PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19....

36
A PACE Market Overview New Jersey PACE Summit June 12, 2015

Transcript of PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19....

Page 1: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

               A  

PACE  Market  Overview  New  Jersey  PACE  Summit  June  12,  2015  

   

Page 2: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACENOW  

More  is  be;er  ü  501(c)3  Not-­‐for-­‐Profit  ü  FoundaFon  Funded  

•  Rockefeller  Brothers  Fund  •  Kresge  FoundaFon  •  Tilia  Fund  •  Energy  FoundaFon  

ü  InformaFon,  Resources,  Advice,  Networking,  Problem  Solving  

•  www.PACENow.org  

2

Represen7ng  PACENa7on  

Page 3: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACE  IN  90  SECONDS  VIDEO  

3

Page 4: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHAT  MAKES  A  PACE  DEAL?  

4

 A  Building  Owner  

Page 5: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHAT  MAKES  A  PACE  DEAL?  

5

 A  Project….  And  a  Contractor  

Page 6: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHAT  MAKES  A  PACE  DEAL?  

6

 Someone  to  Fund  the  Project  

Page 7: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHAT  MAKES  A  PACE  DEAL?  

7

Local  Government  to  “Service”  the  Financing  

Page 8: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHAT  MAKES  A  PACE  DEAL?  

8

Building  Owner  Repays  with  an  Assessment  

Page 9: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHAT  MAKES  A  PACE  DEAL?  

9

Assessment  Repays  Project  Funder  

Page 10: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

OLD  CONCEPT  –  NEW  APPLICATION  

10

1736  –  First  Assessment  District    in  Philadelphia  

 Today  –  37,000  Assessment  Districts  naFonwide  ü  Water  &  Sewer  Service  ü  Parks  ü  Sidewalks  ü  LighFng  ü  Downtown  renewal  ü  Energy  Efficiency  (PACE)    

Local  Government  Financing  –  Public  Purpose  Goal  

Page 11: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHO  CAN  USE  PACE?  

Almost  Any  Building  

11

Page 12: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHAT  FOR?  

12

Projects  that  Save  or  Generate  Energy  

Page 13: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHY  PACE?    Long-­‐Term  Payback  

13

Page 14: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHY  PACE?    Makes  Long  Payback  Projects  Work    

14

The   secure   nature   of   PACE   enables   up   to   20-­‐yr   funding:   projects   with   simple  paybacks  as  long  as  12  years  can  be  implemented  on  a  posiFve  cash  flow  basis  

ü  Increases  NOI  ü  Increases  Property  Value  

Page 15: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHY  PACE?    PACE  Transfers  on  Sale  

15

No  payoff  on  sale  –  PACE  automaFcally  transfers  to  the  new  owner,  like  any  other  real  estate  tax  

ü  No  residual  encumbrance  and  easy  exit.  ü  Takes  the  risk  away  from  invesFng  in  needed  CAPEX.  

Page 16: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

WHY  PACE?  

16

Share  Benefits  and  Costs  with  Tenants    

The  real  estate  tax  assessment  can  be  passed  on  to  tenants  under  most  lease  forms  

ü  Eliminates  the  landlord/tenant  split  incenFve  for  triple  net,    modified  gross  leases,  and  industrial  modified  gross  leases.  

Page 17: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

SIMON  PROPERTY  GROUP  –  GREAT  LAKES  MALL,  OH  

“We  hope  to  serve  as  pioneers  in  this  arena,  encouraging  others  to  explore  the  many  ways  to  reduce  energy  use  now,  rather  than  delaying  sound  financial  and  environmental  decisions.”        George  Caraghiaur,  former  SVP  for  Sustainability  at  Simon  Property  Group  

 

17

$3.4  mil  Energy  Efficiency  –  Mul7  Project  

Page 18: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PROLOGIS,  INC.  HEADQUARTERS  –  SAN  FRANCISCO,  CA  

“Prologis  is  parFcipaFng  in  the  PACE  program  in  order  to  promote  new,  innovaFve  soluFons  for  financing  sustainable  building  improvements.  It  provides  the  flexibility  to  drive  more  energy  improvement  programs  and  that’s  something  everyone  should  embrace.”          Jack  Rizzo,  Managing    Director,  Global  Construc7on  and    Renewable  Energy,  Prologis  

18

$1.4  mil  Energy  &  Solar  Upgrade  –  Mul7  Project  

Page 19: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

SOLAR & EE UPGRADE IN MIDDLETOWN, CT

Harmord  West  Harmord  

Bridgeport  Norwalk  Simsbury  Stamford  Stramord  

Southbury      

Project §  the installation of air units, variable

frequency drives, high efficiency lights, occupancy sensors, air leakage improvements, an upgraded energy management system,

§  and a 260 kW ground-mounted solar photovoltaic system.

