Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3...

8
AbstractThe RENA-3 (R eadout E lectronics for N uclear A pplications) is a 36-channel self-resetting, charge sensitive amplifier/shaper IC with trigger output, wide energy range and sparse readout designed for use with position-sensitive, spectroscopy-grade radiation detectors. It has in recent years been favored to provide the front-end electronics in prototype instruments for various applications – from space physics research through medical imaging to homeland security – that employ CZT or CdTe in the form of planar sensor assemblies or monolithic pixel/strip arrays. We will present a summary of spectroscopic data drawn from the body of RENA-3-based results obtained in our laboratories and by other RENA-3 users. Spectroscopic performance metrics will be discussed relative to the requirements of the specific application targeted in each case as well as from the general standpoint of what may be achievable within this detector-array/RENA-3 approach. A method to automate the test and calibration of RENA-3 ICs will also be described. Index Terms— ASIC, photon counting, radiation detectors, radiation detection, gamma-ray spectroscopy, CZT, CdTe, Si, integrated circuit, IC, RENA-3 I. INTRODUCTION HE RENA-3 (Readout Electronics for Nuclear Applications) is a low-noise, 36-channel self-resetting, charge sensitive amplifier/shaper integrated circuit (IC) designed for use with position-sensitive, spectroscopy-grade radiation detectors [1]. It has in recent years been chosen to provide the front-end electronics in advanced prototype instruments for various applications – from space physics research [2]-[4] through medical imaging [5], [6] to homeland security [7]-[9]. These instruments for the most part employ CZT in the form of planar sensor assemblies or monolithic pixel/strip arrays. Whereas the RENA-3 was developed largely to address the needs of the CZT community, a level of adaptability was designed into this IC to allow its use across a broad range of radiation detectors. Manuscript received November 21, 2008. M. Clajus, S. Hayakawa, T. O. Tumer and Alexander Volkovskii are with NOVA R&D, Inc., Riverside, CA 92507, USA (e-mail: [email protected]). V. B. Cajipe was with NOVA R&D, Inc., Riverside, CA 92507, USA. She is now with the Office of Technology Transfer and Intellectual Property Services, UC San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093, USA. James L. Matteson and R. Thomas Skelton are with Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093, USA The key design features for the RENA-3 IC are listed in Table I. A simplified block diagram for one channel of the IC is given in Fig. 1a and the photographs of the IC wirebonded inside a CQFP package are shown in Fig. 1b. The RENA-3 die size is approximately 6.9 mm × 6.4 mm. Each RENA-3 channel contains a charge-sensitive input amplifier with resistive-multiplier feedback, a differentiator and gain circuit, and two shaping amplifiers (“slow” and “fast”) that operate in parallel. The input amplifier tolerates up to ±5 nA detector leakage current – allowing the inputs to be DC-coupled – and user can individually optimize for 2 or 9 pF detector capacitance. The threshold and the peak detector polarities are externally selectable per channel basis. The amplitude range is 56 ke or 340 ke, corresponding to 250 keV and 1.5 MeV, respectively, in CZT. Since any channel can be operated with either polarity, the RENA-3 can be used with any combination of anodes and cathodes a detector may have. The slow shaper is optimized for accurate pulse height determination, has 16 user-selectable shaping times (15 ranging from 0.29 to 4.5 μs, plus 38 μs, selectable per channel), and is followed by a peak detector and a trigger comparator. A pole-zero cancellation circuit facilitates use of the IC at relatively high count rates (200-500 kCounts/sec) without significant pileup errors. The linearity of the RENA-3 pulse height response is excellent (Fig. 2) and has been measured by others to be better than 0.1% [2]. The fast shaper is optimized for timing accuracy, has a shaping time between 100 and 200 ns, and is followed by its own trigger comparator. The thresholds of both comparators can be adjusted individually for each channel by eight-bit DACs; the DAC range is determined by a pair of externally supplied reference voltages and can thus be optimized for the application at hand. The latched comparator outputs from all 36 channels are wired-or’ed separately for the slow and fast signal paths, and each is made available for event trigger purposes through a low-noise differential output that can be daisy-chained between chips. The relative signal timing between channels can be measured with the help of two user-provided periodic quadrature (sine and cosine) signals whose values are latched into sample/hold circuits when the fast comparator triggers; these “timestamp” values can then be read out through the same differential analog output as the pulse height signals from the peak detectors (see Fig. 3). To minimize power consumption, unused channels can be powered down, as can the fast signal path of any channel that is not already powered down as a whole. When fully powered up, each channel dissipates 5 mW. Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and CdTe Detectors Victoria B. Cajipe, Martin Clajus, Member, IEEE, Satoshi Hayakawa, James L. Matteson, Member, IEEE, R. Thomas Skelton, Tumay O. Tumer, Member, IEEE, and Alexander Volkovskii T 300 978-1-4244-2715-4/08/$25.00 ©2008 IEEE 2008 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record R12-56

Transcript of Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3...

