PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

28
Rank Team Rd.1 Rd.2 Win Score Margin Win Score Margin 1 ADMU A 1 265 5 1 266.5 5.5 2 ADMU B 1 262 6 1 265.5 3.5 3 UPM A 0 262 -4 1 267 10 4 UPD C 1 266.5 3.5 1 262 2 5 UPD A 1 268 7 1 272.5 12 6 UPD B 1 267 9 1 265 8 7 XU A 0 256 -6 1 267.5 6.5 8 DLSU A 0 263 -3.5 1 263 2 9 UPD E 1 266 3.5 1 261.5 2 10 FEU A 1 261.5 5 1 268.5 8 11 DLSU B 1 260.5 2 1 266.5 3 12 UPD D 1 260 1.5 1 262.5 2.5 13 UPD F 0 256.5 -0.5 1 267 6.5 14 UPM B 1 262.5 8.5 1 261.5 1 15 ADMU E 1 259 11 0 260.5 -1 16 UPM C* 0 241.5 -12 1 259 6.5 17 UST A 1 262.5 2 1 263 7 18 ADMU C 1 261.5 2.5 1 265 9 19 UPLB A 1 263 2 1 267.5 7.5 20 ADDU A 0 261 -7 1 263.5 2 21 UPM D 0 262.5 -3.5 1 260 4 22 MIRIAM A 1 263 2 1 264 4.5 23 DLSU C 1 260.5 2.5 0 260 -2 24 UST B 0 258.5 -2 1 258 4 25 UPM E 1 255 3 0 260.5 -8 26 MAPUA A 1 266 4 0 263.5 -3 27 UPC A 0 258 -2 0 261 -2 28 ADMU D 1 260 2 0 261 -5.5 29 UPB ARGU A 1 260 2.5 0 259.5 -2 30 ADNU A 0 257 -2.5 1 262 3 31 ADNU B 0 254.5 -4 1 261.5 1.5 32 UPM F 1 261 1 0 257 -8 33 SORSOGON C/SWING ^ 0 250 -12 0 252 -5.5 34 FEU C 1 257 1 1 260 3 35 UPB DS B 1 263 4 0 260 -2.5 36 FEU B 0 260 -5 0 260 -1.5 37 SORSOGON A 1 262 12 0 257 -3 38 LYCEUM B 0 259.5 -2 0 253 -2 39 LYCEUM A 0 259 -2 1 258.5 3 40 UC B 1 257 0.5 0 262.5 -3.5

