..... .,.".~: . :al~o:t'I,e1~~t.:of.lhe'~~8~ that.she.wa,~,i;n.ju(tid,al·~ust(1~

t\O(3)~IJlil:,f.~"f.;S ..(i'ii -3q?·~1P6·:.and·.:~I~B:~<.I: . on '.'.: '. " .•••• -v , • :•• : -: '. :::_ ~h~'~irt-~~r.te<i~tUig o~ the SaJIi{.in~~r:aftt'i-.~er:.:.:'':;.: .,

: • : ..... : ... :,. '. . .. ::~~~; <if £~~ng:~.;~':~e~~.h:~~.~;,~_.~~..~~tt~p(~·.;'..::::.\;....... ;": commit sUicide•.Hence, "an FtR bbilig .No"·S·S(3)2Ul<l:PRT 'PS ·u/s· .,,;. .~~.

.:',.. ", : ...:- .....~. . ~ .' ~".""' .. "" .... :.,' ," . /:: ',',.. ",: '~.. ' '.... ··.~309:··~ip.·<?· \I,f~~::~eii~~d:.,~(erf .ft:~~lng',''been' < (;~m1?)~~"the.':".-;:'.".' .', • '\ '~", • '.' ,' •••• (." ',','; ••••• :\ ' ., ••••• c ' ' ' • , •••• .' .' •• , '

' ", '; : .inii'estig!1tion:·of~~ca5c-:.al.m.~b.Qvi.,.gJoUr{d)1prima' fade: case' .. '" ;. '.;' , . . . . .': , . .; -:, ::', .:" .": ' . .'.. ", ". . ", . -;:,,' .: . - "', :"~:"~. ,:, . ..-\ ~.. :.

'. .'. -; ·.ag$lP.s~·_~e:·.a«.:;usc:(i/thelrivesugatlllg Age{l<!'j -submrtred ch8.Tge· .'.....,~~,....,'., ,.: :ol:·.:.·':>·, ~.:~::.·~'·: :"~·:.. :,,t~ :..~~.. : ,'- :;. "'; ..' -;' ." .. '

., '.' sI?eet".ror:ttia~ ~gali15tth'e \i~~~~d·{61'.th~;offe1'ice l,iiTder.$ect\bil: :.: '~':';,." • • -: =, . '30Y.fpc D'ixi#tgil{~&Ji~~i:or.:tiWI'..u;eltd:··i::;lM/rt:pa~da.n.~e~:: .'.',:' .L. -' '.: '(~rf";lInint·eh~r~.~nd~rsectioh"300'iPc '~ains; tlle accused0(('.. .' ..', ".

",,:.~::,:"., .. ,'. ". ..' .: ." '." ,".' : " ",' .:: . '". ,,' .. ~,'. :;.- "; .• ,:. ... ', ,. • .. ': "." ..... ~••••••••• '.;;'_z I"'::

"., .:, (.., . : .:.4.1.61.201'4:; Be41-g:..a~jev¢d »1 ille :~pugne:d. \)rdei',; the. accused: .' -: .~., ~:( I~:.. h9.~meet~~i!i:~~;~:;~~::~i~~gt.Oi.i~i~:ih';'t iJi~'la:'~irk 'GO\;i-(pa-3s~d: ':.;.:.:.:': ~/:/ :

:-",:,;'T·':·· :.:;.:' . tJl~:·~.:c,.er;.illt!g~T;~;·~6i~iG':~31;9f,;oltJ~~~:~d·ili-k.~~itJi(,~t,':';: .. : :;~:C~;/._;".:'.. >.:",,: ' '.:<a:~l;1g1e:~ij~~1tg.$~b~·~Jai2;r~tP~!~ti~g~.i.J~d~ts~ci,i~i'a69"":'.:;::; t·, Is. ;:::." .,."~' •• ,.":".: •••• :.;, ; ,','.: :.,: ••• 1, •• :'; •• , ••• .. : '" " •• ,: ':. '.' : •••• ~~,~ ••

, '..:..' ' .. _ l~~;:the;.1d; .ri'i~Cv~;rtt¥~_·c}J\~g~·.CI.(tJ'te~f~e!1ce·.and"~hQt'she: : :: ~ ;::.:~;:t<::--~..: : . :': :~hly·.s~(rher~hUnge': st4K~;(t~stirigi(:4~~(ting:(or:'i~pea('of.:.' •. ', :: (. :,;;~.~}

....: ~~"".. ~:', ..'.: ..... '.:~'. .' .....: .... ::..::;:~..:.: .. ::..... ';:"',.' ':':.. ':','.' ~:,'. ,' .. '._'.;' ..,:." '.:..::'.:.:;.:... ,'.. ". ;AFSPA;·..1958 SlIlce .2flJI2000.at.Ui,~hat·hung«;"'~ke Il; mJj:..\aJl: . ' .. , ":'~"'''':,.'.:.' '.: :". . .":.. . . ,. ..,.' .. '. .....! .... :.•' ..: " ..' '.. ::cr'jY"f;".. ',-:: :",::': ". :.:' ·:·.o'lien6e:;pumshable :4Ilder·Sec;t\tjn.:.36~, J,~~i:b'e~u&e she··:4Sed'.: !:·t~.~;.<

.. "' .. ' ". ' ... :: .. ' ... ,' ... : .. ' ·t.. :::"'~~."...' .0:.••• ~ ... ,'. : .' _." .'•.. , '.' .:1;_·'t ;":"~ >:.' ..-....:.:. ",: huOge". s~rik!eI)'nly In the liiii ot~dh.~joteii(mo~~iiien,t.~8was <wne':- .' . J ':'::-.::?'.;'.\• . • • '.... ••• • or •• ~ '''' , ..' : •••. ~. ., : ,'·t-·.x.·,.

~:... .; :,,: ..•• 1.:b{ tile ~.fatt!i~i-;6£~e N~tiori.;M~~:'.G~(ihi: 'if' IS·ve$e·iiu~nt1.Y..:-: ::::: ,.. "..::.:tff,~,' ••...•• , :. '" .. , j, ..' "',' .. ',"' ....• (.; ...........• : :~':-'i'c:'!:'

. :' '_i' . ,. .... . Subinitted:mat' the -Petitioner i:lIiver·ever!s~~&nMrshe.:\\(OuldiwiJ('.. ;'J:-: " . ,L;~(..... :~ •• j :'" '. :. '. :.... • '. ' •• ' ::.:,' .:' •••• ,: •• ~ :'.) " .:' ~•• ' '. \' t.· ," ',. "t:i-\.:.'.... '.' '. ;. 'fast ·.un'tp:db>th. ·ai1d~the'alJegiition..6f:i1aSi ~td, ci.iaih"hiis '~n ..••.: .' : ':t ;1':',

' •••• ,.~.. !.. • • : • • • ...... : - "(' .;'••••••• ' .. ' - ,.. .,:. " • •••• ,.... • ~•••,,"••

.' .. :._..:~~a'te?.arti~cflillyan!ithus ~sh:;.:·j)tib~~;d:QfuifJiOJ:l.~ri'athe:'C'h'w-~:' .: ./;_:: ;;<~:-;i'·;·::.:·!;··:·";~:·.· ~ ~.. ' ' ' .. " 'f"; ' .. :. ~.. • :.•• "

.', '.' slieet alsO vag\:u~iialleged this filct Without·any,·s.uf6clent.:rnaterlai, ,. ' ... ~: . {.":{:• r, <':··/th~~i~'~~i'~:~~~inattrial/~~~~~t:;~~~~~i:ci;fr~:e;cia:gt':;.'::: .·-)t;~{/

. "'.' . '.' .. :. '" 'uts 309IPC·aga;nst the PeHti6nerbe~U:se:t1ie:alleged.91a:rrI<; for": . ". ".... :::.:/. "':''.::..,..'~t~mptto.;ill.l¥cldeit:' for,iin'o~;~~~;~~ti;h:aiieg~di~'t,o"iMpia~~,::.'.:/:..:Jk)'­

.... :.::';:"~" : ..':':o~:13/3i26i"i"$ince';.OO:p:m: t.O·~~~05\~;~~~iY4Y3/.2i)i.j-""'h~il·.... :.:::'.'~');.•.;;'. f • -..... • '. .... • _ " • • ":';" ••• " •• ,' • ."., • .:' .'. • .' • '" '." .....;. '.': ; :,:. ';:::' , '. '.' th'c:F.m·~a:s'r~stered -and '1i4i:i~~t.ht·Pi:t'it(1)lier..nev~.ati.cq;~d:IO::··.'.,...:;~ ~,:~.,.:;_':..,'.'''''.',..'....;:~~~:>~,,,/,:..:....~lfuiIl1 ~:~~i~tat the.~4~.~~:'.Wn~':~4:';~!ie~~i~~.'aii<lged.:·;. :.~~~.;~:t.:;i:

..,,~.:;.'i'1,.,.;,...:,.::,~;j~!~{.:'.:._oc:~rren~{~nd..a$..B'neh!he:~~ei.of~e Id:'.~.~0W: ~~•.ti:~blit'.~:..';:;',:,)f. ..:.;';·A\·~.01,·..:~,:\~I'. 'b'esctaside '. .' ,.' ,,,,.' ::~, ..:'.,,,",'.',,../;. it(!ll)~~;::',':: :;'.;'.:,'.:'::.....: '.': .....: :';':,:"~;, .::;:.::::·f,. ~.': ;:.····:4::~!;

