Protein Cross-Linking Analysis using Stable Isotope...

23
Protein Cross-Linking Analysis using Stable Isotope-Labeling, Mass Spectrometry, and Integrated Computational Data Processing Jan Seebacher Aebersold Lab, ISB, Seattle WA In Collaboration with Michael Gelb, University of Washington

Transcript of Protein Cross-Linking Analysis using Stable Isotope...

Protein Cross-Linking Analysis using Stable Isotope-Labeling, Mass Spectrometry,

and Integrated Computational Data Processing

Jan Seebacher

Aebersold Lab, ISB, Seattle WAIn Collaboration with Michael Gelb, University of Washington

3D Structure Determination of Proteins and Protein Complexes2

B A

C

NMR

Protein Crystallography

Protein Complex /Protein Interactions

Sequence

Candidate Structures

3D Protein Structure Prediction

Molecular Biology /Affinity Purification /Mass Spectrometry

Modeling

??

3D Structure Determination of Proteins and Protein Complexes3

B

NMR

Protein Crystallography

Protein Complex /Protein Interactions

Sequence

Candidate Structures

3D Protein Structure Prediction

Molecular Biology /Affinity Purification /Mass Spectrometry

Modeling

Constraints

Chemical Cross-Linking

?

A

C

Protein Complex(Proteins A+B)

known 3D structure, pdb.

Method Validation

Protein Sequence A

Protein Sequence B

Cross-Linking Reagent“Molecular Ruler”

“ ”

Inter-Residue Distance ConstraintsProtein Structure PredictionDetection of Protein Interactions / Sites

Cross-linking Reaction

Identification of Cross-linked AA Residues (K, n)

3D Protein Structure

Protein Cross-linking to Study 3D Protein Structure: Proof of Concept4

BA

Digestion, :Proteins Peptides

Protein Cross-linking

[16/18O][16O]

+

[d0/d12]-isotope-codedCross-Linker

1

2

2 1

ABI 4700 Proteomics Analyzer

[16/18O][16O]Robotic LC Fractionation

onto MALDI Plate

Automated MS Analysis:• Isotope pattern recognition• Spectra Alignment• Peptide Data Base Search • Mass Mapping Candidates• MS2 Inclusion List

Automated MS/MS Analysis

• Peptide Identification

• Identification of Cross-Linked Residues

• Generation of “Distance Constraints” for 3D Structure Modeling, i.e. for Rosetta, NMR, etc.

• Identification of potential Interaction Sites

MS1 Acquisition

MS2 (MS/MS) Acquisition

[16O]

18O-Isotope-Coded Buffer

Method Outline: Exp. Workflow + Data Analysis5

1:1 Ratio

Cross-Linking Reagent

Unmodified Peptides + Mono-Links Cross-Links

Protein Complex

Protein-reactive Group

Loop-Link

+

BA

Peptides

Identification by Mass Spectrometry

Digestion Products:

Protease(s)BA

intra-complexCross-Links

dead-end, hydrolyzedMono-Link

6Strategy: Protein Cross-Linking and MS Analysis

Mono-LinkCross-Link or Loop-Link

Peptide N N

O

X X

X X

X X

X X

X X

X X

OH

H

Peptide

2 Da

N

O

X X

X X

X X

X X

X X

X X

OHPeptide [16/18O]H

X: 50% H/D

12 Da

7

[16/18O]

[16O]

Unmodified Peptides + Mono-LinksCross-LinksLoop-Link

MS1 Analysis of isotope-coded cross-linked peptides

Cross-linking Reagent

Peptide N N

O

X X

X X

X X

X X

X X

X X

OH

H

Peptide

[16/18O]

[16O]

2 Da

N

O

X X

X X

X X

X X

X X

X X

OHPeptide [16/18O]H

X: 50% H/D

12 Da

8

Unmodified Peptides + Mono-LinksCross-LinksLoop-Link

MS1 Analysis of isotope-coded cross-linked peptides

This can be automated development of Software Tools

Cross-linking Reagent

MS1 Data Analysis with iXLINK (Parag Mallick)9

2205 2241 2277 2313 2349 2385Mass (m/z)

7631.6

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

% In

tens

ity

4700 Reflector Spec #1 MC[BP = 2302.2, 7632]

2301.1851

2313.2556

2358.2075

2370.28102230.1462

2312.25222242.2180

2287.17072299.2451

2369.27832241.2261 2327.14452311.26492297.07792284.0977 2344.1980 2356.2422

Example MS1 spectra - d0/d12-DSS

12 Da

ABI 4700 Proteomics Analyzer

N

O

O

O

O

ON

O

O

O

2157.0 2198.6 2240.2 2281.8 2323.4 2365.0Mass (m/z)