description

Philippine Intercollegiate Debating Championship 2010 Official Tabs

Transcript of PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

Page 1: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

Rank TeamRd.1 Rd.2 Rd.3

Win Score Margin Win Score Margin Win Score

1 ADMU A 1 265 5 1 266.5 5.5 1 266.5

2 ADMU B 1 262 6 1 265.5 3.5 1 265.5

3 UPM A 0 262 -4 1 267 10 1 267

4 UPD C 1 266.5 3.5 1 262 2 1 265.5

5 UPD A 1 268 7 1 272.5 12 1 265.5

6 UPD B 1 267 9 1 265 8 1 269

7 XU A 0 256 -6 1 267.5 6.5 1 265.5

8 DLSU A 0 263 -3.5 1 263 2 1 262

9 UPD E 1 266 3.5 1 261.5 2 1 267

10 FEU A 1 261.5 5 1 268.5 8 1 265

11 DLSU B 1 260.5 2 1 266.5 3 0 263.5

12 UPD D 1 260 1.5 1 262.5 2.5 0 263.5

13 UPD F 0 256.5 -0.5 1 267 6.5 1 264

14 UPM B 1 262.5 8.5 1 261.5 1 0 262.5

15 ADMU E 1 259 11 0 260.5 -1 1 260.5

16 UPM C* 0 241.5 -12 1 259 6.5 0 260.5

17 UST A 1 262.5 2 1 263 7 0 264.5

18 ADMU C 1 261.5 2.5 1 265 9 0 263

19 UPLB A 1 263 2 1 267.5 7.5 1 259

20 ADDU A 0 261 -7 1 263.5 2 1 267

21 UPM D 0 262.5 -3.5 1 260 4 1 262.5

22 MIRIAM A 1 263 2 1 264 4.5 0 261.5

23 DLSU C 1 260.5 2.5 0 260 -2 1 265.5

24 UST B 0 258.5 -2 1 258 4 1 263.5

25 UPM E 1 255 3 0 260.5 -8 0 263.5

26 MAPUA A 1 266 4 0 263.5 -3 1 264

27 UPC A 0 258 -2 0 261 -2 1 262

28 ADMU D 1 260 2 0 261 -5.5 1 264

29 UPB ARGU A 1 260 2.5 0 259.5 -2 1 262

30 ADNU A 0 257 -2.5 1 262 3 1 262.5

31 ADNU B 0 254.5 -4 1 261.5 1.5 1 260

32 UPM F 1 261 1 0 257 -8 0 266

33 SORSOGON C/SWING ^ 0 250 -12 0 252 -5.5 1 262.5

34 FEU C 1 257 1 1 260 3 0 259

35 UPB DS B 1 263 4 0 260 -2.5 0 261.5

36 FEU B 0 260 -5 0 260 -1.5 1 262.5

37 SORSOGON A 1 262 12 0 257 -3 0 258.5

38 LYCEUM B 0 259.5 -2 0 253 -2 1 259.5

39 LYCEUM A 0 259 -2 1 258.5 3 0 260.5

40 UC B 1 257 0.5 0 262.5 -3.5 1 259.5

41 UPTAC A 0 260 -1 0 261 -6.5 0 256

42 DLSU D 1 261.5 3.5 1 263 4.5 0 258

43 PNU A 0 254 -8.5 1 259 4 1 260.5

Page 2: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

44 DLSU E 0 258.5 -1.5 1 257.5 5.5 0 259.5

45 UPLB B 1 259.5 2.5 0 259.5 -4.5 0 259

46 UPB ARGU B 0 260.5 -1.5 1 260.5 5 0 259

47 DLS - CSB A 1 262 1.5 1 260 1 0 259.5

48 BSU A 0 261 -2 0 259 -3 0 257

49 UB A 0 258 -3.5 0 257 -10 1 262

50 SAN BEDA A 0 254 -2 1 255 2 1 260.5

51 XU B 1 259.5 0.5 0 260 -7.5 0 256

52 UC A 1 254.5 2.5 0 258.5 -4.5 1 258.5

53 UPTAC B 0 261 -2 0 260.5 -6.5 0 257.5

54 TEAM USTHS 1 261 2 0 260 -12 0 258.5

55 MAPUA B 0 256.5 -5 0 261.5 -2 1 262

56 UPB DS A 0 259 -2.5 1 261.5 2 0 258

57 UPMIAG A 0 252 -3 0 259.5 -2 0 258.5

58 MAPUA C 1 256 2 0 259 -1 0 259

59 DLSU F 0 259 -0.5 0 255 -4 1 256

60 PUP B 0 252 -2.5 0 255.5 -3 0 257

61 UPTAC C 0 250 -1 1 255.5 1 0 255.5

62 SAN BEDA B 1 251 1 0 256 -9 0 253

63 DYCI A 0 248 -11 0 254 -4 0 249

64 PUP A 0 258 -2.5 0 256 -4 0 259.5

65 PNU B 0 259 -4 0 254.5 -1 1 257

66 PUP C 0 258 -9 0 252.5 -6.5 0 256.5

67 MIRIAM B 1 258.5 4 0 256 -7 0 255

68 SORSOGON B 0 256 -1 0 255.5 -5 0 256

* UPM-C skipped Rd1 and got speaker scores of 69-69-69-34.5 plus a margin equal to the lowest margin recorded in other matches during Rd1.