, .'~::11;-~1~~~¥.<.. ' . 3:: . ( have hearo"Srtit. '8. Indira' DeVi,:Id;·.A:ddl, PP'f~r: the State-'. '. :g, ';:, :,c;:« ".: ."7"~ ~.~l,~~;;';4·;. .' . +" ••••• •• ,~ •• ': '... • \, ',' •••• ~ 1 ._ ;.;~. :':

"'.'~.'.•l<::-:-.<..::i(f'-~i'l~,~,'_'. and Shri.KhSid'em ,Mani, Id. '<lOl1ll'sel1'oTtil\:' petitioner at1e~h. I.:' ':, A' '.'"it_ < ' , ,: " ....•.... : '; : : ," -, , l'.'~ .:::-\' ..:.~' -~.!.'".:''P' :~~.:~:-~ \'".-:': "'~:.:.':

-:

. :,

.' ". ':,'.. '.'. ', -'." ':'/:', ":.: ' "'", ." .. " ".. "

.' • #' .. ', "

. '. :. /: f -:'. ~.....:: :':.~ ~: • :.: -»

.. " . '" .•... ',." ·:···.~.~·I:· .. ~ "c ••• ,,~~.: ":1\.·•..'·.·.:.~ •. _. . J •

',OJ' •• , •• : -. .:"~~' .:'~:: .;.~ .... : 1.:-· .....

-_ ..-_ ............-,__-..~.,..-. -

"..: ..' ..'

:' ..'':...::.

• .', •••• .... j ••• ~ r·. .:.,..,'. "." ',.: ,'.:: ." ',:j.

. ' .,.:"! '..• -a , :': ,".',.' .

•-~ • : -:.' t. . :tlii::·ttiareii1ils.'!{vruhible-ih (lit' r'e<;l>rd:.· '. : ..' . '. . "".. .' ~ ~. ;.", .. ,-: :'.'y:'""":'::":; /;·i.:. '~' ..:. .: .:.: .;::: '~:;'~ ';.:';',": '.' =.;:,'"..':.;';.::-.,"::":.. :":>.<:.\.:.'.:'.:':::" (.:,;; ~:. :;~)f~:<-: .: ;: : 4, :<Th~i;t~Adcihpp·:Sublnitl)'tliat#l~p;:e~~iitpetitioiier.ha·~"~~··,, . .{:'

" • .' " 'j" • ..... ,.'.: • • .'" .,' , '. ...."... .'" 1,··', ", •~~".:;;.":

. .: '" ..... '>" 'cohtiiiiiinghir :f~ki:i.';'g;~iti:ce':iaoO'fpl':thedema]t4 otrei?i:~'g t~e··...·.... . .. J:' :'(.' ....; ktti~d'~;d;~e~::~pe'tia\~;PolrJ:~i:'.A·~.i95i ~~~~iric~t~e~'.~~~':h'~a':. .1,: i

• ..' ': ," ••• ' 'v.. ,," • :", • r- " ';' . ,,: 'I"~':"'" ; .. ,.,.. I' t, ". .' •

.-, ..tieeni~iien·notirishtOep.t'J)y. .way offorced np$e'fcedihg; I'!erc·e.·the·':', , .. )), '.. '.;:" :'" ...", .'.r.: ..'~.:"i,,' •• ' , • 'I." I". :, • . j •• ' ,",' .:.. • ... : • ,"'. \' •• ,':, .' '" •• ' "

:.: .' .',.<.'; ..' : :., .. (.,':, .: ". petitior,ei'paa'fa,ti.~p).lid'.~o·c.0:~irii~suiCide;",hidi.rall~ ~~h~ tl:t~'~·.~., .. ,J; '~,".," . '. :Ptitvt.·: ·e;;_.:of,S.ie. ti. 'oi,i'.'3. 09:jPC.· :·'A·c':Q. .tdi.;'..:',ly.;.the flriP:;ig. ned..'.d~.ef.'d.·a~.·.. :.'.: :. ": '.' ,:' ~;;:'.r

...... :... ~.. " , I'~'" ~. "1" I. ·;[~:·'r·..,F.-; ..:·;·...: .. ,.i.~.:.. :4'ili·j1ilie;29(4IPli§~ed·.iJi!tru.;·(p);Cas-eN~·.S3.(;f2br4'bythe Ii;!: .; ~.' '.> ~~:.' :'

'..; '-,,:',,;::.:','."i:ihlef~&d~.M·{-:~~~~"~+i;';,·6~l'~$.~·~f6.tiraming'of:c~t:J~ " <" ,::,,:'<"{,:~.~..~.• , ,...:: #" •• : -v". ;> -", :; ::::.:.:~ ..:, .•~ :;:-: : ~~~:-::' : '_;: •..•• "•• ., .:-.: :' .. :' _ :.' • "': •• - I ...... '; :': t~.../:;> ::':':( .' '..'... nof.i;ulfer JrOPi~~1·I~gulQrltY:\\nd'l1ence:ril?Iih(ftot be i~terf~red.'.; '. "'/' '.:~;i" ;::

.·.1··.·::· ~::.::·'..:~· ..:·..:...·.: ..:~ith.~:··:.:"~"::.:.::::':;,,:,~:.:.:...:::.:.::.....: ..... :-.:....': .\ -,~.:::...;.:.:.. :... ' .....~..:~...;:~;~:;:;~~......, .'.~..: .' .,.i '._. .'.:. :........., .....

.'. : , $:: SiufKt1~~~~Qiii;:,}'d;;:'~~~~~~ifot'(1:,; ~c"ii~ed~o~"~.~otnli~;.:·::: :' .i':;. ::. liariJ: his S~b~itr~a ·i.\\~t;:ill~;.e·~~:.ri~:~irt;:':~hali·~6;:!lUb~~~~t~··:':'.;. ....~,>.

ita~rig.charieai~~st;tli~:~~.tirl6~¢/T.Il~·~~~J~~e.r.itQ~t~d:;f~$ti·~~·:.' . : .':.:'. '. si~~e~/ii'i:29()b·~~r.h~ariii~ti;~'~~~$'~{~,~~l kiit\h~.~~()'0 ;:, ';;:' .....• '

. :...;. ',".: ....'.: i:riribc~rit;;i~ili~'i\..:.:..the'Afri,~~;'~~ri:/;itili.iiIi6 ~~Jffu;tt~ij·"~t'· :- j:.:: •... ,.!~.::.~,;!.,.::.....:.·.I.:... ~.:;.•~··...:,::·:.·:·..-::.';:·:.. -J. ",. . . ... , .., :.::

:..: .<. ::.:~'....' I.~·:.',:: .:.:::t~ie~.~::~;::·:e;t:i:;~~i~~ft:t~~;·:!~1~·t,1~::..:~....:;>:;.~;!{\,....... :\ .. '~' ~: :.' ".' :, ':.. ..;,.-: :.:.. • ':.' ., "'-:.~.'J::"".:,.i':::'< -'::: '::: "'.: .>in~ent:U~ by.th~·Fatt\ef-.orth.e:Na:ti~:}"'aha~~·.Gii~.fIbi~. '.-.' -,.~:'·...;:1)}'~;-::.

:.:",;_', ··,tJ,. '.'~ ' .:1••••• : 'S , :.": .;;; ,'.' I. :. ~ ...e- .. ~:--::.':. '.:, ,:_ .... :."": . <'el)(orCeher :·t;ght:u'nder. Ar.ticlli·2l.' pf:tlte;.-COi!lltitu.tion,' Recc.nUy,'·,.o,,:.: -,," ".:f ~";f..:;.:":.:;.::~~;.;'.~iu~~:;f:l~~ie~atio~~~~~Pt~d"~~:~rid~·:~rf.+~t,;~Jii~:~~~~~~~"~.>::::?~:,;':~;ft;:

. .' . Eigo.i!}lit.COrruptiori:.8.tRamL14·Maidil!;t,.New. P~I:l1.j:9,l:1q no 9fin'iinllJ.:. ':.:' : :.. ::~/.:-: .'proce~rlingw~siniti~ted;.:gai.ri~t·bi~i:or.)ilitem~~~o~~ci~:"i~:·).fi~.;, ' ,. '. cr·: > .

•• • I..... ' .. :.....'..•.:..... : ." .••. ~... • •••• :.",';. : . :... . :~.::!.. '.::~Ci1<a.rgll!\·.a~iiistJhe.¢.l'iii!;1)1et,Is::'tha~ <after. '.: : '! : ..'.• \J..i' . ; .