Financial Impact ▪  Energy savings of $224k annually

Impact ▪  51M kBTUs saved

▪  8.5M kWh clean energy produced

$2.5  mil  Energy  &  Solar  Upgrade  –  Mul7  Project  

19  

Page 20: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACENATION    

20

Page 21: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACE  IN  2007  

21  

Page 22: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACE  TAKES  OFF  

22  

29  states  and  DC    -­‐  80%  of  US  popula7on  

PACE  amendment    

2009  

2009  

2009  

2013  

2009  

2009  

2009  

2009  

2009  

2009  

2015  2008   2013  2013  

2013  

2011  

2010  

2010  

2010  

2010  

2010  

2010  

2012  

2010  2009  

HI  ExisFng  Authority  

2015  /  2016    legislaFve  iniFaFves      

2013  

22

2014  

2015  

2016  2016  

2016  

2016  

2015  

2016  

2015  

PACE  enabled  

Page 23: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

RESIDENTIAL  

Page 24: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

Early  stage  PACE  program  development  

PACE  programs  with  funded  projects  

RESIDENTIAL  PACE  TODAY  

24  

   

 PACE  enabled  

40,000+  Homes  -­‐  $750+  million  –  10,000+  Jobs  

24

Page 25: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

RESURGENCE  IN  RESIDENTIAL  

ü  SCEIP,  HERO,  CaliforniaFIRST,  Ygrene,  Alliance  NRG    •  San  Francisco,  San  Diego,  Los  Angeles,  Sacramento,  Placer  

ü  Strong  PoliFcal  Leadership  ü  California  (CAEATFA)  reserve  

•  Municipal  opt-­‐in  insures  mortgage  lenders  

ü  HERO  Program  securiFzes  $470+  million  •  Deutsche  Bank  underwrites  3  deals,  AA  raFng,  -­‐  4.00%  

ü  FHFA  conFnues  to  voice  disapproval    

25

California  Leads  Residen7al  Renaissance  

Page 26: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

COMMERCIAL  

Page 27: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

Early  stage  PACE  program  development  

PACE  programs  with  funded  projects  

JUNE  2010  

27  

   

 PACE  enabled  

27  Projects  completed  -­‐  $5  mil  

27

Page 28: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACE  programs  with  funded  projects  

PACE  PROGRAMS  TODAY  330+  Projects  -­‐  $112+  mil  -­‐  Pipeline  $300+  mil  -­‐  1,620  Jobs    

Early  stage  PACE  program  development  Launched  PACE  programs  

 PACE  enabled  

28

Page 29: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACE  COMMERCIAL  MARKET  STATS    Cumula7ve  Financing  

29

Page 30: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACE  COMMERCIAL  MARKET  STATS    Broad  Applicability  

30

Page 31: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACE  COMMERCIAL  MARKET  STATS    Broad  Applicability  

31

Page 32: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACE  COMMERCIAL  MARKET  STATS    Broad  Applicability  

32

Page 33: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PROGRAM  ADMINISTRATION  

   

   

     

   

   

ü  PACE  Plamorm  –  Municipality  as  “Loan  Servicer”  

ü  Sole  municipality  •  Edina  (MN),    San  Francisco  (CA),    Ann  Arbor  (MI),  

Sacramento  (CA)  

ü  MulFple  municipaliFes  –  ConsorFums  •  California        (California  First,  FigTree,  LA  County)  

•  Florida                  (Florida  Green  Energy  Works,  Ygrene)  

•  Michigan          (MI  Lean  &  Green)  

•  New  York        (Energize  New  York)  

ü  Statewide  –  Uniformity  and  Scale  •  ConnecFcut  

 33

Decentralized  Market  –  Mix  of  Models  &  Providers  

Low  

High  

Page 34: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

CHALLENGES  

34

Volume  is  the  answer  to  all  of  our  problems  

ü  Complexity  –  Keep  it  Simple  

ü  Get  down  that  learning  curve  ü  Track  and  share  data  ü  Cooperate  whenever  possible  ü  Get  to  YES  faster  

 

Page 35: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACENOW  

 David  Gabrielson:  [email protected]    George  Caraghiaur:  [email protected]    Kris4na  Klimovich:  [email protected]    

 

35

Contact  informa7on  

Page 36: PACE%MarketOverview · 2015-06-12 · $2.5!mil!Energy!&!Solar!Upgrade!–Mul7!Project 19. PACENATION%! 20 . PACE%IN2007 21. PACE%TAKESO FF% 22 29!states!and!DC!!N!80%!of!US!popula7on!

PACENOW  

 Vision    PACE  is  a  highly  effecFve  financing  opFon  that  every  building  owner  considers  when  implemenFng  energy  efficiency,  renewable  energy,  and  water  management  upgrades  to  their  properFes.    

Mission  To  be  the  leader  of  and  advocate  for  the  growing  universe  of  PACE  stakeholders;  and  the  provider  of  informaFon,  resources,  consensus-­‐based  advice  and  guidance,  market  network  building  and  soluFons  to  PACE  market  problems.  

 

36

Represen7ng  PACENa7on