^ Sorsogon C was replaced by SWING Team in rounds 3-7

Page 3: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

Rd.3 Rd.4 Rd.5 Rd.6 Rd.7

Margin Win Score Margin Win Score Margin Win Score Margin Win Score Margin

2 1 268.5 3 1 264.5 3 1 267 0.5 1 268.5 4

7 0 265.5 -3 1 268 3.5 1 266 7 1 267.5 1.5

5.5 1 262 1 1 265.5 2 1 266 3 1 266 1

2 0 262 -1.5 1 262 3 1 264.5 0.5 1 268 1

2.5 1 270 5 0 265.5 -1 0 269 -0.5 1 266.5 6.5

5.5 1 263.5 1.5 1 266.5 1 0 266.5 -0.5 0 264.5 -4

5 1 269 0.5 1 266.5 2.5 1 267.5 1.5 0 267 -1

3 1 268.5 4.5 1 267 1.5 1 269.5 0.5 0 265 -1

8 0 265 -5 1 266.5 2.5 1 262.5 2 0 266 -1.5

2.5 1 268.5 0.5 0 261.5 -3 0 264 -0.5 1 264 3

-5.5 0 265 -1 1 261 6 1 267.5 8.5 1 264.5 5.5

-2 1 268 9.5 0 263.5 -2 1 267.5 6 1 261 2

3.5 1 269 11 1 265 3 0 259 -7 1 263.5 5.5

-2.5 1 259 1 0 261 -0.5 1 262.5 5.5 1 264.5 1.5

5.5 0 258 -8 1 263.5 5 1 265 1.5 1 264 2.5

-5 1 265.5 6.5 1 263 8.5 1 264 1.5 1 261.5 2

-2 1 264 5 0 264.5 -3.5 0 262.5 -1.5 1 267 9

-2.5 1 266 8 0 264 -2.5 0 263 -3 1 264 4

1 0 268 -0.5 1 263 2 0 260.5 -2 0 263 -1.5

1 1 265 1.5 1 261.5 0.5 0 266 -1.5 0 259.5 -2

3 1 262 8 0 265.5 -1.5 0 263.5 -1.5 1 263.5 1.5

-5.5 1 261 4.5 0 264 -2.5 1 263 2 0 261.5 -2.5

2 1 262.5 3.5 0 261 -2 1 265 1 0 261 -3

2 0 268.5 -0.5 1 262.5 5.5 1 263.5 4.5 0 260 -6.5

-2 1 261.5 5.5 1 265 5 0 261.5 -6 1 265 6

8 0 252 -2 1 262 3 1 264 7 0 259 -2

6 1 263 5.5 1 266 2 1 261.5 1 0 259 -5.5

5 0 261 -1 1 259 0.5 0 261 -2 1 263 3.5

9 0 263.5 -1.5 1 260 1 0 259 -8.5 1 263.5 5.5

5 1 266 1 0 262 -3 1 258 0.5 0 258 -5.5

1 0 264 -4.5 1 260 2 0 259 -4.5 1 263 3

-1 0 254 -0.5 1 260 4 1 262 4 1 260 3

3 1 262 2.5 1 262 3.5 0 257 -7 1 259.5 2

-8 0 258 -11 0 259 -1 1 256 3 1 255 2

-2 0 254 -8 1 260.5 1.5 0 261 -5.5 1 263 3

4 0 257 -2 0 258.5 -5 1 262.5 4.5 1 260 1

-2 1 261 12 0 260.5 -1 0 257 -5.5 1 261.5 6

2.5 1 258.5 2 1 260.5 3 0 264 -1 0 262 -1.5

-3.5 0 259.5 -2.5 1 258.5 5 1 261 2.5 0 260 -4

4 0 256.5 -4.5 0 258.5 -0.5 0 260.5 -3.5 1 262.5 4

-1 1 261.5 2 1 260.5 3.5 1 258.5 0.5 0 257.5 -2

-1 1 254 2 0 259 -3 0 260.5 -1 0 258 -9

2 0 258 -1 0 264 -2 1 259 4 0 259 -6

Page 4: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

-3 1 259 2 0 259 -3 1 266.5 5.5 0 253 -2

-3 1 259 4.5 0 257 -5.5 0 258 -0.5 1 260.5 4

-1 1 257 2 0 255 -6 1 259.5 1.5 0 259.5 -3.5

-7 0 259 -5 0 257.5 -3 0 253 -3 1 260 2.5

-2.5 1 256 4 1 260.5 1 0 258 -4 1 257.5 2

5 1 254.5 0.5 0 254.5 -8.5 1 264 3.5 0 258 -5.5

2 0 258.5 -9.5 1 261.5 1 0 257.5 -0.5 0 260 -3

-8 0 257.5 -5.5 1 257 2.5 1 258 2.5 0 257 -3

0.5 0 259 -3.5 0 258 -2 0 255 -4 1 259.5 2

-5 0 259 -6.5 1 261 4 1 261 3.5 0 257.5 -2.5

-2 1 259 2 0 258.5 -3.5 0 258 -1.5 0 257.5 -2

5.5 0 256.5 -2 1 259 2 0 255.5 -2.5 0 259 -1

-0.5 1 252.5 1.5 0 260 -5 0 258.5 -2.5 0 260 -3

-4 1 257 7 0 259 -1.5 0 258.5 -2 1 258 1

-5 0 255 -2 0 257 -4 1 260 1 0 255.5 -6

7 0 256 -5.5 0 256 -4 1 258 1.5 0 258.5 -4

-5 1 259.5 2.5 0 253.5 -5 1 260.5 2 0 256.5 -4

-4 0 254.5 -4.5 0 259.5 -1 1 259 1.5 0 255.5 -2

-9 0 249 -12 0 254.5 -2.5 0 256.5 -1.5 1 256.5 1

-7 0 250 -7 0 248.5 -1.5 1 258 1 1 256 2

-3 0 257 -2.5 0 257 -3.5 0 257 -1 1 260.5 4

1 0 257 -2 0 257 -3.5 0 257.5 -1.5 0 255.5 -1

-5.5 0 259.5 -2 1 250 1.5 0 259 -1 0 257 -1

-5.5 0 251 -1.5 0 257 -2 0 258 -4.5 0 256.5 -4

-6 0 252 -4 1 260.5 3.5 0 257.5 -3.5 0 254 -2

Page 5: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

Total

Win Score Margin

7 1866.5 23

6 1860 25.5

6 1855.5 18.5

6 1850.5 10.5

5 1877 31.5

5 1862 20.5

5 1859 9

5 1858 7

5 1854.5 11.5

5 1853 15.5

5 1848.5 18.5

5 1846 17.5

5 1844 22

5 1833.5 14.5

5 1830.5 16.5

5 1815 8

4 1848 16

4 1846.5 15.5

4 1844 8.5

4 1843.5 -5.5

4 1839.5 10

4 1838 2.5

4 1835.5 2

4 1834.5 7

4 1832 3.5

4 1830.5 15

4 1830.5 5

4 1829 2.5

4 1827.5 6

4 1825.5 -1.5

4 1822 -5.5

4 1820 2.5

4 1805 -13.5

4 1804 -11

3 1823 -9.5

3 1820.5 -4

3 1817.5 18.5

3 1817 1

3 1817 -1.5

3 1817 -3.5

3 1815 -4.5

3 1814 -4

3 1813.5 -7.5

Page 6: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

3 1813 3.5

3 1812.5 -2.5

3 1811 -3.5

3 1811 -13

3 1809 -4.5

3 1808 -18.5

3 1807 -10

3 1805 -18.5

3 1803 -9

2 1817.5 -15

2 1812.5 -17

2 1810 -5

2 1809.5 -10

2 1802.5 -4.5

2 1801.5 -15

2 1798.5 -9.5

2 1794.5 -15

2 1789.5 -10

2 1776.5 -32

2 1763.5 -27.5

1 1805 -12.5

1 1797.5 -12

1 1792.5 -23.5

1 1792 -20.5

1 1791.5 -18

Page 7: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

Rank Speaker TeamSpeaker Score

Rd.1 Rd.2 Rd.3

1 Chan, Aaron UPD A 77 78.5 76.5

2 Arcellana, Anna UPD A 77 77.5 76

2 Chu, Jonathan ADMU A 76 76 77.5

4 Tagle, Vinny ADMU A 75 76 76

5 de Castro, Danielle ADMU B 75.5 76 76

6 Simbulan, Pearl UPD A 77 77.5 75

7 Zosa, Alistair UPD B 76 76 77.5

7 Tirthdas, Samantha UPD E 76.5 74.5 77