... ......... M~~~",":'¥~J!":;;.trir'.' ·14/3/.20H at·.apout S:OS·p:m.lt stated.:thatthere aieJ;4 similar::",'":.' ,:.,;> :~r':~~':.;..;~.: :Fl~~:~lnst :ilie:l>~tit:iorie;"With-put:shy; ~;: sh~ria~:be~,(l~~..: ::•...;;'~,•..~/;,.:..::::~.~...:.:.:..::..;.; ~:. . :...... , :. ; .. . . ...:,;'. .... .:: - .:.:_ .~.:~.-.'.:. : ." .'. . .- - '.;_ - .-

... .:.: : :.:.,.:' ·cuStOdy.}iS'.,~der'.tria1.prisl:mer·-jn-_resp~(.Wi!ll..alI\thes.~.Pl~~ " _"< .' ••• :lOo-'. i'" , .•roo. ..•• ': •• :.:..... ,:l!-! :'. ':. '';'':: . .... -:."" ...... :...... :.' .:., '., '_' .•.

••• .<., ... :::.: •• ,: .• ·,' ..WtthO,?t ·.II,nY.:,~bstanhve. 'tri~"<'~~*1Pt:U1e:~~ht>.case..··!~la.;~: '-., .. ! I!.::.:::· '.:'.. '~:-: .:.... ;:rt9tli~g but '~:~~onti~UO\.lS:~1m8e:6(.·pj~$~:·'~r,~ri~)II-~~~d , ,'.. . .

.' . "i~i'atioriof fundQ~eriW:fight,guifrrui.te~d~n~e; ~rti6li:20!2J:iic·tbi·· .. .'. :.~,~,); ::;'..'.c,j~~tieuti~n9~India. -5hrtMani. Ad'vo~teh~~ iieh~rii~il~~·"~;~~:':·'.:i.}:i)hat ih~~eti~6ne~'ill...l'lot"~:criIDiila;!Md :~~ i~d~~a·~~m8'·..a, : .. > ..' :..... : .,.': . . . .,' . ,'. ., ~ ' ' '.'" . .,:..··'·f:··~·:·..politi~Qiright '~i!I\'er<lilmap'd:ou~t to b'c;deai~j,Oliti.~y..:r~e.Id,:: : '. ': " .. ;;'.......:. .. , . :! ... .'. '. ". " '.' '.' '. : . '.: ....., ". :' '.

.,.: '.' .:' . .. . .' ..: .:~..

.':.. "':. "<·::;'::~:·:iH:.:';" ; .. :',.,';,.' t" ," '. • • • '. ...... .' •••~•.. ',:" ... '. ":_..:_._-' _ ...- .' -:--..:.......:.:_ .':,,:..:::.-::~.-'~~.:.':":::;:.: .::.

,

'•• I••.. "

," . " ' ..... ,,'

.. ,''. . .... .'

".: : .. , ,'r': .

, '.....",

, "" .:1! '~"... .

" :.... ' ...

-=--'. ~:.:.,.. ' ..

.....,,~,,;:::~,-' .;' -.-':. ;, .(

,.', 'I ' ".'j ,,' '".. ,',."",' '.' .. ' "" '.:.. .

• ....!. :.:.'.::....:_"'.,.", '.''.' ~..... '.'- ,".

' .."'.:.. '::~,',' '. ,,'. : .. . ~. ".'

'. '. ",'_', " .....:,:... ,

.,':':' :', :' :';,"

'., ..

..' ,', ..,......

I

'"

- ; '. "•...:: •.:: :.,I',:"';..,~.- '. !.

' ...:" ',: .

.' :. . the cOrTlTltiiitil'o'il:o£~ik).'1'offefttC;· Q·ilti·'i'iiij'su'lili' ~:l(iici:'i'S~iJcii~~~;.'F"'.7..~':!:'..:.<t*-:-"- '. ~'.":_·:·~ali~~~~~~I~.~:,{',.:>, ,:;',; .• :~":.,:':;,: ';~::"<:~:;" ,:~-.~<~.>.,.;:<~:'~:' '.':\::.':'!.~;:::._"::.:; ,' .. '..9...· .:ro"c.;'rtil'nit.suj~dc'is.'ror a,:pe,tjo\1.\7dl:Um.anJY·tocm:..ap<IiCt or" .' .:,:,:' /.' .. :~(-,.'.>.. :.....•..tp ::~~·f~'l·.~~ir;~:.~~.b~i~,;.~U~~~n~~::}<?~'..t~~·;i~'~i~e;.~r~.j.;:'~;:<:,/:>.:

. destro,Y.lOg.·his<v. -own.' lite, .:b~g ...COn$(\10US.. of... thllt ,pro.pa,ofe ...... . .>. "::. '.: ;, ':".", ". '. . . ' .. ,' . '.. .. .' . . I.·.. "t.., •...• ,' '. ..".' " I.

, .,'~~n'sequl!nc~;:~a ~'vinli;.a't"thii' tiUle;: .'SJ,ifJicieni nimd' 't9;:.Wi.u .: .,:. :""'., ?':,, .' "i ' . " ~. . ... ,,' ..... ,,' . ,..... ','.:: .•. ' .. " . t· : '; • '. .:. •

:'.'. .'.:. : :..,.: ..d.~~~~tiQ~.:~!Ii~e':?~e '~1~ ~~cide:i.~::l\Qtde~c~ _i~. th~.lrt~a:.~. .' ". ',' .. '!"',':' .' . -. . ~1'l8.l,~od~~.9~ld~rnU:~~;:tht~fore; loo~,!!-ttJi~drc~OtiBl)':.!lleii~i~g~( ,, \:' '.".".':::.~.'

. ~'.,'.:'" ...... :" .' .:" .......t.li-·.;'; -:d:'l'i ·,:,e",ca~~o·f·,."'.liijltiaa'Mii,j'_~;C -A;·;.·.··.·Uhlon.or.L'diIl: .';", ". . .. e.j:-r~.. '~'~'" <>, .~,., ",.: ••••• ~" ~.-. :'_o: jp. .'~'. :.»:'," : .'.:.iP9Q~~ili..J\~1.~?,(ifii~J..Ki;;al~\i.gh·'C6.ufthertl'\i{~t:~·fiQdi~g·or.: .. ';:':;, -;-t.

"::" . ','''''-:;'''::.,':;;'1:;' .,'::! :1v., .t•• " .. -;::'" :: ".!." -:.', .':~ ',' ':. -. .;, ,;.". '~~". :.;: .:. .... ···.:BUt<:1Q!t..;ni"ii.~;l.be~.~i:l:'.d;,,'.c'iln1e~:.:of-.in'tllrie;on. Every· .act.~T :' .: ,or:'. o';. ".'.• • • . ,. :, '', : ...... ,' .•?"~,,' ::' \' .. " ".'" .:~,,!' .."':, ':.".... .' .:. ....', .. ,':i. 'j

.... ,,:': -.", - .:~eifr-desihti:-tilfu :i$~'.:in.•~··~Qge ·desenb2i.l 'bY. the>wilrd . .:.....~<-,,..,'.,.r, . • r.: :'suiclde:'~~6virl~d;::i'!~Jhi. iin'i*!J:;k~'~~f'~{a.~~:~~~~g.~c ,:' .;..~~-.(: ::..:i!:.;: -

", ',:':" -:".:, " ".~: : I"':':'j' .:.~.~.:""-,:'''''':':''''~':-,:' .: ':,: ;. .1 ••···:: '\ .' " .. '. .•,', !... . '. " protiable tQn'seqlJences.. SuiDid4 B",..'ni ....r -.to .'be .pt.iiiuined. : : " .' .j":

': .. :: -, ••:: •• " ... '.:.::'.", ".":.. ;'. , " "," .,:':' .,,',.':,,, '.,' ,',':' .1' ./ ' ':' '~,~

-';': : .' _.:~~~tfonIs.'; tile· f:~~~~1..)1~~e~..)r.h~o'"!l •."~·: .'¥<1.t-4 :.: . .-' .; ';... ". . '.. .~~l.~i.de:t~~~~~·;)1i~~1!-:~~~'~i.:·iii~.~l~·'.l1'~:.cZ perm. 0-; ". ..,: ;yo'

,> . :'. : l'Ciiitiz~Iy::'~Uiri:9..,~:·~tia::'lo~':fli~idi(i~":Thii:'c<ul;u'"'cind ': ::, ..(':.'. i/f:.':.'. '" ;" t .. '~ ::: .. : .. '.' ::'.: .',•••. ,'_~~ :, ',~ ':', ",: ~"~,:',:",,,' /:,,:,; ':t ':.; '.:'., '.' ''', '" .. " .\, '" ",'; ,',,\. J". :i:"

' ....:'.'"..' -'c¥.u~~:.~~':'9 :o~;.~·t~.~~ii~;~d.ects.~!'Ja.whOtIY. .:.. : ~ ,.,.: .. ':" .," :"" , " ' , ... • " • ""j'" " • " ., .. ,. ..... .: • '.' '. • ,t··.' .~.::.::::::.., .'. . ~~~nt' t~rdeciding 't~'S~$«"'~<i~;~:tj,~"';r.:tJ.tI1.;d~h.· .':". ,.; "1:',;

~!.(;::>_:;'; :.:,;~.,:,7;',,,:;::.:,..:~ji!iI~~l1.f:tii.~~·:.':'.':-i"'" .f :;:'-: '~" '.' -.: " .'.• :. :...<::;:: ." :.,:::}f~:·'/"';\(:t..~ ,.. ' :.>.:. ~~t.:wli~re.If· -..:....:. ,:...~:./;[.;

qt!$~ij;i.o[f.:.~d£::~~!n.mjf!,ltlg·~.~~Iidl:le':i>y ·throw,in'g:'- ':".::" ''-:.::.:::i;-!:,;.,,' ",,":

" : "'. ,:.: .. '.' pers.on;·sh{ ~a~ ~ot~gti.il.ty'Of~tte~Pt; .•..' i;: r~~:~'; ' ..:·';':-.·..·:.>·.·::··:···Sh~;.;.;[~)\~b1i\\echang·.·e'd.h~{.~l·ci,. ~. ';'" .. /'....:,,;

::",.,... :"'-~fj:.':" ",,'.' "',',"; ~,,: "":i, :,' ';" 'j' '... \' ',':' • ;':~':.'::'::""~':;':;~':~"-:'" :·,'''::.i ':': . ~':. did anyt!aing:'\Yhich·1nightbe- tegali:!e,q. of the· .. ' . . :<.. ".