Page 1: Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference

Abstract— The RENA-3 (Readout Electronics for Nuclear

Applications) is a 36-channel self-resetting, charge sensitive amplifier/shaper IC with trigger output, wide energy range and sparse readout designed for use with position-sensitive, spectroscopy-grade radiation detectors. It has in recent years been favored to provide the front-end electronics in prototype instruments for various applications – from space physics research through medical imaging to homeland security – that employ CZT or CdTe in the form of planar sensor assemblies or monolithic pixel/strip arrays. We will present a summary of spectroscopic data drawn from the body of RENA-3-based results obtained in our laboratories and by other RENA-3 users. Spectroscopic performance metrics will be discussed relative to the requirements of the specific application targeted in each case as well as from the general standpoint of what may be achievable within this detector-array/RENA-3 approach. A method to automate the test and calibration of RENA-3 ICs will also be described.

Index Terms— ASIC, photon counting, radiation detectors, radiation detection, gamma-ray spectroscopy, CZT, CdTe, Si, integrated circuit, IC, RENA-3

I. INTRODUCTION HE RENA-3 (Readout Electronics for Nuclear Applications) is a low-noise, 36-channel self-resetting, charge sensitive amplifier/shaper integrated circuit (IC)

designed for use with position-sensitive, spectroscopy-grade radiation detectors [1]. It has in recent years been chosen to provide the front-end electronics in advanced prototype instruments for various applications – from space physics research [2]-[4] through medical imaging [5], [6] to homeland security [7]-[9]. These instruments for the most part employ CZT in the form of planar sensor assemblies or monolithic pixel/strip arrays. Whereas the RENA-3 was developed largely to address the needs of the CZT community, a level of adaptability was designed into this IC to allow its use across a broad range of radiation detectors.

Manuscript received November 21, 2008. M. Clajus, S. Hayakawa, T. O. Tumer and Alexander Volkovskii are with

NOVA R&D, Inc., Riverside, CA 92507, USA (e-mail: [email protected]).

V. B. Cajipe was with NOVA R&D, Inc., Riverside, CA 92507, USA. She is now with the Office of Technology Transfer and Intellectual Property Services, UC San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093, USA.

James L. Matteson and R. Thomas Skelton are with Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093, USA

The key design features for the RENA-3 IC are listed in Table I. A simplified block diagram for one channel of the IC is given in Fig. 1a and the photographs of the IC wirebonded inside a CQFP package are shown in Fig. 1b. The RENA-3 die size is approximately 6.9 mm × 6.4 mm.

Each RENA-3 channel contains a charge-sensitive input amplifier with resistive-multiplier feedback, a differentiator and gain circuit, and two shaping amplifiers (“slow” and “fast”) that operate in parallel. The input amplifier tolerates up to ±5 nA detector leakage current – allowing the inputs to be DC-coupled – and user can individually optimize for 2 or 9 pF detector capacitance. The threshold and the peak detector polarities are externally selectable per channel basis. The amplitude range is 56 ke or 340 ke, corresponding to 250 keV and 1.5 MeV, respectively, in CZT. Since any channel can be operated with either polarity, the RENA-3 can be used with any combination of anodes and cathodes a detector may have. The slow shaper is optimized for accurate pulse height determination, has 16 user-selectable shaping times (15 ranging from 0.29 to 4.5 µs, plus 38 µs, selectable per channel), and is followed by a peak detector and a trigger comparator. A pole-zero cancellation circuit facilitates use of the IC at relatively high count rates (200-500 kCounts/sec) without significant pileup errors. The linearity of the RENA-3 pulse height response is excellent (Fig. 2) and has been measured by others to be better than 0.1% [2]. The fast shaper is optimized for timing accuracy, has a shaping time between 100 and 200 ns, and is followed by its own trigger comparator.

The thresholds of both comparators can be adjusted individually for each channel by eight-bit DACs; the DAC range is determined by a pair of externally supplied reference voltages and can thus be optimized for the application at hand. The latched comparator outputs from all 36 channels are wired-or’ed separately for the slow and fast signal paths, and each is made available for event trigger purposes through a low-noise differential output that can be daisy-chained between chips.

The relative signal timing between channels can be measured with the help of two user-provided periodic quadrature (sine and cosine) signals whose values are latched into sample/hold circuits when the fast comparator triggers; these “timestamp” values can then be read out through the same differential analog output as the pulse height signals from the peak detectors (see Fig. 3).