9 Yarcia, Lee Edson UPM A 76 77 76

9 Gandeza, Rene Jr. XU A 73 77 76

9 Falcis, Jesus FEU A 75.5 77 76

9 Gotamco, Ces ADMU B 75 76 76

9 Libot, Gian XU A 74 76.5 76

14 Reyes, Carlito DLSU A 75.5 75.5 75

15 Bernal, Buena UST A 75 76 77

15 Endaluz, Genica UPD C 76 75.5 76.5

17 Chung, Candice UPD E 76.5 75.5 76

18 Bautista, Julian DLSU A 74.5 75.5 75

19 Bautista, Ligaya UPM A 75 76 77

19 Inting, Valeri UPD B 76 76 76.5

19 Abantas, Shidik XU A 73.5 76 75

22 Mallari, Elfermin UPD C 76.5 75 75.5

22 Cocabo, Patrick ADMU B 75 76 76

22 Usita, Katrina UPD B 77 75 75.5

25 Rigodon, Joe DLSU B 75 77 75.5

25 Umanan, Roland Andrew ADDU A 75 76 77

25 Wong, Walter ADMU A 76 76 75

25 Tio, Clarissa UPM A 75 76 76

25 Rodriguez, Ana UPD D 75 75.5 75.5

30 Pine, Ray ADMU C 75 75 75.5

30 Santiago, Pipao DLSU B 74.5 76 74

30 Ortiz, Kayleen UST A 76 75 75

30 Sevilla, Miguel UPD F 73.5 76 76

30 Cruz, Jasmine ADMU C 74 76 76

30 Sana, Marco FEU A 74.5 77 75

36 Robles, Lenard UPD D 74 75.5 75

36 Bustos, John Jake UPLB A 75 77 74

36 Caluag, Iris MIRIAM A 75 76 75

Page 8: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

36 Bersales, Hydra UPLB A 76 76 74

36 Francisco, Crystal DLSU C 75 75 76

36 See, Kurt Gerrard DLSU B 74 76 76

42 Go, Jasper DLSU A 75 74 74

42 Alabastro, Bruneson ADDU A 75 75 76

42 Carrasco, Marlo UPM D 76 74 74.5

42 dela Cerna, John Ray UPD F 72.5 76 75

46 Carpeso, Larraine UPM E 73 74.5 76

46 Dizon, Diane UPM D 75 74 75.5

46 Devoma, Reymark UPLB A 75 76 74

49 de Leon, Gayle ADMU C 75 76 74

50 Lumapas, Ria Danielle ADDU A 75 75 76

50 Siapno, Marc UPD F 73.5 77 75

50 Lim, Joshua ADMU E 74 75 74.5

50 Borromeo, Carlo UPD D 74 74 75.5

50 de Leon, Job ADMU D 75 75 76

50 Carulla, John UST A 75 75 75

50 Yanzon, Jico FEU A 74.5 76.5 76

50 Rivera, Camille MIRIAM A 76 75 75

50 Cerda, Jovan UPD C 75.5 74 75.5

59 Garcia, Rolan MAPUA A 77 76 75

59 Narvacan, Keith UPM B 75 75 75

59 Ouano, Garie UPD E 75 74 76

62 Azurin, Paula UST B 74 74 75

62 Bongcales, Bhea UPM E 72.5 76 75

62 Limsengkeng, Burton DLSU C 74 74 76

62 Bernal, Gabriel LYCEUM A 75 75 75

62 Quitoy, Mark UST B 74.5 74 75

62 Tornilla, Samantha UPC A 73.5 75 75

68 Ghannam, Sandi ADNU B 73 75.5 75

68 Bernate, Dea ADMU E 75 75 74.5

68 Mayuyo, Prince UST B 74 73 76

68 Marquez, Jan Paul UPM B 75 75 76

68 Goh, Mark Anthony LYCEUM B 75 72 75

73 Atumpag, Paulie Kirstie UPB ARGU A 74.5 75 75

73 Gomez, Joy MIRIAM A 75 75 74

75 Paras, Rommel UPC A 74.5 74.5 74

75 Escay, Mark DLSU E 74 75 74.5

75 Diaz, Pochilito DLSU C 74 74 76

75 Baro, Gerald FEU B 74 75 75

Page 9: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

75 Agra, Solina Bianca UPB ARGU A 74.5 74 75.5

75 Butial, Janine UPM D 74 74 75

81 Palomares, Monica ADNU A 73 74.5 76

81 Poche, Salve Carmela ADNU B 73 75 74.5

81 Relloso, Arcci ADNU A 73 75 75

81 Tatcho, Orville UPB DS B 76 74.5 75

85 Cruz, Elmer UPM B 75 75 74

85 Go, Jeremy UPM F 75 74 77

85 Ramos, Amanda UPB DS B 75 75 75

85 Lopido, Christian Arden UPTAC B 75 75 74

89 Cesista, Vincent UPC A 73 74 75

89 Legion, Karen UPM E 73 73 75

89 Chua, Bryan DLSU D 75 75 74

89 Fabros, Julian UPLB B 74 75 74

93 Sevilla, Luis Angelo MAPUA A 75 75 75

93 Sullano, Duane MAPUA A 76 74 76

93 Amil, Christian James UPM F 75 73 76

96 Resurrecion, Efren ADMU D 73.5 74 75

96 Lesano, Roniel SORSOGON A 75 74 73

96 Blanco, Ernesto Lucky UC B 73.5 75 75

96 Evano, John Edward SORSOGON A 75 73 74

100 Dalisay, Don Stanley UPM C 69 74.5 75

100 Delgado, William FEU B 75 74 75

100 Galano, Marco UPB ARGU A 74 73 74.5

103 Cruz, James ADMU D 74 73.5 75.5

103 Garcia, Angelo ADMU E 73 74 74

103 Fernandez, Rembert MAPUA B 74.5 75 75

103 Manigque, Glenn UB A 74 74 75

107 Ramos, Wilmark UC B 73.5 75 73.5

107 Cordero, Sheena LYCEUM A 74 74 75

107 Herradura, Jed Lenard BSU A 75 74.5 73

107 Mayol, Jude Eliazar PNU A 72 73.5 75

107 Basilan, Rebelander UPTAC A 75 74.5 73.5

107 Pontejos, Gabriella UPTAC A 74 75 73

107 Sy, James DLSU D 74 75.5 74

114 Yap, Amity PNU A 73 74 75

114 Evangelista, Leo Patrick UPB ARGU B 74.5 74 75

114 Malit, Fritz UPLB B 75 74 74

114 Garcia, Merryl Josephine ADNU A 74 75 74

114 Dacanay, George FEU B 74 73.5 75

Page 10: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

114 Inso, Andrei UPB DS A 74 75 74

120 Legaspi, Kathryn LYCEUM B 74 73 74

120 Yoro, Marjorie UPB ARGU B 75 75 74

120 Ong, Cesar Ruperto UPTAC A 74 74 73

120 Kier, Carlo Mari UC B 73.5 75 74

120 Fideles, Vika DLS - CSB A 75 74 73.5

120 Sta. Ana, Faye TEAM USTHS 75 75 74

120 Jordan, Jerome UPTAC B 75 73 73

127 Gabunada, Ron Rafael UPM C 69 74 74

127 Vallar, Lorenzven XU B 74.5 74 74

127 Gayares, Danielle UPM C 69 73.5 74

127 Mattus, Carlos MAPUA B 73 75 75.5

