Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our...

12
YSTEMS S L HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact on Power Controller Design By Dr. Sami Ajram SL3J SYSTEMS, S.A.R.L. Pôle d’Activité Y. Morandat 1480 Avenue d’ARMENIE, 13120 Gardanne, France Email: <[email protected]> 1 Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010

Transcript of Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our...

Page 1: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact on Power Controller

Design

By Dr. Sami Ajram SL3J SYSTEMS, S.A.R.L.

Pôle d’Activité Y. Morandat

1480 Avenue d’ARMENIE, 13120 Gardanne, France

Email: <[email protected]>

1

Oct 2010

IEEE PowerSoC 2010

Page 2: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Outline

• Background for High Frequency Switching

• Dealing with Noise

• Challenges For HF Controllers

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 2

Page 3: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

HF DC to DC Converters Challenges

• Challenges for Technologist

– Ultra Fast Power Switches with High Breakdown Voltage

– Low DCR HF Inductor

– Low ESR Capacitor

– Compatible Integration Process

• SiP, SoC etc

• Challenge for Designers

– Voltage ringing is way higher than regulated voltage amplitude

– Differentiate Load transients from Ringing

– Power Consumption in PWM circuitry

– Construct Simple, Scalable and Exportable Design

– Only Simple Ideas work efficiently

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 3

VOUT

VDD

Page 4: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Background, Solid State Power Switching Hi-Lo Transition

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 4

IDSH

VDSH

IDSL

VDSL

Page 5: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

IDSL

VDSL

Background, Solid State Power Switching Lo-Hi Transition

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 5

IDSH

VDSH

Page 6: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Background, Solid State Power Switching Hi-Lo Transition : Waveforms

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 6

IDSH

VDSH

IDSL

VDSL

ISDL

IDSH

VDSH

VDSL

IDiode

BBM or

Adjustable

Delay

Page 7: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Background, Solid State Power Switching Lo-Hi Transition : Waveforms

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 7

ISDL

IDSH

VDSH

VDSL

IDiode

IDSH

VDSH

IDSL

VDSL

Page 8: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Overview of Switch Power Losses Low Side Switch

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 8

• Switching Losses Causes

– Qg Charging and discharging

– CDS Charging (Discharging is often adiabatic)

– Body diode charge recovery (losses induced at HS switch)

– Parasitic Inductor Energy

• Conduction Losses

– Conduction losses in RDSON

– Body diode Forward losses (short time)

– Shoot through current (use BBM)

QG RON

CDSO

LD

LS

Page 9: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Overview of Switch Power Losses High Side Switch

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 9

• Switching Losses Causes

– Qg Charging and discharging

– CDS Discharging (Charging is often adiabatic)

– Ids x Vds crossing at turn on

– Parasitic Inductor Energy

• Conduction Losses

– Conduction losses in RDSON

– Shoot through current (use BBM)

QG RON CDSO

LD

LS

Page 10: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Intrinsic Limitations for Power Train Scaling

• The sum (PAC + PDC) is minimum When (PAC = PDC)

• Reason : PAC x PDC = Constant

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 10

D

DRV

PWR

OUT

IN

IN

AC

IN

MINDCAC KFS

S

V

V

P

P

P

PP0

.2)(

Stage Scaling (20, 50, 100…) KD for CMOS ranges from 10ps to 100ps At 10MHz => for instance F0.KD = 0.001

Page 11: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Device / Process Optimization [S. Ajram, G. Salmer, IEEE Trans. Power Electronics 2001]

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 11

Source

Gate

Drain

TOX

Lg Lgd

P

N+ N

N+

Oxide

Wg: Gate width COX: Oxide capacitance VgsON: Gate-to-source on-state voltage VT: Threshold voltage NsD, µnD: Respectively, the surface doping level and the

electron mobility in the drain-to-channel lightly doped region

NA Channel: Substrate doping level under the gate b: Parasitic substrate NPN transistor current gain vs: Carrier saturation velocity

Process Optimization 1. Set Breakdown Voltage 1.8V, 5V etc… 2. Breakdown determines possible Doping 3. Doping Sets Mobility 4. Engineer Lg and TOX

5. (Mobility + Doping + Gate) Sets Loss Factor

Parameter Physics

Breakdown

Voltage n

dsubBdsB.VV

1

1

1

(VBD) 4

3

162

3

10

11.1.60

ChannelA

g

dsuBN

EV

On-State

Resistance (RON)

1

q N

L

WsD

nD

gd

g. .

Maximum Input

Capacitance (Cin) OXgg

CLW ..

Loss Factor

kD=Cin.RON Dn

Ds

OXggd

.N.q

C.L.L

Note (1) Comment by Pr. Paul Chow, RPI USA

This equation does not fit for bandgap larger than 2.5eV such as for SiC or GaN, use

the following reference instead

T. Paul Chow and Ritu Tyagi "Wide Bandgap Compound Semiconductors for Superior

High-Voltage Unipolar Power Devices" IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ELECTRON

DEVICES, VOL. 41, NO. 8, AUGUST 1994

See Note (1)

Page 12: Power Train Scaling for High Frequency Switching, Impact ... · HTTP:/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com Intrinsic Limitations

YSTEMS S L S. AJRAM, SL3J SYSTEMS SARL, Marseille France

HTTP:/WWW.SL3J.COM/ Partial printouts for our website visitors. Send your comments and requests to contact@sl 3j.com

Slides to be requested

Oct 2010 IEEE PowerSoC 2010 12