one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

181
one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime PILJIN YI

Transcript of one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Page 1: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

PILJIN YI

Page 2: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

or, how quantum matter “renormalizes” classical geometry

PILJIN YI

Page 3: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

one-loop renormalization as selective Gaussian integration

functional Gaussian integral via heat kernel

2d Weyl anomaly & s-wave Hawking radiation

Bogolyubov, Hawking, Unruh, and de Sitter

Page 4: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

references

• Wilson & Kogut, “The renormalization group and the -expansion,” Physics Reports 12 (1974) 75-200.

• McKean & Singer, “Curvature and the eigenvalues of the Laplacian, ” Journal of Differential Geometry, vol.1 (1967) 43-69.

• Barvinsky’s summary of an improved heat kernel expansionhttp://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Heat_kernel_expansion_in_the_background_field_formalism

• Misner, Thorne & Wheeler, “Gravitation,” W.H. Freedman and Company.

• Birrel & Davies, “Quantum Fields in Curved Space,” Cambridge University Press.

• Preskill’s Lecture Note: Physics 236c, “Quantum Field Theory in Curved Spacetime” http://www.theory.caltech.edu/~preskill/notes.html

Page 5: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

one-loop renormalization as selective Gaussian integration

Page 6: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

renormalization = selective integration

Page 7: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

renormalization = selective integration

Page 8: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

recall the Gaussian integration

Page 9: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

renormalization = selective integration

Page 10: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

renormalization = selective integration

Page 11: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

textbook renormalization = selective integration + truncation

Page 12: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

textbook renormalization = selective integration + truncation

Page 13: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

renormalization = selective integration

Page 14: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

renormalization = selective integration

Page 15: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

textbook renormalization = selective integration + truncation

Page 16: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

q.f.t. renormalization = selective path-integral

Page 17: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

example : momentum shell integration

Page 18: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

example : U(1) gauge theory with massive charged field

Page 19: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged field

Page 20: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged field

Page 21: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

functional determinant and functional trace

Page 22: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

log of determinant = trace of log

Page 23: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime
Page 24: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

log of functional determinant of operator = functional trace of log of operator

Page 25: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged field

Page 26: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged field

vacuum energyrenormalization

tadpolecancellation

coupling constant (also wavefunction-)

renormalization

finite terms

Page 27: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged field

Page 28: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged field

Page 29: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged fields

Page 30: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged fields

more generally we may wish to integrate out partially, say,

Page 31: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged fields

more generally we may wish to integrate out partially, say,

Page 32: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with massive charged fields

Page 33: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

functional Gaussian integral via heat kernel

Page 34: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with a massive charged scalar

Page 35: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

U(1) gauge theory with a massive charged scalar

Page 36: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

36

Page 37: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

37

Page 38: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

38

Page 39: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

39

Page 40: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

40

Page 41: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

41

Page 42: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

42

Page 43: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

43

Page 44: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

44

Page 45: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

45

Page 46: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion: power counting

46

1. each

2. each x-integral

3. each s-integral

4. each derivative

5. each x

at each iteration

Page 47: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion for U(1) R.G.

if derivative of field strength can be ignored or is irrelevant

Page 48: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

48

Page 49: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

49

Page 50: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

50

we must now decide what is the most useful decomposition of

we will eventually take for determinant, so Q should be expanded around this position

Page 51: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

51

Page 52: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

52

Page 53: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

53

Page 54: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

54

Page 55: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

55

Page 56: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion for U(1) R.G.

if derivative of field strength can be ignored or is irrelevant

Page 57: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

after one more iteration one-loop R.G. of U(1) gauge theory with massive charged scalar

Page 58: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

excursion: quantum one-loop as a functional Gaussian integralhow to derive the Asymptotic Freedom, or Yang-Mills beta function

Page 59: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory renormalization & asymptotic freedom

Page 60: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

what types of matrices are preserved under the commutator ?

Page 61: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

what types of matrices are preserved under the commutator ?

Page 62: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

a canonical example

Page 63: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

more generally

Page 64: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

what types of matrices are preserved under the commutator ?

Page 65: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

what types of matrices are preserved under the commutator ?

Page 66: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

what types of matrices are preserved under the commutator ?

Page 67: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

what types of matrices are preserved under the commutator ?

Page 68: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

what types of matrices are preserved under the commutator ?

Page 69: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory

Page 70: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

for example

Page 71: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Page 72: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Page 73: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion for U(1) R.G.

Page 74: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion for Yang-Mills R.G.

Page 75: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

75

Page 76: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Page 77: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Page 78: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Yang-Mills fields interact among themselves, so there are additional contribution

Page 79: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Yang-Mills fields interact among themselves, so there are additional contribution

Page 80: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Yang-Mills fields interact among themselves, so there are additional contribution

Page 81: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

gauge-fixing introduces further contribution from Faddeev-Popov ghost, which is like minus of a single complex scalar in the adjoint representation

Page 82: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Page 83: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

Page 84: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Yang-Mills theory with matter fields

asymptotic freedom !!!

Page 85: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

renormalization is selective path-integral

Page 86: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

usual textbook renormalization isselective path-integral + truncation

Page 87: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

but there is far more to such renormalization processes than mere replacement of numbers

Page 88: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

for example, what kind of things happen if quantum matter “renormalize” geometry?