127 Lauzon, Leo Christian UPTAC B 74 75 73.5

127 Bea, Gloria Katrina UPB DS A 74 74.5 74

127 Tarape, Katrina PUP A 74 73 75

127 Ferriol, Joanna Jamaima PNU A 73 74.5 73

127 Salazar, Karl Christian BSU A 74 74 74

127 Sy, Justine MAPUA C 74 74 74.5

137 Santiago, Ferdino Logie LYCEUM B 74.5 72 74

137 Soltes, Nicole DLS - CSB A 75 75 74

137 Serrador, King TEAM USTHS 74 74 74

137 Benosa, Jerwin SORSOGON A 75 73 74.5

137 Barrias, Ariel UPB DS B 74 73 74

142 Vergara, Jerome SAN BEDA A 73 74 74.5

142 Lopez, Ginette PUP A 74 73 74

142 Fang, Mariel DLSU E 74 72 74.5

142 Corpuz, Kevin UPM F 74 73 75

142 Estrada, Leo John UPMIAG A 72 74.5 74

142 Agpawa, Gillian Ellen XU B 75 74 73

142 Angeles, Michelle SAN BEDA A 72 73 74

142 Pascual, Christian UC A 72 75 74.5

142 Dumelod, Rica TEAM USTHS 74 74 73

142 Villapando, Dianne Jane PNU B 74 73 74

152 Aniag, Josef Reymarl BSU A 75 73.5 74

152 Padua, Chris Vincent UC A 73 74 74

152 Sourdis, Fanie FEU C 74 74 74

152 Maniago, Don FEU C 73.5 75 74

152 Pugong, Leizandra LYCEUM A 73 73.5 74

152 Ambat, Daniel Dominic DLS - CSB A 74.5 74 75

152 David, Sheigla FEU C 73.5 74 74

Page 11: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

159 Rodriguez, Pauline SAN BEDA A 72 72 75

159 Au Yeung, Michael MAPUA C 73 75 74

161 Caday, Marchellene UPB DS A 74 74.5 73

161 Cahilig, Ma. Airene PNU B 75 72 73.5

161 Taino, Kenneth ADNU B 72 74 73

161 Dominguez, Je DLSU D 75 75 73

161 Baldevarona, Rosaleah UPMIAG A 72 74 74.5

161 Libre, Abigail MIRIAM B 74 73 73

161 Chong, Chris DLSU F 75 73 72.5

161 Hermogino, Jovvin MAPUA B 73 74 74

161 Lebrilla, Jam UPMIAG A 72 74 74

161 Dado, Therese Ingrid UPB ARGU B 74 73.5 73

171 Tena, Paul Ely PUP B 72 73.5 73.5

171 Laceda, Agosto Harvey SORSOGON B 74 73 74

171 Capina, Xavier Christian PUP C 74 72.5 74

174 Sy, Dianne DLSU F 73.5 73 73

174 Gianan, Emy Ruth PUP A 73 73 74.5

174 Cua, Carmela XU B 73 76 72

174 Ericson, Ivaraxel UB A 74 73 75

178 Barrete, Reuben James PUP B 72 73 73.5

178 Pabillore, Jonathan DLSU E 73.5 73 73.5

178 Mansueto, Nicolette UB A 73 73 74.5

178 Galang, Jumarbel UC A 73 73.5 73.5

178 Rigor, Gary UPLB B 73 73 74

178 Lizano, Jhessa Lizette PUP C 74 72.5 73

178 Dagalea, Lemuel DLSU F 73 72 74

185 Lee, Izzy MIRIAM B 74 73 72.5

185 Pelito, Lois UPTAC C 71 72 74.5

185 Hicban, Grace SAN BEDA B 72 73 73

185 Mempin, Marian Laurice PUP B 72 73 73.5

189 Dellosa, Lovely Valerie PNU B 74 72 73

189 Maceda, Amanda UPTAC C 72 72 72.5

189 Bungcag, Joy SORSOGON B 72.5 73 73

192 Tuliao, Richard MAPUA C 72 73 74

193 Santiago, Kristine Demilou UPTAC C 71 74 73

193 Corral, Ma. Lou Felanie SORSOGON B 73 73 72

195 Morillo, Raevene MIRIAM B 74 73 72.5

195 Castro, Julan PUP C 73 72 72

195 Olivar, Percival SORSOGON C 72 73

198 Sena, Joseph SAN BEDA B 71 73 72

Page 12: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

199 Eugenio, Edgardo DYCI A 72 73 70.5

200 Concepcion, Mae DYCI A 71 72 72

201 Concepcion, Earl SAN BEDA B 72 73 72

202 Blas, April Rose DYCI A 70 73 71.5

202 Oh, Ron-ron SORSOGON C 71 72

204 Dichoso, Charles Japeth SORSOGON C 72 70

Page 13: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

Speaker ScoreTotal Avg

Rd.4 Rd.5 Rd.6 Rd.7

77 75 78 76.5 538.5 76.93

78 75.5 77 75.5 536.5 76.64

78 76 76 77 536.5 76.64

78 76 77 77 535.0 76.43

76 77 77 77 534.5 76.36

77 76 75.5 76 534.0 76.29

76 77 76 75 533.5 76.21

76 77 75.5 77 533.5 76.21

74.5 76 76.5 77 533.0 76.14

78 76 77 76 533.0 76.14

78 74.5 76 76 533.0 76.14

77 77 76 76 533.0 76.14

77 77 76.5 76 533.0 76.14

77 76 77 76.5 532.5 76.07

76 76 75 77 532.0 76.00

75 76 76 77 532.0 76.00

75.5 76 75.5 76 531.0 75.86

76.5 76.5 77 75.5 530.5 75.79

75 76 75.5 75.5 530.0 75.71

75 76 75.5 75 530.0 75.71

76 76 76.5 77 530.0 75.71

75 74.5 75.5 77 529.0 75.57

75 76 75 76 529.0 75.57

75 74.5 76 76 529.0 75.57

75 74 77 75 528.5 75.50

76 74.5 76 74 528.5 75.50

75 75 75.5 76 528.5 75.50

75 75 76 75.5 528.5 75.50

76 74.5 77 75 528.5 75.50

76 75 75 76.5 528.0 75.43

77 74.5 76 76 528.0 75.43

75 76 75 76 528.0 75.43

77 76 74 75.5 528.0 75.43

76 75 76 75 528.0 75.43

76 75 75 75.5 528.0 75.43

77 75.5 76 74.5 527.5 75.36

76.5 75 75 75 527.5 75.36

75 76 75.5 75 527.5 75.36

Page 14: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

77 75 74.5 75 527.5 75.36

75.5 74 77 75 527.5 75.36

75 74.5 76 76 527.5 75.36

76 76.5 76.5 75 527.0 75.29

76 74.5 76.5 74 527.0 75.29

75 76.5 75 76 527.0 75.29

77 76 75 75.5 527.0 75.29

75 77 75 76 526.5 75.21

74.5 76 76 75.5 526.5 75.21

76 76 74 75.5 526.5 75.21

76 76 74.5 74.5 526.0 75.14

75 74.5 76 74 525.5 75.07

77 75 73 75 525.5 75.07

75 75 76 76 525.5 75.07

76 75.5 76.5 74 525.5 75.07

74.5 74 75.5 75.5 525.5 75.07

