

kjsA�jw�WC�9ul 5C�|� wWD�D� |�

RZA}jB�wn�d�1D� |�

}jB�wq$8�w}BRdbd(U}BR1Ld(D�9w}BRdbd(U}BR1Ld(DD |�

s-$Rw>q$8�w}BRdbd(D q$8�w}BR1Ld(D 1�bd( n�bd(HD� |�

kjsA�jw�M�vvu�I FCv�R -%R�uv|� w9D�D� |�

RZA}jB�wn�d�nD� |� d;(

}jB�wq$8�w}BRdbd(U}BR1Ld(D�3{w}BRdbd(U}BR1Ld(DD� |�

s-$Rw>q$8�w}BRdbd(D q$8�w}BR1Ld(D b1�x�bd( (HD� |�

kjsA�jw�5�%|�%Cv 5C�|� wWD�D� |�

Rs%� sd(R��E(Rn((( |�

}�$t� �s}��RZj�R;��}R

M�

Page 88: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

*�1 _s�s8���� 3$j� PB� V3� qs}}$t� �BI� �BI�j

0 VZ�YB��I Ak !Rs8sY ej i$Ps$ |�

0 i�%$R�I Ak V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U �s}}$t�}s�s8 |�

{jBR� sjj |�

�jBAsj tt qqd |�

tt)(� qqd)(� |�

0 |�

0V3� �s}}$t� 8BI� 8BI�j� yt{jZI�R �-��tR$Bt BP �ZA� stI {st�$j�%�� Ikts8${R� |�

|�

0 �s8 *$8�tR$BtR stI _�B}���$�R |� d(

|�

N)d1x�bE� 0j�t��Y BP A�s8 >8H |�

�BY)1n((� 0I�tR$�k >,�b8�nH |�

bb)n(�bE� 0b$I�Y >8H |�

��)n�bE� 0�Y${,t�RR >8H |�

V)bbe��� 0{�BRRTR�{�$Btsj s��s >8�1H |�

e)d�E��dd� 08BIZjZR BP �jsR�${$�k >_sH |�

y)bbe���nbd1� 08B8�t� BP $t���$s >8�;H |�

tZd)(�n� 0_B$RRBt �s�$B |�

e)ebwdbtZd�1D� 0]B���{��I OBZt�:R �BIZjZR >_sH |� 1(

0]Bt%���R ��RZj�R P�B8 }jst� R���RR w�Y${,t�RRccb$I�Y �B }jst� R��s$t w�Y${,t�RRcc b$I�YD |�

j �)n�bE� 0�$} j�t��Y >8H |�

|�

|�

0 ]st�$j�%�� Ikts8${R |�

��)>d�M�x� ;�E�;� ��MxxH� 0pZ�RR PB� {Ys�s{���$R�${ �JZs�$Bt |�

�Bj)d�bE� 0�Bj��st{� PB� tZ8��${sj RBjZ�$Bt |�

PB� YY)dUn |�

js8AINwYYD)P9��Bw�|CRw0D~|CRXw0DKg����wYYD�d�bED�0]Ys�s{���$R�${ RBjZ�$Bt� |�

0p$%�R bs%�tZ8A�� PB� I$&���t� 8BI�R BP %$A�s�$Bt |� n(

MM

Page 89: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�tI |�

|�

js8AIs)js8AINbN� 0*$8�tR$Btj�RR bs%� tZ8A��� |�

- �)N� 0�$} }BR$�$Bt $R s� �tI BP {st�$j�%�� >8H |�

|�

PB� $)dUd |�

}Y$w$D)w{BRwjs8AIsw$De- �Db{BRYwjs8AIsw$De- �DDewR$twjs8AIsw$DeNDL� � � |�R$tYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDLw{BRwjs8AIsw$DeNDL{BRYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDewR$tYwjs8AIsw$De- �Db� � � |�R$twjs8AIsw$De- �D D � 0qY$R $R �Y� 8BI� RYs}� �JZs�$Bt |�

|� ;(

0qY� PBjjBb$t� {st A� %��$h�I Rk8ABj${jk P�B8 �Y� �-��s{��I 8BI� RYs}� �JZs�$Bt sAB%�� |�

|�

I}Y$w$D)js8AIsw$DewwbR$twjs8AIsw$De- �DbR$tYwjs8AIsw$De- �DDewR$twjs8AIsw$DeNDL� � � |�R$tYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDL w{BRwjs8AIsw$DeNDL{BRYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDew{BRYwjs8AIsw$De- �Db� � � |�{BRwjs8AIsw$De- �DDD� |�

0I}Y$w-DbI-� qY� I��$%$�$%� b$�Y ��R}�{� �B �Y� j�t��Y BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� |�

0BP �Y� 8BI� RYs}�� |�

|�

$t�� }Y$w$D)b1ew{BRwjs8AIsw$DeNDL{BRYwjs8AIsw$DeNDDbjs8AIsw$D� |�0 $t�����sj BP }Y$w-D P�B8 ( �B N |� x(

|�

$t�� }Y$1w$D) wR$twjs8AIsw$DeNDLR$tYwjs8AIsw$DeNDD�1eN� 0 $t����sj BP }Y$w-D�1 |�

|�

$t�� I1}Y1w$D) wR$twjs8AIsw$DeNDLR$tYwjs8AIsw$DeNDD�1ejs8AIsw$D�;eN� |�0$t����sj BP wI1}Y$bI-�1D�1 |�

0 8BIsj }s�s8����R |�

8w$D)�BYeVe$t�� }Y$1w$D� 08BIsj 8sRR |�

,w$D)eeye$t�� I1}Y1w$D� 08BIsj R�$&t�RR |�

B8��sw$D)RJ��w,w$Db8w$DD� 08BIsj P��JZ�t{k |� E(

|�

0 _$�9B�jBt�s�$Bt ��stRP�� PZt{�$Bt Ikts8${R |�

M�

Page 90: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

i B)(�((nd�x� 0BZ��� �sIZ$R BP }$�9B �ZA� >8H |�

i $)(�((1E�x� 0$tt�� �sIZ$R BP }$�9B �ZA� >8H |�

V })}$ewi B�1bi $�1D� 0]�BRR R�{�$Btsj s��s BP }$�9��ZA� >8H |�

�BY })��((� 0I�tR$�k BP }$�9B �ZA� 8s���$sj >,�b8�nH |�

Redd)dE�;�bd1� 0}$�9B 8�{Yt${sj X{B8}j$st{�" s� {BtR�st� �j�{��${ h�jI >8�1bWD |�

I nd)bd�d�bd1� 0}$�9B {BtR�st� >8bzH |�

A })nx(((� 0Is8}$t� {B�^{�$t� >W�Rb8�1H |�

� YBjI)(�x�bn� 08sRR BP �$} YBjI�� >,�H |� �(

s)RJ��wdb�BY }bReddD� 0V {BtR�st�� 7$8}j$h�R {BI�� |�

N })1x�;�bn� 0j�t��Y BP }$�9B �ZA� >8H |�

b }t)>d�1nMM�n�MM�MHesbN }�0ts�Z�sj P��JZ�t{$�R >�sIbRH |�

07Bj%� b }teNbse�stwb }teNbsD)�BY }eV }eN }b� YBjI PB� b }t |�

PB� `)dUd |�

8 }w`D)�BY }eV }ewN }b1bsb;bb }tw`DeR$tw1eb }tw`DeN }bsDDL� � � |�

� YBjIewR$twb }tw`DeN }bsDD�1� 08BIsj 8sRR BP }$�9B �ZA� |�

|�

, }w`D)b }tw`D�1e8 }w`D� 08BIsj R�$&t�RR BP }$�9B �ZA� |�

|� M(

{ }w`D)A }e�BY }eV }ewN }b1bsb;bb }tw`DeR$tw1eb }tw`DeN }bsDD� |�

08BIsj Is8}$t� {B�^{�t� |�

|�

, }%w`D)V }eI ndeR$twb }tw`DeN }bsDbReddbwi Bbi $D� |�

0$t}Z� �s$t �Ys� 8Zj�$}j$�R �Y� %Bj�s�� $t}Z� |�

|�

}Y$ }w`D)R$twb }tw`DeN }bsD� 0qY� _$�9B 8BI�RYs}� |�

|�

$t�� 9}Y$ }w`D)s�1bb }tw`D��1bN }ew R$twb }tw`DeN }bsDb� � � |�b }tw`DeN }bse{BRwb }tw`DeN }bsDD� |� �(