, '. ~":'. "...i;ff~~C~'I~~~r~'~JU~ql~iz)1~~:r~:"f~4t.~ini;jwh.e~·~e:':.<._'::~ :~;':~\;'.':.;:-:: .~:.....-: ~~.'. ~cc~seli j~pei:i·intQ:a :,wtU '(0.iViiid: a::hd .~~~ 'io~':the,~iw~;(·......·'··:..S:}·, ;'_,':' '.' .,,:.... .u;d;~beri:~e~~u¢he:Cameo~t o}'the~~~~oi~'G~ria~~oid.-"fiwa~· .:.';~: .::;/)'

.,.:-- >; ,;," ',,' ~eid',fua~ iN.·Abs~~e(if evro.en~e'-'11'a'(he·jun;¢t(~to· ...th~.~~J{to''.~:' '::.:..-:.!:.:.·i.. ,-::.::: ... , ...' 'c~~~t-stii~i~:"'liecouid:'!1~t·.ti~··cori~i~.i5(kn·~if~ti~,.~~!;-':.;..',.:?­

Sccti~n369:·~:. ' -;. '." .." '. ....' . , '.' ':' '.' . :'.:.? ,,':;. ,,"', .:.,. '.,.~:::.' ...,'; ~.:' .' .:····r .':. '.", :'.:.. :. '. ~ ,:-.':"': : "'~;r

:.1'1::. In ~yee::·p..81131··U.li;ieP·:PI'··C.il~8, 1t. w~'&.he,Jd··that. the·' ':;'. ""~.

~~hdjrig.o'{~le~d~rTQOt& ~ith.:~:~{~~tiOnt'~'.i;oi~~o~·~!~;elf.•~':':'::-:...,::....j.::_~j~:i~..di~ -:~;&t·.to 'co~sti~iii~ili:~'ojferi~~~~r.)..~cli?~··$.09.~~:rK:;'" ,:.' .,. , .'.,'". • i " : ' - . • ...' , .. ,...' '. ': ,.' " ",.:': j.

,,' . , .' :, .,' ,:' " :-',t· ••' ','

,..

'..": ..: , '::..:" ':. ,.".'.

~~ 1@!~'''~''~<...i..;;...;.;";';;'" ~~ ....... .i.i.......;.,.:.._;;;..;.;..,.;,..,;,~',;;,,;",;,;,,;,,;;;,,;~~,;;.-..,;; ':

: ':' .~'.,.','.

: ..', : .'.' .. ' .,.. ..~.:' . ,.

. . '. ',; :....:.. :.:..: :" .~.,_: ;'.' :.:." :

.' .;,"

-.: .: "::"

.....'.....,.. ,

. '.....; .

....., '.•• <' • ,-.:: '. ~.'... . ..' '. :..' : .'.':.., _.::,..... ,.. ..' ' ., : ... '. '. i: .-.. '" ..". f..'~?:. In ·ftl)~P.ma!,yi*t:~~';~;',Statp':C)f."All~ii.,P~de.ll:: .: . .,".c •• ';. i

.: ::., .•. ,WNiil~lo~~/~:00,'4ll~994(3:,,:ScC:602;~the";Ap~ii:'c~W:t·:'; ' .. '. :...'.'. ,:, ::1;::::i.~~;:t:i:~:;~e:i~~:6ffe~~,e.:~4)h~l~t....., ',,'~;,: .' '.' r: .~8,-·,,,<.In.:''~'''I'~m~,:t~~ 'j$-j'if<st,tn~e~tt.onto:. . '~;.:.,: ::

, 4:Om>ni"t; SftC.ondq,,~p~tiNfl.~n. to commU 'tt; thfrdlg, .:. ' •i, .. i . ..... .. ·~tt..~t ;,?:.~c.~lt tt./IJ;!M ~~;ryt:sta9li;..':th~(i8i ...

I.':" ':":, '.'.' >SS~~i~t~ij~i$;iI;V£·.,:;~..:",..a.gerre'1l1PtOl)lS<oft'~all.i1'%11?lt1J:a_t,t{!mp.t:,;~~commit (j.f[e!1oe~ ':.'. ;;

:-.::not Wide pUrIJ.shC!tJ.l~:b..it~oIMr:s.J?e.d["" se6t1l}n~;l( maties .. : ....•pun:~1icib1eall attempj4,to #..#init ~lt.in~·PWttsJ.i40I~'U/!th. " ..'. :;

. imprWoi);ri'len(~ar.lanot i:i4~ i1t8se'.Jiwii.i#idblew(t/Ld,edih; A~ . ::.I;ftte~~;.~ rna~e p.~~ts~~/;b.~oo~~,;.e~' ·4.;ttenpt;, . , '.!.~ltltb,itg~'i!.fc4lss/li);fo~~~ {!iiiS~'o/eat¬ .al~~ wlJ;ic!t " "

.. : ! by ,itself.is an..jnjut,y. ~and the i!W1:~t@i!tof ·theoff.,Ijd'er is' ,.... ~," 1M :'8ai}.e· as·if hit had,;,s~~dett:MoraLyuilt; ,must· b., .' . f:::

.'. .;:'.:tlii!i~d.t~i1ijUiy in9rd~r'ip~Wy.p.~@m~';t;A.,s tb.eUijurY .... t·"." ,::~"i~ii:d.t ~ greta as if th!i:!qc!ii.iid ~ ciifnrnffted, <piuy hnlf· " ) :~... E,'

, ; .~.tnepu~iShiM~tis'ciwdrded''>}':< .;: '- .• , .'.. :. ' .. :"). . . " ' ..:." ' ... : ~" ... . :.', - '.'. :'.. ..:: ". ,:.'::'; . ,'" ··:t ..··

..... !' ... ': '.' , :' -, :.. ".~;...: .. ~

-r, ;. i " .'13:. ·.In~gula .MohaU: ~diiY v~-~iti. ~,(;M~:'Praae8h~-': ::.. .. '.,.;;:'. : .:2oi~ie&~~iteJsc,13:;·I~i(j}i.:{S6~1S0>ilii'A;~irCouJ;...: ••••.'::;: :,.

. . de'fiti~s'sutcl~i:;as , • . ~J _.", ' , ." • "

. ,~ ., .• "7; .11u/word Suicid~in. itself is.lo(j,'tie~~'#t.iihe.~in:~hiiindiOO ..'. ". ,';~., ..... ','. Pen.aic.pde. hCiwelier.its.l1iecin,ing:dria:~ ii.~ll kTllmnt·· ..<,

,. .and ~i"'e~; no eXP1a~tloi(/Sui/' iti~(Hts;}s~if~'drid •.\-idi,<' ' .."'. ,',. " 7nea~ :kiliing~thus iltipiYii?-o ati a_ct: o!iietf_kiP!;1g:iii shQi1 (11..... . Y, .' pers.i>~;:~omr.iti~,.liiitc.14~~$~,(/g~~f(itbit..~V.· '.;. i ;'; .,

'" . ~~iTeSP.~H~ (if the-:;;~ :e'liIPibijedbY ~ni til ~1Ii:ft,Jn9 : ' .•".~'.....: i ••..:h~o~~tktnt'itihims~(r.~;.,.; J; .. ' ~: ':L ;..•" '••.... ' :.:) ,

>I~;.'In Gk~'Ka1UVB. S~te 9f Phjd;'1~96·~mu:Eqle{sc,. . .:f6!a~n i99.~:i2} sec: 648~~\;hileuPh~idhlg.th~c(>ri~ht~i:ropEiiJ . ".; .

. i>~(iityofSe~on309 If,¢ and.right t6lite d6es ~ot ~C1u'deriSht to> , . :;:.~:.;:

.. : ..

:. :

" ,,: '.' , .....:'" .,'.

, :.".>. ,,',', ",' .'

';: '~~''';:~,,":'

':.' .· ....c.

. .. .~,~:.;'.

· .:': -'>.

· ....f :; :.:

:.';_:'":''' .'· , - .

... \........ :...

".' ",'..': ' .....' ..' ...' .,'.'' . .;. ,

. ..... .. '"

.... ' . '" .~:": ...... '..~..'. :" -: '.~'.

: .~.. ,. '.' :;., .. , .

. ; .',,'1: ''',' .

.. ... ' .. "'.

.::",.:.;", ': .~... ".'~:".],,"',..,...... ,.:"::':~':.:;.:,

. :>. . ,'..~:~::~~::~;f~:~':;':':''''\ ....