75 75 75 75.5 525.5 75.07

75 74 75 74.5 525.5 75.07

74 75 75.5 75 525.5 75.07

75 74.5 75 76 525.5 75.07

72 75 76 74 525.0 75.00

75 74 75 76 525.0 75.00

76 75 74 75 525.0 75.00

77.5 75 75 74 524.5 74.93

75 76 75 75 524.5 74.93

75 74.5 76 75 524.5 74.93

74.5 75 75 75 524.5 74.93

77 75 76 73 524.5 74.93

75 77 75 74 524.5 74.93

75 74.5 75 76 524.0 74.86

73 75.5 76 75 524.0 74.86

76 75 75 75 524.0 74.86

73 74.5 75 75.5 524.0 74.86

74.5 75 77 75.5 524.0 74.86

75 75 74 75 523.5 74.79

75 76 74.5 74 523.5 74.79

74.5 77 74.5 74 523.0 74.71

74.5 75 77 73 523.0 74.71

74.5 75.5 75 74 523.0 74.71

73.5 74.5 76 75 523.0 74.71

Page 15: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

76 74 74 75 523.0 74.71

75 75.5 75 74.5 523.0 74.71

76 75 74 74 522.5 74.64

76 75 74 75 522.5 74.64

77 75 73.5 74 522.5 74.64

72 74 76 75 522.5 74.64

73 75 75 75 522.0 74.57

72 75 75 74 522.0 74.57

73 75 73 76 522.0 74.57

75 75 75 73 522.0 74.57

76 75 74.5 74 521.5 74.50

75 75 74.5 76 521.5 74.50

74 74 75 74.5 521.5 74.50

75 75 73.5 75 521.5 74.50

72 74.5 75.5 74 521.0 74.43

72 74 75 74 521.0 74.43

73 74.5 75 74.5 521.0 74.43

74.5 74.5 74 75 520.5 74.36

75 74.5 74 75 520.5 74.36

73 74.5 74 75.5 520.5 74.36

74.5 75 73.5 75.5 520.5 74.36

75.5 75 76 75 520.0 74.29

74 73 75.5 73.5 520.0 74.29

75 74 74 75.5 520.0 74.29

74 73.5 74 75 519.5 74.21

73 75.5 75 75 519.5 74.21

73.5 74.5 73 74 519.5 74.21

73.5 73 76 74 519.5 74.21

74 73 75.5 74.5 519.0 74.14

74 73.5 74.5 74 519.0 74.14

73.5 75 74 74 519.0 74.14

74 75 74.5 75 519.0 74.14

74 75 73.5 73.5 519.0 74.14

74.5 74.5 73 75 519.0 74.14

73 75 74.5 73 519.0 74.14

74 76 73.5 73 518.5 74.07

73.5 73 74 74.5 518.5 74.07

74 73 74 74.5 518.5 74.07

75 74 73.5 73 518.5 74.07

73 74 75 74 518.5 74.07

Page 16: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

72 75 74 74.5 518.5 74.07

73.5 74 75 74.5 518.0 74.00

73 72.5 74 74.5 518.0 74.00

75 74.5 74.5 73 518.0 74.00

73 73.5 74 75 518.0 74.00

74 74 72.5 75 518.0 74.00

74 74 73 73 518.0 74.00

74 74 75 74 518.0 74.00

76 75 75 74.5 517.5 73.93

75 73 74 73 517.5 73.93

76 75 75 75 517.5 73.93

73 74 73 74 517.5 73.93

73.5 74.5 74 73 517.5 73.93

73 74.5 73.5 74 517.5 73.93

73.5 73.5 73.5 75 517.5 73.93

73 75 74 75 517.5 73.93

73.5 74.5 74 73.5 517.5 73.93

73 73.5 74 74 517.0 73.86

73.5 74 74 75 517.0 73.86

75 73 72 73 517.0 73.86

74.5 73 74 73.5 517.0 73.86

74 74 72.5 74 517.0 73.86

72 74 75 74.5 516.5 73.79

73 74.5 73.5 74 516.5 73.79

73.5 73.5 74 74.5 516.5 73.79

74 74 76 72 516.5 73.79

72 73.5 75 74 516.5 73.79

73.5 75 74 73.5 516.5 73.79

73.5 74 74 73 516.5 73.79

74 74.5 74 75 516.5 73.79

74.5 74 73 73.5 516.5 73.79

74 74 74 73.5 516.5 73.79

73.5 74 74 73.5 516.0 73.71

73 74 73 73.5 516.0 73.71

74 73.5 73 74.5 516.0 73.71

74 74 73 73 516.0 73.71

74 74 73.5 72 516.0 73.71

74.5 73 74 74 516.0 73.71

73 73 72 74.5 516.0 73.71

74 74 73 73 515.5 73.64

Page 17: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

74 75 73 74 515.0 73.57

72.5 73 74.5 73 515.0 73.57

71.5 74 74 74 515.0 73.57

74 74 73.5 73 515.0 73.57

75 73 73 75 515.0 73.57

71 73 74 74 515.0 73.57

72.5 73.5 74 74.5 515.0 73.57

72 74 75 74 515.0 73.57

74 73 73.5 74 515.0 73.57

73 74 73.5 73.5 515.0 73.57

73.5 73 74.5 73.5 514.5 73.50

73 72.5 74.5 74 514.5 73.50

73.5 73.5 75 73.5 514.5 73.50

73 75 73 72 514.0 73.43

74.5 71.5 74 73.5 514.0 73.43

73 74 74 73.5 514.0 73.43

73 73.5 72.5 74 513.5 73.36

72.5 73 73 74 513.5 73.36

72 72 75 72.5 513.5 73.36

74 72.5 74.5 74 513.5 73.36

73.5 73 76 71 513.5 73.36

72 72 75 74 513.5 73.36

73.5 73 73 74 513.5 73.36

73.5 73 73 73.5 513.0 73.29

74.5 71 74 74 513.0 73.29

73 73 74 74 513.0 73.29

72 74 74 73.5 513.0 73.29

73.5 74.5 74 73 512.5 73.21

73 73 74 74.5 512.5 73.21

74.5 72 74.5 73 512.5 73.21

73.5 72.5 73.5 73.5 512.0 73.14

73 74 74.5 73.5 511.5 73.07

71.5 74.5 74 73 511.5 73.07

72 73.5 74 72 510.5 72.93

72 74 73.5 73 510.5 72.93

71.5 74.5 74 72.5 510.5 72.93

71.5 73 73 73 510.0 72.86

73.5 72.5 73.5 73 509.5 72.79

145.0 72.50

71 72.5 73 74 506.5 72.36

Page 18: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

71 72 74 73 505.5 72.21

71.5 70.5 73.5 73.5 504.0 72.00

70 72 73 72 504.0 72.00

71.5 71 73 72.5 502.5 71.79

143.0 71.50

142.0 71.00

Page 19: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

Rank Adjudicator InstitutionAdj Exam Adj Feedback

Objective Essay Rating Round 11 Jiao, Claire UPD 5 5 52 Mangahas, Gica ADMU 5 5 5 53 Ismail, Sani IIU 5 5 54 De Leon, Dino DLSU 5 5 5 45 Maulit, Jayson SBC 5 5 5 46 Zaldivar, Joan Kristi UST 5 5 5 4.57 Chan, Pam ADMU 4 4.25 4.175 4.58 Solis, Mark Joseph Tajo UPD 3 3.5 3.35 3.59 Aguilar, Jeross INDIE 4 4 4 3.5