To minimize power consumption, unused channels can be powered down, as can the fast signal path of any channel that is not already powered down as a whole. When fully powered up, each channel dissipates 5 mW.

Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position-Sensitive CZT and CdTe Detectors

Victoria B. Cajipe, Martin Clajus, Member, IEEE, Satoshi Hayakawa, James L. Matteson, Member, IEEE, R. Thomas Skelton, Tumay O. Tumer, Member, IEEE, and Alexander Volkovskii

T

300978-1-4244-2715-4/08/$25.00 ©2008 IEEE

2008 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record R12-56

Page 2: Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference

Table 1. Key design features of the RENA-3 ASIC.

Features RENA-3 IC Specifications Signal ranges Two ranges; 56 & 338 ke, externally selectable for

each channel, (9fC/256keV & 54fC/1.5Mev for CZT) Self-trigger out User selectable comparator threshold for self-trig. out Input polarity Positive or negative, selectable channel-by-channel Number of chan 36 (2 with test points for characterization) Noise ≤ 150 e RMS & ≤ 280 e rms for low & high ranges, res Noise optimization

Preamp optimized for 2 pF and 9 pF detector capacitance, externally selectable

DC leakage cur. Tolerant to ≤ 5nA per channel Power consumption

≤ 6mW per channel with all features (reduction possible by powering down certain features)

Fast timing output

≤ 30ns (for timing/coincidence measurements @ peaking time 0.29 µs)

Channel-to-chan time diff.

Implemented to enable determination of time diff. between ≥ 2 coincident pulses for ≤ 5 ns accuracy

Bias current Adjustable through power supply current into input trans

Trigger compar. thresholds

Individually adjustable by internal 8 Bit DACs for each channel

Peaking/shaping 0.29µs to 38µs in 16 steps High count rates Using pole zero cancellation, capable of >200,000 cps

per chip (external ADC will determine actual rate) Key gamma sig. 14, 60, 141, 511, 662, 1,330 and up to 1,500 keV System components

Pipeline A/D converter, FPGA state machine controller, data FIFO

Interface Min. pin count. Up to 8 ICs can be daisy-chained. Readout mode Max. flexibility through programmable hit register Deadtime per event

<5 µs for digital interface. Overall dead time depends on the external ADC used.

Fig. 1a. Simplified RENA-3 channel block diagram.

Fig. 1b. RENA-3 IC wire bonded in a 144-pin CQFP package

Readout of the RENA-3 is controlled by a token register. The register bits are initially set according to the channels’ trigger outputs (default sparse readout) but can be overwritten to allow for a generalized nearest-neighbor readout with maximum flexibility for different detector geometries. For test and debugging purposes, RENA-3 has a test signal input that can be AC-coupled to any combination of channels under user control, and the slow shaper output from any channel can be selected for observation on the analog output bus when data acquisition is not in progress. Additionally, signals from various points along the signal paths of the first and last channel are made available on a total of 21 dedicated, buffered test pads.

Fig. 2. Plot of measured ADC values for 4 fC to 36 fC input signals from the RENA-3 system on-board test pulse generator; using the CZT value of 4.5 eV per electron-hole pair for charge to photon energy conversion, this corresponds approximately to 110 keV and 1 MeV energies. The data were fit to a straight line, the (arbitrary) y-axis offset subtracted and the differences between measured ADC values and corresponding fit results calculated. The deviation is <1% for most data points and is about 1.25% at the extrema. Others have done more detailed and numerous linearity measurements and consistently determined linearity to be better than 1% [2].

Fig. 3. (Left) Scatter plot of the VU and VV 1MHz sine/cosine

waveforms used in RENA-3 to produce the timing signal. The RENA-3 timestamp circuit enables a triggering event to record an analog time value encoded by VU and VV. When a fast trigger event occurs, the sample-and-hold circuit located in the timestamp block opens to capture the analog value currently present on those two input lines. When the result is read out, the relative time of the event to other events may be determined since VU and VV go to all channels in the array. (Right) Example timing resolution plot for two RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference signal. In this example, a 5nsec resolution is observed.

In this paper we present a summary of spectroscopic data drawn from the body of RENA-3-based results obtained in our laboratory and by other RENA-3 users. Performance metrics will be discussed relative to the requirements of the specific application targeted in each case as well as from the general standpoint of what may be achievable within this detector-array/RENA-3 approach.