'_ , .;.'.. ':.>:.:',: '.-"'." .. :' ~:!';.::.::

c~···.,.",:,::.'." ::' :;..

..: , ~

'.". ' <,..:,'!. ';: '.'. '. ,,". ,I.":~'. . :l. . .. '..< ,':. ,''' ." ,••••• ,I •• • ' ". ,.:: ••••

", ... ,'..~:r.\ :.:'. ,.,' I'" .". .', •• ." '\. ,••••'. :::.~." ,:v:" ;:,:, ·.i~.".'.;. "'. '.IX}'.':;:;:--;:·:·' .... :: ,,:'.': ... ::P.~~Ofl~" .'.:' .....

,;".......•..•....•:.•;.?••t:J ~;~.)X,;,....•......•........; ',....;(:;A;i~;ii:~.:..'/' •.'.·..'1·.~~~sf:..: '."J99"5f>:ei1tIn.$.S'06'anq;3fifi iPcrttiaiJ. as'Wuier';' .. .

~~[1~';~y,..:::_:~·;~·3·;~;:··': ;:'~..: ':.:;:~':~~:::·:.~?6::.~;~~id~ii:Ub~~····~·:·1;·~J;~~~;::22~;~S~f~.:.:;~}:}~.,. ..., '; -,". •... '.' • I' ...•.•jlitiiCide.,.'tbiiorlll41r ·d';~s.the 't:omm.ifimn·.6!5~ch.~uicl4~,::<>, , •....:..'.;::,.:,:'. •.. :·~~~Ii:·';bii:.::pti,;.JIj¢., ~t~~·~p,mn~(:,..o/i.:elt~r··.~;: . ".~

'..' .:' ; . : 'dl¥cnp'tirtn .fo,"o·.t(f"l"".whiih may·.ixfeni;t '10"ten·..years, .'::'. . .'':'"<.: :.'.":\.' :;. .. :ari'd s/idil:<:ilso,be [{;;jJ,1e trilirie::· ' .. .r..' :'.:,'". ., :,.....:: •• :'.' .. ,' "", ': ' ',(. ;":: .:~" ", ." .. ,: .:. ,: ,'•• : :.':.:: ', '. ..'.' .' .'.: I ' ::'" ,

, ". . '.. '. ~ .,309. Al'ti\iitpi.'to COil'lJ'i'lit :SuiCide,,'" .lV!Wev.ei'\·t;rttempys tv .• ' ..••.:;.:(;..:<.;:..:.:~..\ .. ' ',,1 ',.~:7:~~;:::/~t~~t!~.ff~z,.tJ:u'~~~:!%'ft:r:~::., "'.::"':••• -, -: - i . • .. ': ••. ':: Bi,npw.·j~;Prl.s~'!!:~n(jo-;:at;et.~~'!1,It.UchfriuJi ·ti;ciei-iii ,:io ". ': :: . ~. " ...'.;.;-;:'.' .~.~ :' -:''_..: ';: one'yed,~·Qr..wiih~/9r~l!JilJ't~tJt_~: .:' .'. ;~.r.:.,,:.'. . . :-:.':.? ", ::'' ~~,~.,:.,;':,.'.-:,::"~:,.,~,:~:~::.:~:.~:.~.',::~.::',..:: ':;::!~~~'~:!;:')~:',:.: _~,' : ~'~.~' ..~:~.:".:.:':~,:'..:'.~.1:..~!;.'~:~I.{~:j' ".,!.; ',: ~:. ',. " -.'.'; ?~Qo..:·,W~·~.of.·~hD:op~' t1u!l.-)ijt~g1t-.S«:tfo,,·-.309~.; '. ~: ..,,".'._. . ~:',":.:.'...._:.::::;rrii:i~iJf:~~i:~~i.~f;J!p~-t~·:~~J,~it;·~~r~·~e~.:..:.\:-i' ... .' ,.

!-g,;~}.:~;: : ;.:.-,.. . . . .,;:~.",lUld'il>Jbe~cOn>ntpU*,Qnaii!r tftilfd.'·tt(..atcin KaU;". ·ctUf ..... :. :. :" .: •• • • '......... .' .. ' "\ ••• '. '" • , ••1. '., ••

.....; .....,:: .. i.(.·.'.:.,..;.·.·.:.·. .: ". ~Pr.tJt.·.tf.l-:.::tJijUtf ~,j:,'?ilJc:~ht~ it ~hlMddbe :cfer~~liil· ':," ;..'., .Pqrf(Ii'll"nt· :a.:'lf ~:,:~~ .l(rt~hl;(ln~u:;..·.:.Il. I',!rlion: .. ' ..... '!

' . .' :.','. .... .., .... ··,:.irtte;;fp;i.S;:~'c'~~e;.i~..~;·#...P#S;t~ii;.~.~"en~~iu,·..ru~:ds...., .'.~..'... :.;:0:: . '.:'.. :' i . . h'iilp; r~.~~~~:f.Uft.~~,,4.:~!Ii~~~' ~i;o.~.:·· ....:..) ::;.:.:-:'.. to ptirll~iii: ·u;.·:.~9~r,t.,t<.:tIUi~~t;tlitg.:·Q[:·d.l.etI*'g '.' , .:~

~..!".,:,.•""::.',••'.i.;.··..:. :i\":" ,. : . : ; ". . >, ~e.ctio,n~~~rit·~~::~f~~h;~~71'~~;~::";':..::".~.:.....::..:.<: ;::.' '.; , ", . t::.'_':.:',.')':~':;':':~'.'::. ·.·.,in the:ias'B;:sess~d:.oc.:P3:rli~iiC'ih~·Ho~~'''.MW&re~_':' .-[

'." : : - ~ :.: :.; : :.: : : ..:.~:,:: : '.' :;~. \.;.:,:, :., ." :.'."·iJ).f9.tmed..the' rtou~e·thaiJht._ GoV:e~$~t:bC Irraitl".i~'lIe.nllmly.. . _.:' .~. "

..:. .:.": .~rl;;~;ingt1eire~~m~ailt1~ri:-~t·~~.~i·s;io~.~:~~li"g :..~.:-:.':.~:'::,{ .

.' ,;.>JJ-}~~~:.;::;;'.\ ;::',,~n ~~ ~r.r:;:..:.~ :'.:'....::::.~:.}:.'~\.";~~:;::;.:~;::.. :::'.::.~'-/:'.:~'::;:.;'::.;::;.::.::....::.:.~.,.'..;~.~'.::~":.. :....'.;":':'.:: .. :." ]6,.::.::!,u·lI&e~;~~Uie:.In·.~ereadiD&:case.o.ti:.~i.ihger~fi..~.~tr~~iSS;,: .. ' :-., .•'·t· .: . "' .•••• ,··.··,1 : :".,' . :.'t- ..

~J~~;fj~'i:Ic.:.:...."...~:.'>•.;.'.. b.iI1.Suilder!ID.·ubeyft: S~~.: ..i\IJt 19~2'AA262;Jh~;A1~~4:. "','.:" , .!.'

.;,.:.::.;-::::;. •. j{ign c.~ui-t:~h~~d'~~dili~h~;;g~~~~;;~vi~~.i~~'(Ji¢;,qff~~~~of: :;/ .,',' .'.': '\.:..\:';'::....:.. ,~ft~~Jlt't;' :S~i~d:p~sh~l?;~tl1'\tlet ~e~#()~~6~i~,~d~~~..~~t'.:.':,. ...•T',,:''.';:" . ..... fasting.(or thfee days.did not. amount '1;(> a!temptto ·s.~iSill.e.'The'.:: . " .:~..:: ru-e·.niPro~h,lced.~toli~WS::.•... ,4 .....: ".:.:.,:::.".: ;;,

i~~r~~~~~t.~;,~!r;aH~~.~<~~·~';:·t:~"·;·".' '. . ';'~'~cl:;~~~':;/;~~;::~k~"<'.:. :.: ·~·1;- o:·'6ut·.de'nieq ·~iiltiiide.irj4siinli<til·~aih.,. 'fie: '.' :.:.;.:-_".;:.:

. . , "__'~." ".,..... ." . ...... .... • I', ' ..,",,, "

:.~.. :proa.~·~..e!,idlmCe.tO·sh?W:.t~ ~;fAJ~,(aJ?ng.:~n',;fu,(oe_ .,':. : ~::~::,&:..':'. ':1IWi1Wjg;di1d'ff~~ ine~·(bhiiTIiUijtce_'o'J.~·IQ.sr...~'Fhe ' .. .:_:,t· :,.._-,_.-~~rts~1~1oU),.·hDw~ver.;.·.~i,.:·~4.t;~!feUiidi::tfUi ..(jeh~_' <:. ~" .,:.::\,,::. ',.,: 13vi4"r#. and.~ oo~;io7tAe~~~Pf~frir::.tlii.t~··:~~i~~d...:.: .... :~'-':

. actuallir·meant ..to fa.st.ta 'death ·Urtless;..hi,s·de(i;r.an.ds·'were· " '. .'". • •• ~..., • .. .. • • '.' ". " I", \. , •

;';jj{<~~~;'::.:: : ~nced1d'i; ".. '::..,:;" ....... . ...: < •.......••.. !.":,'~"'!...., :.. '.:'.~. n.e~6's'iioll tq tliheiherpnji f)f1eriCe,urt~r.~~·~ ~O~J']. ; .•...'.p; ·c..hils P~r.:tnC!~,(!>u~:.TNt p""'I!U' :dWlp"rty ,qboi;(t... '. :.~' • • •••• ',,: • • :'. • • ::.:' :: .! '.:." ':

.•.... . '.. ..', .:........... ;..'... " ..'.:..: . '. ,"; ,

.. '""...