2787.8

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

% In

tens

ity

4700 Reflector Spec #1 MC[BP = 2260.1, 2788]

2259.1016

2265.13602188.0684

2194.1018

2316.1274

2322.15232245.0886

2332.18142251.12892193.0959 2303.10572250.11652174.0688 2331.18922231.0933 2287.1348

Example MS1 spectra - d0/d6-DSG

ON

O

O

O

ON

O

O

O

6 Da

ABI 4700 Proteomics Analyzer

2208.0 2245.2 2282.4 2319.6 2356.8 2394.0Mass (m/z)

2243.7

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

% I

nten

sity

4700 Reflector Spec #1 MC[BP = 2304.4, 2244]

2303.4473

2299.4331

2360.3914

2232.52372228.5054 2356.3596

2289.45832285.42992325.34962324.35792223.4497 2278.3958

Example MS1 spectra – d0/d4-BS3

4 Da

ABI 4700 Proteomics Analyzer

For comparison:

m/z

[Da]

1.85 1.90 1.95

3100

3200

3300

3400 12

[16O] - Peptide Sample[16/18O] - Peptide Sample Image created with program “MTPeak” by Paul Loriaux

Example LC- MALDI MS1 Data (iXLINK output)

LC-MS Fraction (“Retention Time”)

13

Isotope Patterns

MS2 - Acquisition

MS Analysis Workflow

- MS2 Spectra Alignment- Isotope Pattern (Reporter Ions)- iXLINK output (Peptide Candidates)- Peptide Fragment Ion Mass Matching- Peptide Scoring (ProbID[1])

doXLINK Analysis (Ning Zhang)

Mass Pairs

User Validation

14

12 Da

d0 d12

iXLINK Inclusion List

d0

d12m/z

m/z

m/z

[1] N. Zhang et al. (2002) Proteomics 2(10): 1406-1412

* **

*

A “good” MALDI MS/MS spectrum of a light/heavy cross-linked peptide pair

**

*

* *

15

d0

d12

ABI 4700 Proteomics Analyzer

**

*

* *

A “good” MALDI MS/MS spectrum of a light/heavy cross-linked peptide pair

Reporter Ion

Reporter Ion

+ 12 Da

16

d0

d12

**

*

**

*

Some typical MALDI MS/MS spectra of cross-linker- modified peptide species

Mono-Link

Cross-Link

Reporter Ions

17

m/z = 222.1

m/z = 240.1

18Validation of Computed Cross-Linking Results with XLinkViewer (James Eddes)

User-ValidationLocations of cross-linkedResidues in Protein-Complex

Error [Da/ppm]

Matched Peptides “Score”

Analysis Results19

[2] Kortemme, T. et al. Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 2004, 11, 371-379.

Colicin E7 DNAse/Im7 protein complex [2]

Final Results – 3D Structure (1ujz.pdb) – two cross-linking reagents20

ON

O

O

O

ON

O

O

O

N

O

O

O

O

ON

O

O

O

DSG (7.7 Å)

DSS (11.4 Å)

Protein cross-linking protocol was developed using isotope-labeling and LC-MALDI mass spectrometry

Three integrative software tools were developed to analyze protein cross-linking MS and MS/MS data: iXLINK, doXLINK and XLinkViewer

All software is available for download from the SPC website

23 cross-linked amino acid residues were identified in the Colicin E7 DNAse/Im7 Protein complex (with d0/12-DSS and d0/d6-DSG cross-linking reagents)

all lysine residues within < 22.1 Å distance of each other distance constraints(as expected from the cross-linker chain length)

5-10 ug of protein was used per experiment

Compatible with various common isotope-coded bis-NHS ester cross-linking reagents (readily synthesized, or i.e. [d0/d4]-BS2G and BS3 from Pierce)

Method has been validated with additional 5 single proteins (1 week analysis time)

Experiment + analysis can be automated

Potential for high-throughput protein structure analysis

21Conclusions from this Study

Web-Links:http://www.proteomecenter.org/ASMS/Seebacher_ASMS_06_Poster.pdf ____________2006 ASMS posterhttp://tools.proteomecenter.org/XLink.php ____download software + manual

Original Publication:Seebacher, J., Mallick, P., Zhang, N., Eddes, J. S., Aebersold, R., Gelb, M. H. "Protein Cross-linking Analysis Using Mass Spectrometry, Isotope-Coded Cross-linkers, and Integrative Computational Data Processing"J. Proteome Res., 2006; 5: 2270-2282.

http://www.piercenet.com

22References

• Parag Mallick (Cedars -Sinai)• Ning Zhang• James S. Eddes• Nichole King• Richard Bonneau (NYU)• Simon Letarte• Sheng Pan• Bernd Wollscheid (IMSB)

• Ruedi Aebersold

• NHLBI, SPC

• Lars Malmström• David Baker

• Brian Smart (UCB)• Michael Gelb

University of Washington

Acknowledgements