301

Page 3: Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference

II. RENA-3 IN RECENT LITERATURE The two-electrode readout, energy and timing resolution

capabilities of the RENA-3 make it an enabling technology for applications that require three-dimensional (3D) position-sensitive detection. As such, the IC has been used by several groups to develop instruments that implement 3D readout techniques. J. Matteson et al. at UCSD are building a prototype of their CZT Time Projection Detector concept that is comprised of four 1 cm3 eV PRODUCTS CZT detectors each with 1.25 mm2 pitch pixels [2]. Their performance goals of <1 mm 3D spatial, <10 nsec time and <1% at 662 keV energy resolution are typical of CZT-based 3D gamma-ray imaging methods targeting space physics and nuclear monitoring applications. In their preliminary work with RENA-3, they measured a 7nsec FWHM coincidence time resolution between channels using 500keV equivalent test pulses and 15 ns FWHM between two planar 12x12x2 mm3 CZT detectors [2]. They also observed a 1% FWHM 662 keV resolution upon acquiring 137Cs gamma-ray spectra with simultaneous anode and cathode readout using a 20x20x5 mm3 Redlen monolithic CZT pixel array with 2.46x2.46 mm2 pixel pitch [10].

Q. Li et al. used the RENA-3 and cathode-to-anode-ratio depth-sensing correction to obtain 3.2% from a non-corrected 6.1% FWHM at 662 keV in an 8x8 pixel array that they fabricated from a 20x20x5 mm3 Orbotech CZT crystal; they also got 1.6%FWHM at 662 keV with a 15x15 pixel array likewise fashioned out of 20x20x5 mm3 Orbotech material [4].

On the other hand, W. Li et al. reported energy resolution of ~1% FWHM at 662 keV with depth sensing for 8x8 pixel arrays fabricated from 10x10x10mm3 Redlen and Yinnel CZT and read out with RENA-3 [8]. They determined the electronic noise contribution to be 4 keV FWHM and that the RENA-3 response drift introduces a global gain drift less than 0.5% for 3D CZT detectors operated between –5 to 45 °C which will not cause any significant energy resolution degradation. Robust performance under varying thermal conditions is important for homeland security type applications. With the same 10x10x10 mm3 Yinnel CZT pixel array read out by RENA-3, Y. Du et al. developed a 4π direction-sensitive gamma imager with 0.05-0.07 steradian FWHM angular resolution [7]. They moreover measured timing resolution between channels to be 10 ns within the same IC and 30 ns between different ICs.

A similar result, 15.5 ns FWHM, was achieved by P. Olcott et al. with two position-sensitive APDs read out by RENA-3, without any correction for pulse-height dependent time walk [6].

III. NEW TEST RESULTS In this section, we describe results that in effect extend the

applicability of the RENA-3 to other detector types and thus to a broader community of instrument developers and wider range of spectroscopic uses.

Single CZT Detectors with Frisch Collar

Single-element CZT detectors equipped with Frisch collars have been developed by the group of D.S. McGregor at Kansas State University (KSU) [11], [12]. The group recently

presented new methods designed for the commercial scale production of detectors of this type. Frisch collar detectors have reached an energy resolution as low as 1.3% FWHM at 662 keV, or 1.15% with very moderate cooling [12], without the need for correcting the data for the depth of interaction (DOI) of the photons in the detector. This allows for simpler electronics and data processing – desirable in most commercial applications - compared to monolithic pixel detectors, for which somewhat better energy resolution has been achieved with the help of DOI corrections (e.g., references [2], [4], [7], [8], [13]).

Exploratory spectroscopy measurements using KSU Frisch collar CZT detectors read out with a standard RENA-3 evaluation system were performed jointly by KSU and NOVA. The spectral results for tests using 22Na, 137Cs and 60Co sources with 3×3×5 mm3 and 6×6×7 mm3 Frisch collar CZT detectors are shown in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5, respectively. The data clearly show that the RENA-3 higher amplitude range stretches out to 1.5 MeV. This is important relative to nuclear monitoring (e.g., weapons grade uranium is 7% 238U which produces a 1.001 keV gamma ray). Fig. 4 (bottom panel) shows a 137Cs spectrum from one of the preliminary measurements. The energy resolution at 662 keV obtained in the particular example of the 3×3×5 mm3 detector is 2.6% FWHM, which leaves room for improvement. It should be

Fig. 4. Spectra acquired with a 3×3×5 mm3 Frisch collar CZT detector

read out by a RENA-3 IC. (Top) 22Na and (middle) 60Co (blue) spectra showing using the same scale the 511 keV plus 1.275 MeV and 1.173 MeV and 1.333 MeV peaks, respectively. (Bottom). The energy resolution of the 137Cs spectrum is 2.6% FWHM at 662 keV.

302

Page 4: Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference

noted that the RENA-3 system board layout was not optimized for use with these detectors and that the detector connection and experimental conditions during these tests were not optimal either.

Fig. 5. (Top) 22Na, (middle) 137Cs and (bottom) 60Co spectra acquired with

a 6×6×7 mm3 Frisch collar CZT detector read out by a RENA-3 IC showing the 511 keV, 662 keV, 1.173 MeV, 1.275 MeV and 1.333 MeV gamma ray peaks.