.r :'. :, ,.'. ',. ~.

" " :.~.......•-," .,'

" : ...':

:',."

:"" • t "

:',' : ',:

. ,; .

...... "

. .~...::.','.: ..... : ",-,:; ..

" ...

. : . ~:. :..... '"

->. :,.,'. ":~ ,

. . :',,' .,'

:,..... '"":'" ,',:... '

. ',:::' ..,'.': •• < •

~.:.<' '.: .'

. :. . :.. ':,',

, ,

. :.......::.~.~.,~-:~---..:..:.,"~-':..,.,. ,"

. " .. ': '..:': ,,' : ,::.'~'.:', .

,,' ., :,: ..:"; ':.. .: ~~.

, :: .•. s:-', -. ' '.'': ';.. ',j.."

, ", :'

- ..' :. :.:- :- '. •• ...:'; ":;':~':::, ': 'J,

.:.... :' -. ,','"/, '-';" " " :

" ".. , ., ," ,,.

, ~,,'.

..:. '

..•.,.".'.'

-:-,., '. ~.....,;.: \:.,.:'

.' .. :'4 ....",,' ''::'f

.'

. ',...: , .-

':"

, ;

...........': '

..._-, " .:.. :. ",.: .- .••• ""11

,: ..·2l.~:·''·In'' i#iit:'~/K8POOt':"va.', :;~$..~h:;.·plutii~·r:·~:·.·2oi2·....·:~g~',..-.taiiel$Ci;~i~:IZOi219SCc:·~:@'~'1;;an~(:1{..~~.A~x.-co'iirl ~djJi)\vn th~Pri~c:iple~~d prtit:eo!u;.e~~bf:'iolloW~d~l:riie.

" -. ' .J' :::' ••• : ." n- : : ":.'. . ,;. ..... ,,'.. .:.' .... .. .:. ';.:, ",·"'Jr"jilling·of'cnargc 'and held as below:·":,,:~,: " .:.J. ,,!' . :. ..':: :', :"

'. " . :. " .." ..:~.., . '

.: .

cOnSide, tit!~·bl~d.~'~I~'tl~:i.iill~J!~:c~Se;,;tM'~e.ct(oithe p"pdj~ooct .be/ai-ethe CO#rt, butJ.J :1i#.~ld;mf(;Jj~~~:'i2--·rl~ut.Ilg•.·~'!~itdil']j

'. ,l;"w U,ie:;pri>'i gnd' ~b.u;,qf', thit1~lttjl;r.''.evidiD~e;~if'he ~ •.·~·irl!ll~CplnilIndiil~v~; froftil'lnKti",' .ar,Scill'lal&.Anjr.; "".0'''''0''

. >

.' ..'." ,;

s : .': ••••• ::'''." ..

...... '.: : '. ::;. "

. ... ::','...;.

' .. '"

..'

:....,:."

: ,.'. :'

:.' ",:.'. ,:-':"

.... , .

:~,

:, ,.,,'",

.. :

:.~.." ;". .".:'.'

, ' ........ '.. .~:

.~':::..:.,'.. :.. ::~.. ,

:, : ':.::~..., i..·:: .', ; , • P.agei1 oriS r, '. .' - . . . <:.' ..... 1': :.~ .'..: .. ,. '.;:,.:' .. : :.J ':' . :';.:. :.,~ '. "'::',::' ..... ,. :; -:':":::',;.::..

•;,i••' •• • .;" .,' , ,,' • .t.: ".' . .' " .~~:,. I',' .:_. . '. ": ... ' ..-".':':.: r : .',"','':"::'.....: ;~.'. ", ',',',: .:....,\ .~: :: ..... d' ,>

; • <:> :~:~r$~~~J,;f~~"~~~~:~h~;~~~~~J!:;'o;;:~:~~'(;';"~;':,an~ ~gh "t~ t!.VI.,rleliC,e lor '~~ :U-"a!..~i1ilurp.~,'l1/findfng oyt: ,'" ;<,!: ;. ,I

;. < ~h~hl;~';jj,;iiiJt'G;/~~iaCi.~;~~'tti~t:thtacC~~:~i/ ,,:"" J

..". ;:~~~·~~~;ftlt.:~~r.e'th~.~~~rl~~~Q~ci,<~to~~';;t~~;:~q&t:. ';.: ";' ~~ckis.ed~~+e:~~spici~nag~sf,J:he .accused w.lii~B.!l(\~~l;iot~e~n'.'!,' :•.'

p~6periyexpliUi\.ed; ~he·ciouri',will b~ full}'justifieo in. i'raP,ling th~.,.;. .. ,", . ".r:·,.· . .'.. :' 'I" '. . "', ,.: '. '.. ,'. •... : ..'c.harge·an'd5pi1:iceedjlig·~th'tl1etr;~,fly. and la,tgcihowever; if. two

. views are ~dJ~lly~~~ibld.and, t1:~,J,1,1(1ic1is. satisfied. ¢~t~e, .' .... . .. ,' '... .. :. , . ',' '. : .. 1. '.' ::.: ' .~ . • '.: ;. ... . ... , ," ..'

• ~via.ericep~a:uc{:d befoiy~himcgivcs-JjSe i:Q soaie susPidonbU~,~ot. ./~. i ".. :' ;.; : :'<':"". .:'. .". .' ,",.:.. ":. ":." i' •• '! :',', : ,;,!.

gr;aye;:~itispjcionagiririiiftlic O:cclis¢!;J,' he' will be fully within '!lis .: ",:.,_'..o •• " •• ';', ',' ;.... • .... ' •• " • .: • ,'" •• • ,'". • ',. • :. I' '..: ,','~ ••

rignts to diSChiiige'tne :a~\i~~d, " ' . .. ,:'. '. ,." .:. :' '~', , '. : . . "~" :.. . .

',' .;, ....::' .....~.'.:.Zd;, +he;~~~ 'ci~~l~,i;' the :¢a~¢6f'~illl~BIi:{~:~~~~tI .':

st~tedtM~~~~liii:h~20~. (:2) sec -i~ii2062 cnW (iOi'980~;;;'',;':.; ·t}2);Jw1~ne~~~~~~ . dprimaJa~cqse has< ,

.. been dnad~.o~t ilgiiif£s( '. . In €xiitC,isii19. powers ,-. ".'., iindef.;&e~'22'l.'ofih~' . ~d;u;'eiil~;$e.-me~"

:i~i8;iTudg,s_" Whiie·'-oori.:fidl"'fjng··the... ;... . .'. the ..

',: ',: '.,

::. :' \ ..... : .:::: .'" .::..~"':. ',.., .." ;', :.' v ". • ••••". .,'. : ..:" ',,,..::.~'.....

,.

.,:' ", .., ;":.. .. :....: ........ :.....::: " .'.'

"":" ...: .' .. '.... .'.::

...... :

iii) . .There ru:e 14 'FiR Gases .cigi1{ns{ {he'p'tesi?ni ;<wfIi,sed '.. . ' .' ~~iuding,theipre~iht.F.L¢.t~~dsthe~~~d~~ .

iUS (;I~ her) iai>fiiu unio:d~glli~1ie~eve/;sIte ~~::..~ . .e , • '. , reiedsedfrovi'Jail'siMe:2000" .'. .' ". >;',:.' ..... . : ' .:.::. .. :" " . '" '. . .. .':..'. .

. " iii) ,< Since 2000 (he ,.dcCU:S~ hiti; been. :in JNIMS securi.ty ..'~Ci~~y~~~ iw.;efe~d~~ii!.~~~iJ-:': ' ' .•.:; "

,'. >v) In.>6the7;WoTas,.theaecused1tqSMt takenfo'od.t1;rrOugh·~:mout!l'~in&iooo' tiu d~t;;_! '.'" .. , . ' .., . . ,'. .""." . .'. :,.. :,,;, ".: .. ' . :~

. ,:'.. ":: .... :....... . :.

.' ..

.,.: .......:..' .''~" .

.' '.

...;: .'. ' .: ..

'". "

..25:' ..While .f1:ainihg chat.ge.l'iiltlel' Section 3w'ipc, .1lie'·\d.CJ'M/IE ';~~nsi~~eilfiJ~i'~tcirs aid~jJith the :U~diaJ;opinicin~:inFMa:~ 'of•the:' iinpwi11iiti .o'-der.:.; TfJ~; $.aQe • is' .:¢pr~dus;;d fOf prop~r.·· . ,-,, ..