Page 89: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

2d Weyl anomaly and s-wave Hawking radiation

Page 90: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 91: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 92: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 93: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 94: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 95: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

in d=2, metric can always be put in such a conformal form

Page 96: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 97: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 98: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 99: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 100: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 101: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 102: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 103: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 104: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d real massless scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 105: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Taylor expansion of metric

Page 106: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with geodesic normal coordinate system

Page 107: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with geodesic normal coordinate system

Page 108: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with geodesic normal coordinate system

Page 109: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with geodesic normal coordinate system

Page 110: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with geodesic normal coordinate system

Page 111: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with geodesic normal coordinate system

Page 112: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

heat kernel expansion

112

Page 113: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with geodesic normal coordinate system at

Page 114: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d massless real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 115: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

a 2d massless real scalar field coupled to 2d “gravity”

Page 116: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

this result is widely known as Weyl or 2d conformal anomaly

Page 117: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

integrating Weyl anomaly

Page 118: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

quantizing a 2d massless real scalar “renormalize” 2d gravity as

Page 119: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

quantizing 2d massless real scalars “renormalize” 2d gravity as

Page 120: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

s-wave Hawking radiation from black holes

Page 121: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to Schwarzschild black holes

Page 122: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 123: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 124: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

black holes from collapsing stars

Page 125: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 126: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 127: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 128: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

black holes from collapsing stars

Page 129: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 130: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

s-waves of N scalar fields, minimally coupled to spherically symmetric geometry

Page 131: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

quantized S-waves of N scalar fields, minimally coupled to spherically symmetric geometry

Page 132: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

quantized S-waves of N scalar fields, minimally coupled to spherically symmetric geometry

Page 133: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

energy-momentum of N quantized scalar s-wave modes

outflow energy density

inflow energy density

Page 134: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

energy-momentum of N quantized scalar s-wave modes

Page 135: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

energy-momentum of N quantized scalar s-wave modes

Page 136: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

energy-momentum of N quantized scalar s-wave modes

Page 137: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

energy-momentum of N quantized scalar s-wave modes

Page 138: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

energy-momentum of N quantized scalar s-wave modes

Page 139: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

energy-momentum of N quantized scalar s-wave modes

physical initial condition for is

Page 140: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

energy-momentum of N quantized scalar s-wave modes

physical initial condition for is

Page 141: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

no radiation near horizon implies net outgoing radiation far away

Page 142: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

late-time (s-wave) Hawking radiation

Page 143: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Bogolyubov, Hawking, Unruh, and de Sitter

Page 144: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

black holes from collapsing stars

Page 145: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

how do we understand such radiation “out of nothing” via direct quantum analysis of the scalar fields ?

Page 146: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

how does one define a quantum vacuum for a free field in curved space-time ?

how does one define a quantum state in curved spacetime ?

Page 147: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

time-slices/coordinates are needed to define a Hilbert space

Page 148: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

time-slices/coordinates are needed to define a Hilbert space

Page 149: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

we must have an inner product of wavefunctions, which is invariant under time-shift / coordinate changes

Page 150: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

bases related by Bogolyubov transformation

Page 151: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

bases related by Bogolyubov transformation

Page 152: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

operators related by Bogolyubov transformation

Page 153: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with operators related by Bogolyubov transformation

Page 154: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

the vacuum of one Hilbert space is not the vacuum of another

Page 155: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 156: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 157: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 158: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Schwarzschild black holes

Page 159: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

Page 160: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

vs.

sensible for observersat the future horizon

sensible for observersfar away from black hole

modes moving toward infinity

Page 161: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

vs.

sensible for observersat the future horizon

sensible for observersfar away from black hole

invisible but necessary

Page 162: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

vs.

sensible for observersat the future horizon

sensible for observersfar away from black hole

invisible but necessary

Page 163: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

what if the field is massive ?

what about higher angular momentum mode ?

what if the field has intrinsic spin ?

Page 164: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

mode expansion of massive scalars in tortoise coordinate

Page 165: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

mode expansion of massive scalars in tortoise coordinate

Page 166: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

mode expansion in tortoise coordinate

intrinsic spin,angular momentum,curvature effect, ….

Page 167: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

Page 168: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

Page 169: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

as we have to do an analytic continuation in the lower half plane

Page 170: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

Page 171: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

~ bosonic thermal radiationat temperature

Page 172: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

~ bosonic thermal radiationout of a pure quantum state

perfectly entangled pure quantum state

Page 173: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

back to the Schwarzschild black hole

~ bosonic thermal radiationout of a pure quantum state

perfectly entangled pure quantum state fully mixed, thermal state after partial trace

Page 174: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

fully mixed state from a perfect quantum entanglement

Page 175: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

which happens whenever there is an event horizon

Page 176: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with thermal spectra whenever two coordinates are related via exponential

Page 177: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

with thermal spectra whenever the time coordinates are related via exponential

Page 178: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

cosmological horizon in de Sitter universe

typical co-moving observer

Page 179: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

Rindler horizon for uniformly accelerating observers

Page 180: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

the Unruh temperature is a little more subtleas each Rindler wedge has no obvious asymptotic frame;

the Unruh temperature refers to the observer at

more generally, the same formula works for other accelerated observers if is replaced by her own acceleration

Page 181: one-loop quantum physics of matter in curved spacetime

radiative vs. thermal equilibrium

Hartle-Hawking vacuum for BH;Bunch-Davies vacuum for de Sitter;Unruh vacuum for Rindler wedges

radiation vacuum