Planar CdTe Detectors

Strategies to minimize polarization effects in CdTe have led to the use of this detector material in nuclear medicine instrument development efforts [14,15]. Indeed, very recently, literature has appeared reporting positively on performance investigations of prototype brain and small-animal PET scanners using CdTe [16, 17]. This growing interest motivated us to study 10x10 mm2 planar CdTe detectors of different thicknesses from Acrorad on the RENA-3 evaluation system.

The CdTe detectors, depicted in the photograph of Fig. 6, are similar to those used in stacked configurations in references [14] and [16]. We studied several of these planar CdTe detectors as single units. Spectral results obtained with 57Co, 241Am, 137Cs, 22Na and 60Co sources are displayed for the case of a 10x10x1.0 mm3 CdTe detector in Fig. 7 and Fig. 8. A 5.38% FWHM resolution at 122keV and 2.6% FWHM at 662 keV were observed. The 511 keV, 1.173 MeV,

1.275 MeV and 1.333 MeV gamma ray peaks were also easily observed (Fig. 8).

Monolithic 8x8 Pixel CZT Array Redlen Technologies fabricates a monolithic 8x8 pixel

array from 20x20x5 mm3 CZT material as a standard product. This detector design is similar to ~2.5mm2 pixel pitch CZT pixel arrays used in the recently commercialized SpeCZT pre-clinical SPECT system from GE Healthcare [18] and the D-SPECT cardiac imager from Spectrum Dynamics [19]. A special board for this Redlen 8x8 pixel array was developed to facilitate its evaluation on the RENA-3 system.

Example spectral data acquired simultaneously from all 64 pixels with a Co-57 source are shown in Fig. 9. The average FWHM @ the 122keV peak is 5.7% with resolution down to 4% observed in some cases. This superior energy resolution is one of the several known advantages presented by the CZT/readout IC approach to SPECT. With CZT giving typically better than 6% FWHM at 140keV – compared to 10% for NaI(Tl) - simultaneous use of multiple isotopes becomes possible.

Fig. 6. A photograph of Acrorad 10x10 mm2 planar CdTe detectors. These

detectors are available in thicknesses of 0.5, 0.75 and 1mm.

Fig. 7. (Top) Co57 and (bottom) Am241 spectra recorded with Acrorad

planar 10x10x1.0 mm3 CdTe detector. The energy resolution is 5.38% FWHM at 122 keV.

303

Page 5: Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference

Fig. 8. (Top) 137Cs, (middle) 22Na and (bottom) 60Co spectra obtained from

an Acrorad planar 10x10x1.0 mm3 CdTe detector. The figures show the 662 keV, 511 keV, 1.173 MeV, 1.275 MeV and 1.333 MeV gamma ray peaks.

Fig. 9. (Top) Panel of 64 plots of Co-57 spectra acquired simultaneously

from a standard Redlen 8x8 pixel array on 20x20x5 mm3 CZT using the RENA-3 detector system. (Bottom, left to right) FWHM (%) at 122keV versus pixel number, 57Co spectrum for one pixel showing 4% FWHM at 122 keV and photograph of standard Redlen 8x8 pixel array.

Large CZT Detectors with 3-D Localization

Stanford University and the University of California, San Diego are developing the CZT Small Animal PET System for high resolution imaging with 1 mm resolution and 2 - 3% energy resolution. [20], [21] It uses 96 large-volume CZT detectors from Orbotech Medical Solutions that measure 40 x 40 x 5 mm3. Detectors are read out with crossed-strip electrodes on 1 mm pitch for the anodes and 5 mm for the cathodes, which localized interactions to a 1 x 5 mm2 pixel. Localization in the third dimension with sub-mm resolution is obtained with the drift time and cathode-to-anode ratio techniques. Thus, interactions are localized to 1 x 1 x 5 mm3 voxels. A steering electrode between the anodes improves charge collection and energy resolution. Flex circuits connect the detectors to the RENA-3 readout system (192 chips) that is outside the detectors. This technique allows very closely packed detectors that are separated by only ~0.15 mm, which is important for efficiency PET systems. However, the length of the signal traces to the RENA-3 chips is ~15 cm, which increases capacitance and noise, and degrades energy resolution. Three detectors are shown in Fig. 10, where the electrodes are visible.

Fig. 10. Three 40 x 40 x 5 mm3 CZT detectors of the CZT Small Animal

PET System. Anodes and cathodes of the crossed-strip electrode design are visible.