.' .. ,." apprctiiitiOTi Jr tf~~'charge ~rd~T,'." .. ... .,• ;':'<:. . . . ... '. ..' .. t·, '. ,::

,.: .' :: ,,' ,~9:;·ari.ioirt9~~g1:~bfi~B, she~~:tiu::~pii~atio~'f •..' .... ;:~:<: '.' ' filed by;the aCci;si2d,f~r;.dii.c'ha.r.9fiig;1ier;.the ~?~itteiJ.[acts. -: :.j >

;. :arn:tlU.t:';. ':' . ," ',:.': :";. ., '.'-,' . ," .. :.... ·r.

. ... ./)) -.' :..ry: :~4 :~"::c.1i~rUJ''s:~~i.i~-:iit~~~:,kfflr,st ;":f, '" . hunger strike. by<fastmir tiilro 'death on ·.02~11-2000 ':' ; ;;

. :~niandir19~ep~~me;{toj~~d<F~loo~ ~p~d~p.;~~t;·.'. '.., .'.;. ::.., .A~,1955(siC,19i8).~tiie~d~e~was ~~st~b.ii:,:' : ';'" >::

r®'iSi.iti,t1'{j· :ar'l.FIR caSe 'beiitii iv~.246(itJ2.k}PRT. P,s.< :.•.' .' .'....• ,:' -.:' '.; .:.::: ... ;:. ;:.:.. ;

.:"""'"''''''~~W'W~:~I:~a.~~·~~rbdi!;a~.afoii;shecame: .' :",;:',[:'hu~ $triketo:7a:;i~::;:~~i:::~1:~wt~~., :'.:;;,).

.'.,'; ;d~sted agai~~y'i~giSteting~~theittR 'c~~: . ..• '.. .:,. .'. ,

.,.:..',:

, ....

.:.:..',. ,:-,.. .. :r

.., .,. t ."

'. ',::'..~~: :... : . . :, ..

' ...

,..'-. :

'.',', ,

:_ :.:.:.'., .'.

. ".,: .",',' ' ...

. , . ." . ". . ' ." ..'

..'......I .

',",' '.;.. :............ ,.'. ',.:,/1

-:.~.. .'

'. > "., • •• .. l ',' . '.:l .'.....:,".:.......::..--,.....,..,.: ', , ;'.'''. . .' . ..._. ",. ':.: :J.f:::

" :•• "" .. "', ' ..' • ',,: • t I'. ': ••' .' :,'

l :' '",'~'.'or .. :". .' • ,"., '•• ' . '.:.. • ':'.'::.:. ',,;' i,::, ':, .'. .' '..., .,,," , ': ":'Page t5·(JJ'I~..; .... . zo. i :" . ",' '.,," ., .:,,','.;..

. '": '~'.,,:;~. .~I ::.'..:_':.'.'.~'~.•" ' : J.-. ;, I" : ••,•...:. .: !.,.".'. + ~ r .'. ::". ::....:

.< "',' .:'~."" >. ~;,ji;'q:.i ·.b.ic.e;.:n'e'31r~d~d~n(·:~~:ii.tk.:~sikg:iiimplititer..iii·:~;;:":'.: .: "~!.:" , .. ,',,' .: . " ... 'w- ,'... ~ .-:. :.. ".-' ••••. -.. ". ":'" ..... .:'_. I:' .•: ", ..'~ . .. . '.~.:.~, ,,:\~:;;,~,::':.<: ':~:"~i{ri':s~;+ied:'ii~a~'g:sottie~iltngi.th:is'GOes.~~th-~lp\ili.~::pro~ct·~{iori,; "..': '.,':- ; .

.:'..'.;'.;"':~;>")-;'" .. :Thltd ingredi~rit'()r:'~~lime~dy of'the 'act l()'~au~ death:.C:~nnot:be'..... ' -":J~i,~~1"'~'.:.",:;.,.." "',,,. .' ',' ..;::',~.. :.' I •• " .'~ .'.' .' •• :'. ". '. ",," f •••• '.~:

:.:.>';,;0,;":':: :".'~ . '', ,:' .. eitabiishe£l' ift~in.':.the',~na~gesbeet., it .is#~t'~a:t r~(pell.t.i(joei·, ';'<',.: , '.. '" ,:" '\"\' . . . :: .: ..' . ......,,.' ." , " '" '. :.: .. ..;. . .', ' '.\'l ." ~.:. . .•:;','.:: .. ' .i, '. :'":,,c" started he:r .j.\i:e~e'nt,(ast"oiJ, ..l:}-}.3/2014 at·,S:OO pm , I.rnl1]ccbl\t~ly.· ." :'".' . ',' ..... , ,. '.' "\'" '.. '. . . '" ".," . . ,.. , ..;":';':<>. . ", ::irtMher'Tbr~~~,f~ii~'custciii.i'~ci$)1~~as~r;'e-St~don\"i3j,zQl,ll:.:", '.. , ,. ..::.,:.' :::,', ":. . '."!.". _.: ... ": '~',',."". '-,,". ::., ....~... :' ,'" ,', .' .... ' . .' ",'.:. , " '. ; a(S.,o.S pin ipd ,irit~ll'edl«tely.,!)efore her ~rre.st she wa~ on ,(as(f0F. ..~.. " ;.' ,

,:.'.: ..,::;./",;. .: 011.1Y~4 h6Ur.s. ~!1·e"FlR:.Q~d\~ge.;~he7.t:mc;n~o~~,p~y'~'i~: ,0; .' ,'.. ' .'., .. ' :'.per.i!id'.6r24<.nours .for pro'&ecu'tmitt.:e p&itip~runder :s~uo'ri309 -.'.<; .:;':_,::.:' "

'- •. '.:.:.:',.,.:!,'.: ... :;: ..,...;.:'.:_:.;.:.::: .... :, ;.: ip.c;:l,:d~.~6t:h~~~'':a~y;h~·iui~ti.ori·,i~'.hOl~ .~f ';(d~'tiri'g'!~r"2~")):"':: ;~:~. '• .. ' ..• -1.. :: .. • •.••• • I .'. ...! .. ,f •••• • • .' I'

.:':'Iih~::.i.s , n';;t. sUm~h't ,ii> 'tauSc" .~egtlj:.'Medi~~1''Report :'-(lited '._:. .::s-, '.. :. ". •

::'/:t::'/:;::'<\' .: ·i~r5~~O·;.4·::~~bmi~~.t~:..thi_~~·;i..:C(M.liE·~~d~~llia~·~.'<f~cU!~!~:~\',;.': .-.. '" ,,' ... ".... .-bOd.i)y·rttjiriitjty'o~.allY m:aja! menm('illiless"cotiIdbe~·d~teete~ori·.:: ":' :,'"

" ",," ••••••• j .... ~: •• '. ",,:'" ," .' .. ' ...... :. ,',''('1 ,.,',.~ , ':::.::." . ",.~: :,' . • Shannil"- e\(~n a!t~~·long Jasfirigfor 14 Y:ea~:It may' ~:. ft:uitfuf .(,0 .' '.

'. '.>:;::..~..::':'::..',,";:...::' .., '... ' ":~~::JUdicl~ihi~:fh~t~l~~'is?f fii~dU_~~iTji.ilriio/~s.~{.(~·fa~~i?', ;; '; / '\, , " ' 'every. "EKADASHr"·(~lev.'ent}).":!1RY'otl~~lcaieii:ditij:for.~ ~i:io{i'of' ,.•:

:;:",',,', ',',: \. • '.' ••••• ".: ' " , ",.,.' " .: .. '•• : ..:' •• , •• I ., ", '\ •.,' ",''' """ '. 24 hours, .r~.,sldpping-:I;tjnch, a$ a rcllgto~sptj;l.Cti~e:~jl;lloiJ~.~';.'. :;:,.::.:.•'./:. '. ;< ; .il&"~ile eij~~tap;:heal~::·:.Th~.foufth< iri.g;edi~;';t:~iia:iliIh ..irt ·"tJi~,::. .._...;"

.,.:.:'.:",: ..'...',';,:::.....,:..,...':. , ." .. . \ . . .. "" .:,':'.. _. ::-.:~ttiifu~td\.le: to· i!~ti-anC~U9':'fu'~to~i~aiiio ii~te~tabli9.itei:i'.:,~ th~,. , ',.::;:. ,<>

,t't!,:;;:·); ,.,''·~~~~;r::;'*f:;'~~:;~~?:::,,:,,;~/,,,,,,,;~.:...<~.~.:,,<:,. ::< '.:,'..:":~~mjsSlon-:Qr. tlie' :bfTefic~::All~th'el!eJactS: ·clearly",pdiht·.(b, "'c: : ...:" -::;. "'~:'.;.

'..':::~~:,:,.'{,-.:::."").:.'-:~{~'~~j~~'~r!th,e.·pf~'~~~~~·:·s~~i~iiii.~~:~~rii1n~:~~i~)~i.~:;j~·:.6(::-t;:~:·:.y~/::. ,:,:: ,". :"". ".repealing ·the 'AFSPAto"reach its' logical' tonchision.~.Aow<iver,"l.:· . :: :"'. '.'" '.'

