Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert,...

27
Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan: Comparison of Two Coastal Lagoon Systems in Northern Florida Bay, USA Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science, Cambridge, MD, USA and Christopher J. Madden South Florida Water Management District, West Palm Beach, FL, USA

Transcript of Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert,...

Page 1: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the 

Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan: Comparison of Two Coastal Lagoon Systems in Northern 

Florida Bay, USA

Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert,Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko,

University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science, Cambridge, MD, USA

and Christopher J. MaddenSouth Florida Water Management District, West Palm Beach, FL, USA

Page 2: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

2

Page 3: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

3

C‐111

Page 4: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

4

C‐111

Potential problems?

Page 5: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

5

C‐111Water flow => Nutrient regime change => Algal blooms 

Page 6: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Florida Bay is a subtropical coastal lagoon• Shallow, highly enclosed, relatively quiescent, long residence time• High nutrient regeneration rate• Very sensitive to nutrients input

6

Page 7: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Intermittent Closed Open Lakes and Lagoons (ICOLLs) in Northern Florida Bay• Sinks of land‐derived nutrients• Could be very ecologically productive ecosystem (Suzuki et al., 1998; 

Menendez & Comin, 2000)

7

Page 8: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

8

• P‐limited system• Small‐sized phytoplankton are favored

Page 9: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

9

After CERP,• The nitrogen and phosphorus concentrations in northern Florida Bay will increase

• The phytoplankton abundance will increase and community composition will change

Hypothesis

Page 10: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Methods: Site Description

10

Total Dissolved Nitrogen (TDN) (µM)

Total Dissolved Phosphorus(TDP) (µM)

Chlorophyll a(Chl a) (µg/L)

West Lake Chain (WLC) Eutrophic 119.19 0.66 36.94

Seven Palm Lake Chain (SPLC) Less nutrient‐rich 75.58 0.34 1.46

Page 11: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

11

Sampling collection• Apr 2010, Nov 2010, Apr 2011

• May 2013, Apr 2014

Chemical analysis• TND, TDP• Chl a,  HPLC pigments

Data analysis• One‐way ANOVA at p= 0.1

Page 12: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

0

20

40

60

80

100

WLCBefore

WLCAfter

SPLCBefore

SPLCAfter

(µg/L)

Chlorophyll a

***

12

0

50

100

150

200

WLCBefore

WLCAfter

SPLCBefore

SPLCAfter

(µmol/L)

TDN

*

N decreased ,P increased, chlorophyll a declined in WLC while elevated slightly in SPLC

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

WLCBefore

WLCAfter

SPLCBefore

SPLCAfter

(µmol/L)

TDP *

Page 13: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

13

West Lake Chain Seven Palm Lake Chain

0.00.51.01.52.02.5

(µmol/L)

TDP

0.00.51.01.52.02.5

TDP

020406080100

(µg/L)

Chlorophyll a

0.01.02.03.04.05.0

Chlorophyll a

*

0

50

100

150

200

(µmol/L)

TDN

0

50

100

150

200TDN

* *

Page 14: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

14

West Lake Chain Seven Palm Lake Chain

0.00.51.01.52.02.5

(µmol/L)

TDP

0.00.51.01.52.02.5

TDP

020406080100

(µg/L)

Chlorophyll a

0.01.02.03.04.05.0

Chlorophyll a

*

Biomass increased

0

50

100

150

200

(µmol/L)

TDN

0

50

100

150

200TDN

* *

Page 15: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

In steady state• Biomass <= limiting nutrient• Growth rate <= flowFlow will flush cells out when dilution is higher than the maximum growth

15

Chemostat model

Page 16: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

16

West Lake Chain

Seven Palm Lake Chain

Biomass, growth Nutrient, flow

Page 17: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

17

Seven Palm Lake Chain

P P N,P

N,PP P

West Lake Chain Biomass, growth Nutrient, flow

Page 18: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Seven Palm Lake Chain

P N,P

P

West Lake Chain Biomass, growth ent, flow

N,P

Page 19: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Seven Palm Lake Chain

P N,P

PP

West Lake Chain Biomass, growth ent, flow

Page 20: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Seven Palm Lake Chain

P N,P

PP

West Lake Chain Biomass, growth ent, flow

Page 21: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Seven Palm Lake Chain

P N,P

PP

West Lake Chain Biomass, growth ent, flow

Page 22: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

**

Page 23: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Summary

N showed decreasing trend and P showed increasing trend

In the eutrophic WLC downstream, phytoplankton biomass was reduced while the phytoplankton community composition shifted. Phytoplankton cells might be flushed into Central Florida Bay.

In the less‐eutrophic SPLC downstream, phytoplankton biomass was enhanced while the community composition was unchanged. 

Page 24: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

If the flow after CERP is higher than maximum growth, cells in Northern Florida Bay will wash out into central Florida Bay.

If the flow is lower than maximum growth, the phytoplankton biomass in Northern Florida Bay will be determined by the limiting nutrient, P in the system. 

Take Home Message

Page 25: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

Acknowledgement• Field work

– Stefano Accoroni– Michelle Blaha– Stephen Kelly– Joseph Stachelek

• Analytical Service– Erica Kiss– Meg Maddox– Jennifer O’Keefe

Page 26: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,
Page 27: Phytoplankton Response to Changing Nutrients from the ......Yini Shangguan, Patricia M. Glibert, Jeff Alexander, Sue Murasko, University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science,

‐400

‐300

‐200

‐100

0

100

Z‐CU

SUM

Taylor Slough at mouth Water Level

‐200

0

200

400

600

800

Z‐CU

SUM

Seven Palm Lake Salinity