Fig. 11 shows an anode versus cathode scatter plot of data taken with 662 keV gamma-rays in a test setup with ~25 cm traces. The tight ensemble of points is due to 662 keV interactions, and its narrow width and flat slope indicate good energy resolution and uniform charge collection at the anode. The downward curvature at the left end of the ensemble is due to reduced anode signal caused by trapped holes from interactions within ~0.5 mm of the anodes. Since this effect has a clear signature in the scatter plot, the ratio of cathode-to-anode signals can be used to parameterize a function that corrects for the signal reduction due to trapped holes. Such a correction can recover good energy resolution over nearly the entire detector thickness.

Energy spectra may be obtained by projecting scatter plot points onto the anode axis (y-axis). The spectrum for all events is shown in Fig. 12 (top panel), where the resolution is 2.8% and the peak-to-valley ratio is 10:1. Fig. 12 (bottom

304

Page 6: Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference

panel) shows the spectrum for events with the ratio of cathode-to-anode signals between 0.70 and 0.95. (These ratios are indicated by the white lines in Fig. 11.) The energy resolution is 2.1% and the peak-to-valley ratio has the extraordinary value of 50:1, which indicates very uniform charge collection without spurious effects that might reduce the amplitude of a small percentage of the 662 keV events.

Fig. 11. Anode versus cathode scatter plot for Cs-137 gamma-rays (662 keV). 40 x 40 x 5 mm3 CZT detector with crossed-strip readout. 40 x 40 x 5 mm3 Orbotech CZT detector of the CZT Small Animal PET System.

Fig. 12. Spectra of Cs-137 gamma-rays (662 keV). Anode signals of Fig. 11. Upper panel: all events: 2.8% FWHM, 10:1 peak-to-valley ratio. Lower panel: events with cathode-to-anode ratio between 0.70 and 0.95. 2.1% FWHM, 50:1 peak-to-valley ratio.

Si PIN Detector with a JFET Front End

When used with a typical CZT detector optimally connected to it, the RENA-3 exhibits a noise threshold of about 8-10 keV, which is sufficient for applications that need to detect and resolve the 14 keV spectral line of 57Co. To reduce the noise threshold, a plausible approach would be to use a low-noise JFET preamplifier between the detector output and the RENA-3 input. A feasibility study was thus undertaken to determine the experimental conditions under which the noise floor can be reduced with the use of a Si PIN/JFET/RENA-3 arrangement and x-ray spectra acquired down to 5keV. For this, a JFET preamplifier was designed based on N-channel JFET devices from Vishay (SST5484). The preamplifier was used in conjunction with a 7x7mm2 Si-PIN detector supplied by Dr. Cao Xuelei’s group at the Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Science. The performance of RENA-3 IC with the external JFET preamplifier was characterized by recording low-energy spectra from 55Fe, 241Am and 57Co sources.

The spectral plots are shown in Fig. 10. For each plot about 50,000 counts were collected. The energy was calibrated by using the characteristic peaks of the various sources with linear fit. The spectra show that the 7x7mm2 Si-PIN detector when used with a JFET preamplifier and the RENA-3 can provide a signal-to-noise ratio large enough to move the noise threshold down to about 5keV. In the tests the 5.9 keV line from 55Fe and the 6.4 keV line from 57Co spectra could be resolved. Amplifier also improved the energy resolution such that features of the 241Am spectrum near 20 keV became distinguishable.

Fig. 13. (Left), top to bottom) Am241, Co57, and Fe55 spectra acquired

using the Si PIN/JFET/RENA-3 arrangement described in the test. (Right) Zoomed-in views of the various spectra below 30keV.

Linearity Measurements

Simultaneous RENA-3 linearity measurements are presented in Fig.14. Each panel shows the response of the indicated RENA-3 channel to charge pulses from the internal pulser. Four sets of data were taken: highest and lowest gains, each in positive and negative polarity. Average PHA values are indicated red and blue squares and diamonds; the lines are fits, linear for positive polarity, quadratic for negative polarity. Detailed analysis of the data from which this figure was prepared show that the RENA-3 is linear in positive polarity to better than 0.1%. and, in negative polarity to ~1%. Hence, a small quadratic correction may be desirable for negative

305

Page 7: Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference

polarity in some applications. The highest gain is achieved by selecting the smaller FET feedback capacitor along with the highest shaper gain and conversely for the lowest gain.

Fig. 14. Linearity measurement of all 36 channels of the RENA-3

simultaneously. The purple and green symbols represent FWHM's. Note the differing abscissa scales for lowest and highest gain.

Gain and Offset Measurements

Fig. 15 shows the gains and offsets as a function of channel, as determined from the data of Fig. 14. Noting the instructions on the plot, it is seen that the ratio of highest to lowest gains varies from 6.8 to 8.3, somewhat greater than the design value of 6. The slightly higher gain for channel 0 and slightly lower for channel 35 is typical.