",','" "''''.''.. :'. ,:"; ,;.. , ..... ..' a&ree wi~~;'~e fin<,U.n~if. the Id:bJM)JS:~~)h~~i~~ti'~~~d~()f <\: i' ';1' '<~';:''':';:~«,;:.: :- '.. 1u;naainintlli.: right ,;0$' ,lnaitdRted :;'.hy; ;Ar?c.l{ '20(2) ':of ·_;-~tie",· '., ; .'" ;.",.::.",' .. '., co~stitliti~;,;~si~~~~~':e~~lierF1R~~~ri;:v,;ili ~~~~ec(.~.·~fi$drt~t,.... '; t;.,F; /?: :.::,:.:..:.~.:,.:::...' ~ife~~"at~~iI(e~~~tini~:~d.fu6pe~t!~h~r"2Xs n.~y~r::p;;o+~;'.' .," ,X

· .tfiere~isno doublejedpa.rd,y'ititheprii~ntcase: '. ,: ..,: ':-:: :. ',':" ,;

/::.:·A~J?·': :- : ::. ,~; .. ;':': .~.~>:.'.;::':~:,: ..: ....~:.:../.::~:.:_\.:(:::.:~::/.~>.:>"';"'1:~-'.'. .'.' ".~g_: .-Tn~(lclusi0!l; it IS..P-?Q.that ~e·:fr1ost..im);>orta~rillgTedie~.of. ".: .. '. . 1"

:.: '. ':'. .. \ .., .. " .. - " .. -:::. _-". .... .. .. .: .', ... ~.:".. 'inknJWn:' to <Jbrrlrttit ·~t.ikide".1'or.:the' offe~C(:..p~hl<llia1:ile.:Und!<r·.~~.::,':'; :::,. ·.C

. ::'?::= .. : ..:~'<: :' ~ , ., : ::: :.: : :.: ::~..: :~,.:.:::;· . -Section 309 'IPC ,.<:annot.::'b~..estabfish~ 'by ..the· prpste~tion.· bY'::. '''''. 'f!:' '.- ; ;.: " ' ...•.. - '..::' .'~ :' :-: '.. "".:.~:.- ..:. ::":.,_... :.. Pf'9ducing sufficient materials:;txeep! 'Jor,mere ,<d!cgation;,'I' am' of:·:. ". . .':::~}';'.;:· . '. .,,' ":.'. " ._ .: ;;::",~, ,: " " .:' ';';'.;.;, ..:.,..: the firmec(opinion that' the :on.a.rge'rir :a":\"hlpt'tO.'comrrut· 8Uicid~ .. " ~.' :: 1:.' : . .\~:., ' , ,'., '. . . . . .:,.' ", ", ,': ' . '.:' '. ,1'W\\Swrongly. fl'arri¢Qagei~$t the petiti6fier and in '(Ioing_.,s~;:thl"I\),:·"":': "~\JMIIE ...;~~heavilY:i~ttu~(i~~d.by¢;eiiic(~ffa~ii~(t~~iltitiuqG~iy:,." ... ~, i; ";.' :i:~r14-;~~J~:·A~i:~rdingly:'jr~chimil:Sha~lii·is:dls'ch~ea,iro~·.: ;: H

.:., ., ••• ~ " • , .': • ,'. ,', I, , : ',' ," \ I ". :f ,f'· ': ' :.

" t~:,'":, • ".•• " :; .,: " '.

.::: ' ..,; ',\,, ',' '...': :,,' ", . ".. .... ~. :,,':', .:,.:~.'.,:~...:.::.:'. :.~~.~.

':: "...... ,:,'

.,' +':, ,.'

. ~,"

. .....''.:" :.\:......

:,'.. '/::... ,:

.; :" .. ''. ',;',

',! .. ;,,'.,' "

:. ~.:.::::: .;,' . ..

'. ," :::: ..~...•........

... ' .., .... '; ...

.'

',.' . :.':'......:.'.

.. :.... ,.'. "

,- :':.-:f'.

..:. . " _'. : .. :",'",

"::,' .

.'.....:: ...

-'('

.' .., ..'.

: " ...• :'.~',.'.'..._

....:........::'

..', ... ;..,

.: .",'" ,"

•••• • I. .,., .••

Aimounped'fn (Jp-~co!lrt ..::',. ".".. .. ' :' : ..

.........: :'

" ... :,~".

j,.',....:.

: .:, . . '.: " " :.''30.:·:S~nd '~9Plesof:.this:.. order to. ~ !d:" c,JMllE' and

" Supe.r.i.,.ritenderit; Miiqipu.r 6ehinU J~ for 'infoi7na~on: .~d'. ri~~e~sary'a~tion..Return <;8~ r~c~id.~~iidanot&~co~;'~f th~.

. .•~(d'er.··i~::;the' chi~r Seci!!tiirir,· Goyet't1m-ent of i,M;;u,ipqr.; f?,r :, '.'lht6tiiiiition ~hdn~qeStMlryac:tioil. ijahY:- : ..' '.. i

I.;' ...',. ....

,. :

:..

. ;'". -; ...':

. "

'. ,

'," : .. '

.....~

',',

_'._' ..'....._. _. ".._:_ ••• , ••_._ •..i.... •

\.. " .:~_'.__.'•..'

't· ';:.'..'..~..:. . :. '.:

:~.,,'

":~:'.,: .:.,

.:.....

",'

'. :.

.... ".:

',".".":

. "~.,"

,.,:..

. '. :', \ .

'. :.. ~'.:.,..•....,:,.'

. ' '. ';'.'.....:...,.

.." .

. ."',. ,.. '-.':

;.,'.

;., .::.:...'.: ...

". :.. .. '

"." . .'

"c.

',.,",

,.." .

. '" . .....

. ',"'.. .

"f. ~. .:

:·;.,:f.. .:," ".;.' ': /',-.f ,,' . ", ',f"" ••_

".~,.:" ;.. ;:... :. . "~:.?~.;.j ,:.' ',j • " ., I :". ,I' Pas~"1~~f'16'". ",.:" . ,I:' .,' ..... ~".,',<::', ... .: ':',:."". ir • .. .••. .' .:

':'.~:i.. " .:_;:l: :.~:'.~:.:'_':: "":'" :,:: :,t.:>:, ::...C.' :.. . ', r:",:"" ",: •• "',>.: ''':, ',~ .. ' :", ", "":'·"·.~:1·.::\. .., -r, ..~..~ .... .:., :." '\ .' ".~»: ,: ~"'.,:',"; ':.:.':' ,"/.:':,': ':': :~ .\.:.'::.~

: ::.~: .;::.:" ',,: .::' .~..;',•..:. :'.>'.~:.,::":',;;'.j.\~:.':~"::':: ',.... : ..;, . ;, ...,:':, ,: :.',. ~'.'..' {:":- '. :·:f.. .': :',:.',.,',: :::' :: ':',_:,::".••~ ..•~ ': .~e' c~arg~~tl~er;S~~tt.0~3?9J~ ~d tt.!f~imfilgn~p~~~:da!ed

.' 4ll'1JUhe. 20l'i' pa"~ed'inCril:fPfCase.No. 5U14f.19Jl4lR/No.·

...... ::' ". . :0,: .;.:' . . .... ..:' : -. : .. I':' -'. '. . '. :. :,_ '. ." "erik (P) 53 of 2014)· by the 1<.1.. Chief. .;:Judicial.Magistrate • .lmphal.' .' .· . . .. :, :. .' ;'" ." , : '.:. ,., ..... '. '.' : '. . : . ~..Eaat is ~Lii-'iid"':for the aforeSaid. r'ea:.sorts.v' The .petitior;;er be.'.-:. . .... .. ':'.~ :i:: ..'".,. :. . .. ,. . " :." I ," .'.

•released' fiOI~;t(,-U:lI~d.Y;if riot ,required l~':ariy.other case, The'·;. .• :_". .." . .. '; . .. " .::: .I ." • :'.

'~~riiiionP:i;titit is,ie~~r~ingl~,\at!~W~~.a.nddl~~~.~j, ,,"" ,;): ",: t , \; .: -: ';' :;.~':. ;~;.:r "'. .'......>:...J~"I ;. :,''', ',. -. ',:':'.::.:.: ,:' •••••••••:'.,: '\' .. I'-.:

.; 29 ..: ··,.Befo~e"·.e.oncluding.. 1.;am,.t'na,kin.1: ..SQme.: obSd'v;a'til'lT)s,.- ·.Tlie ..'.. ':: -.agitiition(It iri>;n C~u Sh;W}ilii is:i' PdllticitI Idiman'd·tl;;:~ti~a':' "

'" i~\~(ui~e«idsofrci~~lin~a~ld S~i~~;Ff6tit her past ~.on~u~~.i~ .-· seems tliat she .:ir\<iycontinue with the. Jast tilf her d~1llarid is met .:~oli~PilIYby H;",.'Odvernment:' in .the .ci~~,n~ta~~$.· the S~t~;

-:..•...~o~¢rtiU:~rit··;;;aY~e up ~ppfqpri,n~:m~a~utes16ihe~healthand :... " .. ' . .. . ..:s#el¥; such ~s;· no~efeediri!{;i~.·i!,,"c,,~e~h¢.decidel>·ii;o.:co'ptimie..'~tnher 1a~t;:: . .. . . ... '.. . ,

..' .....

. :~

.~ ......~.,..~., ·"i-·_....0·:···· ...__,,__ • _,._..:..

. ....__ .'.