10 Cruz, Eric DLSU 4 3.75 3.825 4.511 Sebolino, Robin DLSU 3 3.75 3.52512 Que, Anna UPD 3 3.75 3.525 313 Sevilla, Juan Miguel UPD 4 3.75 3.825 314 Seso, Rachael PUP 3 3.5 3.35 415 Garcia, Robin DLSU 4 3 3.3 416 Bornilla, Lisha ADMU 4 3.75 3.825 317 de Leon, John Cedrick UPD 4 2.5 2.95 318 Esparagoza, Erwin UPTAC 5 2 2.9 319 Bautista, Gat DLSU 4 2.25 2.775 320 Sales, Steffi ADMU 3 3 3 3.521 Gogo, Lee Arvin XU 4 3.25 3.475 322 Soriano, Mourese UST 2 2 2 323 Fortun, Alexa ADMU 3 2 2.3 424 Villanueva, Bian ADMU 3 2.5 2.65 425 Bermas, Danica Isabel ADNU 5 1.75 2.725 2.526 Saroca, Anzen UPM 4 3.63 3.741 327 Bara, Shaneen UPM 3 2.5 2.65 328 dela Pena, JC DLS- CSB 2 2.5 2.35 3.2529 Canoy, Eleonor Christine UPLB 3 2.75 2.825 230 Santiago, Sofia UST 3 3 3 331 Bayang, JP UST 3 2.38 2.566 3.532 Andaca, Mahon UPD 4 2.5 2.95 333 Dapasen, Richard FEU 4 2.75 3.125 034 Villamer, Quimberly Hyacinth USI 2 1.75 1.825 3.2535 Alerta, Lourraine LYCEUM 3 2.67 2.769 336 Floresca, Gabz MAPUA 4 1.5 2.25 2.2537 Garingo, Vanessa FEU 2 3 2.7 2.538 Lonzagah, Mark DLSU 3 2.5 2.65 3.538 Reyes, Craig Angelo USI 4 2.25 2.775 2.540 Marco, Noe Jr. FEU 3 2.5 2.65 1.541 Lacdao, May UPB DS 3 2 2.3 2.2542 Palomer, Terence Joe UPB ARG 2 2.25 2.175 2.7543 Juan Loa, Nina Isabela UP Miag-ao 4 2 2.6 3.544 Umaguing, Leo Marco PNU 4 2 2.6 345 Fabillar, Kristel UPTAC 4 2.25 2.775 1.546 Pepito, Reymond ADDU 3 1.75 2.125 3.5

Page 20: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

47 Beso, Andrew James PUP 3 2 2.3 3.548 Espana, Razelle PUP 4 2.5 2.95 2.549 Teodoro, Mariama PNU 3 2.25 2.475 250 Gamboa, Blessie UPM 3 2.88 2.916 251 Bustamante, Elena UPM 2 2.75 2.525 3.552 Novida, Claudio MAPUA 4 1.5 2.25 2.7553 Roque, Quarter MAPUA 3 2 2.3 2.7554 Gonzales, Carizza ADDU 2 1.75 1.825 3.555 King, Hany Rose Bien Bien LYCEUM 3 2.25 2.475 356 Locquiao, Lilet UC 3 1.75 2.125 2.557 Santos, Rachelle MC 3 1.75 2.125 358 Magno, Nathaniel ADNU 3 1 1.6 2.7559 Vicher, Ela UPB DS 2 2 2 3.2560 Rivero, Lorraine USI 2 1.75 1.825 1.561 Ballug, Claire Gin Nhoa UC 2 1.5 1.65 262 Pangilinan, Jerraine SBC 3 1.5 1.95 163 Quinones, Edione SBC 2 1.25 1.475 1.564 Castillon, Dien UPM 0 0 0 1.565 Marticio, Marie Tonette LNU 3 1 1.6 266 Benedicto, Maryanne UPC 0 0 0 266 Olivar, Percival SSC 0 0 0 068 Ditchoso, Charles Japeth SSC 0 0 0 069 Oh, Ron-ron SSC 0 0 0 070 Reyes, Adrielle UPM 2 2 2 171 Binondo, Phillip DLSU 0 0 0 3.5

Adj sat out the round

Scores of 0 were given to adjudicators that missed rounds which were not excused.

Page 21: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

Adj FeedbackOverall RatingRound 2 Round 3 Round 4 Round 5 Round 6 Round 7 Total Average

5 5 5 5 5 5 30 5 55 4.5 5 5 5 5 34.5 4.928571 4.94642857142857

5 5 4.5 14.5 4.833333 4.8754.5 5 5 5 5 4 32.5 4.642857 4.73214285714286

5 4 4.5 5 5 4.5 32 4.571429 4.678571428571433 5 4 4 4 5 29.5 4.214286 4.41071428571429

4.5 4.5 3 5 4 5 30.5 4.357143 4.311607142857144 3 5 5 4.5 4.5 29.5 4.214286 3.998214285714294 4.5 4 3 3.5 5 27.5 3.928571 3.94642857142857

3.5 4 2.5 4 3.5 4 26 3.714286 3.741964285714294.5 3.5 2.5 3 3.5 5 22 3.666667 3.631253.5 3.5 3.5 4 3.5 4 25 3.571429 3.559821428571433.5 3 3.5 5 3 3 24 3.428571 3.52767857142857

4 4 3.5 3 3 3.5 25 3.571429 3.516071428571433.5 3 3 4 3 4.5 25 3.571429 3.50357142857143

4 3.5 3.5 4 2 3 23 3.285714 3.420535714285714 3.5 3 4 3.5 4 25 3.571429 3.41607142857143

3.5 3.5 4 3.5 3 4.5 25 3.571429 3.403571428571433 4.5 4 3 3.75 4 25.25 3.607143 3.39910714285714

4.5 2.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 24.5 3.5 3.3754.5 2 2.5 3.5 3.25 4.5 23.25 3.321429 3.35982142857143

3 3.25 4 4 5 4 26.25 3.75 3.31255 3 2.5 3.25 4 21.75 3.625 3.29375

3.5 3 4 4 2.5 3 24 3.428571 3.233928571428573.25 4 4 3.5 3.25 3 23.5 3.357143 3.19910714285714