Fig. 15. Plots of gain and offset as a function of RENA channel number.

The symbols and colors have the same meanings as on the previous figure.

Simultaneous Timing of all Channels

Fig. 16 shows simultaneous fine timing of all 36 channels of REna-3. The terms VU and VV refer to the sampled PHA of the 1.0 MHz cosine and sine waves respectively. The circles indicate that the fast trigger and sample-and-hold circuits are working properly. The irregular patterns for channels 34 and 35 result from interference of the fine-timing oscillator with the inputs due to the circuit layout on the RENA-3 test system.

Fig. 16. Simultaneous fine timing of all 36 channels of RENA-3.

IV. SUMMARY We have presented extensive tests carried out in testing

RENA-3 IC by itself using the test pulse input and also with many different detectors. We also show the versatility of the RENA-3 integrated circuit, which can be used for many different applications without modification. The results show that RENA-3 can be used with a variety of different solid state detectors and can be optimized for specific applications. RENA-3 Evaluation System includes a daughter board which can be customized for different applications and testing. The RENA-3 Evaluation System test results are showing that it is meeting specifications.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The RENA-3 development work was supported in part by OTTC-CCAT grants GT30420 and GT60615 administered by the OTTC of CSUSB. This work was supported at UCSD by California Breast Cancer Research Program Grant 12IB-0092, NIH Grant R01 CA120474, and U.S. Department of Homeland Security/DNDO Contract NBCHC06002 and Grant HSHQDC-07-C-00090. We acknowledge contributions to this work through detector use and information sharing from Prof. D.S. McGregor at Kansas State University (KSU); Glenn Bindley and Henry Chen at Redlen Technologies; Cao Xuelei at the Institute of High Energy Physics (IHEP), Chinese Academy of Science; and Ryoichi Ohno and Wataru Inui Acrorad. We also acknowledge D. Ward and G. Visser for their contributions to the RENA-3 design and development. We acknowledge C. Levin and Y. Gu of Stanford University, and A. Deal, E. Stephan, F. Duttweiler, G. Huszar, and T. Gasaway of the University of California, San Diego for their contributions to the CZT Small Animal PET System.

REFERENCES [1] T.O. Tümer, V.B. Cajipe, M. Clajus, S. Hayakawa, and A. Volkovskii,

“Multi-channel front-end readout IC for position sensitive solid-state detectors,” 2006 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, Vol. 1, p. 384.

[2] J. L. Matteson, R. T. Skelton, M. R. Pelling, S. Suchy, V. B. Cajipe, M. Clajus, S. Hayakawa, and T. O. Tümer, "CZT Detectors Read Out with the RENA-2 ASIC", Paper N10-6, Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, IEEE, 23-29 Oct. 2005.

[3] R. E. Rothschild, J. L. Matteson, M. R. Pelling, R. T. Skelton, S. Suchy, T. Gasaway, F. Duttweiler, P. Leblanc, T. Tumer, V. Cajipe, M. Clajus “HEXIS Module Performance with RENA-3 ASIC Readout” to be presented at the IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium/ RTSD 2008.

[4] Q. Li, A. Garson, I. Jung, M. Groza, P. Dowkontt, R. Bose, G. Simburger, A. Burger and H. Krawczynski, "Test of CZT detectors with

306

Page 8: Performance of the RENA-3 IC with Position- Sensitive CZT and … · 2017. 2. 23. · RENA-3 channels obtained for a 20fC test pulse input and 1V, 1MHz quadrature timing reference

different pixel pitches and thicknesses", 2007 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, Vol. 3, p. 2381.

[5] C.S. Levin, A.M.K. Foudraya and F. Habtea, “Impact of high energy resolution detectors on the performance of a PET system dedicated to breast cancer imaging,” Physica Medica, Volume 21, Supplement 1, 2006, Pages 28-34.

[6] P.D. Olcott, F.W.Y. Lau, and C.S. Levin, "Data acquisition system design for a 1 mm3 resolution PSAPD-based PET system", 2007 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, Vol. 5, p. 3206.

[7] Y. Du, W. Li, B. Yanoff, J. Gordon, and D. Castleberry, "4 pi direction sensitive gamma imager with RENA-3 readout ASIC", Proc. SPIE 6706, 67060V (2007).

[8] W. Li, Y. Du, B. D. Yanoff, J. S. Gordon, “Impact of Temperature Variation on the Energy Resolution of a 3D Position Sensitive CZT Gamma-Ray Spectrometer” IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium, Honolulu, HI, Oct. 26-Nov. 3, 2007, Conference Record, Vol. 3, 1809-1815 (2007).