0$t����sj ( �B N } BP 9e}Y$ }w9D I9 |�|�

$t�� }Y$ }1w`D)N }b1bsb;bb }tw`DeR$tw1eb }tw`DeN }bsD� |�

0$t����sj ( �B N } BP w}Y$ }w9DD�1 I9 |�

�(

Page 91: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�tI |�

|�

0 *s8}$t� PB� ]st�$j�%�� |�

+ s)x(� |�

0JZsj$�k Ps{�B� BP {st�$j%��� $t s$� )db1b9��s� 9��s)Is8}$t� �s�$B |�

|� d((

A s)RJ��w,e8Db+ sb$t�� }Y$1w$D� |�

0s$� Is8}$t� {B�^{$�t� >W�Rb8�1H� P s)A seIk �B�sjw-��DbI� |�|�

A {Bt�)n�bd(� |�

0�$}bRs8}j� {Bt�s{� Is8}$t� {B�^{$�t� >W�Rb8H� P {)A {eIk �B�sjw- R��DbI�� |�0- R UjB{s�$Bt BP �$} sjBt� {st�$j�%�� |�

|�

A R)(� |�

0$t���tsj Is8}$t� {B�^{$�t� >2H� }�B}B��$Btsj �B 8s���$sj R��s$t �s��� |�

0P R)A ReI�1bI-�1w ye I�nk ��js�$%�w-��DbI-�1I� D� yU{st�$j�%�� 8B8�t� BP $t���$s |� dd(

|�

$t���j }Y;}Yw$D)(� |�

0 $t����sj w I�;w }Y$w$D DbI-�;e}Y$w$D D P�B8 ( �B N |�

|�

Aw$D)w A se$t�� }Y$1w$D L A Reye$t���j }Y;}Yw$DD� |�0 �&�{�$%� Is8}$t� {B�^{$�t� IZ� �B sjj �Y��� �k}�R BP Is8}$t� |�

|�

0 |�

|�

0}s�s8����R PB� �sZ�$R {Bt�s{� 8BI�j |� d1(

b)(�1� 0RZ�Ps{� �t���k >Fb8�1H |�

id) ;(�b�� 0{st�$j�%�� }�BA� �sIZ$R BP {Z�%��Z�� >8H |�

i1);(�b�� 0Rs8}j� �sIZ$R BP {Z�%��Z�� >8H |�

i)wdbidLdbi1D�wbdD� 0ie*=]e* iV*=y7 |�

ed)d�E��dd� 0�$} OBZt� 8BIZjZR BP �jsR�${$�k |�

e1)x��M�d(� 0Rs8}j� 8BIZjZR BP �jsR�${$�k |�

�d

Page 92: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

tZ1)(�1�� 0_B$RRBt:R �s�$B BP Rs8}j� |�

e R��)w wdbtZd�1DbedLwdbtZ1�1Dbe1D�wbdD� |�

0ie*=]e* �!*=N=7 !3 eNV7qqy]yqO |�

<)d�bd�� 0<s{,��8�t {BtR�st� >FH |� dn(

9 B)1�xE�bd(� 0�JZ$j$A�Z$8 R�}s�s�$Bt $t |�

0N�tts�ITFBt�R }B��t�$sj >8H |�

�sZ)d� 0e&�{�$%� RY�s� R���t��Y BP 8s���$sj |�

|�

8Z)wieb�1be R���1b9 B�nD�wdbnD� |�

js8AI)d�dEe8Z� 0tBtI$8�tR$Btsj }s�s8���� |�

|�

_ B)b1LMejs8AIew}$b1Db�b}$ew RJ��w;ejs8AI�;ew}$b1D�1L�e}$ejs8AIDb1ejs8AI�1ew}$b1DD� |�

I�j�s B)bMb�b}$ewRJ��w;ejs8AI�;ew}$b1D�1L�e}$ejs8AIDb1ejs8AI�1ew}$b1DD� |�

9��s B)I�j�s B b RJ��wb<eibEbw_ Be}$ebeiDDbw�e}$�1eb�1eibdEbe R���1D�wdbnD� |� d;(

|�

*)w�e}$�1eb�1eibdEbe R���1D�wdbnD� 0 tBtI$8�tR$Btsj I$R}js{�8�t� P�B8 �sZ�$R {Bt�s{� 8BI�j

|�

t)�;� 0e&�{�$%� s��s b�$�Y�$t� Ps{�B� |�

0 7{st _s�s8����R |�

0 A$8B�}Y }s�s8����R - Rw�D) - R {BRwB8��s Ie�D |�- R)d(�bd(� |�

B8��s I)(���neRJ��w,b8D� 0I�$%$t� P��JZ�t{k >�sIbRH |�

k}B)j �b*� 0$t$�$sj }BR$�$Bt BP }$�9B �ZA� P��� �tI >8H |�

%)x�bE� 0R{st �s�� >8bRH |� dx(

z)%b*bB8��s� 0tBtTI$8�tR$Btsj R{st �s�� |�

00s%��s�$t� }��$BI PB� i�7 %sjZ� BP 8�sRZ��I {s�$j�%�� s8}j$�ZI� ��js�$%� �B $�R AsR� |�

|�

q);(bB8��s IeB8��s� |�}$ 9��B)b(�n� 0_y {Bt��Bjj�� 9��B |�

}$ �s$t)d�b;� 0_y {Bt��Bjj�� �s$t $t �s}}$t� 8BI� |�

|�

|�

�1

Page 93: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

0 7$8}j$h{s�$Bt BP q��8R |�

Vd)�BYeVe$t�� }Y$e}Y$e, }bw8e8 }D� 07BjZ�$Bt ]B�^{$�t� |� dE(

Vx)bde�BYeVeB8��s�1e$t�� }Y$� 07BjZ�$Bt ]B�^{$�t� |�

VE)bdeAeB8��se$t�� }Y$� 07BjZ�$Bt ]B�^{$�t� |�

�)ww,b8eB8��s I�1D�1LwAeB8��s ID�1D��x� 0]st�$j�%�� y8}�Ist{� |�_Y$)s�st1wAeB8��s I�,b8eB8��s I�1D� 0_YsR� Vt�j� |�

|�

0 WBtTI$8�tR$Btsj 7�s�� 7}s{� i�}��R�t�s�$Bt |�

0 R�s�� R}s{� 8BI�j� R�s��R s�� J� IJbI�� J}� J}bI� |�

0 bY��� 8BIsj RBjZ�$Bt {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt)7Z8 I}Y$ $w-DeJw�DJ |�

0 stI PB� {st�$j�%�� I�4�{�$Bt ) k} |�

|� d�(

$)d� 0h�R� 8BI� BP {st�$j�%�� stI }$�9B Btjk |�

|�

03B� {js$�$h{s�$Bt _$�9B YsR 8 }� { }� , }� ]st�$j�%�� YsR 8w$D� ,w$D� A�&w$D |�

V Bj)>>( d ( (H� |�

>b,w$Db8w$DbB8��s�1� bAw$Db8w$DbB8��s�� � � |��BYeVb8w$De$t�� }Y$w$De, }b8 }bB8��s�1�� � � |�

w�BYeVb8w$De$t�� }Y$w$De{ }b8 }bA sb8w$De$t�� }Y$w$DDbB8��sH� |�( ( ( d� |�

>( ( b, }b8 }bB8��s�1� b{ }b8 }bB8��sHH� 0RZAR�$�Z��I k} Ikts8${R $t |�

|� dM(

Bj)>>( (H� |�

>b�BYeVb8w$De$t�� }Y$w$De, }%b8 }bB8��s�1b* }Y$w$Db8w$De}$ebeibB8��s�1b*H� |�>( (H� |�

>, }%bw8 }eB8��s�1e*D (HH� |�

|�

] J)>d ( ( (H� 0Jw�D sR BZ�}Z� |�

] -)>}Y$w$D ( ( (H� 0-w�D sR BZ�}Z�U k`w�D sR BZ�}Z�U ��j� I�P� s� �$} b����� }$�9B |�

] -s)>}Y$w$D ( d (H� 0-sw�D sARBjZ�� I�P�j�{�$Bt s� �$} |�

] IJ)I}Y$w$De] J� 0IJw�DbI- sR BZ�}Z�U RjB}� s� �$} |�

* Bj)(� |� d�(

�n

Page 94: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

�tI |�

|�

0 7s8}j� RZ�Ps{� |�

-B)1(�b�b*� 0>8H |�

-d)nx�b�b*� 0>8H |�

kB)(b*� |�

kd)x(��b�b*� 0>8H |�

js8AIs P)1e9 B� 0Ns��${� ]BtR�st� >8H |�

|�

0 FBYtRBt 3�${�$Bt _s�s8����R |� 1((

� {)(� |�

{Bt�s{�)(� |�

R���j�)(�x� |�

�tI�$8�)d(� |�

9)�x1e9 B� |�9��s P)�d� |�

,j)eeVbN� |�8j)�BYeVeNbn� |�B8��s -)RJ��w,jb8jD� |�

�)d1� |� 1d(

�z F)d�E(1d��nn�bd�� |�

R�$P�s�)nb;� |�

,{)R�$P�s�e,j |���s%)%bwjs8AIs PeB8��s -D�

�;