3 3 3 2.5 3 3.5 21 3 3.185254 4 3.5 2 3.5 20 3.333333 3.16253 4 2.5 5 3.25 3 24 3.428571 3.158928571428573 4.25 4 3 2 4.5 22.75 3.25 3.143754 2.5 3 3.5 3 3 22 3.142857 3.10714285714286

3.5 4.5 3 3 3 2.5 23 3.285714 3.105785714285713 3.5 3 12.5 3.125 3.08125

2.5 3.25 4 4 3.5 4 21.25 3.035714 3.058035714285713.5 3 4 3.5 4 3 24.25 3.464286 3.05446428571429

2 2.25 3.5 3.25 4 4 22 3.142857 3.049392857142864 3.25 3.75 3.25 3.5 2.5 22.5 3.214286 2.973214285714293 4 3 1.5 3 4.25 21.25 3.035714 2.95178571428571

2.5 4 3.5 3.25 1.5 18.25 3.041667 2.943753.5 3 2.5 3.5 2.5 3.5 21 3 2.94375

3 3.75 3.75 3.25 2.5 3.5 21.25 3.035714 2.939285714285713 3.75 3.75 2.5 2.5 4.25 22 3.142857 2.93214285714286

3.5 3.25 4 3 2.5 3 22 3.142857 2.900892857142863.5 2.5 2.5 3 3.5 2.5 21 3 2.9

3.25 2 3.75 3.5 2.5 2.75 20.75 2.964286 2.873214285714293.25 3.75 3.25 3.5 2 3 20.25 2.892857 2.86339285714286

4 1.5 3 3.25 2.5 4 21.75 3.107143 2.86160714285714

Page 22: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

3 3 3.5 3.75 2 2.5 21.25 3.035714 2.851785714285714 2.5 4 2.5 3 1 19.5 2.785714 2.82678571428571

2.75 2.75 4 4 2 3 20.5 2.928571 2.815178571428573 3 3 2.75 13.75 2.75 2.7915

3.5 2 2 1.75 4 3 19.75 2.821429 2.747321428571433.25 2 4 3 2 2.75 19.75 2.821429 2.67857142857143

3.5 3.5 3 2 2.75 2 19.5 2.785714 2.664285714285712.5 3.5 3 1.75 3.25 3 20.5 2.928571 2.65267857142857

3 3 2 2 3 2.5 18.5 2.642857 2.600892857142862.5 3.5 3 3 2 2.5 19 2.714286 2.566964285714292.5 2.75 2 3 2.5 2.75 18.5 2.642857 2.51339285714286

3.25 3 2 3 2.75 2.5 19.25 2.75 2.46253.25 2.25 2.75 3.25 0 3 17.75 2.535714 2.40178571428571

2 2 2 2 2.75 3.75 16 2.285714 2.170535714285713 2.5 2 2 2 2.75 16.25 2.321429 2.153571428571431 2 2 2 2.5 4 14.5 2.071429 2.041071428571432 1 2 1 3 2.5 13 1.857143 1.76160714285714

2.5 1.5 3 3 2.5 2 16 2.285714 1.714285714285712 2 2 0 2 2 12 1.714286 1.68571428571429

3.5 0 3 4 2 0 14.5 2.071429 1.553571428571430 2 3 1.5 5 3 14.5 2.071429 1.553571428571430 1 2.5 3 1.5 2 10 1.428571 1.071428571428570 1.5 1 3 2 1.5 9 1.285714 0.9642857142857140 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.142857 0.6071428571428570 0 0 0 0 0 3.5 0.5 0.375

Page 23: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

ROUND ONE:1 THW create a centralized governing authority for Metro Manila2 THW abolish partylists3 The State should not extend protection to national symbols

ROUND TWO:1 Women should reject chivalry to forward gender equality2 Consent should be the only standard in all sexual relationships3 THW ban online virginity auctions

ROUND THREE:1 Africa should allow the 100% foreign ownership of its non-renewable resources2 The state should subsidize competitors when the current market is monopolized by foreign enterprises3 The US should impose stiff sanctions against China for artificially devaluing the yuan

ROUND FOUR:1 THW abandon the search for extraterrestrial life2 THW discontinue the search for previously undiscovered tribes3 THW legitimize the search for justice through duels to the death

ROUND FIVE:1 The international community should always intervene in cases of military coups2 THW halt all aid to Israel unless it stops expanding its settlements3 US should drop Hamid Karzai

ROUND SIX:1 THW hold the Pope criminally liable for abuses of children performed in his term2 The state should not recongize any religious holidays3 THW disallow parents from indoctrinating their children in any religion

ROUND SEVEN:1 THW allow jurors to question witnesses2 No citizen should be forced to purchase insurance3 There should only be one gender-neutral acting award in the Oscars

Page 24: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN4 2 2

18 5 1312 8 4

15 19

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN19 7 1210 3 75 2 3

12 22

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN16 7 9

The state should subsidize competitors when the current market is monopolized by foreign enterprises 16 10 62 0 2

17 17

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN10 7 316 8 88 3 5

18 16

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN20 9 1111 8 33 0 3

17 17

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN7 3 4

12 6 615 3 12

12 22

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN15 11 49 4 5

10 6 421 13

GOV WIN OPP WINTOTALS: 112 126

Page 25: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

OCTOFINALS:1 THBT the media should fully report on suicides2 THW arm journalists3 THW prosecute whenever possible contributors to websites that reveal confidential government information (ie. wikileaks)

QUARTERFINALS:1 THW not forcibly separate commercial banks from investment banks2 THBT it is in the best interest of economically strong countries to pull out of the Eurozone3 THBT no financial institution is too big to fail

SEMIFINALS:1 THW invest in research that aims to bring the dead back to life2 THBT scientists should be disallowed from creating new forms of life3 THBT what happens in Bora stays in Bora

FINALS :1 THBT states have the right to conscript citizens against their will2 THW subject operators of unmmanned war machines to the same treatment as ordinary comabatants3 THBT peacekeepers should be tried by an international body and not their nation states

Page 26: PIDC 2010 Official Tabs

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN3 2 13 2 1

THW prosecute whenever possible contributors to websites that reveal confidential government information (ie. wikileaks) 2 2 06 2

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN1 0 13 1 20 0 0

1 3

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN2 2 00 0 00 0 0

2 0

x debated GOV WIN OPP WIN0 0 0

THW subject operators of unmmanned war machines to the same treatment as ordinary comabatants 0 0 01 0 1

0 1

GOV WIN OPP WINTOTALS: 9 6