[9] G. Cardoso, J. L. Matteson, M. A. Capote, G. J. Batinica, E. Stephan, F. Duttweiler, T. Skelton, T. Gasaway, R. E. Rothschild, G. Huszar, M. R. Pelling, “Second Generation Directional Gamma Radiation Spectrometer,” presented at the IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium, Honolulu, HI, Oct. 26-Nov. 3, 2007.

[10] J. Matteson, private communication. [11] W.J. McNeil, D.S. McGregor, A.E. Bolotnikov, G.W. Wright, and R.B.

James, "Single-charge-carrier-type sensing with an insulated Frisch ring CdZnTe semiconductor radiation detector", Appl. Phys. Lett. 84, 1988 (2004).

[12] A. Kargar, A.M. Jones, W.J. McNeil, M.J. Harrison, and D.S. McGregor, "CdZnTe Frisch collar detectors for γ-ray spectroscopy", Nucl. Instrum. and Meth. A 558, 497 (2006).

[13] G. De Geronimo, E. Vernon, K. Ackley, A. Dragone, J. Fried, P. O’Connor, Z. He, C. Herman, and F. Zhang, "Readout ASIC for 3D position-sensitive detectors", 2007 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, Vol. 1, p. 32.

[14] T. Seino and I. Takahashi, "CdTe detector characteristics around 30C when using the periodic bias reset technique", 2006 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, Vol. , p. 3687.

[15] a) K. Yokoi, Y. Morimoto, H. Kitaguchi, K. Tsuchiya, T. Kawaguchi, and K. Amemiya, "Development of a large FOV semiconductor gamma camera with finely pixelated CdTe detectors", J. Nucl. Med. 53rd Annual Meeting (San Diego, USA, 2006) Scientific Abstracts, p. 54, 2006. b) Y. Ueno, H. Kitaguchi, Y. Morimoto, T. Seino, K. Tsuchiya, N. Yanagita, S. Kojima and K. Amemiya, "Development of a PET scanner using semiconductor detectors", J. Nucl. Med. 53rd Annual Meeting (San Diego, USA, 2006) Scientific Abstracts, p. 185, 2006.

[16] Y. Morimoto, Y. Ueno, K. Tsuchiya, S. Kojima, T. Ishitsu, I. Takahashi, W. Takeuchi, K. Amemiya, T. Shiga and N. Tamaki, "Performance of a prototype brain PET scanner based on semiconductor detectors", J Nucl Med. 2008; 49 (Supplement 1):122P.

[17] T. Naoaki, A. Daizo, T. Akihiko, Y. Takashi, Y. Manabu, Y. Takashi, I. Keizo, Y. Hiromichi, K. Youhei and F. Yoshihito, "Performance evaluation of an ultra high spatial resolution small animal PET scanner using CdTe semiconductor detectors," J Nucl Med. 2008; 49 (Supplement 1):403P.

[18] J. Hugg, F. Jansen, J. Uribe, R. Manjeshwar, H. Lai, J. Pang, X. Guo, "A Small-Animal SPECT / CT System with a Stationary CZT Detector Ring and Rotating Multiple Slit or Pinhole Collimator", presented at presented at the IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium / Medical Imaging Conference, San Diego, CA, Oct. 29 – Nov. 4, 2006. Also see http://www.gehealthcare.com/usen/ fun_img/pcimaging/products/explr_speczt.html

[19] B. Hutton, K. Erlandsson, K. Kacperski, D. Van Gramberg and N. Roth, "Performance evaluation of D-SPECT – A novel dedicated cardiac SPECT scanner", J Nucl Med. 2008; 49 (Supplement 1):124P. Also see: Spectrum Dynamics “D-SPECT™ Cardiac Imaging System” product page at http://www.spectrum-dynamics.com/products/d-spect.html; and, S.S. Ganbhir, “A new Rapid Acquisition Solid State Imaging System for Cardiac SPECT Imaging” presented at the Nuclear Medicine Ground Rounds, September, 2007, found online at http://nuclearmedicine.stanford.edu/ education/grand_rounds/07-08/070904.pdf

[20] Y. Gu, J.L. Matteson, R.T. Skelton, A.C. Deal, E.A. Stephan, F. Duttweiler, T.M. Gasaway, and C.S. Levin, "Study of a High Resolution, 3-D Positioning Cross-Strip Cadmium Zinc Telluride Detector for PET", Paper M02-7, in this proceedings, 2008.

[21] J.L. Matteson, A.C. Deal, Y. Gu, R.T. Skelton, E.A. Stephan, F. Duttweiler, G.L. Huszar, T.M. Gasaway, and C.S. Levin, "Charge Collection Studies of a High Resolution CZT-Based Detector for PET", Paper R17-8, in this proceedings, 2008.

307