Page 95: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

*�n ]B8}Z���s}}$t� 3Zt{�$Bt

PZt{�$Bt >RkR�-(�R����RH){B8}Z���s}}$t�w��-�Z�4s��N�q�}Y$�<�e R���9 B�8Z�js8AI�_ B�� � � |�

I�j�s B�9��s B�b�i�A {Bt��*�-B�-d�kB�kd�%�- R� B8��s�B8��s I�t�j �D |�

�jBAsj tt qqd |�

0 |�

0 VZ�YB��I Ak !Rs8sY ej i$Ps$ |�

0 i�%$R�I Ak V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U {B8}Z���s}}$t� |�

|�

$P 4s�))( 0 ���Z�t R��Z{�Z�� stI $t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R$9�R)R$8R$9�R� |� d(

R$9�R�WZ8]Bt�7�s��R)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ8*$R{7�s��R)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ8!Z�}Z�R)M� |�

R$9�R�WZ8yt}Z�R)�� |�

R$9�R�*$�3��I�Y�BZ�Y)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ87s8}j�q$8�R)1� |�

|�

RkR)R$8R$9�RwR$9�RD� |�

|�

|� 1(

-()>(�(H� 0$t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R��)> H� 0 R��$t� |�

�R)>( (�q (H� 0 R8s}j$t� w�$8��B&R��D }s$� PB� {Bt�$tZBZR stI I$R{���� R�s��R |�

R�� }s�s8w�{A��>R��-u�u��-(wdDD� 0 $t$�$sj$9� �B R�B�� R�s�� tB� d $t =R��*s�s |�

|�

�jR�$P sARw4s�D))d 0 ���Z�t I��$%s�$%�R BP R�s��R |�

|�

I-wd�dD)ZwdD�1� 0 $t����sj BP ��js�$%� I�j�{�$Bt BP {st�$j�%�� b�� |�

0}$�9B �B A� ZR�I $t {B8}Z�$t� �8R BR{$jjs�$Bt s8}j$�ZI� |�

RkR)I-� |� n(

�x

Page 96: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

|�

�jR�$P 4s� )) 1 0 Z}Is�� I$R{���� R�s�� |�

|�

$P ZwxD))d |�

|�

tt)ttLd� |�

$P tt))E( |�

Z }��%)��� }s�s8w�{A��>R��-u�u�D� |�

|�

RkR)RJ��ww-wd�dDb Z }��%wd�dDDbw�bqqdDD� |� ;(

|�

R�� }s�s8w�{A��>R��-u�u��-wd�dDD� |�

|�

tt)(� |�

qqd)�� |�

�tI |�

�tI |�

|�

|�

�jR�$P 4s� )) n 0 ���Z�tR RkR��8 R�s��R sR BZ�}Z�R $t %�{�B� RkR |� x(

|�

|�

%�j $t ) - Rb*eB8��s IbB8��se{BRwB8��s IbB8��se�D� 0�&�{�$%� RYs,�� %�jB{$�k |�k A$) - Rb*eR$twB8��s IbB8��se�D� 0 }BR$�$Bt BP A$8B�}Y ��js�$%� �B }$�9B �ZA� P��� �tI |�

I�j�s)wj �b*LZwEDbZw1DbZwdDbk A$D� |�|�

$P I�j�sk(���xeI�j�s B� |�$P Zw�D))( |�

� {)�� |�

�jR� |� E(

� {)Zw�D� |�

�tI |�

�E

Page 97: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

0 yt$�$sj �Z�RR |�

8)1x� |�

ss)1x� |�

0$t$�$sj$9� |�

$)d� |�

Pw$D)d� �w$D)d� I8w$D)d� Isw$D)d� |�

|�

bY$j� sARwPw$DDk)d�bM m sARw�w$DDk) d�bM m sARwI8w$DDk)d�bM m sARwIsw$DDk)d�bM

$)$Ld� |�

Pw$D)js8AIess�1b1ew RJ��w8�1bdDLw8�1b1DesR�{w8DD L ;ejs8AI�1essbnewdb8LRJ��w8IPIs)js8AIessew RJ��w8�1bdDLw8�1b1DesR�{w8D DL ;bnejs8AI�1ew db8LRJ��w8�1bdD

IPI8)js8AIess�1b1ew 8bRJ��w8�1bdD L 1e8esR�{w8DLw8�1b1Db8bRJ��w8�1bd

;bnejs8AI�1essewbdL8esR�{w8DbRJ��w8�1bdDLdb8D� |�

0 $8}BR$t� I�j�s sR �Y� ,tBbt %s�$sAj� |�

�w$D)ss�1b;ejs8AIessbneRJ��w8�1bdDbI�j�s� |�I�Is)1ess b ;bnejs8AIeRJ��w8�1bdD� |�

I�I8)b;bnejs8AIesse8bRJ��w8�1bdD� |�

0RBj%$t� RkR��8 BP j$t�s� sj��A�s${ �JZs�$BtR |� M(

*3p)>IPIs IPI8�I�Is I�I8H� |�

)>bPw$D�b�w$DH� |�IsI8)*3pQ � |�Isw$D)IsI8wdD� |�

I8w$D)IsI8w1D� |�

ss)ssLIsw$D� |�

8)8LI8w$D� |�

{{)8ess� |�AA)ssLtew{{bssD� |��tI |� �(

_)ss�nbjs8AIess�1ew RJ��w8�1bdD L8�1esR�{w8DD� |�_ Is8}) bwA {Bt�ewZwnDLZw;DL%�j $tDDb}$bibb� |�

|�

�jR�$P I�j�s c)(���xeI�j�s B� |�

��

Page 98: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

� {)(� |�

_)_ BewI�j�s BL9��s BD�1bwI�j�sL9��s BD�1� |�_ Is8})(� |�

8)(� |�

AA)(� |�

�tI |� d((

|�

k �8R)-w1�dD� |�

k R)ZwED� |�

RkR)>_ Is8}� |�

_� |�

AA� |�

k R� |�

k A$� |�

I�j�s� |�

k �8R� |� dd(

� {H� |�

�jR� |�

RkR)> H� |�

�tI

�M

Page 99: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

*�; 3$tI9 3Zt{�$Bt

PZt{�$Bt >RkR�-(�R����RH)htI9w��-�Z�4s����9 B��z F�b�i�js8AIs P�R���j�D |�

�jBAsj tt qqd |�

0 0 G�$���t AkU V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U htI9 |�

0 *s��U ;b11b1((( |�

0 |�

|�

$P 4s�))( 0 ���Z�t R��Z{�Z�� stI $t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R$9�R)R$8R$9�R� |�

R$9�R�WZ8]Bt�7�s��R)(� |� d(

R$9�R�WZ8*$R{7�s��R)(� |�

R$9�R�WZ8!Z�}Z�R)1� |�

R$9�R�WZ8yt}Z�R)1� |�

R$9�R�*$�3��I�Y�BZ�Y)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ87s8}j�q$8�R)d� |�

|�

RkR)R$8R$9�RwR$9�RD� |�

|�

-()> H� 0$t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R��)> H� 0 R��$t� |� 1(

�R)>( (H� 0 R8s}j$t� w�$8��B&R��D }s$� PB� {Bt�$tZBZR s

�jR�$P 4s� ))d |�

RkR)(� |�

�jR�$P 4s� )) n 0 ���Z�tR RkR��8 R�s��R sR BZ�}Z�R $t %�{�B� RkR |�

$P Zw1D))( |�

Pt)(� |�

�jR� |�

Pt)ZwdD� |�

�tI |�

$P Pt))( |� n(

��

Page 100: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

9)(� |�

3R�s�)(� |�

�jR� |�

Pt)Pte}$ebei� |��R)tZ81R��w�e�z FD� |�

9BR)tZ81R��w9 BD� |�

PtR)tZ81R��wPtD� |�

PZt{)>�3<� �R �~w3~w0!�gpDTw0!��DDT� PtR �~� 9BRH� |�

s)P9��BwPZt{�d�d�bED� |�

9)9 Bbs� |� ;(

3R�s�);e�ews�d1bs�EDe�z Fe1e}$bjs8AIs P� |��tI |�

RkR)>9� 3R�s�H� |�

�jR� |�

RkR)> H� |�

�tI |�

d((

Page 101: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

*�x 3$tIR 3Zt{�$Bt

PZt{�$Bt >RkR�-(�R����RH)htIRw��-�Z�4s��,{�js8AIs PD |�

�jBAsj tt qqd |�

0 0 G�$���t AkU V8�B �� 3s�$I |�

0 _�B��s8 ts8�U htIR |�

0 *s��U ;b11b1((( |�

0 |�

|�

$P 4s�))( 0 ���Z�t R��Z{�Z�� stI $t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R$9�R)R$8R$9�R� |�

R$9�R�WZ8]Bt�7�s��R)(� |� d(

R$9�R�WZ8*$R{7�s��R)(� |�

R$9�R�WZ8!Z�}Z�R)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ8yt}Z�R)n� |�

R$9�R�*$�3��I�Y�BZ�Y)d� |�

R$9�R�WZ87s8}j�q$8�R)d� |�

|�

RkR)R$8R$9�RwR$9�RD� |�

|�

0-()>( (H� 0$t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR |�

R��)> H� 0 R��$t� |� 1(

�R)>( (H� 0 R8s}j$t� w�$8��B&R��D }s$� PB� {Bt�$tZBZR s

�jR�$P 4s� ))d |�

RkR)(� |�

�jR�$P 4s� )) n 0 ���Z�tR RkR��8 R�s��R sR BZ�}Z�R $t %�{�B� RkR |�

$P ZwnD))( |�

R)(� |�

�jR� |�

,{R��$t�)tZ81R��wZwnDbw,{ejs8AIs PDD� |�O8$tZR�)tZ81R��wZwdDD� |�

PZt{)>O8$tZR� �T0TR%vw3~}%~0D~� ,{R��$t�H� |� n(

d(d

Page 102: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

R)P9��BwPZt{�Zw1D�d�bED� |�

�tI |�

RkR)R� |�

�jR� |�

RkR)> H� |�

�tI |�

d(1

Page 103: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

V}}�tI$- e

]Bt�s{� �BI� 7$8Zjs�$Bt b$�Y

q�Z� Ns���sj Ws�Z�sj 3��JZ�t{k

yt ]Ys}��� x� �Y� js���sj ts�Z�sj P��JZ�t{k bsR I�{��sR�I Ak s Ps{�B� BP �Y$��k �B $jjZR��s��

�Y� BR{$jjs�$Bt BP �Y� {st�$j�%�� sP��� s Rj$} �%�t�� qY$R s}}�tI$- RYBbR �Y� ��RZj�R BA�s$t�I

P�B8 8s$t�s$t$t� �Y� �Y� s{�Zsj %sjZ� BP �Y� ts�Z�sj P��JZ�t{k� 3$�Z�� eTd RYBbR �Y� ��RZj�R

stsjs�BZR �B 3$�Z�� xT;

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

x 10-9

3

2

1

0

1

2

3

4x 10

-6

LateralSurface

Force(N

ewtons)

Piezoelectric Tube Position (Meters)

Oscillation

3$�Z�� eTdU i�RZj�R BP Ns���sj 7Z�Ps{� 3B�{� 7$8Zjs�$BtR PB� 3$%� ]st�$j�%�� *�4�{�$BtR

d(n

Page 104: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

qY��� s��BbR }B$t� �B �Y� BR{$jjs�$Bt $t �Y� �Y��� ZtR�sAj� P�${�$Bt ��s{�R� VR {st A�

R��t� �Y� BR{$jjs�$Bt Is8}R BZ� 8Z{Y PsR��� �Yst }��%$BZRjk RYBbt� qY$R $R st $8}B��st�

}B$t� A�{sZR� �Y� PsR� I�{sk �$8� bBZjI }�BAsAjk j�sI �B �Y� BR{$jjs�$Bt A�$t� ZtI���{��I

$t �-}��$8�t�sj P�${�$Bt 8�sRZ�8�t�R� W�%���Y�j�RR �Y� BR{$jjs�$Bt bBZjI B{{Z� ��RZj�$t� $t

}BRR$Aj� Is8s�� �B �Y� Rs8}j� RZ�Ps{��

d(;

Page 105: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

$Aj$B��s}Yk

>dH $tt$�� p� _YkR${sj i�%$�b N�����R %Bj� xE� }�n(T�nn� d�ME�

>1H ]s�}${,� iBA��� G� stI 7sj8��Bt� �$JZ�j� ]Y�8$R��k i�%$�b %Bj� ��� }ddEnTdd�;�

d����

>nH Y��}U\\bbb�I$�{B8

>;H +Z$R� �� sj� 7{stt$t� �${�BR{B}k %Bj� �� }n�x� d��x�

>xH �s$%sjI� _� �� sj� WstB��{YtBjB�k %Bj� 1 }�d(nTd(E� d��d�

>EH Z�Ys8� W�V� stI ]Bj�Bt� i�F� FBZ�tsj BP zs{ZZ8 7{$�t{� q�{YtBjB�k %Bj� V�� }�1�(E�

d�M��

>�H !Ys�s� q��RZB stI OBZ{�PTqBZ8$� �� _�B{��I$t�R BP �Y� V8��${st ]Bt��Bj ]BtP���t{��

%Bj� x tZ8� �x]<nx�nE� }nM(MTnMd1� d��x�

>MH isB� 7$t�$��RZ 7� ��{Yst${sj z$A�s�$BtR� n�I �I� VII$RBt G�Rj�k _ZAj$RY$t� ]B8}stk�

i�sI$t�� �sRRs{YZR���R� d��x�

>�H VRYAk� ��3� �s���$sjR 7�j�{�$Bt $t ��{Yst${sj *�R$�t i��I ejR�%$�� _ZAj$RY$t�� !-T

PB�I� d��1�

>d(H BbI�t� 3�_� stI qsAB�� *� qY� 3�${�$Bt stI NZA�${s�$Bt BP 7Bj$IR� !-PB�I =t$%��R$�k

_��RR� !-PB�I� d�x(�

>ddH NB%�jj� ��i� �� sj� FBZ�tsj BP q�$ABjB�k %Bj� ddM tZ8� ; }MxMTME;� d��E�

>d1H Nst�9� ��V� �� sj� _YkR${sj i�%$�b T]BtI�tR�I �s���� %Bj� xx tZ8� dE }d(��ETd(�Mx�

d����

d(x

Page 106: q$}T7s8}j‡]Bt˝s{˝Ns˝‡—sj3B—{‡R$tqs}}$t˙stI]Bt˝s{˝ BI‡!}‡—s ...amfarid.scripts.mit.edu/resources/Theses/NAN-TB00.pdfb;˛ ˛ ^ b;˛ > ˛ < ) ( \ Q bp ~

>dnH Z�tR� V�i� �� sj� Nst�8Z$� %Bj� dx� tZ8� M }1�11T1�n(� d����

>d;H FBYtRBt� ��N �� sj� _�B{��I$t�R BP �Y� iBksj 7B{$��k BP NBtIBt V�%Bj� n1 tZ8 n1;

}�n(dTndn d��d�

>dxH ]s�}${,� i�G �� sj� FBZ�tsj BP zs{ZZ8 7{$�t{� q�{YtBjB�k � %Bj� d; tZ8 1� }�d1M�T

d1�x� d��E�

>dEH �sZ�$R� *st$�j FBZ�tsj BP ]BjjB$I stI yt���Ps{� 7{$�t{� %Bj� dx( tZ8� d }1;nT1E��

d��1�

>d�H FBYtRBt� ��N� stI GBBIYBZR�� F� q�$ABjB�k N�����R� %Bj� x� tZ8 1Tn� }�dxxTdE(� d��M�

>dMH *�I,B%� p�z� �s���$sjR N�����R %Bj� nM� tZ8� x� }nE(TnEE� d����

>d�H �Bbt� qY�BIB�� N� ]Y�8$R��kU qY� ]�t��sj 7{$�t{�� ��Y �I� _��t�${� <sjj� =}}��

7sIIj� i$%��� W�b F��R�k� d����

>1(H NstI8st� =9$ �� sj� 7Z�Ps{� 7{$�t{� %Bj� 1d(� }�NTd��� d�M��

>1dH ZjIZ8� V� stI ]$�s{$� 7� _YkR${sj i�%$�b � %Bj� xx� tZ8 ;� }1E(ET1Edd� d����

>11H pksjB�� q$AB� stI qYB8sR� <s��k� ��$�R{Y�$P� 3Z� _YkR$, T ]BtI�tR�I �s����� %Bj�

d(;� tZ8 ;� }EE�TE�;� d����

>1nH �YBt�� G� stI qB8st�, *� _YkR${sj i�%$�b N�����R %Bj� E;� tZ8 1x� }n(x;Tn(x�� d��(�

>1;H qB8st�,� *� �� sj� eZ�B}YkR${R N�����R %Bj� dx� tZ8 M� }MM�TM�1� d��d�

>1xH sZ8A������ q� _YkR${sj i�%$�b T]BtI�tR�I �s������ %Bj� E(� tZ8 E� }n�1MTn�n��

d����

>1EH *st,Bb${9� <� ��$�R{Y�$P� 3�Z� Vt��bstI�� =tI ��{Yst$,� %B� d�� tZ8 E� }n��T;(��

d����

>1�H ej i$Ps$� !Rs8sY stI OBZ{�PTqBZ8$� �s8sj� *kts8${R BP V�B8${ 3B�{� �${�BR{B}��

��{Ys��Bt${R i�R�s�{Y NsAB�s�B�k� i�}B�� WB� �iN ((T((d� �sRRs{Y�R���R ytR�$�Z��

BP q�{YtBjB�k� 1(((�

d(E